Comparison of evacuation methods used in the Netherlands and the

Download PDF
0 downloads 0 Views 3MB Size Report
Comment
Different models can be used to define the effectiveness of evacuation. ... Dutch and American methods for evacuation as part of flood risk management ...
E3S Web of Conferences 7, 19007 (2016) FLOODrisk 2016 - 3rd European Conference on Flood Risk Management

DOI: 10.1051/ e3sconf/2016 0719007

                      

        !        

  

    

 

   

   !" ! #$  %  & '&$ ! (

! )* +%,     !" ! #$  %)* +%,  - &./0 1 %!  ,2 &  "!  ! !   

                            !  "                    ##$!" %                        ##$" &                "%  '    &                         "    '    (   ##$                                  "  %      (               

     "%                        "



)  *" +"" + "

© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

E3S Web of Conferences 7, 19007 (2016) FLOODrisk 2016 - 3rd European Conference on Flood Risk Management

" # 

DOI: 10.1051/ e3sconf/2016 0719007

%             "Q        (          ( "* • &   *  %       (    K   (              (     

        " • %  *%        

 " • #*  %                  K "

#                    

       "  #                         "  #                 

   (                 !                                                        

   "    (                         "?                                                            @  "                                                     "                       (                     (        (  B "  $              (            (                 "  %                           "

B                  (                                 * • U   V*  U      "                                       " • U   =*  &            !   (    

K  • U   F*  B K      @       K            !" • U   G*  U              

            (    K                        F"

%                            ""                            !  "  ?                                (                    " H        @          "  #       (    (                !          (        (        "J                                           K              "?                           "

X                       (         (         * • J    Z   (       (  (  " • J      Z         (    (                    [   N  \ ] " • U     Z   (         G  ^ "

$ %&'  ?  (                "%     (  K                     "  %    (                            _#)@ Q ! %    #  )  !

   #  "

%               * =" %        K    !   F" )K N  G" &       M" #                          !"

#                    "                        "                            " \                             

%                               "

2

E3S Web of Conferences 7, 19007 (2016) FLOODrisk 2016 - 3rd European Conference on Flood Risk Management

     "^((    (   (           (  (              (   B      

       K N!                  "                    (@     "                                  (         (        "         (             "

DOI: 10.1051/ e3sconf/2016 0719007

          (      " (#      #  )      " ()$  

                     ="

_(                                        "

(      ? (          " ()" *

      

  %  #    )              !                          "%     (                                  " &            

     !     (   (  "%    

   %    "%                                  "   _#)@Q      !    @                    "  ?                  (                  "% ( 

                      !            (      (      (     (                                (     (         !"  %                                               

                             "  %                !              "  #                                     !               

3

E3S Web of Conferences 7, 19007 (2016) FLOODrisk 2016 - 3rd European Conference on Flood Risk Management

DOI: 10.1051/ e3sconf/2016 0719007

#  )   U       K 

#                  #   U           

      &       (          U     (!       (       (!          "%            ( " )                                )                                _

U  #      q       %  (

U  #       (                 (            (

X 

M                     !

&        (  (      !

U @      ( 

 

)  

$ 

_#)@Q  U            

   U         

    J              (  (

           w      !                           (   (   '  )     (    K        ( 

$  Table 1. comprehensive comparison of evacuation models.

     (    (     ( "!

+  ,   

       

%                )   z FV=V   )   )" %       RG  kkMjV k!"MYRF             "     )  =VVV   !         "%   (                    "  #                         "  J                  (           "          (        (              "%       K          "%    K (     (     "  H  =  (             (   "%  

  (( =" H       (

MVVVV    FVVV =VVVVV   FV=M"&                    F"R    G"  ?                     (       (   ("

+)"   

%            (@    

  FFFF       @ x &  )  "%     Yk          (                   (            K      X           X "  %                  ))  ))!  J        #   $   &    )    #$&)! U  z ) )  Uz))!"%            FVV@       "  %              (          ( G=F  

     (             '      (       (                        X   "  %  =VV@                              "                     " +)$   %                                                (                    (       "@      (     ( (     H   ( 

4

E3S Web of Conferences 7, 19007 (2016) FLOODrisk 2016 - 3rd European Conference on Flood Risk Management

 *J      

)#

 *Q @)    

  !"X@  (" ) 

 

Y= YF YG YM YR YY Y` Yj Yk

?R J#  X& X X& z  _J{ _J{kk  X& X X& J#X& J  # Q\& ?jV# RV    z   RV )    RV Q\& Table 2. Road capacities.

`V `= `F

H  (       ! YR RV RV RV RV RV RV RV RV

DOI: 10.1051/ e3sconf/2016 0719007

H G      "%                    "  %      (          * @    *              @ X    *                  @ %   $    *               (      "

)         ! YMVV =YVV =YVV =RVV =RVV =RVV =YVV =YVV =RVV YkVV GFVV =RVV

% (   YFYG YM    

"%                                    "  %  (           ( 

         (   Q               * =" @  *

" U    K     *  =V|              " \     *kV|   

      F" &    )  &)!*     M                               @   !" H F(      (   (  K    )#" G" U    U #!*        G     M"  *    (=F"R}FVq! R" B( *V"F" "       FV|  (    "

 !         !       (  !( K 

                               #  )  "

5

E3S Web of Conferences 7, 19007 (2016) FLOODrisk 2016 - 3rd European Conference on Flood Risk Management

%       (                         (   jV|  "?                                                         " ?                                  "J                  !(     "%     (             (     "

DOI: 10.1051/ e3sconf/2016 0719007

                                     ! (     (                "  #  )       (                                                                    R!" %             (     K    "  J            (    K                           K N             "

\                                                        "%  G         (                 !"?          "H M(                             " U     &   )  U           &  

    

X    X#H! M=VV|   

   

G

j      =VV    &)! FU #F!

=V|

V|X!

=F"R

R   \R! $         #= ! V=BH=!

V

)  V"F

( Table 3. Sensitivity analyses

 #*#           M j       "

MU #M!

FV   \FV!             #F! V"GBHG!

+)(  %       #                   #  )  "?   (           %