Bonn Econ Discussion Papers

Bonn Econ Discussion Papers

Discussion Paper 11/2001

Achieving the First Best in Sequencing Problems by

Manipushpak Mitra

November 2000

Bonn Graduate School of Economics Department of Economics University of Bonn Adenauerallee 24 - 42 D-53113 Bonn

The Bonn Graduate School of Economics is sponsored by the

OW,VWB AO, 6W+5A ,5A W 5,"N,WB +w,5 @?TtT@! |h@ +iti_ L? Li4Mih 2fff `h|tU@u|t|iLhi Wc N?iht|@| L??c _i?@ih@**ii 2e2Sc #D L??c Bih4@?) 5A+A W? @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | *?i@h |4i ULt|c 5t EbbS ThLi_ |@| | t TLttM*i |L @Uii ht| Mit| ) ht| Mit| i 4i@? |@| L?i U@? ?_ 4iU@?t4t |@| t@|tu) iUi?U) Lu _iUtL?c _L4?@?| t|h@|i}) ?Ui?|i UL4T@|M*|) @?_ M_}i| M@*@?Ui_?itt W? |t T@Tih i tL |@| @4L?} @ 4Lhi }i?ih@* @?_ ?@|h@* U*@tt Lu tiî?U?} ThLM*i4tc tiî?U?} ThLM*i4t | *?i@h ULt| t |i L?*) U*@tt uLh U ht| Mit| U@? Mi @Uii_

Wkh

dxwkru lv judwhixo wr Ekdvndu Gxwwd/ Hulf Pdvnlq/ Jhruj Q roghnh dqg Duxqdyd Vhq/ iru wkhlu lqydoxdeoh dgylfh1 Wkh dxwkru lv wkdqnixo wr rqh dqrq|prxv uhihuhh/ zkrvh frpphqwv dqg wkrxjkwixo vxjjhvwlrqv juhdwo| lpsuryhg wkh h{srvlwlrq ri wklv sdshu1 Wkh dxwkru lv dovr wkdqnixo wr Dqlqg|d Ekdwwdfkdu|d/ Ghedvklvk Jrvzdpl/ Mr|gls Plwud dqg Vxndqwd Sdwl/ iru wkhlu khosixo frpphqwv1 Wkh dxwkru judwhixoo| dfnqrzohgjhv wkh qdqfldo vxssruw iurp wkh Lqgldq Vwdwlvwlfdo Lqvwlwxwh dqg iurp wkh Jhupdq Uhvhdufk Irxqgdwlrq +GIJ,1 Wklv sdshu lv d vxevwdqwldoo| uhylvhg yhuvlrq ri d fkdswhu ri wkh dxwkru*v Sk1G1 wkhvlv1

W?|hL_U|L?

W? @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 |ihi t @ *@h}i 4*|?| h4 | i@U ?| ? ?ii_ Lu |i u@U*|) ThL_i_ M) @ T@h|U*@h hiT@h @?_ 4@?|i?@?Ui ?| Ai hiT@h @?_ 4@?|i?@?Ui ?| U@? tihUi L?*) L?i ?| @| @?) }i? |4i AihiuLhic ?|t U hi4@? ?@||i?_i_c ?Uh @ ULt| uLh |i |4i |i) @hi _L? W? |t uh@4iLh!c |i h4 m> o, @ !1 S

Wu @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 lc | ULt| u?U|L? 8 c t@|tit |i ?_iTi? _i?Ui ThLTih|) |i? |i hi*@|i îi TLt|L?t Lu @?) |L ?|t @?_ ,c | }i? w c r @?_ w, c r, c t ?_iTi?_i?| Lu |i Thiuihi?Uit Lu @** L|ih ?|t W? T@h|U*@hc u w c r @?_ w, c r, @hi tU |@| ww, : }Er c r, c |i? uLh @** tihU ?} |4i iU|Lht @?_ t|@|it | }i? Er c r, @?_ Ew c w, c iUi?| îi jW ** 4T*) |@| 7 Ej W 7, EjW c |@| tc jW j,W W? |i ?i | T@h@}h@Tc i ThL_i tL4i i @4T*it Lu tiî?U?} ThLM*i4t |@| t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) @?_ L?i i @4T*i Lu @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 |@| u@*t |L t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) L?t_ih @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l, ' kc 8 , c EX( +nn lc uLh U |i ULt| u?U|L? t *?i@h AihiuLhic uLh |i tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l, c 8 , E% ' @ %n@f c rc r c r, ' rr, ' } , Er c r, c uLh @** % 5 +nn @?_ @ : f Mtihi |@| uLh l, c s , E uLh @** r f @?_ uLh @** r : r, : f AihiuLhic l, t@|tit ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLT ih|) 5t EbbS UL?iU|hi_ |@| |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) Lu @ *?i@h ULt| tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l, T*@)t @ UhU@* hL*i ? |t ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*|) L?t_ih |i tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 le ' kc 8 e c EX( +nn lc ihi |i |4i ULt| u?U|L? t i TL?i?|@*c |@| tc 8 e E% ' @ e% n @f c uLh @** % 5 +nn r nr, r @?_ @ : f W? |t ThLM*i4c s e E r( r c r, ' eer nr, 33eer, ' } e Er c r, c uLh @** r f @?_ uLh @** r : r, : f AihiuLhic le @*tL t@|tit |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) W? }i?ih@*c @** tiî?U?} ThLM*i4t lW c | ULt| u?U|L? Lu |i uLh4 8 W E% ' @ S% n @f c ihi @ : f @?_ S : c t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui r nr, r r( r c r, ' SSr nr, 33SSr, ' } W Er c r, c uLh @** r f @?_ uLh @** ThLTih|) t?Ui s W E r : r, : f Atc |i ti| Lu tiî?U?} ThLM*i4tc t@|tu)?} ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|)c ?U*_it ?L?*?i@h |4i ULt| u?U|L?t L?t_ih @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l^7 ' kc 8 ^7c EX( +nn lc ihi 8 ^7E% ' %2 c uLh @** % 5 +nn W? |t r 3 r, ThLM*i4c }i? r : r, : fc |i h@|L s E r( r c r, ' rr, i r n2 r nr, j t ?L| ?_iTi?_i?| Lu r AihiuLhic l^7 u@*t |L t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) AO,+, tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l ' kc 8c EX( +nn lc | 8 5 6c t ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*i u @?_ L?*) u |i ULt| t *?i@h @?_ |ihi @hi @| *i@t| |hii ?|t

.

Ai u T@h| Lu |i AiLhi4 t _i |L 5t EbbS @?_ i?Ui i L4| |t ThLLu ì ?L t|@|i |hii wi44@t @?_ ThLi |L Lu |i4 Aiti wi44@t @hi ?iUitt@h) uLh ThL?} |i L?*) u T@h| Lu AiLhi4 6Lh |iti wi44@tc tL4i 4Lhi ?L|@|L?t @?_ _i?|L?t @hi ?|hL_Ui_ L?t_ih |L ThL*it w ' Ew c c w? @?_ w ' Ew c c w? ì _i?ic uLh 7 c @ |)Ti w E7 ' w u 95 7 @?_ w E7 ' w u 5 7 AihiuLhic uLh i@U 7 c @ t|@|i wE7 t Lu |i uLh4 Ew E7c c w? E7 w, tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 lc | 8 5 6c t ht| Mit| 4T*i S 4i?|@M*i L?*) uc uLh @** T@ht Lu ThL*it iwc w jc 7 \ E7 EwE7 ' f At wi44@ t _i |L `@*!ih EbHf Bi? |i uLh4 Lu |i BhLit |h@?tuih E2c M@*@?Ui_?itt hi^hit |@| |i 4?44 @}}hi}@|i ULt| t E? S |)Ti tiT@h@M*ic |@| tc E? Ew ' M Ew3 Atc | uL**Lt |@| S uLh @** T@ht w ' Ew c c w? @?_ w ' Ew c c w? c 7 \ E7 EwE7 ' S S 7 M 7 \ E Ew3 E7 ' f wi44@ ** i*T ThLi |i ?i | E?3 |L wi44@t w, 2 tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 lc | 8 5 6c t ht| Mit| 4T*i 4i?|@M*i L?*) uc uLh @** r7 5 +nn c ? [

E&3

&'

#

$

? 8 E&7 r ' f &

E 2

AL ThLi wi44@ 2c i ht| UL?t_ih @ t|@|L? ihi |i tihU?} |4i Lu @** ?__@*t @hi _i?|U@* ì |i? UL?t|hU| |L t|@|it |L _ihi UL?_|L? E 2 iuLhi }?} |i ThLLu Lu wi44@ 2c i ThL_i @ }i?ih@* Uh|ihL? uLh U@*U*@|?} @? iUi?| îi i? tihU?} ULt|t @hi _i?|U@* uLh @** ?|t L?t_ih @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l ' k ' ic 2c jc 8c EX( +nn l | |hii ?|t wi| |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh Mi r ' Er ' r7c r2 ' r7c r ' r7 Bi? |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh rc U@*U*@|?} |i iUi?| îi ? i@U t|@|i H

w ' Ew c w2 c w 5 X t ^|i i@t) 6Lh i @4T*ic u @ t|@|i w ' Ew c w2 c w 5 X rn7rn7r38 E rn7r t tU |@| w : w2 : w c |i? ww 2 : 88 E r( r7c r7 ' @?_ ww2 : E rn7rn7r38 E rn7r ' s E s E r( r7c r7 ' c uLh ML| r ' r7 @?_ r ' f AihiuLhic |i iUi?| îi ? t|@|i w ' Ew c w2 c w c | }i? tihU?} ULt| iU|Lh r ' Er ' r7c r2 ' r7c r ' r7c t j W Ew ' EjW Ew ' c j2W Ew ' 2c j W Ew ' W? }i?ih@*c u ?|t @i _i?|U@* tihU?} ULt|t @?_ ?L?_i?|U@* |)Titc |i? iUi?| îic ? @?) t|@|i wc U@? Mi LM|@?i_ uhL4 |i @tUi?_?} Lh_ih Lu ?| |)Tit ? |@| t|@|i A@| tc ? t|@|i wc u |i |)Tit Lu ?|t @?_ , @hi tU |@| w : w, c |i? jW Ew j,W Ew At t |i }i?ih@* Uh|ihL?c | _i?|U@* tihU?} ULt| @?_ ?L?_i?|U@* |)Titc uLh ?_?} @? iUi?| îi ? @?) tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l ' kc 8c EX( +nn l | 8 5 6 +6 6 w, 2G AL ThLi |i wi44@c i ht| UL?t|hU| |L ThL*it @?_ |i? @TT*) wi44@ L?t_ih @ tihU?} |4i iU|Lh ihi |i tihU?} |4i Lu i@U ?| t |i t@4ic |@| tc UL?t_ih r ' Er ' r7c c r? ' r7 wi| w ' Ew c c w? @?_ w ' Ew c c w? Mi @?) |L ThL*it t@|tu)?} |i uL**L?} UL?_|L?G w : w2 : : w? : w : w2 : : w? 6Lh @** 7 c i UL?t_ih ThL*it wE7 ' Ew E7c c w E7c c w? E7c ihi w E7 ' w u 95 7 @?_ w E7 ' w u 5 7 5?Ui |i tih U?} ULt|t @hi |@!i? |L Mi _i?|U@* uLh @** 5 @?_ ?| |)Tit @hi ?L?_i?|U@*c i ti |i }i?ih@* Uh|ihL? |L _ihi |i iUi?U) îi ? i@U t|@|i Mtihi |@|c uLh @** 7 ijc | ThL*it Ew c w3 E7c S n Atc 7 \*t E7 E7 EjW Ew c w3 E7( w ' jW Ew c w3 E7 ' m7m S?3 7 ?3 rw LhiLihc uLh @** 7 tU |@| ? 5 7c 7 'f E 7 8 EEm7m n 7 |@| tc uLh ThL*it Ew? c w3? E7c j?W Ew? c w3? E7 ' m7m @?_ i?Uic | uL**Lt S S ? 3 |@|c 7 \ E7 E7? EjW Ew? c w3? E7( w? ' ?7 ' E7 7 8 Em7m7 rw? u |i ti|t 6?@**)c uLh @** L|ih |)Tit % 5 iw2 c c w? c w c c w? 3 j Ac i6 c c 6R jc @** tMti|t Lu ijc @hi tU |@| jW E% c w3 E6^ ' &c uLh 6Lw lv txlwh hdv| wr revhuyh wkdw li xqlwv kdyh lghqwlfdo w|shv wkhq rqh fdq hdvlo| lpsrvh d wlh euhdnlqj uxoh wr fdofxodwh wkh hflhqw txhxh1 Lw lv lpsruwdqw wr qrwh wkdw qglqj wkh hflhqw txhxh lv txlwh glfxow li wkh vhuylflqj frvw lv glhuhqw iru glhuhqw xqlwv dqg li wkh frvw ixqfwlrq grhv qrw vdwlvi| wkh lqghshqghqfh surshuw|1

b

S

S

@** ^ 5 ic c Rjc |i? R^' E6^ 8 E&7 r ' f MiU@ti R^' E6^ ' f S 7 W Atc uLh @** % 5 Ac 7 \*t E E7 Ej E% c w3 E7( % ' f Aihi S L4M??} uLhic |i t4 7 \ E7 EwE7 t ?_iTi?_i?| Lu @** % 5 A @** |iti LMtih@|L?t i }i| [

7

E EwE7 ' iw w? j

7 \

? [

&3

E

&'

#

$

? 8 E&7 r &

E

TT*)?} wi44@ @?_ t?} w 9' w? ? UL?_|L? E i }i| UL?_|L? E 2 L?_|L? E 2 ? wi44@ 2 t @ UL4M?@|Lh@* UL?_|L? L? |i |4i ULt| u?U|L? 8 Ai 4i@??} Lu |t UL?_|L? ** MiUL4i i T*U| uhL4 |i uL**L?} _tUttL? #i?i {E8 E% @t {E8 E% ' 8 E%n8 E% Atc {E8 E% 4i@thit |i ?Uhi@ti ? |4i ULt| @t L?i 4Lit uhL4 |4i % |L |4i %n Nt?} |t _i?|L? LMtihi |@| {E%8 E% ' 8 E2%8 E% 54 *@h*)c {2 E%8 E% t }i? M) {2 E%8 E% ' {E%d{E%8 E%o ' {E%d8 E2% 8 E%o ' 8 E % 28 E2% n 8 E% ì U@? t4*@h*) _ihi { E%8 E%c {e E%8 E% @?_ tL L? W| t ?L ^|i i@t) |L ihu) |@| UL?_|L? E 2 S? & 3 ?3 ?3 E%8 E% ' f Atc 8 U@? Mi hih||i? @t &' E &3 8 E&% ' { t@|tit wi44@ 2 u |i E? | Lh_ih _gihi?Ui t 3ihL +,+k 2 Ai 4Lt| LMLt 4T*U@|L? Lu wi44@ 2 t |@| uLh @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | |L ?|tc UL?_|L? E 2 L*_t L?*) uc uLh @** % : fc 8 E% 8 E2% ' fc |@| tc 8 E% ' S OLiihc 8 E% ' S uLh @** % : fc t @ L*@|L? Lu Lh @tt4T|L? |@| 8 t t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} ? +nn AihiuLhic |ihi _Lit ?L| i t| @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l ' k ' ic 2jc 8c EX( +nn lc | t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} 8 c |@| t@|tit UL?_|L? E 2 ? wi44@ 2 Atc @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | |L ?|t t ?L| ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*i +,+k ?L|ih 4T*U@|L? Lu wi44@ 2 t |@| uLh @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l ' k ' ic 2c jc 8c EX( +nn lc 8 E5 6 4t| Mi *?i@h 6Lh @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | |hii ?|tc wi44@ 2 4T*it |@|c uLh @** % 5 +nn c 8 E% n 8 E % ' 28 E2% 6hL4 |t UL?_|L? | t LMLt |@|c u f

8 5 6c |i? 8 ' 8 , c ihi 8 , E% ' @ % n @f uLh @** % 5 +nn AihiuLhic wi44@ 2 ThLit |@| u |ihi @hi |hii ?|t |i? @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 t ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*i L?*) u |i ULt| u?U|L? t *?i@h wi44@ 2 t ?L| i?L} |L ThLi |i L?*) u T@h| Lu AiLhi4 uLh @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | 4Lhi |@? |hii ?|t 6Lh i @4T*ic UL?t_ih l^ ' k ' ic 2c c ejc 8 ^ c EX( +nn lc tU |@| |i |4i ULt| u?U|L? 8 ^ 5 6 t ^@_h@|U Atc |i u?U|L? 8 ^ t tU |@|c uLh @** % 5 +nn c 8 ^ E% ' @f n @ % n @2 %2 @?_ 8 ^ E% n : 8 ^ E%c uLh @** : f W| t LMLt |@| uLh @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | uLh ?|tc 8 ^ 5 6 t@|tit UL?_|L? E 2 Lu wi44@ 2e AL ThLi |i L?*) u T@h| Lu AiLhi4 uLh tiî?U ?} ThLM*i4t | 4Lhi |@? uLh ?|tc i ?ii_ @?L|ih hit*| U t t44@h3i_ ? |i ?i | wi44@ w, tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l ' kc 8c EX( +nn l | @| *i@t| uLh ?|t t ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*i L?*) u | t@|tit |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) ì ThLi |t wi44@ M) UL?|h@_U|L? ì ht| @tt4i |@| |i t|@|i 4i?| ? wi44@ t u@*ti ì |i? UL?t_ih @** TLttM*i @)t ? U @ ULt| u?U|L? 4@) u@* |L t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) 6Lh i@U tU TLtt M*|) i UL?t|hU| @ T@h Lu ThL*it |@| u@*t |L t@|tu) wi44@ iuLhi ThL_?} |i ThLLu Lu wi44@ c i ?|hL_Ui tL4i 4Lhi hi*i@?| _i? |L?t @?_ LMtih@|L?t L?t_ih |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh r ' Er c c r? ì _i?i |i t4 Lu tihU?} |4it Lu @** ?|t R 5 ic ,j @t E, ' S rR 6Lh ?|t @?_ ,c | tihU?} |4i r @?_ r, hitTiU|i*)c *i| R'tc,

7Lq jhqhudo iru d vhtxhqflqj sureohp p @ kQ> I p> +> U..,l kdylqj sro|qrpldo wlph

frvw ixqfwlrqv ri rughu p +wkdw lv I p +{, @

p S

@3

l

dl {l , zkhuh p q 5 vdwlvhv frqglwlrq

+615,1 Wkxv li zh kdyh d vhtxhqflqj sureohp zlwk wkuhh xqlwv/ wkhq sro|qrpldo ri rughu p @ 4/ wkdw lv/ I @ I o vdwlvhv frqglwlrq +615,1 Li zh kdyh d vhtxhqflqj sureohp zlwk irxu xqlwv/ wkhq sro|qrpldov ri rughu p @ i4> 5j/ wkdw lv/ I @ I o dqg I @ I t vdwlvhv frqglwlrq +615, dqg vr rq1

6 , 5 dfc E,o Mi @ ?4Mih tU |@| s E6 , ( r c r, s E+( r c r, c uLh @** + 5 dfc E,o L|i |@| 6 , @*@)t i t|t t?Ui s E+( r c r, t UL?|?Lt @?_ i @hi UL?t_ih?} @** + ? |i U*Lti_ @?_ ML?_i_ ?|ih@* dfc E,o ì _i?i MEr sE6 , ( r c r, uLh @** 5 @?_ uLh @** , 5 ij Aihi uLhic MEr t @| *i@t| @t *@h}i @t |i }it| @*i |@| |i h@|L u?U|L? s c ULhhitTL?_?} |L 8 c U@? |@!i }i? |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh r 54*@h*)c *i| 6 7 , 5 dfc E,o Mi @ ?4Mih tU |@| s E6 7 , ( r c r, s E+( r c r, uLh @** + 5 dfc E,o @?_ i _i?i uEr s E6 7 , ( r c r, uLh @** 5 @?_ uLh @** , 5 ij uEr t @| 4Lt| @t t4@** @t |i *Lit| @*i |@| |i h@|L u?U |L? s U@? |@!i }i? |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh r Nt?} |i ?4Miht MEr @?_ uErc i 4@!i |i uL**L?} LMtih@|L?t @ML| |i iUi?| Lh_ih?} Mtih@|L? doG Bi? |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh r ' Er c c r? c u uLh @?) |L ?|t @?_ ,c ww, : MErc |i? uhL4 |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu MEr i !?L |@| MEr s E r( r c r, c uLh @** r 5 dfc E,o AihiuLhic ww, : s E r( r c r, c w w uLh @** r 5 dfc E,o t?Ui w, : MEr Atc }i? rc u w, : MErc |i? jW Ew c w, c w3 3, j,W Ew c w, c w3 3, c uLh @** w3 3, 5 X?32 Mtih@|L? d2oG Bi? |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh r ' Er c c r? c u uLh @?) |L ?|t @?_ ,c ww, uErc |i? uhL4 |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu uEr i !?L w r( r c r, c |@| uEr s E r( r c r, c uLh @** r 5 dfc E,o AihiuLhic w, s E w w uLh @** r 5 dfc E,o t?Ui w, uEr Atc }i? rc u w, uEr |i? jW Ew c w, c w3 3, : j,W Ew c w, c w3 3, c uLh @** w3 3, 5 X?32 Aiti |L LMtih@|L?t ** Mi ti_ ? ThL?} wi44@ +6 6 w, G L?t_ih @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 lc | @| *i@t| uLh ?|tc |@| u@*t |L t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) AL ThLi |i wi44@c i tL |@| uLh tU @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 lc |ihi i t|t @ tihU?} |4i iU|Lh r @?_ |ihi i t| ThL*itc uLh U |i UL?_|L? ? wi44@ t L*@|i_ 5?Ui lc _Lit ?L| t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|)c |ihi i t| r : r2 : f @?_ @? @TThLTh@|i ti*iU|L? Lu ?|ih@* dfc oc tU |@|c |i h@|L u?U|L? s E+( r c r2 t 4L?L|L?U @?_ ?L?UL?t|@?| ? +c i? iih + 5 dfc o Bi? |@| 8 t UL?|?Lt @?_ t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} @?_ |i 2

_i?L4?@|Lh Lu s E+( r c r2 t ?L?3ihLc uLh @** +c | uL**Lt |@| sE+( r c r2 t UL?|?Ltc 4L?L|L?U @?_ ?L?UL?t|@?| ? + 5 dfc o AihiuLhic L? + 5 dfc oc s E+( r c r2 t@|tit @| *i@t| L?i Lu |i uL**L?} uLh UL?_|L?tG Aihi i t|t 5 Efc c tU |@| s E+( r c r2 t UL?t|@?| ? +c u + 5 dfc @?_ t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} ? +c i?iih + 5 dc o 2 sE+( r c r2 t t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} ? + 5 dfc o 7 5 Efc c tU |@| s E+( r c r2 t UL?t|@?| ? +c u + 5 Aihi i t|t 7 @?_ t|hU|*) _iUhi@t?} ? +c i?iih + 5 dc 7 o dfc e sE+( r c r2 t t|hU|*) _iUhi@t?} ? + 5 dfc o ì UL?t_ih i@U Lu |iti UL?_|L?t ? _gihi?| t|iTt 5A, doG W? |t t|iT i UL?t_ih UL?_|L? 5?Ui |i tiî?U?} ThLM *i4 ?_ih UL?t_ih@|L? t |i L?i |@| u@*t |L t@|tu) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|)c i UL?t|hU| ThL*it ? tU @ @) |@| |i hi*@|i îi TLt|L? Lu |L T@h|U*@h ?|tc | }i? |)Titc U@?}i @t |i |)Ti Lu L|ih ?|t U@?}i At |)Ti Lu UL?t|hU|L? *i@_t |L @ L*@|L? Lu wi44@ wi| r @?_ r2 c ? UL?_|L? c hiThiti?| |i tihU?} |4i Lu ?|t @?_ 2 hitTiU|i*) wi| |i tihU?} |4i Lu ?| Mi r ' @?_ |i tihU?} |4i Lu @** L|ih ?|t 5 ic 2c j Mi r ' ?3 r7 Atc |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh t }i? M) r ' Er c r2 c r c r7c c r7 L|i |@| |i tihU?} |4i iU|Lh t UL?t|hU|i_ ? tU @ @) |@| E? 7 r n r ' 6hL4 UL?_|L? @?_ uhL4 |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu r | uL**Lt |@| s E&7 r( r c r2 s E&7 r n r ( r c r2 @?_ s E&7 r( r c r2 s E( r c r2 uLh @** & 5 ifc c ? j @?_ s E&7 rnr ( r c r2 s E( r c r2 uLh @** & 5 ifc c ?ej wi| ( ' E6@%ds EE? r nr ( r c r2 oc s E( r c r2 L|i |@| |i ?|ih@* @*@)t 7 r( r c r2 c s EE? e7 i t|t t?Ui 6@%iE? 7 rc E? e7 r n r j 4T*it |@| 6@%ds EE? 7 r( r c r2 c s EE? e7 r n r ( r c r2 o s E( r c r2 L?t_ih |L ?4Miht %@ E @?_ %K Ec tU |@|c %@ E 5 (c %K E 5 ( @?_ %@ E %K E Mtihi |@| t?Ui r : r2 c %o E : c uLh @** o 5 i@c Kj Nt?} |i ?4Miht %@ E @?_

%K Ec i _i?i %E2 ' 2 %@ EuE r @?_ %E ' %K E n %K EME r L?t_ih o o o o o |L ThL*it w ' Ew ' %o Ec w2 ' c w ' %E c c w? ' %E @?_ w ' Ew ' c w2 ' %E2c c w? ' %E2 ihi o 5 i@c Kj #i?ic uLh 7 c @ |)Ti wo E7 ' wo u 95 7 @?_ wo E7 ' w u 5 7 AihiuLhic uLh 7 c @ t|@|i wo E7 t Lu |i uLh4 Ewo E7c c w?o E7 L i UL?t_ih |i |ih4t UL?|@??} S wo E' %o E ? |i t4 7 \ E7 Ewo E7 6hL4 |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu %E2 | uL**Lt |@| %%oE2 r AihiuLhic uhL4 Mtih@|L? d2o | t LMLt E uE o E7 |@|c uLh @** 7 ijc tU |@| 5 ij @?_ 5 7c jW Ewo c w3 o E7 54*@h*)c uhL4 |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu %E i }i| %E : ME jW Ewo c w3 r %o E AihiuLhic uhL4 Mtih@|L? do | t LMLt |@|c uLh @** 7 ijc tU o E7 : j W Ewo c w o E7 L UL?t_ih |@| 5 ic 2j @?_ 95 7c jW Ewo c w3 3 @** TLttM*i 7 ijc tU |@| 2 95 7 ì t|@h| | 7 ' c |@| tc wo E7 ' wo L|i |@| t?Ui %E ' %o E n %o EME r @?_ %o E : c wo r( r c r2 c %E : ME r AihiuLhic uLh @** 5 ic 2jc wo ' %E : s E 2 uLh @** r 5 dfc E2o At j2W Ew o : jW Ewo c uLh @** 5 ic 2j }@?c wo uhL4 |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu %o Ec | uL**Lt |@| wo ' %o E s E( r c r2 2 AihiuLhic }i? j2W Ewo : jW Ewo @?_ jW Ew o : jW Ewo c uLh @** 5 ic 2j @?_ %o E s E( r c r2 c i LM|@? |@| jW Ewo ' ? : j2W Ewo ' ? 6hL4 wo |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu %o Ec i @*tL !?L |@|c wo ' %o E : 6@%ds EE? 2 7 r( r c r2 c s EE? e7 r n r ( r c r2 o AihiuLhic u 7 ijc 7 9' @?_ 2 95 7c |i? jW Ewo E7 j2W Ewo E7 L4M??} @** |iti LMtih@|L?t @?_ S o E7( wo c i }i| uLh @** t4T*u)?} |i t4 7 \3t E7 E7 EjW Ewo c w3 o 5 i@c Kjc [

7 \

E7 Ewo E7 ' %o Ed8 Er n r2 n 8 Er n o n ~

E e

ihi ~ t |i t4 Lu |ih4t |@| @hi ?_iTi?_i?| Lu %o Ec ? |i t4 S 7 o 7 \ E Ew E7 6hL4 wi44@ i !?L |@| uLh ht| Mit| 4 S T*i4i?|@M*|) Lu lc | t ?iUitt@h) |@| 7 \ E7 Ewo E7 ' fc uLh @** o 5 i@c Kj AihiuLhic | t LMLt |@| uLh ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*|) | t ?iUitt@h) |@| [

E7 Ew@ E7

7 \

[

E7 EwK E7 ' f

7 \

e

E D

54T*u)?} UL?_|L? E D t?} E ec i }i| i%@ E %K Ejd8 Er n r2 n 8 Er n o ' f

E S

L?_|L? E S U@??L| L*_ t?Ui uhL4 |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu %o E @?_ uhL4 Lh @tt4T|L? |@| 8 t t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} ? +nn c | uL**Lt |@| |i *iu| @?_ t_i Lu UL?_|L? E S t t|hU|*) ?i}@|i AihiuLhic u UL?_|L? L*_t |i?c }i? rc |ihi i t| ThL*it uLh U wi44@ t ?L| t@|ti_ Mtihi |@| i? ?| E& C

[

&

4

w>E D

3

; A ?[

@ [ E Cw>E^ A ? 2 ^'& = o:^

o '&

Eo AD >

E .

uLh @** & 5 ic 2c c ?j W| t ^|i t4T*i ihu) |@| |iti |h@?tuiht @__ T S |L 3ihLc |@| tc ?&' |>E& Ew ' f W? |i _tUttL? |@| uL**Ltc i ThL_i @ _i|@*i_ @?@*)tt Lu ?Ui?|i UL4T@|M*|) Lu |i |h@?tuih tUi4i E . uLh @ *?i@h ULt| tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | |hii ?|t L?t_ih @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 l, ' k ' ic 2c jc 8 , c EX( +nn l W? |t w w>E2 w>E ThLM*i4c uLh i@U t|@|i w 5 X c | r>>E r r>E c i }i| t?} |i E >E2 i^@|L? E .c |>E Ew ' @ w>E2 r>E c |>E2 Ew ' @ w>E Er>E2 r>E @?_ |>E Ew ' @ Ew>E n w>E2 r>E @ w>E r>E2 ì ?L ihu) |@| |t |h@?tuih tUi4i t ?Ui?|i UL4T@|M*i L?t_ih @ tihU?} iU|Lh r ' Er ' c r2 ' 2c r ' @?_ *i| |i |)Ti iU|Lh Mi w ' Ew ' c w2 ' 2c w ' Mtihi |@|c }i? r @?_ wc ' 2 ' 22 ' ' ' S AihiuLhic j W Ew ' EjW Ew ' c j2W Ew ' 2c j W Ew ' @?_ |i |h@?tuiht @hi | Ew ' |>E Ew ' @ Ew n w2 r @ w r2 ' b@ c |2 Ew ' |>E2 Ew ' @ w Er2 r ' S @ @?_ | Ew ' |>E Ew ' @ w2 r ' S@ Mtihi |@| ' | Ew ' S &' |>E& Ew ' f Bi? r @?_ |hi |)Ti iU|Lh wc i UL?t_ih @** TLttM*i _i@|L?t M) ?| uhL4 |t |hi |)Ti w @?_ @h}i |@| |i Mi?i|t |L ?| c uhL4 @** |iti _i@|L?tc @hi ?L?TLt|i #i?i Ew7 c w ( w2 c w c |L Mi |i Mi?i| _ihi_ M) ?| M) _i@|?} uhL4 |t |hi |)Ti w |L w7 c }i? |@| |i L|ih |L ?|t @i @??L?Ui_ Ew2 c w AihiuLhic Ew7 c w ( w2 c w ' L EjW Ew7 c w2 c w c | Ew7 c w2 c w ( w L EjW Ewc | Ew( w L?t_ihc @ _i@|L? M) ?| uhL4 w |L @?) |)Ti w L|i |@|c ?_ih |t _i@|L?c w ' 2 ' ' AihiuLhic j W Ew c w2 c w ' EjW Ew c w2 c w ' c j2W Ew c w2 c w ' 2c j W Ew c w2 c w ' ' j W Ew @?_ i?Ui | Ew c w2 c w ' | Ew Atc Ew c w ( w2 c w ' f L?t_ihc |i _i@|L? M) ?| uhL4 w |L @?) |)Ti wk 5 d c b L|i |@|c ?_ih |t _i@|L?c 2 ' ' 9Uhfdoo wkdw xm @ m / iru doo m 5 Q1

vm

2f

wk

' AihiuLhic jW Ewk c w2 c w ' EjW Ewk c w2 c w ' 2c j2W Ewk c w2 c w ' c j W Ewk c w2 c w ' 9' jW Ew @?_ i?Ui | Ewk c w2 c w ' @ w Er r2 ' @ 9' | Ew ' b@ Atc Ewk c w ( w2 c w ' @ w r2 n | Ewk c w2 c w | Ew ' 2@ n @ b@ ' e@ f 6?@**)c UL?t_ih |i _i@|L? wq b L|i |@|c wq ?_ih |t _i@|L?c 2 ' ' ' AihiuLhic jW Ewq c w2 c w ' EjW Ewq c w2 c w ' c j2W Ewq c w2 c w ' c j W Ewq c w2 c w ' 2 9' jW Ew @?_ i?Ui | Ewq c w2 c w ' @ w r2 ' S@ 9' | Ew ' b@ Atc Ewq c w ( w2 c w ' @ w Er2 nr n| Ewq c w2 c w | Ew ' @ S@ b@ ' 2@ f AihiuLhic uLh ?| | |)Ti w c Ew7 c w ( w2 c w fc uLh @** w7 9' w ) @TT*)?} t4*@h @h}4i?|t i U@? UiU! |@| ?i|ih ?| 2 ?Lh ?| U@? Mi?i| M) _i@|?} uhL4 |ih |hi |)Tit AihiuLhic |i |h@?tuih tUi4i t ML| M_}i| M@*@?U?} @?_ ?Ui?|i UL4T@|M*i

e

L?U*tL?

ì U@? 4@!i @ UL4T@h@|i t|_) Lu @ *?i@h ULt| tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 | |@| Lu |i U*@ttU ?Ui?|i ThLM*i4 Lu ?L?i U*_@M*i TM*U }LL_t ihic *!i |i tiî?U?} ThLM*i4c |i ti| Lu _iUtL?t t ?|i W? |i TM*U }LL_t ThLM*i4 |i _iUtL? t i|ih Lh ?L| |L ThL_Ui |i TM*U }LL_ Ai TM*U }LL_t ThLM*i4 t ?L| ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*i MiU@ti |i M_}i| M@*@?Ui_?itt UL?_|L? U@??L| Mi t@|ti_ ? @** t|@|it Lu |i Lh*_ Ai hi@tL? uLh M_}i| 4M@*@?Ui t |i i |ih?@*|) |@| @? ?__@* U@? 4TLti L? |i hi4@??} ti| Lu ?__@*t Oihic @? ?__@*c M) U@?}?} t @??L?Ui4i?| U@? U@?}i |i _iUtL? Lu @** L|ih ?__@*t Etii Bhii? @?_ w@gL?| Eb.b `*i uLh |i *?i@h ULt| tiî?U?} ThLM*i4c |i i |ih?@*|) |@| U@? Mi 4TLti_ M) @ ?| L? |i hi4@??} ti| Lu ?|t t 4Lhi tM|*i< @?_ t U@T|hi_ M) |i ?_iTi?_i?Ui ThLTih|) Wu @ ?| t @**L||i_ @ TLt|L? & ? |i îi ? tL4i t|@|ic |i? M) U@?}?} |t ULt| T@h@4i|ih |i ?| U@? i|ih U@?}i |i ULt| Lu |i ?|t tihUi_ MiuLhi | E|@| t |t Thi_iUittLh ti| Lh |i ULt| Lu |i ?|t tihUi_ @u|ih | E|@| t |t tUUittLh ti| Ai ?| U@??L| t4*|@?iLt*) @giU| ML| |i Thi_iUittLh @?_ |i 2

tUUittLh ti|t At tLh| Lu i |ih?@*|)c U t Uih|@?*) *itt tiihi |@? |i i |ih?@*|) ? TM*U }LL_t ThLM*i4c t L?i Lu |i UhU@* hi^hi4i?| uLh ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*|) Lu tiî?U?} ThLM*i4t Ai @?@*)tt Thiti?|i_ ? |t T@Tih @Uiit tL4i|?} 4Lhi W? |t T@Tih i @i ThLi_ |@| |i |)Ti Lu i |ih?@*|) |@| t Thiti?| ? |i *?i@h ULt| tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 t @*tL Thiti?| ? @ tiî?U?} ThLM*i4 ihi |i ULt| u?U|L? t i TL?i?|@* W? @__|L? |L |t |)Ti Lu i |ih?@*|) i ?ii_ @ ?Ui UL4M?@|Lh@* t|hU |hi Lu |i ULt| u?U|L? At @__|L?@* ?ii_ 4@!it *?i@h ULt| tiî?U?} ThLM*i4t |i ?î U*@tt Lu ht| Mit| 4T*i4i?|@M*i tiî?U?} ThLM*i4t

22

+,6,+,,5 *@h!ic , O Eb. R*|T@h| hU?} Lu M*U BLL_tc M*U LUi c . hi*c Wc i_ih3L*c Bc @?_ Atc 5 EbHb R5iî?U?} B@4itc ,hLTi@? aLh?@* Lu Tih@|L?@* +iti@hU efc ee D #L*@?c + Eb.H RW?Ui?|i iU@?t4t uLh hLh|) "ii?} hLM*i4tc Ai i** aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Ut bc e2e S Bhii?c ac @?_ w@gL?|c a a Eb.. R@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu 5@|tu@U|Lh) iU @?t4t uLh |i +ii*@|L? Lu hiuihi?Uit uLh M*U BLL_tc ,UL?L4i|hU@ eDc e2.e H Bhii?c ac @?_ w@gL?|c a a Eb.b W?Ui?|it ? M*U #iUtL? @!?} Lh| OL**@?_ M*U@|L?c 4t|ih_@4 BhLitc Ac Eb. RW?Ui?|it ? Ai@4tc ,UL?L4i|hU@ ec S.S BhLitc Ac @?_ wi_)@h_c a Eb.. R5L4i w4|@|L?t Lu #i4@?_ +i i@*?} hLUittitc M*U LUi 2bc f.2e OL*4t|hL4c Eb.b RBhLit< 5Ui4it L? +it|hU|i_ #L4@?tc ,UL?L 4i|hU@ e.c .ee OhU3c w Eb.D R? |i , t|i?Ui Lu **LU@|L? 5)t|i4t `Lti @?T *@|i @t ,^*Mh@ @hi @hi|L T|4@*c 44iL N?iht|) Lu ??itL|@ OhU3c w c @?_ `@*!ihc Ebbf R? |i Bi?ihU L?LT|4@*|) Lu #L4?@?| 5|h@|i}) **LU@|L? iU@?t4tG Bi?ih@* AiLhi4 |@| ? U*_it hi , U@?}i ,UL?L4itc ,UL?L4i|hU@ DHc SH .fe 5tc a EbbS R? W?Ui?|i L4T@|M*|) @?_ _}i| @*@?Ui_?itt ? M*U #iUtL? @!?}c ,UL?L4U #it}? 2c b 2fb `@*!ihc EbHf R? |i L?, t|i?Ui Lu #L4?@?| 5|h@|i}) iU@ ?t4t uLh @!?} T|4@* M*U #iUtL?tc ,UL?L4i|hU@ eHc D2Def 2