Article in final form - Victoria University of Wellington

E=^O`OX] 5  9ZOX 6OK\XSXQ ^Y =_]^KSX RO

"5OX=^O`OX]

R\OO=^KQO 7YNOV 8Oa DOKVKXN +XX_KV R\OO]^KQO.O`OVYZWOX^YP@S\^_KV-VK]]O]SX8OaDOKVKXN =MRYYV] >OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX] ^OMRXYVYQSO] RK`O Z\Y`SNON aKc] YP ]_]^KSXSXQ \_\KVON_MK^SYXKVSXP\K]^\_M^_\O]SX]O`O\KV\OQSYX]YP8OaDOKVKXNLc OXKLVSXQ^OKMRO\]KXN]^_NOX^]^YVSXUaS^RYXOKXY^RO\OVOM^\YXSMKVVc ^Y]RK\O\O]Y_\MO]>RONO`OVYZWOX^YPOVOK\XSXQSX8OaDOKVKXN^YYU

5/8=>/@/8=

ZVKMOaROXWKXc\_\KV]MRYYV]aO\O_XNO\^R\OK^YPMVY]_\OLOMK_]OYP ^ROS\]WKVVOX\YVWOX^]+POK^_\OYP^OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX]^OMRXYVYQSO] SX\_\KV8OaDOKVKXN]MRYYV]RK]LOOX^RO\OKVS]K^SYXLcLY^R^OKMRO\] KXNKNWSXS]^\K^Y\]YP^ROS\ZY^OX^SKV^YMYXXOM^YXO]S^OaS^RKXY^RO\

+L]^\KM^$

^RO\OLc MRKVVOXQSXQ ON_MK^SYXKV MYX]SNO\K^SYX] YP SX]^S^_^SYXKV ]SdO R\Y_QR^ROKMKNOWSMKXNKNWSXS]^\K^S`OSX^OQ\K^SYX

YXVSXOON_MK^SYXRK]NO`OVYZONK^^RO\OQSYXKVVO`OVOXKLVSXQ`S\^_KV

YPMVK]]O]P\YWNS`O\]O]S^O]`S\^_KVON_MK^SYXKV]^\_M^_\O]KXNZ\YMO]]O]^RK^

MVK]]O]^YLOM\OK^ON=^O`OX]###

MYWZVOWOX^^\KNS^SYXKV]MRYYV]RK`ONO`OVYZONaOVVPS^^ON^YZ\Y`SNOK^OWZVK^O PY\^ROSX^OQ\K^SYXYPYX]S^OKXNYXVSXOON_MK^SYXSXOKMRMY_X^\c

,c VSXUSXQ MYWZ_^O\] ^Y ^OVOZRYXO VSXO] ^R\Y_QR WYNOW] K_NSYQ\KZRSM ^OMRXYVYQc NO`OVYZON SX ]O`O\KV ZK\^] YP ^RO MY_X^\c

3

+_NSYQ\KZRSM ^OKMRSXQ K] ^RO XKWO ]_QQO]^] OXKLVO] ^OKMRO\] KXN VOK\XO\]^YROK\YXOKXY^RO\KXN^Y]RK\OZ\SX^KXNQ\KZRSMWK^O\SKVYX

^ RK] KVaKc] LOOX NSPPSM_V^ ^Y Z\Y`SNO Ob^OX]S`O M_\\SM_V_W

MYWZ_^O\]M\OOX]>RS]OVOWOX^K\cPY\WYPOVOK\XSXQRK]]O\`ONWKXc

YZZY\^_XS^SO] PY\ ]OXSY\ ]^_NOX^] aRY K\O \OK\ON KXN ON_MK^ON SX

]WKVV 8Oa DOKVKXN MYWW_XS^SO] `O\c OPPOM^S`OVc 3X ^RO -KX^O\L_\c

MYWW_XS^SO]^RK^K\ONS]^KX^P\YWWKTY\MOX^\O]YPZYZ_VK^SYX>RO

\OQSYXYP^RO=Y_^R3]VKXNKXN^ROXY\^ROK]^MYK]^YP^RO8Y\^R3]VKXN

KN`OX^YPMYWZ_^O\]SX]MRYYV]^RO3X^O\XO^]K^OVVS^O^OMRXYVYQc^aY

]WKVV\_\KV]MRYYV]RK`OPY\WON`S\^_KVMVK]]O]^Y^OKMR]OXSY\]^_NOX^]

aKc`SNOYMYXPO\OXMSXQL\YKNLKXNSXS^SK^S`O]ZV_]KQ\YaSXQ\KXQOYP

MYVVKLY\K^S`OVcSXK\KXQOYP]ZOMSKVS]ONRSQR]MRYYV]_LTOM^]AROX^aY

VOK\XSXQ ]YP^aK\O RK`O MYWLSXON SX 8Oa DOKVKXN ^Y Z\YN_MO XOa

Y\ WY\O ]MRYYV] SX^O\PKMO OVOM^\YXSMKVVc ^Y MYWLSXO ^OKMRSXQ KXN

aKc] YP ^OKMRSXQ KXN VOK\XSXQ SX ]ZK\]OVc ZYZ_VK^ON MYWW_XS^SO]

VOK\XSXQ K `S\^_KV MVK]] S] PY\WON ,Y^R ^OKMRO\] KXN ]^_NOX^] SX K

/VOM^\YXSM ON_MK^SYXKV ]^\_M^_\O] KXN Z\YMO]]O] ^RK^ RK`O LOOX

Q\YaSXQX_WLO\YP\_\KV]MRYYV]XYaRK`O^OVOZ\O]OXMO]SXW_V^SZVO

NO`OVYZONSX\_\KVK\OK]YP^RS]MY_X^\cRK`OLOOXYPSX^O\O]^SXY^RO\

]S^O]N_\SXQ^ROMY_\]OYPK]MRYYVNKc>R\OO]^KQO]MKXLOSNOX^SPSONSX

]YMSO^SO]aS^R]ZK\]OVcZYZ_VK^ON\OQSYX]

^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]SX8OaDOKVKXN

3X +^VKX^SM -KXKNK \O]OK\MR _XNO\^KUOX SX \_\KV 8Oa DOKVKXN ]MRYYV]RK]LOOXYPZK\^SM_VK\SX^O\O]^KXNRK]LOOXKZZVSON^YOb^OXN

S/VOK\XSXQKXN^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]SX]OVOM^ON]MRYYV]

SX

3X ]YWO K\OK] YP ^RO XY\^ROK]^ MYK]^ YP ^RO 8Y\^R 3]VKXN YP 8Oa

QOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ONMYWW_XS^SO]UXYaXK]Y_^ZY\^]€>RO\O]_V^

DOKVKXN ^RO ZYZ_VK^SYX S] KVWY]^ ObMV_]S`OVc 7KY\S KXN WKXc VYMKV

YP^RS]ZONKQYQSMKVKXN^OMRXYVYQSMKV^\KX]PO\RK]LOOXXOaVOK\XSXQ

ZOYZVO]ZOKU^ROVKXQ_KQOPV_OX^Vc=OXSY\]^_NOX^]SX^R\OO]WKVV\_\KV

YZZY\^_XS^SO]PY\]OXSY\]^_NOX^]SX-KXKNK

RSQR]MRYYV]XY\^RYP^ROMS^cYP1S]LY\XORK`ORKNMYX]SNO\KLVO]_MMO]]

^RO

^OKMRSXQ

KXN

M_\\SM_V_W

MKZKMS^SO]

YP

]OVOM^ON

]MRYYV]

>RS]K\^SMVOaSVVY_^VSXOK^R\OO]^KQONO`OVYZWOX^YP^ROKZZVSMK^SYX

SXXK^SYXKVObKWSXK^SYX]SX^RO7KY\SVKXQ_KQO2YaO`O\]_MMO]]SX

YPSXPY\WK^SYXKXNMYWW_XSMK^SYX^OMRXYVYQSO]SX8OaDOKVKXN\_\KV

Y^RO\]_LTOM^]PY\WKXcYP^RO]O]^_NOX^]RK]LOOXNSPPSM_V^^YKMRSO`O

!

9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXYMY_X^O\^RONS]KN`KX^KQOYPRK`SXQPOaYX]S^O^OKMRO\]SXRSQR

MYX]OX^

NO]SQXK^ON

]MRYYV]

SX

^RO

XO^aY\U

KMMOZ^ON

-KX^O\L_\c]^_NOX^]

]MRYYV]SX^RS]ZK\^YP\_\KV8OaDOKVKXNK]WKVV^R\OO]S^OOVOM^\YXSM

,cMYVVKLY\K^SXQSX^ROKZZYSX^WOX^YP]ZOMSKVS]^^OKMRO\]YXOKMR

XO^aY\UaK]NO`OVYZON^Y]RK\O^OKMRSXQ\O]Y_\MO]+]aOVVK]VSXUSXQ

-KX^K^OMR]S^O^YK`YSNN_ZVSMK^SYXYPR_WKX\O]Y_\MO]KXNOXMY_\KQO

aS^RYXOKXY^RO\OKMR]S^ORKNKMMO]]^YKQ\YaSXQ\KXQOYPOb^\KXO^]

^RONO`OVYZWOX^YPKaSNO\\KXQOYPKZZYSX^WOX^]OKMR]MRYYVSX^RO

Ob^O\XKV]c]^OW]$^YVK\QO\_\LKXRSQR]MRYYV]^YZYVc^OMRXSM]SXY^RO\

XO^aY\URK]LOOXKLVO^YZ\Y`SNOS^]]OXSY\]^_NOX^]aS^RKMMO]]^YKX

ZK\^]YP^ROMY_X^\cKXN^Y^RO8OaDOKVKXN-Y\\O]ZYXNOXMO=MRYYV

Ob^OXNON\KXQOYPVOK\XSXQYZZY\^_XS^SO]>OKMRO\]KZZYSX^ON^YKXcYP

SXAOVVSXQ^YX=OXSY\]^_NOX^]SX^RO^R\OO]WKVVZ\ONYWSXKX^Vc7KY\S

^RO-KX^K^OMR]MRYYV]aO\OObZOM^ON^YLOKLVO^YZ\Y`SNOMY_\]O]SX

MYWW_XS^SO]XY\^RYP1S]LY\XOaO\OZ\Y`SNONaS^RKMMO]]^YOKMRYP

LY^R ^\KNS^SYXKV PKMO^YPKMO WYNO YX ]S^O K] aOVV K] YXVSXO K]

^RO Y^RO\ ^aY ]MRYYV] SX ^RO /K]^ -YK]^ XO^aY\U K] aOVV K] ^Y K ]WKVV

\O[_S\ON >RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP ^RO -KX^K^OMR XO^aY\U RK] L\Y_QR^

\KXQOYPXYXVYMKVON_MK^SYXKVKXN`YMK^SYXKV\O]Y_\MO]>RS]XY\^ROK]^

KLY_^ WKXc MRKXQO] SX ^RO KNWSXS]^\K^S`O KXN KMKNOWSM VSPO YP OKMR

MYK]^XO^aY\UK^^\KM^ON^ROK^^OX^SYXYPON_MK^Y\]SX^RO=Y_^R3]VKXN

]MRYYV /KMR ]MRYYV SX ^RO XO^aY\U RK] RKN ^Y VSXU KMKNOWSMKVVc KXN

aRY MYVVKLY\K^ON SX ^RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP `S\^_KV MVK]]O] PY\ \_\KV

KNWSXS]^\K^S`OVc

MYWW_XS^SO]SX^RO]Y_^RO\XZK\^YP^ROMY_X^\c

MYVVKLY\K^S`OVc SX ^RO SX^O\O]^] YP K W_MR L\YKNO\ ON_MK^SYXKV

aS^R

OKMR

YP

^RO

Y^RO\

]MRYYV]

KXN

aY\U

MYWW_XS^c^RKXS^]Y\SQSXKVVcNO]SQXK^ONVYMKVYXO SS/VOK\XSXQKXN^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]SXK

,OMK_]OYP^ROXOMO]]S^cYPPSXNSXQXOa]YV_^SYX]^Y^RONOVS`O\cYP

\OQSYXKVSX^\KXO^

ON_MK^SYX^YQOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ON]OXSY\]^_NOX^]OKMR]MRYYVSX^RO

>RO -KX^O\L_\c \OQSYX YP ^RO MOX^\KV =Y_^R 3]VKXN YP 8Oa DOKVKXN

-KX^K^OMR XO^aY\U RK] RKN ^Y MYX]SNO\ ^RO \YVO YP SXPY\WK^SYX

MYX^KSX] ^aOV`O \_\KV MYWW_XS^SO] OKMR aS^R S^] YaX ]MRYYV AS^R

^OMRXYVYQcSX^ROM_\\SM_V_W0Y\^OKMRO\]]^_NOX^]KNWSXS]^\K^Y\]KXN

\_\KV_\LKX WSQ\K^SYX WKXc YP ^RO]O MYWW_XS^SO] RK`O LOMYWO

ZOYZVO

]WKVVO\KXNOX\YVWOX^]SXWY]^]MRYYV]RK`OPKVVOX3X^ROVK]^NOMKNO

^OMRXYVYQc RK] LOMYWO K WOKX] ^Y OXVK\QO VYMKV ON_MK^SYXKV KXN

]YWO]MRYYV]PKMONMVY]_\OKXNZK\OX^]aO\OPKMONaS^R^ROZ\Y]ZOM^

SXNS\OM^Vc`YMK^SYXKVYZZY\^_XS^SO]

SX

OKMR

YP

^RO

ZK\^SMSZK^SXQ

MYWW_XS^SO]

SXPY\WK^SYX

YPMYX]SNO\KLVONS]\_Z^SYXSX^ROON_MK^SYXYP^ROS\]YX]KXNNK_QR^O\]

/^OKMRSXQKXNOVOK\XSXQSX\_\KV-KX^O\L_\cRK]MRKVVOXQON^RO

>RONO`OVYZWOX^YPKXSX^O\]MRYYVXO^aY\U^RK^LOMKWOUXYaXK]

MYWZO^S^S`OWYNOVYP]MRYYVSXQSX8OaDOKVKXNKXNNOWYX]^\K^ON^RO

-KX^K^OMR€>RO-KX^O\L_\c+\OK=MRYYV]>OMRXYVYQc:\YTOM^L\Y_QR^

`KV_O YP K MYVVKLY\K^S`O SX^OQ\K^ON `S\^_KV Y\QKXS]K^SYX PY\ ]OXSY\

^aOV`O\_\KV]MRYYV]^YQO^RO\^YMYX]SNO\aKc]SXaRSMR^OKMRSXQKXN

]^_NOX^] >RO -KX^K^OMR XO^aY\U RK] OWZYaO\ON ^aOV`O ]WKVV KXN

VOK\XSXQ\O]Y_\MO]MY_VNLO]RK\ON/KMR]MRYYVaK]KLVO^YZ\Y`SNOS^]

QOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ON]MRYYV]^YNOVS`O\KXOb^OXNON\KXQOYP]_LTOM^]

]^_NOX^]

^Y]OXSY\]^_NOX^]

aS^R

^OKMRSXQ

SX

^RO

MY\O

]_LTOM^]

YX]S^O$

/XQVS]R

7K^ROWK^SM] KXN =MSOXMO K] aOVV K] SX]^\_M^SYX SX YXO Y\ ^aY ]ZOMSKVS]ON]_LTOM^]OQ0\OXMR4KZKXO]O/MYXYWSM]KXN+Q\SM_V^_\O ,c MYVVKLY\K^SXQ SX ^RO ^OKMRSXQ YP ]ZOMSKVS]^ ]_LTOM^] LO^aOOX ^RO ]MRYYV]SX^RS]ZK\^YP\_\KV8OaDOKVKXN]OXSY\]^_NOX^]aRYaS]RON ^Y\OMOS`OSX]^\_M^SYXSXMY_\]O]XY^VYMKVVcK`KSVKLVORK`OLOOXKLVO^Y

SSS-_\\OX^SXS^SK^S`O]{^ROWY`O^YYZOXVOK\XSXQSX8OaDOKVKXN =SXMO##"K8K^SYXKV3XPY\WK^SYXKXN-YWW_XSMK^SYX]>OMRXYVYQc=^\K^OQc RK] LOOX NO`OVYZON KXN SWZVOWOX^ON ^R\Y_QRY_^ 8Oa DOKVKXN

9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXROPS\]^YLTOM^S`OaK]^YSWZ\Y`OVOK\XSXQY_^MYWO]^R\Y_QR

YP P_\^RO\ SXS^SK^S`O] ^Y OXMY_\KQO O^OKMRSXQ KXN OVOK\XSXQ >RO]O

^RO_]OYP3->PY\^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQSX]MRYYV]>RO]OMYXNaK]^Y

SXMV_NO ^RO .SQS^KV 9ZZY\^_XS^SO] :\YQ\KWWO KXN ^RO 5K_ZKZK +\K

SXM\OK]O ^RO OPPOM^S`OXO]] KXN OPPSMSOXMc YP ^OKMRO\] KXN ]MRYYV] Lc

ARKUKaRS^S 7K^K_\KXQK 5+A7 Z\YTOM^ 0Y_\ ZSVY^ Z\YQ\KWWO]

ROVZSXQ^ROW^Y_]O3->>RO^RS\NYLTOM^S`OaK]^YSWZ\Y`O^RO[_KVS^c

aS^RSX^RO.SQS^KV9ZZY\^_XS^SO]:\YQ\KWWOLOQKXOK\VcSXLK]ON

YP^OKMRSXQKXNVOKNO\]RSZSX]MRYYV]LcROVZSXQ^OKMRO\]KXNZ\SXMSZKV]

YX

^YSNOX^SPc^ROS\3->XOON]KXN^YNO`OVYZ^RO]USVV]XOMO]]K\c^YWOO^

MYWW_XSMK^SYX] ^OMRXYVYQc L_]SXO]]O] >RO]O SXMV_NON$ 0K\8O^€

^ROW >RO PSXKV YLTOM^S`O aK] ^Y SXM\OK]O YZZY\^_XS^SO] PY\ ]MRYYV]

aRSMRSX`YV`ONKMYWW_XS^cYP^OX]MRYYV]SX^ROXY\^RYP^ROMY_X^\c

L_]SXO]]O] KXN QY`O\XWOX^ ^Y aY\U ^YQO^RO\ SX NO`OVYZSXQ KX

_]SXQ SXPY\WK^SYX KXN MYWW_XSMK^SYX ^OMRXYVYQSO] ^Y OXRKXMO

SXPY\WK^SYX^OMRXYVYQcVS^O\K^OaY\UPY\MO

^OKMRSXQ KXN VOK\XSXQ% 1OXO\K^SYX B:€ SX aRSMR K Q\Y_Z YP OSQR^

>ROXK^SYXKV]^\K^OQcNO`OVYZONPY_\SXS^SK^S`O]$

ZK\^XO\]RSZ]

LO^aOOX

QY`O\XWOX^

KXN

SXPY\WK^SYX

KXN

]MRYYV]SXAO]^+_MUVKXNKXNSX^RO1S]LY\XO.S]^\SM^YP^ROXY\^ROK]^

K+X9X6SXORO9X6SXORS] YXVSXO MOX^\O S] SX^OXNON ^Y ]_ZZY\^ M_\\SM_V_W WK^O\SKV] Z\Y`SNO VSXU] ^Y M_\\SM_V_W ObZO\^] LSVSXQ_KV NS]M_]]SYX

MYK]^ YP ^RO 8Y\^R 3]VKXN YPPO\ON 7SM\Y]YP^ MO\^SPSMK^SYX MY_\]O] PY\ ]^_NOX^]%KXN^RO8Y^OLYYU@KVVOc€Z\YQ\KWWOaRSMRPYM_]ONYXK Q\Y_Z YP PY_\ ]OMYXNK\c ]MRYYV] SX ^RO AOVVSXQ^YX \OQSYX _]SXQ XY^OLYYUMYWZ_^O\]^YOXRKXMO^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQSXWK^ROWK^SM] KXN]MSOXMO >RO 5+A7 SXS^SK^S`O LOQKX SX  KXN PYM_]ON YX ^RO _]O YP

PY\_W]NK^KLK]O]W_V^SWONSKKXNK`K\SO^cYPY^RO\]S^O]=MRYYV]RK`O LOOXOXMY_\KQON^YM\OK^O^ROS\YaXaOL]S^O]KXN^YRK`O^RO]OZVKMON

SXPY\WK^SYXKXNMYWW_XSMK^SYX^OMRXYVYQSO]^YOXRKXMO^OKMRSXQKXN VOK\XSXQPY\7KY\S]^_NOX^]SX]MRYYV]LcZ\Y`SNSXQL\YKNO\M_\\SM_V_W

SX^ROYXVSXO\O]Y_\MOMOX^\O

YZ^SYX] >R\Y_QR ^RS] SXS^SK^S`O 7KY\SWONS_W ]_LTOM^ ]ZOMSKVS]^ L + -YWZ_^O\ RO KSW YP ^RO MYWZ_^O\ \OMcMVSXQ

^OKMRO\]aO\OKLVO^YWKUOVO]]YX]K`KSVKLVOKM\Y]]KX_WLO\YP]S^O]

]MROWOS]^YOXKLVOWY\O]MRYYV]^YYL^KSXWY\OMYWZ_^O\]PY\]^_NOX^ KXN ^OKMRO\ _]O K^ VYa MY]^ >RO ]MROWO RK] LOOX NO]M\SLON K] ^RO

>RO ^R\OO ]^KQO] SX ^RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP `S\^_KV MVK]]O] SX 8Oa DOKVKXNK\OMRK\KM^O\S]ONLc$

\OMcMVSXQ KXN _ZQ\KNSXQ YP MYWZ_^O\] SX ]MRYYV]€ 7SXS]^\c YP /N_MK^SYX##"Z

>ROS\Y\SQSX]SX]WKVV]MRYYV]SX\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]%

ã

+X OWZRK]S] YX MYVVKLY\K^S`O ^OKMRSXQ KXN VOK\XSXQ aS^RSX KX

M:\YPO]]SYXKV.O`OVYZWOX^PY\3WZVOWOX^K^SYXKXN:VKXXSXQ$._\SXQ^RO PS\]^ cOK\ YP ^RO 8K^SYXKV 3XPY\WK^SYX KXN -YWW_XSMK^SYX] >OMRXYVYQc

Y^RO\aS]OMYWZO^S^S`O]MRYYV]c]^OW% ã

=^\K^OQc Z\SXMSZKV] KXN ]OXSY\ KNWSXS]^\K^Y\] SX ]MRYYV] ^R\Y_QRY_^ 8Oa DOKVKXN aO\O Z\Y`SNON aS^R SXS^SKV Z\YPO]]SYXKV NO`OVYZWOX^ YZZY\^_XS^SO]SX^ROS\VYMKVK\OK]>RO]OWOO^SXQ]PYM_]ONYX^RO_]OYP SXPY\WK^SYX

KXN

MYWW_XSMK^SYX

^OMRXYVYQSO]

PY\

^OKMRSXQ

KXN



ã

-YObS]^OXMO

YP

^\KNS^SYXKV

Z\SX^LK]ON

NS]^KXMO

ON_MK^SYX

SX]^S^_^SYX]aS^ROVOK\XSXQ% ã

.S\OM^ QY`O\XWOX^ SX`YV`OWOX^ SX OVOK\XSXQ P\YW ##" aS^R K \KXQO YP SXS^SK^S`O] ^Y OXMY_\KQO YXVSXO VOK\XSXQ ^Y MYWZVOWOX^ ObS]^SXQON_MK^SYXKV]^\_M^_\O]KXNZ\YMO]]O]

VOK\XSXQ N:\YPO]]SYXKV.O`OVYZWOX^=MRYYV]$>aOX^c^R\OO]MRYYV]]^\K^OQSMKVVc

+>R\OO=^KQO:K\^SKV

Z\YPO]]SYXKVNO`OVYZWOX^VOKN]MRYYV]P\YWVK^O##">ROS\Z_\ZY]O aK]^YK]]S]^^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP3->SXY^RO\]MRYYV]aS^RSX^ROS\VYMKV K\OK]/KMRVOKN]MRYYVaK]MRY]OXZ\SWK\SVcPY\^RO3->ObZO\^S]OYXS^] ]^KPP

3X^RO-KXKNSKXZ\Y`SXMOYP8OaPY_XNVKXNKXN6KL\KNY\^aY^RS\N] YP]MRYYV]K\OVYMK^ONSX]WKVV\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]UXYaXK]Y_^ZY\^]€ 9`O\^ROVK]^NOMKNOWKXc]WKVV]MRYYV]SX+^VKX^SM-KXKNKRK`OLOOX MVY]ON KXN ]^_NOX^] ^\KX]ZY\^ON ^Y VK\QO\ MOX^\O] =YWO ]MRYYV] RYaO`O\ K\O VYMK^ON ^YY PK\ P\YW WKTY\ MOX^\O] YP ZYZ_VK^SYX ^Y LO

9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXRO]O \_\KV SX]^S^_^SYX]

aRYZY]]O]]ONKN`KXMONMYWZ_^O\]USVV]SXMV_NSXQaOLZKQONO]SQX

UXYaXK]]WKVVXOMO]]K\SVcObS]^OX^]MRYYV]€]OOU^YZ\Y`SNOP_VV5

4K`K KXN 2>76 >RO VOKN ^OKMRO\ KXN ^RO Q\KN_K^O K]]S]^KX^ aO\O

ON_MK^SYX

\_\KV

KN`S]ON P\YW ^SWO ^Y ^SWO Lc 0KM_V^c YP /N_MK^SYX ]ZOMSKVS]^] K^

Y_^WSQ\K^SYXZ\YTOM^ON^YMYX^SX_O]SXMO^RONOWS]OYP^RO+^VKX^SMMYN

7OWY\SKV ?XS`O\]S^c YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN SX OKMR M_\\SM_V_W K\OK KXN

PS]RO\cKXN^RO]_L]O[_OX^VY]]YPVYMKVTYL]WKXc]WKVV]MRYYV]aSVV

aRO\O ZY]]SLVO ]MSOX^S]^] P\YW ^RO 0KM_V^c YP =MSOXMO 7Y]^ MY_\]O

NOM\OK]O SX ]SdO 8Oa aKc] RK`O RKN ^Y LO PY_XN YP Z\Y`SNSXQ

NO`OVYZWOX^^YYUZVKMO^R\Y_QRSX^O\KM^SYXLO^aOOXVOKN^OKMRO\]KXN

ON_MK^SYXKV YZZY\^_XS^SO] PY\ ]OXSY\ ]^_NOX^] SX ]WKVV KXN \OWY^O

^RO\OMOX^Q\KN_K^O]+V^RY_QRK^^SWO]PKM_V^cWOWLO\]RKNNSPPO\OX^

MYWW_XS^SO] ^RK^ K\O ]^OKNSVc LOMYWSXQ ]WKVVO\ >RO 8Oa DOKVKXN

YZSXSYX]K]^Y^ROWY]^KZZ\YZ\SK^OKZZ\YKMR^YMY_\]ONO]SQX^ROPY_\

WYNOVRK]KMMY\NSXQVcLOOXYPSX^O\O]^SX^RS]ZK\^YP-KXKNK

MY_\]O]aO\ONO`OVYZONY`O\K]Sb^OOXaOOU]_WWO\\OMO]]ZO\SYNSX

PY\

VYMKV

QOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ON

PKWSVSO]

AS^R

^SWOPY\^RO##"##]MRYYVcOK\ >RO.O`OVYZWOX^YP@S\^_KV-VK]]O]SX-KXKNK >RO -KXKNSKX Z\Y`SXMO YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN KXN 6KL\KNY\ RK] K Z\ONYWSXKX^Vc\_\KV]YMSKV]^\_M^_\OKNS]^SXM^S`ORS]^Y\cKXNK_XS[_O M_V^_\O3X^RO##!#"]MRYYVcOK\^RO\OaO\O#]MRYYV]YZO\K^SXQSX ^RO Z\Y`SXMO YP aRSMR 

 Y\

 ZO\MOX^ aO\O VYMK^ON SX \_\KV

MYWW_XS^SO] >RS\^cYXO ZO\MOX^ YP ]MRYYV] SX ^RO Z\Y`SXMO K\O NO]SQXK^ON ]WKVV \_\KV ]MRYYV]€ 8' KXN ! YP ^RO]O RKN POaO\ ^RKX  ]^_NOX^] =O`OX^c YP ^RO]O ]WKVV \_\KV ]MRYYV] K\O KVVQ\KNO 5 aRSMR WOKX] ^RK^ ^ROc W_]^ YPPO\ K ]OXSY\ RSQR ]MRYYV Z\YQ\KWWO >RO \OMOX^ \OY\QKXS]K^SYX YP Z\SWK\c OVOWOX^K\c KXN ]OMYXNK\cON_MK^SYXSX8OaPY_XNVKXNKXN6KL\KNY\SX^Y^OX]MRYYV NS]^\SM^]Z\Y`SNONKXYZZY\^_XS^c^YNO`OVYZ^ROPS\]^NSQS^KV3X^\KXO^SX ^ROZ\Y`SXMO+]aS^ROVOK\XSXQSX8OaDOKVKXN^R\OO]^KQO]SX^RO NO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]MKXLOSNOX^SPSONSX^RS]ZK\^YP-KXKNK

S>RONO`OVYZWOX^YPaOLLK]ON]MSOXMOMY_\]O]SX]OVOM^ON]MRYYV] 3XS^SKVVc aOLLK]ON MY_\]O] aO\O SX^\YN_MON SX ]OVOM^ON ]MRYYV] SX 8OaPY_XNVKXN KXN 6KL\KNY\ SX ^RO LOVSOP ^RK^ ^RO]O aY_VN LOMYWO VOKN]MRYYV]€KXNK]]S]^Y^RO\SX]^S^_^SYX]SX_]SXQXOa^OMRXYVYQSO]SX ^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQ>RS]SXS^SK^S`OaK]MY_X^O\ONLcY^RO\]MRYYV] aRY aO\O K^^\KM^ON ^Y ^RO MYVVKLY\K^S`O 8Oa DOKVKXN WYNOV YP MV_]^O\SXQ ]MRYYV] aS^RSX K NSQS^KV SX^\KXO^ 3X WY`SXQ P\YW ^RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP aOLLK]ON MY_\]O] SX ]OVOM^ON ]MRYYV] ^Y K WY\O MYVVKLY\K^S`OWYNOVKNOMS]SYXaK]WKNO^YVYMK^OMY_\]O]YXVSXO^Y MRKVVOXQO]OXSY\\_\KV]^_NOX^]SX^ROZ\Y`SXMO >RONO`OVYZWOX^YP+N`KXMON:VKMOWOX^+:AOLLK]ONMY_\]O] SX LSYVYQc MROWS]^\c WK^ROWK^SM] KXN ZRc]SM] ^YYU ZVKMO aS^RSX K



NO`OVYZWOX^ ^OKW SX OKMR ]_LTOM^ K\OK  3X NO`OVYZSXQ +: MY_\]O] YXVSXO K VOKN ]MSOXMO ^OKMRO\ SX OKMR NS]MSZVSXO aK] ZKS\ON aS^R K

7SXSW_W]ZOMSPSMK^SYX]aO\OKNYZ^ONPY\MYWZ_^O\RK\NaK\OKXN XO^aY\UMYXXOM^S`S^c+VV]MRYYV]SX`YV`ONSX^ROZ\YTOM^RKN.S\OM:]K^OVVS^O NS]RO] SX]^KVVON ^Y Z\Y`SNO K RSQR ]ZOON NYaXVSXU 3X WY]^ \_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]SX^RS]ZK\^YP-KXKNKNSQS^KV^OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX] SXP\K]^\_M^_\O]NYXY^OXKLVO]MRYYV]^YRK`OKRSQR]ZOON_ZVSXU^Y^RO SX^O\XO^+ZZ\YZ\SK^O]YP^aK\ORKN^YLOSNOX^SPSONKXNO`KV_K^ONPY\ LY^R^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP^RO\O]Y_\MO]KXN^RONOVS`O\cYPSX]^\_M^SYX aS^RSX^RO3X^\KXO^0\YX^:KQO#"aK]]OVOM^ONK]^RO]YP^aK\OZKMUKQO +NNS^SYXKV]YP^aK\OaK]_]ONPY\^RONO`OVYZWOX^YPSWKQO]KXSWK^ON QSP] KXN Y^RO\ NSWOX]SYX] YP MY_\]O NO`OVYZWOX^ >RO]O SXMV_NON =XKQS^1SP-YX]^\_M^SYX=O^ aK] ]OVOM^ON>RS]ZKMUKQOOXKLVON^ROSX]^\_M^Y\^Y^\KMU]^_NOX^Z\YQ\O]]% S^ MYX^KSXON YXVSXO ^O]^SXQ KXN O`KV_K^SYX Z\S`K^O /WKSV K MKVOXNK\ POK^_\OZ_LVSML_VVO^SXLYK\NPY\_]OLcLY^RSX]^\_M^Y\KXN]^_NOX^K VSXU^YVO]]YX]KXNMRK^\YYW]PY\MYWW_XSMK^SYXLO^aOOX^OKMRO\KXN ]^_NOX^

0Y\

\OKV^SWO

SX]^\_M^SYX

7OO^SXQ

:YSX^

KXN

7SM\Y]YP^

8O^7OO^SXQ aO\O ]OVOM^ON >RS] MYWLSXK^SYX YP ]YP^aK\O OXKLVON K ^OKMRO\^YZ\O]OX^\OKV^SWOSX^O\KM^S`OSX]^\_M^SYX^YW_V^SZVO]S^O]+X Y\SOX^K^SYX]O]]SYXaK]Z\Y`SNONPY\]^_NOX^]SX4_XO##"Z\SY\^Y^RO SWZVOWOX^K^SYXYP^RS]Z\YTOM^SX=OZ^OWLO\=^_NOX^]RKN^YVOK\XRYa ^YMYWW_XSMK^OaS^ROKMRY^RO\KXNaS^R^ROS\SX]^\_M^Y\_]SXQ^RO]O XOa^OMRXYVYQSO]LOPY\OMVK]]O]MY_VNLOQSX

SS>OKMRSXQ]OXSY\]MSOXMOSXK]MRYYVNS]^\SM^SX^\KXO^ 3XOSQR^]MRYYV]aS^RSX^RO\_\KV@S]^K]MRYYVNS]^\SM^YP8OaPY_XNVKXN



KXN 6KL\KNY\   ]^_NOX^] aO\O OX\YVVON SX +: LSYVYQc MROWS]^\c WK^ROWK^SM]

KXN

ZRc]SM]

MY_\]O]

ARSVO

+:

MY_\]O]

K\O

K

aOVVO]^KLVS]RON POK^_\O YP ]OXSY\ ]OMYXNK\c ON_MK^SYX SX ^RO ?XS^ON =^K^O] KXN -KXKNK S^ S] _X_]_KV PY\ ]^_NOX^] ^Y LO KLVO ^Y OX\YV PY\

9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXRO WY]^ SWZY\^KX^ KNWSXS]^\K^S`O S]]_O SX ^RO PS\]^ cOK\ YP ^RO @S]^K

SX^\KXO^]aS^RSXaRSMR`S\^_KVMVK]]O]RK`ONO`OVYZON

=MRYYV.S]^\SM^.SQS^KV3X^\KXO^RK]LOOX^ROMYY\NSXK^SYXYP^SWO^KLVO] KM\Y]]ZK\^SMSZK^SXQ]S^O]

3XOKMR]YMSO^c^RO\OS]XYaKMRKVVOXQO^YNO`OVYZZONKQYQc^RK^ S] KZZ\YZ\SK^O PY\ ^RO SX^OQ\K^SYX YP YX]S^O KXN YXVSXO ^OKMRSXQ KXN

>RO XOON PY\ SXM\OK]ON ^OMRXSMKV ]_ZZY\^ PY\ ^RS] XOa YZOX

VOK\XSXQ=^O`OX]7YPPK^^##

8OaON_MK^SYXKVZ\YPO]]SYXKV]

]^\_M^_\ORK]LOMYWOSXM\OK]SXQVc_\QOX^PY\^OKMRO\]KXN]^_NOX^]aRY

K\OOWO\QSXQSX-KXKNK$O^OKMRO\]aRY^OKMR^R\Y_QR^RO3X^O\XO^

K\O _]SXQ SXPY\WK^SYX KXN MYWW_XSMK^SYX ^OMRXYVYQSO] ^Y ^OKMR KXN

W^OKMRO\]aRYWONSK^OYX]S^OLO^aOOXO^OKMRO\]KXNVYMKV]^_NOX^]

VOK\X KM\Y]] NS]ZO\]ON ]S^O] ,Y^R RK`O ^Y LO Z\Y`SNON aS^R ObZO\^

KXNSX]^\_M^SYXKVNO]SQXO\] 



KN`SMO KXN SX]^\_M^SYX SX ^RO _]O YP XOa KZZVSMK^SYX] + ZK\^SM_VK\

+] aOVV K] Ob^OXNSXQ ^RO ON_MK^SYXKV YZZY\^_XS^SO] YP ]OXSY\

Z\YLVOWRK]LOOXNSPPSM_V^cSX]OM_\SXQKXNWKSX^KSXSXQSX]^\_M^SYXKV

]^_NOX^]SX]WKVV]MRYYV]^ROZSYXOO\SXQXK^_\OYPSX^O\]MRYYV^OKMRSXQ

NO]SQXObZO\^S]OSX^ROZ\OZK\K^SYXKXN_ZQ\KNSXQYPMY_\]O]NOVS`O\ON

KXN VOK\XSXQ SX -KXKNK KXN 8Oa DOKVKXN RK] SWZVSMK^SYX] PY\ ^RO

^R\Y_QR^RO3X^\KXO^

^OKMRSXQZ\YPO]]SYXPY\^RONOVS`O\cYPMY_\]O]PY\^ROY\QKXS]K^SYXYP

0YVVYaSXQ K WSXS]^O\SKV SX[_S\c SX^Y aRK^ LOMKWO UXYaX K]

MVK]]\YYW]KXN]MRYYV]KXNPY\^ROP_XNSXQYPON_MK^SYX+]]MRYYV]SX

NS]^KXMO ON_MK^SYX SX MVK]]\YYW]€ SX \_\KV 8OaPY_XNVKXN KXN

\_\KV8OaDOKVKXNKXN-KXKNKYZOX^YYXOKXY^RO\KMKNOWSMKVVcKXN

6KL\KNY\]MRYYV]KNOMS]SYXaK]WKNOLc^ROZ\Y`SXMSKV.OZK\^WOX^YP

KNWSXS]^\K^S`OVc^RO[_O]^SYXK\S]O]PY\^OKMRO\]]^_NOX^]KXNKLY`O

/N_MK^SYX^YKMMOVO\K^OKXNOb^OXN^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP]MRYYVNS]^\SM^

KVVKNWSXS]^\K^Y\]$aRK^S]K]MRYYVSX^RO^aOX^cPS\]^MOX^_\c)

NSQS^KVSX^\KXO^]AS^RSX^RO.OZK\^WOX^YP/N_MK^SYXYP8OaPY_XNVKXN

8Y^O]

KXN 6KL\KNY\ K -OX^\O PY\ .S]^KXMO 6OK\XSXQ KXN 3XXY`K^SYX aK] O]^KLVS]RON ^Y Z\YWY^O YXVSXO VOK\XSXQ aS^RSX KXN LO^aOOX XOa



+:MY_\]O]OXKLVO]OXSY\]^_NOX^]^YLOQSX_XNO\Q\KN_K^ONOQ\OO]aS^R ZK\^YP^ROS\Z\YQ\KWMYWZVO^ONP\YWRSQR]MRYYVSPMY_\]O]K\OZK]]ON

OVOM^\YXSMON_MK^SYXKV]^\_M^_\O]^R\Y_QRY_^^ROZ\Y`SXMO

K^ Q\KNO VO`OV] ]ZOMSPSON Lc ^RO _XS`O\]S^c YP ^ROS\ MRYSMO ?X^SV ^RS] SXS^SK^S`O+:MY_\]O]RKNXY^LOOX^K_QR^YXVSXOY\SX\_\KV]MRYYV]SX

/N_MK^SYXKVKXN:YVSMc3WZVSMK^SYX]

OS^RO\-KXKNKY\^RO?XS^ON=^K^O]

+V^RY_QR-KXKNKKXN8OaDOKVKXNNSPPO\SX^O\W]YPQOYQ\KZRcKXN ^RO ]SdO YP ^ROS\ \O]ZOM^S`O ZYZ_VK^SYX] LY^R ]YMSO^SO] RK`O WKXc MYWW_XS^SO] VYMK^ON MYX]SNO\KLVO NS]^KXMO] P\YW WKTY\ MOX^\O] YP ZYZ_VK^SYX

>ROS\

\O]Y_\MOLK]ON

OMYXYWSO]

XOMO]]S^K^O



>RO @S]^K =MRYYV .S]^\SM^ .S]^\SM^ " MYX^KSX] " ]MRYYV] \KXQSXQ SX ]^_NOX^OX\YVWOX^P\YW^Y >RO\OQSYXSXaRSMR^RO@S]^K=MRYYV .S]^\SM^S]VYMK^ONOb^OXN]P\YW,YXK`S]^KSX^ROXY\^R^ROZVKMOaRO\O

RK`SXQ

4YRX-KLY^VKXNONSX8Y\^R+WO\SMKSX#!^Y^RO,_\SX:OXSX]_VKSX

]_]^KSXKLVO\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]KXNKUOcSX]^S^_^SYXSXKMRSO`SXQ^RS]S]

^RO ]Y_^R 3^ S] K VK\QO QOYQ\KZRSM K\OK MY`O\SXQ KLY_^ ! ][_K\O

^ROVYMKV]MRYYV

USVYWO^\O]>RO\OQSYXRK]KZYZ_VK^SYXYPKLY_^ZOYZVOKXNKX

3X LY^R 8Oa DOKVKXN KXN -KXKNK \_\KV ]MRYYV] RK`O NO`OVYZON

OMYXYWc ]_ZZY\^ON Lc K NS`O\]O SXP\K]^\_M^_\O SXMV_NSXQ PS]RSXQ

SXXY`K^S`O^OMRXYVYQSMKVZ\KM^SMO]^R\Y_QRaRSMR]OXSY\ RSQR]MRYYV

PY\O]^\c PK\WSXQ WSXSXQ K[_KM_V^_\O KXN ^Y_\S]W >RO @S]^K =MRYYV

]^_NOX^] RK`O LOOX Z\Y`SNON aS^R Ob^OXNON KMMO]] ^Y VOK\XSXQ

.S]^\SM^aK]PY\WONSX##

YZZY\^_XS^SO]3XLY^RMY_X^\SO]OVOK\XSXQSX\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]LOQKX

>RO\OaO\O

SX]SXQVO]MRYYV]aRSMRVSXUON^YPY\W\OQSYXKV^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQ XO^aY\U]

P\YW

aRSMR

XK^SYXKV

8Oa

DOKVKXN

KXN

Z\Y`SXMSKV

-KXKNSKX]^\K^OQSO]RK`OOWO\QON >RO ]SQXSPSMKXMO YP ^RO ZK\KVVOV NO`OVYZWOX^ YP \_\KV ]MRYYV OVOK\XSXQ SX 8Oa DOKVKXN KXN -KXKNK RK] LOOX Z\SWK\SVc PY\ ^RO

Lc

 KXNLOMKWOKVOQKVOX^S^cSX4KX_K\c##!

]^_NOX^]OX\YVVONSX^RO"]MRYYV]SX^RONS]^\SM^^K_QR^

^OKMRO\]>RO@S]^K=MRYYV.S]^\SM^S]KZZ\YbSWK^OVc^aYRY_\]Lc

\YKN P\YW ^RO MKZS^KV MS^c =^ 4YRX] aRSMR S] ^RO VYMK^SYX YP 7OWY\SKV ?XS`O\]S^c YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN /SQR^ ]MRYYV] aS^RSX ^RO @S]^K =MRYYV NS]^\SM^^YQO^RO\aS^R^RO>OVO6OK\XSXQKXNROK_^RY\ 5OX =^O`OX] S] K 8Oa DOKVKXNO\ aRY S] :\YPO]]Y\ YP /N_MK^SYX K^ 7OWY\SKV ?XS`O\]S^c YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN -KXKNK aRO\O RO RYVN] ^RO -RKS\ YP >OVO6OK\XSXQ KXN RO4Y_\XKVYP.S]^KXMO6OK\XSXQZZ" =^O`OX] 5 4 ##

 >RO ^OMRXYVYQSMKV MRKVVOXQO ^Y ^RO XY^SYX YP

\_\KVS^cSX8OaDOKVKXN/N_MK^SYX{\OZY]S^SYXSXQ^RO]WKVV]MRYYV 8OaDOKVKXN+XX_KVOVO6OK\XSXQKXN8OaDOKVKXN]OMYXNK\c

]MRYYV]{]YWOZONKQYQSMKVKXNWKXKQOWOX^S]]_O]SX^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP MY_\]O] PY\ PVObSLVO NOVS`O\c :KZO\ Z\O]OX^ON K^ ^RO >OMRXYVYQc PY\ 0VObSLVO.OVS`O\c-YXPO\OXMO7K]]Oc?XS`O\]S^c:KVWO\]^YX8Y\^R =^O`OX]5###>OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX]^OMRXYVYQSO]^OVOVOK\XSXQKXN ^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]PY\\_\KV8OaDOKVKXNO\]9ZOX :\KbS] =^O`OX] 5  7YPPK^ - SX Z\O]] 0\YW NS]^KXMO ON_MK^SYX ^Y O VOK\XSXQ  >RO Y\QKXSdK^SYX YP YZOX MVK]]O] K^ VYMKV \OQSYXKV KXN XK^SYXKV VO`OV] 3X 4 ,\KNVOc /N >RO YZOX MVK]]\YYW  .S]^KXMO VOK\XSXQSX]MRYYV]6YXNYX$5YQKX:KQO >OVVK = ## @S\^_KV ]MRYYV SX K XO^aY\USXQ VOK\XSXQ OX`S\YXWOX^ 2OV]SXUS$?XS`O\]S^cYP2OV]SXUS.OZK\^WOX^YP>OKMRO\/N_MK^SYX

/WKSV$]^O`OX]U*W_XMK