to investigate the effectiveness of herbal toothpaste against gingivitis as compared with ... application of fixed appliance in the herbal toothpaste group.
Journal of Dentistry Indonesia 2011, Vol. 18, No. 3, 68-72
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Herbal and Conventional Toothpastes Roles in Gingivitis Control in Orthodontic Patients Stefani A. Dewi1, Fadli Jazaldi2, Benny M. Soegiharto2 1 2
Undergraduate Program, Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta 10430, Indonesia Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta 10430, Indonesia
ABSTRACT 2UWKRGRQWLFWUHDWPHQWZLWK¿[HGDSSOLDQFHDLPVWRLPSURYHHVWKHWLFVDQGIXQFWLRQRIPDVWLFDWLRQDQGVSHHFK KRZHYHUWKHFRPSRQHQWVRQD¿[HGDSSOLDQFHDVEDQGVEUDFNHWVDQGOLJDWXUHVPD\LQFUHDVHWKHDPRXQWRISODTXH DVWKHSULPDU\HWLRORJ\RIJLQJLYLWLVObjective: $GRXEOHEOLQGVWXG\RIUDQGRPL]HGFOLQLFDOWULDOZDVGHVLJQHG WRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWHDJDLQVWJLQJLYLWLVDVFRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOWRRWKSDVWH LQRUWKRGRQWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK¿[HGDSSOLDQFHMethods:6L[WHHQVXEMHFWVEHIRUHWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HGRUWKRGRQWLF DSSOLDQFHZDVVHOHFWHGEDVHGRQLQFOXVLRQFULWHULD7KH\ZHUHWKHQUDQGRPL]HGXVLQJEORFNUDQGRPL]DWLRQPHWKRG DQGGLYLGHGLQWRWKHWHVWJURXSDQGWKHFRQWUROJURXS*LQJLYDOLQGH[RI/|HDQG6LOOQHVVH[DPLQHGEHIRUHEUDFNHWV ERQGLQJDQGWZRZHHNVDIWHU3DLUHGWWHVWZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLIIHUHQFHVZLWKLQWKHJURXSVDQGXQSDLUHG WWHVWZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQJURXSVDWEDVHOLQHDQGWZRZHHNVDIWHUResults:7KHUHZDV DWHQGHQF\RIGHFUHDVLQJLQJLQJLYDOLQGH[EXWWKHUHZHUHQRVLJQL¿FDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKH DSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HGDSSOLDQFHLQWKHKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWHJURXS7KHUHZDVDWHQGHQF\RILQFUHDVLQJLQJLQJLYDOLQGH[ DQGWKHUHZHUHVLJQL¿FDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HGDSSOLDQFHLQWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO WRRWKSDVWHJURXS7KHUHZDVVLJQL¿FDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSVConclusion:7KHUHZDVVLJQL¿FDQW GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSVKHUEDOLQGLFDWHVHIIHFWLYHQHVVLQJLQJLYLWLVFRQWURODIWHUWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HG RUWKRGRQWLFDSSOLDQFHVRLWFRXOGEHXVHGDVDQDOWHUQDWLYHQDWXUDOEDVHGWRRWKSDVWHLQRYHUFRPLQJJLQJLYLWLVLQ RUWKRGRQWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK¿[HGDSSOLDQFH
ABSTRAK Peran pasta gigi herbal dengan pasta gigi konvensional terhadap kontrol gingivitis pada pasien ortodonti dengan alat cekat. 3HUDZDWDQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWEHUWXMXDQXQWXNSHUEDLNDQHVWHWLNGDQIXQJVLPDVWLNDVL GDQELFDUDSDVLHQ.RPSRQHQSDGDDODWFHNDWVHSHUWL bandsbracketsGDQligaturesGLGDODPPXOXWGDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQMXPODKSODNVHEDJDLHWLRORJLXWDPDJLQJLYLWLVTujuan:3HQHOLWLDQUDQGRPLVDVLNOLQLVdouble blind LQLGLUDQFDQJXQWXNPHQHOLWLHIHNWLYLWDVSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOWHUKDGDSJLQJLYLWLVGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQSDVWDJLJL NRQYHQVLRQDOSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWMetode: (QDPEHODVVXEMHN\DQJDNDQPHQJJXQDNDQDODW RUWRGRQWLFHNDWGLSLOLKEHUGDVDUNDQNULWHULDLQNOXVLNHPXGLDQGLDFDNGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQPHWRGHEORNUDQGRPLVDVL VHKLQJJDWHUEDJLGDODPNHORPSRNWHVGDQNHORPSRNNRQWURO3HPHULNVDDQLQGHNVJLQJLYD/|HGDQ6LOOQHVVGLODNXNDQ GLDZDOVHEHOXPbonding bracketsGDQGXDPLQJJXVHWHODKQ\D 8MLVWDWLVWLNSDUDPHWULNWEHUSDVDQJDQGLJXQDNDQ XQWXNPHPEDQGLQJNDQSHUEHGDDQGDODPWLDSNHORPSRNGDQXMLWWLGDNEHUSDVDQJDQXQWXNPHPEDQGLQJNDQ SHUEHGDDQDQWDUNHORPSRNDQWDUDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKSHUODNXDQ Hasil: 7HUGDSDWNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQXUXQDQ LQGHNVJLQJLYDQDPXQWLGDNWHUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDDQWDUDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKDSOLNDVLDODWRUWRGRQWL FHNDWSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJLKHUEDO7HUGDSDWNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQLQJNDWDQLQGHNVJLQJLYDGDQWHUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQ \DQJEHUPDNQDDQWDUDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKDSOLNDVLDODWFHNDWSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO7HUGDSDW SHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDDQWDUDNHGXDNHORPSRNSimpulan: 7HUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQEHUPDNQDSDGDNHGXDSDVWD JLJLSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOPHQXQMXNNDQHIHNWLYLWDVQ\DWHUKDGDSNRQWUROJLQJLYLWLVVHWHODKDSOLNDVLDODWRUWRGRQWLFHNDW VHKLQJJDGDSDWGLMDGLNDQDOWHUQDWLISDVWDJLJLEHUEDVLVDODPLGDODPPHQJDWDVLJLQJLYLWLVSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWL GHQJDQDODWFHNDW Key words:IL[HGRUWKRGRQWLFDSSOLDQFHJLQJLYLWLVKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWH
68
Journal of Dentistry Indonesia 2011, Vol. 18, No. 3, 68-72
PENDAHULUAN 3HUDZDWDQRUWRGRQWLVHODLQEHUWXMXDQXQWXNPHPSHU EDLNLPDORNOXVLMXJDXQWXNPHQLQJNDWNDQNHVHKDWDQ JLJLGDQPXOXWIXQJVLPDVWLNDVLIXQJVLELFDUDGDQ HVWHWLND13HUOXGLVDGDULSHUDZDWDQLQLMXJDGDSDWPH QLQJNDWNDQMXPODKSODNGDQPHPEHULGDPSDNEXUXN EDJLNHVHLPEDQJDQÀRUDOLQJNXQJDQURQJJDPXOXW .RPSRQHQNRPSRQHQSDGDDODWRUWRGRQWLFHNDWVHSHUWL ligatures, brackets, bandsGDQarchwiresPHPEXDW SODNVXOLWGLMDQJNDXGDULDNVLPHQJJRVRNJLJLPDVWLND VLGDQODMXDOLUDQVDOLYD6WXGLVHEHOXPQ\DPHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZDSODNGLWHPXNDQSDOLQJGRPLQDQGLGDHUDKVHU YLNDObracket GDQGLEDZDKOHQJNXQJNDZDW2.HJDJD ODQGDODPPHQJDWDVLSODNGDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQULVLNR GHNDOVL¿NDVLNDULHVGDQJLQJLYLWLV *LQJLYLWLV\DQJ MXJDGLNHQDOVHEDJDLUDGDQJJLQJLYDPHUXSDNDQVDODK VDWXSHQ\DNLWSHULRGRQWDO\DQJGLVHEDENDQROHKDNX PXODVLSODN92OHKNDUHQDLWXNHEHUVLKDQPXOXW\DQJ RSWLPXPKDUXVGLMDJDVHODPDSHUDZDWDQRUWRGRQWL &DUDPHNDQLV\DQJSDOLQJVHGHUKDQDGDQHIHNWLIDGDODK GHQJDQPHQJJRVRNJLJLPHQJJXQDNDQSDVWDJLJL10 %HODNDQJDQLQLPDV\DUDNDWVHULQJPHQFDULSURGXN DOWHUQDWLIVHSHUWLSDVWDJLJLKHUEDONDUHQDWLGDNEHUVL IDWNLPLDZLGDQGLDQJJDSOHELKDPDQVHUWDEHUVLIDW QDWXUDO3DVWDJLJLKHUEDOPHQJDQGXQJVRGLXPELNDU ERQDWVRGLXPÀRULGDSSP GDQNDQGXQJDQEDKDQ KHUEDO%DKDQKHUEDOWHUVHEXWWHUGLULDWDVNDPRPLO\DQJ PHPLOLNLVLIDWDQWLLQÀDPDVLGDQPDPSXPHUHGDNDQ LQÀDPDVLJLQJLYDechinacea\DQJGLNHWDKXLPDPSX PHQVWLPXODVLUHVSRQVLPXQsage dan rhatany\DQJPH PLOLNLVLIDWDQWLSHQGDUDKDQmyrrhNHPHQ\DQVHEDJDL EDKDQDQWLVHSWLNDODPLGDQSHSHUPLQ\DQJPHPLOLNL VLIDWDQWLLQÀ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
GHQJDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOWHUKDGDSJLQJLYLWLV SDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDW
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informed consent.ULWHULDHNVNOXVLSHQHOLWDQLQL DQWDUDODLQVXEMHNPHQJNRQVXPVLREDWREDWDQDQWLELR WLNDGDODPMDQJNDZDNWXWLJDEXODQVHGDQJGDODPPDVD NHKDPLODQPHPLOLNLSHQ\DNLWVLVWHPLNPHPLOLNLNH ELDVDDQPHURNRNGDQPHPDNDLDODWSURVWRGRQWLOHSDV .HHQDPEHODVVXEMHN\DQJPHPHQXKLNULWHULDWHUVH EXWNHPXGLDQGLEDJLPHQMDGLGXDNHORPSRNGHQJDQ metode randomized clinical trial EHUGDVDUNDQWDEHO EORNUDQGRPLVDVLVHKLQJJDGLSHUROHKNHORPSRN\DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQSDVWDJLJL$KHUEDO*OD[R6PLWK.OLQH %ULWDQLD 5D\D GDQ NHORPSRN \DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQ SDVWD JLJL % NRQYHQVLRQDO 8QLOHYHU .HGXD SDVWD JLJLWHUVHEXWPHUXSDNDQSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOGDQSDVWD JLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO\DQJWHODKGLVDPDUNDQdouble-blind study 3DGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLEDLNNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJL$ GDQNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJL%PHQJJXQDNDQVLNDWJLJL PDQXDOGDWDUGHQJDQWHNQLNVLNDWJLJLPRGL¿NDVL%DVV \DQJGLJDEXQJNDQGHQJDQWHNQLNPRGL¿NDVLSDVWDJLJL À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|HGDQ6LOQHVVSDGDJLJL5DPIMRUG GDQ 6HWHODKVXEMHNPHQJJXQDNDQRUWRGRQWL GHQJDQDODWFHNDWGDQEHUVLNDWJLJLGHQJDQSDVWDVLNDW GDQWHQLNVHVXDLGHQJDQ\DQJSHQHOLWLDMDUNDQVHODPD GXDPLQJJXNHPXGLDQGLODNXNDQSHPHULNVDDQNHGXD 7 'DWD KDVLO NHGXD SHPHULNVDDQ LQL NHPXGLDQ GLRODKPHQJJXQDNDQSURJUDP6366XQWXNPHPEDQ GLQJNDQQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDVHEHOXPGDQVHWHODKSHU 69
Journal of Dentistry Indonesia 2011, Vol. 18, No. 3, 68-72
ODNXDQEDLNSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWD$PDXSXQNHORPSRN SDVWD%GDQMXJDXQWXNPHPEDQGLQJNDQVHOLVLKQLODL LQGHNVJLQJLYDVHEHOXPGDQVHWHODKSHUODNXDQDQWDUD NHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQNHORPSRNSDVWD%3DGDSHQH OLWLDQLQLKDVLOGDWDPHQXQMXNNDQDGDQ\DVHEDUDQ\DQJ QRUPDOXMLQRUPDOLWDV6DSKLUR:LON ROHKNDUHQDLWX GLJXQDNDQODKXMLNHPDNQDDQSDUDPHWULNEDLN\DQJ EHUSDVDQJDQXQWXNPHQJXMLPDVLQJPDVLQJNHORPSRN PDXSXQ\DQJWLGDNEHUSDVDQJDQXQWXNPHQJXMLDQWDU NHORPSRN
3HQLQJNDWDQ LQLEDQ\DNWHUMDGLSDGD JLJLSRVWHULRU GLNDUHQDNDQWHUGDSDWQ\DFLQFLQRUWRGRQWLGDQNDZDW RUWRGRQWL\DQJPHPSHUVXOLWSHODNVDQDDQNHEHUVLKDQ PXOXW21 3HQLQJNDWDQJLQJLYLWLV\DQJEHUPDNQDVHFDUD VWDWLVWLNVHWHODKSHPDNDLDQDODWRUWRGRQWLFHNDWLQL WHUOLKDWSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOSDGD SHQHOLWLDQ LQL 6HEDOLNQ\D SDGD NHORPSRN SDVWD JLJLKHUEDOMXVWUXWHUOLKDWDGDQ\DSHQXUXQDQLQGHNV JLQJLYDO +DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GDSDW GLDVXPVLNDQ EDKZDSDVWDJLJLKHUEDO\DQJPHQJDQGXQJVRGLXP ELNDUERQDWÀ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ÀDPDVLSDGDJLQJLYD NDUHQDPHQJDQGXQJEDKDQKHUEDO\DQJEHUIXQJVLVH EDJDLDJHQDQWLLQÀDPDVL22%HUWRODNEHODNDQJGHQJDQ SHQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQJHQDL HIHNWLYLWDV SDVWD JLJL NRQ YHQVLRQDOGLWHPXNDQEDKZDSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO PDPSXPHQXUXQNDQLQGHNVJLQJLYD\DQJEHUPDNQD VHFDUDVWDWLVWLN3HUEHGDDQLQLGDSDWGLVHEDENDQROHK NDQGXQJDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO\DQJGLJXQDNDQ EHUEHGD\DLWXDGDQ\DtriclosanVHEDJDLDJHQDQWLPL NURED\DQJGDSDWPHQFHJDKUHWHQVLSODNKLQJJD MDPVHWHODKQ\DVHGDQJNDQSDGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLKDQ\D PHQJJXQDNDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOGHQJDQÀRXULGH WDQSDNDQGXQJDQtriclosan
HASIL 3DGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLWHUGDSDWRUDQJSULD \DQJ WHUGLVWULEXVLGDODPSDVWDJLJL%GDQWHUGDSDWRUDQJ ZDQLWD RUDQJ GLDQWDUDQ\D WHUGLVWULEXVL GDODPSDVWDJLJL$GDQRUDQJGDODPSDVWDJLJL% 8VLDUDWDUDWDVXEMHNSHQHOLWLDQLQLEHUNLVDU WDKXQSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQWDKXQSDGD NHORPSRNSDVWD%3DGDDZDOSHQHOLWLDQWLGDNWHUGDSDW SHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNp DQWDUD LQGHNV JLQJLYD NHORPSRN SDVWD JLJL $ GDQ NHORPSRNSDVWDJLJL%7DEHO .HORPSRNSDVWD$ PHPLOLNLUHUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDGDQ3DVWD %PHPLOLNLUHUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYD6HWHODK SHUODNXDQWHUOLKDWSHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDVHFDUD VWDWLVWLNDQWDUDLQGHNVJLQJLYDNHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQ SDVWD%p GHQJDQUHUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYD XQWXNNHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQXQWXNNHORPSRN SDVWD% 3DGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLMXJDGDSDWGLOLKDWDGDQ\DSHUXEDKDQ QLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDVHWHODKGXDPLQJJXSHPDNDLDQ RUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWGLPDQDJLQJLYLWLVSDOLQJ EDQ\DNWHUMDGLSDGDJLJLSRVWHULRU7DEHO 0HOLKDWGDUL GDWDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKSHUODNXDQSDGDNHORPSRN $WHUOLKDWDGDQ\DNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQXUXQDQLQGHNV JLQJLYDGDULPHQMDGLQDPXQSHQXUXQDQLQL WLGDNEHUEHGDEHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNp 6HGDQJNDQSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWD%WHUOLKDWDGDQ\D NHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQLQJNDWDQLQGHNVJLQJLYDGDUL PHQMDGL\DQJVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNSHQLQJNDWDQWHUVHEXW EHUEHGDEHUPDNQDp 7DEHO 'DWDVHEHOXP GDQ VHVXGDK SHUODNXDQ GDSDW GLOLKDW EDKZD SDGD NHORPSRNSDVWD$WHUGDSDWSHQXUXQDQLQGHNVJLQJLYD UDWDUDWDVHEHVDUGDQVHEDOLNQ\DSDGDNHORPSRN SDVWD%WHUOLKDWNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQLQJNDWDQLQGHNV JLQJLYDUDWDUDWDVHEHVDU-LNDNHGXDNHORPSRN SDVWD GLEDQGLQJNDQ SHUEHGDDQ WHUVHEXW EHUEHGD EHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNp 7DEHO
Tabel 1.'LVWULEXVLGDWDLQGHNVJLQJLYDEHUGDVDUNDQZDNWX SHPHULNVDDQ Waktu Pasta N Rerata
Simpang Min Max Nilai p Baku
A
8
B
8
A
8
B
8
T0
PEMBAHASAN
T1
'DULVWXGLOLWHUDWXUVHUWDSHQHOLWLDQSHQHOLWLDQWHUGDKXOX GLNDWDNDQ EDKZD VHWHODK SHPDNDLDQ DODW RUWRGRQWL FHNDWWHUMDGLSHQLQJNDWDQEDNWHULSHQ\HEDEJLQJLYLWLV GDQ JDPEDUDQ NOLQLV JLQJLYLWLV \DQJ EHUPDNQD
WHUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQVLJQL¿NDQp $ SDVWDJLJL KHUEDO% SDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO
Journal of Dentistry Indonesia 2011, Vol. 18, No. 3, 68-72
Tabel 2.5HUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDSHUJLJLEHUGDVDUNDQ ZDNWXSHPHULNVDDQ Waktu Pasta 16 T0
T1
Rerata
Gigi 21
25
36
41
45
A
B
A
B
Tabel 3.'LVWULEXVL GDWD LQGHNV JLQJLYD EHUGDVDUNDQ NHORPSRNSHUODNXDQ Pasta Waktu N Rerata A B
Simpang Min Max Nilai p Baku
T0
8
T1
8
T0
8
T1
8
Tabel 4. 'LVWULEXVLGDWDVHOLVLKLQGHNVJLQJLYDEHUGDVDUNDQ NHORPSRNSHUODNXDQ Simpang Min Baku
Pasta
N
Rerata
A
8
B
8
Max
Nilai p
3HQHOLWLDQLQLPHQXQMXNNDQSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOPHPLOLNL HIHNWLYLWDV\DQJOHELKEDLNGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQSDVWD JLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOXQWXNNRQWUROJLQJLYLWLVSDGDSDVLHQ RUWRGRQWL GHQJDQ DODW FHNDW 3HUEHGDDQ HIHNWLYLWDV EHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNVHKLQJJDGDSDWGLVLPSXONDQ NHPXGLDQEDKZDSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOELODGLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOPHPLOLNLNHOHELKDQ GDODPPHQJDWDVLJLQJLYLWLV
SIMPULAN 3HQHOLWLDQLQLPHQ\LPSXONDQEDKZDSDVWDJLJLKHUEDO ELOD GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ SDVWD JLJL NRQYHQVLRQDO PHPLOLNLNHOHELKDQGDODPPHQJDWDVLJLQJLYLWLVROHK NDUHQDQ\DSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOGDSDWGLMDGLNDQDOWHUQDWLI SDVWDJLJLEHUEDVLVWXPEXKWXPEXKDQGDODPPHQJDWDVL JLQJLYLWLVSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDW
DAFTAR PUSTAKA 3URI¿W:5)LHOGV-U+:6DUYHU'0&RQWHP SRUDU\ RUWKRGRQWLFV WK HG0LVVRXUL 0RVE\ (OVHYLHU +HLQW]H6'-RVW%ULQNPDQQ3)LQNH&0LHWKNH
52UDOKHDOWKIRUWKHRUWKRGRQWLFSDWLHQW,OOLQRLV 4XLWHVVHQFH3XEOLVKLQJ&R,QF /R %XH $1 'L 0DUFR 5 0LOD]]R , 1LFRORVL '&DOL*5RVVHWWL%HWDO0LFURELRORJLFDODQG FOLQLFDOSHULRGRQWDOHIIHFWVRI¿[HGRUWKRGRQWLFDS SOLDQFHVLQSHGLDWULFSDWLHQWV1HZ0LFURELRORJLF 6XNRQWDSDWLSDUN : (O$JURXGL 0$ 6HOOLVHWK 1-7KXQROG.6HOYLJ.$%DFWHULDOFRORQL]DWLRQ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK IL[HG RUWKRGRQWLF DSSOLDQFH D VFDQQLQJHOHFWURQPLFURVFRS\VWXG\(XU-2UWKRG 3HULQHWWL*3DRODQWRQLR06HUUD('¶$UFKLYLR' '¶(UFROH6)HVWD)HWDO/RQJLWXGLQDOPRQLWRULQJ RI VXEJLQJLYDO FRORQL]DWLRQ E\ $FWLQREDFLOOXV DFWLQRP\FHWHPFRPLWDQVDQGFUHYLFXODUDONDOLQH SKRVSKDWH DQG DVSDU WDWH DPLQRWUDQVIHUDVH DFWLYLWLHVDURXQGRUWKRGRQWLFDOO\WUHDWHGWHHWK- &OLQ3HULRGRQWRO =DFKULVVRQ%8&DXVHDQGSUHYHQWLRQRILQMXULHVWR WHHWKDQGVXSSRUWLQJVWUXFWXUHVGXULQJRUWKRGRQWLF WUHDWPHQW$P-2UWKRG 2¶5HLOO\00)HDWKHUVWRQ-''HPLQHUDOL]DWLRQ DQGUHPLQHUDOL]DWLRQDURXQGRUWKRGRQWLFDSSOL DQFHVDQLQYLYRVWXG\$P-2UWKRG'HQW2UWKRS +XVHU 0& %DHKQL 3& /DQJ 5 (IIHFWV RI RUWKRGRQWLFEDQGVRQPLFURELRORJLFDODQGFOLQL FDO SDUDPHWHUV $P - 2UWKRG 'HQW 2UWKRS 1HZPDQ0*7DNHL++.ORNNHYROG35&DUUDQ]D )$&DUUDQ]D¶VFOLQLFDOSHULRGRQWRORJ\WKHG 0LVVRXUL6DXQGHUV(OVHYLHU :LONLQV (0 &OLQLFDO SUDFWLFH RI WKH GHQWDO K\JLHQLVWWKHG%DOWLPRUH:LOOLDPV :LONLQV KWWSZZZJVNLQGRQHVLDFRPBUHSRVLWRU\ 3DUDGRQWD[B3URGXFWB.QRZOHGJHSGI>,QWHUQHW@ >FLWHG$XJ@ 5DGDIVKDU * 0DKERRE ) .D]HPQHMDG ( $ VWXG\ WR DVVHVV WKH SODTXH LQKLELWRU\ DFWLRQ RI KHUEDOEDVHGWRRWKSDVWH$GRXEOHEOLQGFRQWUROOHG FOLQLFDOWULDO-0HG3ODQW $O.KRODQL$,&RPSDULVRQEHWZHHQWKHHI¿FDF\RI KHUEDODQGFRQYHQWLRQDOGHQWLIULFHVRQHVWDEOLVKHG JLQJLYLWLV'HQW5HV- 3DQQXWL0&GH0DWWRV-35DQR\D31GH-HVXV $0/RWXIR5)05RPLWR*$&OLQLFDOHIIHFWRI DKHUEDOGHQWUL¿FHRQWKHFRQWURORISODTXHDQG JLQJLYLWLVDGRXEOHEOLQGVWXG\3HVTXL2GRQWRO %UDV 2]DNL ) 3DQQXWL &0 ,PEURQLWR $9 3HVVRWWL :6DUDLYD/GH)UHLWDV10HWDO(I¿FDF\RI DKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWHRQSDWLHQWVZLWKHVWDEOLVKHG JLQJLYLWLVDUDQGRPL]HGFRQWUROOHGWULDO%UD]2UDO 5HV 6ULQLYDVD61DQGODO%6ULODWKD.$FRPSDUDWLYH HYDOXDWLRQ RI D FRPPHUFLDOO\ DYDLODEOH KHUEDO DQG QRQKHUEDO GHQWULILFH RQ GHQWDO SODTXH
Journal of Dentistry Indonesia 2011, Vol. 18, No. 3, 68-72
DQG JLQJLYLWLV LQ FKLOGUHQ$ UHVLGHQWLDO VFKRR EDVHGRUDOKHDOWKSURJUDPPH-'HQW2UDO+\J 6DVWURDVPRUR6,VPDHO6'DVDUGDVDUPHWRGRORJL SHQHOLWLDQNOLQLV(GLVLNH-DNDUWD6DJXQJ6HWR ,QGRQHVLDQ +RW]35'XOD.)%ODVHU0'HU(LQÀXVVYHU VFKLHGHQHU=DKQEXUVWHQXQ=DKQUHLQLJXQJVWHFK QLNHQDXIGLHLQWHUGHQWDOH%HODJVHQWIHUQXQJEHL =DKQHQRKQHXQGPLWIHVWVLW]HQGHQNLHUIHURUWKR SDGLVFKHQ$SSDUDWXUHQ(LQ9HUVXFKDP0RGHOO 6FKZHL]0RQDWVVFKU=DKQKHLONG *HUPDQ
6FKDW]OH0,PIHOG76HQHU%6FKPLGOLQ35In vitroWRRWKFOHDQLQJHI¿FDF\RIPDQXDOWRRWKEUXVK HVDURXQGEUDFNHWV(XU-2UWKRG :ROI+)+DVVHOO70&RORUDWODVRIGHQWDOK\ JLHQH SHULRGRQWRORJ\ *UDPPOLFK 7KLHPH S 0L]DKDUL((QDPHOGHPLQHUDOL]DWLRQIROORZLQJ RUWKRGRQWLFWUHDWPHQW$P-2UWKRG 0XODOO\%+-DPHV-$&RXOWHU:$/LQGHQ*- 7KHHI¿FDF\RIDKHUEDOEDVHGWRRWKSDVWHRQWKH FRQWURORISODTXHDQGJLQJLYLWLV-&OLQ3HULRGRQWRO