a situation calculus approach


           

   ! !"#$%"& '(
  )+*-,/.$01)2.$,4315768):9;680:9)1?2?2@A3B)168C

DE>FGIHKJ LME>NJOPN Q

Z]S/RTnohBcel&S?A@CBD H G
GKZLONP5QRS%ST9LU5VXW
z

j69Uk8 q/]|]Z_‚UWUklX]|V=tp¶›`]Zdu_XS…UkqzYZrmvbt fgSUWYZVXVXS/[`[`Bq/YZY`noSœdXUknolX[`cep&lX]Zno_XlXSp‚XS*)t|S/S2q/];qœUkckl j ´ VXS/YZ noŠw S , ¢ !   "&t  4%5 $ ) -¢ !   +&  ¤Z¤ UklXV
  -¢ !   4%5 $ ) ¢   4%5 $ ) -¢ !     ¤`¤Z¤ j}YZcwh ]`_XS…VXSzjUWvXfo]$›Z[ZvbaXaucw[Zno]ZnocwlX
, -¢ ,  3./0 698   4%5 $ ) ¢   4%5 $ ) -¢ !   +& 4¤Z¤`¤ ]Zdu_mS/vXq\ce[2hBcwdXS…]ˆh$UWngmlb[Znglb]`S/pBYZno]Zcw_bvXS2[Zfoj$UWhBvXlXcwfovXcm[£UkVXUWS/lXVAceh1VXvXUkY`fonglbž p$UW]Zq/_Xq/S…cwYZt;VXUknolXno] p1UW]Zq/c1]ZnoVXcwl-S¨j€ UkvXfo]…]Z_bS/ceY`   * ]`_XS$pevbl„h1U4 ˜ _XS/YZS:ng[$Uklbce]Z_bS/Y8a‚S/q/vbfgnUWYZno]ŒT]ZcMduS1lXcw]ZS/VŽ_XS/Y`Se|YZS/fUk]`S/V]ZcM]Z_XSAjUWq/]&]Z_uUW]8nolK]`_XS
UkfoS$¥m_Xcmce]`nglbpBVXcwhPUknolT¢}UW[…ceYZnopwngl‚UkfofoBVXS/[`q/YZnod‚S/VKdm £UWlXrm[8UklbV
q S/Y`hBce]`]ˆ¤t|S UWYZS lXVXceS/[Z]2q\YZ]`noceaXfoVM]Znocwt;l=_XS/S/lm]Z_b]ˆUWS/ngY8fo[|cwlXY…S/lXno]Zce_b]2S/Y ]`_XS$pevblTng[…nolXno]ZnUWfgfoAfgcmUkVXS\V-€$“Iq\q/ceY`VXnolXpefom]Z_XS&•&—KVXcwhPUknol 









`-ab`c/`deef !   " 

lXceY `-ab`c/`deef
!   "
VXXcmY`ceS/h[IlX]`cw_X];S S/šlm]ˆSœUWUkngqzf_u]`UW_XdXS2nofgfonono]Œ]Z S/Yz |Ukcwf YZcwfgfUWYZ&ng¢-] ! j}cefofockt;[œ4j’ce¤\Y|€ nglb[Z]ˆUWlXq/Sem]`_uUk]|cevbY?A@CBD H G HGKZLONP5QRS%ST9LU5VXW




aucw[Z S/$q/cwhBauUWYZno[Zcwl-4nol$]Z_XS;VXS¨jUkvXfo]^]`_XS/cwYZ  * ckj £UWlXrm[nolXq\fgvbVXSS/¦mS/q/vX]zUkdXnofono]ŒTaXYZcwaucw[Zno]Znocwl `  p+h/h ` e m  ` n  #   ' nol :1
4%  8  ) ¢ 1 ¤    ¢  # &1 ¤ 


) ¢  ' &1 ¤
“Inglbfong[Z]`c1nUknof‚lX[Zq/no]ZfovXvuVXUWS&]Znoce]Z_bl{S&XUkj}lXcefoV1fock]Zt;_bnoS£lXq\p8ce[`hBno¦=hA[Zce]zlXUklX[`S/VulXUW[`YZSIVMfU4YZt>vXfoS/ck[‘jj}nocelXY…S/YZYZ]`S4nUkUXqz€ _uUkdbngfono]ŒmXq/cwhBaXfoS/]`S/lXS/[`[2ckj'%&4', ]0P  L - +, "_ . T0P V RL ^Y+R /P  W _ / L&P U    P 1U5Q9S% P S U  L8"V dS -U5V LOV%RU 

q _ 9 r; d=  ?s=A_)e$' gIGIG"t7D@I%$I[IaI%uD@=I%A ?@=I%_v4 wa"!$#%$'! !)*I' %$', _ P L &S U5V J 4L 3 9LOV x _ . P5Q P5RZST0L&U5V L CU5N 9U 9\oU 9U S U 

VXL&P U    y _ 9 z; d=  ?B=A B:#FGIo", ]9 P  L - 5, _ Y V

U J Q  T

 R )P , J "_  LLORP /P S P  { P VXST0P , P  _|RP \ V  N T S S }_  S U  ST  VXL S L 3L S L&[S L  L P 1 SVX P &S  U _ 9 ~ =I>€+a%I*‚=I('lM=AT)e$'_:Bv# i"]^ %I*biYjk\]&="l  X
\y=I%Tƒ…„I(' %$[Ia%I*T†$e$'=I 'lB=AN: =I%5, ]0P  L - +, _

. T S

U N SQ0P/S U & P5R

w



m 

u

‚

*  Û4ÒZÒ . 1mÝ Ùgÿ 3wÙgÎ/ÑÖ 6\ÒZÏkÒZђÖ/ý4Ö/ÜZÜ`Î/ËkÏ4×XÎzÙuђÒZ͒×}ђݹÜZגÒZÌ|Ø;Î/ÏkÎ/גÎ/Ïkݹ܌ݹ׍à\ë

k





J 

_



J 

_

J 

w/_

J 

_

e _

J  m

J 

_



P K

_

{ 

_

  N

"_

  N

"_

  

_

 /

/"_



_



_

 KAU5V

"_

K

_

K

_

K

P _

K

7T9P LXR J LOR NU xP U|;RP \ V  N T SS _ 9T L S P1RL o \ U "LXR L&\oPS

NU5V RU 

]VXU  VXP \o\   _9  / U 1LOVXS { U bP5R d P { L  9LST  U bL , L S U V ,}ZY=*I  ; >=*+>I\b\W %I*Ic ; >= ?=A)e$'
 A)eu#%$h !ND@=I% A?NI%$[TiYj"\]^?f, ]0P  L
-
5, "_ K

7T9P LXR J LXR NU  P  _|;RP \ V  N 7T S S _ v U 

b]VX U  VXP \  S T XRP 

P R 9L /P  S U  ^_ 9 KZ P `  P5V VXL  P  m LS LOV +SLXVXL , L S U5V ,YZY=*I  ; d=*IdI\W\b % *+c ; d=  ? =Av)e$'
")eT#%$h !@D@=I% A' d' %$' , ]9 P  L , "_ K

7T9P LXR J LOR NU  oP  W|;RP \ V  N T S S Y _ . RP 

&P5 R 9L  P/S U   R U 

]"VXU 5VXP/\ P  -Q  S )` L "P/S P 19P L : _ v' N' %$' dI =I% D@=I\]^X5 %I*", 2  -  +, /_ K

7T9P LXR J LOR NU  P  |;RP \ V  N 7T S S @ _ / LO]VXL L S   P S U AP   7T9P   NL 1W R U 

^]"VXU 5VXP/\ : _ CI=IX
%$"!^=ABZY=*I  ; >=*+>I\b\W %I*", 2 -  +, _ K

7T9P LXR J LOR NU  , |RP \ V  N T S S , P P R 0P m V SW\%

Q  d/P , P  RK VXU RP V Q S S W  d _ K Q  S )` L "LXNP5QRS _ 9 pQ P \oL  R RL  ,&/

T9P5V   L , P  Y+V  P  L bP R R , L S U V , ; 4a%$  ]Y!)'lN=A%$=s!)'[ *I''d]^d'l ' %$I(a=I%_I%$[
'"l =I%$ %I*Ic ; >= ?@=Av)e$'vt5%$[b#%$h ! D@=I% A' d' %$' , ]9 P  L - ,

_ KAP S ST9L J 

d1LXV (P  AK _ Y _ \ ST _ / LP U    P 1U5Q9S P S U 

99 2 bT0v L 6 Q9P5R  8 &P S U  ]VXU 1RL\ N _ v   "!5#%$' !a!)*I'%&4'4, 2 - +, _ S L ` L P P 
 P  CK;VXL RK KZLOVX\oU/S S @ _  U 0\oU 0U/S U 

^R U 

^P  CS L\^]U VXP5R]VXU   L S U  _ v4   "!5#%$'! !)*I' %$'4,   2 - +, _ J I_  L&LORP /P S P  { P VXST0P P  |;RP \ V  N 7T S S @ T  VXL S4L 3L S _  S U   S )]"VXLXR \ 0P VXW VXLX]U5VXS  _ 9 z; d=  ?B=A7)e$'Y=IX54)e #%& h !BD@=I% A?v=I% ; 4a%$  ]Y!)'l_=A v%$= !)'4[ *I'w' ]^>'l' %$I =I%_I%$[
w'4"l =I%$ % * , ]9 P /L / -
, _ |;RP \ V  N T S S _ "VXP \oL  ST0L ]0P L%U5 N SQ0P/S U  w_    "!5#%$'! !)*I' %$', 2  -
, _ |;RP \ V  N T S S w _ / L SV

S L \oU 9U S U 

SW : _ 9  ; d=  ?YBBv#FG"OI, ]9 P /L  , "_ 0P  "SXT0 L    _ Yv\ 1"VXP   &P5Q P5R SW  ]L N W   ST9L  VXL So4L 3 L S %U5N P  S U  N_ 9  ; d=  ?@=AB#C$DY#F GIH", ]0P  L ", _ 0P  "SXT0 L    P  / P W\oU  / L S LXV _ S P/S L U 

SVXP S VX L ` S L q _ CI=IX
%$"!Y=A ZY=*I I%$[ D@=I\]^X
I =I%
,9   2 - 5, /"_  ]L P R 9  Q9L(U   &S U  ^P  m VXU &L  L _ |;RP \ V  N T S S^P  P  Q U  QV 0LOV _  ]R S S  CP RU 

%]"VXU 5VXP/\ _ 9  m P P5R |tP  P L S L VXW  , L S U5V , ; d=  ?@ƒs!)' ' %$)en#%& h !D@=I%A ?s=I%7ZY=*I  ; d=*IdI\W\b % * , ]0P  L - , _ |;RP \ V  N 7T S S P  P

Q U  QV 9LOV _ VXU \ -Q  S )` L ]VX U  VXP \ S UAP 15 Q S U  x _ 9  QQ V  L  K [ , Q m LOVXL VXP , P  +LU U5V m V SW\% Q  d , L S U5V ,

m



X w 

w

w e4  w

‚

w 



^

s w

‚

v=I%
F7=I%$=I=I%$) ƒ…„I'%5l =I%5lB=AvZY=*I  ; >=4*I>I\b\W %I* ZE'4 X
>'=I' l %v4  F   "!Y#%$' !a!)*I'%&'BG"t , ]0P L - _  ]"V   LXVd|LOV RP , _ K U5V V _ bT0L%P0U/\oP5RU Q

L[S L  Ug]VXU1RL\  LONP Q"RSMVXL&P U   _Wv()F m P5QR A   "!$#%$'! !)*I' %$'4,   2 -
, _   S U V A K P5VXL4 P K VXU RP V Q S S W  d _ / L ` U ]VXU  VXP \o\   _ K PQ O V ]9S , A _   S U VBA K P VXL4 P pK VXU RP V Q S S W  d _@/ L`  U ]L 8  P/S  U B1 W^\ LP U5N+]VXU  VXP \ _9  ZE=4*I l: %v#? ; >=''4[I % * l=AvC"ƒsZ^#> h G $, _   S U VNA K P5VXL4 P _K VXU RP V Q S &S W!  d _^/ L`  UC]"VXU5 VXP \ \   , "P/S P9 1 P L Q"] "P/S L tP S L 5 V  S-W  U SVXP S _E9  ; >= ?&=A )e$'NHI)eb#%$h !$D…=I%A?$=I# % "I $4"l ' †$e$'=I4j , ]9P / L - I, _



{

-

m



U VX\oPLK . P  P P Q UQV0LXV _ P Q

P RST0L&U5VXW U N+VXP \ 8 P/S U ^P 6 Q0P R  8 &P S U  _v9  ; d=  ?@=AB#C$DY#F GIH", ]0P L -
, _ +LU U5V m VSW\%Q

 d P P Q U QV0LOV _ ]
P S Lp1W \oLP U5N NLOVXL  L V Q"RL _N9 = ? =Av)e$'O5>[_#%$h !@D@=I%A ?@=I%TZY=*+a ; d=*IdI\W\ba%I*pI%&[bv=I%$\W=I%$="F =I%$   w'4"l =I%$ %I*", ]0P  L -
, _ P/ 5W\ U / L  S LXV _  RU 

NU V LONP Q"RS VXL&P U   _ v4   "!:#%$'! !)*I' %$', *  ",  2 4- * +, _ Y‚V  P Lb P R R _ Y'I(X5d'l:I%$
V [ NU V  ) ` LOV  S-W m VXL  , _ [ @!)X5'%& Xl _ M K

7 T9P LXR bT  LOR 7 T9LOV _v/ LO]VXL L S  A  P & S  U  L 6 Q0P/S  U9P5RbRU

^ ]VXU  VXP \o\   _ | P P L S L"VXW  , L  S U5V ,vZY=*I  ; d=*IdI\W\b % *+c ; d=  ?B=AT)e$'7gIgI)e 9  m P  P RB #%$h !@D@=I% A' d' %$' , ]0P  L

- 5_ K 9 m VXL  , _ K

7 T9P LXR bT LXR 7 T9LOV _w. U \^]Q0S  ^  VXP/\ 8 & P S  U 1 W ]U S]VXU  L    _9 L; >= ?Y=A #C$DY#F GIH", ]9P  L

- 5, _ P Q UQ"V9LOV _ 

 0L RU

A ]"VXU5 VXP \ _ 9  A K P5QV

 L  V Q0W 9UU  T0L , L  S U5V , ZY=*I  ; d=*IdI\W\W %I*Ic ; >= ?@=Av)e$'WgIGIG T#%$h !$iYjk\]&="l  X5\, ]9P / L 4- +, "_ P Q UQV9LOV _B/ LO]VXL L S  A  P & S  U  LONP Q"RSRU 

k2   SQ9P S  U  P5R O QR Q P5]]"VXU/P T _ 9  ~ =I>€I %I* ; 4]&'lM=A_)e$'7†$e$ >[TiYj"\]&="l X5\=I%uZY=*I "! Y=I4\W"!F  I(a=I%
lN=A_D@=I\W\b=I%5l' %
l  ' '"l =I%$ %I*", "_ P Q UQV9LOV _  ]R  S S   P LONP5QRS%ST9LU5VXW _:9 r; >= ? =A:BBv#FG ", "_ +U

1 _

K m

_

/

L _



 bT

_

 Q"V

/"_

 Q"V 

1«

‚

e u

e



 QV 1 _

s 

‚



P _

 

s 

ws 

 P _

 bT /"_




 e

"_

P5]]LP V _ KAP5V P  9L    RLS S _x/ L&P U   P1 U5Q9S P &S UxQ  ]"VXU/ P T _9 = ?@=AN:B#I, ]9P  L -
,  "_





P ]U  1"RL \oU "LXR AP5]5

I­1±1¬*
 |¬/®2®2¬/­"! 7±  $² ®® …°$¯ ´nglbl2p„]Z_XUknoq/[]`UknoceaXlXa‚[2S/lXnolTVXnoVX¦…S¨t|jUkSxvXdbfo]2YZnoSzfocwŸupe…noq ]ZvbUWYZlXl&VTcevXfoceY-pwUWng]Zq$]ZS\ablsYZ]`cenopwceYˆl…UWj}hBY`cehBhn†lX]Zpu_X‚S–no[ZlTa‚S/ceq/Y`n VX‹ S/q|Y&aX]ZYZc=cwdXabfoS/YZS/hi[`S/cklmjX]$YZS\]ZaXS/qzYZ_XS/[`lXS/nolmqœUW]Œy f YZS/_X[`vXS/cefo]ZY`[$S/h q/cwlXUWq/lXS/VKY`lX¥mnolXaXp„fono]ZVb]`ngSzlbjpUkvb¥”fg]¶S/¾m]ZvX_XS/S/lXcwq/YZSnoS/[&no_XlTS/cepeY`S/S/lXhS\YˆUkj}cefŒY¶€ VX˜ Sz_XjUWS/vX[ZS1fo]2Y`foS/ce[ZpevXnofoq¶]`[j}YZ cwh]Z_X¸ S1vX¥mYzaXº foWnode]Z]`¼ nglb p ¥”UWS/YZS] ˜lXS/S/VXS\V=j}cwYlbS\q/[ZSK]`S1_uUkd‚YZS/]^S/[`]ŒS4vXt|UkfoS/qz]Z_BS/[$lihA]`cehBcspeVbS\cm]ZS/VX_XfuS\S/UkfgY$[&lbV$t;ckjDnongfo]`f|: ]Z
‡YZS/vbhA]Z_ThPckUXjI€ Ukfof{ŠeUkfovXS&aXYZcwaucw[Zno]Znocelb[œt;_Xnoqz_Mt;ngfof{[Zv[q/€ cw2lX]`[Z_XnoVXS/YZS/S¶Yng]Z[I_XY`U&S/S2[`]ˆqœUWUW]ZS[ZS/[4€ [ZvXqz_=]`_uUk]    ˜   )      ¸  4%  8    ¢`¸  ¼}¤ 
¢ b  ¤’¼
˜]Œt V ` ] u _ k U ] ¢ ¢ ` ¤ B ¤ o n 1 [ T U Z [ z ] k U ` ] e S € · ‡ / S ] ‚ d T S ¢  !4¤  8=¢ ¤\e]` _XS/l $  8  ¢Z¸ ¢ !4¤’¼}7¤ $   sUWlXVBt|SIq4$ UklB q\celX q/fovX VbSIdm´  ]Z_XS2$ab YZS/ŠmnocevX([;foS/hAhPU ]Z_‚Uk]  4%¢  ¢ $  )!œ ¤Z¤|no[;$ U& [Z]zUk]ZSw€
 # !  88     )    $  $0    : $ 8  8      ¢ X¢  ¤`¤ U]Zk _uq/ ]`UWng] cw l1 [Z€ ]ZY` nono[‘lXpeU½[‡[ZS/]Z]`cBhAYZvX[`hPq/]ˆ]`UWU vX]ZS/YZ SA[€ t;! j}cwM_XYceUk:1[`lXS2V€ VX]`ce_Xh1_mS=vXUk[4aXnol$ Y`S/XnoŠm[;¢ ngcwlXvXce[$lb¤…S/fonohBS/[…hBaXVXh1]ŒS 1UXlbUk S/lXV-V1€& aXRTY`noS [$S8‹ ¦wauh$yŒUkq/vbY`fo]Zce[Zn]I[ZUkS\fš[`V-_Xj}‚ckvXt;tlX_Xq\]`]Zno_uqˆnoce_1UklŽ] [`_Xj} Y`ckcet;h [  ¤Z¤\€ ˜ c8d‚S/penol-mno];no[;SœUW[Z˜ B]`c$ŠeS/Y`n†j}$ ]Z_uUW] ‹ ¢ X  ¢    ¤   - #    ¢ X¢  ¤  …¢  ¤`¤ /
  ¢ X¢  ¤Z7  

;S/qœUWfof-]Z_‚Uk] ! 

88





%















#













%



































 



.-  #    /






ƒ…noŠeS/lTT]` _XS/[ZS1 cwdX[ZS/Y`ŠeUk¢ X]`ng¢ cwlX[œ{¤
t| SB…[Z¢ S\SB]Z¤Z_‚¤\€Uk]2no]2t;nofof^d‚SB[Zv Bq/noS/lm]8]`c=[Z_Xckt]`_uUk]…j’ceY2S/ŠwS/YZ $ j  no[^U; fonohBno]u cw YZVXnoluUWfŒœ ]`_Xno[-no[]ZY`ngŠmnUkfofoI]`YZvX"S re[`c‘UW[Z[`vXhBS^]`_uUk] no[^U;lXcwlmyfonohBno]‚ceY`VXnoluUkf UklXV1´ fo$ S/]  {žd‚S2]Z_XE S2UWq/]Z8=noce¢ l1[`]ZYZ¤/no€ lXp$l=[`vX]Z_Xqz_1no[…]Zqœ_uUWUW[Z] Se{ dm =]Z¢_XS&$ ¤/VX€ S lXcknot ]Znoceq/lMcelXck$ [`j noVXXS/·YItt;[;¥mnodmhB=nof‡UkS\Y`hBfgm{hPdsU Ž]Z€_X$S:]`_uVXUkS ‹ ‹] lXno]` ngcwlb€ ckj _mvX [œ|dmt





























































































































   5  "        8  5   :  H  "0 )

8      /.    8  5    :  H     5  "3      -3  # '"X'  w'
  # ' O'
 ' )

   8 ( /3   # 


    D      

¢ $¤



-   0   /3   !: $  8  0        8    .   $   $ o       "0         # 


  '    J " 8  !



¸ ¼ ¸ ¼ ¸ ¼ ¸ ¼  t[ˆ UkUW hAYZV=S1 ]` S/c$¦m€ ]ZVX˜S/S/lXc ]Z[`S\noYZd‚cehBS/lXpw[4nolXng€ l{S¶2]Zd‚_uKUWS/qœ];]`Uk_X]ZvbS_X[ZS2S |Vbcw: SzYZjYZUkS\novb[ZlXa‚fgq/]cefovXlX]Z_XVXVXS\S\S\ce[=lXYZq/nolXSS/c>[ Še_X UWS/¢ fg¢cwvbYZSTS/:$hMaX¤`¤£YZ^cwUWt|aulXS=cwV [Znorm]ZXlXno¢ceck:$lbt¤š[œ…_u]Z_XnoU4]=S/ŠeY`S2noS=[=abnoYZ[Z[BS/]`Yˆq/UMUWno[`ngceS/pwfolX_mPS¨]Œyj}]`cw]`_XckYŒS yy ce]Z_ulXUWS$]œq/|cwj}YZcwY`Y$S/[ZS/a‚ŠeceS\lXYZVbS/hBlXq/cmS= VXd‚S/f S/]Œt|S/cWS/lŽj :hBcmUWVXlXS/Vfo[Iq/cWcej Y`YZ:7S/[`auUW˜cwlXlXV„VXq\nolXcepŽlX[`ngS/[`¦m]Z]ZS/S/lmlX]&[`noS/ce¦mlK]ZS/: cwlXUWfolXKWV n†jB