Clusters Within Clusters: SVD and Counterterrorism DB Skillicorn skill ...

1 downloads 0 Views 2MB Size Report
Mar 13, 2003 - W ithout information about the particular data mining algorithm in use, the best .... W e quote from Krebs [12, p4 9] , relying on previous work on the social ...... Susan T. Dumais, Thomas K. Landauer, G eorge W . F urnas, and.
      !"#$%&'( )(  *%+ , /- .10.324576867579;:= @ 457676BAC9 @ .EDF(GHG;> @ F.I9HJ KMLONQPSRMTOUVUXW Y[Z=\]^NQ_LV`3a ]bPQR_*cdP^LV`3e+]^f(gVNh\ ihjj=k'lmUXnVWVo;lmUXTVTXpql TOUVUXW;lsrtoVW u]^f*LONh\hvw]b_x\'gVyz"gXvwf{\hcd_|wLV_}~i_y7gVNQv€LO\hcgX_‚jP^c]b_Pƒ] „ {]^]b_†…ˆ‡'‰Š_cd‹V]^NQ‡hc\Œ Žcd_|X‡h\gX_†‘’_x\hLONQcgz“LV_LV}*LwŽpH”WOk’o ug=P^{vw]b_x\+fNh]^f*LONQ]b}~KMLONQPSR–•bW)(TOUVUXW z“gVfxŒ)NQc|XRx\ P— TOUVUXW€u˜ˆ™˜(j=š)cd`›`dcdPƒgVNQ_ žœ  Ÿb q¡;¢*£V  ¤¦¥¨§O©dª«;¥ž¬?­H§;¬¯®=°H¥²±I³¯´X®t©d¬§t°;¬§;µ^´X¥^¶ƒ¬¯®H·¬¥O©s©8®X©¸± µ^³º¹t¥ƒ¬¥^¶ƒ¬S± ®=°»± µ¬?­;¥~§x¼X±1½ˆ± ¬B¾¨¬®¿¹t¥ƒ¬¥^¶ƒ¬µ^³§x½E½ Àsµh¶b§t½ ¥OÁ&½ ®)¶b§x½ ¶^®X©m©›¥O½ §;¬S± ®=°qµ‚§;ªt§t±I°;µ¬Â§Ã¼H§H¶Oăª©›®=«t°H¹Ã®H·Â½ §O©dªX¥?Àsµh¶b§x½ ¥OÁʱ ÆÇ«qµh¥¿¶^®X©s©8¥O½ §;¬Q± ®=°qµbÈÊÉ ±I°;ª«t½ §V©ŠËV§x½E«;¥¿¹x¥^¶^®=³¯´X®Oµƒ± ¬S± ®=° Ì É)͊Î"Ï"³§x´qµÐËO§O©s± §;¬Q± ®=°tÁ§x°;¹Â­;¥O°;¶^¥¶^®X©m©›¥O½ §;¬S± ®=°tÁ ±1°q¬®€´O©›®ƒÑ)±I³¯± ¬B¾€±1°½ ®^ÒÐÀm¹±I³¥O°qµƒ± ®=°O§x½Vµ^´H§H¶^¥ƒµbȤ¿¥'µ^­;®bҊÁ(«qµƒ±1°qª §O©d¬S± Ó¶H±Ô§t½x¹x§;¬§;µh¥ƒ¬µ“ÒŠ­H®Oµh¥w´t½ §t«;µƒ±I¼t±I½ˆ± ¬B¾Ò¥§O©›ª«;¥’·¸®X©sÁ¬S­O§;¬"É)͊ÎÕ± µ+¥?Ɔ¥^¶ƒ¬Q± ËH¥¯§;¬“¹t¥ƒ¬¥^¶ƒ¬Q±1°qª‚½ ®x¶b§x½)¶^®X©s©›¥O½ §;¬Q± ®=°Ö±1° ¬?­X± µ&µh¥ƒ¬¬S±I°qªÈ

a+R]ž×*|X{Nh]b‡Ccd_\hRcd‡f*LOf(]^NwP^LV_ÙØ ]/{_}]^NQ‡\g)g)}Ùcd_ÚØ*`dLVPQšÚLV_}ÙÛ'R*c\]ÂØ{\LONQ]¨}]b‡hc|X_]b}\g¦Ø(]/‡]^]b_Ücd_ PƒgX`gX{Nq˜

ÝMÞß&àOátâ*ãxà‚äåmáxæ&åçèÝMÞß&àOátâãtà*é~êëÜì íç&îïÝMðß&çátâ*ãXátâ*ãXãxð ãxåàXñ u˜ˆ™˜(j=š)cd`›`dcdPƒgVNQ_ ‡š=cd`d`8òÅP^‡^˜ˆóx{]^]b_‡h{†˜ˆP^L œžŸ^ q¡H¢£V Xô¦¤¦¥¦§O©dª«H¥M¬?­H§;¬€®=°H¥–±1³¯´X®t©d¬§x°;¬Ö§qµ^´X¥^¶ƒ¬Â®H·¯¬¥O©m©›®X©¸± µ^³õ¹t¥ƒ¬¥^¶ƒ¬S± ®=°Ü± µÂ¬?­;¥¿§x¼X±I½E± ¬B¾¦¬®Ú¹x¥ƒ¬¥^¶ƒ¬ µ^³§x½I½ Àsµh¶b§x½ ¥OÁö½ ®)¶b§t½ ¶^®X©s©8¥O½ §;¬Q± ®=°qµC§qªt§t±1°qµ¬Å§‚¼O§H¶OÄ?ª©8®=«t°;¹¦®H·Å½ §O©dªX¥?Àsµh¶b§x½ ¥OÁǹ± Æ«;µh¥€¶^®X©s©8¥O½ §;¬Q± ®=°qµbÈ/É ±I°;ª«t½ §O©[ËO§x½I«;¥ ¹t¥^¶^®=³´X®Oµƒ± ¬S± ®=° Ì É)ÍÎöϳ§x´;µ+ËO§V©¸± §;¬S± ®=°tÁ(§x°;¹²­;¥O°H¶^¥¶^®t©s©›¥O½ §;¬S± ®=°xÁ ±1°q¬®¨´O©›®^Ñx±I³¯± ¬B¾~±1°ž½ ®^ÒöÀm¹±I³¥O°qµƒ± ®=°H§x½µ^´H§H¶^¥ƒµbÈ ¤¦¥Öµ^­H®^ҊÁ'«qµƒ±I°;ª²§O©›¬Q± Ó¶H±Ô§x½(¹)§;¬§;µh¥ƒ¬µÒŠ­H®Oµh¥‚´x½ §x«qµƒ±1¼X±1½ˆ± ¬B¾žÒ¥~§O©dª«;¥Ö·¸®X©sÁ¬?­H§;¬¯É)ÍÎ÷± µ¥?Æ(¥^¶ƒ¬S± ËO¥~§q¬¹x¥ƒ¬¥^¶ƒ¬S±I°;ª ½ ®)¶b§x½x¶^®t©s©›¥O½ §;¬S± ®=°Â±I°¬S­t± µ&µh¥ƒ¬¬Q±1°qªÈ ø ùú’û ü†ýþ€ÿ ûhýŠú u]^\]bPƒ\hcd_|ž\]^NhNhgVNQc›‡hvèP^LV_‚Ø(]Åf(gX‡]b}¨LV‡LV_‚{*_‡h{f(]^Nh‹=cd‡]b}ž}LO\hLÖvÖcd_cd_|fNhgVØ`]bv cd_~ۊRcdPQR/\hR]¯|VgXLV` c›‡&\g ‡]^f*LONSLO\]cd_*}c‹=cd}{LV`d‡“cd_x\gÖ\Ûög/P^`dLV‡h‡h]b‡^\hRNh]bLO\h‡’LV_}‚_gX_ls\hRNh]bLO\h‡^˜ 'g;Ûö]^‹V]^Nb3cd\'cd‡'{*_x{‡Q{LV`3Ø(]bP^LV{‡]\hR] vw]bvØ(]^NQ‡gVyÐgX_]wP^`dLV‡h‡ 7\hR]C\hRNQ]bLO\h ‡ LONh]wLVPƒ\hc‹V]b`ŒM\NhŒ)c›_|Â\g~`g)gVšMLV‡Å‡Qcdv€cd`dLONŠ\g~vw]bv¯Ø(]^NQ‡gVyö\hR]CgV\hR]^N P^`dLV‡h‡“LV‡"f(gX‡h‡hcØ`]V ˜ c\hRgX{\“cd_y7gVNQv€LO\hcdgX_ÂLOØ(gX{\ö\hR]ŠfLONh\hcdP^{`dLON“}LO\hLv€cd_c›_|¯LV`|VgVNQcd\hRv c›_Â{‡h]Vx\hR]Ø(]b‡\ ‡\NQLO\]^|VŒ~y7gVN'}gXc›_|C\hRcd‡+cd‡“\gÂLONhNQLV_|V]y7gVN+\hR]bcdN'LO\\NQcØ*{\]ŋHLV`d{]b‡“\g€Ø(]vwg)}*LV`¸˜ a+R*cd‡R*LV‡C\mÛ"g»cdvwf*`dc›P^LO\hcgX_‡y8gVNw}LO\hL¦v€c›_cd_|²cd_–\]^NQNhgVNQcd‡hv }]^\]bPƒ\hcdgX_ ô LO\\NScØ*{\]b‡w‡hRgX{`d}ÚØ ]/‡h{PSR \hRLO\+c\&cd‡&R*LONQ}/\g€v€LV_cf{`dLO\]\hR]bcN&‹OLV`d{]b ‡ LV_}/\hR]}*LO\hLwv€cd_cd_|LV`|VgVNSc\hRv€‡“{‡]b}~‡QRgX{`d}ÂNh]b`ŒÂgX_~\hR] !" Ø(]^\mÛ"]^]b_ÖLO\\NQcØ{\]b‡^tNSLO\hR]^N\hRLV_‡hcdvwf*`dŒ\hR]bcN‹OLV`d{]b‡b˜ iy LO\\NScØ*{\]b‡öLONh]'PQRgX‡]b_ÖLOff*NhgVfNQc l LO\]b`ŒV)\hR]b_€\hR]ŠLVPƒ\hc‹=c\hc]b‡ÐgVy \]^NQNhgVNQcd‡\h‡öLV_}€\]^NQNhgVNQcd‡\[|VNQgX{f*‡ÐvÖLbŒwØ(]+‹=cd‡hcØ*`d]“LV‡ö{_]ƒZ=f(]bPƒ\]b}ÖPƒgVNhNh]b`›LO\hcgX_† Ø(gV\hR€LVvwgX_|\hR]bv€‡]b`d‹V]b‡ÐLV_}wØ(]^\Ûö]^]b_Ö\hR]'\]^NhNQgVNQcd‡\h‡LV_*}w\hR]bcN\hLONQ|V]^\^#˜ 'g;Ûö]^‹V]^Nq)\hR*cd‡[PƒgVNhNh]b`dLO\hcdgX_Öv{‡\ Ø(]}]^\]bPƒ\]b}‚LO|XLVc›_‡\'LwØLVPhš)|VNhgX{_}~gVyÛ'cd}]b‡fNh]bLV}~}c $({‡h]’PƒgVNQNh]b`dLO\hcgX_¨c›_/\hR]Åf(gVf*{`dLO\hcgX_~LO\Š`dLONh|V]V˜ j=c›_|X{`dLONö‹HLV`d{]Š}]bPƒgXvwf(gX‡hcd\hcgX_Âc›‡öL{‡]^yB{`\g)gX` y8gVN&}]^\]bPƒ\hc›_|w{_x{*‡h{LV`*PƒgVNQNh]b`dLO\hcgX_ÂØ(]bP^LV{‡]’c\ö\NSLV_‡l y7gVNQv€‡"‹HLONScdLO\hcgX_žcd_t\gCfNQgbZcdv€c\ŒV˜Ç™"gV\hR~}c›‡\hLV_Pƒ]’vw]bLV‡h{Nh]b‡&LV_*}֋=cd‡h{LV` cd_‡hf ]bPƒ\hcdgX_ÖP^LV_~}]^\]bPƒ\&fNQgbZcdv€c\Œ yBLON'vwgVNh]]bLV‡Qcd`ŒÖ\hR*LV_~\hR]^Œ~P^LV_‚}]^\]bPƒ\ŠPƒgVNhNh]b`dLO\hcgX_‚}cNh]bPƒ\h`ŒV˜

¦]fNh]b‡]b_x\fNh]b`dcdvÖcd_LONhŒ€NQ]b‡h{`\h‡Š{‡hcd_|ÂLONh\hc ×P^cdLV` }LO\hLV‡]^\h‡^˜’a+R]^Nh]cd‡'`dcd\\h`]]ƒZ=f ]^NSc]b_Pƒ]¯\gž|X{cd}]\hR] y7gVNQvègVyLJh{PQR‚}LO\hLV‡]^\h‡^Ø*{\&Û"]¯LONh|X{]\hR*LO\&\hR]gX_]b‡'Ûö]{‡h]LONh]¯LO\'`]bLV‡h\+f*`dLV{‡QcØ*`]V˜ e']b‡h{`\h‡LONh]Ö]b_PƒgX{NQLO|Xcd_|Çcd_¦\hR]‡]b_‡]Â\hRLO\C&j %’uèRLV‡Rc|XR»}]^\]bPƒ\hcgX_ÚLVP^P^{NQLVPƒŒ¦Û'c\hR–Nh]bLV‡gX_LOØ*`dŒ `g;Û÷y7LV`d‡h]f(gX‡hc\hcd‹V]NQLO\]b‡b'˜ ¦]€LONh]w{_*LOØ*`]V†‡g/y7LONq†\g¨‡f(]bP^cy8ŒMLV_¦cd}]bLV`LV`|VgVNQc\hRv ‡hPSR]bv€L/y7gVNLOff*`Œ=cd_| &j %’uØ*{\“Û"]¯‡hRg;Û \hRLO\'‡]^‹V]^NSLV` ‡\NQLO\]^|Xcd]b‡'LONh]] $(]bPƒ\hc‹V]V˜ ( )Ê+ý *-,./*+úC0 þ *1.2. ÿ 3546û hýú . i\‡]^]bv€‡cdv€f*`dLV{‡hcdØ*`]V*|Xcd‹V]b_¿gX{NfNh]b‡h]b_t\Å}LO\hL¨vÖcd_cd_|Â\]bPQR_gX`gV|Xc]b‡¯LV_*}¦{_}]^NQ‡h\hLV_}cd_|ÂgVyö\hR]wfNhgVØl `]bv€‡gVyÐPƒgX{*_t\]^Nh\]^NQNhgVNQcd‡hv¨ \hR*LO\’}*LO\hLžvÖcd_cd_|ÖÛ'cd`d` Ø ]LOØ*`]\g/Ø ]C}]^f*`dgqŒV]b}¿LV‡ÅLÖy7NhgX_x\h`dcd_]\gxgX`[LO|XLVc›_‡\ \]^NhNhgVNScd‡h7 v BLO\’`d]bLV‡\c›_‚\hR]Ccdv€v€]b}cdLO\]y7{\h{Nh8] S˜ ŠgqÛ"]^‹V]^Nb Lž{‡]^yB{` NhgX`]y8gVNÅ}LO\hL/v€cd_*cd_|Öcd‡LV‡’LÂ×`\]^Nb v€LOš=cd_|~c\Å]bPƒgX_gXvÖcdPC\g‚‡]b`]bPƒ\L~v€LV_LO|V]bLOØ*`]‡h{Ø*‡]^\’gVy“cd_}cd‹)cd}*{LV`d‡+y7gVNÅyB{Nh\hR]^N‡hPƒNS{\hcd_xŒM{‡hc›_|/\NQLV}c l \hcgX_LV` cd_x\]b`d`dc|V]b_Pƒ]Å\]bPSR_cdó){]b‡^˜“i_¨\hRc›‡+‹=c]^ۏ\hR]Ø(]b_]ƒ×*\+gVy[}LO\hLžv€cd_c›_|wcd‡+fNScdv€LONQcd`dŒ€\gÂcdv€fNhgq‹V]\hR] ] $(]bPƒ\hc‹V]b_]b‡h‡ŠgVy gV\hR]^NŠPƒgX{_x\]^Nh\]^NhNhgVNScd‡hv vw]^\hRg)}gX`dgV|Xc]b‡^˜

¦]ÅLV‡h‡h{*vw]Vxy7gVN“\hR]’‡hLOšV]’gVy PƒgX_PƒNh]^\]b_]b‡Q‡^=\hRLO\“Ûö]’LONh]’}]bLV`dcd_|Û'c\hRÂ}LO\hLV‡]^\h‡“Û'RgX‡h]ŠNhg;Û'‡“}]b‡hPƒNQcdØ ] cd_}*c‹)c›}{LV`d‡’LV_}–Û'RgX‡]žPƒgX`d{v€_‡LONh]/LO\\NQcØ*{\]b‡gVy&\hRgX‡]/cd_}*c‹)c›}{LV`d‡^:˜ 9gVNC]ƒZ=LVv€f*`]V[}LO\hLV‡]^\h‡Cv€c|XRx\ PƒgX_x\hLVcd_‚cd_y8gVNQvÖLO\hcgX_/LOØ gX{\&Û'RcdPSR¨P^c\hc]b‡&LV_Mcd_}c‹=cd}{*LV`RLV‡+‹=cd‡hcd\]b}†=gVN+Û'RcdPS:R ;c|XRx\h‡+R]RLV‡+\hLOšV]b_†˜