Home
Add Document
Sign In
Create An Account
Article in final form - Victoria University of Wellington
Recommend Documents
No documents
Article in final form - Victoria University of Wellington
Download PDF
2 downloads
13 Views
274KB Size
Report
Comment
A Three-
stage
Development of
Virtual
Classes in New Zealand. Schools .... about many changes in the administrative and academic
life
of each school. .... senior students in small schools have to leave
home
to complete their education at ...
E=^O`OX] 5 9ZOX 6OK\XSXQ ^Y =_]^KSX RO
"5OX=^O`OX]
R\OO=^KQO 7YNOV 8Oa DOKVKXN +XX_KV R\OO]^KQO.O`OVYZWOX^YP@S\^_KV-VK]]O]SX8OaDOKVKXN =MRYYV] >OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX] ^OMRXYVYQSO] RK`O Z\Y`SNON aKc] YP ]_]^KSXSXQ \_\KVON_MK^SYXKVSXP\K]^\_M^_\O]SX]O`O\KV\OQSYX]YP8OaDOKVKXNLc OXKLVSXQ^OKMRO\]KXN]^_NOX^]^YVSXUaS^RYXOKXY^RO\OVOM^\YXSMKVVc ^Y]RK\O\O]Y_\MO]>RONO`OVYZWOX^YPOVOK\XSXQSX8OaDOKVKXN^YYU
5/8=>/@/8=
ZVKMOaROXWKXc\_\KV]MRYYV]aO\O_XNO\^R\OK^YPMVY]_\OLOMK_]OYP ^ROS\]WKVVOX\YVWOX^]+POK^_\OYP^OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX]^OMRXYVYQSO] SX\_\KV8OaDOKVKXN]MRYYV]RK]LOOX^RO\OKVS]K^SYXLcLY^R^OKMRO\] KXNKNWSXS]^\K^Y\]YP^ROS\ZY^OX^SKV^YMYXXOM^YXO]S^OaS^RKXY^RO\
+L]^\KM^$
^RO\OLc MRKVVOXQSXQ ON_MK^SYXKV MYX]SNO\K^SYX] YP SX]^S^_^SYXKV ]SdO R\Y_QR^ROKMKNOWSMKXNKNWSXS]^\K^S`OSX^OQ\K^SYX
YXVSXOON_MK^SYXRK]NO`OVYZONK^^RO\OQSYXKVVO`OVOXKLVSXQ`S\^_KV
YPMVK]]O]P\YWNS`O\]O]S^O]`S\^_KVON_MK^SYXKV]^\_M^_\O]KXNZ\YMO]]O]^RK^
MVK]]O]^YLOM\OK^ON=^O`OX]###
MYWZVOWOX^^\KNS^SYXKV]MRYYV]RK`ONO`OVYZONaOVVPS^^ON^YZ\Y`SNOK^OWZVK^O PY\^ROSX^OQ\K^SYXYPYX]S^OKXNYXVSXOON_MK^SYXSXOKMRMY_X^\c
,c VSXUSXQ MYWZ_^O\] ^Y ^OVOZRYXO VSXO] ^R\Y_QR WYNOW] K_NSYQ\KZRSM ^OMRXYVYQc NO`OVYZON SX ]O`O\KV ZK\^] YP ^RO MY_X^\c
3
+_NSYQ\KZRSM ^OKMRSXQ K] ^RO XKWO ]_QQO]^] OXKLVO] ^OKMRO\] KXN VOK\XO\]^YROK\YXOKXY^RO\KXN^Y]RK\OZ\SX^KXNQ\KZRSMWK^O\SKVYX
^ RK] KVaKc] LOOX NSPPSM_V^ ^Y Z\Y`SNO Ob^OX]S`O M_\\SM_V_W
MYWZ_^O\]M\OOX]>RS]OVOWOX^K\cPY\WYPOVOK\XSXQRK]]O\`ONWKXc
YZZY\^_XS^SO] PY\ ]OXSY\ ]^_NOX^] aRY K\O \OK\ON KXN ON_MK^ON SX
]WKVV 8Oa DOKVKXN MYWW_XS^SO] `O\c OPPOM^S`OVc 3X ^RO -KX^O\L_\c
MYWW_XS^SO]^RK^K\ONS]^KX^P\YWWKTY\MOX^\O]YPZYZ_VK^SYX>RO
\OQSYXYP^RO=Y_^R3]VKXNKXN^ROXY\^ROK]^MYK]^YP^RO8Y\^R3]VKXN
KN`OX^YPMYWZ_^O\]SX]MRYYV]^RO3X^O\XO^]K^OVVS^O^OMRXYVYQc^aY
]WKVV\_\KV]MRYYV]RK`OPY\WON`S\^_KVMVK]]O]^Y^OKMR]OXSY\]^_NOX^]
aKc`SNOYMYXPO\OXMSXQL\YKNLKXNSXS^SK^S`O]ZV_]KQ\YaSXQ\KXQOYP
MYVVKLY\K^S`OVcSXK\KXQOYP]ZOMSKVS]ONRSQR]MRYYV]_LTOM^]AROX^aY
VOK\XSXQ ]YP^aK\O RK`O MYWLSXON SX 8Oa DOKVKXN ^Y Z\YN_MO XOa
Y\ WY\O ]MRYYV] SX^O\PKMO OVOM^\YXSMKVVc ^Y MYWLSXO ^OKMRSXQ KXN
aKc] YP ^OKMRSXQ KXN VOK\XSXQ SX ]ZK\]OVc ZYZ_VK^ON MYWW_XS^SO]
VOK\XSXQ K `S\^_KV MVK]] S] PY\WON ,Y^R ^OKMRO\] KXN ]^_NOX^] SX K
/VOM^\YXSM ON_MK^SYXKV ]^\_M^_\O] KXN Z\YMO]]O] ^RK^ RK`O LOOX
Q\YaSXQX_WLO\YP\_\KV]MRYYV]XYaRK`O^OVOZ\O]OXMO]SXW_V^SZVO
NO`OVYZONSX\_\KVK\OK]YP^RS]MY_X^\cRK`OLOOXYPSX^O\O]^SXY^RO\
]S^O]N_\SXQ^ROMY_\]OYPK]MRYYVNKc>R\OO]^KQO]MKXLOSNOX^SPSONSX
]YMSO^SO]aS^R]ZK\]OVcZYZ_VK^ON\OQSYX]
^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]SX8OaDOKVKXN
3X +^VKX^SM -KXKNK \O]OK\MR _XNO\^KUOX SX \_\KV 8Oa DOKVKXN ]MRYYV]RK]LOOXYPZK\^SM_VK\SX^O\O]^KXNRK]LOOXKZZVSON^YOb^OXN
S/VOK\XSXQKXN^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]SX]OVOM^ON]MRYYV]
SX
3X ]YWO K\OK] YP ^RO XY\^ROK]^ MYK]^ YP ^RO 8Y\^R 3]VKXN YP 8Oa
QOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ONMYWW_XS^SO]UXYaXK]Y_^ZY\^]>RO\O]_V^
DOKVKXN ^RO ZYZ_VK^SYX S] KVWY]^ ObMV_]S`OVc 7KY\S KXN WKXc VYMKV
YP^RS]ZONKQYQSMKVKXN^OMRXYVYQSMKV^\KX]PO\RK]LOOXXOaVOK\XSXQ
ZOYZVO]ZOKU^ROVKXQ_KQOPV_OX^Vc=OXSY\]^_NOX^]SX^R\OO]WKVV\_\KV
YZZY\^_XS^SO]PY\]OXSY\]^_NOX^]SX-KXKNK
RSQR]MRYYV]XY\^RYP^ROMS^cYP1S]LY\XORK`ORKNMYX]SNO\KLVO]_MMO]]
^RO
^OKMRSXQ
KXN
M_\\SM_V_W
MKZKMS^SO]
YP
]OVOM^ON
]MRYYV]
>RS]K\^SMVOaSVVY_^VSXOK^R\OO]^KQONO`OVYZWOX^YP^ROKZZVSMK^SYX
SXXK^SYXKVObKWSXK^SYX]SX^RO7KY\SVKXQ_KQO2YaO`O\]_MMO]]SX
YPSXPY\WK^SYXKXNMYWW_XSMK^SYX^OMRXYVYQSO]SX8OaDOKVKXN\_\KV
Y^RO\]_LTOM^]PY\WKXcYP^RO]O]^_NOX^]RK]LOOXNSPPSM_V^^YKMRSO`O
!
9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXYMY_X^O\^RONS]KN`KX^KQOYPRK`SXQPOaYX]S^O^OKMRO\]SXRSQR
MYX]OX^
NO]SQXK^ON
]MRYYV]
SX
^RO
XO^aY\U
KMMOZ^ON
-KX^O\L_\c]^_NOX^]
]MRYYV]SX^RS]ZK\^YP\_\KV8OaDOKVKXNK]WKVV^R\OO]S^OOVOM^\YXSM
,cMYVVKLY\K^SXQSX^ROKZZYSX^WOX^YP]ZOMSKVS]^^OKMRO\]YXOKMR
XO^aY\UaK]NO`OVYZON^Y]RK\O^OKMRSXQ\O]Y_\MO]+]aOVVK]VSXUSXQ
-KX^K^OMR]S^O^YK`YSNN_ZVSMK^SYXYPR_WKX\O]Y_\MO]KXNOXMY_\KQO
aS^RYXOKXY^RO\OKMR]S^ORKNKMMO]]^YKQ\YaSXQ\KXQOYPOb^\KXO^]
^RONO`OVYZWOX^YPKaSNO\\KXQOYPKZZYSX^WOX^]OKMR]MRYYVSX^RO
Ob^O\XKV]c]^OW]$^YVK\QO\_\LKXRSQR]MRYYV]^YZYVc^OMRXSM]SXY^RO\
XO^aY\URK]LOOXKLVO^YZ\Y`SNOS^]]OXSY\]^_NOX^]aS^RKMMO]]^YKX
ZK\^]YP^ROMY_X^\cKXN^Y^RO8OaDOKVKXN-Y\\O]ZYXNOXMO=MRYYV
Ob^OXNON\KXQOYPVOK\XSXQYZZY\^_XS^SO]>OKMRO\]KZZYSX^ON^YKXcYP
SXAOVVSXQ^YX=OXSY\]^_NOX^]SX^RO^R\OO]WKVVZ\ONYWSXKX^Vc7KY\S
^RO-KX^K^OMR]MRYYV]aO\OObZOM^ON^YLOKLVO^YZ\Y`SNOMY_\]O]SX
MYWW_XS^SO]XY\^RYP1S]LY\XOaO\OZ\Y`SNONaS^RKMMO]]^YOKMRYP
LY^R ^\KNS^SYXKV PKMO^YPKMO WYNO YX ]S^O K] aOVV K] YXVSXO K]
^RO Y^RO\ ^aY ]MRYYV] SX ^RO /K]^ -YK]^ XO^aY\U K] aOVV K] ^Y K ]WKVV
\O[_S\ON >RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP ^RO -KX^K^OMR XO^aY\U RK] L\Y_QR^
\KXQOYPXYXVYMKVON_MK^SYXKVKXN`YMK^SYXKV\O]Y_\MO]>RS]XY\^ROK]^
KLY_^ WKXc MRKXQO] SX ^RO KNWSXS]^\K^S`O KXN KMKNOWSM VSPO YP OKMR
MYK]^XO^aY\UK^^\KM^ON^ROK^^OX^SYXYPON_MK^Y\]SX^RO=Y_^R3]VKXN
]MRYYV /KMR ]MRYYV SX ^RO XO^aY\U RK] RKN ^Y VSXU KMKNOWSMKVVc KXN
aRY MYVVKLY\K^ON SX ^RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP `S\^_KV MVK]]O] PY\ \_\KV
KNWSXS]^\K^S`OVc
MYWW_XS^SO]SX^RO]Y_^RO\XZK\^YP^ROMY_X^\c
MYVVKLY\K^S`OVc SX ^RO SX^O\O]^] YP K W_MR L\YKNO\ ON_MK^SYXKV
aS^R
OKMR
YP
^RO
Y^RO\
]MRYYV]
KXN
aY\U
MYWW_XS^c^RKXS^]Y\SQSXKVVcNO]SQXK^ONVYMKVYXO SS/VOK\XSXQKXN^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]SXK
,OMK_]OYP^ROXOMO]]S^cYPPSXNSXQXOa]YV_^SYX]^Y^RONOVS`O\cYP
\OQSYXKVSX^\KXO^
ON_MK^SYX^YQOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ON]OXSY\]^_NOX^]OKMR]MRYYVSX^RO
>RO -KX^O\L_\c \OQSYX YP ^RO MOX^\KV =Y_^R 3]VKXN YP 8Oa DOKVKXN
-KX^K^OMR XO^aY\U RK] RKN ^Y MYX]SNO\ ^RO \YVO YP SXPY\WK^SYX
MYX^KSX] ^aOV`O \_\KV MYWW_XS^SO] OKMR aS^R S^] YaX ]MRYYV AS^R
^OMRXYVYQcSX^ROM_\\SM_V_W0Y\^OKMRO\]]^_NOX^]KNWSXS]^\K^Y\]KXN
\_\KV_\LKX WSQ\K^SYX WKXc YP ^RO]O MYWW_XS^SO] RK`O LOMYWO
ZOYZVO
]WKVVO\KXNOX\YVWOX^]SXWY]^]MRYYV]RK`OPKVVOX3X^ROVK]^NOMKNO
^OMRXYVYQc RK] LOMYWO K WOKX] ^Y OXVK\QO VYMKV ON_MK^SYXKV KXN
]YWO]MRYYV]PKMONMVY]_\OKXNZK\OX^]aO\OPKMONaS^R^ROZ\Y]ZOM^
SXNS\OM^Vc`YMK^SYXKVYZZY\^_XS^SO]
SX
OKMR
YP
^RO
ZK\^SMSZK^SXQ
MYWW_XS^SO]
SXPY\WK^SYX
YPMYX]SNO\KLVONS]\_Z^SYXSX^ROON_MK^SYXYP^ROS\]YX]KXNNK_QR^O\]
/^OKMRSXQKXNOVOK\XSXQSX\_\KV-KX^O\L_\cRK]MRKVVOXQON^RO
>RONO`OVYZWOX^YPKXSX^O\]MRYYVXO^aY\U^RK^LOMKWOUXYaXK]
MYWZO^S^S`OWYNOVYP]MRYYVSXQSX8OaDOKVKXNKXNNOWYX]^\K^ON^RO
-KX^K^OMR>RO-KX^O\L_\c+\OK=MRYYV]>OMRXYVYQc:\YTOM^L\Y_QR^
`KV_O YP K MYVVKLY\K^S`O SX^OQ\K^ON `S\^_KV Y\QKXS]K^SYX PY\ ]OXSY\
^aOV`O\_\KV]MRYYV]^YQO^RO\^YMYX]SNO\aKc]SXaRSMR^OKMRSXQKXN
]^_NOX^] >RO -KX^K^OMR XO^aY\U RK] OWZYaO\ON ^aOV`O ]WKVV KXN
VOK\XSXQ\O]Y_\MO]MY_VNLO]RK\ON/KMR]MRYYVaK]KLVO^YZ\Y`SNOS^]
QOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ON]MRYYV]^YNOVS`O\KXOb^OXNON\KXQOYP]_LTOM^]
]^_NOX^]
^Y]OXSY\]^_NOX^]
aS^R
^OKMRSXQ
SX
^RO
MY\O
]_LTOM^]
YX]S^O$
/XQVS]R
7K^ROWK^SM] KXN =MSOXMO K] aOVV K] SX]^\_M^SYX SX YXO Y\ ^aY ]ZOMSKVS]ON]_LTOM^]OQ0\OXMR4KZKXO]O/MYXYWSM]KXN+Q\SM_V^_\O ,c MYVVKLY\K^SXQ SX ^RO ^OKMRSXQ YP ]ZOMSKVS]^ ]_LTOM^] LO^aOOX ^RO ]MRYYV]SX^RS]ZK\^YP\_\KV8OaDOKVKXN]OXSY\]^_NOX^]aRYaS]RON ^Y\OMOS`OSX]^\_M^SYXSXMY_\]O]XY^VYMKVVcK`KSVKLVORK`OLOOXKLVO^Y
SSS-_\\OX^SXS^SK^S`O]{^ROWY`O^YYZOXVOK\XSXQSX8OaDOKVKXN =SXMO##"K8K^SYXKV3XPY\WK^SYXKXN-YWW_XSMK^SYX]>OMRXYVYQc=^\K^OQc RK] LOOX NO`OVYZON KXN SWZVOWOX^ON ^R\Y_QRY_^ 8Oa DOKVKXN
9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXROPS\]^YLTOM^S`OaK]^YSWZ\Y`OVOK\XSXQY_^MYWO]^R\Y_QR
YP P_\^RO\ SXS^SK^S`O] ^Y OXMY_\KQO O^OKMRSXQ KXN OVOK\XSXQ >RO]O
^RO_]OYP3->PY\^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQSX]MRYYV]>RO]OMYXNaK]^Y
SXMV_NO ^RO .SQS^KV 9ZZY\^_XS^SO] :\YQ\KWWO KXN ^RO 5K_ZKZK +\K
SXM\OK]O ^RO OPPOM^S`OXO]] KXN OPPSMSOXMc YP ^OKMRO\] KXN ]MRYYV] Lc
ARKUKaRS^S 7K^K_\KXQK 5+A7 Z\YTOM^ 0Y_\ ZSVY^ Z\YQ\KWWO]
ROVZSXQ^ROW^Y_]O3->>RO^RS\NYLTOM^S`OaK]^YSWZ\Y`O^RO[_KVS^c
aS^RSX^RO.SQS^KV9ZZY\^_XS^SO]:\YQ\KWWOLOQKXOK\VcSXLK]ON
YP^OKMRSXQKXNVOKNO\]RSZSX]MRYYV]LcROVZSXQ^OKMRO\]KXNZ\SXMSZKV]
YX
^YSNOX^SPc^ROS\3->XOON]KXN^YNO`OVYZ^RO]USVV]XOMO]]K\c^YWOO^
MYWW_XSMK^SYX] ^OMRXYVYQc L_]SXO]]O] >RO]O SXMV_NON$ 0K\8O^
^ROW >RO PSXKV YLTOM^S`O aK] ^Y SXM\OK]O YZZY\^_XS^SO] PY\ ]MRYYV]
aRSMRSX`YV`ONKMYWW_XS^cYP^OX]MRYYV]SX^ROXY\^RYP^ROMY_X^\c
L_]SXO]]O] KXN QY`O\XWOX^ ^Y aY\U ^YQO^RO\ SX NO`OVYZSXQ KX
_]SXQ SXPY\WK^SYX KXN MYWW_XSMK^SYX ^OMRXYVYQSO] ^Y OXRKXMO
SXPY\WK^SYX^OMRXYVYQcVS^O\K^OaY\UPY\MO
^OKMRSXQ KXN VOK\XSXQ% 1OXO\K^SYX B: SX aRSMR K Q\Y_Z YP OSQR^
>ROXK^SYXKV]^\K^OQcNO`OVYZONPY_\SXS^SK^S`O]$
ZK\^XO\]RSZ]
LO^aOOX
QY`O\XWOX^
KXN
SXPY\WK^SYX
KXN
]MRYYV]SXAO]^+_MUVKXNKXNSX^RO1S]LY\XO.S]^\SM^YP^ROXY\^ROK]^
K+X9X6SXORO9X6SXORS] YXVSXO MOX^\O S] SX^OXNON ^Y ]_ZZY\^ M_\\SM_V_W WK^O\SKV] Z\Y`SNO VSXU] ^Y M_\\SM_V_W ObZO\^] LSVSXQ_KV NS]M_]]SYX
MYK]^ YP ^RO 8Y\^R 3]VKXN YPPO\ON 7SM\Y]YP^ MO\^SPSMK^SYX MY_\]O] PY\ ]^_NOX^]%KXN^RO8Y^OLYYU@KVVOcZ\YQ\KWWOaRSMRPYM_]ONYXK Q\Y_Z YP PY_\ ]OMYXNK\c ]MRYYV] SX ^RO AOVVSXQ^YX \OQSYX _]SXQ XY^OLYYUMYWZ_^O\]^YOXRKXMO^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQSXWK^ROWK^SM] KXN]MSOXMO >RO 5+A7 SXS^SK^S`O LOQKX SX KXN PYM_]ON YX ^RO _]O YP
PY\_W]NK^KLK]O]W_V^SWONSKKXNK`K\SO^cYPY^RO\]S^O]=MRYYV]RK`O LOOXOXMY_\KQON^YM\OK^O^ROS\YaXaOL]S^O]KXN^YRK`O^RO]OZVKMON
SXPY\WK^SYXKXNMYWW_XSMK^SYX^OMRXYVYQSO]^YOXRKXMO^OKMRSXQKXN VOK\XSXQPY\7KY\S]^_NOX^]SX]MRYYV]LcZ\Y`SNSXQL\YKNO\M_\\SM_V_W
SX^ROYXVSXO\O]Y_\MOMOX^\O
YZ^SYX] >R\Y_QR ^RS] SXS^SK^S`O 7KY\SWONS_W ]_LTOM^ ]ZOMSKVS]^ L + -YWZ_^O\ RO KSW YP ^RO MYWZ_^O\ \OMcMVSXQ
^OKMRO\]aO\OKLVO^YWKUOVO]]YX]K`KSVKLVOKM\Y]]KX_WLO\YP]S^O]
]MROWOS]^YOXKLVOWY\O]MRYYV]^YYL^KSXWY\OMYWZ_^O\]PY\]^_NOX^ KXN ^OKMRO\ _]O K^ VYa MY]^ >RO ]MROWO RK] LOOX NO]M\SLON K] ^RO
>RO ^R\OO ]^KQO] SX ^RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP `S\^_KV MVK]]O] SX 8Oa DOKVKXNK\OMRK\KM^O\S]ONLc$
\OMcMVSXQ KXN _ZQ\KNSXQ YP MYWZ_^O\] SX ]MRYYV] 7SXS]^\c YP /N_MK^SYX##"Z
>ROS\Y\SQSX]SX]WKVV]MRYYV]SX\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]%
ã
+X OWZRK]S] YX MYVVKLY\K^S`O ^OKMRSXQ KXN VOK\XSXQ aS^RSX KX
M:\YPO]]SYXKV.O`OVYZWOX^PY\3WZVOWOX^K^SYXKXN:VKXXSXQ$._\SXQ^RO PS\]^ cOK\ YP ^RO 8K^SYXKV 3XPY\WK^SYX KXN -YWW_XSMK^SYX] >OMRXYVYQc
Y^RO\aS]OMYWZO^S^S`O]MRYYV]c]^OW% ã
=^\K^OQc Z\SXMSZKV] KXN ]OXSY\ KNWSXS]^\K^Y\] SX ]MRYYV] ^R\Y_QRY_^ 8Oa DOKVKXN aO\O Z\Y`SNON aS^R SXS^SKV Z\YPO]]SYXKV NO`OVYZWOX^ YZZY\^_XS^SO]SX^ROS\VYMKVK\OK]>RO]OWOO^SXQ]PYM_]ONYX^RO_]OYP SXPY\WK^SYX
KXN
MYWW_XSMK^SYX
^OMRXYVYQSO]
PY\
^OKMRSXQ
KXN
ã
-YObS]^OXMO
YP
^\KNS^SYXKV
Z\SX^LK]ON
NS]^KXMO
ON_MK^SYX
SX]^S^_^SYX]aS^ROVOK\XSXQ% ã
.S\OM^ QY`O\XWOX^ SX`YV`OWOX^ SX OVOK\XSXQ P\YW ##" aS^R K \KXQO YP SXS^SK^S`O] ^Y OXMY_\KQO YXVSXO VOK\XSXQ ^Y MYWZVOWOX^ ObS]^SXQON_MK^SYXKV]^\_M^_\O]KXNZ\YMO]]O]
VOK\XSXQ N:\YPO]]SYXKV.O`OVYZWOX^=MRYYV]$>aOX^c^R\OO]MRYYV]]^\K^OQSMKVVc
+>R\OO=^KQO:K\^SKV
Z\YPO]]SYXKVNO`OVYZWOX^VOKN]MRYYV]P\YWVK^O##">ROS\Z_\ZY]O aK]^YK]]S]^^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP3->SXY^RO\]MRYYV]aS^RSX^ROS\VYMKV K\OK]/KMRVOKN]MRYYVaK]MRY]OXZ\SWK\SVcPY\^RO3->ObZO\^S]OYXS^] ]^KPP
3X^RO-KXKNSKXZ\Y`SXMOYP8OaPY_XNVKXNKXN6KL\KNY\^aY^RS\N] YP]MRYYV]K\OVYMK^ONSX]WKVV\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]UXYaXK]Y_^ZY\^] 9`O\^ROVK]^NOMKNOWKXc]WKVV]MRYYV]SX+^VKX^SM-KXKNKRK`OLOOX MVY]ON KXN ]^_NOX^] ^\KX]ZY\^ON ^Y VK\QO\ MOX^\O] =YWO ]MRYYV] RYaO`O\ K\O VYMK^ON ^YY PK\ P\YW WKTY\ MOX^\O] YP ZYZ_VK^SYX ^Y LO
9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXRO]O \_\KV SX]^S^_^SYX]
aRYZY]]O]]ONKN`KXMONMYWZ_^O\]USVV]SXMV_NSXQaOLZKQONO]SQX
UXYaXK]]WKVVXOMO]]K\SVcObS]^OX^]MRYYV]]OOU^YZ\Y`SNOP_VV5
4K`K KXN 2>76 >RO VOKN ^OKMRO\ KXN ^RO Q\KN_K^O K]]S]^KX^ aO\O
ON_MK^SYX
\_\KV
KN`S]ON P\YW ^SWO ^Y ^SWO Lc 0KM_V^c YP /N_MK^SYX ]ZOMSKVS]^] K^
Y_^WSQ\K^SYXZ\YTOM^ON^YMYX^SX_O]SXMO^RONOWS]OYP^RO+^VKX^SMMYN
7OWY\SKV ?XS`O\]S^c YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN SX OKMR M_\\SM_V_W K\OK KXN
PS]RO\cKXN^RO]_L]O[_OX^VY]]YPVYMKVTYL]WKXc]WKVV]MRYYV]aSVV
aRO\O ZY]]SLVO ]MSOX^S]^] P\YW ^RO 0KM_V^c YP =MSOXMO 7Y]^ MY_\]O
NOM\OK]O SX ]SdO 8Oa aKc] RK`O RKN ^Y LO PY_XN YP Z\Y`SNSXQ
NO`OVYZWOX^^YYUZVKMO^R\Y_QRSX^O\KM^SYXLO^aOOXVOKN^OKMRO\]KXN
ON_MK^SYXKV YZZY\^_XS^SO] PY\ ]OXSY\ ]^_NOX^] SX ]WKVV KXN \OWY^O
^RO\OMOX^Q\KN_K^O]+V^RY_QRK^^SWO]PKM_V^cWOWLO\]RKNNSPPO\OX^
MYWW_XS^SO] ^RK^ K\O ]^OKNSVc LOMYWSXQ ]WKVVO\ >RO 8Oa DOKVKXN
YZSXSYX]K]^Y^ROWY]^KZZ\YZ\SK^OKZZ\YKMR^YMY_\]ONO]SQX^ROPY_\
WYNOVRK]KMMY\NSXQVcLOOXYPSX^O\O]^SX^RS]ZK\^YP-KXKNK
MY_\]O]aO\ONO`OVYZONY`O\K]Sb^OOXaOOU]_WWO\\OMO]]ZO\SYNSX
PY\
VYMKV
QOYQ\KZRSMKVVcS]YVK^ON
PKWSVSO]
AS^R
^SWOPY\^RO##"##]MRYYVcOK\ >RO.O`OVYZWOX^YP@S\^_KV-VK]]O]SX-KXKNK >RO -KXKNSKX Z\Y`SXMO YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN KXN 6KL\KNY\ RK] K Z\ONYWSXKX^Vc\_\KV]YMSKV]^\_M^_\OKNS]^SXM^S`ORS]^Y\cKXNK_XS[_O M_V^_\O3X^RO##!#"]MRYYVcOK\^RO\OaO\O#]MRYYV]YZO\K^SXQSX ^RO Z\Y`SXMO YP aRSMR
Y\
ZO\MOX^ aO\O VYMK^ON SX \_\KV
MYWW_XS^SO] >RS\^cYXO ZO\MOX^ YP ]MRYYV] SX ^RO Z\Y`SXMO K\O NO]SQXK^ON ]WKVV \_\KV ]MRYYV] 8' KXN ! YP ^RO]O RKN POaO\ ^RKX ]^_NOX^] =O`OX^c YP ^RO]O ]WKVV \_\KV ]MRYYV] K\O KVVQ\KNO 5 aRSMR WOKX] ^RK^ ^ROc W_]^ YPPO\ K ]OXSY\ RSQR ]MRYYV Z\YQ\KWWO >RO \OMOX^ \OY\QKXS]K^SYX YP Z\SWK\c OVOWOX^K\c KXN ]OMYXNK\cON_MK^SYXSX8OaPY_XNVKXNKXN6KL\KNY\SX^Y^OX]MRYYV NS]^\SM^]Z\Y`SNONKXYZZY\^_XS^c^YNO`OVYZ^ROPS\]^NSQS^KV3X^\KXO^SX ^ROZ\Y`SXMO+]aS^ROVOK\XSXQSX8OaDOKVKXN^R\OO]^KQO]SX^RO NO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]MKXLOSNOX^SPSONSX^RS]ZK\^YP-KXKNK
S>RONO`OVYZWOX^YPaOLLK]ON]MSOXMOMY_\]O]SX]OVOM^ON]MRYYV] 3XS^SKVVc aOLLK]ON MY_\]O] aO\O SX^\YN_MON SX ]OVOM^ON ]MRYYV] SX 8OaPY_XNVKXN KXN 6KL\KNY\ SX ^RO LOVSOP ^RK^ ^RO]O aY_VN LOMYWO VOKN]MRYYV]KXNK]]S]^Y^RO\SX]^S^_^SYX]SX_]SXQXOa^OMRXYVYQSO]SX ^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQ>RS]SXS^SK^S`OaK]MY_X^O\ONLcY^RO\]MRYYV] aRY aO\O K^^\KM^ON ^Y ^RO MYVVKLY\K^S`O 8Oa DOKVKXN WYNOV YP MV_]^O\SXQ ]MRYYV] aS^RSX K NSQS^KV SX^\KXO^ 3X WY`SXQ P\YW ^RO NO`OVYZWOX^ YP aOLLK]ON MY_\]O] SX ]OVOM^ON ]MRYYV] ^Y K WY\O MYVVKLY\K^S`OWYNOVKNOMS]SYXaK]WKNO^YVYMK^OMY_\]O]YXVSXO^Y MRKVVOXQO]OXSY\\_\KV]^_NOX^]SX^ROZ\Y`SXMO >RONO`OVYZWOX^YP+N`KXMON:VKMOWOX^+:AOLLK]ONMY_\]O] SX LSYVYQc MROWS]^\c WK^ROWK^SM] KXN ZRc]SM] ^YYU ZVKMO aS^RSX K
NO`OVYZWOX^ ^OKW SX OKMR ]_LTOM^ K\OK 3X NO`OVYZSXQ +: MY_\]O] YXVSXO K VOKN ]MSOXMO ^OKMRO\ SX OKMR NS]MSZVSXO aK] ZKS\ON aS^R K
7SXSW_W]ZOMSPSMK^SYX]aO\OKNYZ^ONPY\MYWZ_^O\RK\NaK\OKXN XO^aY\UMYXXOM^S`S^c+VV]MRYYV]SX`YV`ONSX^ROZ\YTOM^RKN.S\OM:]K^OVVS^O NS]RO] SX]^KVVON ^Y Z\Y`SNO K RSQR ]ZOON NYaXVSXU 3X WY]^ \_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]SX^RS]ZK\^YP-KXKNKNSQS^KV^OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX] SXP\K]^\_M^_\O]NYXY^OXKLVO]MRYYV]^YRK`OKRSQR]ZOON_ZVSXU^Y^RO SX^O\XO^+ZZ\YZ\SK^O]YP^aK\ORKN^YLOSNOX^SPSONKXNO`KV_K^ONPY\ LY^R^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP^RO\O]Y_\MO]KXN^RONOVS`O\cYPSX]^\_M^SYX aS^RSX^RO3X^\KXO^0\YX^:KQO#"aK]]OVOM^ONK]^RO]YP^aK\OZKMUKQO +NNS^SYXKV]YP^aK\OaK]_]ONPY\^RONO`OVYZWOX^YPSWKQO]KXSWK^ON QSP] KXN Y^RO\ NSWOX]SYX] YP MY_\]O NO`OVYZWOX^ >RO]O SXMV_NON =XKQS^1SP-YX]^\_M^SYX=O^ aK] ]OVOM^ON>RS]ZKMUKQOOXKLVON^ROSX]^\_M^Y\^Y^\KMU]^_NOX^Z\YQ\O]]% S^ MYX^KSXON YXVSXO ^O]^SXQ KXN O`KV_K^SYX Z\S`K^O /WKSV K MKVOXNK\ POK^_\OZ_LVSML_VVO^SXLYK\NPY\_]OLcLY^RSX]^\_M^Y\KXN]^_NOX^K VSXU^YVO]]YX]KXNMRK^\YYW]PY\MYWW_XSMK^SYXLO^aOOX^OKMRO\KXN ]^_NOX^
0Y\
\OKV^SWO
SX]^\_M^SYX
7OO^SXQ
:YSX^
KXN
7SM\Y]YP^
8O^7OO^SXQ aO\O ]OVOM^ON >RS] MYWLSXK^SYX YP ]YP^aK\O OXKLVON K ^OKMRO\^YZ\O]OX^\OKV^SWOSX^O\KM^S`OSX]^\_M^SYX^YW_V^SZVO]S^O]+X Y\SOX^K^SYX]O]]SYXaK]Z\Y`SNONPY\]^_NOX^]SX4_XO##"Z\SY\^Y^RO SWZVOWOX^K^SYXYP^RS]Z\YTOM^SX=OZ^OWLO\=^_NOX^]RKN^YVOK\XRYa ^YMYWW_XSMK^OaS^ROKMRY^RO\KXNaS^R^ROS\SX]^\_M^Y\_]SXQ^RO]O XOa^OMRXYVYQSO]LOPY\OMVK]]O]MY_VNLOQSX
SS>OKMRSXQ]OXSY\]MSOXMOSXK]MRYYVNS]^\SM^SX^\KXO^ 3XOSQR^]MRYYV]aS^RSX^RO\_\KV@S]^K]MRYYVNS]^\SM^YP8OaPY_XNVKXN
KXN 6KL\KNY\ ]^_NOX^] aO\O OX\YVVON SX +: LSYVYQc MROWS]^\c WK^ROWK^SM]
KXN
ZRc]SM]
MY_\]O]
ARSVO
+:
MY_\]O]
K\O
K
aOVVO]^KLVS]RON POK^_\O YP ]OXSY\ ]OMYXNK\c ON_MK^SYX SX ^RO ?XS^ON =^K^O] KXN -KXKNK S^ S] _X_]_KV PY\ ]^_NOX^] ^Y LO KLVO ^Y OX\YV PY\
9ZOX6OK\XSXQ^Y=_]^KSXRO WY]^ SWZY\^KX^ KNWSXS]^\K^S`O S]]_O SX ^RO PS\]^ cOK\ YP ^RO @S]^K
SX^\KXO^]aS^RSXaRSMR`S\^_KVMVK]]O]RK`ONO`OVYZON
=MRYYV.S]^\SM^.SQS^KV3X^\KXO^RK]LOOX^ROMYY\NSXK^SYXYP^SWO^KLVO] KM\Y]]ZK\^SMSZK^SXQ]S^O]
3XOKMR]YMSO^c^RO\OS]XYaKMRKVVOXQO^YNO`OVYZZONKQYQc^RK^ S] KZZ\YZ\SK^O PY\ ^RO SX^OQ\K^SYX YP YX]S^O KXN YXVSXO ^OKMRSXQ KXN
>RO XOON PY\ SXM\OK]ON ^OMRXSMKV ]_ZZY\^ PY\ ^RS] XOa YZOX
VOK\XSXQ=^O`OX]7YPPK^^##
8OaON_MK^SYXKVZ\YPO]]SYXKV]
]^\_M^_\ORK]LOMYWOSXM\OK]SXQVc_\QOX^PY\^OKMRO\]KXN]^_NOX^]aRY
K\OOWO\QSXQSX-KXKNK$O^OKMRO\]aRY^OKMR^R\Y_QR^RO3X^O\XO^
K\O _]SXQ SXPY\WK^SYX KXN MYWW_XSMK^SYX ^OMRXYVYQSO] ^Y ^OKMR KXN
W^OKMRO\]aRYWONSK^OYX]S^OLO^aOOXO^OKMRO\]KXNVYMKV]^_NOX^]
VOK\X KM\Y]] NS]ZO\]ON ]S^O] ,Y^R RK`O ^Y LO Z\Y`SNON aS^R ObZO\^
KXNSX]^\_M^SYXKVNO]SQXO\]
KN`SMO KXN SX]^\_M^SYX SX ^RO _]O YP XOa KZZVSMK^SYX] + ZK\^SM_VK\
+] aOVV K] Ob^OXNSXQ ^RO ON_MK^SYXKV YZZY\^_XS^SO] YP ]OXSY\
Z\YLVOWRK]LOOXNSPPSM_V^cSX]OM_\SXQKXNWKSX^KSXSXQSX]^\_M^SYXKV
]^_NOX^]SX]WKVV]MRYYV]^ROZSYXOO\SXQXK^_\OYPSX^O\]MRYYV^OKMRSXQ
NO]SQXObZO\^S]OSX^ROZ\OZK\K^SYXKXN_ZQ\KNSXQYPMY_\]O]NOVS`O\ON
KXN VOK\XSXQ SX -KXKNK KXN 8Oa DOKVKXN RK] SWZVSMK^SYX] PY\ ^RO
^R\Y_QR^RO3X^\KXO^
^OKMRSXQZ\YPO]]SYXPY\^RONOVS`O\cYPMY_\]O]PY\^ROY\QKXS]K^SYXYP
0YVVYaSXQ K WSXS]^O\SKV SX[_S\c SX^Y aRK^ LOMKWO UXYaX K]
MVK]]\YYW]KXN]MRYYV]KXNPY\^ROP_XNSXQYPON_MK^SYX+]]MRYYV]SX
NS]^KXMO ON_MK^SYX SX MVK]]\YYW] SX \_\KV 8OaPY_XNVKXN KXN
\_\KV8OaDOKVKXNKXN-KXKNKYZOX^YYXOKXY^RO\KMKNOWSMKVVcKXN
6KL\KNY\]MRYYV]KNOMS]SYXaK]WKNOLc^ROZ\Y`SXMSKV.OZK\^WOX^YP
KNWSXS]^\K^S`OVc^RO[_O]^SYXK\S]O]PY\^OKMRO\]]^_NOX^]KXNKLY`O
/N_MK^SYX^YKMMOVO\K^OKXNOb^OXN^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP]MRYYVNS]^\SM^
KVVKNWSXS]^\K^Y\]$aRK^S]K]MRYYVSX^RO^aOX^cPS\]^MOX^_\c)
NSQS^KVSX^\KXO^]AS^RSX^RO.OZK\^WOX^YP/N_MK^SYXYP8OaPY_XNVKXN
8Y^O]
KXN 6KL\KNY\ K -OX^\O PY\ .S]^KXMO 6OK\XSXQ KXN 3XXY`K^SYX aK] O]^KLVS]RON ^Y Z\YWY^O YXVSXO VOK\XSXQ aS^RSX KXN LO^aOOX XOa
+:MY_\]O]OXKLVO]OXSY\]^_NOX^]^YLOQSX_XNO\Q\KN_K^ONOQ\OO]aS^R ZK\^YP^ROS\Z\YQ\KWMYWZVO^ONP\YWRSQR]MRYYVSPMY_\]O]K\OZK]]ON
OVOM^\YXSMON_MK^SYXKV]^\_M^_\O]^R\Y_QRY_^^ROZ\Y`SXMO
K^ Q\KNO VO`OV] ]ZOMSPSON Lc ^RO _XS`O\]S^c YP ^ROS\ MRYSMO ?X^SV ^RS] SXS^SK^S`O+:MY_\]O]RKNXY^LOOX^K_QR^YXVSXOY\SX\_\KV]MRYYV]SX
/N_MK^SYXKVKXN:YVSMc3WZVSMK^SYX]
OS^RO\-KXKNKY\^RO?XS^ON=^K^O]
+V^RY_QR-KXKNKKXN8OaDOKVKXNNSPPO\SX^O\W]YPQOYQ\KZRcKXN ^RO ]SdO YP ^ROS\ \O]ZOM^S`O ZYZ_VK^SYX] LY^R ]YMSO^SO] RK`O WKXc MYWW_XS^SO] VYMK^ON MYX]SNO\KLVO NS]^KXMO] P\YW WKTY\ MOX^\O] YP ZYZ_VK^SYX
>ROS\
\O]Y_\MOLK]ON
OMYXYWSO]
XOMO]]S^K^O
>RO @S]^K =MRYYV .S]^\SM^ .S]^\SM^ " MYX^KSX] " ]MRYYV] \KXQSXQ SX ]^_NOX^OX\YVWOX^P\YW^Y >RO\OQSYXSXaRSMR^RO@S]^K=MRYYV .S]^\SM^S]VYMK^ONOb^OXN]P\YW,YXK`S]^KSX^ROXY\^R^ROZVKMOaRO\O
RK`SXQ
4YRX-KLY^VKXNONSX8Y\^R+WO\SMKSX#!^Y^RO,_\SX:OXSX]_VKSX
]_]^KSXKLVO\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]KXNKUOcSX]^S^_^SYXSXKMRSO`SXQ^RS]S]
^RO ]Y_^R 3^ S] K VK\QO QOYQ\KZRSM K\OK MY`O\SXQ KLY_^ ! ][_K\O
^ROVYMKV]MRYYV
USVYWO^\O]>RO\OQSYXRK]KZYZ_VK^SYXYPKLY_^ZOYZVOKXNKX
3X LY^R 8Oa DOKVKXN KXN -KXKNK \_\KV ]MRYYV] RK`O NO`OVYZON
OMYXYWc ]_ZZY\^ON Lc K NS`O\]O SXP\K]^\_M^_\O SXMV_NSXQ PS]RSXQ
SXXY`K^S`O^OMRXYVYQSMKVZ\KM^SMO]^R\Y_QRaRSMR]OXSY\ RSQR]MRYYV
PY\O]^\c PK\WSXQ WSXSXQ K[_KM_V^_\O KXN ^Y_\S]W >RO @S]^K =MRYYV
]^_NOX^] RK`O LOOX Z\Y`SNON aS^R Ob^OXNON KMMO]] ^Y VOK\XSXQ
.S]^\SM^aK]PY\WONSX##
YZZY\^_XS^SO]3XLY^RMY_X^\SO]OVOK\XSXQSX\_\KVMYWW_XS^SO]LOQKX
>RO\OaO\O
SX]SXQVO]MRYYV]aRSMRVSXUON^YPY\W\OQSYXKV^OKMRSXQKXNVOK\XSXQ XO^aY\U]
P\YW
aRSMR
XK^SYXKV
8Oa
DOKVKXN
KXN
Z\Y`SXMSKV
-KXKNSKX]^\K^OQSO]RK`OOWO\QON >RO ]SQXSPSMKXMO YP ^RO ZK\KVVOV NO`OVYZWOX^ YP \_\KV ]MRYYV OVOK\XSXQ SX 8Oa DOKVKXN KXN -KXKNK RK] LOOX Z\SWK\SVc PY\ ^RO
Lc
KXNLOMKWOKVOQKVOX^S^cSX4KX_K\c##!
]^_NOX^]OX\YVVONSX^RO"]MRYYV]SX^RONS]^\SM^^K_QR^
^OKMRO\]>RO@S]^K=MRYYV.S]^\SM^S]KZZ\YbSWK^OVc^aYRY_\]Lc
\YKN P\YW ^RO MKZS^KV MS^c =^ 4YRX] aRSMR S] ^RO VYMK^SYX YP 7OWY\SKV ?XS`O\]S^c YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN /SQR^ ]MRYYV] aS^RSX ^RO @S]^K =MRYYV NS]^\SM^^YQO^RO\aS^R^RO>OVO6OK\XSXQKXNROK_^RY\ 5OX =^O`OX] S] K 8Oa DOKVKXNO\ aRY S] :\YPO]]Y\ YP /N_MK^SYX K^ 7OWY\SKV ?XS`O\]S^c YP 8OaPY_XNVKXN -KXKNK aRO\O RO RYVN] ^RO -RKS\ YP >OVO6OK\XSXQ KXN RO4Y_\XKVYP.S]^KXMO6OK\XSXQZZ" =^O`OX] 5 4 ##
>RO ^OMRXYVYQSMKV MRKVVOXQO ^Y ^RO XY^SYX YP
\_\KVS^cSX8OaDOKVKXN/N_MK^SYX{\OZY]S^SYXSXQ^RO]WKVV]MRYYV 8OaDOKVKXN+XX_KVOVO6OK\XSXQKXN8OaDOKVKXN]OMYXNK\c
]MRYYV]{]YWOZONKQYQSMKVKXNWKXKQOWOX^S]]_O]SX^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP MY_\]O] PY\ PVObSLVO NOVS`O\c :KZO\ Z\O]OX^ON K^ ^RO >OMRXYVYQc PY\ 0VObSLVO.OVS`O\c-YXPO\OXMO7K]]Oc?XS`O\]S^c:KVWO\]^YX8Y\^R =^O`OX]5###>OVOMYWW_XSMK^SYX]^OMRXYVYQSO]^OVOVOK\XSXQKXN ^RONO`OVYZWOX^YP`S\^_KVMVK]]O]PY\\_\KV8OaDOKVKXNO\]9ZOX :\KbS] =^O`OX] 5 7YPPK^ - SX Z\O]] 0\YW NS]^KXMO ON_MK^SYX ^Y O VOK\XSXQ >RO Y\QKXSdK^SYX YP YZOX MVK]]O] K^ VYMKV \OQSYXKV KXN XK^SYXKV VO`OV] 3X 4 ,\KNVOc /N >RO YZOX MVK]]\YYW .S]^KXMO VOK\XSXQSX]MRYYV]6YXNYX$5YQKX:KQO >OVVK = ## @S\^_KV ]MRYYV SX K XO^aY\USXQ VOK\XSXQ OX`S\YXWOX^ 2OV]SXUS$?XS`O\]S^cYP2OV]SXUS.OZK\^WOX^YP>OKMRO\/N_MK^SYX
/WKSV$]^O`OX]U*W_XMK
×
Report "Article in final form - Victoria University of Wellington"
Your name
Email
Reason
-Select Reason-
Pornographic
Defamatory
Illegal/Unlawful
Spam
Other Terms Of Service Violation
File a copyright complaint
Description
×
Sign In
Email
Password
Remember me
Forgot password?
Sign In
Our partners will collect data and use cookies for ad personalization and measurement.
Learn how we and our ad partner Google, collect and use data
.
Agree & close