36
Edited by Mayeul Kauffmann
Building and Using Datasets on Armed Conflicts M. Kauffmann (Ed.) IOS Press, 2008 © 2008 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
107
! "" # " $ % & % " '( ' ( " %
') % ' $ " $ $ $ $ $ * "$" $ '
$ %"" " " $ # " $'( % ' % + ," - ' % ," " % '( " ' ( %
" %'( " % ' ( % !$ '(
"
% " ' % # % . ' /' 0' 1' 2' 3'
"% $ % $ ( % ! $ % % $ ! % % $ 4 , '
5 ! 7 8 (9 ; !?/?/! ( ! 0 ! /@A/! ( ! ( !(? " ! 7- !!! - ( =6 # # % / " ! 4 6 0%%/ ( !( 6 / ! ( 6, '%%/ ,. " ! 4@!,. ,. ! ( 6, ' 6 # / , ' '%%/ 7 ! ! ( - ! 7 -( ; /! ! '(%! (5B! ( - - /! (/!(? 8 ! .( ! (> 9! = 6 1 7 ,. " ! 4!,. " ! 4! " ! 4!#$ ! 4 " ! 4! 6 ' '7 ,.! ( ?!/??!C??!/???!C??? ! ( ?!C??!/???!@???!C??? ! ( ?!/???!@???!C???!C???? ! ( ?!/???!C???!@????!/????? , % )," + - +W-'( % " 4 % $ $E! .OO%%%'; * 'O'( % " /'2' /'3' +E! 8' @-') %&D; +; " - % '# " + " - " +% " - .OO'; * 'O ; ' '
116
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
, ' " " ), ( % % # ' ( % G1I% /'" & & % % & &+ ''LS'ML SM$ L/@@0M L /@@0M-'( % +0'0'- " # + & " -' $ + 0'- % S/@@0 0 /@@2$ % 2$@@@ /@$@@@$% S /@@30 /@@8$ % /@$@@@ @@$@@@'
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
117
!$* " - + " # ," ' ) $ " $ "
% 'J % " ," " " + -$ ' ; " ' " S 0 '( " S 'J " %" ' %
% L " M' $ " /; , $ %
.L % " " @@@ " /; M' E % %; % @@ TTT ; $% " @@@ ; '(%+ - +( 1-" ')! $ ; " % J %; %; + S/@@2 /@@3-'P% " $ " " @@
' L " M% " " ' D & ' $ $ AR+ -% " 1) ') ! L AR M$ ! L AR ! " M'( % ! "') * L " M$ % $ %$ '
( % %& ! <
=# % =# %
S/@@27S /@@2
@
S/@@27 /@@2 @ S/@@37S /@@3
3@@
S/@@37 /@@3 3@@ S/@@87 /@@8 @
@ 3@@ 3@@ @ @
118
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
' 4% !% / '( ; ,
" ' )
$ "" "
% ' , $ " , " ' D $ " " $ " " ! '( " " # !' $ . " " ! $, " '" & %" '( $ $% &% !%" " + % " % " " -$ $ $% ! ' ( % " ' $ "
$ % F $ F E'
% + - $ " " % " &% !% '( % &%% % & % " ' " " % ' ( % &% " " % $ , ' " % " '2( '% ;#
J ;
G2I$% ' " " % " 'P% " $ % %' " $ $ " % '( " % + $ &$ '-'3 & ' ( " H %%
'P ! $ .( % +
" % $ * &-'( % 2( L /@@1' "M+ ! -$% LX M% " % L/@@1' M+ " -' 3 4F % G3I$ &F LD &/@@1' '
M+% $% " -
L /@@1' "M% " 'J $ ; " $ + L /@@1M % -'( & 4D /@@1' ; &'
4D /@@1' ' "
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
119
+ " " -' ( % & + $ % " $
" -' ( , " + L"M L" M-. " '@'@$ " '@' $" '@'/$" ' '@$" '/'@$"/'@'@' $
" " $ &$ % ' $ " % L" '@' 7 @S/@@8M+@ O @ % $ -'( " + - $ " ' $
" '8 $ %
, " ' $ " " % ' % ! %
% 2 @ 'D $ " % % " '( %$% % %% " $ &%% ! ' ( % " % " $ 'D$ + % - % % $ LM + 4 % - L M
+ E!%4 % %7& E! -H $ % % 'P% " $ ! + -H $" + - " % $ '?( & " %
$ + -' $!* + . ( , " & " % +' ' - " ' " " % & " # " ' ( " "
' % " ! 'E F S R1 R1 'P %
& & '( & + DKE- 1'
8( % $ % % ' $L 8' @M% /@@8' " % % ' ?( % %L M G1I+),J -$% $ L)J M$ , 'D
$ % '
120
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
:3B%3%BD03 25%65"2)535E%5600! ,25%5E%5600! F25%5E%5600! F%3G%5E%5600! - 25%5E%5600! 25%5E%5600! H:2B:$I3$ 35)253($2"B :3B%3%BD03 02I3 B0%3:%BD03 :EHE065 B0%3:%BD03 BE06525%>2:"% B0%3:%BD03 B253G B0%3:%BD03 BE065 >2:"% B0%3:%BD03 BE065 JB:&B: @CC >2:"% B0%3:%BD03 BE065 %23"%BH>2:"% :3B%3%:2))3: E5 >E:3B&:EKD3)25 25"3:%25%E "3% (6"3: ! ! (L6HB%3L! "
!# # (E0! $ "
,(E0 ,! F(E0 F! F(E0 F! - (E0 - ! (E0 35 :3B%3%:2))3: % & ' E5 >E:3B&:EKD3)25 25"3:%25%E "3% (6"3: ! (L303%3L! (E0! ,(E0 ,! F(E0 F! F(E0 F! - (E0 - ! (E0 35 :3B%3%:2))3: ()* E5 >E:3B&:EKD3)25 25"3:%25%E "3% (6"3: ! (L25"3:%L! (53K! $ "
,(53K ,! F(53K F! F(53K F! - (53K - ! (53K 35 , (P% 4;R1 +%DKE2'@' @ % -
121
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation *D #
/ ( # / (
/@@8; ;0@ *C @.@@.@@ T/' 3?'@'
) D(
/
/
D
?@@
/@@8
/@@8; ;0@ *C @.@@. 2 T/' 3?'@'
) D(
/ 032
032
?@@
/@@8
/@@8; ; 1 * C 2.@0.@@ T/' 3?'@'/
R( / 032
032
?@@
/@@8
/@@8; /; 1 * C 2.@0.@@ T/' 3?'@'/
) D(
0 032
031
D" T// D
TT
/@@8; /; 1 * C 2.@0.@@ T/' 3?'@'/
) D(
1 032
032
/@@8
TT/
S % 4 'P +"- " 0@'(%% & $S % DD " 'S &
'T ! ( 3+ ! -'( D + % , / 032- % ( 2' ( ' 4 " % $ %& + " -$% % ' ( 2$ ,
$ &%% %$% % + )R
-' " %
L M $ ! %% % ' ! " R' ( R TT8 ' ! $ " % $ +
-$ %$ $ " % " " @' R &" +G8I$ '/-' ( " " ! " " ') "
'(& ! ( 2$" 0@ " /@@8+ " - " '@'@ " 1 /@@8+ " - " ' '@' TS S '%$ JD%& " , % & % . 25"3:%25%E JB063" /!@!@!L6"L!/M??!@??N 25"3:%25%E JB063" @!AOC!AOC!L:L!/M??!@??N 6HB%3 "3% (/P@/K&3:32(@ 25"3:%25%E JB063" A!AOC!AOF!L6 " +" : L!/P@@!/PP/ 25"3:%25%E JB063" F!AOC!AOC!L:L!/PP@!@??N @( " $ .OO ' 'O !' L (QM'& LM
LEM '
122
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
$$ * + * + . $ " !
$ %& & ' " $%
%&$% " " $ % % " " $ " %$ 'P " " " ' $$ ) )') ' 4 $ %
" " ' ( ' " ' $$!2 *( . * ' ( % ! & $ " ' " % " , ' $$$ ) ( ) % ( % $ $ %'P $ " %%
% + . " * " J$ " $ -' $$,0 ) ) ( %" % " 'D $ $ & % 'A" F
" " + $ " " -$ &
'( %$ " $% %" ' $$3 ) (' 2 ( ' $ " $ " ') ' $ " ( &
% '( % " ! +% # -'
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
123
% " " $% " 'D $ "" % " $ H
% %& %& ' " % " &% % $ $
! L M % $ $ ') %&$ L M + % $ % ,# -$ ') $ $ '(& ') $ " " ') $ " % $% % " + $ " % -' (!% % #/ # ( " % ' " $
'( . " % ' ,
0 4(
& / % '( " '( " 'DJ F +G?I$ 1' 2'0-'P
" ' 4 $ % ! % + -$ &' 4 ! $ ! % % ') " " $ ! %
$ E$" +$ $ & " -' (
$ ' )D " %') $% )D 0 33; " $ " ' , % %
' GTI ! %, $ " '
/ L & M ! '
124
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
4 " $ , ' ! $ RF + $ ED$ E'''-' R " % ' 0 (% $ " " % + -' ( " " '( "
% +$ $ -$ ' D$ @@Y % $ , ; + DKE *% . DD % DD)/@@@ DD/@@@-' $ "
& $ % " + -2 %; $ %; % 7 4 R &' 1 ! +% " - %( 3' ,!+ 4( $ & % "
' + $ - JD+ D -' JD DKE +D K E - , 'P% " $ DKE" H % ' $ % L M L M" JD+ R DKE$ DKED " /@@@ J/- " . " + L " & % M-'( $ % L M L M % ( 3'
+! ! % 4 R1 / 0
/ 032 032
/ ( / 032 031
# / ( D D" D
?@@ ?@@ T//
/@@8 T/ TT
1
032
032
TT/
/@@8
0D " .OO ' 'O E ' Z U @?' +E 8 S/@@?-' 1' D J F + G?I$ " $ 2'/- L 1 1 1 ,(AOFAOCM & R1 4 $ & 4 R1 '4 ;% $ ! ;% 'R L M " % % L MH % " R " % R %" 4 'D $ " % ! " ' " $ DKE; +JD-" % % ;; $ %;; '
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
125
& % % " & % " .OO%%%' ' O O ,[ " [% [ & O')% JD$ % + -' ) JD " & % $ % & + %#% %JD % %-' ,$* ( D "
'4 $ $ $; $ # ; ' ( + G @I # -' ) $ + -$ % "
% + ),J * $G I /-' ,, ( " % $ % + $ % " -' ( D ) ) +D))- /? $ %T2 2'( $ +
% $ ! - % '( % $ ' ) D)) $ D)) '( " $ " D)) ' $D)) & " ! % " $ $ ' ) $ & ;?; 3 $ $ %%
' /3D))% ; + -'(
; $ , !%&' 3 + $ $ '''- . %& $'( % ' D)) %+ %%& "
-$ /3
$ % ' $ & $L ()X )M L\ ])" M' 2( + % L M -.QR4#SL T)&2XI05EHY:"%6JKG$*8Z9[1\ -]. +,;'7^=_ 3) $ %
, '( %DKELE)M , + " & -'
126
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
( &% H % % % $ ' ,35) ( " + % - 'D $ % " ' $ L M' % ; $% # + L@'2M L'2M-' 4 $ ;; " , " $ " + '2 /H 1'2 1$ '/2 '/-'( +% " - '( ;; " # )3@22T' ,6 ( $ +% %1 -$ $ )D ?3@ '( ! . •
•
( LQQQQM $%%0 S/@@? /@@?@ 0 + % % $ # -' " + -' ( ! LQQQQ;;M %
+/@@?;@ S/@@?-'
& /@@?O O0 , %& ' & ;; QQQQ$;;QQ$;;QQ$QQQQ " " , ' 4 " % + -$ % $ # 8' " )D ?3@ ; $ ! + ! # " -' ,7% 85 *+ 9 ( % " L " M$ " ' , $ " + $LQ ML M-$ " L " M % 8 $ /% % /@@?;@ ; 3( 2@820^$' ' 3S /@@?$ 2.@8 20 $A(G " % & I'( )D ?3@ ./@@?;@ ; 3(
[email protected]^' )D ?3@ " .OO '%& 'O%&O)D [?3@ + @S/@@?-'
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
127
' JD % " % & ' % " $ $ $# $; $ " L;33M' ( ! & R)X $% " % ; @+- B @+ -' X % " 'P% " $
" $ ;??+L M-$;88+L M- ;33+L M-$% H + $ '''-% " ; @B @ " $% %;??$;88;33 '( " # " "
" ') $
% $ " L " M% & %' " % L " M + ," " $ $/ 0$$J $ -' ,:0 0 ) $ " " " ') $% & " ! % ' ,:") + L M-$ ! ! $
% ?' " ' $" " , $ ' L " M& + -$ ! ' ) &$ $ !
! ! + ''L $ @ @M L M$LX $ ! /23 M L !M-')
$ % % + $DKE;
L"+/23-M % ! -' ,:!5 ; ) ; $ % $ '( ! & E +_E-% % ' QE % & " _E$ +% -'
?( ! , $ ! , % ! '
128
M. Kauffmann / Enhancing Openness and Reliability in Conflict Dataset Creation
( A % + G?I$ " $ 2'/- ! ; 'P% " $% # $
" ! 'D QE $
# % % " " + LQE M% " "
-' *>.
