Keywords: OBO Foundry, ontology, signal transduction pathway, semantic web, OWL. 1 Introduction ... of pathway data in standard, machine!readable formats is ...
,&%2 ,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ%LRPHGLFDO2QWRORJLHVā%XIIDOR1?CC?"(+$%?4"5#'"$M'0@+$>!+$FH!$ *
$
9I-0(0$#45-?&($)?"5&'6450:$0N4#..;$
78,&.2%&9$ H'7"'D')#"5$ 0DD?&5$ -#($ 600"$ B45$ '"5?$ 5-0$ )&0#5'?"$ ?D$ #$ C4.5'54:0$ ?D$ .#&70+$ B46.').;$ #1#'.#6.0$ B#5-@#;$ :#5#6#(0(=$ %?(5$ C#,0$ 5-0'&$ )?"50"5$ #1#'.#6.0$ '"$ #5$ .0#(5$ ?"0$ ?D$ (010&#.$ (5#":#&:$&0B&0(0"5#5'?"$D?&C#5(+$645$5-0&0$#&0$.'C'5#5'?"($5?$0J'(5'"7$B#5-@#;$&0B&0(0"5#5'?"$ D?&C#5(+$'").4:'"7$4":0&45'.'O#5'?"$?D$#$)?CC?"$(05$?D$6'?C0:')#.$?"5?.?7'0(=$I?$#::&0(($5-'($ .'C'5#5'?"+$@0$:010.?B0:$#"$#BB&?#)-$5?$&0B&0(0"5'"7$6'?.?7')#.$B#5-@#;($5-#5$&0.'0($?"$5-0$4(0$ ?D$ ?"5?.?7'0($ D&?C$ 5-0$ PB0"$ E'?C0:')#.$ P"5?.?7'0($ QPEPR$ S?4":&;+$ '").4:'"7$ 5-0$ 30.#5'?"$ P"5?.?7;$Q3PR+$#":$#:-0&0($5?$5-0$.?7')#.$B&'")'B.0($?D$?"5?.?7;$:010.?BC0"5$#:1?)#50:$6;$5-0$ S?4":&;=$ I?$ :0C?"(52$ 5-0$ 45'.'5;$ ?D$ 5-'($ &0B&0(0"5#5'?"$ #BB&?#)-+$ @0$ -#10$ )42:$ )?CB&0-0"('10$ B#5-@#;$ &0B&0(0"5#5'?"($ D?&$ 5-0$ ('7"#.$ 5&#"(:4)5'?"$ B#5-@#;($ '"'5'#50:$ 6;$ (010"$ ?D$ 5-0$ C?4(0$ I?..T.',0$ &0)0B5?&($ QI/3R=$ >4&&0"5$ 0DD?&5($ '").4:0$ 5-0$ :010.?BC0"5$ ?D$ #BB&?#)-0($D?&$45'.'O'"7$5-0(0$&0B&0(0"5#5'?"($D?&$B#5-@#;$#"#.;('(=$ :$65".;,;41% :"&%(&2*3+(&%#,%,&(%?*%,?$"%("+(%&+$"%*+("!+6% #,% $?)+(&9% #'(/% +% ,#'.3&% ,*)&+9,"&&(% $/2*)#,&9% /-%(!/%2+#'%*+)(,C%/'&%*+)(%$/'(+#'#'.%+%3#,(%/-% +33%&'(#(#&,%'+2&9%#'%("&%*+("!+6%+'9%/'&%*+)(% $/'(+#'#'.% +% 3#,(% /-% +,,&)(&9% )&3+(#/',% ("+(% !"&'%(+@&'%(/.&("&)%,*&$#-6%("&%*+)(#$#*+'(,%#'% +'9% ,()?$(?)&% /-% ("&% *+("!+61% :"&% 3#,(% /-% '+2&9% &'(#(#&,% #'$3?9&,C% -/)% &+$"% &'(#(6C% +% "+'93&% ?,&9% (/% )&-&)% (/% ("&% &'(#(6% !#("#'% ("&% ,*)&+9,"&&(C% ("&% $/))&,*/'9#'.% /'(/3/.6% (&)2C% +'9% ("&% ?'#L?&% #9&'(#-#&)% +,,/$#+(&9% !#("% ("&% (&)2%#'%("&%DED%M/?'9)6%/'(/3/.6%("+(%#,%("&% ,/?)$&%-/)%("&%(&)21%:"&%+**)/+$"%(/%)&*)&,&'7 (+(#/'%#,%*)/$&,,7$&'()#$C%+'9%("#,%#,%)&-3&$(&9%#'% ("&%3#,(%/-%+,,&)(&9%)&3+(#/',C%("&%8?3@%/-%!"#$"% )&3+(&% +% *)/$&,,% (/% ("&% 2/3&$?3&,% ("+(% *+)(#$#*+(&%#'%("&%*)/$&,,C%+,%9&,$)#8&9%8&3/!1% :/% $?)+(&% )&3&=+'(% *+("!+6% #'-/)2+(#/'% #'(/% ,*)&+9,"&&(,C% +% 9/2+#'% &B*&)(% )&=#&!&9% ("&%*)#2+)6%3#(&)+(?)&%(/%/8(+#'%#'-/)2+(#/'%-/)% *+("!+6,% #'#(#+(&9% 86% )&$&*(/),% -/)2&9% -)/2% :;IIJ' :./$$;IP'!"#$%("#)"$)*)+&",*$%"&'' :6)!#/-";3'
!"#$%&'()!"#$%&%'()*+,-.!/-0/-,-#$+$1%#!*1%&%'12+&!0+$34+(,5! 6+23!*%7!2%//-,0%#.,!$%!+!$(0-!%8!-#$1$(5!93%4#!1#! 0+/-#$3-,-,!+/-!+**/-:1+$-.!#+;-,!8%/!$3-!%#$%&%'1-,! 8/%;!43123!$-/;,!8%/!-#$1$1-,!%8!$3+$!$(0-!+/-!1;0%/$-.5! -!+//%4,!/-0/-,-#$!$3-!!"#$%"&'()(%"*'! /-&+$1%#5!?>/0&-!+//%4,!/-0/-,-#$!$3-!(*!+&+#$(*!+#.! !"#$,-*)'(.*!/-&+$1%#,5!!=&+2@!+//%4,!+/-!+,!&+*-&-.5!
4!)'/50*6$/7' ?/)*0$'?/"?)-#-.'./$$IP'' !"#$%("#)"$)*)+&",*$%"&''DP=Q3'
!"#$%("#)"$)*)+&",*$%"&'' -1' ?/(-"/?' -"' #/)*1' !(' #,/' =>' !"#$%"&'' )/$0#-!"' 0"?' #,/' H>II'WHUP¶SODVPDPHPEUDQH·EKUG'0"?'-1'.A)8 )/"#$&'0'.0"?-?0#/')/$0#-!"'1AC*-##/?'#!'#,/'=>3'
!"#$$%&'()*+,-$.&)/&&,$0,1&2&,1&,)$ 3+,)*,4(,)-$
!"5$$%&'()*+,-$6&)/&&,$0,1&2&,1&,)$ 3+,)*,4(,)-$(,1$78+9&--&-$
D,/' =>' )/$0#-!"' !"#$%"&'' 01' ?/(-"/?' C/#+//"' #&6/1'!('-"?/6/"?/"#'.!"#-"A0"#1'EFG'-1'A1/?'#!' )/$0#/' *0.)!*!$/.A$0)' .!*6$/5/1' #!' #,/-)' .!*6!"/"#' 6)!#/-"1' 0"?' #!' )/$0#/' 6)!#/-"1' #!' 6)!#/-"'?!*0-"1'A1-"%'#,/'011/)#-!"1'
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
:*0.)!*!$/.A$0)'.!*6$/5;H>IIJK'!"#$%"&'' :6)!#/-";' :6)!#/-";'!"#$%"&'':6!$&6/6#-?/'?!*0-";IIJ''
!"#$%&''()*+,-!"#$%"&'()(%"*'-!"#$.&/0(,1*--
!"#$%&''()*+,-&."/(0.#-LR/03'&-3%./N/.D)*@:-OUAL(*!.&.#$(*- H534- '"&%/G/%/.D- 2/.$I&0J3%./N3.&H"#$.&/0-R/03'&-R/03'&-T,1*MM9-
!"#$%&''()*+,-!"#$+,'%,'$%"&'()(%"*'!23%#$2$4&%543#-%$2"4&6()*778,1*-!"#$%&''()*+,-!"#$+,'%,'$%"&'()(%"*'!"#$.&/0(,1*9-
!"!##$%&'()*+,#-%(.%%+#/0*1%,,%,#
:$#-&632"4&;-
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
',)$3.%)$! /+.)'+,1! +5! +,)+(+3'$1! 0')#! /%)#0%*1! %,2! -+7/4)$! +;$.! )#$! ',)$3.%)$2! .$1+4.-$! /.+;'2$1!%!&$,$5')!)#%)!+4)0$'3#1!%,*! /+11'&($! (+11! +5! $:/.$11';')*8! I56! #+0$;$.6! 14-#! %! (+11! +5! $:/.$11';')*! 2'2! /.$1$,)! %! 1'3,'5'-%,)! 2'1%2;%,)%3$6! )#$! +,)+(+3*D&%1$2! -+.$! .$/.$1$,)%)'+,1! -+4(2! &$! $,#%,-$2! 0')#! 2+7%',D1/$-'5'-! ',5+.7%)'+,! )#%)! 7%*! ,+)! &$! %--$11'&($!)+!%((!%,%(*1'1!)++(18!
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
V8! 9',,6! =8K86! $)! %(86! .!*- A:")- %&2'*8,- :")8(8*#4"'"+"#*
