Apr 26, 2004 - find that the reform increased both the educational attainment and the ... Keywords: Human Capital, Evaluation of Education Reform, CompreM.
EDUCATIONAL REFORM, ABILITY AND FAMILY BACKGROUND Costas Meghir Mårten Palme
THE INSTITUTE FOR FISCAL STUDIES
WP04/10
!" #
#
%
#
$ %
& '
( )
#
*
+
#
% , %
#
#
-
.
/ , & & &0 1&2 13 /, 4 4 6. * ) 7 $ 1 , 8 # 8
$
89
;
# 4
4
#
4 !
#
5 < >
< = ?
! !
;
+ +
% 8
6
= *4
6 ?
C
B8
4 :
1
) 1 > , # ! ! @ ! 5 A =
4
:
!"
:
$ 4
9 )
1
$ 6 5 ! $
%
6 < 4
=
? < 4
! / 4< !
1 6 %
% 6 %
#
5 4=?
6 %
4 6
$
# 54 6
#
!
"
(
(
"
.
: ";
"
$
$
" .
;
"
"
"
"
"
1
;
)
)
.
?
"
!.
$
@!
(
!
!"
!
" 2 2
'
"
"
!
!
$!
$
. " ! "2 #
1 +
" =!
"
$
$
!
!
!"
"
( 3
"
"
!
"
!
( :
!
!
"
.
"!
" ! " ( ?
!" ! "
3
!
$
"
-" $
!
! "
6
$
!"
( ( "
.
( 3 $
!
! $
"
( "
?
"
) $
"
6
$ )
"
"( 3
B "
$
" ! " ( " .
%
"
!
(
! "
. #
"
%
$ $ "
2
.
! " !"
! "
! "
!
! "
E ' 0 ( #
(
-
"
#!
A
"! ! (
!
A !
(
!
.
! " 5
!
"
) !
"
"
)
.
$"
$ .
"
)
.
!
!
"
"
.
.
. !
"
!
"
"! ! .
3
"
! 1
" "!
. "
"
"
"
! ,
=!
"
"
"!
"
!
"
9 "
"
"
" . #!
)
"
@!
(
4
"
( 3
I-'
"
.
" .
-=!
!
! :
I
$
D
# .
"
" !2
"
( 3
$
1
)" !
"
%"
" .
" .
!
$
( :
.
"
"
(
$
!
"!
"
!
"!
" !
!" $
.
;
.
$
!( :
!
$
"
1 "
.
"
"!
!"
.
!
"
;
;
1 " (
.
"
3
H "
"
.
""
(
& 3
$
"
3
$
$
!"
3
$ $ $
B
!"
$
&
'
!"
! ;
>I-
$
$
!
$
!"
$
1 "
$
.
( ,
1 "
.
$
$
" !"
8
!" 1 "
$
. (
!
1 "
$
$
$ "
( "
" D #
!
.
4(
2
" $
. 5 .
!
"
"
!
""
+
'(
$
!
:
&
(
.
.
;
( ,
(
"
=!
3
=!
$
$
$
( 8
(
$
"
" !"
$
$
(
' 0B( + 03I & 3
J
#
H #
4
.
H #
"
!" $
3
!"
( 4 $
1 "
! ;
;
$
!
"
&" !
'( 8 .
(
1 "
!
!
!
&" !
""
3
"
"
!
"
!
.
=! ( :
.
!
$
$
$
"
'( 3 !
"
(
$
$ "
.
! ;
%"
!"
" "
"
!
$
.
.
" $
(
3
;
1 "
.
( 3
"
"
!
1
"
.
$
(
&
"
8
"
$
$
.
!
. 4 2 $
$ $
=!
3
1 " 4(4D
$
1
!
"
%"
.
.
$
$
$
.
. ( :
.
$
. !
.
(
( ,
! ; %"
!
&
"
$ $
!
) $
$
(
. ! ;
$2 1 "
"
" &2 ( D' .
"
( D
$
( >
>I-
(
6( D 1 "
8
1 "
3 .
"
. (
1 "
!
$
$
!
" 3
2 )
.
" (
2
2 1
" .
. !
;
1 "'
!
"
< #
$
# &$ *
% ' (
+
"
,
# &$
*
+
#
*
' (
" "
.
%
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
- )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
- )
) /
.
+ &$
) )
- . &
)
+0
1
) )
) )
) )
)
)
)
)
)
1
1
1
1
< #
$
# &$ *
% ' (
+
"
,
# &$
*
+
#
" "
+ &$
' (
.2
+0
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
- )
)
- )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
1
1
1
1
1
* #
$
# &$ *
% ' (
+
"
,
# &$
*
+
#
"
+ &$
.2
+0
3
%
$
")
"&$
+
"% 6
9 3
'
)
)
- )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
- )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
- )
)
)
)
)
)
1
1
1
1
1
$ % 4
!
3
' (
"
)
67
"
$
.
.
5
! ' &
) 4
$
&$ &
!"
!" & "
. $
& $
)
"
!
D $
!
( 3
$ " $
%"
! ( 3 "
! $
. !
"
"
"
"
"
$
( 3
! . !
$
!"
$
! !
!"
$
;
!
! ;
,
" 5
!"
'5 $
"
=!
!"
$
!"
( 1 "
$
$ !"
$
1
"
2. ! $
. 2 %"
"
(
$
1 " %"
$
!
$
!
!
""
1 "
!
.
$
$
. !
. $
!"
$
$ (6D $
! 1 "
8
$
( =!
&4( D .
!
C
$
"
(6D $
!
!"
! ; "
"
"
$
=!
$ "
"
=!
$
! (
" $
" @!
$ !"
!
"
!"
!
"
,
$
$ 1
"
$
1 "
4( D( ' () 3
(
6
!
! $
!
"
$
( ,
;
$ !" 8
$
. B
. !"
$
2
!
"
$
$
. !
.
(
" $
1 "
"
" %
$ !
.
. ! "
! "
&" !
.
! "2 3
;
6'
89 ,
&
. !
$
.
&
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
"
)
)
)
)
)
)
!
"
)
)
)
- )
- )
- )
)
)
)
. !
$
% +
! .
#
,
!
.
3
- - 9
;
! $
3
:
.
" $
9 3
!" &
9
"
$
(
,
> . &.
3 !
2 !
$
!
$
%
"&$
2
3
6 6@
3
$
( J
" $
$
( >$ !
&
"
$
$ 4 (6D $
( D
8 "
$
! $
;
! "
. !
! " "
$ "
$
( >. $
6'
" )
( ,
" !
( D
"
!
$
! !
"
"
(
! "
1 "
! "
1 "
! "
&
! "
( 8 !
$
.
(
.
;
!
'"
.
'
"
!
!
,
$
. &
(
( "
!
$2 $
!
( 3
"
!
2 3
,
$ - ";
1 "
.
.
! (
" ";
$
;
"
$
!
"
!
1
( ? "
,
.
!
$3
6
! "2
6
: ! 2. !
$
$ ( 6( , #
E
$
%
$ 3
B
2
!"
.
"$
1
%"
D
8
3
!
1 " ( 3
.
!
'
$ ! "
; ' $
!
$
!
;
$
%"
!
! ;
2. !
$
$
B
. ( ,
&" ! $
K
!
"
!"
$
'( :
"
.
(
$
!
2
$7
!"
$ ;
"
.
! "
$
( 6
. ! (
.
"
!
( 3
!
. (
!
$
!
" $
2
" %)
1 "
.
!"
$ !
3 !
.
"
(
+ , 3
$
$
-
!"
!" $
1 " $
!
"
. ! "
( 8
!
. $
( " $
.
.
"" %"
!
$
$ 2
" ! ; .
. ( 8
$
! $
5
. !
"
!"
$ $
#
# %
=!
.
.
$
!
; .
;
.
K
%
! ;
$
! ( A .
8 #
"
. !
. !
" $
$
! ;
"
"
"
!
$ !
( 3
"
$ $
" !" !"
(
#
# #
8 @
$ '
!
# > . &
> . &
&
&
1B
&
&$
"
.
. "
) )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
1B
)
0 1
!
89
!
&
)
) )
)
1
!
)
)
"1 B
-
)
)
1B
.
0 1
+ &$
) ) )
1B
, + &$
- . &
)
.
"
3
)
67
& /
> . &
) 67
,
- . &
)
67
@ !
3 )
1B
+$
#
)
)
1
)
1
1
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
1
1
1
1
$
. & >
.
#
"
+
:
&1
"
.
#
" +
' , ,
&
3
%
$ $
0
= !
& 1 +2C $
"
+
&
=
3 .
=
'
+
'
$ 1B
:
&1
( &
N E . 6( $ A
4' L "
J( & ' L3 J( 2: (
! ( :
J( &
-
(
( J
I( @( ,
!" " 4
MN
@ !
"
"
2 (
E ! N "
-" "
9
N
>(
6 (
2
(
" N
"
2 9
-
6' L:!
.
:
(
(
& ' L3 N3 E .
8
1 " $ -"
2
2 ( & - ";
( 8 ; & * +
$ 42 4 (
( :O =. !"
+( J .
( : ";
@( & 62 (
" ( : ";
@(@( $
@(@( : ";
'A
-"
?
2
(
(
"
$
2
" .
&
2
$3
"
(
4( : -"
-"
"
" @( @( : "; * . $
I "!
!
1 " $ !" ; $I
' L "
' LJ
1 "
$ "
(
&
1 " -" (
2 (
( ?( + !
( -.
'L
E( E . N ?(( -
' L N 3
& N - " "
6' L " ,
& 4 'L I ! &
(' A
$ "
"
" E ! " E . 4
"
J " # ! :!
? ;$ 6 2 (
-!
N E
"
.
$ $ I
P ; AP98
(
. ! ;
$
" 2
J
( +!
( ?( & Q
6( I $
' L =! * .
"
+( !
J( +
3
!" $ E
!
& 4 ' L:! " I N
/
3 - "
.
! $ "
@ !
N 8 ; ( 9 3 "
1 " 2
( ( I " )
;
( E .
K (
E( -" B
( I
I
(
(
3(
;! *
!
(
! !
" $
& 3! 2 $2 " I
(
" 9 8 6C (
4(
( & 8
-( & 4 ' L-; . $O ( (
"
(,
" "
" N
(
( 8 J(
+( *( 9 .
"
?( & 4 ' NE N@ ! $ " E( & * . !
>( & J
& .
'L 2 6 2
6' L " $
. -"
! ! 62
;$!
-" " 9
I RA !
9 ,O O; .
9
)
N - ";
"; "
)
-
" H! " " * .
N( ,
2
(
/ ! 1 " " 6 64 26 (
4' L !" A P ;( 'L " $ "
' L3 !
! N ,-
"
9
!2 ;
$E
N 3 "
$
$*
S(
N
(
