Computational phylogenetic approaches to language

-BOHVBHF QIZMPHFOJFT .JDIBFM %VOO .BY 1MBODL *OTUJUVUF GPS 1TZDIPMJOHVTJUJDT  "VHVTU 

 *OUSPEVDUJPO *O QSJODJQMF BMM IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT JT QIZMPHFOFUJD TJODF QIZMPHFOFUJDT FODPNQBTTFT UIF TDJ FOUJ੗D JOWFTUJHBUJPO PG UIF EFTDFOU PG PSHBOJTNT JO HFOFSBM 8IJMF QSPUPUZQJDBM QIZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTJT JOWPMWFT JOWFTUJHBUJOH UIF FWPMVUJPOBSZ EFTDFOU PG B DMBTT PG CJPMPHJDBM TQFDJFT TVDI QIZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTFT IBWF BMTP CFFO BQQMJFE JO PUIFS EPNBJOT FH TPDJBM PSHBOJ[BUJPO NVTJ DBM JOTUSVNFOUT EFDPSBUJWF NPUJGT PO UFYUJMFT  BOE JOEFFE DBO CF BQQMJFE UP BOZ EPNBJO XIJDI WBSJFT BDDPSEJOH UP HFOFSBM FWPMVUJPOBSZ QSPDFTTFT य़F SFBTPO UIBU JO MJOHVJTUJDT UIJT UFSN JT PॏFO VTFE JO DPOUSBTU UP PUIFS GPSNT PG IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJD JOWFTUJHBUJPO JT UIBU QIZMPHFOFUJD BQQSPBDIFT NBJOUBJO UIFJS NFUIPEPMPHJDBM MJOL UP UIF JOWFTUJHBUJPO PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ QSPDFTTFT JO PUIFS NPTUMZ CJPMPHJDBM EPNBJOT य़F BQQFBM PG JODPSQPSBUJOH UIF BOBMZTJT PG MBOHVBHF JOUP B HFOFSBM UIFPSZ PG FWPMVUJPO JT UIBU DVSSFOU FWPMVUJPOBSZ UIFPSZ P੖FST B SJHPSPVT RVBOUJ੗BCMF BQQSPBDI UP QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF "T 'FMTFOTUFJO TUBUFT JO UIF QSFGBDF UP IJT NPOVNFOUBM *OGFS SJOH 1IZMPHFOJFT ۠QIZMPHFOJFT PS FWPMVUJPOBSZ USFFT BSF UIF CBTJD TUSVDUVSFT OFDFTTBSZ UP UIJOL DMFBSMZ BCPVU EJ੖FSFODFT CFUXFFO TQFDJFT BOE UP BOBMZTF UIPTF EJ੖FSFODFT TUBUJTUJDBMMZۡ 'FMTFO TUFJO  YJY  -JOHVJTUJD QIZMPHFOFUJDT JODPSQPSBUFT UIF XIPMF BQQSPBDI PG UIF QIZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE ۘ VTJOH MBOHVBHF QIZMPHFOJFT BT UIF IJTUPSJDBM CBDLCPOF UP RVBOUJUBUJWF NPEFMT PG MBOHVBHF DIBOHF JO PSEFS UP UFTU IZQPUIFTFT BCPVU IVNBO EJTQFSTBMT QSPDFTTFT PG DVM UVSBM DIBOHF BOE UIF FWPMVUJPO PG PUIFS MJOHVJTUJD TVCTZTUFNT TFF 4FDUJPO   *O UIJT TFOTF QIZ MPHFOFUJD MJOHVJTUJDT JT CSPBEFS JO JUT BNCJUJPOT UIBO IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT TFFLT UP JMMVNJOBUF UIF IJTUPSZ PG MBOHVBHFT BOE POMZ TFDPOEBSJMZ TFFLT UP TBZ TPNFUIJOH BCPVU UIF TQFBLFST PG UIPTF MBOHVBHFT JO BQQSPBDIFT MJLF MJOHVJTUJD QBMBFPOUPMPHZ BOE TPDJPDVMUVSBM SF DPOTUSDUJPO TFF $IBQUFST 93&')FHHBSUZ BOE 93&'&QQT

BT XFMM BT HFOFMBOHVBHF DPSSFMBUJPO $IBQUFS 93&'1BࠨFOEPSG  य़F RVBOUJ੗FE BMHPSJUINJD BQQSPBDI UP QIZMPHFOFUJDT TUBSUFE JO UIF FBSMZ T 'FMTFO TUFJO   -JOHVJTUJDT IBT CFFO QBSU PG UIJT NPWFNFOU UXJDF ੗STUMZ XJUI UIF EFWFMPQNFOU PG MFYJDPTUBUJTUJDT BOE HMPࡇPDISPOPMPHZ JO UIF MBUF T BOE BHBJO XJUI UIF EFWFMPQNFOU PG NPEFM CBTFE IZQPUIFTJTUFTUJOH BOE VTVBMMZ #BZFTJBO BQQSPBDIFT TUBSUJOH BSPVOE  TFF 4FDUJPO   य़F BJN PG UIJT DIBQUFS JT UP QSFTFOU B PWFSWJFX PG DVSSFOU RVBOUJUBUJWF BQQSPBDIFT UP MBO HVBHF DIBOHF य़FTF BQQSPBDIFT BSF JODSFBTJOHMZ XFMM SFDFJWFE XJUIJO MJOHVJTUJDT CVU SFNBJO DPOUSPWFSTJBM JO TPNF DJSDMFT JO QBSU CFDBVTF PG UIF DPO੘BUJPO PG MFYJDPTUBUJTUJDBM BQQSPBDIFT 

XJUI CF॒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੗OFE "DDPSEJOH UP 4XBEFTI IJNTFMG UIF MFYFNF TIPVME CF UIF TUZMJT UJDBMMZ VONBSLFE FWFSZEBZ XPSE DPSSFTQPOEJOH UP UIF NFBOJOH "DDPSEJOH UP 4XBEFTI ۠IF SVMFT GPS ੗MMJOH JO UIF MJTU GPS FBDI MBOHVBHF NBZ CF TUBUFE BT GPMMPXT B 5SZ UP ੗OE POF TJNQMF FRVJWBMFOU GPS FBDI JUFN CZ EJTSFHBSEJOH TQFDJBMJ[FE BOE CPVOE GPSNT BOE UIF MFTT DPNNPO PG UXP FRVJWBMFOUT C 6TF B TJOHMF XPSE PS FMFNFOU SBUIFS UIBO B QISBTF FWFO UIPVHI UIF NFBOJOH NBZ CF CSPBEFS UIBO UIBU PG UIF UFTU JUFN D 8IFSF JU JT JNQPTTJCMF UP ੗OE B TJOHMF FRVJWBMFOU PNJU UIF GPSNۡ 4XBEFTI   0CWJPVTMZ DBSF TIPVME CF UBLFO UIBU XPSET DPSSFTQPOE UP UIF JOUFOEFE NFBOJOH FH 4XBEFTI‫۠ ۝‬CBSLۡ JT UIF ۠TLJO PG B USFFۡ OPU UIF ۠OPJTF PG B EPHۡ  ,BT TJBO FU BM  IBWF QSPEVDFE B VTFGVM TFNBOUJD TQFDJ੗DBUJPO GPS B XJEFMZ VTFE WFSTJPO PG UIF 4XBEFTI MJTUT *O B QIZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTJT UIF MFYFNFT BSF SFQMBDFE CZ UIFJS DPHOBUF DMBTT SBUIFS UIBO EFBMJOH XJUI UIF MFYJDBM GPSNT UIFNTFMWFT TP UIBU BMM MFYFNFT XIJDI EFTDFOE GSPN B DPNNPO BODFTUPS BSF JOEJDBUFE CZ UIF TBNF DPEF

-BOHVBHF " -BOHVBHF # -BOHVBHF $ -BOHVBHF %

.FBOJOH  MFYFNF DMBTT NIȨN B NIȨN B MȔU C

.FBOJOH  MFYFNF DMBTT DȨċ Y LȨU Z LșU MQșD Z [ MQșU [

5BCMF  .VMUJTUBUF DPEJOH PG UXP NFBOJOHT B C Y Z [ BSF DPHOBUF DMBTTFT ۠ ۡ NFBOT VOLOPXO 5BCMF  TIPXT BO FYBNQMF GSBHNFOU PG B DPHOBUF DPEJOH NBUSJY GSPN B 4XBEFTI MJTU 5FDI OJDBMMZ UIJT JT B NVMUJTUBUF NBUSJY TJODF FBDI NFBOJOH B DIBSBDUFS JO QIZMPHFOFUJD UFSNT NBZ IBWF NVMUJQMF WBMVFT FH Y Z PS [  य़JT NBUSJY DBO CF USBOTGPSNFE JOUP B CJOBSZ QSFTFODF BCTFODF NBUSJY CZ USFBUJOH FBDI DPHOBUF DMBTT BT B DIBSBDUFS TFF 5BCMF  य़F QSFTFODFBCTFODF NBUSJY IBT UIF VTFGVM QSPQFSUZ UIBU JU DBO IBOEMF NPSF UIBO POF DPHOBUF TFU QFS NFBOJOH BT JO -BOHVBHF $ .FBOJOH   $PSSFDU DPHOBUF DMBTTJ੗DBUJPO JT OP USJWJBM NB॒FS %VOO (SFFOIJMM FU BM  BOE #PVDL BFSU FU BM  VTFE B EBUBCBTF PG DPHOBUF DMBTTJ੗DBUJPOT DIFDLFE BHBJOTU QVCMJTIFE EBUB GSPN FUZNPMPHJDBM EJDUJPOBSJFT $PHOBUF KVEHFNFOUT NBZ BMTP CF TVQQMJFE CZ IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUT BT JO 3JOHF 8BSOPX BOE 5BZMPS 

BOE (SFFOIJMM #MVTU BOE (SBZ   1IZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTFT DBO BMTP CF DBSSJFE PVU PO DPHOBUF DBOEJEBUF EBUB XIFSF DPHOBUF DMBTTJ੗DBUJPO JO UIF TUSJDU TFOTF QSPWFE CZ IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJD NFUIPET IBT OPU CFFO PS QPTTJCMZ DBOOPU CF DBSSJFE PVU य़F 

-BOHVBHF " -BOHVBHF # -BOHVBHF $ -BOHVBHF %

$PHOBUF TFU C Y Z           

B   

[    

5BCMF  #JOBSZ QSFTFODFBCTFODF DPEJOH PG DPHOBUF EBUB GSPN 5BCMF  EBUB JO UIFTF UXP DBTFT MPPLT JEFOUJDBM CVU VTJOH DPHOBUF DBOEJEBUFT SBUIFS UIBO QSPWFO DPHOBUFT OFDFTTBSJMZ BEET B GVSUIFS VOGPSUVOBUFMZ VORVBOUJ੗FE MFWFM PG VODFSUBJOUZ UP UIF BOBMZTJT $PE JOH GPS MFYJDBM DBOEJEBUFT SBUIFS UIBO USVF MFYJDBM DPHOBUFT JT DSVDJBM GPS PUIFS LJOET PG BOBMZTJT FTQFDJBMMZ UIPTF XIFSF UIF SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPO JT TQFDJ੗DBMMZ BCPVU CPSSPXJOH PS BENJYUVSF 'PS JOTUBODF 4IJKVMBM FU BM  NPEFM IPSJ[POUBM USBOTGFS PG MFYJDBM JUFNT JOTJEF GBNJMJFT BOE #PX FSO  VTFT DPHOBUF DBOEJEBUFT UP DMBTTJGZ UI DFOUVSZ XPSEMJTUT PG 5BTNBOJBO MBOHVBHFT JOUP QSPCBCMF MBOHVBHFT BOE MBOHVBHF GBNJMJFT *O QSJODJQMF BOZUIJOH XIJDI DBSSJFT B QIZMPHFOFUJD TJHOBM DBO CF VTFE BT UIF CBTJT GPS TPNF LJOE PG QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF BMUIPVHI PG DPVSTF UIF LJOE PG QIZMPHFOFUJD TJHOBM DPOTUSBJOT UIF JOGFSFODFT XIJDI DBO CF NBEF "T JO DPOWFOUJPOBM IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT QIZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTJT DBO NPEFM OPUJPOBMMZ VOJRVF FWFOUT JO UIF IJTUPSZ PG B MBOHVBHF GBNJMZ TVDI BT TPVOE DIBOHFT BOE NPSQIPMPHJDBM JOOPWBUJPOT य़F QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOJFT BQQSPBDI 3JOHF 8BSOPX BOE 5BZMPS  /BLIMFI 3JOHF BOE 8BSOPX  NPTU DMPTFMZ BQQSPYJNBUFT B GVTJPO PG USBEJUJPOBM BOE QIZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPET य़FJS EBUBCBTF /BLIMFI FU BM  JODMVEFT DPHOBUF TFUT BT XFMM BT GFBUVSFT SFQSFTFOUJOH NPSQIPMPHJDBM BOE QIPOPMPHJDBM JOOPWBUJPOT UIFJS TUBUJTUJDBM BOBMZTFT BSF EFTJHOFE UP JODPSQPSBUF UIF TBNF BTTVNQUJPOT UIBU B USBEJUJPOBM IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJD BOBMZTJT XPVME NBLF TFFLJOH B USFF XIJDI JT NBYJNBMMZ DPNQBUJCMF XJUI BMM UIF FWJEFODF GPS TVCHSPVQJOH QPUFOUJBMMZ JODMVEJOH FWJEFODF XIJDI JT DPO੘JDUJOH JO UIF QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOFUJD OFUXPSLT BQQSPBDI /BLIMFI 3JOHF BOE 8BSOPX   0UIFS LJOET PG BOBMZTFT BSF OPU TP UJHIUMZ DPVQMFE UP USBEJUJPOBM IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT BT UIPTF CBTFE PO DPHOBUFT BOE TPVOEDIBOHFT *G USBEJUJPOBM IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJD JOQVU JT VOBWBJMBCMF PS GPS TPNF PUIFS SFBTPO VOGFBTJCMF UIFO BQQSPBDIFT UP QIZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTJT CBTFE PO QIPOPMPHJ DBM TJNJMBSJUZ BSF BQQFBMJOH य़FTF NFUIPET VTF TPNF LJOE PG GPSNBMMZ EF੗OFE EJTUBODF NFBTVSF UP DPNQBSF MFYFNFT CFUXFFO MBOHVBHFT य़JT NFBTVSF DBO CF VTFE UP JEFOUJGZ DPHOBUF DBOEJ EBUFT %VOO BOE 5FSSJMM 

CVU NPSF PॏFO JU JT VTFE UP HJWF BO FTUJNBUF PG UIF BNPVOU PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ DIBOHF CFUXFFO MFYFNFT XIJDI BSF B QSJPSJ QSFTVNFE UP CF DPHOBUF -FYJDBM TJN JMBSJUZ NFUIPET BSF QBSUJDVMBSMZ TVJUFE UP JOWFTUJHBUJPO PG EJBMFDU EBUB TJODF UIF QSFTVNQUJPO PG DPHOBDZ JT XFMM KVTUJ੗FE 1SPLJÇ   *O HFOFSBM MFYJDBM TJNJMBSJUZ NFBTVSFT XPSL CFTU BU SFMBUJWFMZ TIBMMPX UJNFEFQUIT (SFFOIJMM   1IZMPHFOFUJD NFUIPET BSF OPU MJNJUFE UP XPSLJOH XJUI MFYJDBM NPSQIPMPHJDBM PS QIPOPMPH JDBM GFBUVSFT *O XPSL PO UIF IJTUPSJDBM DPOOFDUJPOT CFUXFFO UIF 1BQVBO MBOHVBHFT PG *TMBOE .FMBOFTJB GPS FYBNQMF %VOO FU BM  JOWFTUJHBUFE UIF IZQPUIFTJT UIBU UIF UZQPMPHJDBM TJNJ MBSJUJFT CFUXFFO UIFTF MBOHVBHFT SFUBJOT B IJTUPSJDBM TJHOBM PG FBSMJFS DPOUBDU PS TIBSFE BODFTUSZ 

EFTQJUF UIF BCTFODF PS KVTU VOBWBJMBCJMJUZ PG MFYJDBM FWJEFODF #FDBVTF PG UIF MJNJUFE ۠EFTJHO TQBDFۡ PG MBOHVBHF 3FFTJOL BOE %VOO 

UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ PG DIBODF TJNJMBSJUZ JO UIF UZQP MPHJDBM EPNBJO JT IJHI BOE QBSUJDVMBS DBSF NVTU CF UBLFO UP VTF BQQSPQSJBUF TUBUJTUJDBM UFTUT JG TVDI EBUB JT UP CF VTFE UP TVQQPSU EFUBJMFE DMBJNT BCPVU IJTUPSZ PS UP NBLF JOGFSFODFT BCPVU EFFQ UJNF EFQUIT .PEFMT PG TUSVDUVSBM UZQPMPHJDBM EBUB QSFTVNF UIBU VOSFMBUFE MBOHVBHFT NBZ IBWF JEFOUJDBM WBMVFT GPS TPNF UZQPMPHJDBM QBSBNFUFST XIJDI NBLF UIFN QBSUJDVMBSMZ VTFGVM GPS UIF BOBMZTJT PG DPOUBDU BOE BENJYUVSF 3FFTJOL 4JOHFS BOE %VOO 

BOE HFOFMBOHVBHF DPSSFMBUJPO )VOMFZ FU BM    %JTUBODFCBTFE NPEFMT PG ࠩBOHF " EJTUBODFCBTFE NPEFM PG DIBOHF FTUJNBUFT UIF BNPVOU PG DIBOHF CFUXFFO UXP MBOHVBHFT GSPN UIF BHHSFHBUF BNPVOU PG EJ੖FSFODF CFUXFFO UIFN %JTUBODFCBTFE NFUIPET PG QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF BMM VTF TPNF LJOE PG EJTUBODF NFUSJD UP NFBTVSF IPX NVDI FBDI UBYPO EJ੖FST GSPN FWFSZ PUIFS POF य़FSF BSF UXP EJ੖FSFOU LJOET PG EJTUBODF NFUSJD XIJDI BSF DPNNPOMZ VTFE JO MJOHVJTUJDT TIBSFE DPHOBUF QSPQPSUJPO BOE TPDBMMFE -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF B XPSECZXPSE NFBTVSF PG QIPOFUJD TJNJMBSJUZ  -FYJDPTUBUJTUJDT -BOHVBHF DMVTUFSJOH CZ DPHOBUF EJTUBODF JT UIF FBSMJFTU GPSN PG TUBUJTUJDBM QIZMPHFOFUJDT EPOF JO MJOHVJTUJDT " TUBOEBSEJ[FE MJTU PG NFBOJOHT B ۠4XBEFTI MJTUۡ PS UIF MJLF 4FDUJPO  JT VTFE UP DPNQJMF XPSEMJTUT SFQSFTFOUJOH FBDI MBOHVBHF PG UIF TBNQMF 'PS FBDI QBJS PG MBOHVBHFT UIF EJTUBODF CFUXFFO UIFN JT UIF QSPQPSUJPO PG DPSSFTQPOEJOH UFSNT XIJDI BSF OPU DPHOBUF JO UIF UXP MJTUT य़F JOWFSTF PG EJTUBODF   E JT UIF QSPQPSUJPO PG UFSNT XIJDI BSF DPHOBUF CFUXFFO UIF UXP MJTUT BOE DBO CF UIPVHIU PG BT UIF TJNJMBSJUZ PS QSPYJNJUZ PG UIF MJTUT  य़F QBJSXJTF EJTUBODFT CFUXFFO UIF MBOHVBHFT BSF UBCVMBUFE BT JO 5BCMF  -BOHVBHF " -BOHVBHF # -BOHVBHF $ -BOHVBHF %

-BOHVBHF "          

-BOHVBHF #

-BOHVBHF $

-BOHVBHF %

      

   



5BCMF  1BJSXJTF EJTUBODFT GSPN 5BCMF  -BOHVBHF " BOE -BOHVBHF # EJ੖FS JO  PVS PG  DPNQBSJTPOT TP IBWF B EJTUBODF PG  CFDBVTF PG NJTTJOH EBUB ۜ ‫ ۝‬EJTUBODFT GSPN -BOHVBHF % BSF DBMDVMBUFE PO UIF CBTJT PG POMZ  DPNQBSJTPOT *U JT JNQPSUBOU UIBU UIF DSJUFSJB GPS JODMVTJPO JO UIFTF MJTUT BSF DMFBS PUIFSXJTF CJBTFT UP UIF EJTUBODF DBMDVMBUJPO NBZ CF JOUSPEVDFE TJNQMZ EVF UP BWBJMBCJMJUZ PG NBUFSJBMT GPS B QBSUJDVMBS MBO HVBHF "DDPSEJOH UP UIF 4XBEFTI  DSJUFSJB DJUFE BCPWF UIFSF JT NJOJNBM BMMPXBODF NBEF GPS TFNBOUJD DIBOHF LOPXO DPHOBUF UFSNT XIJDI EPO‫۝‬U ੗U UIF TFNBOUJD DSJUFSJB NVTU CF JHOPSFE  4XBEFTI BMTP EPFT OPU BMMPX DFMMT UP DPOUBJO NVMUJQMF MFYFNFT BT JO -BOHVBHF $ .FBOJOH  JO 5BCMF   #VU JO FBDI PG UIFTF DBTFT UIJT JT BO BOBMZUJD DIPJDF PUIFS DSJUFSJB BSF QPTTJCMF CVU UIF EJTUBODF NFBTVSFNFOUT BSF POMZ DPIFSFOU JG UIFTF DSJUFSJB BSF BQQMJFE DPOTJTUFOUMZ य़F UFSN HMP॒PDISPOPMPHZ JT TPNFUJNFT VTFE BT B TZOPOZN PG MFYJDPTUBUJTUJDT CVU TPNF 

TDIPMBST BSF QVODUJMJPVT BCPVU EJTUJOHVJTIJOH UIF UFSNT *G UIF UFSNT BSF UP CF EJTUJOHVJTIFE MFYJDPTUBUJTUJDT SFGFST UP UIF QSPDFTT PG DMVTUFSJOH MBOHVBHFT CBTFE PO EJTUBODFT DBMDVMBUFE GSPN NFBOJOH MJTUT XIFSFBT HMP॒PDISPOPMPHZ SFGFST UP B NFUIPE GPS VTJOH UIFTF EJTUBODFT UP JOGFS DISPOPMPHJDBM EBUFT .D.BIPO BOE .D.BIPO    य़F HMP॒PDISPOPMPHJDBM NFUIPE GPS EF UFSNJOJOH EBUFT JT CBTFE PO UIF QSFNJTF UIBU PWFS B TVਖ਼DJFOUMZ MBSHF USFF JT JT BDDFQUBCMF UP BTTVNF B DPOTUBOU SBUF PG DIBOHF *O UIF MBUF  BOE T UIF QSPNJTF PG HMP॒PDISPOPMPHZ TFFNFE WBTU 4XBEFTI  UBMLT CSFBUIMFTTMZ BCPVU UIF ۠EJTDPWFSZۡ PG B NFBO SBUF DPOTUBOU PG MFYJDBM DPHOBUF UVSOPWFS CFMJFWFE UP CF  q  QFS  ZFBST GPS DVMUVSBMMZ OFVUSBM WPDBCVMBSZ "DDPSEJOH UP UIJT DPOTUBOU B QBJS PG MBOHVBHFT XIJDI TQMJU  ZFBST BHP XPVME TIBSF  PG UIF UFSNT JO B NFBOJOH MJTU B  ZFBS PME TQMJU XPVME TIPX  —    SFUFOUJPO BOE TP PO *G ZPV BDDFQU CPUI UIF WBMJEJUZ BOE UIF WBMVF P৐ UIJT SBUF DPOTUBOU JU JT GBJSMZ TJNQMF UP EFUFSNJOF UIF BHF PG BOZ MBOHVBHF SFMBUJPOTIJQ 4XBEFTI  ۗ  य़F QSPCMFN XJUI UIJT XIPMF MJOF PG SFTFBSDI JT UIBU UIF DPOTUBOU SBUF PG DIBOHF UVSOFE PVU UP CF JMMVTPSZ य़F SBUF PG MBOHVBHF DIBOHF WBSJFT EVF UP B OVNCFS PG EJ੖FSFOU GBDUPST "NPOHTU UIPTF UP B॒FNQU UP RVBOUJGZ UIJT JT /F॒MF 

XIP TIPXT B HFOFSBM QB॒FSO PG GBTUFS MBOHVBHF DIBOHF JO TNBMMFS DPNNVOJUJFT UIF TBNF QIFOPNFOPO BT GBTUFS HFOFUJD ESJॏ JO TNBMMFS CJPMPHJDBM QPQVMBUJPOT

BOE "ULJOTPO FU BM 

XIP TIPX UIBU IJHIFS SBUFT PG DPHOBUF UVSOPWFS BSF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI MBOHVBHF TQMJU UJOH FWFOUT $PNQVUFS TJNVMBUJPOT CZ DPNQVUBUJPOBM CJPMPHJTUT IBWF TIPXO UIBU EJTUBODFCBTFE DMVTUFSJOH JT FYUSFNFMZ TFOTJUJWF UP EJ੖FSFODFT JO SBUF PG DIBOHF JO EJ੖FSFOU CSBODIFT PG UIF USFF 1FFS   GPS SFGFSFODFT

BOE PUIFS NPSF SPCVTU NFUIPET OPX FYJTU TFF 4FDUJPO   " SPMF SFNBJOT GPS EJTUBODF NFUIPET UIF "VUPNBUFE 4JNJMBSJUZ +VEHFNFOU 1SPHSBN "4+1 #SPXO FU BM  )PMNBO FU BM  NBLFT FYUFOTJWF VTF PG EJTUBODFT CVU TFF (SFFOIJMM 

BT EP UIF EJBMFDUPNFUSJD UFDIOJRVFT EJTDVTTFE JO 4FDUJPO   -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF *OTUFBE PG XPSLJOH GSPN B EJTUBODF NFBTVSF CBTFE PO DPHOBUF DMBTTJ੗DBUJPO JU JT BMTP QPTTJCMF UP XPSL EJSFDUMZ GSPN UIF TJNJMBSJUZ CFUXFFO UIF QIPOPMPHJDBM GPSNT PG XPSET य़JT JT VTVBMMZ EPOF VTJOH TPNF WBSJBOU PG UIF -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF B NFBTVSF PG IPX NBOZ PQFSBUJPOT BSF SFRVJSFE UP UVSO POF TUSJOH PG QIPOFNFT JOUP BOPUIFS 5P DIBOHF B ۠IBXLۡ JOUP B ۠IBOETBXۡ SFRVJSFT UXP TVCTUJUVUJPOT BOE UISFF JOTFSUJPOT GPS B EJTUBODF PG ੗WF JU DBO BMTP CF EPOF XJUI POF EFMFUJPO BOE GPVS JOTFSUJPOT TFF 'JHVSF  GPS BOPUIFS JMMVTUSBUJPO  य़F EJTUBODFT CFUXFFO POF TIPSU XPSE BOE POF MPOH XPSE XJMM BMXBZT CF HSFBU CFDBVTF PG UIF OVNCFS PG EFMFUJPOT SFRVJSFE

BOE TP JU JT DPNNPO UP OPSNBMJ[F UIF NFBTVSF BMPOH B UP TDBMF CZ EJWJEJOH CZ UIF MFOHUI PG UIF MPOHFS XPSE य़F -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF NFBTVSF DBO CF DVTUPNJ[FE JO NBOZ PUIFS XBZT UPP %J੖FSFOU XFJHIUT DBO CF HJWFO UP JOTFSUJPOT BOE EFMFUJPOT BOE UIF EJTUBODF DPTU PG B TVCTUJUVUJPO DBO CF DBMDVMBUFE GSPN QIPOPMPHJDBM GFBUVSFT TP UP DIBOHF B U UP B E DPVOUT BT MFTT EJTUBODF UIBO B DIBOHF GSPN B U UP B ċ  य़F TVCTUJUVUJPO NFBTVSF DBO BMTP CF NBEF NPSF DPBSTF TP UIBU DMBTTFT PG TJNJMBS QIPOFNFT BSF USFBUFE BT JEFOUJDBM BT JT EPOF JO UIF "4+1 QSPKFDU )PMNBO FU BM   *O UIF "4+1 BMM QIPOFNFT BSF DPMMBQTFE JOUP  DMBTTFT TP GPS FYBNQMF - SFQSFTFOUT BMM MBUFSBMT FYDFQU GPS M #SPXO FU BM  UP BMMPX NBYJNBM DSPTTMJOHVJTUJD DPNQBSBCJMJUZ य़F MPTT PG QIPOPMPHJDBM EJTUJODUJWFOFTT JT DPNQFOTBUFE GPS CZ UIF FYUSFNFMZ MBSHF TDPQF PG UIF 

DPNQBSJTPO ۘ  MBOHVBHFT BOE EJBMFDUT BU UIF UJNF PG UIF )PMNBO FU BM  QBQFS

 ɒ B L

ۘ

S  *OTFSUJPO

ۘ %FMFUJPO

‫އ‬

‫އ‬

‫ އ‬4VCTUJUVUJPO ۘ ‫ އ‬4VCTUJUVUJPO ۘ

 Ƀ țJ L T Q J

Q J F S 

'JHVSF  -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF )PX UP UVSO B ۠4IBLFTQFBSFۡ JOUP ۠+BDRVFT 1JFSSFۡ JO CSPBE QIPOPMPHJDBM USBOTDSJQUJPO XJUI UXP TVCTUJUVUJPOT B EFMFUJPO BOE BO JOTFSUJPO GPS B -FWFO TIUFJO EJTUBODF PG GPVS  8IFO UP VTF EJTUBODF BOE XIFO OPU UP VTF JU 0OF TFSJPVT DSJUJDJTN PG UIF -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF NFBTVSF JT UIBU JU JT POMZ B DPIFSFOU NFBTVSF PG MBOHVBHF DIBOHF XIFSF UIF GPSNT CFJOH DPNQBSFE EFTDFOE GSPN B DPNNPO BODFTUPS य़F -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF CFUXFFO OPODPHOBUF JUFNT JT OPU QSFEJDUFE CZ UIF EFHSFF PG SFMBUFEOFTT PG UIF UXP MBOHVBHFT UIBU UIF XPSET DPNF GSPN *O UIF DPNQVUBUJPOBM EJBMFDUPNFUSZ USBEJUJPO (PFCM  )FFSJOHB BOE /FSCPOOF  UIJT PCKFDUJPO JT MBSHFMZ JSSFMFWBOU TJODF NPTU XPSET JO B DPNQBSBUJWF EJBMFDUPMPHZ XPSEMJTU BSF DPHOBUF *O BEEJUJPO UIF UJNF EFQUIT PG TFQBSBUJPO CFUXFFO EJBMFDUBM WBSJFUJFT JT HFOFSBMMZ NVDI TNBMMFS UIBO CFUXFFO WBSJFUJFT SFDPHOJTFE BT EJT UJODU MBOHVBHFT NFBOJOH UIBU WBSJBUJPO JO SBUFT PG DIBOHF IBT MFTT JO੘VFODF PO UIF BNPVOU PG MJOHVJTUJD EJ੖FSFODF 5BLJOH UIFTF UXP GBDUPST JOUP BDDPVOU UIF BNPVOU PG QIPOPMPHJDBM EJG GFSFODF CFUXFFO UXP EJBMFDUT DBO CF DPOTJEFSFE B HPPE QSPYZ GPS UIFJS BNPVOU PG IJTUPSJDBM TFQBSBUJPO %JBMFDU EJWFSTJ੗DBUJPO UFOET UP CF XBWFMJLF SBUIFS UIBO USFFMJLF BOE RVBMJUBUJWF EJG GFSFODFT CFUXFFO EJBMFDUT BSF VTVBMMZ SFQSFTFOUFE CZ JTPHMPTTFT य़FTF RVBOUJUBUJWF BQQSPBDIFT UP EJBMFDUPMPHZ EJ੖FS GSPN UIF JTPHMPTT BQQSPBDI JO UIBU JTPHMPTTFT TIPX EJTDPOUJOVJUJFT XIJMF EJTUBODF NFBTVSFT HJWF B DPOUJOVPVT DMVTUFSJOH $PNQVUBUJPOBM EJBMFDUPNFUSZ NFBTVSFT BSF VTV BMMZ BOBMZTFE BOE WJTVBMJ[FE VTJOH OFUXPSL NFUIPET 0OF WJWJE UFDIOJRVF GPS WJTVBMJ[JOH EJBMFDU DMVTUFST JT UP USBOTGPSN UIF QBJSXJTF -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF NBUSJY JF UIF EJTUBODF DBMDVMBUFE GSPN FBDI WBSJFUZ UP FWFSZ PUIFS WBSJFUZ VTJOH NVMUJEJNFOTJPOBM TDBMJOH .%4 XJUI UISFF EJ NFOTJPOT य़FTF EJNFOTJPOT DBO UIFO CF DPOWFSUFE UP JOUFOTJUJFT PG UIF UISFF DPMPVS BYFT JO UIF 3FE(SFFO#MVF DPMPVS TQBDF BOE UIF SFTVMUJOH DPMPVST DBO UIFO CF VTFE UP DPMPVS UIF EJBMFDU QPMZHPOT PO B HFPHSBQIJD NBQ )FFSJOHB   *O HFOFSBM WBSJFUJFT XJUI TJNJMBS SFMBUJPOTIJQT PG TJNJMBSJUZ BOE EJ੖FSFODF UP UIF PUIFS WBSJFUJFT DPOTJEFSFE XJMM IBWF TJNJMBS .%4 WBMVFT XIJDI JO UVSO XJMM QSPEVDF WJTVBMMZ TJNJMBS DPMPVST /PUF UIBU UIF 3FE(SFFO#MVF DPMPVS TQBDF JT OPU QFSDFQUVBMMZ FWFO IVNBOT EJTDSJNJOBUF NBOZ NPSF IVFT JO TPNF BSFBT PG UIF DPMPVS TQBDF UIBO PUIFST NFBOJOH UIBU WJTVBMJ[BUJPO CZ 3(# USBOTGPSNFE .%4 WBMVFT JT JOUSJOTJDBMMZ EJT UPSUFE 3FBM TDJFOUJ੗D BOBMZTJT PG EJTUBODF SFMBUJPOTIJQT NVTU CF OVNFSJD 'PS FYBNQMF .BOOJ 

(V©SBSE BOE )FZFS  VTF .PONPOJFS‫۝‬T BMHPSJUIN UP EFUFDU CBSSJFST BCSVQU DIBOHFT JO MJO HVJTUJD EJTUBODF VODPSSFMBUFE XJUI HFPHSBQIJD TQBDF -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF JT B HPPE QSPYZ IPXFWFS GPS IJTUPSJDBM SFMBUFEOFTT XIFO UIF MBOHVBHFT CFJOH DPNQBSFE TIBSF B SFDFOU DPNNPO BODFTUPS #FDBVTF -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF CFUXFFO OPO DPHOBUF MFYFNFT JT OPU B NFBOJOHGVM NFBTVSF PG IJTUPSJDBM SFMBUFEOFTT UIJT NFBTVSF JT B QBSUJD VMBSMZ SJTLZ UFDIOJRVF UP VTF GPS MPOH EJTUBODF DPNQBSJTPO *U CFDPNFT JODSFBTJOHMZ VOSFMJBCMF XIFO USZJOH UP RVBOUJGZ PMEFS MJOHVJTUJD SFMBUJPOTIJQT *G B QBJS PG MBOHVBHFT BSF OPU SFMBUFE BU BMM UIF -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF CFUXFFO UIFN JT TPMFMZ B GVODUJPO PG UIFJS TJNJMBSJUJFT JO QIPOPMPHZ BOE QIPOPUBDUJDT BT XFMM BT DIBODF %VOO BOE 5FSSJMM  QSFTFOU B NFUIPE GPS JOWFTUJHBUJOH UIF CBTF SBUF PG DIBODF TJNJMBSJUZ CFUXFFO XPSET GSPN UXP EJ੖FSFOU MBOHVBHFT CBTFE PO UIF ۠0TXBMU 4IJॏ 5FTUۡ 0TXBMU    य़F 0TXBMU 4IJॏ 5FTU XBT DPODFJWFE PG BT B WBMJEJUZ UFTU GPS MFYJDPTUBUJTUJDT UIF SBUF PG TIBSFE DPHOBUF DBOEJEBUFT CFUXFFO UXP MJTUT XBT DPNQBSFE XJUI UIF SBUFT PG TIBSFE DPHOBUFT CFUXFFO MJTUT XJUI UIFJS SPXT P੖TFU CZ POF UXP UISFF FUD य़VT GPS B MJTU PG  NFBOJOHT ZPV XPVME CF BCMF UP DPNQBSF UIF QFSDFOUBHF PG BQQBSFOU TIBSFE DPHOBUFT JO UIF USVF TFNBOUJDBMMZ BMJHOFE MJTU UP UIF QFSDFOUBHFT PG BQQBSFOU DPHOBUFT JO  TFNBOUJDBMMZ VOBMJHOFE MJTUT य़JT UFTU XPVME PCWJPVTMZ CF RVJUF EJਖ਼DVMU UP EP CZ IBOE TJODF UIF MJOHVJTU XPVME IBWF UP NBLF  DPHOBUF KVEHFNFOUT LOPXJOH UIBU BMM CVU POF QFSDFOU PG UIFN XFSF CPHVT DPNQBSJTPOT *U XPVME CF EFTJSBCMF UP EP UIF DPHOBUF DPEJOH CMJOE XJUI OP LOPXMFEHF BCPVU FJUIFS PG UIF MBOHVBHFT JOWPMWFE XIJDI JO QSBDUJDF XPVME NFBO UIBU UIJT QBJOGVMMZ UFEJPVT BDBEFNJD UBTL DPVME POMZ CF EPOF CZ TPNFCPEZ XJUI OP QSJPS FYQPTVSF UP UIF BSFB 6OTVSQSJT JOHMZ UIF 0TXBMU 5FTU XBT SBSFMZ DBSSJFE PVU JO QSBDUJDF %VOO BOE 5FSSJMM  QSPQPTF B NPEFSOJ[BUJPO PG UIF 0TXBMU 4IJॏ 5FTU DBMMFE UIF 0TXBMU .POUF $BSMP 5FTU य़JT JT B WFSTJPO PG UIF 4IJॏ 5FTU VTJOH B -FWFOTIUFJO NFBTVSF UP QSPQPTF DPHOBUF DBOEJEBUFT य़F EJTUBODF UISFTI PME BOE UIF QBSBNFUFST PG UIF QSFDJTF WBSJBOU PG UIF -FWFOTIUFJO NFBTVSF BSF UVOFE BHBJOTU B TFU PG USBJOJOH EBUB य़JT NBLFT JU QSBDUJDBCMF UP DBSSZ PVU MBSHF OVNCFST PG DPNQBSJTPOT TP UIF BE IPD ۠TIJॏۡ NFUIPE GPS TFMFDUJOH  TFNBOUJDBMMZ VOBMJHOFE MJTUT UP DPNQBSF DBO CF SFQMBDFE CZ UIF TUBUJTUJDBMMZ NPSF TUBOEBSE .POUF $BSMP SBOEPNJ[BUJPO UFDIOJRVF XIFSF UIF XPSEMJTUT BSF SBOEPNMZ TIVਗ਼FE UIPVTBOET PG UJNFT JO PSEFS UP HFU B SFMJBCMF TBNQMF PG UIF EJTUSJCVUJPO PG EJTUBODF NFBTVSFT VOEFS UIF TFNBOUJDBMMZ TDSBNCMFE DPOEJUJPO "4+1 DPNQBSJTPOT IBWF CFHVO UP VTF BO 0TXBMU .POUF $BSMPUZQF QSPDFEVSF UP DPSSFDU UIFJS NFBO -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF CZ EJWJEJOH JU CZ UIF EJTUBODFT CFUXFFO TDSBNCMFE XPSEMJTUT *O QSJODJQMF UIJT TIPVME JOEJDBUF UIBU UIF NFBO -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF NFBTVSFE CFUXFFO POF QBJS PG MBOHVBHFT TIPVME CF DPNQBSBCMF UP UIF NFBO -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF NFBTVSFE CFUXFFO BOZ PUIFS QBJS PG MBOHVBHFT 0OF PVUDPNF PG UIF DBTF TUVEZ PG QSFTFOUFE JO %VOO BOE 5FSSJMM  XBT UP EFNPOTUSBUF IPX WVMOFSBCMF EJTUBODF NFBTVSFT BSF UP VOEFUFDUFE MPBOXPSET "O BQQBSFOU IJHI EFHSFF PG MFYJDBM DPNNPO BMJUZ CFUXFFO UIF OPO"VTUSPOFTJBO MBOHVBHFT PG UIF 4PMPNPO *TMBOET WBOJTIFT XIFO QSPCBCMF MPBOXPSET BSF SFNPWFE &WFO POF PS UXP MPBOXPSET JO B XPSEMJTU HJWF B TUSPOH GBMTFQPTJUJWF TJHOBM



 $IBSBDUFSCBTFE NPEFMT PG ࠩBOHF "O BMUFSOBUJWF GBNJMZ PG BQQSPBDIFT UP QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF LOPXO BT DIBSBDUFSCBTFE NPEFMT PG DIBOHF FTUJNBUF UIF SFMBUJPOTIJQ CFUXFFO UXP MBOHVBHFT CZ JOGFSSJOH UIF QBUIXBZT CZ XIJDI FBDI FWPMWFE GSPN UIFJS DPNNPO BODFTUPS य़F EJ੖FSFODF CFUXFFO UXP MBOHVBHFT BDDPSEJOH UP B EJTUBODF NPEFM JT BMXBZT FRVBM UP PS MFTT UIBO UIF EJ੖FSFODF BDDPSEJOH UP B DIBSBDUFSCBTFE NPEFM "OPUIFS XBZ PG MPPLJOH BU UIJT JT UIBU UIF EJTUBODF CFUXFFO UXP MBOHVBHFT JT UIF TIPSUFTU QBUI GSPN POF UP BOPUIFS " DIBSBDUFSCBTFE NPEFM JT DPOTUSBJOFE UP QSPWJEF BO FWPMVUJPOBSJMZ QMBVTJCMF QBUIXBZ UP FBDI MBOHVBHF GSPN UIFJS JOGFSSFE DPNNPO BODFTUPSBOE UIJT JT BMNPTU BMXBZT B MPOHFS QBUIXBZ UIBO UIF TIPSUFTU EJTUBODF GPS UVSOJOH POF MBOHVBHF JOUP BOPUIFS य़F TIPSUDVUT UIBU EJTUBODF NFBTVSFT UBLF BSF NPSF TFSJPVT UIF GVSUIFS CBDL JO UJNF UIF DPNNPO BODFTUPS JT MPDBUFE $IBSBDUFSCBTFE NFUIPET BSF UIVT NPSF SFBMJTUJD NPEFMT PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ QSPDFTTFT य़F FBSMJFTU BOE VOUJM SFDFOUMZ UIF NPTU XJEFMZ VTFE DIBSBDUFSCBTFE NFUIPE GPS JOGFSSJOH QIZMPHFOZ XBT UIF QBSTJNPOZ NFUIPE 4XP੖PSE BOE 4VMMJWBO   य़F QBSTJNPOZ NFUIPE TFFLT B USFF UIBU FYQMBJOT B EBUB TFU FH B TFU PG DPHOBUF KVEHFNFOUT CZ NJOJNJ[JOH UIF OVNCFS PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ DIBOHFT SFRVJSFE UP QSPEVDF UIF PCTFSWFE TUBUFT य़JT NFBOT UIBU USFF TUSVDUVSFT BSF QSFGFSSFE UIBU QMBDF JOOPWBUJPOT XIFSF UIFZ BDDPVOU GPS UIF HSFBUFTU BNPVOU PG PCTFSWFE EJWFSTJUZ BT QPTTJCMF य़JT JT B TJNJMBS MPHJD UP UIBU VTFE VTFE JO UIF MJOHVJTUJD $PNQBSBUJWF .FUIPE USFFT BSF DPOTUSVDUFE PO UIF CBTJT PG TIBSFE JOOPWBUJPOT BOE XIFSF QPTTJCMF B USFF UPQPMPHZ JT GPVOE JO XIJDI FBDI JOOPWBUJPO IBT PDDVSSFE POMZ PODF 4UVEJFT VTJOH TJNVMBUFE EBUB TIPX UIBU QBSTJNPOZ NFUIPET BSF XFBL BU SFDPWFSJOH UIF USVF FWPMVUJPOBSZ USFF JO QBSUJDVMBS LJOET PG DPOEJUJPOT य़F NPTU TFSJPVT PG UIFTF JT QSPCBCMZ MPOH CSBODI BࡇSBDUJPO MPOH CSBODIFT CSBODIFT XJUI B MPU PG DIBOHF JO B USFF XJMM UFOE UP CF DMVTUFSFE UPHFUIFS FWFO JG UIFZ BSF POMZ EJTUBOUMZ SFMBUFE JO UIF USVF FWPMVUJPOBSZ IJTUPSZ य़JT PDDVST CFDBVTF XIFSF UXP CSBODIFT IBWF CPUI VOEFSHPOF B MPU PG DIBOHF UIF NPTU QBSTJNPOJPVT BDDPVOU JT BMXBZT UP CVOEMF UIF UXP CSBODIFT UPHFUIFS BT B TJOHMF TFU PG JOOPWBUJPOT XJUI B SFMBUJWFMZ TNBMM BNPVOU PG JOEFQFOEFOU EJWFSTJ੗DBUJPO BU UIF FOE 1BSTJNPOZ NFUIPET IBWF SFDFOUMZ CFFO PWFSUBLFO CZ TUBUJTUJDBMMZ NPSF SPCVTU CVU DPNQVUBUJPOBMMZ IBSEFS MJLFMJIPPE NFUIPET XIJDI BSF OPU TVCKFDU UP UIJT QSPCMFN  -JLFMJIPPE NFUIPET -JLFMJIPPE NFUIPET TFFL UP FYQMBJO B TFU PG PCTFSWFE EBUB CZ RVBOUJGZJOH IPX MJLFMZ JU XBT UP IBWF CFFO QSPEVDFE CZ B QBSUJDVMBS QSPDFTT य़F MJLFMJIPPE - JT UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ PG TFFJOH UIF PCTFSWFE EBUB % VOEFS B QBSUJDVMBS IZQPUIFUJDBM NFDIBOJTN )

GPSNBMJ[FE BT -  1 %])  8JUIJO QIZMPHFOFUJDT UIF IZQPUIFTJTFE NFDIBOJTN JT BO FWPMVUJPOBSZ QSPDFTT SFGFSSFE UP BT UIF ۠NPEFMۡ XIJDI DPOTJTUT PG B NBUIFNBUJDBM EFTDSJQUJPO PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ DIBOHF " NPEFM NJHIU UZQJDBMMZ JODMVEF USFF UPQPMPHZ BOE CSBODI MFOHUIT BT XFMM BT FH UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ UIBU B OFX DPHOBUF TFU BQQFBST JO UIF USFF BOE UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ UIBU B SF੘FY PG B DPHOBUF TFU JT MPTU य़F NPEFM JUTFMG JT OPU JO RVFTUJPO XJUIJO UIF MJLFMJIPPE DBMDVMBUJPO UIF NPEFM JT UIF SFTFBSDIFS‫۝‬T IZQPUIFTJT BCPVU UIF NFDIBOJTNT PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ IJTUPSZ CVU EJ੖FSFOU NPEFMT DBO CF DPNQBSFE BOE FWBMVBUFE TFF 4FDUJPO   .BYJNJ[JOH UIF MJLFMJIPPE PG UIF QBSBNFUFST PG B USFF UIF NPTU MJLFMZ CSBODI MFOHUIT UIF 

NPTU MJLFMZ USBOTJUJPO QBSBNFUFS WBMVFT FUD JT HFOFSBMMZ USBDUBCMF UP FYBDU NBUIFNBUJDBM NFUI PET )PXFWFS ੗OEJOH UIF CFTU USFF UPQPMPHZ PVU PG UIF WBTU TQBDF PG QPTTJCMF USFFT JT FYUSFNFMZ DIBMMFOHJOH BOE OP BMHPSJUIN JT LOPXO UIBU HVBSBOUFFT UIBU UIJT CFTU USFF XJMM CF GPVOE JO BOZ SFBTPOBCMF BNPVOU PG DPNQVUBUJPOBM UJNF 4DINJEU BOE )BFTFMFS   *U JT OPU QPTTJCMF UP TPMWF UIJT VTJOH SBOEPN TBNQMJOH PG USFF MJLFMJIPPET TJODF UIFZ BSF WFSZ TLFXFE UPXBSET MPX MJLF MJIPPE WBMVFT BOE POMZ B UJOZ QSPQPSUJPO PG UIF USFFT JO UIF TQBDF SFQSFTFOU HPPE TPMVUJPOT UP UIF FWPMVUJPOBSZ IZQPUIFTJT .PTU SFBTPOBCMZ TJ[FE SBOEPN TBNQMFT PG USFFT GSPN UIJT TQBDF XJMM DPOUBJO OP IJHI MJLFMJIPPE USFFT BU BMM BOE UIFSF XPVME CF OP XBZ UP LOPX UIBU UIF IJHI FTU MJLFMJIPPE USFFT JO UIF TBNQMF XPVME DPVOU BT IJHI XJUIJO UIF EJTUSJCVUJPOT PG MJLFMJIPPET JO UIF FOUJSF TQBDF य़F QSBDUJDBCMF TPMVUJPO UP UIJT JT UP VTF #BZFTJBO .POUF $BSMP .BSLPW DIBJO .$.$ TBNQMJOH य़JT BMHPSJUIN TFBSDIFT UIF USFF TQBDF GPS UIF SFHJPO PG IJHIFTU MJLFMJIPPE *U TUBSUT BU B SBOEPN QPJOU JO UIF TQBDF BOE CZ SBOEPNMZ QFSUVSCJOH UIF QBSBNFUFS WBMVFT BU UIBU TQBDF DPNQBSFT UIF MJLFMJIPPE TDPSF PG UIF DVSSFOU QPTJUJPO JO UIF USFF TQBDF UP UIF OFX TFU PG WBMVFT *G UIF OFX WBMVFT IBWF IJHIFS MJLFMJIPPE UIFO UIF TBNF TFBSDI JT SFQFBUFE GSPN UIF OFX QPTJUJPO य़JT GVODUJPOT MJLF B TJNQMF IJMMDMJNCJOH BMHPSJUIN JG MJLFMJIPPE JT FMFWB UJPO UIFO UIF TFBSDI SFBDIFT PVU BOE NFBTVSFT UIF IFJHIU EJ੖FSFODF PG B OFBSCZ QPJOU BOE JG JU JT IJHIFS UBLFT B TUFQ JO UIBU EJSFDUJPO *O UIJT PWFSMZ TJNQMF WFSTJPO PG UIF BMHPSJUIN UIF TFBSDI XPVME SJTL HF॒JOH TUVDL BU B MPDBM NBYJNVN BU UIF UPQ PG B GPPUIJMM SBUIFS UIBO BU UIF UPQ PG UIF NPVOUBJO  UIF SFBM BMHPSJUIN IBT B OVNCFS PG XBZT GPS EFBMJOH XJUI UIJT 3BUIFS UIBO DPNQMFUFMZ JHOPSJOH MPXFS MJLFMJIPPE QPTJUJPOT JO UIF USFF TQBDF UIF TFBSDI XJMM SBOEPNMZ BDDFQU QSPQPTBMT UP NPWF UP MPXFS MJLFMJIPPE QPTJUJPOT JO QSPQPSUJPO UP EJ੖FSFODFT JO MJLFMJIPPE TP JU XPVME CF NVDI NPSF MJLFMZ UP BDDFQU B NPWF UP B QPTJUJPO XIJDI JT POMZ TMJHIUMZ MPXFS CVU XPVME NPTU MJLFMZ SFKFDU B NPWF UP B WFSZ NVDI MPXFS MJLFMJIPPE QPTJUJPO  &WFSZ UIPVTBOE TUFQT PS TP UP BWPJE BVUPDPSSFMBUJPO TBNQMJOH PG TUBUJTUJDBMMZ OPOJOEFQFOEFOU USFFT GSPN UPP DMPTF JO UIF QBSBNFUFS TQBDF

UIF USFF QBSBNFUFST BOE MJLFMJIPPE WBMVF BSF TBWFE UP UIF QPTUFSJPS TBNQMF 'JHVSF  TIPXT B UZQJDBM SFDPSE PG MJLFMJIPPE PS FMFWBUJPO GPS IJMM DMJNCJOH PWFS UIF TFBSDI *G BMM HPFT XFMM BॏFS BO JOJUJBM QFSJPE PG XJME PTDJMMBUJPO UIF TFBSDI SFBDIFT B SFBTPOBCMZ MFWFM NBYJNVN TUBUF य़F JOJUJBM QFSJPE ۘ UIF ۠CVSOJOۡ ۘ JT EJTDBSEFE BOE UIF SFNBJOEFS PG UIF TBNQMF SFQSFTFOUT NPSFPSMFTT FRVBMMZ IJHIMZ MJLFMZ TFUT PG QBSBNFUFST TUSJDUMZ TQFBLJOH UIFZ BSF TBNQMFE JO QSPQPSUJPO UP UIFJS MJLFMJIPPE  *O QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF UIFTF QBSBNFUFST UZQJDBMMZ JODMVEF USFF UPQPMPHZ CSBODI MFOHUIT BOE USBOTJUJPO QSPCBCJMJUJFT  &WPMVUJPOBSZ NPEFMT *O 4FDUJPO  JU XBT NFOUJPOFE UIBU POF PG UIF HSFBU UIFPSFUJDBM XFBLOFTTFT PG HMP॒PDISPOPMPHZ XBT UIBU JU BTTVNFE B DPOTUBOU SBUF PG DIBOHF 3BUF PG DIBOHF JT JODMVEFE JO MJLFMJIPPE BOBMZTFT BT UIF DMPDL NPEFM " TUSJDU DMPDL DPSSFTQPOET UP UIF DPOTUBOU SBUF PG DIBOHF BTTVNQUJPO BOE JO CJPMPHZ BT JO MJOHVJTUJDT JU IBT CFFO TIPXO FNQJSJDBMMZ UP CF JOBQQSPQSJBUF JO NBOZ DBTFT 'FMTFOTUFJO  ۗ  4FWFSBM PUIFS NPSF SFBMJTUJD DMPDL NPEFMT IBWF CFFO EFWJTFE 4P DBMMFE SFMBYFE DMPDL NFUIPET SFMBY UIF TUSJDU DMPDL BTTVNQUJPO CZ BMMPXJOH SBUFT UP WBSZ BDSPTT UIF USFF DIPTFO GSPN B QSPCBCJMJUZ EJTUSJCVUJPO XIPTF NFBO JT EFUFSNJOFE CZ UIF SBUF PG UIF QBSFOU CSBODI %SVNNPOE FU BM   य़JT SFMBYFE DMPDL QBSBNFUFS JT JODPSQPSBUFE BT QBSU 

−950 −1050 −1100

Model B: Post−burnin harmonic mean = −1025

−1200

−1150

Log Likelihood

−1000

Model A: Post−burnin harmonic mean = −1001

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

Iteration (x 10000)

'JHVSF  -JLFMJIPPE USBDF .$.$ TBNQMJOH VOEFS UXP NPEFMT " BOE # य़F #BZFT 'BDUPS   — MJLFMJIPPE PG .PEFM " m MJLFMJIPPE PG .PEFM #   XIJDI JOEJDBUFT ۠WFSZ TUSPOHۡ TVQQPSU GPS .PEFM " TFF 4FDUJPO   PG UIF B QSJPSJ NPEFM PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ DIBOHF %J੖FSFOU LJOET PG QSPCBCJMJUZ EJTUSJCVUJPO DBO NPEFM QSPDFTTFT XIFSF SBUF DIBOHF PDDVST DPOUJOVPVTMZ BMPOH B CSBODI PS XIFSF SBUFT DIBOHF BU OPEFT JOEFQFOEFOUMZ PG CSBODI MFOHUI "OPUIFS DMPDL NPEFM UIF SBOEPN MPDBM DMPDLT NPEFM %SVNNPOE BOE 4VDIBSE 

USFBUT SBUF WBSJBUJPO BT B TFSJFT PG JOEFQFOEFOU MPDBM DMPDLT FBDI FYUFOEJOH PWFS B TVCSFHJPO PG UIF DPNQMFUF USFF य़F OVNCFS PG EJTUJODU MPDBM DMPDLT SFRVJSFE UP BDDPVOU GPS UIF PCTFSWFE EBUB JT B QBSBNFUFS FTUJNBUFE CZ UIJT NPEFM XIJDI NBLFT UIJT UFDI OJRVF BQQMJDBCMF UP RVFTUJPOT PG DMBEFTQFDJ੗D SBUF WBSJBUJPO " OPUF TIPVME BMTP CF NBEF IFSF PG OP DMPDL NPEFMT *O DBTFT XIFSF JU JT VODMFBS XIJDI DMPDL NPEFM JT BQQSPQSJBUF GPS B EBUB TFU JU NJHIU CF UFNQUJOH UP VTF B NPEFM XIJDI FOGPSDFT OP DMPDL BU BMM #VU UIJT XPVME CF B NJTUBLF B OP DMPDLT NPEFM FYQMJDJUMZ TUBUFT UIBU UIFSF JT OP MJNJU PO UIF FWPMVUJPOBSZ WBSJBUJPO CFUXFFO CSBODIFT ۘ BO BTTVNQUJPO XIJDI JT FWFO MFTT MJLFMZ UP CF B HPPE ੗U UP UIF SFBM FWPMVUJPO QSPDFTTFT UIBO BOZ PG UIF PUIFS DMPDL NPEFMT BWBJMBCMF 1ZCVT   "MPOH XJUI UIF DMPDL NPEFM XIJDI TQFDJ੗FT IPX SBUFT DIBOHF HMPCBMMZ BDSPTT CSBODIFT B TVCTUJUVUJPO NPEFM NVTU BMTP CF TQFDJ੗FE JOEJDBUJOH IPX SBUFT EJ੖FS GSPN DIBSBDUFS UP DIBSBDUFS FH GSPN DPHOBUF TFU UP DPHOBUF TFU  .PEFM DPNQMFYJUZ JT EF੗OFE CZ UIF OVNCFS PG QBSBN FUFST UIF NPEFM IBT BOE JO HFOFSBM B HPPE NPEFM TIPVME IBWF BT GFX QBSBNFUFST BT QPTTJCMF 4FDUJPO   य़F CBTJD TVCTUJUVUJPO NPEFMT GPS CJOBSZ EBUB BSF UIF TJNQMF POFSBUF PS UXPSBUF NPEFMT 'JHVSF B  *O B POFSBUF NPEFM B TJOHMF QBSBNFUFS R FYQSFTTFT UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ UIBU B DIBSBDUFS TUBUF  XJMM UVSO JOUP  PS WJDF WFSTB *O B UXPSBUF NPEFM UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ UIBU  XJMM UVSO JOUP  R JT FTUJNBUFE TFQBSBUFMZ GSPN UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ UIBU  XJMM UVSO JOUP  R  य़JT JT 

(ii)

b

Rooted trees (i)

(i)

a

0

1

(ii)

0 1

c

(iii) 1 0

1 0

(iii)

Unrooted tree

a

b

c

b

a

c

c

a

b

'JHVSF  6OSPPUFE BOE SPPUFE USFFT "O VOSPPUFE USFF NBLFT OP BTTVNQUJPOT BCPVU DISPOPMPHZ य़SFF QPTTJCMF SPPUT BSF NBSLFE JۗJJJ  UIF CBS PO UIF CSBODI MFBEJOH UP B JOEJDBUFT B DIBOHF CFUXFFO TUBUF  BOE TUBUF  PG B GFBUVSF LOPXO UP PDDVS PO UIJT CSBODI PG UIF USFF &BDI SPPU IZQPUIFTJT BMMPXT ZPV UP NBLF EJ੖FSFOU JOGFSFODFT BCPVU TVCHSPVQJOH BOE EJSFDUJPOT PG DIBOHF *G UIF USFF JT SPPUFE PO J

UIF TQMJU CFUXFFO B BOE C D JT UIF FBSMJFTU JO UIF USFF BOE UIVT C BOE D BSF TJTUFST BOE UIF FWPMVUJPOBSZ DIBOHF PG TUBUF JT GSPN  UP  JG UIF USFF JT SPPUFE PO JJ UIFO B BOE D BSF TJTUFST BOE SPPUJOH PO JJJ QVUT UIF FBSMJFTU EJWJTJPO CFUXFFO D BOE B C  JO CPUI UIFTF MB॒FS DBTFT UIF FWPMVUJPOBSZ DIBOHF PG UIF GFBUVSF JT  UP  B NPSF SFBMJTUJD NPEFM JO UIBU UIF SBUF PG JOOPWBUJPO JT USFBUFE TFQBSBUFMZ GSPN UIF SBUF PG MPTT " USFF QSPEVDFE VOEFS B UXP SBUF NPEFM NVTU CF SPPUFE TJODF ZPV OFFE UP LOPX UIF SPPU QPTJ UJPO UP LOPX XIFUIFS B DIBOHF JT  ‫  މ‬PS  ‫  މ‬TFF 'JHVSF   4PNF QIZMPHFOFUJDT QBDLBHFT SFRVJSF UIBU UIF SPPU CF TQFDJ੗FE CZ UIF SFTFBSDIFS CVU TJODF UIF SPPU TFMFDUJPO EFUFSNJOFT UIF PWFSBMM USFF MJLFMJIPPE VOEFS BOZ HJWFO SBUFT IZQPUIFTJT JU JT QPTTJCMF UP FTUJNBUF UIF USFF SPPU BT QBSU PG UIF UPQPMPHZ FH BT JO #&"45 4FDUJPO   य़F HBNNB NPEFM BTTVNFT UIBU FBDI DIBS BDUFS CFMPOHT UP POF PG B TQFDJ੗FE OVNCFS PG SBUF DMBTTFT  'JHVSF C TDIFNBUJDBMMZ JMMVTUSBUFT B UISFF DMBTT UXP SBUF WFSTJPO PG UIJT NPEFM य़F SBUFT GPS FBDI DMBTT BSF TBNQMFE GSPN B HBNNB EJTUSJCVUJPO B QSPCBCJMJUZ EJTUSJCVUJPO XJUI UIF VTFGVM QSPQFSUZ UIBU JUT TIBQF JT DPOUSPMMFE CZ B TJOHMF QBSBNFUFS य़JT DPVME CF FYQFDUFE UP CF B CF॒FS ੗U UP MJOHVJTUJD EBUB BT EJ੖FSFOU UFSNT PO UIF 4XBEFTI MJTU IBWF EJ੖FSFOU TUBCJMJUZ य़F DPWBSJPO NPEFM 'JHVSF D HJWFT BOPUIFS XBZ UP BDDPVOU GPS SBUF WBSJBUJPO JO UIF EBUB 6OEFS UIF DPWBSJPO NPEFM UIF SBUF PG FBDI DIBSBDUFS JT BMMPXFE UP WBSZ BMPOH UIF CSBODIFT PG UIF USFF य़F 4UPDIBTUJD %PMMP NPEFM 'JHVSF E DBQUVSFT B LFZ GFBUVSF PG SFBM DPHOBUF IJTUPSJFT UIBU B DPHOBUF TFU NBZ POMZ CF JOOPWBUFE PODF JO UIF EBUBTFU 0OF QBSBNFUFS HPWFSOT UIF EJTUSJCVUJPO PG SBUFT PG DPHOBUF TFUT BSJTJOH JO UIF EBUB BOE BOPUIFS QBSBNFUFS UIF EJTUSJCVUJPO PG SBUFT PG MPTT PG UIFJS SF੘FYFT /JDIPMMT BOE (SBZ   य़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



(a) Binary simple (no rate variation) q One rate (reversible) model

(b) Gamma (among site rate variation) q01 q10 Two rates

(c) Covarion (site-specific rate variation)

(d) Stochastic Dollo (cognate-birth, word-death)

'JHVSF  4VCTUJUVUJPO NPEFMT (BJOT BOE MPTTFT PG SF੘FYFT PG DPHOBUF TFUT BSF NPEFMMFE BT B

PDDVSJOH BU B TJOHMF SBUF PS BU B EJTUJODU SBUF GPS HBJOT BOE B GPS MPTTFT C EJ੖FSFOU SBUFT GPS EJ੖FSFOU DPHOBUF TFUT D EJ੖FSFOU SBUFT GPS EJ੖FSFOU CSBODIFT BOE E B SBUF PG JOOPWBUJPO BOE B SBUF PG MPTT  *OUFSQSFUJOH UIF SFTVMUT 

.PEFM ࠩPJDF

य़F MJLFMJIPPE TDPSF PG BO BOBMZTJT JT UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ GPS UIF PCTFSWFE EBUB UP FWPMWF HJWFO B QBSUJDVMBS NPEFM &WFO BTTVNJOH UIBU GPS FBDI NPEFM UIF PQUJNBM QBSBNFUFS WBMVFT IBWF CFFO JOGFSSFE TPNF NPEFMT TUJMM ੗U CF॒FS UIBO PUIFST य़F EJ੖FSFODF JO BDDFQUBCJMJUZ PG UXP NPEFMT DBO CF FYQSFTTFE CZ UIF #BZFT 'BDUPS XIJDI JT DBMDVMBUFE BT UIF SBUJP PG - )‫ ܒ‬UIF MJLFMJIPPE PG IZQPUIFTJT POF BMTP FYQSFTTFE BT ۠1S %])‫ ۡ ܒ‬UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ PG UIF EBUB % VOEFS )‫ ܒ‬UP UIF MJLFMJIPPE PG - )‫ ܓ‬PS ۠1S %])‫ ۡ ܓ‬BT GPMMPXT #'‫ ܓܒ‬

- )‫ ܒ‬ - )‫ ܓ‬

य़F #BZFT 'BDUPS TUBUJTUJD JT PॏFO FYQSFTTFE BT UXJDF JUT OBUVSBM MPHBSJUIN MPH#'‫ ܓܒ‬SBUIFS UIBO VTJOH UIF SBX SBUJP #'‫ ܓܒ‬-JLFMJIPPE SBUJPT BSF UIF TBNF BT UIF EJ੖FSFODF JO MPHMJLFMJIPPET UIVT MPH#'‫   ܓܒ‬MPH- )‫ ۗ ܒ‬MPH- )‫ 

ܓ‬य़F JOUFSQSFUBUJPO PG UIF #BZFT 'BDUPS TUBUJTUJDT BSF HJWFO JO 5BCMF  य़F #BZFT 'BDUPS JT OPU MJLF B QWBMVF JU JT POMZ NFBOJOHGVM JO UFTUJOH POF IZQPUIFTJT BHBJOTU BOPUIFS " OFHBUJWF #BZFT 'BDUPS TJNQMZ TVQQPSUT )‫ ܓ‬PWFS )‫ ܒ‬XIJDI JODJEFOUBMMZ NFBOT UIBU UIF #BZFT 'BDUPS UFTU DBO HJWF FWJEFODF JO GBWPVS PG UIF OVMM IZQPUIFTJT UIF TUSPOHFTU FWJ EFODF GSFRVFOUJTU TUBUJTUJDT DBO HJWF GPS UIF OVMM IZQPUIFTJT JT OPU UP SVMF JU PVU  /PUF BMTP UIBU UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ PG HF॒JOH UIF PCTFSWFE EBUB XJUI B NPEFM IBT OPUIJOH UP EP XJUI UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ UIBU UIF NPEFM JT DPSSFDU य़F CFTU NPEFM JT BT TJNQMF BT QPTTJCMF CVU OPU TJNQMFS B NBYJN B॒SJCVUFE UP &JOTUFJO  8IFSF MJLFMJIPPE SBUJPT EP OPU QSPWJEF B DMFBS GSPOUSVOOFS UIF BOBMZTJT TIPVME CF CBTFE VQPO UIF GSPOUSVOOJOH NPEFM XJUI UIF GFXFTU QBSBNFUFST 

5SFF TBNQMF

य़F SFTVMUT PG B #BZFTJBO QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF BOBMZTJT BSF B TBNQMF PG USFFT BT XFMM BT MPHT PG PUIFS NPEFM QBSBNFUFST PG JOUFSFTU BTTPDJBUFE XJUI FBDI PG UIFTF USFFT

TBNQMFE JO QSPQPS 

#'‫ܓܒ‬  UP   UP   UP  

MPH#'‫ܓܒ‬  UP   UP   UP  

&WJEFODF GPS )‫ ܒ‬PWFS )‫ܓ‬ /FHMJHJCMF 1PTJUJWF 4USPOH 7FSZ TUSPOH

5BCMF  (VJEFMJOFT GPS UIF JOUFSQSFUBUJPO PG #BZFT 'BDUPST BOE -PH #BZFT 'BDUPST BॏFS ,BTT BOE 3BॏFSZ  

UJPO UP UIFJS QPTUFSJPS QSPCBCJMJUZ य़JT TBNQMF UZQJDBMMZ SVOT UP UIPVTBOET PG USFFT BOE JU JT PG DPVSTF OPU GFBTJCMF TJNQMZ UP JOTQFDU JU CZ FZF 4VNNBSJ[JOH BMM UIJT PVUQVU JO B TJOHMF DPIFSFOU OBSSBUJWF JT EJਖ਼DVMU य़JT JT VTVBMMZ CFTU EPOF VTJOH TPNF GPSN PG WJTVBM TVNNBSZ य़FSF BSF TFWFSBM QPTTJCJMJUJFT 'PS B USFF TBNQMF NPTU QSBDUJUJPOFST DVSSFOUMZ QSFGFS B NBYJNVN DMBEF DSFEJCJMJUZ USFF 'JHVSF B  य़JT JT B USFF TFMFDUFE GSPN UIF USFF TBNQMF XIJDI NBYJNJ[FT UIF QSPEVDU PG MJLFMJIPPET PG FBDI PG JUT CSBODIFT य़JT USFF DBO CF USFBUFE BT UIF CFTU SFQSFTFOUBUJWF PG UIF USFF TBNQMF #SBODI MFOHUIT BSF VTVBMMZ UBLFO GSPN UIF NFEJBO PS NFBO PG DPSSFTQPOEJOH CSBODIFT JO UIF TBNQMF " NBYJNVN DMBEF DSFEJCJMJUZ USFF DBO CF DPOTUSVDUFE VTJOH UIF 5SFF"O OPUBUPS UPPM PG UIF #&"45 QBDLBHF %SVNNPOE FU BM   य़F DPOTFOTVT USFF NFUIPE IBT BMTP CFFO QPQVMBS BT B XBZ PG TVNNBSJ[JOH TFUT PG USFFT $POTFOTVT USFFT BSF CVJMU CZ SBOLJOH BMM UIF CJOBSZ TQMJUT JO B USFF TBNQMF BOE CVJMEJOH B USFF XIJDI JODMVEFT BMM UIF CSBODIFT UIBU EPO‫۝‬U DPOUSBEJDU BOZ NPSF IJHIMZ SBOLFE CSBODI 0OF PG UIF EJTBEWBOUBHFT PG B DPOTFOTVT USFF JT UIBU UIFSF JT OP HVBSBOUFF UIBU B USFF XJUI UIF TBNF UPQPMPHZ BT UIF DPOTFOTVT USFF XJMM BDUVBMMZ CF QSFTFOU JO UIF USFF TBNQMF य़FSF JT OP HFOFSBMMZ BDDFQUFE XBZ UP TQFDJGZ UIF CSBODI MFOHUIT PG B DPOTFOTVT USFF $POTFOTVT USFFT DBO CF NBEF VTJOH NBOZ EJ੖FSFOU TPॏXBSF QBDLBHFT UIF ۠DPOTFOTVTۡ GVODUJPO PG UIF "1& QBDLBHF JO 3 1BSBEJT $MBVEF BOE 4USJNNFS  TFF BMTP 4FDUJPO  JT B DPOWFOJFOU BOE ੘FYJCMF PQUJPO 8IJDIFWFS LJOE PG USFF SFQSFTFOUBUJPO JT VTFE JU JT OPSNBMMZ EFTJSBCMF UP BOOPUBUF CSBODIFT XJUI DPO੗EFODF FTUJNBUFT UIFJS QPTUFSJPS QSPCBCJM JUJFT GPS B #BZFTJBO USFF PUIFS LJOET PG DPO੗EFODF FTUJNBUFT TVDI BT CPPUTUSBQ WBMVFT FYJTU GPS OPO#BZFTJBO USFFT  " %FOTJ5SFF WJTVBMJ[BUJPO PG UIF USFF TBNQMF HJWFT B WJWJE SFQSFTFOUBUJPO PG UIF FOUJSF USFF TBNQMF CZ PWFSQMP॒JOH BMM UIF USFFT PG UIF TBNQMF JO QBSUJBM USBOTQBSFODZ 'JH VSF C  'JOBMMZ JG DPO੘JDUJOH HSPVQJOHT JO UIF USFF TBNQMF BSF PG JOUFSFTU UIF USFF TBNQMF DBO CF TVNNBSJTFE XJUI B DPOTFOTVT OFUXPSL )PMMBOE FU BM   &BDI CSBODI PG B USFF JO UIF USFF TBNQMF SFQSFTFOUT B QPTTJCMF CJOBSZ TQMJU PG UIF EBUB य़FTF TQMJUT BSF XFJHIUFE BDDPSEJOH UP UIFJS GSFRVFODZ BOE VTFE UP DPNQVUF B TQMJUT HSBQI 8IFSF UIF TQMJUT BSF DPNQBUJCMF UIF TQMJUT HSBQI JT JEFOUJDBM UP B USFF XIFSF TQMJUT BSF JODPNQBUJCMF FBDI TQMJU JT SFQSFTFOUFE CZ B DPMMFDUJPO PG QBSBMMFM FEHFT XIFSF JODPNQBUJCMF TQMJUT BSF PSUIPHPOBM TFF 'JHVSF D  य़F MFOHUI PG UIF FEHFT DBO CF VTFE UP SFQSFTFOU UIF XFJHIU JO UIJT DBTF GSFRVFODZ PG UIF TQMJU 

1SJPST

0OF PG UIF HSFBU BEWBOUBHFT PG UIF #BZFTJBO BQQSPBDI UP JOGFSFODF JT UIBU JU BMMPXT ZPV UP JOUF HSBUF NBOZ EJ੖FSFOU GPSNT PG QSJPS LOPXMFEHF "QBSU GSPN UIF EJTUSJCVUJPOBM QSJPST PO NPEFM QBSBNFUFST 4FDUJPO 

JU JT GSFRVFOUMZ EFTJSBCMF UP JOUFHSBUF B QSJPSJ LOPXO FMFNFOUT PG USFF TUSVDUVSF य़JT JT EPOF CZ DPOTUSBJOJOH UIF .$.$ TFBSDI UP UIPTF QBSUT PG UIF QBSBNFUFS TQBDF 

'JHVSF  4VNNBSJ[JOH UIF QPTUFSJPS USFF TBNQMF "TMJBO QIZMPHFOJFT %VOO #VSFOIVMU FU BM  WJTVBMJ[FE XJUI B .BYJNVN $MBEF $SFEJCJMJUZ .$$ 5SFF C %FOTJ5SFF BOE D $PO TFOTVT /FUXPSL /PUF IPX UIF VODFSUBJOUZ BCPVU UIF DMBTTJ੗DBUJPO PG UIF MBOHVBHF ۠+BI )VUۡ JT SF੘FDUFE CZ B MPX QPTUFSJPS QSPCBCJMJUZ WBMVFT C NVMUJQMF QPJOUT PG PSJHJO BOE D B CPY TIPXJOH DPO੘JDUJOH TQMJUT XIFSF UIF USFF UPQPMPHJFT BSF DPOTJTUFOU XJUI UIF QSJPS LOPXMFEHF य़JT DBO IBWF UIF TJNQMF QSBDUJDBM BEWBOUBHF PG TQFFEJOH VQ UIF BOBMZTJT ۘ JG UIF EBUB DPOUBJO B TUSPOH TJHOBM GPS QBS UJDVMBS FMFNFOUT PG TUSVDUVSF UIFO TFBSDIJOH PUIFS QBSUT PG UIF USFF TQBDF NBZ TJNQMZ CF VO OFDFTTBSZ #VU USFF QSJPST BSF BMTP UIF NPTU EJSFDU XBZ UP JOUFHSBUF TVCHSPVQJOH LOPXMFEHF CBTFE PO MJOHVJTUJD $PNQBSBUJWF .FUIPE DSJUFSJB TVDI BT QIPOPMPHJDBM BOE NPSQIPMPHJDBM JO OPWBUJPOT $POTUSBJOJOH UIF USFF TFBSDI UP BSFBT PG UIF QBSBNFUFS TQBDF XIJDI BSF DPOTJTUFOU XJUI DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE JOOPWBUJPOCBTFE TVCHSPVQJOH JT B QFSGFDUMZ WBMJE XBZ PG JOUFHSBUJOH USBEJUJPOBM DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE BOE DPNQVUBUJPOBM QIZMPHFOFUJD NFUIPET PG USFF JOGFSFODF BOE DBO HJWF SFTVMUT XIJDI BSF HSFBUFS UIBO UIF TVN PG UIFJS QBSUT DPNCJOJOH DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE TVCHSPVQJOH JOGPSNBUJPO JOUP B #BZFTJBO .$.$ BOBMZTJT BT QSJPST BMMPXT JOGFSFODF PG J USFFT XIJDI BSF GVSUIFS SFTPMWFE UIBO UIF TVCHSPVQJOHT QSPWJEFE CZ TPVOE DIBOHFT JJ DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE USFFT XJUI NFBOJOHGVM CSBODI MFOHUIT PS DISPOPMPHJDBM DBMJCSBUJPOT BOE JJJ DPNQBSB UJWF NFUIPE USFFT XJUI RVBOUJ੗FE FTUJNBUFT PG VODFSUBJOUZ BOE SBUF DIBOHF *O BEEJUJPO #BZFTJBO 1IZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF NFUIPET DBO CF VTFE UP UFTU CFUXFFO DPNQFU JOH TFUT PG QSJPST VTJOH UIF MJLFMJIPPE SBUJPT UFTU 4FDUJPO   'PS JOTUBODF XIFSF UIFSF BSF DPO੘JDUJOH USFF DPOTUSBJOUT CBTFE PO BQQBSFOU TIBSFE JOOPWBUJPOT B MJLFMJIPPE SBUJP UFTU XPVME BMMPX B UFTU PG XIFUIFS UIF DPHOBUF IJTUPSJFT TVQQPSU POF TVCHSPVQJOH IZQPUIFTJT PWFS UIF PUIFS



 .PSF DPNQMFY DBTFT *U JT BMTP QPTTJCMF UP VTF QIPOPMPHJDBM BOE NPSQIPMPHJDBM JOOPWBUJPOT BT DIBSBDUFST JO UIF BOBM ZTJT SBUIFS UIBO DPOTUSBJOUT य़JT JT UIF BQQSPBDI UBLFO CZ 3JOHF 8BSOPX BOE 5BZMPS 

BOE /BLIMFI 

JO BO BOBMZTJT XIJDI TFFLT UP SFDPODJMF CPUI DPHOBUF IJTUPSJFT BOE TIBSFE QIPOPMPHJDBM BOE NPSQIPMPHJDBM JOOPWBUJPOT 8JUIJO UIF #BZFTJBO 1IZMPHFOFUJD *OGFSFODF BQ QSPBDI JU XPVME QSPCBCMZ CF NPTU BQQSPQSJBUF UP EP UIJT VTJOH QBSUJUJPOT ۘ DBSSZJOH PVU UIF BOBMZTJT XJUI B EJ੖FSFOU NPEFM VTFE GPS DPHOBUF FWPMVUJPO UIBO GPS NPSQIPMPHJDBMQIPOPMPHJDBM JOOPWBUJPOT " TJNJMBS QBSUJUJPOFE BOBMZTJT DBO CF VTFE UP DBSSZ PVU QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF PO PUIFS LJOET PG EJTQBSBUF EBUB XIFSF EJ੖FSFOU FWPMVUJPOBSZ QSPDFTTFT BQQMZ UP EJ੖FSFOU QBSUT PG UIF EBUB %VOO FU BM  BOE %VOO  QSFTFOU #BZFTJBO 1IZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODFT CBTFE PO UZQP MPHJDBM GFBUVSFT PG MBOHVBHF SBUIFS UIBO MFYJDPO य़F SBUJPOBMF JO UIJT DBTF XBT UP JOWFTUJHBUF UIF IJTUPSZ PG B TFU PG MBOHVBHFT TIPXJOH UZQPMPHJDBM TJNJMBSJUJFT XIJDI XFSF TVHHFTUJWF PG B IJTUPS JDBM SFMBUJPOTIJQ CVU XIJDI EJE OPU TIPX MFYJDBM TJNJMBSJUJFT TVਖ਼DJFOU UP EFNPOTUSBUF UIFJS SF MBUFEOFTT 4FF BMTP %VOO BOE 5FSSJMM   य़JT BQQSPBDI IBT CFFO BEPQUFE GPS MBOHVBHFT XIFSF TVਖ਼DJFOUMZ DPNQMFUF XPSE MJTUT BSF VOBWBJMBCMF FH %BOJ«MTFO %VOO BOE .VZTLFO   य़F SFMJBCJMJUZ PG IJTUPSJDBM JOGFSFODF CBTFE PO UZQPMPHJDBM GFBUVSFT JT UIF TVCKFDU PG TPNF DPOUSPWFSTZ %POPIVF BOE .VTHSBWF  %VOO FU BM   B OPODPOUSPWFSTJBM VTF PG UZQPMPHJDBM GFBUVSFT JT GPS DPNQBSJTPO PG UIF MJOHVJTUJD TJNJMBSJUZ CFUXFFO MBOHVBHFT XIJDI BSF OPU PS OPU LOPXO UP CF SFMBUFE GPS UIF QVSQPTFT PG IZQPUIFTJT HFOFSBUJPO PS UFTUJOH QB॒FSOT PG HFOFUJD WFSTVT MJOHVJTUJD EJWFSTJUZ %VOO  3FFTJOL 4JOHFS BOE %VOO  )VOMFZ FU BM    " OVNCFS PG #BZFTJBO QIZMPHFOFUJD NFUIPET EFBM XJUI SFUJDVMBUJPO य़F SFUJDVMBUFE USFF NPEFM PG 4IJKVMBM FU BM  BEBQUT TPNF PG UIF JOTJHIUT PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ NJDSPCJPMPHZ UP MJOHVJT UJD RVFTUJPOT PG GBNJMZJOUFSOBM CPSSPXJOH #BDUFSJBM FWPMVUJPO JT IJHIMZ DPNQMFY BT CBDUFSJB IBWF B OVNCFS PG NFDIBOJTNT XIJDI BMMPX UIFN UP DPNCJOF BOE FYDIBOHF %/" JODMVEJOH TXBQ QJOH PG UIF %/" DPEJOH GPS DPNQMFUF GVODUJPOBM TVCTZTUFNT FH BOUJCJPUJD SFTJTUBODF  " OB¯WF SFDPOTUSVDUJPO PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ IJTUPSZ PG CBDUFSJB XPVME JOGFS BO BODFTUSBM NFHBCBDUFSJVN BM SFBEZ FNCPEZJOH UIF QSFDVSTPST UP BMM UIF %/" EJWFSTJUZ PG JUT EFTDFOEBOUT य़F FTTFOUJBM JOTJHIU PG UIJT NFUIPE JT UP BQQMZ UIF VOJGPSNJUBSJBO IZQPUIFTJT UIBU CBDUFSJB JO UIF QBTU XFSF OPU TVC TUBOUJBMMZ EJ੖FSFOU UP CBDUFSJB JO UIF QSFTFOU NPSF QSFDJTFMZ UIF TJ[F PG UIF HFOPNF PG BODFTUSBM CBDUFSJB TIPVME ੗U XJUIJO UIF EJTUSJCVUJPO PG PCTFSWFE HFOPNF TJ[FT JO QSFTFOUEBZ CBDUFSJB " #BZFTJBO QIZMPHFOFUJD USFF TFBSDI JT DBSSJFE PVU XJUI BO BEEJUJPOBM ۠IPSJ[POUBM HFOF USBOTGFSۡ QBSBNFUFS य़JT QBSBNFUFS JT PQUJNJTFE UP NBJOUBJO UIF JOGFSSFE HFOPNF TJ[F BU BODFTUSBM OPEFT UP XJUIJO UIF TUBUJTUJDBM EJTUSJCVUJPO PG LOPXO CBDUFSJB य़F MJOHVJTUJD BEBQUBUJPO PG UIJT VTFT UIF TBNF MPHJD SBUIFS UIBO JOGFSSJOH BO BODFTUSBM MBOHVBHF DPOUBJOJOH BMM UIF MFYJDBM EJWFSTJUZ PG UIF DPOUFNQPSBSZ MBOHVBHFT UIF BMHPSJUIN JOGFST MFYJDBM USBOTGFS XIFSF JU DBO Fਖ਼DJFOUMZ BDDPVOU GPS TIBSFE DPHOBUFT JO EJTUBOU CSBODIFT #Z LFFQJOH UIF JOGFSSFE TJ[F PG UIF BODFTUSBM MFYJDPO XJUIJO UIF CPVOET PG UIF PCTFSWFE EJTUSJCVUJPO UIJT BWPJET QVTIJOH UIF EBUF PG QSPUPGPSNT GVS UIFS CBDL UIBO UIFZ OFFE UP CF 3JOHF 8BSOPX BOE 5BZMPS  UBLF B EJ੖FSFOU LJOE PG QFSTQFDUJWF UP UIF QSPCMFN PG 

QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF GSPN UIF #BZFTJBO JOGFSFODF BQQSPBDI य़FZ EFWFMPQ BO BMHPSJUIN UP UFTU UIF QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOZ QSPCMFN UIBU JT XIFUIFS B USFF DBO CF GPVOE XIJDI QFSGFDUMZ SFDPODJMFT B TFU PG QIPOPMPHJDBM NPSQIPMPHJDBM BOE MFYJDBM DIBSBDUFST *O B TFSJFT PG UFTUT PO EBUB GSPN UIF *OEP&VSPQFBO MBOHVBHF GBNJMZ UIFZ TIPX UIBU B QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOZ JT OPU QPTTJCMF 8IJMF NPTU DIBSBDUFST XFSF DPNQBUJCMF XJUI B TJOHMF FWPMVUJPOBSZ USFF UIFSF XFSF JODPOTJTUFODJFT MPDBMJTFE QBSUJDVMBSMZ JO UIF (FSNBOJD MBOHVBHFT QSFTVNBCMZ SF੘FDUJOH CPSSPXJOH &YUFOTJPOT PG UIJT NFUIPE SFQPSUFE JO /BLIMFI 3JOHF BOE 8BSOPX   8BSOPX FU BM 

BEBQU UIF QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOJFT NFUIPE UP TFBSDI JOTUFBE GPS QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOFUJD OFUXPSLT य़F QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOFUJD OFUXPSL JOGFST B USFF XJUI B DFSUBJO OVNCFS PG DPOUBDUSFUJDVMBUF CSBODIFT XIJDI BMMPX IPSJ[POUBM USBOTGFS FWFOUT य़F NFUIPE TFFLT UP NBYJNJTF UIF BNPVOU PG USFFMJLF DIBSBDUFS USBOTNJTTJPO BT QFS UIF QSFWJPVT QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOFUJD USFF BQQSPBDI

BOE NJOJNJTF UIF DPOUBDU FEHFT BOE USBOTGFS FWFOUT *O B DPNQMFUF EFQBSUVSF GSPN USFF BOE OFUXPSL NPEFMT UIF 4536$563& NFUIPE 1SJUDIBSE 4UFQIFOT BOE %POOFMMZ  3PTFOCFSH FU BM  JOGFST BODFTUSBM QPQVMBUJPO TUSVDUVSF CZ NPEFMMJOH FWPMVUJPOBSZ BENJYUVSF य़JT NFUIPE IBT CFFO VTFE CZ 3FFTJOL 4JOHFS BOE %VOO  UP JOWFTUJHBUF MBOHVBHF EJTQFSTBM BOE DPOUBDU JO UIF 4BIVM SFHJPO BOE FYQMPSF UIF QPTTJCMF USBDFT PG BODJFOU "VTUSBMJBO1BQVBO DPOOFDUJPOT  5FTUJOH IZQPUIFTFT BCPVU MBOHVBHF ࠩBOHF फ़BOUJUBUJWF QIZMPHFOFUJD BQQSPBDIFT UP MBOHVBHF DIBOHF TIPVME OPU CF USFBUFE TPMFMZ BT BO BMUFSOBUJWF UP USBEJUJPOBM NFUIPET JO IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT "T B UPPM GPS JOGFSSJOH MBOHVBHF QIZ MPHFOZ RVBOUJUBUJWF NFUIPET BSF JOTFQBSBCMF GSPN UIF $PNQBSBUJWF .FUIPE य़FZ BSF NFUIPE PMPHJDBMMZ JOTFQBSBCMF CFDBVTF UIFZ SFMZ PO UIF TBNF GVOEBNFOUBM OPUJPOT TVDI BT ۠DPHOBDZۡ CVU BMTP DPODFQUVBMMZ JOTFQBSBCMF CFDBVTF UIF $PNQBSBUJWF .FUIPE QSPWJEFT B LJOE PG HPME TUBOEBSE GPS FWBMVBUJOH OFX QIZMPHFOFUJD SFTVMUT #VU GSPN BOPUIFS QFSTQFDUJWF RVBOUJUBUJWF QIZMPHFOFUJD NFUIPET IBWF NVDI CSPBEFS BNCJUJPOT UIBU UIFZ BSF UIF ੗STU TUFQ GPS JODPSQPSBU JOH TUBUJTUJDBMMZ GSBNFE NPEFMT PG IJTUPSJDBM SFMBUFEOFTT JOUP UFTUT PG IZQPUIFTFT BCPVU FWPMWFE QIFOPNFOB *O B SBUIFS VOGPSUVOBUF DPMMJTJPO PG UFSNJOPMPHZ UIFTF NFUIPET BSF DBMMFE ۠DPN QBSBUJWF NFUIPETۡ JO FWPMVUJPOBSZ CJPMPHZ MFTT PॏFO ۠य़F $PNQBSBUJWF .FUIPEۡ CVU TFF )BS WFZ BOE 1BHFM   1IZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPET VTF QIZMPHFOFUJD USFFT UP NPEFM PUIFS FWPMWFE BTQFDUT PG MBOHVBHF य़JT DBO JOWPMWF JOGFSFODF PG BODFTUSBM TUBUFT UFTUT PG EJTQFSTBM PS EFS PG MBOHVBHFT SBUFT PG DIBOHF BOE FWPMVUJPOBSZ SFHJNF DPFWPMVUJPO PG BTQFDUT PG MBOHVBHF PS PG MBOHVBHF BOE DVMUVSF .BDF BOE 1BHFM  93&'(SFFOIJMM   %BUJOH BOE 1IZMPHFPHSBQIZ य़F UFDIOJRVFT GPS EBUJOH QIZMPHFOFUJD USFFT BSF DMPTFMZ JOUFHSBUFE JOUP #BZFTJBO QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF BT JNQMFNFOUFE CZ UIF #&"45 QBDLBHF BMUIPVHI JU JT QPTTJCMF UP MPH USFFT DBMJCSBUFE CZ TVCTUJUVUJPO SBUFT POMZ *U JT POMZ B TNBMM DPODFQUVBM TUFQ GSPN TVCTUJUVUJPO SBUFT UP DISPOP MPHJDBM SBUFT JG TPNF USFFJOUFSOBM DISPOPMPHJDBM DBMJCSBUJPO QPJOUT BSF LOPXO TVDI BT BODJFOU JOTDSJQUJPOT SFDPSEJOH UIF BSSJWBM PG B OFX FUIOPMJOHVJTUJD HSPVQ PS BSDIBFPMPHJDBM FWJEFODF EBUJOH UIF ੗STU BSSJWBM PO BO JTMBOE

OPSNBMJ[JOH GBDUPST DBO CF DBMDVMBUFE GPS FBDI CSBODI BD DPSEJOH UP XIBU JT SFRVJSFE UP NPSQI UIF VODBMJCSBUFE USFF TP BT UP NBUDI UIF DBMJCSBUJPO QPJOUT 

य़F EBUFT PG JOUFSOBM OPEFT BSF TQFDJ੗FE BT B QSPCBCJMJUZ EJTUSJCVUJPO BOE EJ੖FSFOU UZQFT PG EJTUSJCVUJPO DBO FYQSFTT EJ੖FSFOU LJOET PG QSJPS LOPXMFEHF " MPHOPSNBM QSJPS DBO FYQSFTT B TJUVBUJPO XIFSF XF LOPX UIBU OPEF /‫ ܒ‬NVTU CF EBUFE CFGPSF UJNF 5‫ ܒ‬CVU VOMJLFMZ UP CF B MPOH UJNF CFGPSF B OPSNBM QSJPS FYQSFTTFT LOPXMFEHF UIBU OPEF /‫ ܓ‬NVTU CF BSPVOE UJNF 5‫ ܓ‬XJUI B DFSUBJO TUBOEBSE EFWJBUJPO B VOJGPSN QSJPS FYQSFTTFT UIBU OPEF /‫ ܔ‬NVTU CF TPNF UJNF CFUXFFO 5‫ ܔ‬BOE 5‫ ܕ‬%VSJOH UIF .$.$ QBSBNFUFS TFBSDI JU JT QPTTJCMF UP MPH UIF JOGFSSFE EBUFT GPS UIF SPPU BOE BOZ PUIFS VOPCTFSWFE JOUFSOBM OPEFT PG JOUFSFTU 0UIFS LJOET PG IJTUPSJDBM QSJPS BSF BMTP QPTTJCMF *O UIF QIZMPHFPHSBQIJD BQQSPBDI B NPEFM PG TQBUJBM EJ੖VTJPO JT JODPSQPSBUFE JOUP UIF NPEFM BMPOH XJUI TQBUJBM QSJPST 8BMLFS BOE 3JCFJSP  #PVDLBFSU FU BM   य़JT BMMPXT QSPCBCJMJTUJD JOGFSFODF PG UIF TQBUJBM MPDBUJPO PG QBSUJDVMBS OPEFT JO UIF QBTU "T UIF TQBUJBM JOGFSFODF JT JODPSQPSBUFE JOUP UIF MJLFMJIPPE DBMDVMBUJPO UIJT SFQSFTFOUT B QSJODJQMFE WJPMBUJPO PG UIF QSJODJQMF PG ۠0OMZ -JOHVJTUJD &WJEFODFۡ $BNQCFMM     $IBSBDUFS FWPMVUJPO 0OF PG UIF QSJODJQBM VTFT PG QIZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPET JT UP NPEFM UIF FWPMVUJPO PG DIBS BDUFST BMPOH USFFT य़F USFF JT HFOFSBUFE JOEFQFOEFOUMZ UP UIJT BOBMZTJT JO F੖FDU UIF #BZFTJBO USFF TBNQMF JT B QIZMPHFOFUJD QSJPS JO UIF BOBMZTJT PG UIF FWPMVUJPOBSZ CFIBWJPVS PG BOPUIFS DIBSBDUFS 1IZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPET DBO CF VTFE UP JOGFS BODFTUSBM TUBUFT PG B GFBUVSF XIJDI JT LOPXO UP FWPMWF BMPOH XJUI UIF GBNJMZ य़FSF BSF UISFF SFRVJSFNFOUT J B HFOFBMPHJDBM IZQPUIFTJT JJ B NPEFM PG USBOTJUJPOT CFUXFFO TUBUFT PG B GFBUVSF FH QSPCBCJMJUJFT GPS USBOTJUJPO GSPN ۜQSFTFODF‫ ۝‬UP ۜBCTFODF‫ ۝‬BOE GSPN ۜBCTFODF‫ ۝‬UP ۜQSFTFODF‫ ۝‬BOE JJJ B TFU PG PCTFSWBUJPOT PG GFBUVSF TUBUFT GSPN UIF UJQT PG UIF USFF 'SPN UIFTF UIF NFUIPE BMMPXT VT UP JOGFS UIF NPTU MJLFMZ QBSBNFUFST PG UIF NPEFM BOE UIVT UP NBLF QSPCBCJMJTUJD KVEHFNFOUT BCPVU UIF TUBUF PG UIF GFBUVSF BU VOPCTFSWFE OPEFT PG UIF USFF य़JT JT B TUBOEBSE UFDIOJRVF VTFE JO DPNQVUBUJPOBM QIZMPHF OFUJDT BOE IBT CFFO BQQMJFE JO DVMUVSBM FWPMVUJPOBSZ TUVEJFT PG LJOTIJQ BOE SFTJEFODF TZTUFNT JO "VTUSPOFTJBO +PSEBO FU BM  +PSEBO  BOE *OEP&VSPQFBO TPDJFUJFT 'PSUVOBUP )PMEFO BOE .BDF  'PSUVOBUP B C D

BT XFMM BT UP JOGFS BODFTUSBM TVCTJTUFODF NPEF JO #BOUVTQFBLJOH TPDJFUJFT .BDF BOE )PMEFO   "ODFTUSBM TUBUF SFDPOTUSVDUJPO NFUIPET IBWF CBSFMZ CFHVO UP CF FYQMPJUFE GPS QVSFMZ MJOHVJTUJD RVFTUJPOT 1IZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPET DBO BMTP CF VTFE UP UFTU GPS FWPMVUJPOBSZ EFQFOEFODJFT JF XIFUIFS DIBOHFT JO POF USBJU PO B USFF SFHVMBSMZ DPSSFTQPOE UP DIBOHFT JO BOPUIFS USBJU य़JT UFDIOJRVF DVSSFOUMZ BWBJMBCMF BT UIF %*4$3&5& UFTU JO UIF #BZFT5SBJUT QBDLBHF IBT CFFO VTFE UP UFTU FWPMVUJPOBSZ IZQPUIFTFT JO BOUISPQPMPHZ BOE MJOHVJTUJDT )PMEFO BOE .BDF   VTF UIF NFUIPE UP TIPX IPX UIF DVMUVSBM JOOPWBUJPO PG QBTUPSBMJTN MFE UP UIF FWPMVUJPO PG MBDUPTF UPMFSBODF BOE QBUSJMJOFBM EFTDFOU JO #BOUV TPDJFUJFT TFF BMTP .BDF BOE )PMEFO   %VOO (SFFOIJMM FU BM  VTF UIF TBNF NFUIPET UP UFTU TPNF PG %SZFS‫۝‬T HFOFSBMJ[BUJPOT BCPVU UIF (SFFOCFSHJBO XPSE PSEFS VOJWFSTBMT  &WPMVUJPOBSZ PSEFSJOH BOE FWPMVUJPOBSZ NPEF * EBUF UIF TUBSU PG UIF NPEFSO QIZMPHFOFUJD FSB JO MJOHVJTUJDT UP (SBZ BOE +PSEBO 

XIPTF DMFWFS USFBUNFOU PG EJTQFSTBM PSEFS BT BO PSEFSFE TFU PG NVMUJTUBUF GFBUVSFT BMMPXFE UIFN UP 

VTF B QBSTJNPOZ BOBMZTJT UP UFTU UIF 5BJXBOFTF 0SJHJO IZQPUIFTJT GPS "VTUSPOFTJBO -BUFS #BZFTJBO BOBMZTFT BEESFTTJOH UIF TBNF RVFTUJPO IBWF JNQSPWFE VQPO UIFTF CFHJOOJOHT TUBUJT UJDBMMZ CVU IBWF OPU QSPEVDFE B TVCTUBOUJBMMZ EJ੖FSFOU SFTVMU (SBZ %SVNNPOE BOE (SFFOIJMM   )PMEFO  BEESFTTFT B TJNJMBS RVFTUJPO GPS #BOUVTQFBLJOH DVMUVSFT CVU JO UFSNT PG TVCTJTUFODF SBUIFS UIBO TQBUJBM MPDBUJPO य़F CFTU LOPXO TUVEZ JT "ULJOTPO FU BM 

XIJDI UFTUFE XIFUIFS UIF "VTUSPOFTJBO MBO HVBHFT TIPXFE QVODUVBUFE FWPMVUJPO PS KVNQT JO UIF SBUF PG DIBOHF DPSSFMBUJOH XJUI OPEFT PO UIF USFF 1VODUVBUFE FWPMVUJPO DBO CF NFBTVSFE XJUI 1BHFM‫ڣ‬T ͜ POF PG 1BHFM‫۝‬T UISFF DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE TUBUJTUJDT 1BHFM    1BHFM‫ڣ‬T ͝ BMPOH XJUI #MPNCFSH‫ڣ‬T , UFTUT GPS QIZMPHFOFUJD TJH OBM UIF FYUFOU UP XIJDI B USBJU FH B GFBUVSF PG MBOHVBHF GPMMPXT B QB॒FSO XIJDI JT EFUFSNJOFE CZ QIZMPHFOZ 1BHFM   #MPNCFSH (BSMBOE BOE *WFT   1BHFM‫۝‬T PUIFS QIZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE UFTU 1BHFM‫ڣ‬T ͖ XIJDI UFTUT XIFUIFS SBUFT PG DIBOHF JODSFBTF PS EFDSFBTF PWFS UJNF EPFT OPU IBWF BOZ PCWJPVT BQQMJDBUJPO UP BOZ MJOHVJTUJD RVFTUJPOT  $PODMVTJPO 3FDFOU BEWBODFT JO RVBOUJUBUJWF BQQSPBDIFT UP MBOHVBHF IJTUPSZ IBWF QVU EJBDISPOJD BQQSPBDIFT BU UIF GPSFGSPOU PG NPEFSO MJOHVJTUJDT य़F QPXFS PG DPNQVUBUJPOBM QIZMPHFOFUJDT BOE OFUXPSL BOBMZTFT UP QFSGPSN FYQMJDJU UFTUJOH PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ TDFOBSJPT JT POMZ CFHJOOJOH UP CF FYQMPSFE  5FࠩOJDBM BEWJDF .S#BZFT )VFMTFOCFDL BOE 3PORVJTU  3PORVJTU BOE )VFMTFOCFDL  JT B HPPE HFOFSBM QVSQPTF #BZFTJBO 1IZMPHFOFUJD *OGFSFODF QBDLBHF BOE JT XFMMEPDVNFOUFE BOE SFBTPOBCMZ FBTZ UP VTF #&"45 %SVNNPOE FU BM  JT NPSF DPNQMFY CVU JT BMTP DMPTFS UP UIF GPSFGSPOU PG NFUIPEPMPHJDBM EFWFMPQNFOU JO QIZMPHFOFUJDT BOE UIF EFWFMPQFST BSF BDUJWF QBSUJDJQBOUT JO MBO HVBHF FWPMVUJPO QSPKFDUT य़F 4UPDIBTUJD %PMMP NPEFM JO #&"45 XBT JNQMFNFOUFE TQFDJ੗DBMMZ GPS NPEFMMJOH UIF FWPMVUJPO PG MBOHVBHF 0OF PG UIF EJਖ਼DVMUJFT JO VTJOH #&"45 JT UIBU JU EPFTO‫۝‬U P੖FS BOZ EFGBVMU TF॒JOH UIF EFWFMPQFST EP OPU XBOU UP FODPVSBHF SFTFBSDIFST UP VTF TPॏXBSF XJUIPVU NBLJOH JOGPSNFE EFDJTJPOT BCPVU QSJPST य़JT VODPNQSPNJTJOH B॒JUVEF JT P੖TFU IPX FWFS CZ UIF GSJFOEMZ BOE IFMQGVM VTFS DPNNVOJUZ य़F QIZMPHFOFUJD QBDLBHFT QSPWJEFE GPS UIF 3 TUBUJTUJDBM QSPHSBNNJOH MBOHVBHF BSF IJHIMZ ੘FYJCMF BOE UIF OVNCFS PG EJ੖FSFOU QBDLBHFT JT HSPXJOH SBQJEMZ य़F 1IZMPHFOFUJDT 5BTL 7JFX PO $3"/ http://cran.r-project.org/web/views/Phylogenetics.html JT B DPOUJOVPVTMZ VQEBUFE MJTU PG UIF EJ੖FSFOU NFUIPET BWBJMBCMF  0VUTUBOEJOH QSPCMFNT 1IZMPHFOFUJD MJOHVJTUJDT JT BO BSFB VOEFSHPJOH SBQJE EFWFMPQNFOU BOE XF DBO MPPL GPSXBSE UP JNQSPWFNFOUT BOE GVSUIFS EFWFMPQNFOUT UP NBOZ PG UIF JEFBT EFTDSJCFE BCPWF 8JUI SFTQFDU UP QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF QSPQFS XF DBO FYQFDU UP TFF NPSF XPSL PO DPNQVUBUJPOBM SFQMJDBUJPO PG UIF $PNQBSBUJWF .FUIPE EFUFDUJOH TPVOE DIBOHFT JOGFSSJOH DPHOBUFT BOE TPVOE DIBOHFT TJNVMUBOFPVTMZ  "U UIF UJNF PG XSJUJOH #PVDIBSE$´U© FU BM  EPFTO‫۝‬U ZFU P੖FS B VTBCMF NFUIPEPMPHZ GPS OPOEFWFMPQFST UP BQQMZ UIFJS UFDIOJRVFT CVU XF DBO FYQFDU UIBU UIJT BQQSPBDI XJMM HBJO JO QPXFS BOE DSFEJCJMJUZ #PSSPXJOH BOE SFUJDVMBUJPO JO USFFT IBT CFFO BEESFTTFE 

/BLIMFI 3JOHF BOE 8BSOPX  4IJKVMBM FU BM 

CVU UIFTF NFUIPET BSF OPU DVSSFOUMZ NBUVSF FOPVHI UP CF VTFE NPSF XJEFMZ OP TUBOEBSE TPॏXBSF JODPSQPSBUFT UIFTF NFUIPET BOE UIFZ BSF OPU ZFU CFJOH VTFE PVUTJEF UIF UFBNT UIBU EFWFMPQFE UIFN 0ODF QIZMPHFOFUJD OFUXPSL NFUIPET CFDPNF NPSF XJEFMZ VTBCMF UIFO XF DBO IPQF UIBU JU XJMM CFDPNF QPTTJCMF UP CFHJO VTJOH OFUXPSLT JO QIZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE IZQPUIFTJT UFTUJOH 1IZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPET BSF BMTP EFWFMPQJOH SBQJEMZ BU UIF NPNFOU BOE UIF QPTTJCJMJUJFT GPS VTJOH UIFN UP FYBNJOF OFX MJOHVJTUJD RVFTUJPOT JO USFFMJLF QIZMPHFOJFT BSF DFSUBJOMZ OPU FYIBVTUFE FJUIFS 'JOBMMZ XF DBO BMXBZT VTF CF॒FS EBUBCBTFT य़JT TIPVME JODMVEF NPSF IJHIFS RVBMJUZ MBO HVBHF EBUB BT XFMM BT MJOHVJTUJD EBUBCBTFT MJOLFE UP EBUBCBTFT GSPN UIF DVMUVSBM HFPHSBQIJ DBM FDPMPHJDBM IJTUPSJDBM BOE CJPMPHJDBM EPNBJOT य़F "VTUSPOFTJBO #BTJD 7PDVCVMBSZ %BUBCBTF http://language.psy.auckland.ac.nz/austronesian/ BOE UIF *OEP&VSPQFBO -FYJDBM $PH OBUF EBUBCBTF http://ielex.mpi.nl/ TUBOE PVU IFSF BT MBSHF BDDFTTJCMF EBUBCBTFT VOEFSHPJOH BDUJWF EFWFMPQNFOU  'VSUIFS SFBEJOH ‫( ۦ‬SBZ (SFFOIJMM BOE 3PTT  JT B TIPSU TVSWFZ PG QIZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPET BOE IPX UIFZ DBO TIFE MJHIU PO MJOHVJTUJD RVFTUJPOT ‫ ۦ‬/VOO  QSFTFOUT BO BDDFTTJCMF CPPLMFOHUI TVSWFZ PG QIZMPHFOFUJD DPNQBSBUJWF NFUI PET ‫ ۦ‬/JDIPMT BOE 8BSOPX  TVSWFZ TPNF PG UIF RVBOUJUBUJWF NFUIPET VTFE UP JOGFS MJO HVJTUJD QIZMPHFOJFT BOE UFTU UIFJS QFSGPSNBODF BHBJOTU TPNF TBNQMF MBOHVBHF EBUB ‫ ۦ‬-FNFZ 4BMFNJ BOE 7BOEBNNF  JT B DPMMFDUFE WPMVNF XJUI DIBQUFST USFBUJOH BMM UIF NBKPS UIFNFT JO QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF ‫ ۦ‬1BSBEJT  JT B VTFGVM NBOVBM UP IFMQ SFTFBSDIFST JNQMFNFOU UIFJS PXO QIZMPHOFUJD BOBMZTFT VTJOH UIF 3 TUBUJTUJDBM QSPHSBNNJOH FOWJSPONFOU 

3FMBUFE UPQJDT ‫( ۦ‬SFFOIJMM‫۝‬T DIBQUFS PO UIF %FNPHSBQIJD DPSSFMBUFT PG MBOHVBHF DIBOHF BMTP EJTDVTTFT UIF QSPCMFN PG QIZMPHFOFUJD OPOJOEFQFOEFODF PG PCTFSWBUJPOT PG DVMUVSBM BOE MJOHVJTUJD EJ WFSTJUZ ‫ ۦ‬$IBQUFST CZ )FHHBSUZ 1SFIJTUPSZ UISPVHI MBOHVBHF BOE BSDIBFPMPHZ BOE 1BLFOEPSG )JT UPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT BOE NPMFDVMBS BOUISPQPMPHZ BSF DPODFSOFE XJUI MJOLJOH IJTUPSJDBM MJO HVJTUJDT UP FWFOUT BOE JOEJWJEVBMT FYJTUJOH JO UIF QBTU UISPVHI RVBOUJUBUJWF BOE TUBUJTUJDBM NFUIPET

3FGFSFODFT "ULJOTPO फ़FOUJO % "OESFX .FBEF $ISJT 7FOEJ॒J 4JNPO + (SFFOIJMM BOE .BSL 1BHFM  -BOHVBHFT FWPMWF JO QVODUVBUJPOBM CVSTUT 4DJFODF    ۗ #MPNCFSH 4JNPO 1 य़FPEPSF (BSMBOE +S BOE "OUIPOZ 3 *WFT  5FTUJOH GPS QIZMPHFOFUJD TJHOBM JO DPNQBSBUJWF EBUB CFIBWJPSBM USBJUT BSF NPSF MBCJMF &WPMVUJPO    ۗ 

#PVDIBSE$´U© "MFYBOESF %BWJE )BMM य़PNBT - (SJਖ਼UIT BOE %BO ,MFJO  "VUPNBUFE SFDPOTUSVDUJPO PG BODJFOU MBOHVBHFT VTJOH QSPCBCJMJTUJD NPEFMT PG TPVOE DIBOHF 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF /BUJPOBM "DBEFNZ PG 4DJFODFT #PVDLBFSU 3FNDP 1IJMJQQF -FNFZ .JDIBFM %VOO 4JNPO + (SFFOIJMM "MFYBOEFS 7 "MFLTFZFOLP "MFYFJ + %SVNNPOE 3VTTFMM % (SBZ .BSD " 4VDIBSE BOE फ़FOUJO % "ULJOTPO  .BQQJOH UIF PSJHJOT BOE FYQBOTJPO PG UIF *OEP&VSPQFBO MBOHVBHF GBNJMZ 4DJFODF    ۗ #PXFSO $MBJSF  य़F SJEEMF PG 5BTNBOJBO MBOHVBHFT 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF 3PZBM 4PDJFUZ # #JPMPHJDBM 4DJFODFT    ۗ #SPXO $FDJM ) &SJD 8 )PMNBO 4¸SFO 8JDINBOO BOE 7JWFLB 7FMMVQJMMBJ  "VUPNBUFE DMBTTJ੗DBUJPO PG UIF XPSMET MBOHVBHFT EFTDSJQUJPO PG UIF NFUIPE BOE QSFMJNJOBSZ SFTVMUT 456' ‫ ڝ‬-BOHVBHF 5ZQPMPHZ BOE 6OJWFSTBMT    ۗ $BNQCFMM -ZMF  )JTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT BO JOUSPEVDUJPO &EJOCVSHI &EJOCVSHI 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT %BOJ«MTFO 4XJOUIB .JDIBFM %VOO BOE 1JFUFS $ .VZTLFO  य़F TQSFBE PG UIF "SBXBLBO MBOHVBHFT B WJFX GSPN TUSVDUVSBM QIZMPHFOFUJDT *O &UIOJDJUZ JO BODJFOU BNB[POJB SFDPO TUSVDUJOH QBTU JEFOUJUJFT GSPN BSDIBFPMPHZ MJOHVJTUJDT BOE FUIOPIJTUPSZ FE "MG )PSOCPSH BOE +POBUIBO % )JMM ۗ #PVMEFS 6OJWFSTJUZ PG $PMPSBEP 1SFTT %POPIVF .BSL BOE 4JNPO .VTHSBWF  5ZQPMPHZ BOE UIF MJOHVJTUJD NBDSPIJTUPSZ PG *TMBOE .FMBOFTJB 0DFBOJD -JOHVJTUJDT    ۗ %SVNNPOE "MFYFJ + 4JNPO : 8 )P .B॒IFX + 1IJMMJQT BOE "OESFX 3BNCBVU  3FMBYFE QIZMPHFOFUJDT BOE EBUJOH XJUI DPO੗EFODF 1-P4 #JPMPHZ    F %SVNNPOE "MFYFJ + BOE .BSD " 4VDIBSE  #BZFTJBO SBOEPN MPDBM DMPDLT PS POF SBUF UP SVMF UIFN BMM #.$ #JPMPHZ     %SVNNPOE "MFYFJ + .BSD " 4VDIBSE %POH 9JF BOE "OESFX 3BNCBVU  #BZFTJBO QIZMP HFOFUJDT XJUI #&"6UJ BOE UIF #&"45  .PMFDVMBS #JPMPHZ BOE &WPMVUJPO    ۗ %VOO .JDIBFM  $POUBDU BOE QIZMPHFOZ JO *TMBOE .FMBOFTJB -JOHVB    ۗ %VOO .JDIBFM /JDMBT #VSFOIVMU /JDPMF ,SVTQF 4ZMWJB 5VGWFTTPO BOE /FFMF #FDLFS  "TMJBO MJOHVJTUJD QSFIJTUPSZ B DBTF TUVEZ JO DPNQVUBUJPOBM QIZMPHFOFUJDT %JBDISPOJDB    ۗ %VOO .JDIBFM 3PCFSU 'PMFZ 4UFQIFO $ -FWJOTPO (FS 3FFTJOL BOE "OHFMB 5FSSJMM  4UB UJTUJDBM SFBTPOJOH JO UIF FWBMVBUJPO PG UZQPMPHJDBM EJWFSTJUZ JO *TMBOE .FMBOFTJB 0DFBOJD -JOHVJTUJDT    ۗ %VOO .JDIBFM 4JNPO + (SFFOIJMM 4UFQIFO $ -FWJOTPO BOE 3VTTFMM % (SBZ  &WPMWFE TUSVDUVSF PG MBOHVBHF TIPXT MJOFBHFTQFDJ੗D USFOET JO XPSEPSEFS VOJWFSTBMT /BUVSF ۗ 



%VOO .JDIBFM 4UFQIFO $ -FWJOTPO &WB -JOETUS¶N (FS 3FFTJOL BOE "OHFMB 5FSSJMM  4USVDUVSBM QIZMPHFOZ JO IJTUPSJDBM MJOHVJTUJDT NFUIPEPMPHJDBM FYQMPSBUJPOT BQQMJFE JO *TMBOE .FMBOFTJB -BOHVBHF    ۗ %VOO .JDIBFM BOE "OHFMB 5FSSJMM  "TTFTTJOH UIF MFYJDBM FWJEFODF GPS B $FOUSBM 4PMPNPOT 1BQVBO GBNJMZ VTJOH UIF 0TXBMU .POUF $BSMP UFTU %JBDISPOJDB    ۗ %VOO .JDIBFM "OHFMB 5FSSJMM (FS 3FFTJOL 3PCFSU " 'PMFZ BOE 4UFQIFO $ -FWJOTPO  4USVDUVSBM QIZMPHFOFUJDT BOE UIF SFDPOTUSVDUJPO PG BODJFOU MBOHVBHF IJTUPSZ 4DJFODF    ۗ 'FMTFOTUFJO +PTFQI  *OGFSSJOH QIZMPHFOJFT 4JOBVFS "TTPDJBUFT 4VOEFSMBOE 'PSUVOBUP -BVSB B 3FDPOTUSVDUJOH UIF IJTUPSZ PG NBSSJBHF BOE SFTJEFODF TUSBUFHJFT JO *OEP &VSPQFBOۘ4QFBLJOH TPDJFUJFT )VNBO #JPMPHZ    ۗ  C 3FDPOTUSVDUJOH UIF IJTUPSZ PG NBSSJBHF TUSBUFHJFT JO *OEP&VSPQFBOۘ4QFBLJOH TPDJFUJFT NPOPHBNZ BOE QPMZHZOZ )VNBO #JPMPHZ    ۗ  D 3FDPOTUSVDUJOH UIF IJTUPSZ PG SFTJEFODF TUSBUFHJFT JO *OEP&VSPQFBOۘ4QFBLJOH TPDJFUJFT OFP VYPSJ BOE WJSJMPDBMJUZ )VNBO #JPMPHZ    ۗ 'PSUVOBUP - $ )PMEFO BOE 3 .BDF  'SPN CSJEFXFBMUI UP EPXSZ )VNBO /BUVSF    ۗ (PFCM )BOT  %JBMFDUPNFUSZ B TIPSU PWFSWJFX PG UIF QSJODJQMFT BOE QSBDUJDF PG RVBOUJUBUJWF DMBTTJ੗DBUJPO PG MJOHVJTUJD BUMBT EBUB *O $POUSJCVUJPOT UP RVBOUJUBUJWF MJOHVJTUJDT FE 3 ,¶IMFS BOE # 3JFHFS ۗ %PSESFDIU ,MVXFS (SBZ 3% BOE '. +PSEBO  -BOHVBHF USFFT TVQQPSU UIF FYQSFTTUSBJO TFRVFODF PG "VT USPOFTJBO FYQBOTJPO /BUVSF    ۗ (SBZ 3VTTFMM % "MFYFJ + %SVNNPOE BOE 4JNPO + (SFFOIJMM  -BOHVBHF QIZMPHFOJFT SFWFBM FYQBOTJPO QVMTFT BOE QBVTFT JO 1BDJ੗D TF॒MFNFOU 4DJFODF    ۗ (SBZ 3VTTFMM % 4JNPO + (SFFOIJMM BOE 3PCFSU . 3PTT  य़F QMFBTVSFT BOE QFSJMT PG EBS XJOJ[JOH DVMUVSF XJUI QIZMPHFOJFT  #JPMPHJDBM ࡋFPSZ    ۗ (SFFOIJMM 4JNPO +  -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODFT GBJM UP JEFOUJGZ MBOHVBHF SFMBUJPOTIJQT BDDVSBUFMZ $PNQVUBUJPOBM -JOHVJTUJDT    ۗ (SFFOIJMM 4JNPO + 3PCFSU #MVTU BOE 3VTTFMM % (SBZ  य़F "VTUSPOFTJBO CBTJD WPDBCVMBSZ EBUBCBTF GSPN CJPJOGPSNBUJDT UP MFYPNJDT &WPMVUJPOBSZ #JPJOGPSNBUJDT 0OMJOF  )BSWFZ 1) BOE .% 1BHFM  ࡋF DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE JO FWPMVUJPOBSZ CJPMPHZ 0YGPSE 0YGPSE 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT )FFSJOHB 8JMCFSU +BO  .FBTVSJOH EJBMFDU QSPOVODJBUJPO EJ੖FSFODFT VTJOH MFWFOTIUFJO EJT UBODF 1I% य़FTJT 3JKLTVOJWFSTJUFJU (SPOJOHFO )FFSJOHB 8JMCFSU BOE +PIO /FSCPOOF  %JBMFDU BSFBT BOE EJBMFDU DPOUJOVB -BOHVBHF 7BSJ BUJPO BOE $IBOHF    ۗ 

)PMEFO $ +  #BOUV MBOHVBHF USFFT SF੘FDU UIF TQSFBE PG GBSNJOH BDSPTT TVCTBIBSBO BGSJDB B NBYJNVNQBSTJNPOZ BOBMZTJT 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF 3PZBM 4PDJFUZ # #JPMPHJDBM 4DJFODFT    ۗ )PMEFO $MBSF BOE 3VUI .BDF  1IZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTJT PG UIF FWPMVUJPO PG MBDUPTF EJHFTUJPO JO BEVMUT )VNBO #JPMPHZ    ۗ   4QSFBE PG DB॒MF MFE UP UIF MPTT PG NBUSJMJOFBM EFTDFOU JO BGSJDB B DPFWPMVUJPOBSZ BOBMZTJT 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF 3PZBM 4PDJFUZ PG -POEPO 4FSJFT # #JPMPHJDBM 4DJFODFT    ۗ )PMMBOE #BSCBSB 3 ,BUIBSJOB 5 )VCFS 7JODFOU .PVMUPO BOE 1FUFS + -PDLIBSU  6TJOH DPOTFOTVT OFUXPSLT UP WJTVBMJ[F DPOUSBEJDUPSZ FWJEFODF GPS TQFDJFT QIZMPHFOZ .PMFDVMBS #JPMPHZ BOE &WPMVUJPO    ۗ )PMNBO &SJD 8 FU BM  "VUPNBUFE EBUJOH PG UIF XPSME‫۝‬T MBOHVBHF GBNJMJFT CBTFE PO MFYJDBM TJNJMBSJUZ $VSSFOU "OUISPQPMPHZ ۗ )VFMTFOCFDL + 1 BOE ' 3PORVJTU  .3#":&4 #BZFTJBO JOGFSFODF PG QIZMPHFOZ #JPJOGPS NBUJDT ۗ )VOMFZ ,FJUI .JDIBFM %VOO &WB -JOETUS¶N (FS 3FFTJOL "OHFMB 5FSSJMM .FHIBO & )FBMZ (FPSHF ,PLJ 'SBO§PJTF 3 'SJFEMBFOEFS BOE +POBUIBO 4 'SJFEMBFOEFS  (FOFUJD BOE MJOHVJTUJD DPFWPMVUJPO JO OPSUIFSO *TMBOE .FMBOFTJB 1-P4 (FOFUJDT    )VOMFZ ,FJUI FU BM  *OGFSSJOH QSFIJTUPSZ GSPN HFOFUJD MJOHVJTUJD BOE HFPHSBQIJD WBSJBUJPO *O 1PQVMBUJPO HFOFUJDT MJOHVJTUJDT BOE DVMUVSF IJTUPSZ JO UIF TPVUIXFTU 1BDJटD FE +POBUIBO 4 'SJFEMBFOEFS ۗ 7PM  +PSEBO 'JPOB .  " QIZMPHFOFUJD BOBMZTJT PG UIF FWPMVUJPO PG "VTUSPOFTJBO TJCMJOH UFSNJ OPMPHJFT )VNBO #JPMPHZ    ۗ +PSEBO 'JPOB . 3VTTFMM % (SBZ 4JNPO + (SFFOIJMM BOE 3VUI .BDF  .BUSJMPDBM SFTJEFODF JT BODFTUSBM JO "VTUSPOFTJBO TPDJFUJFT 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF 3PZBM 4PDJFUZ # #JPMPHJDBM 4DJFODFT    ۗ ,BTTJBO "MFYFJ (FPSHF 4UBSPTUJO "OOB %ZCP BOE 7BTJMJZ $IFSOPW  य़F 4XBEFTI XPSEMJTU BO B॒FNQU BU TFNBOUJD TQFDJ੗DBUJPO +PVSOBM PG -BOHVBHF 3FMBUJPOTIJQ ۗ ,BTT 3PCFSU & BOE "ESJBO & 3BॏFSZ  #BZFT GBDUPST +PVSOBM PG UIF "NFSJDBO 4UBUJTUJDBM "TTPDJBUJPO    ۗ -FNFZ 1IJMJQQF .BSDP 4BMFNJ BOE "OOFNJFLF 7BOEBNNF FET  ࡋF QIZMPHFOFUJD IBOE CPPL $BNCSJEHF $BNCSJEHF 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT .BDF 3VUI BOE $MBSF + )PMEFO  " QIZMPHFOFUJD BQQSPBDI UP DVMUVSBM FWPMVUJPO 5SFOET JO &DPMPHZ  &WPMVUJPO    ۗ .BDF 3VUI BOE .BSL 1BHFM  य़F DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE JO BOUISPQPMPHZ  $VSSFOU "OUISPQPMPHZ    ۗ



.BOOJ 'SBO[ &UJFOOF (V©SBSE BOE &WFMZOF )FZFS  (FPHSBQIJD QB॒FSOT PG HFOFUJD NPS QIPMPHJD MJOHVJTUJD WBSJBUJPO )VNBO #JPMPHZ ۗ .D.BIPO ".4 BOE 3PCFSU .D.BIPO  -BOHVBHF DMBTTJटDBUJPO CZ OVNCFST 0YGPSE 6OJ WFSTJUZ 1SFTT 64" /BLIMFI -VBZ  &WPMVUJPOBSZ QIZMPHFOFUJD OFUXPSLT NPEFMT BOE JTTVFT *O 1SPCMFN TPMWJOH IBOECPPL JO DPNQVUBUJPOBM CJPMPHZ BOE CJPJOGPSNBUJDT FE -FOXPPE 4 )FBUI BOE /BSFO 3BNBLSJTIOBO ۗ 4QSJOHFS /BLIMFI -VBZ %POBME " 3JOHF BOE 5BOEZ 8BSOPX  1FSGFDU QIZMPHFOFUJD OFUXPSLT B OFX NFUIPEPMPHZ GPS SFDPOTUSVDUJOH UIF FWPMVUJPOBSZ IJTUPSZ PG OBUVSBM MBOHVBHFT -BOHVBHF    ۗ /BLIMFI -VBZ 5BOEZ 8BSOPX %PO 3JOHF BOE 4UFWFO / &WBOT  " DPNQBSJTPO PG QIZMP HFOFUJD SFDPOTUSVDUJPO NFUIPET PO BO JOEPFVSPQFBO EBUBTFU 5SBOTBDUJPOT PG UIF 1IJMPMPHJDBM 4PDJFUZ    ۗ /F॒MF %BOJFM  *T UIF SBUF PG MJOHVJTUJD DIBOHF DPOTUBOU -JOHVB  ۗ  ۗ /JDIPMMT (FP੖ , BOE 3VTTFMM % (SBZ  %BUFE BODFTUSBM USFFT GSPN CJOBSZ USBJU EBUB BOE UIFJS BQQMJDBUJPO UP UIF EJWFSTJ੗DBUJPO PG MBOHVBHFT +PVSOBM PG UIF 3PZBM 4UBUJTUJDBM 4PDJFUZ 4FSJFT # 4UBUJTUJDBM .FUIPEPMPHZ    ۗ /JDIPMT +PIBOOB BOE 5BOEZ 8BSOPX  5VUPSJBM PO DPNQVUBUJPOBM MJOHVJTUJD QIZMPHFOZ -BOHVBHF BOE -JOHVJTUJDT $PNQBTT    ۗ /VOO $ -  ࡋF DPNQBSBUJWF NFUIPE JO FWPMVUJPOBSZ BOUISPQPMPHZ BOE CJPMPHZ $IJDBHP 6OJWFSTJUZ PG $IJDBHP 1SFTT 0TXBMU 3PCFSU -  य़F EFUFDUJPO PG SFNPUF MJOHVJTUJD SFMBUJPOTIJQT $PNQVUFS 4UVEJFT JO UIF )VNBOJUJFT BOE 7FSCBM #FIBWJPS    ۗ   " QSPCBCJMJTUJD FWBMVBUJPO PG /PSUI &VSBTJBUJD /PTUSBUJD *O /PTUSBUJD TJࡄJOH UIF FWJEFODF FE +PTFQI $ 4BMNPOT BOE #SJBO % +PTFQI ۗ "NTUFSEBN +PIO #FOKBNJOT 1BHFM .BSL  *OGFSSJOH FWPMVUJPOBSZ QSPDFTTFT GSPN QIZMPHFOJFT ;PPMPHJDB 4DSJQUB    ۗ   *OGFSSJOH UIF IJTUPSJDBM QB॒FSOT PG CJPMPHJDBM FWPMVUJPO /BUVSF    ۗ  1BSBEJT &NNBOVFM  "OBMZTJT PG QIZMPHFOFUJDT BOE FWPMVUJPO XJUI 3 OE FE 4QSJOHFS 1BSBEJT &NNBOVFM +VMJFO $MBVEF BOE ,PSCJOJBO 4USJNNFS  "1& BOBMZTFT PG QIZMPHFOFU JDT BOE FWPMVUJPO JO 3 MBOHVBHF #JPJOGPSNBUJDT ۗ 1FFS :WFT 7BO EF  1IZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF CBTFE PO EJTUBODF NFUIPET *O ࡋF QIZMPHFOFUJD IBOECPPL FE 1IJMJQQF -FNFZ .BSDP 4BMFNJ BOE "OOFNJFLF 7BOEBNNF ۗ $BN CSJEHF $BNCSJEHF 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT



1SJUDIBSE +POBUIBO , .B॒IFX 4UFQIFOT BOE 1FUFS %POOFMMZ  *OGFSFODF PG QPQVMBUJPO TUSVDUVSF VTJOH NVMUJMPDVT HFOPUZQF EBUB (FOFUJDT    ۗ 1SPLJÇ +FMFOB  'BNJMJFT BOE SFTFNCMBODFT 1I% य़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ۗ 3PORVJTU ' BOE + 1 )VFMTFOCFDL  .3#":&4  #BZFTJBO QIZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF VOEFS NJYFE NPEFMT #JPJOGPSNBUJDT ۗ 3PTFOCFSH /PBI " +POBUIBO , 1SJUDIBSE +BNFT - 8FCFS )PXBSE . $BOO ,FOOFUI , ,JEE -FW " ;IJWPUPWTLZ BOE .BSDVT 8 'FMENBO  (FOFUJD TUSVDUVSF PG IVNBO QPQVMBUJPOT 4DJFODF    ۗ 4DINJEU )FJLP " BOE "SOEU )BFTFMFS WPO  1IZMPHFOFUJD JOGFSFODF VTJOH NBYJNVN MJLF MJIPPE NFUIPET *O ࡋF QIZMPHFOFUJD IBOECPPL FE 1IJMJQQF -FNFZ .BSDP 4BMFNJ BOE "O OFNJFLF 7BOEBNNF ۗ $BNCSJEHF $BNCSJEHF 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT 4IJKVMBM /FMTPO4BUIJ +PIBOO.B॒JT -JTU )BOT (FJTMFS )FJOFS 'BOHFSBV 3VTTFMM % (SBZ 8JMMJBN .BSUJO BOE 5BM %BHBO  /FUXPSLT VODPWFS IJEEFO MFYJDBM CPSSPXJOH JO *OEP&VSPQFBO MBOHVBHF FWPMVUJPO 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF 3PZBM 4PDJFUZ # #JPMPHJDBM 4DJFODFT    ۗ  4XBEFTI .PSSJT  -FYJDPTUBUJTUJD EBUJOH PG QSFIJTUPSJD FUIOJD DPOUBDUT XJUI TQFDJBM SFG FSFODF UP /PSUI "NFSJDBO *OEJBOT BOE &TLJNPT 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF "NFSJDBO 1IJMPTPQIJDBM 4PDJFUZ    ۗ 8BMLFS 3PCFSU 4 BOE -JODPMO " 3JCFJSP  #BZFTJBO QIZMPHFPHSBQIZ PG UIF "SBXBL FYQBO TJPO JO MPXMBOE 4PVUI "NFSJDB 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF 3PZBM 4PDJFUZ # #JPMPHJDBM 4DJFODFT    ۗ 8BSOPX 5BOEZ 4UFWFO / &WBOT %POBME 3JOHF BOE -VBZ /BLIMFI  " TUPDIBTUJD NPEFM PG MBOHVBHF FWPMVUJPO UIBU JODPSQPSBUFT IPNPQMBTZ BOE CPSSPXJOH *O 1IZMPHFOFUJD NFUIPET BOE UIF QSFIJTUPSZ PG MBOHVBHFT FE 1FUFS 'PSTUFS BOE $PMJO 3FOGSFX ۗ $BNCSJEHF .D%POBME *OTUJUVUF GPS "SDIBFPMPHJDBM 3FTFBSDI



*OEFY BODFTUSBM TUBUF SFDPOTUSVDUJPO 

QIZMPHFPHSBQIZ 

"TMJBO 

QPTUNBSJUBM SFTJEFODF 

"VTUSPOFTJBO  

QVODUVBUFE FWPMVUJPO 

#BOUV 

SFUJDVMBUJPO 

#BZFT 'BDUPS  CPSSPXJOH GBNJMZ JOUFSOBM  DPHOBUF DBOEJEBUF  DPOTFOTVT USFF  DPWBSJPO NPEFM  EBUF DBMJCSBUFE USFF  EJTQFSTBM PSEFS 

TPDJPDVMUVSBM SFDPOTUSDUJPO  4UPDIBTUJD %PMMP NPEFM  TVCTJTUFODF NPEF  5BTNBOJBO MBOHVBHFT  USFF DISPOPMPHZ  XPSE PSEFS 

EJTUBODF NFUSJD  HBNNB NPEFM  HFOFMBOHVBHF DPSSFMBUJPO  HMP॒PDISPOPMPHZ  *OEP&VSPQFBO  LJOTIJQ TZTUFNT  MBDUPTF UPMFSBODF  -FWFOTIUFJO EJTUBODF  MFYJDPTUBUJTUJDT   MJLFMJIPPE NFUIPET  MJOHVJTUJD QBMBFPOUPMPHZ  MPOH CSBODI B॒SBDUJPO  NBYJNVN DMBEF DSFEJCJMJUZ USFF  NPEF PG FWPMVUJPO  0TXBMU .POUF $BSMP 5FTU  0TXBMU 4IJॏ 5FTU  1BQVBO MBOHVBHFT  QBSTJNPOZ NFUIPE  QBTUPSBMJTN  QFSGFDU QIZMPHFOZ  QIZMPHFOFUJD OFUXPSLT    QIZMPHFOFUJD TJHOBM