Finance and Economics Discussion Series Divisions of Research & Statistics and Monetary Affairs Federal Reserve Board, Washington, D.C.
Housing, House Prices, and the Equity Premium Puzzle
Morris A. Davis and Robert F. Martin 2005-13 NOTE: Staff working papers in the Finance and Economics Discussion Series (FEDS) are preliminary materials circulated to stimulate discussion and critical comment. The analysis and conclusions set forth are those of the authors and do not indicate concurrence by other members of the research staff or the Board of Governors. References in publications to the Finance and Economics Discussion Series (other than acknowledgement) should be cleared with the author(s) to protect the tentative character of these papers.
%'& & )(('*+-, !"$# .0/2131547698:=@?A4B6 CD/"EGFH13IDJK:L.M=N13IO4BP Q2RTSURWVYX5Z\[_ ¾ (VBE7*,3l;.19;>02/2Ti~0¸0235B*,P1AB0&S>=4?7(.H73hYZ=9/hBE70&L198X?.0¸=AYBE70¸*,(aB/ 1NoB02PC;T=9/ 1A8d0O8@1935B*@-*XB^:G=9YÔ35?7S>3^B*vB?KB*,=9(!ST0B^i$0O02( E7=4?.35*,(76#3502/LW*@-0D3l19(.Hb-O=9(.3?7P;KB*X=4(}?.3*X(.6P=4PC02(aB-O=9(.HK*XB*,=9(>3l*,P;78,*X0DHbSW:!1G(70O=K-O8,1433*,-21A8-=4(.35?.PC;7B*,=9(350DH!*,(brf*@1AR2RO0D35* 0B2s½198t_U` =GST0C-O=9(.3*@3^B0O(aBli*XBE35*,(76G35B=K- |V1A(>HV;7/*,-O0CH71AB1.Ti$0&3E7=Ni ×P¸?.35BCST0{64/0D1NB0O/UBE.1A(Mp.s n7*XP;78,:W*X(76H{-=4(.3?7P;KB*,=9( E7=4?.350 ;7/*@-023E>1L90$(7=ABf64/=Ni(¸Y1935B02(7=9?.69EC=NL90O/BE70;.1935BfÚ4Øl:90D1A/ 3 B=U35?.;7;>=4/5Bf13P198X8,0O/028,143^B*,-O*vB^:¸=AYT3?7S.35B*XB?7B*,=9(_ 7?./5BE70O/DWiE70O(Gi~0lYZ=9/ -0hBE70P=KHK0O8TB=CST0u-O=9(.3*,35B02(aB$i*XBEGS>=9BEE7*,35B=4/*@-O198>E.=9?.3*X(.6¸;7/*,-O023$1A(.HG3^B=K- |z/0OB?7/(.32 i$0{Q.(>HkÛP&?.3^BST08@1A/6902/\BE.1A(p7sÖØ9Ø7*XP;78,:W*X(76w19(M0O8@1935B*@-*XB^:w=AYu35?7S>3^B*vB?KB*,=9(1NB8X0D1935Bzn7s n7_M` E7*@3C0235B*,P1AB0*,3 8@1A/690O/fBE.19(YZ=9?.(.Hz*,({;7/0OLW*,=9?.3Ô0OP;7*,/*@-O198T35B?.H7*X0D3O_ ÜG` E.0230h=ABE70O/ 35B?.HK*,023~?.30lHK*XÈ0O/0O(aB$P=KHK028,3$1A(.H{HK*vÈ0O/0O(aBH71NB 1 3=9?7/ -0D3$19(.HGBE702/0OYZ=9/0hBE70O*,/)0D3^B*XPz1NB02319/0(7=9BH7*X/02-B8,:G-=4P;.1A/ 1AS78,0lB==9?7/ 32_ *X(>1A8,8X:4 i$0{-O19(7(7=9B\Q.(.Hw19(a:3OT1A(.H#/02198d`d/021435?./:/0B?7/(.3O_)yl?7/);>1A/ 1AP0B0O/)0D3^B*XPz1NB023*,P;78,:#1/02198/*,3|atYZ/0O0U/ 1NB0U=AYf1NB)8,02143^B
4
;T0O/ -0O(aB;>02/5
:90D1A/D_lÝ-8,?.HK0&BE.1ABlBE7*,3lYZ/ 1AP0Oi$=9/|>i*XBE.=9?KBuYZ?7/BE702/uP=KHK*XQ>-O1AB*,=9(½*@3u*X(>35?K»-O*X02(4BuB=/023=98,L90 BE.0U02Fa?7*XB^:;7/0OP*X?.PÞ;7?7R2RO8,0\1A(.HKi~0\-O=9(Nß^0D-B?./04WBE70U=9BE702/P14-/=&;.?7ROR28X0D3 PC02(aB*,=9(70DH19S>=NL409_
à
á
Vâhã
Ý1NB)E.143$BE70YZ=48X8,=Ni*X(.6C;T0O/
;>02/*,=KH{?KB*X8,*XB^:T¤
ä
jt
7^m ¥
jå½ &
j
½m7 mW4
(.1A(.-O*,198193350OB3~*X( :W*X028,H.3
)
Z ¬ SW:ö ¥
sOs2s
*)
,+ ?78,0O/02Fa?.1AB*,=9(.32¤
iE702/0uBE.0U;7/*@-*,(76|902/(.0O8o ª
ª
Z¬
¾ (#BE.0¸E7=4?.35*,(76
- ³
¶
ý
$ °
ý
³
± ³ µ ¶
]¦ /. ª
Z¬
¦ ¨ª
Z¬
- ,³ ´ - ³ 0 ¥
p
Z¬ ,1 ®
¥
p
j pam
7*@3HK0Q.(.02H#193
Z¬
¥¯
Z¬ Á
Â\¶T·32
Z ¬ j m½j
j
m½j
$ + ?78,0O/)0DF4?>1NB*,=9(d.i$0¸19335?.PC0\BE70CHK*XLW*@HK0O(>H½6587 ÿ ± ³:9 $ ³ 58; ÿ ± ³ 9 ³
Z¬ Ä
m
Ä
¥
m
ý
4 ý
j
42
Ä m
j 9 m
T*,3h;.1A*@HV*,(#BE70C-?7//0O(aB
¶ ¶ ;T0O/*X=KH#1A(.H{BEW?.3h3502;.1A/ 1NB0hBE70\HK*,La*@HK02(.HGYZ/=4Pð*vB 3)-O19;7*XB1A8½6a1A*,(K?7(78,*,|90=9?7/ B/0D1NBPC02(aB =9Y Q>(.1A(.-O*,198193350OB32_ yhY-O=9?7/ 309aBE70U0OJK;>0D-B1AB*,=9(.3 *,(wj p4m$1A/0(7=AB=9S>3502/L402H½_ ¾ (#=9/ HK0O/$B=z0D3^B*XPz1AB0uBE70U;>1A/ 1AP0B0O/ 3~=9YdBE7*,3)PC=KHK028t i$03;T02-*XYZ:BE.1NB
¦
ª
Z¬
¦ ¨ª
Z¬
2
Z ¬
4
1 ®
< Zû ¬
1A(>H19335?.PC0hBE.1AB~BE70u0JWo;T=435B~E.=9?.3*X(.6¸0O//=9/ 3
¥
Z¬
ª
Z¬ ª
Z¬
¥
Z ¬ < Zû ¬ =
j n4m
1 =< Z1 ¬
j Úam
Z¬
1A(.Hz0OJWo;T=435B~L402-B=9/~=AYQ.(>1A(.-O*,198>02//=9/ 3BE.1NB1A/0)*,(.HK0JK0DHSW:ö
< Z¬ >1A/0l(7=9BYZ=9/02-21935B1AS.8X0u?.3*X(76z19(a:{*X(KYZ=4/Pz1AB*,=9(#H71NB02H#1NB B*,P0>~=4/ S>0OYZ=9/09_Ý=a350i$0/0D3-21A8,0 1A(>H SW:@?
g)=9B0uBE>1NB)i$019/0(7=9Bh1AS78,0uB=z*@HK0O(aB*vYZ:
±
19(.HA? û
/023;>0D-B*,L9028X:4_` E7*,3B/ 1A(.35YZ=9/Pz3ÔBE70U?KB*X8,*vB^:{YZ?7(.-B*,=9(V193$YZ=48X8,=Ni)3O¤ jå&jB?
jZC? ±
j
°
½m? m
4 û
¬ ýED ; ý FD G ÿ
ýED ;
±
m
û
]
jo^m
¶
ý D ; E 19(.HBE70¸/0D3-21A8,*X(76C=AYf 1A(.H E.193 (.=0È02-B =9(GBE.0\35=48X?KB*X=4(G0OJ7-0O;7BB=z1NÈ02-B)=9?7/0D3^B*XPz1NB0U=AY _ -O19(M1A8,i 1:W3\PC0D- E.1A(.*,-21A8,8X:]ST0G30BCB=}R20O/=!ST02-O19?.30{i$0{=9S>3502/L401 < Zû ¬
*X(>1A8,8X:4(7=AB0BE>1NBz1L90O/ 1A640L198X?.0{=AY
;7/*,-O0U*X(>HK0JGYZ=9/)E7=4?.3*X(7619(.H(7=ABh1;./*@-0U8,0OL40O8o_~` =35020BE7*@3OTHK0Q>(70UBE.0U;7/*@-0U=9YE7=9?.3023143ML
û .iE.0O/0 û *@3=9?./
=9S>3502/L402H!;./*@-0C*X(>HK0JbYZ=9/E7=9?>35*,(76V1A(.HNL*@3uBE.0z;.1A/ 1AP0B0O/uBE>1NBU8X*,(7|K3=9?./U;7/*@-0*,(.HK0OJ!B=BE.0B/?70;7/*@-08,0OL40O8o_ u*,L90O(GBE.0U=ABE.0O/;.19/19PC0OB02/3~=AYBE70P=KHK0O8~j ¯ >Ô.19(.H{½mKBE70LN1A8,?70U=9YOLUBE.1NBh30B 3$BE70\1L40O/ 1A640)LN1A8,?70U=AY B=R20O/=31NB*,35Q.0D3
L
¥
P iE702/0,T¼*@3$BE.0U8,143^B;T0O/*X=KHG=AYH71NB 1C19(.H ª
P
Z¬ ¶
P Q
P
¶
Q
¶ ü j
ý
° ª
Z¬
Ä m
- ³@G ´ - ³G µ /R
< Zû ¬
j a ( m
8 S Ä û
¶ ý ü ¶ ¶ *@3)HK0OQ.(702H193 *,(02Fa?.1NB*X=4(=4/5BDUL¸*@31A8,i 1:W3 30Bh3?.- EGBE.1AB¸j a ( m~*,3)31NB*,35Q.0DH½_
V
WYXuOX
yl?7/Ô-O=9(.3?7P;KB*X=4(1A(.HzE.=9?.3*X(.6\H71NB 1\1A/00JK;7/023350DH193f/021987;T0O/
-21A;7*XB1UFa?.19(4B*vB*X0D3O_fyl?7/~0235B*,P1AB0D3f=AYBE70h;T=9;7?.8,1A B*,=9(YZ=4/BE70¸0O(aB*,/0UÉh(7*vB02H}ÕWB1NB023)19/0uB 1A|902(YZ/=4PðBE.0[Z0O64*X=4(.1A8
+ -=9(.=9P*,-'l-O-=4?7(aB327;7/=KHK?.-0DHSa:{BE70]\~?./0D1A?
+ -=4(7=9P*@-')(.198X:K3*,3uj\ + 'um_ ^l./=4P
=AY
(_"NpuB=Cn9p9pAq>ABE70lÉuÕ;>=4;7?78@1NB*X=4(E.193Ô69/=Ni(z1NB$19;7;7/=JK*XPz1NB0O8,: ;T0O/ -02(aB
;T0O/):4021A/D_
`bacd egfKhji#kacml ` =lP021435?./0 -=4(.35?.PC;7B*,=9(Ai$035?.SKB/ 19-B/02198K-=9(>35?7P;KB*X=4(&=9Y>E7=4?.3*X(7630O/La*@-0D3 j193/0O;T=9/B0DH¸*,( q=AYT`1AS.8X0hn7_ Ú._ l=AYTBE70)gl1NB*X=4(.1A8 ¾ (.-O=9P01A(.HrÔ/=KHK?.-Bf'h-O-O=9?7(aB 3m YZ/=9P8,*,(70
8,*X(70
=AYTBE.1ABÔ319PC0$B 1AS78,099B=AB 1A8K/02198
-=4(.3?7P;KB*,=9(V*,(.-8,?.3*XL40\=AY0OJW;T0O(>HK*vB?7/023)=4(!-=4(.35?.PC02/hHK?7/ 1AS.8X0U64=a=KH732_ n]yl?7/l;7/*,-O0U*X(.H70J#YZ=9/h-O=9(.3?7P;KB*X=4(V?.350DH B=zP0D193?7/0U*,(go>1AB*,=9(#*,(#BE70¸-21A8@-?78@1NB*X=4(G=9Y/0D1A8½/0B?./(.32.HK02(7=AB02H
± « .*@3)-O=9(.3*,35B02(aB)i*vBE#BE7*@3hHK0OQ.(7*XB*,=9(_ p}gh=AB0
BE>1NBh*,(VBE.0\;7/=W-O0233=AY;7?./64*X(76zE.=9?.3*X(.63502/LW*@-023YZ/=4Pï=NL40O/ 1A8,8-=9(>35?7P;KB*X=4(.i$0\Pz1:{*,(aB/=KHK?.-0&1CB*,(a:V19PC=4?7(aB =AYlPC0D193?7/0OP0O(aB&02//=9/&*X(aB=}=9?./C-O=9(.3?7P;KB*,=9(+3502/*,0232*,(.-/021435*,(76VBE70GL4=98@1NB*X8,*vB^:]=9Yl-=4(.35?.PC;7B*,=9(M19(.HI*,(.HK?.-O*X(.6 (702641NB*XL403502/*@1A8.-O=9//028,1AB*,=9(&*X(BE70)69/=Ni BEC/ 1NB0D3O_`d=U?.(.HK0O/ 35B1A(>H¸BE70)8@1NBB0O/Ô0È02-BDaH70O(7=9B0=9S>3502/L402HC-=9(>35?7P;KB*X=4( *,(C;T0O/*,=WHq193sr AB/?70)-O=9(.3?7P;KB*X=4(143 419(.H1A(C*ts *ts H½s4PC0D193?7/0OP0O(aB0O//=4/HK/1i+193%t _ BE.0O(vI8,=96ujsr m ¥
vI8,=96hjtOm
¾ Y½8X=46hjur m ¥
8X=46hjOm
t
vqt Ù7=4SWLa*,=9?>358,:9vqt *@3(702641NB*XL40O8,:{30O/*,198X8,:-=4//0O8@1NB02H½_kÝb0¸1433?7P0uBE.1ABBE70B/?.0
;7/=K-0233YZ=4/l8,=96ljt^m)*,31/ 1A(>HK=9Pºi$198X|TBE>1NBl*@3>vI8,=96ljOm ¥xw i*XBEb*X(7(.=NL1AB*,=9(.3
w $BE.1NBU1A/0¸?7(>-=9//0O8@1NB0DH#i*vBE
ty¸YZ=9/&19(W:NzG1A(.HN1A(.H]?>350zBE70{U198XPz1A(w*,8vB0O/\B=!?7(.-O=NL902/\1A(w?7(.H70O/8X:W*,(76!3502/*,023UYZ=9/\8,=96hjo^muBE.1NB¸i$0?.30*,( =9?./\0OP;7*,/*@-O198Ô1A(>1A8,:W3*@3O_` E7069/=Ni BE]/ 1NB023U=9Y~BE70Q.8XB02/0DH]3502/*,023\19/0z8,0233U(702641AB*,L90O8,:b19?KB=K-O=9//028,1AB02H}BE>1A(]BE.0 ?7(KQ>8vB0O/02H69/=Ni BEG/1AB0232KS7?KBBE70U8,0OL9028½=AYBE70B^i$=3502/*,02319/0S.1435*@-O198X8,:z*,H70O(aB*@-O198fjZ(7=9Bh35E7=Ni(Tm_
{|i}a~!dEcj=U* d
eg
@Mkdsl Ýb0z?.30(7=9P*,(.1A8ST0O64*X(.(7*X(.6A
=AYåF4?>1A/B0O/UÚAoP=9(aBE3O_F4?>1A/B0O/8,:¸02Fa?7*XB^:¸/0B?7/(.3O4i~0l3^B?.HK:&BE70h3*XJ>1APz1N7/0O(.- E;T=9/B5YZ=9 8,*X=a3BE.1ABd1A/0f1LN1A*,8,19S78X0=4(02(7(70OBE\7/0O(>- EC 3i$0OSU3*vB09EaB5B;¤P&S.17_ B?.- |_ H71A/BP=4?KBE_ 02H7?j;.19690D3 Y19-?.8vB^:|40O(_ YZ/0O(.- EjK_
?7*@- |W8X:z3?7PP19/*,RO*,(76>4BE70U.19P1A
./02(.- E;T=9/B5YZ=48X*,=43$-8@19335*XYZ:35B=K- |K3$143Ô02*vBE70O/35Pz1A8,8¸=4/]S7*X6> ¸iE70O/0lBE70U3;78X*XB5
ø ê5ÝÿÝ´äcåµÙcÞOáyè ó Û¡Û´Ùcã5Þ}ßBà3US.19302H]=4(=W=4|4oB=9oPz19/|40BU02Fa?7*XB^:ÙÔ3^B=K- |W3\i*vBEwBE70{E7*X64E70235B¸ST=W=9|atB=A
Pz1A/|90BU0DF4?.*vB^: / 1NB*,=4319/0C-O1A8,8,02H5LN1A8,?70u35B=K- |K3OBE708X=Ni$0235B19/0&BE.0N69/=Ni BE{3^B=W- |K32d1A(>HVBE.=430C*,(0OB^i~020O(5(702?KB/ 1A8o_ 3;78X*XB ;>=4*X(aB3$1A/0BE70uÚ4pNBE{1A(.H"NpNBE{g6UÕ
+
` E.0
;>02/-O0O(aB*,8X0D3O_.=9/Ô=4?7/$S>=4(.H{19(.H35B=K- |;>=4/5BYZ=98,*X=a3Oai~0u-=4(aL40O/Bf(7=9P*,(.1A8
B=/02198½/0OB?7/(.3 SW:{1A;.;7/=4;7/*,1AB0O8,:19-2-=4?7(aB*,(76¸YZ=4/)/021A8,*,RO02HG-=4(.35?.PC02/5
;7/*,-O0l*,(go>1AB*,=9(
Z±^¬ ²
Ä
±^² _
k~ cm=/eEci#kiF a:¡]¢aEe8d
kc_£ {ms
¤uk~ Jdsl Ý02/5-O19;7*XB1z35B=K- |{=9YE.=9?.3*X(.6zE.193h69/=Ni(1ABfß^?.35Bup7s qz;T0O/ -0O(aBh;T0O/
:90D1A/$iE70O/02143fBE70/0D1A8;T0O/
-21A;7*XB1C-=4(.35?.PC;7B*,=9({=9YdE7=4?.35*,(763502/LW*@-0D3$143$;7?7S78,*,3E70DH{SW:BE.0,\ 69/=Ni(
+ '¼*,({BE70Ug ¾ r½'E.143
s"¸;T0O/ -02(4B;T0O/):40219/2_
Ý\
+ '£0D3^B*XPz1NB0hYZ=4/ÔBE7/0O0u/0D193=9(.32_
*X/ 35B2 BE70{òu1LW*,3U19(.H¦¥)0D1NBE.-=9B0H71AB1V1A/0zHK0Q>(702H0{-O=9(.3*@3^B0O(aB\i*vBEwS>=9BEIòl02-O0O(7(7*@1A8 ñ~0O(.3?.3U=9Y6¥h=9?.3*,(76 H71AB1z1A(>H#/02;>0D1NB531A8,023 P021435?7/023)=AYE7=9?>350U;7/*@-0232_ÕW02-O=9(.H½.BE70Cr0O/ 35=4(.1A8dñ~=4(.35?.PC;7B*,=9( BE>1NB*,3l;7?7S78,*@35E70DH!SW:BE70\
+ JK;T0O(.H7*vB?7/0¸E.1A(.H7S>=W=9|
+ 'ïjÉ\_ÖÕ_òl0O;.19/5BP0O(aBl=9Y$ñ~=9PP0O/ -09 (¨(9pamHK0D3-O/*,S>0D3)BE70¸64/=Ni BE!*,(VBE70C0235B*,Pz1NB0
=AY=Ni(702/5
=K-O-O?7;7*,02HG(7=9P*,(.1A8 /02(4BCjåBE.0\EW:a;T=ABE70B*,-21A81AP=9?7(aBh=Ni(.0O/o=K-O-O?7;7*,0O/ 3$i~=4?78,H#;>1:B={/02(4BhBE702*X/lE7=9?.3*,(76 ?7(7*XB3fYZ/=4PÇ1U8@1A(>HK8X=4/H>m193ST0O*,(76\1NÈ02-B0DHSa:C:90D1A/oSW:a
:90219/Kß^?.HK69P02(4B 1A8zjZ;s_ m19Hß^?.35BP02(4B 3YZ=4/Ô- E.1A(.69023B=UBE.0 Fa?.1A8,*XB^:z=AYdBE70E7=9?>35*,(763^B=W- |_*X(>1A8,8X:471A(.HG/028,1AB0DH½aBE70>\ BE.0¸g ¾ r½'
+ 'ÛHK0so>1NB023~BE70(7=4P*X(.198½0235B*,Pz1NB0=9YK3;.19-O0l/0O(aB ¸*,(
SW:{BE70Cñ$r ¾ YZ=4/)0O*XBE.0O/h=Ni(.0O/ 3sK0DF4?.*XLN1A8,0O(aB)/0O(aBh=4/ B0O(>1A(aBh/0O(aB2THK0O;T0O(.H7*X(76{=9(BE70&35;T02-O*vQ>-\8X*,(70\*XB02P
B=G;7/=WH7?.-0C1/021A8 0235B*,Pz1NB04_U` E70ñ$r ¾ 0235B*,P1AB0&=AYÔ- E.19(7690D3B=/0O(aB198d;7/*,-O023l8X*,|9028X:#E.143h1{8,19/640¸HK=Ni(Wi$19/H#S.*,143 jtu=4/H7=9({19(.HzLN1A(>u=W0OBE702PÀjonAp4pAqammaiE7*@- Ei~=4?78@Hz*X(>HK?.-01A({?7;Wi$19/HS7*@193ÔB=&69/=Ni BEz=9Y/0D1A8.E.=9?.3*X(.6&30O/La*@-0D3Ô143 ;7?7S.8X*@35E.02H#*,(GBE70\g ¾ r½'¸_.Ý1NBBE.0UY19-BBE.1AB)=9?7/)0D3^B*XPz1AB0U=AYBE.0UE7=9?.3*,(76z3^B=W- |G*,3)69/=Ni*X(76CP=9/0 38X=Ni8,:zBE>1A(GBE70[\
+ '0D3^B*XPz1NB0UE.193 *,P;>=4/5B 1A(aB*XP;78,*@-O1NB*X=4(.3 YZ=4/=9?7/;.19/19P0B02/ 0235B*,P1AB0D3O_ ¬
ó èµèrÙyü\Ùcã5Ú âOá^ßYá¼áyÚBÝ(.H};>1A/ 1AP0B0O/h0D3^B*XPz1AB023198X=4(76 BE.0¿5LN1A8,8,0O:g=AY BE7*@3\64/19;7EbBE.1AB¸/?.(.3YZ/=9P ` E702/0 *@31A(¸0OJ719-B)jZ
BE70;>1A*,/{jå ¥
p7s q
p7s (¨(¨(amhB=#BE.0;.1A*,/{j ¥
m;.19*X/BE.1NBfP*,(7*XP*,RO0D3BE701AS>35=48X?KB0 L198X?.0$=9YTJ»¼¼
` E70UHK*XÈT02/02(.-0U*,(BE70LN1A8,?70U=9YdBE.0UE7=9?.3*,(76PC=4P0O(aBS>0OB^i~020O(# =AY½BE7*@3f69/ 1A;.Ez8X*,|9028X:C/0so.02-B3Ô(a?.PC02/*@-O198.02//=9/D_Ö =ABE70O/ 3 8,*X|40u*XB)i*XBEVHK*XÈT02/02(4B)LN198X?70D3$YZ=9/ ¯ *X64?7/0
1A(>H
¥
¥
p.s"Ap1A(.H1A(W:z=ABE70O/\j
½é5
p.s Ú&4m _ p7sÀ"Np._
m;.1A*,/3Ô*X(BE7*@3ÔLN198X8,0O:#j19(.H
m 143 02Fa?.198X8,:LW*,19S78,0-21A(.H7*,H71AB0D3$YZ=9/=9?./;.1A/ 1AP0B0O/ 0235B*,Pz1NB0232_
m$;>1A*,/3 1NB)=4(70;.1A/B*@-?.8,19/)-=9P&S7*,(.1NB*X=4(G=9Y ¯
1A(.H
_fÝiE.0O(};>1A*,/0DH#i*vBEVBE701A;.;7/=4;7/*,1AB0
Þáyèµè@áyÞOáyè ú5àBåµà ßBêUá^ß üÉÙcèµèµÙ´çAà´æ5Ùcã5Ú à7áyܼíOèµÝfínÝ¡Ú7åµÙ}âºåµà Å fßBêOÚ7Ùcã5äcê ø ê5ݳâOå Ý´ÚBÝ¡ÞOÛ¡ÝLåµÞaßBêOݳùcáyèµãOݳÙyü\ßBêOÝ1A*,/*X(BE.0uLN198X8,0O:
i*@35EbB=V- E.19/14-B02/*,RO0&E7=NiBE7*@3=9(70E7=4?.35*,(76#P=9P0O(aBU/0235B/*,-B3lBE70z02(aB*,/0C;.1A/ 1AP0OB0O/U3;.19-O09_ 1A(.H
R < û S 19(.H&*vBf=K-O-O?7/ 31ABf1AST=9?KBf ¥
¾ (iE>1NBfYZ=48X8,=Ni)3fi$0)i*,8X8>B/021AB~1A8,8 j
3*XP;78,:G3E7=Ni)3~BE.0YZ02193*,S78X0\30B)=9Y$j
YZ=9/C1A8,8~/021435=4(.1AS.8X0LN1A8,?7023&=AY ¯
p.s ((¨(
èÇÆgÈoÎ7ë
ÊÊ
p
TP*,(7*,PC*,RO0D3lBE701AS.3=98,?KB0\LN1A8,?70&=9YÔJ»¼¼ i$0uST0O8,*,0OL90BE.1NB
Ê
R < û S 69*,L902( _Ug)=AB*,-O0\BE.1NBUÊÛp*@3h=4(78X:YZ0D193*XS78,0CiE70O(
½ÛnAp7_ ¾ Y
p7KMP¸?.35BS>0U8@1A/6902/~BE.1A(Vp.s n7_
c0OBu 3 3^B0O;S.19- |{19(.H{-O=9(.3*@HK0O/$BE.0US.193*,-l*,(4B?7*XB*,=9(GYZ=9/ BE.*,3 /023?78XB2_ ¾ Bh-O19({ST03E7=Ni(GBE.1ABE7=9?.30u;7/*@-0D3 31AB*@3^YZ: BE.0YZ=98,8X=Ni*,(7602Fa?.1AB*,=9(
¥¼¦
y
Í ü½øËÌ
y
Î ü
ª
Î ¬½}ÐÏ
josy¬½
$ ä ä ±
jt y ¬½
y^¬½^m s ^y ¬½ m
jon m
` E70-?7//0O(aBu;./*@-0C*,3u0DF4?>1A8B=GBE70;7/0230O(aBUHK*@3-O=9?7(aB0DH!LN1A8,?70C=AY$?.3502/u-O=435B32½iE7*@- E}*@30J719-B8,:#19(.1A8,=964=9?.3)B=BE.0 -=4PPC=4(G/023?78XB YZ=9/;7/*,-O*X(.6302-O?7/*vB*X0D3O_ ÕW?7;.;>=a350YZ=4/¸1VP=9P0O(aBUBE.1NB¸i$08,*XL40z*X(I1VH70B02/P*,(7*@3^B*,-zi$=9/8@H½ *,P;78,:a*,(76Vi$0{-O19(]*X64(7=9/0CBE70G0JK;>0D-B 1NB*,=9(>3 =9;T0O/ 1NB=9/D.1A(>H#iE70O/0 ª
*@3)i$0O8,8 19;7;7/=JK*XPz1NB02HSW:1{-=9(>3^B 1A(aB2_ ¾ (#BE.*,3li~=4/8@H½KBE70¸64/=Ni BE#/1AB0\=9Y;./*@-0D3)35E.=9?78@H
/=9?764E78X:zPz1AB- EBE70U64/=Ni BE{/ 1NB0u=9Y ?.30O/)-O=435B32_Ôu*XL40O(=9?7/ YZ/ 1AP02i~=4/|4BE70D350\1433?7P;KB*,=9(>3 *XP;78,:
vM8X=46 ùj m½jBvI8,=96~
vI8,=96 m
jon9n4m
` E70C1L90O/ 1A640UF4?>1A/B0O/8,:G64/=Ni BEV/1AB023&jZ0OJW;./0D3302HV1ABu1A(!19(7(W?.1A8/ 1NB0m =AYf/02198dE7=4?.30¸;7/*,-O0232>/02198d;T0O/
-21A;7*XB1{-=9(7 3?7P;KB*,=9(1A(>Hb/02198f;T0O/
-21A;7*XB1E7=4?.35*,(76!35B=K- |}*,(w=9?./\319PC;.8X019/0
s qgÑnKs Ú_Ñ{ 19(.Hwp7s q8ÑÀ/0D35;T02-B*,L90O8,:9_\ 19302H
=9(]0DF4?>1NB*,=9(jtn4n9mdBE70zLN1A8,?70z=AYBE.1NB¸/02-O=9(.-O*X8,023lBE70230{1L902/19690&69/=Ni BE-02H!BE7*@3u0235B*,Pz1NB0C=AY$Sa:VFa?7*XB0z1S.*vBD_¸7=4/u0OJ71AP;78,09*vY~BE70C8@1935B 0O*,69EaBU:90D1A/ 3h=9Y$H71AB11A/0&=4P*vBB02H}YZ/=9P¹BE70z319PC;.8X04d1A(b0235B*,P1AB0=AY £ù©p7sÖØ*@3=9SKB 1A*,(702H_Cu*,L90O(bBE.0CE.*,35B=4/*@-O198 1L902/19690 69/=Ni BE/ 1NB023f=9Y/0D1A8T-=9(>35?7P;KB*X=4({1A(>HCBE70uE7=9?>35*,(76¸35B=K- |4*XYdbi~02/0h1¸(70O6a1NB*XL40(a?.P¸ST0O/Da31:C
¥Û p.s Ø7
BE.0O(IBE7069/=Ni BEw/ 1NB0G=AY)E7=4?.30{;7/*,
[email protected]L90{S>020O(kH7=9?7S78,0BE70#1L90O/ 1A640=9S.30O/L90DH]69/=Ni BEw/ 1NB0G=NL902/\BE.0 0O(aB*X/0U319PC;.8X04_
{|i}a~! ¸ afsci _+gh0JWB2~i~0B/:]B=-21A8,8X:4i$0i*,8X8$/0235B/*,-B\=9?7/&;.1A/ 1AP0B0O/U0D3^B*XPz1NB023\YZ?7/5BE70O/ SW:*,(.-8,?.HK*,(76CBE70\14H7HK*XB*,=9(.198½P=9P0O(aB)-=4(.HK*XB*,=9(GBE.1ABBE70U1L902/19690lL198X?.0u=9Y
< Z¬ *@3 RO02/=&YZ=9/)19(G0DF4?>1A8,8X:a
i~02*X64E4B02H 1
S7?7(>HK8X0=9YÔBE.03*XJb.19P1A
./02(.- E}35B=K- |!;T=9/B5YZ=48X*,=432_&ÕW*,P*X8@1A/B={BE70z;7/0OLW*X=4?.3u350D-B*,=9(d69*,L902(}LN1A8,?7023lYZ=4/ ¯ i$0-21A({Q.(.H#1C/19(7690l=AY ;>1A*,/3 =9Y$jå
m$35?>- E{BE.1NB BE.0\1AS.3=98,?KB0uLN1A8,?70=AY BE70\1L40O/ 1A690hL198X?.0u=9Y
9
19(.H
< Z¬ *@3 PC*,(7*,P*XR202H½_ 1
*X64?7/0 Ú;.8X=9B3BE.0)1AS.3=98,?KB0 LN1A8,?70=9Y>BE7*,3Ô1L90O/ 1A640Ô02//=9/YZ=9/ V¥ BE.0O/019;7;T021A/ 3$B=ST0\1CL198X8,0O:1A8,=9(76CiE7*@- E#;.1A*,/3$=9Y jZ
Øl19(.H
¯b¥
p.s ((4ØK_'h3i*XBECBE70E7=9?>35*,(76P=9P0O(aB2
m 31NB*,35YZ:zBE.*,3P=4PC02(aBh-=9(>HK*vB*X=4({YZ=4/)3^B=K- |W32_
yl?7/3^B/1AB0269:(70G=4?7/19HKP*@33*XS.8X0;.1A/ 1AP0OB0O/3;.19-O0{*@3¸B=}Q>(.HM;>1A*,/32*vYlBE702:w0JK*@3^BDf=AYjå BE>1NBh30BS>=9BEBE.0\1AS.3=98,?KB0LN1A8,?70D3 =AYJ»¼¼ _ÒZ)0235B1NB02H½Ti$0¸1A/0\8,=a=4|W*X(76YZ=9/&jZ
R < û S 1A(.HGBE70\1L902/19690)LN1A8,?70U=9Y < Z¬ B=R20O/=C64*XL40O(GL198X?.023$YZ=9/ ¯ 1
p7s p9p
YZ=9/ ¯¥
p.s ((¨(._
1A(.H
Ó Ô_ÕÖ R < BS Ó Ê 1
p7s p9p _\gh=AB*@-04BE708,*X(.0C*,(bBE70ST=AB5B=9PC
/*,69EaBu-O=9/(70O/u*,(+j
1933=W-O*,1AB0DH{i*XBEVE7*,69E.0O/)LN1A8,?70D3=AYÔ_5Ü \$?KB2T193 ¯ BE.0U;>=4*X(aB¸j !¥
×6Ø egkiF *sf]kegf
¥
19(.H
19(.HV×ji*vBEVw35?7;.;7/0D3302H>m~BE.1ABu31NB*@35YZ:{BE70&-O/*XB02/*@1
p7s (¨((69*,L90D3lBE708,=Ni~0D3^BuYZ021435*,S78,0&LN1A8,?70=AY$Ô
¯+¥
m
m);.1A*,/ 3BE>1NBl8,*,0¸*,(VBE70&LN1A8,8X02:W3h=AYfST=ABEVBE70&E7=9?>35*,(76{19(.HV3^B=K- |GP=9P02(4B 3O_
*X64?7/0\q{3E7=Ni)3O.YZ=9/u3502L90O/ 1A8dL198X?.023)=9Y ¯ TBE70&L198X?.023YZ=4/
Ó J»¼¼ R < û S Ó Ê
p.s Ø4ØK_¸.=9/U1A(W: ¥
*@3)/02HK?>-02HKBE70&350OB)=AYf19HKP*@33*,S78X0j
m35;.14-0C*,3
¯ 8@1A/6902/lLN198X?70D3u=AY
1A/0
m;.19*X/ 33E7/*,(7|K3 B=Ni$19/H
m _
eÙ ÙsÚ _ *,(.198X8,:94B=\?.(.HK0O/ 35B1A(>H*vYBE.*,3~P=WH70O8.*@3Ô-21A;.19S78,0=AY½0JK;78@1A*,(7*,(76UBE.0)02Fa?7*XB^:&;./02PC*,?7P
;7?7R2RO8,09Wi$0)*X(WL40O(aB~1\/*@35|aoYZ/020)193350OBfBE.1AB~;.1:K3~1\-=4(.3^B 1A(aB~/021987/0B?./(=9YCÛ{;T0O/ -02(4B$0214- EF4?>1A/B0O/Ô*X(=4?7/ÔE.*,35B=4/*@-O198 31AP;78,09_Ýb0 BE70O(30219/- E¸YZ=9/BE.0)35Pz1A8,8,0235BfL198X?.0=AY|ÛG35?.- E&BE>1NBBE.0h1L902/19690ÔLN198X?70 =9Y>BE70
+ ?78,0O/0DFa?.1NB*X=4(C02//=9/YZ=4/
BE.*,3 EW:W;>=9BE70OB*@-O198½/*@35|YZ/0O0u/0B?./(*,3$R20O/=.K1A(.HK=9?7/ P=9P0O(aB)-=4(.HK*XB*,=9(.3~YZ=4/)3^B=W- |z/0B?7/(.3 1A(.HGE7=9?>350u;7/*,-O023 1A/0 1A8@3=31NB*,35Q.0DH½_~` E70U8,=Ni$0235B)L198X?.0U=AYÜÛ!*,3
9 ;T0O/ -0O(aB);T0O/):40219/2_Ý35?7P;KB*X=4(
19330B5
;7/*,-O*X(.6VYZ/19P0Oi$=9/|Ti*XBEkE7=9?>35*,(76bB/021NB02HI30O;T0O/ 1NB0O8,:]YZ/=4Pô-=4(.35?.PC;7B*,=9(I*,(k?7B*,8X*XB^:9$-O1A(.(7=ABC/0D35=48XL40BE.0 02Fa?7*XB^:;7/0OP*,?7PÞ;.?7ROR28X04_
Þþ&#")ã2#!%Oß³à¹âÒ²áXU%â ± Ý
` E70Y14-BBE.1ABUBE70zE.=9?.3*X(.6#35B=K- |d19(.H!BEW?.3USW:}1933?7P;KB*,=9(35*,(76V3502/LW*@-0D3O½64/=Ni=4(1NB /0D1A8T*X(aB02/0D3^B / 1NB0D3~19/0l(7=AB35B1NB*X=4(.1A/:i*vBE7=9?7B 14H7HK*XB*,=9(.1981433?7P;KB*X=4(.3Ô=4( BE.0l?KB*X8,*XB^:YZ?7(.-B*X=4(_f` E7*@3 -O1A(GS>030O0O({*XPP02HK*@1NB0O8,:YZ/=4PþBE70u;7/*,-O*X(.6¸|902/(.0O8o40DF4?>1NB*,=9(Hz=NL902/B*,P0l?7(.8X0D332¤$jt'lm
1A(>H)64/=Ni1NB~BE70u319PC0u1L902/19690 /1AB044=4/lj\m~wíN ]
30O;.19/19S78X0¸?KB*,8X*XB^:V1A(.Hb}*@3l(7=AB1A(}19/64?7P0O(aBh*,(VBE70C|902/(.0O8o_l
p
_ ¥Û# *,P;78X*,023
pz*XP;78,*,023\ñ~=9S7S7
òl=9?7648,143;7/0YZ02/02(.-0D3l19(.H#BE.0 ¥
Y19-BBE.1AB)E7=9?>35*,(763502/LW*@-023 E>1L90u69/=Ni({P¸?>- E8,0233Fa?7*@- |a8,:zBE.1A(#-=4(.35?.PC;7B*,=9(VHK=W023 (7=9B)Pz1NB5B0O/D_ ')(G1A8XB0O/(.1AB*,L90);T=4335*,S7*,8X*XB^:9WiE7*@- Ei$0l19/0h-O?7//02(4B8X:C0JK;78,=9/*,(76.a*,3ÔBE>1NBÔBE7019335?7P;KB*X=4(BE.1AB$E.=9?.3*X(.6¸3502/LW*@-0D3 1A/0U8,*X(70D1A/8X:G;7/=9;T=9/B*,=9(.198B=BE.0¸E7=4?.35*,(7635B=K- |{iE.0O/0BE70\;./=4;>=4/5B*X=4(.1A8,*vB^:Y19-B=9/)*@3h-O=9(.35B19(aB)*,3)1;>=W=9/l- E7=9*@-04_ ¾ Y *,(.35B0D19HGE7=9?.3*,(76C30O/LW*,-O023 1A/0h;./=KHK?.-O02H193 31:å_æ¸j
mKiE70O/0
*@3$BE70U35B=K- |z=AYE7=9?>35*,(76.aBE70O/00JK*,35B3 1C8@1A/690
-8@1933 =AY;7/=W-O023350D3~YZ=9/Måz3?.- EBE.1AB
h¥£¦Yçè Á
èé
Z¬
Â
¶T·
ËÌ
$
m °|ê ³@´ ³,´ :ë ÿ ± ³@´ µ $ j m ° ê ³ ÿ ³ ë ³ µ ±
j
42
ÏÐ
Z¬
jonAÚam
!ìÇí îí
*,(4B0O/0235Bf/1AB0D3f1A/0)3^B 1NB*X=4(.1A/:9919(.H&BE70hPC=4P0O(aB~-=4(.HK*XB*,=9(CYZ=9/ÔE7=9?.3*,(76U*,3Ô1A8@35=\31NB*,35Q.02H_u*,L902(åU*,3f?7(7=9S>3502/LN1AS.8X04 i$0i*X8,8$E.1L90B=}19335?.PC0{*vB 3¸35B=K- E.1935B*@-z;7/=9;T0O/B*,023\*X(I=4/H70O/UB=!0235B*,Pz1NB0{BE70{;.1A/ 1AP0B0O/ 3U=AY BE70{P=KHK0O8o_
¾ Yi$0
BE.*X(7|G=AYE7=9?.3*,(76z3502/LW*@-023 143 S>02*X(76;7/=KHK?.-O02H½719(.H@å*@3 LW*X02i~0DHG1431C;7/=KHK?>-B*,LW*vB^:{;7/=K-O0233OK3=9P0UHK*,3-*,;78,*X(.0UP1: ST0YZ=9?7(.H*,(BE70UE7=4P0u;./=KHK?.-B*,=9(8X*XB02/1AB?7/0zj30O0YZ=4/0J71AP;78,0\u/020O(Wi~=W=KH½gZ=4690O/ 3=9(K1A(>HGÝ-09$e=98osÔØ"K~gh=._q. ØE_" ØE( _
Ú
õ q ö òu1LW*,32ÔV=4//*,32Ô19(.H=ø4=9(.1ABE.19(ù¥h021NBE.-=9B04$nAp4pAq>>` E70Vrf/*@-0G19(.H
?.1A(aB*XB^:w=AY,Z023*@HK0O(aB*@1A8c 1A(.Hk*X(kBE.0
Éh(7*vB02HVÕaB 1NB0D3O CÝb=4/|W*,(76zr1A;T0O/D_
õ Ø ö òu1LW*,32T!=9//*@3O1A(>Hø9=4(.1NBE.1A(3¥)021ABE.-O=AB09nAp4p4ØKú*¥h=9?.3*X(.6G1A(>H#BE70\$?.3*X(70D33Uñ~:K-8,09 zYZ=4/5BE.-=4PC*,(76> ¾ (aB0O/ (.1AB*,=9(.198
+ -O=9(7=4PC*@-ûZ0OLW*,0OiU_
õ ö òl*X02i~02/5BD + /i*,(WnAp9p4Ú7 ` E70h` /021NBP0O(aBÔ=AYyli(.0O/ yu-2-?7;.*X0DH¥)=4?.35*,(76¸19(.H{yhBE.0O/~òl?7/ 1AS78,023~*,({1&ñ~=9(>35?7P02/ rÔ/*@-0 ¾ (.HK0OJ òh*@3-?.335*,=9(Vr19;>02/ Éh(7*,L90O/ 3*vB^:z=9YÜ\$/*vB*,3EVñ~=48X?.P¸S7*@1g)=.s>p9ÚNp¨&._
õ " ö .0O/(.1A(.H70OR
eh*,8,8,1L40O/ HK09Oø90D35?.3C1A(>Hwòh*,/|w/?70O640O/Dn9p9p û ñ~=9(>35?7P;KB*X=4(M1A(>HMÕK1LW*X(.6V=NL90O/¸BE70c*XYZ0#ñ~:K-8,09¤ ¥h=Ni
¾ P;>=4/5B 1A(aB)1A/0¸ñ~=9(.3?7P0O/òl?7/19S78,023 üubÝ02(.HK*XB?7/0¹Z*@35|1A(.Hsa19(.H` =WH.HzLN1A(>u=W0BE70OP#7nAp4pAq>C'Ûñ~0O(aB?7/:=AYdòl=Ni(Wi$19/H\$*,143f*,(zBE.0uV=a3^B ¾ PC;T=9/B19(aB ñ~=4PC;T=9(.0O(aB=AYBE70&ñ$r ¾ ¤7` E70¸ñ$1930u=9YÜZ)0O(aB198dÕWE70O8XB02/2
( qA^nAp4p9Ú7 ÝsKñ~=W=98,0O:C02HsarÔ/*,(.-0OB=4(É)(7*,L902/3*vB^: rÔ/0D332Kg)0Oiþø40O/ 3502:9_
õ 9Jö u/?7ST0O/D ø4=430O;7EHNZ)=9ST0O/B¸~s!1A/B*,(nAp9p9q.6` E70Z=98,0z=AY òh?./19S78X0{u=W=KH73U*,(1A/:GÕK1LW*X(.643)19(.H#BE.0¸Ý33*X=4(r19;>02/27gh=.s|""NÚ7_
õ Ú ö u:4=9?7/|9=>ø4=430O;.EA1A(.Hqø4=430O;7EC`d/ 19-O:97jtn9p9p9qam÷Éh3*X(.6û¥h=9P0!1A*,(aB0O(>1A(.-O0$19(.H]Z)0O;.19*X/ 3 B=\ÕWP=W=ABECef1A/*@1AS78,0 + 1A/(7*X(.6432 ¸Ýb=4/|W*,(76zr1A;T0O/D_
q
õ q ö ¥l1A8,8t½')8@1935B19*X/,ZUs,½1A(.Hb'$B3?.35E.* ¾ (7=4?709n9p9p9Ú.ú` E70&c 1A/690&Õ71AP;78,0q\$0OE>1La*,=9?./)=AYfBE70zu0O(702/198X*,RO0DH!V0BE7=KH =9YV=4PC02(aB3
+ 35B*,Pz1NB=9/*,(#!*,335;T02-O*vQ>02HV=KHK0O8@3O ø9=4?7/(.1A8½=9Y + -O=9(7=4P0B/*@-O32ae=48ts 9 q>KÚ¨
Ú(Aq>_
õ Ø ö cd?.3^B*X6>¥h1A(.(7=lg¸sXA19(.H\ÕaB* ß^(zCs2ef19(¸g)*,0O?Wi$0O/S7?7/69ENnAp4pAq.j'k` E70O=4/:u=AY¥h=9?.3*,(76uñ~=98,8@1NB02/198tAñ~=9(>35?7P;KB*X=4( ¾ (.3?7/ 1A(.-O09K1A(>HZ)*,3|{rf/0OP*@17 ¸Ý02/2_
õ ö cd?.3^B*X6>_¥l1A(7(.=&g\s,K1A(.HÕaB* ß^(CsWef19({g)*,0O?Wi$0O/S7?7/69EWnAp9p9q. *¥)=4?.3*X(76zñ~=98,8,1AB02/198tKñ~=9(.3?7P;KB*,=9( ¾ (.35?./19(.-04 19(.H@Z)*,3|GrÔ/02PC*@17¤')(
+ PC;.*X/*,-21A8r02/3;>0D-B*XL409 ¸7=4/5BE.-=4P*X(76ø4=9?7/(.198T=9Y*,(.1A(>-09_
õ " ö !19/5B*X(dEZ=9ST0O/B$s,4nAp4p9Ú7j ñ~=4(.3?7P;KB*,=9(Aòl?7/ 1AS78,0$u=W=KH732A1A(.H&`d/ 1A(>314-B*,=9(&ñ~=a3^B 3O ¾ (aB0O/(.1AB*,=9(.1984*X(>1A(.-O0 òl*,3-?>33*X=4(r19;>02/2Kgh=.sj"9ØE7_
õ & ö !-Du/1AB5B0O( + 8X8,0O(dýZ*@- E.1A/ H Z=46902/3=9(½19(.H3Zh1A(.H7198X8Ýòh02;.1A/BP0O(aB=AYÔñ~=9PP0O/ -04U\$?7/0D1A?G=AY
+ -=4(7=9P*@-l'h(.1A8,:K35*@32 (¨(4p7_
õ n9n ö rÔ*,19RORO0D35*o2!=9(7*,|N17!1A/B*,(\ÕK- E7(702*,HK02/2D1A(.H\ÕK0O8@1A8,0f`d?7R20O8on9p9p4Ú7!¥)=4?.35*,(76>ñ~=9(>35?7P;KB*X=4(1A(.H'h330B rÔ/*@-*,(76. Ý02/5BDdr0B0O/DýZ*@- E.1A/ H Z=46902/3=9(½19(.H3Zh1A(.H7198X8Ý