Educational reform, ability and family background - Institute For Fiscal ...

11 downloads 0 Views 218KB Size Report
Apr 26, 2004 - find that the reform increased both the educational attainment and the ... Keywords: Human Capital, Evaluation of Education Reform, CompreM.
EDUCATIONAL REFORM, ABILITY AND FAMILY BACKGROUND Costas Meghir MÃ¥rten Palme

THE INSTITUTE FOR FISCAL STUDIES

WP04/10

!" #

#

%

#

$ %

& '

( )

#

*

+

#

% , %

#

#

-

.

/ , & & &0 1&2 13 /, 4 4 6. * ) 7 $ 1 , 8 # 8

$

89

;

# 4

4

#

4 !

#

5 < >

< = ?

! !

;

+ +

% 8

6

= *4

6 ?

C

B8

4 :

1

) 1 > , # ! ! @ ! 5 A =

4

:

!"

:

$ 4

9 )

1

$ 6 5 ! $

%

6 < 4

=

? < 4

! / 4< !

1 6 %

% 6 %

#

5 4=?

6 %

4 6

$

# 54 6

#


!

"

(

(

"

.

: ";

"

$

$

" .

;

"

"

"

"

"

1

;

)

)

.

?

"

!.

$

@!

(

!

!"

!

" 2 2

'

"

"

!

!

$!

$

. " ! "2 #

1 +

" =!

"

$

$

!

!

!"

"

( 3

"

"

!

"

!

( :

!

!

"

.

"!

" ! " ( ?

!" ! "

3

!

$

"

-" $

!

! "

6

$

!"

( ( "

.

( 3 $

!

! $

"

( "

?

"

) $

"

6

$ )

"

"( 3

B "

$

" ! " ( " .

%

"

!

(

! "

. #

"

%

$ $ "

2

.

! " !"

! "

! "

!

! "

E ' 0 ( #

(

-

"

#!

A

"! ! (

!

A !

(

!

.

! " 5

!

"

) !

"

"

)

.

$"

$ .

"

)

.

!

!

"

"

.

.

. !

"

!

"

"! ! .

3

"

! 1

" "!

. "

"

"

"

! ,

=!

"

"

"!

"

!

"

9 "

"

"

" . #!

)

"

@!

(

4

"

( 3


I-'

"

.

" .

-=!

!

! :

I

$

D

# .

"

" !2

"

( 3

$

1

)" !

"

%"

" .

" .

!

$

( :

.

"

"

(

$

!

"!

"

!

"!

" !

!" $

.

;

.

$

!( :

!

$

"

1 "

.

"

"!

!"

.

!

"

;

;

1 " (

.

"

3

H "

"

.

""

(

& 3

$

"

3

$

$

!"

3

$ $ $

B

!"

$

&

'

!"

! ;

>I-

$

$

!

$

!"

$

1 "

$

.

( ,

1 "

.

$

$

" !"

8

!" 1 "

$

. (

!

1 "

$

$

$ "

( "

" D #

!

.

4(

2

" $

. 5 .

!

"

"

!

""

+

'(

$

!

:

&

(

.

.

;

( ,

(

"

=!

3

=!

$

$

$

( 8

(

$

"

" !"

$

$

(

' 0B( + 03I & 3

J

#

H #

4

.

H #

"

!" $

3

!"

( 4 $

1 "

! ;

;

$

!

"

&" !

'( 8 .

(

1 "

!

!

!

&" !

""

3

"

"

!

"

!

.

=! ( :

.

!

$

$

$

"

'( 3 !

"

(

$

$ "

.

! ;

%"

!"

" "

"

!

$

.

.

" $

(

3

;

1 "

.

( 3

"

"

!

1

"

.

$

(

&

"

8

"

$

$

.

!

. 4 2 $

$ $

=!

3

1 " 4(4D

$

1

!

"

%"

.

.

$

$

$

.

. ( :

.

$

. !

.

(

( ,

! ; %"

!

&

"

$ $

!

) $

$

(

. ! ;

$2 1 "

"

" &2 ( D' .

"

( D

$

( >

>I-

(

6( D 1 "

8

1 "

3 .

"

. (

1 "

!

$

$

!

" 3

2 )

.

" (

2

2 1

" .

. !

;

1 "'

!

"

< #

$

# &$ *

% ' (

+

"

,

# &$

*

+

#

*

' (

" "

.

%

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

- )

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

- )

) /

.

+ &$

) )

- . &

)

+0

1

) )

) )

) )

)

)

)

)

)

1

1

1

1

< #

$

# &$ *

% ' (

+

"

,

# &$

*

+

#

" "

+ &$

' (

.2

+0

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

- )

)

- )

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

1

1

1

1

1

* #

$

# &$ *

% ' (

+

"

,

# &$

*

+

#

"

+ &$

.2

+0

3

%

$

")

"&$

+

"% 6

9 3

'

)

)

- )

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

- )

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

- )

)

)

)

)

)

1

1

1

1

1

$ % 4

!

3

' (

"

)

67

"

$

.

.

5

! ' &

) 4

$

&$ &

!"

!" & "

. $

& $

)

"

!

D $

!

( 3

$ " $

%"

! ( 3 "

! $

. !

"

"

"

"

"

$

( 3

! . !

$

!"

$

! !

!"

$

;

!

! ;

,

" 5

!"

'5 $

"

=!

!"

$

!"

( 1 "

$

$ !"

$

1

"

2. ! $

. 2 %"

"

(

$

1 " %"

$

!

$

!

!

""

1 "

!

.

$

$

. !

. $

!"

$

$ (6D $

! 1 "

8

$

( =!

&4( D .

!

C

$

"

(6D $

!

!"

! ; "

"

"

$

=!

$ "

"

=!

$

! (

" $

" @!

$ !"

!

"

!"

!

"

,

$

$ 1

"

$

1 "

4( D( ' () 3

(

6

!

! $

!

"

$

( ,

;

$ !" 8

$

. B

. !"

$

2

!

"

$

$

. !

.

(

" $

1 "

"

" %

$ !

.

. ! "

! "

&" !

.

! "2 3

;

6'

89 ,

&

. !

$

.

&

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

"

)

)

)

)

)

)

!

"

)

)

)

- )

- )

- )

)

)

)

. !

$

% +

! .

#

,

!

.

3

- - 9

;

! $

3

:

.

" $

9 3

!" &

9

"

$

(

,

> . &.

3 !

2 !

$

!

$

%

"&$

2

3

6 6@

3


$

( J

" $

$

( >$ !

&

"

$

$ 4 (6D $

( D

8 "

$

! $

;

! "

. !

! " "

$ "

$

( >. $

6'

" )

( ,

" !

( D

"

!

$

! !

"

"

(

! "

1 "

! "

1 "

! "

&

! "

( 8 !

$

.

(

.

;

!

'"

.

'

"

!

!

,

$

. &

(

( "

!

$2 $

!

( 3

"

!

2 3

,

$ - ";

1 "

.

.

! (

" ";

$

;

"

$

!

"

!

1

( ? "

,

.

!

$3

6

! "2

6

: ! 2. !

$

$ ( 6( , #

E

$

%

$ 3

B

2

!"

.

"$

1

%"

D

8

3

!

1 " ( 3

.

!

'

$ ! "

; ' $

!

$

!

;

$

%"

!

! ;

2. !

$

$

B

. ( ,

&" ! $

K

!

"

!"

$

'( :

"

.

(

$

!

2

$7

!"

$ ;

"

.

! "

$

( 6

. ! (

.

"

!

( 3

!

. (

!

$

!

" $

2

" %)

1 "

.

!"

$ !

3 !

.

"

(

+ , 3

$

$

-

!"

!" $

1 " $

!

"

. ! "

( 8

!

. $

( " $

.

.

"" %"

!

$

$ 2

" ! ; .

. ( 8

$

! $

5

. !

"

!"

$ $

#

# %

=!

.

.

$

!

; .

;

.

K

%

! ;

$

! ( A .

8 #

"

. !

. !

" $

$

! ;

"

"

"

!

$ !

( 3

"

$ $

" !" !"

(

#

# #

8 @

$ '

!

# > . &

> . &

&

&

1B

&

&$

"

.

. "

) )

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

1B

)

0 1

!

89

!

&

)

) )

)

1

!

)

)

"1 B

-

)

)

1B

.

0 1

+ &$

) ) )

1B

, + &$

- . &

)

.

"

3

)

67

& /

> . &

) 67

,

- . &

)

67

@ !

3 )

1B

+$

#

)

)

1

)

1

1

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

1

1

1

1

$

. & >

.

#

"

+

:

&1


"

.

#

" +

' , ,

&

3

%

$ $

0

= !

& 1 +2C $

"

+

&

=

3 .

=

'

+

'

$ 1B

:

&1
( &

N E . 6( $ A

4' L "

J( & ' L3 J( 2: (

! ( :

J( &

-

(

( J

I( @( ,

!" " 4

MN
@ !

"

"

2 (

E ! N "

-" "

9

N

>(

6 (

2

(

" N

"

2 9

-

6' L:!

.

:

(

(

& ' L3 N3 E .

8

1 " $ -"
2

2 ( & - ";

( 8 ; & * +

$ 42 4 (

( :O =. !"

+( J .

( : ";

@( & 62 (

" ( : ";

@(@( $

@(@( : ";

'A

-"

?

2

(

(

"

$

2

" .

&

2

$3

"

(

4( : -"

-"

"

" @( @( : "; * . $

I "!

!

1 " $ !" ; $I

' L "

' LJ

1 "

$ "

(

&

1 " -" (

2 (

( ?( + !

( -.

'L

E( E . N ?(( -

' L N 3

& N - " "

6' L " ,

& 4 'L I ! &

(' A

$ "

"

" E ! " E . 4

"

J " # ! :!

? ;$ 6 2 (

-!

N E

"

.

$ $ I

P ; AP98

(

. ! ;

$

" 2

J

( +!

( ?( & Q

6( I $

' L =! * .

"

+( !

J( +

3

!" $ E

!

& 4 ' L:! " I N
/

3 - "

.

! $ "

@ !

N 8 ; ( 9 3 "

1 " 2

( ( I " )

;

( E .

K (

E( -" B

( I

I

(

(

3(

;! *

!

(

! !

" $

& 3! 2 $2 " I

(

" 9 8 6C (

4(

( & 8

-( & 4 ' L-; . $O ( (

"

(,

" "

" N

(

( 8 J(

+( *( 9 .

"

?( & 4 ' NE N@ ! $ " E( & * . !

>( & J

& .

'L 2 6 2

6' L " $

. -"

! ! 62

;$!

-" " 9

I RA !

9 ,O O; .

9

)

N - ";

"; "

)

-

" H! " " * .

N( ,

2

(

/ ! 1 " " 6 64 26 (

4' L !" A P ;( 'L " $ "

' L3 !

! N ,-

"

9

!2 ;

$E

N 3 "

$

$*

S(

N

(