27 Oct 2009 ... Cost Check. Job Definition. Gear box. Gear box. Flender catalog for planetary
gear boxes. Two planetary stages and one spur wheel stage.
Cost Minimization for the Planet Carrier by Optimizing the Topology 3rd European HyperWorks Technology Conference Ludwigsburg, 03. Nov. 2009 © Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved.
Gear box Gear box
Flender catalog for planetary gear boxes
Job Definition Cost Check
Introduction of a new optimization software
Optimization Model
Two planetary stages and one spur wheel stage
Result Benefit
Page 2
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Job Definition Gear box
What do we know about the optimization potential ?
Job Definition Cost Check Optimization Model
Past:
Experience
Present: Experience, simulation, computer-assisted optimization (OptiStruct)
Result Benefit
Cutting treatment
Source: Flender Page 3
2009-10-27
Casting technology
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Cost Check Gear box
Total cost of the gearbox
Job Definition Cost Check Optimization Model Result Benefit
Raw material represents 1.5% of the whole gearbox Cost reduction by reducing the amount of raw material is unimportant However – we may be able to optimize Æ weight Æ stiffness Page 4
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Topology Optimization – What is it? Gear box Job Definition
“A CAE tool to create ideas in the development process” Used: OptiStruct software
Cost Check Optimization Model Result Benefit
Source: Altair Engineering
Method: change finite elements by density 100 % density solid material (red) Page 5
2009-10-27
0 % density no material (blue) © Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Model Gear box
Main problem: Misalignment of the planet axis
Job Definition
Æ worsens the teeth contact
Cost Check
Æ reduces the lifetime of bearings and teeth
Optimization Model Result Benefit
Page 6
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Model Gear box
Designed space consists of finite elements
Job Definition
Designed space (blue)
Cost Check
Non-designed space (red) Æ not changeable
Æ changeable
Optimization Model
Cyclic symmetry
Result
Linear computation model
Benefit
Page 7
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Model Gear box
Boundary conditions:
Job Definition
Specified force & torque
Cost Check Optimization Model
Results:
Result
Misalignment of planet axis
Benefit
Volume
3 different kinds of optimization: Minimize volume by specific misalignment of planet axis Minimize misalignment of planet axis by specific volume (30%) Minimize misalignment of planet axis by specific volume (50%)
Page 8
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Results Gear box Job Definition Cost Check
The results are not digital - one or zero! It’s all about density distribution 0.0
0.1
0.3
0.9
Optimization Model Result Benefit
Page 9
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Layout A Gear box
Target: minimize volume by a specific misalignment of planet axis
Job Definition
Weight (raw material): -12%
Cost Check
Misalignment of planet axis +30%
Optimization Model Result Benefit
Page 10
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Layout B Gear box
Target: minimize misalignment of axis by specific volume (30%)
Job Definition
Weight (raw material): +3%
Cost Check
Misalignment of planet axis: -5%
Optimization Model Result Benefit
Page 11
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Layout C Gear box
Target: minimize misalignment of axis by specific volume (50%)
Job Definition
Weight (raw material): +26%
Cost Check
Misalignment of planet axis: -36%
Optimization Model Result Benefit
Page 12
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Comparison Gear box Job Definition Cost Check Optimization Model Result Benefit
Page 13
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Benefit Gear box Job Definition Cost Check
Benefit of this analysis:
Optimization
The carrier in our current products is in excellent shape
Model
Rules for design
Result
First experience gained in Siemens MD
Benefit
Page 14
Future: apply in other areas - (gearbox housing…)
2009-10-27
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved. Industry Sector
Dr. Torsten Bunge Siemens AG, Mechanical Drives Research and Developement Department Alfred-Flender-Straße 77 46395 Bocholt, Germany Phone: 02871/92-2046 Fax: 02871/92-1500 E-Mail:
[email protected]
© Siemens AG 2009. All Rights Reserved.