Knowledge Organization of Integrated Water Resources Management ...

Download PDF
7 downloads 395 Views 1MB Size Report
Comment
The results of this research were the @nowledge domain of water resource ..... Appendix A: Classification Structures (Top Levels) of the knowledge domain.
#"(, /(%  '(   

,.&"--   )-



UDC 005:628.1(593) Preliminary Communication

&'.$ ) &"1+"'&'&+ )++)*',)* & %&+  *'!""-) *"&!"$& ++('& .''&%

   

 !   #   ! ! # !   " #

,$+!",%*,#

  

 !     ! # !   " #

&"&)#)

  

  !  ! #  " # 

*+)+ -=>HHIJ9N>H6E6GID;I=:G:H:6G8=EGD?:8IDCI=::K:ADEB:CID;6C(CIDAD8 ,:6G8= ;DG "CI:K:G 6H>C + -=6>A6C9

-=:HIJ9N6>B:96I9:K:ADE>CH 6C9 FJ6A>I6I>K: G:H:6G8= 7N 69DEI>CDJ   ZH @CDLA:9H>I>DC 6EEGD68=  >;I::C :ME:GIH >C8AJ9>CC I=: 6G:6H D; :CK>GDCB:CI6A :CC::G>CCE 

6H:9 DC I=: :8DCDB>86AAN 6C9 HD8>6AAN HI6I>HI>86A 96I6 9JG>CA6C9=6H 7::C HJ;;:G:9;GDB;ADD96C99GDJD9>86AAN6C9I=:6BDJCID;96B6B:H L6H =>AA>DC ., DG   B>AA>DC ., DC 6K:G6 DK:GCB:CI 8DCH>9:GH I=6I ;ADD9 6C9 9GDJDJH I=G:6IH ID I=: C6I>DC6A 9:K:ADEB:CI 6C9 H>;>86CIAN D7HI68A:H ID I=: FJ6A>IN D; A>;:  JGI=:GBDG: L6I:G >HHJ:>HK:GNBJ8=>CI:GG:A6I:9L>I=DI=:GC6IJG6AG:HDJG8:HHJ8=6H;DG:HIGNA6C9:8DHNHI:B :I8 6HL:AA6H=JB6CH:IIA:B:CIL=>8==6H6C>BE68IDCI=::8DCDB>8C I=:#D=6CC:H7JGC-=6>A6C9 6C9 7:>C:9 >C I=: IL:CIN ;>K: G>K:G 76H>CH >C I=: 8DJCIGN &>C>HIGN D; '6IJG6A +:HDJG8:H6C9CK>GDCB:CI-=6>A6C9



06I:GG:HDJG8:H>C-=6>A6C9L>I=6C6G:6D;67DJI  @B86C7:=N9GDAD86AAN 9>K>9:9>CIDIL:CIN ;>K:G>K:G76H>CH -=:6K:G6C;6AA;DG6AADK:GI=:8DJCIGN>H 67DJI  BB -=:IDI6AKDAJB:D;L6I:G;GDBI=:G6>C;6AA>C6AAG>K:G76H>CH>C-=6>A6C9>H :HI>B6I:96I  B>AA>DCB D;L=>8=E:G8:CIDG6GDJC9  B>AA>DCB >HADHI I=GDJDC :K6EDIG6CHE>G6I>DC 6C9 >C;>AIG6I>DC 6C9 I=: G:B6>C>CAA>DCB 8DCHI>IJI:HI=:GJCD;;I=6I;ADLH>CG>K:GH6C9HIG:6BH -=:EDEJA6I>DCD; -=6>A6C9>H6GDJC9 B>AA>DC -=:G:;DG:I=:6K6>A67>A>IND;L6I:GG:HDJG8:H>H B E:G E:GHDC :68= N:6G L=>8= >H HI6I>HI>86AAN 8DCH>9:G:9 ID 7: =>DCC::9:9>CL6I:GG:HDJG8:HB6C6C8AJ9:H I=:>C;DGB6I>DCD;DI=:GG:A6I:9G:HDJG8:H6C968I>K>I>:HHJ8=6HA6C96C9A6C9JH:;DG:HIA6C9 HDB: DI=:G HD8>6A 6C9 :8DCDB>8 >C;DGB6I>DC :I8  ':ILDG@ D; >C;DGB6I>DC >H C:8:HH6GN ;DG EA6CC>CIH >BEA:B:CI6I>DC "CI:GC6I>DC6A DBB>HH>DC DC "GG>DC 6C9 G6>C6K:G76H>CH6G:9NC6B>8DK:GHE68:6C9I>B:6C968=6CC6CNH>CK:G 76H>C HNHI:B =6H >BEA>86I>DCH ;DG I=: L=DA: HNHI:B  -D JC9:GHI6C9 I=: HNHI:B 9NC6B>8H 6C9 =:AE HDAK: EGD7A:BH >C 6 G>K:G 76H>C 6 =DA>HI>8 BJAI> H:8IDG 6EEGD68= 6I I=: G>K:G 76H>C H86A: >H C::9:9   G>K:G 76H>C 6EEGD68= >H CDL G:8DO:9 6H 6 8DBEG:=:CH>K: 76H>H ;DG BDG: :8DCDB>86AAN HD8>6AAN 6C9 :CK>GDCB:CI6AAN HJHI6>C67A: L6I:G G:HDJG8: B6C6H 00 

  88DG9>CE   "+& >H 9:;>C:9 6H [I=: EGD8:HH D; 8DDG9>C6I>CDC B6C6I=>C6K:CG>K:G76H>C>C DG9:G ID B6M>B>O: I=: :8DCDB>8 6C9 HD8>6A 7:C:;>IH 9:G>K:9 ;GDB L6I:G G:HDJG8:H >C 6C :FJ>I67A: B6CC:G L=>A: EG:H:GK>CC6+>K:G6H>C+:H:6G8=  => +>K:G 6H>C L=>8= L>AA G:;:GG:9 ID 6H + >C I=>H E6E:G DG>C6I>CCH >H I=: A6GBEDGI6CI G>K:G ;DG I=: :8DCDB>8 6C9 HD8>6A 9:K:ADEB:CI D; 'DGI=:6HI:GC -=6>A6C9  "I 8DK:GH 6C 6G:6 D; 6EEGDM>B6I:AN  HFJ6G: B:I:GH68GDHHIL:AK:EGDK>C8:H -=:L6I:GD;I=:+>HJH:9=:6K>AN>CE:DEA:ZH:K:GN96N A>K:H  "I >H 6AHD 6 G:HDJG8: ;DG ;>H=:GN 68JAIJG: >C9JHIGN IDJG>HB IG6CHEDGI6I>DC 6C9 :A:8IG>8EDL:GEGD9J8I>DC -=:+=6H6AL6NH7::C>CI=:>CI:G:HID;G:H:6G8=:GHL=D6G: G:8DO:96H:ME:GIHDCI=:+>CBDC>IDG>CCI>DCI=6IB6N 7: 6;;:8I:9 7N L6I:G 8DCHJBEI>DC :HE:8>6AAN ;GDB 68JAIJG: 6C9 >C9JHIGN  -=: :CK>GDCB:CI6A6C9:8DAD86A96B6C9JHIGN6ADC< I=: G>K:G =6K: 7::C 6 K>I6A >HHJ: ;DG H:K:G6A N:6GH !N9GD 6C9 IJI:   ):DEA:A>K>CC>CBDC>IDG>CCI>DC>I>HD7K>DJHI=6I6 A68@ D; @CDLA:9CAA :M>HIH 7:IL::C I=:B  "C 699>I>DC I=: :ME:GIHZ @CDLA:98=H=DJA97:JH:9;DGI=:L6I:GG:HDJG8:B6C6C=6HCDI7::C86EIJG:9 8A6HH>;>:9DG>CI:CID6C>C;DGB6I>DCHNHI:B;DG9:8>H>DCB6@>C
DCH D; 6 ;ADD9 ;DG:86HI L6GC>CC DG9:G ID G:9J8: =JB6C B6I:G>6A 6C9 8JAIJG6A ADHH:H 6G: 86GG>:9 DJI >C JGDE:6C9,DJI=;G>86)6G@:G  

C9G:J :I 6A    6AHD :MEG:HH:9 I=: DE>C>DC I=6I I=: EA6CC>CHDC9GDJDC6C9B>I>DC

-=:JH:D;BD9:AH6C9:8>H>DC,JEEDGI,NHI:BH,,=6HEA6N:96C>BEDGI6CIGDA:>CI=: 9:K:ADEB:CID;I=:#J86G6H>C)A6CH;DG6ABDHIILD9:869:H6HL:AA6H;DGI=:9:K:ADEB:CI 6C9 >BEA:B:CI6I>DC D; I=: ,E:8>6A GDJI>DC )A6CH ,)  -=:N >C8AJ9:ADCCJBI:GB6A:GI6C9H=DGII:GB:B:GI>DC B:6HJG:HI=6I6G:68I>K6I:9JH>CO:9GDJIDG>CC6I>DC D; 96I6 EGDK>9:9 7N I=: ,, DC EG:8>E>I6I>DC HIDG6C G:H:GKD>GH CG>K:GH

:G6C 6C9 )>6H:8@>   6AHD 9:K:ADE:9 6C DCIDAD9:9 H:6G8= :CC: C6B:9 !N9GDH::@ I=6I 6AADLH JH:GH ID FJ:GN BJAI>EA: =N9GDAD8 G:EDH>IDG>:H H>BJAI6C:DJHAN JH>C< @:NLDG9H  -=: @CDLA:98= 8DK:G:9 I=: L6I:G FJ6A>IN B:I:DGDAD9:9 I=: A>C@6:CI>;>8 :K:GN96N A6C8= L6H :K:CIJ6AAN JH:9 ID G:HDAK: H:B6CI>8 =:I:GDIN >HHJ:H7:IL::CI=:96I6G:EDH>IDG>:H6C98AJHI:G>CH8DK:G>CCO>CCDC,NHI:B!",

&DG:DK:G :886GDC> :I 6A    HIJ9>:9 I=: >CI:DC D; DCIDADI= 86H: 76H:9 6C9 GJA: 76H:9 G:6HDC>CCID 6C :CK>GDCB:CI6A 9:8>H>DC HJEEDGI HNHI:B  -=>H >CI:DC >BEGDK:9I=:BD9:A>CC;DGB6I>DC67DJIL6HI:L6I:GIG:6IB:CIEGD8:HH:H6C9G:HDAK:9 :M>HI>CBE6HH:H>CI=:G:6HDC>CDC D;ILD @>C9HD;86JH: :;;:8IG:A6I>DCH=>EHID>BEGDK:I=:8DBBJC>86I>DC6BDC;;:G:CI:A:B:CIH 6C96GDCB:CI6A9:8>H>DC HJEEDGIHNHI:BI=JHG:9J8>CI>:H

H ;6G6HI=: H:B6CI>8 H:6G8=HNHI:BH D; L6I:G G:HDJG8:H >C;DGB6I>DC 6G: 8DC8:GC:9 >C -=6>A6C9I=:B6?DGA>B>I6I>DCD;:M>HI>CCI:DC;DG>9:CI>;N>C< I=: L6I:G EGD7A:B L=>8= D;I:C G:HJAI:9 >C 6C 6C6ANH>H D; I=: 96I6 ;GDB BJAI>EA: HDJG8:H

:IL::C I=:H: >C;DGB6I>DC HDJG8:H I=:G: 6G: 6AHD I=: A>B>I:9 HJEEDGIH ;DG JH:GH ID ;>C9 I=: 96I6G:A6I:9IDI=:>G>CI:G:HIH



































































*

$0(('& -.&,.$ ' $'+$+

$'(0% (+ '"2-"('("'- +-0-+



-=: LDG9 9>H6HI:G >H 9:;>C:9 7N I=: .C>I:9 '6I>DCH 6H 6 H:K:G: ;6>AJG: D; 8DBBJC>IN EA6CC>CCK:ADHHD;=JB6CA>;:6C9B6I:G>6AH6C99:K6HI6I>DCID:8DCDB>8 GDCB:CI  .HJ6AAN I=: 6;;:8I:9 8DBBJC>IN >H JC67A: ID =6C9A: HJ8= 9>H6HI:GH JH>CIH DLC G:HDJG8:H  ,DAJI>DCH ID B>C>B>O: G>H@H ;GDB C6IJG6A 9>H6HI:GH L:G: CI=:A6HI9:869:  L=>8=L6HC6B:9I=:["CI:GC6I>DC6A :869: ;DG'6IJG6A>H6HI:G+:9J8I>DC\7NI=:"CI:GC6I>DC6ADBBJC>IN />HJ6A>O>CCI:GC6I>DC6A 9>B:CH>DCH D; 9>H6HI:GH 6:; ;GDB I=: "CI:GC6I>DC6A DBBJC>IN86C7:BDHI:;;:8I>K:

>H6HI:G&6C6C8DAC0>A=>I: 

-=: EG>C8>EA:H D; G>H@ B6C6C B6CN L6NH HJ8= 6H  C8DJG6CBEGDK:B:CI 6C9 6EEA>86I>DC D; H:6HDC6A 6C9 H=DGI:G I:GB ;DG:86HIH   :K:ADE>CCI:IDG>CC;DGB6I>DC 9:A>K:GN HNHI:BH   :K:ADE>CDJH A:K:AH D; CI>DC 68I>DCH 6C9 EGDCCDC6AHIGJ8IJG:I=6I:C=6C8:H8DDG9>C6I>DCL>I=>C6C97:IL::CA:K:AHD;A=>I: 

H I=: KJAC:G67>A>IN ID 9GDJC8G:6H:9 G:8I:9IDG:9J8:G>H@H6HHD8>6I:9L>I=>IHD88JGG:C8:I=GDJCIGD9J8I>DCD;EA6CC>CBEGDK:DE:G6I>DC6A86E67>A>I>:H6C9B>I>DCB:6HJG:HI=6I6G:6>B:96IG:9J8>CH8=6CC:BE=6H>H>HADCI>CH6HI:GB6C6H>HB6C6DCD;I=:8N8A:

-=>HE6E:GEG:H:CIH6C:M6BEA:D;=DLID6EEANI=:8N8A:D;9>H6HI:GB6C6C8A:H 6C9 G:H:6G8= E6E:GH H:K:G6A :M6BEA:H D; L6I:G G:HDJG8:H B6C6H8DK:G:9  (C: D; :M6BEA:H >H I=: ;ADD9 B6C6H  L=D9>96 G:K>:LD;:;;:8I>K:;ADD9>C;DGB6I>DCHNHI:BH;DG 6EEA>86I>DC>C,DJI=;G>866C9;DJC9I=6II=:HJHI6>C67A:EG:K:CI>DC6C9B>I>DCHIG6I::H H=DJA9 7: 68=>:K:9 L>I=>C 6 =DA>HI>8 >CI:7JI: ID I=: EG:K:CI>DC 6C9 B>I>DCD;;ADD9ADHH:H

-=:EGD8:HHD;L:6I=:G;DG:86HIH >CKDAK:HI=:8DAA:8I>DCD;B:IGDAD86A>C;DGB6I>DCID 6A:GI67DJIEDI:CI>6A;ADD9:K:CIH>CI:GBHD;AD86I>DC6C9I=:C6IJG:D;:K:CI "I>HH>B>A6GID L=6I L6H 9DC: 7N )6G@:G   L=D HIJ9>:9 6C9 9:H>:I6A E:GHE:8I>K: >CKDAK>CCCH G:H:6G8= >C I=: EG:K>DJH E6E:G D; $6:L7DDCB6   I=: G:H:6G8=:GH JH:9 )A:HH>H   6C9 )6G@:G   8DC8:EIH ID 9:H>DCHNHI:BD;I=:=>+>K:G6H>C !DL:K:GL=:C:ME6C9>C;;>8JAI>:H>C8G:6I>CH>I>DC G:I:CI>DC 6C9688:HH ID @CDLA:96AAN >C I=: 86H: D; =>6A>O:9 @CDLA:9H @CDLA:9I >H 6AHD G:;:GG:9 ID 6H :ME:GI>H: DG :ME:G>:C8:  ,DB:I>B:H =DL:K:G @CDLA:99:H L>I=>C CDC =JB6C D7?:8IH :>I=:G >C 6 HIG6>C 6 8DC8:EIJ6A L6N

:H>C;DGB6I>DC ;DG :M6BEA: 86C 7: H::C 6H 6C :MEG:HH>DC D; @CDLA:98:H B69: 7N I=: 9:H>HH:CH:I=:L6I:GG:HDJG8:HB6C686A8DBEA:M6C9>AA 9:;>C:9 EGD7A:B L=DH: DEI>B6A B6C6G:H 6C >CI:9>H8>EA>C6GN 6EEGD68=

-=>H6EEGD68=86C7:G:68=:9L>I=6C>CI:AA>AIJEDCI=:8DC8:EIH6C9B:I=D9HD; =JB6CG:6HDC>C86I>DC 7N I=: 8DC8:EI D; =>:G6G8=>86A 86I:O6I>DC8DCH>9:G>C;;:G:CI6IIG>7JI:H7N:K6AJ6I>CHI>8H D; I=: 96I6 L>I= 6 =>:G6G8=>86A 8AJHI:G>CDC  -67A:  K:H :M6BEA: D; >CHIGJB:CI ;DG 8A6HH>;N>C8= 8DBEDH:9 D; I=: ;DAADL>CC DC8:EI ,J7 9DB6>C IIG>7JI:H +:A6I>DCH=>E &:6C>CC -=6> A6CCI=:+;GDB;DJGJC>K:GH>I>:HAD86I:9 DC+>CI=:CDGI=:6HID;-=6>A6C96C96AHD>CI:GK>:LHL>I=H:K:C8:GHL=D =6H7::C>CKDAK>CI=L6I:GB6C6CI=:+6C9,JBB6G>O>CGB>CI>DC)GD8:HH 96EI:9;GDB%>DJ  6C9)6NC::I6A  

DB6>C DC8:EI

6H:9 DC I=: 6C6ANH>H D; I=: 96I6 ;GDB I=: A>I:G6IJG: G:K>:LH 6C9 I=: :ME:GIH I=: @CDLA:9C DC L6I:G G:HDJG8:H B6C6;>:9 JH>CC 8DC8:EIH  -=: EG68I>86A 8A6HH>;>86I>DC D; @CDLA:9C >C I=: DGO6I>DCH G:HEDCH>7A:;DG + B6C6C -=6>A6C9 L=>8= 9>K>9: I=: EGD8:HH D; L6I:G G:HDJG8:H B6C6CIDI=G::EGD8:HH:H)A6CC>C;>86I>DCD; @CDLA:9CJH>CH6HI:GB6C6A=>I: L=>8=8DBEG>H: D; EGD8:HH:H DG:86HIH &DC>IDG>CCIG6I: E! -,-DI6A >HHDAK:9,DA>9H -!-DI6A !6G9C:HH 8>9>IN A@6A>C>IN >D8=:B>86A (MNC< >C-=6>

+:A6I>DCH=>E

1

2

,NCDCNB

1:H .C9:G

=

8

A

>

>

B

:E6GIB:CI D; GDJC9L6I:G +:HDJG8:H

:E6GIB:CI D; GDJC9L6I:G +:HDJG8:H



'D

#(.+'%( "'(+&-"(' ' (+

'"2-"('% ,"',

=:B>86A(MN9: DC9J8I>K>IN >HHDAK:9(MNA6C9:E6GIB:CID;CK>GDCB:CI6A*J6A>IN)GDBDI>DC+:DC6A CK>GDCB:CI6A(;;>8:6C9I=:+DN6A-=6>,JGK:N:E6GIB:CI

68=6H6B:B7:GD;I=:L6I:GG:HDJG8:HB6C6II::6C9I=:9>HIG>8I D;;>8: 6I I=: 9>HIG>8I A:K:A B6C6II::  ,>C8: L6I:G G:HDJG8:H B6C6DCH >CKDAK: BJAI>EA: 6:H >C 8DAA67DG6I>DC I=: L6I:G EGD7A:BH G:A6I:9 ID >C;DGB6I>DCBJHI7:DGO:9>CBDHI:;;>8>:CIL6N6HH=DLC>C-67A:

HI;6GB:GH>CHD>A6C9L6I:G8DCH:GK6I>DC EG68I>8:H6C9HD>A>BEGDK:B:CIH::9EGD9J8I>DC;DG 8DK:G8GDEH6C9HD>A>BEGDK:B:CIB6I:G>6AHIG6CH;:G I:8=CDADIHG:H:6G8=D;HD>A9:K:ADEB:CI6C9 HD>AH8>:C8:;DGBJAI>EA:EJGEDH:H6C9JH:H

,D>A6C9%6C9"C;DGB6I>DC %6C9.H:)A6CC>C
DC

)GDBDI:6C99:K:ADE;6GB:GHID7:H:A; G:A>6CIID EGD9J8:68JAIJG6AEGD9J8IHL>I=IN6C9 ID:CG;6GBD88JE6I>DC>C6HJHI6>C67A: B6CC:G

)A6CI"C;DGB6I>DC 8JAIJG:%6C9.H: "C;DGB6I>DC

:E6GIB:CID; 06I:G+:HDJG8:H

,J8N B:6HJG:HG:A6I:9IDL6I:GG:HDJG8:H &6C6DCG:HIDG6I>DC6C99:K:ADEB:CID; 9>G:8I:9HJE:GK>H>DCBDC>IDG>CDC6C9 8DDG9>C6I>DCEGD7A:BH6HHD8>6I:9L>I=L6I:G G:HDJG8:H

!N9GD"C;DGB6I>DC ", 06I:G6C9%6C9HA>9: "C;DGB6I>DC 06I:G,IDG6C+>K:GH6C9,IDG6DC +>K:G6H>C0+&)A6C

:E6GIB:CID; >H6HI:G)G:K:CI>DC 6C9&>I>DC

)GDK>9:EG:A>B>C6GN6HH>HI6C8:6C9G:A>:;IDK>8I>BH 6C9G:8DK:G76H>8>C;G6HIGJ8IJG:L=>8=>H96B68I>BH"C;DGB6I>DC +:H8J:6C9K68J6I>DC "C;DGB6I>DC

&(*#$*%

!))*( (,$*!%$$ !*!*!%$

(%,!&("!#!$(.))!)*$$("!*% ,!*!#)$(%,()!!$()*(+*+(- ! !)#$$(*%* &+"!

 !*!#) $%(#*!%$  )+$ ,+*!%$

$%(#*!%$

"*(!!*. $(*!$ +* %(!*.%  !"$

$(*'+!($*($)#!*"*(!$(. *%* *(%&%"!*$ "*(!!*.+* %(!*.  * (%,!$!" "*(!!*.+* %(!*.  %* ("*(!$(.%$)+#()+$( * "-* (%$$$! %(!$%+$*(!)

#$*(*%( %"+#)$,")

$%(#*!%$

(%,!$!" #!$!)*(*!, ($!/*!%$

(,$*$#!*!*&+"!$$,!(%$#$*" $())-"")&(%,!!*%,!*!#)$ %%(!$*-!* +* %(!*!)%( %"!)*! ))!)*$

 )+ $ ,+*!%$

$%(#*!%$  !*!#) $%(#*!%$

%##+$!*.

,"%&#$*

&(*#$*

+&&%(*,"%&$)+)*!$* "%"%$%#. .&(&(!$!$%(#*!%$%(* %##+$!*.

*!%$"+("

,"%&#$* $%(#*!%$

  

 

&(*#$*% (%+$-*( )%+()

,"%&$#$(%+$-*(()%+()*% * !(+""&%*$*!")%)*%&(%#%** (%-* %* $*!%$0),"%&#$*!$)+)*!$" #$$(

(%+$-*()%+()

$%(#*!%$

 ! *%(%"%!"

&(*#$*

(%,!#*%(%"%!"!$%(#*!%$)(,! $%,($#$*"+$!*)!$)*$*+(" !))*()

*%(%"%!" $%(#*!%$

0

-

-

  

.

1

2

3

4

5

2

6

7

8

9

4

:

2

7

;




8

?

4

@

@

7

>

=

8

A

>

>

B

#(.+'%( "'(+&-"(' ' (+

!%$" $*( %( %

$%(#*!)$ &  $%"%. %(* )*  !"$

(%,!*)(,!)("*!$*%)& * $%"%.$%!$%(#*!)

'"2-"('% ,"',

% $%(#*!) $&

$%(#*!%$

&(*#$*% (%,!$$,!(%$#$*"!$%(#*!%$)(,! $,!(%$#$*" $*%((.%+*$".*!"()(  +"!*.(%#%*!%$ ,"%&#$*$* $%"%.*($)(*%'+"!*. %$*(%"* $,!(%$#$*

$,!(%$#$*" $%(#*!%$

!%$" $,!(%$#$*" !

*(+"!*.%$!*%(!$

$%(#*!%$

%$+*$,!(%$#$*"'+"!*.#$#$* ,"+*!%$)$#%$!*%(!$)-"")*% &+"!) $,!(%$#$*"!$%(#*!%$

%." !+(,. +(,.(%+$$!(*%&(&(#&%(

&(*#$* %+$*(.))+(!*.$,"%&#$*

% $%(#*!)$&

$%(#*!%$

  :H>CKDAK:99JG>C:G6G8=>86AHIGJ8IJG:9D;"0+&86H:D;I=:+ D

E

F

G

H

I

F

J

K

L

M

H

N

F

K

O

P

O

Q

R

L

S

H

T

T

K

R

Q

L

U

R

R

V

-

-

-

$0(('& -.&,.$ ' $'+$+

$'(0% (+ '"2-"('("'- +-0-+



-=: G:HJAIHD;I=>HG:H:6G8=L:G:I=:@CDLA:9CD;L6I:GG:HDJG8:B6C686A HIGJ8IJG:9 7N ;DAADL>CC I=: B6C6C-=6>A6C9  -=:)A6CC>CH:9D;I=G:: HJ7 9DB6>CDG:86HI>CIDG>CCHG:H:6G8=>HHJEEDGI:97N-=: G69J6I:,8=DDA$=DC $6:C.C>K:GH>IN-=6>A6C9

((&"/  $**""+"'& +),+,)* '( -$* ' +! #&'.$  '%"& *+),+,)')+!*" &'.+))*',)*%& %&+"&')%+"'&*0*+% $&&"& DG:86HIH Y

W

W

X

Z

[

\

]

^

[

_

`

a

b

]

c

[

`

d

e

d

f

g

a

h

]

i

i

`

g

f

a

j

g

g

k

#(.+'%( "'(+&-"(' ' (+

'"2-"('% ,"',

A>B6I:(JIADD@H +>K:G6C9,IG:6B;ADLDG:86HI ,D>A&D>HIJG:DG:86HI &DC>IDG>C< GDJC9L6I:G"C;DGB6I>DC GDJC9L6I:G%:K:A ADL GDJC9L6I:G*J6A>IN ,JG;68:06I:G"C;DGB6I>DC 6B +:H:GKD>G6C9%6@: +>K:G6C9,IG:6BADL ,JG;68:06I:G*J6A>IN"C;DGB6I>DC )D>CI,DJG8: 8JAIJG6A06HI:L6I:G DB:HI>806HI:L6I:G "C9JHIG>6A06HI:L6I:G )=NH>86A=:B>86A6C9>DAD86A BBDC>6 '>IGDK>IN >H8=6GIGDK:)=DHE=DGJH -:BE:G6IJG: -JG7>9>IN 0:6I=:G6C9A>B6I:6I6 +6>C;6AA -:BE:G6IJG: K6EDG6I>DC 0>C9 ,JCH=>C: ADJ9 >G)G:HHJG: 0:6I=:G&6E

)A6CC>C< G:6"C;DGB6I>DC6C9 ", !N9GDADC;6AA 06I:G*J6A>IN GDJC9L6I:G*J6A>IN ,JG;68:06I:G*J6A>IN %6C9.H: %6C9.H:"C;DGB6I>DC 8JAIJG:G:6 DG:HIG:6 .G76CG:6 06I:GH=:9G:6 ,D8>D 8DCDB>8"C;DGB6I>DC )DEJA6I>DC GDLI=+6I: m

n

o

p

q

r

o

s

t

u

v

q

w

o

t

x

y

x

z

{

u

|

q

}

}

t

{

z

u

~

{

{



W

W

l

$0(('& -.&,.$ ' $'+$+

$'(0% (+ '"2-"('("'- +-0-+



-DI6A)DEJA6I>DC '6I>DC6A+JG6A:K:ADEB:CI"C;DGB6I>DC 06I:G"C;DGB6I>DC GDJC9L6I:G%:K:AH GDJC9L6I:G*J6A>IN ,JG;68:06I:G%:K:AH 6B +:H:GKD>G6C9%6@: +>K:G6C9,IG:6BADL ,JG;68:06I:G*J6A>IN 06I:G,JEEAN6C9:B6C9 DB:HI>8DCHJBEI>DC -DJG>HB"C9JHIGN 8DAD86A6A6C8: "GG>DC8JAIJG: !N9GDEDL:G *('&* A:GI GDJC9L6I:G%:K:A GDJC9L6I:G*J6A>IN ,JG;68:06I:G%:K:A 6B +:H:GKD>G6C9%6@: +>K:G6C9,IG:6BADL ,JG;68:06I:G*J6A>IN +:H:GKD>G6C9%6@: +>K:G6C9,IG:6BADL 06I:G,JEEAN 0:6I=:G B:GDC"C;DGB6I>DC -G6CHEDGI6I>DC"C;DGB6I>DC />8I>BH"C;DGB6I>DC +DN6A+6>CB6@>CDC '6IJG6A+:HDJG8:6B6DC +:H>9:C8:"C;DGB6I>DC 06I:G,JEEAN"C;DGB6I>DC GDJC9L6I:G"C;DGB6I>DC

)&* 3 4 B:H   )  !DGH7JGI:6@:G -   /6A:CI>C: 

   !N9GD:H@IDE 0:7 H:GK>8:H 76H:9 HD;IL6G: ;DG =N9GDAD8 96I6 9>H8DK:GN 9DLCAD69 K>HJ6A>O6I>DC 6C9 6C6ANH>H ,3)/-,+%,1"* -$%**),'  -&14"/%   Y 

34 C9G:J #  #  :GG:G )DAD &   ):G:O 6C9   ,DA:G6     :8>H>DC HJEEDGI HNHI:B ;DG 9GDJCK:G 76H>C ,E6>C 1(

Y

W

W

€

Z

[

\

]

^

[

_

`

a

b

]

c

[

`

d

e

d

f

g

a

h

]

i

i

`

g

f

a

j

g

g

k

#(.+'%( "'(+&-"(' ' (+

'"2-"('% ,"',

!-/*$    -,'/%00 ")/,0 201/"*)"   2*6 

=IIE B:IGDCJ JA7 68 7: >B68H 86>GCH " 6C9G:J56 E9;9DLCAD69:9&6G8= HI 

34 '" 6C9 6CC B6C66 76H>C >CI:K:G 76H>C B6C6A HI  

34 DB6H #  %ADG:CH     -=: ,-+&, )GD?:8I %>C@>CHI>8 6C9 :BE>G>86A@CDLA:9C;D6C:ME:GIHNHI:BID6HH:HHHIG:6BB6C6:BHH DG< >:BHH  EGD8::9>CK>H@R $     $CDLA:9H>I>DC ;DG 9:8>H>DC HJEEDGI HNHI:BHDC6C:A:8IGDC>86HH:B7ANA>C: 5.%/1601%+04)1(..*)#"1)-,0  

34 AD76A 06I:G )6GIC:GH=>E     0=6I >H "0+& =IIE LLL DC ,NHI:B ;DG :8>H>DC ,JEEDGI =IIE 76ALD>H 8DB 76ALD>H 69B>C>HIG6I>DC ;JAA5E6E:G ;;E   E9; 9DLCAD69:9:7GJ6GN I= 

3

4 !N9GD6C9IJI:   6H>8>C;DGB6I>DCD;=>+>K:G6H>C

=IIE LLL =6>> DG I= L>@> >C9:M E=E  9DLCAD69:9#6CJ6GN I= 

3 4 "CI:GC6I>DC6A DBB>HH>DC DC "GG>DC 6C9 G6>C6A:H DC 06I:G ;DG DD9 6C9 +JG6A :K:ADEB:CI >C -=6>A6C9 =IIE LLL >8>9 DG< 8DJCIGN5EGD;>A: =IBA 9DLCAD69:9 :8:B7:G I=  

3 4 %>DJ 1 "      $CDLA:9H>I>DC >HHJ:H I:8=C>FJ:H 6C9 B:I=D9DAD@JA:8@N (  6C9 )DC8:      $CDLA:9C L6I:G G:HDJG8:H B6C6I>DC ;DGI=::H>CCC:I6A E:GHE:8I>K: /-#%%$),'0 -& 1(% ,1%/,"1)-,"* -,&%/%,#% -, *.),% %1%-/-*-'6",$%0-*.),%/-'/"++% &6N G>IO:GA6C9 3 4 )6G@:G # 6C9DG9=6B&   C:K6AJ6I>DCD;;ADD9;DG:86HI>CC< 6C9 G:HEDCH: HNHI:BH >C I=: JGDE:6C .C>DC !"1%/ %0-2/#%0 ","'%+%,1

  

3 4 )6NC:) + ( &:C9DCT6  #D=CHDC,  ,I6GG:C#    DC8:EIJ6A @CDLA:9H>I>DC >C 7>DB:9>8>C:  B:I=D9DAD86A G:K>:L -2/,"* -& )-+%$)#"*,&-/+"1)#0   

3 4 )A:HH>H%    G:K>:LD;:;;:8I>K:;ADD9;DG:86HI>CC86I>DC>C,DJI=;G>86 !"1%/   

m

n

o

p

q

r

o

s

t

u

v

q

w

o

t

x

y

x

z

{

u

|

q

}

}

t

{

z

u

~

{

{



W

W



$0(('& -.&,.$ ' $'+$+

$'(0% (+ '"2-"('("'- +-0-+



34 -6CDCHCK>GDCB:CI)GDDCD;I=:FJ6A>IN6C9HJEEAN D; ;G:H=L6I:G G:HDJG8:H 6EEA>86I>DC D; >CI:C96GI>8A:>9 9DLCAD69:9 #6CJ6GN I=  

34 0>A=>I:    $CJIHDC  %     GDJDCH ;DG HJ88:HH .1)-,0%$)1%//",%%,,%0%/)%0   

„

‚

‚

ƒ

…

†

‡

ˆ

‰

†

Š

‹

Œ



ˆ

Ž

†

‹







‘

’

Œ

“

ˆ

”

”

‹

’

‘

Œ

•

’

’

–