Deakin Research Online - DRO

Deakin Research Online Deakin University’s institutional research repository

DDeakin Research Online Research Online

This is the published version (version of record) of: Rahaman, Ahadur, Abawajy, Jemal and Hobbs, Michael 2007, Taxonomy and survey of location management systems, in 6th IEEE/ACIS International Conference on Computer and Information Science : (ICIS 2007) in conjunction with 1st IEEE/ACIS International Workshop on e-Activity (IWEA 2007) : proceedings, The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc (IEEE), Los Alamitos, Calif., pp. 369-374.

Available from Deakin Research Online: http://hdl.handle.net/10536/DRO/DU:30008085

Copyright : ©2007 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. However, permission to reprint/republish this material for advertising or promotional purposes or for creating new collective works for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or to reuse any copyrighted component of this work in other works must be obtained from the IEEE.

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

&! 9.'( :$,)6;! 37/4.492! )$*$:-)-*9+! .75$947*!

)$*$:-)-*9!;->+! @-..A B#7*-+! /.&-9779#+! B-'87*$.! %4:49$.! $88489$*9+! CDE=! $*%! )7/4.-! %-?45-8! ;->:>+!)7/4.-! B#7*-8!$*%! DF"G8=!#$?-! .-%! 97! 04'-.-88! )7/4.-! %-?45-! )$*$:-)-*9! 8289-)8! $8! 8#70*!4*!H4:&'-!I>!!!

5$..-%! 5-..8! ;$! :'7&B! 7N! 5-..8! N7')! $! '-:489'$947*! $'-$! ;("=! 9#$9! $'-! )$*$:-%! /2! $! )7/4.-! 80495#4*:! 5-*9'-! ;3E@=! 57**-594*:! %4'-59.2! 97! 9#-! /$5M/7*-! B&/.45! 80495#-%! 9-.-B#7*-! *-907'M8! ;DEOP=>! Q*! -$5#! 5-..! 9#-'-! 48! $! /$8-! 89$947*! ;LE=+! '-8B7*84/.-! N7'! '-.$24*:! 57))&*45$947*8! 97! 9#-! &*%-'*-$9#! 368! 7?-'! B'-A $884:*-%! '$%47! N'-R&-*52>! "! LE! $.87! )$4*9$4*8! .75$947*! 4*N7')$947*! %$9$/$8-! N7'! )$*$:4*:! 36! .75$947*8! 8&5#! $8! #7)-! .75$947*! '-:489-'! ;6->+! #70! 97! 9'$5M! 9#-! 368! 9#$9! )7?-! N'7)! B.$5-! 97! B.$5-=! 48! 7*-! 7N! 9#-! )789! 4)B7'9$*9! 488&-8! 4*! 04'-.-88! )7/4.-! *-907'M8>! Q9! 48! #$*%.-%! /2! .75$947*! )$*$:-)-*9! ;! T?-'2! 94)-! $! 36! )7?-8+! 498! :-7:'$B#45$.! .75$947*! 4*N7')$947*! 48! &B%$9-%! %2*$)45$..2! 97! 9#-! *-$'-89! /$8-! 89$947*>! "*! $&97)$9-%! #$*%A7NN! '-:489'$947*!B'75-88!$..708!36!97!80495#!/-90--*!/$8-! 89$947*8!97!8&BB7'9!)7/4.492!-NN-594?-.2!$*%!-NN454-*9.2>! O#&8!)7/4.-!!

?=(0$1"23$%(&"%"5.&.%2(6'62.&(( TU4894*:! !!

H4:&'-!IJ!K4'-.-88!)7/4.-!8289-)!$'5#49-59&'->! 36J!37/4.-!#789+!LEJ!L$8-!89$947*+!! 3E@J!)7/4.-!80495#4*:!5-*9'->! !

! H4:&'-!WJ!! !

6th IEEE/ACIS International Conference on Computer and Information Science (ICIS 2007) 0-7695-2841-4/07 $25.00 © 2007

?=!

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

?=?=(0$1"23$%(&"%"5.&.%2(62,+12+,.( TU4894*:! ! Q*!$!5-*9'$.4V-%!!K#-'-! $8+! 4*! $! N&..2! %489'4/&9-%! 85#-)-+! 9#-! .75$947*! 4*N7')$947*!48!%489'4/&9-%!$..!7?-'!9#-!*-907'M!9#'7&:#! .75$947*!'-:489-'8! ;!! ^84*:! 907A94-'! #4-'$'5#45$.! 89'&59&'-+! 9#-! 8289-)! 57*9$4*8! 6! 3&.94A94-'! 85#-)-8! $'-! 5.$884N4-%! /2! 9#-! *&)/-'! 7N! )&.94A#7B8! '-R&4'-%! 4*! N$54.49$94*:! 57))&*45$947*! /-90--*! 907! 7'! )7'-! *7%-8>! O#-8-! 8289-)8! #$?-! B'7?-*! 97! 85$.-8! /-99-'! 9#$*! 907! .-?-.! $*%! 5-*9'$.4V-%! 85#-)-8! $*%! 8#708! 4)B'7?-%! B-'N7')$*5-!&84*:!7B94)4V$947*![Z\>!!

?=B=(0$1"23$%(&"%"5.&.%2(62"%)",)6( 3$17'!!^*%-'!P7*AQD!89$*%$'%8!0-!#$?-!907!)$17'! )&.94A94-'! %$9$/$8-! #4-'$'5#2! /$8-%! 89$*%$'%8J! 4*9-'4)! 89$*%$'%! YI! ;QEAYI=! $*%! :.7/$.! 8289-)! N7'! )7/4.-! 57))&*45$947*8! ;CE3=! )7/4.-! $BB.45$947*! B$'98! ;3"D=>! QEAYI!48! -U9-*84?-.2! &8-%! 4*!$%?$*5-%! )7/4.-!


B#7*-! 8289-)8! ;"3DE=>! CE3! 7*! 9#-! 79#-'! #$*%! 48! &8-%!)789.2!4*!T&'7B-!N7'!%4:49$.!5-..&.$'!8289-)8AI_``! $*%! B-'87*$.! 57))&*45$947*! 8289-)8( [a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b\>!!

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

?=C=(0$1"23$%(&"%"5.&.%2($A.,"23$%6(

H4:&'-!ZJ!@.$884N45$947*!7N!%2*$)45!&B%$9-!85#-)-8>! ! Q*! $! 84)B.-! 94)-! /$8-%! %2*$)45! 85#-)-+! .75$947*! &B%$9-! 4*N7')$947*! 48! %-B-*%$*9! 7*! $! %2*$)45! 94)-'! ?$.&->!^84*:!9#48!85#-)-+!9#-!979$.!5789!:-98!#4:#!$8!9#-! @3(! ?$.&-! '-)$4*8! 8)$..+! 84*5-! )7'-! 5-..8! $'-! 4*?7.?-%! 97! .75$9-! $! )7/4.-! *7%-! 9#&8! '$484*:! 9#-! B$:4*:!5789>!! D74*9-'! /$8-%! %2*$)45! &B%$9-! 85#-)-8! 57&.%! /-! 5.$884N4-%! 4*97! 84)B.-! N7'0$'%4*:! /$8-%! $*%! .-?-.! N7'0$'%4*:!/$8-%!85#-)-8![d\>!"!84)B.-!B74*9-'!/$8-%! 85#-)-! 07'M8! /2! 8-994*:! &B! $! N7'0$'%4*:! B74*9-'! /-90--*! 6! O#-'-! $'-! N-0! )$17'! 57*89'$4*98! 7N! B74*9-'! N7'0$'%4*:! 85#-)-! $8! '$%47! N'-R&-*52! ;(H=! #$?-! %4'-59! 4*N.&-*5-! 7*! 9#-! '7&94*:! 498-.N! 87! 9#-! ?$.&-! 7N! (H! *--%8! 97! /-! 57*89$*9! 97! $5#4-?-! )$U4)&)! B-'N7')$*5->! K$89$:-! 7N! 8289-)! '-87&'5-8! $*%! #$*%8#$M-! B'75-88! /-90--*! *7%-8! $*%! B'79757.8!5$*!/-!)$17'!%'$0/$5M8!7N!8&5#!$!)7%-.>!!!

"! !!

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

B=!!


!"! :-*-'$.! '-B.45$947*! 85#-)-! %-N4*-8! '-B.45$947*! .-?-.! $.7*:! 049#! '-B.45$947*! B.$5-)-*9! 7N! %$9$! 4*! $! %489'4/&9-%! -*?4'7*)-*9>! K-! 5$*! 5.$884N2! '-B.45$947*! /$8-%! &B%$9-! 85#-)-8! 4*! 907! 5$9-:7'4-8! 8&5#! $8J! '-B.45$9-%! &8-'! B'7N4.-! $*%! 07'M4*:! 8-9>! Q*! '-B.45$9-%! &8-'! B'7N4.-! 85#-)-+! &8-'! B'7N4.-8! $'-! '-B.45$9-%! $9! 8-.-59-%! .75$.! %$9$/$8-8>! Q9! 5$*!'-8&.9!4*!#4:#-'! 7?-'$..! 84:*$..4*:! 5789! /&9! 8&'?4?-8! 84*:.-! B74*9! 7N! N$4.&'->! O#-8-! 85#-)-8! $'-! -UB-*84?-! 97! 4)B.-)-*9+! '-R&4'-8! -U5-884?-! 57)B&9$947*$.! B70-'! $*%! *-907'M! /$*%04%9#>! (-B.45$947*! 85#-)-8! 8&5#! $8! 9#-! 7*-! B'7B78-%!4*![IW\+!%-B-*%8!7*!9#-!7/8-'?$947*!7N!8-9!7N! 87&'5-8! &8-%! /2! $*2! 8B-54N45! 368>! P&)-'45$.! '-8&.98! #$?-! 8#70*! 9#$9+! 049#! .70! @3(! ?$.&-! 9#-8-! 85#-)-8! B-'N7')!8$)-!$8!*7*A'-B.45$9-%!85#-)-8>! "! 84)B.-! 5$5#4*:! /$8-%! 85#-)-! 8&5#! $8! 907! .75$947*! 9'$5M4*:! $.:7'49#)! ;O!Q*!-$:-'!5$5#4*:!-?-'2!94)-!$!36! 9'$?-.8! 97! *-0! .75$947*+! 5$5#-%! 4*N7')$947*! '-:$'%4*:! 9#$9! &8-'! 48!4))-%4$9-.2! &B%$9-%>!O#-2! ! ! '-R&4'-! .75$.! M*70.-%:-! $*%! 4*9'7%&5-! N$&.9! 97.-'$*5->! Q*! B-'! &8-'! /$8-%! 5$5#4*:! 85#-)-! [IY\+! .75$947*! 4*N7')$947*! 48! 5$5#-%! 4*! *-$'/2! 84:*$.! 9'$*8N-''4*:! B74*9! ;EOD=! 4*! $! ! P&)-'45$.! '-8&.98! #$?-! 8#70*! 9#$9+! 9#-! %489$*5-A/$8-%! 85#-)-! 48! /-99-'! 9#$*! 94)-A/$8-%! $*%! )7?-)-*9A/$8-%! 85#-)-8! 4*! 9-')8! 7N! 9#-! -UB-59-%! &B%$9-! '$9-! N7'! 0#45#! '-R&4'-%! 8-$'5#! *&)/-'8!$'-!:'-$9-'!4*!94)-!$*%!)7?-)-*9!/$8-%!9#$*! 9#$9! 7N! %489$*5-A/$8-%! 85#-)-! /&9! '-R&4'-! 84:*4N45$*9! 57)B&9$947*$.!B70-'!$9!36![W\>!! Q*! $! )7?-)-*9! 9#'-8#7.%! /$8-%! &B%$9-! 85#-)-+! $! B'-%-N4*-%! 9#'-8#7.%! ?$.&-! 48! 8-9>! O#&8! 8-994*:! $! 8&49$/.-! 9#'-8#7.%! ?$.&-! 48! $! 5'&54$.! 57)B7*-*9! N7'! :$4*4*:!)$U4)&)!B-'N7')$*5-!N'7)!8&5#!85#-)-[Id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b`f!.-88!4*! 3DLE!9#$*!9#$9!7N!DLE>!D$:4*:!%-.$2!'-)$4*8!$8!7*-! 7N! 9#-! )$17'! 57*5-'*! 4*! 3DLE! $.7*:! 049#! &B%$9-! *&)/-'8![Ia\![Ib\!$*%![Id\>!

C=(*.",1E($A.,"23$%( E-$'5#4*:g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`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`\>!!


C=! D-'! &8-'! /-#$?47&'! /$8-%! 8-$'5#! 85#-)-8! 5$*! /-! 5.$884N4-%! N&'9#-'! /$8-%! 7*! 9#-4'! 07'M4*:! B'4*54B$.8! 4*97J! )7?-)-*9! B$99-'*+! 4*9-:'$9-%! 85#-)-! $*%! 94)-! $*%! 89$9-! 4*N7')$947*! /$8-%! 85#-)-8>! O#-2! &8-! &8-'! /-#$?47&'!B$'$)-9-'8!$8!B'4)$'2!87&'5-!7N!4*N7')$947*! 57..-5947*!$8!0-..!$8!7B-'$947*$.!89'$9-:2!:-*-'$947*>!! "! )7?-)-*9! B$99-'*! /$8-%! B'-%45947*! 85#-)-! 8&5#! $8!9#-!7*-!%-85'4/-%!4*![WI\+!&8-8!&8-'!)7/4.492!B$99-'*! $8!9#-!/$848!7N!N7')&.$94*:!B'-%45947*!$'-$8!97!/-!B$:-%! 0#-*! $! 5$..! $''4?-8>! O#-! )$4*! $%?$*9$:-! 7N! 8&5#! $.:7'49#)!48!9#$9+!-?-*!049#!9#-!07'89!5$8-!85-*$'47!9#-! B$:-%!$'-$!&*%-'!9#48!85#-)-!48!.4)49-%!97!%2*$)45$..2! B'-%459-%!.75$947*8!7*.2+!*79!07'.%A04%->!Q9!8$?-8!$!.79! 7N!84:*$..4*:!5789!57)B$'-%!97!! ]*-! 8&5#! 85#-)-! B'7B78-%! 4*! [WX\+! &8-8! &8-'! 8B-54N45! $594?494-8! $9! $! .75$947*! $.7*:! 049#! 94)-! V7*-+! %&'$947*+! 9'$*84947*! )$9'4U! -95>! O#-! 85#-)-! B'7?-%! 97! 7&9! B-'N7')! )789! 79#-'! 84)4.$'! 85#-)-8! 4*! 9-')8! 7N! 7?-'$..! 5789>! ]*-! )$17'! %'$0/$5M! 7N! 9#48! 85#-)-! 07&.%! /-! 7?-'%-B-*%-*5-!7*!&8-'!B'7N4.->!! ^84*:!QD!/$8-%!B$:4*:!9-5#*4R&-8!-$5#!36!'-B7'98! 498!.75$947*!QF!$8!49!5'788-8!B$:4*:!$'-$>!O#&8!97!.75$9-! 9#-!8$)-!36+!9#-!85#-)-!8-$'5#-8!9#-!'-B7'9-%!B$:4*:! $'-$>!O#-8-!QD!/$8-%!$.:7'49#)8!5$*!/-!$:$4*!5.$884N4-%! 4*97!9#'--!)$17'!8&/!5$9-:7'4-8!8&5#!$8!89$945+!$%$B94?-! $*%! %2*$)45! %-B-*%4*:! 7*! 9#-! *$9&'-! 7N! B$:4*:! B'75-%&'-8>! E9$945! QD! /$8-%! 85#-)-8! 8&5#! $8! B$:4*:! -U9-*847*8! N7'! )7/4.-! QD! 7'! DA3QD! [WY\! 4*9'7%&5-8! $'5#49-59&'$.!$*%! B'79757.! 488&-8>! O#-2! $'-! 57*84%-'-%! 89$945! 4*! $! 8-*8-! 9#$9! 9#-! 57?-'-%! B$:4*:! $'-$! 48! B'-%-N4*-%>! O#&8! 49! 48! 4*N-$84/.-! 97! %-9-')4*-! 7B94)$.! B$:4*:!$'-$!&84*:!89$945!85#-)-8>!! "%$B94?-!QD!/$8-%!B$:4*:!85#-)-!%48B.$28!%2*$)45! /-#$?47&'! /&9! 4*! $*! $%$B94?-! )$**-'>! H7'! -U$)B.-+! $.:7'49#)! B'7B78-%! 4*! [W`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a\>!

F=(G$%1H+63$%( !O#48!B$B-'!N75&8-8!7*!$*! $.9-'*$9-!$BB'7$5#!97!5.$884N2!-U4894*:!! ,$4*+! $*%! H>! "*1&)+! h@$5#4*:! 4*! #4-'$'5#45$.! &8-'! .75$947*! %$9$/$8-8! N7'! D@E! D-'87*$.! K4'-.-88! @7))&*45$947*i+! 0(((& 0)2,-).2+$).%& F$)',-,)",+! H-/'&$'2! Iddd+!BB>!Yda!j!Z``>! [W\! S4*5-*9! K+! E>! K7*:+! $*%! S>@>3! !IY+!*7>!Z+!E-B9-)/-'g]597/-'! W```+!BB>!I_AWY>! [X\! e>! P$7'+! $*%! 6>! ! [Y\! ">! ($#$)$*! $*%! ,-)$.! "/$0$12+! hE&'?-2! 7N! .75$947*! )$*$:-)-*9! N'$)-07'M8! N7'! 04'-.-88! 8289-)8+! F-$M4*! ^*4?-'8492!O-5#*45$.!(-B7'9+!*7>!@`bg`X+!"B'4.!W``b>! [Z\! l>! ($9*$)+! E>! ($*:$'$1$*+! $*%! ">! O>! F$#/&'$+! h"*! -NN454-*9! N$&.9A97.-'$*9! .75$947*! ! ! ! ! )$*$:-)-*9! B'79757.! N7'! B-'87*$.! 57))&*45$947*! *-907'M8i+! 0(((& 2-.)9."2+$)9& $)& M,#+"=%.-&3,"#)$%$*4+!?7.>!Yd+!Q88&-!a+!P7?-)/-'!W```+!BB>! WXZdAWXad>! [a\! Q>!H>!"M24.%4V+!,>!35P$4'+!,>!67+!6>!^V&*$.47:.&+!$*%!K>! K$*:+! h37/4.492! )$*$:-)-*9! 4*! *-U9A:-*-'$947*! 04'-.-88! 8289-)8i+!G-$",,/+)*9&$'&2#,&0(((+!?7.>!_b+!Q88&-!_+!"&:&89! Iddd+!BB>!IXYbAIX_Y>! [b\! ">C>! S$.M7+! h@-..&.$'! QDJ! $! *-0! $BB'7$5#! 97! Q*9-'*-9! #789! )7/4.492i+! ! [d\! (>! ,$4*+! $*%! k>L>! $-69+! ?7.>!I+!*7>!W+!,&.2!IddZ+!BB>!IdbAWI`>! [I`\!K>! 3$+! $*%! k>! H$*:+! hO07A! ($#)$*+! K>! ].-84*8M4+! $*%! D>! C/&'V2*8M4+! Q*9-'*$947*$.! 07'M8#7B! 7*! 04'-.-88! $%A#75! *-907'M8+! 3$2! A ,&*-!W``Y+!BB>!bXAb_>! [IW\!E>! ($1$:7B$.$*+! $*%! L>(>! L$%'4*$9#+! h"*! "%$B94?-! $-6+)*&TJ$?+"$1&ULVW+!]597/-'!IddZ>!

[IX\!,>! "/$0$12+! hD$'$..-.! !IYXYAIYYY>! [IZ\!">D>! E489.$+! ]>! K7.N87*+!$*%! k>! 6&$*:+!h34*4)4V$947*! 7N! 57))&*45$947*! 5789! 9#'7&:#! 5$5#4*:! 4*! )7/4.-! -*?4'7*)-*98i+! 0(((& 2-.)9."2+$)9& $)& @.-.%%,%& .)/& /+92-+?=2,/& 9492,19+! ?7.>! d+!Q88&-! Y+!"B'4.! Idd_+! BB>! Xb_! j! Xd`>! [Ia\!E>!e#7&+!">!E-*-?4'$9*-+!$*%!O>!D-'54?$.+!h"*!-NN454-*9! ! [Ib\!Q>! H>! "M24.%4V+! ,>E>3>! 67+! $*%! k>L>! !aWd!j!aX_>! [I_\!@>! (78-+! hE9$9-AL$8-%! D$:4*:g(-:489'$947*J! "! C'--%2! O-5#*4R&-i+! 0(((& 3-.)9."2+$)9& $)& 8,#+"=%.-& 2,"#)$%$*4+! ?7.>!Y_+!*7>!I+!,$*&$'2!Iddd+!BB>!IaajbX>! [Id\!">!L$'AP72+!Q>!l-88.-'+!$*%!3>!E4%4+!h37/4.-!^8-'8J!O7! ^B%$9-! 7'! P79! 97! ^B%$9-ni+! !YW+!*7>a+!Iddd+!BB>!YbXAY_a>! [WI\!,>! L4-89-'N-.%+! $*%! l>! ,7/)$**+!hO#-! &8-! 7N! B'-%45947*! $'-$8! 97! 4)B'7?-! )7/4.492! )$*$:-)-*9! ".:7'49#)8i+! G-$",,/+)*9& $'& 2#,& 0)2,-).2+$).%& F$)',-,)",& $)& 3,%,"$11=)+".2+$)9+! @#$.%4M4+! ?7.>Y+! ,&.2! Idd_+! BB>! YYaj YZ`>! [WW\!C>! K$*+! $*%! T>! ! IdZjW`X>! [WX\!l>!l2$)$M2$+!$*%!l>!,7/)$**+!h! O>! @$)B/-..+! hDA 3QDJ! D$:4*:! TU9-*847*8! N7'! 37/4.-! QDi+! 37/4.-! P-907'M8! $*%!"BB.45$947*8+!?7.>!b+!Q88&-!W+!"B'4.!W``W>! [WZ\!6>! l>! l4)+! hF2*$)45! QD! D$:4*:J! "*! "%?$*5-%! ! [Wa\!l>6>! @#4$*:+! $*%! P>! E#-*72+! hD-'N7')$*5-! 7N! $! %489'4/&9-%! .75$947*! )$*$:-)-*9! 85#-)-! N7'! 04'-.-88! *-907'M8i+! !"#$$%& $'& (%,"2-$)+"9& Z& F$1@=2,-& !492,19+! (3QO+! S4597'4$+! "&89'$.4$+! QTTT! C.7/$.! O-.-57))&*45$947*8! @7*N-'-*5-+! ?7.>! b+! F-5-)/-'! W``X+! BB>!XdaXA!Xda_>!

(
