in new assiut city (nac), from cradle to grave lca analysis. .... Adjusted Life Years; PDF Potentially Disappeared Fraction of species; eq equivalents; y year.
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 349 – 356
I="CI:GC6I>DC6A DC;:G:C8: "CI:G9>H8>EA>C6G>IN>C CC::G>CB7 +
7?3;876/7=+57137//;371/9+;=6/7=1B9= +9+7'73?/;6A 7J>A9>CC:CI GDA: >C HJHI6>C67A: 9:K:ADEB:CI 6C9 :CK>GDCB:CI6A >BE68IH -=:G:;DG: I=: 6>B D; I=>H E6E:G >H JH>C;: 8N8A: 6HH:HHB:CI % IDDA ID 6HH:HH I=: :CK>GDCB:CI6A >BE68IH D; I=: 6C INE>86A G:H>9:CI>6A 7J>A9>C< ,>B6)GD /
L6HJH:9>CI=:6C6ANH>H JC9:G",( HI6C96G9H +:HJAIHH=DLI=6I I=:B6>C8DCIG>7JIDGID6AADI=:G :CK>GDCB:CI6A>BE68IH6G:B6>CAN I=DH: G:A6I:9ID:C:GCI=:DE:G6I>DC6A JH:HI67JI>CHEDH6A H8:C6G>DH EGDK>9: EDH>I>K: :CK>GDCB:CI6A >BE68IH 7N
JGI=:G EDHH>7A: B:6HJG:H ID :C=6C8: I=: :CK>GDCB:CI6A >BE68IH 6G: B:CI>DC:9 >CI=: E6E:G 8DC8AJH>DCH
P -=:JI=DGH )J7A>H=:97N AH:K>:G%I9
© 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). CC::G>C
DC6C9 DGE::G G:K>:LJC9:GG:HEDCH>7>A>IND;Y):IGJ&6>DGZ.C>K:GH>IND;->G;: 68=HI6H8DBEDH:9D;6CJB7:GD; 68I>K>I>:H DG >C9JHIG>6A EGD9J8IH I=:H: HI6C:9 6H B6I:G>6A 68FJ>H>I>DC B6CJ;68IJG>CCI:C6C8: 6C9 :C9 D; A>;: "C 86H: D; 7J>A9>C6AH B6CJ;68IJG>CDCJH:6C9B6>CI:C6C8:6C9:C9D;A>;: 4 5
DGG:HEDC9>C6A;GDBI=::6GI=IG6CHEDGI6I>DCD;I=:H:B6I:G>6AHIDI=:B6CJ;68IJG>C< AD86I>DC B6CJ;68IJG: D; ;>C>H=:9 DG >CI:GB:9>6I: B6I:G>6AH 7J>A9>C86I>DC 6C9 E68@6CHIG>7JI>DCD;7J>A9>CHE=6H:688DJCIH ;DG68I>K>I>:HG:A6I>CDCD;67J>A9>C86AANI=:;DAADL>C< 68I>K>I>:H6G:>C8AJ9:9>CI=>HHI6DCD;B6I:G>6AH6C9EGD9J8IHIDI=:EGD?:8IH>I:JH:D;EDL:GIDDAH 6C9 :FJ>EB:CI 9JG>CDC D; I=: 7J>A9>CI: ;67G>86I>DC 6C9 :C:GI: LDG@ ):GB6C:CI >BE68IHIDI=:7J>A9>CI:6AHD;6AA>CIDI=>HHI6JI >IN ' ;GDB 8G69A: ID H -D HIJ9N 6 G:H>9:CI>6A E6II:GC 6C9 6C6ANO: >IH BD9:AHI=:6G:6D;:68=E6II:GC=69ID7:86A8JA6I:96ADCI=>IHE:G8:CI6CI=:=DJH>CHIHD;;>K:E=6H:H -=:;>GHI6C9I=>G9E=6H:6G:AD86I:9>CI=: H:8DC99>HIG>8I 0=:G:6HI=:;>;I=HI6CI=:;>GHI9>HIG>8I6C9I=:H:8DC96C9;DJGI=E=6H:H6G:AD86I:9>CI=:;JIJG: :MI:CH>DCD;I=: ' 45
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
JC8I>DC6AJC>I -=:;JC8I>DC6AJC>ID;I=:HIJ9N>HI=:JH67A:;ADDGHE68: B D;I=:7J>A9>CH I=:6BDJCID;B6I:G>6AG:FJ>G:9IDEGD9J8:67J>A9>CCA9>C< HIJ9>:9 >C8AJ9>C6A B6CJ;68IJG>C;: 9>HEDH6A >C8>C:G6I>DC 6C9 DG G:8N8A>CC8AJ9>C6AH 6C9 :C:G;: 8N8A: HI6I:8IJG6A B6I:G>6AH 6C9 6HH:B7A>:H >C8AJ9: EG>B6GN B6I:G>6AH 6C9 6AA 699>I>DC6A B6I:G>6AHG:FJ>G:9;DGI=:EGD9J8IXHB6CJ;68IJG>CC8AJ9>CK:H8D6I>CC>H=>CI= I=: :M8:EI>DC D; @CDLC 8=:B>86AH I=6I =6K: =>GDCB:CI6A >BE68IH 6I ADL A:K:AH -D I=: 7:HI D; I=: 6JI=DGH @CDLA:9DJH 6JI=DGH A>I:G6IJG: L=>8=EJ7A>H=:9>C 4 5 CK:CIDGN96I676H:I=JH I=:6JI=DGH8DAA:8I:96AA G:FJ>G:9FJ6CI>I>:H6C9HE:8>;>86I>DCH D;I=:G:H>9:CI>6A7J>A9>CC -67A: 6C96CNB>HH>CAA 7: I6@:C ;GDB A>I:G6IJG: G:K>:L 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A E6E:GH L=>8= HJBB6G>O:9 >C >C +,/C+ /= +54
5 6HHJBEI>DCH 6C9 8D>CK:CI/ 6I676H: >CI=:,>B6)GDHD;IL6G:
-67A: DAA:8I:9 FJ6CI>I>:H6C9HE:8>;>86I>DCHD;I=: H:A:8I:9 G:H>9:CI>6A7J>A9>C< >C A9>C< &6I:G>6AH
,I::A $
IN @< B
,6C9 BI=:9:CH>IN @< B
G6K:A BI=:9:CH>IN @< B
06I:G;DG8DCHIGJ8I>CA9>CI:GI=:9:CH>IN @< B
0DD9:C BI=:9:CH>IN @< B A6HHB 6C9 I=:I=>8@C:HH 8BI=:9:CH>IN @< B
-G6CHEDGI6I>DC
DCHIGJ8I>DCD; J>A9>C8 B 6C9 I=:I=>8@C:HH 8BI=:9:CH>IN @< B
)A6HI:G)6>CIH B 6C9 I=:I=>8@C:HH 8BI=:9:CH>IN @< B
GDB :B:CI 6C97G>8@ 9>HIG>7JIDGH ID7J>A9>CI: $&
GDBDI=:GB6I:G>6AH9>HIG>7JIDGHID7J>A9>CI:$&
-NE:D;-GJ8@IG6CHEDGI6I>DCH
(E:G6I>DC6A.H:
:BDA>I>DC C9 D; %>;:
DGIG6CHEDGII=:8:B:CI
IDC;DGDC:IGJ8@ -GJ8@H.C>I;DG $&
DGIG6CHEDGII=:H6C9 B ;DGDC:IGJ8@ -GJ8@H.C>I;DG$&
DGIG6CHEDGII=:7G>8@
7G>8@C::9DCANDC:IGJ8@;DG$&
DGIG6CHEDGII=:HI::A $AA>CI;DG $&ID9>HEDH6AH>I:
,(>IC::9HIGJ8@JC>I ;GDBIGJ8@IDCC6I>DC6A :B:CI&>M:G6C9I=:LDG@:GH>CI=:7J>A9>CI:;DG$&IDI=: 9>HEDH6AH>I: 768@6C9;DGI=
DG9G>AA>CCI:G
DG-G69>I>DC6A :B:CI&>M:G
0DG@>CI:G
A:8IG>8>IN DCHJBEI>DC&DCI=AN$0
06I:G DCHJBEI>DC&DCI=AN B
'6IJG6A 6H DCHJBEI>DC&DCI=AN B
%&$%-" %"3 1 /+- &.0."!/+!")+(&.%/%" 0&(!&*$ #/"- 4" -.(&#"., *
+-'&*$%+0-.
+( -$ . +*.0),/&+* &/"-
+-/- *.,+-/+0/,0/+# 0&(!&*$!")+(&/&+* /+!&.,+. (.&/"
&.,+. (. "* -&+
*!#&(( &.,+. ( *!"0."
#-+) 0&(!&*$) /"-& (.2&(( "-" 4 ("! *!/%"-") &*!"- 2&(( " 0-*"!* &*"- /&+*
353
Ahmed Abdel Monteleb M. Ali et al. / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 349 – 356
&6CJ;68IJG>CC8AJ9:H 8G69A: ID C7A: -=>H >C8AJ9:H G6L B6I:G>6A :MIG68I>DC 6C9 EGD8:HH>CCI:GB:9>6I: IG6CHEDGI6I>DC 6C9 ;>C6A B6CJ;68IJG>CB>I6I>DCH =DL:K:G HDB: B6CJ;68IJG>C6A 6C9 :C:GG:B:CIH ;DG 6HH:B7A>CC9DLH -=:B6CJ;68IJG>CHA>HI:9;DG:68=:CIGN9:I6>A>C;>8>C8AJH>DCHDG :M8AJH>DCHI=6I;6AADJIH>9:D;I=:8G69A: ID 8G69A: H8DE: -G6CHEDGI6I>DCD;JEHIG:6BG6LB6I:G>6AHDG>CI:GB:9>6I: EGD9J8IHID;>C6AB6CJ;68IJG>CHC8AJ9:9>CI=:,>B6)GD96I6H:IHJI>A>O:9L>I=>CI=>HIDDA -G6CHEDGI6I>DC G:FJ>G:B:CIH7:IL::CI=:B6CJ;68IJG:G6C9>CHI6AA6I>DCDGJH:D;I=:EGD9J8I6C96II=::C9 D; A>;:D;I=:EGD9J8I 6G: >C8AJ9:9;GDBI=>HHIJ9N "C;G6HIGJ8IJG:7J>A9>CC:GNG:FJ>G:9;DGI=:B6CJ;68IJG>CA9>C6AH 6H L:AA 6H E68@6C6AH 6G: >C8AJ9:9 6C9 6G: 8DCH>9:G:9 >CH>9: I=: H8DE: D; 6HH:HHB:CI
C9 D; A>;:IG:6IB:CI>H76H:9DC =NEDI=:I>86AH8:C6G>D7:86JH:"7C6NI6@EGD?:8I>C CA9>CI>DC 6C9 6AA 8DBEDC:CIH AA L>I=DJI 6CN 7:C:;>I -=>H >C8AJ9:H I=: G:A:K6CI B6I:G>6A 8DAA:8I>DC G6I:H ;DG G:8N8A>CCG:B:CIH ;DG G:8N8A:9 B6I:G>6AH>C8>C:G6I>DCG6I:H6C9A6C9;>AA>CCG:B:CIHI=:G:8N8A>C6AH>H BD9:A:9 JH>C9:9 7JG9:C 6EEGD68= L=:G: I=: 7JG9:C D; EG>B6GN B6I:G>6A EGD9J8I>DC >H 6AAD86I:9 ID I=: HJ7H:FJ:CIA>;:8N8A:76H:9DCI=:FJ6CI>IND;G:8DK:G:9H:8DC96GNB6I:G>6A -=:>BE68IH6HHD8>6I:9L>I=A6C9;>AA>C< 6G:76H:9DC6K:G66AEGDE:GI>:HHJ8=6HEA6HI>8L6HI:7>D9:C:GIB6I:G>6A ,E:8>;>8:C9 D; A>;:H8:C6G>DH6G:9:I6>A:9;DG:68=:CIGN >CI=:C:MII67A:
30/-B-5/369+-=+GDCB:CI6A >BE68IH D; I=: 9>;;:G:CI DEI>DCH
=6G68I:G>O6I>DC ;68IDGH DG :FJ>K6A:C8N ;68IDGH 9:H8G>7: I=: G:A6I>K: >BE68I D; I=: 9>;;:G:CI :CK>GDCB:CI6A ;ADLH4 5 A6GO6I>DC ;68IDG B:6CH 6 A6GBE68I ;DG I=6I ;ADL =6G68I:G>O6I>DC ;68IDGH 6G: BJAI>EA>:9 7N :68= D; I=: :CK>GDCB:CI6A ;ADLH ID 8DCK:GI 6AA I=:B >CID 6C :FJ>K6A:CI 6BDJCI D; I=: 86I:C9>86IDG -=: 86I:C9>86IDG >H I=: ;ADL I=6I >H JHJ6AAN 6HHD8>6I:9 L>I= I=6I E6GI>8JA6G >BE68I 86I:CHI6C8: ( ;DG C< 86I:7:H I=: :CK>GDCB:CI6A >BE68I 86I::H L=>8= 6G: G:FJ>G:9;DG% ">CK:CIDGN>CKDAK:9>C,>B6)GD/
-=>HHIJ9NJH:9I=:"&) - K:GH>DC* 86I:GDCB:CI6A>BE68IH D;I=: 6C INE>86A G:H>9:CI>6A7J>A9>C
O6I>DC;68IDGH6C996B6IHD;"&) - K:GH>DC* 4 5 4HDJG8:5
&>9ED>CI86I:9ED>CIG:;:G:C8:HJ7HI6C8:
6B6IN86G8>CDCDG :F
!JB6C=:6AI=
475
+:HE>G6IDGN>CDG8H
@CID6>G :F
!JB6C=:6AI=
475
"DC>O>C6I>DCH
F 6G7DC >CID6>G :F
!JB6C =:6AI=
475
(ODC:A6N:G9:EA:I>DC
@CID6>G :F
!JB6C=:6AI=
475
)=DID8=:B>86ADM>96I>DC +:HE>G6IDGNDG8H;DG =JB6C=:6AI=
@CID6>G :F
465
FJ6I>8:8DIDM>8>IN
@:I=NA:C: CID L6I:G :F
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
465
-:GG:HIG>6A:8DIDM>8>IN
@:I=NA:C:CID HD>A :F
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
475
-:GG:HIG>6A 68>9>;>86I>DC CJIG>;>86I>DC
6B6I
'DGB6A>O:9 96B6I
%2
)D>CI
C 6
C 6
!JB6C=:6AI=
@CID6>G :F
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
) QBQN
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
)D>CI
354
Ahmed Abdel Monteleb M. Ali et al. / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 349 – 356
4HDJG8:5
&>9ED>CI86I:9ED>CIG:;:G:C8:HJ7HI6C8:
485
FJ6I>868>9>;>86I>DC
@CID6>G :F
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
485
FJ6I>8:JIGDE=>86I>DC
@CIDL6I:G :F
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
475
%6C9D88JE6I>DC
B (G86G67A:A6C9 :FQN
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
06I:GIJG7>C:9
>CK:CIDGN>CB
8DHNHI:BFJ6A>IN
@CID6>G :F
A>B6I:8=6C;: HJEEDGIHNHI:B
4") 5
AD76A L6GB>C
O:9 96B6I
@CID 6>G :F
)D>CI
&#
)D>CI
+:HDJG8:H +:HDJG8:H
)+* #& ),*-837.3-+=8;)-* ).*-837?/7=) #* #$$/98;=+7.)'%#*# (3< -=:C:ILDG@;ADLD; J>A9>CC >< I=:8DBE6G>HDC7:IL::CI=:7J>A9>CBE68IHED>CID; K>:L -=:G:6G:I=G::>BE68IH L=>8=>C;AJ:C8: C:K:ANDCI=::CK>GDCB:CI C6B:AN I=:G:HE>G6IDGN>CDG8H CHD7H:GK:9I=6II=:DE:G6I>DC6A JH:E=6H:>HI=: B6?DG8DCIG>7JIDGIDI=:96B6IN8A>B6I:8=6CDC -=: B>C>BJB :;;:8I >H DC I=: :8DHNHI:B FJ6A>IN 9:DC -=: ;>CA9>CHEDH6AH8:C6G>D 7N )I 8DED>CI;DGI=::CK>GDCB:CI
>< CK>GDCB:CI6A>BE68IDJI;ADLH;DG I=:JH67A:;ADDGHE68: B D;I=:7J>A9>C< JC9:G C9ED>CI>BE68I
355
356
Ahmed Abdel Monteleb M. Ali et al. / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 349 – 356
" 88DG9>CH67DK: I=:G:HJAIH>C9>86I:I=6II=:JH: HI6H6AHDI=: B6>C8DCIG>7JIDGID6AADI=:G :CK>GDCB:CI6A >BE68IHL=>8= 6G:B6>CANG:A6I:9ID:C:GCI=:DE:G6I>DC6A JH: HI68= 8DCIG>7JI: ;GDBI=:IDI6A:;;:8IH -=:B6>C>BE68I 86I::HI=6I=6K:I=:7>CDG8HCH I=: B6>C >BEGDK:B:CI DEEDGIJC>I>:H >C I=: =DJH>C:>CI=:G:9J8I>DCD;I=:>BE68IH>C I=:JH:HI6AHIE:DEA: 7:=6K>DG EA6NH67>< GDA: I=:BEGDK:B:CIDEEDGIJC>I>:H6G:>CI=:9:H>HCDI:LDGI=NI=6I DJGG:H:6G8=EG:H:CIH6JH:;JA6C6ANH>H;DG=:AE>CHI>8HD; 69K:GH: :CK>GDCB:CI6A :;;:8IH D; 6C 7J>A9>CC9 I=: :CK>GDCB:CI6A HDAJI>DCH ID B>C>B>O: I=: 69K:GH: :CK>GDCB:CI6A >BE68IH HJ8= 6H G:9J8>CCC< HJHI6>C67A: B6I:G>6AH 6C9 DG8DCHIGJ8I>DC6HH:B7A>:H L>I=ADC8:A>K:HHJ8=I=6II=:N6G:G:EA68:9A:HHDK:GI=:7J>A9>C;:8N8A: 6C9 JH>CC67A:;J:AH6C9G6LB6I:G>6AH >CI=:7J>A9>C6AEG:E6G6I>DCHI6GHI 6JI=DG LDJA9 A>@: ID I=6C@ 6C &>C>HIGN D; !>DC &D! ;DG EGDK>9>CB I=: ;>C6C8>6A HJEEDGI )= H8=DA6GH=>E ;DG I=>H G:H:6G8= 6H L:AA 6H I=: K:GH>IN D; ,8>:C8: 6C9 -:8=CDADCA>IN6C9IDDAHC::9:9ID8DC9J8II=>HLDG@
4 5 #DH=> , " J>9:IDJ>A9>C;: N8A:HH:HHB:CI>C)G68I>8: -=:B:G>86C"CHI>IJI:D;G8=>I:8IH E
45 J>C:: # %>;: N8A:HH:HHB:CI C(E:G6I>DC6A J>9:IDI=:",(,I6C96G9H $AJL:G869:B>8)J7A>H=:GH DG9G:8=I KDA
45 G:C6 +DH6 %>;: 8N8A: 6HH:HHB:CI D; :C:GGDCB:CI6A >BEA>86I>DCH D; I=: >BEA:B:CI6I>DC D; 8DCH:GK6I>DC I:8=CDAD:H >C H8=DDA7J>A9>CC&:C9DO6GC6J>A9 6C9 CK>G #DJGC6A KDA CD EE W
45 ,8=:J:G ) $:DA:>6C +:EE: %>;: 8N8A: :C:GGDCB:CI6A E:G;DGB6C8: D; 6C:L JC>K:GH>IN 7J>A9>CC< 8=6AA:CBEA>86I>DCH ' KDA EE W
45 DA: + C:G6I:9L>I=I=: 8DCHIGJ8I>DCD;6AI:GC6I>K: HIGJ8IJG6AHNHI:BH ' KDA CD EE W
45 A> .H>CBJA6I>DC ;DG HIJ9N>CC;AJ:C8: D; K:GI>86A H=69>C8:H DC I=: I=:GB6A E:G;DGB6C8: D; G:H>9:CI>6A 7J>A9>CGDCB:CI6AB6C6;:8N8A:6HH:HHB:CI W )G>C8>EA:H6C9;G6B:LDG@ ,I6C96G9H JHIG6A>6',0JHIG6A>6
4
5 67:O66 % +>C8VC6 />A6G>TD7 /)RG:O6 6HI:AA6 %>;:8N8A:6HH:HHB:CI% 6C9A>;:8N8A::C:GH% D;7J>A9>CA9>C:L +:C:L67A:6C9,JHI6>C67A: C:G:LH KDA EE W
4 5 A> ':
