Jun 5, 2012 - A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system. 5 yeAr reform plAn. June 2012. AustrAliAn cApitAl te
Australian capital territory
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system 5 year reform plan June 2012
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan © Australian Capital Territory, Canberra 2012 ISBN 978-0-642-60581-8 This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced by any process without written permission from the Territory Records Office, Shared Services, Treasury Directorate, ACT Government. GPO Box 158, Canberra City ACT 2601. Published by Publishing Services for the: l
Treasury Directorate, ACT Government
Enquiries about this publication should be directed to: Treasury Directorate GPO Box 158 Canberra City, ACT 2601 www.treasury.act.gov.au
Publication No 12/0715 http://www.act.gov.au Telephone Canberra Connect 132 281
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
1
Contents Treasurer’s Message
2
Executive Summary
3
Why is Reform Necessary?
8
Summary of Reform
10
Reform is Fiscally Responsible
12
The Reform Includes Targeted Support Measures
13
Reform Measures
14
Impact of Reform
16
Households 16 Businesses 18 First Home Buyers
19
Renters 19 Rental Investors
20
Older Canberrans
21
Distribution of Reform Impacts
22
Abolishing Duty on Insurance
22
Payroll Tax
22
Phasing Out Duty on Conveyances
23
Improving Progressivity of Residential Land Tax
23
Utilities Network Facilities Tax
27
Residential General Rates
28
Distributional Impacts on Pensioners
32
Individual Tax Reform Measures
33
Removing Duty on Insurance
34
Abolishing Conveyance Duty
36
Reducing Payroll Tax
39
Improving the Progressivity of Residential Land Tax
41
Abolishing Commercial Land Tax
46
Residential General Rates
47
Commercial General Rates
49
Utilities (Network Facilities) Tax (UNFT)
50
Expanding Assistance to Households
51
Abbreviations 56 Glossary 57 Find Out More
59
2
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Treasurer’s Message The ACT has a modern, thriving economy with high quality services and infrastructure. However, our future prosperity depends on being able to fund the services and infrastructure the Canberra community deserves and expects. The ACT’s taxation system allows the Government to support those in need, to function effectively, and to make investments for the benefit of current and future generations. However, our taxation system has become outdated, and is in need of reform. The Commonwealth’s tax review (the Henry Review) and the ACT Taxation Review (the Quinlan Review) both concluded that the ACT’s taxation system – similar to other states and territories – is inefficient and unsustainable. Both reviews also outlined a plan for reform. The ACT Government’s vision is to create a tax system that is fairer, simpler and more efficient, and that is sustainable for the long term. We will reduce taxes for those on lower incomes, make taxes simpler to understand and administer, and reduce distortions on household spending and business activity. Further, we will continue to provide appropriate and targeted assistance and financial support to those who need it. Taxation reform is difficult for a number of reasons. Changing taxes means changing how people share the costs of our society’s functioning. It would be easy to wait for joint national action on reform. However, this could be a very long wait and it increases the likelihood of sharp adjustments to services or tax policy settings in the future, which could harm the social and economic wellbeing of the Territory. Delaying reform also reduces the potential benefits to the Territory’s economy from a simpler and more efficient system. This Plan is the first stage of what will be a long-term process. Reform needs to be phased in to avoid distortions in the market. Together, the reform measures announced in this first stage make a substantial improvement in the Territory’s taxation system. The benefits of these reforms are economy wide – the costs and benefits are spread across the whole community. The Taxation Reform Plan will support economic growth, make the Territory’s taxes sustainable in the long run and allow the Government to maintain and enhance the high standard of living our community enjoys. Andrew Barr MLA Treasurer June 2012
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Executive Summary Background The need for the reform of State and Territory taxes was highlighted in the Commonwealth’s Australia Future Tax System (AFTS) report. The subsequent review of the Territory’s taxation system commissioned by the ACT Government reaffirmed the AFTS’ finding regarding the efficacy of some of the major taxes. The ACT Taxation Review concluded that there are risks to the long term sustainability of revenues for the Territory – a number of major taxes are unfair, have high economic efficiency costs, are highly volatile, and as such are unsustainable. The ACT’s taxation system is not unique in relying on such taxes; all State and Territory jurisdictions need to resort to those taxes given their circumstances. The ACT, however, has a unique opportunity to commence structural reform. The relatively higher socio-economic status provides capacity to cushion the transition costs of reform. The Territory, due to its combined state and local government functions, also has access to a base for what is considered a highly efficient tax – a broad based tax on land. The Review highlighted the necessity for the reform to be over a long time frame. It suggested that measures and steps could be taken that combined will lead to structural change over time.
Taxation Reform Plan The Government in its response, released along with the Review report, reaffirmed its commitment to the reform of the Territory’s taxation system, and commenced a process of further consultation with the community and business. The 2012‑13 Budget includes a package of measures to commence reform.
Approaching the Reform The measures in the package are not developed as annual initiatives; they represent a 5 Year Taxation Reform Plan. The Plan sets the broad direction for reform, and makes some measured changes to the taxation system. For this Plan, General Rates is adopted as the revenue replacement base. This is the base identified in AFTS and the ACT Taxation Review as the most efficient taxation base available. The Plan improves the overall fairness of the taxation system.
3
4
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan Duty on conveyances is considered a highly unfair tax. A small number of households contribute disproportionately to the funding of services, at a time when their circumstances may necessitate a move. The Plan commences a phase out of duty on conveyances for both the residential and commercial sectors. The Plan makes the taxation system simpler, by combining some of the taxes. Commercial Land Tax will be combined with the commercial General Rates system. The Reform measures combined are aimed at improving the economic efficiency of the taxation system. By the end of the forward estimates period, the share of transaction taxes will reduce from 29 per cent of the total taxation to 23 per cent. The share of efficient taxes will increase from 29 per cent to 38 per cent. The excess economic burden is estimated to reduce by around $169 million cumulatively over the next five years. By the end of the first 5 Year Reform Plan, the Territory’s taxation system will be fairer, simpler, and more efficient. The Reform Plan is fiscally responsible. Revenue foregone from abolishing or phasing out of unfair and inefficient taxes is replaced annually through more efficient taxes. This ensures that while the tax settings are adjusted, the capacity for priority services is preserved. The Plan is socially equitable. Revenue replacement is also accompanied by improving the progressivity of the overall system. Tax brackets based on land values and increasing marginal tax rates are being introduced. The impacts of revenue replacement measures on lower value properties are relatively lower – in fact, close to a quarter of dwellings will be subject to lower General Rates. Impacts on pensioners and households on statutory incomes are further ameliorated through significantly increasing the General Rates rebate cap. The Plan is designed to support key policy objectives. The progressivity of the residential Land Tax system is being improved to reduce rental pressures for median priced dwellings. A more efficiently working housing market from the phase‑out of conveyance and Land Tax reform will be more attractive to investment in rental accommodation, and improve rental affordability. The phase-out of conveyance duty on commercial transactions, changes to landholder provisions, and the treatment of wholesale unit trusts should make the ACT relatively more attractive for commercial investment. A simplified tax system for businesses and the extension of the tax-free threshold for Payroll Tax should support business and jobs growth. The Plan is measured and designed to minimise distortions.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan In general, taxes change behaviour. Changes in taxation settings, even when improving the efficiency of the system, can have adverse effects. The annual adjustment measures in the Plan are deliberately kept small so as not to distort markets or decisions by households or businesses. Cumulatively, however, the adjustments represent a significant change. By the end of five years, conveyance duty on a block of land would reduce by up to 45 per cent. For a home valued at $450,000 the tax will reduce by around 35 per cent. While the general direction of reform is set, the Plan provides opportunity for a community conversation to continue for the future reform.
Reform Measures The key reform measures are: l
Duty on insurance policies will be abolished over the next five years. The tax on general insurance and life insurance policies will be reduced by 20 per cent every year from 2012‑13.
l A
phase out of duty on conveyances will commence. The marginal tax rates will be adjusted every year to progressively reduce the duty. The changes will apply to both the residential and commercial sectors.
l Revenue
replacement will be through the General Rates for both the residential and commercial sectors. The progressivity of the General Rates system is being improved to make the revenue substitution more equitable.
l
Commercial Land Tax is being abolished and substituted by an increase in commercial General Rates on a revenue and cost neutral basis.
l Residential
Land Tax is being made more progressive to reduce the tax burden for properties below the median price.
l
The tax-free threshold for Payroll Tax is being increased to $1.75 million.
l Motor
vehicle registrations will be based on environmental performance of the vehicles. This reform will commence in future years once the Green Vehicle Rating guide has been completed.
l A
number of legislative amendments are included to improve the functioning and operations of various taxes. Significant amendments relate to: – Align more closely to landholder provisions in the Duties Act 1999 with New South Wales (NSW). – The treatment of wholesale unit trusts. – Abolishing duty on subleases.
5
6
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Targeted Assistance Measures The Plan includes a number of targeted support measures to ameliorate the impact of reform, or to improve access. l
The cap for General Rates rebate will be increased from $481 in 2011‑12 to $565 in 2012‑13, an increase of 17 per cent. Pre 1997 pensioners subject to uncapped rebate, will receive a 50 per cent rebate on any Rates increase.
l
The Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme (PDCS) is being extended by three years. The property value thresholds are being increased with a full concession available up to a value of $570,250 (the 75th percentile value) and a partial concession up to $715,000 (the 90th percentile).
l
The income threshold for the Home Buyer Concession Scheme (HBCS) is being increased by 25 per cent to $150,000. The eligibility will be limited to new dwellings, land purchased for a first home, or significantly renovated dwellings.
l
The Rates Deferral Scheme (RDS) is being extended to non pensioners. The option will be available to people over 65, whether working or retired, with below average incomes and the unimproved land value above $390,000 (the 80th percentile). Households need to have at least 75 per cent equity in the dwelling to be able to defer the tax as a charge on the dwelling.
l
The Duty Deferral Scheme (DDS) will be available to those eligible for HBCS or First Home Owners Grant (FHOG).
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
The Impacts of Reform There will be an improvement in the overall economic efficiency from a net decrease in excess economic burden. By the last year, the annual net benefit will reach around $57 million. Cumulatively, over the five years, the economic benefit is estimated at around $169 million. The budget’s reliance on relatively inefficient taxes will reduce. The share of inefficient taxes will reduce from 71 per cent to 62 per cent by 2015-16. Average savings per household from the abolition of duty on insurance will be $34 in 2012‑13 increasing to $171 based on the current premiums. In 2012‑13, phasing out duty on conveyances will reduce the duty by 2 per cent for $1 million transaction, and by 13 per cent for a $0.2 million transaction. These benefits will increase to 14 per cent and 45 per cent by the last year. From 2012‑13, residential Land Tax will reduce for around 74 per cent of the properties by an average of $208. For some suburbs, the decrease will be up to 16 per cent of the current Land Tax payable, which should reduce pressures on rents. Around 12 per cent of the properties will have an average increase of $602, and up to 14 per cent of the current rent payable. Residential General Rates will increase by $122 on average. Around 24 per cent of the properties will have a rates reduction. On average, General Rates will decrease for the bottom two property value quintiles. Reforms to Payroll Tax will result in 115 businesses in the Territory no longer having to pay this tax. On average, all businesses with a payroll above $1.75 million will receive a benefit of around $17,125.
7
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
8
Why is Reform Necessary? Some of the major taxes have high economic costs Chart 1 Economic cost of major taxes 50
Total compliance, administration, and economic efficiency cost per dollar of tax is:
45 40 Cents per dollar
35
around 43 cents for duty insurance;
l
30 25
around 38 cents for duty on conveyances; and
l
20
around 36 cents for Payroll Tax.
15
l
10 5 0 General Rates
Land Tax
Payroll Tax
Conveyance General Duty Insurance
Combined, these taxes comprise around 60 per cent of total taxation.
Some taxes are highly volatile and unreliable Chart 2 Volatility of major taxes 30 Conveyance duty stands out as the most volatile and unpredictable tax.
Volatility (%)
25 20 15 10 5 0 General Gambling Payroll Rates Tax Tax
Land General Conveyance Tax Insurance Duty
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Why is Reform Necessary? Some of the major taxes are unfair l
Conveyance duty raises around one quarter of the taxation revenue from around 9 per cent of the people whose circumstances may necessitate a move to different accommodation.
l Rising
conveyance duty discourages people from moving to accommodation that meets their needs.
Index = March 2003
Chart 3 Number of transactions and conveyance duty on median price 250 200 150 100 50 0 2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
Duty Turnover
2009
2010
2011
Trend (Duty) Trend (Turnover)
Unfair, inefficient and volatile taxes are unsustainable l
With an unsustainable revenue base, delivery of priority services to the community is at risk. l Expenditure on services for the aged is considerably higher than the average, reaching close to $25,000 per person for people aged 80 years and over. l A taxation system reliant upon unfair and inefficient taxes cannot support priority services for an ageing population.
30 25 20 15 10 5
Age categories (years)
85+
80–84
75–79
70–74
65–69
60–64
55–59
50–54
45–49
40–44
35–39
30–34
25–29
20–24
15–19
10–14
5–9
0 0–4
Expenditure per capita ($’000)
Chart 4 ACT Government spending per capita by age
9
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
10
Summary of Reform A fairer taxation system Chart 5 Effective conveyance duty rate
Effective conveyance duty rate (%)
7.0
Over the next 5 years, conveyance duty rates will be reduced as part of a long term phase out of this tax.
l
6.0 5.0
At the end of 5 years, duty on some transactions will reduce by up to 45 per cent.
l
4.0 3.0
The reform is equally applicable to residential and commercial sectors.
l
2.0 1.0 0 0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
Property value ($’000) Current system until 5 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2016
Chart 6 Moving towards a progressive General Rates system 0.45
Residential General Rates will be made more progressive.
l
Rate (%)
0.40
Tax brackets and increasing marginal tax rates are being introduced.
0.35
l
0.30 0.25 0.20 100
200
300
400
AUV threshold ($’ 000) Current system until 30 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2012
500
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Summary of Reform Chart 7 Moving towards a more progressive Land Tax system Effective land tax rate (%)
2.0
Residential Land Tax is being made more progressive.
l
1.5 1.0
Tax rate reduces for land values up to $400,000 to encourage investment in affordable rental accommodation.
l
0.5 0 100
0
200
300
400
500
700
600
800
AUV ($’ 000) Current system until 30 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2012
A simpler taxation system Abolish duty on general insurance
Increased General Rates – Commercial
Abolish duty on life insurance Phase out conveyance duty Abolish Commercial Land Tax Reduce Payroll Tax
Replace revenue through
Abolish duty on transfer of subleases Align more closely with NSW wholesale unit trusts provisions
Increased General Rates – Residential with enhanced concessions Adjustment to Utilities (Network Facilities) Tax to reflect land value appreciation
A more efficient taxation system l
2011–12 29% 71% 2015–16
Inefficient taxes
62%
The ACT Taxation Reforms will increase the overall economic efficiency of the ACT’s taxation system by an estimated $14.5 million in the first year of reform, increasing to $57 million in 2016-17.
l
38%
Efficient taxes
The share of inefficient taxes will reduce and the share of more efficient taxes will progressively increase over the next five years.
11
12
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Reform is Fiscally Responsible l Revenue
foregone through phasing out of unfair or inefficient taxes is replaced by more efficient taxes.
l
The reform package has been designed to maintain revenue neutrality annually over the 5 Year Plan period. This will preserve capacity for government services, and social and economic benefits that flow from those services.
Table 1 Total budget impact from tax reform
2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 ($ million) ($ million) ($ million) ($ million)
Revenue Foregone Abolish Duty on General Insurance
-9.29
-19.33
-30.17
-41.84
Abolish Duty on Life Insurance
-0.43
-0.90
-1.40
-1.94
Phase Out Duty on Conveyances Residential Sector
-5.20
-6.54
-12.12
-18.15
Commercial Sector
-2.46
-2.98
-4.86
-6.49
Extend Payroll Tax Threshold
-6.81
-7.27
-7.75
-8.27
Abolish Commercial Land Tax
-54.58
-56.66
-58.78
-60.95
Total Revenue Foregone
-78.77
-93.67
-115.07
-137.65
Revenue Replacement Adjust Utilities Network Facilities Tax Rate
3.16
3.32
3.49
3.67
Increase General Rates
75.62
90.35
111.58
133.98
Total Revenue Replacement
78.77
93.67
115.07
137.65
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Net Budget Impact
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
The Reform Includes Targeted Support Measures General Rates Rebate for Pensioners l
The cap on General Rates Rebate for pensioners, veterans and concession card holders is being increased by 17 per cent, from $481 in 2011-12 to $565 in 2012-13.
l
The pre-1997 pensioners will continue to receive 50 per cent rebate on any increase in their General rates.
Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme (PDCS) l PDCS l
is being extended by three years.
The Scheme’s criteria are also being extended. Properties up to the 75th percentile value ($570,250) will receive full concession. The concession will progressively reduce by 90th percentile value ($715,000).
General Rates Deferral Scheme l
Currently, pensioners are able to defer their General Rates. Rates deferral options will be available to non-pensioners above 65 years, whether working or retired.
l
The eligibility will be on the basis of income, land value, and equity tests.
l
This will support ageing in place by providing a choice to households with high value properties, but relatively low incomes to defer their rates as a charge against the property.
Duty Deferral Scheme l
During the phase out period of the conveyance duty, deferral option will be available to eligible households.
l
The deferral will be available to purchasers eligible for the HBCS or the FHOG scheme, and property value below the median.
13
14
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Reform Measures Taxation reform will take place over the next 20 years. Reform will be implemented in five year periods. The first 5 year tranche of reform will commence 6 June 2012.
Abolish Duty on Insurance l Over l
the next five years, duty on insurance is being abolished.
The tax rate at which insurance duty is levied will be reduced by 20 per cent every year.
Abolish Duty on Conveyances l
Duty on conveyances is being abolished over the next 20 years. The conveyance duty rate will be progressively reduced over the next five years.
l
These decreases form the first steps towards the long-term reform of abolishing duty on conveyances.
Abolish Commercial Land Tax l Land
Tax on commercial properties is being abolished and placed on commercial general rates, combining and simplifying the taxes paid on commercial properties.
General Rates l
General Rates will be used as the base on which to replace revenue lost as a result of abolishing inefficient taxes.
l
The system will be made more progressive to ensure the system is fair and equitable.
Extend Payroll Tax Thresholds l
The Payroll Tax threshold is being increased from $1.5 million to $1.75 million.
Increasing the Utilities Network Facilities (UNFT) Tax l
The UNFT rate will be increased to $921 per kilometre to reflect recent growth in average unimproved land values.
Legislative Measures Duties Act (Land Rent Scheme) l Legislative
changes clarify that the dutiable value of a land rent lease has the same value as a normal crown lease.
l
This will ensure that the leases are treated in the same manner as other crown leases and attract the appropriate duty as intended under the scheme.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Reform Measures Short-term subleases l
Duty will not be payable on transfers of subleases with a term less than 30 years.
l
This will remove a nuisance tax on the ACT business community and streamline the asset transfer process and reduce regulatory and compliance burdens on ACT businesses.
Wholesale unit trusts l
Wholesale unit trust schemes are used by national and international investors. Simplifying landholder provisions will improve the ACT’s attractiveness to large wholesale investors, increase our investment competitiveness and more closely align the ACT with NSW.
l
These changes will more closely align the ACT provisions to NSW, reduce the administrative burden on trust companies and simplify compliance in landholder provisions.
Land Rent Scheme l Recent
legislative amendments to the Land Rent Scheme will help improve its operation and further reduce barriers to entry in the ACT residential property market. – Community Housing Canberra will now be able to access the scheme at the 2 per cent discount rate. – Households whose circumstances change will be able to immediately move from the 4 per cent to the 2 per cent rate.
l Other
changes will help streamline existing processes and reduce the administrative burden on the ACT Revenue Office.
Rates and Land Tax Amendment l Amendments
have been made to the Rates and Land Tax Acts to charge Rates and Land Tax on common areas within a Community Title Scheme at a more appropriate level. Currently the common area is charged Commercial General Rates, due to the fact it is not specifically classified as either residential or rural.
l
Under the amendments, if all the leases within a Community Title Scheme are residential, then the common area will be charged Residential General Rates.
15
16
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact of Reform There are economy wide benefits from the reform measures in the package. Because the tax reforms are a package of actions, it would be wrong to judge the social impact of each action in isolation. The social impact needs to be assessed as a package. Over the next 5 years, the share of duties on insurance policies and conveyances, Payroll Tax, and narrow Land Tax will reduce from 71 per cent to 62 per cent. These taxes have economic burden of 35 to 45 cents for every dollar raised in revenue. The share of the more efficient broad based Land Taxes will increase from 29 per cent to 38 per cent. The improved sustainability and stability of the revenues will ensure the sustainability of the priority services such as health, education, emergency services, child protection, and services to the disabled and the aged.
Households The reform of the ACT’s tax system will help ensure that education, health and other services to the community can continue to be adequately funded. There are wide social benefits from some of the reform measures. However, the reform will affect individuals and households in different ways, depending upon a range of factors and their circumstances. Those include: l
their housing tenure, whether they are homeowners or renters;
l
the value of home owners’ home and land;
l
whether they are eligible for concessions; or
l
whether they are employed in private enterprises subject to Payroll Tax.
The 2003 Canberra bushfires highlighted home underinsurance of between 25 per cent and 30 per cent. The ABS data indicates around 32 per cent of households with incomes up to $30,000 have no insurance.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact of Reform In 2009-10, on average, Canberra households paid $171 in annual insurance taxes. By 1 July 2017, these taxes will be eliminated. The reduced cost of insurance should allow more households to insure. Working families will be more able to afford to buy insurance against mishaps which diminish their capacity to work. The cost of disability income insurance premiums will decline by 9 per cent because the tax on disability insurance is being phased-out. While concessions are available for first home buyers and those re-entering the market, conveyance duty is an impediment to moving house if circumstances change. The Government has acknowledged that reform to conveyance duty needs to occur over a long period of time. However, over the next five years, there will be quite significant benefits for households as well as businesses. For a block of land valued at $200,000, the duty will reduce by 46 per cent. For a dwelling price of $450,000, the duty will decrease by 35 per cent. Commercial property transactions will receive the same benefits under the reform. All of these benefits will have some offsetting costs including higher UNFT and higher General Rates. The exact cost impact will depend on individual householder circumstances. Impacts by suburbs, districts, property values and incomes (as relevant) are provided in the following sections. The taxation system has a range of concessions and rebates. Those will remain available, and in some cases are being enhanced.
17
18
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact of Reform Businesses Businesses will benefit from lower cost pressures because of reduced Payroll Tax and the abolition of insurance taxes. The extension of the Payroll Tax free threshold from $1.5 million to $1.75 million from 1 July 2012 will result in the ACT having the lowest payroll taxes in Australia for businesses with yearly payrolls up to $4.7 million. Businesses with a payroll of $2 million, employing around 30 full-time workers, will pay $17,125 less Payroll Tax each year. Larger businesses will also benefit. From this one measure, cost of doing business in the ACT is expected to fall by $6.8 million in 2012-13. The savings for business will grow each year thereafter. The abolition of insurance taxes will reduce business costs by $4.6 million in 2012-13. It will continue to substantially reduce business costs until it is fully phased out in 2016-17. The construction sector, in particular, will benefit from the targeting of the HBCS towards new houses only. The reform will simplify tax matters for business. The commercial component of Land Tax will be transferred over to the General Rates framework, eliminating the need for businesses to pay separate Land Taxes. Duty will no longer be payable on transfers of subleases with a term less than 30 years, a clear nuisance tax on ACT businesses. This will streamline the asset transfer process and reduce business compliance burdens. Wholesale unit trust schemes are used by national and international investors. Provisions affecting wholesale unit trusts have been aligned more closely with those applying in NSW.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact of Reform The duty liability threshold has been raised to 50 per cent of landholder property and will reduce the reporting burden. Simplifying landholder provisions will improve the ACT’s attractiveness to large wholesale investors and increase our investment competitiveness. Business will contribute towards paying for these benefits with increases in Commercial General Rates and the UNFT.
First Home Buyers Eligible first home buyers will have access to a full exemption of conveyance duty for new homes worth up to $385,000. This compares to a maximum concession for homes worth up to $375,000 currently (for both new and established homes). In addition, the income threshold (at which first home buyer concessions cut out) will be more generous, rising from $120,000 presently to $150,000. The income threshold is even higher for first home buyers with children. Over time, conveyance duty on all homes will be abolished. This will benefit all other first home owners who are not eligible for the current concessional arrangements. More progressive Land Tax on rental homes will encourage the building of more lower-cost homes. That will reduce cost pressures on all lower-cost homes, both rental and owner occupied. That, in turn, will benefit many first home buyers.
Renters More progressive Land Tax on rental homes will encourage the building of more low cost rental homes. This will be of most benefit to renters seeking low-cost stand alone accommodation. Some renters are unable to access the first home market. The new benefits for first home buyers will encourage some renters into a first home purchase by making first homes more affordable. More first home buyers and more low-cost homes are expected to reduce pressures on demand for public housing.
19
20
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact of Reform Rental Investors Overall, the reform is expected to encourage investment in rental accommodation. The phasing-out of conveyance duty will lower after-tax costs for rental investors, whether they are ACT residents or live outside the ACT. This is because the ‘loss’ of tax deductibility is worth less than the gain to investors from no longer paying conveyance duty. ACT conveyance duty will continue to be a tax deductible loss until it is eventually phased out. A more efficient housing market will be relatively more attractive for investors. Rental investors will also benefit from lower cost pressures from the phasing-out of insurance taxes by 1 July 2016. Finally, rental investors will benefit from lower Land Tax on low cost rental housing, although more up-market rental housing will face higher Land Tax.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact of Reform Older Canberrans Many older Canberrans will benefit from the Targeted Assistance Measures included in the Taxation Reform Package. Those include: l
the Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme;
l
General Rates Rebate;
l
General Rates Deferral; and
l
Duty Deferral Scheme.
In general these measures support Ageing in Place. The Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme (PDCS) provides concessions on conveyance duty to help eligible pensioners move to accommodation more suited to their needs, such as from a house to a townhouse. The concessional duty of $20 for pensioners will be extended to include a broader range of properties: up to $570,250 for land and improvements and $300,000 for land alone. The Rates Deferral Scheme (RDS) allows pensioners to defer payments of their General Rates, on which a relatively low rate of simple interest is charged. This is being expanded to allow people above 65 years satisfying income, assets and equity criteria to defer their rates. The cap on General Rates Rebate in the first year will increase from a maximum of $481 to $565. Capped rebate recipients will receive a rebate with a maximum value of 38 per cent of the average General Rates bill. Uncapped recipients will continue to receive a 50 per cent rebate. Older Canberrans with more assets will specifically benefit from a number of the other reforms. With home, contents and car assets to protect, the phasing-out of insurance duties will provide many older Canberrans with significant savings. In addition, the phasing-out of conveyance duty will result in lower financial penalties for those wishing to downsize their housing needs in retirement.
21
22
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Distribution of Reform Impacts Abolishing Duty on Insurance Average savings for households in 2012-13 will be around $34. The tax will reduce by 20 per cent every year, and savings will increase commensurately. Average household savings by income quintile are provided in the table below. Table 2 Average insured household savings by income quintile Income quintile
Gross household Savings Savings Savings Savings income p.a. 2012-13 2013-14 2014 -15 2015 -16 ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
1st
0 to 51,000
21
41
62
82
2nd
51,001 to 87,700
27
53
79
106
3rd
87,701 to 124,500
32
63
95
126
4th
124,501 to 181,000
37
74
110
147
5th
181,001 and above
50
100
151
201
34
68
103
137
All households
Payroll Tax The changes to Payroll Tax will reduce the tax burden for an estimated 1,865 businesses in the ACT by an average of $17,125 and will result in an additional 115 businesses no longer paying Payroll Tax.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
23
Distribution of Reform Impacts Phasing Out Duty on Conveyances The changes to duty on conveyances will reduce the tax payable on properties with a value up to $1.2 million in 2012-13, increasing to $3.6 million in 2016 -17. In 2012-13 homebuyers will save around 12 per cent on a property valued at $500,000, increasing to 34 per cent in 2016 -17. Table 3 Impact on property values of phasing out conveyance duty Property value ($’000)
Duty payable current ($)
Duty payable Savings 2012-13 ($) (%)
Duty payable Savings 2016 -17 ($) (%)
200 5,500
4,800 13 2,960 46
300 9,500
8,550 10 5,460 43
400 15,000
13,300 11 9,460 37
500 20,500
18,050 12 13,460 34
600 26,250
23,550 10 18,460 30
700 32,000
29,050 9 23,460 27
800 37,750
35,050 7 29,210 23
900
43,500
41,550 5 35,710 18
1,000
49,250
48,050 2 42,210 14
Improving Progressivity of Residential Land Tax The adjustments to marginal tax rates will result in the effective tax rate reducing for properties in the first four land value quintiles. The maximum benefit will be for properties in the fourth land value quintile, which should reduce rental pressures for standalone dwellings around the median property value. For unimproved value of $270,000, the decrease in tax will be around $400. Land Tax will increase for properties with unimproved values in the highest quintile. Table 4 Impact by land value quintile from changes to Land Tax Land Median Current land New land value tax tax quintile ($) ($) ($)
Average Percentage Current New change change effective tax effective ($) (%) rate (%) tax (%)
1st
0 to 92,000
370
364
-6
-1
0.61
0.60
2nd
92,001 to 142,000
832
750
-82
-10
0.70
0.64
3rd
142,001 to 229,000
1,482
1,257
-225
-15
0.81
0.69
4th
229,001 to 320,000
2,567
2,170
-398
-16
0.93
0.79
5th
320,001 and above
5,330
5,655
325
3
1.10
1.15
24
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Distribution of Reform Impacts Around 74 per cent of the residential properties currently subject to Land Tax will have a reduction in tax payable by an average of $208. Around 12 per cent of the properties will be subject to increased tax at an average of $602. Around 13 per cent of the properties will have no change in tax payable. On average, tax payable on residential properties currently subject to Land Tax will decrease by an average of $79. Table 5 Impact of Land Tax reform Number of properties
Average change in tax amount ($)
Increase 3,921 602 Decrease 23,285 -208 No change
4,313
0
Total 31,519 -79
The following table provides average change in Land Tax by suburb. Land Tax for rental dwellings in the outer suburbs in Tuggeranong and Belconnen will reduce by up to 16 per cent. Table 6 Impact by suburb from changes to Land Tax ($) Suburb Current Land Tax New Land Tax Change Change average per dwelling ($) average per dwelling ($) ($) (%) AINSLIE
5,509 5,927 417 7.6
AMAROO
2,071
ARANDA
4,294 4,408 114 2.7
BANKS
1,967
BARTON
1,393 1,319 -73 -5.3
BELCONNEN 871 BONNER
1,328
1,791 -280 -13.5 1,677 -290 -14.7 763 -108 -12.3 1,137 -192 -14.4
BONYTHON 1,381 1,202 -179 -13 BRADDON 1,052 1,044 -8 -0.7 BRUCE
1,116 1,026 -90 -8.1
CALWELL
1,863
1,605 -259 -13.9
CAMPBELL 3,530 3,800 270 7.6 CASEY
1,611
1,420 -191 -11.9
CHAPMAN 4,387 4,493 106 2.4 CHARNWOOD 1,633 CHIFLEY
CHISHOLM 2,587 CITY
1,373 -260 -15.9
2,584 2,563 -21 -0.8 358
2,237 -350 -13.5 345 -13 -3.6
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
25
Distribution of Reform Impacts Table 6 Impact by suburb from changes to Land Tax ($) [continued] Suburb Current Land Tax New Land Tax Change Change average per dwelling ($) average per dwelling ($) ($) (%) CONDER
1,835
COOK
2,527 2,409 -118 -4.7
1,581 -255 -13.9
CRACE
1,565
CURTIN
3,532 3,676 144 4.1
1,326 -239 -15.3
DEAKIN
5,275 5,849 574 10.9
DICKSON 2,856 2,902 46 1.6 DOWNER 3,624 3,622 -2 -0.1 DUFFY
2,843 2,698 -145 -5.1
DUNLOP
1,754 1,491 -263 -15
EVATT
2,234
FADDEN
3,097 2,853 -245 -7.9
1,916 -318 -14.2
FARRER
3,339 3,305 -35 -1
FISHER
2,993 2,773 -220 -7.3
FLOREY
1,977
1,722 -255 -12.9
FLYNN
2,561
2,186 -375 -14.6
FORDE
1,828
1,594 -235 -12.8
FORREST
3,663 4,188 525 14.3
FRANKLIN 1,380
1,169 -211 -15.3
FRASER
2,203
1,878 -325 -14.8
GARRAN
2,534 2,673 139 5.5
GILMORE
2,069
1,765 -304 -14.7
GIRALANG 2,418
2,070 -348 -14.4
GORDON
1,561 1,343 -218 -14
GOWRIE
2,363
1,976 -387 -16.4
GREENWAY 1,017
893 -124 -12.2
GRIFFITH 1,865 1,961 96 5.1 GUNGAHLIN 1,541
1,310 -231 -15
HACKETT 3,176 3,221 45 1.4 HALL
6,191 6,763 571 9.2
HARRISON 2,036 HAWKER
1,720 -316 -15.5
1,693 1,575 -118 -6.9
HIGGINS
2,565
HOLDER
2,356 2,147 -209 -8.9
2,196 -369 -14.4
HOLT
1,321
1,119 -201 -15.2
HUGHES 3,157 3,247 90 2.9 ISAACS
3,277 3,206 -71 -2.2
ISABELLA PLAINS
1,565
KALEEN
2,768 2,497 -271 -9.8
1,337
-229
-14.6
KAMBAH
2,183
1,901 -282 -12.9
KINGSTON 1,260 1,158 -103 -8.1
26
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Distribution of Reform Impacts Table 6 Impact by suburb from changes to Land Tax ($) [continued] Suburb Current Land Tax New Land Tax Change Change average per dwelling ($) average per dwelling ($) ($) (%) LATHAM
2,111
1,760 -351 -16.6
LYNEHAM 1,239 1,213 -27 -2.1 LYONS
2,224 2,241 17 0.8
MACARTHUR 2,468
2,154 -314 -12.7
MACGREGOR 1,605
1,356 -249 -15.5
MACQUARIE 2,420
2,264 -156 -6.4
MAWSON 1,927 1,905 -22 -1.1 MCKELLAR 2,646
2,342 -304 -11.5
MELBA
2,029
1,757 -273 -13.4
MONASH
1,739
1,517 -221 -12.7
NARRABUNDAH 3,548
3,749
NGUNNAWAL 1,374
1,198 -177 -12.9
NICHOLLS
1,876 -233 -11.1
OAKS ESTATE
2,109 882
763
201
-119
5.7
-13.5
O’CONNOR 4,021 4,299 278 6.9 O’MALLEY 7,001 7,835 833 11.9 OXLEY
2,054 1,829 -225 -11
PAGE
2,472 2,240 -231 -9.4
PALMERSTON 1,635
1,402 -234 -14.3
PEARCE 2,874 2,916 42 1.5 PHILLIP
1,033
907 -127 -12.3
PIALLIGO 5,814 6,277 464 6,245
REID
2,515 2,721 206 8.2
RICHARDSON 2,085
7,034
788
8
RED HILL
12.6
1,747 -338 -16.2
RIVETT
2,772
2,473 -299 -10.8
SCULLIN
2,001
1,717 -284 -14.2 2,050 -367 -15.2
SPENCE
2,416
STIRLING
2,005 1,870 -135 -6.7
THARWA
1,889
1,601 -288 -15.3
THEODORE 1,778 1,511 -267 -15 TORRENS 3,497 3,486 -11 -0.3 TURNER 1,459 1,500 41 2.8 WANNIASSA 2,557
2,274 -283 -11.1
WARAMANGA 2,865
2,670 -196 -6.8
WATSON
1,705 1,658 -47 -2.8
WEETANGERA 3,442 WESTON
3,403
-39
-1.1
2,722 2,569 -153 -5.6
YARRALUMLA 6,707
7,511
804
12
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Distribution of Reform Impacts Utilities Network Facilities Tax The Utilities Network Facilities Tax (UNFT) rates are being adjusted to reflect growth in land values. The impact of adjustment by income quintile, assuming that utilities passed on the tax to consumers, is provided in the table below. Table 7 Impact in price by income quintile Income quintile Gross household Average increase income p.a. in price p.a. ($) ($) 1st
0 to 51,000
16.17
2nd
51,001 to 87,700
17.73
3rd
87,701 to 124,500
19.63
4th
124,501 to 181,000
18.81
5th
181,001 and above
26.22
All households
22.19
27
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Distribution of Reform Impacts Residential General Rates General Rates will be reformed, with about 24 per cent of properties having a decrease in rates. For all but the most expensive land value quintiles, General Rates will fall or rise by less than $67 a year on average. The increase only represents revenue replacement, but does not reflect the benefits to households from reduced taxes on insurance, conveyance duty or Payroll Tax. The increase in General Rates is not uniform across all properties. Comparing 2012-13 General Rates without reform to 2012-13 General Rates with reform shows that around 24 per cent of the properties will have a decrease in their General Rates payable. Chart 8
Cumulative changes in General Rates, 2012-13
100 90 80 AUV percentile (%)
28
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 -0
-$50
$50
$100
$150
$200
$250
$300
Changes in General Rates The 24th percentile of properties (AUV of $180,000) will have no change in rates. Lower value properites will have a rate cut.
The 50th percentile, or median, of properties (AUV of $273,000) will incur an additional $40 in general rates.
The 80th percentile of properties (AUVof $390,000) will incur an additional $160 in general rates.
Table 8 below provides the change in rates by Average Unimproved Value (AUV) quintile. Table 8 Change in General Rates by AUV quintile AUV quintile
AUV (2012-13) Average General Average General ($) Rates (2011-12) ($) Rates (2012-13) ($)
1st
0 to 156,000
2nd
Difference (%)
778
775
-3
156,001 to 250,000
1,079
1,074
-5
3rd
250,001 to 300,000
1,257
1,279
22
4th
300,001 to 390,000
1,421
1,488
67
5th
390,001 and above
2,036
2,378
342
All properties
1,276
1,399
123
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
29
Distribution of Reform Impacts The following table provides average change in General Rates by suburb. Table 9 General Rates impact by suburb District
General Rates (2011-12) ($)
AINSLIE
General Rates (2012-13) ($)
Difference ($)
1,800 2,190 390
AMAROO 1,116 1,195
79
ARANDA 1,607 1,871 264 BANKS
1,132 1,199
67
BARTON 1,115 1,216 102 BELCONNEN 800
842
42
BONNER 1,015 1,013
-2
BONYTHON 1,049 1,095
46
BRADDON 933 1,008
75
BRUCE
1,011 1,066
54
CALWELL 1,144 1,222
78
CAMPBELL 1,842 2,222 380 CASEY
1,017 1,026
9
CHAPMAN 1,650 1,908 258 CHARNWOOD 1,051
1,107
56
CHIFLEY 1,370 1,518 148 CHISHOLM 1,238 1,339 101 CITY
662 686 23
CONDER 1,144 1,207
64
COOK
1,278 1,454 176
CRACE
1,006 1,038
CURTIN
1,603 1,889 286
DEAKIN
2,218 2,774 557
31
DICKSON 1,385 1,607 222 DOWNER 1,464 1,657 192 DUFFY
1,310 1,465 156
DUNLOP 1,068 1,091
23
EVATT
79
1,225 1,304
FADDEN 1,344 1,497 152 FARRER
1,600 1,856 257
FISHER
1,269 1,417 148
30
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Distribution of Reform Impacts Table 9 General Rates impact by suburb [continued] District
General Rates (2011-12) ($)
General Rates (2012-13) ($)
Difference ($)
FLOREY
1,184 1,299 114
FLYNN
1,234 1,325
91
FORDE
1,118 1,146
28
FORREST 2,684 3,530 846 FRANKLIN 1,014 1,049
35
FRASER
86
1,205 1,291
GARRAN 1,612 1,934 322 GILMORE 1,185 1,261
76
GIRALANG 1,217 1,302
85
GORDON 1,084 1,140
56
GOWRIE
77
1,156 1,234
GREENWAY 873 907 34 GRIFFITH 1,598 1,897 298 GUNGAHLIN 997 1,060
63
HACKETT 1,507 1,757 250 HALL
1,832 2,207 375
HARRISON 1,092 1,149
57
HAWKER 1,377 1,593 215 HIGGINS 1,213 1,319 105 HOLDER 1,240 1,375 134 HOLT
1,016 1,075
59
HUGHES 1,638 1,952 313 ISAACS
1,432 1,643 212
ISABELLA PLAINS
1,050
KALEEN
1,294 1,403 109
1,113
62
KAMBAH 1,190 1,284
94
KINGSTON 1,008 1,027
20
LATHAM 1,142 1,216
74
LYNEHAM 1,137 1,155
17
LYONS
1,346 1,519 174
MACARTHUR 1,263
1,377
114
MACGREGOR 1,059
1,078
19
MACQUARIE 1,266 1,418
151
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
31
Distribution of Reform Impacts Table 9 General Rates impact by suburb [continued] District
General Rates (2011-12) ($)
General Rates (2012-13) ($)
Difference ($)
MAWSON 1,241 1,353 111 MCKELLAR 1,233 1,356 124 MELBA
1,210 1,314 105
MONASH 1,157 1,240 NARRABUNDAH 1,607
1,891
NGUNNAWAL 976 1,015
82 283 39
NICHOLLS 1,234 1,349 115 OAKS ESTATE
957
997
O’CONNOR 1,706 2,039
40 334
O’MALLEY 2,052 2,566 514 OXLEY
1,197 1,298 101
PAGE
1,165 1,267 102
PALMERSTON 1,064 PEARCE PHILLIP
1,128
64
1,449 1,643 194 858 890 32
PIALLIGO 1,999 2,365 366 RED HILL
2,646
REID
1,686 2,064 378
RICHARDSON 1,136 RIVETT
3,408 1,207
762 71
1,253 1,375 122
SCULLIN 1,149 1,237
88
SPENCE
87
1,195 1,282
STIRLING 1,296 1,411 115 THARWA 1,073 1,086
13
THEODORE 1,106 1,177
71
TORRENS 1,520 1,729 209 TURNER 1,104 1,241 137 WANNIASSA 1,268 1,379
111
WARAMANGA 1,276
154
1,430
WATSON 1,192 1,316 124 WEETANGERA 1,517
1,772
255
WESTON 1,307 1,447 140 YARRALUMLA 2,331
2,879
548
32
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Distribution of Reform Impacts Distributional Impacts on Pensioners Property owners who receive a Centrelink or Department of Veterans’ Affairs pension with entitlement to a Pensioner Concession Card, or a War Veteran’s pension are eligible for a rebate of up to 50 per cent of their rates. Pensioners in receipt of a rates rebate prior to 1 July 1997 are not affected by the capped rebate, and maintain their level of concession until they are no longer an eligible pensioner. From 1 July 2012 the cap on the General Rates Rebate is being increased by $84 to $565, more than offsetting the Fixed Charge component of General Rates ($555 for 2012-13). This increase will reduce any effect changes to the General Rates system would otherwise have on all rebate recipients, while also providing greater assistance than previously available for capped recipients with an AUV below $350,000. The table below outlines the change in rates payable by AUV for current recipients of the General Rates Rebate. Table 10 Impact of reform by AUV quintiles AUV quintile AUV ($) Proportion Previous New average Change ($) of rebate average rates rates recipients (%) payable ($) payable ($) 1st
0 to 156,000
11
394
387
-7
2nd
156,0001 to 250,000
17
553
526
-27
3rd
250,001 to 300,000
22
695
676
-19
4th
300,001 to 390,000
25
826
855
29
5th
390,001 and above
25
1,173
1,394
221
All households
294,909
100
788
840
52
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Individual Tax Reform Measures Removing Duty on Insurance Abolishing Conveyance Duty Reducing Payroll Tax Improving the Progressivity of Residential Land Tax Abolishing Commercial Land Tax Residential General Rates Commercial General Rates Utilities (Network Facilities) Tax (UNFT) Expanding Assistance to Households
33
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
34
Removing Duty on Insurance Insurance taxes are duties based on premiums paid for general and life insurance. The ACT Taxation Review concluded that insurance taxes are highly inefficient. They are essentially transaction taxes, although they are levied on aggregate premiums and are less likely to be visible to the consumer. The duty increases with the level of insurance cover and may create adverse consequences of under insurance and less than optimal production of insurance products. Under insurance caused by insurance taxes can impose a direct cost on governments where there is an expectation of direct assistance should a major catastrophe occur. Overall, the Panel found that these taxes are no sustainable in the long run because of the pressure on governments to provide compensation after the event. The Panel recommended that duty on general insurance and life insurance be abolished. The Government will abolish duty on general and life insurance premiums over a period of five years, by reducing the tax by 20 per cent per year. The new rates for the next five years are shown in the Table below. Table 11 Duty on insurance Current system
New system
Until 30 September 2012
from 1 October 1 July 1 July 1 July 1 July 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Duty on insurance Rate (%) Rate (%) General Life
Chart 9
10
8
6
4
2
0
5
4
3
2
1
0
Duty on general and life insurance schedule, marginal rates and thresholds
12 10
Rate (%)
8 6 4 2 0 0 Current system
1 Oct 2012 General insurance
1 July 2013
1 July 2014 Life insurance
1 July 2015
1 July 2016
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
35
To provide Insurance Companies with sufficient time to adapt to these changes, the reduced rates will come into effect from 1 October 2012.
Impact on Households Abolishing duty on insurance will reduce the cost of general and life insurance policies for all households and businesses in the ACT. The savings for ACT households depends on whether they insure and how much they insure. Around 68 per cent of ACT households earning up to $51,000 gross annual household income have an insurance policy, compared with almost 100 per cent of the highest income bracket. For average households which insure, the savings will eventually reach $103 per year for those with the lowest income (up to $51,000 per annum), to a maximum of $251 per annum for households in the highest income bracket. Table 12 Insurance tax burden by household income Income quintile
Gross household income p.a ($)
Duty on insurance for Households with Households with no those with insurance ($) insurance (%) insurance (%)
1st
0 to 51,000
103
68.4
31.6
2nd
51,001 to 87,700
132
85.5
14.5
3rd
87,701 to 124,500
158
92.3
7.7
4th
124,501 to 181,000
184
93.8
6.2
5th
181,001 and above
251
99.6
0.4
171
87.9
12.1
All households
Source Treasury Directorate, Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2010 Household Expenditure Survey, Australia: Summary of Results 2009-10, Cat. No. 6530.0, ABS, Canberra and unpublished data from the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, APRA; Department of Human Services, Sydney.
Households and businesses with insurance will save 2 per cent on insurance in the first year, increasing to 10 per cent in the final year of reform. For example, an ACT household paying $2,500 per year in insurance will save $50 in the first year of reform, increasing to $250 in the fifth year when insurance duty is abolished. The savings on a variety of different premium amounts is shown below. Table 13 Savings on insurance premiums Annual premium paid ($)
2012-13 ($)
2013-14 ($)
2014-15 ($)
2015-16 ($)
2016-17 ($)
1,500
-30 -60 -90 -120 -150
2,000
-40 -80 -120 -160 -200
2,500
-50 -100 -150 -200 -250
3,000
-60 -120 -180 -240 -300
The Independent Competition and Regulatory Commission will be tasked with monitoring in the future to ensure that consumers receive the full benefits of the savings.
36
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Abolishing Conveyance Duty Conveyance duty is levied on the value of property when it is transferred. It is a progressive tax with varying marginal tax rates based on the value of property transacted. The Taxation Review found that conveyance duty is an inefficient tax that distorts consumer behaviour and exercise of housing preferences, leading to a misallocation of resources in the economy. It is inequitable, as the tax burden is carried out by a small number of people transacting, and it only applies to those who purchase real property. Conveyance duty is a very volatile and unpredictable source of revenue for the Territory. The Panel recommended that conveyance duty be abolished over a 10-20 year period. Over the next five years, tax rates will be progressively reduced to phase out the conveyance duty in the longer term. The reduction in the marginal tax rate will focus on the lower tax brackets. The benefits of reduced tax will initially flow to properties valued below $1.2 million. The reforms will combine two previous thresholds to one threshold of less than $0.2 million. A new intermediate tax bracket is also being introduced between $750,001 and $1 million. To minimise any possible distortion in the market from introducing reform, the new conveyance duty rates will commence 6 June 2012. The new rates and thresholds for conveyance duty are provided below in Table 14. Table 14 Conveyance duty rates and thresholds Current system until 5 June 2012 New system
6 June 1 July 1 July 1 July 1 July 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Thresholds Rate (%) Thresholds Rate (%) Up to $100,000
2.0
$100,001 to $200,000
3.5
Up to $200,000
$200,001 to $300,000
4.0
$300,001 to $500,000 $500,001 to $1,000,000
2.4
2.2
2.0
1.8
1.48
$200,001 to $300,000
3.75
3.7
3.5
3.0
2.5
5.5
$300,001 to $500,000
4.75
4.5
4.15
4.0
4.0
5.75
$500,001 to $750,000
5.5
5.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
$750,001 to $1,000,000 6.5 6.5 6.5 6.5 6.5 Above $1,000,000
6.75 Above $1,000,000
7.25 7.0 7.0 7.0 7.0
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Chart 10 Conveyance duty schedule,
Chart 11 Comparison of conveyance duty,
marginal rates
average rates
8
7
7 Effective conveyance duty rate (%)
6
Marginal tax rate (%)
6 5 4 3 2 1
5 4 3 2 1 0
0 0
200
400
600
800
1,000 1,200
Property value ($’ 000)
0
200
400
600
800 1,000 1,200 1,400
Property value ($’ 000)
Current system until 5 June 2012
Current system until 5 June 2012
New system from 6 June 2012
New system from 6 June 2012
New system from 1 July 2016
New system from 1 July 2016
Impact on Households This reform will mean homebuyers will pay less conveyance duty on properties valued up to $1.2 million (increasing to $3.8 million in 2016). These decreases in conveyance duty payable by homebuyers reflect the phased abolition of stamp duty in the ACT over the next 10 to 20 years. The following Chart shows the benefits received by households from the reforms at a range of property values.
37
38
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan Chart 12 Reduction in conveyance duty over a 5 year period
$8,540 $7,790
$7,040 $5,540 $4,040
$300,000
$400,000
$500,000
$600,000
$700,000
Price of the property you buy 2011-12
From 1 July 2016
Table 15 Comparison of new conveyance duty with the current system Current system until 5 June 2012 Property value thresholds ($)
Duty payable ($)
6 June 1 July 1 July 1 July 1 July 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Duty payable ($)
100,000
2,750
2,400 2,200 2,000 1,800 1,480
200,000
5,500
4,800 4,400 4,000 3,600 2,960
300,000
9,500
8,550 8,100 7,500 6,600 5,460
500,000
20,500
18,050 17,100 15,800 14,600 13,460
750,000
34,875
31,800 29,600 28,300 27,100 25,960
1,000,000
49,250
48,050 45,850 44,550 43,350 42,210
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Reducing Payroll Tax Payroll Tax is imposed on private sector wages and other forms of employee remuneration. The Review Panel noted that views on the efficacy of Payroll Tax differ. There is evidence that it reduces employment, creates a welfare loss and provides an inefficient method of raising tax. Its efficiency and equity would depend on the circumstances for States. Overall, it performs relatively well. It was recommended that the ACT retain a form of tax on payroll to maintain a diversified tax system and work towards national harmonisation of the system. The ACT Government is reducing the tax burden for all businesses located in the ACT and encouraging growth of small to medium sized firms. As a first step, the tax-free threshold will be raised from $1.5 million to $1.75 million. The tax rate will be held constant at 6.85 per cent. The current system and new rates and thresholds for Payroll Tax are provided below. The new system will begin from 1 July 2012. Table 16 Payroll Tax rates and thresholds Current system until 30 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2012 Threshold Rate (%) Threshold Rate (%) $1,500,000
6.85
$1,750,000
6.85
Chart 13 Payroll Tax schedule, marginal rates 8 Marginal tax rate (%)
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0
1
2
3
Size of payroll ($ million p.a) Current system until 30 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2012
4
5
39
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
40
Impact on Business All businesses in the Territory will benefit from paying a reduced amount of Payroll Tax. Around 115 businesses with payrolls between $1.5 million and $1.75 million will no longer have to pay this tax. These reforms will make the ACT the most competitive state in the country up until $4.7 million. The Chart shows a comparison between NSW and the ACT (before and after the reforms).
Chart 14 Comparison of ACT and NSW Payroll Tax 600
Tax payable ($’000)
500 400 300 200 100 0 0
1
2
3
4
Size of payroll ($ million p.a) NSW ACT current system until 30 June 2012 ACT new system from 1 July 2012
5
6
7
8
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
41
Improving the Progressivity of Residential Land Tax Land tax is applied to all residential properties that are rented, including boarding houses, multiple dwellings, dual occupancies and granny flats. For the residential sector, land tax is currently applied to a narrow base of rental properties. A broad based land tax is considered to be efficient. The Review Panel noted that the ACT is in a unique position among States and Territories to have access to a broad based land tax base in General Rates. The Government is making the residential land tax system fairer and more equitable. It will provide significant savings for properties with a land value below $400,000. The tax burden on properties between $80,000 and $400,000 will decrease. The new rates will commence 1 July 2012. Table 17 Residential Land Tax rates and thresholds Current system until 30 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2012 Average unimproved value Rate (%) Rate (%) Up to $ 75,000
0.60
0.60
From $75,001 to $150,000
0.89
0.70
From $150,001 to $275,000
1.15
0.89
$275,001 and above
1.40
1.80
Chart 15 Residential Land Tax schedule,
Chart 16 Comparison of Land Tax, effective tax rates 2.0
2.0 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
Effective land tax rate (%)
Marginal tax rate (%)
marginal tax rate
1.5 1.0 0.5 0
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
AUV ($’000)
0
200
400
600
800
AUV ($’000)
Current system until 30 June 2012
Current system until 30 June 2012
New system from 1 July 2012
New system from 1 July 2012
42
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact on Households Under the new residential Land Tax rates around 76 per cent of properties will receive an average decrease in land tax of $208. Around 12 per cent of properties will incur an average increase of $602. The Land Tax burden of the remaining 12 per cent will be unaffected by the changes. Rented properties valued up to $390,000 will receive a reduction in their total Land Tax bill. This will help to improve the supply of affordable stand along properties in the rental market. It will also help reduce the pressure on rental prices in the Territory. Chart 17 Average impact on Land Tax for AUV values $168 $368 $403 $273 $143
$150,000
$200,000
$250,000
$300,000
$350,000
Investment property AUV 2011-12
From 1 July 2012
The following table shows the changes in Land Tax payable for a range of properties up to $350,000. For example, a property with an AUV of $300,000 would receive a benefit of $368 on their annual Land Tax charge. Table 18 Changes in Land Tax by AUV AUV ($) Previous Land Tax payable ($) New Land Tax payable ($) 100,000 673
Difference ($)
625
-48
200,000 1,693
1,420
-273
300,000 2,905
2,538
-368
350,000 3,605
3,438
-168
400,000 4,305
4,338
33
450,000 5,005
5,238
233
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan Around 76 per cent of properties will receive a fall in their average Land Tax bill. Table 19 Average change in Land Tax for suburbs under reform Suburb Current Land Tax New Land Tax Change ($) Change (%) average per dwelling average per dwelling ($) ($) AINSLIE
5,509 5,927 417 7.6
AMAROO
2,071
ARANDA
4,294 4,408 114 2.7
1,791 -280 -13.5
BANKS
1,967
BARTON
1,393 1,319 -73 -5.3
BELCONNEN 871 BONNER
1,328
1,677 -290 -14.7 763 -108 -12.3 1,137 -192 -14.4
BONYTHON 1,381 1,202 -179 -13 BRADDON 1,052 1,044 -8 -0.7 BRUCE
1,116 1,026 -90 -8.1
CALWELL
1,863
1,605 -259 -13.9
CAMPBELL 3,530 3,800 270 7.6 CASEY
1,611
1,420 -191 -11.9
CHAPMAN 4,387 4,493 106 2.4 CHARNWOOD 1,633 CHIFLEY
CHISHOLM 2,587 CITY
1,373 -260 -15.9
2,584 2,563 -21 -0.8 358
2,237 -350 -13.5 345 -13 -3.6
CONDER
1,835
COOK
2,527 2,409 -118 -4.7
1,581 -255 -13.9
CRACE
1,565
CURTIN
3,532 3,676 144 4.1
1,326 -239 -15.3
DEAKIN
5,275 5,849 574 10.9
DICKSON 2,856 2,902 46 1.6 DOWNER 3,624 3,622 -2 -0.1 DUFFY
2,843 2,698 -145 -5.1
DUNLOP
1,754 1,491 -263 -15
EVATT
2,234
FADDEN
3,097 2,853 -245 -7.9
FARRER
3,339 3,305 -35 -1
FISHER
2,993 2,773 -220 -7.3
1,916 -318 -14.2
FLOREY
1,977
1,722 -255 -12.9
FLYNN
2,561
2,186 -375 -14.6
FORDE
1,828
1,594 -235 -12.8
FORREST
3,663 4,188 525 14.3
FRANKLIN 1,380
1,169 -211 -15.3
FRASER
2,203
1,878 -325 -14.8
GARRAN
2,534 2,673 139 5.5
GILMORE
2,069
1,765 -304 -14.7
GIRALANG 2,418
2,070 -348 -14.4
GORDON
1,561 1,343 -218 -14
43
44
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan Table 19 Average change in Land Tax for suburbs under reform [continued] Suburb Current Land Tax New Land Tax Change ($) Change (%) average per dwelling average per dwelling ($) ($) 2,363
1,976 -387 -16.4
GREENWAY 1,017
GOWRIE
893 -124 -12.2
GRIFFITH 1,865 1,961 96 5.1 GUNGAHLIN 1,541
1,310 -231 -15
HACKETT 3,176 3,221 45 1.4 HALL
6,191 6,763 571 9.2
HARRISON 2,036 HAWKER
1,720 -316 -15.5
1,693 1,575 -118 -6.9
HIGGINS
2,565
HOLDER
2,356 2,147 -209 -8.9
2,196 -369 -14.4
HOLT
1,321
1,119 -201 -15.2
HUGHES 3,157 3,247 90 2.9 ISAACS
3,277 3,206 -71 -2.2
ISABELLA PLAINS
1,565
KALEEN
2,768 2,497 -271 -9.8
1,337
-229
-14.6
KAMBAH
2,183
1,901 -282 -12.9
KINGSTON 1,260 1,158 -103 -8.1 LATHAM
2,111
1,760 -351 -16.6
LYNEHAM 1,239 1,213 -27 -2.1 LYONS
2,224 2,241 17 0.8
MACARTHUR 2,468
2,154 -314 -12.7
MACGREGOR 1,605
1,356 -249 -15.5
MACQUARIE 2,420
2,264 -156 -6.4
MAWSON 1,927 1,905 -22 -1.1 MCKELLAR 2,646
2,342 -304 -11.5
MELBA
2,029
1,757 -273 -13.4
MONASH
1,739
1,517 -221 -12.7
NARRABUNDAH 3,548
3,749
NGUNNAWAL 1,374
1,198 -177 -12.9
NICHOLLS
1,876 -233 -11.1
OAKS ESTATE
2,109 882
763
201
-119
5.7
-13.5
O’CONNOR 4,021 4,299 278 6.9 O’MALLEY 7,001 7,835 833 11.9 OXLEY
2,054 1,829 -225 -11
PAGE
2,472 2,240 -231 -9.4
PALMERSTON 1,635
1,402 -234 -14.3
PEARCE 2,874 2,916 42 1.5 PHILLIP
1,033
907 -127 -12.3
PIALLIGO 5,814 6,277 464 6,245
REID
2,515 2,721 206 8.2
RICHARDSON 2,085
7,034
788
8
RED HILL
12.6
1,747 -338 -16.2
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
45
Table 19 Average change in Land Tax for suburbs under reform [continued] Suburb Current Land Tax New Land Tax Change ($) Change (%) average per dwelling average per dwelling ($) ($) RIVETT
2,772
2,473 -299 -10.8
SCULLIN
2,001
1,717 -284 -14.2 2,050 -367 -15.2
SPENCE
2,416
STIRLING
2,005 1,870 -135 -6.7
THARWA
1,889
1,601 -288 -15.3
THEODORE 1,778 1,511 -267 -15 TORRENS 3,497 3,486 -11 -0.3 TURNER 1,459 1,500 41 2.8 WANNIASSA 2,557
2,274 -283 -11.1
WARAMANGA 2,865
2,670 -196 -6.8
WATSON
1,705 1,658 -47 -2.8
WEETANGERA 3,442 WESTON
3,403
-39
-1.1
2,722 2,569 -153 -5.6
YARRALUMLA 6,707
7,511
804
12
46
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Abolishing Commercial Land Tax The ACT Taxation Review recommended that the Government transfer the commercial component of Land Tax to General Rates on commercial properties. From 1 July 2012, the Government will abolish Commercial Land Tax by combining it with the current Commercial General Rates system. This will simplify the current taxation system and reduce red tape for ACT businesses. Commercial properties will no longer need to pay land tax in the ACT. Table 20 Current Commercial Land Tax marginal rates and thresholds Current system until 30 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2012 Thresholds Rate (%) Rate (%) 0 to $150,000
0.89
0
$150,001 to $275,000
1.25
0
Above $275,000
1.59
0
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Residential General Rates The ACT Tax Review concluded that General Rates are an efficient and adequate tax. However, there is considerable scope to improve the rating system, and to establish it as a base for a stable, efficient and fair source of taxation. Improvements could also make the system more coherent to Government’s policy objectives. Effective tax rates are flat, as it is the feature of municipal services cost recovery system. Some progressivity exists because of the land values in the rating formulae. The ACT Taxation Review recommended that General Rates be levied through a two-part charge incorporating an element to meet the cost of providing basic city services and a progressive general taxation component contributing to general revenue. The Review Panel noted that the ACT is in a unique position among States and Territories to have access to a broad based land tax base in General Rates. The Government is adopting General Rates as a base for partial revenue replacement. The progressivity of the General Rates system is being improved with the introduction of a number of tax brackets and increasing marginal tax rates. From 1 July 2012, the new flat fixed charge will be $555 for all households. The current $16,500 AUV threshold is being abolished. Four thresholds are being introduced to improve progressivity of the system. Table 21 General Rates thresholds and marginal rates Thresholds Rate (%) 0 to $150,000
0.2236
$150,001 to $300,000
0.3136
$300,001 to $450,000
0.3736
Above $450,001
0.4136
Fixed charge
$555
Chart 18 Change in General Rates system 0.45
Rate (%)
0.40 0.35 0.30 0.25 0.20 100
200
300
400
AUV threshold ($’ 000) Current system until 30 June 2012 New system from 1 July 2012
500
47
48
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Impact on Households Overall, properties with an AUV below $200,000 will have a decrease in general rates. Around 24 per cent of properties will incur a decrease in rates payable, with 76 per cent incurring an increase. This, however, does not take into account the benefits received by households as a result of other reforms, such as reducing insurance duty. The increase in rates is not a new charge. General Rates on ACT households generally increase each year, in line with increases in the Wage Price Index (WPI). However, this Plan lowers the General Rates bill for almost a quarter of households, and adds modestly to the bill of most other households to accommodate the reduction and removal of other taxes as part of reform measures. The Government is very mindful of cushioning the impacts of tax reform on lower income households. The ACT Government provides a General Rates Rebate to eligible households. The maximum rebate available to eligible recipients is being increased from $481 to $565, reflecting the changes to the General Rates system. In addition the current RDS, allowing eligible households to defer payments of their general rates, will be expanded with the introduction of an additional set of standard eligibility criteria on which people can be assessed. The scheme will now be available for those people aged over 65 years; income will be assessed on the lessee’s joint annual income; and an AUV above $390,000 will be introduced. This will help alleviate any additional tax burden incurred as a result of moving to a more progressive General Rates system, in which households with a higher AUV will incur an additional increase in General Rates.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
49
Commercial General Rates Commercial General Rates will move towards a progressive system. Three thresholds and marginal tax rates are being introduced. From 1 July 2012, the fixed charge will be $1,213 and the $16,500 AUV threshold will be abolished. Table 22 Commercial General Rates Thresholds Rating factor FESL rating factor (%) (%) 0 to $150,000
1.9070
0.4093
$150,001 to $275,000
2.2670
0.4093
Above $275,001
2.6070
0.4093
Fixed charge
$1,213
These thresholds and tax rates also provide revenue replacement (or transfer) of commercial Land Tax. This change will reduce administration costs for business, and simplify the tax system. The transfer is cost neutral for individual businesses.
Impact on Business On average General Rates on a commercial property will increase by $1,211 replacing inefficient taxes, such as duty on insurance and conveyance duty. However, most of this revenue replacement is on properties with a value above $560,000. Commercial properties below the average AUV ($129,000) will incur an increase in General Rates ranging from $11 to $299. This table shows the average increase in commercial General Rates by AUV decile. Table 23 Commercial General Rates payable by AUV decile AUV deciles
AUV CURRENT tax NEW tax Change ($) payable ($) payable ($) ($)
1st
27,046 1,720 1,773 53
2nd
45,189 2,106 2,195 89
3rd
67,787 2,588 2,721 133
4th
94,336 3,153 3,339 186
5th
129,256 3,897 4,151 254
6th
186,333 5,244 5,610 367
7th
329,743 9,002 9,650 649
8th
563,819 15,627 16,736 1,109
9th
973,333 27,218 29,133 1,915
10th
2,300,333
64,779
69,304
4,525
50
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Utilities Network Facilities Tax (UNFT) The Utilities Network Facilities Tax (UNFT) is applied to the owner of a utility network facility that is installed on, or under land in the ACT. This includes gas, telecommunication, electricity, water and sewerage network providers. The amount of UNFT payable is calculated by multiplying the determined annual rate by the linear route length of the network. The ACT Taxation Review found that overall, the UNFT is an efficient tax as it is a tax on land consumed by linear infrastructure of utilities. As it is applied directly to utility providers and passed directly onto consumers, it is unlikely to distort investment decisions. The Government will align the amount of UNFT payable by utility network businesses in 2013 to reflect the growth in average unimproved land value since it was introduced in 2006. The UNFT rate per kilometre will increase to $921 per kilometre for the year ending 31 March 2013. This will be indexed by growth in WPI in future years.
Impact on Households The UNFT is charged to utility providers who then choose to absorb the cost or pass it onto consumers. In the event that businesses pass on all the higher UNFT costs, this is expected to increase average household utility bills on average by about $22 per year.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Expanding Assistance to Households The Government will continue to provide additional assistance for low income households to help cushion them from taxation reform. l
The Home Buyer Concession Scheme eligibility criteria will be more closely targeted.
l
The Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme will be expanded.
l A l
Rates Rebate of $565 will be provided to eligible households.
The Rates Deferral Scheme will be expanded.
Home Buyer Concession Scheme The Home Buyer Concession Scheme (HBCS) is an ACT Government initiative, administered by the ACT Revenue Office, to assist people in purchasing residential land or a home, by charging duty at a concessional rate. It provides a full concession on the amount of conveyance duty payable for eligible households. Other households are able to pay conveyance duty at a concessional rate. The ACT Government is expanding the current property thresholds and income criteria while also, closely aligning the HBCS with the NSW Government’s Scheme First Home New Home. These changes will better assist home buyers purchase a new property while also supporting new land supply and stimulating the local economy. As at 6 June 2012, the HBCS will only apply to the sale of new land or the construction of a new house. An eligible property will include: l
new homes;
l
substantially renovated homes; or
l
vacant blocks of residential land.
To increase accessibility to the scheme, the income threshold will be extended by 25 per cent to $150,000. This will increase by $3,330 for each dependent child, up to a maximum of five children. The Government is expanding the property value threshold at which a full duty concession is provided. This will increase to $385,000 for house and land. A partial duty concession is available for properties valued up to $450,000. The property values at which a full duty concession is available is for land only. This will increase to $235,000. A partial duty concession is available for properties valued up to $263,000. These changes will come into effect from 6 June 2012. The Charts on the following page show changes to house and land property thresholds under the reforms.
51
52
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan Chart 19 Changes to house and land property
Chart 20 Changes to land property thresholds
thresholds Median
Median Partial concession
Partial concession $375,000
$385,000
Full concession
2011-12
Partial concession
Partial concession $208,900
Full concession
From 6 June 2012
$235,000
Full concession
Full concession
From 6 June 2012
2011-12
note Median for house and land was $470,000 in 2011-12. For land only the median value was $263,000.
To ensure that there are no distortions to the market from undertaking this reform, the Government will continue with the current HBCS until 31 August 2012. At this stage it will be phased-out. Between 6 June and 31 August 2012, the two schemes will run concurrently so as to not cause market distortions and allow those in the housing market currently looking for a new property to continue doing so and receive the concession.
Table 24 Comparison of current HBCS system and new system Current system until 31 August 2012
New system from 6 June 2012
Thresholds- residential Duty payable Thresholds - residential Duty payable home (existing) home (new and renovated) $0 to $385,000
$20 (minimum duty)
$385,001 to $450,000
$24.10 for each $100 $385,001 to $450,000 that exceeds $385,000
$24.10 for each $100 that exceeds $385,000
Above $450,000
No concession
No concession
Thresholds - vacant block
Duty payable Thresholds–vacant block Duty payable
$0 to $235,000
$20 (minimum duty)
$235,001 to $263,000
$22.55 for each $100 $235,001 to $263,000 that exceeds $235,000
$25.55 for each $100 that exceeds $235,000
Above $263,000
No concession
No concession
Income eligibility threshold $120,000 note
$0 to $385,000
Above $450,000
$0 to $235,000
Above $263,000
$20 (minimum duty)
$20 (minimum duty)
Income eligibility threshold $150,000
The income eligibility threshold is increased by $3,300 per dependent child up to five children.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
General Rates Rebate Property owners who receive a Centrelink or Department of Veterans’ Affairs pension with entitlement to a Pensioner Concession Card, or a War Veteran’s pension are eligible for a rebate of up to 50 per cent of their rates, as well as a rebate of 50 per cent on the Fire and Emergency Services Levy shown on the rates bill. Pensioners in receipt of a rates rebate prior to 1 July 1997 are not affected by the capped rebate, and maintain their level of concession until they are no longer an eligible pensioner. Currently there are two types of General Rates Rebate recipients; uncapped and capped. Uncapped recipients are provided a 50 per cent rebate on their current General Rates under a grandfather clause in the Rates Act 2004. The rebate for capped recipients is calculated annually based on changes to both the rating factor and fixed charge. In 2011‑12 the General Rates Rebate was capped at a value of $481. As part of the Governments Taxation Reform Package the cap on the General Rates Rebate is being increased from $481 to $565. While current uncapped rebate recipients will receive change in their rebate equal to 50 per cent of the change in their General Rates bill. The change in the General Rates Rebate will reduce the rates payable for around 6,900 recipients (71 per cent) of the current capped recipients that live in a property with an AUV below $350,000, while alleviating the overall change in rates payable for the remaining 29 per cent.
53
54
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme The Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme (PDCS) provides support to older Canberrans to access accommodation appropriate to their needs. The scheme is open to an eligible pensioner who is in receipt of: l
an Australian age pension (Centrelink or Department of Veterans’ Affairs equivalent) and who holds a pensioner concession card;
l
a disability support pension and is 50 years of age or more and who holds a pensioner concession card, or
l
a Department of Veterans’ Affairs Gold Card for one year prior to the transaction.
Currently a full concession is provided on properties with a value up to $470,000 and a partial concession up to a value of $595,000. While a full concession is available on land with a value up to $208,900 and a partial concessional available on land with a value up to $260,000. The PDCS is being expanded to increase access and eligibility to the scheme by increasing the values at which a full and partial duty concession is available. Under the new system the value up until which a full duty concession is available (for existing houses) will be increased to $570,250 and a partial duty concession will be available for properties up until $715,000. The value up until which a full duty concession is available (for land only) will be increased to $300,000. A partial duty concession will be available for land up until $403,000. These changes are outlined in the table below.
Table 25 Comparison of current PDCS system and new system Current system until 30 June 2012
New system from 6 June 2012
Thresholds Duty payable Thresholds New duty payable residential home residential home 0 to $470,000
$20
0 to less than $570,250
$470,001 to $595,000
$20.75 for each $100 $570,251 to $715,000 that exceeds $470,000
$20.60 for each $100 that exceeds $570,250
Above $595,001
No concession
No concession
Thresholds–vacant land
Duty payable Thresholds–vacant land New duty payable
0 to $208,900
$20
$208,901 to $260,000
$15.45 for each $100 $300,001 to $403,000 that exceeds $208,900
$13.05 for each $100 that exceeds $300,000
Above $260,000
No concession
No concession
Above $715,000
0 to $300,000
Above $403,000
$20
$20
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Rates Deferral System The Rates Deferral System (RDS) allows eligible households to defer payments of their General Rates, on which a relatively low rate of simple interest is charged. Households eligible for deferral of rates include pensioners, property owners suffering substantial financial hardship, and people with disabilities. Under the Rates Act 2004, pensioners have a statutory right to defer their General Rates payment. From 1 July 2012, the following eligibility criteria will apply. The criteria include tests based on age, AUV and income. l
Age test: Lessees aged over 65 years of age will be able to access the scheme.
l
Income test: Lessees’ combined income must be below annual average earnings (currently $80,770).
l
Asset test: The unimproved land value must be higher than the 80th percentile value (currently $390,000), to be adjusted annually.
l
Equity test: Lessees must have at least 75 per cent equity in their home.
These changes will allow a greater number of older Canberrans to access the scheme and help alleviate any additional pressure incurred from tax reform.
55
56
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Abbreviations ABS Australian Bureau of Statistics ACT Australian Capital Territory AFTS Australia’s Future Tax System AUV Average Unimproved Value AWE Average Weekly Earnings AWOTE Average Weekly Ordinary Time Earnings DDS
Duty Deferral Scheme
CGC
Commonwealth Grants Commission
CPI
Consumer Price Index
FHOG First Home Owner Grant Scheme GSP
Gross State Product
GST
Goods and Services Tax
NSW New South Wales PDCS Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme RDS Rates Deferral Scheme UNFT
Utilities (Network Facilities) Tax
WPI
Wage Price Index
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Glossary Average Unimproved Value (AUV): In the ACT, the average of the past three years unimproved land values. Compliance cost: Expenses incurred in meeting the requirements of legislation or regulations. Compliance costs include a wide range of monetary and non-monetary costs. Duty Deferral Scheme (DDS): Under the Duties Act 1999, an eligible person who purchases an eligible property can elect to defer payment on their conveyance duty. Efficiency: Efficiency means making the best use of resources. ‘Technical’ or ‘productive’ efficiency means producing as many goods or services as possible from a given set of inputs. ‘Allocative’ or ‘economic’ efficiency means putting productive resources (like labour, land or capital), to their highest value use and distributing goods and services to consumers in a way that best satisfies consumer needs and wants. First Home Owner Grant Scheme (FHOG): States and Territories are required to fund a FHOG to offset the impact of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on the price of new homes. General Rates Rebate system: Property owners who receive a Centrelink or Department of Veterans’ Affairs pension with entitlement to a Pensioner Concession Card, or a War Veteran’s pension are eligible for a rebate of up to 50 per cent of their rate. There are two categories of rebates recipients; uncapped and capped. Uncapped recipients are provided a 50 per cent rebate on their current General Rates under a grandfather clause in the Rates Act 2004. The rebate for capped recipients is calculated annually based on changes to both the rating factor and fixed charge. Goods and Services Tax (GST): The GST is an indirect, broad-based consumption tax. Gross State Product (GSP): The total value of production within a State or Territory which is the State/Territory equivalent of gross domestic product. Home Buyer Concession Scheme (HBCS): The HBCS is an ACT Government initiative, administrated by the ACT Revenue Office, to assist persons in purchasing residential land or a home, by charging duty at a concessional rate. Pensioner Duty Concession Scheme (PDCS): The PDCS assists eligible pensioners who move to accommodation more suited to their needs (for example, moving from a house to a townhouse) by charging duty at a concessional rate.
57
58
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Glossary Percentile: The ACT population or ACT property values distributed into 100 equal sized groups in order of income or value. For example, the 50th percentile is the middle or ‘median’ group. Progressive taxation: Where the average rate of tax increases as income increases. Rates Deferral Scheme (RDS): Under the Duties Act 1999, an eligible person who purchases an eligible property can elect to defer payment on their General Rates bill. Utilities (Network Facilities) Tax (UNFT): A charge on owners of utility network facilities, including electricity, water and wastewater, gas and telecommunications. Volatility: The volatility of tax collection is measured in this paper by the variance of tax collections around their compound annual growth rate. Wage Price Index (WPI): The WPI is a price index which measures changes over time in wages and salaries for employee jobs, unaffected by changes in the quality or quantity of work performed. Changes in wages and salaries resulting from changes in the composition of the labour market are excluded from the WPI movements.
A fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system >>> 5 year reform plan
Find Out More Find out more about the ACT Government’s five year plan to a fairer, simpler and more efficient taxation system visit: l ACT
Treasury website: www.treasury.act.gov.au
l ACT
Revenue Office website: www.revenue.act.gov.au/functions/contact
or phone (02) 6207 0028
59