Dynamic assessment, as manner of alternative process-based assessment, is currently at ..... 2.4.5.1First axis Å A Jungian typology . ...... Static measures can be utilized and extended dynamically (Lidz & Thomas, 1987) and ...... contextualised perhaps more so due to the nature of Soviet psychology's history (Sutton, 1988).
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
!
"
"
#"
$
%
$&
' ( )*! +' ,*, $ * * +' -!( -!( +)+ !
,.
-
-
2334
.,-+ /
-,*! +'
*+ ,
+' --+ $010'0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
'
$" 0,
5
7
"
5 9
8 *
6 0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
Acknowledgements *
"
"
• • •
10
• •
* $
" $ 7
"
9 +
/
7 "
" 10
"
$
7
-
9
7
9
"
"
"
#"
,
" " :
9
;
7
?@?&
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
Summary $
9 9
9 7
7
"
9
"
9
"
0
"
7
9 "
7 "
"
"
A
"
" "
"
"
" 0, " "
" #"
9 B0F@> 2332& 7 0,
" 2
#"
" " 7 " 9 0-
7 "
"
C
0
"
0 *
7 9
" "
*
0 ,
"
- " 6
7
#"
7
7
7 "
"
9
"
7
"
#"
"
"
7
""
"
A
9 7
"
7
7
0 * "
"
7 0 ,
" "
9
7
" 7
7
" 0
7
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
B $
9 9
9
9
9
"
9 9
9
9
9 - 7 9 9 #"
9
9
"
9 .
9
9
9
"
9
9 9
0
Opsomming $
7 "
9 " 7
G
7
7 " 7
9
" 7 "
0$ 7
H
9
" 7 7
7 "
"
7 -
7
7
7
7 " 7
" 7
7
7
9
"
"
"
7 " " 7
7 7 0$
"
9
0 7 " "
G "
G
0 7
7 "
"
"
7
G
7 7 7
5 0G
G
9
E
7 7
" 7
7 9 7 0$
"L
9
0 5 G
0 *
"
7
7
%>F@> M 2332& 7 "
G
&7
-"
"
G 7
G 7
J 7 "
7
" 7
7
"
7 0+
7 7 "
7
" 7
" 7
" G
7 "I
9G
%
" 7 7 "
7 7
"
9
"
7 7
97
7
$
7 "
7 0$
" "
0 -
7 "
G
"
7
"
7
7 "
"
7
I 7
G
7 " 7 "
0$
7
7 0 * " 0 $
9
5
JA "
7 "
7 7
K
$ " 7
:
7 7 "
7
"
7 J 9 G
-
0 $ " 9 7 "
0 "
"
7
" G "
7
0$
"
"
"
"
7
7 7
"
G "
7
0$
7 " 7
7
7
7
.
" "
"
"
7 7
" 7 "
7
0 $
7
=
7
"
H
0*
7 "
"
"
" $
" G 7
" 7
"
H 7
7 "
"
= " "
9
"
9
7 9
) 7 . =
" 7 7 7 0* " " 0 7 " 9
H
7
7
7
7 " "
" "
" 7
0
=
7
7 9
9 "
7
G
7
7 " 9 7 " 9G $ 7
9 B0 ,
>0>
02
"
" "
7
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 > 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >
>0P
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2
>0Q $
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2
>0R
"
>0@
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P
- "
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q
A
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 R
>04 $ >0? *
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 @
>0?0>
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 4
>0F
"
>0>3 (
"
(
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ?
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 F
2
20> ,
"
202 )
"
9 "
2020>
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3
20202 E" 20P
00000 >3
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3 "
20P0> *
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >> 7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>
20Q )
/
" 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>
20Q0>
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>
20Q02 *
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>
20Q0P -
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >2
20Q0Q
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >2
20Q0R
M
20Q0R0>'
M
1"
20Q0R02 "
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q "
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >4
M
7 0
20Q0R0P0R 20Q0R0P0@
% 7 0
20Q0R0P04 20Q0R0P0? 20R -"
"
% ,& M
"
&7 0
"
0000000000000000 >?
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2P
7
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2@
7 0
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P2
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 PP 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 PQ
204 $ 2040>
"
" O " " 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P>
20@ $ / "
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 PQ
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q?
2040>0> - 7
.
A
"7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 RR
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 43 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 42
20?0> $
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 4P
20?02
"
20?0P - " 20?0Q +
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >P
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q
20Q0R0P0P (
20? ,
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >2
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >P
20Q0R0P02 *
20402 ("
"
/
M
20Q0R0P0> ,
7
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >2
M
20Q0R0P *
20Q0R0P0Q
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 4? "
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ?2 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ?Q
7
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
20?0Q0> ) 7
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 F3
20?0R !
M
20?0@ (
;0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 FR
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 F4
20?04
7
20F -"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3@
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3F
20>3 (
"
( P0> ,
7
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>>
P$ "
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>2 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>2
P02 -
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>2
P020>
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>R
P0202 -
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>4
P0P -
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>F
P0P0>
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >24
P0Q
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >2F
P0Q0>
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >P>
P0Q02
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >P@
P0Q020> (
9
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >P?
P0R *
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q2
P0@ *
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >R2
P04 -"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >R@
P0? B0R@
P0F
A
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >R?
P0F0>
A
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >RF
P0F02
A
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >RF
P0F0P
A 7
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@>
P0F0Q
A 7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@>
P0>3
A
7
/-
7
000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@P
P0>30> *
" 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@R
P0>302 *
" 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >4>
P0>30P *
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >4@
P0>> (
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >44
P0>>0> *
#"
P0>2
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?>
P0>P (
"
(
Q*
Q0> ,
"
Q0>0> *
#"
% E& 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >4?
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?2
"
/
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?Q
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?Q
Q02
7
7 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?Q
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >FP
Q020> *
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >F@
Q0202 *
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 23P
Q020P -"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 23R
Q0P -
"
Q0P0> -
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 23@ "
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 234
Q0P0>0>
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 23F
Q0P0>02 *
"
Q0P02 -" Q0Q
"
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 224
Q0Q0>
"
Q0Q0>0>
7
Q0Q02 * Q0Q020>
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 22F 7
Q0Q0>02 " Q0Q0>0P (
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2>@
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 22@
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2P2
M :
"
7 "
" " 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2PP 7 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2PQ
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2Q3 "
/
- 7
A
"
"
00000000000000000000000000000 2Q2
7
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
Q0Q0202 (
M
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2QP
Q0Q02020>
" 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2Q?
Q0Q020202
6
Q0Q020P
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2QF 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2R3
Q0Q020P0>
M
Q0Q0P -" Q0R , Q0@ (
( R0> ,
A
" "
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2@4
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 243
R$ "
/
000000000000000 24P
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 24P
R0>0>
/
R02 $ R020> *
000000000000000000000000000 2RQ
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2@R
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 24Q
" )
6
%))*&
7
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 24R
"
% (,)&/
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 24@ R020>0> % & +
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 244
R020>02 % &
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 244
R020>0P 0Q 0R 0@ (% & R020>04 (% & (
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 24? 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2?3 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2?3 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2?3
R020>0? (% &
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2?3
R0202 R02020> % & +
"
7
%), &
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2?P
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2?R
R020202 % &
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2?@
R02020P % & +
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P>@ A )
7
%)
$&00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P>4
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P>?
R020?02 % &
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P>F
R020?0P
R020?0Q 02
"
20
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P@?
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P@F
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P43
20> *
"
2020 GA
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P43
* M
AA 7
2020>
,,,
$0 0 B
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4>
" " 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4>
20P
7
20P0>
R0P
0-
6
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4Q
" " 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4Q
20Q (
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4R
20R )
7 "
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4@
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4@
P0> (
"
"
P02 '
"
P020>
"
"
P0202
"
"
P0P P0P0>
000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P@4
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P@4
>0 ,
P0
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P@>
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P@>
"
" "
"
" "
*
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4@
%2R
B
6
"
" *
B
&000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4?
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4? %22
6 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?3 6
&000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?>
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
P0P02
"
Q0 $
"
"
-
6 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?P
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?@
Q0> B
A
Q02 -
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?@ 6 A
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?@
Q0P
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?4
Q0Q )
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P??
Q0R ,
- "
Q0@
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?F
R0 ( @0
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P??
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?F
"
7
@0> '
=
-
< '"
>0 ,
"
=
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?F
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 PF2
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 PF2
2( >0 ,
M
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?F
"
"
#"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q>4
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q>4
>0> E"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q>4
>020
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2R 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2R
20P0>0>( 20P0>02
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2R 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2R
20P0>0P (
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2@
P0
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q24
Q0 $
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QPQ
Q0> = R0 (
" "
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QPR
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QP@
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QP4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
)
"
' "
> *
' "
2
' "
"
7
7 7
%
9 >F?Q9 02>4& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000 >4 % S
T
9 233R9 0>2Q&00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2R
' "
Q
' "
R*
' "
@$
7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P3 ,E
,E " "
7
4, (
' "
?)
' "
F*
' "
>3
" ' "
9
" 9$ FF49 0P>Q& 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 R3
- 7
A %>F??9 0PR&
.
,E
"
"
%
9 >F??9 0QQQ& 000000000000000000000000000000000 @P
A 6
""
>> )
000000000000000000000000000 Q3
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q4
/
%
' "
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 F
"
P $
+6
' "
" 7
7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000 @@
"
%
"
9 233Q9
0>Q25 -
000000000000000000000000 4Q
9 233Q 9 233Q &0 (
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 4@ ' "
>2
$
A %>>F49 0>PP&
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 44 ' "
>P
' "
>Q ,
%) 9 >FF@&
' "
>R $
' "
>@
' "
>4 *
' "
>? 1
' "
>F
' "
23 '
7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 4F
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ?3 " A 7
%>FFF9
" 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ?>
0R&
"
"
"66
,E
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ?P
"
A %>F?2 9 0243&
"
A
7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ?4
9
A %>F?@&
0 ?F 9 ,E %
&
00000000000000000000000 F>
M
7
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 FQ ' "
2> )
' "
22 *
%-
' "
2P *
' "
2Q -
' "
2R
' "
2@
' "
24 % &
9 >F??9
7
%
0Q R&0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 F@
9 >F?P9 04@&/ "
=
7
A
%' 6 9 23329
A %>FFF
- "
" 0
9 2333&
000000000000000000000000000000000000 FF
7 & 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3> #"
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >3P "
" "
"
9
%
"
%
"
>FF4
9 23329 0PQ4&0 00000000000000000 >3Q
9 233Q &00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >34 7
%
9
>F4P9 0>@&000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>Q ' "
24 % & *
%=
9 233P9 0>P>&000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >>R
' "
2?
' "
2F
9%
' "
P3 *
' "
P>
' "
P2 (
' "
PP (
' "
PQ
' "
PR *
' "
P@ (
' "
P4
(
""
' "
P4
(
""
' "
P? (
' "
PF $
"
' "
Q3
%
2>
/ " (
7 7
9$
%( *7
7 9$
T *7
%>F439 0P&
7
"
A %>F?? &
0000000000000000000 >PP "
7
%' "
" A %>F?? 9 0>4&
00000000000000000000000000000000000000 >2P
9 >F439 0P& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >P2
"
7
" 7
7
" %
00000000000 >PR
9 >FF29 02?&00000000000000000 >Q>
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q> 7
7
T$
%+
9 >F?@9 0@2& 00000000000000000000000000000 >QQ
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >QQ
9 >F4?9 02@2&0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q4 %
9 >F4?9 02@2& 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q?
""
%>F4?& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q? " TU
"
%
9 >F4?9 02@?&0000000000000000000000000000000000 >Q?
9 >FFP9 0>?&000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >RR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
Q> , "
' "
Q2 , "
' "
QP
" A
7
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@3
"
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@3
0'
%>F4>&9 045 %>F4P&9 0@F?5 %>F4@&9 0P3>5 %>F?Q&9 023>5 %>F?R&9 0P 5
%>F?4 &9 >@45 %>F?4 &9 2@?5 %>F??&9 02F5 %>FF2&9 R3Q0 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@Q ' "
QQ
A %>F??&
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@@ ' "
QR % &
A %>F??&
"
% &+
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@F
' "
QR % &
A %>F??&
"
%4R
' "
Q?
A %>F??&
" 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >44
' "
QF $
' "
R3 '
' "
R>
' "
R2 *
' "
RP
' "
RQ *
' "
RR
"
' "
R@
& "
' "
R4 *
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >43
"
9
9 >F??00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >4Q
"
7 7
"
%
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000 >44
9 >F@Q& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?>
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?@ 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?4 "
7
"
7
9
"
" 7
=
"
" 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >?F 7
%
%
+
A %>FF4& "
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >F2
5
"
" 9 233R9 0PFQ& 00000 >F3
9 >F@Q9 0@3& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >F2 "
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >F4
' "
R? *
7
"
" ' "
RF *
' "
@3 *
%
"
,E
9 >FFQ9 0Q>Q&0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 23> " "
" ' "
"
-*
#" %
@> ,
"
)
7
" 0000000000000000000000000000 232
7
7
7
" 9 >FF@9 0>@R&00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 22> 7
7
%
T
9 >FF49 024P&0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 22Q ' "
@2
' "
@P *
"
' "
@Q
' "
@R (
' "
@@
' "
@4 *
' "
@? B
' "
@F
' "
43
' "
4> *
"
"
7
#"
7
" 000000000000 2P@
"" / 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2Q> "
/
7 (** %=
"
#"
"
#"
"
" 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2QR /
-
A %>F?P& 7 7
7
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2QP
9 23329 233P& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2QR
"
"
A
$ ', %=
7
#"
%
"
"
9 (**
"
>' "
>
2' "
>.
9 233P9 0F@& 00000000000000000000 2Q@
7
, *%
FF> 9 0>?F& 00 2RF
9 233R9 0>2F& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2@R
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2@F 6
"
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?4 ""
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2?
7
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
) *
>
/
%
FFP9 0>4R&V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QQ *
2
*
P
*
Q
"
% 7 A
7
9 233> 0P3?5 *6"
9 233>9 04&00 QR
/
"
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q@ "
"
%-
9
>F4R& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 R4 *
R (
7
9 %
*
@*
*
4*
*
? (
*
F ) 7
*
>3 '
*
>2
"
"
2333&00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >23 %
W9 >F?F& 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >P?
%'
T$
9 >FF2&00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >PF
"
"
"
%
9 >F?4 9 >F??&00000000000000000000000000 >R?
%>F??& 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@> " '
A
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 >@P
7 "
A
% "
9
>FFP9 0P>?5 B
9 233Q& 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2>Q
*
>P
7
*
>Q
-* 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2>R "
>FFF5
7
6
"
%1
9
9 >FF@& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2>F
*
>R (
-*00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 22P
*
>@ 1"
-*
>R 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 22Q
*
>4 (
%+
9 >F?@& 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 22@
*
>? - " "
*
>F
*
23
" %
=
" >*
>-
>*
2
>*
P -"
>*
Q
*
R
>*
@
>*
4
>*
?$
>*
F
>*
>3
>*
>>
>*
>2 $
>*
>P
2*
>
& 2$
2*
P$
2*
Q*
2*
R*
2*
@$
2*
4*
2*
?*
7
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2R4
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 24@ 6
" "
-
%-
6 A
6 9 >F?F& 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4Q 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4R
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P44 7
*
" B
A
"
"
-
-
" 6
B
A
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4F 6 A
B
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?3
A
B
A
"
-
-
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4? 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P4?
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?>
"
" "
"
6 A "
* $
"
" "
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?2 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?P 6 A
6 A
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?Q 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?R
"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 P?? 7 7
%#" 2*
"
9 >FF49 >FFF& 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2@Q
"
%#"
>9 29
"
7 0 " "
P& 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2P A
"
9
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2?
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Q2F " " A #"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QP>
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QP2 ""
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QPP "
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QPQ 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 QPQ
7
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
Chapter 1 Introduction and background to the study 1.1 Brief overview of the study * "
"
"
9 "
7 7
" 7
7 " "
" "
0* 7
9>
7 7
7
"
"
"
0,
9
"
0 $
7 " "
"
" 9 "
" #"
" 0*
"
7 0 (
7
" "
9
#"
"
0
9
" " 7 "
0
" 7 "
7
7 " "
9 9
"
0 " "
"
"
"
"
9
"
0 "
7 9C
"
D
"
0* 9
"
0
" "
7
7 "
9
"
9
" "
" 9
"
; $
; "
" "
9 "66
0 =
; ,
9
"
"
#" "
"
0
"
9 7
"
" 0 ,
" 9 ""
" "
" 7
" "
""
7 9
"
" 9 9
0 7 "
7
"
" "
#"
0
1.2 Motivation and rationale ,
7 "
% 7
0
"
9
9
" 7
0 * "
"
=
" "
0+
"
9
7
9 7 "
0, "
7 9
"
"
"
9 :
0 * "
9
"
9
9 " "
"
"
"
" "
&9
"
" "
" "
" 7 "
" 0 *
>
C
D
C
D
"
"
"
" 9
"
:
*010
"
0
>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
= "
A
C
D%
=
9 >FF4&
"
"
"
0
+7
9
9 "
%
" 7 9 7
"
" " 7
9
"
7 "
& 0 '
9
"
92 "
9
"
9 7
7
GG
9
7 "
AA
9
"
" 77
0
"
:"
"
7 0,
7
7
:" 9
"
"
C 7
D
"
"
"
"
7
"
9 "
7
9 0
1.3 Research orientation " "
9 "
"
"
" "
0
9
"
0*
" 7 "
"
7 "
"
9
"
" "7
"
"
(
" 7
7 "
%
F4P5 >F?4&9 7
7 *
9
7
=
"
9 >FRF5
0
"
0
" %
F?4&0 , 9 "
D
%
"
"
C
7
"
" "
0*
0
0
1.4 Delineation and discussion of chapters to follow *
"
"
7 0 *
" 7
0 ,
"
" - 7
P
7
"
9
"
P
"
"
" "
% "
" " 9 >FF?5 "
9 9 >F?4&0 "
" % "
" 5
"
7 "
7
2
"
"
+
"" 7 " 0 ( "
"
) 7. 0 (
2
9
7 " "
7 7
"
7 7 0 ,
" &0
2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
#"
0
"
"
"
" "
9
9
9
0*
"
" "
"
"
0 (
9
Q
9
"
"
" 0(
"
R
7 7
" 7
"
0 ( "
0*
>
- " ""
"
"
"
0
1.5 An in-depth look at why such a study is necessitated " " C " D " " % " 7 9 >FF4& "
" "
"
" %
9 >F4F&0 * 0$
7
7 "
4
"
%
"
&
7 " " "
,
& C
-
%
9 233>&0 +
>F4P
< A 9 >F4@&0 ,
" D
C
X
"
"
0 "
4
%
" 9
9 2333&0
>FP@
9 >F??&0 * B Y - 7 0 Y, " "
M
& %.
"
"
"
"
>F 7
" "
"
9 0 0
9
"
9
% "
. 0$
"
X U 0 ' X9 X
X
$ 7 9 X "
" "
"
ZU $[& "
:" X
X0 ) B"
%>F@2&;
0* 7
"
9
"
" "
& 7 7
9
7
0
7 9 9
"
" "
9
%
X
F4P9
" "
7
7 9 "
7
"
X U $ X
X
=
" 7
" %233> &9 .
@
"
D
7
0= "
"
" ' "
" %-
F?4&0 , 7 - 7 " " 7 Y Y
-
"
9
"
7 9 >F4@&
"
7 "
0
7
A
"
"
"
< 9
0@ * "
" "
"
7
"
" "
0,
"
" 7
"
Q
. X
" "
"
" " D
R
7
"
* "
"
"
7
R
C
7 7 9
>FR3X 0
"
7
"
"
&
9
"
0, "
#" Q
>F23X %
"
7
0 9 "
9
9
9 0
%*"
"
9
9 "
9 97
9
9 9
9
9 >F?2&0
P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" " "
%' "
"
7 7
% "
9
" 9 >FF?&9 9 2333&
T$ 7 %.
"
7 9 >F4F&9 %'
T " O " " O
O
5
%-
T'
9
9 >F?@&
0
7 %2332&
9) "
YV
7
" 7 "
"
& % 02&0 * 0) " " Y % " &0 +
" Y
" 9
7 "
" %(
9 >FFR5
*
T *6"
"
"
" 0 0, "
0
"
9
9
9 >F?@5 "
:
9
" ":
T
7 " 9 2332&0
"
" 7
7 "
7 0,
9 >F43&0 ,
9 9
"
%< T -
7
7
7
" "
[
7 " 9 " "
"
:
"
'
" "
7 9
7
9 Z
7
" 9 2333 5 .
9 >FF25 ) 6 T
"
"
" " "
Z [Y %
" 9 " " "
"
"
" 7
7 7 %T 9 2332&9 " " 7 %. 9 >F4?&9 T 9 >FF45 9 >F?F&9 % 9 233Q 5 E" 6 T - : 9 >FF4 &9 O " "
TU
9 >FFP 5 $ 9
"
" T) 7
9( "
9 >F4Q5
0
1.6 Pertinence to the South African context - "
9
"
7
"
"
"
"
"
" 0*
7
"
7
0 "
"
#" % "
"
>FFQ9
- " 9 23325
"
" " T
7 9 233@& " "
7 7
9
" &%
*
9
7 9
9 23335
" "
"
9,
" "
"
0, 7
7
"
9
" 0
&0
9
"
"
9
"
#" " " " 0*
" 7 0
9
7 "
"
" "
" 0$
7 "0
7 9 #" 9
"
" "
" 7
%233>& " 9
"
"
9
"
7
0 "
"
"
"
"
9Y
"
% 0>?@&
?
,
" 0
"
"
" 7 9
7
7 7 9
#" "
" Y "
- " 7 #"
0
>FFQ9 #" "
#"
9
0
Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
0
%
9 233R &0 * 7 X " "
%233> &
" "
"
9 #"
"
0
%233>& 7 "
" 9 %233> & X
"
9 "
7
"
" %233> &
X
7 "
" 7 "
%233>&
X9
%233> &
9F
"
"
7
0 Y* "
9 % & Y % 0>>2&0 B 9 " 7 9 7 % 9 233>5 2332&
7
"
9
"
0 >FF?5 " 9
7
7 7
"
A
Y
9
"
>>
%B
:" 9
%233>&
"
"
7
-
%233> &9
7 0)
7 "
9 " 9 %
"
"
7
%
9
#" 7 0
9 0,
0 "
7 9
" 9 &
&
" 9
#"
9 B #" Y % 02>4&0
9
7
"
" "
9 233>&0 "
%233>&
;$ "
" 7 " 7
9 "
" "
"
"
7
"
7 9
-
Y "66 Y / % &
"
0>@2 >@P&0
0
"
9>3 "
Y
"
X
7 "
" Y%
7
" #"
"
7
"
% &
0 9
" " 0 7
B
"
9 " 7
0
"
"
0 7 0* A
"
9 7
"
7
"
0
1.7 Dynamic assessment’s entanglement *
" 0,
"
" " "
"
%1
7
9 >F?F5 )
' " ' < ' " X " >FF?
9 >F?3&5
X
"
7
7 "
7
" 7 '
>F4F " < X %>FF?&
0 ,
7 "
" "
%>FF@& " "
>>
>FF2
0 $" "
"
F >3
"
7
7 "
7
"
9 "
7 "
" 7 7 9
%233>&
%-
9= 7
9(
"
9'
7 9
T
0. " 9 >FFR&0
" 9 0, 7 7 9 7
< " "
0
R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
9
#"
0*
0 X
"
233> ,
*
"
"
: "
"
7 "
4
"
" " "
7 #"
" "
2
0
0 +
"
-
%233> &0 *
"
"
7 %-
7 " "
T
9 233> &0 $
0
"
"
"
9
" "
Y 0
Y #"
"
"
9 " #" 7 9
%>FF2& #"
7
7
" "
"
P
9
Q0
9
7
"
%'
"
6
FF39 0>?&0 ,
%
0, "
" "
7
" "
7 7
" 9 233> &0 " 9 "
>F3Q& %-
"
7
"
" 7
0 2
0* "
& " 9 Y= " " ;D % 92R4&0 " " " 0(0 " A :"
X
9-
%233> & "
FF2&
9
" 9 7 %233>&
" 0(
"
A %>FF@&
"
0
@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
0< 7
Y
9
" " 7
" 7
"
"
0*
" Y 0, "
7
"
0,
9 7
"
"
"
9
"
P0
1.8.1 A personal note on philosophical affiliations ,
" "
"
9
A
"
" " 9
9
9
" " =
" " 0P&0 *
/ " A
9C
"
9
"
7
0 9 >F43&; ) 7
"
C "
$ " %>FFF&9 " 7 " %
$
C
7
&
" 9' .
9
9 $
"
0>Q $ "
"
7 7
" "
91
&
7
9
(
"
"
"
"
"
9
" 9 9 >F?29 0>P?&0 * " " D %>F439 7 "
D %< "
%
"
"
"
%
D % 07&0 "
"
9 < 51 ( 5 1 7 " 7 7
" 7
" ) 9 $ 7 " -" 9 (
5
" " 9
(
9
" 9 "
7
A 9
"
9
"
7
9
7
" " 6
C 9 " >R
" "
" D % 0Q3&0
7 9
9 >F?F&0 * %>F?R&
7 "
" "
9
"
A
A
"
%B"
" 0*
"
7 9 >FF3 5 -
T
9 >FF4&0 "
A
9
"
7 "
" ;=
9
* "
"
7
C " 7 "
D %-
" D %1 #" 9 >FF?9 043&
7
" "
=" C
9 &
7 %-
"
" &0 *
7
&9 "
" 7
9
9 >FF4&0 ' 9
" 0* 7 " " " %
9
,
T=
" "
% " :
0 %
&0 *
7 0*
""
#" A
7
"
"
"
"
>R
" 7 " 9
" 0*
7
>Q
9 >F?4&0 ( 9
%
"
"
#"
"
7 =
9 %+" :"
"
7 7
5
"
" " 7 9 >FF2&5
" #"
#"
9 9 "
7
%
"
9 "
0 #"
%-
T=
9 >FF4&0
4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0 '" 7
"
"
"
7 7 "
0= ;
; = " C 5 ;*
7
@
7 9 "
C
D
7 9 D % 0@?&
#"
97 A
7 " 9 " 9 7 #"
" "
" C
"
9
9 "
" 7
7 "
" 7 7
#" %
" 7 9 "
"
" 7 7 7
9 0*
9 "
"
5 "
#" 0
0 ( " 9 D " " ' %>FF?& 7 7 7
0
0
"
7
9
C
7
"
8-
"
"
9
0-
7 9 7 " 7
0 '" "
/ " 9
" 9
9
" " "
9 :"
:"
"
"
7 0 +
"
7 *
" 9 "
"
"
D
9
" "
9 233R&0 ,
9
"
"
7
9
"
"
"
#" "
8)
"
#" 9
"
0>4 *
"
9
9
"
"
"
" :
0,
9 " "
"
9
7
""
0,
C
D
" " 9
7 " 0, 7
"
7
" "
" 2 M Q9
"
9
9
" "
" "
0*
"
"
"
"
"
" &0 *
"
"
"
"
0
1.9 A map to the study *
"
" 7
"
7
"
C
"
%
DM
"
7
>
"
9
" "
'
9 7 "
>4
" /
7 9
"
"
0
7
%
"
2&
" %
"
"
7 "
"
"
%
"
7
"
29 "
"
P
7 "
"
"
"
" 0(
>@
" "
7 " "
% "
0*
&
"
& " 9 233P&0
"
9
"
9
"" 9 " 9
9
0 ??4] &5 5 X "
' , = 1 "
9-
5 ,
5
E" =
,
" %
'&
9
"
9 -
( "
- "
% - (&
"
- FFR&0 , '+9
" 0
"
"
7
2
9 "
9
"
"
9 3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
"
"
0
7 9 "
"
7
7
9
"
0
2.3 Model utilised *
"
7 "
"
7 "9
"
9
7
"
B0F4R&
7
" 0Q
7
7 7
7
" " " "
9 " "
"
" 7 0 '
9
"
A
7
7 "
" 7 "
"
"
9 #" 0, ( 5
" 0
"
A "
" P
A 7
9
"
" 9
7
"
9 " A
"
0 *
C D "
9
"
" "
9
7
"
0*
" 7 7 0
9 "
7
"
"
" " 0 = 9
7
"
0
2.4 Laying personal cards on the table: a deck of truth ,
"
"
" "
"
"
" "
" "
A 0
2.4.1 Geographic and socio-political location *
"
7
9- "
0
0
"
"
7 " "
" 0*
0
9
" "
"
9
" "
=
#"
"
" 7
9
"
"
0
2.4.2 Time " #"
0*
"
"
0*
" "
0 R
' "
& %"
"
9 >F?@& " C
@
"
*
" W
& "
"
9
%
" 0
C"
9 " 223R D
"
9 233R0 =
% ,
@
"
0 -"
"
%
7
"
/ R
" &0 * D
A
Q
"
7 %
7 "
0*
"
"
0 9 ' " " -
" & %= A
"
"
9 >FF@&0 "
8 %(
T.
9 233R&0
>>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
0 7 " 7 #"
7 " " 04 *
"
9
7
9
7
9
"
7 "
"
#"
" "
9 #"
"
"
"
"
0
2.4.3 Schooling within psychology
?4F
9 0? *
"
:
"
" "
7 9 "
"
7
""
&
0*
-
7
"
"
"
"
A
"
- "
7
"
233R 7
&
,
"
%
0*
"" %
" 7
9 0* "
0 +" 0 4
C " M
7 0 " " 7
% 7 0 " O " " M
% ,& M &7 0
"
"
2.4.5.3.1 Introduction '
7
7
7
"
>?
7
%
"&
9
7
" "
"
"
7
7
"
A
0,
"" ; %1 9 2333&0 , T 9 23339 0>F3&0 , " ;& " 7 " % " " " 7 " 7 7 5' T " " 0, 9 " :" " "" 0 ( 7 " " " A 0+ " ;D %-
"
7 7
"
"
C
% 0 -" "
" 7
#"
7 "
" 7
9 >FF4& 9 " 7
7 " 7 0* 7 " D7
7
"
7
#" " =
" 0
" C %233P9 0F& "
/ 7
" "
"
"
9
9
9
6
" "
"
"
0
2.4.5.3.2 The mind-body problem *
"
"
"
"
0 ' %
F?>&
"
0
>F
"
7
5
7 %-
>@ >4
" 9 =
% 9 (
"
9
"
9 >FFR5
7
7
7 "
9
>F
T
0' 7
"
A
7 7 "
:"
"
7
0 "
0 7 "
"" %
" 7 "
%FRF&0
#"
%
>?
23
9 '
#" "
, 7
& 7
"
% 7 9 >F?R5
7 " "
7
*
>4PF9
"
$
"
"
"
A %$
" 77 "
A
7
7
%
9 233> &9 "
"
"
D22 % "
C " A
C A
D
9C D " 7 7 0 (" "
9 >F?>&9 #" %B" 9 233>&0
%"
7 "
&
"
"
" % =^ ""
9 23335 ) 7 % "
Q
" "
9 23335 %
-
A
" 7 9 23335 9 23335 + 9 233> 5 9 233>& " & " " 7
E" 7
9 >FFP5 *"
9 >F@4&0
&
9 >F?F&0 7 " % 9 "
9 233>&
9
"
< "
9
7
"
&0 * 9 233R5
%-
9
"
%B : 7 T
9 "
9
"
"
0
:"
"
22
$ ("
% "
"
"
2R
7 " 5 -6 _ "
(
7
" "
"
%>F?F&&0 ' 0-
9.
" 5(
" 9 %233>&5
"
< " "
* 0, %2332&
" " " %)
D2R
C
9 233>&0
$ 1
9
"
%233P& 9 C
7 7 " "9 >FF@ &
9 >FF4&
2P 2Q
" AA %
GA
" 7 >FFR5
" 7
%(
9
7 "
7
:"
7 "
"
0*
"
7
"
9 233R&0 7 O
)
2>
7 7 7 " #" 9 2333&0 * " " #" 7 % 9 233R&0 * 7 7 % 7 7 " 7
-
* "
" 9 C D % 0Q2&0
"
"
"
9(
" & 9 >F?F5
"
"
"
7 7 & #" A
%
A
9 >F?F5
#" 7 7 9
#"
#" 7
" 9 >F@4& %
9 >F?P5 *"
"
" 02Q
T
7
" %233R&
= "
" 9 "
"
9
"
%
9 2333&
%
" 7 " 9 2333&0
%
7 "
9 >F?P5 $ " 9 6 9 233Q5 = 9 2332&0
" % 9 >FF?5 ' 6 9 >FFP9 23325 2P %
%
5 ( "
"
7
7 9
" 5
& %( 9 >F?@5
7
7 0* 9 233@&0
" "
9 >F?@&0 *
"
D " 7 9
6 A * A C " %= 9 >F4P " "
,, D 9 >F4@&0
7 "
" %
A
"
9 2333&0
" 9 #"
0 " "
7 9 7
"
C
#"
7
0 D
0
>R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
GA
" 7
)
D
7 7
9
"
"
9 9 >F@4& % "
9 >F?@524 *" 7 9 7 " 7 " "
%( "
%>F?3&0
"
7
D% "
"
" P0@&0 C* " 7 9 ( " 9 >FF?9 0@>P&0 *
"
"
7
9
"
2F
&0 , '
" % "
( " "
" " "
"
7 "
#"
%
B
7
7
0$ "
9
7 "
A %2333& #"
7 %2333&
( " I7 "
2F ,
" 7
B"
0* * "
9
P3
+
%
9
" 7 "
" "
7
"
C
D
9 233>&
6
9 >FF?&0
" "
" 9
"
7 "
"
"
7 "
7 D % 0Q?F&0 7
"
9 "
"
0
T
7 9 " 9 >F4>&0 + " 7 5( 9 233@&0 ( 7 0+ " 9 >FF25 ) 9 >F??&
7 " "
7
%
9
" 7 %B
9 >F425 ' "
"
"
" 7 % %
FFR&0 #" " 7 :" 7 " 7
;* " & 0
%
%>FFF&
7 7
9 233P 5
7 7
7
9 C
"
0 * 5C :
%-
5 "
9
"
%233P&
9 >F?F&0 =
9
7
%>FF?&
% "
"
7
"
2?
7
#" "
"
D%
9=
7 ( "
"
0*
7
9 7 "
24
" 1
= C
>?F3
" 7 "
7
%
FFR & : " D"
D "
7
" "
0
T +
9 >FFR&0 * " " O 0* " "
7
(
" 9 233>&
7
"
2@
7 7
"
"
"
"
"
%$ 7 9 " 7 % 02>P&5 " " 0 , 9
9 233P&
"
0,
7
7 9
"
%>FF?& % 024?& "
% 7
%B
"
"
" "
D 5 0 0 9 >F?@&0 '
" %< "
"
9 >F?Q& %
"
" 7
%
B"
" " C 9 233>5 -
"
2?
7 " "
" P3
"
9
%" 9 233P& 9 >FF4&0
%' " 0
"
A " 7 " 9
7
"
7
"
"
"
9
""
P
"
7
"
"
0 * " 9
" +
"
" 9
>FF@&0 *
9 >FFR &02@
9 233P 5 B"
"
7 #"
%
F?Q& "
"
"
" 0
%)" C 7
7 7
9 233P5
"
9 >F?>&9
"
D
"
2
0
"
7
7 7
< ( $
$
) 7
9 >F?Q9 02>4&
FFF5 =
:"
"
G " U
9 >FFR5 "
5 9 233>&
%=
9
A
FF4&0 * 7 0 5
=
0 A %233R & "
" % 9 >FF4& 9 7 " 9
" " 9 "
a
"
&0
7 "
P>
"
" 7
"
D %=
= 7 7 D % 022>&9 " D % 02??&0 ( " 9 >FF@&0 * G " A " %$
9C C
"
"
%
7 7 5P>
"
" " " 0 *
9 >FFR&0
>4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%>FFQ&P2 % M 7
7 " "
"
0 +" C
"
"
7
"
"
FFF& 9 7
*
7 "
D%
:"
"
" " 9 " 7
"
"
7
"
9 >F??&9 " 7 "
" "
-#"
9 >FFQ&
7
9 C,
" D % 022?& %B
T
9 2333&0 7
"
" "
7
9 0(
PP
"
7 %
%
* %$ 69 >F?P&0 ,
T)
7
" "
" & 9 >FFR5 9 >F?F&
" " % 233P5 $
"
%
&9 "
7 "
9
7 " & "
0
7 %
=
P@
9
0
9 >FF4&9 9 >FFR&0 *
%
" & 7 " %1 9 % 9 2333&
7 " 7
"
9 % 1
9PQ
7 "
7
PR
9 233P&9 7 "
"
7 "
7 " 7 A7
9 233P&
7
" 9
%( 9
"
"
"
" "
"
9
0
2.4.5.3.4 G–dominated vs. multiple intelligence (MI) – dominated leanings towards the understanding of intelligence 7 9
" 9
" * : "
"
"
"
9 7
" " 7 &C
%< 9 233R9 0QF2&0 233R & %
PR
"
" "
9 7
0*
P4
9
7
T$ 7
9
T+
D
9 233R9 0QP>&0 ,
" 0
"
D 79
&
#"
"
5
C
7
7
#"
"
D %>FFQ9 0PP>&0 "
"
" " "
0
0 7 "
9C D
7 " 7
7
C
D
7 "
" 7 "
"
9
"
A
%
7 " 9 2333 &0
0 " " "
" A " " " % 0( 9 >FFR " &&0 " A " :
7 9
" %-
9 "
"
C
7
9 23339 0@Q&0 7 "
"
% &
0*
0, 7 "
"
"
C "
.
9 9 9 233P & 9 >F??& "
% "
5 " P@
" "
"
"
9
A
7
%-
" 7
"
0
"
" 7 "
C
"
7
9.
#"
D%
"
"
9
9 "
" PQ
7 7
"
= " ,
9
% D %+
PP
"
" 9 >F?>&0
" 9 >FF4 5P4 " " T 9 2332& 0 " 9 23 7 " "
>F3Q % 9
%
?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0 7 " " C -
"
7
7
7 %$ "
A %< Q0 " &
" C " D 9 >F?25 , 7 7 7
7 9 233R&5 7
Z
[
9 7 7
I7 P? 9 >F?45 -
7
" 9 >FF>& D%
9 >FF?9 0P&0 " " " 7 0 9 7 "
7 7
7 "
" "
7
7
"
"
-
7
!" 9 "
7 T
%( %-
"
%
0, 7 7
9 >F?@5 ' &7
A
9 >FF@5
9 ( %-
T U
" T*
9 >FF@5 B " #"
"
9 >FF@&0 , 7
7
9 >FF4 5 B 9 >FF45 " 9 " " " #" "9 233@5 B " TB " 9 233@5 . 0= "
$ " #"
"
#"
; '" PF
%( 9
9 9" "
7
"
" 9 >FF4&0 ,
$ D5 7
" 9 233@& "
%
" 9
#"
" "
7
5
%,
9 $
%
9 >FF45 1
Q>
'" %
E" %>?QF& 9 >F445 9 >FF35 Q2 ) A "
6 9 >FF>5 ) 6 % "
P?
=
7 -
" * A
Q3
7 8 " 9 233P&0
-
Q>
9 >FF@5 " " 9 >F??5 -
9 >FFF&
"
A
"
9 >F?>5 *
%>FFF&
"
9
" 9 >FF4&0
" :
9
" "
#" " %
" "
" 9
"
"
A
"
% "
7 9 >F4F&5
" B"
-
"
FF4 5 $" < >F34 %$" < 9 >F43&0 * & 7 7
"
7
A ) 9 233>&0 %< :
" 0)0 * 9 >FFP&0
7
7
0)
9
" 9 7
" "
%
"
9 >F43&0 *
%
FF>&0 Q2 (
7
$
% "
*
"
D
'
D
0
"
%>FF4&&0
9 >F4?&0 7 " 9 >F4R&0
5-
C "
V0
%2333&5 B 7 C
"
7
PF
"
7 "
7
Q3
9 >FF? 5 9 9 T " T 9 >F?@5 B 7 9 >FF45
>?RF5 (
%
D "
7
T= 7 5
"
C
A %>FF4&
7
% %
F?>&0 & %$
A
0'
9 9 >FF2&0 * %$
7 " 7
"
>F
9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
C
7 7
& %
FF49 >FFF5 7 #" 9 >FF4&0 +
%
:"
#" * 7
"
A
7 "
C 7
9 "
#"
7 "
C "
"
#"
"
" #"
"
9
"
" "
#"
7
9 >FF? &
233Q &0 (" " "
"
&
9
"
" " :
"
7
7 5 )
T . 7
" " %
& T1 9 233Q&0Q@ 9 233R& "
0 * 9)
( "
%>FF4&
"
9-
T
%B
QR
"
=
" "
Q@
"
"
7
9
FF4&0 * 9 %
" 5 C
D
T
9
#" 7
0* 0
%=
9 >FF4&0
7
"
5
F?R&0
9
9 >FF4&0 *
" 7
"
9 233R5
FF4& "
5
" "
9 < "
9
T 9 >FF?&0 *
" T
FF@& "
0*
" :"
7 "
9
" #" "
QQ
#" "
:"
7 "
QR
%
" 9 0 0
,E
"
7
,
% 9 2332 0QP *
QQ
% 9. 9 - "6 T = " 0 *
9
0
0
#" 7 "
7
7
0
7 "
7
"
" 7
7
"
%$
" "
"
#"
9 "
7 7
7
7
" 51
"
0 =
7 "
7
"
% :" 7 #"
9 "
0 7 "
7
0*
7
D 7
" " " "
"
"
7
" "
$
9
" #"
" 7
7 9
7 9
"
( "
" : A %233P& 7 "
"
9
0 ,
7
79 233R&0
7 "
5 7 "
D0 ;*
5
"
D
#"
" "
" 0 -"
7
9
%-
5C % 0?>&0 *
" : &0 *
D "
9
D0 *
*
0
9
9
"
" 7
7 "
C 7 7
" "
7
C "
Q&9
": ,E
9 233R
0 %
9 >F??& %
8&
23
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>FF@&0
7
7 "
" " %$"
" 9 >FFQ&0
T
FFQ&0 " 9 23335 =
%
FF45
T $ 0 -"
"
"
7 "
7
"
;+
5 "
%
:" "
" #" %(
"
" "
M
7
"
7 "
5 7 9 T =
0 9
9 >FF45 ,
9
" "
:"
"
9 >FF45 7 "
"
7
"
" 9 >FF>&0 *
" 0 *
0*
9
7
"
7 #" "
"
C 7 "
7
7
"
"
"
0
7 "
1
9 "
*
7
" "
"
"
" 1
"
" "
:
7
"
,
7
0 * "
0 ("
"
7
" 9 "
7
C
D 7
0 7
"
""
" 7 "
" "
"
" 7
&
7
0*
7 " M
(
"
7 7
#" 7
0 -
"
0* "
7 "
7 "
9
7
"
"
0
"
" 0,
"
=
"
7
" &0 1
#" D
" 9
7
" 7 C
7 % 7
"
M
0
"
" 0
"
%
"
"
.
0
7 " A %>FF? &
01 "
7
D "
"
"
"
-"
7
"
&
0*
"
9 "
"
#"
Q4
" "
9
"
"
"
"
T
7 9
"
T
>0
"
" "
"
" " "
7
7
" " ; 1" 9
9 >F?@&0
7
0 , 7
T
" 69
"
"
"
" 233Q 5 =
9 -
"
"
9 0Q4
D
% 0)*
" 0 >FF@&
C
9
"
C #" D " A %>F?3& C " $
% D 7 " 9
"
"
9 C
" "
"
" D %233Q9
0>>&0
2>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" *
"
"
"
" 7 0
>0
"
A C
" "
DM
"
" "
1 " M 7
7
0
"
A
"
"
"
*
"
*
"
9 7
"
0
A "
"
" A
0 *
*
A
5
M "
0 1 "
7
"
"
" 01 7
#"
0
%"
*
"
9 >FF? & "
M
"
7
A
% "
9
" "
A
"
A
C
% &
7
0 * "
7 "
A "
0* " "
7
"
7
"
0
" "
" "
7 7 "
"
7
A
C
"
"
DM
"
" #" "
"
"
0-
9
%
" 9 >FF4&9 A
T-
9 233Q5
9B
0
9
7 0 "
7
0
$
A %$
"
7
0*
" "
7 7
" "
7
" "
7
1
#"
"
" "
0
"
"
0
D
"
0
" 7 9
" 7
-
0! 9 C
"
" " " 9
"
@0
" " 0* % 9
7
"
" 0
"
" "
0)0 *
&
7 "
9
"
"
0*
"
7
"
"
" 0
=
A
"
" &
D
R0
A
"
"
"
" "
7
A 7 1
"
Q0
" 9 )
" "
%
9 A
0
A
A
" 9 " " & "
"
9
P&0
7
"
(
" " "
"
P0
7
"
7
F3Q " * 7
7
" "
0
"
" 7
7
A
" "
7
0
C 7
M* -
" "
"
" "
A
%*
A
"
"
9 20
-
" "
U
0
"
"
T
9 233R&0
F?R&0
7
"
"
" " " "
%1
" / "
"
T$
9 233Q5 C C
"
#" %
"
7 7
% " 9 >FFQ&0
" %$ 7
9
"
"
D "
"
9
"
C
" 9
0
"
7 9 9 >FFQ&0
66 9 >FF25 -
Y
#" 7 9 >F?@5 ) 9 >FP35Q? " D C 0, % " 9 2332& D 0* " " " " 9 9 >F?2& 7 " " "
"
" "
M "
"
7 %>F?R& 7 " " D "
( 7 " "
"
C
" "
M
7 "
:" 7
"
" 7
" "
T 1" 9 233R& 7 7
D % 022P&0
0
2.4.5.3.5 Emergence (irreducibility) vs. reductionism *
"
"
"
0 ( " 7 9QF
7 #"
"
"
%
" " 9 23335 U
0R3 •
"
" "
•
9 >F435 . "
7
" 9 233R &0 F?R&
"
7
7 "
*
9
"
9 >F43&0
" " 9 " 7
"
9 6 A T * 7 9 >FF?5 " 9 233P& "
7 0' 7 %) 6 TB 7 " 7 " %
&
9
"
9 >F435 . "
FF25 1 9 >FF4&0 $ 7 ;%>F?4& 0 7 " 5 7 RP " " 7 0* "
8+
7
" %
" 9 *6" "
* "
7 " "
#"
" A
"
9
"
"
"
"
C
"
%>FF@ & "
9 "
" : 7
"
< "
& 9 >F??& " "
0 * %
"
RP
"
"
& )
C
"
7
%-
7 9 >FF4&0 -" 7 0 '"
" "
7
"
7 7
A
"
7" D % 02F&
9 "
"
" *
7
9
:
7 " " C
" /C D % 02>4&0 5
" 7 " 0 * " " " %233Q& 7 " 0* 0 7 " 7 " 7 &0 - " %233Q& " G "A "
7
A
" %2333&
7 7
9
"
% " "
" "
" "
" %-
7 9 233>&
8( #"
%
" *"
0 FF4&0
" "
&0 !
" "
.
9 7 " 7 "
"
9 >FFP&0 ,
7 "
7
9 233R&0 -
%>F?4& " "
"
0 5
"
7
"
" "
7
5 ( >FQF9
0*
5 7 D % 0Q?3& %233>&
" #"
D % 02R3&0
"
"
"
:
"" 0 0
2Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%
9
&0 F?@5RQ
"
7
P " 7
%
9
7 #" 7
% S
0$ T+6
9 233R&0
% S
9 233R9 0>2Q&
T
( "
"
.
7 "
( "
∗
7 /
/
•
bb
• • 7 "
/
• •
∗$
"
* "
bb " "
0 9 233R&; =
%)
9 7
C
"
D
; =
7
"
"
7
"
" "
"
7
7
" " 7
5
7 %
6T-
9 233R&0 *
#"
" %=
7 "
C* "
; "
9 0
FFF&0 9
9 233R5 = 7 " 7
7 "5
9 >F43&0 * 7 " " "
9
7 "
7 " %
" "
" 9 >FF@5 B
%
F?4 &0 *
"
"
7
7
RR
:"
0
97 "
"
" B
"
9
C
" 0=
9 A %>FFF&
#" 7 %>FFF9 022@&
=
7
7 " 9
" 9
"
A 7
"
7
7 "
7 =
7 "
9 ;
M
7 "
&
"
C
0(
7
"
7 5
5 D&
%
"
D%
"66 T=
" 9 >FF45 *" " 7 ;
" "
0, "
" 0 F?4 5 *"
0= %-
"
9
9
7 "
233P&0 *
" 7 9
7
"
;
7
9
7
7
"
" " %>FFP& 7 9 %C 7
A
9 0@&
D
9 7 0* " " M #" 0D
" " 9
7
7
R@
7 " 9
9 M "
" "
"
9 0 7 "
7
7 9
"
% " C 9 23329 0R3>&0 =
7 9 >F?4 &
%
"
" "
T
7 " 9 T - " 9 >FF@5
9 >FFR&0
*
" "
" " "
"
T
9 "
9
:"
0
2.4.5.3.6 Realist vs. relativist approaches towards research *
"
"
7
7
0
7 9
7
7 7
D % 0>4& 7
RR R@
1
= 9 23335 % %
F@?5 =
" " 7 D %- " 9 233Q9 0P2&0 , 7 D% W9 >F??9 7 0
"
?Q3 C* " 9 23335 = 9 >F??&0 = A " B 7 10-0 & T( 9 >F@?5 + 9 >F?@5 *" 9 >F@4&0 9 >F?>5
FFR&0 )
C "
7
% "7 "
$
C 7
" 7
7
" +
0 "
7 0>?&0
"
"
D% "
#" 7 "
9 2332&0 * B" A "
" "9
=
A A
A
" 9 233Q5 7 "
"
#"
" 7
7 " "
;
2@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
0 *
" "
"
0
7 9
" W %233>& " 9 " D % 0>33&0 ' % " < "
F?F& " D 7 9 7 9" 9 >FF3&0 *
: B BL
7
" "
#"
" 9 233R&
%
FF?& Q% %-
6 9- : " 7 "
%< 7
7 " 9 2333&0
T %>FF4&
7 "
" "
7
"
" A %>FF4 & % 0>2P&0 (
7 "
" 5
> %
FF45 < %B
9$
" " 7
7 9
" C
T
"
"
"
RF
9
9 233>&0 !
" "
" 9 "
" " 7 "
7 "
9
5
"
"
7
" 7
" A
7
7
" & " 7 O %( 9
" "
A
9 >FF@&0 *
7
" " 7 9 >FF4& C " 7
"
" 7 "
7
"
9 >FF49 0Q>R&0 7 " @3 " 9 %>FFR& 9 7 9 " " 7 9 " % W9 >F??&0 5 - 7 B %233P& "
" "
9 7
D %
9 233> &0 !
C 9 233P9 0>P&0 B " ' 9 7 " "
%
"
%
" 7
"
" 9 233P&0
"
C D " 9 >F@R5 " 9 >FFQ9 23325 " " 0 7
(
7
& %=
RF
C
"
%
7
7
7
7 7
9 >F?@&0 *
7 D0 A %< 9 >FF45 < " 9 233P9 023R& " % T + 7 9 2333& 9 C G 7 7 " 5( 9 >FFF5 " " 7
"
"
"
%$
7
"
" B" "
@3
%
7
#"
"
R?
9 7
"
(
&5 D %B " 9 >FF4&0 , 9 7 9 9 7
"
9
"
-
R4
%
" " 9
&0 9 233>5 6 9- : 9 7 9 233>5 9 233>5 = < " :
" 9$ 9< 9 2332&9
" TB"
9 >FF3&
7
9 233>&0
24
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
" "
%< "
C 0,
Q&0
" "
7
"
#"
9
"
< 7
"
"
9 7
FF?9 23339 233>9 23329 233P&5 < %233R& " " " "
7
"
"
%
9 233Q9 233R&
" 7 9
"
5
P C
7
%
" "
"
%
"
D
"
"
9 233R&0 * "
:"
"
7 "
&0 *
%>FF49 >FFF9
0 (
"
"
" 6
U 7
0
"
7
>FFR&0 , " " % % 9 233P5 " 233Q5 233R&0 * " 9 >F?3& " , * 9 " < 9 7
"
0 , " "
0@P $ 9 "
7 ;
"
" " 9 2333&0 , 9 >FF?& " " "
"
" "
" " = "
" " " " 9 >F@P& 7
" %(
"
"
" % "
T
9 9
9
#"
%
"
9
&0
%233>&5 %>FFP& " 7 " ( " "
B "
0 "
D
"
"
C 7
0*
%-
9 0
"
"
7 0 FFR&0 0
0 FF45 = 9 233P& D5 < 9 >FF?9 0@@& C
$
9
"
" "
" " %-
"
7 "
"
9 "
"
" 7
" 9 " D0
" 233>& 7 7
9 233>5 9 9 >FFP5
%
7"
0*
9
9
"
"
" "
%-
9
#"
7 0* %>F?@9 0P22&
%
"
"
"
@P
" & Q?3 "
"
0=
9
@>
%Q?3 6 7
0$ U
" 9
7
@2
" "
@2
7 7
"
7 9
0 FFF5 = 9 >FFF&9 7 " " " " 7 D %)
9 :" C D9 9
) 0* 7
"
%"
"
9 >F?4 &0 * %$ 7
9 >FRF9 0?4& " " #" " " C D 7 " 7 7 7
9 >FF4&0 C, 9
7
7 #" %$ ) " 9 >FFQ&0 =
7
" % " #" 7 C d 9 233>&0 * " 7 7 9 " " " %< 9 233> 9 233> 5 ( 9 >F?@5 ( >FF45 9 >F?4 5 - 7 9 2333& @R 9 % " T " " " 7" 7 " " 0" 7 9 " , 7 " @@ " #" 7 % Q&0 % & 7 " % " 9 >FFP & " 9 7 7 " 9 = " " " " " " " 9 7 " " 7
C D " 9 69 23325 9 23335 9 233R5 " 9 0@Q , 9 233Q5 1" 9 >F@35 9 >FF@5 9 " 9 233>5 ' 9 23335 9 2333&; * % 9 >FF?5 " 9 2333&9 " " : 9 %2333& 0 D5
" "
"" C 7 D " #" 7
" " 7
7
9
"
Q0 9 >F?P&0 *
%
7 "
" " 9 >FFF9 022P&0 * 7 D 7 7 Q0
D%= C
" % 0 ! 9 C
"
" 7 "
7
#" %
"
7
" "
"
"
" 9 23335
9 T " O " " "
" &
"
" *
7
"
"
7
7 7
"
;
7
9
9
C %>FFF&
" " %
" "
C"
"
'7
$ "
"
7 "
7
9
@4
9-
9 " 9
"
7 9
"
/
A
%>F?F&
7 7
0
@R
" % 0
& ;=
7 "
" "
" ;
7 "
5 %
&0 * 7 A %
9 9 233Q&9 9= 7 "
"
" 7
"
% " 7 9 >FFF5 - "
9 2333&0 + I7 "
7
9
: 7 9 233>&
%
9 233>&0
7
" "
"
9 "
"
C " D " "
7
&% ;D ,
"
"
7
7
5 "
%B"
7
7 "
: "
:
"
9 >FFQ&0 ,
*
" "
"
7 9 %1 T E" " %FFP&0 9 2333&0
"
" "
" " "
"
7 5
7
0
2F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0 ,
7 " "
7
"
"
0(
"
%=
9 233P&
A
7 6
" #" % " %-
&
"
9 >FFP&
"
7
"
0(
7
" %
"
T
9 >FF45
" "
0(
7 "
%
A %>FF4& " &
" "
' "
0
"
Q
9 >FF45
"
7
T ' "
9
9
"
A " 0
" 7
T '
" 9 >FF4&
A
" 7
"
C
D
C
0
D0
"
7 7
O
" "
Q
0
7 7
=+ )$ >
7
=+ )$ =+ )$ ,
=+ )$ 2 7
=+ )$ < =+ )$ ,,
=+ )$ P =+ )$ ( =+ )$ ,,,
=+ )$ Q =+ )$ $ =+ )$ ,.
=+ )$ 2 ,-
) *,. *+ =+ )$-
F?@5 T 9 >FF45 T 9 >FF4& " " % O 7 & " " " " 7 " " % " 9< T= 9 >FFQ5 = 9 >FFF&0 " " " " " " 5 " " " " 7 " " " " %) 9 >FFR&0 ! 7 " " % 7 7 " " " " 7 & 7 7 7 " " A 7 %( T '" 9 >FF>& 7 " ,E %) " 9 >FF>&0 ! 9 7 7 " 7 % " & % 7 & %1 9< 9 @F 9 B T " 9 >FF4&0 * " " A A " %-#" 9 >F?@5 . " 9 >F?4& " " 7 "5 " 0* " 7 7 7 7 9 7 % " 9 = T 9 233R&0 7 " " 7 " " " % T) 9 >FF45 . T -"6" 9 233>&0 * " 7 " 9 " #" " " " " %-"6" T . 9 >FF4&0 %2333& 7 9 C " G A D % 0>2P&043 * 7 " " 7 " %( 9 " 9 $ < " T ) 9 >FF4&04> * 7 " " 7 "" 0 * " 7 " 7 7 %< T' 9 >FF4&0 >F4> (0 0 = 9 " 7 7 7 " 7 7 " % 9 >FFQ&0 *
"
%
& %'
"
9 >F?35
"
0
" " D5 7&
A "
" " T
FFQ :"
#" /
42
7
C
"
9
"
"
A
"
"
7
7
TB
7 %
"
4>
" "
" C
( 233P&
M "
"
"
%>FF4 & "
7 %+
"
" 9
9 233R&0 , 7 " " %=
"
"
%< "
" "
7
&
9
"
7
42
"
7
7
"
A
"
7
" D % 0RP>&0 "
" 7 "
9 >FFQ&0 "
+ " 7 ) "9 + 9 9$ ' 9 T " 9 233R5 9 233R5 233Q&0 , " T 9 >FF4&0 7 " #" &
7 9
"
&
@F
9 233@9 "
9 >FF4&
9 233R&0 %
@?
9 >FF4&0 %
7 9 7 " 7
T 0 +
7
" 9
+ ( 43 +
7
7
" %
%
" 7 5 $
" 6
%-
" %C
"
"
"
"
7
7 9 +A 99- " T ) " 9 233R5 = 7 9 ( 7 9 7 %< T
7 " 69
99( 7 "
69 9 $X ,E % 9 >FF4&0
" T
% &0 " 9 >FF45 , " : "
$
5 >FF4&0 8
"
7 0 FF4&
D
"
99 9$
9 9 7 9 ) *" 79 -6 9 T % 7 9
P>
0 9 9 9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%(
9
" 7
,E T ) 9 >FF4&0 ,
" 9$ FFQ5 -
" 9 233R5
7
" 7
T
9 >FFQ5
%$
"
9.
9 FF4 &0
"
" 7 " ; " "
" " 0 *
%
"
C
D
" 7 0 " " 9
7 0
0
9 "
" 7 0
7
9 "
"
2.4.5.3.8 Static vs. dynamic assessment of intelligence and potential "
" " 0 *
7
" "
7
"
"
7
9 "
7
"
%
" 7
"
7
4R
"
0*
"
" 7
0
FF@& "
5-
9
0*
"
"
0! 9 "
" 7 0
:" #"
"
9 7 0,
"
;+
;
2.5 Summary *
7
"
& "
%=
9 233P&0
#" "
"
"
" "
"
% 7 "
7
"
7
0 *
" 0,
;* " 0' "
7
" "
"
" 9 7
"
A
7
7
7
"
9
9
" 9
9
% "
& "
:"
7 0
"
"
7 7
20Q
" 0 *
"
"
0
, "
7 9
"
0 *
"
:"
7 "
/
#" "
"
9
7 7
"
9
7
"
"
" 0 ,
"
7 7
7
" 7
&
7
% "
7
9 9
"
" 7
PP
9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
" " " 9
7 "
9
7
"
"
" A
"
"
7
7
A "
"
0* 9 " ;
04@
"
7
"
7
"
" " " " %
7 " 7
M
"
&0 ,
7
7
7 "
" "
7
"
9
7
"
" 044 ,
7 "
0
(
0 + 9 "
9 " "
7
7
"
7
"
04?
"
0 -
"
7
" " 5 ) 7 .
0* B
9
7 "
7
7 9"
0
- 7 -
"
0
2.6 Dynamic assessment within intelligence * 7
"
7
7
"
" 7
"
"
9
" 0
7 5
7 "
7
0 * 9
" 9
"
"
"
7
9
7
"
7
0)
"
9
"
" "
R0 '
0 * 9
"
"
"
" 0
2.7 Dynamic assessment: fundamentals $
7 " 9
#" >FF?5 B >FF45
9 9= 9< 9 >F?45
T %< : 9 >F?Q5
FF?5 B T 9 2332&0 , " %( 9 >FF>5 % & 9 >F?F5 = 9 233P&0
' " " 0 " M
7
9 7
0 + " 7
7 "
' 9" 9
&
" 9 &
7 9 >FFQ5 T9 T< 9 >F?F5 ) 69 >FF>9 ) 69 " " T ( 9 >F?? 5 9 >FFP5 "
7
%
CB
" D %>FF29 023>&
"
"
" 7 C
7 9
;! 9
D
7 "
"
7
#"
;
0
:" 7
,
A
0*
0 " 7 0+ " " 7 "0+ 9 7 9
7 9 0 7
0
PQ
7 "
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
.
7
&
"
% %'
9
FF4& " 7 A " % " T( 9 >F?? & 9 9 >F?@5 9 >F??5 9 >FF4& 7 %< T F4@5 " " 9 " 7 >FF4&0 *
"
"
7
%
"
7 9 >F?@&0 * 9 %) 69 >FF2 &0 ,
7 % 9 >FF@&0
7
%' "
"
"
9
7
(
9=
9
"
T
9 >FFP5 '
6< 7 " 9 >FF@&0 * % T( 9 2333&0 *
7 %( 7 " 7 4F % 7
69
9= 9-
T< "
" ,
7 5 $
9 C
7
D 7 9 " 9
9
T
"
7 7
T ) 9 2333& 7
"
9 " "
&9 %< 9 9 >FF2&0 ,
T$
" " "
7
" 9 %$
7 " "
" "
7
9 >FFP&0 %
"
""
5
"
"
7
"
" ' " " "
,
A
"
" 0 +
% F?Q&0 * 7 " T
FF2&0 ) " " A
FFR&
T(
7
% "
9 >FF2&0 ' " %' " " 7
9
A " 9 >FFQ& 7
"
" & %) 69 >FF2 5 %$ 9
. " 7
0* "
7
9 2333 &0
9
0$ " %(
"
"
• • • • •
* ( * "
7
7
"
$ 7
7
C
7
7 D
7 7
9 :"
9 "
%(
7 " %
T
"
T=
9 2333&0 *
"
9 2333&0 ' "
"
+
"
7 7
-
4F
0(
9 >FFQ&/
%-0 ' "
"
7
7
7
7
9
0
PR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
2333&5
7 0
"
5 " %*6" T B 9 >F?4&0 * " 9 " 9 23325 < 9 $ 9 . 9 FF4&0 * ;$ 7 & & %( #" • • • • • •
7
7
7
69 >F?4&0 "
"
. ""
%$
%
% 233>&0 )
7
A A U $
%" " T B"
9 &
9
" D
"
/
7 7 %
5 B 6"
"
9 233R&
: "
7
"
8 (
R
"
7
"
"
A "
7
"
0
$ " (
" "
7
""
5 0 0
7
7 "
" 9 2333&
T( 7 " " A
" %" 7 " 9 2333 9 2333 5 *6" %FF3&0 7 " % 7
T 7
7
7
%$ 7 :
& %< 7
!
" 5
7
%' 9 7 9 7 "
9 >FFP&0 "
O
"
0 9$
7 9 T< 7 " 9 >FF4&0?3 $
9 >FFP&0
F?45 *6" T' " 9 >FF25 - " % T
9 2333&0 *
"
" 7
#"
7 7 " 9" " " T + 6 9 >FF25 *6"
9 )
69 9 = " 9 >FFF&0 *
FF2&0 * %< 9(
&%
7
7 9 >FF2&0 * " % - "9- " 9U T' : 9 2332&9 7 A " " 2333 5 1 9 2333&0 ( " 7 7 " " 7 >FFR5 9 >FFR&0 * " 9 " 9 " " " *
"
% ' "
%
T-
" 9 23335 1
7
" 7
7 7
0*
7
0
9 (
T $"
" 7 % "
9 >FFQ5
T
"
7
"
"
& % " 9
"
" " " " 9 233>&0
%
9
" 7
" 9
%
7
A
7 "
7 7 "9
"
" "
"
"
233P &0 7 " 7 #" 7 7
" " T.
9 >FF25
7
"
#" 0 * 7 " " " & %' 9 2333&0 ,
9
"
& 7
9 2333&
9
%
7 "
" 7 " .
9 >FFP&0
7 "
T 9 >FFP&0 ( 5 0 0 %B 6" T 9 2332&?> " " 7
" T(
"
"
9=
7
B
" % "
7
T
& "
7 "
' " .
% 7
&
0 ' "
.
" "
% &
8&
7
" "
"
"
" %"
" 0,
" " %
>FFR&0 + , * 9
"
?2
"
.
7 "
9
9
#"
9 "
"
0( "
" 7
7 %
0
7
0 7 "
"
0*
0*
" " "
#" 7
"
7
" ?P
9
7 9
9
0
9B
7
" %=
"
" " T=
" " 0 9 >FF@&0
#"
77
T
9 >FF2&0 * "
7
P4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
?Q
0*
7 9
" " 7 " A
7
7
" 7
"
7
%B
"
7 C
7
7
&% " 7
7 "
7 " "
7
#" 9 233P&0 ( " 9 7 0
% "
"
#"
"
" "
" $
D 9 7 9 233P&0 (
9
. "
7
5
"
A
"
T T *6"
" 9
.
7 %
9 2332&0 $ 9 >FFR&0 ) " 7 7 " " 9 7 " % 9 >FF@&0
7 " 9 >FF4&0 ,
7 ?R
7
?Q
?R ?@
+
"
T
" 9 >F?4 5 $
9 >FF@5 .
9 $
9 .
9
" %(
T
F?45 ) 69 7
" 7 " "
7
7
" T(
9
T
" "
" #" 9 >FF25 ' "
9 9
91 " "
%< 9B
T *6" %) "
9 >F?4&0 9 >FF35
9 2332&0 * " %FF2& " " 7 %( 9 >F?F5 ( T $ 9 >FF2&0 , 9 : ,E ?4 7 " %< 9 ( 9 = T 9 >FFP&0 * 9 7 % " . 7 U $5 C 7 7 D5 ( 9 23339 04& " 7 7 %< T ' 9 >F4F5 $ 9 9 T < 5 9< T( 9 >F?@&0 < " 7 " 7 % 9 T 9 >FF@& " 0* " " 0* " 9 " " " " " " 0 9 A 0, " " % " R & " %B 7 T 9 233Q&0 " " " ,E " 0
"
" 7 "
":
"
" 7 7
7
% " 7 & 7 T. 9 >F??&0
%
"
=
M 9
"
A
9
"
%
" - " 0+
?4
%
FFP 5 9 *6" T . " 9 >FF25 T 9 >FFP5 1 9 >FF25 9= T . . :7 9 >FFP&0 + " 9 9 7 %B T 9 >FF@&9 " " % " 9 >FF@5 *6" 9 >FF@&0 , " 7 9 7 " % " &% = 9 >F?2& " 7 " " 7 " %F4>5 9 233>&0?F , " 7 " 7 " " " " " %. T -"6" 9 233>&0 %-
T
" 7
7 D 0F3 7
C 6 . 7 "
"
"
"
%
F?45 9 >FF@5
9 .
" " %7 " "
%
& 6
&
7
9 >FF@5 9 >FF25 - " T 9 >FF2& 7 % T 9 >FF@5 < : 9 >F?Q5 B T - " 9 >FF@5 U " T 6 9 2333& %C D 7 C D &0 , " " " " %. 9 >FF4 5 ' 9 >FF4& " " C D C D 0 7 " " " 0 7 9 7 " 7 7 7 7 6 7 " 7 " " C D% 9 >FF4&0 * " 7 %. 9 >FF4 &0 $" 7 " 9 " " 7 " 9 7 0 ' " A 7 " " 9 7 " 0, " 7 " - " 7 9 " " %- " 9 >FF@& 7 " 7 %- " T 9 >FF3&0 ' " " " " #" %< "7 9 >F425 + 9 >F42& " " " 7 %) 69 >FF2 &0 , 9 *6" %233>& - " %>FF2& A " - " " 0 $ A 9 " " - " " 9 9 9 7 " #" " 0 *
7
%FF4&0 ' " A ) " 9 9 " " 7 >FR3A % 0-0 ' " 9 2333&0 *
9
7
9 7
*
F>
" " "
"
7
"
"
" 9 %) 69 >FF4&0 * " " " 7 " " % 9 2333&0 $" " #" 7 9 7 7 7 "
9 " 0
7 9
"
7
"
7 7
" "
< "
%
9 >FF@&
"
%FF4&0 7 "
% ": "
9(
:
T
9 >FFP&0 , " 7 " T= 9 2332&0 *
7
"
" 7
%
A
" "
7 " 7 "
0* "
"
5
7
"
"
7 "
"
6
% " " %' " 9
" " 7 9 1
" & 9 B
#"
7
T
9 >F?4&0
"
7 "
"
#" ' "
7
"
7 1
" % " % 9 233P& 9 23335 ) 69 >FF4&0 , F?45 ' " 9' " 9' 9 2333 5 9 23335 = 9 23325 = " 7 9 >FF2& % " " " 7 7 %1 9 2333&0
% 9
23335 ) " >FFR&0 *
9 >F?4 5 ( 9 >F?45 "
7 5B 7 2333&9 "
%FF2& " %*6" " "" 9 23335 ) 69 2333 &0 $
T "
T
" "
"
" 9 "
F>
"
"
9 "
*6"
"9
7
"
"
"
%2333 & "
& 7
T 9
9 23325 1 9 T = 9 %= 9 2332& "
"
" 7 " 7
%1
"
- " 9 "
" " "
9
" #"
" #"
"
7 "
0 9
%
9 2333&0
"
"
" "
0
Q2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 9
7
"
7
9 >F?4
- "
" 6
"
' "
%- " 9 B $ %- " 9
A )
-
T1
0, " "
" 6 9 23329
% "
"
%) 6 T * 9 >F?4& 9 233@&0 * " % #" e 9 23325
T 7
7 >F?4&0 * 7 %) 69 >F?>&0 (" "
%1
T' "
9 >F?4&0 * " 5F2 " 7
" %) 69 >FF45 ) 0 %) 69 233>5 ( " " " "
7
•
T
- 7
T
&0 * 7
9 >FF4&
9"
" 7 " T7 "
#" = " 7
"9- " 9U
T'
:
9 2332&
9 >F42&0 *
7
"
7 " "
" "
7 7
"
9 "
"
" 7
:"
"
"
"
>FF3&0 *
>
" 0* "
"
%-
0 *
9
*
" "
:
- "
" 7 "
7 "
"
"
7 #"
% 7 5$
FF>& " 0
"
"
"
"
" 0,
" "
A "
" "
"
9
" 0' "
0 9
" .
"
9
7
%*6"
F2
" 9 >FF?5 ) 69 >FF45 " "
%$ B
- "
"
" "
7 %( /
7 "
9 >FF2&
9 >FF@&0
"
"
B 6 T' 9 >F?4&0 *
0
" " %
9 T
7 " 9
QP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
>
/
%
FFP9 0>4R&
" U (
7
7 (
< % , 7 7 -
&
"
.
% 7
M
7
% "
&
9
7 7 "
" "
" 7
" " 9
%
9
9
&
"
7 "
M *
7 M
6 M
&
&
7 7
M M
7 %
0P3?5 *6"
$
9 233>9 04&
-
• •
• •
•
7
•
" •
.
•
$
• •
7
•
"
7 M
•
•
7
$
•
(
9 "
9 9
7
9
'
• •
+ 7 " ,
7 7
•
+
•
=
•
"
&
(
•
$
- " "
•
'
• 9
•
=
"
•
9
•
• •
#"
7
M
-" :
7 M
•
7
7 %
"
:"
&
•
,
%
7
•
7
•
"
" + :
•
• •
"
•
9"
•
"
""
7
•
+
7 " (
7 7
"
•
+ :
•
7
7 %
&
•
"
"
•
M
7 " •
"
(
•
•
" "
"
• •
' "
A
7 •
FF@5 9 >F??&9 7 9 " " % T -: 9 >FFP5 % " 9 >F?2&0 " 7 % 9 >FFR&0 $ 7 " 7 " 7 " %-" 66 9 2333& " C D " " - 7 " " % 9 2333&0 + 7 < " " " 7 0< 5 7 " " % 9 >FF?5 ( T 9 23335 ) 6 T * 9 >F?45 T( 9 2333& " %( " " " %
FF4 5 9 >FFF5 9 2332&0FQ 9( 9= T
69
9=
9 >FFP&0
V 9
0 *
"
%>F?@&
" "
" "
F?F&
7 " .
' " "
"
"
"
" :
' "
"
0
9
"
"
0*
7
" "
7
" ,
7 "
"
" 7
"
0.
"
" "
FQ
"
, 7
"
" " 9 >FFP5 -
T -
%) 69 >FF2 &0 ,
" 7
0
+
"
" " 7
"
9 >FFP&
A
"
" "
"
9 %' "
T' "
9 233>5 -
" 7 "
" 0*
%
7 9 >FFF&0
" 9 >FF2&0 "
Q?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" " "
%
FFP&0
9 >FF45 ) " 4 #"
"
7
" 9 233R5 0 -
(
A
"
>F23A "
"
: 7
"
0$ =
%>F24&
9
C
7
7 9 >FF4&0 *
D%
& % 0RQ4&0 "
7 "
7
"
" C " D%
"
"
" 7
V & % 0RQ4&0 *
7
7 7
0
QF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
4, %
(
/
9
" 9$ FF49 0P>Q&
M +" &
A
7
7 , * 7
) ) ,
)
7
( ) 7
' "
%
7
&
' "
-+
7
$ !
, (
' "
7
-
*
' "
-(
%
" "
7
& 0*
"
A - " "
"
7
" A
%
FF@&0
R3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%
" " T . 7
% C
%F??& % " 8&0 , 7 " " 7 7 %- " 9 2332&0 < 7 " " " % & 7 " %( T < " 9 >FFQ5 ( 9 233R5 T ) 9 >FF4&0 , 7 & " 5 " " 7 7 " T B 9 233R9 0RP& 7 " 9 7 " " 7 " 9 2333&0
*
" " 7 9
" " "
"
%
%B 6"
9 2332 &0 .
" " "
9 " " " " %B 6"
" " %
" "
" "
9 >F?4&0
"
"
D %' "
" 9 >FFP5 ) "
T *6"
9 >FFR&0 = "
T *6"
%
A 7
9 2332&0 7
7 0+
7
9 0*
7
D
7
"
;*
C
D5
"
9
B
*
" " 7
"
9
7 9
FPR& % B " 9 2332&5 0 + %>FRF&9 0 " %>FR?& %) 6 T 9 2333 &9 0 - " %>F@3& % ) 69 >FF>9 233>& - " >F@> %) T 9 >F@>&0 " =" 9 %>FP3& $ = %>F24& % " 9 >FF25 " 9< T$ 9 >FF4&0 " 9 9 E" %>?PR& < % 7 &
" 0* % "
" 9 233>5
T
#" " 0=
" /
" " 7 0( T 9 23329 04P&9 0 (" " 9 " " 0* " #" 9 >FFP& " " "
" 7
C
7 9 '
9 ' "
7 7 9 >FF35 ) 69 >F?>9 233P5 " " 7 7 7 9 &0 * 7 %' " 7 "
9 2332&0 * 7
" "
"
7
%T*
"
" "
T
7
9FR
"
9 >FFP 5
" 0 .
"
7 9
7 :
9" #" 7
W
7 " "
9 233>&
"
"
"
A
7
"
%
7
"
9 233>&0 (" " %>FF4& 9
% " 7
' " %
T
FF4&
9
"
7 (
" %* 9 2332 & "
"
7 "
9 233Q &0 & %9 0 ' " A
D%
"
" 7 A
7
"
7 "
FR
"
"
9 %) 69 >FF2 & " "
%>F22&9 "
7 "
" 9 2332&0
7
7
"
0
R>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
#" %>?P?&9 7 " " ) 7 "
'
9
%"
"
" 7 "
7 U $5 " 9 %' "
7 5
F@
" "
&0
F3?&9 %>F2?&9 " 5. % " 9 >FF@&9 B %>FP3&9 " 5 - 6 %>FPR&9 5. %>FR4&9 7 " " 9 7 " 0 < 7 " 7
T A
&9
" " >F@Q&9
"
"
" 0
"
%>F@2&9
" "
"
"
-
9 %>F@F9 >F4>&
7 =
" < % =
7
9
"
9
"
-
B
0
" 0*
"
" 9
"7 7
%B 6"
" 7 #" 9 23325
" T
0
"
" "
"
%) 69 >F?4 &0 , " " ' " 9 " 7 9 $ T - 7 9 2333&0 * " " >F23A "
" "
)
9 1
9 < 7
%) 69 >F?4 &0
>FR3A 0 + 9 "
"
7 7
"
"
" %) 69 >F?4 &
>F@3A "
0 01
9 " " T B 9 >F?4&0 ) %FFQ&0 *
5 9 7
" D %
7
9
"
TB "
"
7 9 >FFQ&0 $" C
7
9 23325
7
%$
"
&0 , " & F?4 &0 * " T 9 233@&0 , 9 "
7 "
"
233@9 9 " " 9
9 "
" " %< 9
" %E"
%
9
7
" "
" "
7
%
" 9 >FF4 &0
9-
T =^ M
" >F43A
9
>FF3A
"
9
&9 0,
6
9
"
9
" 9 >FFP5 $ " 9 6T-
%
9
F43A %(
F4
%) 69 >F?4 &0 7 " " %
FFR&0 "
7
>?33A "
9 "
R2
9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" "
"
&9
"
9
9
9
7 " 9 9 9 9 9 &% 9 23325 < T $ 9 >FFP5 ( 9 B 9 23335 T 9 233R5 " 9 >FF25 B T *6" 9 >FF25 B 9 >F?45 B 9 * " T B 9 >FF25 B 9 T 9 233>5 B " 9 >FF?5 B 6" 9 23335 B 6" T 9 23325 ) 69 233Q5 ) 6 T 9 2333 5 - " 9 23335 - " 9 - " 9 U T ' : 9 23325 - 7 T = 9 >FF25 99 ( T 9 >FFR5 T 9 23335 *6" 9 2333 9 233>5 69 9= T( 9 23335 = 9 23325 = 9 " T= 9 >FFR5 = T- f 9 >FFR&0 * " 7 " 7 7 " " " #" 0$ 7 " 7 " " % T 9 233P&0 * " 7 9 9 " " :" " " 7 :" % T 9 233P&0 7 " 8 "
, "
%
"
9 0
7 9
:
"
" "
7
>FF3A
7
0 %
Q
, * "
9 " 9
&0
" "
" 9 (
9
FFP5
9 >FFP5 -
%(
9 >FFP5 T
T= 9 2333& % 7 9 23325 T " 7 9 233>&0 *
" C" 9 2332&0 . % "
" 9 %
%
& %* "
7 9 >FFP5 - :
'
""
7 9 >FFP 9
"
"
"
" Q&0
" .
=
7
9
9 2332&0 ,
"
" 9
" 0
" " D 9 >FFP 5
7 F?
7
" " " 9 5 0 0 "
7 " "
9
FFR 5 - 7
9 2333&0 * " " >FP3A
"
9< "
* A T 1
a
"
" %'
T.
9 2332&0 * 7 "
7
7
7
7 " >FFP &
!
9
" 0$
. :7
- "
0$
" 7
%FFP&0
"
%*
"
" #" ' "
7
7 " " " " #"
7
7
"
"
,
%
"
"
9 233>5 T
9 >FF>5 9 233Q&0 = "
#" *6" 9 233>&0 ) 7 7 " " " 7 7
" W
6( " " " "
T
9 233>5 B 6" " "
" " T "
9 2333&0 B 6"
7 9 *" 9 >FFP& 7
9 2332&0 % T "
7
" " #"
"
"
"
%
7
7
"
7
0* " -
0 *
0,
" "
" 9 >F?@5
" 7 "
7
"
T 9
-"
%>FFR&
A
>FFP& "
9 233P5 ' " 9 >FF25 U " %
7 %
%$ " T
9 2332 5 *6"
" " %B 69 B 6
7
%) 69 233>&0
&
" ' "
9
"
" "
A
T)
"
9 "
% ":
9(
:
T
9
"
T 9 2332&0 * " " 7 " 7 % " 9 >FFP 5 ) 69 >F?>&9 7 " " " 7 7 " " 0, " " " % 7 " " " 7 & " " " 7 % 7 7 & %1 9 ' " 9 9 B T *6" 9 >F??5 9 233Q5 *6" 9 2333 &0 (" " 7 " " " " " 7 7 " 7 " " A 7 7 " % 9 >FF4&0FF (" " 7 7 % U "T 6 9 2333& " " 9 0 " " 7 7 %' " 9 9 T 9 >F?3&0 * 7 7 " 9 " #" " %B 9 2333&0 * " " " 7 " %9 2333& 7 0 (" " " " " 5 9 7 " " #" " " " :" 0* " " C " " D " " " 7 0 (" " " " " " " " " % 9 >FF2&0 * " " " " 7 0 9 " 7 " 7 " 0 -" " 7
7
"
" 7 7
0*
"
"
"
"
9 >FFP&0 * 9
"
" " 0*
"
" "
"
#"
" "
7
%
T
" 9
9*
"
""
9
9
7 0 % 9 7 " " "
$ 7
FF
" "
"
#"
" "
" =
%-
%2333&
7
0$ 7
, " " "
T FFF5 " 7
2@0> 0R2> "
" W 6( = "
$0 0' "
9 10)0
T
9 233>5
C
" 9 2333&0 D
C
D
T
= T 0)0
%>FF4&0 , "
0
RQ
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%-
T
" " " "
9 23325 " % %( 9 >FF@ &0 * " " 7
7
T :
9 233> &0 )
" &
%*6"
"
" "
" A
9 2332&
"
7
' " %B 6" T
" ,
9
A
0 7 -
%
.
A 9 >FFR&0
"
9 2332 9 2332 &0 %(
(
9 >FFR&0 (
" " %
T 7 "
"
7
"
"
&0
2.7.1.1 Soviet ideology and Vygotsky’s manoeuvrability within the system " 7 .
7 9
7
"
7 >33
•
C " 0*
%>?F@ >FPQ&
.
) 7-
A
7
•
" 6
.
"
"
- 7
- 7
C
D
"
%
- 7
7
%
>3>
: "
"
% "
,
A
9. 7
#" P
P
7
A
" 7
% " " A
"
7
5( T7 9 >FF4&
B , #"
& "
C
- "
>3>
"
%B 6"
" " "
"
,
9
9 >FF3& % 5 6
9 "
" *
7
9
"
0*
A
"
"
"
7
"
-
7
" " ""
9
"
"
9 >3P
7 "
"
;, 7
7
"
0'
- 7
" 0 -
9
"
0
"
"
T
"
. 0
"
" >3P
P&0 " 5
.
" 7
&
"
"
9 >32
%
0
0 FF4 7 7
9 >F4?5 B
"
" 9 >FF4&0 * "
"
5
" •
%
Q
A - 7 7
. =
=
"
"
•
" &0
"
>32
"
*
9 >FF4&
"
"
•
&
" 7
•
" 9 >F??&
7 " "
•
" %-"
A
. .
"
7
A
"
•
7
/
7
•
D
"
- 7
"
A
0 "
9
"
=
%>F?>&
= "
7
"
9- 7
"
0 "
%
9 233>&0
RR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
0* 7 "
"
. "
A
9 7 " 9 "
7 " #" %2333&
•
"
" "
" A7 •
* "
"
7
%
"
7
"
- 7
9
" "
>3Q
-
0*
C " D 9 " "
"
0* U $ " "
Q
" C- 7 D0 A %>F4R& 0
" "
0*
9 9 " 7
" "
&
" .
" "
"
"
" "
"
A
"
"
"
0>3Q
- 7
-
9 "
:
"
%>F4R& " 7
" .
7 " #" - "
9 .
0,
.
0
" - 7
4RR
7 •
0.0 ) "
" "
M 0
) "
7
7 %>4>> >4@R&
9 %
7
)
2332&0 < 9 " " * 7 "
•
"
"
1 "
' " %) "
T$ 9
M "
"
"
9 233Q& "
7
5
>?@3A
A #" M " 0*
•
9
9 " " 0 0)
%>?R? >F2>&
" 9
7 •
*
7
• •
( * M %>?F@ >F@R& +
• •
M ,0 0 -
7 %>?2F >F3R&5 M ,0 0
"
"
"
7 7 %>?F3 >FP@&
7 "
M 0 0M .0 0
?4F >FR4& M
??Q >FQ2&
M
0 0< 7
$
%>??Q >FQ>&
%>FP3 >FR3&
"
" " 7 0*
•
7
"
"
C
" " " ' "
"
" "
7 " M -0)0 "
7
5 7 "
•
7 0
7
D
"
% ' "
•
7
0 7 "
7
"
"
9 "
"
, 7 " "
M )0-0 . & %>??F >F@3& "
9 0 0 )"
7
7 "
0)
"
7
7
"
M 0 07 7 " %0 0
0,0 U
"
& •
)
7
%C 9 >F?2& "
D& "
"
7
- 7 0"
"
%< " 9 >FRF5 ( >?3@ " %
9 >F?25 79
R4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>FF?&0
3R " 7 " %B 6" 9 >F?@& " " >F23A " " 7 " % 9 >FF?&0 * 7 " " 9 " " $ " 7 . % 5. . T. 9 >FF>& " " 7 7 % 79 >FF?& " %9 >FFP5 = 6 9 >FF@&9 " 7 " %) 9 >FF25 . 9 >F?> &0 " " 9 . 9 " 9 7 %= 9 >FF?&9 7 " C D " %< T' 9 >F4F5 9 >F?F&0 5 B" & % B" & ) 79 >F?>&0 . %>F4?& % 5 9 233>&9 : " . " " %B 6" 9 >F?@5 " "9 >FFP& " 6 7 %*6" 9 2333 &0 * " " 7 " 7 " " 7 " " 0* " 9 " " " " % T 9 >FF4&0 * " " " % " "9 >FFP&0 . A 7 D 7 %. 9 >F4?&0 7 0 * 7 " " 7 % 9 >FF?&0 " 9 >FF?&/ "
"
" "
" 7
" "
7 0* >F2F0 *
,
" . " " 5 " %)
% 0
9 >FF25 0
" " "
"
" " 7
"" C
#"
9
" " % •
-
C
D "
7 " •
*
"
"
0
7 9
7 "
7
7 • • • *
*
"
#"
7 "
" 9
U $
>F23A "
7
C
7
C" 7 7 "
>3R
"" %B " 9 >F42&0 ( " . A C " D %9 >FF? & 7 %< 9 2333&0 * %B 7T 9 >FF?&0 * " 7
" " D 7
7 D>3@
C 7
. 9
" %
"
9 9B
79
" D D %< " 9 >FRF9 0QP&0 * D %) 69 >FF>&
C A
/
7
9
7 "
7
' "
$ 7
7 A
7 7
7 .
" C
7
>3@
7
7
- 7
B
#" "
9 " %-" %2333& 0*
9 9 233R&0 " "
%2333& % 9 >FFR 9 0FF&0
: .
9
"
7
0* 7
7 " "
.
C " C
D
U $
"
7 " 9
0+ "
"
D
R?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>34
" - 7 %B
7T T.
.
&0 *
. 9 2333&0 . 9>FF>&
" "
"
7
%
0 "
P&0 -
9
0
7
#"
"
7
7 " " 7 " 9 233P &0
%
•
>F>4 >FP@/
•
>FP@ >FR3/
"
9 233>&0 "
>FR3A " 7
%233P& #"
"
"
7
"
"
7 "
9
7 7A %
>FR3 >F?3A /
•
%
9
>FP@ -
" •
' " "
7
%233Q & "
%.
7 "
"
>3?
"
"
"
0,
"
=
&
7
7
"
=
/
•
"
"
"
"
=
+
7
"
"
= 7
7
"
- 7
"
" "
9 233P&0
7
"
9 *6"
0 $ T. "
" % 7
& %34
,
' " . 9 >FF>9 0P4& . A " % 9 >F?@&0 >FR3A 9 & %= 7 " >F@3A " "
A 7 "
% >F43A ' " A %' 9 2333&0 >3?
" " 9 2333 &9>3F
"
#" 7 9 . T *" 7
" A 9 >FF2&0
>F43A .
" C %U $&0 * 7
7
"
" 7 7 . 9, 7
7
"
' " 0,
"
" "
9
" -
% "
7
7
9 >FF2&0
0 .
A 7
>3F
9 #" " 7 9 " "
" "
"
7
0
"
" 7
7 "
"
"
7 7
"
"
9 "
"
"
7
"
"
% " 9 >FF4&0 ' "
" 0 0*
"
. 7
5
A
0
#" 9 233P &
%
' " "
%-
7
7 D% ' "
%
0 "
" "
9 233> &
9 >FF2&0 * 7 9 : 9 2333&0 ' " A
/ "
%) 6 T
%
%
9
"
7
"
%
"
" ""
7 7
" : " : 7
7
" "
%
7
&
"
7
0 "
7 9
)
-
%) 69 2333 &0
RF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
7
7
"
"
9 7 7 T.
' "
0 7 C
7 7 " 7T
F23 >FQ3A " " " 7 " %
9
" % 9 233P5 9 >FF@&0 -"
9
D :"
. 2333&0 *
" 9 233P5 .
7
&
A
&
"
"7
0
"
"
#"
7 7
&9 - 7
#"
"
" W 9 >F??5 . "
D %
" 9 >FF@&0 * %.
" .
9
2R " 7 #" 9 >FF2&0 ( - 7 " " " " :" #" - 7 0 " 7 D % 0PQ@&0 7
9 7 "
=
"
"
79 >FF?&0 9 >FF?& " %*6" T
9 "
: 0
"
C
7 " 0
" 7 T
#" "
7
% % - 7
0 %B
"
7
7
Q3
9 2333& "
" 7
"
7
& 9
: C- 7
"
"
" C
>FP@ " #" >FP@9 1 " C "
7
%>F?F& 7
" D
7 " 9
- 7
/ •
7 7 7 " 7 >FF4&0 * = < 79 9 " " " 9 " & 9 >FF@5 " " " "
%
-
7 " >F3P
& M
, "
7 7A
" 9*
9
7 9!
" %B 6" 9 >F?@&0 7 " C : 7 %< " 9 >FRF&
7 7 7A
7 " -
"
%U
=
9
7
>FR3A 7 7
7 7A " 9 >F4R5 .
7
% 9 >F?>&0 , "
T " 9
%
)
7
" & "
% " "
" >>3
"
7
"
"
"
A " 9 >FFQ &0>>3 < A
7
0+
7
" " " #"
"
" " - 7 " " " " < 7 7
>FP3 7 0.
%.
9 >FFQ & "
" 7 "
"
9
0 F?2& " "
%
F42 5 - 7
(
7 0
@3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
%.
9 >FFQ &0 *
7
9
0 % "
7 7A
7 9 :" "
9
7 "
7
& •
" &
"
" 7
%
T = " " " " 0 *
" 9
9 >FF25 ) 69 >FF>&0 , 7 7
" "
: "
" A
"
"
"
7 7
"
" #"
" "
7
7
" 9 23335 B
7 7T
F?>&0 . " % "
7
>>>
" " A
9 >FF?& "
0' " "
&
7
9 "
%. %.
•
%
F?> &0 C( 7 9 >F?> 9 0>R>& 77 " " %. 9 >F?> & " " >>> %. 9 >FFQ &0 " 7 " " 7 7 " 7 7 9 " C D %. 9 >F4?9 >FFQ &0 * " " " . 7 7 " &0 , . A o " - 7 9 . A " 7 " o . 9 " 7 " 7
"
7 6T(
7 " %>F4?&
7
7 7
&0 )
" .
" 0 ,
. T 9 >FF4&
9 >FFQ &0 ,
"
7
"
7
"
"
"
9
"
"
"
.
W 9 >F??&0
7 "
7
=
A #"
U $ 9 >FF>&
%
9 7
0 " " "
" "
"
: & % " >FQ3A * " "
%
.
7 "
"
A
D
7
7 0 7
" >>2
$ 7 "
A
% 5
" "
" 7 " "
%
9 " 9
T)
% .
.
.
9 >F@@&0
5 "
7
7 ' " 9 >F?Q& ' " A %>FFQ&
"
7 "
5 9
" %
" "
9 >FF?5 .
"
" 9 >F4?&
9
* 7
>>2
5
"
" 7
7
%) .
"
"
"
9 233R5 9 "
6T7
9 233R&0 %"
"
&0
@>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
.
o
A 7 "
7 " " 0 D(" " 9
F@@& 9 >F?F&0>>P >FP@ >FR3 %A "
"
" #"
%(
7 " %
>>P
7
7 " 9 %1 7 9 >F?F&0 ! " " . A T ) 9 >FFR5 T 5 " " 7 " "
7
) "
" 9
;
7
%>FFR&
9 >F?25 .
9 >F??&0 -"
7 - 7 7 "9 " - 7 9 >F4R&0 + 7 % 7 7 9 >FFR&0 ' " - 7 0
"9 .
" 7
7
7
"
" ? "
O- 7
"
0
@2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
?)
"
* =
F??9 0QQQ&
7 "
7
' "
.
/
"
/
) 7 7
/
)
-" =
"
/
7 7/
=
7
7
"
0 ' "
9 9
9
9 < "
" "
D5
%< "
7
A
7
#"
5 "
"
"
"
*
"
" >F>4 * 7 "
%
=
"
"
"
%(
9 >FF@&0>>Q , 7 % ) 9 >F4R& "
>>Q
* *
7 " " " 9 TB 7 9 >FF45 * >F>4 7 " - 7
"
7 9
0- 7 9
9 0,
" 9
7
"
9
9 >F4F&0 1 7 CZ [ " 7
9 " A %>F?F&
" - 7 7
" D % 0 &0 $"
" "
" "
9 >F?Q& "
9 7
"
"
/ C* *
7 " - 7
-0
" #"
7
7
G " "
7 A
(
(
0
" * "
0
9
"
%>F?Q9 0RQQ& 7
" "
T (
" "
" - 7
9 233Q 5
"
7
7
7
%
7 "
"
" 7
" *
: "
" " 7 "
%.
"
7 "
7
7
=
" 7 9 "
9 >F@@&0
)
C 9 >F4F&0 - 7 " " #"
9
" 9
"
A0 ! 7
7
9
D0
@P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9 >FF@&0>>R *
%+ "
C 9 79 >FF?& %B 6" 9 >F?4&0
%
+
"
#" 7
D
0,
" 9 >F4F&
7 "
D %$ 7 - 7
- 7
=
-
% " 9 >FFQ&0
*
" 7
7
" "
" . %233P&9 .
- 7 " 5
% )
" -
• •
-" $
7
7 "
" "
5 )" 7 9 >FF@&0 C*
9
9 >F4?5 B 6"
A "
7 " "
% -
" "
= 7
"
7
"
" .
7 - 7 %( 9 9 >FFR5 ! 7 . A B < " ) 79 >FFP B 9 >FF49 0Q&0 * " 7 " " " 7 0>>@ $" >FP3A )" . A 7 9 " " 7 %1 7 9 >F?F&0 )" - 7 ( " " ) %>F4R& " " " #" % " " 7 5 -" 9 >F??& 7 " " % 9 >F??&9 " #" % " h : 9 >F?4&0 * 7 % W 9 >F??& %* 9 >FF@&0 7 %233P& . : 7 " " " = . 0 = " 0= - 7 ;, 9 " " " 8 " - 7 7 " " 7 " 9 " 9 " " 7 " " 0 * 7 " " 9 " " 9 >F4R& 7 " 0 %>F?2& " 7 0< g %>F42& . " 9 9 " " " " " / T
%
9 "
%
7
"
T
A
0
7
&
7
>F23 >FP3A
- 7
& • • • •
>>R
% *
% *
+
= >>@
" " 7
"
.
" 0F&0 * #" &
& 7
" 9
% "
" "
7 "
%
" " 5*
" 7 " 9 >FF@&0 + " X 7 V 0Z
" " 9
9Y
"
"
6
"
9
"
[ Y
"
" Z
-
" " -
"
"
%
T
7
Y%
" X
9 233Q &0 '"
" "
%B 6" 9 >FF3& . %
9 B 6"
9 "
" "
"
9. 7
0 -"
" "
9
"
[
" " "
" 7
%
"
& Z
X 7
0
" 7
7
7 Y % 02Q3&0 = " " "
9 >FF@9
"
>F23X 9
Y " " " "
T
"
" "
%
>F2?
09
79 >FF49 0444&0 . 7 "" 0 9
>F>4
%
"
9 " "
"
7
[ Y %B
"
-
"
: 9V
"
>FPQ
" "
"
9
8 7
Y "
#"
7 "
"
7
.
"
79 >F@>&
=
>F2? Y
"
&
&
0 >F23
#"
&0
@Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
+
. % 7
A
" "
"
0 *
9
" 0,
&
7 9
7 "
"
%
F?2&0
7A "
A
"
" /
A
#" "
"
.
" 7
"
7 %-
U $
0 . >F@Q %$
T(
9 >FF2& )" A
>4
" 7
A U $ 7
#"
A
A
U .
9
"
" 0 *
7 "
" 7
7 "
"
0 * " - 7
7 : 7 9 >FF@&0 +
9 "
"
"
. A " "
U $ 9 2332&0 C D " A U $ % 9 >F3Q 7 7 "
9 >F?2&
0
;
@R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
F*
A %>F??9 0PR&
.
A 6
7
"
(
7
7
(
U
7
7
7 % 7 &
,
6 6
"
$
"
6
"
* (
-
,
-
,,
-
,,,
-
,.
* 9
9
7
7 7
%)
"
" & %-
" " .
79 >F@>&0 )
9 9 >F?F&0 * " % 7
7
= "
"
9 >FF?&0 " " % ) 7A
%
7 "
.
)"
9)
7
" 9 >FF@& 7 A % W 9 >F??&
5W 9 >F??5 )
9 233P&0
" .
%=
9 >F?>&0
.
7 %
9 233>&0 .
9
"
7
#"
"
7
7 "
0 - 7 D% "
"
7
0*
"
"
9 >FF25 B
" 7 #"
"
7 9 >F425 - 7 7 "
" "
7 9 >FF@&0 , %$
7 " T (
% =
7 0 . 7 " "
"
* "
C 7
" " ;= 9 =
7 D
A "
7
7
" ' "
"
%-
)
9 >F4R&0
" 9 2333&0>>? 9 233>9 233P&0 + " "
9 >FFP& 0 , 7 " 0 0
"
7 "
" 7
% T * 9>F?@5 7 "
A "
"
>>?
C " "
&%
=
" "
7 9 >FF2&0
" %B 6"
7
"
"
#"
" "
9" W 9 >F??&0
7
" .
%
7 T=
7 "
7
"
7 9
"
%
"
A 9
)
"
=
A
"
7 "
9
9
0
@@
0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' %( T 9 >F4?5 B 6" T *" 7 9 >FF2&0 1 A %B 6" 9 >F?@& " . " %( T9 >F4?&0 * .
=
"
1 9 >FF35 C
" " "9 >FFP5 . 7 "
D
" .
7 %.
.
.
9 >FF@&9 7 "
0
9 9 >FFR&0 #"
% " 23335 .
7
7 "
9 >F?2& " . T.
D
7 7 "
>FR@
.
7 0)
7
" 9 %
"
"
& 7
5
9 >FF@&0 , "
A " 9 "
9
" 7
0
"
" >FP@
"
0>23 *
"
FRF&/
T< "
0>2>
"
:
• • • • •
" %B 6" 9>F?@5 *
-
"
*
•
A
9 >FFQ&0 "
%
7
. "
"
#"
F?@&0
*
"
7
9 >FF2&0
7
"
7
- 7
=
%(
9 >F?2&0
"
7
"
9.
7
9
0
C
" 7
D
7 #" %) 6 T
"
"
7
9 9 >F?25 -
%
FFQ &0
9 "
%
"
&0 ,
" •
9 9 >FFQ&0 * T )" 9 >FFQ&0 " "
"
" " A
: %)" %.
"
"
"
"
7
A &/
7
0 -" 9 >FFR&0 * " 7 " "
" G
>2@
9 >FF2&0 ,
233@>2@
"
9
" "
.
"
"
"
7 9
7
0 -"
5 0 0
"
"
" " %(
9 9
9
9 233Q &0 9
0 -
F4?5 B 6" 9 >FF3& 7
. " " %$ . 9 23335 $"7 9 23335 ' T ' 9 >FF45 ) 9 >FFR5 " 7T 9 23335 9 >F?F5 69 233>5 $ T$ 9 23325 9$ T* 9 23335 * T. e 9 >FF@&0 , " " " " . " 7 %( 9 >FFP5 9 >F?F&0 A . A " 7 " 7 %9 >FF@&0 * :" 7 A 7 " 7 " 7 7 % & U $ %. & %. 9 2333&0 . %$ T$ 9 2332& A %* T . e 9 >FF@ &0 ' 9 " A . A % 9 233P& 7 " 7 " " 7 7 5 " " 7 #" " 7 %( T 9 >FFP&0 i %>FF@& C 7 " 9 " 9 9" 7 " 7 9 " " : 9 9 " 9 9 " 7 . " : D % 0R4&0 * 7 7 %= 6 9 >FF@& 7 " 9 " % A " 7 " . " " 5= 9 >FF@&0 * 7 " " 7 %< 9 >F??5 9 >FF@&0 " 7 . 9 " 7 % " T= 9 >FF2&0 " " - 7 C " D 7 C D A 7 - 7 " " %* T. e 9 >FF@ &0 7 " " 7 5 7 " " 7 " 0 9 9 7 " " 7 " 7 " %F@3A >F43A ) 6 %>FF2 & 7 " A " " ) 6A %>FF2 & " 7 #" 5 7 " 5
>23
"
" 0$ #"
0, 5
9
"
5
43
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
"
"
:
0
"
57 :
0+ >FF2
C
"
0 >2? *
D
C#"
0 "
0>24 = 9 RRj "
"
7
"7 D
2Qj "
0
7 9 P2j
"
"
"
"
"
>Pj "
"
9
0
" A
7
7
" 0 * 0 * #"
" "
A "
"
" "
"
7 "
"
0*
7
%
& %)
T
7
- 7
9 233>5
A %>FFF& " 7
" 9
" #" %>FF2 & " 7
7
22?
"
0*
#" 0>2F *
&9 7
"7
>3
Q2j
) 6
?
0' 7 7
"
" :
0*
"
"
0 "
0-
"
7 " 0$ " ) 6A %>FF2 & " < ,. 7 %>FFF& " 7 0* " B
" 0 , =,-( ,,, ) 6 %>FF2 & "
" 0*
) 6 %>FF2 & %Q@j FPj
0+ "
9 >F?4&0
$ "
%2333&
"
"
" 7
A
" "
7
0, 7
"
"
0
"7 "
7 0*
B
7 "7 >FFQ "
#" >FFF0 *
7
"
5 7
" "7 7 0,
0*
#"
7 "
"
0
4Qj "
"
#" % " 7
"
0 >>F #" 7 @
9
&0 %
&0 "
"7
" 7 2
9 "
"
R2j
7
"
" "
0+ "
0* " "
"
"
: 0'
"
"
9 7 7
"
0
*
>24
,
9 A
C
"
233>
" D
"
C
D C
- " >2?
" * 7 "
7
" D%
C
D " 9 ) 6A %>FF2& 9 23325 " T
% " " "7 233@ 23340 " 7 " 233P0 - " 7 "
9 >FF@5 0 " #" " 9 233@& "
7
7 " "
2 233R0 $" "7 9 "
"
7
7
"
" " 7
7
"
7
0
" 0*
"
#" - "
"
"
"
9
9
"
#" #" #"
"
0 9
8 *
"
"
% "
>2F
"
7 69 233>&
&0 "
" 9
7 9 #"
>33 "
9
"
0 O
"
0 "
7
" "
0
4>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
0 *
"
#" #"
" "
7
9
7 0*
7 7
7
9
7
0$ " ' "
B "
" B
,
0,
0 $
9
" 9
7
" 9 "
" " 9
%2333& 9
9
"
"
"
0 %2333&
" 7
A
7
9
/ • • •
. * $
•
*
"
" 7
7
" 7 " "
7
"
"
" "
"
*
B
%2333&
/ • • •
$ = *
• •
$"
"
"
"
"
7
9
7 7
"
"
7
"
"
9 "
,
9
"
"
#"
" "
"
"
% 7
7 " &
7
9
" #" " 7
" "
0 "
7 0
2.8 Intelligence * 7
" 7
7 "
"
" 5
0,
"
"
"
" " 7 &
9 9 :"
9
" 0 $
" "
%
0-
#"
"
9
"
"
"
0*
"
/
7
A
" 0=
0* "
9
" 7 7
7 " "
#"
"
7
" 0*
"
" "
9 " : 0>P3 =
"
"
9
"
0
>P3
C
7 D
9 " 7
" #"
9
"
7
0
42
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
2.8.1 Desperately seeking a definition>P> * -
7
%
9 >FF4 5 "
9 >F?4&0 7 % " % 9 T " "9 " 7 D " A >?RR 7 " A 7 " " " " " " " " 7 "
" *
C " " :
& 9 233R&0 ,
T < %1 %'"
"
9 >FF25 9 >FF35 9 >F?2 & 9 233R& 7 " C T 9 233R9 04&0
D %= 7 " %1
9 >FF? &0 * " " 7 #" 7
A
" 0* :"
7
/ FF@& %>FF@ & ""
"
"
" 77
A
"
0>PP *
" 7 7
" >P2
9
" " - *A 5 "
7
"
C 7 "
"
"
:"
7
7
7 " " "
"
>P>
% 7
""
"
>P2
7 "
D
"
7 7 7
0,
< A 9 C Z [ >FF? 9 0>>>&0 9 " , 1 A %>F?2 & " ; >PP * " : 9 " 9 5 " " 7 7 %9 233> 9 233Q&0 * 7 % 6 T< 9 >F?4& " %>F?29 0>?P& 7 " 5C D% &0 , " 1 " 0- " 7 7 " 0* 7 " 5 " " " 5 :" 0, 9 7 " " 9 0 C D " 9 9 % % 7 " C D A " 7 0 " 9 7 " " 7 % T$ " 7 0* CV 7 7 D% T ) 69 233>& 7 % " ) T1 9 233R&0 < 5 9 9 9 233R&0 * " " 7 " "0
7
"
A
D% 0
0 FF?& 7 ;+
"
7 9 7 " 0 " 9
" 7 "
7
" "
"
" " A
7
"
" = "
7 7
" 9
,
"
>P4
" " "
"
+
"
,EA 7 9 2332&0 * " - " 7 7 7 " 7 " " 7 9 233Q&0 * 7 7 " 0 B 6 A %233Q& 7 " " 7 7 >P@ " " %< T$ 9 233@&0 7 7 " %9 ' 9 ( T 9 >FF@& " A " " 7 " " " " 0>P4 A %233R& 7 " : " 0 * " " " " 0 7 9 7 " 0, 7
,E
>PR
7
0
>3
'
9 >FF4 &
7
T .
0 D C
5
9
C 7
7 5-
#"
7
C 7 " "
>PR
"
7 "
9 "
" 9
>3 0 7
%>FF4&
%
7 " "
$
9
7
"
,E
,E0 , 7
"
"
7
" 9 233R&
"
>>
"
>P@
9.
9 >FFP&>PQ A %>FF4 & 7 T$ 9
"
7
"
>PQ
T
%+
"
"
"
' "
9( 0
"
"
%-
"
"
0 , " 0+ * "
"
"
%= "
; "
"
" D
"
" 7
%* 5
"
9 >FFQ&0 ;*
0 #" "
7 A
0 D % 0?>&9 "
7
0,
" 7 C"
"
" "
7
9
" 7
7
7 "
9
[
"
"
P "
" " 7 9 233R&0 * C
"
9 CZ "
%>FF4& 7 " 7 0 7
"
0( ;
9 "
" "
7 "
7 7
0
4Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" 7
" " #"
" " 0< " " " C A 7 "
" " " 7 >FF?9 0?>&0 , 2332& "
9 ' "
7 " " "
"
7
%(
7 >FFR&0
A %>FF?&
7 " 77 0 $ " " " " D% "9- " 9U T' : " 9 >FF?5 9 >FF?& "
7 7 "
%-
" %
FF?&0 .
9 7
7 "
"
"
7
%' "
"
0 * C
D %-
" " $ 9 233Q9 "9 233Q& %= 9 >F?F&0
" "
" " " " :
0, " ;( 7
7
. " 7 9
%>F2>&
7
"
7 "
7 "
7
" 7 "
9 >FF?&0
"
" 7
D 9 %>F?F&
-
"
9
#" " 7
7 7
" "
9 9
7
" 0 7 "
" >2
" A C 7
""
"
0 +7 "
0*
"
"
( "
" ;
7 "
D
7 %>F?F& 9 " %*" " 9 >F4F&0 ' " 7 $ A %>FF4& 0 0 " A "
0 $ " 7
7 7
>P?
9 233R&0 , % 9 >FF?& 7 " %B T
%>F4F&
0' " "
>P?
7
" " 7 7
"
7 7
"
"
7
0 9
%(
7 " " C 9 >F?R&0 ! 9 $
7 "
7 "
7 " %U
A
9 9
" 0*
" 7
T 7
%>FF?&
#"
7
%
F?3&0 *
"
9 9
>>
5 0
7 ;
" #"
"
0
4R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
>> )
"
%
9 233Q9 0>Q25 -
) )
bb
7 " %
&
" &
. • • • •
, B
$
7
$ ,
.
bb
"
%
7 • • • •
9 233Q 9 233Q &0 (
" "
bb
"
"
"
7 • • • •
, 7 ( 7 ,
" "
; "
"
• • • •
$ ,
• • • •
$
• • • •
-6 $ $ $
bb "
" 7
; 7 " "
"
"
" "
" "
0 * "
7
bb
" "
0
7 "
)
"
7
"
7 "
0 7
"
7 7
" " 0 *
7 "
5 " "
9 7 7 7 9
7 "
"
" 0
9
7
%7
7
&
7
9 %
7
"
7
&0 7
* %
" " & " *
7
""
0 9 " "
7
7
0$ 0 .
9 7
7 "
7
M "
C
D
7 9 "
0 +" "
7 7 "
0
4@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
>2
$
A %>>F49 0>PP&
7
+
7
*
(
-
(
-
,
7
"
"
)
"
"
C-"
"
D
"
< $ 7
"
" +
.
.
,
"
(
>>
>2 7 "
* " >0 20
%
,
%
,
%
7
& 7 " &
"/ " 77
&0 , 9U
" 9 233R&0 B
T /
7 "
6
%
7
0 " 7 7 7
%233Q&
7
%
&
7 "
"
9
7 7 "
7 Z
9
7
C 7
%
7 "
[
7 9 0,
"
&
7 "
9
7 "
D
" 0
A "
' "
7 9 "
"
7
"
" 7
7 "
"9
0
44
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
2.8.2 Approaches towards the study of intelligence %
P&
7
7
7 9
9
7
"
9 "
"
" 7
"
"
" %7
%) 9 >FF@&0>PF , " " 9 %( 9 >FFQ&0>Q3 ,
9'
T '" 9
9 233R&0 7 0 , "
"
233Q &
"
7 7 7 9
9
" " 7
C
D%
9
"
9
7
" ;*
% " "
"
7 %=
9 >FF? &0 &
" C
&
"
"
% D
9
7
9 7 "
"
=
0- 7
7 9
0
" .
A
"
"
7
7
"
7
7
7
%
9
233Q &0 ' 7
"
" "
7 0
&0 *
%' "
7 7
FF29 7
T' " " 7 9 233R5 ) T B" 6
T( " 02>R&0 7 %
"
9 233Q&0 C,
" %
9 >FFQ&0 "
7
&9 7 "
7
0' "
7 0 *
" "
"
7
"
7 7
>P " 7
0 "
;(
0' "
" 0 %>FFQ & " :"
"
>Q
"
9
7
" #"
"
0
>PF >Q3
*
" #"
*
9 "
"
"
7 "
" "
" 0
" 7
= 0
7 " %( " 9 " %>F?F&
T
" 9 >FFQ&0
66 7
8 C" "
D
C
D 7
4?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' " -
>P
%) 9 >FF@&
"
7
%
"
,
% -
"
7 9
"
&
A
M " 0'
9
9
FF?&0 * "
%
A 7 A
9
"
"
"
7 0 *
0
" Q&
-
A
0*
"
"
0
" " ,E
>3 F $ ? 4 "
@ R
, F
Q
7
? 4
P
@ "
2
Q $
>
R $ 7
P 2
$
> F
?
4
@
R
Q
P
2
>
3
" "
"
FFF &
"
"
0
7 9
7
" "
"
0$ %>FFF &0
C
D
" "
9 7
" 7
0' " "
7 " "
%
7 "" 9 >FF? &
% #" 0*
"
" 9 23325
7 " T (e
7
9 2332&0 $
"
""
A
" 9
#"
?P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0,
"
" P?3
P?3
%
"
"
"
7
&8 +
9
"
"
#"
" 9 >FF? &0>QP #" " 7 " 0 * 7 7 "
%"
" " 7
#"
"
C 7
D
7 %-
" 9 C
7 0 $" 6 "
" "
D
0 7 9
0 $ 7 "
7 "
7
0
" "66
0*
A
"
"
9
" 9 >FF@&0
T=
" 7 9 7
" 9>QQ
B
7
9
" "
7 9 >FF? &0 0
7
0*
"
9
"
7
7 %
"
9
2.8.4 Omnipresent issues within approaches towards intelligence research .
"
" A
7 0, "
"
%& $ 7
"
" % ;&0 *
" "
7
"
7
" "
"
"
"
"
%
#"
"
P&0 * & %-
7
7
7
" 0
%
"
&
"
" 7
7
0,
7
7
"
"
#" "
" "
7
% &
FF3&0 "
"
" 7 7 C
;
7
" 7
T7
9
" "
9 >FFF&0 ,
9 >FF3&0 QQ >QR
"
% " 9 >FFQ&0 7 T 9 >FF4&0
7 TQP
%( %=
7 "
>F43A
" "
"
7
7 "
7 >FFQ&0
FFF&0 *
" 9 >FFF&
7 " % " 9 >FFR&0 E"
"
%-
" "
% 7
"
"
7 " C
" 7
"
" "
Q&
7
0
#"
" %
7 "
" " />QR
7
&0 ,
" 7
P
" " " M Q0 ,
"
7 "
0
?Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0*
"
" "
#"
O
" 0-
"
"
"
"
"
"
" &
"
" "
7
"
"
"
" " " ; "
; "
5
9 " "
"
7
6
" "
0(
7
"
"
&0
7 0,
7
"
" " "
"
#" 9 A
9
" "
" "
"
"
#"
"
7 "
0= ;*
T= " " 233@& " " "
7
>Q@
*
" 9 A
"
7
7 " " 0$
" 0
5
"
"
#"
7 7 9 >FF25 (
" " 5 " 7 ;* 9 >FFF& " " " " %< 9 >F4P5 9 >FF45 6 T( 9 >FFF5 T 9 >F?45 79 233Q5& " 9 >FF? 9 ) " 9 >FF35 ) 9 T= 9 >FF45 9 >FF? 5 . 9 T 9 9 >F?P&0 ! " 7 >Q@ 7 " " " %( " 9 7 T 9 >FF35 ( 9( T '" 9 >FF25 1 9 >FF45 ) 9 9 >FF45 9 233R5 9$ ' 9 ( T " 9 233>&0 * " " " " 9 9 " " 7 " 7 %) 7 T) 9 233R&0 * 7 7 " " 7 0 * 7 7 % " 9= T 9 233R& % " 7 5 9 " 7 %= 9= 9 )" 9 T 9 233R&0 + " %' 9 >FF>&0 7 9 " 9 9 7 " %9 >FF49 >FF? &0 ! ' " " " 7 ,E ,E % ,E 51 9 >FF? & %< 9 9* T< 9 233R5 ' 9 >FF?&0 ,
7
"
0* "
"
"
/ A %>FFQ& " " 7 7 " 7 % 9 >FF? 5 6 % 9 >F?P5 1 >F?R5 = T
7
; " ;
7
"
" " #" 7 7
0 $
7 "
"
" 9
"
9 0
" "
"
"
7 9
9
;
7 %
9
7 0 =
" "
0(
"
"
-
7
; , "
"
"
7
"
"
:"
0* "
7
9
0*
% M
" 7
" 0,
"
0"
/
7
9
"
"
#"
"
"
7
7
C 7
7 #"
%
9
R3j D " "
9 R3j " &0
"
" " 7
7 0,
7
?R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" "
,E " 0' "
" >4 "66 " 7
7
"
,E
8+
" "
0
?@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
>4 *
"66
,E
"
" 7
*
!
.
>F3@
2
(
2
bb
"
"
30Q3
30?3 7
,E *
" "
7 C
,
,E
+ $!* +
7
2
,( '' (* *,
C
D D0
D ,E C
"
2
"
0* :"
7 % 7 2
(
233@
"
30Q3
30?3 7
,E
7
&0 *
:"
" " ,E
bb
2
"
#"
7
7 " "
" "
"
" "
5
2
"
7
0+
C
"
"
"
7
D
"
7 7 0* %1
"
7
" 9 >FF? &9
7
" ,E ,E
7 77 &0
,E
7 " 9
,E
0%
" "
"
" ,E
7
"
0*
" ,E ,E
"
"
0*
/
2
>0 20 P0
,E ;
Q0 R0 @0 40
7
"
%
9 ,E "
" ,E
7 9
9 "
7 "
7
&
"
"
"
"
"
7
" 0 0
" "
,E
"
7 ?0
" 0
7
"
7 c ,E
" "
%
"
"
&
0
,E
"
"7
7
7 0
" &
"
" "
"
"
7
%7
" 7
"7 0
"
"
"7
%
& 0 0
7 " "
7 "
,E
; $" " " " 5 ,E " 7
7 70 70
" A
7
7
7 " "
" "
" #"
5
"
% >F3@ 7 0
7
7
"
7
"
0
"
2
233@
& " 7
%
,E
& 7
" "
" F0
,EA
7
"
"
,E
9 ,E
;
" 7
5 "
%,E& 2
"7 % &
M " 7 % &0 ,
7
"
?4
5
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
% &
" " " "
"
7
7
7
2
" 0 * 5
" %
7
T=
9 >FF?&
P0 * 7
0
"
T ) 7 9 >FF>& 7
"
% "
7 %
"
7
"
7 %-
7 9 >FF?&0 0+ " 5 9 >FF? &0 ) "
#"
% 7
" "
" :"
"
9>Q4 *
" 9 "
%
" 7
"
7
7 "
" "
&0
9
"
7
"
0 A 7 " 9
9 M
7
P&0 -
%>FF? &
7 " 7 9 >FFF&0 + 8 0*
7
"
" "
$
" #" 7
7
" #"
"
"
"
"
A
" • •
* *
#" #"
*
0
"
P
#"
Q0
7 7
"
9 233R& "
"
" %
7
%
"
7
& %
FF? &
M " 5=
#" "
T
/
" •
9 >FFF5 *
"
"
" #"
%-
7
*
9
T
9 2332&/
M 9 233R 5 9 >FF?&5 T $ 9 233@&0 9 233@5 9 >FF@& 9 C 9 >F??9 02F3&0 = & M
" 7
7
7 " " %
" 7
#"
69
9
T
"
" %'
T
9 >FF?&0
9 233R&0 5
" "
#" 7
7
" " "
"
7
" •
A
" 5 " %
• *
7 " " >> 7 " T ,
7
% 7 &0
"
9 >FFF&
7 " 7
>Q4 >Q?
*
" " 1
"
1
9
7
& "
7
" 7 " 7
>Q?
7
#" 7
"
" %
0 "
9 "
"
"
7 7 "
"
"
A
0
" 7 0
" "
7 9
7 "
"
0 0
1
9
7
"
"
" 1
0
??
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 :"
A "
" 7 "
" 7
" " 5 & %< 9 %>FF?5 < 9 T$ 9 >FFQ5 $ " %< 9 >F?R& " %$" 9 233R&0 7 9 1 >QF
;D %< "
9
< & Q 9 23325 $ 9 233Q5 $ "T 7
T T-
" 9 >F?R9 022>&0 1
T
" " " 0 " " 7 0
% 9
%
7 9 >FFQ 5 " 9 >FF?&0 1 " 9 233Q5 ) 9 >FF@& 7 " 9 " A " %>F@F&0 * " 9 >FF@& C
" %) A %>F?2 & "
9 "
" % *& 7 " 01
>?
0 ""
" *
%>F?2 &
"
*
,E "
>F@3 >F43G 9 >F4>&0
FFR& " 7 %B 7 9 >F?@&0 7 9 " 9 " 0 , " %* 9 >FFQ& " " 7 7 " " 7 9 " #" " 7 0 " 9 %>FF4& C " " D % 02R?&0 A %>F?@& " " " 7 "
" 9 >FFQ5 (
"
T B "
5
9 >F?45 9
&
7
7
#"
7 "
7 " 7 " 7 " "
" #"
"
" 9
"
>F
0
F3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
>F
A %>F?@&
9 ,E %
&
-
" 7 "
(" "
FFQ5 "
" 9 >FFQ5 7
"
9 >FFQ5 +
9 >FFQ&0 7 9
9 0
" " %( T < " 9 >FFQ5 1 9 >FF4&0 < " GA AA GA 7 " :" "
T " &0 * A %>FF2& 7
7
"
"
9B
" 7
7
"
" " "
"
"
:"
1
"
#"
" "
""
9 >FF4&
7
7
" % "
>R3
7 "
AA
" :
7
%
7 0
&
%
"
9 "
7
9 "
7
"
"
0 7 / • • • •
* * * 7 , " / 7 "
7 7 "
"
"
' "
"
* " 7 , " / "
&
9 >FF29 02&
7
*
7 %
%
9
>R3
"
7
$
• • •
" 7
/
7
7
7
7 7
"
%
" "
7
9 >FF29 02& "
7
"
"
""
7
0
F>
" ; "
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
$
"
7
7
7 "
" "
7
" "
7 "
7 " 0 * " 9 >FFQ&0 =
7 %$
7
9 "
9 7
"
7 "
7 0*
7
9
" 7 ;,
" #"
7 0'
"
" 7 9
7 9 "
"
#"
"
7 " 0*
7
"
" 7 "
"
7
"
"
7 0 7
9 % & 9 >FFQ &0 " 9 7 & 7 " %( " 9< T= 9 >FFQ&
7 7 "
" O %
%1
.
A
" "
% 7 "
0 + 7
0$ T-
%
,E
E" %( "
"
"
" 9 >FFQ&0 *
"
>R>
"
0
" % 9 >FF@& "" "
7
"
5
7
%
9 >F?F&0 "
7
7
7
"
" " "
GA " " 7 0
FFF&9
7 0
7 9
9 >F?@&9 " 7
7
" " "
"
"
9
0
7
"
#"
7
"
"
"
"
"
7 " 9 % "
"
"
#" #"
7 "
7
"
9>R2 , 9 >FF@& 7
% "
8,
7
"
"
7 0 , 9 " " " " A 07 " " 9 " " " " ; = " ; =
"
"
&0
" "
7 "
"
>RP
#"
"
7
" " " >R2 *
AA 7 7
#"
"
"
9
" " 0* #"
"
"
"
"
7
9
"
0
R>
" % "
"
"
"
% 7
7
"
"
"
"
9 "
" T$
7
"
9>RP
" %B
" ,E ,E; 9 >FF4&
"
O "
"
0
,E
9
0(
"
&
"
"
#"
9 " " "
"
A
7
7
" %
.
" 7
"
" 9
" T- :
"
7 9 >F?@&
7
" 7 " 9
9 >F?F&0
"
" 7
" 7 "
" 7 " >FFQ5 7 0
O
0 +" #" 7 "
7
"
" "
"
0= "
0 7
"
GA "
7
7
"
0 AA % 0R>4& "
" 0
F2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
;* " *
7
7 " "
" 7
O
9 0+ "
-
9 >FFQ&0 * O &
7 %
7 %B
%
-
7
7 " 7 9 >FFQ&0
7
& " "
% %
9 >FF?5 -
" T
9 "
GA
" 7 " 0 "
7
" 0' "
"
AA 7 0* "
"
QR %
7 "
7
7
"
7
7
O
"
9
7
P&
"
%
A %>F??& &
( "
- :
7
%>FF@&
" "
" %>FF?& " " " " %$ 9 >FF? 5 7 " 7 "
7 "
"
%$ 7
"
T
9
9 >FFF&0 , " 0 ,
" 7
7
"
" 9 >FF?&0 -" 7
"
A 0
7 "
0 ,
"
" 0* "
9
"
"
7
7
"
7
7
" ,
" "
0
" "
7
" 7 A
9
"" 0 * " " " "
FF?& " 7
"
% 7& *
" :
7 :
"
; %B 7
7 " :
0 7
"
9 >FF4&0
* 7 9
0 0
"
9 "
"
9'
7 " "
%
"
%
"
"
9
9 >FFQ5 " 7 &9
7 0
"
9
A
" 23 7 ;
7
9 0 * 7
%"
0
#" #"
0*
"
#"
7
7
" 7
*
"
"
"
>RQ
&
7
" 7
"
;= "
% %
" ; " "
" "
:"
"
"
&0
"
"
"
5 %-
7
"
"
9 >FF? &0 (
5 7
-
"
7
7 " " 9
9
9
9
$
69 >FFF& " 9
0 , "
(
" 0,
9
9 >F?R&0 ,
"
%(
9
RQ
" 7
'
"
"
"
7
9
"
"
0
"
"
0
FP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
"
" 7
" 7 9 >FF? &0 * " " 9
>FFF 5
' "
0
7 9 "
#" "
"
0(
%
23 '
7
M
-
$
" "
0
7
"
7
" #"
9 "
7
9
-
"
%>FF?& :"
"
" #"
"
7 7 " 0*
-
" "
(
-
" #"
7
$7
"
" "
$7
" "
$
7
A "
*
"
"
" "
7
9 "
9 " " 9
"
9
" 0* 7
"
&
"
7 7
" %
" "
" "
"
7 0, " #"
" 0 $
"
"
0 *
7
" 7 "
"
7 7
0
"
"
" "
7
. =
" "
7 "
"
0
7 " =
FQ
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" "
7
7
6
"
7 " %
" 9 >FFF&0
"
"
7
%
7
9 >FF? &0 * 5 " 7 "
5 "
5 "
7
5
#"
5
7 "
" 9
%
" " " ; '" 9
T
9 >FFF&0 = " 7
%
7
&
7
6
7 %) T B" 6
"
%
7 "
9 233Q&0
&
"
9
7
" %$
7
6
9
9 >FF? &
9
A
%) 9 >FF@&0
"
9 " " 0>RR * A " " 7
" '
%
7 "
" 0 *
" 7
"
"
" "
" 0,
"
"
7
"
7
" " 9 >FFF& " 7 0
% "
0 A %>FFF&
"
"
" " 7
"
"
&
6 "
"
7
"
"
7
"
7
" 7
"
%
9
>FF4&0
2.8.5 Yesteryear and today – how far have we come? *
: "
" " "
7
>F2>
""
"
7 " 5
"
"
"
7 7
0
A %233Q& "
#"
7
C* 7 " 0>2R&0 7 "
?R " ""
" 9 :
""
"
"
" 0
7 "
" 9
*
9
A
D %* "
9 >F2>9
7 "
"
"
%< >F2>
7
0*
9 >FF?&0 1" % " 9 >F2>&0 *
"
% 5 0 -"
7
"
"
%
0, "
%>F2>&
" "
" "
"
" "
" "
" 9
A
"
A %>FF2& '
0 -
%
&
%>F2>&
0* " 0(
A %>F2>& " "
0 -
"9 " 7
"
" 7
7 "
"
/ 6
"
"
0'
>RR
"
0 8 * "
" *
& 9
0
7 "
"
9 >F2>&0 * 6 5
" " 6 "
7 7
" "
*
" D0 +
"
7 7
7
C
9
7 0, 9
9
;
FR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 "
"
0$
9
"
9
7
0 '"
" 7
7 "
"
7
>F2>
( 7
%>F2>&
7 "
A
7
7
9 7
" "
CV 7 7 " "
" %
" 7 9 >F2>&
(
%>FF?& " 0 = "
;*
" " 0
" 7 "
%>F2>& D % 0>PF&0 ,
"
% 7
6 9 233R&0
#" 0!
" %>F2>&
7 C
7 " "
7
7
"
D
" "
7 "
"
" 0
"
7 7 "
"
&
?R
7 " %=
0 *
; "
" ;
FF? &0 *
%-
D
"
0 +7 >F2> " "
9 "
7 9 >F??&0 " / 7 " 9 7 7 " 7 0* 7 " 7 " " 7 9 >F??&0 ' " 2> " 0
%9
" " O 7 "
' "
"
%-
2> )
%-
9 >F??9
7 "
7
7
0 *
"
0
7
" " O
"
"
5
7 " 7
"
" "
"
0Q R&
, •
"
T $
7 "
< / /
=
% 7 " &9 9 " "
" " 9
%
&
• (
7 / 7
7 % 9
9 9
9
&9
9
7
%
"
5
&9 7 •
F2>0
" "
7
"
"
9
"
" " "
"
%
>F2> " 7
" 7 "
" &
9
>F2> %A
9
" "
F@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
%-
T
FF?&0
"
"
"
" %=
"
T
"
7 7
9 233R&0 9 >FF? &
%$
" "
"
"
"
"
"
>F2> " "
7
0
2.8.6 Cognition ,
" " " 9 5 ) 69 >FF2 &9 7 %' 6 9 23325 9 23325 1 9 >FFP5 7 % " 9 >FF?& " " " " 7 0$ "
7
9
" "
>FFF&0
"
"
7 9
7 "
9 7
7
7
" 9
7
" 9
9
9 2333&0 , "
"
" 7
"
"
0
7
"
:"
" 9
7 "
0 *
9 O
" " "
7
"
7
0 7
"" 9 >FF4&0
7
7 7 7
"
"
D % 0P3F& "
7 "
/
%>FF? &
" C
7
" 0>R4 =
"
7
9
" "
"
7
" 9
%
9 (
9 2333&0 *
"
9
"
9
"
" "
" "
7
%
&
"
7
" % 0*
9 "
7 " " 5 "
7 " %B
0 *
0
T
7 7
7
7
"
9 >F?R&0
: "
" #" "
7
* "
%
>F?@5 =
T 7
7 "
T(
9 >FF45
F?@&0
7
>R@ >R4
T(
"
" 0 9 2333&
T$
0*
>FFR5 '
9 7
7 "
"
" %$
"
"
%- "
7
" 0 1 " 5 "
7 "
%+ T B " 9 2333&0 7 "
"
"" "
9 233R&
7
"
" 9 "
" " "
"
" 7
7
"
A
" 7 " "
" %( "
7 " %>FF4&9
"
9
%
9
9
7 "
"
#" 9 >F??&0
%
"
A
" "
9
" " 0* 9 " " " "
0 ,E
7 "
7
"
0
9
" "
" "
0
F4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0*
" 0 *
"
"
O
"
0 .
7 "
"
"
" " >FFR5
7 9 >FF?&
( "
"
9 "
"
% $ &
% >F?3A % " %
"
9 233>&0 * " 9 2332&0 * 7 " "
7 "
%1
7
"
" " "
7
9
9 233>&0 "
"
" >R?
7 0
9 0
" =
%>FF4 & %>FF?& "
7
7 "
" "
"
7
0+
7
9
7
"
0
*
7 %
9
7
7 "
C
D%
7
& 9 7 W9 >FF4&0
& 7
7
% O
"
' "
P&9
A
"
"
7
%
" 6
7 0*
7 7 9 >F?F&
7
7
%-
7
7 " 9 2332&0
7 7
7
&
7
7
"
"
"
0*
" "
9 7 7
7
" N 9 >F?45 $ )
T( 7
" 9 23335 $
"
"
,
0' "
22 "
>F33 7 "
" "
9 "
7 U $A T 7 "
9 >FF@5 7
"
"
#"
"
9
7
$ "
0 %>FF4&
7
7 9
7
9
0
7 9
9
"
"
9
" 9 >FF@&0 ) " "
' "
9 "
"
%>?R? >FQ4& 0 E" "
"
9 "
"
"
9 "
%$ 7
" " 9 >FF@5 B
7 9 "
"
T
" "9 >FF@ &
T .
"9 >FF@ & 7 & 9 >FF@&0 .
&%
0
7
#"
%.
%
%
7 " 7
9
"
0 "
" %$ ( 9 >FF@5 $ %>FF4& " " " 0* 9
233>&0 $ (
0* %
"
"
" 7
7
%
R?
" 9 '
% 7
7
"
7
7
"
-
9
" "
7 " 7
>FF?5
7
7 9 " % 7 "
7
& " "
"
7
% "
& Y
Y0
F?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
22 *
7
%
9 >F?P9 04@&/
4
7
A
? )
@ >3
-"
"
>0 20 P0 Q0 R0 @0 40 ?0 F0 >30 >>0
R
Q
(
"
F
" P
2
>
>>
7
" " "
" 7 "
" " " "
7 7 "
"
•
*
•
*
"
"
. "
"
" •
*
•
*
"
" "
"
" "
7
"
7 9 0+
:
% % "
9- 7
9
"
6T1 "
" " " " ;>RF D % 0P2Q&0 ( " "
" A 9 >FF4&0 , 9 >FF3&
" ) 9 >F445 (
"
%>FR?
%
FF4& " 9 >F??&
" " "
"
9
9
C
9 " "
"
"
7
" • •
( )
"
"
"
>RF
"
)
" " %=
7
"
5 0 0
"
9 " 0)
"
7 "
"
"
9 >FF?&
FF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 9
"
" "
"
0 * #"
%
9 >FFF&0 ! " 7 " 0 -" " "
" " 7
FF@&9
"
T$
9 2333&8
" " 9 " "
" "
9 %
"
" "
" 0 ) 9
' "
2P "
>@3
B
-
7
" " "
"
( "
7
6 ( " % "
9 >F?45 *"
9 2332&0 B %
" 9 %' 6 9 2332& 9 >FFF5 9 >FF?&0
T
A 9 >FF4&0 7
9 >F@4&0 +
" 7
*" "
" "
A
" 0
"
, %
%
"
)
9 >FF4&0
7
5
)
&
7
" " : 7
:
7
G
7
% "
),U
%
"
)
7
7 CV
A
" 9
" 5 7
a a
7
7
" :
7 9 " " D %>FF49 04F&0 #" " "
9
7 9 >FF4& " >F@3A &
7 "
"
9 "
9 9
"
7 "
D %$
9 233Q9
9 >F?4&0
>@Q
0P@& 7
"
7 "
5 Q
"
G %
%
F@4& " 7 "
9 2333&5 "
"
0
7
>@2
"
"
7
"
" "
"
>@>
"
0
9 >FP@9
%F?4&0 *
7
>@R
" &
"
% %
" "
%
:" 7
%
"
%
A "
>@2
7
9 "
9>@>
7
" 7
% .
"
" "
9
9
"
"
>@R
" "
"
7 7 "
"
"
>@P
"
"
" "
"
7 "
" " " 9 >FFQ&0>@3 '
T
7
"
"
%
F@3A 0 %>F??& "
0 >FQ30
>33
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
2P *
"
%' 6 9 23329
-
"
0
7 &
$
>/
(
"
"
"
2/ ( 9 "
9
-
"
7
" 7
"
P/ $ "
"
7 >
(
>
" "
(
9
>
"
" (
7 "
"
7 9 " 9 "
2
*
9 6
2
9
2
7 " "
" 9 "
7 "
"
*
7 7
" "
"
P
P
"
"
" "
P
"
,
9
" 9
"
"
9 "
%
C
D&
"
" "
7
"
"
(
"
>
( %
" "
(
"
>
"
(
"
"
"
& 7 " "
(
"
2
(
"
(
"
7 "9
2 "
>3>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
"
&
"
"
% GA " 7 9 >F?3&5
%>FF4&
9
"
7
% "
9
"
0
"
;
7 %=
7
"
"
"
" 7 7 "
" " 7
7 "
G " %
"
"
9 7
0 ,
" " 0,
7 "9
9
#" 7
" 7 9 >F42& " &0 +" &0
) >@@
" 7 %
7
&
7
7
"
%
" 7
7
9
"
9 97 " A >F@4 7
" 9 2332&0 ) 9 09 233Q&0 * " 7 7 7 " #"
" "
"
0* % 9
7 0
9 2332&9
7
"
"
"
% 7 "
P0Q020>
7
"
7
"
PQ&0 * "
"
0 * 7
7
"
0,
"
0
"
"
P
"
7 "
" 2
" "
7
9
" " 0 ' " 2R "
%
" "
"
" 0
09 233Q5 %$ 7 " 9 >F?4&0
#"
7
" 20Q0R0P020 " " #" " 7 "
"
7
9
7
7 7 " 7
>FR3A %$ 7
7
" 9
7
"
"
"
7 "
7
" "
9 233>&
9 7 9 >F?4&0 $ 9
(
A
9 9 >F?45>@4 B
%
FFF5 0
"
"
"
; "
" "
" " 0=
7
" 9 0+
"
"
" ;
:" AA % 0?2&9
9 2332&0 $ " " " 7 " % 7 "
7
"
2
"
"
" "
9
"
2Q
" -
>@@ >@4
FR?
0
>32
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
=
' "
A %>FFF "
2Q -
- "
9 2333& "
=
(
A %>FFF
#" 7 "
- "
7
0
9 2333&
#"
7
"
7 " M
"
+7
(
"
*
( ( ,
( )
.
" 7 "7
7
9
"
7
"
M
(
"
7
7
,
(
7
-
"
"
$
(
(
"
7
0
7 7
0-
9 "
7
7 7 "07
>3P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
2R
"
" "
9
9
" "
%
"
>FF4
9 23329 0PQ4&0
" " 9
9
"
" "
" 9 9 " 9
9
9
9 9
9
9
9
"
-"
7
"
7
"
7
"
"
2
2Q0
>3Q
7 "
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
(
"
7
"
"
; * %1 "
"
" " 7 " " " 9 233>&0 * " " % 9 >F?4& " 7 " % 9 >FF49 233>9 23329 233P5 T 9 >FF25 9$ T 9 233P5 9' 9 ' T( 9 233Q5 9 T) 9 233>5 T 9 >FF?9 2332 9 2332 9 233P5 T9 >FFQ5 9T " 9 233P5 9( " 9 T) " 9 >FF?&0 , 7 7 " 9 " 7 " % " T 9 233>5 T 9 >FFF9 23339 2332&0 $ 7 " " " % & " " 7 " " 7 % T9 >FFF&0 , " #" 7 " " " ; * 7 " " 9 9 " 9 " " 9 " " " " 7 0 7 " 7 " 9 7 9 7 " " 0 *
" #" 7
"
" "
% 7
9 >F?4&
7 7 " "
"
"
% "
&0
" +
"
"
"
"
"
0+ "
" 7 "
"
%
"
7
" 9 >F?P "
T < "
7 "
"
7 9 >F?4&0 7 "
0
"
"
"
* 7
7
9 >F?4&0 ( 7 9
7
" " :
0 %
" 7
7
7
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
7
A
" "
"
7
9
7
" "
"
"
0 *
7 9
C
"
"
(
7
7 "
0 "
9
7 0
,
(
7 9 "
7 "
7
9
9
"
"
"
"
7 9
"
#" D " D
7
0 C
%
#"
"
7
9 >F?49 0>F&0 = #" 9 "
"
9
9 "
%
0 *
" 9 >F?4&0
>3R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
2.8.7 Non-intellective factors 7 9 >F?45
"
7 >F?4 5 9T= " " 9 7 " 0, ,E 9 7
9>@?
" 9 >F?45 =
T "
T -:
FFR5 9 >F?F5
9 F?4 9 9 >F?45
" %F@P5
"
9= 9 ": #" %) " 9 >F425 -
"
%(
" 9 >FFQ&9
9 >FF@&0 +
7
" 7
"
7
" 7
"
"
"
5
% 7 " 9 233@5 < 9 >FF25 ( " % & ,E " "
9 "
" "
"
" 7
"
"
0
"
0
>3@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
2@
9
"
%
9 233Q &
* •
"
*
% &9 c
o
]
7 9 o
7
"
Z "
[D %. 7
7 %$&
% &
"
7 • •
*
7
7
.
7
%.&
7 "
"
7
0*
5 . ` "
7 . O. 9 "
"
F??9 0Q?3& 9
T '" 9
7
" 9
•
% &
9
" 7 •
% & "
%C 7
"
. O.
V
7
9 "
7
9
7 #"
"
O ,
7 ≠
"
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
FF?& A 7
T < 7 " )" %>FFQ&
T
7 7 7
9
"
9 >FF25 6 T 7
9 "
9 9 >FF?&0 *
T -
%( 7 %
7
"
"
"
7 %
- 7 6
"
7
" %$ 7
" 9 233>& 9 233R&0 *
7
7
9 >F?F&5
A "
7 "
"
"9
"
0 " %0 0
" 9
" &0 *
9 %-
"
T @F
>F43A 5 ( " " 9 7
9 >FFP5 7 7 " 9%
C >43
%< C
9 >FF?&
D
9=
5 - " %( 9 >FF3&0 +
%(
T
FFR&0
" " 7
9 >FF?&0 * " "
" @R&
D
A
* " "
% T
"
" 7 " 7
7
9(
9
>F43A % 7 " 7 %!" 9 >F?R&0 , 0 9 >F?R& 9 >FFP&0
9 >F??& " #"
"
7
" "
7 A
" 9 >FF@&9
"
0*
7 % "
"
0
"
7
7 9
" &
" "
7
" #"
"
0
>3?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" "
"
%
=
" & 7 " " " T 6 9 >FF?5 - " 9 ) T+ 6 9 >FF2&0 0 " 7 9 7 " 9 7 " %F?4 &0 %' 9 233>& " 9 " 9 5 " %-"6" 9 T 9 233>&0
" "
%$" "
A 7
7
7 " 7 7 "
" ,
:"
" 7 "
"
9
9
7 " "
7
7
#"
" " 7 9
"
7
7
"
" 7
9 " "
"
" & %) 69 233>5 -"6" 9
7
9 #"
7 " "
=
"
>4>
%
7
""
%$ 9(
9 23325 " :
T
9 233>&0 " "
0>42 )
7 " 9 4>
"
"
" 7 "
" "
" ;
7
;*
>3F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" " 7
"
7
0 +
7
7
0
(
#" ) 7.
.
A
0* 0,
" 0
9
"
"
"
7
0
"
"
"
.
A
0,
"
"
" "
"
0"
"
9
0
"
0*
"
" 7
0,
7
9
7
7
"
7 0
7
6 =
"
9 7
" "
* 7 7
9
"
" "
7
"
7
7
"
"
0* 7 7 " 9 7
9
" 7
7
0)
"
7 9 "
0
9
A
7
"
"
7 9 "
"
9
"
7 #"
7
7 #"
"
0*
"
"
:"
7
0 $
A
"
7
7 "
9 7
' "
7
7
"
7 .
0 *
:
"
"
"
"
7
"
7
0 (" 7 7 7
7
0. 7
"
7
"
7
A
" "
"
7
7
"
0
A
"
"
"
"
"
"
:"
7
7
" 9 "
7
0
" 7
"
"
7
C " 0
D
" 7
"
" "
7
A 6
"
7
0 *
"
"
0 $
"
7
"
"
"
9 "
9
"
"
"" 7 7 9
"
0
7
" "
*
" 7
" #" "
0*
7 " 7 " "
"
"
9 " 7
"
0
"
9
9
"
7
7
" "
"
" " 7 " " " % &0 -
#" 7
% "
"
"
0* " " #"
0+
7
7 " 7
"
7
"
"
7
&
0, "
"
9 "
"
9 "
" "
5
" 0*
"
" 7
"
7
>>3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0 +
9
" 0*
"
"
9
"
5 "
" -"
0
"
7 "
" 0*
0*
7
"
" "
""
"
0* ""
7
" 7 "
D
7 7
6
" "
7
0 (
7
7 "
0 $
9 #"
"
7
"
5 " 7 0 *
9 7
9 "
" %
7
"
" "
7
"
C
" "
9 7
"
9
&
"
7
0-
7 "
7 "
"
"
7
% &0 *
"
" 7
0 -" 9 C 7 "
" D
"
9
"
7
9
9
0$
A
"
7
" "
"
7
"
"
0)
9
"
9 "
0
>>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
Chapter 3 Delineation of the meta-theoretical framework 3.1 Introduction *
" 7
9 7
0
7 9
9 "
"
"
" 7
" 7
0*
"
9
9
7 >
"
"
"
"
"
0*
9
7
"
"
C
D
"
9 " " 0,
0*
"
"
9 9
"
0
0 + 7
"
"
" : 0
=
"
"
7
9
" " " % "
" "
" " 9 "
"
#"
" %'
9 >F?@& " 9
9
"
"
"
7
9
7
"
" 0
"
9 >F?3&0 9 92 " 9" " 7 " 7 " %" 9 2333& 7
"
"
"
9 7 "
" #"
"
"
" "
"
7 9
#" 0* 9 "
7
" 9
7 9 "
"
"
"
0
3.2 Science *
" %
#" W9 >F??5 " T " %< 23335 - " 9 233Q&0 "
D %=
% 9 >F??&0 * 9 >FFR5 $ " 9
& "
6
9-
" 9 >F439 02>&0
F?>5
"
9
" 9 %$
9 &%
% " 09 2333&
"
9 >F?>5 ' "
T
9 >FF25 - "
9 9
7
+
#"
9 >F?>5 .
7 9 >FRR5 $ " 9 " #" " "
k
#" 7 "
7
9 >F?>&0
9
D
%>FF29 0QFR&/ C "
%233P&
9 >FPF5
"
"
" =
9 23335 7
9 >F?4&0P "
%* " " % "
T *"
"
"
2
" "
9 >F?R&0
*
>
& 9 23335 ' 6 9 23325
"
9 '
% T =^
9
9
0
"
" 9 "
" : 7
C
:
" D % 02& 9 " "
=
5C %233P&
9
"
% 0>P2&0
P
"
7
"
" : 0 ,
9
"
" 7
"
%
7 "
9 7 7
&0
>>2
D
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
F?3& 7 " D % 0P4 P?&0
9 233Q&
"
9 9 7
9 9
7
"
7
" "
"
" C "
" "
7
"
" " "
"
" " " %: " 0 233@0 * 7 0 = :
9
"" "
Q
7 A
"
#" :"
"
#" %
9 >F4F&
D %< 5
9 >FF4&0 *
" "
5" &
"
"
C @
%B
9 >F?R5 -
D 9 >FF? & :"
"
7
" " 7
#"
5
#"
" 7
9
"
" #" "
"
" %' 6 9 2332&0 $ " "
"
"" 9 "
"
0
"
7 #" 9
5
.
"
7
7
7 0 FF49 0>>?&0 ,
" 7
"
7 7
T=
7
"
"
" D %-
" 0,
"
"
" "
" 7 0
"
#"
7
7
;
@
" "
9
" " "
0 ,
" "
"
7
"
"
9 >F4Q9 0P@2&0
0
"
R
"
"
"
" 9 " 9
" 0 %$
9 7
7
7
7 #"
Q&0
"
C
*
9 >F?3& % " 9 " 0*
0,
"
"
A
"
"
"
%
7
9 " 0*
7
"
"
%
9
" "
" "" 0R * " 5
"
"
" 7
"
0 1"
5
"
" " 0
" 7
-
7 "
"
"
+
29 7
7 0
T
7
" "
" "
6
00
7
"
0 $
7
%
"
9 "
" 7
" " 7 " 9 >F@R5
"
&
" #"
9
7
7 7
" 0Q
7
0 "
9
7 7 7
" "
:
>>P
D
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0' "
0, 24 "
9 :"
"
""
7
"
"" 0
' " 24 % & >F4P9 0>@&
7
%
9
7
"
-
, 7 7
)
M "
(
" 7
-
-
-
-
7
>>Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' " %=
24 % & * 9 233P9 0>P>&
(
$
;;
,
"
7
"
(
-
7
"
<
FP3A 9 233R&0 9 233P5 -
?
T *" 7 9 2333& %=
T
"
4
9 $
"
&
" 9
7 9 >F@45
"
0
'
79 >F?45 " %( 9 %
7
#"
" 7 "
%
&
%
7 "
"
"
7 7 " 9 >FRF &0 )
;;
" 9 >FF?9 233P5 " " " 9 233P&0 * :
"
9 6 T < 7
"
" >FQ3A
A
3.2.1 Explanatory mechanisms in science " %) 4 ?
%233P&9 +
" "
"
7
9
9 2333&0
"
7
9
"
" #"
7
9
"
%233Q&
7 " 7
9
%$
>RQP
&9
"
0 "
"
0
>>R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%< (
%>FQ?&
9
" 9 233>5 9 >F?R& 7 " " + 0 , " 9 >F??5 $A 9 >F?@5 " 9 >FFP 5 9 >F4F5& " %7 " " & " 0>3 " " " %" 9 2333& " 7 >> " 7 " " " 7 " " 97 %= 9 2332&0>2 %>F4F& " " " " " :" " " $ 9 C D>P 7 7 " " " "0 " % 9 >F4>& 7 0 " " % Q& %$ 9 T B 9 >FFQ5 9 >FFQ&0 7 9 " 7 " A 7A " " 9 233P5 69 233R& % #" 7 7 5 Q&0>Q
%< 7
" "
"
" "
0 9 >F?R&0 ,
% *
5 * " " 7 %
T
F
&%
*
"
" "
"
7 " 7 "
9 >F?@&0 +
:
7
" "
7 -
0
7
7 "
(
"
7
"
" A "
"
"
7
& "
" 7 0* "
"7
:
$ "66 " 7 9
" "
" 7 9 " 7
" 7
%$ "
:"
" "
" 7
5
"
7 " 7
0 7 C
7
7 D
%
" 7 T %-
Q& % A 7
7
"
" " 9 233>5 T 09 >F?R& "
"
%
F??&0 7
233@ "
0>3
*
" 9 "
A
"
" T *7 9
9
U
9
& " %
F?R&0 6 %233R&
D "
7 M
7
D "
7
7
7
"
" #"
7
Q0 %' " 9
5
9 233Q9 0>RP&0 7 A
I7
7 C "
9
" % " :"
5
"
-
A %
F4P&0
7 "
9 >F??&0 "
M 7 "0
" 7 7
" "
" >R
"
9
"
" 7
>Q
P
"
9 >FFP&0 "
:" 7
:
" 0
"
" 7 "
9
"
%
7 " "
#" " % 7
" " 7
A
>P
"
%B
( ,
0, "
7
9
0,
"
7 9 #"
7 -
>> >2
Q
Q0 %>F@4&9
*"
0*
" "
"
0, "
T
" "
"
"
"
"
"
9 >F@4&0 *
=
" 0>R " 7
"
% 9 >F?R5 *"
0*
9 7
"
" " %>F?@& " 9< 7 0' 9 5 9 7 " " 9 0 ( "
7 9
F
"66 5
"
T
9 >FF2&0 ,
9 QA
" "
;* 7
0
>>@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%>FF3& C
7
9
" A "
" 0, "
"
; >FP3 >FR3A 6 9 >FF>5
% "
7
7 T " %) %
9 >FF45 -
" #"
7
"
7 " 9 " 7 9 " 9 >F?4 & "
" 7 >4
%
& 0*
"
" "
"
%
6
9 >FFR&0 -" 7 "
7
"
% "
% " &
0
"
"
9
9 2333&0 ,
9
" "
%=
9 2332&0 ( %
7 &0 ,
" "
"
%) " 7
7
;-
"
"
" "
#"
"
"
7
7
7
7
7 7
" "
7 9 >FF4&0 9 >FF>& 9 >F4F&0 *
#"
"
"
D
9
( "
"
7 >@
"
7 " "
C
9 "
:
"
D
7 7
5
#"
7
2
7 "
7
9 "
"
7
"
0 "
" " "
0,
7
" 9
" 7
"
7
" " "9 9 2333&0
" %)
"
"
3.2.2 Scientific theories *
"
" %
F@?& " %< " "
%>?P? >F>@&9 % " %>?23 >?42&
9 233R&0
7
"
"
9 & %(
"
% 9 >F?@&0 = % " & 9 " 7 % 9 >FF?5 9 233>5 = 9 >F?@& 7 %$" W9 233>5 9 23335 E" 9 23335 9 >F43& 9 >F?@5 9 >F?45 9 233>&0 * " " 7 " 7 5 9 >FF>>F&0 " 7 " " " %= 6 9 2332&9 " " " " %B 9 233Q& " " " 7 923 " " 7 " " " 7 " 7 " " 7 7 " % " " " $ %9 >FFR&0
9
"
9 >F?F5
"
>@
, " ) 02@&0 Q& >? * #" >4
>F 23
-
C "
9 C
9
D%
66
"
7 T'
1
7 7 7
"
"
"
"
%
7 "
7 " "
"
"
0*
#" 7 #" "
" 9 7 "0 *
"
"
" "
9 >FFR9 0>@R&; ,
&
A
;- " ; D %9 >F?49 -0-0 - 7 %
7
9 >FF?&0
" 7 : "
= 7 7 9
7
7 % 7
>?
" 9 2333&
0,
%( 7
"
" " %B "9 233@&; * #" % 9 233Q5 B "9 >FFF&5 A 9 "
A " %< 7 0-
1
" "
D% W
9= 9 >FFP&0 ;=
C#" " 9 233R9 0Q??&0
7
"
>??2 " % " 9 233@&0 7 9
>>4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 7
7 "
7
% "
9 >FFF&
"
"
"
0 *
" "
% "
"
%
9
& 7 " %* 7 " 7 $ 1 "
" ;,
7 " 9 >FF@&0 * O
"
%-
9 23325 *
"
" 7 "
%
"
%
2&9
7 9
"
%>?RF >FPP&
% 9 233>& % & %' 6 9 >FFP& 9 233>5 * " 9 233> &0 " #" % 9 233> 5 9 233>&0 * %) 9 233>& " 7 % "
•
% "
"
"
" %
%.
' "
"
5
7
"
&9 9 2333&0 * 7
"
7 "
"
9 T ( 7 9 2333&0 ,
7 " "
"
" "
2>
"
"
" +
22
;& %
"
9
7 "
(
%< "
"
" " 1
7 "
9 >FFP5 0* 7 %
9
" 6-
9
9 233R&0
%>Q4P >RQP&9 , 9 7
9
9
T .
"
%*
9 233Q5
9 233>&0 * 7 " "
" %)
9 %
"
" "
7 " 9 2333&0 *
" 9 23335
% 9 23325
"
" "
"
"
9 >FFP&0 , 9 23325
9 -
" "
9 233> &
%
" &9
"
" 9 " %
??> >FQQ&9 = " 7 7 " &
0
"
&
7 " " 233> &0
7
%) "
"
"
9
9 "
" -0
7
" "
" 7
"
9
%
" 9
0 *
>F4@& >F?R&0 ,
9 >FF@&0
9
" :"
" 9 233P&0 , 0
&
7 "
97 7
" "
0 "
7
"
9
"
%
"
9 2333&0
>>?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
02P -" 7 " "
7 7
9 7
7
" 7 9
9
" %
F435 -"
" 9 >F?R5
7 7
% 7 &
>FP> %
/OO 0
T 0
O
O
F@R& l
%" &0 -
9 2333&0 -" "" " " D 7
9 233> &0 -"
""
F?@& 0
" A
7 9 >FF25
A
"
>F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
"
0
F?4&
! " #"
9
(
5
" "
= " >FFF
9
& 5C 7 9 0+ 9C D 7 " C D D % &
% 0QF@&0
>23
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
2?
9%
9 2333&
7
,
" "
" " 79 233R & C " :
%" 0*
"
9 D
"
D 7 9 " / 0$
7
" 2?0
"
"
" 7
7 "
"
0*
"
"
Q?3 " ;' #"
" 7
9
"
D% "
2 "
"
" 0 =
"
9
"
"
" :
"
7
" :
D % 023>&0
"
"
" 7 "
"
" 7
%2333 &
:"
C
" " D % 024?&0
9
7 9
" : 9 233>&
"
" 7
"
7 "
"
"
7 %B
#"
" :
9C
7
#" 7 "
" 9
" "
9 >FF39 0>P& " 0 ,
A
A %>FFF&
7
" "
"
%>FF3& 5C
:"
7
9
C "
#"
0
"
"
%< "
0,
)
" : 9)
9
T
" %233@9 02& A
"
7 % 9 >FF3& " 9 2332&8 * 7 A "
7 "
7
>2>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
, :
" "66 0 0- 9
" 9 9 7
"
7
"
7 "
%
"
A 9
"
9
" ;* "
9
7
" T "
%
7 7
" "
"
"" " "
0
" "
0 5 * 9 >F?>&0 7 9 7 % & 0 7 9 >F4F5 . 6 : 9 233P& 7 " " %) 9 233Q&0 $ " 0 "
;9
" "
5 "
7
7
7 9 0* "
"
" -
9
% *( & %
"
"
"
"
7 " D9
C"
A +
9
" *
9
" 7
"
" -
"
" "
7
7
"
0
"
9
9
"
0* "
7 9 2333&0
%B
7
7
" 7 " #"
"
" 7 7
0*
7 #"
7 7
;* %B
7
%$
9 2333&0
"
"
" "
" "
7
" "
"
7 " 9
7
9 2333&0
" "
"
"
0*
#"
7 9 9
" "
9
5
"
0 %233>&
#"
" "
0 0
7
7
" 7 7
"
7
9
" %C
7
D5 = "
"
9 " "
0*
7 9
"
"
" 7
0*
"
"
" 7
"
" "
0 "
"
" 7
"
"
9 "
"
9 >FFF9 0232& :"
,
"
"
"
"
" :
"
"
"
0 70
"
/
" 0
"
0,
" 7 7 " "
" 7
7
7
" " "
; ' "
" " 7 " 7
7 7 0$
:" 7 0
" 0 " " "
" "
"
; " "7 0' "
7 " 2F " "
"
>22
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
2F
/
7
7
>
,
-
-
"
2
; =
C
D ;
,
P $
$
"
"
7
" "
24
%2333&
"
"
"
7
0*
"
"
/ • • • • • • • • •
24
*
7 :
7 7
7 " " "" 7
7 #"
2?
"
7 7
2?
7
"
0* :" "
C
"
" "
D5
" "
7 " /
"
"
7
" 0 FP>9 0PQ? " %233P&9 6
%>F43&
" :
5
"
9 :
7
:
D
" :
7
" " " " : 7 0,
;
D % 0
:
7
0 7
" :
7
0
:
"
"
#"
0
. 7
" "
7
" 7
" 7
"
0 * "
"
"
"
7 " 7
" 7
7
9 "
" : "
" 0 ,
"
"
#"
"
7
9 "
0P3 *
"
7
"
9
"
0
5
"
9
, " 7
" :"
7
9
"
9
"
+ " " "
" 7
" 7
9 7 "
7
"
" 7 7
%
" 9 2333&0 5
0 $
2F P3
"
"
0 97
" "
"
" "
0
>2Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
" 7
:
" 0+
" " :
0 , 7
9
7 "
7
#" 9
"
7
"
7 0 -
"
9 " 7 9
:
9
7 "
"
0,
"
0
;
" "
#" C
"
" "
5 7 7
" " %2333& "
0
"
"
9
D "
%
& "
#"
" " " 0
9
0P>
"
7 "
0 7
"
P2 " &0 * 9 233R&0
(
7
"
7 7
9
9
"
"
" "
7
"
7
&
"
"
"
#"
"
Q0
" "
7 9 7
"
" : "
" A
"
" 9
" 9 >FF?& 7 9 "
%( 0
""
7 7
9
"
"
" "
" " "
"
"
0*
9
7
%(
97
T'
0* "
"
9
7
"
"
9 9 9 >FF@ 5 >FF@ & "
%
Q&0
"
7
7
" 0
#" " "
7
0 "
9
" " 9 " 9 >FF?& C " 9 23339 024>&0
%! " D%
#"
"
"
"
"
$
7 0
7
" %2333& 0* " "
" 0
"
A
9
7
" " ""
9
"
7 " "
"
*
+ T=
7 "
9 "
" "
" %2333& 0* 7
:
" "
P2
"
%7 "
"
P>
7 9 2333&0 &5 " 7 #" "
5 " " " %
%
FF29 0PQ3&0 1" "" " " " " 7 "
D% "
0
7
"
9 "
"
" 5
"
7
D0 -
0 0
" 9
"
*
0
"
%>FF2&
"
7
"
7
9 " "
" "
7
0 (
" 7
7
9
#"
PP
7
7
0+
,
" 7
"
" 9 "
9
7 " 7 ,E 7 " " 5C " D% " 9 23339 0242&0 * " "
7 "
,E "
" 7 " 7
0
>2@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
0 ,
7
" "
9
"
" 9
"
" "
0 #" %* "
>2@
"
"
"
0=
" 7
7 " T)
7 9 >F?R&9
" 5 "
"
"
>443 0
"
"
"
3.3.1 Explanatory mechanisms in social science ,
"
"
" "
0
%233>&
"
7
" " 0 0 0 70 70 70 7 0
"
0* ( " " + *
"
0
9 7 0 " " 7
' $
"
*
9
7 "
" "
%
" 7 %$ T " % 9 23335
"
" 9 >F?@5 9 233P& " 9 >F?R&0 , 0 = "
7
9 233>&0
"
"
C"
D
" "
"
"
0 " "
" "
"
7
" 9 233>&0 "
% 7 "
"
%
"
"
7 "
" "
7 "
"
"
0 $"
9 " "
" 7
6
"
7 &5
%
"
%
"
9
"
"
% 7 "
&
&5 & "
" "
"
"
%233>& " "
7 " % % " &0 -
7
" "
7 "
7
A %2333& "
"
"
0
9 " " 7
" "
7 "
"
*
M
"
"
7 7
" " " "
0
" 7
0 -"
"
0
9 >FFR5
"
"
"
"
7
7 " "
7 9
7
%
7
"
" 7 " " "
"
0
" "
"
"
"
7
"
"
&0 , 0 *
"
"
9 7 "
A7
"
"
7 -
" 7 "
9 >F4F9 "
" &
7 0
' "
9
"
"
"
"
&
" "
"
7
" "
5
"
0 -"
D
9 233>&
7 "
9 %'
%233>& 7 " 7
A "
9 0 0C "
0 %
" 7 "
7 "
" "
C %'
D 9 >FF4&0
>24
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
PQ
"
* "
"
"
9
9 7 7 " %. " %>F4F& 6 7 "
" PR
" "
"
" " " 7 "
"
7 " 9 233@&0
9
"
" "
0, 9 233>&0 ) 9 " % " 9 >FF?&0 7 9 7 " " " " #" 9 C"" 7 9 " " %233>&
%' 7 " 7
9
" 0P@ ( "
7 7 D % 02R&0
7 5
C 7
D 0-
" "
" 7
"
"
%
& "
"
"
0
* "
7
7
7
"
' 9 " : 7
" 0 "
9 " %233>& "
0 9 "
7 "
7 7
0 -"
" "
7
" M
"
"
9
"
7
7
7 7
"
"
"
7
0
9
"
5
"
"
"
"
"
PR
*
9 "
"
"
" 0+
" 7
7
"
7 9
"
" "
9 "
7 "
" "
7
"
>@3
" "
" " 9
"
"
D %=
7
"
9 233>9 0QFP&0 9
7 7 0 0*
7 7 9
7
" 7
C 7
:
"
7 "
+
9
9
D
7 &
9
,E9 " 0$ "
C
9 >F?R&0
" "
%233>& " "
"
9"
T
; ;, 0 $
7
P@
7 "
9
9
#" "
PQ
7 " " : 0=
9 "
7
" %-
0(
"
9
7 7
7 7
" 0
"
"
"
"
"
0,
"
9
"
" #" "
"
0
"
#" "
" "
" 7
" 0
"
9
7 7
""
"
"
)
9
"
"
"
"
" :
9
0
9 "
"
7
"
"
7
" 0*
"
" "
7
7
"
5
"
-
A
0 *
"
7 ;, " 7
" "
7 "
" 0 (
"
"
"
0 5 "
" " / :"
%
7
7 "
0* " 7 "
7
" 7
7 & D%
C "
9 "
"
%
9 2332&0
>2?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9 7 8
"
7 " "
5 "
0
3.4 Psychology 9
"
7 "9
7
7
7
%
7
9 2333&0 *
" "
7
7
"
0
"
7 9
"
"
9 233P&0 +
" "
"
&0 ="
" "
"
" "
5"
"
9
0* %< D
7 "
C
A
" 9 .
9
%
" 9 >F?R5 *
9 >F?R5 9 #"
"
T %
" #"
>F?F&0 *
7
9
"
" 9 7
" :
9
9
"
"
% C " : D&0 =" % 9 >F?R&0
"
>?F@
$
>>3
" 7
" " >F?F&0 "
Q33 %2333& P4 " " C
7
"
"
7 " 0! "
9 %' " T 9 >FF25 D 7 " " " " " " % " 9 2333& " "
C 7
" D
0
7
0
7 "
"
"
" "
;,9 9 2333&9 ;*
%( "
#" 7
"
=
"
"
"
7 9 >F?R5
9 >FF45 "
"
A
9 A
0*
0= 9
#"
" ;=
7 7
"
"
#"
/
;=
"
"
;
7 ;=
;, %( B"
" 9 >F?R5 -
9 >F?@5
%233>& 7 7 "
"
% 0*
"
9 >F?@&0 &
%
#"
7
C >F?39 0?F&0 * " 0*
7
7
"
C
D0 *
7
P4
7 9 >FF4&0
%$A
9 >FR25 $A :" / "
"
9 >FFP5
9$
9
$ "
"
7
T, "
" W9 23325
9 7
7 9 >FF45
9
" 9 233P5 -
9 >FFF 5 7 "
9 >FFF5
%2332&
9 >F?R9 >F?45 ' " "
9 >FF45 "
9 233> " 7
0
9 >F@F5
5
%(
"
"
7 9 >F@>5
9 233Q
" 7
" 0 * 9 23335 7 "
"
% "
9
9
6 9 >F43&0 ,
" "
9
7 "
A
.
9
7
" 7
T= "
T-
" " 9
9
" " )
D%
#"
9
-
"
" "
7
&
" "
" 7 &0 * " 0 " A %>FF4 & C " D
0
>2F
T
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
"
" *
"
"
"
7
"
"
P?
""
7 0 *
"
" :
= " 7 " D%
C
"
" 7 7 %
7 "
9 >FFF&0
7 "
0
;$ %2333& "
"
7
"
%)
$
7 " " 7 " 0Q3
"
"
7 " 7 7 "
A C
%>F??&
7 7 >F@3A
D
" >F43A % % " 9
" "
9
" 0
"
"
" 9 233>5
9 2332&0 9
9
" 0 $
"
7 C
D #"
9 0 0
" D #" 0
F??&0
%7
7 "
9
9 9 >FF4 & % A " 7
7 9 7 "
7
Q&0 O
0 $ "
"
7
0
"
7
"
" "
7
7
0
PF
, 233P&
" " %'"
7 "
9 >F@4& "
7 7
7 D%
" :" < 6
7
C
9 >FF45 " "
7
"
#" G #"
=
%
B
9 233P&0
"
7
9
,
7
7
" 9 >FF@9 022>&
9
"
9 2333&0 7 "
7 A C " 0 E"
9
A 7
C
D% ' "
%
0
7 "
9 " #" 0
7
%) 7 9
7
" 7 "D "
Q>
A =" A T + 9 233Q5 " 9 "
"
"
"
"
Q3
7 '
" 7
"
& 9-
7
"
%
9 7 "
&
9 2333& 7
C
"
" "
7 "
9 9 0 0
7
" =
7
7
"
" "
9
9 2333&0PF 9 233P& %$ 7 9
%$A 5 "
7
" 0Q> * %
" 7
"
9$
*
7
7
#"
" 7
" "
" 7
0,
;
P?
" :
5
9 >F?F9 233>&0 * " 9 " " " % " " 7 9 >F?>&0 * " " 9 " " " 9 " 7 " % 9 >FF4&0 ( " " " 7 7 & %*" 9 233>&0 * 1 9 < T " 9 233Q& %$ 9 >FFR&0
%
9 >FF?&0 *
"
" 7
" %B"
7
%=
" 0
A
" & %$A "
" 6
>?@2 "
" A 9 9 23339 0 &9 %B" 9 >FFR &0 0 "
6A $
"
0
>P3
9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.4.1 Explanatory mechanisms in psychology *
7 7
" "
"
&Q2
% " "
"
" #"
"
"
"
"
"
%)
" "
7 "
%=
"
9 >FFQ&
" "
7 " A
7 0
>FQ3
7
%
9 >FFQ&0 *
9
7 0
"
"
"
"
"
#"
" #"
" 0'
7
"
"
" 9
#" "
"
0*
9
7 7 "
" "
"
0 *
#"
0
"
9 2333&0 , " 0' "
"
9 " "
0'
9
A
9 >FFF&0QP ,
P3
R20 ' " "
0,
' ' %
" "
7
0,
9
9" "
%-
a
" #"
#"
" %$ ) "
9 >FFQ&0 *
" 9 >FFQ& "
"9 7
"
"
9
9 "
" 7
,
A 9 $ 7 9 7
G
C
9 7
9
7
"
"
%) 9
9 7
+
%233Q&
9=
9
;) 9
9
0 * 9 >F?P&0 * 7 "
T=
D " " 0- 7 0*
:"
" 9 >F??&0
" T 7 "9 " 9 2333&0
7 " 9
A
%
%
9 9
9
#"
"
" 7
7
"
%( 7 9 2332&0 = 7
7 "
9
" 7
9 0
" 9 "
"
A
"
0
7
0*"
7
7 7 9
"
" "
0* "7
"
%
" 7
9 2333&0
0
"
"
"
9 "
%
"
9 2333&0 ,
I7
7 " 0
7
;+ 7 7 7 0 * " 7
9
"
Q2
;+ 7 9
7
"
9
7 7 "
7
" " 9
"
"
9
" 7
0 +
"
7
* #"
" 0 *
"
7
" :
7
" "
*
" " QP
"
0 F?4&0
9 >F439 0P&
*
*
$
7
$ ,
QQ
, %( " "
" 5
9 233R5
T
9 % 6 9 233R&0
7 9 B"
" '
' A
& "
A 7
>P2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
P>
(
9$
(
*7
%>F439 0P&
2
(
7
" Q
(
*
P
*
$
(
Q
( (
7
P
Q
R
$ ,
7
7
.
7 C
-
" C
D
)
" D
"
5 "
(
5
7 0
"
7 D
C "
7
"
7 0
" O
" O " "
5
7
" " *
" " / "
"
9
*
,
"
7
" "
" " " " *
" "
"
7 0
>PP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9
0 '
%>F@?&
" 9
%>F@?& >FR@&
(
)
7 7
%>F42&
0 "
9
T )
9 >F429
"
0@4@&0 +
C 0*
C
D 9 0 0
" "
-
G
"
7 A
"
%>F@?&
7
%( "
"
T )
9 >F42&0 0,
" 7
9
" "
" "
"
"
" "
9
9
0 *
"
0QR = 9
" 9
"
7 "
0,
"
9
"
"
" 9
7 " 7 " A
"
0
" "
"
7 "
" %>F@?&
-
"
0 $ 0+
" 7
" *
" #"
" 0 +
5
7
"
7
"
"
7
"
7
9
7
9
7
7
9
9 >F?45
"
"
"
T-
" %
F4@9 0PP&0 X* "
Y5 (
&9 X 0 * "
X
X
" "
9 >F??&0 7 % 9 >F43& " 0* " " % " 9( A %>F?? & 8&0 " P2 0 * " 0* " " D9 C
C "
"
0
>F?@&
A
Y
"
" "
"
" %=
"
'
T-
9
X " "
" " 7 7 C "
:" " "
D
"
5
0 *
C D0 %>F43& #"
9
9
O
"
0
QR
+
" "
C " 9
D% "
"
& 0*
"
"
9
" "
9 9
:
0
>PQ
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
P2 (
A %>F?? &
"
UAA ,
,
,
UA +
>
+
0(
" "
>PR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.4.2 Psychological theories " "
0* " " " 0= 7 "
" = "
"
"
C 0*
"
"
>3>/
7 7
(
%>F?? &
7
0*
"
7
7 D " 7 97 0
7
" 7
7
"
"
7
%(
" &0
7 7 7
9 >F?? &0 ,
7
-
"
%(
*
" "
0*
"
"
" 7 "
7
%
97
&
"
"
7 "
"
"
7 "
0 , " %>FFP&
( 7
"
9
" 7
7 " " 0 *
7 "
"
"
"
" 0' "
" 9 >F?>5 < 9= >F?@5 *" 9 >FFP5 = " 7
7 " "
9 23335 . 7 "
" Q& %
Q@
* 7 Q4 * Q? QF
" " 7
,
" " 9 >F?F5 1 9 >F?39 " 9 >F?>5 9 >FF25 U 9 >FF>&0 * 7 " " 7 " 0 7 #" #" 7 0 " 7 7 "9 >FF@ &0 " %233R& " D " 7 7 " " #" " 9 >F??9 6 9 >F43&0 1 %>F?3& 7 9 TU T=
7 " 9
B 9 >FFR5 2 , " "
7 7
9 2332&0 * 0+ " "
0
#" %
9 "
"
"
%= 7
"
7 "
7 "
" 7
C
"
7
9 "
"
"
" 0
"
"
"
A
"
7
"
9 >F?? &0
7 7
%
0Q? 9 233>&0
7
% ="
"
" Q4
7 #"
" 7
-
"
7 "
7
9
7 0-
" 0Q@ *
7
% 9 >F4F5
9
T *" 9 23335 9 >F435 9
6 9 >FF25 7
" "
#"
7 #" 7
#" 7 QF
"
7
%-
9 >F??5 " 0 *
%
" "
7 0
7
9 >FF4&0 7 " 7
" "
7 0*
7 "
0 9
"
;
>P@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
%
7
< 9
DR3
7 "
7 7 9 >FF25 -
%< " "
"
&9 %
9 >F435
"
9 2333&0 * %$
7
"
7 "
%
FF4& "
0*
"
7 " " C 7 D C D7 9 23335 +" 9 >F?45 >FP3A >F@3A 9 " >FR3A %+" 9 >F?4&0
7
7 23335 ( 7 9 23325 ) 9 23335 ) 9 >FF4 5 9 >F?F&0 * 7 " 7 C 7 D " % " 7 5 9 233>& " 9 " 9 % 9 2332&0 $ %>FFF& 9 " 7 9C 9 " " " 7 9 " " %9 >FFP& %9 >F?4 &0 " %>F4?& " A " " C D % 0222&0 9 7 " 9 7 C " 7 0) " Q0 )
7 "
" "
%
"
7
-
&9
" &9 0
7
9
7 "
9
7 "
" 9 "
7 "
D
9 7
"
" D%
"
"
" W9 >F??&
"
" "
7
9 "
"
" 5 " 0 7
"
7
" 9
#" 9 2333&0 ,
"
"
%E"
9
2&
7
9 >FF?&0 "
"
%-
"
5 7 " 7 "
9 >F?4 &0 7
" 7 9
"
%>F?F& #"
0
A
#"
7 7 "
#"
9
"
7
9
"
" "
"
9
=
*
Q "
"
9
7 7
" C
"
9 " 7
0 * % ""
%)
"
7
7 =
"
" 7
9 T
" 9
D % 02@@&0 )
"
7 "
%
9
9 9
"
7
•
7 T
%(
" "
:
" 0
"
"
•
C "
9 >FF3&
"
* "
" "
0
0
""
9 >F4>&0 *
9
#"
9
9 " "
7 A
0! 7
9
0
W
0, ;
R3
*
<
P4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.4.2.1 Concepts, definitions and propositions ,
9 "
7 7
9
" " "
" "
9 "
9
"
0 D "
"
7 9
" ,
0
9
7 "
7
0
"
W %>F?F& 0 , 0 W %>F?F&
"
7
7 "
"
@*
%
(
9
0,
9
"
*
7 9
9
" W9 >F?F9 0@3?&0 *
D% "
7
"
%
*
@
9
0
W9 >F?F&
&
"
*
$ =
" "
" "
$
"
7 7 "
%>F4F&
" "
0$
"
7
7
"
9
C
"
9
7 "
9 0+
"
D
: 9
"
0 * " 9 %>F4F&9 7
9
7
7
9 7 "
0%
2&
"
7 9 >FF3&0 * 7 #" 0 !
%$ C
D
C
D
7 "
7 " "
7 #"
"
" 9 "
"
0
,
" "
9
" "
;. 9 >FF3&
%$
""
" 7 " 7
" 7
9
" "
W %>F??&
7 "
"
9
9 >F439 0FQ&0 ' 7 &9 & "
"
$
%>FF2& 7 "
%" 7
"
"
9 9
7 "
% %
"
7 9
7 9
9
&0
9 >F4>& "
&0 =
"
"
C 7
7
" D%
"
%
D 9C
;' "
"
" %
9 9
9 9
6
% 9
" " 0*
& 7
>P?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9
9 %
9 >F4>&0 (
;,
"
R>
" 0! 9
C
W %>F??&
0"
" "
" 7
"
"
" %233> & "
9 %'
T$
#"
"
9
" 0 4*
%>FF2&
" 97
9
>9 "
*
7 " $
0R2 '
"
" 0
"
9
"
7
D
7 "
"
7
" #"
4 "
0
9 >FF2&
* $ $
-
(
-
"
#"
$
"
"
-" *
"
'
$
%>FF2& 0-
"
0
0
7
" "
0 7 "
/
" 9 "
"
0
7
5
7 7
0( "
7
0,
"
7
7 9 " 9 0 0
&
%
7 7
+
7
&0
"
"
0 (
"
"
" "
"
" "
7 T ) " 9 >FF4&0 C D" "
% 9
"
PP0 * A
" "
%'"
0 " 9 >FF25 B
T$
"
#"
"
"
"
"
"
0
" 7 % 7 7 7
7
9 0 0
%'
7 "
"
7 " 9 233R&0 ,
"
" 29
"
"
7 9
"
"
"
9 >F?>&0 "
7
"
0 %7
R> R2
* +
C
"
< 9 0=
9
Q0Q0>0P
"
"
"
"
7
"
0 "
;$ 7
" "
:
A "
PQ
7
7
"
" ;
" 0
>PF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
D %(
9$
T *7
0*
9 >F439 02F&0 /
"
7
"
0
7
" " 0 '
9
7
"
"
9
"
%
&
0
" "
0'
9
"
0
" '
9
"
5 7
" "
9
7
9 #"
%
"
"
0
&9
"
70
7 0 > 7
6 6
"
"
"
"
"
5
"
" " 70
% 7
&
0* 9
0'
" " 5 0 0
%
"
"
" 7
"
"
9
9
7
&0 "
5 0 0
"
7
"
"
9
" 70
" " #"
#"
7
"
0,
"
0,
7 9
"
7
"
7 0
9 " "5 " 9 0 0
"
"5 %( 7
7
0 '
9 7
9 >F?? & " 7 O " " "
" "
7 " "
"
" "
7
"
7
%
0
%>F?3&
&0
0 , 9 0 -" 7 "
%>F?3&
9
%
9
"
7 "
7 7
7
9 " 7 0
%
Q&0 9 >F?3&0
%= 9
" "
7 9( " 5 0 0
" " %
"
" 7
9
" 7
&0 -"
" "
7 "
7
0'
" "
9 " " "
"
7
" " " %>F?? &
9 0 0
" 9 "
7
"
" 7
&0
"
"
0 * 7
0
9
7
9
" 9
5 0 0 0
" "
7
>Q3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
PP (
7
(>
(
(2
%'
T$
(P
)
9 >FF29 02?&
$
)
+
,>
' "
PQ
,P
O
"
,
(
,2
"
,
M
*
(
"
M C #"
D
"
>M
*
2M
"
"
7
C D -
"
"
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 7 7 >F@3
'
• •
"
T$
9 >FF2&0
"
"
"
" 7
( 7
7
9
7
, 7
"
%
/
"
"
" 7
•
7 7
7
"
"
% "
" 7
&
3.5 Theory appraisal #"
" C
" 7
D
; C
D; % C
" 0, %
7
&% 0*
7 0 -"
A" "
"
7
%
7
7 0 7
I7 7
" 0. #" % >FF4&0 ,
F?4&0 D7 "
8 %T) 9 >FF3&0 * 7 9 >F?4 &0 -" 7 " 9 " " 0 * " " 9 7 " 7 " &0 %>F?4&9 7 " 7 % " " 9 7 9 7
" % 9
9 >F4>&0 7 " & "
% 7 9 9
" " )
7
: "
"
&
0 7
%>F43&
"
7
7
" 7 " :
" &
7
0
7
:
"
"
" "
"
#"
"
Q&0RP *
%
0-
% " "
9
"
"
9 "
0
FFR& C< " B0
" 7 9 >F4?5 " "
R020>> 9 "
5 $ " 9
9
"
6
9 "
9 "
7
"
D 9
T " 7
"
"
"
0
< 9 E"
%>F4>9 >F?F9 >FFR& " "
7
9 >F?4
)
"
" 9 >F??&0
F43&0 * % 9 2332&0
" 7
"
7
" C
7
#" " 0 2Q "
7
>Q2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>@23 "
RR
"
7 "
" 7 % 9 >F?4 &0 < A %< 9 >FRF& 0 *
%-
"
"
" 7 7
" %
5 -
5
%( :
"
9
7 "
9 9 >FF3&0 * " 9 >FFF&0 * "
"
C " D 7 %>F?4& 0* &0
7
0 ) "
"
"
%(
"
" " 7
0 " 0
" 7
"
"
7 "
7 %
W9 >F??&0
6
'
%>F43& " 0 ' "
7
"
9 >FFF&
7 9
7
"
7 9
"
"
9
0"
9 PR
9
"
" 7 " 7 " 7
"
" " P@
RR
< %+ *
7 " " "
: :
7 :
I7 7
"
R@
"
" #"
7
"
%)
9
"
"
9
9 "
0
0
7
7
"
*
7
M
0,
9 >F4?&0 * " %
%
" "
"
"
" ; -"
"
"
7
9 233>& " 7
9 233>&0 * 9 >F43&0 ,
"
%( " " %
"
7
%
" "
9
" 7
%< % 6 7 %
9
%>F43& D % 0F>&R@ 7 M "
"
70
7 " 9 2333&0 "
6
0
0
7
" "
" %)
" 7
9 233>5
I7
" "
"
"
5) 0
C
7
" "
9 >F4>& "
"
" &0 * 7
+
"
W9 >F??5
7 " 7 7 0 * 0
C
7 %B
%'
T$
9 >FF?& "
D
"
9 >F?@9 0RF& 7
" "
"
9 >FF2&0 * " 7 "
"
7
" 7
0=
7 " ;" 5
0
>QP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
PR *
" 7
" 7
7
%+
9 >F?@9 0@2&
*(
7
V 00
)
V 00
7
V 00
$
%+
7
7
V 00
V 00
)
V 00
$
&
c$ c,
' "
P@ (
A %>F?? 9 0>4&
" 7 $
V 00
7
V 00
" "
7 7
" 7 "
,
"
7
$
"
#" 7
,
"
7
C
"
D
>QQ 7
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
* 7
" " "
0 , "
7
"
"
"
9
%(
9 >FFF&0 , " "
%
"
7 7 C
7 9 2333&0 " "
"
=
"
"
%
9 " 5 _: C 7
7 7 " 9
7 " "
7
7 "
"
7
7
0)
" 9
9
" 7 0 *
T D
9 2332& " 9 "
"
7
"
"
%
"
9 23335 -
7 9
0 ; 7
" 9
"
& %(
D T
7
7 0 *
7 "
"
7
"
"
A 7
7
9 233>&0 *
"
7
"
9 "
"
0
7
#"
0 9
9 0,
9 " 9 >F??&0 *
9 " 0-
%=
C
" "
7
%
7
7
" 7
%(
9 >FFF5 " "
9 233>5 #" 7
"
" "
:
"
"
"
9
:
"
7
"
&9 "
;RF
"
OE"
" 7 "9
9
7 0= "
&
O7
7 7
7 %B" 9 >FF3 & %>FF2& 7 7 " " D %
7 "
7
7 "
9
: 7 "9
"
$"
0
" 7
"
:
B *
" "
7
" 9 >FF3&0 * "0 (
0
7
7
"
"
RF
:"
7
7 0 !
#"
"
7 0!
"
R?
" 7 9
7
R4
" ;R? "
9
"
"
A B"
%
" "
5 9
"
"
%
9
A
7
"
5
"
0, 9 233P&0 ) " " " 0
T
9 "
0 ,
C %*"
_:
" 7
9 233>&9R4
"
7
D
9 >FFF5
" ;-
9 >FFF5
9 C
7
9 7
7
#"
7
9 >F?4 &0 " 7
9 "
" "
"
"
% "
7
" " "
7
7 " %(
"
7
"
" " 7 " 7 9 23325 * " 9 233> &0 ! " 9 " " " % 9 233>&0
" "
"
" 7 7 A ; ( "
7
"
7 "
9
; $
7 "
"
D
7 7 " "
" 7
"
7 0
9 233>&0 0
" "
0-
%
" 9
& "
" 0
>QR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
B
%>F4>& / • • • • • •
"
9
7
7
9
" " " 7
7
5
"
#"
#" "
>FFP &0 ,
#" 7
9
7
0+ 7
%' "
#"
T
&0
7 9 %>FF2&
9 2332&0 " 9
7 7
"
"
% "
"
" 7
#" "
%>F4?& 7
" " C "
D % 0PQ@&0 ( " "
0*
" "
"
0
) "
" "
0 #"
"
" %B
9( 7 7 %
"
7 "
0, "
"
"
7 7 "
7 9 >FFP&
5
A ""
9 >FFP& " 9 " 7
%
7
0* 7
%-"
"
" 7
9 >F??&0 (
"
7
9 >FFP &0 * %. 9 >F?@&0 * " 7
9 T
D "
"
" -
"
C
" "
"
" 9 >F?@5 7
"
7
%
9 7 %
9
9 >F4>& 0 *
" 9 " 9
%>F?R&
"
0
7 "
"
%
" 7 %>F4?&
" " #" 7
;) " " A " 9 >FF@&0
7
" "
9
7
*
"
9
7 0 )
7
"
0,
"
7
0-
9
#"
"
7
9
" "
7
7 " "
"
0,
7
7 "
"
"
0
"
9
"
" 7
% " %
" " & 7
"
" 5 " 9 >FFF&0 7
%= 7
7
T
9 >F??&0 * 7
7 "
0$
;+
7
;,
;* 0
-
7
"
%>F?>& 7
7 "
" 9 ""
%>FF2&
A C
"
7 9 >F??&0 " " D % 02@2& A
"
%>F?4& "
" %" 7
P4
9 >F?4 & " "" 9 0
"" 0
" 7 " 7 7 %>F?>& A %>F4?&
7
7
"
" %)
7
"
9 >F??&0 , "
7
A " "
"
" "
9 7
7 0
%>F4?5
"
>Q@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
P4
(
""
%
9 >F4?9 02@2&
*
=
7
-
$
)
9
%>F4?&
7
""
%C %>F@>&@3
7 9
"
C
0, 9 >F4P9 0>Q&0 $ 7
D5 "
" [
Z "
"" 9 7 "
"
7
-"
" T1
D "
%
" "66 "
"
"
A >F4F
%
&7
"
" 7
%
" T'
9 233R&0 %B
"
9
"
7
7
7 ""
"
"
7 9
7 "
"
7 7 %>F4P5 >F4?&
0
0 *
"
"
"
9
"
P4
5 " "
9 233R&0 , 7
7
0'
9
9 >FF2& % " " &
0)
0,
02@R&0 )
"
" "
T
"
7
97
"
233R5 =
7 0 * "
7
7 %
9 >F4?9 9 C
9
@>
" "
C
"" "
%>F4?& 0+ 9
9
9 D %
7
7
D 02@Q& 5 " %
"
PF0 *
7 "
"
"7
" "
"
9
P? "
7
"
0
@3
* >F4F ,
@>
"
"
>F@> 2 "
7
"
&M
7 7
"
@/ * 0
"
#" "
0 "
"
" 7
"
0(
9
0
>Q4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
P4
(
""
%
9 >F4?9 02@2&
)
7
$
' "
P? (
7
O
""
%>F4?&
)
7
C
D%
&
C
D% $
$
"
&
C
D%
7
O
7
,
$
"
$
PF $
"
"
$
"
%
$
"
7
"
7
"
9 >F4?9 02@?&
7
+ *
"
7
,
' "
"
"
7
) )
7 (
"
"
>Q?
&
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
(
"
P?
"
"
PF9 "
%
7
" : "
7
"
" 0,
"
7
7 "
7 7
"
" 7
7
0* A C
"
" "7 7
"
7
7
" " 9 %>F4?&0
"
7 % 02@F& % 7
D
" "
7
0 + "
9
"
" 7
9 >F?4&0
9 "
7 "
5
"
%>F4?& "
"
&0
; ( -
9 7 " 9 23339 233@5 ' T$ 9 >FF25 9 >F?35 9 >F4?5 = 9 >FFF&0 , %( T 9 >FQF&0 =
" 9 >F4?5 B"
% 9 >F445
9 23325
"
@2
%)
9 >FF4 &; -" 7 %>FF2& " A 6
"
7
"
0
%
F?Q&0
'
%233>& 9 9
M *
6
7 "
7 "
5C
0
+
"
7 9
"
"
" "
" 77
%
" 7
" 7
7
"
"
%(
T. _
7
9 233P&0 ,
"
"
7
C
D0 . 9
" D % 0RF&0 + A 9 >FF4&0
0
"
9 " 7 7
"
9
9
"
9
9
"
0* -
%
9
" % 7 7 9 >F?R&0 ( : :" " %2332& "
9 2332&; % "
"
9
% 7 Q0 *
9
"
"
9 >FFR5 T
"
0$ "
" >F4?&0 ,
"
" #"
"
:" " "
"
" "
)
9
7 ;
9 >FF@5 < 9 >F?>5 "
-
9 >F?>5
"
)
T -
9 >F?3&0 * "
"
7 " %
C "
7
"
" %23339 0>323& 9 " " "
9 >FF@&
D0
7
9 %2332&
9
9 •
>/
"7
%
7
7
"7 % • • •
2/ P/ Q/ +
,
9(
" A
%2333&
6
%
-
A
@P
( " #" 7
:
7 7 0 *
"7 &0 = &
7
9 233>& "
7
"
& &@P
7
#"
" %>FF23 "
"
7
" #"
%>F?>& D % 02P3&0 ' A
% W9 >F??5 -
%
" " "
"
@2
7
"
0C
" 9 2333&0 (
%(
%2333&
6
7 %
9 >FF2& "
" 9 "
0
>QF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
#" 7 0=
9
9
"
6 @Q
0 * T
( 7
9 >FFR&0
7
%
%(
9 233@5 " 7
& "
8, 7
7 "
" 5
"
;
+
#" 7
"
(
5 7
9
"
5 ;*
;
"
0 0=
"
7
"
5
" 0 ,
0@R 9
"
"
" " 0 , "
7 "
"
%
0
9
9 7
7 7 "
9 >F4?&0 ,
"
%>F4?& 9 " 0 *
" 9
"
7
7
9 0
;
"
"
"
" %2333& 9
%>F4?& "
#" 9 " "
" 7
9 •
7 9
9 9
9
9
9
7
7
" •
" "
•
A "
B
M 7 " 7 "
"
%>F4>&
M 5'
" % 9 23325 = 6
9 2332 5
A
" "
"
"
" "
" :
"
,
9 >F??&0 * " %=
" " 7
E"
"
" " %>F?>&9
"
" 0*
"
7
7 9
9 B9 "
( " 7 @R +
7 "
"
" 7
9
" 7 "
"
@Q
9 >FFF&0 * 0* 7 9
A
:"
"
0
"
" 7 %
"
&
7
"
" 0(
0 ) 0(
" ;*
0 7
T "
"
-
" 9
"
A 0,
7 " "
%
9 %>F?>& "" " % 0*
9
7 0,
"
7 -
#"
9 2332&
"
" 7
" "
:
&5
"
0 "
7 "
9
7 " 7 "
%
7 "
9
#" " "
: %(
% " 0
7 9
7
" A %>FF2& " A
T . _ 9 233P&0 a A " 9
9 & %( 7
" T
"
7 9
*" A 9 >FFR5 9
T
"
( 9 >FFP&0 R3
A
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
&5
"
" 9
@@
" 9
%
A 9 >F4?
&0 *
"
7
7
0 * "
#" 5 9 >FFR 9 >FFR 5 - " " % &9 7 & "
%B" "
#" 9 23335 -
9 >F??&0 *
"
" D %B" 9 >FFR 9 023>&
C " "
"
7
%
9
%
"
(
%>F42&
"
7 " 7 "
0*
"
"
0
%
& "
0, 0
7 " "
9
" 7
9 0*
"
"
7
)
9 %>F??&9 5
9
B"
7 "
)
T-
9 9
" "
FFF&
"
0 "
7 " 0, :
%C"
0+
"
7
%>FFF& 0=
9
7 9 "
"
" 9
" "
0
" %>F?4&9 =
"
9 >F??&;
A %>F?4& 9
7
*
%)
7
9
"
0*
" " 7
7
"
"
"
"
;
7
7 7
0
7 7 "
"
"
7 " "
7
9
"
%
"
7
" " 5
"
"
" 0*
#"
" 9
9 " :
"
0
"
"
0 0= 9 7 : 7
" "
7 A
9 >F?3&
7 +
"
"
%>F44&
"
7 9
" 7
@4
/
7
7
@@
&
0
:" • • • •
7
"
"
9
0@4
"
#"
7 "
0
0
>R>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.6 Towards a meta-theory .
"
"
7
7
7 07 %' " T 9 23325 = T= 7 7 " 7 7 % T 9 233Q5 F?4&0 * 7 %T = 9 >FF4&0 + " @F " % 9 >F??&0 6 %>FF@& 5 7 " " 7 0* " 9 ; %>FF2& " " %2332& A % &9 C " D % 0PQR&0 ( ;* " #" 7 " 7 " 7 " $ " " " C " " 7 D% "
)
'
"
%>FFP&
"
9 C D % 0>4Q&0 + "
9 " "
" "
%)
T'
9 >FF2&0 + " "
7 C
9 >FFP& 7 "
9@?
" 0< %)
0 7
7
" 7
7
%
FF>& "
" " " %
"
7
0 " 9 7 " " 0)
9
@?
T "
D % 0>QQ&9 %233P& %
C "
7
&
7
" " 7
7 U
7 "
"
" 7
"
7 "
7
9 7
A
0
7
" " %2332&0 *
' "
" "
"
7 7
" 7
"
"
" 0,
% "
"
" &9 9 >FF>&0 * 7 #"
%U
" "
9
" "
7
"
" "
"
" " "
"
;=
7
"
&0
A %>FF>& 9
@F 43
" *"
"
9
"
"
"
7 " 5
%
U
O %= 0 33&0
7 9 5
&
9 >F43&0
7 7
9
9
6
9
9 >F?3& " D % 0R&0 $ 7 " %233Q& C
"
9 >FFP&;
"
" 7
9
0$ TU
O 7 7
"
U %>FFP& 9 >FFP&0 "
T'
% & "
9 >FFP&0
7
9
"
7 7 %>FF4&9
% "
"
"
0
0 " "
G
A
"
" 9
0U
%>FF>&
"
9
"
0
>R2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
"
"
0
7 ,0
"
"
7 A
7 E
#" "
"
"
"
0*
7 "
7
%
"
,,,0
"
%>FFR&
&
,,0 9
6
/
7
"
#"
7
#"
" "
"
%
7
& 9 B"
- 7 %>FF29 0@?P& C 7 "
7 "
"
D
7 " %
"
"
" 2&0 +
"
"
"
" " C 7 09 >FF29 0@P?&0 *
" % " "
9
9=
; "
"
"
" "
" 5
91
" 0 ,
;
"
7
D
4>
#"
"
" *
"
5
5 9
"
91
0
9
"
9 "
0
9
8=
"
7
7
"
9
"
7
9
"
"
9 7
%
09 >FF2&0 =
;
"
"
" 7
% "
0=
"
&
"
"
"
0
A 7 9
"
"
7
0=
9
" "
7
; "
" "
" 9
42
7
; 9
"
7
"
9$
*
7 " 9 )"
9.
7
"
"
5
"
9
"
5
9-
A
#"
"
84P "
"
%>F??& 7
0 " %
"
9 23335 U "
>FFP &04Q $ 0 7
9
9 >FF>&0 , "
7
%>F??&9 7 %
F?F& 7
7 9
" 9 "
"
"
"
:
7
"
C "
%< 0 9 "
7 "
7 "
"
" =
54R
"
9
0= /
7
4> 42
9
"
"
" 7
T U 9 >F??&
T
7
"
•
4R
%< "
"
4P * 4Q -
9 9
7
" %>FF2&
7
7 9
TU
9 >FFP 5 *"
9 >FFP&0 0
D
#"
"
7
0
"
5 "
#"
% E&
"
7 "
0
>RP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
• • •
7 7
"
" 7
7 "
7 0 * "
T= ,
" 7
"
F?F?5 *"
#" =
9 >F?@
9 >FF2&
" A 29 7 &9 = = " 7 D % 0>Q>&0 * " & " " 9 " 9 0* 9 " : 7
%
%-
9 =
U
" 7 %>FF2& " "
"
C "
" "
9
"
9
" "
0=
" 7
"
7 "
" "
C
0*
D
"
9
"
:
7
04@
7 7
"
"
9
7
9
7
7 44
% •
%
" " "
%>F?F& " 0 ,
7
"
"
M
9
&
7
0 '7 " /
" 9
#"
0
7 " >FFP&0
"
%
FFP&0 * " 7 " "
#"
" " 0
"
C %
"
7 9
7
"
7 "
0 +
0* "
7
7
" 7
M A
%1
7 %
FFP& 0, 0* "
9 >FFP&
M
" 0 (
7
#"
"
" '
9
7
"
%
FFP&0
FFR&
5
5
4@
7
: "
7
7
7
% A B"
A
"
9
9
0 7
7
" "
*
5
7
" 44
:
5
9
FFP& " " Q3 7
:
9
"
%
&
04?
7
7
TU
9 >FFP9 0>?&
B
R@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9 0*
4F
$
%
9 >F4>5 " 7
A "
%
7 9
9 >F4R&0 *
"
I7 7
7
" &0 ,
" " : -
" 7
" 7
0?3 ,
"
9 :"
% 9 233Q&0 )
9 .
" 7 "
%-
T 1 7 9 233P& 7 " "
"
9 A
F@?5 >F4P&0?2
D C*
7 7
7 %
A
" " " " " "
9 "
7
" "
C
%) T
"
0?> (
" 9 "
" "
"
7
0 ( "
7
"
&0 " 9
B" 6
"
" 7
" >F@3A
" 7
9 >F??&0
" >F?3A 0
"
A
9 0
"
7 9
"
"
9 " 0* "
< *
"
" 9
7
"
%
0?P * " %>F?R9 >F?4 9 >FF2&
"
" "
=
"
"
7
7 9
6
%-
9 $
9 2
"
"
*m "
& %(
"
%
9 >F4>5
"
"
"
9 " " " "
-
%
T
"
-
n 9 233Q&0 $ 9 7 "
9 >F?>&0
"7
7
"
" " 0 "
2
#"
7
0 ' " ,
0* 7
>FRF % "
"
9 >F4>&0 99
" "
" %>F?F& 7
7 *
0*
"
7
7 " 7 B"
A
7 "
"
" ?Q
0
7
0 #" "
#" ?P
9 ' 7
9
" ?2
A "
- " %>F@2&?Q
" B 9 >F?4 5 >F?4 &0 B A
,
?>
0
"
7
9-
" 0
"
-
"
'
M B"
" 7
" 9
"
, ,
"
" "
%
?3
" "
" & 7
%< 9 >F?Q& ) 9 >F4@5 >F?Q 5 >F?R5 >F?4 5 >F?4 5 >F??&0
4F
" "
7 9
7 0 A
"
0
7 "
9
"
" 0
" C " D
7
7
" "
7 "
B"
%- "
9 233Q&0
" 7
"
0 "
9+
" 0
% "
" " "
A
9 ' 9
B" 9 7 "0 7
7 9 7
A
0+
"
"
" "
7
" " "
"
"
&0
>R4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 " C %>F?R5 >FF3&0
/
"
D %>FRF&
" 7 7 D0
A
:
7 " >F@29 " >F4P
7 >4?2 7
7
"
"
>F2F A
=
%>F?4 &0 C
?R
" 9 "
9 0 *
%
7 "
""
"66 "
7
7 "
0
A
"
7 " 0' "
"
"
" "
" "
7
"
"
A
&
" " 9
$ "
:
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
" %
" "
"
"
"
9 7
"
"
0 0 *
" 0
"
"
"
&
7
9
"
"
0
3.9 Madsen’s meta-science and meta-theory *
" 7 9
" 7
" 7
7
"
"
9
"
7 0*
" 7 0< "
?@
7 " "
9 7
"
7 "
7
"
% 9'
7
7
9 >FFR&0 *
*
7
"
""
"
"
0*
"
"
?4
" 0* ?
"
A
"
-
7
"
7 "
? (
7
7"
7 "
#"
A
0 -
" " 7 " " "
" 9 0
" 97
7
0 "
"
7 7 "
" "
"
%
9 >F?4 9 >F??&
(
,
7 >
(" "
-
(" "
2
"
" P
*
c-
2c-
?R
"
?@ ?4
Pc
0 7
0* =
C "
A
"
D
"
0
7
" "
7 7
"
C 0 "
20 ,
D
7 "
"
0
>R?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.9.1 Madsen’s definition of science < >F?4 5 >F??5 >FF35 >FF2& • • •
9
"
" 9
%>F?R5 5
*
7 %7
T B 69 >FF@&0 "
" 9 F?R5 >F?4 & & 0 , " 9 9
0 %
"
7 "
9 C D %>F?R9 0Q&0
" "
7 "
"
" "
9 " 7
" "
3.9.2 Madsen’s definition of meta-science?? 9 7
" 5
9 7 &
%
7 0* %>F?R5 >F?4 &0 *
7 "
7
"
0 A >FRF
7 7
7 "
0* "
"
7
" "
9
7 0*
7
*
7
"
" C
"
7
" "
%
"
%>F43&
7
"
7
%>FR4& %>F?R&9
9 0 *
7
"
0
"
7
7
"
"
"
0'
D
0 &0 *
7 9
" C
7
,
" 7
%>F?4 &0 =
:
0 *
7
7
"
%>F?R& 0
F@2&9 )
"
"
% B"
7 0?F , 7
"
D0
7 7 9
/
0
"
-" 7
?F
7
"
0,
"
??
0 * 7
"
"
7
9
" "
"
0,
"
7 7
7 7
A "
7
"
- " %
" &
% "
"
A
0
>RF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
7 #"
" "
"
7 7
% " "
' "
" "
Q> , "
0F3 *
" 7
0* 0
7 7
7 5
#" 9 >F?F&0 ' " ' " Q2
" 9 >F?F5 "
Q>
" "
"
" 7
%
-
7
*
7
%
"
7 "
/
&
7
&
7 &
"
%
"
" :
7
"
' "
Q2 , "
"
*
7 %
7 &0 *
" "
"
*
7
B" A 7
%
7 7
7 "
7
" 7
"
%
5
-
"
% 9
&0 *
:"
" &0 *
"
9
,
%
&
"
F3
"
7
7
7
7
"
"
#" A
"
9
&
" "
0
#"
0
>@3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.9.3 Madsen’s view on theory =
"
7 9
>0 20
" 0 0 0
"
" " 7
7
*
" 9
*
"
%
"
F ) 7
"
%
"
"
&9
&
"
(
%>F??& 7
"
F0
%>F??&
) 7
$ "
*
"
"
-
7 " )
7
9
7 "
"
" 9 7
0( "
0,
7
"
7
" 9
"
" *
"
%"
&
*
7
* 7 "
" "
* % &
9
"
O
" %
7
&
bb
% &
bb
%>F??& "
9
"
7
9"
"
9 %
:"
"
" 7
:" "
A
7
& %)
" 7
"
7 9 >F?3&0 * 7 " 0 B"
" " "
#"
0
3.9.4 Madsen’s view on modelsF> " " " 23325 < 23325 =
F>
" " 7 " % 9 >F??&0 * 7 " " A 9 23335 ( 9 >F?R5 $ 9 233>5 $
#"
"
*
9 233P5 ( 7 >FPP&0 *
" 9
"
"
" 9 >F?F5 $
9 23335 1
%< 9 >F?F5
1
9 9
"
"
" "
A
7
0
"
"
P0R02
0
>@>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
"
%$ "
9 233>&0
R3
"
5
" 7A %>?QR >F>@&9 "
•
#" "
7
0
9
%2333&/F2
%>?P4 >?F?&9 "
"
9 $
•
7
7
%
" 7
"
"
&
0* "
7
7
7
"
" 7
A %>?4F >FRR&9 7
•
"
%
"
-
9
&
9
"
"
"
A
"
7 •
=
7
%>R4? >@P4&9
9
"
"
7
" =
"
•
.
"
%) "
7 7
" "" 9 >FF3&5 = 1 % 9 >F??&0 *
A
7
0
D %$
9 2333&0 #"
"
T B
%$
9 23329 233P5 " 7
9 233R&0 *
7 5
7 "
"
9 233>&
0 %
7
7
9 233>&
9 >F?R&
%
9 >FFR&0
9
7
%233P&
9
%>F??&
"
0 "
$
D
7 "
" 9 >FFP5 9 9
"
F2
"
7 7
9 >FFR& "
9 9
9
9
%
%(
C "
#"
>FF2
" 9 >FF3 5 "
" " 7 " " %' 9 >FFR5 B" C
9 233Q& %
&9 9 >FFF5 ) "
" "
9 2332& %>F?3&
"
9
#"
" %>F?F&
"
9 233>5
9 "
1 6 0 " 9 >F?45 B
5
9 >F??5 $ " ' " A
"
"
"
% 7
%
F?4&
"
>3
0
%>FF@&0
>@2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
>3 '
"
$
"
%"
$
&
7 M
7
M
7 • • •
-
"
%
"
(
"
&
%
/
7
%
&
& %>F??& " 0
7
9
C 7
&9
7 7
7 %
9
"
"
"
&
%>F??&9
" Q2
7 9
D
C
" "
D
% 7
0* 0*
7
0 7 % " " "
"
" &0
7
' "
" 0 *
#"
"
0
3.10 Madsen’s overarching framework: Systematology - a comparative meta-theoretical taxonomy *
"
A 9
" 0 ' "
QP
7
7
9
" 9 A
0, " 0
"
7
0 7
" "
9 9
"
9 7 7 " %>F?4 9 >F??& 7 0* 7
"
0 0
>@P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' " QP A 7 0' %>F4>&9 045 %>F4P&9 0@F?5 %>F4@&9 0P3>5 %>F?Q&9 023>5 %>F?R&9 0P 5 %>F?4 &9 >@45 %>F?4 &9 2@?5 %>F??&9 02F5 %>FF2&9 R3Q0
*
A
" " * ,)+-+
7
!
>
Q
* *
7
+ !
Q
>
*
2
R
P
2 *
, ,( )
,
-
P
'"
7
7
$
7
F??9 0P3&0 * "
D % &
7
0
7
%
"
%
&0
+ *
"
7 " %
7
&
"
(
"
2
"
"
"
" 0*
"
9
"
"
9
%>F??& 7
" "
" :
"
9
9
"
/
FR
*
"
7
"
9
"
9 "
7
#" " #"
%>F??&
" #"
"
20 *
9
7 "
"
0 * "
" " "
"
"
7 "
•
" 0
;
7 #" " #"
"
0, " "
0
• %>F??& 0 +
"
7
% #"
%
" " % " "
& &0 < 7
" 7 &
FP
FR
=
F4
% &0
F??&
"
% &+
"
+
(
"
@F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
QR % &
A %>F??&
"
%43
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.10.2 The hypothetical-stratum *
7 7 0 *
7
" "
7
" 9 >FF2&0 *
%
7 7
7 7
9
"
7
0 %>F?R5 " " A " 0 , 0* 7
7
>F?4 5 >F?4 5 >FF2&0
" 0 * 7
9
" "
7
"
7 /
• • •
-
0
7
7
7
"
7 7
7
0 '
7
%
9 " "
7 #"
" "
0,
7
9 7
&9
"
D 7
9 "
7
"
" " •
7 "
0< 7
7
7
"
%
"
0 ,
A
"
"
"
&
"
% %
+ (
"
"
D9 C
7
D
% " D "
C
9
& 5 %
7 "
"
"
"
7 &0 + " "
C
D "
%
" "
7 &0 (
"
"
•
*
D
7 "
A 0
7 7
& &
"
9 7
7 "
"
"
"
/
- " " 7 "
"
"
& &
" " C
7
/ & & &
" "
7 /
"
7
*
B
C
"
7 5
C "
0
9
" "
" 9 " "
0* "
0
>4>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
- " " 9 •
*
"
$ "
$
$
"
"
"
%
$
" C
D9 C
7
&7 C
D
7 7
9
D0
7 7 7
" &
.
"
"
7 7 " "
"
7
7 " &
" "
7
7 7 &
7 0
#"
.
"
C
0(
"
9 D9 C
D
" D0
C
"
7
7
7 7
"
C
D
7 7 "
"
" "
7 7
7
0
"
" 7 0*
" 0 7 9
0
7
7 "
"
" 0*
"
A
9
9 • +
"
7
& " "
" " " &
"
0) 0
"
"
"
'"
"
"
0 '" 7
"
"
"
" 0 & 7
"
7
7
"
"
7
7
0
• 9
%
&
"
/
&
>42
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
" 0 *
"
7 "
-"
" %
"
" &
7 " A
%
0 E
&0 & 7 0 -"
7 -
A
""
E
7
%
&0
* *
" "
7 9
9
* " "
"
"
7 "
0
9
0
/ 7
" 7
"
" 7 "
"
"
" " 7
" "
0
A
"
7
" 0
"
" "
"
" •
7 "
A
7
"
"
7
"
%
%B" 9 233>&0
9 '
&
• 7 "
" 0 ' " Q@ "
7
"
0
>4P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
Q@ -
"
9
9 >F??
"
"
-
-
4Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
Q4
A %>F??&
"
"
-
*
+ +
$
9 7
"
9
9 "
9
"
7
9
" " *
9
'" $ " $
9
7
7 9
7
$
"
$
-
7
"
>4R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.10.3 The data stratum *
"
" "
9
*
9
7
0*
"
7
/
"
*
" 7 9 " 0
7 7 7 0* " "
$
"
"
7 "0 * "
"
"
&
" 7
" " 9
"
7 7
7
9 " 7
7
9
7
"
0* 9
%
7
"
"
" " 7
"
"
D "
" "
0*
A
C
7
"
"
&
0 '" " %
" / 7
" %
7
&
&0 ,
/
"
*
7
9
/
*
"
"
,
7
/
7
& ( "
7 "
"
0*
"
"
*
/
"
-
7
" 0
"
7 "
A
" :"
9
/ " " 0,
" "
"
" "
7
9
7 *
7 M
7 %>F??9 0RF&0
"
7
"
"
"
"
Q?
0
>4@
9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
Q?
A %>F??&
"
*
"
( "
"
'"
F?4 &9 0>435 %>F?4 &9 02@P5 %>F??&9 0>20
0'
3.11 Considering the whole text 9
9 0,
"
7 0 7
" "
9 9 "
0. 7
7
"
#" "
" % E&
#" #" #"
%
& 7
0
>44
0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
"
7
7
% :
"
9
"
7
&0 *
7
"
7
9 "
0*
"
#"
"
9
"
"
0 "
"
" 0 *
:
7
"
9
7 7
7 7 "
"
" 0
"
7
"
9
0
3.11.1 The testability of theories - hypothesis quotient (HQ) " 9 #"
"
"
>32
" A
"
#"
7 " 7
#"
"
A
" C#"
7
9=
"
7 7
0 9
"
%
9 2332&0 *
7
7
D %>F?Q 9
"
0>?R&
0
"
"
0
%>F?Q & 7 B" %
% "
0 B"
7
9 F?Q &
0* :"
E %>F?Q & 7
"
" %
0* "
" D %
7
7
7 9 >F??9
7 0@>&9
"
" 0*
7
0 0*
%
"
7
9
& 0,
-
%
7
9
0* 7
E
A
"
"
" 0 * "
"
-
>3R
%
"
&
7
"
7
"7
0* %>F?Q &9
A
"
0 E
"
"
7
"
/
-
" 7
"
9
9
7
#" "
7
"
"
0*
7 0 " A
7
7
"
7 ,
7
"
7
"
"
7
0
" " ""
0 0*
0*
0* "
-
2
0
7
7 " 0 * "
7 " >3R
7
0
E
9
>3Q
9
"
$"
>3P
&0>3Q
7
"
"
9
9
C
" 9
,
&
/
"
>32
" 6 9 *a B" A
9
&0
& >3P
$
9 4?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
o%
Ec
o%
&
-& ]o %
*
&
#"
7 A
>3@
' " A
0'
"
%>F?Q & "
"
' " A
4
"
C,
o%
Ec * -
"
' " A " E #" ""
7 "
E A 9
o%
9
0
>0 20 P0 Q0 R0 @0 40 ?0 F0 >30 >>0 *
%
7 & -% " & -% &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M %
3
"
" 7 D >F2@&
0*
7
/
& & & & & & & &M
%
&
"
& & -& c 25 o %
& c P5 o %
& c @0 *
&
-& ]o %
c @OR c >02
& 7
#"
' " A
7
E
9
" "
" " 7 "
"
E
"
&
o%
"
%
' " A C
E"
, 0* "
7 &
7 ' " A
9 o %
o%
2 " 5
7
""
Ec
%>F?Q 5 >F?4& 7 7 " 7
0*
% % % % % % % 7 % " % % %
E
7 " 0 E
E
"
9 "
"
A 7
0*
7 " %
9 >F?Q &0 , 0 * #"
" " 7
7 7
0
,
0*
"
" "
"
" 7
#"
0!
"
" 9
"
>3@
' " A 0' 9 "
"
@O%2]>& c 2
EA
%>F?Q & 7 % " " & #" 0
&
"
c
&
7 ' " A ' " A E >029 "
"
E -O
&
-& ]o %
9
D %>F33O>FRP& & % " 9 #" " "
%
"
0* E
"
0
" ' " A "
#" A
"
0
F?Q&5 7
E9 "
%>F?Q& " 5 "
-
%>F?Q&5
"
7
7 #"
"
0
%>F?Q & 0
>4F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
A
E
"
" 0 B
%
7
&
9
7
7
" #"
0
"
O " 0*
>34
7
M "
"
"
"
#"
0 9 "
"
"
7 ""
7
7
% "
9 0
"" " " "
>34
" O
O 7 9 7 >F@Q>3?&0 * * 7 "
"
"
R3
7 " 0
6
%>F43&
" 0 *
/
*
"" 0* 7 7 9 7 " /( %>FFF&5 W %>F??&5 %>F43&5 + %2333&5 %233> &5 " %2332&5 %>FF25 2332&5 %>F4F&5 + %>F?@&5 %>F@Q&5 -" %233> 5 233> 5 233> &5 * " %233> &5 *" %>F4P& = %>F?R&0 ' 7 " %7 & 7 7 " %>F4?& 7 7 7 0 >3? , 9( ( 9 9 " " " 7 "" % " 9 23335 6 9 >F43&0 " 9 7 " " C 7 D :" " "" 0= " " 2 "" 9 7 " 9 " " 9C 7 " 7 " 7 " D %$ 1 9 < T - " 9 233Q9 02?3&0 , 7 " M " " %1 9 >F?F&0 , " " 9 " " ; C< " " O 7 D %1 9 >F?F9 0RQ&0 ( Q " 0
>?3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
R3 '
7
"
%
9 >F@Q& *
-
(
"
$
(
7
"
-
-
"
"
-
7
" 9
"
7
,
" " 7 "
"
"
"
7
"
"
#"
9
"
9
9
"
"
9
9
9
#"
7
9
7 "
0 *
:
7
5 "
7 "
-
"
:
""
9
7
"
"
9
"
0
3.12 An amalgamated Madsenian framework * $ 7 "
9 B0FFF9 233P &0 ' " 0
7
7
7 "
7 C
" "
%
" 7
"
9
"
7
" "
5
"
7
" A D
7
&9
"
" 7 9
7
9 0 *
7
0 * "
A
0
" "
"
9
7
"
"
" 7 A
7
"
" "
"
9P
"
"
" "
"
#"
"
* "
9
" "
9 233P& 7
9
0 +
"
"
% A
9 >FF@&0 ( 9 7 " " "
" "
9 7 " 7
"
*
P
A
A
7 9
%
" "
5
D5
#"
%0*
>
9
9
" "
7
7
" :"
#" 7
7
" I7
" 9 7 "
"
C "
" "
#" "
" "
9
"
"
%
FFF& "
C "
"
"
#"
D % 0>3Q&0 , A 0* "
A
7
#"
"
"
7 5 = #" 9
• • • •
#"
%
" "
"
9
"
A 9 >FFR&0 , 7
T =
"
" "
5 "
" "
" "
*
" 7
7
" #"
"
0
"
"
C "
"
"
D
9
"
7 "
9
0*
7 >FF?&0 , " ' " R> 7 0*
" 9
FF?&
" 7 " &9 7
"
" 0*
" " 7
"
" D %
"
9
" 7 7
" D %=
"
9 >F?R&0 -
9 >FF4 9 0PP&0 *
:
9C 7 "
"
"
C
"
#"
A :
0*
" "
"
9%
7
& "
"
"
0*
"
" "
7 C
"
D
7 0
7
%>F@R&
#"
9
"
7 " 0 "
#"
%
9 >F?3 " /
7 0 0 0 70
7 "
F@P& " " "
9
7
" 9
7
" 0*
7
0
"
7 9
" T $
9
" 7 "
"
7
9 >F?> 9
"
"
7 9
9
"
"
"
7 0
7
"
" 7
9
7 " "
0 - 7
"
"
" "
" %< 7 " " " " 7 " " 7
7 "
7
% "
"
9 7
9
"
"
9
"
7 " "
6
M
"
"
" 9
"
>4R39
%
C7
" "
" 7 "
" ;&0
"
D "
"9
>?R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0Q *
" %-
a
#"
7
9 >FFQ&/
• • • • •
#"
7
" "
"
' "
#"
7
"
9
R>
("
-
* '+
-* *,-*,( ) '+
*
"
7
*,( ) '+
$ *,+
$ *,+
$ *,+
7 7
5
7
"
"
9
7
0
"
7
0 (" 7
"
"
9
0* #"
7
7
" 7 7 "
#" 0
C
D
C
7
D0 * "
" "
9
" #"
7
"
Q
"
0$ " "
"
0,
" "
7
0' "
R2
0
"
9
"
9
"
"
" 0
>?@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
R2 *
$ c #"
,E
$
,E
"
• •
" " E"
• • •
7
"
"
9 " 7 9 0 A %233>& 7 C 9 9 " 7 " 5
"
"
#" 7
0+
%
" 9 >FF?5 - 7
#" %< " 9 >FF?5
%
C*
9 23329 233P5 < 9 233R&0 * -
=
D
" 7 "
7 9Z [0 *
[
Z " 7
"
" ['
" " " f0
"
" 0' " " " 9 "
9 "
"" "
"
" 9 7 "0 "
7
" " " Df " #" "
"
C
#"
" %
" " #"
"
9
9 " #" "
%
FF4&9
" " A
" " 7 " 9
f
" %
&0 " C " 9 >FF?&
7
#" 9 233R5
%
@&0
D%
#"
f
" "
7 " f
" 9
A "
7 "
"
&0 "
"
"
*
0 %
"
"
" "
"
= 9 " 9Z
9
"
C
"
"
" D % 02>>&0 * 7
#" 7 9 "
9 >FQ@&0 9 " 9 >FF4&
7 0, 7 7
"
7 "
7
" "
7
% 9 >FF4&0 ! " D % 0PRF&0 * " "
C
" "
E" C D "
"
"
" "
7
"
0
"
5
#"
"
$
7
$ 7
• • •
" "
"
c #" 7 "
0 ,E
,E 9
"
,E
>?4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
C
"
D
" "
0*
#" %233>&9 " 7 &0 " " 9 =
9 %
"
9 "
7
7
"
"
9
%
FF?5 B
9 >FF?&0
• • • •
"
%
" " "
9
"
"
6 "
•
"
(
"
"
9
"
" %"
"
%< "
9 233>&0 , %
"
7
" 7
&
#"
" 0(
7
9 233R5 "
"
"
%>FF?&
"
7
9
"
"
"
"
%
" "
&
" "
"
(
"
" "
:"
7
%B
9 >FF?&
"
%
"
%
" "
&0 ) &
%
7
" 7
A
" "
" %
= "
A %>FRR&
7
&
:
"
" 9 233>&0
"
0* 7 "
5 -
7 " " 9 >FF4&0 ,
"
" " %>FF?&9 " 7 "
9
&
"
7
" "
%>FRR&0
6
0* 9 >FF?5 < " A
7 " "
"
%>FF4&
&
6 M
"
"
"
"
%
" "
" 9
"
"
/
7
"
0
7
"
0' 0*
"
"
&0 7 %>FF?&9
F@4& 0 7 " " C 0 ' " RQ9
7
%
%
0
&
9 #"
"
" %B
7 9
9 "
7 "
"
"
" 7 0' "
0 "
RP "
" "
D +
" 0
%233R&
" "
"
" 7
"
7
7 7
0
>??
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
RP
" 7
"
( 7
( 7
( 7
"
" " ( 7
"
"
( 7
"
,
( 7
"
( 7
( 7
(
"
"
7
" ( 7
"
( 7
"
"
7
"
7
>?F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
RQ *
7
9
"
" 7
%
+
" 9 233R9 0PFQ&
(
(
"
(
7
> *
$
"
"
"
"
"
"
2 +
"
/
,
" 7
P (
$
( 7
/
/
"
7 ,
>
7 "
"
6
*
2
" "
( 7
P
*
" "
7 "
"
7
5
"
"
" #" 0
• • • •
@
"
-
"
"
"
C
D
7
"
"
0* "
"
C
D"
7 9
"
7
" 5
9
"
7
7
% " 7 %=
"
9 "
" "
"
"
% p
9 U"
9
" #"
5
"
p0@ 9 233P&
9 9U
"
T
"
9 p #"
T
7 7
"
7 7 " 7
7
" %
7 "
" %
FF2&0 * " p0
"
" "
"
"
• •
0*
" 0*
" 9 "
7 "
" #"
9
7
" "
7 "
"
"
" "
233>&0 FF4&0
>F3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
p
"
"
0
"
#"
7
7
7 " bb
p
"
"
0*
"
"
%
FF4&
"
"
"
;
"
" " 9 >FF?&0 *
%
" #"
" "
"
" "
" " 7 9
" "
0
"
"
"
0 "
" " "
%
0$
& %< #"
%
F@Q9 0@3&
, (
""
" (
"
(
-
"
-
"
"
-
R@
& "
=
A %>FF4& "
=
?
" "
8
7 "
"
7 "
:
' "
"
"0*
0=
0
>F2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
4.2 Mathematical foundation " "
" 0F ,
"
"
"
" 9
9 %(
>FFF5 9 >FF?5 " 9 >F?P& "
T C
#"
Q
7 9 233P&0 *
%
0
7 "
%
D
"
7 "
%= 7 T *7 #" 9 >FFQ&0
" 9 $ & "
%=
9 >FF4&0 " " 9 >F43&0
"
"
9
C "
(**
7
"
9>3 .
"
>>
A "
9 "
7
0 "
"
7
"
%
FF>& "
7
/OO
0
0
O
" 7&0 , 9 >FF>5
OB
A
%< 7
" "
7
"
5
"
7 " 9 >F?P &0 *
" 9
< "
%
FFR&0 ) "
T
9
< >F?4&0 *
C
"
"
"
%$
" 9 "
9 "
9 9
7 a "
0
"
9
" 7
0 "
>3
" " "
"
"
%
9 9 >FFQ&
9
"
7
"
9
0*
9 " %
" /OO
0
% 0
O
T l
O
&0 = &0 %-
A
7
"
9
7
&0 A
0
% 9
" " :
FF4&9
"
" "
,
"
9 >FFF9 02&0
"
" F
M 7 9
" "
"
0
7
"
7
7 D 7
" 0*
"
FF?&
0 *
* "
7 9 %, *
" :
"
"
%
"
"
"
9 >F4R5 )" 9 >FF49 %< " 9 >F?P 5 9 >FF?9 0F&0 " 9 7
"
" "
9
9 >FF45
7 9
>FR3A %(
* %$ "
9 >F435 $
" 9
"
"
9$
9
9 233>&0 ,
P 0
9 T *7
T
9 233>&0
0
>FP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0 *
"
7
9
" 9 9
" D % 0>R>&0 9 7
7
-
"
a
9
%>FFQ&9
a "
%>FFQ& % 7
C &
0
0,
"
7 •
" " 0 ,
• • •
+ -
•
,
•
-
"
"
"
" 7
7
"
7 7
7
#" 7
" "
"
"
7
"
7
" C " D "
"
#" 7 #"
"
9 "
7 "
7
" 9 " " 9 >F?P&0 = 9
"
"
" & 7
7
0 7 " 0
"
0>P *
"
9 %)
9
A 7 9 >F4F&
" 7
"
7
7
" "
7 " 9 >FF4& "
%$
0* " :
"
9 7 #" D %
F4F&0
" " 9 " " 9 >F@R5 , 9 233>5 ) 7 9 233P5 9 7 6T. ) 9 23335 #" % " " " " C 7 % & "
"
"
>Q
7 %
FF@5 9 23325 9 >FFR9 >FF?5 = 9 9 >FFF& "
8
" " "
0! "
0
9 "
7 9 " >Q " 9 >F4Q5 ( 9 >FF@5 7 T 9 >FF25 9 >FF45 9 >FFR5 #" " 9 >FFF&0 A " 7 "
%>FFQ&
"
"
9
- a *
"
"
0
"
"
6 >FF>5 < + e 9 233R5 >FF4&0 ( " " %= 9
" " 7
7
9 >F?P &
*
0
7 " " "
9 >F?P 9 02F>&0 < "
9
9
7
C
7 "
% "
"
:
7
" " 9 >FR?&0 *
"
"
" 7 " 0*
" %'
7
9
7 7
9 " : "" 0+
" %
#"
0
9
"
"
"
" "
7 9 >F?P&0
% "
%
"
"
7
0
" "
#" "
"
>P
"
0 ) 9
"
>2
"
7 "
,
"
"
+
" A %>FFQ&
- a />2
"
9 "
%U 7
"
9 233R&; + #"
" %$
9 233R&0
;
>FQ
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
"
"
7 7
7 7 "
9 9 ,
"
"
%
@
#" " 9
7
:
"
" 7 7
0 7 9 >F?3&0 ' " 7
%
" " 9
>4
&
)
9 #"
7 >?FF %( 9 233@5 ( 7 T " 9 >FFP&0 C " D % "
>F?45 -
A
#" %) 7
9 >FF45
T
9 >FFR5 $ 7 9 >F?P5
"
" %$ 9 >FF4&0 W %>?RQ >F>2& 9 " 9 ) %>?@2 >FQP& 9 W9 =
" " " % 9 233Q&0 $ 7
"
7
,
"
"
" "
>FP> 9
FF45
" B"
9 233Q& a %
& %B
=
9 >F?35 "
7 9 >F?P&9
"
"
"
7 " : 9 >F?P&0 (
%("
%
#" 9 >F@@5 = "
"
A
"
7
7 9 #"
= " "
9 9 7
%
9 >F?35 B
"
9 >F?P&0 *
,
" A ;*
" >@ >4
%) 6 *
9
"
" % 7
A "
% 7
7
7
" 7 7
"
5 9 >F@R5
T
& U
" 7 9 >F@@&0
" &0 =
A
#"
"
9 >FF4&0
"
"
%
9
A %$
5 7
% 9 >F?P&0
" " "
" 7
" #"
5 %< 9
"
7 9
9 233P&
A
"
"
7
9 %
U
7
0*
7 >F@@&0 =
"
%233@& 9
D 7
9
" 0>? *
C
"
9 >FF?&0
: "
9 >FF?5
A
9 "
"
9 >FFQ& " "
" " " " D %>F?P9 044&0 , " " ;,
;* 7
9 >F?P &0>R ( " 9 >FFQ5
%
" " " 0 *
" 7
< "
>?
" #"
"
%) 7 9 233P&9
+" "
>R
9 "
0* "
"
"
04P&0 7
"
0!
0*
B 7
9 "
#" A ;,
9
0 "
#" "
7
7
" ; "
"
9 >F44&0 "
"
"
0
>FR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
9
" " % 7
7 #" " "
9
" 9 >F@R&0 =
T
0
7
" "
9 7
" "0 * "
:
C
9 D
&
%
/
7
" 7 % "
7
" "
" 7
"
"
9 >F?P &0
4.2.1 The philosophical implications of mathematics>F ,
" "
9
9
"
" C
0* D
"
0
"
7
0 *
7
%$ 9 233P&9 "
"
%
9 233P&
< 7 7
9 C 9 233P&0 *
7
" " 7
D 9
9
"
"
"
9 >F4Q&023 "
%< "
"
"
9
"
" 7 %
" " "
9 " 9
7
7 9
" 0 9
" " 7 7 "0
"
" "
"
;=
*
"
9
7 " C " D
" O " " 9
:
"
"
9
7 9 >FFF&0 =
%
9
"
;
" #"
"
"
" 7
;* " 0 9
9 " " 02> ' "
5
;=
" 7
"
7
;=
; 7
O
5
"
7
"
9 R4
:
"
" " 9
"
0 0 ,
"
" 9
"
7 0
>F
:" 7
"
"
9
0-
"
"
7 "
9 7
23
7
"
" "
"
7 7
"
9
"
" A "
"
"
" %>FF?& 7 " 7 "
0 &
9
" " 0*
7
9
D0 *
% C " D " 0
9 >FFQ&0 "
C 7
2>
%
A
9 "
#" 7
0
>F@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' " "
R4 *
5
"
,
P "
9
2 " 9
9
" 9 0
" 7
"
"
9 #" 0 )
"
7
7 " *
0 ("
0 "
" 7
% &
"
0
"
*
9
"
7
> '+
'+
'+
> c (
" Pc
" "
$ *,+ -
$ *,+ -
$ *,+ -
2 c " 7
" "
0
>F4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
, " B A >F?P5 ) 7 9 233P& " 7 " 7
A % % A
;& 9 >FFQ9 233R5 - "
%
" 9 233Q&0
5
"
0 :
&5
233>5 - " 9 233Q&022 " , 9 233>9 0PRR&0 * 0* 7 " 7 "
7
C
"
"
"
" & %,
A
#"
" %) 7 9 233P5 - " " "
D %( "
0
7 9 233Q&0 $ 7
7
" 9
" %- "
" 9 233Q&0 *
" %) 7 9 233P5 - " "
7 "
9 233Q&0 *
"
"
"
"
0*
"
"
"
*
"
"
F?P 5 ( 9 >FF@5 (" 9 >F?P5 $" 9 >F?P5 >F@45 ) 9 >F4F5 9 >FFF5 = 9 >F4Q&0 * " " " " % 9 >FF?& " " 9 7 " " 0 " 9 %< " 9 >F?P 9 >F?P &0
"
7
" " 7 A %>?Q? >F2R& 7 " " ) 6 A % 9 >FF?5 a 9 >F?P 5 9 23325 = 9 233P&02Q * A " 7 " ' " 7 " A %( 9 >F?P 5 ' 9 >F?P9 9 >F@@5 - " 9 233Q&0 " 9' 92R " " 7 " = A 2@ 9 >FF>&9 7 ' A " 7 " %' 9 >F?P&0 ) 6 " " $ ' 0 9 >F@R&0 " = A " ( A %>?QR >F>?& 24 #" " %( 7 & %< T 6 9 >FF>5 a 9 >F?P 5 - " 9 233Q5 9 >FF35 = 9 >F?P&9 " 0 * 9 ( 9 W 9 >FFF& 0 "
" =
6
"
%
22
"
" %>??Q9 >?FP9 >F3P&
B
'
A
7
7
" 2P 2Q
"
7 7
*
"
$ 0 -
9 :
"
"
B
7 0+
% 9 "
:" 9 >FF?&0 = 9 " "
C
2R 2@ 24
, C* "
"
#" "
A
"
9
"
T
% 7
T
/ 9 >F?P &0
T
%>F?P&
9 >F@R&0 "
"
' 7
7
" 0
7 '
"
" "
#" A
9 >F@@5 7 "
" 0) 0 *
"
7 =
T
" 0
%< D "
"
" 0, ' % "
A %< "
%
?4> >FRP " " " 7 " %- " 9 233Q&0 " " 9 " : 7 " % 9 >F??&0 * C " D9 " % 9 >F?P5 = 9 >F?P&0 * 6 " % 9 >FFF&0 * " " % " 6 ( " A "" " 7 " " 5 9 C : 7 : D % 9 >FF?&9 " %>F?P&0 7 7 " 9 " " " " " " " 0, A 7 "
5 >?F> >F@R&0 *
" CQD
:"
0 -" "
%>??Q& U
7
A
A %(
A '
7
"
&
'
7
a
% "
&
"
P2
7
"
0 * 7
9 %
9 >FFF& % :" "
7 9 C"
"
D "
"
"
7 "
T
" " " "
"
" %
FFQ&9
9
" 9 >F?P&0 *
"
&0
% a " 9 " " " "
9
A %
R020F&0 *
" 7 "
7
"
" 7
9
"
"
"
7 "
"
0
" "
"
>F?P &0 * "
"
0 ,
"
7
"
:"
& 7
0, 7 "
"
%
F?P5
" "
" 7
"
%>F?P & 7 0' "
RF "
"
"
" "
*
% '
0 *
"
9
"
P>
0+
9 >F?P &0 & "
7 "
9
"
" C
"
7
7 7
9
" " 9 >F?P&0PQ ( " : 7 ; , " 7 % 7 0
T "
" 7
7 %
7
" 0
" "
5
"
" #"
%
" " 9 "
" % 0 R? "
& 9
" 7
C,ED0
P&
"
A
"
0
P2
* " PP * PQ * "
" "
" 8
9
9
%>FFQ&
:"
6
"0* "
"
"
0*
7
"
"
" 0+
7
"
"
0*
" " 0 *
#"
0
"
""
0
9
" "
" 7 0
0- 9 "
9 9
C "
D 9
233
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
R? *
7
"
"
"
%
9 >FFQ9 0Q>Q& *
/
"
* *
/
/
"
"
" "
%
"
7
&
*
" 9 7
"
%
&
" "
0 , "
7
" C
"
"
7
D %$"
9
" " #"
P0 9 233P5 " 7
% 0
7 9 >F?P&0 * 7 7
% "
" " " 7
7
0*
"
%,
" & "
" 9 233>&0 *
" "
: 7 "
7
7
C@D
C2 C 0PR - "
C? C "
9 2
"
9 " "
" " "
9
%
9 >F?P&0 "
"
&
"
" " 0
7 %
C
%
&
"
0 * "
9
0= D #"
"
" "
"
" 7
7 7 %'"
PR
9 233>&5
"
7
" "
"0 * "
0,
#"
@]2c?
" "
7
7 "
"
" %,
9
" 9 " "
7 %
7 " 7
@
9
*
9
9 >F?P &0 @]2c? 00* " " " "
"
C " D
0
" "
"
7 :"
" 7 9
9 >F?P9
"
0*
" "
"
"
" 0* : "
9
C]D0 = 7
" 7
7
0>3R&0 !
7
" "
*
9 9 >F@4&0 *
"
1
" "
C "
B 7
"
"
" "
"
M 7
A %>FFR& 0 F?P9 02F>& " / #" "
; :"
" :"
0
"
:
"
"
" 7 "
"
" " ; -"
"
0 "
#"
" " "
5 5
"
7
" A
*
"
0 , 7
7
" "
"
7
"
0
/C D0 +
0
' "
RF *
"
,E
"
"
,E9
9 0
*
"
,E/
?R
>P3 C " "
D 0 " " "
9 7
"
7
7
"
0
"
" 5
"
" " -
7
"
RF
"
R?0
"
%>FFQ&
9 0 *
"
"
"
% "
7 &0 '
"
"
>F2Q& "
7 7 "
"
%
"
"
"
% "
5
9 >FFF& 0 7
7 7
7
"
" %
F@@5 9
" 7 +
W9 >F?P&0 "
"
"
0 "
:
"
P@
#" 7
P@
7
%( 7
T
>>3 7
9 >FFR&0
232
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
" "
%
FFR&0 * 9" 9 " 9 >FFF&0 +
%
'
"
"
"
"
" 5 "
0P?
9 7 " $ 9 >F@@&0
%
A "
" " 5 " 7 7 "
5P4 "
"
0 *
"
"
B
4.2.2 The link made manifest PF
D%7
"
9
"
9
&
"
" AA % 0
9
9 A $
9 $
9 " 9 >F??&0 -" " 7
0 #"
"
"
,E9
%
"
"
"
:
" " "
"
9 7
&
"
7
7
"
0
" 2 %
9
233> &0 7 " 5
9
9
O 9
*
"
"
"
:
%
&
"
%
"
&
& %
&0
F?3& " %
#" " "
9
" "
"
9
% 0 * %' "
"
% " 7 % " 9 233R&0
( : 97 ?0 * #" "
" "
" 7 0 &
" 7 " " 0* " 7 " " 7
"
0
"
Q2
#" 7
"
7 "
Q>
"
" &
"
9
"
7 "
#" "
: 9
"
E"
Q3
%* " 9 233> &0 * 7
0
GA
QP
7 "
7
9
7
/* :
AA
7
7
(
:
5 OOOOO
" " 0
#"
A GA
9
7 "
" "
" 20
; "
#"
•
Q>
9 "
•
9
7
:
: "
7
9 233P&
"
7
"
7
" "
9 "
" 7 9 233Q 9 0RQ&0 *
& %
9( ,E
" 7 A
,E ,E
"
D "
D %
7
9 ,E 7 "
9 233> &9 ,E
" 9 " DC
C C %
0 ,
7
& "
" "
7
"
0'
"
9
0 9 "
"
"
7 7
7
5
0 0
2 "
0 *
7
&
0* "
"
C
7
7
D % 0PRF&0
23Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 " 7 *
0QR *
"
7
#"
"
"
"
#" % "
"
%
A
"
"
#"
0* "
0*
" "
"
0*
GA
#"
& "
&
"
#"
7
" "
#"
"
7 7 " 7 $ 7
7 9 >FF?5 7 "
,
"
"
"
"
7
0*
"
"
9 >F?>&0Q@
Q4
O
"
"
9
7 97
#" 7
"
7
" "
"
"
9 >FFF&0
7
" "
"
7
"
9 >F?3&0
9 >F?3&0 ) 6 %233P& 7 @ P :
"
9 7 "
" "
%= A
9 7 " &%
%
>?0
7
T 7 " "
%
" #"
: D
"
"
&0QF #" 7
%
7
" " 9 >FF> 5 "
" #" 7
"
%(
0
,
" 7 "
9
%>F?3& "
"
%
0 =
7
9
,
7
"
" " ; %- 7 T 9 >FF2&0 * " % " 9 >FF4 5 ) 9 23335 " 9 >F4?5 " " "" 7 " %- 9 >FF@& 7 " 7 9 7 7 " 9 >FF?&0 %>F?3& " 0Q? 9 " 7 C %= 9 >FF4 9 0>>Q&0 :
"
5
AA "
7
7
9 >FFP &0
R3
" "
"
0 *
0 "
%B 0
9 >F?>&9
4.2.3 Summary *
"
"
"
"
"
" 9
7
"
"
"
"
QR Q@
+ GA " * "
Q4 Q? QF
"
0
"66
#" A AA0 "
"
9 #"
7
"
"
" "
0 7 " 7 5 " "
#" #"
" " 7 %
& "
#" " 7 O C
7
7 "
" & D5
D "
:
9
"
" 0*
9
"
9
7 0* "
AA
"
" 7
"
7 9 0* "
*
R3
" 7
#" " : 9
7 9 0
" 0,
7 "
0
"
D0 %- 7
" T
" " "
" %233Q& " " %( 9 >FF> &0 7 " %( 9 >FF?&0 " % 79 >FFP&0 " " 7 " % 7 " " " 7 " " 9 >FF2&0
GA " 0
"
23R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
"
"
0*
7
0
" "
A
"
7
9
" 0*
&
"
"
"
"
"
"
%
I7
7
"
#"
7
0*
"
0 "
" 7 "
"
"
9
0
"
7
0
"
"
0
" "
0(
7
7 7
0
"
7 7
*
" 7
"
0* & 7
%
" *
7
"
C " D
0 #" 0 ,
"
"
0
7
7
"
"
#"
0, :
9
7
0,
"
7 9
0
7
7 9
"
9
"
7
"
"
7 "
9
0
" " 0*
7 "
"
" "
7
"
A
"
" "
"
B
0 *
"
" 9
7
0
0, " 7
7
9
9
" "
0*
7
7 "
" : 0,
"
"
7
"
7
9
"
0
*
9
#"
"
"
"
" 0 * " ;(
"
"
0
:
"
"
; *
" ""
" "
9
"
"
7
0< 7
9
"
0
4.3 Statistical foundation " *
"
" 0-
7 " " %
7
67 " A
"
#"
" "
7
" "
"
7 7 7
#"
" 9
" 7 %%
0
7 " 7
9 >FFP&0
FFF&
" P&0
#"
#" %
FF45 %
" " " "
"
" 9 >FF@&0 *
%
" 9 >F?4&0 , 9 >FF4&0 *
7 "
9
" "
7
" 0 *
#"
"
#" C
"
0
:
" "
%>FF@&
"
"
"
D % 0Q3?&0 "
29 " "
" " 0
" "
"
"
#" P
0(
"
: "
" 9 "
'
A
#" "
#"
0
7
"
7 9 & 9
" %-
T "
% "
7
9 >FF4&0 *
%
"
&
" =
"
" " 9 >FF4 9 >FF4 5 ( 9 233R&0 =
% % "
:" 9 >FF? 5
9 9 >FF45
0
#"
"
9 2333& ;*
" 0 .
"
"
#"
#"
9
0 C, -* Z " " " :
%>FF4&0 * " " -* >FF49 0PP@&0 = 0
% :"
"
"
Z [ "
7 [ 9 23339 02Q@&9
" D % "
"
:"
"
7
#"
C
" D
"
"
& " "
0* %
7 ;*
6 "
9
4.3.1 Statistical issues *
"
"
>F@2& %>?FR >F?3& % " < " < " < " A >4>P
7
9 >FFP&0
"
"
9
7 "
>F@P % "
7
"
7 7 "
#"
"
7 7 9 >FF4 &0 -
%=
< 3%
" " &
'
"
"
s
"
9
/OO
0
" A
?F3
%>?FQ >F?>&
#" " 7
* 7 "
"
"
%= 9 >FF4 &0 %< 9 >FF>&0 , 7 " 0 " 7 :" "
9$
9 >FFF&0
234
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>
" %< 9 >FF>&0 A " 9 >FF4 9 0PQ& " " " " " 0 * " 7 7 " %= 9 >FF4 &0 " 9' >F23 7 7 7 " " %" , * & %= 9 >FF4 &0 , 7 7 " 7 " " 0 7 9 " " 7 " R2 " * ' " %*'-,& " < 0 * 7 " % & 7 " " " 7 " " " %B 69 >FFF5 = T *'-,9 >FFF&0 " 9 " 7 #" " " " 0$ 9 7 " " 0 + #" 7 " " #" 7 < " " 7 " " 0 C
35 " : A "
7
"
"
"
"
" 7
0 *
7 7
"
,
0 "
7
"
"
7
7 "
7
""
7 "
7
"
0*
9
"
"
0 E"
" "
7 0,
" 7
9 7
"
7
7
" "
5
"
" "
"
7
"
"
"
"
7 " 7
"
D %=
"
0 -"
2 Q0
"
"
7
"
7
9 " "
9
7 "
7 7 0* " 9
" P0 $ 7 0 ,
"
0, " 7 0
0$
"
"
" %
&
" 0 * 7 " "
0 *
9
M " 0-
"
*
7 7 "
"
"
7 "0(
"
"
"
" "
0 * #"
" #"
"
2Q
" 7
"
#"
0
*'-,
" 9
T *'-,9 >FFF&0 * •
"
" "
"
"
7 7
"
>FFF "
"
%=
/
C
D
"
"
M
"
; •
" 7 9
R2
*
" >F>3 % "
" 7
7
"
"
"
0
"
9
"
% 9 >FFP& " %>FF@& >4>P %= 9 >FF4 &0
A
& " "
>?Q3
0
9
"
0
23?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
"
6
7 "
•
7
*
6
9
"
"
"
"
9
"
"
"
" "
"
RP
6
"
"
" " C T *'-,9 >FFF9 0@3P&0 *
D %=
"
" "
" 7
0
4.3.1.1 Historical contingency $
9
" :"
>FF@&
7
9
9 0* " 9 >FF4&0 *
%-
" -*
%
7
0* C
9
7
" : "
RP
#" 9 >FPP&0 , 0' A A
9 "
7 9 % 7 9)
" ) 6
" "
7 0 1"
D %>FR?9 0>Q3&5 C
(
'
#" '
"
9
>@@3
" "
" 0 5
"
9
A
"
7 "
7 7
9
0 %9B A
0
9 >FFF&0 '
7
7 " 7 "
7 0 "
#"
A
7 0
"
#" "
"
0*
$
B0
'
0( 8 #" " #" 0 ' " 6
0 %
5 9
5
7
7
7 " "
"
7
" :
5 5
"
" :
"
7 "
"
"
;* 9
7
9
9RR %
%>F44& "
"
9
0*
TBL
5
0 "
9< 7
< "
RQ
%>FF2& 9
"
0
A
09 >FF3&
9
9
A 09 7 " #" "
9$ < 9"
6 9 >FF4&0
"
6
7
% %
T =0-0 $"
9
&0 * "
9 >FF@5 '
7
7
#"
9 )
"
7 9 >FR?5 6 9- : " " %< 9 >FF>&0 * 9 >FR?& " "
7
>" '
" 7 " A " %'
%' "
2
7
0
"
9)
7
RR
"
FF35 " 9 :" T " ) " %E" 9 7 7 #"
% "
7 7 D
" 2&0 = " ;+
"
"
#" P&
"
7
9
"
" "
'
A
" C D%>FR?9 0>P@&
7 9 7 % %>FR@9 >FR?&
R&0
9 >FF4&0 7
"
C
" " #"
D%>FR?9 0FQ&0
23F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9
" 0
"
"
0" 9 7 " ' %
:"
%>FFF& "
"
>F>39
'
9
7
7 0 7
7 "
%'
5 + & D%
" 0R@ * 9 >F?@&
*
7 " "
5 7
7
7
7
P 0
9 9 9 7 " % >FQ3 >FR3A 5 " 6
7 7 " C
"
9 "
#" %B
" "
9
" >FRR %-
(
" T
"
#" 7
9 7
7
7 %+ %233>&
0 0* " 9
#"
9
" D9 7
0*
7
" "
9 233Q&0 *
7 C 9 >FF4& "
" .
9 >FFF& "
9 233P&0 " %
9
9 7
"
"
7
9 >F?@&0 C
9
'
"
"
#"
A
D % 02>Q&0 7
2
"
0
*
#" "
7 " "
"
6 9 >FF>9 02RR5 #"
9 " "
9
0 "
#" 7 " >FF4&0 >FQ3A 7 - 7 " %- 7 9 >FQ@9 >FR> &0 - 7 7 9 ( % 7 9 " 7 % 9 >FF4&0 , " :
"
9 7 7
#"
7 7
0
9 " 9
>4>3
9 #"
" 09 >FF3&0 * 7
" " 9
"
6
" " 1
%>FFP&
7
" #" 0R4
A
" 7 9
"
F@3A #" %+ 9 >F?@&
7 >FR3A
" #"
0
7 %
#"
7 9
" 9 2332&0 -
"
7
"
"
%
$
9
9 7 9
9 >FFF&0
"
9
" "
0-
"
"
7
7
0
R@
7
% "
9 )
" %B
"
" & 7
9
%$ 9 >F4?&0 ,
9 233Q&9 7 0 "
" +
9
" "
9
0 C-
7
D 0-
5
" "
>RP2 "
" " "
" "
7
7
" 0 D
0
7 9
7 "
"
& #" 0 *
" "
"
0 "
#"
0 "
7 %
"
" " 0 " "
" 0C "
" " 7
6 " 9
" "
" " * " :
" " 9
" R4
"
0
7
0
2>3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
'
7 0
F?@&0 * 9 >FF4& & %B
9 >FF25
%B
#"
@2
>0 * " " %233P9 023F& @P #"
%B
9 >FFQ&0 $"
7 " #"
7 7 "
" " C 7
"
< 0 ,
< "
" 0
7
9 233Q&0
9 "
7 9 7 %
:"
#"
"
" TU ; %
9 233Q5 = " " : 7
" #"
9
7
"
, 9
" 9
7 % " 9 $ T U" " 7 " 7 " " " >>0
"
5
"
7 " 9
" 7 %>F?@& : 7
0+
7
7
FFP&0 "
"
0
RF
* %B 9 233Q&0 @3 < @> . % 9 >F??5 " C : 7 D ;< 7
'
"
0* #"
7
7
T$ 7
9 >FF?5
T
9 233>5 " T 8
" "
" " 9 0 0 6
"
7 "
0)
@2
( 7 >FFR&0 +
"
% "
% " "
"
09 233Q&0 " " 7
9 7 "
"
7 "
)
9 9 >FFQ&0
7
7
7 7 " 8 7 9 7
$
%233@9 0>3@& 7
09 233Q&0 * 3
7
" >0
7 9 "
" :
"
7
" 7 V 7
0 F@P&0 #" 5
09 233Q&0 C< #"
9 V0
T- 7
" 9 >FF@&0 *
6
" "
9)
A " "
" "
% :" 9 >FF25 -
"
"
%.
"
" "
"
"
@P
09 >FF3&0 * 9 >FF2&0 ,
%$" %" "
"
"
6 %)
9 233P&
"
R?
% 7
"
D0
7
FF45
"
7
7 9 .
"
"
"
" 0
7 9
FF45
" :
" "
"
>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
>> $
#"
" :
7
%
T
9 >FF4&
$ ' #"
O (
•
-" :
7
O, 7
FF35 :"
9 233>&
"
"
%" "
&
&
%
"
% "6
&9 9 >FF4&0
FF25
9
7
%
F??&0 P 9 )
"
" T- 7
>F@P&0
@Q @R
" :
7
F?@&0 , " 7
0
2>2
9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
B %
t
9 233Q/
% u &@@
&c % & % u &c % &
%&
7
"
% u &c % & % u & #"
O
% &@4
A
/
% &
% &/ %
t
&
:"
"
% & % u & #"
@?
%
&
% &/ % u & % &
7 % &
%"
&
%
%
"
&
& % u &
' >FF25 B " " "
7
#"
%
7 "
" 9 233>5
"
9
9
:" T
9 >FF45 + : D %'
"
9 >F?@& 9 >FR?9 0F&0 "
" "
FF2&0 , 7 " #"
+
' '
" 7 /OO
7
F?@&0 * " 7 9 0 0 " " #" "
7
%+
'
% u &9
@4
9 >F?45
A "
9
#" 0 A
" 6 9 - :
% 9 >FFP5 B
>FP4
9 >F?@&0@F
%+ 9
"
" j 2F&0 ,
l j 2?
7 "
9
7
% 7 " v %
%
C
" "
-*&
9 233Q& "
9
9
"
09
7 :
%
9 >FF@&0 + '
9 " 7 7
"
"
F?@&0
/ D
7
"
7
FF4&0 (
:"
7 #"
7
7
"
%
9 >F?4&
C " "
'
5
"
7
:
%
>2& /
*
>2
'
>FFP9 0P>?5 B
A
9 233@&0 ( '
"
" 7 " " A
" %
"
7
7
" 7
0 9
9 >FFP&0 ' %>FR?& " D % 0>2R&0 *
"
"
9 >FFQ5 9 >FF45 : " 9
" % "
7
A
-* " 3& %( % "
" " "
7
9 >F4?&0
% u " 7 :"
" 0' 9 " 7 9 D %( 9 >FFQ5 " " -*
" 3
"
7 >FF35
0 9 0 0
7 9 >F?4& " % 9 >FF4&0 -" " 0*
%
"
" 9 2333& 7 #" "
#"
7 7
% (" 233R5
"
"
%(
%>FFP9 0P>?&
7 "
9 7 "
"
A
% "
9
9 233Q&
'
7 "
>0
-
20
-
%*&
P0
(
"
Q0
$
+
" 7 "
*
7 "
R0
:
7 "
+
"
5
:"
+%
5
"
>0
-
20
-
P0
-
Q0
(
R0
+
%*&
"
w7 "
: "
:
+
9 >F?4&
9 >F?4&
7 " * 7 "
7 "
% & *
%
5 5
:
+
* 233R&0 "
6 A &
C A " :
D "
* 43
>P
*
+
"
" "
%B -*; *
9
%
: 7 0* 3 9 >FFQ5 9 >FF4& C " D %B 9 233Q5 9 2333&0 , % 9 >F@4& ( %>FF? & 7 7 " " 0* 7 7 %B 9 233Q&0 , 9 7 9 C D C : " D % " 9 233R5 9 >FF45 T' " 9 >FF4&43 3 A 7 " %B 9 233Q&0 * O " " % 9 >FF4&0 * * %233P& " 7 " : " 7 " % " " " 9 C + " 5 " 9 >FF40 2 20Q0R0P0@ 7 &0 %>F?F& " C 7 D % 0P@& C " " D% &% 9 >FF?9 0R9 >FF3&0 -*0 D
%>F??& C
"
7 7
3
%( -*
%2333& D
#"
7
0
2>Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
>P
7
-* -*
%
"
"
= :
"
" :
+
&
+
A
A w
" +0 * "
: *
"
*
,, +0
,
w
"
0 -*0 ,
+7
6
" 6
"
0
7
6
"
" $
* 7 -
6 "
7 :
"
"
7 7
5 " "0 * "
: :
"
"
A " "
" *
:
5 "
"
0
"
O
"
" -*
-
7
-* :
"
"
7
0 " "
C
D
-
"
" , " 7 -
9
9 7 " %
"
" "
7 7
7 &%
"
0
"
9 >F@4&0
"
"
% 7 7 P "
" " 7
& " %>FF4& M
" "
5 -* % 9 " -*
233>&0 ,
0, "
7
" "
7
7 "
"
"
7
' % " 7 " 9 233Q5 +
" 9 >FF@5 " 9 #" #" " >FF39 0>3@9 >FF>&0 #"
7 "
+&5
#" 9 >FF4&0 * 7 7 " " 7 7 ; $
"
9 >FFP& 6
% "
C
09 >FF35
"
D "
C
D 7
7 #"
%( "
7
9
w
z
, "
5 :" T
" *
9 >F?@&0 *
% )
0, 8
"
" %B
< "
7 "
"
,,
7 #"
"
%233R&
7 9 "
*
" " >F@4 % 9 >FF?&0 ) 7 %B " " % - " & % 9 >FF4&9 " " >F@3A %B 9 233Q&0 * " "
>F@49 +&
#"
*
9
' 9 233R5 B 9 233Q5 " " %( 9 >FFQ&0 9 >FF? 5 6 09
" "
2>R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
;,
7
$
" " "
#"
" "
7
0 *
7
"
"
7 0 7
"
" 7
"
*
A "
0
"
0+ A
7
E C 7 D
" 7 "
%
9
R " 9
-* "
R&0
"
"
"
• •
4>
9 < T "
%
#"
9 >FF4&9
"
A ,
" 9
" "
' " "
" >A " " -* 0
6 0 -*
" "
%233R& "
"
7 6
7
"
6 "
"
7
"
#" D
"
0, " 9
0
" M
: "
9
%>F4?& " 0,
D 7
"
0
" " 0,
2
P9
#" #"
9 "
" "
"
7
" 5
-* 7
0 ;
C
7
"
7
7 "
7
9
C
"
"
" 9 #"
" " 7 " 0
"
7
" 0C 7
:
7
9
D #" 7
7
" "
7 " 7
"
"
" "9
"
=
7
"
7 " ,,
*
"
"
7 "
*
7
7
9
" • • •
7
/
• #" 5" "
; -*
"
"
"
"
"
0 *
" "
"
7
0
4.3.1.2 The hegemony of null-hypothesis significance testing " " - "
"
: " " 5 "
/ "
0*
" 7 %
FFF&
"
" 7
4>
" %
"
#" #"
Q
0 *
7
0
#"
7
%+
9 >F?@5
" I7
-* "
9 >FF4&0
2>@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 "9
" 7
:
7
7
" D %< 0
" 7 233R&042
%) 7
9
9
T=
7 "
9 233P9 04?&
-* 7 "
7 "
>FF>5
$
D%
9 >FF4&9 " %B 9 233Q&0 = " 7 % "
" -*A 7 7
9) "
"
9 233R&0
9 -
9 C 9 >F@P5 B " " "
T- 7
-*
"
"
-* %
9 >FF@5
:" " 7
" #"
7
"
7
7
5
"
7 7
& 7 7
"
A
:
"
7 7
7
" 9 7
3&
:
%
5
0, 7
% & " "
7 G
" %w&0 , :
30
,
"
#" "
70
0* " %>FF@&
)
w9
*
,
,
"
0 *
-*
9 )
-* " %( 9 >FFQ5 9 >F4?9 >F?F9 >FF35 9 >FF45 C " D% 9 >FF@&5 C D% 9 >FF3& : 9 >FF4&0 , 7
"
" 9 "
0
7 9 " " " "
7
" %>FF@& " " 9 >FF45 T " "
"
0
3
9 "
( -* 9
30
:
3
z ,,
9 :
30
3
" > z0 * %( 9 >FF>9 2332&9 " " 9
7
3
: #"
" "
5
w
7 " 9
:
A
&0 7 "
w
7 "
" 7
70
+
9
7
0
%
"
9 >FF4&8 0 ) " %>FF@& 7 " /
#"
%
%
3
" "
"
7
"
9
9 " 9 T
" &0 *
9
&
" 7
0
"
9 233Q5 ) " 9 >FF@9 0>@>5 ) 7 " ;+ " " %B " 9 233>&
7 9 2333&0 , %-
"
9
0
%
FF45 B 9 233R5 B " 9 >FF4&0 , " " C " " D% " T
9 233>5
$ 9 >FF45 D %B 9 233Q&5 9 >FF2& C " "
" 7
A "
0
2>4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%
F@P& 9 7 " : " 0 * " 7 #" 7 " 7 " 7 " 0 3 " " " 7 " C D% 6 9- : 9 9$ 9< T B L 9 >FF39 0FP&0 %>FF@& 7 6 87 " 7 % " 9 >FF4&0 ) 9 " 6 " #" 3 " :" %B " 9 233>&0 , 3 3 " * , 3j Rj " * ,, %( 9 >FFQ&0 * " A 9 " 0 C : " : 0 * " G 9 9 " ;AD %) " 9 >FF@9 0>@P&0 " :" % 6 9 >FF3&0 " " : " 7 7 %( 9 >FFQ5 9 2333&5 0 0 y 7 " > y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
•
•
•
4P
' " * %B 9 233Q5 " " " $ 7
4Q
A +0
:
" :
-* 9 >FF35 +
/OO
7 "
%
"
"
"
" 7
O % "
:
" 7
7 9
7 A
7
9
0 7 "
7
303R; =
" " " 7 0 "O"
" " "
0 "
&
9
"
;
" 7 " ; =
" "
0 0"
0 FF@&0
F?4&0 ( " 7 % O " 5 9 >FF35 9 2333 5 $ 6 9 >FF3& % 7 " 7 5 + 9 >F?@ " 5$ 6 9 >FF35 9 >FF3& " : : " 7 %< 9 T= 9 233P5 B 9 233Q5 9 >F@45 9 23335 = 9 233Q&5 0 0 : " 7 %B " 9 233>&0 %>FF39 >FF?& 7 " ' + ' " -*0 9 : 5 7 7 #" " 0+ ' 5 0+ 7 " 7 #" #" " 7 #" 0 * 9 9 " " 7 % & * >Q " / 7
*
D %B
>Q
"
>FFF5
7
6
"
-
"
6
9
"
-
7
6
"
O
,
.
bb 7 *
A %
$
%>FF39 >FF4&4R C " 9 >FF45 0 " 5 >F4?9 9 " "
O O
D %
&
7
7 -*0
9 233Q& "
"
A #" 7
F23A %$
6
"
9 >FF3&0 * "
"
%>FF?&
"
C "
< 0+ "
D
)
&0
-*
"
7
"
7
7
" 0
bb
O
"
%B
4R
%1
9 >FF@&
"
-*A " A 09 %233P&
7
9
0
0
2>F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
(
2
"
9
9
" "
%
F@4&
9 233>&0 ,
7
"
#" "
" #"
/
"
o o o
7
"
" 6
5
"
"
D% 7
"
"
" 7 9 >F@49 0>>>&
&% 7
"
"
7
-* C 7
7
:
0 *
9
"
9
7
" •
,
"
"
7
" "
7
"
0*
"
7
"
"
"
6 7 "
:" 6
&0 *
%
2 0 303> w
303R
9 233Q& "
9 233>&0 7 " A 303@
: >A "
' "
D
"
0* % "
7 "
0 ,
7
" "
9 233R&0 -" "
-*
" "
C
D P5
5 CV 9
A9 "
" 7 #"
" D%
G 0,
& % 0>>Q&0 *
"
" " 7 7
"
6
"
" "
7
%>F@4&
9" 9
6
9
G
B"
" ; * 303R 7
0
0"
"
" "
"
" #" " "
"
9
9 "
"
"
9
"
9 >FF? &
7
7
09 9
9 233R&0 ,
"
w 7
0 * 0*
"
9 >FF? 5 " 7 7
; (
7 D
C
6 % "
:" %( 9
" "
%
"
" %(
" "
" 9
%B "
-*
7 0*
: 9 233R5 B " " 0*
9
6 :"
7
(
9 0,
"
:
7
"
7 0,
;
" 7
"
P " 7 >FF35 " >FFP&0
"
"
%233R&
"
C
7
P 7
0
"
4@
: "
0"
2 " "
"
"
"
0
"
A "
"
%233P&
%233>&0
223
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
(
"
7 #"
" 0*
" )
" %>FF@& o 7
-*0 7
7 "
"
5
" "
"
"
0 "
"
"
"
9 "
"
7
"
7
"
" 7
o
-*
"
"
/
0*
7
"
7
#" 9 "
"
9
"
"
7
"
7 "0
"
" "
o
"
"
7
"
"
' " "
@3 *
-*
#" %
"
" " 9 >FF@9 0>@R&
)
7
7
7
Score
Long-term effects of mediation 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Day Test score experimental group Test score control group "
o "
"
#"
7 0 * 0 *
7
#" "
7 "
" " 0* 7
"
•
"
" 7 "
%&
" "
7 9 7
"
7 " 0
-*
" 3
"
:
%
7 9
% &
9
" "
" #" o
0* " 0* 9 9
% " ED c CE
u "
:
& { 303R
3
u D9
7
& 7 "
5 %
"
C
9 2333&
22>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
% &
y % 3 u &44 9 >FF45 ( 7 %>F4?& -" 0 7 9 7 % u
"
% u
T
3&
-* 9 >F?@5 *
9 23335 + %>FF3& C
%( 9 233P&0
9 >FFQ5 B
9 233R5 7
9 :" #" 9
7 9
&y
"
%
#"
u
& % 02>&0
FFQ9 0FFF&0 #" "
"
3
7
"
M "
:"
%"
9
%
8-
T
9 233>&0 , 20Q0R0P0@
2
" 9
"
3
:
-*
6 % u 3& 9 233Q&0 * "
-* %B
• • •
, $ *
3
u &9
%
u &9
%
u &
" 9(
9
3
%$%>FFQ& "
&
%
3
P "
u
: 7
3&
"
"
30
,
7 3
" /
" %
,' *
9 2333&
"
&
" 3
7 9
-* % " -* %B "
"
• • •
%
, $ *
& 9 233>5
9
3
$
"
7
%
"
&
"
7 "
" "
"
/
"
" 7
3
"
"
"
7
0,
"
"
"
0'
/
< • • •
,
*
" "
" 5 "
( • •
44
% 6 7 % * ,,, 9 " 9 >FF45 B 9 233R5 " /
&
7
7 T *
F?@&0 %+ 9 >F?@&0
"
3
"
7
222
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
4?
• * '
(9
$ • • •
, * *
" 9 "
9
3
6
9 -*
" "
-*0 /
" %
"
&
"
"
" "
3
7
%>FF>&
"
9
" 0* #"
%
% Q&
D
" " " 9 >FF49 0>32&0 " 7 ; "
%
+ "
%>F?@&9 #" 7 &0
Q&9
9 #"
;*
"
"
6 A %>FF>&
#"
C
" " #" 9
9
"
"
" "
7
0 % "
-* >R (
9 0 * " A 2049 >? c 303>0 * " #" 7 G A8
"
&
" %23
-*
0
*
0
*
0
*
70
*
70
*
"
%>FFQ& 9
7 "
30FF *
7
"
"
7 (
0=
" "
0
5
" "
7
"
"
A
-*
"
70
(
D
7
"
7 0
( "
"
2 Q
"
4?
5
P&
9 7
#" " %>FF>& 7 #"
6
"
"
>R *
9 :"
"
0, C
" %
(
7 7
7
3
7
" 0
"
"
C,
9
D0 "
22P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
>@ 1"
-*
0
#" 7 0*
8* 0
9
" "
" " "
"
7
7
7 0*
A 0 "
"
9
9
" 0 =
0 0-
" "
0
"
0*
"
9
0*
"
6
7 7
0
70 * "
0 * "
" 7
"
70
"
3
0
FFj
"
0 FF45
7 9 >FFQ5 " 9 >FF@5
" 9 0 "
3
7 "
7 C
•
"
: :
3
6
FF4& 7 7 5 % T 9 >FF45 9 >FF4&0 6 0( 7 9 7 9 0 ' " @> " 0 " 7
%
7 9 >FF45
"
9 7
" " "
D0
)
•
-* 9 >FF45
7 #" 7 A "
:
3
7 "
$
0
0) 6
6 7
A )
, 9 >FF49 024P&
"
7
:
0*
30 "
7 9 " "
7
7
%
T
3
FF4&9
" " "
9
#" "
w
FFj 0 * 7 "
A 7 " 9 >FF?&0
% 7 " " " " " -* "
' "
& "
9
0
"
7 #"
%233R& "
" 7
7 A " 7
"
" 9
7 " % 7
0
7 %
9
" "
T= " 9
FRj
-*
&
9 233P&0 (
" 7
"
0
7
7 %233Q&9 ) #" " "
%>FF4&9 B
"
+
%>F?@&
"
7
-*
" " " D %)
7 7 " 9 >FF@9 0>@?&
#" " %>FF@&9
%>FF4&
"
-* 7
" %B
"
%>FF4&9
"
%233R&9
%2333& 7
9 "
7
5 0 0 "
-*0 * 9 >FF4&
5 "
"
%
-*
0
9 "
9
"
]
%>FF4&
"
0,
FQ3 >FR3A 0 $"
9
F42&0 (
%
9( 7 7 "
" "
9U
9 >F?>&0 ,
9
" %
F43&
#" "
" "
7
2A
"
"
" " "
7 9 233P&0 *
R020>30 %>FRR&
7 9< "
"
" 0*
" " 9 0 "
0 * T *7
9$
9
%) 69 2333 & A " 0,
" "
#"
5 T "
7 "
" 7 %< 7
"
9 233P5 -" 0"
9 >FF3&0 97
"
,E0
9 9
" ,E
7 9
" "
7 "
" "
" 9 >F43& "
"
" 7
" 0 $
#"
0*
" 0* #"
7
" "
"
"
Q
7
7 "
%
Q0>0>
7
"
7
7 % RQ "
& "
"
7
0 -
9 - 7 "
7 "
%
FQ3A " 5 "
9 >FF2&0
7
"
7
"
C
"
"
7 " "
0 "
9 0$
"
"
>FP3A M >F@3A D
7
5 7
9 9
7
7
9
7 5
" %B
9 >FF?5
$
"
a
" "
9 >FFQ&
" " 7 ;= "
0 "
"
"
%+
9 >FF?&0 F43& "
#"
" " %>F?3& 9
" #" 0
9 "
"
7 #" "
" "
" #"
9 "
% 0 0 #"
9 "
" " "
" "
7
9 7 0+
"
9 >FFP & "
"
0(
" 9$
"
9 0
" "
/
* o
*
#" = " 7 = =
o
*
" "
;,
"
"
C D "
"
"
"
; "
"
"
;
" 7
"
"
7
" " 0 ,
7
#"
" " " "
"
7 " "
7
"
9$
"
"
wc { 9 "
"
T *7 /
9 >F439 0>>&0
r c {PP
%
&0
0* 7
7
" 9 233>&0
%
"
7 "
7
"
%$
"
-
"
"
"
0, "
7
"
7 9 0 7
9 0-
"
0
" "
0 FF@&
7 *
"
7
" 7 9 >FF?5 9 >FF2& " " " 7 7 " 97 "
" 9
0 7 "
#"
"
" '
7
"
0*
?@ %
" "
9 "" :"
9 * 0*
9
"
"
" 9 7
#"
%>FF@& C " D0 * " " " " 0 ) A 9
7 "
" 7
)
* D
" " D?Q
" 7 #"
%233>& C
" "
"
" %>FF>&
"
7 " 9 >FF?&0 #"
%B 7 "
7 7
" 0
;
2P2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>FF2&0 $ 7 %- a
7
7
7
"
" 9 9 >FFQ&0
7
)
"
:
7
"
"
" "
" " %
" %FF25 - 7 T 9 >FF2&0 * " 7 " " " " " " 7 " % & %( 9 >FF2&0 + ' A %>?@3& " 9 0 >?@25 " A %>??R& A 7 " 5 6A %>??4& " " a A %>F3>& #" ( A %>F23& " 7 " 5< A >FP> " - 7 A %>FQ@& " >F@3A 7 " " 0' )" *" %>F@Q& %< 9 >F@>5 9 >F@@5 B 69 >F@Q5 )" T *" 9 >F@Q5 9 233R5 9 >FFF5 T )" 9 >F?@&0 * A " " )" 9 B 69 -" *7 %>F4>9 >FF3& " " A 7 %< 6 9 >FF25 ( 9 >FF25 B " 9 >FF25 - 7 T 9 >FF25 - a 9 >FFQ&0 "
*
%>FF@& " 5 #" #" & #" " " * " "
#" 7 9 >FF25 B " - 7
A
% "
"
"
"
"
" "
7
" "
7
R>
0
" 7
P " 0(
?R
5 " "
5 " " 0 -" " " "
7
"
%
7 "
" "
9
" % C " "
"
D %-
a
5
" " "
"
& "
% " " 9 2333&0
"
"
%< 0
"
#"
7 7
" "
7 "
"
7 " "
9 >FFQ&0 ( " 0< "
"
% " #" 9 >FFF&0 * " : "
9 233>&
I7 0 *
"
" &9 " :
7 "
: 7 "
9
0
4.4.1.2 Rules of concatenation – the necessary additive structure "
"
"
" "
" " A #"
7
#" " %+
" " "
"
a
#" 7
7 #" #" 7 7
a " :
%
" " 9
%>FFF&
" 9 9 0 E" " " 9 "
0, #" 9
" %>FFF& 9 7
&0 * %>F3>&
9
?R
* "
"
*
A
A %>FF@&
C
D0 *
"
9" "
"
7 "
"
7
" "
9 >FFQ&0 *
#" #"
%
"
0$ 0* 9 >FFF&0 * 9 0* 7
#"
#" " " #" 7 " " " #" %>FFF& %( 9$ T *7 9 >F43&0 %>FFF& #" 7 " " 9 9 0* 5 : " 0* #" : " 0 " 9 #" a A " 0 a A 7 "
C
D "
0
2PP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
#"
-"
%>FR>& "
%>FP>& % " E &0 "
" 7
"
7
7
>0
9 0 0 0
*
9 >FFF&0 - 7 A " % " % 9 >F@Q " #" 7 /
9
9
7 9 2332&0
7 %>FFF9 2332& " " " 0 * :
7
" 5
c
6 " 6 "
20 P0 Q0
6 6
R0 @0 40
9
]6 ]6
c c
96] x6 96] c ]6 69 ] % ] 6& c % ] & ] 6
9 9
9 " 9
{
69 "
9
7
7
6c ]
"
"
9
"
"
7 "
9
*
#" "
9
"
" 0 *
" > M Q9
" " 7 0 7
0 "
7
"
7 "
"
7
9
"
7
0*
7
7 0>>@&0
"
=
0 ) " " ;, ;,
9 9 R M4
7 0 -"
" 7
"
5 " < 9 " ,
0 *
7 "
7
"
" "
0( :
9
9
" Q0Q020P
"
0 ) "
" " 9 " 7
" "
"
0
6
0
"
D%
0*
" "
/ C
"
7 0 ,
" "
0*
" " " 0?@*
%233R& "
7 9
7
" 9
7
:
"
7
7
"
"
"
" 9 "
x
9
9 "
" " 0,
#" "
"
%
"
"
&
:
0* "
x
Ax A
" 0*
0, % A
A&
"
0*
" " #"
" 0 7 &0 :
" 7 0' A
#"
' )"
A %>F?@&
"
0
" 7 "
:
0=
" " " "
"
7
" "
" "
%
" "
"
"
" "
7 9
"
7 0>4F >?3&0
7
% 7
' Q020> 9
4.4.1.3 Conjoint measurement as fundamental extensive " " =
?@
9 T=
*
7
" "
% 0 (
9 >F23&
7
9 >F4F&
"
4
7 "
%
T )"
%>FFF9 0R>&0 0R2 @2
: " % 9 >F?@&0 ,
%>F@Q9
T )"
9 >F?@5
9
2& 7
0
2PQ
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" #"
"
7
"
7 0+
"
0
7
9* "
7
9 :
"
%
" D
#" " "
9 233P &
" 7
" " " 0 '
7
" 9 233P&0 *
%
7 9 "
" 7 " 9 233P &/
?0 F0 >30
7 ,''
" " #" 7 " 9 233P & " %1
9
#" 7 "
%>F?3& 7
9 9 ,''
7 ,''
9 9
}
} 9 } 9
9 7
9
} } 9 }
" "
"
7 "
" "
"
#" ;
7
#"
"
#"
"
>F3Q9 "
A
9 #" " "
c
0
" 7 9 233R&0 * 9 %= 9 >FF4 &0 ' " @2
7 %
} "
> R0 7
7
#" 7
0?4 " ) 7 A %>FP4& " " 7 % = 9 >FF4 &0
"
"
0 &%
"
?4
" 7
#"
%
" "
0*
"
7
:"
" 7 :" #"
A C
7
7
? >3 " %
] c " "
7 9 #"
&
9 7
7
0
7
8=
2PR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
@2
"
+
>
" R9
"
>c
92c
" 7
7
9Pc
#"
" 9Qc
9,
7
Rc7
"
"
9
`
/
•
,
7 -
2
P
Q
R
1 6 A
>
2
P
Q
R
A
*
=
•
( *
"
" "
==' "
"
" V
9 >FF4 9 0PQ
" #" *
9 "
-"
,
0 +" "
+
A
>
7 " A C 9 >FF4 &0 +
%=
" D "
"
/ " "
#" 9 >F3Q
0 FF4 9 0PQ
=
0 A
/ %(
7
9
>FF> & • •
" 1 6
0*
A "
•
" 0
•
"
" " "
C >
/
7
"
" A
"
" 7
7
8& "
"
"
"
0
9 "
"
*
" 7 "
" #"
"
7 7
0,
" 9 #"
9
9 "
" "
*
" " /
%
"
"
7
#" 7
" " :
"
& "
" 0=
#" 7 "
% "
7
VV
A %233P& / • *
•
;*
"
M
• •
D
"
2
"
•
"
"
"
" 7
"
,
7 7
/
" 7
;"
%
&
7 :"
"
2P@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
"
" 5
•
T=
9 >FF4&
"
" 7
%>?@Q >F3F
" "
• "
9 % ≥>
9
& " %
7
7
7 9
"
5
9
" "
"
&
7 "
9 • •
* $"
7 " G A
:" " 7
#" 7 • • •
"
7
#" #"
C#"
"
9
D
"
9 233P9 02Q&
" #"
" " "
" 9 " "
" " 7
9
"
0
7
:
"
" 9 2332&0 "
" & %
FRF& % - a 9 >FFQ& : : " %- a 9 >FFQ&0 * 2332& 7 " #" : "
" C
"
"
*
%
"
7 7
7 "
"
#"
"
%
%
% &
9
#"
C *
9 "
5 9
"
" 7
*7 % "
"
%>F43& 9 >F??&
%
7 " & • •
: 7
"
7 "
"
" %
O
7 o
*
7
0*
7 7
#"
& 7
7
7
" 7 " 7 " 0 -"
7 9
"
" 7
2P4
0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
??
> >3 $ "
7
Q0Q0>02
%B 9 >FF?&9 Q0Q0>0P
% &/
(
$ " |% & ]
% &0
#" "
7
%
FFF& " < , * 7 " 0* " 7 " 0 " " " 7 9 " 7 "
" "
9 >FFQ5 9 < 0?F *
& "
7 9 } 9 233R&/
2
" T
" , *
%1
: " " 9 233P&0
>
9 >F445 9T=
P&
7 % 7 %
2
*
2&
%
&
0
P
" " %< = 9 >FFF5 =
o
P % P9 % P9 % P9
>&
P
P
o
2& P&
} " % >9
2 % 29 % 29 % 29
>&
%233R&0
7 7
P@ " 7
" 0
"
< "
" 7 7
"
0(
"
0
2P?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9 " 5
7
" "
9
"
" :
9 :9
A
/
θ ] β:
% :& c %
o
θ ] β:
>]
5 β:
:&
" ,
o
7 7
>
7
/
%
:&
%
θ ] β:
c
:&
"
o o
θ
:
30R
0
*
:
• • •
" 9 % :& 7 5 0 0 % :& ≥ % &9 % & ≥ % &9 % :& ≥ % &
• •
% %
&≥
:&
%
≥ :&
%
"
&
" %
• • • * 7 >F@Q&05 0 0
"
7A
" " 7 9 •
"
B
"
7A
7
"
%
"
, θ 2 ] β > ≥ θ> ] β 2 θP ] β 2 ≥ θ2 ] β P θ2 ] β > ] θ P ] β 2 ≥ θ> ] β 2 ] θ 2 ] β P θP ] β > ≥ θ> ] β P " " 7 " "
B
& " &
"
"
#" 9 233R&0 *
" " %
FF?& "
9
9
" " "
" :
, ! B "
A
" "
" #"
0 0*
9 " 0,
"
"
" "
"
"
#"
, *9 " " 0
7
7 "
" 7
"
%
"
8
2PF
0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
4.4.2 Test theory
FF4& " " " 9 9
*
"
"
" 7 "
A " "
9
#" D % 0>4@&0
" < "
$
"
"
0
0
" C
7 #"
" %2332& "
"
7 %>FFF& 7
"
"
7
"
"
7
"
9
FF4&
" "
"
0 F@?&0
9 >FF4&0 0* 7
"
7
9
&0 "
%
" "
"
M
"
" "
9
P
7 " :"
"
0
7
0
" 0+
#"
9
"
7 0
" 7 "
0
7 "
7 "
A
"
7
7
"
"
9 >FFF&0 $ & #"
" *
"
0 ,
"
$
0
"
7 "0( "
7
"
"
9 >FFQ&0 7 "
"
>F23A %
7 " % " ' " 9
%
7
"
"
" 7
A
*
"
"
" *
P&0 $ " "
9
"
#" "
7 " 7
"
0 $ "
7 7
7
% "
"
0
0
$
0 , " " 0,
"
9
"
7
7
7
"
7
"
7 ;, "
"
"
0*
" 0 ' " 7 "
9 "
" "
"
" "
"
7
"
" " "
" "
@P
#" 9
"
0* 7 "
7
"
7
"
0 0 ,
9 7
/
" "
7
" "
" " 7 0 ("
0$
"
#" 0=
0* " 0 ("
7
" " 7
" 7 "
"
7 7
"
"
" 7
0
2Q3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
9
A
"
"
"
5
" 7
7 "
0*
"
%-
0 7
" % " " " 0 $" "
7
' "
"
7 A
% 0 5
FFF& 7 9 " A 9 2333& %B 9 >FF?&0
" " 0
" 7
"
7 "
0*
"
6
, *
9 #"
" 9
&
" "
7 " "
"
"
9
9
" %233@&0 *
(**
, *
"
0
@P *
"" /
*
, $
'" "
"
,
$
C
F>
0=
" 7
D
"
9
"
0
2Q>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
4.4.2.1 Representational measurement: the legacy of Stevens’ arbitrary powerful scales of measurement "
5 " 9
7 " " 7
9 >FF?&0F2
FQ@& " "
" " 0' "
7 %>FR?& /
-"
U
%>F@P& %
7
χ c { `9 ≥ ->V V V V V 0- x
o
9 " 0 +
7 - 7
7 " 0< " " "
" "
"
T )"
9 >F?@&0
"
≥ ->V V V V V 0-
7
" " 0 *
7
`0 •
" " "
"
7
5
9 " "
" &0
9
"
" 7 %>F?@&
9 )"
%
A " " " "
"
7
7
0*
7 "
#" •
"
" "
ℜc{
o
9≥
>V
7
x0
VVVV0
"
2
" " 0 7
•
)
9
χ
7
ℜ0 -
" "
7
" 5
- 7
>FQ@9 - 7
7
"
0*
" 7 " A #" 7 7 %>F3P&9 1 %>FP@& T )" 9 >F?@&5 1 A % 9 2332&0
( "
9
FF49 0* " " 0 7 - 7 A 7 " " A
7
T=
%- 7 9 >FFQ&0 * 7 "
7 7 %
"
"
"
- 7 7
9 6 T
-
7
" "
7 % 9 )
"
"
"
" 9 2332&0
%
F@@5
7
"
7
F2
%
"
"
7
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
-
>FQ3 '
A 0*
"
%
- 7 #"
0 0(
"
"
A
" 7 "
"
A
"
"
5
"
" '
"
"
" %B " 9 >FF25 9 >F@Q& " " " 2332& :" -" 9 233>&0 - 7 " #" 0- 7 A >FFF5 9 >F@Q& " "
"
%>FQ@&
9 7 "
"
7
"
" " =
9
"
9
" 7 9 >FQ@&
" A 7 "
"
" " 9 233P9 0>3&0
9
2Q2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%
FFF9 2333&0 ' " #"
"
7
@Q
" "
9
#"
0 " "
9
7 9
"
0 *
"
" "
" 0
%>F@Q9
" 7 0* " "
"
" "
" %
@Q
/
"
"
' "
0F@ F4&
"
"
9
"
&0
"
/
7
#"
"
" 7
#" + :
9 9 "
" 9
9
7 %,''&
9 "
"
9 96
0 * "
A9 A9 6A
" " "
0 0
:
9
"
9
9
"
"
"
"
" " 9 "
:
"
0
"
9
C
D0 -
"
8
9 " "
4.4.2.2 Classical test theory – a goal for inferenceFP * %-
7 9 >FFF& "
"
7
"
"
7 7
"
7
0* "
7 7
FP
" Z
[ 7
/
" 0* "
9 D %>FFF9 >FF&0
#"
7
" 7 %
G " A
C
"
" G
A O
7
2QP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
5 (
9 >FFF9 0>F3&0 * /`% 7 &c*% " &] % & %< 9 >F?@5 $ 9 >FFF5 9 >>F4 9 >FFF5 B 9 233R5 " 9 >FFF5 >FFQ5 " 9 >FF25 " 9 >FF>5 - 9 >FF@5 -" 9 >FF3&0 * % G " A " 5 $" < 9 >F43& " 7 >F3Q " %( T 9 >F?@5 $" < 9 >F435 " $ 7 9 >FF?&0FQ C$ " Z " 7 0 [9 " 9 7 7 D %9 >FFF9 0>FF&0 ( %(**& " 9 " 9 " 7 " %-" 9 >FF3&0 ( (** " % 9 >FFQ& " 7 " " " " 0 $" 7 9 " " " 7 " %= 9 2332&0 * " 9 < %233R&9 " 5 9 " 0 , (** 6 " " % " >FFF&0 * " " " " " " 9 B %>F?>& " " 0* (** % $ 9 >FFF& %(**A 5 ( >FF?&0 * 7 " " " " %(**A " 5 B 9 >FF?5 ( 9 >FF?&9 %B 9 >FF?5 9 >F?3&0 * 7 " #" 7 :" (**0 7
9 >F?@& %-
#" 9 233Q5 ( T
"
9
7
" 7
97
9
7 9 >F?P5
&% $
7 (
% 9 >FF?&0 *
"
9 >F?R&0 (** 9 >FFF&0 " 6 9 (** , *
"
" , *
(** "
7
A
" %-" 9 >FF3&0
97
*
" " 0
( -
"
7
"
0
"
-0 9 >F?>&
'
" =
%23329 233P&
" "
(** %< " &
%
T 0 (** " %
0 9 2332&0 * " &0 ' " @@ "
"
" 7
" 0 *
7 9
" 0+ 0, (**
= %
(**
0
0(
9 7
FQ
"
"
"
#" "
7 (**
"
(** " 7 " 0 (** "
"
, * 9
"
7
"
7
"
5
T T
9
"
@R
9
"
9
" 7 "
"
5
" 7 " " "
""
" A
7 #"
9
%
" (**
7
"
%
7
7 0
"
"
(** 7
7 , * " (**9
7
" "
7
T
0 (**
" 9
"
T 9
A
" " "
%7
7
"
"
"
" #"
"
&
7 7
" 9 "
' "
9 >FFF&5
%
" %-
9 >FFF&0
2QQ
5
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
@R (
>0 20 P0 Q0
(** %=
`c*] ` c *- ] *7 ] ` c *- ] ] ` c *- ] *. ]
9 23329 233P&
(** ]
"
-!-*
`/ */ " 7 " / / 7/ 7 / /
' "
0*
0 = "
%233P&
"
7
5 C
"
7 7
"
" " "
9
#"
"
D A9 G
7
7
7 G
"
0*
7 CA6 7
A9 G G
@@
A9 G A9 G AD % 0FR&0
9
7 7
7
A9 A
"
7
"
*c "
*
" "
-!-*
(c
"
*
"
%
7
"
"
&
" " * " " "
7
0
,
,
( "
"
(**
, *
O %
7
5
"
9 >F?2&
O
9
"
"
9 "
" "
" " " "
7 9
0*
" 7
9 (** 0 = %233P&
(**5 7 (** % % $ ',& " "
9
"
, *&0
" "
@40 *
"
A $ "
"
Q0Q02020> "
(**0
2QR
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
@4 *
/ "
A
$ ', %=
]] ]]
49? 5] P
> >
R
P
]]
4
R
F
4
]
9 233P9 0F@&
]]
5]
>2
F
]]
>P
>2
]
]]
>P9>Q
]
5]
>R
>P
>F923 >?
>R
>F
>?
]
2>
>F
]
5]
2>
]
]
]
]]
5]
%49 ?&
2
Q
2
@
Q
?
@
(
7
%>P9 >Q& >3
?
>>
>3
>Q
>>
>@
>Q
,
%>F9 23& >4
>@
(
7
>4
23
22
23
,,
22
(
7
]
* , "
*
$ ',
"
"
(**
"
"
" 9
A 7 "
"
97
" 0( " "
7 " "
0* 9
7 97
7 , *
"
"
:
"
7
0 * "
%= MC
#" "
" D %=
9 233P&0
7 9
9 " 9 0F@&0 7
7
, * 7
7
0
V
2Q@
,,,
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
(
"
7 "
V
*
0' 7 , E> E4
#" 7
E25 7 E4
E? &5
E2 EP E?
, E2 7
EQ5 7
"
E@ "
EP
E4
E?5
5
EP
E@&
0 9
* ,
7 " E>Q
7 EP5 , EP 7 E@ %
7 7
5 E2 E@ %ER E>P
7
9
%E&/
" EQ
EP
7 "
E@ E4
ER
"
"
5 ER9
7 9
7
"
E@
"
, *
"
* "
"
#" T=
"
9 >FF@9 0>PQ&0
" " 7
C,
9 " 77 % 5C 7 " %
7 D%
"
" "
7
"
*
"
7
7
"
5 " ,
9 " " 9 >FF49 0?3&0 #" 9 9 " &9
)
" 77
" 9 D% 7
" 9B " "
9
"
" G
"
9
"
#" 1 9
A ;,
A #"
;,
" 9
0 , "
#"
"
"
7 9
7
9
#" " 0 (**
#" "
0 , 7
" ""
7
7
9
"
"
7 0 C(**
0 -"
7
7
0 "
9
"
"
7 " A
" 6 D 9
) 7 "
G
7 0,
"
"
" 7 " 9 9
" & %>F?R9 0Q?4&0 * " 5 9 0
"
#"
7 "
"
7 " 0 C,
7 D %=
9 >FFF9 0>2@&0 *
"
"
7
#"
0 " "
(** " 7
%>FF4& , *A
%
FR3A >F23A 0 " %, 7 T$ 9 >FF>5 1 9 >FF2& " 0$ A 7 " %- : 9 >FFP &0 9 7 9C " D %) 9 >FF4 & " 7 " 9 " 7 " " % 9 >F?4& 0* " % 9 2333&/
%1
*
" "
5
" 7
C"
"
F@29 04& " " D 7 0 (**A >F@29 , * 9 >FF4 & " " " 0< %>F@4& " (** 9 " , * 7 7 C 7 " D %< 0,
*
" 7 9 >F?>&9
""
7 9 2333 &0 *
< %
"
7 %
"
"
0
"
A
%
0
9 233P&
"
7 >FFF&0 $ " %*6"
" 7 9
7
,E " 8 " " T %1 9 >FF2&0 7
% 9 >FFR5 -
09 >FF@&0
T
%7 >FF29 2333&0 *
"
7
"
-:
"
7
"
#" " 7 " "
" "
A "
7
8 >FR2 >F@3
"
" " %< 9 >F@4&0 $ 7
9 9 >F@45 %>FFF& 7 "
9 >FF> 9 2333&9 "
" 0
-
"
7 "
#" 7 " :
5
"
7 C
7
D0 , % :" " "
, "
0 * " D
C 7 0
F@4 " "
7
0$
% " : 7
7
7 7
#" "
"
9 >F43&0 )
%>F@4&
"
7
#"
T '"
"
#" 9 2333& " "
%(
&;
7 0
7
9
%>FFF9 "
9
" %
9 >F?4&
2Q?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" %>FQ@&0 ,
- 7 0)
9
7 7
7 " " 9
"
"
" "7
"
T
(**
" %
9 >FF4 &0 (** " 9 >F?4& "
2332
"
" T '"
%( 9 >FFR&0 + "
%"
"
7 "
, *
9 233@& " , *7 7
" "
7 (**
9 >F435
- " , *% "
9 9 23325
C $ < %2333& " 0* 0 ) 6 %2332&
7
D "
" "
0 C,
"
"
9 " D % 0>2P&0
" 7 9
9 7 9 ) 6 %233P&
"
5
9
0 (
"
>FP3A
"
%=
9
"
7 " 9 >FFR&0
9=
"
7
"
#"
9
= %>FR4
9 >FFR&0 (
T '"
" ( 9 >F43&0 "
"
9
'"
9
"
%>F43&
%=
9
" T $"
FFQ&0
4.4.2.2.2 Generalizability theory "
7
"
" T$ 7 7
"
9 >FF?5 -" 7 " " "
(**A 7 " " ( 9 9 9 >FF3&0 * "
"
"
"
9 :
" 7 "
%>F42& %
"
%
(** %( "
7
% "
%(
T
9 >F?@&0 , 9 >FFF& "
(** % "
%
T$ 6 0
6
"
" %
7 7 "
9 >FF4&
:" 7
" "
"
&0 , 7 %)" 6 T ) 9 >FFF&0 " 7
"
6
" 9 (**
0 >F4?&0
6 9 >FF?&
"
" "
9 >FF35 " T $ 6 9 >FF4&0 ( 7
7 7 "
6 9 >FFF5 "
" A
$ 9 >FFF5 " " " 9 >FFF& 9 " 6
9 >FF?& 6 %)" 6 T )
9 9 >FF?5
"
7 "
"
0 "
"
% "
9
" %-" " "
7
T
9 >F?@5
" "
: " % " >FF?&0 =
% " " " 9 >FF45 B 7
T$ 6
FFF&0 " 9 " % (** " "
6 9 &
0. "
9 >FF?&0
7 (**
7 7
%
& 7 #"
7 (**
7
9
T$ 7 "
9
"
"
5 " "
"
7 7
9 >F?>&0 + " 9 " 7 " :
" A
6 T $ 7
" "
"
#"
" "
6 %(
9 >FF3&0 *
"
% " 6 (**0 ,
"
2QF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9
6 0
FFF&
%
7 0 "
"
T
"
7 "
6
"
= "
7
7 "
7 " , *9
"
%
"
"
"
:"
0 "
7 " #" "
9 "
#"
&
"
6
" 6
7
6
" %>FFF& "
"
0
, * " "
, *
0
9 T
6
"
%>FFR& 7 , * "
9 >FF25 B " % " " 0 *
7
7 6
9 >FF3&0 * % " T
" %>FFF&
"
" % "
, *
7 " 7
$
0 "
:" 7 #"
0
=
7
" "
"
&
"
"
"
7
6 9 >FFF&
" 0 '
7 9 >FFF&0
$ 9 "
7
7
9" 9 >FF?5 " "
7 7
" % 9 >F?@5 $ " 9 >FF25 -" " " 7 (** 0 .
T
" " "
$
5 (
T $ 7 7 "
7 7 9 9 >FF?&0 * " 7
233Q&0 $ 7 " #" 7
"
9
9
6 7
7 0,
7
0
"
, *
9
0
4.4.2.3 Modern test theory *
9
2333&0 * % 7 233Q&0 , %< %
"
7
" "
" 7 " 7
7
" 9
T . 9 >FF>&0
T
7
9 233P&
" >F43A
0,
7
#"
" "
7
, *
"
0FR*
"
(** %
F?3&0
%= 7
" "
5 7 "
7
%>F?P&
9
A
"
-
, %>F?P& >FQR 9 >FQR
* "
"
7
7
A >F3Q T 9 " 9 "
9 233R5
>F23A "
"
9 " B
(** %
FF4&0
2R3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
:"
7
7 9 9 >FF@&0
%
7
7 "
9, * " 7 %
9
7
"
"
7
7
D %(
7 " " %< " "
7 7
*
7 "
"
C %
"" 9 >FF4&0 , 9 7 %( 9 >F@4&0 ' " 7 " 7 7 09 233P5 9 >FF?&0 * 7 " 7 " " 7 ;
FF25 ' _ 6< 9 23335 1 9 23335 " = 9 233Q&9 " " % 69 T 9 >FF@&0 " 9 < " %>FRR&0 * " 7
θ
" Σ %" : θ,&
"
" 7 9 23335
" "
9< "
" " 9 233R&0 9 %>FFR& " " "
7 % ,E " T9 >FFR5 9 " % " 9 >F?25 B 9 >FF?5 7 " " " " 7 " 9
0* " 7
&0 (
" 7
7
&
"
7
7 9 >FFR5
T* " T. %
9 >FFP5 " T
9 "
7 (
7 0
9
" "
" :5
"
$0
&0 $ 9 %233P& % " 7 7 " " 7 0 "
0* :
7
#"
"
"
7
"
"
" 9.
& %< 7
#"
"
9 233Q&; * 9
" 7
"
6
" " % "
T ;
FF3&
0* ;(
"
0
FF4& 7 "
" "
"
"
"
9 " , *
"
"
"
"
" " 7 " C
"
%
#" D
"
" 0 7
9 >FFF&0
2R2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
0 * 7 "
0 * 7 " A * " M
" 0 7 7
#" "
7 " A " " 0 , #" #" 7
7 " A
&
" " "
7 9
&9
" "
"
"
"
"
%0 9
"
0>2@&0 " " " , *
7
&
%0 9 "
"
#" " %>F4>& %
9 %
" 0, 7 %
%
&"
#" " " 0C C "
"
0 %
"
"
9
9 D&
A 7 D%
9 233Q9 "
" 0
"
7
9 7 "
"
" 6
9
0*
7
9 "
"
9 233Q&
7
, *%
"
&
(** %
"
9 "
&
9 >FF4 &/
0
+
"
(** " >M " 2M " P M #" " QM " RM , * " >
0 0 0 0 0 " 0
0
0
"
2M
0 0
" "
PM QM
" 7 "
"
" 9
" " "
"
9
" "
7
" , *
7
"
9
O
"
" 0,
#"
" " 0 *
#"
" 0
"
RM :"
7
7
% #"
"
( "
"
;, 0 * "
" " "
7 "
%
7
#"
"
7 "
&
"
"
#"
" %233Q&0
7
"
"
7
"
"
#"
%233P9 233Q&
7 %
FFQ&0 , " ; )" 9
" 7 9 0
0 #"
7
"
" 9
"
"
0
9 #" 7
"
" 0
7 "
#"
7
" #"
" 0,
" 0 -"
#"
"
#"
$
"
"
0=
"
"
7
7
"
"
0,
7
" "
0 #"
"
9 A #"
9
" "
"
" "
9 9
7
:
&
" 9 233Q5 (
T 9 " ;* " " " " D% 9 233Q9 0>2Q&0 , " " T < 9 >FFR5 9 >F?P&9 " " " 0= 9 233R& 9 ;, " 7
#"
7 9 >FF2&0 *
"
"
7 "
;C "
" " 9
"
7 "
% 9 %
"
7 ;= "
0
2RP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
"
7
#"
7 7
" "
" " "
"
0 0 0
= = =
" 0 +"
< #"
#" 9 233R&/
%
FF>&
%.
"
" %233P9 233Q& " ; %< T M " " 29 P Q
0
"
%
% &
9
"
#" "
%
33
7
"
(
"
"
+.
,
7
7 "
("
'
)
-
• •
-
•
+.
•
•
" %)
9 >F4Q&
•
E" %( -
T
( " >F4P9 >F?2& )
#" %
%B "
T )
T
F4>&
9 >F@P& ("
'
• •
+ #" % 0F@@&
( *
%*"
•
9 >F@P&
•
" 9 >F?2& #" 9 >F?2& #"
>F4@5 B $ >F445 B
• ,
•
7 "
• •
( >F42& C* " D '"
#"
%+A(
"
9 >F@P5 %B
"
T
9
%B
9 >F?2&
9 %)
9 >FR?& " %( 9 >F42&
%=
T
bb) bb
bb
T • • • •
%' ) ' ) >F?3& (
9 >F4Q5
T-
9 >F4?& ))
"
%'
T
9 >F4F5 '
9
9 >F?2& %) 6
9 >F@@5
"
%
9 >F4?&
-
• • • • • • •
>33
(
"
*
" "
% m "
T
9 >F?2& %= ( >F@R5 " , 7 ( ,
9 >F4?&
%$ 9 >F44& " %B " 9 >F?2& % 9 >F?>& %6 9 >F4F& %' " 9 >F4F&
T
0
2RR
9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
A
"
% "
"
7
)(]&
Q0Q02029 >F?3A "
#" T
)(
% "
9 233Q5 = 9 >F?F& " %< 9 >F@29 >F@45 9 >FF25 7 9 23335 ) 69 >FF>&0 , 7 " #" " 7 ( . %233R& " " " 0* 0 7 7 % 7 9 9 T U 9 233R& 7 7 " %$ 9 T= 9 >FFR5 % " & " 7 7 " %= 9 >F?F& 7 " 7 %B " 9 233Q&0 ( , * " " " " %B 9 >FF?&9 " A " % )(& % T ( " " %-)* & % 9 >FF4 9 2333&0 * 7 , * " " %B 9 >FF4& %- " 6 9 233R& " 7 " % " 9 >F??&0 ( 9 A" " " " % " 9 >F4?& A " 7 #" 7 0
*
"
*
7 )(A9 >FF> 9 >FF> & " "
% &
9 >F?25
(
23335
" " " " %'
7
9
T " " 5
9 >FFQ9 >FF4 & %, 9 >FF>&0
9 233Q& 0 * 7
"
%
7
9 >FF?&0 $" >3>
7 7
7 " 9
% T * 6 9 >FFQ&0 7 9 9 >FFP & 7 7 " 7 9 233R&0 , " " " % 9 >F?4&0 $ 7 9 " " %( T 9 >F?@&0 , 9 " 0 θ9 C " θ 7 θ
%< 9
9 2333&0 * 7
%- : %
9 >FF> &0 ,
7 %
7 7
9 0.
" 9 7 7 D %>F?39 044&0 &
"
" A
0
7
"
"
9
D
7
"
'
"
>3>
9
*
%
' #"
7
0
" D%
%>FF49 0>F3&
9 >FF4 9 022R&0 &0 7
"
% "
"
9
7
7 " 9 " 9 " 0 $
" " #"
7
"
7
" 0, 7
"
C
#" " 7
7 "
7 9 #"
"
7 7
"
"
7 7
2&0
7 %>FF4&>32 "
" 7
>32
" "
:" , *
5
0 *
"
6 A C
#"
7
" 9
0* "
"
" 0
7
"
7
0$ "
C D % 0>?F&0
7 "
% " 9 "
" %
&0
2R@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" "
)( "
'
" :
)
9
A
7 "
%>F?R&
A %>F42& 7 "
"
" " "
)(5 &0 * 9 >FF@&0 0
7 "
7 " %
9 >FF> &0 , 7
#"
9 2333&
%)) 7 " %
&9
A 9 >FF> &0
" >3P
=
7
%
" "
%7
=
7
"
9 7 9 7
7
" "
))
#" "
7
%
0 *
=
)( 9 "
7
" "
7
7
7 7
0*
Λ
" "
"
/ *
>? - " "
"
, " "
7 9 >F@45 B
%( 7
:"
7 θP
θP
"
7 /
"
#"
%
" "
*
>]
3
λ% &
%
%Σ
λ% &
>0 *
T=
"
" 7 & %-
/
%( " 9
%2332& " " "
"
=
" "
'
"
D % 9 " 7
9
T. 9 >FFP&0 , 9 >FFR&0 * #"
)(
"
"
#"
#" 7 9 >FF>9 0QFF&0 0$
"
=
"
"
7 "
9 %θ&
0+
" 0 C*
9
"
0,
" "
"
9 9 >FF4&0 * T '" 9 >F435 % T -: ; 7 9
#"
"
"
"
"
" "
9
" 9
9"
9 >FF4&0 % "
,
"
7 0*
"
"
'
" )(
&
>?0 $
"
>3P
"
9 233Q&
5β 5 λ% C
" " " Λ
"
"
(
θ: M β &
>3R
9=
T
θ: M β &
" %
5 θ2 " #" & " "
A %>FF>9 >FF29 23335
9 23339 0R>P& 7 " % 9 >F?49 >FFR&9 % 9 >FFR&0 +
5
9
7 7 7
7 5 θ:29 V 9 θ:
D%
"
9
" 0 θ>
9 2333&0 *
7
>3R
>?
&c
&
>3Q
>3Q
θP 3 3 >
A θ>
" "
%Σ
θ:>
9 9 >F?>&0 $"
θ2
"
0 *
%` % &: c >θ:9 β ,9 λ %
θ2 3 > >
0*
θ> θ2
7
θ> > > >
+ > 2 P
Λ
"
"
" %β&
" "
"
" 7
0 "
"
0 ;
2R4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
7
#" 0 7 A %>FF> 9 >FF29 >FFR9 2333&
A %>FF2& " /
"
7
0
• " 0.
"
" 7 7
• 7
9
" " 0
"
7
" >3@
7 "
" 7 7
" "0 ,
9
7
0, "
(**
"
7
7
#" Q0Q0>02
"
9
7
" 7
9
"
0,
7
7
•
" #"
7 %
#"
" & " 9
, *
7
7
0,
" -
9 >F4F&0 * 7
•
" >FFP5 -
7 "
"0 9< "
a
• %=
9 T
%=
7
"
"
" T=
9 =
"
%B " 9
9 >FFP& " 7 9 >FF4&
T
, * 0 $" )( 7
"
A
"
" •
7
A
7
" "
7 •
"
! % $
•
7
-*& "
9C
"
7
" 0 )
D "
9
" / • • • • •
"
"
"
" 7 7 7
"
9
0,
A %>FFR&
)(] 7
0, 7
7
)( " " %
9
"
7
" " " " 9 >FFR&0 0$ 7 9
"
"
FF@&0 *
0' "
&
0
"
" #" 7 9 >FF> &0 ( %>FF> &
/: " 9
"
7
"
3@
"
" #" "
@F
Q0P0>02
"
" (** 9 23339 0R>?& 0 , 9 , * " "
*
%
%-" 9 >FF3&0 + " 0 "
" "
"
"
"
%-"
% %
" " 7
"
"
F?@&0
2R?
9 &9
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
7 "
7 " % 7 " "
" 7
9
"
&
"
7
/
7
#"
7
7
0*
"
"
7 "
0,
#" ;*
(
"
A %>FF>& "
7
0
' "
@F
7
#"
%
9 >FF> 9 0>?F&
ξ : c θ: ,
>
7
,
>
7
> V V 00V 0 ,
*
1
- "
,
"
$
V V 00V 0 ,
9
1
7 9"
, *
A " 7
,
7
7 7 "
> V V 00V 0 ,
"
1
7
"
0 $ < A %2333& " " 0 $ < A %2333& " " " %233R& 9 "" T+ FF? % 9 233R&0 ( 7 7 7 7 9 "" " % 9 233R&0 * :"
%$
P
7
%( *& ( * 7
, * 7 "
9 7 " 0 "
9
"" 7 " C
/ 7 7
"
7
9 " "
"
" " 7
+
" 7
"
7
7
7 "
7 #" 7 " "
" "
7
7 "
" 9 233R&
" 0*
" 7
7 Q
9"
0 7 7
9 5=
7 7
7
9 *
%
" 7 0 *
7 "
% "
P 7
"
/
" 7
2RF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" " 7
&0
%233R& "
(
7
0*
"
F?F& &
7
7
C D 9 233Q&0 7 " 7 7 9 " " = %>F?F& " 7 " " %= T$ 9 >FF4&0 * 7 7 " 7 7 " " 7 " " 7 7 >3? % &9 " %< 9 >FFP5 ' T' 9 >FF45 ' T 9 >FF?5 9 23335 T= 9 >F?35 1 T 9 >FF@5 T - " 69 >FF45 ( " 9 >FF45 T : 9 23335 T 9 >FFR5 - " 6 9 233R5 9 23335 -" 66 9 23335 . T 9 >FF2&0 7 #" A " >3F % 9 9 ' = 9 ) 9 " T = 9 >FF@5 " "9 >FFP&0 * 7 #" %( 9 2332&0 7 " 7 " " 9 " % 7 & " %T 9 2332&0 , 7 " 7 " 7 " " " 0 = " " " ;* " 7 7 9 " " " 0 ";* #" " 0* " 5 0 ' " " 0 * " - " " 0* " ' 9 F?F& - " " A % * @F 7 & 7 % T ( 9 233Q&0
" 0*
"
%
"
"/
"
>3F
7 " 7
0 7
"
"
" %( -
7 %$ W9 >FF>&0 * 3?
)
%
>34
7
-
8
:"
0 9 23335 B" 9 >FFQ& "
" "
9 23335 " " 7 7 "
(
9 2333&0
" " 7
A %
7 "
7 " 7
7
5
7
:" " 7 9 >FF25 < T : " " 7 6
" 7 9 >FFQ&0
7 7
7 0
7
7 ;
7
2@3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
$"
"
9 =
%>F?F& "
A
"
" 7 0,
" "
%
"
"
0=
"
A
&-
%>F?F&
"
"
"
7
7
7
5
9
"
"
"
7
7
"
7
9
"
0= "
"
A %>F?F& %θ
O
7
"
"
0
7
" "
-
9 7
"
7 7
β:&
A
"
" >>3
"
7
0
"
θ
0= 7
"
"
7 A %>F?F& 8
, * 9
#" " 9
9
/
β: ] Σ φ τ 9
c >9V 9 9 : c >9 V 9)0 c
φ
5τ
:
"
7
"
"
9
9 φ c %φ >9V 9 φ & "
c 9
" 0*
"
0
" 3
0$
%:&
%&c
/
:
ψ %σ :&
" :
φ c>
"
"
% :θ 9 β :9 τ 9 φ & c Zψ %σ :&[
: Z>
ψ %σ :&[ >
τ
&
:
%σ :&
ψ %σ :& c
%σ :&
>]
%θ ] β: ] Σ φ c
%θ ] β: ] Σ φ
>]
τ
" 9
&
"
9
"
c%
" < %:&
7 &=
0 7
: Z>
ψ %σ :&[
>
"
+ "
" " " " A >F@3
7 "
7 % ( ) &
"
%
9= %>FF@& % "
"
7
9
T=
9 >FF4&0 * 09 >FF4&0 *
)(
" " "
" "
" " "
" 9
7
A =
"
%
" "
:
, *
*
7
&/
"
>>3
/%
7
"
0 +
"
9 &
"
"
% θ 9 β9 τ9 φ,& c Π: Zψ %σ :&[
•
%>F?F&
>9V
%= 9
7 , *& %
" " 9 233Q&0
A
)(A
%
9
% T = 0 , "
( ) &9 9 >FFR&
&
2@>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" 7 T=
"
"
9 >FF4&0 1
0,
" %= 7 "
T= 7
9 >FFR&0 , " " %=
=
"
%
" 9 >FFR&0 7 09 >FF4
T=
9=
"
" #"
" 9
" "
( )
5 0 0 ( )
%>FF4&0 *
9 >FFR& "
9 #"
=
T=
6
" 9 0-
"
%= 9
7 7 3
" #"
>
7
7
0*
9
/
% : θ ] ′: ξ&
%`: c >5 9 9 ξ θ& c
9 9 % c39>9 V 9 :&0 `: `: >
:
Σ
% : θ ] ′: ξ&
7
7
7 "
7 7
′0 ξ
/
θ& c Ψ %θ9ξ&
%` c
30 `′
9
c>
:]>
7
7 7
Z ′ % θ ] ξ&[
:
0 * % c >9 V 9
" c >9 V 9
:
0*
0 * "
7 9
=
:
>
Σ
Ψ %θ9ξ& c
3
Z6′ % θ ] ξ&[
θ
0
( ) 9
θ29 V θ$& %=
( )
" T=
" 0*
7
′0 ,
>
7
"
0
"
9 $9
"
7 9 9 :
0
0*
9 *
( ) ( ) /
"
θ
c %θ>9
7
$ `> " 9
9
"
0 7
:
>>
9 233R& ( ) " % c>9 V 9 $&
9
>
5 "
6∈Ω
*
&
%=
T=
9 >FFR&0 *
%
( ) &9
% : θ ] ′: ξ&
%`: c >5 9 9 ξ θ& c
:
Σ
% : θ ] ′: ξ&
*
c>
( ) "
7
"
7
0
9
9
ƒ% 5 ξ θ& c Ψ %θ9ξ&
Z ′ %
7
θ
Σ
%θ>
7 0$c>] %θ> ]ξ> & ] ]θ2 ]ξ> ] ξ2 & ] %θ> ]θ2 ]θP ] ξ> ] ξ2 ]
> Z6′ %>>
= = - - ) ,` $ " % "
%233R& " <
FFR&0 * " " "
9
"
7
" "
"
" " 7
7
7
9
"
"
%$
FFR& 7
$
FF4& &0 ,
(
$W
"
*
"
7
7
7
"
5 "
" 9 "
$+-9 "
9
" >FF49
7
=
9 " "
0 * 0
7
" =
A %>FFF&
C
D
2@P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>F0 *
44Q %
Q02&
9 >?P4 %
Q0P0>&
9 >?@3 %
Q0Q0>0>&
69 >??4 %
Q0Q0>0>&
9 >F23 %
Q0Q0>0>&
( :
%
7
" #"
"
%
Q02& Q0P0>0>&
&
7 "
(
%
&
#"
" " 9 430
9 >FF49 >FFF&
&
cx
/ "
7 "
- "
%
0,
"
D % 0>2>&0 *
>F
A "
" #"
"
)" O *" Q0Q0>0>&
" 5 0 0
9 >F@Q %
9 >FR? % Q0Q0>0P %>F?3& " &
&
& "
'
7
* " Q0Q0>0P
"
:
"
%
"
"
$7 "
9 >F23 %
"
%
"
9 >F2@ % 20?02& 9 >FQQ %
) 7 9 >FP4 %
Q0P& 2040>0>05 Q0Q02& Q0Q0>0P&
" &
7 "& 9
7
B
FR3 %
Q02&
9 >FF2
2@Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
43
"
"
9 (**
9 233R9 0>2F&
c{ 9≥x +c{ ` 9≥x
'" " (
β:
%
&
" "
/ ≥
"
"
" "
:
θ
"
"
" "
`:
:
,
'"
, *%
FF39 0QF&
/ " " "
"
,
7 "
7 "
:
9 9
/ 7
" "
"
"
" 9
7
"
7 "
9
, *
7
7
" "
"
0 '"
"
4.4.3 Summary C*
" DM
"
"
"
"
0 * " 7
0
" " 9"
" 7 "
9 9 7
7
:
"
" " " #"
#" 9 "
"
"
9 7 " 7
"
"
"
9
0 " "
0 *
" "
"
"
0,
9
#" " 9"
" "
" 9
"
#"
"
" " #"
" 7 ;* 0 "
#" "
9
9 7
0$
9
#"
"
" 7 "
0 "
" 7
"
"
" 0
"
"
7
0* 7
7
0*
"
2@R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 " "
0-
A
"
7
" "
"
" 0
" *
"
"
" • • •
" "
0
9
, * ,
" "
" "
$
7
•
"
"
" "
•
7 M
5 "
7
•
7
*
"
"
• •
"
"
"
"
7
7
"
"
"
•
"
7 "
9
"
"
"
"
" #" "
•
"
"
"
"
0*
"
"
"
"
" 7
0 -"
" "
"
" "
9
0 -"
"
7 " "
" 0- 7 >FQ3A
7
"
"
7 #"
9
"
7
"
"
7
"
9
"
:
" 0'
9 0
7 7
" "
"
: " "
"
7 #"
" 7 "0 < "
" 0 * "
7 7 " "
0
"
7
0 * 9
"
9
0
0
7
#"
"
9
7
"
"
0*
7
"
9
" 7 " "
"
"
"
" "
7
"
"
"
9
A P0
#" 7 0
"
"
"
" "
7 "
"
"
"
"
0,
"
- 7 " "
7
7 9
•
7 #"
"
" "
7 7
"
"
7 9 0 * " 9 " 7 "
9
" " 0* #"
" 7
"
M "
#"
" 0
2@@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9 " " " "
" "
7
7
:"
0 ,
" 7
" 7
0 (
"
:
"
9
7 (
" "
"
&9 ,
9$
"
0
"
"
7
-
" " " 0
"
"
>P (
"
"
#" A
#"
9
6 "
7
"
>FQ3 >F43A
"
#" "
9
" "
"
7
"
7 7
9
" ;* "
" -
" " "
7
"
" &0 *
7
" O
"
0
0*
7
7
:"
U
#" % 0= "
"
"
" "
>2 "
"
:
" 0*
0
7
#" 9
7 9
4.5 Integrating Madsen - attenuating the framework ,
"
A #" "
#" "
A
:" #"
" >F?Q& " #" >>2
*
"
"
9
5
""
"
"
" " " 0
" *
"
" 0
"
"
#" 0* "
" 7 "
"
7
"
#"
"
"
"
"
"
" A
7
7
8 0
7 R
"
9 "
"
>>Q
" "
"
" "
7 9 >F?Q&0 = 0, % 9
" A
5
"
7 9 >F?Q5 -
9 >F?Q5
"
>>P
>>Q
%
Q
" " 9
9
0
"
9
A
9
9
"
"
5
0* 7
"
7
"
"
7
0
9
"
"
"
"
%
7 &9
9 " &9
"
%
"
&
%
7
A
"
"
7
&
A
"
% 7
" "
"
0 5
/ 7
"
"
9
" "
9 0. "
0
#"
" "
" 7
O 7
7
" "
"
" "
"
9 4> 9 O
"
9
A 7
" "
C % &D "
A "
7 9 0* " 9
#" 7 9
"
9
0 :" 9
"
9
"
7 " "
&0 *
"
0 "
7 " % E& 7 " * " " 0* + 7
" 0*
7 "
:
9 0 -"
% 0*
" 0
9
" " 7
/
0
"
0
7 7
7 " "
7
7 7 0* " "
" "
9 "
"
" " 7
7
0 * 9
0= 7
"
9
0
C
"
"
A 7
7 A
"
" A A 20 (
" 7
" "
"
7 "
"
P
9 &
"
"
0 (
" , *
P0 *
7
"
, *
"
9
"
:
"
7 #" #" " "
9
" "
9
#"
9 "
7
"
"
7 0,
"
7
9
"
"
9
#"
9
9
"
9 0, " 0 )"
7
:
"
" " "
" 7
"
7
9
0*" 0 (" "
7
7 " " 9 #" " 0 -"
9
" 9 "
"
"
0 "
#"
#"
0 " "
"
7
7
7 9
:
"
"
7 9
"
"
9 9 "
: 7
0
: "
9 7
0
" "
"
"
0,
"
7 "
7
"
7
7
:
" 7
"
0 + :
7
"
9
"
5 " "
9
D 0
0
"9
7
:
7 "
9
9
-
" 7
"
"
" 7 7
" 7
" #" 7
* "
7
"
"
"
.
0 7
. "
0* 7
"
" "
7 A
9 - 7 9
9
"
.
7
A " "
7
/
9 "
0*
"
0 7
A 7 9
0 "
0-
0
7
"
7
7 7 7 0
7 "
"
#"
7
"
7
0
5.1.1 Exploring the framework for dynamic assessment and intelligence: the eight considerations *
7 0
7
A "
"
"
"
>MQ0 *
9
" 5 "
%
9
"
9 " 0$
&
" &0 *
"
"
9 9
7
" "
O
0+
7
9
"
"
"
7
" 9
"
% "
0
,
"
9
/
"
O
,
O
9
"
9
"
"
9
7
/
" *
>
,
O
O
"
7 7 7
7 70 , "" 9
"
"
7 "
7
. "
0
24Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
5.2 Dynamic assessment and learning potential models conceptualised within the framework .
"
7 "
" "
9
A
9
" 0*
"
9
"
7 0(
"
0,
7
" O
O
"
/ >0
*
"
O " "
"
O
"
" "
"
"
"
""
0 (
7
7 "
"7 "
"
"
"
" "
"
"
" "
" " " 0*
% 9
"
* " 9
"
• • • • • • • • • • • • •
"
"
"
9
A
E
7
"
"
&0 *
" "
7
"
0 7
" R020> * ) % (,)&/ R0202 R020P $ R020Q %>F4?9 >FF29 2333& R020R $ 7 B 7 R020@ * R0204 R020? ' " %2332& R020F * %2333& R020>3 R020>> R020>2 * 1 R020>P *
"
"
7
" *
9
9
"
23
" 0
"
0 ,
" "
" 7 " 7 "
"
9
A
7 9
7 0
"
7 " 0
9
"
0 + "
5 0 0
0* 7 "
9
" 20
7 #"
0
/ 6
0
%))*& "
7 %2333 &
< "
"
7
%), & %$
"
"
%2333& &
%2333&
/ =
(
=
A
7
%2332& 7
%2333& %) 7
%- ( *&
A )
& 7
/ 7
" %
" % ('-& )*& -
/ " %2333& 7
%)
%( &
24R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
23
"
-
-
-
R020>
-
R0202
"
,
"
"
"
"
"
C "66 D "
-
R020?
-
R020F
' " " "
7
"
"
"
0 ( " 0 * 7
"
7
" "
" -
R020P
-"
-
R020>3
("
"" "
" " -
R020Q
$
0 7 #"
5
-
R020>>
G
A
( "
-
R020R
$
"
7
R020>2
(
"
"
7 0
0*
"
"
" 0 ,
" "
-
R020@
7 0
-
R020>P
" "
" 0
" "
" "
" " "
-
R0204
*
7 "
"7
5.2.1 The Leipzig learning test (LLT) and the adaptive computer assisted intelligence learning test battery (ACIL): diagnostic programmes "
< "
A %2333 & )
6
%))*& 7 "
7 "
7
"
"
0 $ "
7 "
*
" "
0
" 0* "
"
A 7
7 "
7
" 0 7 "
7 "
" 7 "
"
#"
" "
"
7
#"
0 * 7 7
-
7 7
7 " 7
7 " #"
"
#"
"
"
7 0*
#"
7 #"
9
& 9
))* .
7 0 E" "
7
" 7 "
))* = 7
7 "
" "
"
"
" "
9
0
"
" =
0
7
7 "
7 " 7 " 9 7
7
#" "
7
%7
"
0
" =
7
,E 0 )"
9
" " "
"
9
"
24@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
"
0*
"
" 0,
"
• •
"
.
#"
•
#" #" o o * "
5
&M %
& c F5
%
% " % " % &
%
& & #"
&
& c>
E
(,) c >O%>]F& c 30>
(,) 7
"
))*
"
(,)0
5.2.1.5 B(iii) Hypothesis system " 7 7 " " 7
" "
7
7
" 0 *
"
7 9
7
7
9
))* "
" 7 %
R020>0Q&
&0 *
"
0(
7 7 7
%
))*
&
7
6
7 " 0*
" "
7 "
" 0 @4 %
Q&0 *
"
"
5 " $ ', "
7
" (,)
A
7
#"
9
" "
7
"
"
" "
0* "
"
0
5.2.1.6 C(i) Abstract data 9
P9 7
0 , 7 7
0 '" "
"
"
: "
" 7 0*
(,)
" 7 "
7 7
0* ))*
"
"
7
(,)
7
))* " ))* 0
9 "
=
7
,E
"
"
5.2.1.7 C(ii) Concrete data *
7 7
" #"
" 7 " " 7
7 " 7
0'
9 0*
"
7
7
"
0
9 7 "
0*
7
"
0
5.2.1.8 C(iii) Prime considerations *
" 7
7 0* 7
" "
"
7 &9
"
7 "
7 ))* 0*
0 *
7 (,)
7
" "" 7 " 9
7
7
" %
" "
7
" :
7 #"
"
9 " "
7
7
0 )
%
0 *
"
"
6 0
&0
"
7 9
7 9 " : 7
" 7
%
&
2?3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0 *
))* %
"
"
7
"
"
% $-&
&
"
0
$-
" "
"
" "
9
0
"
0+
"
" 7
" :
" 9
7
"
9
7
0
7
9
$7
#" "
7 5 0 0 "
0,
9
$"
Q
#"
0* 7
" " "
" "
"
"
" "
7 "
0 "
(,) /
" 7 9
"
"
7
7
" 7 % "
" 7
T
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
.
"
#"
*
( 0"
%
"
9
"
" 7 "
%
Q
" " 0,
"
"
A " 9 A 7
9 .
9
A
7
7
0+
9
"7
" - 7
7
(,) 7 " 9 0*
" & 7
7 "
7
" 0
"
7 9 "
7
7
"
"
/
A
0$
"
" A 7
0*
"
" 9
7
0=
"
% A
9
&P
"
"
7
"
"
"
"
9 "
"
"
P
9 ;
"
"
" " 0 0* " " ; "
"
9 "
"
0, 0* "
7
9
" (
"
A 7
"
& "
5
C
D
" "
7
0$
" 6 9
0, 0*
0*
"
" "
0
2?2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
C=
7
(,)9
"
"
(,)
7
:"
0,
9
9 A
9
"
!
9 9
0+
"
" 7 " " 9
7
7 "
D% "
T
>& "
% " 7
" D " "
" 9
"
7 "
),
"
% &
0*
7
"
0 )
0 *
" 0
" "
7 "
% "
7
" "
%&
9
"
9 &0 *
9 "
&
" 7 "
7
"
"
7
" 7
9 0* "
),
"
C
7 7
"
&
%
,E
7
& %
,EA 9 0* "
"
7
7 "
0
0+ 7
" 9
9 9
0 *
2?P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
),
4?
" "
"
% 9
" 7
0 7 " 0
&
%2333&
7 "
"
,
9"
7
9 " "
0
7
7
%
O "
"
"
" 7
&9
"
#"
0*
7
"
"
7
0 *
7 "
9
" 7
0
9
#" " "
%
A
,
7
"
0= 7
"
"
9
" " :
7
,E
0 *
" ), 9
"
7
" "
0* & ;*
7
C "66 D
7 " 0 7
U $0 " "
7
#" "
"
"
"
9 " 7
"
9 " "
7 "
"
"
"
0*
0. 7
7
#" "
"
7
9
0,
" #"
0
7
#"
9 ),
"
7
9
&
"
#"
&0 ,
7
7 "
9
% "
9 &
% 7
0
/
"
"
#" 7
7 9
D
0
), 7
7
7 "
0
F4?9 0R@P&0
" = *
0 7
"
#" "
7 "
7
"
"
#"
A
"
"
7
"
7
D %(
"
7
" 9
"
7
"
" 7
T
"
0
7 9
A
G "
A
0
"
7
" " " 7 7 "
0
"
7
9 0
&0 * A 0
" G7
A
5.2.4.2 A(ii) Philosophy ( +
"
0 *
"
"
9
" 0 *
A 7
9
9
0
"
"
"
"
=
A
" Q9 /
*
"
0,
2
)
G
A
7 " 7
o o o
-
" %
#"
"
"
&
"
7
"
7
"
7
"
"
7
"
" =
""
7 "
"
" ;
5.2.4.3 B(i) Hypothetical terms *
7 7
0 '
" "
"
" A
0*
7
9 0' 7
7 % 7
9 A G " " "
A&0 * /
2F?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0
% 0 0
0
" "
$
M % &
+
0
0 0 $ " 7 0 *
(
&
M
M
5
5
7 M % &
5 5 7
" 7
"
%
" 5
" 7
"
7
&5 " 7
M
5 7
7
7
"
7
7
"
"
" "
7
5
" 7
5 " "
5 "
5
M
"
" " " "
7
"
= "
" 5
" 7 D %(
7
T=
C 9 23339 0@F3&0 *
7
0*
#"
0*
" " "
A
" A
/ %>& %2& %P& %Q& , "
< < *
7 " " "
7
9
" 9 7
7
" "
9
%
"
" "
7
" "
&
0
7 "
" E
" "
"
"
7
7
"" "
;=
% " 7 7
0 * 7
%
&0 *
"
7 0*
7 7
7 &
7 "
" " " " 9
"
" " 0+
%. "
"
"
7
7
& "
"
" "
7
" "
"
7
"
0* 9
" " "
"
0*
7 " "
"
"
"
" 9 " "
" "
" " 7 0 ,
"
5 0 0 " " "" 0
7
0
5.2.4.4 B(ii) Scientific hypotheses *
% • • •
% % %
% " % 7 % 7 % 7 % % % %
& &M &M &M
% % %
& "
M 7
7 "&
"
&
7 & #" #" #" &M &M &M &M
&M-% &M-% &M-% % % % %
7
& & "
" O
& O
M
& &
& &
2FF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
% %
-& c P5
&M %
E
& c R5
%
%
M
&
&cP
(
=
A
"
c PO%P]R& c 30P4R
A
0
5.2.4.5 B(iii) Hypothesis system
7 7
0*
"
"
0
7
"
7
"
7 7
" 9
"
"
"
%
"
" 7 "
A %>FF25 2333& " 9 "
' "
&0
7
"
9( 0*
A %2332& "
"
"
"
" =
"
"
"
" "
9
"
=
7 Q& "
"
9 0>?>5 23339 0@?P&0
• • •
" (
9
7
" D %>FF29 0>?>&0 * = %>FF2&9
"
"
7 "
"
C "
9
"
%( " /
9
7 " 9 9 >FF29
T=
7
7 7
,
9(
"
7 "
7
%
"
A
"
"
0,
"
" &
7
"
%
*
) 7
• • • •
7
"
"
,,
- " "
• • • •
(
" %
9 %
" "
9
•
9
7
9 9
& 9
&
7 "
%
9 "
&
• • ,,,
$ • • • • •
( ,
O O
5.2.4.6 C(i) Abstract data *
" " 0*
" 9
0
"
"
9
"
"
* *
"
C " 7
9
" "
7
" C G " "
9 DQ %(
P 7 A
9 23339 043@&0
A #"
0 * G
"
A
A
0
"
"
G
" T=
P0Q 0 G=
D A0 =
2
" P
"
D
9
7
"
>0 20
7
"
7
"
9
"
"
"
7
#" 7
0
"
" P0
#"
+ " Q0 ,
" "
7 " 0* 7
A
7
"
A
"
"
5
7 "
"
*
7 0*
7 ?
7
0$
7
" " #"
&0 , * #"
C
0* 7
9 "
"
9 7 *
G
7 "
A "
7
"
7 Q0
" 9
"
" 7
" "
7
7
:"
7
D
7 % 7
7
9
7 #"
%
7
0 C=
0*
0 7
"
9 " :" T = 9 23339 043?&0 , 0 * " A %>FRR&
#" 7 7
P
E
" "
"
" 7
" "
7 "
7
7 7
7 9
" " #" #" "
7
"
7 " 0 *
"
" "
"
7
0
"
7 9
"
"
D %( (
Q&0
5.2.5 Dynamic assessment of the level of internalisation of elementary school children’s problemsolving activity "
9 "
0
7 9
7 7
?
*
" 7 "
"
" E
0 *
-9
7
7
"
0*
"
P9 "
C
7
D
(
"
:"
=
9 23339 04340
P3>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
EA 0 / A
7 "
:"
"
" "
"
0
0,
"
"
"
9
" 9
7 " 0 -"
" "
:" "
"
0 *
"
B
7
%2333&
#"
"
A 7
" "
" "
7
"
0= " "
7
7 " "
A
0* 0 "
" 0
7 9.
"
0,
7
7
7
#" 0 * 7 "
7
7
" 7 "
7 7 0
9
7 "
"
"
0
5.2.5.1 A(i) Ontology *
"
7
"
7
" 7
7 7
7 0* " 7
0* "
"
0 +
0 -"
"
"
9
9
" "
7 7 7
"
#"
"
7 " "
0* " 7
7 #"
" 7
.
"
7 "
7
" "
" 0 * 0 " " 0
" 9 #" 0
"
7 "
7 7 9 7 "
"
"
7
7 " "
" "
"
9
" 7
"
9
9
"
M "
7
" "
9
" "
9
9
"
"
7 0*
*
"
"
"
>
7
0*
7
7
5 0 0
" 7
0*
7 0 - 7
"
7
7 " #"
" 7
"
"
7 "
7
9
" "
7
7
"
0. :
0 *
" 9
" "
7
" "
7
7 #"
,E
0
7
"
7 "
0
5.2.5.2 A(ii) Philosophy * *
7 "
"
7 "
0
7 "
A
0(
7
"
0*
"
7 "
0
& c 3022
0 7
#"
"
7 7 "
0
"
7 7
" 0 (
"
0
5.2.6.5 B(iii) Hypothesis system *
" " "
"
7
7 0 ,
"
"
7
9
#"
0*
"
" "
0
5.2.6.6 C(i) Abstract data *
"
A
0
A
7
0
5.2.6.7 C(ii) Concrete data " #"
"
7
7
#"
0*
" 0= "
"
0
5.2.6.8 C(iii) Prime considerations %2333&
"
7
" 0 *
7 "
" 7 "
7 "
)
0*
)
#" "
"
" 0*
7 "
7
0 *
,
>
"
)
-"
%&
(
9
-"
% &
(
9
-"
% &
7 "
"
+
7
"
9 9
7
+
7 "
>
0! 0
,
% &
)
-"
%&
(
9
-"
% &
(
9
-"
% &
-"
%&
-"
7 "
"
% &
"
"
-"
% &
"
"
-"
%&
"
"
-"
% &
"
"
-"
% &
"
"
(
>
]>
9 7
2
2
,
%
&
]> 7
P
P
* *
""
"" ""
> >
"" 77 " "
&&
" " 0 +7 0 +7 7 7
0 .0 . " "
" % " % "
" "
7 7" " 9 9 " &0 &0
*
*
" 7 "
7
& 7
A " "
7 "
" " , *
7
,
" 0
"
7
0= 0(
9 5 7
A % "
,
" "
"
7
% 7
7
7 9
" 7
" "
" 0 ,
"
0 + "
9 0*
7 7
9
"
"
%23339 0>24&
P>3
%
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
(
"
7
9
0*
"
A
"
9
"
,E
+ #" 7
" "
%
& % "
"
#" "
7 " "
7
0*
"
0=
&0 *
7 C
,E
7
"
"
7
%) & " )
D
"
"
0 *
" %
" &
7
,E
0 >
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
5.2.7 Swanson-cognitive processing test (S-CPT) *
" "
"
"
" %= &0 = #" 7
7
" " 7 " 9
" "
9
" 7
0 * "
" "
7
7 7 "
" " "0 0 *
7
7
" " 0 ,
"
0
A 7
"
" D
#"
" 0* 9
"
%$ &9
"
C &0 ,
D 7
"
"
D C
D
"
7
C
0( "
"
7
;*
9 "
9
"
0(
" "
%
"
" &
"
0
"
0
"
;
7
29
7
7
9
7 "0 =
7 ";
7
0=
"
" #"
0*
0* "
7 " 9
0*
D 9
" "
0! 7
D
C
9 0 *
"
-( *
0"
= " 5
"
*
7
7
0 3
;-
" 0 C*
7 5 0 0
"
7 " 9 7 0(
"
7 0* 0 * " 7
"
"
#" 5 A ;,
c
0
C D 0*
C
"
#"
c 9
"
7
0 D
"7
9 "
"
" " "
D 7
7
0
P>2
0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
- 7
" •
"
* *
•
M 9M
7
C
7 "
"
"
"
#"
M
9
"
7
"
" -
7
* "
%
7 .
"
" "
" "
%
A
5
0 (
"
CQD
7 :"
"
- ( *0
"
0*
6
#"
" 9
A :"
#" #"
*
"
* *
7
" - ( *A 7
" ;*
C
7
C
" ;
"
""
7 " 7
0 * 0,
C
D C
7 7 D
0*
#" 8, "
" 0
" 7 9
" "
" :
7 -( *
"
7
"
D
;*
0 =
7
" "
/
7
%
7 0
"
"
0*
" 7
"
*
7
& " 9
" "
"
"
&0 *
-( * " "
-( * "
0* "
7
-( *
; 9
C
9 ;*
" C
"
7
0= 7
7
•
"
7
7
A
"
" " #"
7
0
9
"
,
0+ 7
D "
9 " 0
& "
0
(
" "
9 "
7
0
0( "
7 7 " " 0 D C " " " " #"
"
"
%
"
7
7
7 " "
D
"
"
9
0*
0* "
" "
9
9
"
7
"
0) 7
A
7
0* $, #" 7 7 C2D " " 7 0
Q " 0* 0 7
"
#"
9
2&
" &
"
•
/
C " D
M
•
"
% &0 =
U $
•
D ,E
7 7
.
(
7
9
"
* *
"
A
" • • •
9
%
"
" : "
,E
D
"
9 "
" "
"
" #"
0* 7
" 0*
-( * -( * "
"
"
P>P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
•
*
" "
" 7 "
0 * 0
"
5
A " "
5.2.7.1 A(i) Ontology *
"
0, 7
"
9 "
#"
" " 0
0
7
0*
#"
"
7
"
7
A
7 0*
7 "
7
0* "
0*
7 0*
9 %
" 7
"
7 "
7 "
"
" ;*
A
0+ 0 '
0$
"
D
" "
"
M
C "
"
"
"
"
9 "
"
"
8& +
9
-( * 7
7
9
" " "
% 9
&
"
"
%
(% &
&0
5.2.7.3 B(i) Hypothetical terms -
A
-( *
"
9
"
A
7
0
9 7
A
"
7 %
"
"
;,
9 "
P&0
9 -
A
7
9
"
C
D
"
P>Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
0 C= 7 D
C
D
" " A
" "
"
"
9
9
"
9 #"
7
"
"
7
- ( *0 * " 9 97 " 9 " " % 7 7
" #"
0* " -( *
" "
"
7
7
" 9 7 7 7 &0
0( " " " #" 9
"
" #"
"
" 0
"
9 " 9
5.2.7.4 B(ii) Scientific hypotheses 7 0 , " " E
0*
"
*
% • • •
7 0*
-( *
&
% % %
&M % &M % &M %
% " • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • %
7
0
& & &
7 &
% % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % %
" " " " " " " " " " " &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M %
-& c >>5
%
E
& c 45
%
= = = = = = = = = = =
& -% - %7 " & -% " & -% & -% & -% " & -% & -% & -% & -% & -% 7
& & #"
& &
& #" #"
& & & & & #"
&
& & "
& & & & &
& c P0
- ( * c PO%>>]4& c 30>@ E
"
0, "
" "
0*
-( *
0
5.2.7.5 B(iii) Hypothesis system -
" • • •
, = %
"
7
"
"
/ 7
"
%
&
" & 9-
A %
" "
"
"
"
&
P>R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
• " %
" •
"
" 9
7
"
7 "
"
7
P&
*
" 7
"
/
7
?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
) T
9'
"
$
" 9 2332& "
' "
" "
" 0
" "
)
"
9
"
9
" " 9 ' "
" 0 (" 7
7
9
7 "0 0 %2332& 7 " 0* 0*
7 9
7
%' " 0*
"
$A
7
.
#"
7
" 7
7 9
"
"
7
" " #" 9
9
0
"
"
"
$ 9
+
7
-
(" "
"
" O
"
"
7
7
)
( #"
7
*
7 "
7
7
"
"
0
"
7
" "
" 5 0*
7 " 9
"
% 7 0 *
" "
& "
7 "
&0 "
"
"
7
0' " "
"
"
" 9
" 0
9 $
)
0
" " " 7
"
7
"
,
7 "
"
" % "
" #" 7
" 7
" $ " A
7 ,
7
)
7
M
0 -" 7
A
" 7 " " #" 7 0 9
9
"
9
"
"
"
7
#"
7
7 0
5.2.8.2 A(ii) Philosophy +
9 0
9
7
:" " " 7
"
A 7
"
"
0 $ 0*
)
$A 0 '
"
" % 7 )
& $
" 9
"
"
)
$
"
" "
P>F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
%-( & " 0
*
)
"
$
) "
7 "
9
"
%
" &0 " )
% O
7
7 0
)
$
9 & "
"
9 "
7
$
) 7
7
0 ,
$A
& "
5
" )
" 7 7
$
0
) $ 7 " "
"
0,
7
"
7
7
9
0 "
7
7 "
9
7 " A
0 *
7
" 9
"
7
0* 0*
" "
A 7 " 0 * 7 " #" 7 "
"
)
$ 7
" " )
"
"
"
7
) 0 ' " "
7
$
"
" 7
"
0*
"
0+ ""
" "
7
"
" 0 ' "
7
0 * 7
P0 *
7 7
7
"
0=
"
C
#" " 0 *
D "
"
" "
" 0 *
0 B
" "
;* 0 , "
$
"
" 7 "
"
"
7 " "
7 7
9
"
#"
" "
9
"
#"
:"
"
$ "
"
7 0*
7
7
)
$
0
" "
"
9 $A
$A 7 "
9
9 9
)
7
7 " 7 #"
)
0(
7 "
*
)
" 0
"
" "
#"
*
"
-(
0+ " % "
"
% ) & ' "
0*
"
"
"" " #"
) $ " "
2F " "
"
)
7
$
0
P23
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
)
M
M
"
0 $ "
7 7
"
G 7
A
&
"
M )
M
"
"
%7
7
" 7
0 *
)
"
$
0 " " "
"
"
7
"
" "
,
"
,
; C
;
D
$
C
;
A
D
A
5.2.8.3 B(i) Hypothetical terms ' "
A )
$ 7 7
7 0
)
7 0* "
7
"
$A
9
G
A
"
G
A0
7
" )
$
0+ 7 " G
"
#" 7 A
7 "
7 7
#"
;
0
9
"
Q
0
; *
)
$
7
"
0, "
" 7
"9 9
0* •
" 0* " "
"
7
7
9 7
7 -
' " 7
"
7
A
E
A
/
M
P2>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
o o
) )
9 9
o o
) )
9 9
7 7 %
"
%
"
&
& %
"
&
7
"
6 9
9 #"
" %
"
& ) ) , ,
o o o o o o o o o o
" "
%
& "
" 7
7 0
7
"
9 9 9 9
&
9
% %
& &
7 " % 7 7 7 %
& "
7 &
7
"
#"
" 7 "
& &
& %
7 " A ) 9 & ) 9 $
& %
%
%
o o
" %
#"
) ) ) )
o
•
9
% " "
% " "
"
% " "
&
&
M P0 * " 0 " #" 7 " " 0 "
E 0 *
"
"
&
9 -& c ?5
" 7
7 &
% % % % % % % % % % % % 9 % % %
• • •
/
&
% "
%
9
7
"
#"
7
7 7
#"
7
7 "
' "
9
7 0 * 7
7 " 7
7
"
0
5.2.9.5 B(iii) Hypothesis system * " 0 "
" "
PA
" 0* 9.
-
"
"
7
" 77
A 9
' "
0+
0* %
"
P&0 * 0*
" 0*
"
7
" 0
#"
"
" 7 9
"
" #"
7
"
" "
"
#" 7
9
"
"
0 ,
7 C
: D
%
"
G
A
"
7
"
&;
5.2.9.6 C(i) Abstract data *
"
"
7 "
7 *
"
7
A
7
9
7
9
0 0 "
"
P2F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
7
9 7 "
0+ 0 *
7 " %
&
C
6 9
7
D %'
6 T (
6
P&0 ( #" " " " =
7 " #"
"
% "
7 0*
/C 7
" &
" 7
"
#"
"
" 0, 7
" 9 "
8-
9
9 "
0,
0, 7
"
#"
"
"
"
C
7 D
C
" #" D
"
" 7 " "
PP2
0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
@ *
"
9
"
"
0* 9
" 7
" 9
"
"
" 7
&
" 7
"
7 % 7
" %' >0
"
"
7
"
#" 6
/ 2/
"
(
"
" &
"
P/ Q/ R/ @/
" "
"
"
9
7
9
"
7
"
" 0
" A " #" 0 *
0 ('-
"
" " "
"
%
""
&
7
7
"
%
""
"
"
"
7 /
"
)
"" "
"
"
" ""
" >/
"
"
7
" "
2/
7
"
0
"
C
D
%
&
"
"
"
P/
"
#"
"
7
"
Q/
7
7
%
"
""
"
#"
"
"
#"
R/
&
9
7 "
"
0 *
"
7 7
- "
"
"
"
(
9
"
" "
" 9 " 0 ,
7
"
"
0*
0
7
"
#" /
"
" 0$
"
7 "
"
"
"
""
"
7
" 9
0*
9 7 9
"
5.2.10.1 A(i) Ontology * "
('"
" " "
%
" 7 7
"
"
" 7
&
"
0
7
"
" 9 7
"
"
" "
" 0+
('"
" 0 ) 6 %2333 &
7 "
"
0
PPQ
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
(
9 7 " " 9
* "
" 7
7 "
7
0* " 7
7 " 7 "
7
" #"
"
,E
"
"
7
"
" "
"
0 7 7 C
"
" 7 "
%
7 7
7
7
#" ""
7
" "
" 7 " 07
7 &
0 ) 6 %2333 & 7
"
7
% "
"
"
"
"
"
0
" "
"
" ('-
"
7
"
7 7 " #"
#"
9
" "
" #"
&0
0*
"
" "
"
7
"
" 9 ) 6 %2333 & "
"
"
7 " 0 !
"
7
"
0 "
7
"
,E
7 9 7 D
7
0,
" " " "
"
0
>& 0 *
" D
C "
-
*
% •
7
% "
%
-& c @5
0
&
%
• • • • • • • • • • • • •
" 7 "
&M
%
7 7 7 7 7 7 7
O O O O O O &M &M &M &M &M &M &M
"
""
:
7
&
7 &
% % % % % % % % % % % % %
7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 %
&c45
%
" " " " " " "
% " % & % " % 7 & % & % 7 & % 7 &
& & & & & & &
-% -% -% -% - %7 - % #"
& 7
& "
&
7 "
& & &
&c>
PP4
&
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
E
('" " " 9 ) 6 %2333 & 9 7 " 0
"
c >O%@]4& c 30340 * 7 E " 9 7
('-
7 0
0 - " "
9
"
"
0* 7
5 7
" " "
9
7 7 0$ 0
7
7
"
"
"
%0 0
9
& '
9
7 0 )
"
0
"
"
A
7
"
0 *
7
0 9
0 * " .
#"
7 7 7
7 "
7
" #"
"
0+
"
" 7 "" 7
#"
7 " 0* "
" "
0,
"
/
=
-
'
*
C
9
"
D
7
"
"
" 6 "
• • • •
" " " "
" " 7
,
)
0
" "
( 0 ( ; +
7 " "
" C
D
; +
" 5 5
9 "
-
"
5.2.12 The Mindladder model: using dynamic assessment to help students learn to assemble and use knowledge ,
9 7
" "
"
5
9
O
9 9
"
0*
"
9
7
0 "
7 "
"
"
0 $"
7
9
"
9 7
9"
0*
" "
%
"
" 0*
7 7
9
"
" 2& 9
" 7
0 , 0,
"
9 "
" " "
" 7 7
A "
"
7
9 2333& "
O
"
"
P9
"
" E
7 "
7
%1
"
7
7
" 0* 2
7
PQ4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
9
"
"
0.
7
"
"
%
&
%
&
"
9 0B
" " "
7 #"
"
7
0
" 9 "
7 0
. "
0
" 7
"
5 " "
"
9
" 7
:" 7
0
*
"
"
7
0 )
9
7
"" "
0 *
"
9
7
0 *
7
7
7 0 *
7
0 *
"
7
" 0*
"
#" 0+
1
20 ( " C
7 9 23339
0>??&0 * "
"
0*
"
"
#"
D
5
" R020R %
"
" #"
7
0 C " 0 * "
" " &0 ( " "
"
%2333&
" %1
" 7
" #" 0* 7
7 7
7
" 7
" "
7
7 7
7 " "
"
7 9
:
0, O "
5
' "
#"
#"
"
""
*
9' "
7
D
7
" 7
0$
"
0
/
PQ?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007) #"
$
•
,
7
" "
9 "
• ) 7
7
" " " "
9
7
• *
7
9
" 5
7 9
7 ( =
7
"
9 " #"
7
0 *
#" 7
7
%
0 -" "
%
" "
"
"
% %
0
#" #"
&
"
0.
7 * 5
#" 7
" 7
& "
" "
7 &9
"
7 *
O
"
5
5
7
"
&
/ • • • • •
, *
M
7 "
5.2.12.1 A(i) Ontology *
A 9
"
" &0 * ' " " 0$ 7 "
% #" "
"
"7 7
" "
"
%
"
A " "
7
#"
%1 #" 7
&>P
A "
"
7
0 :
7
"
0
" 7
0,
"
" "
"
7
"
"
0
P
9
7
7
7
"
0>??& C " A 9 *
0B
&
7 "
" D
C
C
"
0
0B
" "
0
D
"
0
PQF
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
5.2.12.2 A(ii) Philosophy *
"
7
"
7 "
7
0< 0*
"
-
7
"
" 0, 7
7
4R
"
"
7 " "
C
7
7
0 * " 9
"
"
"
7
7
0 *
" 7 " 9 23339 0>F@&0 E" 7
V D %1
9 7
0
5.2.12.3 B(i) Hypothetical terms ,
7
7
9
0 *
7 7
" 7
9
0
9
9
"
"
0$ 7 " "
0* 9
"
9
7
" 7
9 " 7
" 0*
7 7 " 7
/ "
"
#" " 0
9
7 7
"
"
" 9 9 "
"
"
0 =
7
7
7
7
7
"
A " " 0* " " 0
7
7
"
9 7 9 " 9
9
"
9
"
0 *
9
9 9
"
7 7
" 0
0
5.2.12.4 B(ii) Scientific hypotheses " " 7
* • • •
%
&
% % %
&M % & #" &M % 7 &M % " "
% " • • • • • • • • • • • •
"
"
0( "
9 0
"
7
& 7
7
9
#"
&
7 &
% % % % % % % % % % % %
7 7 7 7 7 7 " " " " " " o
% % % %
& -% & &M-% 7 & &M-% & & -% & &M-% & &M-% " && &M-% & &M-% & &M-% & &M-% " 7 "& &M-% & " &M % 4R9 " " &M % 7 " &M % " & &M % & &M % &
& &
PR3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
% % % % % % % % % % % % o
&M &M
" " " " "
%
" % % % % % % % % % %
o
% % &M &M &M &M &M &M &M &M &M &M "
7 7 7 7 7 " " " " "
%
"
" " " " " " " " #"
% % % % % % % • • • • %
% % % %
-& c >>5
7 7 7 7 %
&M &M &M &M
& c 4R 5
%
& 7 "& " &
% % % % %
& &
&
" % % : %7 % % &M &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M % &M &M &M &M &M &M &M &M
& & 7 "
&
& " &
" %
& 7
"
& &
7 & 7
& & 7 &
" "
& & & &
%
"
% % % % % % %
& & &
& & 7 "
&
& &
& & & &
&cP
E
c PO%4R]>>& c 303P 0= 7 0,
7
% % % %
9
"
"
" 7
7 0(
1
" 7
"
" #"
"7 9 0*
#"
7
" 7
M 0 *
9 0
5.2.12.5 B(iii) Hypothesis system * " "
G " #"
0 B " "
"
A
9
A
0
"
"
7 #"
7 7
" " "
" " 0
7
"
7 "
7
"
" 5
"
7
"
" " 0* 0 * " 0 " 7 7 "
7
"
7
7
"
C
D 7 0* 7
PR>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
5.2.12.6 C(i) Abstract data *
-
7
" 7 9 0*
7 "
7
%7
"
0 '"
"
7
& 7
"
7
9 #"
7
7
7 7
7 "0 *
0
5.2.12.7 C(ii) Concrete data *
"
7
"
7 7
9
"
9
9
9
"
#"
0 *
"
"
9
0
5.2.12.8 C(iii) Prime considerations +
"
#"
" C-
7
9
#"
#" #"
"
7
#" 1
0,
C D % 023P&0 ,
#"
"
D % 0>?F& "
9
0
"
7
7 "
9
7 %2333&/
7
7
9
7 9 1
, *
"
0
" 7 7 D
C
0
" 0*
" "
" #"
%
"
97
" & "
#"
0 $
" 7 0 *
9 "
"
#"
"
"
7
"
0
0
5.2.13 The cognitive modifiability battery (CMB) * *6"
7
%( &/
" 7 A A
"
" C
* "
A
"
/ 0
7 0 ,
D
7 "
" (
7 c >0?? c 3022
R020@
)
-
R0204
- ( * c 30>@
-
R020?
)
-
R020F R020>3
c 30>P ('- c 3034
-
R020>>
)* c 30?R
-
R020>2
-
R020>P
c 303P ( < c 30>4
/ 0.03 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.10 0.13 0.16 0.17 0.22 0.37 0.40 0.50 0.85 1.88
"
#"
E
7
"
7
7
" 7
9
91
"
3 E
"
7 " 0' " A " ' " A
E
highly testable highly testable highly testable highly testable highly testable highly testable highly testable highly testable highly testable highly to partially testable highly to partially testable highly to partially testable highly to partially testable not very testable
7
7
$ c 303@
7
Mindladder LPAD ACFS LIR ACIL EPA S-CPT CMB LEM Carlson and Wiedl model Dynomath LLT ARLT Analogical reasoning
30PR
E
&>Q
7
c
-
>Q
"
"
&
3% 9
R020R
,
E
0*
))* c 30R (,) c 30> ), c 303? $ c 30Q ( = 30P4R
"
A
'
-
"
E
R020>
"
0
E7 -
7
P0
"
7
A
7
#"
A "
" "
0 "
0*
"
"
"
"
" 0(
*
" "
"
7
"
7 7 "
2
7 " 7 E
" A %2333& "
" "
0*
"
0
PR?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" 7
0
7 9
30>F
"
7
0 * 7
"
"
"
0
7
A %2333& ) 30>F
A "
0*
5
9 "
"
7
" 0* B 7 " "
"
7 A %2333&
#" 0 *
0* #"
"
1"
0
"
"
"
0
"
B
" A %2333& 0 *
7
0
"
7
7 "
"
30PR
"
9 5 0*
7 " #"
%
7
"
9
"
7
"
" E &
• • •
9
7
#"
7
"
"
0 ,
"
"
"
7
#"
/
" ; " ; " ;
"
0 * #"
"
0*
7
0
5.4 Conclusion (
R
"
"
" 7
A
7
0 =
A " "
7 "
9
7 "
" 9 7
0*
"
" 0
20 *
"
O "
"
"
%
"
R020>9 R02029 R020P9 R020R9 R020F R020>>0 " 9 " R02029 R0204 R020>20 * " % & R02029 R020@ " 7 " 7 % 7 0 " " R020Q9 R020@9 R02049 R020F9 R020>2 R020>P0 7 R020>P 7 R02040 " " P
PRF
&
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
R020?0
" 0 ( 7 R020>30
7
*
E "
"
7
" "
"
A
"
D
9 0*
E
0*
9
"
7 "
"
"
"
"
0,
"
"
"
"
" 7
"
5
"
"
7
"
"
"
"9 0$ "
"
"
" 9
"
7 7 9
0*
"
0 * 9 9
7 "
"
0 9
0,
7 7 0*
"
9 9
#"
0 7
7
"
7
9
C
""
0 , 7 7 "
7 9
" " 0 " 9 "
7
7 0=
" "
9
" 0$ "
"
" 9
0*
" " " 0*
7 ; *
"
5
"
"
"
7 "
7 0,
"
" "
"
0 9- " "
"
"
C
D
9
" "
7 "
0,
" "
7 7 9
"
7 0- "
9
7
"
"
7 "
"
"
9
"
"
9 C
"
D0
"
"
A
0 ,
"
A 7
7
0,
7 " "
"
"
9
7
7 7
0* "
"" 9
" "
0
6.2 Fundamentals *
"
7
"
" 7
"
"
7
" /
•
*
" 7
" A 7
"
• "
#"
*
"
"
" 1
5, " 7 % A
&5
5
"
*
o
5,
"
" 9 C
D5
"
7 " " 0*
9
" " /
7 & 5
5 0 *
"
% M 5
"
7 0 % M
" O " " 7
" "
&7 0
"
% ,& M 5
" "
"
"
"
"
7 0
"
"
" #" *
"
"
/
o •
"
7
"
9
#"
"
"
A #" 9
0
"
" "
7
"
" 0*
" #"
>
"
"
7 7
"
9 7
"
"
"
0
"
" "
"
"
0
P@>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7
7
"
0 * 2
"
"
7 0 * "
7
"
/
" "
" 0 * 5 7
" "
"
"
"
0,
0 *
"
5
"
"0
$
9
"
9
7 9- 7
"
:
"
""
"
20 *
" 0( A " 0-
"
"
7 "
""
7 "
"
7
0 *
7
" "
7
. 0 P "
.
" 7
,
7 "
"
- 7 "
7
7
" "
"
" "
7 "
"66
"
0 =
$
" 0
"
7 7
"
7
9
"
" "
0
"
0 0
"
"
0,
" 0*
" " 7
0*
"" "" 0
0
E"
- 7
0
"
"
"
"
7 =
7
7
"
0 "
7 7
"
7 7
A "
" 9
0* "
" 7
"
0 A
" #"
" 0* A
A
7
"
"
" G
- 7
"
" 0
7
"
7
:
" 7
7
"
"
7 7
9
" "
" 7
"
"
0
" "
" "
A
"
"
" 0*
"
7 7 7
"
" "
7
7
"
" 7 0 +
"
"
"
"
P0
6.3 Theory, meta-theory, science, the social sciences, psychology and assessment (
P
"
"
9 "
9
9 "
0*
A
5
9 7
"
7 *
" :
C
7
" "
9
"
7 0
"
7 " "5
A
9
"
D0
0 * 7 7
" : "
9
"
"
#" "
7 0
P@2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
* " 7
" 9
"
7
"
7 9
*
9
0 "
"
7 7
0 *
" "
"
" 7
"
" "
7 "
"
7 7 "
" 7 9
97 "
" "
"
0*
0* 7
"
7
0
" "
"
9
9
7
0
"
"
"
0* " 7
"
"
9
"
9
"
"
0 7
7
0 *
9 "
"
9 "
"
7 9
" 0
"
B0F43A D % 0>2F&0 $ " 7
"
"
;$
" " 7 "
"
&
' 7
#"
A
7
A >?@F " 0
C
" D% 7
7
7
9 >F?>9 022Q& "
P@Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
" 7
7
C "
"
Z
7 "
[D % 0@?@&0 , "
"
Z
[
0 = " *
"
A
9
"
"
#"
7
E
0 :
"
"
9
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
9
7
7
" 9
7
0 ( :"
29 P "
" "
Q 0+
"
"
M
"
9
" 7
9
"
0 *
"
0
%
" " #"
& "
"
7
7
"
"
"
"
9
E
"
" "
" "
"
B "
7
" 0 1 A %2333& A %2333&
"
" 7 0,
9 7
; *
"
0
" (**
7
;*
"
7
7
"
0
E 0
(** " " #"
9
#"
"
" E 0* 0 * E 0 "
E E
9
7
"
7
7
*
5
"
"
9
0
"
A
0 ,
"
"
" #"
"
"
"
" A
0$ %
&
7
7
"
"
"
" "
0
FFQ &0 , "
" "
0
" A 7 7 " 0
#" 7 7
7
" %2332&0 * "
-
"
"
9 >F?4&0 6 6 6 7 7 "
"
0
"
7
9 >F?25 = 7 " " " 7 #"
" %0 0
"
0 )"
" T1
,
"
6
7
7 0
"
7
"
"
"
233> 2332> )" " 9 " )" 0 " " &0 ( P3 " 6 9 " " 0* 7 #" "7
"
"
" "
*
9 233@&0 * "7
"
%
"
6
T "
"
" " 6
" #" 9
-
"
- "
7
,
"
"
0+
"
"
"
" " - " 9 " "
9 " 9 &0 - F4F&0
P@4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 "
7
"
%$ "
"
"
"
"
0 *
"
%2332& " #" 0* 4 0*
%233@& 7
"
"
>R
"
" "
"
" 7 "
" 7 "
"
0 0*
"
2F " " 0 * "
"
" "
FFP5 7 7
7 "
*
"
" "
" 7 "
9 233P&0
%
2
0-
@3j
" 9 23325
% "
7
" "
$ " %- " 9
*
" 7
7
%) 6 T
" 0 * 9 2333 &
0
$
"
A 233P
0
P@?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
7 9
7 "
"
"
9
" "
6 6
"
0*
"
"
" 7 0'
"
7
7
"
"
7
0
#"
7
"
6
"
"
9 " 7
" 0 * 7 0,
7
7
"
7 7 "
" " "
" 7 "
0 * "
7
0
"
" 7 "
7 "
6 7
9 -
7 "
7
7
"
0*
9
7
7
0
7
7
*
0 , "
9
0 >F@>
"
"
7
- "
7
"
7
7 7
" "
%2332&
" %233@&
7
" %233@&
- " 0
"
2F
7
"
%0 0
"
&0 * "
7
"
&0 , "
" %233@&
"
"
9
9
"
0
" "
7 "
"
0*
9 7
7
% "
"
"
- "
0
7
"
9
" %>F@> 233>& " 9 "
"
"
"
7 9
7
7 0-
" 7 9 2> 7
"
7
" 7
" 0
9
" "
" 7
"
" %2332&
"
0 *
" "
7 "
"
"
"
"
"
" 0
"
%2332&
1.2 A brief tour of meta-analysis , "
" " " 0,
" 9
7
" "
" " "
"
%( ( A % 9 >F?P&0 * 6
T " % "
>FFQ& " 9 %- " T
"
" "
" "
" #"
" A
#"
T1 9 >F?25 - " 9 >F?P&0 * 7
7 " 5
9 233Q&
GA
" 9 >F?R5 = 9 >F?4&9 233> 2332
"
0 " A 9 A 6 9 >F?F5 - " T " " 9 0 0
" "
7 " " " AA %( 7
#" " "
A "
" 7
%"
"
7 9 "
0 >F4@ %(
>F3Q " 6
" " 7 " "
"
6
"
" >FF25 ( "
" "
"
" 0* " " 7
0 , " " " " 9 233Q5 B" T B" 9 >F?F&0 * 9 >FFQ&
#" 9 7 9 9 >FFQ &0 * 7 " 9 >F4F9 >FFR&0 * "
"
7
"
" *
9 "
9
7
7 9* $ 9 T) 9 >FF>5 "9< " " 7 " " " " %
%< "
$
9
" T 9 T " " 9 >FFQ5 7 " 7 "
P@F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
P
%FF>&0
" -
6 9 >F?F& T " " < A "
#" 9 >FF@&0 *
" %+
9 >FFQ5 -
7
" 9 "
" 7 " "
"
" "
"
%
7 "
"
"
"
9
"
"
"
%$
6 9 >F?F5 -
09>F?25
"
T
FFQ5
" 6 5
7
"
9
"
9 09 >FFQ&0 ' %
:
" "
" "
QA "
7
"
$ 7
7 " " 9 >FFQ5 =
9 >FFQ5 =
"
"
9 >FF@5
9
9 >FFQ5 "
7 " 9 >FFQ&0
"
% " " " R 5< 9 >FFQ5 " 9 >FF45 &9 " 9 >F?>5 - " T 9 >F?P&0 , 7 " % 9 9 >F?>&0 * " 9 "
" "
" 7
7
" 9 >FFQ&0
"
9 "
%- "
T
9 >F?P&0 (
7 6
" 6
"
%
FFQ5 % A %
" "
A
9
A
(
T
9 >FFQ5 = 9 >F?4&0 * " U9' A 9 >FFQ&0 *
GA
AA &5 "
0
2. Method 2.1 Two-fold purpose of the meta-analysis *
7
" - "
0
" " #" "
@
0"
9
7 "
"
9C
"
" 9
"
" "
"
"
Z
'
" 6
" 0-09 O
9 O
7 - --
9 0 7 0 9 =0 09 9 $0(0 T " 7 9 10 0 0 7 7 0* 7
7
7
Y
"
"
- --
09 >FFQ&0 " " " 0 * 7 " "
7
% "
09
"
7
"
#" 0(0
"
" 7
" "
%>FFR&
7
" 9 7 " 7 9 9 233R&0 7 0( " / G( ( 7 0 5 G$-* $-* *A 1 9 FFQ9 0>FR&0
" "
"
"
0@ ,
7
FFQ5 %
7 7
&
20P
0 (
" 9 >FFR&0 *
"
7
"
2>2 7 #"
B
-
7 0< 7 &5 " 0* " 6 0
6
" "
0
"
%
2.2. ‘’META – Easy to answer’’ version III by D. A. Kenny *
7 7
E"
$ 7
0B $+-
&
" > " 2
A
7
9
"
"
"
&
, + *
" *
;! /
" % " % 6 %6 .
;
& 6 & &
% % 6 % < -$ %
& & 7
& 6
"
&
6 = $
"
"
"
; %*
;!
9 ,
"
" '
" , , ,
6 9
9
#" ; ! % % >& " `
"
,
(
>&
" *
#"
" "
,
6 9
" 9
"
" > " 2 ;
"
7
GA
" "
, + *
"
` ;
;! *
,
" &
/ "
" + *
"
7
AA /
{ >x `
{>x
" ;!
" " #" #" ; ! %
` ; 7
GA
AA /
" >&
` ; " >
P42
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
, ,
% "
9
>&
" 2
`
"
;! + *
*
,
;
"
7
7
"
GA
AA
"
/
" > " 2 " , ,
6
9
9 "
, % &9 , % &9 , + * , %"&9
, + * , %7&9 ,
7 "
#" ; ! ; % >& " > % >& " 2 " ` 7 % & 7 %7&; % & " %"& 7 " " ;! ; * " 7 " " > %B 7 & 7 " " 2 " ;! ; * " " 7 " 7
"
+ * * , %U&9 " , 9
6 %
,
9
" + *
* "
,
, , ,
9 9
+ * * , 9 " , 9
6
9
" + *
,
*
U
" "
, ,
6 9
9 *
GA
AA
7
GA
AA
;
"
` " `
`
; >&
" > " 2
` ;!
7
GA
AA
7
GA
AA
` ; >&
" > " 2
` ;!
;
"
7 " " "/
" -" -" : 7
"
/
#" ; ! % % >& "
* "
; "
"
" + *
7
" U
,
"
; " >
; " #" ; ! ; % >& " > >& " 2 " ` ;! ; "
% ,
AA 7
A
/
;! #" 6 #" ; ! % % >& "
"
,
GA
G7
;
" 9
7
"
#"
"
7
` #" %U& ; " >
" , ,
AA
/ 7 " " ' %*& #" ; ! % >& >& " 2 " ` ;! " #" ; ! % >& >& " 2 " ` ;! "
"
,
GA
"
, 7 " , %*&9 " 6 , 9 % , 9 ,
7
>
20 *
GA "
AA "
" 6
P4P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
6
7
*
6
7 7 < -$ 6 ( 7 '
#" U %*
"
"
"
9
7
& *
* "
" 9
"
0
* * 0< 7 0
7 9
" "
"
*
"
0* "
"
"
"
7
"
" 0*
7 "
0*
"
"
" "
F
"
"
7
2.3 Meta-analysis programme version 5.3 by R. Schwarzer * *
7
9 7
0-
" /OO %
6
" 0
&0 $ "
6 " " 6 0$ 0 -
'
7
n
F?F& 9
%-
6 A
" 7
R030 6
9
"
0
7
" 0 *
"
/ >*
>-
6
"
)
. )
%-
-
6 9 >F?F&
. )
-
. )
-
*,),*, ( 7
$
'
("
'
-
-6 ( , (
$
)
-
= "
0+
9 .9 (
*
E"
2.3.1 Programme structure * %
"
"
" 9
"
% 9 0 0 7
" GA"
AA
"
"
&
9 O
0*
"
7 "
"
*
" %>F?F& "
7 9
7
0' 7
"
0
0
$ >3 6
7 " &0 * " 9 6
7 "
" 9" 0' " >9 " 9 "
7 #" " " 29
6 A 9 6 9 " " 7
9
" 6 6
"
6
"
7
AA9
" 5 9
9 "9 GA
6
" "
9
"
" "
"
9
0 >03 9 6
7
" "
"
"
" 6
"
7 "
" " 7 " 0,
A
"
6 0
" -
" 6
9 6
7 %>F?F&0 '
6 6
" " 06 0 * 2
/
P4Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
2
"
-
6 A
& 7 "
&7 "
2
'7 "
2
(
7 "
•
#"
'&7 "
' "
•
& #"
#"
7 " %
&
=
&
&7 " &
6
%
'
6
&
6
&7 "
/
&
FFQ5 "
9 >FFR5 #" " " %B 9 7 "
"
6
"
6 9 >F?F5 -
"
A
(" 6 *
"
7
0,
"5 "
6 A 0 , 06 A 7 "
" 7 "
A
"
0
> 233R5 B 9 >FFR&0
7
"
6
9
" %
" " " "9 "
" " 9 >FFQ&0 9 233Q&
%( 0B
" "
" " " T
"
" 7
7
"
" "
7 "
0
"
" "
"
7
7 9 " 7
6 7
7
B
"
A
0
"
0
7 "
"
"
0
2.5 Limitations of the programmes and violation of assumptions B
A
"
-
"
6 A "
7
"
" "
"
"
" 7 7 "
"
"
"
"
0 '
"
7
"
"
" "
"
7 "
7
"
7
>3 6
:
"
9 7
" "
"
"
"
" 0F * % 9 >FFR& 9 7 9 " 0, 7 " " " " 9 22 6 " 0 7 9 " 6 0 7 " " 7 7 " " " " 0* 0= "
" " " 0 * 6 "
" "
0
3. Results 3.1 Criteria used for inclusion of studies +
22 7
4
"
"
"
"
>Q
#"
7
" "
"
"
%2332& " 0*
" "
" 7
9
"
"
%233@&9 " 7 " 9 4 " " " 0*
" " "
"
"
" 0
" "
"
)"
"
"
0*
" " 0, 0
"
,
"
"
:
F
"
9
"
7
2F
" 9
-
"
%2332&
P4@
0
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
+
22 " "
" "
7 "
7
9 7 " & " 0' % "
"
7 7
6
%>F??& % " " %( ,
>F
" 9 233Q&0
7 "
>042 " 9 Q&0
6
7
0
) 6
" 9 " " " " 23 7
" &0 * 6
2>
" 0 * 2&
>
" "
7
7 "
9 7
" % "
"
0 * "
"
"
"
P
2R "
9
% "
6
" " 7 D % 0>R3&0 , 6 @0Q>@ >P0?3@ 6 202>>&0 * " "
7
0)
7
7
" 7 %22
220>3 ,
"
0
&0 * " "
" 6
"
"
"
"
0 "
0
0
"
Q0 >*
-" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -" -"
P -"
"
> 2 P Q R @ 4 ? F >3 >> >2 >P >Q >R >@ >4 >? >Fb 23b 2>b 22 2P 2Q 2R
>3
< < " " " " " $ $ $ $
. . . .
%>FF@& %>FF@& %>FF@& %>FF@& %>F?F& %>F?F& %>F??& %>F??& %>F??& %>F??& %>F??& %>FFF& %>FFF& %>FFF& %>FFF& %>F??& %>F??& %>F??& %>F??&
) ) )
%>F@>& %>F@>& %>F@>&
5 >29 >P9 >@
>4
"
7
0 , / c Z%
> 2 P Q > 2 > 2 P Q R > 2 P Q > 2 P Q > 2 P > 2 P
%>F??& %>F??& %>F??&
" " AA
7
"
%0 0
9
"
"
GA
7
7
"
' "
" "
202 M >P0?0
"
/ GA
6 & *
"
"
" 0 $" " %>F@>& % "
&9
"
6 / ) %30?P9 30?R9 >03?& 6 7
5 7 "
7 6
" %>02@
5 7 " 0 + "
" 0, >& ] %
" 6 "
(
2&[O >
]
25
7
"
"
"
" 7
/ -$c Z%
>
" >&-$> ] %
2
>&-$2&[O%
>
]
2
7 M 2&0
9 " " "
" 7
P44
/
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
Q
FF@&
) *
F?F& *
7
7
. "
$ .
$5
6 7
%>FFF&
X
7 "
"
7 " " *
"
"
- "
7
%>F??&
- " *
"
7 "
%>F??&
7 " - "
)
* " "
%>F@>&
0 "
* "
%)
%>FF?&
" "
7
7 7 $&
"
7
9
" ,
(
"
3.2 First run with outliers included (25 effect sizes) 3.2.1 Results using META by Kenny *
R
" >*
R
" -"
"
B
A
"
2R 2@>F
-" : 7
>042??•
6 6
7
*
R03F
6
>0@F?2
7
>04P?Q
7
302?>@
< -$
>3P204>QFb
-#"
7
U
0• ' " { 0333>
2Q
2Q0Q23?b
'
∗
2Q
30PRF2 M 30@Q3? 6
(
30>32Q
P?R4 "
"
*
-(,,
0
7
0 '
7
/
P4?
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
-" "
> 2 P Q R @ 4 ? F >3 >> >2 >P >Q >R >@ >4 >? >F 23 2> 22 2P 2Q 2R
$
@
*
"
B
A
*
2 "
>F >F >F >F >?> >?> >3@ >3@ >3@ >3@ >3@ @3 @> >33 @4 43 43 PQ PQ 24Q 24P 2@Q F? F? F?
2> 2> 2> 2> >?P >?P >3? >3? >3? >3? >3? @2 @P >32 @F 42 42 P@ P@ 24@ 24R 2@@ >33 >33 >33
6
>0>22> 30@23Q 3042R2 30>2P2 ?0>4?@ 30?@@4 3 302Q?2 30FF2F ?02QR@ 30>F?R 30P3R4 30RP?@ 30FFP4 30Q>3> 30R3>P 3043Q4 >03FP> 20>@24 @0PFF3 >P04@?4 30R3Q4 30>2F3 ?0?R2F 30>RQ4
6
>0>@?F 30@Q@P 304RRQ 30>2?P ?02>24 30?43Q 3 302R > ?0P3QR 302 30P3F@ 30RQRP >033>2 30Q>Q? 30R3@? 304>2P >0>>?3 202>>F @0Q>@@ >P0?3@4 30R3@> 30>P33 ?0F2>Q 30>RRF
30R2P3 30P2>P 30P@?4 @042RP Q0>2?? 30Q33? 3 30>2R> 30QR3R Q0>?4R 30>33Q 30>RQ> 302@43 30P?F2 3023RF 302PRQ 30P22P 30Q4@4 304P>R 30FRQF 30F?F4 302Q@2 @0RR3P Q0QF4? 40?QQP
20QP>F >0Q23> >0@QQ> 302?FR R0RQ42 R0@2P@ 3 >02F3? Q0?F24 30QP3P >03PQ> >0>F@R 20>>RQ Q03QPQ >0@F44 >0FF>2 204@>4 20FP?? R03@R4 2R044?3 P20R@R@ Q03RF2 30@Q4Q 30QQQP 3044R4
%
20@4R2 >0Q4F2 >042?F 302FP? R0RRQF R0??4Q 3 >02FF3 R0>F@> 30QP>R >03PF2 >023?? 20>@Q3 Q022@3 >04224 203242 20?QFR P0>@22 @02R@2 RP02@R? >>Q0Q42@ Q0>24Q 30@QF? 30QQR4 3044?FQ
7 &
304@>R 30@@3@ 30@?QP 30RPP@2 30QF4FP 30433QQ 30R 30R@2R 3042R2 30R23F 30RR32 30R443 30@PPR 30@FQ@ 30@32F 30@>44 30@@>> 304P?P 30?@R4 30F44Q 30FFQ? 30P4@? 30Q@42 30Q44R 30RPF2
> %
7 &
302P?Q 30PPFP 30P>R@ 30Q@@P 30R323 302FFR 30R 30QP4Q 3024Q4 30Q4F3 30QQF4 30Q22F 30P@@Q 30P3RP 30PF43 30P?22 30PP?? 302@>@ 30>PQ2 202R2Q R0>2?P 30@2P> 30RP24 30R22Q 30Q@34
%
> " >&
2 % " 2&
>3 >> >3 >> >3 >> >3 >> F> F2 F> F2 RQ RQ RQ RQ RQ RQ RQ RQ RQ RQ PR 24 P2 P> 4F 2P PQ PR Q? 2Q Q? 2Q 2Q >2 2Q >2 >QP >PP >P@ >PF >PP >PP R2 Q? R2 Q? R2 Q?
Q0R?2R Q0R?2R Q0R?2R Q0R?2R >P0R244 >P0R244 >30PF2P >30PF2P >30PF2P >30PF2P >30PF2P 40?4Q33 40FP42R >303FFR ?0P3@@2 ?0Q?R2? ?0Q?R2? @ @ >@0@>P2 >@0R?P> >@0P3FR >3 >3 >3
P4F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
3.2.2 Results using meta-analysis by Schwarzer *
4
" >*
4
"
"
-
-
6 A
" "
6
-
"
2R
*
6
2@>F
>02@>Q
-
30R?QR
?0RQ>@
-$
20F22@
>02R33
-
30R?2F
?0QF@4
-$
20F>QF
6 +
7
7 6
:"
6
+
7
7 6
:0
Y= 6 -
]
30Q@4R
U
>30QQ2Qb
,
Y
3033>@
. FRj
-$
30P4F?
(
303Q33
-
303Q33
30RRRP
E
>3P20@F@4 c 2Q
7 Y 6
Y
>02P>P
-
30R?2F
$ )* FRj
(
303??4
20P4PFbb
-
U
20>>22
7 +
7
7
?0QF@4>
"
7
?0Q33F
"
7
>0>P
7
B 6 "
6
FRj ( 7
*
{ 0333>0
∗∗
>3>P042>3
c 2Q
%>F?P&
>02@2>
FRj ( 7
>0>4>2
30RPP@
.
30333P
30R3RP
30R@3F
(
>0PRR
2>P?0?R@>
#" +
∗
303FR4 E
A '
Y
' 023
>2?0F>R>
' 0?3
>P0Q4?4
Y $ )* ' 0R3
P@0R@@3
{ 033R0
-(,,
7
0*
?
-
6 A
0
P?3
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
?$
-
6 A
-" "
-
6 " >
%
" &
%
6 " 2 " &
6
>
>3
>>
>0>@?F
>
2
>3
>>
30@23R
>
P
>3
>>
304RRQ
>
Q
>3
>>
30>2P2
>
R
F>
F2
3033?2
>
@
F>
F2
30?43Q>
>
4
RQ
RQ
3
>
?
RQ
RQ
302R
> >
F
RQ
RQ
>
>3
RQ
RQ
303?P
>
>>
RQ
RQ
302
>
>2
PR
24
30P3F@
>
>P
P2
P>
30RQRQ
>
>Q
4F
2P
>033>P
>
>R
PQ
PR
30Q>Q?
>
>@
Q?
2Q
30R3@
>
>4
Q?
2Q
304>2Q
>
>?
2Q
>2
>0>>?
>
>F
2Q
>2
202>>F
>
23
>QP
>PP
@0Q>@4
>
2>
>P@
>PF
>P0?3@4
>
22
>PP
>PP
30R3@>
>
2P
R2
Q?
30>P3>
>
2Q
R2
Q?
303?F2
>
2R
R2
Q?
30>RRF
>
3.3 Second run with outliers excluded (22 effect sizes) 3.3.1 Results using META by Kenny *
F
"
"
B
*
>3
"
0
P?>
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
F
"
-"
"
B
"
22 23P2
-" : 7
6 6
*
30PPRQ 7
30Q4?4
6
P02?@P b
7
30PQ3?
7
30>RQ3
< -$
7
∗
{ 033R0
∗∗
2>
30Q2P3 M 30R443 6
(
'
A
-#" U
>3P0PPP@ bb
2>
R0R@F4 bb >R@
{ 0333>
P?2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
-"
>3
* $
"
B
A
>
$
*
2
"
6
6
>
%
"
2
%
%
% 7 &
7 &
"
"
>&
2&
>
>F
2>
>0>22>
>0>@?F
30R2P3
20QP>F
20@4R2
304@>R
302P?Q
>3
>>
Q0R?2R
2
>F
2>
30@23Q
30@Q@P
30P2>P
>0Q23>
>0Q4F2
30@@3@
30PPFP
>3
>>
Q0R?2R
P
>F
2>
3042R2
304RRQ
30P@?4
>0@QQ>
>042?F
30@?QP
30P>R@
>3
>>
Q0R?2R
Q
>F
2>
30>2P2
30>2?P
@042RP
302?FR
302FP?
30RPP@
30Q@@P
>3
>>
Q0R?2R
R
>?>
>?P
?0>4?@
?02>24
Q0>2??
R0RQ42
R0RRQF
30QF4F
30R323
F>
F2
>P0R24
@
>?>
>?P
30?@@4
30?43Q
30Q33?
R0@2P4
R0??42
30433Q
302FFR
F>
F2
>P0R24
4
>3@
>3?
3
3
3
30R
30R
RQ
RQ
>30PF2
?
>3@
>3?
302Q?2
302R
30>2R>
>02F3?
>02FF3
30R@2R
30QP4Q
RQ
RQ
>30PF2
F
>3@
>3?
30FF2F
>
30QR3R
Q0?F24
R0>F@>
3042R2
3024Q4
RQ
RQ
>30PF2
>3
>3@
>3?
?02QR@
?0P3QR
Q0>?4R
30QP3P
30QP>R
30R23F
30Q4F3
RQ
RQ
>30PF2
>>
>3@
>3?
30>F?R
302
30>33Q
>03PQ>
>03PF2
30RR32
30QQF4
RQ
RQ
>30PF2
>2
@3
@2
30P3R4
30P3F@
30>RQ>
>0>F@R
>023??
30R443
30Q22F
PR
24
40?4Q3
>P
@>
@P
30RP?@
30RQRP
302@43
20>>RQ
20>@Q3
30@PPR
30P@@Q
P2
P>
40FP42
>Q
>33
>32
30FFP4
>033>2
30P?F2
Q03QPQ
Q022@3
30@FQ@
30P3RP
4F
2P
>303FF
>R
@4
@F
30Q>3>
30Q>Q?
3023RF
>0@F44
>04224
30@32F
30PF43
PQ
PR
?0P3@@
>@
43
42
30R3>P
30R3@?
302PRQ
>0FF>2
203242
30@>44
30P?22
Q?
2Q
?0Q?R2
>4
43
42
3043Q4
304>2P
30P22P
204@>4
20?QFR
30@@>>
30PP??
Q?
2Q
?0Q?R2
>?
PQ
P@
>03FP>
>0>>?3
30Q4@4
20FP??
P0>@22
304P?P
302@>@
2Q
>2
@
>F
2@Q
2@@
30R3Q4
30R3@>
Q03RF2
Q0>24Q
30P4@?
30@2P>
>PP
>PP
>@0P3F
23
F?
>33
30>2F3
30>P33
2>
F?
>33
?0?R2F
22
F?
>33
?0F2>Q
30>RQ4
30>RRF
302Q@2
3
3
@0RR3P
30@Q4Q
30@QF?
30Q@42
30RP24
R2
Q?
>3
Q0QF4?
30QQQP
30QQR4
30Q44R
30R22Q
R2
Q?
>3
40?QQP
3044R4
3044?F
30RPF2
30Q@34
R2
Q?
>3
3.3.2 Results using meta-analysis by Schwarzer *
>>
"
"
-
6
*
>2
"
0
P?P
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
>>
"
"
-
-
6 A
" " 6 6
+
7
7 6
:"
6
+
7
7
:0
6
-
22
*
30Q>P@F
-
303F@4@
3023@33
-$
30QRP?4
30Q3RR>
-
303FQF@
30>F?PF
-$
30QQRQ>
Y= ]
302P43P
U
R0>F3>b
6 -
FRj ( 7
30>Q4R
6
,
303QR>>
-
-$
303QR>>
30P2@R
FRj ( 7 +
7
30>@F4 7
"
7
"
7
Y
30PQ?>
$ )*
>3P202Q>> c 2>b
E
Y 6
23P2
Y
303323P
.
"
-
303F>3
-
30R2@@
P0?2P4b
U
30>F?P
7
30>>FR
3034?? E
>320@F?R
c 2>b
PF04P j B 6 " 6 FRj ( 7
023 ' 0?3
0∗
FRj ( 7
30>@F?
30>2?2?
.
30333R
303?Q@ +
'
%>F?P&
302R?4
A ' >@02FQ3
(
30>4>R
#" Y
30PQ?>
>3F0FP@2 Y $ )*
' 0R3
@0@?2Q
>20Q2@R
{ 0333
P?Q
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
>2 $
"
-
-" "
"
%
-
6 " >
%
" &
-6 " 2
6
>
>3
>0>@?F
>
2
>3
>>
30@23R
>
P
>3
>>
304RRQ
>
Q
>3
>>
30>2P2
>
R
F>
F2
3033?2
>
@
F>
F2
30?43Q>
> >
4
"
-
" & >>
>>
>>
6 A
RQ
RQ
3
?
RQ
RQ
302R
>
F
RQ
RQ
>
>
>3
RQ
RQ
303?P
>
>>
RQ
RQ
302
>
>2
PR
24
30P3F@
>
>P
P2
P>
30RQRQ
>
>Q
4F
2P
>033>P
>
>R
PQ
PR
30Q>Q?
>
>@
Q?
2Q
30R3@
>
>4
Q?
2Q
304>2Q
>
>?
2Q
>2
>0>>?
>
>F
>PP
>PP
30R3@>
>
23
R2
Q?
30>P3>
>
2>
R2
Q?
303?F2
>
22
R2
Q?
30>RRF
>
"
B
A
"
A
"
P?R
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
4. Discussion " "
"
"
9
"
"
0*
"
7
0
4.1 Kenny’s programme ,
" " "
"
" "
" %B
"
9B 6
7 2>0 * "
" 6
7 30PPRQ
T+
6
9 >FFR5 6
"
"
" " 5 7 7 " 9
0*
" 0*
6 c R0R@F4
" " 9 >FFR&0 * " % " " " { 3033> *
&
9 < -$ % 0* " A
6 &
" "
7
;
"
" #" "
0 *
6 6 " ( 6 30PPQ
6 " B "
0 0 >R@ %- "
9 >F?R5 - "
T
>2
9 233P&9 " 9 302 %
9 >F?P&0 B
" &9 30R %
"
& "
" "
"
7 A %B
9
"
" " "
7
" 0*
" "
&
7 " 7 " 0,
" 6 "
#" %
9
23P2 { 3033R c 7 "
5 P02?@P
9 " 6 7
"
*
" 6 "
" " 7 30? %
A
>R@ " 7
"
" 6
" 0$ 6 9 >F?F&0 * "
" & %-
6 0
4.2 Schwarzer’s programme * "
6 GA "
"
" " " &0 * PF04Pj
23P2 7 6
A
* -
6 A 30R
9
B
97 "
5 6 09 >FFQ&
>2
C >FF@9 022F&0
-
" 6 A 0 "
7
9
7 " " "
#" %
&
7
" "
7
0,
+ A 30PPRQ 7 " B %>F?P& 7 "
B 6
30PQ?>P " 9 " " 6 A 6 7 % " " "
9
;
6 A "
7
7
"
"
6 "
" 30?
302P43P
"
7
" "
" 6
0*
6 #" % -
#" AA
"
" 7 A 0
"
GA 30PQ?>P "
7 0 7 0+
7 AA
"
3029 30R
30R
A 0 "
7
"
0
"
A
"
" B "
0-
7 30PQ?>P % 9 FRj 6 9 >F?F& %( "
6
&
0
6 " 0
303>24P
7 6 9 233Q&0
9 9 "
" %
" 0
" D %B
T
"
" 9
P?@
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
*
" " " 0' "
>' "
:"
"
> "
6
>
6
"
"
" "
"
>
"
220
"
Effext size range according to study number 1.4 1.2
1
18
Effect size
1
9
14
6
0.8
3
17
2
0.6
13
0.4
16
15 12
8
0.2
11
4
0
22
10
7
5
21
20
-0.2 -0.4
19
-0.6
Study number
4.3 A search for moderators $" " "
6
#"
"
: 0 *
7
"
"
6
2> 6
6 9 9 >FFR -
233P5 6
"
0
" %(
%
>P&
>j 9 Rj >3j 6 %>F?F&9 C " 7 6
#"
6 "
" %
" 7
" 7 " 9 %>F?R&AA % 0PP&0 7 0
"
%"
%
"
"
"
7
>F
"
7 7
" "
" >P
7 7
9
9
" &0
7
" "
:
9
" "
"
% 6
" " " 6 &
7
5 " "
" 9 >FFQ5 B
6
"
" )
" T=
"
6 9 >F?F&0 6 A
" #" 7
9 233Q5 6
" "
"
6
"
7
6 9 >F?F&0 ( "
&
"
"
7
&9
-
%
"
"
7 " " "
"
0* "
0
P?4
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
>*
>P
6
"
() -*
- * > j Rj
>3j ) . )- +' -, () -*
,',(
(
>
-"
,$ >
-6 c
>0>@?F
-"
,$ >?
-6 c
>0>>?3
-"
,$ >Q
-6 c
>033>P
-"
,$ F
-6 c
>03333
-"
,$ @
-6 c
30?43Q
-"
,$ P
-6 c
304RRQ
-"
,$ >4
-6 c
304>2Q
-"
,$ 2
-6 c
30@23R
-"
,$ >P
-6 c
30RQRQ
-"
,$ >@
-6 c
30R3@3
-"
,$ >R
-6 c
30Q>Q?
-"
,$ >2
-6 c
30P3F@
-"
,$ ?
-6 c
302R33
-"
,$ >>
-6 c
302333
-"
,$ 22
-6 c
30>RRF
-"
,$ Q
-6 c
30>2P2
-"
,$ >3
-6 c
303?P3
-"
,$ 4
-6 c
303333
-"
,$ R
-6 c
3033?2
-"
,$ 2>
-6 c
303?F2
-"
,$ 23
-6 c
30>P3>
-6 c
30R3@>
() -* -"
2
,$c >F ,
7
-
-
- 6 c F20P@P@
- 6 - 0 $ 7c R?0P33@
(
-
-6
c 30R3F?
4.4 Limitations of the meta-analysis '
4
"
"
% "
"
22&
"
" " 4
"
9 22
"
6
22
" 7
"
>3 " "
" "
"
0
&5
"
"
" "
"
#" % 7
" "
- " "
"
#"
0*
" - "
7 A
&
0*
" "
9 0 0
"
7
%
7
7 "
" " 6
7 " "
"
7 0>3
7 "
7 7
" "
"
" " 9 " "
" 6 9 >2 0* "
7 "
" 7
0 " 7
7
9
0
4.5 Implications of the findings for dynamic assessment research in South Africa *
6 "
" "
30PPRQ 6 A
"
B 0 ,
A
7
" " "
"
"
" "
30PQ?>
7
7
9
"
" 0*
6
#"
- " 6
7
-
- "
"
7 " 7 "
" 0*
"
P??
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
"
7 "
" 4
"
0* "
9
7 9
7
0
4.6 Recommendations 0
" "
"
"
7 A
9
" "
"
$
" ""
""
"
0
"
9
0,
"
"
"
0
- " "
"
" " 7 " 0
"
" " :"
"
7
9
" 7
"
""
" 0,
"
"
"
0 " 6
9
B 0 *
9 "
"
"
-
6 A 7
% "
7
"
0
"
"
"
"
" #"
7 - " 0 ,
"
7
"
" 0 " "0 7
7
" " "
"
" "
#"
6
6 7 9 " #" 7
"
"
" 0 $
"
" 6
7
& "
#"
7
"
"
0
5. Conclusion *
"
/
- "
7
"
" 0
" "
"
" "
7 0
" 30PPRQ 6 9
6
0 $"
#"
"
" 7 "
"
"
7
" " 0 )
"
7
" 9
"
"
" " 0 "
"
"
"
"
"
" " "
7
7
"
" #"
"" 0* 9
"
#" "
""
"
0
" - "
" "
0* 7 "
" 30PQ?> 7 9
7 ,
"
"
9
0
6. Excursion into a potentially rich field of investigation – an aside to this meta-analysis 6.1 From GeneWays to MemeWays>P 9
>P
(
>FF@ 7 "
%
7 "
%
" 7
" *
%
Q
>Q
"
&
9
7
9
" "
"
"
A
"
7
" 9
"
7
7 "
0 "
7
"
& "
7 7
7
"
- " " "
% 0 "
7 7 "
0 06 0 * 7
0
P?F
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
9
0 " 7
, '
"
7
"
7
9 GA = 9 233Q&
AA % 6 " "
9)
79 B
9B "
9B 9
"
"
9 !"9 $"
"W9 =
"
"
0, "
9 =
0
&
"
"
9
" 7
" 7
GA
AA "
7
"
#" 0
"
"
7 9 233R&0 +
0 *
G
A 97
9
9 #" A
7
"
"
" #" " " 9
0
*
7 " 0
7
7
7 =
"
9
7
:"
" "
7
%233P&
"
" " 0
"
"
"
9 9
"
9
"
9 %(
7 "
" /
7 "
" %=
"
9
7 9 "
7
" 0 *
" 7
&9 9 23325
"
7 7 " "
"
% 7 9 233P5 =
T=
7 "
9 " 9 233Q&0 &9
"
9
% 0>R>&0
"
7
" #"
7
7
7 "
" 9 9 9 9 23325 = 9 233P 5 = 9 233P & 7 " T ) "9 233P5 = 9 9 T= 9 233P5 ! %
"
" 9>@ "
9
" T=
%=
"
"
" * "
9 233P 9 0>R>&0
" 9 233P&0
%
R
>R
#"
0
"
" "
&9
&
9 -0 0bb
%2&>FF@ %P& 7 " ' " X 7 %Q& 7 9 6 " %R& " %@& B U" " %4&* " ) $5 %?& 2> % 2Q& %F& 2 %>3& = " " %>>& " " " %>2& - 4 % F&5 7 >Q %>P& ) $ " 9 6 " %>Q& #" " 9 9 7 " " %>R& % & " 5 " 7 %>@& < " %>4& >Q %>?& 3>/ " 7 " 5 32/ " % C " D " %>F& 7 9 #" 9 9 9 9 7 " #" " 2 " %23& " + 6 " A 0 " `c2R9 -$c>R0??9 c>35 `c@39 -$c>R0P29 c>35 c20F4 % {303>&0 ( `c230?9 -$c>40@Q9 c>>5 (
" " / `cQ20R9
PF2
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
-$c>Q0@R9 c>>5 c3032 % x30>&0 + 6 / `c2>0F9 -$c>?0?29 c>35 `cRF0R9 -$c>F0R9 c>35 cQ03R % {3033R&0 ( `c2P0P9 -$cF0QF9 c>>5 ( `cQ@9 -$c2203@9 c>>5 c30@RQ % x30>&0( " % &/ ( / `c>@029 -$c202P9 c>35 `c>R0R9 -$c>0F@9 c>30 ( `c>@049 -$c>9 c>>5 ( `c>P0R9 -$cP0>Q9 c>>0 / `c>P0Q9 -$cQ0?@9 c>35 `c4029 -$cP0>39 c>35 ( `c>20R9 -$c20FP9 c>>5 ( `c@0?9 -$cP0>P9 c>>0 * 7 " / " c>04R {30> " / c @0?4 {30333R M 7 9 " " 7 % " " & %2>& 3> 32 " 6 " " % GA AA GA " AA9 " " " " " 7 &0 + " " " " 0 %22& ( / " " %2P& 6 9 + 6 " " " % " &0 ( " " 0 %>&-
9 ,0 0
%2&>F?@ %P& %Q& 7 %R& " %@& 1 %4& *
7
7
"
= $ " " " )
7
$&
" )
$
"
"
' "
X
%
"
7
%?& >R@ %F& 2 %>3& < " % " & %>>& 7 7 " %< & " 7 = 0 R2 >3Q %>2& >F0R@ >4 P> %>P& $ " 7 %$ *& % 7 9 0 0 $ O* $ O & % *& % 7 9 0 0 O* O &9 7 - " 0* %$ O$ O$& %>Q& , 0 0' 7 7 " 9 7 7 " " 9 7 " " " #" " %>R& $ *% & *% & " 7 7 " % Q " & %>@& ' c >3Q 7 44 7 24 7 " 5 c R2 7 24 7 2R 7 " %>4& %>?& >/ 7 7 " 7 " 7 " 0 2/ * " 7 " " " " ' " " " 0 -" 2 * " 7 " 7 " " %>F& ' 7 7 " 9 7 7 " " 9 7 " " " #" " %23&* 7 %0 0 7 &9 " 0$ *= " / c>R@9 $ *% & c >@0?F9 $ *% & c 230FP $ *% & c Q0>P5 c>30FQ c3033>0 $ 7 " cR29 $ *% & c >203@9 $ *% & c >@0Q2 $ *% & cQ02P5 c@0@2 c3033>0 7 " c>3Q9 $ *% & c >F0P>9 $ *% & c 2P0>? $ *% & c Q0345 c?0@F c3033>0 *= " / c>R@9 *% & c >30R@9 *% & c >40P2 *% & c @04R5 c>F0?4 c3033>0 $ 7 " 9 cR29 *% & c 402F9 *% & c >20?R *% & c R0>F5 c404? c3033>0 7 " 9 c>3Q9 *% & c >20239 *% & c >F0R@ *% & c40RP5 c230@? c3033>0 "
7 7
" / 7 % 7 $ T
T 303Q5 $ &T 7 303Q9
7 303P9 $ 303R *%
>/ 7 c 30PQ % *% &T 30349 *% * % " / T *% &T 7 &9 *% &T %
" 0, 6 0 T >0?Q@9 $ * % &9 $ * % &T 7
"
" / 7 " % 7 7 " &0 7 c303>& 9 T 7 30RR % c303>&9 $ *% &T 30>P9 $ * % &T 30>F9 $ * % &T 7 303?5 $ *% &T 30349 $ * &T 30>29 *% &T 7 303@9 *% &T 30349 *% &T & T 30>39 * % & T 7 303R0 c 30239 T 7 30>R9 $ *% &T 302R9 $ * % &T 7 302@5 $ * % & 303P5 $ *% &T M 302@9 $ * % &T 7 302F % 30>@9 *% &T 7 302>9 *% &T 303R9 *% &T 7 3039 &T 303@9 * % &T 7 303P0 * " 9 " ' X 30?2F9 T 7 20R@R % c{303R &9 $ * % &T &T 7 20324 % c{ 303R &9 $ * % &T 20>2@ % c{303R >0@?>0 " / " >0 9
"
22
&
, 7
2 " / 0 0 ' " " 7 " 0 $. * $ " / " " / 7 c ( $,*" 303?% &9 '% >O??& >@0FP9 c 30333% 303R&9 *% & 303Q% &9 '% >O??& >0F?9 c 30>@P9 $ * % & 303R% &9 '% >O??& P0F>9 c 303R>0 " #" c 30>?Q% 303R 303>&0 ' " " 30>3 7 7 " ' " " 0 * " 7 / . / " 3043% &9 '% >O??& QR04@9 30333% 303R 303>&9 *% & 3022% &9 '% >O??& >0?29 c30>?>9 $ * % & 3022% &9 '% >O??& 20F?9 c303?? " #" c 30PQR% 303R 303>&0 ' " " 30>3 7 7 "
PFP
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
' "
" / 7 '% >OQQ& 30RF9 c30QQ?9 $ * %
0 $,- $. * $ " /" " c ( $,*" 303R% &9 '% >OQQ& 30F@9 c30PP29 *% & 303Q% &9 & 303R% &9 '% >OQQ& >04?9 c30>F3 " #" c 303FQ0 ' " " 30>3 7 " 7 ' " " 0* " 7 / . / 3 " 30>@% &9 '% >OQQ& 30PQ9 c30R@29 *% & 30PP% &9 '% >OQQ& >03>9 c30P239 $ * % & 30P3% &9 '% >OQQ& 202@9 c30>Q3 " #" c303F@0 > " 30>>% &9 '% >OQQ& 30>@9 c30@?F9 *% & 302F% &9 '% >OQQ& 30?>9 c30P4P9 $ * % & 30P3% &9 '% >OQQ& 20Q?9 c30>22 $ *% & 30Q2 % &9 '% >OQQ& P0R2 c 303@4 #" c30>@R0 ' " " 30>3 7 ' " " 0 7 " 0 2 " " " 0
, 7 2 " / $. * $ " / " / > " $ *% &9 $ * % &$ *% &`$ *% &/ ( $,*-/ $ * % & 303@% & '% >O??& 20?@ c 303FQ9 $ * % & 30>2 % & '% >O??& >0>Q c302??9 $ *% &`$ *% & 3033 % & '% >O??& 30@> c30QP? " #" c 303P?0 . / $ *% & 302P% & '% >O??& >0>@ c 302?Q9 $ * % & 304@ % & '% >O??& >0P> c302R@9 $ *% &`$ *% & 303P % & '% >O??& 30F> c30PQ2 " #" c 303>F0 2 " *% &9 $% &9 *% &` $ % &0 ( $,*-/ *% & 3033% & '% >O??& 3033 c 30F4F9 % & 303F % & '% >O??& 30F2 c30PQ>9 *% &` *% & 303> % & '% >O??& 30@3 c30QQ2 " #" c 3032@0 . / *% & 303?% & '% >O??& 303@ c 30?3R9 *% & 30>3% & '% >O??& 303P c30?RF9 $ *% &`$ *% & 3033 % & '% >O??& 3033 c30F@R " #" c 3033R 2 " " 7 " 0 $,- $. * $ " / " / > $ *% &9 $ * % &$ *% &`$ *% &/ ( $,*-/ $ * % & 30>2% & '% >OQR& @0?> c 303>2 % 303R&9 $ * % & 30>Q % & '% >OQR& >0P4 c302Q?9 $ *% &`$ *% & 3032 % & '% >OQR& P0Q4 c303@F " #" c 30>F2 % 303R&0 . /$ *% & 30RP% & '% >OQR& P042 c 303@39 $ * % & 30>@ % & '% >OQR& 303R c30?229 $ *% &`$ *% & 303R % & '% >OQR& 30?R c30P@P " #" c 30>@R % 303R&0 2 *% &9 $ % &9 * % &` $% &0 ( $,*-/ * % & 303>% & '% >OQR& 303> c 30F2F9 % & 303F % & '% >OQR& 30?R c30P@29 *% &` *% & 3032 % & '% >OQR& >0FR c30>43 " #" c 3034F0 . / * % & 3032% & '% >OQR& 3033 c 30F429 * % & 30@2% & '% >OQR& >0P> c302RF9 $ *% & ` $ * % & 30>> % & '% >OQR& 20Q@ c30>2Q " #" c 30>330 ' " 7 9 " #" 303R0 * 0$ *% & " $ *% & " 0, " " 29 " #" $ *% & " " #" 0$ *% & #" c 303@P ( $,*$ *% & #" c 303@? . 0* " ( $,*#" $ *% & $ *% & 303@P " 30>F29 #" c 30>2F9 ' % 2OQR& c P0@Q % 303R&0 ' . #" $ *% & $ *% & " 303@? 30>@R9 #" c 303F49 ' % 2OQR& c 20@ 0* " 2 7 " " ( $,*-0 ' 7 9 $ *% & 0+ " " " 0 %2>& " 7 7 7 " " " 7 0* 7 " 7 " 9 " 7 " 7 7 0 " 0 %22& ( 7 / 7 " " " " 7 9 7 < >0 7 / 7 $ * * " 0 $ * *0 -" : 7 / 7 7 % 7 7 &5 9 9 % &0 %2P& " " 6 9 7 #" 9 +. X " " 9 7 9 0 " 5 '>0F@ % $ *O$& '30QF % *O$& % cP & c30>23 30@F@ 7 0 * $ * " +. 0 0 >R " " 6 >R@ >Q> % " &0 %>&U
66 9 -0 0
%2& >FF2 %P& 7 " " 7 " " %Q& 7 = %R& " %@& 1 " %4& * " 7 " 7 7 " %?& 2@ %F& > " 7 " " 7 Q %>3& = " %>>& - " " 7 " >2 0= " 7 7 7 %>2& >4 2R %>P& " /< #" %@& 7 7 " %>4& < %>?& >/) 0 2/ " 7 " %>F& * ' " A
"
7
%
"
=
&
' " 0 >Q
5 %
*&5
" 7
7 9
%
% %) --,&0 ) 7
*O*&5
7
*O &5
"
9
" %)- &5
0
" 9
"
7
" 7
" "
0 7
"
0
PFQ
P/
University of Pretoria etd – Murphy, R (2007)
%23& 7 0= 0 c 2@0 ' " c " c 7 % 0 " " 9 ) --, " )> )>39 - E< " 9 20@>9 ) --, )> PQ0>29 Q0R>9 )2 P30@29 Q0Q49 )P 2R0339 Q0RF9 )Q 2>0>29 @0QF9 )R 2@02R9 R0PF9 )@ 2R0>29 ?0?R9 )4 >?0339 P0RQ9 )? 2Q0P49 Q0>39 )F 2@0339 40>R9 )>3 2?02R9 @03?5 - E 240R9 20@49
