Kyoto University Research Information Repository

0 downloads 0 Views 1MB Size Report
nests were placed in normal density and ten nests were placed in high density in the Ma'Daerah hatchery, Terengganu,. Malaysia. A sample of at least 10 ...
KURENAI : Kyoto University Research Information Repository Title

Author(s)

EFFECTS OF HATCHERY NEST DENSITY ON THE EMERGENCE SUCCESS AND QUALITY OF CHELONIA MYDAS HATCHLING Van de Merwe, Jason; Ibrahim, Kamarruddin; Irvebrant, Michaela; Whittier, Joan

Citation

Issue Date

URL

2002

http://hdl.handle.net/2433/44170

Right

Type

Textversion

Conference Paper

publisher

Kyoto University

了75

EFFECTS OF HATCHERY NEST DENSITY ON THE EMERGENCE SUCCESS AND QUAL]TY OF CHELONlA MYDAS blATCHLlNG

JasonvandeMerwel,Kamarruddinlbrahim2,

Michaelalrvebrantl,andJoanWhittierl

i

2

DepartmentofAnatomicalSciences,theUniversiLyofQueensland,St・Lucia, β〟sb∂ne,QL亡〉4072,A〟Sね〟∂ TurtIeandMarmeEcosystemCenter(TUMEq,RantauAbang,23050Dungun, 殆佗叩9∂叫M∂/∂yS由.E−m∂〟了抽155@ya/100・COm

ABSTRACT lbmaximisehatcherye什iciency,neStSneedtobeplacedascloseaspossible,Whilenotcompromising emergencesuccessorhatchIingquality・HatcheriesinPeninsulaMalays.apresentEypEacenestsataboutO・6mand O.7mintervalswithinand betweenrows,reSPeCtively.Theaimofthisexperimentwastodeterminetheeffectsof increasingthenestdensityonemergencesuccessandqualityofemerginghatchlings・1nJune2002】tWentyLnine nestswereplacedinnormaldensityandtennestswereplacedinhighdensityintheMarDaerahhatchery・lbrengganu・ Malaysia.AsampleofatleastlOhatchlingsemergingfromthesenestsweresub]eCtedtoarunningtrialoverl・6m andwereweighed,meaSuredandscalecounted・TheemergencesuccessandtheproportionofhatchIingswith abnormalscalecountsdidnotdifferbetweenhighandnormaldensitynests・Hatchlingsfromthehigherdensity nestsrans■gniRcantlys10WerthanthosefromnormaldensitynestsandhadIoweTTTiaSS−1engthratios・ltisargued thatsIowerrunnlngSPeedsrepresentalongerexposuretoshorepredationanddecreasedvigourfortheoffshore dispersa■・Furthermore,lowermass−lengthratiorepresentsreducedresidualyolkstoresandlowerenergy reservesavailablefortheswimfrenzyperiod・ThedevelopmentofeggsinhighdensityclutchescouIdbeafFected byreducedgasexchangebetweentheclutchandsurroundingsubstrate・ThiscouldresultfTOmadjacentnests competingforoxygenfromthesamearea・FromthecurrentresuLts】itisrecommendedthatnestscontinuetobe relocatedintohatcheriesatnormaldensitytomaintainthequaEityofemerginghatchlings・ Keywords=hatcheTy,neStdensity,Cheloniamydas】emergenCeSUCCeSS,hatch[i=gquality

lNTRODUCT[ON closeEyassociatedwithbudgetconstraintswherebythis Aspartofaconservabonpr喝rammeS,伽eDepa血1ent methodisalwayscheaperandlesslabourintensivethan insitu(natural)incubation・ ofFisheriesMalaysia(DoFM)hasrunaseriesofmarine Theincubationsuccessofmarineturtleeggscan tultlehatcheriesthatincubateeggstoproducehatchlings beinfluenced bya numberofbioticaabioticfactors forthepurposeofmaintainingitsturtlepopulations・TurtLe incIudingnestlocation,depth】temPe「atUre】inundation・ eggexploitationisanissueinthecountryandthis programmeisameanofprotectionaga■nStCOLlectionfor beach eTOSion,Predatorsandmicroorganisms(FowEer. 1979;Witze11,1981;Mrosovsky,1983;Comelius.1986; localeggmarkets・Frommanagementpointofview・the WynekenetaEL11988;Connant,1991;Eckert・1992; chooseofhatcheryforhatchlingproductionhasbeen

7了6

Kamarruddin and AbduトRahman,1994:Sundin,2001; With2.5cm mesh ofplasticmaterial(locally known as BlamiresandGuinea,2001;Fr)Ck,2003).lnaddition,handling netlon)and shadedvvith nursery−tyPed blackcEoth of CanaIsoleadtomortalityofturtIeeggs(Limpuseta[., 75%lightTetention.Thisproductionhatcheryaccommodated 251clutchesofgreenturtleeggsin2002. 1979)andithasbeenoneofthefactorsthatcommonry reduce hatch oremergence success ofeggsin the DensityexperimentrTh「eemiddlerowsofnests hatcheries. inthehatcherywereusedinthisexperiment(Fig,2)・A SetOfnormaldensitynests(a)andhighdensitynest(b) Over40years,the performance ofhatcheryln WaSSeParatedbyadistanceofabout2mtoavoidshar]ng thePeninsuIarMaIaysiahasbeenmerelybasedonemeト gencesuccess,thatis,thepercentageofhatchlingsthat e恥ctonparamete「sstLrdied.1もnclutcheswerererocated SuCCeSSfully emergefrom a numberofeggsincubated. at a higherdensityin the firstweek ofteamlofthe Althoughincubationsuccessisanimportantindicatorof EARTHWATCH v01unteerprogramme(1−8July,2002). hatcheryperFormance,reSultanthatchlingsexratiosand NormaldensitynestshaveapproximatelyO,6mbetween hearth orin otherwords,thequalityofhatchlings have theircentreswithin rows and O.7m between rows(Fig. neverbeen attempted.This studywas promptedtofiII 2a,),Thehighdensitynests haveO.46m betweentheir CentreS(Fig.2b.).Whenhatchlingsemerged,aSanlPleof thesegapsandtoimprovemanagementprogrammeaimlng atEeastlOhatchlingsfromthesenestsweresubJeCtedto atincreasIngtheproductionofhealthyhatchIingsincor陀Ct a runnlng trialoverl.6m trough and were weighed. SeXratios.SpecifECaIly.theobjectiveofthisstudywasto quantifytheeffectofnestdensityinthehatcheryonthe measured and scale counted.AbnormaIity was deter− emergencesuccessandqualityofgreenturt[e.CheJonia mined as any hatchlingwith a scalecountdiffe「sf「om aduItls scale count.The peTCentage Of abnormal my(ね5h8tC州∩9S. hatchlingsfrom each nest(from the sampFe,N=10−20) WaSthencaFculated andthemean percentofabnormal hatchlings was comparedfor high and normaldensity MATER]ALSANDMETHODS nests.The nests were excavated andits contents were examinedtoquantifytheemergence success,AcomL Studysite−Weconductedthestudyataturtle hatcheryontheeast−facednestingbeachofMa■DaeTah, ParisonofaEIparameterswasnladebetweenhatchlings from highdensitynestsandthosefrom nomlaldensjty l盲rengganu.MaIaysia(Figurel).TherectanguFarhatchery, measured20m[ongx8mwidexl.6m highwasfenced nests.TheANOVAwasusedforastatisticalanalys[SOf thefactoraffecting nestdensity.Normalitywastested byvisualinterpretationofQ−Q pIots,Homogeneitywas tested by Levene■stest.

戸/9.7M∂p5わ0肌′佃扇udγ5鹿Of伽〃edde〃殉′e叩enme〃f∂r肋−D∂e帽わfu州e厄仙e/γ花佗n9ga叫睡/aysJ∂

‖7

「∂ノ

(り

0.6m

0.6日

くニ

三ニ × ×

×

×

× ×

× ×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

×

× ×

× × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × ×

FIgure2.Thedensityofnestsposit旧nedjn thehatche/y(a)normaldensiレ Nests:例hjgh densitynests 仰1re叫.

︵s盲︶p器dsぎ盲u⊃∝

00∩︶∩︶0

︵邑ss心00コS山じ亡註﹂む∈山

=工二 =]二

ロ.1Z8

0.126

0124

D122

0120

0.118 0118

10

10

N(〉mal

High

Nest Density

鞠.3 亡meJ甘enC()SUCCeS5r%+SqofC/?e/0∩由my〔/∂S cJぃねわe5/ncuぬfed∂‖1帥de/1S/レ「0.〃6mbe加ee/川eSr可 ∂nd/10/m∂/dens/少P6−0.7mbe血佗enne5呵/∩〟1e几ね■

DaeJ加わaねわery乃佗れ99∂叩,〟8by由′2002・N 博P√e5enfs納enL椚止erofnesね・

RESULTS

N=

11X)

2拡

High

No「mal

Density 句.4 Me8∩几椚J血9叩eed「十S匂ゎrC/1e/0∩由mγ由古 山8ねわ伽9SeJ¶e/甘巾9加mJ噌わde/1粥川eSねandJlOJm∂/ deJ7SJレ∩郎短扉Maロ∂e/苫わh∂fcJleJy花代叩9∂nLJ一 〃a/∂咋/∂2002.〃帽p佗Se/1rS柚∋nU/刀berofわ∂fc/1〟n9S・

Comparison ofhatchling mass−length ratios Themass−SCL(StraightcaTaPaCelength)ratioof hatchlings emerging from normal density nests (0.463+0.001)wassignificantlylargerthan hatchlings fromhighdensitynests(0.457十0・003)(ANOVA:df=1.F =4.375,P<0,05,Figure5).Homogeneity satisfied

Comparison of nest emergence success DataontheemergencesuccessoflOclutchesof respectivehighdensityandnormaIdensitynestswere COmPared.Therewas nodifferenceintheemergence (Levenes:P>0.05), success betvveen high densitynests(89・94%+1・78) andnormaldensitynests(90L49%十1・78)(ANOVA:df= Determination ofabnorma[hatch=ngs 1.F=0.048,P>0.05).Homogeneitywassatisf.ed(Levene: P=0.564).TheresultsaresummarisedinFig・3・ Thepercentofabnormalhatchlingsfromhighden− sity nests(42.0+6・5)was notsigniflCantlydifferent Comparison ofhatchIhg running speeds Figure4indicatedthathatchlingsf「omnormalden−fromthe percentofabnormalhatchIingsfrom normal densitynests(51.8+2.9)(ANOVA:df三=1,F=1・888. sitynests(0.130m/s十0・002)ransignificantlyfaster P>0.05)(Figure6)・Hon10geneitysatisfied(Levene: thanhatch[ingsfromhighdensitynests(0・120m/S+0・003) P>0.05). (ANOVA:df=1.F=6・511,P<0・05)・Homogeneitysatis− fled(Levenes:P>0・05)・

イ7∂ 粥 幻

身︻mF亡0亡﹄<一∪む2¢L

62 伽

T⊥

糾 0葛正二葛∪ヱ、SS佃≡

開 班 別 Nomal

Nor川al

High

High

父 NestDl∋nSlり

Nest Density

F/9.5 −Me∂∩厄fc/?//∩9maSS−SCL相打0「+SE)わr C/1e/oJ血mγ由ざわ∂fc/1伽9Sfncu上沼fe(ゴ∂fno〝¶a/ de/?Sff/es∂ndハa加ノ/∩9S/ncub8ねd∂=7ノ9わde/1ざ/〟es 融几ね■ロ∂e帽わわ∂fc/?eJγ几ね/∂γ由2002.N佗β侶Senfs

納eJIUmbero=1afc仙叩S.

〇一馬∝﹂US‖SS勺≡

︵s、∈︶p岩倉∪⊃∝ぎ≡〇一芸

Hatchling Scales

F桓.6 丁わeme∂nperCenfイ%十Sq of∂加0〝¶∂J CJle/oJl由my由s雨fc/?/小郡=k昨=壇沖1e/1∫/レaJld 〃0/m∂J由nsfレ〃eSfs/ncub∂fedarM∂‘加e招わ 九arc/1e/γ乃帽〃99∂nU,M∂/8γ引∂,2()02.NreJ)reSeJ†f5 的eJIU/¶ber ofnesfs.

HalchlingSca始S I

I

■ Norm81

■ No「mal



I

▲ Ab110rmal

▲ Abn【)Tmal N= 112

144

46

No「ma】

34 Hi!才h

NestDensl吋

鞠.7几イeaJつrU/1れ血95Peed「+SE)ofC/1e/oJつ由mγ由s ハ∂rC/1血卵面的noJma/a〃d∂加orm∂/5C∂/ecouJ?rS わuJld/∩〃0rm∂/de/1S′レ∂nd/1帥dens/レハ郎fsar Ma●伽e/苫わわa仙e/γ几佃/∂yS/a2【)02・

N= 221 243

5る

Normal

42

H喝11

Ne$tDensity

F短.8 んね即m∂SS−SCLJ召fわ「十S∈ノOrC/1eJoJl/∂my由S ハ∂fcわ〃〃95〝/折口omaJ∂〃dabno/Tn∈/5Ca/e c〔〉Unf∫ わuJld/∩〃0仰∂/deJ75/少∂nd/伯山dens/少ne5fs∂fM∂‘ D∂e/加わ∂fc/†eJγ几佃/∂y由2()02.∂;引1dbwere S/9∩/徹∂nf/yd/触re′7りLS亡)了P<0・り・

Comparison of running speeds between hatcMings with abnormalscale counts and hatch]ings with normalscale countsin normal density nests and high density nests

Comparison of mass・SCL ratios between hatchlings with abnormal scale counts and hatch[ings with normalscale countsin nornlal density nests and high density nests

Theinteraction between scale counts(abnormal/ Therewasnosignificantdifference(ANOVA:df normal)and nestdensity(high/normal)wassignificant =1,F=0.154,P>0.05)inrunningperFormancebetween (ANOVA:df=1,F=6・778.P<0・05)(Fig・8)・PostHoc hatchlingswith abnormaland nomla−scalecountsin LeastSignificantDifferencefoundnormalhatchlingsfrom eithernormaldensityorh弓ghdensitynests(Fig・7)・

了79

normaldensity nests had a higher massrSCL than all exchangebetweentheclutchandsur「Oundingsubstrate. Thiscouldresultfromadjacentnestscompetingforoxy− genfromthesameareaandwarrantsfurtherinvestigaq tion.The findings revealed an advantage of having CEutchesincubatedinnormaldensityoverhighdensityln DISCUSS[ON termsofrunnlngPerfo「mance.FrDmthecurrentresurts, The emergence success and the proportion of it iS recOmmended that nests continue to be relocated hatchlings with abnorma]scale counts did not differintohatcheriesatnorma[densitytomaintainthequalityof betweenhighandnormaldensitynests,Hatchlingsfrom emerging hatchIings. the higher density nests ran significantly slower than hatchlingsfromnormaldensitynestsandhad[owernlaSSL ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS length ratios.Itis argued that slower runnlng SPeeds represent a[onger exposure to shore predation and TheauthorsaregratefultotheDirectorGenera[of decreased vigourforthe offshore dispersal.Smaller Fisheries Malaysia for his persistent support.We are hatchlingsfaceincreased riskofp「edationandfurther−indebted to a11EARTHWATCH2002vDlunteers fortheir assistanceinrunnlngthestudy.ThanksarealsDdueto more,10WermaSS−length ratio represents reduced re− Sidualyolkstoresand[owe「ene「gyreservesavailable therangersatMa’DaerahSanctuaryandtechnicaLstaff OftheTurtleand Marine Ecosystem Center(TUMEC), fortheswimfrenzyperiod.Thedevelopmentofeggsin RantaL(Abang,lbrengganu. highdensityclutchescouldbea什ectedbyreducedgas Othe「groups(P<0,1),

REFERENCES

Blamires,S.).andGuinea,M.L,2001.Theinfluenceoftemperatureon egg mortality,emergenCeSuCCe hatchlingsexratioforflatbacksea(Natatordepressus)atFoBay,Northernlbrritory】Australia・http:// www.arbec.com.my/sea−turtles/art21julyseptOl,htm Connant,11A.,1991.GhostcrabpredationonemergentseaturtlefromreIocatednestson aBarrierlsland,NorthCaroLina.M.Sc.thesis.WesternWashingtonUniveTSity,WashingtonD・C・,50pp・ Cornelius,S.E.,1986,TheseaturtleofSantaRosaNationalPark.FundaciondeParquesNacionales Rica.64p.

EckeTt,S.A.,1992.Boundfordeepwaters.NaturalHistory,46(11);15−19・ Fowler,LE.,1979,Hatch柚gsuccessandnestpredationinthegreenseaturtlelCheloniamydas】atlbrtuguero・ Costa Rica,Ecology.60(5):946−955.

Frick,M.G.,2003.Thesurfcrab(AIt)naeuSC/Tbra血s):Apredatorandpreyitemofseaturtles・ManneTLJrtJe 〃e〝S/effe′N0.99,2003.16−18. Kamarruddin,l,AndAbdul・Rahman,K,1994・Areportonthepreliminary■nSituhatchingofgreentultle・Chelonia mydas(Linnaeus)eggsinPulauRedang.鴨rengganu・Proc・Fish・Res・Conf,DOFMal・・1V:379−387・ Limpus,C・J・,Baker,VandMi”er,J・D・,1979・Movementinducedmor[alityofloggerheadeggs・HelPetOlogjca35, 335−338.

Mrosovsky,N・,1983・ConservmgseaturtLe・TheBritishHerpeto10glCalSociety・London・ SundinG.,2001.AlbstofThreeSimpLeTrapDesignsforSuitabi(ityinControrlingDTePredationonSeaTurtleNesting Beaches.UniversityofSouthCarolinaBeufortPritchardsIsrandResearch&Education・(http://www・SC・edu/ beaufort/Pritchar/「esOO・htm)

Witzell,W.N.,1981.Predationon」uVeniEegreenseatu州es,Che/oniamydas・bygrouper・Promicropslancelotus (Pisces=Serranidae)intheKingdomoflbnga,SouthPacific・BulIetinofMarmeScience31(4):935−936・ Wyneken,J・,Burke,tJ・,Sa.mon,Nl・andPedersen・D・K・・1988・Eggfailureinnatu「alandrelocatedseatur[le nests,HelPetOIogy22.88−96・