Jun 19, 2017 - Investment Services, Software, & Technology. 3.9% ...... Inc., Ambit Private Banking Business. Bankin
Financial Technology Sector Summary Week of June 19, 2017
1
DEAL DASHBOARD Financial Technology $11.7 Bn | 1,179 Deals
(3)
LTM Financing Volume
$77.6 Bn | 683 Deals
Last Twelve Months
Select Recent Financing Transactions
Company
(3)
Industry Stock Market Performance (1)
Amount ($MM) $300.0
LTM M&A Volume
160
Select Recent M&A Transactions
150
Target
Acquirer
EV ($MM)
140
$1,381.0
130
$145.5 $140.0 $65.0
$304.0
120
$89.0
110 100
$33.0
90
$28.0
80 6/16/16
$22.5 $12.0
NA 8/1/16
9/14/16
10/28/16 12/13/16
1/26/17
4/26/17
6/9/17
NA
Exchanges
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus Banking & Lending Technology
Online Broker Dealers
$12.0
3/13/17
Payments
Investment Services, Software, & Technology
NA NA
Healthcare / Insurance Technology S&P 500
Quarterly Financing Volume
(3)
Quarterly M&A Volume
$10
$8
500 $8.9 299
298
$6
316
276
400 300
$30
219 196
$25 $20
(3)
205
250 188
$24.9
$24.5 $20.8
$20.4
200 150
$15 $4
200
$2
$2.6
$2.6
Q3 2016
Q4 2016
$3.0
$0 Q2 2016
Financing Volume ($Bn)
Q1 2017
Financing Deal Count
100
$10
100
$5
0
$0
50 0 Q2 2016
Q3 2016 M&A Volume ($Bn)
Notes: Source: Capital IQ, CB Insights and GCA FinTech Database. Market Data as of 6/16/17. 1) Refer to footnotes on page 5 for index composition. 2) Represents transactions announced between 6/5/17 and 6/19/17. 3) Deal counts include transactions with undisclosed funding amounts and enterprise values for financing and M&A transactions respectively.
Q4 2016
Q1 2017
M&A Deal Count
2
GCA OVERVIEW Financial Technology Team
San Francisco
New York
One Maritime Plaza, 25th Fl. San Francisco, CA 94111 (415) 318-3600
640 Fifth Avenue, 10 Fl. New York, NY 10019 (212) 999-7090
th
London
Tokyo
1 Southampton St. London WC2R0LR United Kingdom +44 20 7484 4040
11-1 Marunouchi 1-chome Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 100-6230 Japan +81 (3) 6212-7100
Sean Minnihan
Peter Bang
Derek Bell
Paul DiNardo
Steve Fletcher
Rob Freiman
Managing Director Global Head of FinTech
Managing Director
Managing Director
Managing Director
Managing Director
Director
Phone: (212) 999-7077 Mobile: (917) 364-6230
[email protected]
Phone: (212) 999-7074 Mobile: (917) 783-4057
[email protected]
Phone: (212) 999-7089 Mobile: (914) 953-0689
[email protected]
Phone: (212) 999-7097 Mobile: (650) 483-7246
[email protected]
Phone: (415) 318-3661 Mobile: (415) 518-6725
[email protected]
Phone: (212) 999-7075 Mobile: (973) 229-0436
[email protected]
Glen Kruger
Michio Suzuki*
David Krueger
Saif Malik*
Alexander Berry
Malik Gill
Director
Director
Vice President
Vice President
Associate
Analyst
Phone: (212) 999-7082 Mobile: (617) 792-6496
[email protected]
Phone: +81 3-6212-7145 Mobile: +81 90-7412-9411
[email protected]
Phone: (212) 537-4534 Mobile: (616) 822-7179
[email protected]
Phone: +44 (0) 207 038-3216 Mobile: +44 (0) 778 606-8553
[email protected]
Phone: (212) 999-7079 Mobile: (818) 851-2300
[email protected]
Phone: (212) 537-4529 Mobile: (646) 668-6714
[email protected]
* Saif Malik is a Vice President at GCA Savvian Europe Limited * Michio Suzuki is a Director at GCA Corporation
3
SECTION I: Market Summary
4
MARKET SUMMARY Industry Stock Market Performance 160
170
Last 12 Months
Last 3 Years
160
150
150
140
140
130 130 120
120 110
110
100 100
90
80 6/16/16
90
8/1/16
9/14/16
10/28/16
12/13/16
1/26/17
3/13/17
4/26/17
6/9/17
Indexed Price Performance Sector
3 Months
Banking & Lending Technology Healthcare / Insurance Technology Payments Financial, Data, Content, & Analytics Exchanges Investment Services, Software, & Technology Information Processors / Credit Bureaus Online Broker Dealers
8.1% 6.9% 6.2% 5.4% 5.2% 3.9% 2.4% (1.8%)
80 6/16/14
10/2/14
1/20/15
Payments
1 Year
3 Years
23.2% 7.7% 25.0% 20.8% 24.4% 18.1% 18.0% 43.9%
61.6% 36.1% 36.5% 3.6% 42.6% 47.3% 49.0% 53.4%
5/8/15
8/26/15
(1)
3/31/16
7/19/16
11/4/16
Exchanges
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics
Online Broker Dealers
12/14/15
(3)
(5)
(7)
Investment Services, Software, & Technology
2/22/17
6/12/17
(2)
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus
Banking & Lending Technology
(6)
Healthcare / Insurance Technology
Notes: (1) Payments: ADS, AIM:SCH, ASX:PPT, AXP, BGC, BOVESPA:CIEL3, CATM, DFS, EEFT, ENXTPA:EDEN, FDC, FLT, GDOT, GPN, MA, PAR, PYPL, SHOP, SQ, TSE:3769, TSS, UEPS, V, VNTV, WEX, WPG, WU, XTRA:WDI. (2) Exchanges: ASX:ASX, ATSE:EXAE, BME:BME, BMV:BOLSA A, BOVESPA:BVMF3, CBOE, CME, ICE, JSE:JSE, KLSE:BURSA, LSE, NDAQ, SEHK:388, SGX:S68, TSX:X, WSE:GPW, XTRA:DB1. (3) Financial Data, Content & Analytics: DNB, ENXTPA:FIM, FDS, HOSE:HHS, MCO, MORN, MSCI, RATE, SPGI, TRI. (4) Information Processors / Credit Bureaus: ACXM, EFX, FICO, INTX, LSE: EXPN. (5) Online Broker Dealers: AMTD, ETFC, GCAP, GLBR, IBKR, SCHW. (6) Banking & Lending Technology: ACIW, BKFS, ELLI, ELVT, EPAY, FIS, FISV, INTU, JKHY, LC, ONDK, PFMT, QTWO, SWX: TEMN. (7) Investment Services, Software, & Technology: BR, DST, ENV, FNGN, LSE:ALFA, SEIC, SSNC. (8) Healthcare / Insurance Technology: ATHN, CRD.B, DAR:CRDB, EBIX, GWRE, MJSO, SPNS, BSE:532254, SY, VRSK.
5
(8)
(4)
MARKET SUMMARY EBITDA Multiples and Margins
2017E EBITDA Multiples
2017 EBITDA Margins
Healthcare / Insurance Technology
17.9x
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus
Exchanges
Online Broker Dealers
15.2x
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics
14.5x
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics
Investment Services, Software, & Technology
14.4x
Banking and Lending Technology
Banking and Lending Technology
14.2x
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus
Exchanges
0.0x
10.0x
32.9%
30.6%
26.7%
25.6%
Healthcare / Insurance Technology
9.8x
5.0x
39.3%
Payments
12.5x
Online Broker Dealers
46.1%
Investment Services, Software, & Technology
13.7x
Payments
58.8%
15.0x
Notes: Numbers represent medians of sub-sectors. Details available in later pages.
20.0x
16.4%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70% 6
MARKET SUMMARY Price / Earnings Multiples and PEG Ratios
2017E Price / Earnings Multiples
2017E PE / Growth (“PEG” Ratio) | Long-Term EPS Growth
Banking and Lending Technology
29.6x
Healthcare / Insurance Technology
28.9x
Online Broker Dealers
26.2x
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus
24.9x
Healthcare / Insurance Technology
Exchanges
2.1
10.6%
Banking and Lending Technology
2.1
15.5%
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics
2.1
10.6%
2.1
13.8%
Investment Services, Software, & Technology
23.4x
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics
23.0x
Investment Services, Software, & Technology
Exchanges
Payments
0.0x
21.6x
17.8x
5.0x 10.0x 15.0x 20.0x 25.0x 30.0x 35.0x
Notes: Numbers represent medians of sub-sectors. Details available in later pages.
14.2%
2.5
1.5
16.0%
Payments
1.3
14.5%
Online Broker Dealers
1.3
17.4%
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
7
MARKET SUMMARY LTM Price Performance and 2017 P/E – Payments / Banking ($MM)
($MM)
Networks Visa Inc. Mastercard Incorporated American Express Company PayPal Holdings, Inc. Discover Financial Services Sector Average
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$217,125 $130,726 $72,798 $62,273 $23,230
20% 30% 32% 40% 16%
27.0x 28.3x 14.3x 29.1x 10.1x
$101,230
28%
21.8x
Prepaid Blackhawk Network Holdings, Inc. Green Dot Corporation Net 1 UEPS Technologies, Inc. Sector Average
Integrated Payments Hardware / Technology
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$19,633 $16,653 $13,655 $11,888 $10,849 $8,814 $8,336 $8,220 $2,115 $1,208 $496 $177 $33
(9%) 54% 20% 14% 13% 160% 58% 11% 9% 6% 7% (16%) (16%)
15.0x 11.8x 22.9x 18.5x 18.2x NM 27.9x 23.9x 75.1x 10.2x 15.5x 19.6x NM
Sector Average
$7,852
24%
23.5x
Money Transfer
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$8,992 $4,593
1% 14%
11.4x 19.3x
$6,792
8%
15.3x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$14,192 $13,323 $6,061 $4,503
23% 0% 47% 19%
13.7x 17.3x 22.7x 19.8x
$9,520
22%
18.4x
Merchant Processing Cielo S.A. First Data Corporation Global Payments Inc. Vantiv, Inc. Total System Services, Inc. Square, Inc. Wirecard AG Worldpay Group plc GMO Payment Gateway, Inc. EVERTEC, Inc. SafeCharge International Group Limited Planet Payment, Inc. JetPay Corporation
The Western Union Company Euronet Worldwide, Inc. Sector Average
Closed Loop Alliance Data Systems Corporation FleetCor Technologies, Inc. Edenred SA WEX Inc. Sector Average
Ingenico Group - GCS NCR Corporation VeriFone Systems, Inc. Cardtronics plc Everi Holdings Inc. PAR Technology Corporation Sector Average
Banking and Lending Technology Intuit Inc. Fidelity National Information Services, Inc. Fiserv, Inc. Jack Henry & Associates, Inc. Temenos Group AG Ellie Mae, Inc. Black Knight Financial Services, Inc. ACI Worldwide, Inc. LendingClub Corporation Q2 Holdings, Inc. Bottomline Technologies (de), Inc. Elevate Credit, Inc. On Deck Capital, Inc. Performant Financial Corporation Sector Average
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus Experian plc Equifax Inc. Fair Isaac Corporation Acxiom Corporation Sector Average
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research. Market data as of June 16, 2017.
0
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$2,321 $2,027 $557
24% 81% (2%)
25.0x 20.3x 5.5x
$1,635
34%
16.9x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$5,683 $4,820 $1,927 $1,522 $467 $136
(13%) 37% (9%) (16%) 365% 81%
17.3x 11.8x 11.8x 11.7x 6.9x NA
$2,426
74%
11.9x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$35,740 $28,162 $26,473 $8,137 $6,278 $3,790 $2,713 $2,631 $2,266 $1,560 $1,004 $349 $304 $127
31% 15% 17% 25% 63% 30% 13% 6% 13% 40% 6% NA (18%) 56%
30.6x 20.1x 24.3x 32.3x 37.4x 59.7x 28.7x 47.7x NM NM 25.1x 23.1x NM NM
$8,538
23%
32.9x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$19,152 $17,140 $4,193 $2,062
19% 17% 22% 21%
22.3x 23.5x 26.2x 35.9x
$10,637
20%
27.0x
8
MARKET SUMMARY LTM Price Performance and 2017 P/E – Securities / Cap. Mkts. / Data & Analytics ($MM)
($MM)
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$42,875 $38,230 $11,754 $11,721 $9,924 $2,928 $1,099
33% 26% 10% 24% 37% 34% 24%
26.0x 21.6x 17.3x 20.1x 26.2x 15.0x 18.4x
Sector Average
$16,933
27%
20.6x
Exchanges - Asia
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$31,163 $7,688 $5,642 $1,314
10% 24% (4%) 16%
36.1x 22.5x 21.8x 25.4x
$11,452
12%
26.4x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$19,943 $16,502 $2,927 $846 $515 $367
33% 41% 28% (7%) 57% 21%
19.6x 25.0x 17.0x 15.2x 15.8x 34.7x
$6,850
29%
21.2x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$7,719 $3,519 $718 $708 $695
44% 38% 35% 41% (4%)
62.2x 15.1x NM 12.4x 18.0x
$2,672
31%
26.9x
Exchanges - Americas
0
CME Group Inc. Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. Nasdaq, Inc. BM&FBOVESPA S.A. CBOE Holdings, Inc. TMX Group Limited Bolsa Mexicana de Valores, S.A.B. de C.V.
0
Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing Limited ASX Limited Singapore Exchange Limited Bursa Malaysia Berhad Sector Average
Exchanges - Europe
0
Deutsche Börse Aktiengesellschaft London Stock Exchange Group plc Bolsas y Mercados Españoles JSE Limited GPW Hellenic Exchanges - Athens Stock Exch. Sector Average
Trading Platforms MarketAxess Holdings Inc. BGC Partners, Inc. Investment Technology Group, Inc. INTL FCStone Inc. Virtu Financial, Inc. Sector Average
Investment Services, Software, & Technology Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc. SEI Investments Co. SS&C Technologies Holdings, Inc. DST Systems, Inc. Financial Engines, Inc. Alfa Financial Software Holdings PLC Envestnet, Inc. Sector Average
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research. Market data as of June 16, 2017.
S&P Global Inc. Thomson Reuters Corporation Moody's Corporation IHS Markit Ltd. Verisk Analytics, Inc. MSCI Inc. FactSet Research Systems Inc. The Dun & Bradstreet Corporation Morningstar, Inc. Bankrate, Inc. Sector Average
Online Broker Dealers The Charles Schwab Corporation TD Ameritrade Holding Corporation E*TRADE Financial Corporation Interactive Brokers Group, Inc. GAIN Capital Holdings, Inc. Global Brokerage, Inc. Sector Average
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$8,861 $8,612 $7,820 $3,659 $2,411 $1,556 $1,672
17% 12% 32% 4% 47% NA 8%
22.6x 24.2x 19.8x 18.0x 28.3x NA 30.4x
$4,941
20%
23.9x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$38,281 $33,046 $23,386 $19,416 $13,746 $9,554 $6,706 $3,907 $3,342 $1,007
38% 11% 26% NA 6% 42% 7% (16%) (4%) 42%
24.0x 19.3x 23.0x 23.0x 26.2x 29.2x 22.7x 15.1x NA 16.1x
$15,239
17%
22.1x
Market Cap.
LTM Price Performance
P/E 2017
$56,053 $21,476 $10,187 $2,487 $280 $12
47% 38% 49% (0%) (5%) (78%)
26.2x 24.2x 18.8x 27.2x 69.2x NA
$15,083
8%
33.1x
9
SECTION II: Payments / Banking
10
PAYMENTS / BANKING Public Company Valuations: Financial Metrics $MM, Except Per Share Data Stock Price 6/16/17 Networks Visa Inc. Mastercard Incorporated American Express Company PayPal Holdings, Inc. Discover Financial Services
$94.17 121.96 81.45 51.84 61.10
LTM Price Range Low High $73.25 86.65 57.15 34.00 50.32
$96.60 126.19 82.00 55.14 74.33
Equity Value $217,125 130,726 72,798 62,273 23,230
Net Debt $7,966 (2,444) 26,093 (8,928) 11,654
Enterprise Value $232,497 128,309 100,491 53,345 35,459 Mean Median
Merchant Processing Cielo S.A. First Data Corporation Global Payments Inc. Vantiv, Inc. Total System Services, Inc. Square, Inc. Wirecard AG Worldpay Group plc GMO Payment Gateway, Inc. EVERTEC, Inc. SafeCharge International Group Limited Planet Payment, Inc. JetPay Corporation(1)
$7.24 18.12 89.55 60.60 58.95 23.56 67.46 4.14 57.43 16.65 3.35 3.30 2.10
$6.19 9.90 64.63 50.98 46.22 8.42 36.10 3.17 34.40 14.15 2.34 2.75 1.75
$9.57 19.01 93.52 66.24 60.64 24.97 68.00 4.14 62.30 18.60 3.78 4.97 3.25
$19,633 16,653 13,655 11,888 10,849 8,814 8,336 8,220 2,115 1,208 496 177 33
$2,018 18,121 3,417 3,075 2,797 (546) (770) 1,689 (224) 592 (115) (5) 9
$22,809 37,760 17,217 15,259 13,661 8,268 7,565 9,909 1,900 1,804 381 171 125 Mean Median
Money Transfer The Western Union Company Euronet Worldwide, Inc.
$19.08 87.61
$18.07 65.33
$22.70 90.23
$8,992 4,593
$2,160 (159)
$11,152 4,436 Mean Median
Closed Loop Alliance Data Systems Corporation FleetCor Technologies, Inc. Edenred SA WEX Inc.
$254.90 144.41 25.99 104.98
$185.02 121.52 17.57 80.67
$266.25 176.42 27.40 122.91
$14,192 13,323 6,061 4,503
$18,804 3,322 623 2,173
$32,996 16,645 6,757 6,684 Mean Median
Prepaid Blackhawk Network Holdings, Inc. Green Dot Corporation Net 1 UEPS Technologies, Inc.
$41.20 39.53 9.67
$28.88 20.79 8.37
$44.90 40.20 13.81
$2,321 2,027 557
$373 NA (198)
$2,698 NA 363 Mean Median
EV / Revenue CY 17E CY 18E
EV / EBITDA CY 17E CY 18E
Price / EPS CY 17E CY 18E
EPS Long Term Growth
PEG
Revenue Growth 17E/16A Y/Y MRQ
12.7x 10.6x 3.1x 4.2x 3.6x
11.6x 9.5x 2.9x 3.6x 3.5x
18.3x 18.4x NM 16.4x NM
16.3x 16.4x NM 14.0x NM
27.0x 28.3x 14.3x 29.1x 10.1x
23.4x 24.4x 13.0x 24.4x 9.2x
17.5% 16.2% 10.1% 17.5% 9.4%
1.5 1.7 1.4 1.7 1.1
14.2% 12.2% 9.5% 17.3% 11.4%
23.5% 11.8% (4.0%) NM (2.6%)
6.9x 4.2x
6.2x 3.6x
17.7x 18.3x
15.6x 16.3x
21.8x 27.0x
18.9x 23.4x
14.1% 16.2%
1.5 1.5
12.9% 12.2%
7.2% 4.6%
6.0x 3.2x 5.0x 7.2x 2.8x 4.8x 5.0x 6.2x 9.2x 4.5x 3.3x 2.9x 1.7x
5.6x 3.0x 4.6x 6.6x 2.7x 3.8x 4.1x 5.7x 6.7x 4.4x 2.9x 2.6x 1.6x
13.3x 12.5x 15.4x 15.2x 11.7x 66.4x 16.9x 15.2x 33.1x 9.7x 10.5x 10.0x 25.2x
12.2x 11.8x 13.8x 13.7x 10.9x 37.5x 13.6x 13.4x 25.3x 9.4x 9.0x 8.3x 20.5x
15.0x 11.8x 22.9x 18.5x 18.2x NM 27.9x 23.9x 75.1x 10.2x 15.5x 19.6x NM
13.7x 11.0x 19.7x 16.5x 16.7x 60.7 22.2x 20.6x 53.6x 9.7x 13.7x 15.2x NM
7.8% 10.6% 13.9% 13.9% 11.9% 85.4% 26.1% 20.6% 25.0% 8.5% NM 25.0% NM
1.9 1.1 1.6 1.3 1.5 NM 1.1 1.2 3.0 1.2 NM 0.8 NM
0.7% 4.0% 41.9% 25.2% 12.2% 34.9% 34.8% 32.6% 75.7% 2.6% 11.1% 10.0% 32.4%
3.2% 0.6% 46.9% 13.4% NA 21.7% 23.4% 13.3% 89.8% 6.1% 3.2% (7.0%) 62.7%
4.8x 4.8x
4.2x 4.1x
19.6x 15.2x
15.3x 13.4x
23.5x 18.5x
22.8x 16.6x
22.6% 13.9%
1.5 1.3
24.5% 25.2%
23.1% 13.3%
2.1x 2.1x
2.0x 1.9x
8.6x 11.1x
8.3x 9.6x
11.4x 19.3x
10.8x 16.8x
7.6% 14.0%
1.5 1.4
0.1% 8.9%
0.4% 8.1%
2.1x 2.1x
2.0x 2.0x
9.8x 9.8x
8.9x 8.9x
15.3x 15.3x
13.8x 13.8x
10.8% 10.8%
1.4 1.4
4.5% 4.5%
4.2% 4.2%
4.2x 7.5x 4.6x 5.6x
3.8x 6.9x 4.2x 5.1x
16.5x 14.3x 12.1x 13.9x
14.6x 12.7x 11.0x 12.1x
13.7x 17.3x 22.7x 19.8x
11.9x 15.4x 20.6x 17.1x
14.1% 15.7% 13.6% 15.4%
1.0 1.1 1.7 1.3
9.5% 20.7% 31.1% 17.5%
12.1% 25.6% 13.2% 41.5%
5.5x 5.1x
5.0x 4.6x
14.2x 14.1x
12.6x 12.4x
18.4x 18.5x
16.2x 16.2x
14.7% 14.8%
1.3 1.2
19.7% 19.1%
23.1% 19.4%
1.2x NA 0.6x
1.1x NA 0.5x
11.4x NA 2.3x
9.8x NA 2.3x
25.0x 20.3x 5.5x
20.6x 17.5x 5.2
15.2% 16.8% NM
1.6 1.2 NM
17.5% 17.4% 10.7%
11.1% 11.0% 9.8%
0.9x 0.9x
0.8x 0.8x
6.9x 6.9x
6.1x 6.1x
16.9x 20.3x
14.4x 17.5x
16.0% 16.0%
1.4 1.4
15.2% 17.4%
10.6% 11.0%
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples based on CapitalIQ Consensus Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM. 1) Convertible preferred equity assumed at 2x liquidation preference.
11
PAYMENTS / BANKING Public Company Valuations: Financial Metrics (Cont.) $MM, Except Per Share Data Stock Price 6/16/17 Integrated Payments Hardware / Technology Ingenico Group - GCS NCR Corporation VeriFone Systems, Inc. Cardtronics plc Everi Holdings Inc. PAR Technology Corporation
$91.49 39.77 17.23 33.35 7.07 8.61
LTM Price Range Low High $76.43 25.20 14.94 32.58 1.15 4.50
$124.19 49.90 20.98 56.00 7.47 9.00
Equity Value $5,683 4,820 1,927 1,522 467 136
Net Debt
Enterprise Value
$121 2,927 743 956 983 (4)
$5,808 8,904 2,697 2,478 1,450 132 Mean Median
Banking and Lending Technology Intuit Inc. Fidelity National Information Services, Inc. Fiserv, Inc. Jack Henry & Associates, Inc. Temenos Group AG Ellie Mae, Inc. Black Knight Financial Services, Inc. ACI Worldwide, Inc. LendingClub Corporation Q2 Holdings, Inc. Bottomline Technologies (de), Inc. Elevate Credit, Inc. (1) On Deck Capital, Inc. Performant Financial Corporation
$139.49 85.19 124.65 104.79 90.05 111.23 39.00 22.29 5.61 38.10 24.78 8.38 4.19 2.52
$103.03 68.03 92.81 79.00 48.80 77.60 33.06 15.11 4.03 25.23 18.48 6.50 3.29 1.50
$143.81 87.32 126.28 106.46 94.68 114.38 42.20 23.97 6.79 40.50 28.35 8.98 6.46 4.07
$35,740 28,162 26,473 8,137 6,278 3,790 2,713 2,631 2,266 1,560 1,004 349 304 127
($1,093) 8,800 4,330 7 169 (393) 1,467 603 (534) (82) 39 414 743 24
$34,647 37,074 30,803 8,144 6,447 3,396 5,225 3,234 1,731 1,478 1,043 763 1,054 151 Mean Median
Information Processors / Credit Bureaus Experian plc Equifax Inc. Fair Isaac Corporation Acxiom Corporation Intersections Inc.
$20.65 142.58 135.40 26.26 4.35
$15.86 110.87 105.70 20.47 1.70
$21.85 143.09 139.00 30.40 5.75
$19,152 17,140 4,193 2,062 104
$3,210 2,546 510 59 8
$22,374 19,750 4,703 2,120 112 Mean Median
EV / Revenue CY 17E CY 18E
EV / EBITDA CY 17E CY 18E
Price / EPS CY 17E CY 18E
EPS Long Term Growth
PEG
Revenue Growth 17E/16A Y/Y MRQ
2.1x 1.3x 1.4x 1.7x 1.6x NA
1.9x 1.3x 1.4x 1.7x 1.5x NA
10.2x 7.6x 9.2x 7.5x 7.0x NA
9.3x 7.2x 8.0x 7.6x 6.6x NA
17.3x 11.8x 11.8x 11.7x 6.9x NA
15.5x 10.9x 11.1x 11.1x 14.8x NA
11.1% NM 15.0% 13.5% 20.0% NM
1.6 NM 0.8 0.9 0.3 NA
14.6% 2.1% NA 15.8% 6.4% NA
0.5% 2.4% (10.0%) 17.9% 15.4% 19.1%
1.6x 1.6x
1.6x 1.5x
8.3x 7.6x
7.7x 7.6x
11.9x 11.8x
12.7x 11.1x
14.9% 14.3%
0.9 0.8
9.7% 10.5%
7.6% 8.9%
6.5x 4.0x 5.3x 5.6x 9.2x 7.7x 4.8x 3.2x 3.0x 7.6x 2.9x 1.1x 3.0x 1.1x
6.0x 3.8x 5.1x 5.2x 8.3x 6.3x 4.4x 3.1x 2.4x 6.0x 2.7x 0.9x 2.8x 0.9x
16.9x 12.0x 15.0x 15.7x 26.3x 23.4x 10.2x 12.8x 31.7x NM 13.1x 7.5x NM 13.4x
15.1x 11.4x 14.0x 14.6x 22.8x 17.7x 9.1x 11.9x 13.4x 72.3x 11.8x 4.8x 33.4x 8.2x
30.6x 20.1x 24.3x 32.3x 37.4x 59.7x 28.7x 47.7x NM NM 25.1x 23.1 NM NM
27.7x 17.8x 21.7x 29.4x 32.3x 45.7x 24.5x 38.7x 26.3x NM 21.0x 6.6x 17.7x 45.8x
15.9% 11.7% 11.5% 11.0% 15.5% 23.1% 14.1% 12.5% NM 32.0% 17.3% NA NM 20.0%
1.9 1.7 2.1 2.9 2.4 2.6 2.0 3.8 NM NM 1.4 NA NM NM
9.7% 1.4% 4.7% 4.9% 10.6% 21.8% 5.6% 1.4% 15.0% 29.2% 4.4% NA 20.0% (5.6%)
10.3% 3.4% 4.7% 6.2% 10.4% 26.3% 6.7% 2.4% (17.4%) 31.9% (0.2%) 17.0% 20.9% (13.5%)
4.6x 4.4x
4.1x 4.1x
16.5x 14.2x
18.6x 13.7x
32.9x 29.6x
27.3x 26.3x
16.8% 15.5%
2.3 2.1
9.5% 5.6%
7.8% 6.4%
5.1x 5.8x 5.0x 2.3x NA
4.8x 5.4x 4.7x 2.1x NA
14.5x 15.8x 19.1x 12.0x NA
13.7x 14.5x 17.2x 10.3x NA
22.3x 23.5x 26.2x 35.9x NA
19.9x 21.2x 22.1x 26.2x NA
9.6% 11.5% 16.0% 17.4% NM
2.3 2.0 1.6 2.1 NA
NA 8.3% 4.6% 4.0% NA
NA 14.3% 10.5% 0.1% (11.4%)
4.5x 5.0x
4.2x 4.7x
15.4x 15.2x
13.9x 14.1x
27.0x 24.9x
22.3x 21.6x
13.6% 13.8%
2.0 2.1
5.6% 4.6%
3.4% 5.3%
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples based on CapitalIQ Consensus Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM. 1) Revenue growth rates based on gross revenues before provision for loan losses and fundraising costs.
12
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
6/15/17
LendingTree, Inc.
Deposits Online, LLC.
Data / Analytics
$33
NA
6/13/17
Fiserv (Europe) Limited
Monitise plc
Banking Technology
$52
0.7x
Mobile Payments
NA
NA
Networks
$1,381
4.3x
Treasury Management
$2
NA
Mortgage Servicing
$304
NA
Student Lending
NA
NA
Financial Software
NA
NA
Retirement Administration
NA
NA
6/13/17
Halcash North America, Inc.
Helena Activos Líquidos Internacional, S.L. Qiwi plc
6/9/17
Otkritie Holding JSC; Otkritie Investments Cyprus Limited The Bankers Bank
6/8/17
ECN Capital Corp.
US Dataworks, Inc., Substantially All Assets Service Finance Company, LLC
6/7/17
Incenter Mortgage Solutions LLC
Campus Door Holdings, Inc.
6/7/17
Longview Solutions, Inc.
Tidemark Systems, Inc.
6/6/17
Ascensus, Inc.
Kravitz, Inc.
6/6/17
CoreLogic, Inc.
Mercury Network, LLC
Mortgage Technology
NA
NA
6/2/17
GTCR, LLC
Sage Payment Solutions, Inc.
Merchant Processing
$260
NA
6/1/17
Flywire
PACE Financial Group Ltd.
Invoicing
NA
NA
6/1/17
Aquiline Capital Partners LLC
Output Services Group, Inc.
Bill Pay
NA
NA
5/31/17
KeyBank National Association
HelloWallet, LLC
PFM
NA
NA
5/30/17
Optimal Blue LLC
Mortgage Tech
NA
NA
5/29/17
First Data Corporation
Comergence Compliance Monitoring, LLC CardConnect Corp.
Merchant Processing
$758
1.2x
5/24/17
Ebix, Inc.
Itz Cash Card Ltd.
Prepaid
$120
NA
5/17/17
Coupa Software Incorporated
Riskopy, Inc.
Risk / Data
NA
NA
5/17/17
North American Bancard Holdings, LLC
Total Merchant Services, Inc.
Merchant Acquiring
NA
NA
5/16/17
Mswipe Technologies Pvt Ltd
PayU Payments Private Limited
POS
NA
NA
6/12/17
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
13
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
Credit Bureau
$3,293
11.3x
EVO Payments International, LLC
Bureau van Dijk Electronic Publishing BV Zenith Merchant Services Inc
Merchant Acquiring
NA
NA
5/10/17
Swedbank AB (publ)
PayEx Finance AB
Consumer Payments
NA
NA
5/10/17
Cayan LLC
Card Payment Services, Inc.
Merchant Acquiring
NA
NA
5/8/17
AltaPay A/S
IPS Limited
Ecommerce Payments
NA
NA
5/1/17
FleetCor Technologies, Inc.
Cambridge Global Payments
Cross-Border Payments
$675
NA
4/25/17
Vantiv, Inc.
Paymetric, Inc.
Payment Processing
NA
NA
4/24/17
HCL Technologies Limited
Urban Fulfillment Services, LLC
Mortgage Processing
$30
0.6x
Ecommerce Payments
NA
NA
Accounting Software
NA
NA
Financial Software
NA
NA
Clearing
$27
NA
Coupons / Rewards
$455
1.5x
Banking Software
NA
NA
Sourcing Software
$45
NA
Merchant Acquiring
$32
NA
Ecommerce Payments
NA
NA
Digital Banking
NA
NA
Payment Processing
NA
NA
VAR
$38
6.2x
5/15/17
Moody's Analytics, Inc.
5/12/17
4/19/17
Ant Financial Services Group
4/19/17
Asset Vantage Inc.
HelloPay Singapore Pte. Ltd (nka:Alipay Singapore) Financial Navigator, Inc.
4/12/17
Stone Point Capital
Bankruptcy Management Solutions
Network For Electronic Transfers (Singapore) Pte Ltd. Harland Clarke Holdings Corp.
Banking Computer Services Private Limited and BCS Information System RetailMeNot, Inc.
4/11/17 4/10/17 4/10/17
New Access SA
4/7/17
Coupa Software Incorporated
Fidelity National Information Services, Inc., Ambit Private Banking Business Trade Extensions Tradeext AB
4/5/17
Nets Oy
4/5/17
Bain Capital & Advent International
OP Financial Group, Merchant Acquiring Business Ratepay
4/4/17
BNP Paribas SA
Compte Nickel
4/3/17
CU Cooperative Systems, Inc.
The Members Group LLC
4/3/17
CardConnect Corp.
MertzCo, Inc.
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
14
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
Payment Processing
NA
NA
Card Processing
$220
NA
Anti-Fraud
NA
NA
Gateway
$25
NA
Authentication
NA
NA
Payroll Software
NA
NA
Acculynk, Inc.
Ecommerce Payments
$85
NA
RAGE Frameworks, Inc.
Digital Transformation
NA
NA
Merchant Acquiring
NA
NA
Banking Technology
$3,459
2.8x
Acquirer
Target
4/3/17
Avangate Inc.
2Checkout.com, Inc.
3/31/17
M1 Limited
Areeba s.a.l.
3/29/17
Mastercard Incorporated
NuData Security Inc.
3/28/17
Wirecard AG
MyGate Communications (Pty) Ltd
3/27/17
Nxt-ID, Inc.
FitPay, Inc.
3/21/17
Visma AS
Bluegarden Holding A/S
3/16/17
First Data Corporation
3/14/17
Genpact Limited
3/13/17
Wirecard AG
3/13/17
Vista Equity
Citibank's Merchant Acquiring Services in Asia Pacific DH Corporation
3/13/17
Payment Data Systems, Inc.
Singular Payments, LLC
Vertical Payments
NA
NA
3/8/17
Flagship Community Bank
BankMobile
Mobile Payments
NA
NA
3/7/17
Optal Limited
Invapay Payment Solutions Ltd.
B2B Payments
NA
NA
3/6/17
TA Associates Management, L.P.
Interswitch Limited
Digital Payments
NA
NA
2/28/17
Technology Crossover Ventures
Retail Merchant Services Ltd.
Payment Services
NA
NA
Fintellix Solutions Private Limited
Data / Analytics
NA
NA
Tilt.com, Inc.
Crowd Funding
NA
2/27/17 2/23/17
Argus Information & Advisory Services, LLC Airbnb, Inc.
NA (1)
2/23/17
MYOB Group Limited
Paycorp Holdings Pty Limited
Payment Solutions Provider
$37
2/22/17
Bharti Airtel Services Limited
Seynse Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
Online Lending
NA
NA
2/16/17
CampusLogic, Inc.
Cegment, Inc.
Lending Tech
NA
NA
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM. 1) Reflects updated merger consideration of $18 per share on April 15, 2017
NA
15
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
Telepin, Inc.
Mobile Financial Services
NA
NA
Oxygen Finance Ltd.
Satago Ltd.
CF Management Software
NA
NA
2/14/17
Temenos Solutions Australia Pty Ltd
Rubik Financial Limited
Financial Software
$59
1.9x
2/14/17
PayPal Holdings, Inc.
TIO Networks Corp.
Payment Processing
$185
2.6x
2/8/17
Deluxe Corporation
RDM Corporation
Banking Software
$67
3.2x
2/8/17
Realtime Electronic Payments
Sigma Payment Solutions Inc.
Loan Servicing
NA
NA
2/6/17
Klarna AB
Billpay GmbH
Ecommerce Payments
$64
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
ATMS
NA
NA
Real Estate Tech
$150
NA
Electronic Payments
NA
NA
Prepaid
NA
NA
Loyalty / Rewards
NA
NA
Acquirer
Target
2/16/17
Volaris Group Inc.
2/16/17
2/1/17
i3 Verticals, LLC
2/1/17
Social Finance, Inc.
Randall Data Systems, LLC and CSC Links, LLC ZenBanx, Inc.
1/31/17
Cardtronics plc
Spark ATM Systems (Pty) Ltd.
1/31/17
Zoopla
Hometrack
1/30/17
Ingenico Group - GCS
TechProcess Payment Services Limited
1/30/17
Green Dot Corporation
UniRush, LLC
1/27/17
Ebates, Inc.
Cartera Commerce Inc.
1/26/17
Alipay (UK) Limited
MoneyGram International, Inc.
Money Transfer
$1,936
1.2x
1/26/17
Fusion RMS
Innovantum Technologies Ltd.
POS
NA
NA
1/25/17
McPayment Pte Ltd
Genesis Payment Solutions Pte Ltd.
Merchant Acquiring
NA
NA
1/24/17
Solera Holdings Inc.
Digidentity B.V.
Identity Protection
NA
NA
International Payments / FX
NA
NA
Ecommerce Payments
NA
NA
1/18/17
Clearent, LLC
1/18/17
AnaCap Financial Partners LLP
Payment Alliance International, Merchant Service Division Heidelberger Payment GmbH
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
Accounting Software / Healthcare Payments Mobile Banking
16
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
1/18/17
Augeo Affinity Marketing Inc.
Edo Interactive Inc.
Loyalty / Rewards
NA
NA
1/17/17
Clarus Merchant Services
North American Merchant Services, Inc.
ISO
NA
NA
1/17/17
Clarus Merchant Services
BC Technologies
ISO
NA
NA
1/16/17
Daimler Financial Services AG
PayCash Europe S.A.
Electronic Payments
NA
NA
ConCardis GmbH
Merchant Processing
NA
NA
Closed Loop
NA
NA
Financial Software
NA
NA
Merchant Acquiring
NA
NA
Crowdfunding
NA
NA
Online Lending / Lead Gen
NA
NA
1/11/17
Advent International Corporation; Bain Capital Investors, LLC Intellitix Holdings Limited
1/10/17
Coupa Software Incorporated
1/13/17
Loc Pay Systems B.V. Spend360 International Ltd
1/10/17
Clarus Merchant Services
1/10/17
GoFundMe, Inc
ANARAQ Holdings, LLC, Payment Processing Assets CrowdRise, Inc.
1/6/17
Rock Holdings Inc.
LowerMyBills, Inc. and Classes USA, Inc.
1/5/17
IRIS Software Group Limited
PS Financials Ltd
Accounting Software
NA
NA
1/4/17
EVO Payments International, LLC
Sterling Payment Technologies, Inc.
Merchant Processing
NA
NA
BBVA Bancomer, S.A.
Openpay SAPI de C.V.
Ecommerce Payments
NA
NA
Mobile Payments
$32
NA
Fraud Protection
NA
NA
Merchant Acquiriing
$30
1.3x
Fraud Prevention
NA
NA
Online Consumer Lending
NA
NA
eCommerce Payments
NA
NA
Merchant Services Portfolio
$8
NA
12/23/16 12/23/16
Volkswagen Financial Services AG
12/19/16
Akamai Technologies, Inc.
PayByPhone Technologies And PayByPhone And Mobile Payment Cyberfend, Inc.
12/19/16
SENJO GROUP Pte. Ltd.
Kalixa Payments Group Limited
12/6/16
American Express Company
InAuth, Inc.
12/1/16
Flexpoint Ford, LLC
Purchasing Power, LLC
12/1/16
Visa Inc.
CardinalCommerce Corporation
11/29/16
BluePay Canada ULC
VersaPay, Merchant Services Portfolio
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
17
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
11/23/16
Klarna AB
Cookies Labs GmbH
Money Transfer
NA
NA
11/20/16
Symantec Corporation
LifeLock, Inc.
Anti-Fraud
$2,362
3.6x
11/16/16
LendingTree, LLC
Iron Horse Holdings, LLC
Lead Gen
$130
NA
11/15/16
Versara Lending, LLC
Peerform, Inc.
Online Lending
NA
NA
11/14/16
Finical, Inc.
Safeguard Bankcard, LLC
Merchant Services
NA
NA
11/10/16
Intrum Justitia AB
1st Credit Limited
Collections
$163
2.6x
11/10/16
MetaBank
Specialty Consumer Services, LP
Online Lending
NA
NA
11/10/16
NPC Group, Inc.
Moneris Solutions, Inc.
Merchant Acquiring
$425
NA
11/7/16
GTCR, LLC
RevSpring, Inc.
Healthcare Payments
NA
NA
11/4/16
BC Partners; Medina Capital
Easy Solutions Inc.
Fraud Detection
NA
NA
11/4/16
Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc.
M&O Systems, Inc.
Accounting Software
$25
NA
11/1/16
Hansen Technologies Ltd
DST Billing Solutions Limited
Billing Software
NA
NA
10/26/16
Groupon, Inc.
LivingSocial, Inc.
Ecommerce
NA
NA
Online Lending
NA
NA
Credit Cards
NA
NA
10/11/16
Lendingkart Technologies Private Limited CVC Capital Partners Limited; Cinven
10/10/16
First American Mortgage Solutions, LLC
TD Service Financial Corporation
Mortgage Technology
NA
NA
10/10/16
Intuit Inc.
MTS Global (Europe) Limited
Accounting Software
NA
NA
10/10/16
TRGRP, Inc.
Priory Solutions Limited
Billing Software
NA
NA
10/10/16
Euronet Worldwide, Inc.
YourCash Europe Limited
ATMS
NA
NA
10/6/16
Capital One Financial Corporation
Paribus Co.
Ecommerce
NA
NA
10/18/16
Finectar Technologies Pvt. Ltd. NewDay Cards Ltd.
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
18
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
10/6/16
Qiwi plc
Plati Potom OOO
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
Ecommerce
NA
NA
Risk / Analytics
$6
2.3x
DirectCash Payments Inc.
ATMS
$453
2.1x
Merchant Processing
NA
NA
Billing Software
NA
NA
Point of Sales
NA
NA
Regulatory DataCorp, Inc.
Compliance/Risk
NA
NA
Bitnet Technologies
Digital Currency
NA
NA
Closed Loop
NA
NA
Check Processing
NA
NA
Payment Processing
NA
NA
Prepaid
NA
NA
Digital Banking
NA
NA
Mobile Payments
$1,224
5.2x
Gift Cards
NA
NA
10/3/16
Gresham Computing plc (nka:Gresham Technologies plc) Cardtronics Holdings Limited
9/15/16
Payroc LLC
The iTransact Group, LLC
9/14/16
Amdocs Limited
Vindicia, Inc
9/7/16
iZettle AB
Intelligent Point Of Sale (Sales) Limited
10/4/16
C24 Technologies Ltd.
8/18/16
Vista Equity Partners LLC; Vista Equity Fund III, L.P. Rakuten, Inc.
8/4/16
FleetCor Technologies, Inc.
Travelcard Nederland B.V.
8/4/16
Battery Ventures
Insert Mobile Technologies, Ltd.
9/6/16
8/3/16
SIA S.p.A.
7/31/16
InComm, Inc.
UniCredit Business Integrated Solutions, Card Processing Activities in ValuAccess Limited
7/28/16
BPCE SA
Fidor Bank AG
7/5/16
MasterCard Incorporated (nka:Mastercard Incorporated) Next Group Holdings Inc.
6/30/16
Blackboard Inc.
Higher One Holdings, Inc.
Prepaid
$237
1.5x
6/29/16
Wirecard AG
Citigroup Inc., Prepaid Card Services
Prepaid
NA
NA
7/21/16
VocaLink Holdings Limited Transaction Processing Products, Inc.
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
19
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
Investors
Target Subsector
6/15/17
Ingo Money
NA
$12
Camden Partners, CNF Investments, MissionOG
Risk Management
6/9/17
Cardlytics
NA
$12
Undisclosed
Loyalty / Rewards
6/8/17
AvidXchange
Series F
$300
6/7/17
Plynk
Series A
$28
Caisse de depot et placement du Quebec, MasterCard Worldwide, Peter Thiel, Temasek Holdings Swiss Privee
6/3/17
Max
Series A
$23
Credit Mutuel Arkea
6/1/17
Zopa
Series F
$41
Northzone Ventures, Wadhawan Global Capital
5/31/17
TouchBistro
Series C
$12
5/30/17
Wave Accounting
Series E
$24
5/26/17
RateSetter
Series C
$17
Napier Park Financial Partners, Recruit Holdings, BDC IT Venture Fund, Relay Ventures, Kensington Capital Partners BDC Venture Capital, CRV, Exhibition Capital, HarbourVest Partners, National Australia Bank Clean Energy Finance Corporation
5/25/17
BillTrust
Series D
$50
Riverwood Capital
5/24/17
Zibby
Series C
$14
5/23/17
R3
Series A
$107
5/22/17
LedgerX
Series B
$11
Blumberg Capital, CURO Financial Technologies, MissionOG, Tribeca Venture Partners Banco Bradesco, Bangkok Bank, Bank of America, Bank of Montreal, Barclays Huiyin Blockchain Venture, Miami International Holdings
5/17/17
Additiv
Series A
$5
BZ Bank Aktiengesellschaft
5/16/17
Neighborly
Series B
$25
5/16/17
LevelUp
NA
$37
8VC, Abstract Ventures, Bee Partners, Emerson Collective, FinTech Collective, Govtech Fund, Maven Ventures CentroCredit Bank, JP Morgan Chase, U.S. Boston
AP Automation Money Transfer PFM Digital Banking POS Accounting Software Online Lending AR / Invoicing Consumer Lending Blockchain Cryptocurrency Financial Software Marketplace Lending POS / Loyalty
5/15/17
Wacai
Series C
$42
5/11/17
Verse
Series B
$20
Ally Bridge Group, China Broadband Capital, China Development Bank Capital, New Horizon Capital e.ventures, Greycroft Partners, Spark Capital
5/10/17
Kreditech
NA
$120
PayU
Consumer Credit
5/9/17
Finxact
NA
$12
Live Oak Ventures
Banking Software
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
PFM Mobile Payments
20
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
Investors
NA
$42
Long Ridge Equity Partners
5/9/17
Broadway Technology
5/4/17
Signifyd
Series C
$56
American Express, Bain Capital Ventures, Menlo Ventures
5/4/17
MPP Global
Series B
$15
Albion Ventures, Grafton Capital
5/3/17
Nav
Series B
$13
5/2/17
Aicai
Series C
$32
Clocktower Ventures, CreditEase Fintech Investment Fund, Goldman Sachs, Point72 Ventures Zhongshunyi Financial
5/2/17
ServiceChannel
NA
$54
Acce
5/1/17
Airwallex
Series A
$13
Gobi Ventures, MasterCard, Sequoia China, Tencent
4/29/17
Satispay
NA
$15
Iccrea Banca
4/26/17
Ivalua
NA
$70
KKR
4/26/17
Robinhood
Series C
$110
DST Global, Index Ventures, NEA, Ribbit Capital
4/24/17
Token
Series A
$16
EQT Ventures, Octopus Ventures, OP Financial Group
4/19/17
IceKredit
Series A
$16
China Creation Ventures, Lingfeng Capital
4/18/17
Factom
Series A
$8
Harvest Equity, Peeli Ventures
4/13/17
College Avenue Student Loans
NA
$30
Comcast Ventures, Leading Edge Ventures
4/11/17
Mswipe Technologies
Series D
$21
DSG Consumer Partners, Falcon Edge Capital, Fosun Capital
4/10/17
MintQuantum
Series A
$15
Undisclosed
4/6/27
Upgrade
Series A
$60
4/6/17
WeCash
Series C
$80
4/6/17
Flow
Series A
$16
Union Square Ventures, Credit Ease, FirstMark Capital, Noah Holdings, Ribbit Capital, Sands Capital Ventures China Merchants Innovation Investment Management, Forebright Capital Management, SIG Bain Capital Ventures, Fung Capital, Forerunner Ventures
4/5/17
Jucaicat
Series A
$15
TIZA
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Target Subsector Banking Software Ecommerce Fraud Protection Ecommerce Credit Scoring Student Logistics / Payments Vertical Payments Cross-Border Payments Mobile Payments Spend Management Software Online Brokerage Banking Software Underwriting Technology Blockchain Student Loan Marketplace Mobile Payments Online Lending Online Lending Credit Scoring Cross-Border Payments Online Lending
21
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
Investors
4/5/17
Savedroid
NA
$22
Rhineland-Palatinate, Angel Investors
3/31/17
Fiilament
Series B
$15
Bullpen Capital, Verizon Ventures
3/30/17
Yongqianbao
NA
$67
Golden Brick Capital Management, CICC Alpha
3/29/17
ShapeShift AG
Series A
$10
3/27/17
cloudvirga
Series B
$15
Access Venture Partners, Earlybird Venture Capital, Pantera Capital, Lakestar, Blockchain Capital Incenter
3/27/17
Creamfinance
Series B
$22
Capitec Bank Holdings Limited
Target Subsector PFM / Digital Banking Blockchain Online Lending Digital Currency Mortgage POS Online Lending
3/23/17
Dadao Financial
Series B
$29
3/23/17
Clarity Money
Series B
$11
China Renaissance Private Equity Fund, PAG, Sequoia Capital China Citi Ventures, RRE Ventures
3/23/17
Qtum
NA
$15
Undisclosed
3/22/17
figo
NA
$12
Berliner Volksbank Ventures, DB1 Ventures
3/22/17
Avaloq
NA
$300
Warburg Pincus
Banking Software
3/20/17
Nested
NA
$10
GFC, Passion Capital
Real Estate Tech
3/15/17
Flow
Series A
$13
Bain Capital Ventures
3/14/17
solarisBank
NA
$28
Arvato Financial Solutions, SBI Group
3/13/17
Canopy
NA
$20
Epic Ventures, Deep Fork Capital, NEA, Pelion Venture Partners
3/13/17
Viva Republica
Series C
$48
3/9/17
Currencycloud
Series D
$25
3/8/17
Veem
Series B
$24
Altos Ventures, Bessemer Venture Partners, Goodwater Capital, Partech Ventures, PayPal Holdings Anthemis, GV, Notion Capital, Rakuten FinTech Fund, Sapphire Ventures GV, NAB Ventures, SBI Investment Co.
3/7/17
Qapital
Series A
$12
Anthemis, Northzone, Rocketship VC
$102
BBVA, Toscafund Asset Management, Woodford Investment Management
3/6/17
Atom Bank
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
NA
Real Estate Tech PFM Blockchain Bank API
Ecommerce Digital Banking Accounting / Tax Software Money Transfer Cross-Border Payments B2B Payments PFM Digital Banking
22
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
3/3/17
UpStart
NA
$33
3/2/17
Sensibill
Series A
$12
First Round Capital, Khosla Ventures, Rakuten, Third Point Ventures Information Capital, OTEAF
3/1/17
Clearbank
NA
$31
CFFI Ventures, PPF Group
2/24/17
Social Finance
Series F
$500
GPI Capital, Silver Lake, Softbank Group
Online Lending
2/23/17
Nymbus
NA
$16
Home Credit Group
Bank Software
2/23/17
Tala
Series B
$30
IVP, Ribbit Capital
Credit Scoring
2/22/17
Monzo
NA
$25
Orange Digital Ventures, Passion Capital, Thrive Capital
Digital Banking
2/22/17
Prospa
NA
$19
AirTree Ventures
Online Lending
2/22/17
Ecrebo
NA
$15
Joseph Schull, Octopus Ventures, Sir Keith Mills
Investors
2/22/17
Creditas
Series B
$19
2/20/17
True Balance
Series B
$15
Nasper's FinTech Arm, Redpoint Ventures, World Bank's International Finance Corp SoftBank Ventures
2/20/17
Kakao Pay
NA
$200
Ant Financial
2/13/17
CrediFi Corp
Series B
$13
2/9/17
Better Mortgage Inc.
Series B
$15
2/8/17
Exactuals LLC
Series A
$10
31Ventures, Battery Ventures, Carmel Ventures, Liberty Israel Venture Fund, OurCrowd, Stax Goldman Sachs, Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, Pine Brook Partners City National Bank, TTV Capital
2/2/17
Paytm E-Commerce
NA
$200
Alibaba, SAIF Partners
1/31/17
Feedvisor Ltd.
Series B
$20
1/31/17
Knock
Series A
$33
1/30/17
Earnix
NA
$14
1/26/17
Raisin GmbH
Series C
$30
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
General Catalyst Partners, JAL Ventures, Oryzn Capital, Square Peg Capital, Titanium Investments Correlation Ventures, FJ Labs, Great Oaks Venture Capital, Greycroft, Redpoint, RRE Ventures Jerusalem Venture Partners, Israel Growth Partners, Vintage Investment Partners Index Ventures, Ribbit Capital, Thrive Capital
Target Subsector Online Lending Expense Mgmt Software Banking Software
Offers / Marketing Online Lending Mobile Balance Management Mobile Payments Data / Analytics Mortgage Origination Vertical Payments eCommerce eCommerce Real Estate Tech Data / Analytics Cash Management
23
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
1/25/17
BitFury
NA
1/19/17
Iyzico
1/13/17
Investors
Target Subsector
$30
Credit China FinTech Holdings
Blockchain
Series C
$13
212 Ltd, International Finance Corp., Vostok Emerging Finance
HouseCanary
Series A
$33
Alpha Edison, Europlay Capital Advisors, Raven Ventures
1/12/17
Funding Circle
Series F
$82
1/11/17
CompareEuropeGroup Ltd.
Series A
$20
1/11/17
iZettle AB
NA
$60
1/10/17
Advanon AG
Series A
$14
Accel Partners, DST Global, Index Ventures, Ribbit Capital, Union Square Ventures ACE & Company, Nova Founders Capital, Pacific Century Group, SBI Holdings Inc. American Express Co, Creandum, Index Ventures, Intel Capital, MasterCard Inc., Northzone Ventures b-to-v Partners, Swisscom Ltd., VI Partners
1/10/17
MobileCause Inc.
Series B
$15
Level Equity Management LLC
1/9/17
Activehours Inc.
NA
$22
1/9/17
FreeCharge
NA
$57
Felices Ventures, March Capital Partners, Matrix Management Corp., Ribbit Capital LP SnapDeal
1/5/17
CloudCraze LLC
Series B
$20
Insight Venture Partners, Salesforce Ventures
eCommerce Payments Real Estate Data / Analytics Online Lending Lead Gen POS Online Lending Crowdfunding Online Lending Mobile Payments B2B Commerce
Series E
$24
Credible Labs
NA
$10
American Express Ventures, BlueCross BlueShield Venture Partners, Relay Ventures, Verizon Ventures Undisclosed
1/4/17
Magento Commerce
NA
$250
Hillhouse Capital Management
1/3/17
Monese
Series A
$10
Exponential Ventures, Korea Investment Partners, STE Capital
Digital Banking
1/3/17
Tandem Bank
NA
$43
House of Fraser
Digital Banking
Series A
$20
Oak View Group, Shamrock Capital Advisors
1/5/17
Payfone
1/4/17
Fraud Protection Online Lending eCommerce
12/20/16
Appetize Technologies Inc.
12/15/16
Kreditech
NA
$10
Rakuten Fintech Fund
Online Lending
12/14/16
BillFront
Series A
$35
4FINANCE, Finleap, NIBC Bank N.V.
Online Lending
12/8/16
Thanx Inc.
Series B
$17
Icon Ventures, Javelin Venture Partners, Sequoia Capital
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
POS
Loyalty / Rewards
24
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
12/7/16
Nubank
Series D
$80
12/5/16
MoneyLion Inc.
Series A
$11
11/28/16
Five Degrees Solutions
Series A
$13
Digital Sky Technologies, Founders Fund, QED Investors, Sequoia Capital, Tiger Global Management Citizen VC, Clocktower Technology Ventures, Edison Partners, FinTech Collective, Montage Ventures 5square, Karmijn Kapitaal, Velocity Capital Private Equity
11/25/16
Stripe Inc.
NA
$150
CapitalG, General Catalyst Partners, Sequoia Capital
Investors
11/24/16
Ximu Financial Information Services
Series A
$15
11/23/16
Wynd
Series B
$32
China Merchants Venture Capital Management Co., Ltd., Zhixin Capital Bpifrance, Orange Digital Ventures, Sodexo Ventures
11/23/16
Udaan.com
Series A
$10
Lightspeed Venture Partners India, Lightspeed U.S.
11/18/16
AdvisorEngine
Series A
$20
WisdomTree Investments, Inc.
11/15/16
eOriginal, Inc.
NA
$27
LLR Partners, Inc.
11/15/16
Mavenlink, Inc.
Series D
$39
Goldman Sachs Growth Partners
11/10/16
Teamleader NV
Series B
$10
Fortino Capital
11/7/16
Zafin Labs America Inc.
NA
$10
Beedie Capital Partners, Vistara Capital Partners
11/1/16
StayClassy Productions Inc.
Series C
$30
10/26/16
nanoPay Corporation
Series A
$10
10/25/16
Lendio Inc.
Series D
$20
10/24/16
AEVI
NA
$11
Bullpen Capital, Galileo Partners, JMI Management Inc., Mithril Capital Management, Salesforce Ventures APAGM Services, Goldman Sachs Merchant Banking Division, Jarnac Capital Management, Rohatton Blumberg Capital, Comcast Ventures, Napier Park Global Capital, North Hill Ventures, Stereo Capital, Tribeca Venture Partners Adveq Management
10/21/16
China UnionPay Merchant Services
NA
$296
Everbright-IDG Industrial Fund
10/20/16
PaySimple Inc.
NA
$115
Providence Equity Partners
10/20/16
TravelBank
Series A
$10
Accel Partners, New Enterprise Associates
10/18/16
PayCommerce Inc.
Series B
$22
Tritium Partners
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Target Subsector Online Banking Online Lending Banking Software eCommerce Payments Rating Agency POS Trading Platform Broker Software Electronic Transaction Software Financial Software CRM / Invoicing Software Banking Software Crowdfunding Digital Currency Online Lending POS Merchant Acquiring ISO / Gateway Expense Software Cross-Border Payments
25
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
NA
$11
Investors
10/18/16
IbanFirst
Xavier Niel, Other Investors
10/18/16
SecureKey Technologies Inc.
Series D
$21
10/13/16
TouchBistro
Series B
$13
10/12/16
Nexus Systems
NA
$28
Bank of Montreal, CIBC, Desjardins, RBC, Scotiabank, TD Bank Financial Group BDC Capital, Huff Capital, Kensington Capital Partners, Relay Ventures, Round 13 Holdings Inc. Mainsail Partners
10/7/16
FlexiLoans
NA
$15
Angel Investors
Target Subsector Banking Software Identity / Authentication POS AP Software Online Lending
10/5/16
Money Forward
Series D
$11
10/4/16
Iwoca Ltd.
Series C
$27
9/30/16
Remitly, Inc.
NA
$38
Isetan Mitsukoshi Holdings, Mizuho Capital, Fenox Venture Capital, Toho Bank, Gunma Bank, Fukui Bank, Shiga Bank Prime Ventures, Acton Capital Partners, Commerz Ventures, Global Founders Capital, Redline Capital International Finance Corp, Silicon Valley Bank
9/30/16
Financeit
NA
$17
DNS Capital LLC, The Pritzker Organization
9/30/16
Payoneer
NA
$180
Technology Crossover Ventures, Susquehanna Growth Equity
Cross-Border Payments
9/29/16
Kyriba Corp.
NA
$23
Bpifrance Investissement SAS, Daher Capital, HSBC Bank PLC
Treasury Software
NA
$88
Series A
$23
Gulf Islamic Investments, Iconiq Capital LLC, K1 Investment Management LLC, Kuwait Investment Authority Fenbushi Capital, Wanxiang
NA
$11
BDC Capital, CRV, Social Capital, HarbourVest Partners
51Credit
Series C
$310
9/22/16
Avalara Inc.
Series D
$96
9/21/16
FirstP2P
Series C
$70
9/29/16
Apttus Corporation
9/26/16
Juzhen Financials
9/22/16
Wave Accounting Inc.
9/22/16
Tiantu Capital, Xinhu Zhongbao, HgCapital, Shenzhen Qianhe Capital Management Sageview Capital, Technology Crossover Ventures, Warburg Pincus CCB International, San Shan Capital Partners
9/21/16
Nav, Inc
Series B
$25
9/15/16
Ripple Labs Inc.
Series B
$55
Experian, Kickstart Seed Fund, Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, Peak Venture Partners, Tencent Holdings Ltd. Accenture Technology Ventures, CME Ventures
9/14/16
GreenSky Credit
NA
$50
Fifth Third BanCorp
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Accounting Software Online Lending Money Transfer Consumer Finance
Quote-To-Cash Blockchain Accounting Software Online Lending Tax Software Online Lending Business Lending Digital Currencies Online Lending
26
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
Investors
9/14/16
Tipalti Solutions Ltd.
NA
$14
SG VC
9/13/16
Uno Home Loans
NA
$17
Westpac
9/9/16
Juvo
Series A
$14
Freestyle Capital, Seed-Resolute, Wing Venture Capital
9/8/16
SmartAsset
Series B
$12
9/1/16
Boku
Series E
$14
8/30/16
Paytm
NA
$60
8/30/16
Behalf
8/26/16
MobiKwik
8/22/16
InCred Finance
Contour Ventures, Fitz Gate Ventures, IA Capital Group, Javelin Venture Partners, New York Life, Peterson Ventures, TTV Capital, Benchmark, DAG Ventures, GMO Payment Gateway, Index Ventures, Khosla Ventures, New Enterprise Associates MediaTek
Series C
$27
NA
$40
Mission OG, Sequoia Capital, Spark Capital, Viola Private Equity, Vintage Ventures Management Ltd. NET 1 UEPS Technologies, Inc.
Series A
$75
Alpha Capital Partners, IDFC Alternatives Ltd.
Series C
$48
Clara Lending
NA
$27
Bronze Investments, Data Collective, Google Ventures, QED Investors, Radicle Impact, Susa Ventures, SV Angel, Thomvest Redpoint Ventures, Venrock
8/15/16
Nymbus
NA
$12
Vensure Enterprises
8/8/16
Yunnex
Series B
$45
Ajisen Ramen, GSR Ventures
8/5/16
Mosaic
NA
$220
Core innovation Capital, Obvious Ventures, Warburg Pincus
7/28/16
Paidy
Series B
$15
Arbor Ventures, Eight Roads, Itochu Corp., SBI Holdings, SIG Asia
7/27/16
Gongzi Qianbao
NA
$30
SBCVC
7/25/16
QwikCilver Solutions Private Limited
NA
$10
Accel, Amazon, Helion Venture Partners, Sistema Asia Fund
8/22/16
LendUp
8/17/16
7/20/16
Deposit Solutions
NA
$17
7/20/16
Omise
Series B
$18
7/19/16
CommonBond, Inc.
Series C
$30
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
e. Ventures, Finlab, Greycroft Partners, Peter Thiel, Valar Ventures 500 Startups, Ascend Money, Golden Gate Ventures, SBI Investment, Sinar Mas Digital Ventures August Capital, NB Private Equity Partners, Nyca Partners, Social Capital, Tribeca Venture Partners, Victory Park Capital
Target Subsector AP Automation Mortage Software Mobile Credit Analytics Financial Education Mobile Payments Mobile Commerce SMB Lending Mobile Payments Online Lending Online Lending Mortgage Technology Banking Software POS Online Lending eCommerce Payments Payroll Gift Cards Open Banking Platform Gateway Online Lending
27
PAYMENTS / BANKING Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
Investors
7/19/16
Deal4Loans
NA
$15
Franklin Templeton Group
7/13/16
i3 Verticals
NA
$10
Undisclosed
7/11/16
WeSwap.com
Series B
$10
Ascot Capital Partners, EC 1 Capital, IW Capital
7/7/16
Coinbase, Inc.
Series D
$11
Mistubishi Capital, Sozo Ventures, Bank of Tokyo
7/7/16
Payment Card Technologies
NA
$13
Undisclosed
7/4/16
NeoGrowth Credit
NA
$35
6/28/16
BizFi
NA
$20
6/28/16
PredictSpring
Series A
$11
6/28/16
Lendingkart. ltd.
Series B
$32
6/27/16
D3 Banking
Series E
$16
6/23/16
Circle Internet Financial
6/22/16
Pearl Capital
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Series D
$60
NA
$20
Aspada, IFMR Investments, IIFL Private Wealth Management, Khosla Impact, Omidyar Network, Quona Capital Metropolitan Equity Partners Beanstalk Ventures, Benvolio Group, Felicis Ventures, Novel TMT Ventures Bertelsmann India, Darrin Capital, India Quotient, Mayfield, Saama Capital West Partners Accel, Baidu, Breyer Capital, China Everbright, CreditEase, General Catalyst Partners, IDG Capital Partners Arena Investors
Target Subsector Online Lending Merchant Processing Multi-Currency Prepaid Bitcoin Debit Online Lending Online Lending Mobile Commerce Online Lending Online Banking Money Transfer SMB Finance
28
SECTION III: Securities / Capital Markets / Data & Analytics
29
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Public Company Valuations: Financial Metrics $MM, Except Per Share Data Stock Price 6/16/17 Exchanges - Americas CME Group Inc. Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. Nasdaq, Inc. BM&FBOVESPA S.A. CBOE Holdings, Inc. TMX Group Limited Bolsa Mexicana de Valores, S.A.B. de C.V.
$126.18 64.57 71.16 5.75 88.57 52.98 1.85
LTM Price Range Low High
Equity Value
$92.29 48.15 61.19 4.54 61.58 38.04 1.47
$42,875 38,230 11,754 11,721 9,924 2,928 1,099
$127.66 64.79 72.52 6.32 90.29 60.42 1.99
Net Debt $857 5,686 3,169 (359) 1,292 462 (118)
Enterprise Value $43,732 43,985 14,923 11,365 11,228 3,390 988 Mean Median
Exchanges - Asia Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing Limited ASX Limited Singapore Exchange Limited Bursa Malaysia Berhad
$25.33 39.75 5.27 2.45
$22.43 33.11 5.03 1.92
$27.33 40.23 5.67 2.60
$31,163 7,688 5,642 1,314
($27,067) (734) (529) (115)
$4,110 6,954 5,113 1,202 Mean Median
Exchanges - Europe Deutsche Börse Aktiengesellschaft London Stock Exchange Group plc Bolsas y Mercados Españoles JSE Limited GPW Hellenic Exchanges - Athens Stock Exch.
$106.76 47.47 35.23 9.89 12.28 6.08
$74.00 28.90 23.18 9.49 8.25 4.31
$106.85 47.47 37.61 14.65 13.15 6.30
$19,943 16,502 2,927 846 515 367
$649 (1,265) (362) (153) (31) (107)
$20,758 15,865 2,566 693 485 260 Mean Median
EV / Revenue CY 17E CY 18E
EV / EBITDA CY 17E CY 18E
Price / EPS CY 17E CY 18E
EPS Long Term Growth
PEG
Revenue Growth 17E/16A Y/Y MRQ
11.7x 9.5x 6.2x 9.4x 11.1x 6.0x 5.8x
11.1x 9.0x 6.0x 8.7x 9.9x 5.8x 5.5x
16.4x 14.9x 12.3x 14.7x 17.9x 11.2x 10.6x
15.1x 13.7x 11.5x 12.7x 14.9x 10.5x 10.0x
26.0x 21.6x 17.3x 20.1x 26.2x 15.0x 18.4x
24.2x 19.2x 15.9x 17.2x 22.9x 13.9x 17.1x
12.1% 13.7% 9.8% NM 32.1% NM 11.9%
2.1 1.6 1.8 NM 0.8 NM 1.5
3.9% 3.4% 14.5% 68.8% 54.0% (5.9%) 23.5%
(0.5%) 0.9% 7.3% 21.3% 108.9% 0.2% 5.1%
8.5x 9.4x
8.0x 8.7x
14.0x 14.7x
12.6x 12.7x
20.6x 20.1x
18.6x 17.2x
15.9% 12.1%
1.6 1.6
23.2% 14.5%
20.4% 5.1%
2.6x 11.5x 8.5x 9.4x
2.3x 11.0x 7.9x 9.1x
3.6x 15.1x 14.5x 15.9x
3.2x 14.3x 12.9x 15.3x
36.1x 22.5x 21.8x 25.4x
31.6x 21.6x 18.8x 24.4x
3.2% 4.2% 3.1% 4.5%
11.4 5.4 7.1 5.6
10.3% (9.2%) 9.2% 15.0%
10.6% 1.5% (5.2%) (6.6%)
8.0x 9.0x
7.6x 8.5x
12.3x 14.8x
11.4x 13.6x
26.4x 23.9x
24.1x 23.0x
3.7% 3.7%
7.4 6.3
6.3% 9.8%
0.1% (1.8%)
7.3x 6.9x 7.1x 4.0x 5.9x 8.2x
6.8x 6.4x 7.1x 3.5x 5.8x 6.1x
12.4x 13.7x 10.7x 10.7x 10.2x 25.5x
11.5x 12.1x 10.7x 8.7x 9.8x 12.7x
19.6x 25.0x 17.0x 15.2x 15.8x 34.7x
17.4x 21.9x 16.8x 12.5x 14.5x 30.1x
11.3% 15.3% NM 4.6% NM 10.6%
1.7 1.6 NM 3.3 NM 3.3
(4.8%) 11.9% 6.1% (1.9%) 10.3% 20.3%
(3.4%) 2.4% (6.5%) 16.0% 5.6% (32.7%)
6.6x 7.0x
5.9x 6.2x
13.9x 11.6x
10.9x 11.1x
21.2x 18.3x
18.9x 17.1x
10.5% 11.0%
2.5 2.5
7.0% 8.2%
(3.1%) (0.5%)
(1)
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples based on CapitalIQ Consensus Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
30
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Public Company Valuations: Financial Metrics (Cont.) $MM, Except Per Share Data Stock Price 6/16/17 Investment Services, Software, & Technology Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc. SEI Investments Co. SS&C Technologies Holdings, Inc. DST Systems, Inc. (1) Financial Engines, Inc. Envestnet, Inc.(1) Alfa Financial Software Holdings PLC
$75.36 54.26 38.33 59.24 38.35 38.15 5.19
LTM Price Range Low High $59.86 42.12 26.15 47.26 23.56 30.80 4.16
$78.00 54.40 39.17 64.33 45.75 41.47 5.73
Equity Value $8,861 8,612 7,820 3,659 2,411 1,672 1,556
Net Debt
Enterprise Value
$997 (661) 2,336 470 (138) 245 0
$9,858 7,950 10,155 4,129 2,273 1,917 1,556 Mean Median
Financial Data, Content, & Analytics S&P Global Inc. Thomson Reuters Corporation Moody's Corporation IHS Markit Ltd. (2) Verisk Analytics, Inc. MSCI Inc. FactSet Research Systems Inc. The Dun & Bradstreet Corporation Morningstar, Inc. Bankrate, Inc.
$148.49 45.78 122.25 47.53 83.14 105.62 169.94 105.90 77.85 11.25
$99.15 38.23 87.30 32.78 75.60 71.51 149.39 100.46 67.74 6.91
$149.17 46.44 122.54 47.67 87.40 109.29 183.64 141.57 85.49 11.95
$38,281 33,046 23,386 19,416 13,746 9,554 6,706 3,907 3,342 1,007
$1,154 6,571 1,813 3,574 2,129 1,379 180 1,332 (83) 113
$39,435 39,617 25,200 22,990 15,875 10,933 6,885 5,239 3,260 1,120 Mean Median
Online Broker Dealers The Charles Schwab Corporation (3) TD Ameritrade Holding Corporation (3) E*TRADE Financial Corporation (3) Interactive Brokers Group, Inc. (3) GAIN Capital Holdings, Inc. (3) Global Brokerage, Inc.
$41.92 40.67 37.05 36.58 5.88 2.00
$23.83 26.37 21.52 31.97 4.54 1.45
$43.65 47.41 38.61 39.68 8.75 11.00
$56,053 21,476 10,187 2,487 280 12
$3,802 1,765 2,612 4,638 (110) 163
$59,855 23,241 12,799 7,125 170 176 Mean Median
EV / Revenue CY 17E CY 18E
EV / EBITDA CY 17E CY 18E
Price / EPS CY 17E CY 18E
EPS Long Term Growth
PEG
Revenue Growth 17E/16A Y/Y MRQ
2.3x 5.4x 6.1x 2.0x 4.7x 2.9x NA
2.3x 5.0x 5.7x 1.8x 4.2x 2.5x NA
12.8x 14.5x 14.7x 9.5x 14.3x 15.3x NA
12.2x 12.7x 13.4x 9.1x 12.4x 12.3x NA
22.6x 24.2x 19.8x 18.0x 28.3x 30.4x NA
20.9x 20.9x 17.6x 15.7x 24.9x 24.2x NA
NM 13.5% 16.0% 10.0% 25.0% 20.0% NM
NM 1.8 1.2 1.8 1.1 1.5 NA
21.6% 5.8% 13.2% 35.6% 14.2% 14.6% (100.0%)
46.5% 7.7% 25.8% 6.5% 23.9% 19.7% #DIV/0!
3.9x 3.8x
3.6x 3.4x
13.5x 14.4x
12.0x 12.3x
23.9x 23.4x
20.7x 20.9x
16.9% 16.0%
1.5 1.5
0.7% 14.2%
#DIV/0! #DIV/0!
6.8x 3.5x 6.5x 6.5x 7.6x 8.8x 5.5x 3.0x NA 2.2x
6.4x 3.4x 6.2x 6.2x 7.2x 8.2x 5.1x 2.9x NA 2.0x
14.5x 11.8x 13.8x 16.6x 15.4x 17.2x 16.0x 10.5x NA 8.9x
13.5x 11.3x 13.1x 15.3x 14.3x 15.6x 14.8x 9.9x NA 7.8x
24.0x 19.3x 23.0x 23.0x 26.2x 29.2x 22.7x 15.1x NA 16.1x
21.6x 17.9x 21.1x 19.9x 23.7x 25.1x 20.9x 14.4x NA 13.7x
13.1% 8.0% 10.2% 13.5% 10.4% 14.3% 10.6% 7.3% NM 15.0%
1.8 2.4 2.3 1.7 2.5 2.0 2.1 2.1 NA 1.1
2.5% 1.6% 7.1% 29.2% 4.4% 8.2% 9.7% 3.9% (100.0%) 16.3%
8.4% 0.8% 19.5% 53.9% 2.0% 8.0% 4.5% 1.7% 9.1% 26.9%
5.6x 6.5x
5.3x 6.2x
13.9x 14.5x
12.8x 13.5x
22.1x 23.0x
19.8x 20.9x
11.4% 10.6%
2.0 2.1
(1.7%) 5.7%
13.5% 8.2%
6.9x 6.3x 5.7x 5.0x 0.5x NA
6.2x 5.5x 5.3x 4.4x 0.5x NA
NA 13.7x 12.3x 7.4x 3.6x NA
NA 11.5x NA 6.5x 2.0x NA
26.2x 24.2x 18.8x 27.2x 69.2x NA
21.8x 20.0x 16.3x 23.1x 8.4x NA
20.0% 18.7% 16.2% 13.5% NM NM
1.3 1.3 1.2 2.0 NM NA
16.1% 11.4% 7.7% (0.0%) (17.4%) NA
18.0% 6.8% 12.1% (19.8%) (49.6%) (23.9%)
4.9x 5.7x
4.4x 5.3x
9.2x 9.8x
6.7x 6.5x
33.1x 26.2x
17.9x 20.0x
17.1% 17.4%
1.4 1.3
3.6% 7.7%
(9.4%) (6.5%)
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples based on CapitalIQ Consensus Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM. (1) Financial metrics pro-forma for Yodlee acquisition. (2) Financial metrics reflect IHS / Markit merger. (3) Enterprise Value and Net Debt exclude Cash.
31
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months ($MM) Announced Date 6/13/17
Acquirer
Target
Lending Science DM, Inc.
Scoring Solutions, Inc.
5/30/17
Thoma Bravo, LLC; Thoma Bravo Discover Fund Partnership London Stock Exchange Grouop
6/1/17
Intercontinental Exchange, Inc.
5/31/17
HealthEquity, Inc.
The Yield Book, Citi Fixed Income Indices BofA Merrill Lynch, Research Division, Index Platform BenefitGuard, LLC
5/17/17
Liquidnet Holdings, Inc.
OTAS Technologies Limited
5/10/17
Cinnober Financial Technology AB
Ancoa Software Ltd.
5/10/17
TTT Moneycorp Limited
Commonwealth Foreign Exchange, Inc.
6/7/17
Riskonnect, Inc.
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
Risk / Analytics
NA
NA
Risk / Compliance
NA
NA
Analytics
NA
NA
Indices
NA
NA
401k Solutions
NA
NA
Trading Platform
NA
NA
Analytics
NA
NA
FX
NA
NA
5/9/17
Apex Fund Services (Bermuda) ltd
5/3/17
ETF Securities Ltd.
5/2/17
Ncontracts LLC
Equinoxe Alternative Investment Services ANZ ETFS Management (AUS) Limited (nka:ETFS Management (AUS) Limited) Supernal Software, LLC
4/27/17
Invesco Ltd.
Source UK Services Limited
Exchange Traded Products
NA
NA
4/27/17
AdvisorEngine, Inc.
Kredible Technologies, Inc.
Broker Software
NA
NA
4/26/17
Virtus Partners Holdings, LLC
Alphakinetic Limited
Fund Management Software
NA
NA
4/20/17
Brelion, LLC
Peer Realty, LLC
Crowdfunding
NA
NA
4/18/17
Investment Grade Technologies LLC
TradeWarrior Inc.
Broker Software
NA
NA
4/18/17
Investoo Group
100ForexBrokers.com
FX Lead Gen
NA
NA
4/7/17
StatPro Group plc
UBS Delta AG
Risk / Analytics
$14
0.8x
Trading Platform
NA
NA
Shareholder Servicing
$350
NA
4/3/17
Cowen Group, Inc. (nka:Cowen Inc.)
3/27/17
DST Systems, Inc.
ConvergEx Group, LLC (nka:Cowen Execution Services LLC) International Financial Data Services Ltd.
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
Fund Administration
NA
NA
Exchange Traded Products
NA
NA
Risk Management
NA
NA
32
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
3/22/17
Trumid Financial LLC
Electronifie Inc.
Trading Platform
NA
NA
3/21/17
Sterling Trading Tech
CBOE Livevol, LLC, Livevol X
Trading Platform
NA
NA
3/20/17
FactSet Research Systems Inc.
BI-SAM Technologies S.A.
Risk / Analytics
NA
NA
3/17/17
BinckBank N.V.
Pritle N.V.
Robo Advisors
NA
NA
3/16/17
Horizon21; H21 Macro Ltd.
Leonteq AG
Investment Platform
NA
NA
3/15/17
Virtu Financial, Inc.
KCG Holdings, Inc.
Trading Services
$1,268
0.9x
3/9/17
Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc.
Message Automation Limited
Trade Processing
NA
NA
3/8/17
Numerix LLC
TFG Financial Systems
Risk
NA
NA
3/7/17
Hellman & Friedman LLC; GIC Pte. Ltd.
Allfunds Bank S.A.
Mutual Fund Platform
NA
NA
3/3/17
European Energy Exchange AG
Nodal Exchange, LLC
Exchanges
NA
NA
3/1/17
Payward, Inc.
Cryptowatch
Analytics
NA
NA
2/21/17
Covisum, LLC
PrairieSmarts, LLC
Risk Platform
NA
NA
2/15/17
Moody's Corporation
Data / Analytics
NA
NA
2/15/17
AdvisorEngine, Inc.
SCDM Germany GmbH, Structured Finance Data and Analytics Business Wealthminder, Inc.
Wealth Management Software
NA
NA
2/6/17
Thomson Reuters Corporation
Avox Limited
Compliance Data
NA
NA
2/6/17
Thomson Reuters Corporation
Clarient Global LLC
Regulatory Data
NA
NA
2/1/17
BT Group plc
IP Trade SA
Trading Technology
NA
NA
2/1/17
StoneCastle Insured Cash Sweep, LLC
Intermedium Financial LLC
Broker Software
NA
NA
Regulatory Tech
NA
NA
Fund Management Software
NA
NA
1/30/17
Compliance Solutions Strategies
1/27/17
Linedata Services S.A.
Advise Technologies, Ascendant Compliance Management, The Gravitas Technology Services, LLC
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
33
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
Think Liquidity LLC
Risk / Analytics
NA
NA
Visible Alpha, LLC
ONEaccess
Data / Analytics
NA
NA
FairFX Group Plc
Q Money Limited
Online Brokerage
$2
NA
Access Investors Network, Inc.
Investing Platform
NA
NA
Spark Finance, LLC
Data / Analytics
NA
NA
Acquirer
Target
1/25/17
IS Prime Risk Services Inc.
1/23/17 1/19/17
1/18/17
North Capital Investment Technology Inc. StockTwits, Inc.
1/9/17
InvestCloud, LLC
Babel Systems Limited
Trade Processing
NA
NA
1/4/17
Dash Financial LLC
LiquidPoint, LLC
Trading Platform
NA
NA
Capital Markets Software
NA
NA
Quant House SAS
Trading Platform
NA
NA
Broker Software
$67
NA
Fund Administration
$89
NA
Online Broker
NA
NA
Fund Administration
NA
NA
Fund Administration
NA
NA
Crowdfunding
NA
NA
Trading Platform
NA
NA
Fund Administration
NA
NA
1/18/17
1/4/17 1/4/17
NewSpring Capital; NewSpring Holdings L.P. Company owned by Pierre Feligioni
Vertical Management Systems, Inc.
12/20/16
FactSet Research Systems Inc.
Vermilion Software Inc.
12/15/16
SS&C Technologies Holdings, Inc.
Conifer Financial Services LLC
12/9/16
comdirect bank Aktiengesellschaft
OnVista AG
12/1/16
Benefit Plans Administrative Services, Inc. Ascensus, Inc.
Northeast Retirement Services, LLC (nka:Cohiba Merger Sub, LLC) National Retirement Services, Inc.
11/30/16
Capital Foundry LLC, Investment Arm
EquityNet, LLC
12/5/16
11/28/16
Virtu Financial, Inc.
11/28/16
MainstreamBPO Limited
Teza Technologies, Select Strategic Telecommunications Assets Galileo Fund Services Limited
11/28/16
Insurance Services Office, Inc.
IntelliStance, LLC
Data / Analytics
NA
NA
11/21/16
London Stock Exchange Group plc
Mergent, Inc.
Data / Analytics
$144
NA
11/21/16
AcadiaSoft, Inc.
ProtoColl
Collateral Management
NA
NA
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
34
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
11/14/16
Playtech plc
CFH Group A/S
Foreign Exchange
NA
NA
11/8/16
Preqin Ltd.
Baxon Solutions Limited
Broker Software
NA
NA
11/2/16
Folio Dynamics Inc.
SAS Capital Management, LLC
Broker Software
NA
NA
10/24/16
TD Ameritrade Holding Corporation
Scottrade Financial Services, Inc.
Online Brokerage
NA
NA
10/24/16
SS&C Technologies Holdings, Inc.
Salentica Inc.
Broker Software
NA
NA
10/20/16
Forum Trading Solutions Ltd
GMEX Technologies Limited
Trading Technology
NA
NA
10/14/16
Morningstar, Inc.
PitchBook Data, Inc.
Data / Analytics
$225
7.2x
10/13/16
Investview, Inc.
RoboVest, Inc.
Trading Platform
NA
NA
10/11/16
Drillinginfo, Inc.
GlobalView Software, Inc.
Trading Platform
NA
NA
10/10/16
Yodlee, Inc.
Wheelhouse Analytics, LLC
Data / Analytics
NA
NA
10/6/16
Ion Investment Group Limited
Reval Holdings, Inc.
Treasury Software
NA
NA
9/28/16
SourceHOV LLC
TransCentra, Inc.
Treasury Software
NA
NA
9/26/16
CBOE Holdings, Inc.
BATS Global Markets, Inc.
Exchanges
$3,680
1.9x
9/22/16
Thomson Reuters Corporation
REDI Holdings, LLC
Data / Analytics
NA
NA
9/21/16
LexisNexis Legal & Professional Inc.
Intelligize, Inc.
Trading Platform
NA
NA
9/14/16
IRESS Limited
INET BFA Pty Ltd.
Data / Analytics
$10
NA
9/14/16
SS&C Technologies Holdings, Inc.
Wells Fargo Global Fund Services LLC
Fund Administration
NA
NA
9/13/16
TD Securities Inc.
Albert Fried & Company, LLC
Trading Platform
NA
NA
9/7/16
McKinsey & Company, Inc.
PriceMetrix, Inc.
Broker Software
NA
NA
8/25/16
BGC Partners, Inc.
Perimeter Markets Inc.
Trading Platform
NA
NA
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
35
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
8/24/16
Yintech Investment Holdings Limited
Gold Master (HK) Company Limited
Trading Platform
NA
NA
8/11/16
Aegon UK plc
Cofunds Holdings Limited
Personal Financial Management
NA
NA
8/11/16
KCG Hotspot FX LLC
Javelin SEF, LLC
Ratings Agency
NA
NA
7/25/16
E-Trade Financial
OptionsHouse, LLC
Trading Platform
NA
NA
7/18/16
Moody's Singapore Pte. Ltd.
Korea Investors Service, Inc.
Ratings Agency
NA
NA
7/7/16
Legg Mason, Inc.
Financial Guard LLC
Robo Advisors
NA
NA
Advisor Software
NA
NA
Risk & Analytics
NA
NA
6/30/16 6/20/16
Teachers Insurance & Annuity Association of America, Endowment Markit Ltd.
MYVEST CORP Prism Valuation Inc.
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
36
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months ($MM) Announced Date 6/13/17
Target Futu Securities
Series
Amount
Series C
$146
Investors Matrix Partners China, Sequoia Capital China, Tencent Holdings
6/9/17
Singapore Diamond Investment Excg.
Series B
$10
6/8/17
Addepar
Series D
$140
Alain Vandenborre, Richard Ji, Simon Murray, Vertex Venture Holdings 8VC, Harald McPike, Valor Equity Partners
6/7/17
MoneySmart
Series B
$10
Golden Gate Ventures;Kakaku.com;SPH Media Fund
Target Subsector Online Brokerage Exchanges Broker Software Lead Gen
6/6/17
Cadre
Series C
$65
5/25/17
Prumentum Grouop
Series A
$25
Andreessen Horowitz, Breyer Capital, Ford Foundation, General Catalyst, Goldman Sachs, Khosla Ventures Fremont Group, The Cynosure Group
5/16/17
Symphony Communication Services
Series C
$63
BNP Paribas, Goldman Sachs, Google
5/11/17
Wealthsimple
NA
$37
Power Financial Corp.
5/4/17
Fumi Technology
Series A
$15
Hongdao Fund, Mobai Capital, Shunwei Capital
4/26/17
Quovo
NA
$10
F-Prime Capital, Napier Park Global
4/13/17
55 Capital
Series A
$10
Calibrate Management, Point72Ventures, Tectonic Ventures
Advisor Software
3/31/17
The Naga Group AG
Series A
$13
Fosun
Trading Platform
Investment Platform Robo-Advisor Messaging Robo-Advisor Trading Platform API Manager
NA
$13
OpenFin
Series B
$15
2/7/17
Folio
Series A
$16
Mizuho Capital, Mobile Internet Capital, Softbank, Mizuho Securities Bain Capital Ventures, DRW Venture Capital, J.P. Morgan, Nyca Partners, Pivot Investment Partners JAFCO, Monex Ventures, Rakuten Fintech Fund
1/31/17
Wealthsimple
NA
$15
Power Financial Corp.
Robo-Advisor
12/24/16
Pakistan Stock Exchange
NA
$84
Chinese Consortium
Exchanges
12/23/16
Nutmeg Savings and Investment Ltd.
NA
$15
Taipei Fubon Commercial Bank
12/22/16
Axoni
Series A
$18
12/15/16
Personal Capital Corp.
NA
$25
2/19/17
One Tap Buy
2/16/17
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Andreessen Horowitz, Digital Currency Group, Euclid Opportunities, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan Chase & Co. Thomson Silicon Valley Bank
Trading Platform Trading Platform Asset Management Platform
Robo-Advisor Distributed Ledger Robo-Advisor
37
SECURITIES / CAPITAL MARKETS / DATA & ANALYTICS Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont.) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
12/14/16
Stash
Series B
$25
11/17/16
Peer Street Inc.
Series A
$15
11/17/16
T-REX Group Inc.
Series B
$10
Investors Breyer Capital, Entrée Capital, Goodwater Capital, Valar Ventures Andreessen Horowitz, Felicis Ventures, The Kaiser Family Foundation, Montage Ventures, Rembrandt Venture Partners The Ecosystem Integrity Fund, Safeguard Scientifics Inc.
Target Subsector Robo-Advisor Crowdfunding Risk / Analytics
11/1/16
Droit Financial Technologies
Series A
$16
Andreessen Horowitz, Bessemer Venture Partners, Khosla Ventures, Point72 Asset Management, Spark Capital Amanda Investment Group, Balderton Capital Management, Pentech Ventures, Schroders Bain Capital Ventures, Khosla Ventures, Lightspeed Venture Partners, Nyca Partners, QED Investors, SV Angel DRW, Goldman Sachs, Pivot Investment Partners, Wells Fargo
10/31/16
Riskalyze Inc.
Series A
$20
FTV Management Group LP
10/26/16
AX Trading Group
NA
$20
Undisclosed
Trading Platform
10/17/16
InnoTREE Network Tech Co.
Series B
$15
Baoli (Hengqin) Capital Management
Data / Analytics
11/14/16
Quantopian
11/14/16
Nutmeg Saving and Investment Ltd.
11/14/16
Roofstock Inc.
Series C
$25
NA
$32
Series B
$20
Trading Technology Robo-Advisor Crowdfunding Trading / Regulatory Software Broker Software
10/12/16
Cloud9 Technologies
NA
$30
9/30/16
OpenGamma
NA
$13
JPMorgan Chase & Co., ICAP, Barclays, Point72 Ventures, Hudson Ridge Asset Management Accel Partners, ICAP Plc
9/21/16
OurCrowd Ltd.
Series C
$72
Undisclosed Investors
Crowdfunding
9/14/16
InvestCloud
NA
$25
Undisclosed Investors
Broker Software
9/12/16
Quandl
Series B
$12
August Capital, Nexus Venture Partners
Data / Analytics
8/18/16
Lancai
Series B
$27
Letv.com
8/17/16
Crowdcube
NA
$11
Balderton Capital
7/22/16
Fantex
NA
$59
Undisclosed
Trading Platform
7/13/16
OpenDoor Trading
NA
$10
J F Hartfield & Company
Trading Platform
7/6/16
National Stock Exchange of India
NA
$135
Veracity Insurance Solutions
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Trading Technology Risk / Analytics
Investing Platform Crowdfunding
Exchanges
38
SECTION IV: Insurance / Benefits
39
INSURANCE / BENEFITS Public Company Valuations: Financial Metrics $MM, Except Per Share Data Stock Price 6/16/17 Healthcare / Insurance Technology Quintiles IMS Holdings, Inc. Verisk Analytics, Inc. athenahealth, Inc. Guidewire Software, Inc. Ebix, Inc. Sapiens International Corporation N.V. Crawford & Company Polaris Consulting & Services Limited Majesco Symbility Solutions Inc.
$87.13 83.14 145.36 67.24 55.00 11.37 9.00 3.71 4.80 0.35
LTM Price Range Low High
Equity Value
Net Debt
$61.21 75.60 90.11 49.18 44.80 11.12 7.56 2.19 4.50 0.25
$19,116 13,746 5,790 5,001 1,734 558 506 379 175 83
$7,452 2,129 186 (477) 186 5 175 (82) 1 (6)
$88.43 87.40 146.75 70.30 65.10 15.98 14.37 3.79 6.29 0.42
Enterprise Value $26,568 15,875 5,976 4,524 1,920 562 681 297 176 77 Mean Median
EV / Revenue CY 17E CY 18E
EV / EBITDA CY 17E CY 18E
Price / EPS CY 17E CY 18E
EPS Long Term Growth
PEG
Revenue Growth 17E/16A Y/Y MRQ
3.3x 7.6x 4.9x 8.3x 5.5x 2.1x 0.6x NA 1.4x 2.5x
3.1x 7.2x 4.3x 7.0x 4.8x 1.9x 0.6x NA 1.2x 2.2
13.1x 15.4x 22.8x 39.9x 16.3x 19.6 5.0x NA 17.9 48.5
12.1x 14.3x 18.8x 27.8x 14.4x 12.4x 4.5x NA 11.3x 38.0
19.2x 26.2x 78.1x 78.8x 18.7x 31.6x 12.2x NA 53.3x NM
16.7x 23.7x 60.6x 57.3x 17.1x 18.4x 10.3x NA 22.9x NA
14.2% 10.4% 25.1% 18.3% 15.0% 10.0% 10.0% NM NM NM
1.4 2.5 3.1 4.3 1.2 3.2 1.2 NA NM NM
49.6% 4.4% 12.9% 21.4% 17.0% NA 1.7% NA NA 20.4%
72.5% 2.0% 11.4% 24.9% 11.3% 14.1% (3.6%) 13.6% (12.8%) 14.8%
4.0x 3.3x
3.6x 3.1x
22.1x 17.9x
17.1x 14.3x
39.8x 28.9x
28.4x 20.6x
14.7% 14.2%
2.4 2.5
18.2% 17.0%
14.8% 12.5%
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples based on CapitalIQ Consensus Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
40
INSURANCE / BENEFITS Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months ($MM) Announced Date
Acquirer
Target
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
5/17/17
Advanced Solutions International, Inc.
Innovative Software Solutions, Inc.
Benefits Software
NA
NA
5/3/17
Genpact Limited
BrightClaim, Inc.
Claims Management
NA
NA
4/27/17
Disruptive Capital Finance LLP
REG UK Ltd.
Insurance Risk Management
$10
NA
4/25/17
Vertafore, Inc.
RiskMatch, LLC
Insurance Analytics
NA
NA
4/6/17
Open GI Limited
Transactor Global Solutions Limited
Insurance Software
$50
NA
3/13/17
The Travelers Companies, Inc.
Simply Business
Insurance Tech
$490
NA
2/28/17
Advent International Corporation
CCC Information Services Inc.
Claims Management
NA
NA
Healthcare Payments
NA
NA
Insurance Tech
$102
1.3x
Revenue Cycle Management
NA
NA
Benefits Platform
$4,800
2.1x
Insurance Tech
NA
NA
Lead Gen
NA
NA
2/21/17
CareCredit, LLC
2/15/17
Sapiens International Corporation N.V.
Citibank, N.A., Citi Health Card Portfolio StoneRiver, Inc.
2/14/17
Riverside Partners LLC
2/10/17
The Blackstone Group L.P.
2/9/17
Charles Taylor InsureTech Limited
Medical Reimbursements of America, Inc. Aon plc, Benefits Administration and HR Business Process Outsourcing Otak Limited
2/8/17
Compare Africa Group
TopCheck UG (haftungsbeschränkt)
2/7/17
Centauri Health Solutions, Inc.
Human Arc Corporation
Revenue Cycle Management
NA
NA
1/26/17
Insurity, Inc.
Valen Technologies, Inc.
Insurance Data / Analytics
NA
NA
Benefits Software
NA
NA
Telematics
$49
NA
Insurance Data / Analytics
NA
NA
1/25/17 1/19/17 1/4/17
PlanSource Benefits Administration, Inc. Inflexion Private Equity Partners LLP; Inflexion Enterprise Fund IV Duck Creek Technologies, Inc.
Next Generation Enrollment, Inc. My Policy Limited Yodil, Inc.
12/23/16
Ebix, Inc.
Wdev Soluções em Tecnologia S.A.
Insurance Tech
NA
NA
12/19/16
Guidewire Software, Inc.
ISCS, Inc.
Insurance Tech
$160
NA
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
41
INSURANCE / BENEFITS Selected Recent Acquisitions – Trailing 12 Months (Cont’d) ($MM) Announced Date
Target Subsector
Enterprise Value
EV / LTM Revenue
HR/Benefits Software
NA
NA
Claims Admin. Software
NA
NA
Insurance Exchange
NA
NA
Insurance
$1,430
NA
Revenue Cycle Management
NA
NA
HAS and COBRA Administration
$235
NA
Analytics
NA
NA
Convey Health Solutions, Inc.
Healthcare Insurance Administration
NA
NA
ACR Capital Holdings Pte. Ltd.
Reinsurance
NA
NA
Insurance Trading
NA
NA
Insurance Software
NA
NA
Insurance Data
NA
NA
Acquirer
Target
12/15/16
Mercer LLC
Thomsons Online Benefits Limited
12/8/16
Insurity, Inc.
Systema Software, LLC
11/30/16
Vimo, Inc.
Array Health Solutions Inc.
11/28/16
Allstate Non-Insurance Holdings, Inc.
SquareTrade, Inc.
11/17/16
nThrive, Inc.
Adreima, Inc.
11/1/16
WageWorks, Inc.
ADP's HAS & COBRA Businesses
10/24/16
AIR Worldwide Corporation
Analyze Re Inc.
9/29/16
New Mountain Capital, LLC; New Mountain Partners IV, L.P.; Eir Partners Shenzhen Investment Holdings Co., Ltd.; Shenzhen Qianhai Financial Applied Systems, Inc.
9/28/16
RGI S.P.A.
IS2, eTrading Platform for Personal Lines Kapia Solutions Sas
9/26/16
Callcredit Information Group Limited
Recipero Limited
9/26/16
IRESS Limited
Financial Synergy Pty. Limited
Insurance Software
$67
3.2x
8/9/16
Applied Systems, Inc.
Relay Software Limited
Insurance Software
NA
NA
8/4/16
Guidewire Software, Inc.
FirstBest Systems, Inc.
Risk Assessment
$34
NA
8/4/16
Benefit Express Services, LLC
Transcend Technologies Group, Inc.
HR Software
NA
NA
7/21/16
GoHealth, LLC
1SourceAdmin LLC
HR Software
NA
NA
6/29/16
Global Healthcare Exchange, LLC
H-Card, LLC
Healthcare Payments
NA
NA
10/6/16 10/5/16
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Wall Street Research Estimates. Multiples 100 considered NM.
42
INSURANCE / BENEFITS Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months ($MM) Announced Date 6/13/17
Target Snapsheet
Series
Amount
Series D
$12
6/1/17
Bright Health
Series B
$160
5/24/17
PolicyGenius
Series C
$30
5/12/17
Vet+a
NA
$27
5/10/17
Clover Health
5/2/17
One Inc.
4/27/17
Singapore Life
4/25/17
Hibob
4/20/17
Lemonade Inc.
Series D
$130
NA
$16
Series A
$50
Series A
$18
NA
NA
Investors Tola Capital Bessemer Venture Partners, Cross Creek Advisors, Flare Capital Partners, Greenspring Associates, Greycroft AXA Strategic Ventures, Fika Ventures, Karlin Ventures, MassMutual Ventures, Norwest Ventures Kartesia Advisor First Round Capital, Google Ventures, Greenoaks Capital Management, Palm Drive Capital, Sequoia Capital American Family Ventures, AXA Strategic Ventures, Centana Growth Partners, MassMutual Ventures Impact Capital Holdings, IPGL Arbor Ventures, Battery Ventures, Bessemer Venture Partners, Eight Roads Ventures Allianz
Series A
$25
BIMA
NA
$17
Munich Re/HSB Ventures, Ribbit Capital, TLV Partners;, Zeev Ventures Axiata Digital
Trov
NA
$45
Munich Re HSB Ventures
4/10/17
Next Insurance
4/10/17 4/6/17
Series C
$25
Decisely
NA
$60
3/25/17
Ottonova
NA
$16
Highland Capital Management, Accel, Aspect Ventures, CRV, Northwestern Mutual Future Ventures, Pilot Wall Group Two Sigma Private Investments, EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants B-to-V Partners, STS Ventures, Tengelmann Ventures
3/21/17
Jellyvision
Series B
$20
Updata Partners
4/4/17
Amino
3/30/17
3/17/17
simplesurance
NA
$21
2/22/17
EverQuote, Inc.
Series B
$13
Allianz SE, Rakuten FinTech Fund, Rheingau Founders, Route 66 Ventures Link Ventures, Second Alpha
2/7/17
CXA Group
Series B
$25
B Capital Group, EDBI
$50
Altimeter Capital, Four Rivers Group, Greenspring Associates, Matrix Partners, Scale Venture Partners, Sequoia Capital
1/5/17
Namely Inc.
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Series D
Target Subsector Insurance Tech Insurance Innovator Insurance Lead Gen Insurance Software Insurance Admin Insurance Software Insurance Software HR Software Insurance Insurance Tech Insurance Tech Insurance Tech Benefits Software Benefits Software Insurance Tech HR Software Insurance Tech Insurance Marketplace Benefits Software HR / Benefits Software
43
INSURANCE / BENEFITS Selected Recent Equity Financings – Trailing 12 Months (Cont’d) ($MM) Announced Date
Target
Series
Amount
12/5/16
Lemonade Inc.
Series B
$34
11/15/16
CareCloud
Series C
$32
11/3/16
EasyPolicy
NA
$10
Investors Aleph, General Catalyst, Google Ventures, Sequoia Capital, Thrive Capital, Tusk Ventures, XL Innovate Adams Street Partners, Blue Cloud Ventures, First Data, Intel Capital, Norwest Venture Partners, PNC Financial Services Group, Burman Family Office, Unilazer Ventures
10/20/16
EverQuote, Inc.
Series B
$23
10/19/16
Ladder Financial Inc.
Series A
$14
10/4/16
Hixme Inc.
Series B
$14
9/28/16
Sedgwick
NA
$500
BrownSavano Direct Capital Partners, Oceanic Partners, Stratim Capital LLC, T Capital Management LLC 8VC, Canaan Partners, Lightspeed Venture Partners, Nyca Partners LLC Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, Propel Venture Partners, Rosemark Capital Group, Transamerica Ventures Fund Caisse de Depot et Placement du Quebec
9/26/16
InstaMed Communications, LLC
NA
$50
Carrick Capital Partners LLC
9/21/16
FinanceFox
Series A
$28
Horizons Ventures, Target Ventures
Notes: Source: CapitalIQ and Pitchbook.
Target Subsector Insurance Revenue Cycle Management Insurance Lead Gen Insurance Lead Gen Life Insurance HR Software Claims Management Healthcare Payments Insurance Tech
44