An Exact Algorithm for Solving Difficult Detailed Routing Problems

An Exact Algorithm for Solving Difficult Detailed Routing Problems Kolja Sulimma

Wolfgang Kunz

J. W. Goethe-Universität Frankfurt

J. W. Goethe-Universität Frankfurt

[email protected]

[email protected]

ABSTRACT


 

  !#"%$ !%$& #' (!"*),+-
! !./ #0 12 34 15*
6
! 72 8:9%; K:3@GP1
_"%@ ! ^ $Y_``Q> K:3@ GP1
*>!#N&) b& :
SJ > JGcK
  P;& d./ d!B "%$ (L2R (.]$ ' 

"A.e
! K K
F V #&! P 6GP1
*ZKNJ KNS  V# ! K  ) column

3

dogleg

1

3 left edge port

1

right edge port

2 1

unconnected port

track

fPg/hHiVjJkmln*oqpr@s:tu(r&vUv(w,s!x y t:z#{|}x ys~Fx v/yE*€Xz‚ Sz#€@tRx@| rS~Fƒr&€E€z4v…„>"% (N_'>FN_  _
 Z> !FN%GR (5;! #&( R"%@N& }) C ^L (N&Ž'>FN^"%@N  }0   6 "%;^  (FNYGP
Y >$E!^,#?4 #    (NH) C 
‡ Z> !N^ (5;! "%@N  # d (5;! ( >! ?4FNŠ./
 #;K …# !‘_ 6> 3@‘mNS
! ?#FN8./ d?4! >F ‰!!#PF  (N*N # #) +-
Q"%#ZŠ#"%"%.T "R (Y.2
SK
! - #   $ ' "O (d  …$E >6Q
d#$DNQ'E>#"A'E# N  >5 .]
R:
  }) W LK !FND
R"%7"%@N  }0‰'&2
L ! > 1d  1
"cF7># ?4 "% ]# ! K @$ ' "’ZK  P %#N N 1# …!#Z6S ;"% d"%!"% >5;) “Š” k@jJ•Z–J—Vk;•˜#k&™T™U•ZjšEiV–Fg}›VhVn 
d! "% ‡.œ
2 !‡FS'E $ (!FNJ7 '1> KJ >5$E#>1#
 (NR'E‡ FN‡Q7# "%8‡ (3# 15%R'E   K' dGP1
  N ! ) ž‰Ÿ gU–F˜#—H š ¡Y¢Ji…£…£ešj–n 
$& #' (!"¤ZK 7 ^  (FGFN Q
J?#R$E > KJ >57>
$E Š@5L (5;! F) C .&
!  !B&(ZeP># &( *
  *$& #' (!"¦
#?4!X #  *"%@N  }0 
L ( 1
"AGP  VMN^F) ž g}›‰hE™/k,™/¥@§Ek@j^¨…šhE™/k@hE¢#n  1

LG-N&UNL…ZœF0JG'E!

(!?4
Jœ
 #  d"%@N& ;FR'E!B@N FN# ^ (5;! 7N # LGP1
Œ# 15,"% L:
S
  # 1
"*) ©2  # 
"ª> d #&
 :
  ;GP1
6#?4R& " 'E! «….  d> KK3&)+-
 $$& #$ (J-.T $$ FJ( GP1
8 K(
;>.T >G- KN8!B@># -.V#& ‡$$ #K
% "Š 1Ž (5;! L #&N.T 
%  Z> !FN (5;! R"%@N  })

1

1

1

0

1

0

1

0 2

1

0

1

0

2

ÓÔ՜Ö×ØÙ>Ø Ø!Ú@ÖØÛÙ>ÜÔÛمÖ× Ø Ö×Ø!ÔÕØ!ÖÜÝFÞß@ÕØ!Ù>àß1ÖÔáßÜ(Û ØFÞÕÕà Û;ÖÜ(â%Ø áTÔՇÞÕKÞÝ!ÖKÞçßØ2ÝK×ÞÛÛØ!ßåPÜUæ@Ö×SçEØ!ÝÔ#â%ØÙ ÖÔ;Ô Ù>â^ÞßßHáTÔÕdè&ÕKÞÝ!ÖÜÝFÞߜÞèèßÜÝFÞJÖÜ(ÔÛÙê ë-×ØLÝK×ÞÛÛØ!߉ÕÔà ÖÜÛã%è&ÕÔ#çßØâìå-ÞÙdÜ(Û;Ö>ÕÔ@æ&àÝØFæSç@íSîÞÙ>×Ü1é â%ÔÖÔRÞÛæQï;ÖØä4ØÛ Ù2ðñ!òVÜÛ,ñó4ô@ñêõŽÖ‡ÜÙPÞ7åØßßVÙZÖàæ ÜØFæ^è ÕÔ#ç ßØâ ÞÛæ8Ö× Ø!ÕØØ!Ú&ÜÙZÖPá}ÞÙZÖdÞß(ãÔÕÜ1Ö×â%هÖ×ÞÖPè ÕÔJä@Ü(æ ØØÖÔÔè é ÖÜâ^ÞßeÙ>Ô#ßà&ÖÜ(Ô۝Ù>à Ý:םÞÙÖ×ØRãÕØØæ&íÕÔ#à&ÖØ!ÕLè ÕØÙ>Ø!Û@ÖØæ,Üۏð öFòŽê î2ÔFåØä4Ø!ÕF÷eÝK×ÞÛÛØ!ß]ÕÔà ÖÜÛãDÜيÔá/ÖØÛà Ù>ØFæXÜÛXÖ×Ø%ÝÔÛ;ÖØ!Ú@֊Ôá ÖÜâ%Ø!éŽÝÔ#Û Ù>àâ%ÜÛãÖÔ;Ô#ß1øÔJåPÙêùÓÔÕ^Ø!Ú Þâ%èßØ#÷-â^ÞÛ;íÙZÖKÞÛæÞJÕKæ ÝØß߉èß(ÞÝ!Ø!ÕÙPÙ>èEØÛæ^×Ôà ÕÙ-áTÔÕ6Ù>Ü(âRàß(ÞÖØæSÞÛÛØÞßÜÛã%ÞÛæSÙZÖKÞJÖØ ÔáÖ× ØLÞÕ>Öú‡ûDüØDÜ1ÖSÜÙ8Û ÔÖSÛØÝ!ØÙ>ÙÞÕ>íÖÔX×ÞFä4ØDä4Ø:Õ>íYáTÞÙZÖ ÕÔ#à&ÖÜÛãRÞßã#ÔÕÜÖ× â%ÙêeõÛ ÙZÖØFÞ#æH÷@ÜÖâ^Þý4Ø!Ù Ù>ØÛ Ù>ØdÖÔ7Ù>èEØÛæ%Ù>Ôâ%Ø â%ÔÕØÝÔ#â%è à ÖÜÛã6èEÔFå-Ø!Õ]Ô#Û7ÕÔ#à&ÖÜ(Û ãÜÛÞÛÞÖ>ÖØ!â%è ֜ÖÔ2á/à Õ>Ö× Ø!Õ Üâ%è ÕÔJä4Ø6Ö×ØLþ;àÞß(Ü1Ö íSÔáœÖ×ØdÕØÙ>àß1ÖÜÛã%ß(Þí;Ô#à&ÖFê ë-×Øâ^ÞÜۊâ%ÔÖÜ(äÞÖÜÔÛRáTÔÕeÖ×Üٜå-ÔÕýR×ÞÙçEØØÛ7ÖÔÕKÞdÝØßß@ÕÔ#à&ÖÜ(Û ã ê]ï;ÖKÞÛæÞÕKæLÝØßß&ã#ØÛ Ø!ÕKÞÖÔÕÙ]ÞÛæ Ô#Û^Ö×Ø6øí^ßØFÞJáœÝØßßHã#Ø!ÛØ!ÕKÞJÖÜ(ÔÛ*ØÛ ÝÔ#à Û@ÖØ:Õ-Ù>â^ÞßßHçà&ևæ&ÜÿÝàß1Ö ÕÔ#à&ÖÜÛãÜãÛ ï@í&ÙZÖØâ%ÙPÝK×Ô;ÔÙ>ØRÝK×ÞÛÛØ!ßVÕÔ#à&ÖÜÛã%áTÔÕÜÛ;Ö>ÕKÞÝØßߜÕÔ#à&ÖÜ(Û ã êPõ Û é Ö>ÕKÞÝØß߉ÕÔ#à ÖÜÛ ã%ÝßØFÞÕß1íDçEØÛ Ø ÖهáUÕÔ#âOÔ#à&ÕÞçÜßÜÖ íQÖÔ%×ÞÛæ&ßØ èEÔÕ>ÖÙLÜÛÙ>Ü(æ&Ø^Ö× ØÝK×ÞÛ ÛØß ÞÛæÔ#ç ÙZÖKÞÝßØÙ7Ù>àÝK×XÞÙRä@Ü(ÞQè ßUÞÝØ!é â%ØÛ;ÖÝ!Ô#Û;Ö>ÕKÞÜÛ;ÖÙ%á/ÕÔ#â ßUÞí;Ôà Ö%á/ØFÞÖà&ÕØÙ^ÔáÖ× ØDÞÝ!ÖÜä4Ø÷-èEÔ#ß1í ÞÛæmÝÔ#Û;ÖKÞÝ!ÖQß(Þí;Ø!ÕF ê 6ßÙ>Ô ÷6Ö Ô ÛæYÖ×ØÔ#è&ÖÜ(â^Þß6ÕÔà ÖÜÛã[ÜÙ ä4Ø!Õ>í^Üâ%èEÔÕ>ÖKÞÛ;Ö-áTÔÕPÜÛ@Ö>ÕKÞ7ÝØßßHÕÔ#à ÖÜÛ ã ê  ÕÔà ÖÜÛãŠÞßã#ÔÕÜ1Ö×â Ö×ÞJÖÕKÞÝKýDÝÔàß(æŒâ^Þý4؊Ü1ÖÙ>Üç ß(Ø^ÖÔ*ÕØFÞß( Ü ØSÞDßØFÞá6ÝØßß-Ü۝Ö× Ø8ÞßßÔ;ÝFÞÖØFæÝØ!ß(ß×ØÜã#×;ÖF÷ Ö×@àÙPæ&Ø!ÖØ!ÕÜÔÕKÞJÖÜ(Û ãÖ×ØÙ>ÜÛã%ÔáeÔ#ÛØ ÝÔß(à â%ÛSÜÛ*â%ÔÕØØ!Öjz;{G|PÔá]Þßß èEÔ#Ù>Ù>Üç ß(ØÖ>ÕKÞÝ:ýSÞÙ>Ù>ÜãÛâ%ØÛ;ÖهáTÔÕ6Ö× Øè ÕØ!ä&ÜÔàÙPÝÔ#ßà â%Û*ÞÛæ è ÕÔ@æ&àÝØ!ÙPފÙ>Ø!j Ö z;{eÔá]Þß߉èEÔ#Ù>Ù>ÜçßØÕKÞÝKýSÞÙ>Ù>Üã#Û â%ØÛ;ÖÙ-áTÔÕ Ö×Ø2Ýà Õ>ÕØÛ;ÖPÝÔßàâ%Û*ÞÙPÔ#à Öè à ÖFêõ Û*Þææ Ü1ÖÜÔ#ۉ÷Ù>Ôâ%Øàç&ÕÔ#à&ÖÜ(Û ØÙ-Û ØØFæ^Ü(Û&áTÔÕâ^ÞÖÜÔ#ÛDÞçEÔ#à&Ö-Ö×ØèEÔÕ>ևßÔ;ÝFÞÖÜÔÛÙê

2. ALGORITHM

ØæXÞßã#ÔÕÜ1Ö×â¦Ü(Ù7Ö×Ø%ÝÔÛÝØ!è Ö7ÔáPÖ>ÕKÞÝKý Þ Ù>Ù>ÜãÛâ%ØÛ;ÖÙêªÖ>ÕKÞÝKýÞÙ>Ù>Üã#Û â%ØÛ;ÖÜ(ãÛÞß(Ù6ÖԊÕÔ#à&ÖÜÛãRÖ>ÕKÞÝ:ý@Ùê XØRÕØè ÕØÙ>Ø!Û@Ö7Þ^Ö>ÕKÞÝKýÞÙ>Ù>Üã#Ûâ%Ø!Û@ÖLç;íDÕØÝ!ÔÕKæ ÜÛ ãQáTÔÕRØÞÝK× Ö>ÕKÞÝKýSÖ× ØLÙ>Ü(ãÛÞ߅Ö×ÞJÖ2ßØFÞFä4ØÙ6Ö×ØLÝÔß(à â%Û*Ô#ÛDÖ× Ü(ÙPÖ>ÕKÞÝKýE
ê dß1é ÖØ!ÕÛÞÖÜä4Øß1í;÷&å-ØLÝÔ#à ß(æQÕØÝÔÕKæQá/ÔÕdØFÞÝK×DÙ>Üã#ÛÞ߅Ö× ØÖ>ÕKÞÝKýSÖ×ÞJÖ Ü1Ö]Ü(Ù]Ô#ۉêeë-×Ø:ÕØPÞÕ Ø œÖ>ÕKÞÝ:ý@ÙeÙ>ÔÖ×ÞJÖ]Þã#Üä4ØÛRÝÔ#ßàâ%ÛRÝFÞۊÔ#Ûß1í çEØ%Ý!ÕÔÙ>Ù>ØFæç@íŒÞJ֊â%ÔÙZ Ö Ù>Ü(ãÛÞß(ÙêõŽÖ7Ü(ÙLÖ×Ø:ÕØ!áTÔÕØ8Ù>à&ÿ%ÝÜØÛ;Ö áTÔÕ6ØÜ1Ö×Ø!ÕPÙ>Øâ^ÞÛ;ÖÜ(Ý6ÖÔRÕØè&ÕØÙ>ØÛ;ևÖ×Ø6Ö>ÕKÞÝKý8ÞÙ>Ù>Üã#Û â%ØÛ;ևç;í8Þ é\Öà èEØß  "!-ÔáÜÛ;ÖØã#Ø:ÕÙ6ÜÛQÖ× Ø2ÕKÞÛ ã#$ Ø # %&'"(Žê ë-×Ø7è ÕÔèEÔ#Ù>ØFæ,ÞßãÔÕÜ1Ö×â¤à Ù>ØÙÙ8Ö× Ø*ÝK×ÞÛ ÛØ߇áUÕÔ#â ßØ!á/Ö^ÖԝÕÜã#×;ÖF÷PÔÛØ*ÝÔßàâ%ÛmÞJÖSÞ

2

0

(c)

¯P°/±H²V³J´^µH¶·E¸¹ º»&¼E½d¾4º;¿!¾ÀÁe¿F¾¼(»@Á>¿ÃFÄ ¼/ÅEÆÇÄ@ÈH¿Â¾2¾É»&ÆSÊH¼(¾ ¸/º%Ë]¸(¹ ÅÀ!¾7½2Ä º»&¼/¼;¿FÂÀ:¾¾2ʉÄ&ÁKÁ!¸(ÌH¼(¾d¿!À!»@ÃÍ ÁJÎ]ύ¿‡ÃJ»&º^ºÄ;¿-¾#º@¿:¾À Ä º¿Â¾^ÁK¾ÃFÄ ºÐ,¿!À!»@Ã͉щÌH¾ÃJ»&ÅÁ¾^»QÊHÄ&À:¿ILKMOPBCC B,kG F\>T7NL\DE%MF"I,|}†OkJM%kWTC x RB,kFILKMnABCDE%FIjN.T7A0x6Q"S6IjN.TA.x6kJM&K!T,Y1MnBFC]S6IqkB
A0KB+G AMH OPB7NZILKM y NLHVIIjN.T7A0xeWˆM|M8G ILKM8NnHVI.T;NjInT6RB+\+C M\6B7NZkM~RB%FBI,e }qF‰IjN.TA.x3Š'‹Œv‹hMTA.KŽBOUILKMvAB+F y \DN.T7ILG BFH(BOnIjN.T7A0x H ŠILB>ŒJŠvTC]NLM,TRS‘RM8ILM0NLE%GFMH
kKM8ILKM8N
ILKM8NLMvG H6T>RB+\C M\ ABFFM8A8ILG B+F‰QM8IqkJMMF’IjN.TA.x HŒUTFR‰Œ “Še z KM(B+FC S'A.KBG AM C M8OIG HILB%RMAGRMUkKM8ILKM8NXILKM0NLMUGHTABFFM8A8ILG B+FvILBILKMUFM8p I IjN.TA.xe z KG HnNLM,RDAMHXILKM~FDE
QM8NBOlB+gILG B+FHnOBN&M,T7A0K?IjN.TA.x ILB>” e=•DNjILKM8NLE%BNLM+‚[ILKM8NLM(GH~FB?A.KB+G AM(OPB7NILKM6CTHVIIjN.T7A0x‚ TFR(ILKMnILBI.TC{F DE~QM8NWBO[RB+\C M\+HXG HT;IXE%B+HVI„ou…/‡,e z KG HQBDFR'G H%FBI
ILG \K I,‚JQMA,T7DHjMILKM8NLMvT;NLMODNjILKM0NNLM8t HVIjNLG A8ILG B+FHB+F%ILKMXRB+\+C M\Hel•BNJM8pTE%gC M+‚"T|RB+\CM8\~QM\G FFG F\ B+FTF>B"AADgG M,R–IjN.T7A0xwA,T7FBFC]S–MF!R?B+FTFM8E%gIqSvB+FMTF!R Y G AMJY1M0NLHLTe€}†F&E%B+HVI[ABC DE%FH{ILKM F DE
QM0N/B7O!gB+HjHjG QCMRB+\C M\+H G HCM8HjHXILKTFhj—7˜ 2.3 Channel width minimization

z B y F!R‘ILKMwE%GFG E
DE™A0KTFFMCXkG@R ILKŽš›ILKM?TC \+B7NLG]ILKE E DHVIQMGF Y1Bx1M,R%OPB7NM,TA.KA.K!T7FFM8C!kG@R ILKd‚HVI.T7NjILG F\~kG]ILKILKM
A.K!TFFMC/RMFHjG]IqS"e z KM|A8B+E
QG FM,RNLDF"ILGE%MUG HXILKM&HjDEœBOILKM NLDF"ILG E%MHB7O TC C{GF Y1Bx+T;ILG B+FHe z KM>NLDF"ILG E%MBO%T‘HjG F\CM'G F Y1B+xT7ILG BF“\7NLB;kH–HjDgM0NLM8pgBt FM8F ILGT7C/kG]ILK?ILKM&A0KTFFMC/kGRILK{e z KM&OPB+C C B,kG F\DFM,ž"DTC G]IqS KBCRHOBN&T7C C/OPDFA8ILG B+FHUŸwILK!T7IZ\NLB,k T;IZC M,T7HVIUM8pgB+FMF"ILG@T7C C S) ¡£¢ …/‡ Ÿ/`§¦c%‹©¨Zª"Ÿ/`Pšnc0e z KM(A8B+E
QG FM,R>NLDF"ILGE%M%B7OTC CWG Ft Y1Bx+¤8T;¥ IL‡ GBFHZkG]ILKT(A.K!T7FFM8C€kG@R ILKDg?ILB(š«ILKM0NLM8OPB7NLM%GHZB+FC]S Q"S6TUAB+FHVI.TF"IOPTA8ILB7NC@T;NL\+M8NWILKTF6G]OdkJMZKT+R%x FB,kF%ILKMZBgILG]t E
DE“A.K!T7FFMC"kG@R ILK
G FTRYTFAM+e z KMQMFA0KE6T7NLx G F\NLMHjDC]ILH C G HVILM,R–G F z TQC M¬
HjKB,k«ILK!T;InILKM|B;Y1M8NLKMT+RwOPBNZILKM
G]ILM8N.T;ILG Y1M A,T7CC G F\’G H(FM\C G\G QC M+e z KMwCTHVIAMC CZB7O&M,TA.K5I.TQC MwAB+C DE%F K!T7HT
E
DA0K6KG\M8NXY+T7C DMILKTFTC CdB7ILKM8NA8MC CHXBOdILK!T;IAB+C DE%F ILB+\M8ILKM0N,e

3. IMPLEMENTATION

ˆ=MWG E%gCM8E%MF"ILM,R|ILKNLMMY1M8NLHjG B+FHlB7O{ILKMTC \+B7NLG]ILKEve}qE%gC M8t E%MF"I.T7ILG BF f DHjM8H[TKTHjK|HjM8I€ILBXHVILBNLMJILKMlHjM8IB7OIjN.T7A0xUT7HjHjG \+Ft E%MF"ILHed}qE%gC ME%M8F I.T;ILG B+Fn­?DHjM8H[TWKM,T7gUHVIjNLDA8ILDNLM ILKT7I/TC C B;kH BOM0pT7A8IYGT
E%G FGE%G ®,T;ILG B+FwT7F!RHjBE%M|KMDNLG HVILG AUNLDF"ILG E%MZG Et gNLB;Y1M8E%MF"ILHeU}qE%gCM8E%MF"I.T7ILG B+F?¯DHjMHnE~DC]ILG Y+T7CDM,RwRM8AG HjGBF RGT7\N.TE%HnILB(NLMgNLM8HjMF"InILKMHjM0I&BOJIjN.T7A0x?T7HjHjG \+FE%M8F ILHUQ"S?G]ILH A.K!T7N.T7A8ILM8NLG HVILG AUOPDFA8ILG B+F{e }qF=TC CG E%gC ME%MF"I.T;ILGBFH|TvIjN.TA.x=T7HjHjG\FE%MF"I~G H~HVILB7NLM,R'TH TFvT7NjN.TS(BO[hG F"ILM\M8NLHGF(ILKMnN.T7F\+MUB7O°~ILB|hkG]ILKILKMUYTC DM

± RMFBILG F\TF?ME%gIqSIjN.TA.xwTFR’¬|ILB%hRMFBILG F\(B+FM~B7ODg ILB~hHjG\F!T7CHXA8NLBHjHjGF\ILKMn\G Y1MFvABC DE%Fde 3.1 Implementation A

}†F6ILKG HJG E%gC ME%MF"I.T;ILGBFILKMIjN.TA.x%THjHjG \FE%MF"ILHWT;NLMZHVILBNLMR G FTK!THjK–HjM8I&B7ORSF!T7E%G A
HjG ®M+e z KM8NLM6T;NLMDg?ILBh0i/T7HjHjG \+Ft E%MF"ILH GF6ILKMXHjM8IT7F!RILKMZTC \+B7NLG]ILKE©G]ILM8N.T;ILMHB;Y1M8NILKMXkKB+C M HjM8IOPBNnM,TA.K?BO ILKM|a=AB+C DE%FHe z KM
RB+\CM8\+H&T7NLM~\+MFM8N.T7ILMR Q"STnNLMA8DNLHjG Y1MTC \+B7NLG ILKE²ILKT7IFMM,RHlABFHVI.T7F IlILG E%MOBNWMTA.K BO/ILKMU³6‹Ž„ o†…/‡ FM8k“THjHjG \+FE%MF"ILHe z KMnkBNLHVIA,T7HjMnNLDF"ILG E%M BO/ILKMUT7C\BNLG]ILKEœG HWILKM8NLM0OPBNLM ´,µ!¶· _`Ph0i „ o c }uI%G HgMHjHjG E%G HVILGA(ILB>E~DC]ILG gC]S=ILKM(kJBNLHVI6A,T7HjMF DE~QM8N
B7O gB+HjHjG QCM(RB+\+C M\H|kG]ILKILKMkB7NLHVI
A,T7HjM%F DE
QM0NUBOWIjN.T7A0x>THVt HjG \+FE%MF"ILHT7HILKM0S5A,T7F¸FMY1M0NB"AA8DNvHjG E~DC]I.TFMB+DHjC S"e£•BN M8pTE%gC M
T(AB+C DE%F?kG]ILK>h0i{IjN.T7A0x?T7HjHjG \+FE%M8F ILHUATFKT,Y1M
FB RB\+C M\HnT7IZTC Cb‚)T7F!RwTABCDE%FkG]ILK–„o†…d‡RB+\C M\+HE
DHVIXKT;Y+M C MHjHWILK!T7Fh8i ¹ `PhL¹+„c0iIjN.T7A0x(THjHjG \FE%MF"ILHe ˆ#G]ILKnILKGH{G E%gC ME%MF"I.T;ILGBFnQMFA0KE6T7NLx H!kG]ILK|DgZILBºIjN.TA.x H ABDCRQMnNLBDILM,R(GFvT~NLM,THjBF!T7QC M|TE%B+DF"IWBO[ILG E%M+e

3.2 Implementation B

}†F–ILKGHUG E%gCM8E%MF"I.T7ILG B+FwIjN.TA.x?THjHjG \FE%MF"ILHUT;NLMHVILBNLM,R–G F TnKMTgDHjGF\nILKMF DE~QM8N[BO{Y GTH FMMRM,R~ILBUA0NLM,T7ILMILKMIjN.T7A0x THjHjG \FE%MF"I
TH~ILKM6x1M8S"e z N.T7A0x=THjHjG \+FE%MF"ILH|kG]ILK'C MHjH
Y GTH T7NLMZgNLB"AMHjHjMR y NLHVI,‚ NLMHjDC ILG F\
G FvT&NLB+DILG F\~kG]ILKvT|E%GFG E
DE F DE~QM8NB7OUY G@T7He z KG H6gNLB RDAMH6TA8G NLA8DG]I6ILK!T7I6KTH6C B,kM8N gB,kM8NvAB+FHjDE%gILG BF¸TF!R#HjE6T7CC M8NwRMCTS¸RDM–ILB'ILKM–C B,kM8N NLMHjG HVI.TFAM&TFRA,T7g!TA8G I.T7FAMUB7O[ILKMZkG]NLMHXT7HXkJMC C/T7HT~QM8IjILM8N SG MCR#RDNLG F\’E6TF DOPTA8ILDNLGF\e£»G FGE%G ®G F\'ILKM?FDE
QM8N6B7O Y GTHXE%G\K"IZT7C HjB(NLMHjDC]IZG F?THjE6TC C M8NZC@TS"BDIG]OlA8B+E%g!T7A8ILG B+FvG H DHjMRTHXT
gBHVIjtugNLB"AMHjHjG F\%HVILMgde f H/TWKM8DNLG HVILG ANLDF"ILGE%M[BgILG E%G ®,T7ILG BFnILKM THjHjG \+FE%MF"ILH{kJM8NLM FB7IJgNLB"AMHjHjM,R6ABCDE%F%Q"SABCDE%FQDIJG F(T&RMgILKt y NLHVI E6T7Ft FM0N,e z KG H€G H[TWC BI/ObTHVILM0NGF&E6T7F SZA,THjM8H[QMA,TDHjMlILKM8NLMlDHjD!T7CC]S T7NLM~T%C BInB7OJgBHjHjG QC M
BgILG E6TC{NLB+DILG F\+HZOBNUT%\GY+MF?gNLB+QC ME G FHVI.T7FAMTFRILKMTC \+B7NLG ILKE¼A,T7F'HVILB+g'TH
HjB"B+F‰TH
ILKM y NLHVI B+FMnG HXOB+DF!RG FHVILM,T+RB7O[MF DE%M0N.T7ILG F\|ILKME½T7C C§e

3.3 Implementation C

}†F~ILKG HG E%gC ME%MF"I.T;ILGBF|kJMWDHjME~DC]ILG]tuY+T7CDM,R|RMAG HjG B+FRGT7t \N.T7E%H¾u»¿Z¿nH‚!À ÁÂÝILBUNLMgNLMHjMF"I ILKMA0KT7N.T7A8ILM8NLG HVILG AOPDFA8ILG BF BO[ILKMUHjM8IXBOIjN.TA.xTHjHjG \+FE%MF"ILHe z KG HXG HZT7FwTggNLB1T7A0KHjGE%G]t CT7NILB~ILKMnB+FMngNLM8HjMF"ILM,RG F>À Ä;ÂueJ­JDIUÀ Ä;Â]Å#RMHjgG]ILMUG]ILHWILG ILC M0Å HjB+C Y1M8H|ILKM(KT7N.RM8N|E6T®M%NLB+DILG F\wgNLBQC MEve f H~TF=M8Æ)M8A8I
B7O ILKM6E%B7NLM\MFM8N.T7CTggNLB1T7A0K’ILKM(kJBNLHVI%A,T7HjMNLDF ILG E%MILKM8NLM \NLB,kHXM8pgB+FMF"ILG@T7C C SG Fh[ª,a[eÇZDNXTC \BNLG]ILKE^K!T7HT|NLDF"ILG E%M C G FM,T;NG FILKMnA.K!TFFMC)C MF\ILKva[e z BHVILBNLM%ILKMHjM0I~B7OIjN.TA.x>THjHjG \+FE%MF"ILH&kJM%AB+FHVIjNLDA8IUILKM A.K!T7N.T7A8ILM8NLG HVILG AOPDFA8ILG B+F
ŸvÈÉ"Š˜˜8˜jh.Ê o€ËÌ É7° Í,Š7ÊILK!T7I/NLM8ILDNLFH¬ OPB7NlTILDgMC"ILKT7IG HAB+F"I.TG FM,R
G F~ILKMWHjM8IBOIjN.T7A0x|THjHjG \FE%MF"ILH TFR ± OBNT~ILDgMC{ILKT7IG HFB7I,e »¿n¿ÎBgM8N.T7ILG BFHA,TFQMnDHjM,R(ILB
E%B RG]O@ST7C C€THjHjG \FE%MF"ILH G FUILKMHjM8I€HjG E~DC]I.TFMB+DHjC S"e€•BN/M8pTE%gCM[ILBgQI.TG FUILKMHjDQHjM8I BO€TC C{THjHjG \+FE%MF"ILHILK!T;IWK!T,Y1MZTFM8E%gIqS~IjN.TA.x%Œ[ILKMZA8BObT7A8ILBN BOŸ=OBNÏ,Ð · °GH&ABE%gDILM,R{e(Ñ B+E%MDHjM8OPDClBgM8N.T7ILG BFH~T7NLM NLM,RDAM,R6ILB
HjG E%gC MUgBGF"ILM8NWNLMRG]NLMA8ILG B+FHe •B7N&TF?M8pT7E%gC M~BF?KB,k«ILKM|A.K!TFFMCdNLB+DILM0NUB+gM8N.T;ILMHnBF ILKMZ»¿n¿3HjM8INLMgNLMHjMF"I.T7ILG BFH‚AB+FHjG@RM8NWABC DE%F6Á~B7O€•€G \DNLM ¬+e •€G \DNLM|Ò|HjKB,kHTC C{ILKMZYTC GR(IjN.T7A0x(THjHjG \FE%MF"ILHJILKT7IA,T7F

Track 1

0

Track 2

Track 3

Track 4

4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

0

0

4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

0

0

4 1 2 3

4 1 2 3

4 1 2 3

Track 1

0

0

4 1 2 3

4 1 2 3

0

Track 2

4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

Track 3

0

Track 4

0 4 1 2 3

0

4 1 2 3

4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

0

4 1 2 3

1

Ó ÔÕ)Öd×;Ø£Ù{ڲۉÜ~ÜÞÝ8ßàÝ8ßá.ß+â ã0ä1ã,å æâ3çbæݖãèß5áLß;ãæ ç
ã8Ý8ä éê ä á.á8å ëâì(ß1â"ãá&ç§Ý8æì¼í åëî!Ý8ß?ïð?ñèßÝ8ß?å@á~ä>à!ä1ãè’ç§Ý8æìòã,èß Ý8ææ ã|ã0æ–ãèß>ó(ã8ßÝ,ìvå@âäô€çbæÝ~ßä é,è’ä á.á8å ëâì(ß1â"ãå@âã,èßá.ß;ãð õ æââßé,ãåæâ!áã8æ(ã,èß%ö6ã8ßÝ,ìvå@âäô)ä Ý0ßæìvå ã.ã8ß÷vçbæÝUé7ôä Ý,å]ãLø ð ùú"ûLù8üûLýþ
ÿ  % ú @ ü  ½ûLýù ù @û€þüLù
ÿjý ÿûLýù üLùüLùÿjùú"û!7ûLþ+ú €ûLýþÿÿjù8û " ü #ù$ üL% ù $ $'&{ù !û ()$ ù " üjûLÿ*,+-.ÿVû/úúù8ûwûLýù=úù ÿjþ +'ú 10~ û ~ûj!ü 2435#76ýþ 8ÿ ú9+ú :,7!ü ýÿ ûLEý ;û;üLDù ÿjù $.G1ù0Yü :. üLù xVùú" û I:#?6ýùWüLùYÿ  ]ûLLÿ  1ù8!ü 7ûLþ +úLÿ ú ûLýù8ÿjùUYÿ '; >,7!ü ý\ÿ 7üLù 20ýù $ û F;!û þ / ú ÿY ;ÿV!û 7ú ûLþ 2dYÿ ùù $ '1W6ýD ù .ýþ ú .2üLþ]ûL'ý %ÿ 7üLù ; þ $%þú" û UûLýù =yE243#> ùUûLEý 7û8J ù ÿjù $9ú'$þ ÿûj!ü 7úYÿ '7üLùú"ûW û 
ûLý=ù  ü !ü @%ù0ü  3.4 Experimental Results

z 8ù üLÿjþ+úÿnBh7úE$Z^2 ûLýù7üLþ]ûLý'{ýù8üLùþ@' ù%ù8ú ûLù$Zþ ú | G %ùú"û?7úE$ ;E ü   ûLþ ú'\+ úHXÿjù8ûW2 E; ùú 0ý ,OYO?ü > ùÿjÿY7 üü  úúþú F;ûD0Œ‹ M DŽ+ ú/.&dþ úV 6 Q ÿT: ÿVûLù-

0

4 1 2 3

0

4 1 2 3

1

ÓÔÕ)Öd×;% Ø )Ú(ñZèßۉÜ~ܜç§Ý8æìòí å ëî!Ý09 ß vä"çPã0ßÝ
áLæì(ßà)æåâ"4㠑 ßÝávå@â#ôß2’ß+ô=“‰èä ’ ß^”{ß7ß1â¸é,èäâë ß÷#ã0æ‘Ý8ß1ì(挒 ߖäô@ôWã8Ý8ä éê ä á.á8å ëâì(ß1â"ãáWã,èä1ãUî!á.ß÷–ã8Ý8ä é ê “ð

Track 1

0

Track 2

Track 3

Track 4

4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

0

0 4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

0 4 1 2 3

0

4 1 2 3

4 1 2 3

1

Ó ÔÕ)Öd×;ØP•{Ú
ñZèß(ۉÜ~ܽç§Ý8æì í åëî!Ý8ß–ä"çPã0ß+Ýnãèß(à{æåâ"ã8ßÝá åâ’ô ß’ ß+ôL“?èä ’ ß”{ß7ß1â'ìæ ’ß÷>ã0æ>åâ!÷)å@é,ä1ã0ß(ãèä1ã|ãÝ8ä é8êP“?å@á æ!é;é7î!à)åß÷_”ø?á0åëâäô˜—wå@â?äô@ôdä á.á8å ëâì(ß1â"ãá,ð

™Yš!›2œ4Vž ¦ ¬ ­ ¯ « « «¦

Ÿ §V¨ §§Œ© §V¨ §§ª §X¨« °\±

 7¡