Adaptive Nonlinear System Identification with Echo State Networks. Herbert Jaeger. International University Bremen. D-28759 Bremen, Germany.
"! #$ " &%(')* + , & - ./'0- 1* 2 , 435 DFE+GI`HKJIaFEMb LNc+GI6"dSOQe P 7+fgEM8:LS\^9;R@JX7+T$Hh8:_iEUOQHhV =@EkHK?AjAJX7+WIl1OYBCG[HK7+Z]JI8 _m\^L JIHKE+_>Z HKE nUo phq&rts&rhuNvxwzy|{~}uIrhmroz r
1 |UC JX;£ L JXRHKUWIEAP>HhHJXW[G[V G^P&LNP OYGXJJXH1¤ ]EAEUGXHHhJXG[G[L ^OYEUP P&JXOQJIEUMW1j+1¥JI^P&|_¦E*^§UL U(JIO¨H1]L0P&GXEAEAUWIPNH4OQV W~¢|HhGXH©RWW~LSPSOQAJI;H©UL]¢]JIP+RQP&L L |JIGI&mAH |GXjMP0G$ UJX¡|OQWxHKHKh¢@P&Uª|j@JXGXJXJIL HKHKOYhE&EAUG^HKJI¢«EUJXHhHhª+UE+Z Ga GIGIJOQ_mLSOQLSEUR^OQEUP m|GXW~UU|OYGXGiL ªURQH HKOY&P &|GGXW4U|ªCGHKhP P&_iEUEUHKH©W>¬GIL®OQP RQE2OYEA^HKLSHhJ©OQ j+UGXEUWKO¨¯+`UHhHhRQGIZ°HhJXW~_iP&RYOYVNEML LNªUGIOQRYP H]EGXL&P W~P&|PSa ±²WIhJI|OQ³ªCHKW_iLSOYEUEOQ_iP EUOY´©RQLNO EUGXHmOYP&EkL ¢U¶L |µxGXULSO¨GIW>OQP L E*J~GXWXOQhURYH«HK_>JIHKHiVOYªAHKL&$W~W4H©¢²GXUP&HE²ªAGXL UWIHmOQ]·$OQ¸¢UHK*L LSWiRQ L P&EAJI¢¶OYGIA¢|_Hha ¢|EUHhJ PN§E²¥·$JXP ±®_¹½L WI¢UZ|L W[|GXGIHhOQ_¾V HiO¨W RQOYEUL H©¢ULSL J4|GIWIOQZ|V W[HKGXRYHhZ_mO¨Wh¢|mHhE+GIOYW4 AH©LS¢@E0Hµx¡ULSU_iH>URQEUH PNj§LE²ºK»NªCa¼HhGIEA*H UP GJIWa PSP EUH©GIWhUÀkH4WI·$CHK¸2OY MLSKRQLS RQP YZ&JXjMOYGIGXUU_mHiW§P hL EJIV&JXHhZmJX PNHhV EMHKJ;H ¥JXJP LN_¿GIH>RYLSOQEUEAH©¢®LSJ$_>WIO¨ZWXL W~GI¢:HKÁ[_mAW~W^GI_iGIPiHKE&EUG4P EAKRYLSOQE®EUHKªCL HJ ¢|HGXHhJX_iOYEUH©¢LNG$¢|HKWIOQ E«GIOQ_>H&  Ã&Ä |UŧÆÇCUÈ~Å Ä DtCG HhJXOQWV+O¨WILSHKOQ¢gJGIGXJP2LSOQWXEUL:OYZ«EAGIAGXLSHKG U¢|EAOYOQÉ)¯+UUH©WRYGI¥OQP HKJW1JX§HKOYGIA*JIJXHHh¡|E+OQGÊW~GIEUOQEUHhUJLSLSRQR| EAP&HJIG[OY^GIUP _mJXWWxAËL:·$V HgWIP)WX¥L JXJP _(AJIH©§OQRQ¢|AH©¢|W~HKA¢²JIH©W~L |¢ a GIA£ P)JXWIHKH WIWI]UHhCJX̧V HhÍP&JXnUOYVJήOQ¤mWIHKϬP ¢«ÐtxqSGIÐt¢|JriZLSEAOQEUrL OQм_iEUÑ;mOQÎNKuIPSW ÒNÓϧ·$U^OQ|°WKK^WLS1ÔEURQªMJXL PNHmJIV+&HhO¨Hi¢|¡|HihP OÕGXL2JHK¢|¢EUHhPNJªV PSZ²HKxRÊWIºKL U» EAOÕG»&¢*LSWxªUHKPSRQL Z²WIUOQAHhEUJ1JIOYH©GXGIW~WP"HK§E&_m·$GXHKLS¢*EMÔLSOYEA O¨UHiW§|ALSG0AWIHKL U¢"EAJIP+¢ML&L Ö:W§P&L J ¥ªHKZ"¢|a¼GIªAJL&LSOQEUmOQEUP A|mGXUDF|EG©;P&JXµx¢|UHKH J1GIP&P®EUEUP&HK_iGIUOQP |E«GIH)LHKOY&¢|&H©W~GOQW^JXHKPS¢*×GXP U|O¨W§GXUJI|H©GgW~HK¢|JIV&ZP EAOQL J;_>EUO¨HhhG[WKj×P&P&JIEU)RQZ"L JIGIH1UEUHmP ^G§HhOQM LS+EUGW&HKPS¢ GI¥P P2P&AEUL)EAEU¢²H©RQOY¬EAOQGIE5HKOQP LSEMØJ1e:WxÙJXHh¥Ø JI ÚNP&JXÙ¼_¦mHKWX³WIGXOYUP&GIEkH |JIGXH©P µxW~JXHKUOQL JIH0V&RÊP GIOQUWmOQJ^HKØÛP GId©PiJXÙtZ«>GIAÜP H4WIP OQ|_>UGXOQUR¨LSWK|jMJ GJXOQAH¢U¥EUHKHKOÕL2JIGHKW$AEALSL JXH©W1H4WJXhHKL L hEARQHh¢"hE+UGI_mR¨RQLNZ®LSGIH©EªC¢@ZHh;HhHEµx¡UULSOQEA_iO¨W§¢|UHhªCRQCP HKHhW1OQREMWh¢|L ¢|HhE®PNE+§GIªCRQZE H OQEUE+HhV&G[HKW~P&GIOQJI&|LSWXGI¤]HK¢]Ø cNÙOYEØ f:L>Ùt _iP JXHªUOQP RQP &OQKLSRQYZiP&JIOQHhE+GIH©¢]WIHGIGIOQEUiUEA¢|HKJxGIUH EAL _iHP £ RQO¨¯&AOQ¢2W[GLNGXH DFWXEݯ&MGILSUJXO¨HKWWX¤"LSJIGI·$O¨¸RQH*UD2L RY¢|&HKP WXJXOÕJXGXOYUªC_HjMUL]PNÞ_>HhGIU|P|¢W"¥hP&L JEL&ªCW[G1HP hEUP RQENO EUÁ[P&H0OYEUL&H©¢U¢LS|§GLNOYGIGXOYP&E"GIU+H EAPN£ §JIH©EU¥JIJP&W~OQ_ßV H²RQO RYEUH©HKL L W~GJ WIWIZZW~W~GIGIHKHK_m_/Wh§5OÕGXµxUHAOYJX&HKWIU¯+RÕAGXOYLSEARQOYG[Z·OQ¸E+aFP E|V&ßHhJXO¨ WmHhEMhL AH]LSWIªUMRQHKHHK¢PSLSGIEAJ¢L JIH©OYEAW~O¨¢|ALàL RºK»SHKaËJIGXJXP J©P&°JX¢|áUHKUJiJIGIEUUP HKEUJI_iRQO EUP&HKJIL H&J j GILSARQ H PN$L UWUP&JXEUP&H1L&GI)P)Z¢|OYH©HKW~RQOQ¢U W§E2L EUUP&JXEUOYP&RYOQJIEUOCH©HKLSW~JxGIOQGI_mJL LNGI&H©HhWxJPSWL&GIhJhL P J¢|OYEAOYEAggCGXHhPiJI¥WIP CJXHK_iOYL MEAKLNH1GIOQAP L EMJXWL âN_> HhGIHKJXW^LSEA¢]GIAW ã[ä;åæ çKåæè©éhê[ëæì[í&î ï çKð+ñ ò¬çhåæòó+åÕçhì[ëæéKð+ï ñ&ôXïFòXê[ëæõ|ô¬ñ ëæð ì[í+ëæï çhêFì[ëæòåæô çê[ô òéKð&ö
QOP E&mu¬GXJIмOQwP|EUÍ ¢|H$rmMRQHKÎSL HKuËWgJIs+EUqNLSOQAEUE¶w ©LSqSP AÐËEiw ÎS_iGXCUoHhH4E+GXº©H©LS»N¬GIGIGIOQiP OQP EP&E²JXPS¢|b)xHKJ;JIGIH©AWIhH)ZL W~RYªAGI¨HKWxL _³WIGIO¨AiO¨Hg¢|GIHKªAH©E&L&GXUW~OÕEUO¨ C O¨h¯&O¨LNA¢|GXH HKOYP&L&"E>WGXLSHKL EMWI¢®GIOQP Ê¢|E |H MHK"¬EUGXOÕ¢|OYGXP&HKOYP&E_>EA4P&W$EA¢|P W~HK;GIWXJLNJX|GIOQH©ªMW4H©WWL GIUEAA ¢ H UW~GIJXAOYEM¢|Z&OQ;URYH©HKWPSGIOQP AE®WIOYe0EA§GIJXUL AH$W^·$U¸ki LSRQ P&JIOYGIU_(§OÕGXi^|EUHhG[P&JI|WLSEM¢0AJIH©W~HKE&GWL W~OQ_gARQLSGIOQP E ÊÈIÈ~Æ k°Å × Å½&| Ä @ ÅÓ § P áU·$UP&GIJxU³GI|UG1§H W~OYWXGIZ|LS W~&GIHHh_mP OYW0E+LiGI¥ HKW~JIHKOQEM_iEULSHhURJRQLSEUH1RkHEAGIG[JXPS^HKGXP LNLSJXGXGI_iOQP UHhEkE+EUj|G$OYOQGXE2OYWKEj×GIULØ e©O¨W§Ù¥W~¬OQLSEUJI GIRQO¨HgHgRQHhH h¡P DGIEAJL&L]WI¢UOQ¢U¢|OQEUHhJXJUHKWX|LmWG P&¢|UEUO¨WXEARQZ]OÕJXG©HjW~GIOQLSEUHhEMaË&GX¢²RYOYHh_ia¼L2OQH EUW~UOQ£ EU|JI H©G©W~RQjUH>HKW~JIOQHV&EU¡P &GIOQRYJJXHhL¤ a P UGIU ×| GUEUOYGKÊ0µxU ×HÓ~OQ¬EUjULS|EAG¢*LNG×L ¬GIOQGX_>OYVNHLSGIOQP E®P ºÓÓO¨W GIUÊHi×P&|j:GIL&U¬UGXOYG1VNLNUGXEAOYP&OÕG EAO¨WkW P @|OYE+×GI¬HK JIEMDFE+LSGIR HKAJIEUEAOÕL GRWL P JIEAH EUÓHK ×GI OQP E ¥^JXHhP â OQ_ +GXGXUWxHxLSOYJXEUHAh|P GÓRQYUH©EU¬GXOYGÓHK¢«OYE+OYGXEPLSGXUE H§EUHhG[¹P&JI_m OQLNEiGIJXL OY¡E "a¼HK(RYHK_> HKE+:Gx¬j|Ë^P HhRQUOQ _i+GXEMW^P ^HhOQP& EU+GEUHKV H©GI¬OQGIP P&EAJ W^&P OQEU HhOQ E&RQHhGX_iHhJX¬HKEAjE&LSLSG>REA¥¢mJXHKPNGIOYU&+H^GXV W HK¶GIP&º4J L ¥EAOQEU¢"UOQUEUG~UaF|LSEAG1 ¢atEUHKOYHh&G[&xGP&µxW JIAUH4ta¼)GIP P |LSa¼GXJXP&UH ||GI UGA¡||^H©G¢HhOQ ªMP&+HhEUG¥EUP W H©JXHg¬GIRQOQHKP LS^EmJX§EU^OQOQHhEUR ×OQA ªC+jAH4GG[WÓZRYH©UOQE]LSOQKJXLLSEURQHKYZ2¢kjU°OQE®GIAºhLH a WIALSJW~HJXL EA¢|P&_ÔP EAEUHKGIOQV+OYG[Z4ALSG~GXHhJXEkáOQ UJXH º^WI HhGXUH©W×GXUH§W~HhGIU>AWIHK¢0OYE0GIAOQWL J~GXOQhRYH&
' )(+*,*,*+(-&/. '
"9:@ A
"&
! "
2435
CED
> GIH,JK%
L6
768% =
"9L:GMHJ
$# " %
10 '
"9: @ AB% FED
> GIH,J
L> @ A
N internal units input unit
output unit
^áOYHh&OQ U+JXH GXWKº Ê\^L&W~O¨xW~HhGIUmP k|g&P RQO¨¢mLSJXJIPN$W U¡|HK¢i^HhOQ +GXWKÀ&¢AL WIUHK¢iLSJXJXPN$W @GXJXL OYEMLSªURQH µxUH4L&¬GIOQVNLNGXOYP&E«P OQE&GXHhJXEALSR@AEUOÕGW$LSEM¢]GXUH P UGIU|G$AEUOÕG$O¨W§U¢ULSGIHK¢L&hP&JX¢UOYEU0GIP Ó@ 55º:º: + Ó × 5ʺ: 5Ó º: º©kI ~ 5º:~ [Ëb&º: §^H]UHKUJIHKH JImH«W[AGW~LSH«EA¢AGXL WEU¥kP&ÀJ @LSE Hh(RQHh_iº©4HhE+OQWiG~at§L E¶O¨W~HiP |LSGXUOYP&AEARYO¨LShR^LSGIEUOQP P&E²OQWIH]P ÓV&GIHKA¬GXH>P AJ©ÀEUOÕ G EUP&EU(RQOYEUº©H© LSJXÓOÕG[ Z&jÔ¥P Jº©I§4UO¨W>O¨L V RQOYH©EU¬H©GXLSP JXJxOÕG[Z5P EM hLNGXHhEALS§GIOQH©RY¢ixªC¥JIH«P&_ MW~H©¢¶UHKJIº©H&;jÊLSGIPEAP+¢ ¶Ó µ×JLSOQEUº:¬OQEUÀU²LSEM¢U¢ LSGXL*OQW>O¨W;L*GXW~UGXH1LSGIP OQP |EAGXUL |JIZG§UDIÖEUßOYG WxWIOQEU P EAEUL aR GI O¨HKLSJ~RÊGLSOQP&EàEA ×¢|hOYP GIEAOQP ¢UEAOÕGXWKOYP&EA±® ×W>P ~GI¬JXUHgH"U5EAJXHKHUhG[HhOQ^EWIHhP RQGXJXZ U¶jCH)OÕW[GEULNGXHhUGIG[HH>P&ªCEUJIHKH"G[h^P O¨_iW4P JXAHK«W)CO¨¢UL&W1LSW~W[GIZGH©_iLS¢JI|GIL&GXHKhPS¢2hGIP O¨¥hJXJL P ¢|RY_ßOYQEAZ°«G[OQ^EAGXP¶P]¢|HhLS[Cº:JXHh¬ªUEMjOYGI¢|GIJHhULSE+HKJXG]EZ2P AW~GXEALSOQ¢|GIEUHhH©OÕJWa ÓWIHK¯+»+U Hh;EM»+HKWÊLSÓEA ¢0× OQWÓJIU×Ei§P OYGIE>V&GIHhAJX H$H WIL GX_>P2H§H©L OQEU®UUP G;GIUW~H©HK¯&JKAgHhDtEAÓhGIH§UOYO¨EiW ªCP&PSEAGIm¢|OYKGIOQL P WIE*HKWKUjNP GIUR¨¢UH§WKJXjHKGIWIUUHiRYGIJXOQEUHK WIHhW[JXGV LNP GXOQHJ EUHhG[P&JI W~GXLNGXH§OQR UL WIZ+_i|GXPSGXOQKLSRQYZ ¢|HKMHKEA¢gP&EURQZ P E4GXUHxOYEAU|GUO¨W[GXP JXZ jSLSEM¢ GIAHEUHhG[P&JI ì~íNçKìFëæì ð&ô¬ñ ëæð çKç ëæï Qê~ì[çKó&ó&ì[ð+éKí&ê[ëÕé çh¨åôIê ñ iô çì[í+ôî4çì[ëÕòç ê[ôð+ïFéhéKì[ó&ôê[õ|òéNôïé íNì[î Óå í+ëæò~í ò¬çhð õ|ô ¨ôIì[òIí&ô¬ñ Yê[é©î ON
+N
# '5D
P%
Q "6R# " SDT> @ A
0 "7D
P%
W GMHJ "> GMHJ ' '5D
XQ
#
'_a`bdc " ' )(I0 ' J'fhgMikj J'fhgMikj )(bl#
U "YD \ ']D
,N
"7D
!DVU "5D
)(-# ' D
W GMHJ
5# "=D
(
' 'ZD
(-# '[D
Oe
+^
C# ' )(Ol# "
atvu wpw)qxqxqy
zy r
nm +r )y w,{k|K}~Lw,S|
po zy
q
y
sr
r
O¨UW§JXP WIL COQHh¢]JIG[GIZ®PiO¨ªCW4H L P&EE&GXrJXÍL&nU¬GXÎ)OYVϬOYÐtG[qSZ"Ðtr4PSCrh/ÐËÑ;)ÎSuIDFÒ EËUJX|L&1¬GX¬OQAhH>OYG4WI|xÉ)L W1OQHh¥E+P GAEAP&¢EAGI¢|AOYGILSOQGgP E«L2¥P J^H©LSGI AHKH J HKP UEMPi¢|W[OÕGGXOYLNP&GXE H WIØ e:|ÙkÉ) OQV HKH©WKW§jAEMLiLS¢|_iHHhGRQLSZ OQjARYH©GI¢2PmL&HhhEMhW~P UUJXE+H GKGI MLNG$GXUHgWIMH©¬GIJLSR×JXL&¢|OYMW P O¨W$RQHKWXWxGIMLSE"UEUOYG[Z O¨WmP&P EALSEMUW~JXO¨UH¢|JXGXHhP:HhJ4¡|RQZ]OYGI_mUL HmLSW^GI¥GHKP&L ¢RYWIQ²PNª$ZP W §GIUhhP H"P _i_iEUUUHh|G[|GXGXOYHP&EAJIGIUxH)DFEWIP&A|GXUGI«AH®|GIAG0LS|^G§ HhGIOQU L H +UGXUGXW JXJXL P&WIOYL AEUOQ×EUjiGXGIAHhUJXLNO¨JXG4W>P JGXGXUL&HmW~GXHKOQWmL WIAMHhHKJ4RYQP&HK¢|GIUP UUGG × Ô â × × Ó ×I + O¨RQOYW0EU_iH©LSOQJXEUOÕG[OQ_>Z²OQOQ´hW H©¢¶UEMOQ¢|EP EUGXUHmH2ª_>ZH© LSEàIWI¯+Aâ0L JIOYH]E*WIGIHhUEMO¨W~W H&HK¶JIJX$P J PSGX¢|H]Hh AGXAEULNOYGIG>OQP GIEkA H«H CH)H©¬¢|GmUPSª5$ GXUH2~P |GXâ U|GmEUP ×EUa GIÎNAy|H§Ð GIy|H©ÐL ÊUµxHKUJ H$uIP&rh_>{tϬAwÕsS|GXq LS@GIOQLSP EAE>¢PS I O¨âSWÓ L RQOYEUKH© LSJJXHh&JI H©×WI WIOYÓP&Ek × I HhJXH^@O¨×WÓ~L ÓWIGI UHhH§GXEU>HhG[PS@P&LSJIE> P W mOYuIEArhH { LSRQ P&JIOYGIA_½¥P J§GXUH HhE+GIOQJIH RQHKL JIEAOYEU>UJXP|HK¢UUJIH º §_máOÕLN¡]GIJXL0OY¡ ·$WI§AOYGI««GIL>ALSWIG OYEU&RYHOYEAU|G$º LSP EAªU¢]GXLSL0OQEAWIOYWKEA RQHP UGIU|G§UEAOÕG©jUWIKLSRQOYEUgGIUH1^HhOQ +G b|§·§¢ULNUGE(LGI¥UJXP O¨W_ ·$OYEUOY GIO¨LSR0ªZÔGIJLS¢|EMJIOQW~VOQHhOYEAE+G*L OÕG°EA¢Ô§OYGIP&(RYQHKGIUG²HJXGIHhH©_mL LSUOQEUOQEUOQEU OQEUOQEUUUU|GG WIOY&EUEAHG[LS^R¼ P JX`O¨W~W~GX_iLSGIO¨H©WIWW GU I UP H_iJIUHK_i| GX×L H]OY EAGXOYUEUH1AGXJXWIL Hh ×OYAEUI¢|OQmEUP a¼JXOQPNEUxV JXHKHa¼§JXaFWIWIO¨OYH WI&H2EALSOQE+R¨WxGIâ:P jLL EAI_m¢¶ LNAGIâ JX|OYG ¡ Ü (×ÊOQE+OQ_gGIP4AL RÕGLShEUâP 8SRQHKUP ¿_iAWIEmRY¥Z&§V j$AHKHhP&GIJXP&RYH QJHK8+G A *¢|HhJXEAOYPSGIHGIH©W^GIJLSxEAOYE+WICGIP>P&WIGXH©U¬H P |GXU|GhP EUEUH©¬GXOYP&EAWhÀGXUH4UÝO¨W§EUPNGIJLSOQEUHK¢k GIµxAP&UHÓ_iH$MU_iPN|^P|GIOQHh¢|EUJ@HK RYO¨OQW@GXEUUGX P§H$CAEUPNWIHhHÓG[HKL JÓ¢UP&¢|JIPS4@OYGILSOQP&P E)|EMGI^LSARS||EUG;P&OQEUE® RQJXOYPNËEUb $H©LSWÊ J@§GXJXOÕH$GXL mEAAW~EUWI¥H§HP G[JXU^_iHKP JILSH$JXGIgOQL P WIEAWXOY´K¯+WCH AP LS+JXGXHKU¢0HÓUV EUH©HKHhLSJXG[CWIOYHhP&P&JE0JIxP L:W[Z4GGILNUGXGIP H§H EUOYÓEAHh hG[×JIH©P&L ¥JIP&WI HJ WGI~AGXLNHGXRQH Hh®EU ¸×GIH0G b >b hP ¢URQUHh_iEUP EMGIkH]V&L"HKRQGIHhP EAJ^SGI Ê×b Ý b× P&|GIUUG0^ ×HhOQ +G4 V ×H©¬GIP&Jg LS×EM ¢ × I׬ HVNLShJXHKOQL "E+GIGxAP H0^EU¼Hhb G[ P&JI2U¢ULNGXH«~º©UEAAL EU H©¢@jMâ ªA|G hP _iU|GXH0P&|GIA|GXW§â OÕGX®GXUHg¥P&RYQPN§OQEU @ º© º©I µxµxUUHH RQ£ HKJXL HKJIWIEUHhOQJXEUV >P OQUJ¤0JXPL hEAHK¢2¢|AGIJIUH H0JXOYHhEA_mULS|OQG EAW^OQWRYOQEUEUPNH©LSJ$GXLSLSEMA¢«MH©EA¢"PNªZ2 RQPO EUH©WHKL RQOJ HLSEMGI¢"AOQ¯&W ML ¢|JLNGXOQ4hP EUEAHK¬GXOYP&EAWK ºb| §`¥UJXEMOQV AHxLSGIEUA&H$HK¢A| 5§OYGI>GXUH§GIJLSOQEUOQEU OQEUU|G©Ê`O¨W~_iO¨WIWOQEUOYGIO¨LSRAGIJLSEAWIOYHKE+GL EA¢iP&RYQHKG JIHKP&_mRYQHKLSOQG^EUOYGXEAU]H LSGIUJLS&OQ_iEUOQHhEUE+iGIH©U¢"JXHW[aFGW~LNOQ GIH©EAW L RQW ×â JIPNxat§ ×O¨W~^H OYE+OQE+GXPiGIP Li¦hP 1RQU_iOQ_gE2UV&RYGXHKL GIEUP HhJxP&A8WI RYZ&j U P _iU|GXH GIUH MW~HKA¢|PSatOQE+V&HhJW~H âNjULSEA¢2UUG ( â8S x A§µxUH4UÝO¨W§EUPNÝJIH©L ¢|Zi¥P&J§H¡|URQP OYGXLSGIOQP Ekj|AWIOQEUiP |GXU|G$¥P&JI_0URQL2 ¬ Ã Æ Ä UÈ $È Ä Â ßÅÓAÆ k5 $& "Å ÜÈ Ä DFL E)EUGXP&UEUO¨RQW^OYEUWIH©HKLSGIJ^OQP W~Z|EmW~GXGIUHh_½H1O¨¢|P&HhJIE+GXOQEUOÕ M&KW;LNPSGXOY@P&GIEiAH1GXL L WIU _iµxHhAE+HGXHKWI¢)ZW~L GIHKRY&_½P JX^OÕGXL&UW_½OYE+§GXJIOYP|RQ¢|ªMAH hHK¢|¢mHh_iOQE]P&L4EAW[WIGXUJXJXLSV GIHKH©Z&¢maF§LSEMOÕGX¢ a UEUOY MKLNGIOQP EUa¼AL MHKJ4ØÕºÙ¼DtG$O¨W$L2ºK»SGI|atP J¢|HhJx·$±®ÔWIZ|W[GXHh_ 6
S6
g
+N
J 'gI@
A
> GIH,J
W GIH,J
" %
0
' > GMHJ "
J'fhgMikj
" (-# "
J'fhgIi j
'
W/GIH,J W/GIH,J > GIH,J
56
"
J'fhgMikj
' )(-#
JkfhgIi j
"> GMHJ '
J'fhgMikj ^
'
g
D
"
kW/GMHJ z0
kW/GMHJ 0
bN
JkfhgIi j
" )(I# " bD U '
" JkfhgIi j
> GIH,J7%
> GMHJ
x# ' ? ORD # ' "!)H,g$ "f# " " (-& " (,*+*,*,(I& . " (-&% " (-&'% ' )(,*+*,*+(-&(%. "
B> GMHJ "!)H+g "f# OVD
)
)N
0 "5D
%
W GMHJ '> GIH,J # ' D "!)H,g$ "f# "!)H+g "f#
)*
"
+N
#
" W GIH,J
!)H,g$ "f#
+
,
L
--
/.
10
2-
354
*
0
'
J'fhgMikj L> GIH,J % !)H,g$ "f#
76
"
N
º© » × » »&e × [ º Ûe Ê f& × ¶» Yº Ëe& GI¢| OQO¨P rhW[E*GXмÑ;JIOQªUÎNuIHK|Ò>OYGX&OYÏh+P&rhG1E*ÐËy _mOQELNo GXØ JI OYE¡ º KºÙtjGIËUº©P&Hi» EU»0JXEUHKHKWIU|GIRYÝOQGIVOQEUOÕ^G[«Z²L&JW^eL:U]JIHKjk_mAEULSLNP JXGXHKEUJI¢)OYa¼¡®´Kª+Hh^JXZiP)L& AW¡JXOQHKEUHOYaF&iWX+hLgGXLSW RQJHKLSWI¢"L EM_i¢|GIP"P U_RYL«H©j|¢"WIW~CM¥JXHKLSP ¬JGX_¾W~JXH1L URÊEAP JXEAOÕL&¥EU¢|P&JIOYHKM_Wa PSJLS;EA»A¢| cAP&jU_¦GX+^MHhWOQ HK+EAG§W~AV JIHKOQEUGImP&J GXUHgiH©WIUL P]_iW~UGXRYLNH©GX¢«H4¥UJIP&JXP _ CHhL>JIG[UZUEU¬OY$¥P $JX_¿E*OY¢|EAO¨UW[GX|JIGOQªUA|EUGXOÕOYG P&E«xL PNW$V&HhLSJ G~GXØ L&$» UQHKº ¢I» §YºhOYÙ¼GI *L WIØ » ZuIIW~qN»GIwzHKMeN_¿wzÙ¼+j|s2¼L&e Wx OYqN§E°ÐFq]OYGIØYº¬mqSÙ¼CÓLSiE>µxAмOËuI H O¼qS ¢@wzEUAÊHwzG[+OQ^EUs+UP o |JX$mG^E2W~^H©DIL&¯&Ö W^AÝHhJIEAUGXEhJXHxL L OYWXEUKLSOQ_iEUP&iJXU¢|RQW~HKOQH©EU¢0¯+0U¥JXGIHhP P"EA_h[Hº:GX^xU§H§L W^OÕUGXUEU2JXOY¥HhGIP UMJXHLS_³JXGXHKJX¢U¢)L OQW~OYªEUGIZ]JXOQEUOYªA¢U>|JIOYOQGIEAVOQP UOYEUEi|0G$PNGIV ¥AP&HKHJJ W~LSº©GIAb Hh» M»_iWiHhGXOYE+_iHKGIH©JIHH¢®W[¢|GXGXJXHhO¨WIL AKOYW0EALSJOY§EU¢|"OYHKGI¢@L RY&AµxP EUJXOÕU¥OÕGXP&HUJI_/_JXHh_mj×EALSLSP EAOQO¨EU¢W~HOQEUL"@bS ׺K»+» gb:»&atPSRY»®HKEUEUWISHhOQGX´hG[*H«P&L »AJIU ¶»& » _iW~»AGXHhº LSE+*GIGXH©HK`1Wi¢*LNGP HKL"|JIGXH2¥UJX|P HhE+_G4GI^HKGIJIHhAH©OQH]¢ + AOQG E+JGIW~V PGiHKbSGIGIA»&P&»HJ ^L&W§hLSR¨ARQLSGIHK¢k ´ Ah HKJr¬JIW[ϬP*Gмwz+W[bSG» s LS»«JIGIµx^OQEUUHh²JXHmH®W~RQGXHK¢|LNL O¨GXJIWIH]E+KLSG4§JP ¢|OYGIUHK¢@GIUEU|HhG4áU§JXV&RQP Z°HK_ GIP JXGIHKJ ULNH²xGXHKL JI¢W4HK_iGXOYEAHKL W~W~OYGIGXEAOQL EUOYRYEU*QHK¢OQEUb L U» EAU»&¢*G0»*¥GIW~P&UGIJ>HKHmAb EUWhb jxHh» G[GX»"UP&H²W~JIGI²HKA^±²WhjL&|W P ½JIA§GXE*HKUW~O¨G]¥JX°P Hh_¹JXGIJIAP&LHJ ±*| " ! ^L&WÊHKW~GIOQ_mLNGIH©¢@5VNLSRQUH§PS@±*| $# » » +b$xL WÊ¥P&UEA¢@ _iLS% EÝÎNOQWI>OQEUi|®grhGXAj;UÐËH]ÏGXU5GXH*JX[L º©_iOY0EAP&OYµxEUJIH"*UH2GXHhJXJXEUL JIP OYP&EAO¨JgWIOYEUH)ªUàUGIHKG>¢UJILN_ OQ_iGL¶U@JIO¨ W]PN×VgJXOQHKEU¥¯+U"UEAGXOQ¬JXUGXHKOYH]¢5P&EAGXLSHKWiEMW~G>L ¢W>HKGIJIL®UJXP HJXJ©Hh_i&UP ¼RQb JXL H®0JIOQ´hl1UHKJXHhJKHKEUjÊhHKOQWIWIJXRYH®L OQ RYQ+GXZ UGIjÊRQH²Z¶GXURQHKH«P&L _iJIR¨LSEUUJXOQEU JIP HKMJa GICJHhP LSGOQOQE&EUUGH©Wg®¢"+HhP L:¡UE*V L H)¬e GX» RYZ»)±²RQ¢AOY|&LN H4GXL]OQE"MP&GIUOYE+HiG»W¢|H©» +WIcL:hV AJIHgjOQªML H©EA¢±²¢¶ºK|L »& »N&at» U»SEUa¼OY# AGEUH» OÕ¡UGgULS^_iº&jC|UÜL2RQH eSjGX»NJXLSatL E*UOYEAEULSHKOYUG¢°&^_>P&|E HKÔE+&GIGX» HKJX»&¢®L »OYb EAM»NHKatP&¢"UOYE+EUP&GOYE¶GWgºK+»&L:U» V »H ±*| # » » »&f cU GIØY% ºJÙÎNLSOQL EUEAOQEU¢²qSiu¬_mw¨ÏhW~H©ÎNL ¯&CE+AoZ²HhEAPSµxhGIUAH1H2HhxJ4ªCL UHKW^W~AGmªU±*RYO¨WI±²|UHK|¢ A(L ÐËuXM#qNHKwzJXA» W wzb L s AªMº P&Ø '|Ù$GgHKPN·$JI^JXP HhV&J0HhP J©GXª|j JXL GGXULSOYEAOQH EUOYEUHKRQHh"¢¶V HKL OYREUPSMØÕH©ºLSAÙxJ JIP&H©GXEP"O¨W~L²OQªMP HmRYE«HKEUªAJISL&HKGXMW~àH©P&¢²J~bSGXP&»&HKE¢» _iEUWIUO¨P|¯+ªMU¢|P&HKHh|RQW*GIOYEAOQ_mØ SÙLSR@P&GIP¶_iGXJXL MGIOYUHhEAGIHOYOYEUGIWIOQ)P L Eg_>WX§HUHKOYGGI_>L 0WIH©`|WhWhÓL EU$OY*Rz$GI);HKO¨W«JJIP&WIJI+UH©AW~ªUUP _iJXRYGXPNOQW)WXV§WIOYOY§_iP&UE«UPJXP PNHh¡V GXH"CUHhOQP&JIWEÔGIARQZ LSØÕº¬CLSÙ UHhJ§AJXHKRYDxOQWIHKU^¢4RÕHhG WmE+G§ ªOYáZàE+atGX+\L P)E5),L>)P ¥µ®JJI¢|OQHhGXHhEAHKJ]¢U|RYPSZ a _mLS&EUOÕGXA¢|H LSEM¢«JXHKL&«LiWIRYOQ +GIRQZ)ªCHGIGIHhJUJIH©O¨W~OQP E«GIMLSE2GIUH JXHKWIURYGXWxJXHhCP JIGIH©¢]UHKJIH& - .¶0Ä / È Ä ÊÆ2 1$||È~Å Ä Å 436587 Ä @ ÅÓ \^W~GXHKLSKEMLS¢UALSWIJH¢GXUJIH©H U¢|HJW~GXOQHhV JXH)_iL OYEARY&LSP GIJXOQP OÕGXE2U_mPSW P ¥|P GXJ0OY_m±²LS|RÓÔËLSU_i&OQ_iEUOQHh_>E+OQGI´KH©LS¢AGIOQP P E°|GXUEU|PNG$§^EHhOQ¥ JXP +_GXW^O¨L W§¢ULgL |RQOYGIEAOQV HKLSH)JxRQOGEUL HKWIL J j O¨WIWIWÓOYOY&&EAEAL LSLS_>R|R¨WOQUR OQJXL P|J; §H©×WIOY WIGIOY)EA1GXUKHLSE>>ªML ªM WI×H$OQ>L OQULS¢|JXUH©H)RQL OYH©GIPS¢4J×LSGXEMáP W[D[¥P · P&EUJIRQGX_iOYLSEAHKUHx¢a¼^^OYHh|E+OQàGX P+HKGL W~GIE OQ5_mP&OYLN|HKGIGIEUOQUP HhUJ¬E×ÊGm ADÊWIRYOQGIL HKWXEAJXW~L WAR_>@OËH^H ×GXQj+AgGILNAªGLSZ¶GXG UL ¾H§EJIOQH©OQEUEUL UEU¢||HhHKGJJ UDFEmJXP|GX¢|UAH¬^G$|§â OYGI®hP L>E+GIGHhLS¡+|G©atj ^GXHhUOQH +OQEUG§UV UHKG^GIWIP&OY&J4EA LSR¨W;â L JIHxGXUH1b @* ×b P&_iMâ P&EUâ Hh E+×GX W;PS@GXUHL U _iHhE+ GX×HK¬¢ OQV EUH©U¬GX|P G J©jEUL HEAG[¢«^P GIUJX)H W[P&G|LNGIGXAH|V&GHKW~¬OQGX P EMJ©LSj+R@GIUO¨W^H1GIGXUL H |atEUHhG[HKOY&P&&JIG^mV AH©JI¬HhGIa¼P&P&Jx|OQGIWUGIUAGgH L U _i HKE&â @GXHK ¢«×P |GXU|G§^HhOQ +G ðçhåæï9;: ²Cí&ê[ôÓé ôXçKöò¬ó çhì[åÕí+òXéKó+ê[åÕïkçhì[î : ô¬ñí+ëæïFô§ò¬ì[í+çhåÕçhåÕ2ô òXê[ó+?KèKçKåÕôXçhåæKê ó+ì[ô¬?©ô ñçhåÕì[ó&í+ô$ôçKëÛê èhê[ôôï AÓ]@Cëæì[õ|Bí0ôXD EGò¬ì[FIçKí+ó&H ô ïFY&ôÊê[é©åÕì[éhî5í+ì[;ôïÓê[ì[î1ô¬ì[ñ1ó&íõ|åÕçç ìôXït¨éhKì >êç Jz|î =ôXôXëæêê[ïFéKò¬öçhî åæòô¬ó+çhåÕð1çhì[ïFôëæMñ èKLö B BNHPO '7D
%
*
" !D
*
"
"
:
D
O*
"
' !D
* b*
4% [6 O(
K> @ A
* O( *
Oe
( *
U "
> GMHJ "!)H,g$ "f#
J'f#"J
%
* O
J'f#"J
U '
Jkf#J
*
J'f#"J
* O
Y
*
Jkf#J
T
*
J 'gI@ A
%
)
=&
' )(+*,*,*+(-&/. '
D
zy { |m O ,r
y
y
'
"9
(+*,*+*(-9 . )N$0 ' $% O D
!|m O x| m b J 'gI@ A q
r
t
t t
9
&
+N K K0 ' " dD *+, * *pDV9 . & . "
kW GMHJ
0 "
r Mt
$r
t ,t
)y
N8 7 ¼8:7 7+8
5??$CE¶P P&JIGXEUL RYEAOQEUH2H&)LSRQ½ P JXOYPGIP|U¢²_ OQE+OYE¶GIJXP|GIU¢|H2A¬LSGXUOYP&&E²_>GXHKP®E+GI·$HK¢°¸*^|O¨W OQWIV HHKGIE*GIOQEUOQE5*WIØ bNUÙ¼P&jU§RQ¢°UP&¢UWIPH GI AH¥P&RYQ PN×§ OQEU OQV ×HKE]~¬jLSE«LSGgP CHKL&HhE|*atHhGXEAOY¢U_iHKH¢@jG[ZßUO¨hº)L RY¢|QZiHGXEUHhJXP _>E|aFOQW~EUGXH]LNGXL OYP&E°EALSLSUJXZ>&_>GIJHKLSE+OQGIEUHKOQ¢EUgP&DI|Ö GIA|W~GgH©¯+^UHhHhOQEA +hHG V H©¬GXP J ×^§AOQZOYHKRQ¢AW§L0&PP¢«_iP|¢|HhRkP GXUH4AJIJXHhE+G^GIHKL&UHhJ$WIZ|W[GXHh_ GIáUO¨P&LSJIRQ_mZ]L ¢|RYQO¨Z WIhj+P LSUE)E+·$GIH©¸¢iWILS¯+RQA L P JIJXH OYGIU£ U_(JXH¥atP HhJ;JXJX^P |J¤5P UGIU|G^HKOY&+GÓUC¢ALNGIH_iOYEUOQ_iOY´KHKWÓGIUHH¡|MP&EUHhEUa #%$ â ' &U â &U) ( Ú+ # â §ªCH1UHKP&JIª|H GXL OYEAHK¢2º«LNGxOQWgGIOQGI_iA+HH,&]* ÎS§uËs&UrhHKмE2ÐËwzL0s EU* Hq G[Í ^ÐtÎSP uJXmLS§EA¢OYGI«GIUH ' &U4AO¨JIWgJXHhGIE+UGxH2P _i|GXPU¢U|HhG$R^^P |HhOQGX U+|GXG>W GIALSG>^P U ×R¨¢ ^P UR¨¢]ªCH Hh_iURQPNZ H©¢«LSG$LSRQ@GIOQ_iHK-W & º PV µx@HKUJXW@HKWIªCJIOQP HHEkG[L ^jCJI§HHhHKU_iE4O¨L ²EP Z0_iO¨W1VNULS¢UUJXHGXO¨GXLNLSL GXE+OYOYRQGXP&HKWEA¢®P LS×RSP h|·$P&G ¸W~GKOYiEj:W~L µOQRY_i&L P ªUUJXRQRQOÕH«O GXhUOÕº:G[_mb|Z&Qj:WÓº4L _iEAOYEà¢1OQEUEØ OYbN_iUÙÓ_iOQLS´hEAHhOQEUJX¢²OQ«KOYLSE²ËÚ&R W~GIGXj+UL ¢|H>ªUO OYRQHhOYHKG[JXª"Z OYEUkGI0DUAGIOYEiP WIHÓJXGXO¨ULLSRÊHh£ OQAVNJLSL GIEAJNOYL RQL ¢|L& Hh¤H a L KP&_>MLSEZOYEU0GIAOQW§MLSCHhJ© _GIiµxA^OQH$WXP"L JX¢NLSAÁ[GIALSOQP JW[LSGXªM_i_iHhHhG[HE+GXHh/G HKJHh.W EiGXAULSLSHEAJ¢2L Hh¡|GXGIhUHhHKHgJXWXO¨WÓW~hH0P ±²EGI|V U5HKH)JI&GIP JHhL EAJhHH¡UOYEAGXH©OY2_iWIWÓCH0HhhJI±²P ¥P EA|JXW~_m^GXL ÊLSE+EAOY-G EMhHi0@UxPSJX$µxJIH©LSA¢>E°H4ª+_i·$Z0¸OQGIWXA*L 2H ¢:L Á[1AMRY&AW[P GXJXGI_>OÕAGXHKLSUE+GI_ GOQP EAOQW;GIV AH©PSHW GIOQE®AH4GIAL H0¢UL RQOY|_iGXLSOYG GIOQPSP ÓE]P AmJIP|OQEUH©HWIa¼GIWKJj|LSLSOQEAEU¢]OQEUGI]AP&H E®P |OQE|GX AOY_mEUOYLSGIRkHmW~W~GIGXH©LNL GX¢|OYZ+P&EAaFW[LSGJXLNZ«GXH1GIJ±²LSOQUEUOYEAGX«A¢ULNG$LSGX^LUP AáARQ¢«P J1ªMOYH EAW~P&GXª|L GXEAL OYH&EUj@H©¢L _iOQEiOQWXL L W~¢NGIÁ[H©AL W[¢|GXZ+_iaFHhW[GE+LNG^GXP Hx3 WI.OYGIALSGIOQP » E>4H_i¡UHKHKL HKEA¢UWWÊGXGXAULNHxG^GIGIAAHhH$P JXGIHJGXL OQKLSOQRQEUYZ04L HKJIUJXP OQHhJÓVNP LS@ªAGIRYHxUHP UL GI¢AOQ_gLS|UGX_ßOYV&H¥§LSRQOY GI)P&JIWXOYGILSU_i_ H GXLSL RQ *P&JI^OYGIHhAOQ _ +G ¢UV HH©GIHK¬JIGX_iP J1OQEURYHKHKEUWSGIGXAMH01Hhª¡Z CP EA» Hh]E+G1iP µxAGIUH0HiGXOY±²_i|HmP&EAP&W~EGXV LSHhE+JXG, HK0EAL H&WXW~"j P|4 O¨LN6GX5)HK7 ¢" §áAP OYGIJ1°H¡UL LSE_i·$U¸RQH j Á[GX0 AL W~|ÞGIat_iV b HKHh» E+GI»®G«P&J^^L RQEAP Hh¢5AEARQS¢GIP&2OYE_iGXV UUHhJIJXRQZP& UHKLSEA E H2HH¡U¡|CH©WIP W>EUHK±²E+|G] LSJXJXH"HK¢|JIHKMRQ¬LSGIGIOQHKP ¢EGXªPZ5GI9ºU8:H"42¥HKP&V JI&HhJXHZ¶GIGIOQbSEU»&»²W~L GIHhGIMP WhJ)àL ±"EA¢àOQWXGIL A¢|H a ºº LSEA¢ 0 # º º . ¼d 7 K< ?!3A@,BDCFEHGJI,EK ' M8
?×8 L < 3GJ M98 7+8 h¼¢àd Hm«^L K|ULS4 E_i;ªMHhD>E+H§GXHKAOQ¢R WIHKºK¢|¢» HK»S_>GIa¼PàAP&EUEAUOÕW~JXG GIHKJ¢|LNO¨UGI¬H4GÖNGXj@¢|UªUH©O¨W~|W)OQG0 §EEUOYGIPNGI5(UHGX¢|UHhGXH¶GIJXHhL&ºKJX»S_i+GIOQOY|EUEAatàHmP JOÕ¢|GAWgHKLSJiJb L WIZ|GIW[HhGXJXHhO¨_b«W[GXOQP KË|W]e&GX¬UP |>G4D>Là^JX·$HHhatOQ¸ A++WIHGa V ZH©OYHK¬RQGX¢P JgLiP&_iEUO¨RQWIOYEUL&H«¢:Á[§AW~OÕGIGX_iHh·$E+¸GP ÓA . HGIGIÝOQEU» Ûe>LSßEA¢» L>f GXf+OYe|_ijHgLSEMhP ¢¶EAW~GXP&L EAE&W~-GO¨¢|0 HKJIOQEU b » »U^OYEMb »&H bUGIjAHg¯&L EMWIWhZx_>¼Ud a GIEAP L GI_>O¨hHKL RYRYZ&QZijÓP |±²GXOYU_m LSR@±²» » |&¶b|jO¨WxGIALSUH«A_iJIP:O¨¡|WIL&OQ_i¢:Á[LSAGIW~HKGIRY_iZ0HhGIE+U+G H .±*ß|¶» P Ûe"kGIRQUHGXH1# W0P AmW0OQEUHH¡|a¼CGIJHKLS¬GmOQEUH©L²¢iEU±²HG[|^(P JXPS j »W~GX»LSE++Gb °0 º©e » bS »&»*# _m# » L » &HKciWi¥MP&WmJHGX¡|UCH>HKP ¬EUG2RQOYEAH>±²L&|¢U LS|GP LNEGXV&OYP&HhE*JX LNHhzEMGXHhH«J GIPP&E+GIV&AHhH®JX HHK¡|EACHKH&¬1GXHKµx¢5UH0L&W~GIZOQ_i_iHm|GIP P GIEUO¨ a ±*|ª#Z]L0L ¬GXP J§P 9º 8N4 HhV&HhJXZ]bS»&»0W~GIHKAWh
Q
N ' )(I0 ' J'fhgMikj J'fhgMikj > GIH,J " "!)H,g$ "f#
"
7
kW GMHJ
be
0
J'fhgMikj
kW GMHJ
%
0
(
0
%
K> GMHJ ' "!)H,g$ "f#
b(,*+*,*(I
N
%
*
Y
%
%
D
*
Q
%
* O X3
* b * O
*
%
D [ %
*
%
*
IG§ OQ_iuIJqNLSHKwzUMW>Cwz+HKH¡|¢*s°UGI RQAP|qSH)¢|Ðtq&HKJKoW> k§ WhU¡|«HKMEPSHKJI4OQ¢|_iËJXe&OQHhV E+Hh§GXEWgOYGI§§¶OÕOÕGXGXL2°GXO¼GIL AO¼EU H«¢@k¶WIZOQáUW~EUGIUUHKJI_|GIAGiHh¼¥JXe JX_>P 4_ P&JIJIHKH&V Ø j×» HKIL D1» RYH©JIeNHK¢*Ù¼U°GIR¨L AµLSH©P*Gg¢*GIªCAGIP UH«AH)EAWIP&Z¢¶JIW~OQGIP& HK|OQ_ EAGIUL WIRÓUP GX_iWKP j;EUHhDaa W~GXLSE+GW§» I» »+e Kº Ûe I» Yº§ªZ]¥JIHKH1MLSJLS_iHGXHhJW j|GXP>P&ª|GXL OYE º© 5GXL EU × × [ Ê f& Ê × c+ µxbS»&U» O¨»1WÓWIW[ZGXHhW~AGIHKWK_(j x L WÊ JXUE0¥P HKJ$JIH$º©» L&» WIWI»&OY»&EUW~GIHKHK¢gAEUWÊHh§OYGIJ)LSEALSEi¢UP O¼_Ô O¼ ¢@VN×LSRQGXUHKH©L&WUGXLSHhJ&HhOQEUE>U¥|JXP G;_³¥JIP&L _¿ÝØ »eSI» » ÔeNÙ¼OYE+ÓGIHKV&JIHhVNJXL Z R LSWIHKJX¯+P UAHhEAEM¢ GIH Aj@H§JXAHKOQWIMH©¬GXRQOYHKV&L HJIRQP&Z"JIOQW~ UOQEAPNLS$R+WP&GXJXEAL W[EAGLSW~OYE+GIGXOQP WKEMWáOQªCAHSG[bS^àHhHKWIEUPN¢|$O WkHhGXJXUHhH^E+GJIH©£W~HhUARYGIOQOQWIEUP|¢|HKGIH©WX¤)L HKUV HKHhJJXP&Z®|bSGIU»&» U»G W~GIHhMWh §U |OYy|GIG©Aj>ML L°wz+EAs´K¢ÔHhJXÐzLnAPr EULSP AO¨ W~_iH Hh{ PS$ÌE+]GI H©WI¢OY´KHP q |s+»UGXÎNU» u¬|»&wzÐ¥G2»Unº°HKx OY&L &W²µxG«AOYEAV HàWIHKHhJIGIGIP&H©JK¢OQxDtE&G2L GXPW*^W[L&GXGUW)LSHJI¢|GIJXW~HKOYGX¢V&LSHhGIE5¥HJIP&ªA_ ZàC¢UGI´KLSUHhGIJXH²H&Pj>GIHKW~L&L&GXW®LNUGXOQHEÔHhJ]L GIOYEAAE|¢ H a POQ´hmHK¢OQEUHL hGIhJP LSJOQ¢|EUOQOQEUEUAÞGIP°µxGXAUH¶H²A·$JI¸H©WIhJIL OQ|RY&GIP OQP JXEMOÕGXW)U_ OQV ¥HK§EOYGIOYE(¥Ø P&b:JIÙ &LSHEMG~GX¢àOYEAGIUHKL&E ¬GXJIP AJ²E5»AGI P&f& f&He GX]UHhxJ«L §WOÕOQGXEU5OÕGXGIOQL ARÕH a EU ÊHhG[× P&JIU× ¢ULNGXHKWKj>GIP ×P _i UU×GIH«¥JIP& _¹× GXUHLSU&_> ×HK~E+>GIHKL¢¶W~H©OYEU¯&AA|HhEAG hH«EUHhP G[1LSP&AJI _iW~GXHhLNE+GXGIHKH©W ¢¶ÓP& |×GI UUG ^EUHhHhG[OQ +P&G JImV â HKP&|GIGIP&UJXUW G × G×LS¬EU]µxUH©â W~HmP&| GI×A |G4Ó×HK~OY& +G V&HKGIP JW1HKJIHiAWIHK¢*GXPKLSR¨UR¨LNGXHmL ^WI UP rªAϬJXWI>y HK¯+ÐËAÏUJIo P|HháAE+¢|JIG§AP&RQ_HhGIEUOQP GI EAUGIW |Hxa@JXºKHK »&×WI»gURYjAªUGIOQRQEUP|±*|RQ|WhHh EASáW^GIOYUMaX;HKº©JIbS» H1\5» E»&&U»OY_iV&WIHKHKHh¯+WxJXUOQLiKHKLSEARQRQP YZm&H©L WH©JIP W[OYGXCGIOYA¢|_m_>H©LNW~O¨GXOQJXHKHK¢)U¢4RYP ¥P&JIGKP&| _GIA|L:GXV W HKJXL ×OQEUL EA§¢gOÕGXEAUHOQG~E a DFP EEMW~GIHhAG0H)¢|RQO¨L&W~W[JXGgU|GIGXUOYJXP&HhE°HmOQHKW0UOQWIRQHKP|LS¢|JXHKRQWKZ²jJXGIHKUH)P& HhEU¡|OQM´KP&L EUªUHhRQH E+GIO¨LS$R^R¨W~P±²GXUUÔH«hP P&EE+V V&HKHhJIJX& HhHKEAEAhHiHiWILNCzHhGXHhHKJ4¢H©_mL LSGXHhUUH©O¨W WIPGIA¢UHH UJXHK¢|O¨¬GXHK¢«GIOQ_iH4P&EAW[GLSE+GKjUL&WxJIHKV H©LSRQHK¢)ªZmGXU,H 0 b » »iW~RQP CH RYOQEUH OQEAWIHhJIGIHK¢«OQEáOQA;b \ µx¢|H©UWIHghJI¢UOQªMPSH©G~GX¢>HK¢"OYE>AGIP AJXH$OY´KUP JXE+HhGXVL OYP&R@ARYOQWEUHgWIHKOQ¬E®GXOYP&áEkOYMbSU\JXU_iJIO¨WIL OYJIEU|&WxRYZ&GXj ULNH0zGXHhJ;±²h|P E5V P HKJIÊ&GIHhUEAH0hH P j:mGXUOYEAH$HP a¼GIEAJRYLSOQEUOQEUHHKaF¢±*U| O¨WIWÓOYV&RQH©PN^EAHKJLSGIGIUAJXL H EmPSGIAGIH$UP H4mWIZ|OQEUW[HGXHh_ ±²Ë|e §$JI+H©µxW~kUO¨W;hc&L EmjU§ªMUHO¨H¡|UOYR¨EALShOQEUUHKJ¢>W§RYGXP&UEUJXSP a¼UGI&HKiJI_¿GIUHP JXD~D[JX·ÔHhR¨LNËGILSOQ|P EMGXP WJXOQHhE JXGIHKAW~H a WIOYP&&JIEAJXLSHhR¨R LNGXOY P&×E)j&RQP&HhEUJÓ OQEmGIUPSH©GIWhAjUHhHKJ;V HK^E«P J§¢UOYWKGIj «L UEU¡|P&HKEA¢2W[GALNL GXJXOYP&L _>EALSHhJXGIOÕHKG[ZgJXW PSGIUH W~OQ EAÓL µxRUUOQEiOQWxGI_iUH§H©¢|GXOYOY_iA_0H©WIa¼KGILSHKJIRQH$_¿PSEUGIP AEUH a W~L GX¢ALNLSGX|OYP&GEALNGILSOQJXP OYEG[Z®hL P E]_iGXUPmJXLmP _iHhO¨W~JIH©GXL W$OYGXEU¢|HmHKC HhJXHhJI¥HP ¥JXP _iRQYL PNEAH>GIUPSO¨^W§GIEUAP&H>EAW[P GmLNGXOYOYEUP&HmEALSL JXRY&OÕG[P Z&JX OÕGXU_jkªU|G GXUHiP EURQOYEAH áWIOYOY´KMH b DtGmOQWO¨WmL1LSRQUP &ML LSJIJXOYHhGIE+AGg_>GXO¨ALNUG)RYP LNGÓzGXPSHhMJ)GIUW~GXH$L ¢|J~GXHKOYV EUHK*RYP&¥UJX_iP _/HhE+G´hHKP JIMPMGXjUGIHxA_iHhJXHKH2LSEiO¨WiLSLSªMEàW~P&OYRYEA|OÕGXGXHxOQL P R§|HGXU¡||MGÓP&EU^HhHhE+OQGX OQ+L G R LSJXªCPNP xUGIG4ºK» P »&§»UL j+ªA§WIP URQHh|JXGIHKHmLSzVNGILSHKRQJxUGIH©UW4H4PSx±²GXU|H)5P U¢|GIHKUV |HhG>RQP MW^HKOYL>&+JXGXHhWK&j×UURQL E+JxGIOQARxLNL®GIGIHhW[GJXLSE°ªUOQRáOY´©OQALNGIAOQbSP \§E°LS G0L"W~OQ´hH]PS áW~GIOYHhEMMLSWxRQYOYZ&E2jAáGIAOYMH AHbS¡|`ÔMHKWIJIUOQ_iPN$HhE+W§GKLSjAE2V+O¨PNWIV AHKLSJIRQR¨YL:Z«Zi¢|PSHh _iP EM×W[ GXJXLSWIP GIOQRQEUO ¢Mg^GX§UH OÕGXUJX@HKh ×OQWI OYP&E2¢|P LSG~zGIGIH©HK¢AJ$^P PSEV&GIAHhJXH RQHhL&EMW[G H ºK »&» ^OQEUHh)OQC GXÎN+JXÐFGXL rWgOYEU§ÎNOQEUU P&xCWIÎSH«GIw¨UÏL H>rªARQW~L qSP&CJIRY&UHhGIJH«Ï¬ÐtGIWIq&UOQ}´hH>w H«wzEUÐ ¢UP HhO¨o WICH HhjM+EAGGI¢ULSUW0EAHi¢UP W~L E¶_mJX¢ L GIURYQPH2HhmJEUGIOYP EAUO¨H"WIH>H]GI_iJOQEALSHKW~OQL EUHKE®J~OQEUGXP HK¶|¢°GXPSUOQgE+|GI^G P²|GIHKUOYW«H2&+ZEUGXOYHWgHKG[RQ^¢AHW]P ¡JXGIP&HK|EAGI¢|WIUUOYV&UJIHGa ^P ¢|EAO¨HhWIRYOQhOQ EUA+H WXGgW~RQOQHKW~P OQLSE*´hJXH®EUOYEàOQËEULNmØzeNGXÙzHhHJ0¡|gCWIDFHhHEJXGIOYGI_iP RQOYEUEAHKRQ"E&OYEAG$P HgxEGXL JXUW§L R¨OY¢ULNEUGIP OQH©EUEULSMH4MjkP 4L«GILSUWIEAHKOY_i¢JI§OQEURO¨L WIP&H1J OQWIO¨OYH)¢|EHKV W~E&OQHK´hGXJXH)OQWIKH0KLSLSRQhYE°P Z«JXJIªCªUHKHm|RQLSGP GI§ªAOQP WIOYE"GIHhAJXªCV P H©H|G[¢@G^ EAHh5P HKE*O¨W~AH P&Hh|OQEEAGIWIUGIHhAUJIHGa GIOQP E×jkHKOY&+GXW1 JXHh W~P2RQL JI&HgGXALNG GXUH)·$¸*LSRQ P&JIOYGIA_¾HhE+GIHKJIH©¢²L2JIHK OQP E*PSEU_iHKJIO¨hL R ( *
* ( * ( O* ( *
"5D
%
( $(
( $(
" ?D
"
:
'*
(
7D
1 "
" !D
*
( *
(
" " (-&
)D
' )(,*+*,*+(-&v. " (-&% ' )(-&'% ' )(+*,*,*+(-&'%. ' C> GMHJ ' "!)H,g$ "f# L0 ' % "> GMHJ ' )(-# ' "!)H,g$ "f#
K0 "
]# " %
"
L^
5%
"
( ( S( O
'
20 '
vN
5
OQEALSRQP&_iW[GWILSHhOQRYRQªUO¨Z)LSOQRJ«JXOÕG[Hh¥Z&R¨JXLN^P GX_µxHK¢]A GIWKPm jU·$áGXUa¼¸ªMH4@L EU WIP&HKOQ¢5WIH ·$GIHKJIÞ_¿GXOQWJXL OYJXEUAOQEUO¨LSR@WXUUHKHKJIH4_>¥H©P W*J$Ø E:UÙtj_i§HhJXUO¨O¨hLSRkW~L GXJIL H²ªUOQhRYP O G[_iZ jCULm|GLNP GXEMOYP&¢|EAOÕGXLSOYRQP&YEZ
)
Teacher output signal
Log10 of NMSE
0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3
4
2000
-0.5
2000
4000
6000
\1
8000 10000
4000
6000
8000
10000
-1 -1.5 -2
Log10 of av. abs. weights
Teacher
3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5
vs. network
0.6 0.5
`0 á`OYHh&V UHKJXRYH>P&Ub _i$HhgE+@Gµ×P H©L UHKOYHK&J&P GWhUGIU`g|@G© ¸×L&\W[G0ºK» ±*»m|W~ GIHKA§W OYGI$*¢|HKUWIJIOYH©JX¢|HK¢°O¨¬GIËH©W~¢®P&RYO¨ªA¢AL&W~HKLSRYEAOQEU¢"H>EALSHEAG[^¢®P WIJXRQP &CatUHhJXRQOYHKEU¢|H&O¨¬ GXHK¢ ¢AL WIUHK¢AxWIOQ EAL RËáUP&J$¢|HGLSOQR W§WIHhH1GXH¡GK
0.4
2000
4000
6000
8000 10000
9950
N
10000
+N
~È @ÇÈ[Å Ä ¥GIP AHKJP&V WIP&HhH0JEULSRQLSOYR EURQPS Hx|P&^GIJIAOYHhGIH;OQA ^_i+HhGÓWgRQÕL ¥at¢UPNV L EUHK|PNJIGX§VLSEOQGIHhOQHhP JXEkJIOYÊP&EJ~µxatØÕ UºhJÙzHxL U¢|LSOQJXHh¢UHE+LNGIiGXa¼H$ªA L&W~P+:H©W[¬¢$GjWÊ·$§MUHKJ°HKJIGIH GIOQ_iJ/LSH$OQEUW[OQOQGXWEUHhEU>HhL OYG[E>RY&P GIP&AJXJIOÕH§2GXU_>W~_mOQP+´hWkH&W[GhL HhµÉmE Z+ªMhAOYHOQHKKE+ALSGÓW~RQH©YPSZ&¢ j JXP W~GXHhEALSRQRYOYEMOQH©EU¢UWH²LSP&JE0RQ¢gHKR¨L LSL JIJXUEA UOYH^EUJXP&EUL HhLSG[ARQ HKP&P W@JIJXGX|OYGIJXWUL ¥OY_ P E>JÊW~OQU_mW]JXHKL G[hRYZ|OQUWIEUOYO¨P&HhhG[E«LSRQP&ZP JIJ|_i¢|W^HhP J¥JXP&P H®JX ¢|HhHK¡JCP Hh EMº©W~» OQV »&H²GIb µxA»&L EjSA§WKW[jNUGGIHhLSAJXEAH$HK¢AL&·$LSWJ¸^¢à+|atGIªAHKL&G[W~AZH©EUU¢gOQOQ¯+KULSUH©RQYWhZ $UPN^ HhV&HhJ©jSGXUOQWx¢|JL:§ªAL&0_iOQ +G^ªCH P _iCHhEAWXLNGXHK¢]ª+Z>GXUH1¥P RQYPN§OQEU4UJXP CHhJIGIOQHKWPS·$¸+a OQ_>ARYO¨OYG[Z"PS¢UHKWIOY&E*LSEM¢"OY_iURQHh_iHKE&GLNGXOYP&EkÀkJXP ªUAW~GªCHhML:V+OQP J1§OYGI²RQOYG~GIRQHiEUHhH©¢ ¥P J§RQHKL JIEUOQEU>ALSJLS_iHhGIHhJ§MLSEA¢a¼GIAEUOYEAA AW~GIP _>aF¢|HKWIOQ E°PS·¸+aF|W4§OYGI¶AJIH©WIhJIOQªMH©¢GIJL OQEU"AL JXL _>HhGIHKJXWKj×GXJXL EAW~a ¥HhJXJIOQEUi^HhRQÕatUEA¢|HKJXW~GIPP|¢)RQO EUHKL J$W~Z|W~GIHh_mWx_iHGXUP|¢UWxGXP>EAP EURQOYEAHKLSJ$WIZ|W[GXHh_mWK Z|W[GXHh_mW §OYGI¶RQP EASatRQL&W[GXOYEU"WIUP JIG~a¼GIHKJI_ _>HK_iP JXZ*hL EªMH«RYH©LSJXE&G©«Ó¡ARYP&OÕGLSªURQH |Ô_>HK_iP JXZ]W~MLSEAW§&JIPNݧOÕGX®EUHhG[P&JI]WIOQ´hH)L EALSRQZ|W~O¨W§OQE¶Ø ÚNÙz P&EAWIOQ¢|HKJ§GIAH »SGI)P&JX¢|HKJWIZ|W[GXHh_ ¶º: àGLSEU×Ë» Ûb × *» » × f 6 [ º Û|e (Ê5§ºKOÕ«GX»&² b Êf&Li GXÊHKW~¶×G1 eS»&±*$» ^|»& L&»UW§º©P RQ;HK@LS»UDtJXG E+» xG» cAL P Wº m§RQHKOQµxEUL HgJIUE+HiªGÓZe|ªºZiL a¼GIL&¶»&&»N »&'at"»NUatEUUP OYEUJG¢|OYGLSHhAJL UWI_iZ| _iW[HhGXE+HhHKGI_E&H©GX¢"HK@¢m L&|¢U(ÝLS|§º©GX OÕOYGXV& H Li±²|P »A bU º N JX$³HKRQL ^ OQOY«V EHhL0E²L WIRY¼RYOYHKjÊ_iV P OQHhRE°RL JPSGXURQHhH]UV&JIHhH©ROQEAPSO¨W~¢°OQP UP E²JI^H©OQGW O¨L W~WILNOQ|P GIE«GXWgL L OYEUP&W;H©EAGI¢®WIP|OQ¢U¢|OQE*L:HKJIZ ^H©W¢|_iÔOYEP&V|W~LSWKG^ªCCJXPN&HV JX MH L&EUjÊ¢|HKOQL ¢]Hh¢AE+ LSG~J|atL ªAGX¢|L OYV&OQWIHhH²HKE+¢2G~atL GXªAUHKL& W~U_iH©EA¢>HhOQE+¯+GIGXUHKHKH©¢AAW EU§OQ^¯+OYGI|UH©WhL W WIhOYL _iAOQWIR H^L J &JXE+L&A¢|_gOQHhªCE+G~HhatJ4ªAP L ^WIHKGX¢4JXL GIOYH©EMLSUªUEURQO¨Hi¯&AHKHKWOY&GIJ&LSGOQWmEiHh`0V&HhJX);Z4JIP&P +EAAEUP HKJXPNGIVCOQjP E>UJXOQV:HKLSOY&GIH)&GÓhOQP E>_iGI_gUH$UEA·OQKLN4GIOQj P §EC¬U«HhJX\^HKL&HhWa
Sôô içhì[í&ôî4çhì[ëæò¬çð+éKì[ôXõ|éNé ¨éKêñ ôXì~çKëæå ï
'
%
/
%
] /4%
FN
'BD
O*
"
'
"
$ "
D
%
*
*
m
poFr
*
^
)
" D
zy
'
%:
"
$D
R0 "5D
%
W~GXULSEM¢UWLSGIJJ¢LSOQ·$E²P&EURYW$Z2V|GXWhUCHiP ||GXUW§|JXG HhR¨LNGIHKH4OY&L&+W GXWKjMGXGIUP H>E+AS_g§ªCµxHhJAWWKP jA;·$UEUOYGXWW L P JIH WI_iOY_iP&OQJIR L H4JIhRQZP _iMAHKJ~L ¥P&G§JI_iGIAOQL EUE HKU¯+|UG]OQVNWILSOQ RQHhEAE+L G>R§^P EU|H"WKhL E$JIPNHh^a¼AHhWIV H«HKJKGIjU§H®UWXHKLSE_i^H P £ JXJX+HKOQWIEUHh"JXV §P&OYOYJGI¤UàjÓL&|¢U¢|OQWhEUjÊ¥P&P J0EURQH©Z L °EUEUHKHhÜ GIJP&LSEUOQEUEUHKH©¢¬GIP&OQP |EMG~Wa ªDFLSEEMZ2¢²GIWIUOQ^_gO¨WgHhUOQh RYGXOY+JL GXEUWKAHhm_iP&AµxW~GXW~URQL Z«O¨EAW GIAH&JLSL jkOQW1§EU¥OYOYP&EAGI¶J mOY_gLEMW[U GRYJXLSGIPNEAOQU§hRQH>OQHgEUªC«¥H©HhLNEHKGIUEA_0JIHHgªM¡|HKU¢UJ RQHP GIPSOYH©GI$¬HKGXWI¢*P OY_0J¥WxP&UJ ¥RÕJIGJIP&LSP&_¾EUªMHKP P L)GXAW1W~WIOQRQOYEUZ®E&JIGXRYHH©U¯+H)£UJI$OYH©JXW~HKD~HK*¢*JIV&OQP EAP UW[OQGIJXGXU¤«OÕGX||Ø G GIWhÙ¼H j GIHKA¯+HAL JXRËHK°¯+UµxO¨W~UOYGIHHWIEUOY´KHH2Gx_i¢|O¨P|WXL ¢|¢|HhVNR@LSWIE+OY´KGHKLSW; ¥H]P JxPS^||W;W0V|WKOQ W0GX¥JXUL&JI¢|GIOÕAGXOYHhP&JiEAªALSRLSR¨·$LSEMHK¢¶W^ªMª+H©ZP&_0_>AH1¶L WIZL&_>W[GXUHhGIJ>PSGXP OQmKLSOYRQEAYZH GIHJ¡|LSCOQHhEUJIOQGIEUO¨AW~H1j§¥&P&JIJ§H©LNEUGXP HhEUJ]RQO WIEUOY_iHKL UJ$RQO¨L ¢UOYG[L Z |j$GIOQLSV EMH ¢_iGIP|U¢|H*HhRQ OYEAHKEUAHh JLSR$CP&WXWIOYªUOQR OÕG[ZGIP¶Hh¡|URYP&OÕG2RYOQEUH©LSJIatWIZ|W[GXHh_mW ^ P UJXJX OQ!W~HKGX¢Ü L RYQLSHhGJ]7 ¥GXP B UJ«¶HU7 áUE| JgL EA l>¢à L )hLShJXHhRQRQP&HhWKJ:LNGXOYHhEU°JXHKP&WIE+UV&RYGXHhWkJX P&HKE EAJIH©H& UJXIJXÌÓHhE+ÌÓGkÌ EUH G[^uIqSP UJXÏh$o GX JXL rhOYy|EAuIOYEUq $ k T$rhмEUÑ;OY¥ÎNZuIOYÒNEAÏ j º º+ & Ú&f+d UdN»&fUjbS» »&»U Ø b:Ù4\1+áMLSJXALSEU at\^P&JIP&NÁ[HhEZ &q мw Nr ;w ÐFruÏ nArXÎSu )qNC w Í qNмwÎNUÏ 5OQR HhZ jº©f f cA Ø NÙ4¸ÓW[GX JI4H©LS_ áUHh R¨¢|L NRYLS_m_iLSkE)j A`0RÕGX Hh0Jx GX);JXL JIOYP&EU+OQEUA0P JX¥PNP VCJxj JXHK á^AJI×JX;HhE+L G HKEAEkHhUjJL LSEARC¢°EUHá^G[^ ÓP JXA|LSWhE×2DFE ;MEUAgLS EMiAHK¢|U_0Z UHhRÕGXEMOÕWa LSAEAw h¢ yAr¬AÏ jUMÓLSL EAH©¢|W§HKbS^f L URYQe H Mj HK¢|RQOYGIP&JXHKWKJKjAj º©f ÎNf cAwzCrqNu ²ÎK&r wzs :qS Í r q Í ÒS{ Î r Í n{ Ø SÙ ªMAHK A$L:HhVJIOYGIP&´KJ~ªMatªAHKJIL&MW~jH©¢m4JI P&+ªMLSP HKGX WKHKJKj|DFELSEMá^¢«|á^VNLSME | LSP JXEU_iUHhHKRQJIHhJ©Ekj|¸kH©H©¢|LSOYJXGIEUP J©OYEAj 0GXuIPiÎ Í o JXP NUÐ¥EAn ¢]Ì y|L uXÎGW~o Z_0% ÎSªM P&* RQoÓWxÎSOQE u¬Ðto AÐFo Ì % NjAAL H©W§dS» c Udº:b|&D );JIH©WIWKj|$_mW~GIHhJ¢UL _2jAb » »+b| Ø e:Ù OY4EA +JXLSHKHhh&UHhJIJ©JXHhE+G EUµxHhUUJH LSR ¤ HKEUHhUG[PP&JIW~|GXWKLS GIH©¤ LSl U±®AJI` P+L ·$HhCGIP P JIG LSEAº L &RYcUZ|j WIOYEUl ±®LS` EA¢ a GXJXl1L HhOYEUJIaa _m+G~LSGIE ÛÖ&Ö:§§LNGI OQP EM_mLSR ¢@ ¢|H:·§Ö HK)ÊWIHhHKP L AJXRYHN Ö $HKDFJIEAªCW~HhGIJIOYGKGIU +GILSH Hh&HhJ¥P Ö J);UªURQO KP LN_iGIOQUP |EMGXWhHh +J GI_iRË| OQHhEAhH j b » »Uº& Ø ÚNÙ 4l ±® +` LSHK a¶HhJ©l1¦HhJX_iUL P&E J~G2GIHKLSJIGI_ OQP EA_iL R2Hh_i·$P&HKJIWIZ5HKLSOQJEÜH©DFUEAPàW~GIOYW~GIGX|LSGXGIHH¥EUP HJ G[^P P JX|_iWhU¦|GXl HhJ5±®`|aFOQ·§HhEAHhChH P j²JIGb » º:e »&bUbUj +G~GI ÛÖ&Ö:§§ _m¢@ ¢|H:Ö )ÊHhP ARYHNÖ $HKJIªCHhJIGK +LSHh&HhJÖ );UªURQO KLNGIOQP EMWh +GI_iRË ØÛd©Ù 4·Êµ§ ·$+LS¸ÓHKj: Hh J©½á«µ×LSEA|¢GXP GXJXUOQL HÓRH©P&UE PGXW~JXGXL LNOYGXEUHÓOQEUEUHhG[JIH©P&JIU1JXLSJIHKUE+UG«JXP&EUL&HKUkJXSL l R±®EAH`àG[^·§P HhJXCWKP jJIG;hº©PNe V fUHhJXj:OQáUEUJLSU+\ EA),U)PS¥µ HKJ j DFEAW~GIOYGI|GXHg$D~jCbS» »+b| Ø cNÙ W[GLSªU±®RQHL W~L&GXLSWIWKGIjÓHKW µ Ê5EULNHhGàWIA¥JRQLSL _iHh HhHK^JKjP JXL EA¢¥P&J;4EUHK±®UJXL L JIRAJP&LS_i_U|GX·§LSHKGIOQL P RÕa¼EmGIOQªA_iL&H«W~H©¢>P&P _iEmUC|HhGIJIOQEUGIUJXªA§LNOÕGXGXUOYP&P EAUWKG +G~GI ÛÖ&Ö:§§ O¨Wh GIU&JXL ´ LNGÖ:OQ O¥Ö:_mL L&WIW¬Ö:AW~ ARQHKW¬ÖN¸|±atVCºK» Ú| C¢|[j&bS»&»&b| Ø fNÙ GXLSGIOQP ±®E¶L&OQL E¶WXWh jHKµxEUHhkJX×O¨mEULSGXHhWXAJXUL R RLS _iHKO¨JKjJXPLSEAhOY¢ J4AOÕGWh±®®LSDFJXEàJXL _2\^mH©Ü Hh_iJ©jP|¢|HKRµx¥UP J JIAJXEkHKjL RÕLSa¼GIEAOQ¢ _iHiih P _iªCUHh|JIaa _m L:Z Hh J©jHK¢UOÕGXNP MJ±"Whj D[µ )Ó:JXqSHK WXÍ Whr¬jUÏ2b » wz »&bU rhy|uIq * ÎNu¬mqNмwÎN uIÎ Í rÏϬwz+s :ϬÐtrh uXÎ Í o L
%
>
e
!z
(
'&
2
)
vN
!
)
)
!
)(*,+
-
$#%
"
Ie
.
+
' N
p
+
dN
/
dN
/
)
dN
+N
0
56" *7(3(-*+
1
"
)
e
2#3%4& "