Herbal and Conventional Toothpastes Roles in Gingivitis Control in ...

Journal of Dentistry Indonesia 2011, Vol. 18, No. 3, 68-72

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Herbal and Conventional Toothpastes Roles in Gingivitis Control in Orthodontic Patients Stefani A. Dewi1, Fadli Jazaldi2, Benny M. Soegiharto2 1 2

Undergraduate Program, Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta 10430, Indonesia Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta 10430, Indonesia

ABSTRACT 2UWKRGRQWLFWUHDWPHQWZLWK¿[HGDSSOLDQFHDLPVWRLPSURYHHVWKHWLFVDQGIXQFWLRQRIPDVWLFDWLRQDQGVSHHFK KRZHYHUWKHFRPSRQHQWVRQD¿[HGDSSOLDQFHDVEDQGVEUDFNHWVDQGOLJDWXUHVPD\LQFUHDVHWKHDPRXQWRISODTXH DVWKHSULPDU\HWLRORJ\RIJLQJLYLWLVObjective: $GRXEOHEOLQGVWXG\RIUDQGRPL]HGFOLQLFDOWULDOZDVGHVLJQHG WRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWHDJDLQVWJLQJLYLWLVDVFRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOWRRWKSDVWH LQRUWKRGRQWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK¿[HGDSSOLDQFHMethods:6L[WHHQVXEMHFWVEHIRUHWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HGRUWKRGRQWLF DSSOLDQFHZDVVHOHFWHGEDVHGRQLQFOXVLRQFULWHULD7KH\ZHUHWKHQUDQGRPL]HGXVLQJEORFNUDQGRPL]DWLRQPHWKRG DQGGLYLGHGLQWRWKHWHVWJURXSDQGWKHFRQWUROJURXS*LQJLYDOLQGH[RI/|HDQG6LOOQHVVH[DPLQHGEHIRUHEUDFNHWV ERQGLQJDQGWZRZHHNVDIWHU3DLUHGWWHVWZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLIIHUHQFHVZLWKLQWKHJURXSVDQGXQSDLUHG WWHVWZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQJURXSVDWEDVHOLQHDQGWZRZHHNVDIWHUResults:7KHUHZDV DWHQGHQF\RIGHFUHDVLQJLQJLQJLYDOLQGH[EXWWKHUHZHUHQRVLJQL¿FDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKH DSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HGDSSOLDQFHLQWKHKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWHJURXS7KHUHZDVDWHQGHQF\RILQFUHDVLQJLQJLQJLYDOLQGH[ DQGWKHUHZHUHVLJQL¿FDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HGDSSOLDQFHLQWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO WRRWKSDVWHJURXS7KHUHZDVVLJQL¿FDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSVConclusion:7KHUHZDVVLJQL¿FDQW GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSVKHUEDOLQGLFDWHVHIIHFWLYHQHVVLQJLQJLYLWLVFRQWURODIWHUWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI¿[HG RUWKRGRQWLFDSSOLDQFHVRLWFRXOGEHXVHGDVDQDOWHUQDWLYHQDWXUDOEDVHGWRRWKSDVWHLQRYHUFRPLQJJLQJLYLWLVLQ RUWKRGRQWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK¿[HGDSSOLDQFH

ABSTRAK Peran pasta gigi herbal dengan pasta gigi konvensional terhadap kontrol gingivitis pada pasien ortodonti dengan alat cekat. 3HUDZDWDQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWEHUWXMXDQXQWXNSHUEDLNDQHVWHWLNGDQIXQJVLPDVWLNDVL GDQELFDUDSDVLHQ.RPSRQHQSDGDDODWFHNDWVHSHUWL bandsbracketsGDQligaturesGLGDODPPXOXWGDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQMXPODKSODNVHEDJDLHWLRORJLXWDPDJLQJLYLWLVTujuan:3HQHOLWLDQUDQGRPLVDVLNOLQLVdouble blind LQLGLUDQFDQJXQWXNPHQHOLWLHIHNWLYLWDVSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOWHUKDGDSJLQJLYLWLVGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQSDVWDJLJL NRQYHQVLRQDOSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWMetode: (QDPEHODVVXEMHN\DQJDNDQPHQJJXQDNDQDODW RUWRGRQWLFHNDWGLSLOLKEHUGDVDUNDQNULWHULDLQNOXVLNHPXGLDQGLDFDNGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQPHWRGHEORNUDQGRPLVDVL VHKLQJJDWHUEDJLGDODPNHORPSRNWHVGDQNHORPSRNNRQWURO3HPHULNVDDQLQGHNVJLQJLYD/|HGDQ6LOOQHVVGLODNXNDQ GLDZDOVHEHOXPbonding bracketsGDQGXDPLQJJXVHWHODKQ\D 8MLVWDWLVWLNSDUDPHWULNWEHUSDVDQJDQGLJXQDNDQ XQWXNPHPEDQGLQJNDQSHUEHGDDQGDODPWLDSNHORPSRNGDQXMLWWLGDNEHUSDVDQJDQXQWXNPHPEDQGLQJNDQ SHUEHGDDQDQWDUNHORPSRNDQWDUDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKSHUODNXDQ Hasil: 7HUGDSDWNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQXUXQDQ LQGHNVJLQJLYDQDPXQWLGDNWHUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDDQWDUDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKDSOLNDVLDODWRUWRGRQWL FHNDWSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJLKHUEDO7HUGDSDWNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQLQJNDWDQLQGHNVJLQJLYDGDQWHUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQ \DQJEHUPDNQDDQWDUDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKDSOLNDVLDODWFHNDWSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO7HUGDSDW SHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDDQWDUDNHGXDNHORPSRNSimpulan: 7HUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQEHUPDNQDSDGDNHGXDSDVWD JLJLSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOPHQXQMXNNDQHIHNWLYLWDVQ\DWHUKDGDSNRQWUROJLQJLYLWLVVHWHODKDSOLNDVLDODWRUWRGRQWLFHNDW VHKLQJJDGDSDWGLMDGLNDQDOWHUQDWLISDVWDJLJLEHUEDVLVDODPLGDODPPHQJDWDVLJLQJLYLWLVSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWL GHQJDQDODWFHNDW Key words:IL[HGRUWKRGRQWLFDSSOLDQFHJLQJLYLWLVKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWH

68


PENDAHULUAN 3HUDZDWDQRUWRGRQWLVHODLQEHUWXMXDQXQWXNPHPSHU EDLNLPDORNOXVLMXJDXQWXNPHQLQJNDWNDQNHVHKDWDQ JLJLGDQPXOXWIXQJVLPDVWLNDVLIXQJVLELFDUDGDQ HVWHWLND13HUOXGLVDGDULSHUDZDWDQLQLMXJDGDSDWPH QLQJNDWNDQMXPODKSODNGDQPHPEHULGDPSDNEXUXN EDJLNHVHLPEDQJDQÀRUDOLQJNXQJDQURQJJDPXOXW .RPSRQHQNRPSRQHQSDGDDODWRUWRGRQWLFHNDWVHSHUWL ligatures, brackets, bandsGDQarchwiresPHPEXDW SODNVXOLWGLMDQJNDXGDULDNVLPHQJJRVRNJLJLPDVWLND VLGDQODMXDOLUDQVDOLYD6WXGLVHEHOXPQ\DPHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZDSODNGLWHPXNDQSDOLQJGRPLQDQGLGDHUDKVHU YLNDObracket GDQGLEDZDKOHQJNXQJNDZDW2.HJDJD ODQGDODPPHQJDWDVLSODNGDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQULVLNR GHNDOVL¿NDVLNDULHVGDQJLQJLYLWLV *LQJLYLWLV\DQJ MXJDGLNHQDOVHEDJDLUDGDQJJLQJLYDPHUXSDNDQVDODK VDWXSHQ\DNLWSHULRGRQWDO\DQJGLVHEDENDQROHKDNX PXODVLSODN92OHKNDUHQDLWXNHEHUVLKDQPXOXW\DQJ RSWLPXPKDUXVGLMDJDVHODPDSHUDZDWDQRUWRGRQWL &DUDPHNDQLV\DQJSDOLQJVHGHUKDQDGDQHIHNWLIDGDODK GHQJDQPHQJJRVRNJLJLPHQJJXQDNDQSDVWDJLJL10 %HODNDQJDQLQLPDV\DUDNDWVHULQJPHQFDULSURGXN DOWHUQDWLIVHSHUWLSDVWDJLJLKHUEDONDUHQDWLGDNEHUVL IDWNLPLDZLGDQGLDQJJDSOHELKDPDQVHUWDEHUVLIDW QDWXUDO3DVWDJLJLKHUEDOPHQJDQGXQJVRGLXPELNDU ERQDWVRGLXPÀRULGDSSP GDQNDQGXQJDQEDKDQ KHUEDO%DKDQKHUEDOWHUVHEXWWHUGLULDWDVNDPRPLO\DQJ PHPLOLNLVLIDWDQWLLQÀDPDVLGDQPDPSXPHUHGDNDQ LQÀDPDVLJLQJLYDechinacea\DQJGLNHWDKXLPDPSX PHQVWLPXODVLUHVSRQVLPXQsage dan rhatany\DQJPH PLOLNLVLIDWDQWLSHQGDUDKDQmyrrhNHPHQ\DQVHEDJDL EDKDQDQWLVHSWLNDODPLGDQSHSHUPLQ\DQJPHPLOLNL VLIDWDQWLLQÀDPDVLDQWLVHSWLNGDQMXJDDQDOJHVLN11 7HUGDSDWEHEHUDSDSHQHOLWLDQ\DQJPHQXQMXNNDQHIHNWL YLWDVSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOGDODPPHQJDWDVLSODNGDQPHUH GDNDQJLQJLYLWLV6WXGLWHUGDKXOXPHQ\HEXWNDQEDKZD SDVWDJLJLKHUEDOPDPSXPHQJDWDVLSODNGDQJLQJLYLWLV OHELKEDLNGDULSDGDSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO WHWDSLSDGD SHQHOLWLDQODLQQ\DWLGDNPHQXQMXNNDQSHUEHGDDQ\DQJ EHUPDNQD2OHKNDUHQDSHUEHGDDQKDVLOSHQHOLWLDQ WHUVHEXWGDQEHOXPDGDSHQHOLWLDQPHQJHQDLHIHNWLYLWDV SDVWDJLJLKHUEDOSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODW FHNDWPDNDSHQHOLWLLQJLQPHQJHWDKXLHIHNWLYLWDVSDVWD JLJLKHUEDOGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQ VLRQDOWHUKDGDSJLQJLYLWLVSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQ DODWFHNDWGL5XPDK6DNLW*LJLGDQ0XOXW3HQGLGLNDQ )DNXOWDV .HGRNWHUDQ *LJL 8QLYHUVLWDV ,QGRQHVLD 56*03 ).* 8, $GDSXQ WXMXDQ GDUL SHQHOLWLDQ LQL LDODK XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL SHUEHGDDQ LQGHNV JLQ JLYDVHWHODKSHPDNDLDQSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOSDGDSDVLHQ RUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWPHQJHWDKXLSHUEHGDDQLQ GHNVJLQJLYDVHWHODKSHPDNDLDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO SDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWPHQJHWDKXL SHUEHGDDQLQGHNVJLQJLYDVHWHODKSHPDNDLDQSDVWDJLJL NRQYHQVLRQDOSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDW GDQXQWXNPHPEDQGLQJNDQHIHNWLYLWDVSDVWDJLJLKHUEDO

GHQJDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOWHUKDGDSJLQJLYLWLV SDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDW

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informed consent.ULWHULDHNVNOXVLSHQHOLWDQLQL DQWDUDODLQVXEMHNPHQJNRQVXPVLREDWREDWDQDQWLELR WLNDGDODPMDQJNDZDNWXWLJDEXODQVHGDQJGDODPPDVD NHKDPLODQPHPLOLNLSHQ\DNLWVLVWHPLNPHPLOLNLNH ELDVDDQPHURNRNGDQPHPDNDLDODWSURVWRGRQWLOHSDV .HHQDPEHODVVXEMHN\DQJPHPHQXKLNULWHULDWHUVH EXWNHPXGLDQGLEDJLPHQMDGLGXDNHORPSRNGHQJDQ metode randomized clinical trial EHUGDVDUNDQWDEHO EORNUDQGRPLVDVLVHKLQJJDGLSHUROHKNHORPSRN\DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQSDVWDJLJL$KHUEDO*OD[R6PLWK.OLQH %ULWDQLD 5D\D GDQ NHORPSRN \DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQ SDVWD JLJL % NRQYHQVLRQDO 8QLOHYHU .HGXD SDVWD JLJLWHUVHEXWPHUXSDNDQSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOGDQSDVWD JLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO\DQJWHODKGLVDPDUNDQdouble-blind study 3DGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLEDLNNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJL$ GDQNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJL%PHQJJXQDNDQVLNDWJLJL PDQXDOGDWDUGHQJDQWHNQLNVLNDWJLJLPRGL¿NDVL%DVV \DQJGLJDEXQJNDQGHQJDQWHNQLNPRGL¿NDVLSDVWDJLJL ÀXRULGHGHQJDQIUHNXHQVLGXDNDOLVHKDULGDQGXUDVL GXDPHQLWVHODPDGXDPLQJJX7HNQLNVLNDWJLJL LQLGLDMDUNDQVHFDUDODQJVXQJNHSDGDVHWLDSVXEMHN GHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQPRGHOJLJLGDQPHPEHULNDQ OHPEDUSHWXQMXNWHNQLNVLNDWJLJL6HODLQLWXSHQHOLWL MXJDWHUXVPHQJLQJDWNDQVXEMHNVHFDUDEHUNDODXQWXN PHQ\LNDWJLJLGHQJDQVLNDWSDVWDGDQWHNQLNVLNDWJLJL \DQJSHQHOLWLDMDUNDQ6HWHODKPHQMHODVNDQWHNQLNVLNDW JLJLNHSDGDVXEMHNSHQHOLWLDQSHPHULNVDDQJLQJLYLWLV SHUWDPDVHJHUDGLODNXNDQGLPDQDVXEMHNEHOXPPHQJ JXQDNDQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDW7 3HPHULNVDDQ JLQJLYLWLVGLODNXNDQGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQLQGHNVJLQ JLYD/|HGDQ6LOQHVVSDGDJLJL5DPIMRUG GDQ 6HWHODKVXEMHNPHQJJXQDNDQRUWRGRQWL GHQJDQDODWFHNDWGDQEHUVLNDWJLJLGHQJDQSDVWDVLNDW GDQWHQLNVHVXDLGHQJDQ\DQJSHQHOLWLDMDUNDQVHODPD GXDPLQJJXNHPXGLDQGLODNXNDQSHPHULNVDDQNHGXD 7 'DWD KDVLO NHGXD SHPHULNVDDQ LQL NHPXGLDQ GLRODKPHQJJXQDNDQSURJUDP6366XQWXNPHPEDQ GLQJNDQQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDVHEHOXPGDQVHWHODKSHU 69


ODNXDQEDLNSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWD$PDXSXQNHORPSRN SDVWD%GDQMXJDXQWXNPHPEDQGLQJNDQVHOLVLKQLODL LQGHNVJLQJLYDVHEHOXPGDQVHWHODKSHUODNXDQDQWDUD NHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQNHORPSRNSDVWD%3DGDSHQH OLWLDQLQLKDVLOGDWDPHQXQMXNNDQDGDQ\DVHEDUDQ\DQJ QRUPDOXMLQRUPDOLWDV6DSKLUR:LON ROHKNDUHQDLWX GLJXQDNDQODKXMLNHPDNQDDQSDUDPHWULNEDLN\DQJ EHUSDVDQJDQXQWXNPHQJXMLPDVLQJPDVLQJNHORPSRN PDXSXQ\DQJWLGDNEHUSDVDQJDQXQWXNPHQJXMLDQWDU NHORPSRN

3HQLQJNDWDQ LQLEDQ\DNWHUMDGLSDGD JLJLSRVWHULRU GLNDUHQDNDQWHUGDSDWQ\DFLQFLQRUWRGRQWLGDQNDZDW RUWRGRQWL\DQJPHPSHUVXOLWSHODNVDQDDQNHEHUVLKDQ PXOXW21 3HQLQJNDWDQJLQJLYLWLV\DQJEHUPDNQDVHFDUD VWDWLVWLNVHWHODKSHPDNDLDQDODWRUWRGRQWLFHNDWLQL WHUOLKDWSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOSDGD SHQHOLWLDQ LQL 6HEDOLNQ\D SDGD NHORPSRN SDVWD JLJLKHUEDOMXVWUXWHUOLKDWDGDQ\DSHQXUXQDQLQGHNV JLQJLYDO +DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GDSDW GLDVXPVLNDQ EDKZDSDVWDJLJLKHUEDO\DQJPHQJDQGXQJVRGLXP ELNDUERQDWÀ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ÀDPDVLSDGDJLQJLYD NDUHQDPHQJDQGXQJEDKDQKHUEDO\DQJEHUIXQJVLVH EDJDLDJHQDQWLLQÀDPDVL22%HUWRODNEHODNDQJGHQJDQ SHQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQJHQDL HIHNWLYLWDV SDVWD JLJL NRQ YHQVLRQDOGLWHPXNDQEDKZDSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO PDPSXPHQXUXQNDQLQGHNVJLQJLYD\DQJEHUPDNQD VHFDUDVWDWLVWLN3HUEHGDDQLQLGDSDWGLVHEDENDQROHK NDQGXQJDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO\DQJGLJXQDNDQ EHUEHGD\DLWXDGDQ\DtriclosanVHEDJDLDJHQDQWLPL NURED\DQJGDSDWPHQFHJDKUHWHQVLSODNKLQJJD MDPVHWHODKQ\DVHGDQJNDQSDGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLKDQ\D PHQJJXQDNDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOGHQJDQÀRXULGH WDQSDNDQGXQJDQtriclosan

HASIL 3DGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLWHUGDSDWRUDQJSULD \DQJ WHUGLVWULEXVLGDODPSDVWDJLJL%GDQWHUGDSDWRUDQJ ZDQLWD RUDQJ GLDQWDUDQ\D WHUGLVWULEXVL GDODPSDVWDJLJL$GDQRUDQJGDODPSDVWDJLJL% 8VLDUDWDUDWDVXEMHNSHQHOLWLDQLQLEHUNLVDU WDKXQSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQWDKXQSDGD NHORPSRNSDVWD%3DGDDZDOSHQHOLWLDQWLGDNWHUGDSDW SHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNp DQWDUD LQGHNV JLQJLYD NHORPSRN SDVWD JLJL $ GDQ NHORPSRNSDVWDJLJL%7DEHO .HORPSRNSDVWD$ PHPLOLNLUHUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDGDQ3DVWD %PHPLOLNLUHUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYD6HWHODK SHUODNXDQWHUOLKDWSHUEHGDDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDVHFDUD VWDWLVWLNDQWDUDLQGHNVJLQJLYDNHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQ SDVWD%p GHQJDQUHUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYD XQWXNNHORPSRNSDVWD$GDQXQWXNNHORPSRN SDVWD% 3DGDSHQHOLWLDQLQLMXJDGDSDWGLOLKDWDGDQ\DSHUXEDKDQ QLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDVHWHODKGXDPLQJJXSHPDNDLDQ RUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDWGLPDQDJLQJLYLWLVSDOLQJ EDQ\DNWHUMDGLSDGDJLJLSRVWHULRU7DEHO 0HOLKDWGDUL GDWDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKSHUODNXDQSDGDNHORPSRN $WHUOLKDWDGDQ\DNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQXUXQDQLQGHNV JLQJLYDGDULPHQMDGLQDPXQSHQXUXQDQLQL WLGDNEHUEHGDEHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNp 6HGDQJNDQSDGDNHORPSRNSDVWD%WHUOLKDWDGDQ\D NHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQLQJNDWDQLQGHNVJLQJLYDGDUL PHQMDGL\DQJVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNSHQLQJNDWDQWHUVHEXW EHUEHGDEHUPDNQDp 7DEHO 'DWDVHEHOXP GDQ VHVXGDK SHUODNXDQ GDSDW GLOLKDW EDKZD SDGD NHORPSRNSDVWD$WHUGDSDWSHQXUXQDQLQGHNVJLQJLYD UDWDUDWDVHEHVDUGDQVHEDOLNQ\DSDGDNHORPSRN SDVWD%WHUOLKDWNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQLQJNDWDQLQGHNV JLQJLYDUDWDUDWDVHEHVDU-LNDNHGXDNHORPSRN SDVWD GLEDQGLQJNDQ SHUEHGDDQ WHUVHEXW EHUEHGD EHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNp 7DEHO

Tabel 1.'LVWULEXVLGDWDLQGHNVJLQJLYDEHUGDVDUNDQZDNWX SHPHULNVDDQ Waktu Pasta N Rerata

Simpang Min Max Nilai p Baku

A

8

B

8

A

8

B

8

T0

PEMBAHASAN

T1

'DULVWXGLOLWHUDWXUVHUWDSHQHOLWLDQSHQHOLWLDQWHUGDKXOX GLNDWDNDQ EDKZD VHWHODK SHPDNDLDQ DODW RUWRGRQWL FHNDWWHUMDGLSHQLQJNDWDQEDNWHULSHQ\HEDEJLQJLYLWLV GDQ JDPEDUDQ NOLQLV JLQJLYLWLV \DQJ EHUPDNQD

WHUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQVLJQL¿NDQp $ SDVWDJLJL KHUEDO% SDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDO


Tabel 2.5HUDWDQLODLLQGHNVJLQJLYDSHUJLJLEHUGDVDUNDQ ZDNWXSHPHULNVDDQ Waktu Pasta 16 T0

T1

Rerata

Gigi 21

25

36

41

45

A

B

A

B

Tabel 3.'LVWULEXVL GDWD LQGHNV JLQJLYD EHUGDVDUNDQ NHORPSRNSHUODNXDQ Pasta Waktu N Rerata A B

Simpang Min Max Nilai p Baku

T0

8

T1

8

T0

8

T1

8

Tabel 4. 'LVWULEXVLGDWDVHOLVLKLQGHNVJLQJLYDEHUGDVDUNDQ NHORPSRNSHUODNXDQ Simpang Min Baku

Pasta

N

Rerata

A

8

B

8

Max

Nilai p

3HQHOLWLDQLQLPHQXQMXNNDQSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOPHPLOLNL HIHNWLYLWDV\DQJOHELKEDLNGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQSDVWD JLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOXQWXNNRQWUROJLQJLYLWLVSDGDSDVLHQ RUWRGRQWL GHQJDQ DODW FHNDW 3HUEHGDDQ HIHNWLYLWDV EHUPDNQDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNVHKLQJJDGDSDWGLVLPSXONDQ NHPXGLDQEDKZDSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOELODGLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQSDVWDJLJLNRQYHQVLRQDOPHPLOLNLNHOHELKDQ GDODPPHQJDWDVLJLQJLYLWLV

SIMPULAN 3HQHOLWLDQLQLPHQ\LPSXONDQEDKZDSDVWDJLJLKHUEDO ELOD GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ SDVWD JLJL NRQYHQVLRQDO PHPLOLNLNHOHELKDQGDODPPHQJDWDVLJLQJLYLWLVROHK NDUHQDQ\DSDVWDJLJLKHUEDOGDSDWGLMDGLNDQDOWHUQDWLI SDVWDJLJLEHUEDVLVWXPEXKWXPEXKDQGDODPPHQJDWDVL JLQJLYLWLVSDGDSDVLHQRUWRGRQWLGHQJDQDODWFHNDW

DAFTAR PUSTAKA 3URI¿W:5)LHOGV-U+:6DUYHU'0&RQWHP SRUDU\ RUWKRGRQWLFV WK HG0LVVRXUL 0RVE\ (OVHYLHU +HLQW]H6'-RVW%ULQNPDQQ3)LQNH&0LHWKNH

52UDOKHDOWKIRUWKHRUWKRGRQWLFSDWLHQW,OOLQRLV 4XLWHVVHQFH3XEOLVKLQJ&R,QF /R %XH $1 'L 0DUFR 5 0LOD]]R , 1LFRORVL '&DOL*5RVVHWWL%HWDO0LFURELRORJLFDODQG FOLQLFDOSHULRGRQWDOHIIHFWVRI¿[HGRUWKRGRQWLFDS SOLDQFHVLQSHGLDWULFSDWLHQWV1HZ0LFURELRORJLF 6XNRQWDSDWLSDUN : (O$JURXGL 0$ 6HOOLVHWK 1-7KXQROG.6HOYLJ.$%DFWHULDOFRORQL]DWLRQ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK IL[HG RUWKRGRQWLF DSSOLDQFH D VFDQQLQJHOHFWURQPLFURVFRS\VWXG\(XU-2UWKRG 3HULQHWWL*3DRODQWRQLR06HUUD('¶$UFKLYLR' '¶(UFROH6)HVWD)HWDO/RQJLWXGLQDOPRQLWRULQJ RI VXEJLQJLYDO FRORQL]DWLRQ E\ $FWLQREDFLOOXV DFWLQRP\FHWHPFRPLWDQVDQGFUHYLFXODUDONDOLQH SKRVSKDWH DQG DVSDU WDWH DPLQRWUDQVIHUDVH DFWLYLWLHVDURXQGRUWKRGRQWLFDOO\WUHDWHGWHHWK- &OLQ3HULRGRQWRO =DFKULVVRQ%8&DXVHDQGSUHYHQWLRQRILQMXULHVWR WHHWKDQGVXSSRUWLQJVWUXFWXUHVGXULQJRUWKRGRQWLF WUHDWPHQW$P-2UWKRG 2¶5HLOO\00)HDWKHUVWRQ-''HPLQHUDOL]DWLRQ DQGUHPLQHUDOL]DWLRQDURXQGRUWKRGRQWLFDSSOL DQFHVDQLQYLYRVWXG\$P-2UWKRG'HQW2UWKRS +XVHU 0& %DHKQL 3& /DQJ 5 (IIHFWV RI RUWKRGRQWLFEDQGVRQPLFURELRORJLFDODQGFOLQL FDO SDUDPHWHUV $P - 2UWKRG 'HQW 2UWKRS 1HZPDQ0*7DNHL++.ORNNHYROG35&DUUDQ]D )$&DUUDQ]D¶VFOLQLFDOSHULRGRQWRORJ\WKHG 0LVVRXUL6DXQGHUV(OVHYLHU :LONLQV (0 &OLQLFDO SUDFWLFH RI WKH GHQWDO K\JLHQLVWWKHG%DOWLPRUH:LOOLDPV :LONLQV KWWSZZZJVNLQGRQHVLDFRPBUHSRVLWRU\ 3DUDGRQWD[B3URGXFWB.QRZOHGJHSGI>,QWHUQHW@ >FLWHG$XJ@ 5DGDIVKDU * 0DKERRE ) .D]HPQHMDG ( $ VWXG\ WR DVVHVV WKH SODTXH LQKLELWRU\ DFWLRQ RI KHUEDOEDVHGWRRWKSDVWH$GRXEOHEOLQGFRQWUROOHG FOLQLFDOWULDO-0HG3ODQW $O.KRODQL$,&RPSDULVRQEHWZHHQWKHHI¿FDF\RI KHUEDODQGFRQYHQWLRQDOGHQWLIULFHVRQHVWDEOLVKHG JLQJLYLWLV'HQW5HV- 3DQQXWL0&GH0DWWRV-35DQR\D31GH-HVXV $0/RWXIR5)05RPLWR*$&OLQLFDOHIIHFWRI DKHUEDOGHQWUL¿FHRQWKHFRQWURORISODTXHDQG JLQJLYLWLVDGRXEOHEOLQGVWXG\3HVTXL2GRQWRO %UDV 2]DNL ) 3DQQXWL &0 ,PEURQLWR $9 3HVVRWWL :6DUDLYD/GH)UHLWDV10HWDO(I¿FDF\RI DKHUEDOWRRWKSDVWHRQSDWLHQWVZLWKHVWDEOLVKHG JLQJLYLWLVDUDQGRPL]HGFRQWUROOHGWULDO%UD]2UDO 5HV 6ULQLYDVD61DQGODO%6ULODWKD.$FRPSDUDWLYH HYDOXDWLRQ RI D FRPPHUFLDOO\ DYDLODEOH KHUEDO DQG QRQKHUEDO GHQWULILFH RQ GHQWDO SODTXH


DQG JLQJLYLWLV LQ FKLOGUHQ$ UHVLGHQWLDO VFKRR EDVHGRUDOKHDOWKSURJUDPPH-'HQW2UDO+\J 6DVWURDVPRUR6,VPDHO6'DVDUGDVDUPHWRGRORJL SHQHOLWLDQNOLQLV(GLVLNH-DNDUWD6DJXQJ6HWR ,QGRQHVLDQ +RW]35'XOD.)%ODVHU0'HU(LQÀXVVYHU VFKLHGHQHU=DKQEXUVWHQXQ=DKQUHLQLJXQJVWHFK QLNHQDXIGLHLQWHUGHQWDOH%HODJVHQWIHUQXQJEHL =DKQHQRKQHXQGPLWIHVWVLW]HQGHQNLHUIHURUWKR SDGLVFKHQ$SSDUDWXUHQ(LQ9HUVXFKDP0RGHOO 6FKZHL]0RQDWVVFKU=DKQKHLONG *HUPDQ

6FKDW]OH0,PIHOG76HQHU%6FKPLGOLQ35In vitroWRRWKFOHDQLQJHI¿FDF\RIPDQXDOWRRWKEUXVK HVDURXQGEUDFNHWV(XU-2UWKRG :ROI+)+DVVHOO70&RORUDWODVRIGHQWDOK\ JLHQH SHULRGRQWRORJ\ *UDPPOLFK 7KLHPH S 0L]DKDUL((QDPHOGHPLQHUDOL]DWLRQIROORZLQJ RUWKRGRQWLFWUHDWPHQW$P-2UWKRG 0XODOO\%+-DPHV-$&RXOWHU:$/LQGHQ*- 7KHHI¿FDF\RIDKHUEDOEDVHGWRRWKSDVWHRQWKH FRQWURORISODTXHDQGJLQJLYLWLV-&OLQ3HULRGRQWRO