Adaptive Wireless Mesh Networks Routing Protocols - umexpert

0 downloads 0 Views 335KB Size Report
Abstract Y The attractiveness of Wireless Mesh Networks. (WMNs), in ... A comparison of existing ..... between PDr and routing overhead. all speed types have.
2010 Symposia and Workshops on Ubiquitous, Autonomic and Trusted Computing

           









    

             

                

! "       #  #     # $ 

$%

$  & '   &      

# $  % %   $     



  & % %     

    # $   &  (    

   %$       #  

 %( )           

$%            

*         (  

  $     %        

   !    "     +   

   %       %     

        (    

  %          

%   %      %# $(  %  

*              

 (



* '  &  4 ,./  ,5/ 4 ,-6/ 7,-8/,-9/ ,.:/   *2 "# ,.; .?+ '   "# ( (((  '"&3 -   # $ %! @  ( ( '  & +(  & ) + "# )  "  ,55/   (+()    (& "     2 ' ( ((  (  &")     ),.A/ " (* &2' + "#  +(*  &  2 '  "#  .      @  & +(   2 +*   &'2) ( + 222)(#2#&++) ** & 

   !    "# $%  "& &'(    '   #) ( &  *  ++( ' " "#   )+() ( ' (( + $ % "      ( ,- .-/   "  0&  -  1          !   " "# ( (      ( +) * ) # '   & 2 &     2 '   ) '& & 2   & + ((  '& + ''( +        ' "# 

5  &        ( '   2  & +   2    & (     "  ,../     *) ( "# (   >?+(  !  $>B% ( ,.5/  +'   C+! (2  & ))("#$ &     2)%   C+ !  ( +' 2  >B  A  '

 ( #   @  &    (  +"2)2  '( ('  & +((12)' ( '+ '  (    "  ,--/   +"  ( 2 +*)D  ('( ",56/     '   ++  &   '"  (  +* + +( + ' +  (  (  2) (   * 2  ' +* +(     '     ?+ &  "       ( +(4 (4+*  *)?&+* &+( +   (  ((   '   "#  ( 4 (4  

 

  > !  >>0

  



   ( " +*   *) ' +( +   *  + ' +  *)& "# (   '(   4  "' * ( +( 

0& -3 "#

()*" &+( *2 &  +* ( (   "  ( 978-0-7695-4272-0/10 $26.00 © 2010 IEEE DOI 10.1109/UIC-ATC.2010.28

 142

(  0 ,&6 % 6 2  !,62"

( ,%'  - .  !,-."

4,5/(((*( &&     (( ' 4 +(  4 )   )++*+' (' # 2#&  4   2(   =  $>F% (*) &    (   +) $>% &   *     2#  ?+ ''(  "     > & $>%    ''( + & 2   +     (   +(' = "2+   "  2'  

   +(* )+ +(     + ) $% " (      ( ' '&2))(& #'& 2 "    '  #    &  "#  (+)2  +) ( )    C &   - + & 2 ("+&) ! $!% &   '   (    " +( &  ( 2) ,-./01--,/)12-

!,0)"  ,,-,34/5,,-/)12- !5)" " (  "2?+ ? 2( 

 4 " +  2 '   ( 2 '   ?+   +*     " +5)21/,71/)1,7 !" 01--,/)12- !0)"(   ?  2( " (     "   *  '   41 + *+("#+'( 

 "

,-./01--,/)12- !,0)"

)     '= ()  ( 2) ,-./01--,/)12- !,0)"  1  +()' + +'& 2 & "   C & *) *) (  )    ( ' ' - + & 2  '  & 2       (    . + & 2  "# ')      ( 1  '   + + ' &#+&) 

 "

+ ( "&   #+        & 2 '     (('   ' +(#          '

 (    " *      '    & 2 ,5/  '    *      " 2 (* 0  ,A;/ 

  &  +(    2) '   "#    +'(( 2   (# *)  $% " (     '( '   ((' )+(#(**+(#   # 2#& (  2)  &  + ' 2  2( '=  &  *  " &   "# +'( (    " #+  &    2#     &  +(#  (  (& * ' 

 ,68-:/ &&  ?  '' 2"   & +  2"  *   +"( +" *) * E 1((&)  &  " *  ' C &  +*   +( (*)#' $= (#(' %  (    & +  2   " * +(  2"   +" ( +  (& C *  (( &* ,9/" (  *) 2 '   & "#     '  && +* (     ('&  C + 2  # '  '= () 2"  "#    +" ( +    & "# +'(2 

 "

 "

5)21/,71/)1,7 !"

01--,/)12- !0)"

C>G>4  $C%   +  4  (*  # '    "#  '   1 (*   & '  & 2  ' 01--,/)12- * --, 16/01--,/-,..      ( 2#  '   (*   &'& 2 "('  & 2) & 2   #2#& ++ '= )     *& &  C *  "  "# +'( (  " #  &     2#&   &  +(#    "  (     & +  *  '   "#  C"* &  " C " ( 2"  ( +  &*  "  2)'( +" +(& (    ('   )   2 "'((+2()  & +   "#    2   (( C *    'C+2+*+ 

,,-,34/5,,-/)12- !5)"

  + +    ,,-,34/5,,-/)12- !5)" " (   '*'&+&)!$!% & "     ' * #   2 (+  )    ) $%   ! &   (   ! & (  '  + & 2  " (   (       !& ' &2((  

 2 ) 2    "   !   &  +(   & *  ,6 8/ 2   +(     +  ,9/   &&2''(  & + ,-:/ 0  ( 2((  (!  & +(*  +&  "    "#   " +*   "# +'(  ?+ +2" C!* " ( +'!* + C* *(* 

0   '   ,?+, 





  * & '      )   )  2)''(' 41+(2) & '' * ' + +(   " . ,A:/  '&+'&  .5 ' &' +J+ ,- ,+ K " - .     *  $     &  %    +'( (  + "2-     " (  "# ' ;:  "  -;  ( +    +( ) "  -::: B -:::    +' 5:      " *&      ''(      A





 



     

 



 



 



0& 53* 

144



 





0         ?  '' 2"    & *    + )+ * +  *  '    =   : ; (  0  +';K$"2)%+2"9:M "  * = .(" '+ '-:-;K"+2"9:M' *  -(  2"  ""# " (        '  &      )  ( *    "  " *  +2 '&'9:M +';K    (   *  ' - ( "  '  +'-:-;K * ': ;(  2  

 *&2)*  4 '& 2 ( &  & &   +( ( &  

  +  4   +(  (

4 '(* (+2"

4  4  2   (+   "+(  "  4 2 "* (+ 4   5(  ,-. !,-."

   +*  ,-5/ +(    ' # 2#    2) (      2( '      "  ' 'J #   & 2   " (  & 2   +((& ( &#   '    ' 2) *J 3   4  &.  4 */%& "23   (    2'#2#1 #2?(  ++  "( & 4 */%& '3   *- & 2   4 */%&   " ( &  2) *  4 &. 5  H    2) * *  '  )'//*0'&1/  2//6'%% " +*)        "# (      +  ,-5/  "  

  &    " *  (+   

4   4> I!  ( ?  & +( '        & +(  +&  )  2  2 '  "# (  &  "# & +'( "   )    *    ) "&'  ) 2'+* & +(   2& ++ '    ( 2 (&   " )+J   '    

 %   ,-5 59 A: A- A. A5/    (   $#      ,-A AA A;/    ( " (2  (    ++ +*  &+(2 "(&  

 

6( # $

!."

(   (  .   

 '   +* +(    (&)   ? ' ?&   & +(     & +( " )() ( & ( + )+ "# '   &+('"



. & %  '

  ++  ,55/  2) ( (  >*4()($ 4%    * 2) '    "#  I)  4  (+  2     ((+  ,5-/   (  ,A-/  4 "&  (  & 2  2     (* +(# '   & 2   &    + *    ++(    2     +(#   (  0   (( * ' 4 ' ("2   +   (+   4 *    2  & +( +    ( =       + )'//*0'&1/  0'&1/  (  2)" ( 2 4*  ! &*  'C*!*"")2' . ; " (   2  '  *  ' !  C * " (   ;  . ( +(*)       "     +' 2   '  (+   2  *  & ) &  *  '

& 2)( 

 (  ,62

+* 4 ,.9/  2) ( '  + 2) '& 5  ' 2) *J "  & H)+()( (#&  2'-

+ & 2  +* 4 " ( " (  +++ 2) *  2     ( " ''( )'//*0'&1/ ' 4 " (    ((&)  : 6; $ & % - : $%  ; : $"%     " (+ 4 "  +*+(#()   8(    &6 % 9 # $ !"



 ++  ,5-/    ((+ 

+* 4  +*" 2' - + & 2  2) (+&  (    + *'& 2 1 2 >( 2"  *&  2) (''& 2 *  * 2%**)  D     & (3'0('&*3 $" (   = *  )'//*0'&1/  4% +  4 2



)  &   (  

C)2  & +(   (2 ' " '')+' &+(&+(   ' )2  &+(   2++ ' '"3  145

( .  0$#     

!.0"

**   (*       +2 ' &  *  ( ( &(2 (         )  "     +'2  4 

C  ,-A/   ++( +('( +( " (    +) (  + & "   +(# *  &    & ) D   C  (  +*) 2  +(*  (*  " (    2)      "  +(*     +(*  "    2  & +( "    (*  "  4 +( '    & &  H() +(*   (  ()  '   2) 2'(&''(2)  "#  (*)+(# ''( "2(E'* 1" * & +(*       "    ''(" *+(* $+ ) (* &% 

     "     &    ")" (+ 4   4  !  )+* &+( *2++' 2+'( "# C"*      '  +* =   ( * 2  ''(  &  2 .  5      + ++ ' (  '   6 +(*" ++3 

   "   C  +' "  &  2) "  (+  4 "  " *  2  * & ) &  *  "   (  " 2) 

8  

  

  

 %  !"

   

 %  !"

4

2)$* '= ()' ( &-

+ & 2 %

C>G>4 



4

2)$* '= ()' ( &-

+ & 2 %





2)$* '= ()' #H#%

C>G>4  NI>



2)$* '= ()' ( &-

+ & 2 O%

C>G>4  N!G>4 



  



+*

4

8( 5%  !5-"

!  $!% ,5A/   )2  & +( ' (2' 4 !"+  &2 * ((&  '"#   +( " *    ' + " (   +(* (*  (     ) " ++(*$++ %'"#    -:  " "(  (*  $+ %'"# 2&& -:   (( &"# $'++ %  &   -:  +(  $+ %    "   -:  "( & (+ $+ %  (    &   (+     "  +&    +*  +  $++    + %2  '&" 

 



   ,59/  "   !   2 D   42  & ) & +(#   4'&"# 

 

 5( $   ! "

,5;/(2' 4   '   4    *

4 $ %   (  ")+  "   "     "  4     & +( $&  4 & & % )+* &   ")"#(+*(2) 1+*    2) $*)%2) &    2 ' # 2#  '  * ") $  "  2 ' # 2#% "# " * & & $&  '

+( '( &%2) *&")+  "  " *    & $  2 ' ")+ % '   * '   " )

 

146

 >G>

2.3( +!+



  

8  

  

  

 %  !"



 +

C 

 N 4

''( * # = )

+& ' +(** (* 

!

4N

"# 

"( & 2" 4 



N 4

2)$* '= ()' #2#%

+ &  

253C)2 &(!+

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

4  !!   ++" *')(+  4 N   *"   +(     & +( +'( 2    2 '     * *"*+* &+($+'    (*  +(* +(%    (  '& 41 * " &   2)  )  0     *   "( +*+(   '&  * (2     *+& ' +* ( " 2 + '  & +('( "#*$D   %      '& " +  *+  +*( 2&2"#+))#' "#*+' &+(   

!L>I>>  ! '  $! %  '  2)  

 I*  + 2)   3.  7       " 3   '   "     (  ! (   &       '8+&   >0>>!> 

,-/  0  #) B &P  *) "#Q '''      !*A5$9%++ .55:.::;  ,./ ! > # >  H&)     P  C(  (4($ 4% &Q&49+:,.::5  ,5/  !  R(= P+  # &( $%Q&4 9:;:.::5 ,A/ !  (  !  >  #  !  +  P'&  +

(*     '   4  & (Q ''' %'*.::;  ,;/    L  I)    #D P C(   ( 4( $ 4% '(  ( "  (*     Q 2%'%        * 6++ 9-.9.-.::8  ,* & +'( '   ( "# & 4 "   & (  ' & ( ((*)Q''' (&.::;  ,6/ !  I    I(  R   P   + 2  )' +'(' ("#*Q,, " ' . 2   .::;  ,8/ !  I     P+*& +'( '    ( "# 2) &+Q''' %.::;  ,9/ 7  !  C &   H     # P & Q ''' (&.::3 '( )  &Q'''/*.::<  ,--/           L    & P> (&   E&1 (+   &'" H) "  ( 'Q     <  '    &3  !  )Q 3)**2.::8  ,-A/ 4   2 S  R  C  >  IT  PC 3 

)2+* &+('2 ("#Q  *7)*.::5 

 

147