Oct 14, 2011 ... Perceptual and Cognitive Development and Plasticity. Moriah Thomason ...
between Neural Degradation and Cognitive Aging. Shu-Chen Li ...
Institute of Gerontology
Margret M. and Paul B. Baltes Foundation International Conference
!"#$%&'()*+,(-."/".0*1# 23(")*()4*2$5(6"137 8*91:)"."6$*;$!0$,'()'!*(0!*5)/H +&(),1!1(''>!,)-!+#$!1&)C!@$+;$$)!@$#,.&(0>!@0,&)!'+05/+50$! ,)-!'(/&$+36!706!8,040$+!:,1+$'!;,'!,!+0,&1H@1,I&)4! 0$'$,0/#$0!&)!2'3/#(1(4&/,1!4$0()+(1(43!;#(!/(5)+$-! DPRQJKHULPSRUWDQWFRQWULEXWLRQVVRPHRIWKH¿UVW '+5-&$'!.,1&-,+&)4!2'3/#(1(4&/,1!%$+#(-'!*(0!-&,4)('&' (*!-$%$)+&,6
"#50'-,3>!J/+(@$0!KL>!MNKK YZLN
O$1/(%$ G&1,03!G6!D,+)$0 P&/$H90$'&-$)+!*(0!D$'$,0/#>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3
YZ[N
J2$)&)4!0$%,0C' :(0&'!:,1+$'>!8!,)-!9!:,1+$'!S(5)-,+&()!,)7$2,0+%$)+!(*!9'3/#(1(43>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3!!
\ZNN
T$3)(+$!20$'$)+,+&() !70$'-$)> 2)+,&'314405"64",'7%+#0$%(%.1.8'25&191&:;)%4%()%(& !R)&.$0'&+3!(*!U,1&*(0)&,H:$0C$1$3> -#"1('=%9%,046%(&'"()'*,".&151&:'>+440#&1($ 31$?;@%9%,'A0$(1&10(
KNZ[]
:6V6!U,'$3>!U(0)$11!R)&.$0'&+3!O$&11!U(11$4$!(*!8$-&/&)$>! 70(,1(%"#'7%+#0B%?"910#",'A?"($%.'=+#1($ &?%'C#"(.1&10('D(&0'"()'E+&'0F'2)0,%.5%(5%'
KKZK]
E(,!J*$)>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3G C?%'=%9%,046%(&'0F'!%60#:'>:.&%6.'1('&?%'-#"1(
KKZ[]
:0&4&++$!DW-$0>!R)&.$0'&+3!(*!G,%@504> *%#5%4&+",'"()'A0$(1&19%'=%9%,046%(&'"()'*,".&151&:'
KMZK]
8(0&,#!"#(%,'()>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3> *,".&151&:'0F'-#"1('"()'-%?"910#'1('D(F"(5:'"() H"#,:'A?1,)?00)
KMZ[]!H!K[Z[]
X5)/#
K[Z[]
!"##$%&'(()'45,$&'=>$&>',&8'1%&#-5,$&-#'%&'*+,#-$.$-/ X,0'!:^/C%,)>!T,0(1&)'C,!=)'+&+5+$+>!Q+(/C#(1%!_!8,B! 91,)/C!=)'+&+5+$!*(0!G5%,)!7$.$1(2%$)+>!:$01&)> 7%+#0&#"(.61&&%#'D6"$1($G'/+(5&10(",'-#"1('>%I+%,"% 0F'A0$(1&19%'C#"1(1($J
K]ZK]
E,*+,1&!D,I>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3> 7UDMHFWRULHVRI%UDLQ$JLQJWKHLU0RGL¿HUV "()'A0$(1&19%'A0##%,"&%.J
K]Z[]
U(**$$!:0$,C
KbZNN
7$)&'$!U6!9,0C>!R)&.$0'&+3!(*!"$B,'!,+!7,11,'> A0(.&#"1(&.'0('*,".&151&:8'>+#4#1.1($'&$-$:"'*+,#-$.$-/',&8'-0"'45,$&'$& ?%5 C%#"&0,0$15",'A0(.&#"1(&.'0('*,".&151&:'
KKZK]
d$$!X$$!Q#&)4>!8,B!91,)/C!=)'+&+5+$!*(0!G5%,)!7$.$1(2H %$)+!,)-!G5%@(1-+!R)&.$0'&+3>!:$01&)> C?%'=%9%,046%(&'0F'H41.0)15'!%60#:'25#0..'&?%'@1F%.4"('
KKZ[]
7&,)$!U#54,)&>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3> %#0&0(1('1('>:("4&15'*,".&151&:8 &#+5&+#%'1('D(&%#"5&10('K1&?'&?%' -#"1(;=%#19%)'7%+#0?15'/"5&0#'Q-=7/R'N%(%
K[ZLN
Q/(++!76!8(**,+>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3> A0$(1&19%'"()'7%+#",'A0##%,"&%.'0F'A0#&1.0,'HP40.+#% 1('3+6"('2$1($
K]ZNN
V(#)!O((-,0->!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3> S.1($'/+(5&10(",'!"$(%&15'!R)&.$0'&+3!(*!8&/#&4,)> 7%+#016"$1($'244,15"&10('&0'A0$(1&19%'C#"1(1($'1('E,)%#' 2)+,&.
KbZK]!H!KcZLN KcZLN
8(-$0,+$-!7&'/5''&()6 8(-Z!R1%,)!X&)-$)@$04$0>!89=:>!:$01&) U1('&)4!0$%,0C' E,*+,1&!D,I
!"#$%&"'("#')** UD"7!e!U$)+$0!*(0!D$4$)$0,+&.$!"#$0,2&$'!70$'-$) "$/#)&'/#$!R)&.$0'&+^+!70$'-$)>!,)-!7fE` 7+,-$%&',&8'E7&.-$%&,+'D"+":,&." F-51+!#&22(/,%2,1!)$50(4$)$'&'!1&*$1()4!20(-5/$'!1(;! QXPEHUVRIQHZJUDQXOHFHOOVWKDWDGGWRWKHPRVV\¿EHU /())$/+&()!@$+;$$)!+#$!-$)+,+$!4305'!,)-!UFL6!"#$! #32(+#$'&'!&'!+#,+!)$;!)$50()'!,0$!/0&+&/,1!+(!+#$!*5)/H WLRQRIWKHGHQWDWHJ\UXVDQGVHYHUDOVSHFL¿FIXQFWLRQV #,.$!@$$)!#32(+#$'&I$-6!O$!*(11(;!+#$!&-$,!+#,+!+#$! )$;!)$50()'!,11(;!,)!,/+&.&+3H-$2$)-$)+!(2+&%&I,+&()! RIWKHPRVV\¿EHUWUDFWLQRUGHUWRFRSHZLWKVLWXDWLRQV (*!)(.$1+3!,)-!/(%21$B&+36!"#$!20$/50'(0!/$11'!+#,+!,0$! '+&%51,+$-!@3!,/+&.&+3!,)-!+0,&)&)4!%&4#+!@5&1-!52!,!h)$5H URJHQLFUHVHUYH´WKDWDOORZVÀH[LEOHUHVSRQVHWRFRJQLWLYH /#,11$)4$'!&)!+#$!/(50'$!(*!1&*$6 :3!)(;!%,)3!'+5-&$'!#,.$!&).$'+&4,+$-!+#$!*5)/+&()! (*!+#$!#&22(/,%25'!,*+$0!,-51+!)$50(4$)$'&'!#,-!@$$)! '5220$''$-!(0!,@1,+$-6!!#,.$!@$$)!0,0$6!9#3'&/,1!$B$0/&'$!,)-!$).&0()H %$)+,1!$)0&/#%$)+!@(+#!&)/0$,'$!,-51+!)$50(4$)$'&'!,)-! ,0$!,--&+&.$!&)!+#$&0!$**$/+6!G(;$.$0>!-$'2&+$!'&%&1,0!$)-! UHVXOWVWKH\DSSHDUWRKDYHVSHFL¿FVXEHIIHFWVRQDGXOW )$50(4$)$'&'6!F0$!+#$'$!-&**$0$)/$'!,1'(!*(5)-!&)!@$#,.H LRUDOWDVNVWKDWDVVHVVQHXURJHQHVLVVSHFL¿FIXQFWLRQV" :HXVHDPRGL¿FDWLRQRIWKHFODVVLF0RUULVZDWHUPD]H +#,+!,11(;'!+#$!,),13'&'!(*!+#$!'+0,+$4&$'!5'$-!@3!+#$! %&/$!+(!),.&4,+$!+(!+#$!#&--$)!21,+*(0%6!"#$0$@3!;$!/,)! DVNKRZQHZQHXURQVPLJKWLQFUHDVHFRJQLWLYHÀH[LELOLW\ -50&)4!+#$!,/?5&'&+&()!,)-!0$.$0',1!2$0&(-!(*!+#$!+,'C6! F0$!+#$!0$'51+'!(*!+#$!+;(!4,&)H(*H*5)/+&()!2,0,-&4%'! FRPSOHPHQWDU\WRWKHORVVRIIXQFWLRQH[SHULPHQWV" S0(%!+#$!@$#,.&(0,1!/()'$?5$)/$'!(*!@(+#!2('&+&.$!,)-! QHJDWLYHUHJXODWLRQRIDGXOWQHXURJHQHVLVD¿UVWV\QWKHVLV /,)!@$!,++$%2+$-!(*!;#,+!+#$!)$;!)$50()'!,0$!4((-!*(06!
2QHNH\FRQVHTXHQFHRIWKH¿QGLQJVLVWKDW³UHJXODWLRQ´ @3!,/+&.&+3!,)-!h*5)/+&()i!(*!+#$!)$;!)$50()'!#,.$!+(!@$! 0$4,0-$-!,'!/())$/+$-6!
+,-.,)%/0%12*3" E$50('/&$)/$!=)'+&+5+$>!R)&.$0'&+3!(*!U,1&*(0)&,!,+ :$0C$1$3>!7$2,0+%$)+!(*!9'3/#(1(43!j!G$1$)!O&11' E$50('/&$)/$!=)'&+&+5+$ '@5)4$g@$0C$1$36$-5 45,$&'9":"+%;!(0!0$1,+&(),1!&)+$40,+&()6!=!;&11! +#$)!-&'/5''!+#$!/#,)4$'!&)!@0,&)!'+05/+50$!,)-!*5)/+&()! +#,+!'522(0+!0$,'()&)4!-$.$1(2%$)+!(.$0!/#&1-#((-!,)-! ,-(1$'/$)/$6!S&),113>!=!;&11!20$'$)+!$.&-$)/$!*(0!&%20(.$-! 0$,'()&)4!,@&1&+3!,*+$0!&)+$)'&.$!+0,&)&)4>!@(+#!&)!/#&1-0$)! ,)-!&)!/(11$4$!'+5-$)+'6
14%5)6"7% O$&11!U(0)$11!8$-&/,1!U(11$4$! Q,/C1$0!=)'+&+5+$!(*!7$.$1(2%$)+,1!9'3/#(@&(1(43 @k/MNNMg%$-6/(0)$116$-5 ?%&+$&",5'?"75%@"0,:$%5,+'10,&>"# 975$&>'-0"'G5,&#$-$%&'(&-%',&8'H7-'%3'=8%+"#."&." F-(1$'/$)/$!&'!,!-$.$1(2%$)+,1!2$0&(-!/#,0,/+$0&I$-! @3!'5@(2+&%,1!-$/&'&()'!,)-!,/+&()'6!"#$!+0,-&+&(),1! $B21,),+&()!(*!,-(1$'/$)+!@$#,.&(0!#,'!@$$)!'544$'+$-! +(!@$!-5$!+(!+#$!20(+0,/+$-!-$.$1(2%$)+!(*!+#$!20$*0()+,1!
/(0+$B6!d$+>!+#&'!$B21,),+&()!*,&1'!+(!,//(5)+!*(0!-&**$0$)/H $'!@$+;$$)!/#&1-0$)!,)-!,-(1$'/$)+'>!()13!,-(1$'/$)+'! 0$1,+&.$!+(!,-51+'6!O$!20(.&-$!,!%(-$1!+#,+!+,C$'!&)+(! /()'&-$0,+&()!+#$!-$.$1(2%$)+!(*!+#$!20$*0()+,1!/(0+$B! +(4$+#$0!;&+#!'5@/(0+&/,1!1&%@&/!0$4&()'!l$646>!)5/1$5'! ,//5%@$)'!j!,%34-,1,m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l&%@,1,)/$!%(-$1m6!"#&'!-$.$1(2%$)+,1! 2,++$0)!%,3!@$!$B,/$0@,+$-!&)!+#('$!,-(1$'/$)+'!;&+#! 4$)$+&/!(0!$).&0()%$)+,113!@,'$-!20$-&'2('&+&()'!+#,+! &)/0$,'$!+#$&0!0&'C!*(0!'5@(2+&%,1!0$451,+&()!(*!@$#,.&(06
89)%:;"* O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3 X&*$'2,)!U(4)&+&.$!E$50('/&$)/$!20(40,%! =)'+&+5+$!(*!!%$%(03! ,//50,/3!&)/0$,'$-!;&+#!,4$6!"#$'$!,4$H0$1,+$-!&)/0$,'$'! &)!%$%(03!,//50,/3!;$0$!2,0+&/51,013!0(@5'+!*(0!%$%(03!
+#,+!;,'!0&/#!&)!-$+,&1'>!,'!,''$''$-!@(+#!@3!'5@k$/+&.$! ,)-!(@k$/+&.$!%$,'50$'!(*!%$%(03!?5,1&+36!=)!,11!'+5-&$'>! @0,&)!,/+&.,+&()'!,''(/&,+$-!;&+#!%$%(03!;$0$!*(5)-!&)! 8"X!,)-!9SU!,/0(''!,11!2,0+&/&2,)+'6!F/+&.,+&()'!,''(/&H ,+$-!;&+#!$)/(-&)4!,)-!0$+0&$.,1!(*!%$%(0&$'!+#,+!;$0$! ULFKLQFRQWH[WXDOGHWDLOVLQFUHDVHGZLWKDJHLQVSHFL¿F 9SU>!@5+!)(+!&)!8"X>!0$4&()'6!8$%(03H0$1,+$-!,/+&.,+&()'! &)!1,+$0,1!2,0&$+,1!/(0+$B!-50&)4!$)/(-&)4!,)-!0$+0&$.,1! ,1'(!&)/0$,'$-!;&+#!,4$6!"#$'$!0$'51+'!'544$'+!+#,+!0$H 4&()'!&)!+#$!9SU!,)-!2,0&$+,1!/(0+$B!+#,+!,0$!&%2(0+,)+!*(0! -$/1,0,+&.$!%$%(03!20(/$''$'!#,.$!20(+0,/+$-!-$.$1(2H %$)+,1!+0,k$/+(036!7$.$1(2%$)+,1!$**$/+'!&)!8"X!0$4&()'! ,0$!'5@+1$!,)-!,22$,0!*(0!%(0$!-$%,)-&)4!%$%(03!+,'C'! (0!%$%(0&I,+&()!(*!%(0$!/(%21$B!%,+$0&,1'6
1#,3, P()H8$11$H9,0C!KK>!MNK[b!G,%@504 @0&4&++$60($-$0g5)&H#,%@5046-$ *"5.";-7,+',&8'1%>&$-$:"'9":"+%;!8$00&11!9,1%$0!QC&11%,)!=)'+&+5+$! ,)-!7$2,0+%$)+!(*!9$-&,+0&/' %(0&,#g;,3)$6$-5 !;,-$,+',&8'G"&$-$%&) $JLQJ5HODWHGDQG*HQHUDO,QÀXHQFHV "#$0$!,0$!%,0C$-!,4$H0$1,+$-!1(''$'!(*!@(+#!20$H!,)-! 2('+H'3),2+&/!%,0C$0'!(*!-(2,%&)$04&/!)$50(+0,)'H %&''&()6!`,01&$0!;(0C!&)-&/,+$-!+#,+!'5/#!1(''$'!,0$! SRZHUIXOPHGLDWRUVRIDJHUHODWHGFRJQLWLYHGH¿FLWV l$646>!$B$/5+&.$!*5)/+&()'>!'2$$->!;(0C&)4!,)-!$2&'(-&/! %$%(03m6!=!;&11!0$.&$;!/500$)+!;(0C!()!+#&'!+#$%$! *(/5'&)4!()!l,m!+#$!0$1,+&()'#&2!@$+;$$)!-(2,%&)$! l7Fm!,)-!:JX7!,/+&.&+3!-50&)4!;(0C&)4!%$%(03n!l@m! 2#,0%,/(1(4&/,1!'&%51,+&()!(*!/(4)&+&.$!,4&)4!@3!%$,)'! (*!,!7F!,)+,4()&'+n!l/m!0$1$,'$!(*!7F!-50&)4!/(4)&+&.$! 2$0*(0%,)/$n!l-m!+#$!1&)C'!,%()4!-&**$0$)+!-(2,%&)$04&/! 2,+#;,3'n!,)-!l$m!+#$!0(1$!(*!7F!&)!/(4)&+&.$!21,'+&/&+36 8);$&>',&8'$-# 0RGL¿FDWLRQE\9DVFXODUDQG*HQHWLF5LVN)DFWRUV =)!.&.(!)$50(&%,4&)4!'+5-&$'!(*!#$,1+#3!,-51+'!0$.$,1! -&**$0$)+&,1!'#0&)C,4$!(*!+#$!@0,&)!2,0$)/#3%,!,)-! $B2,)'&()!(*!+#$!.$)+0&/51,0!'3'+$%>!;&+#!+#$!+$0+&,03!
,''(/&,+&()!l20$*0()+,1!,)-!2,0&$+,1m!/(0+&/$'>!+#$! )$('+0&,+5%>!,)-!+#$!/$0$@$115%!'#(;&)4!+#$!40$,+$'+! 0,+$!(*!'#0&)C,4$>!,)-!;#&+$!%,++$0!$.&-$)/&)4!,!#&4#13! )()1&)$,0!1&*$H'2,)!+0,k$/+(03!(*!.(15%$!/#,)4$6!"#$! %$/#,)&'%'!(*!+#$'$!/#,)4$'!,0$!5)/1$,0!@5+!+#$3! XQGRXEWHGO\UHÀHFWPXOWLSOHSK\VLRORJLFDODQGSDWKRORJLH /,1!20(/$''$'!+#,+!&)/0$,'$!,)-!-$/0$,'$!@0,&)!.(15%$6! 6XFKLQÀXHQFHVLQFOXGHDSRSWRVLVGHP\HOLQDWLRQ 41&('&'>!,)-!-$!)(.(!)$50(H!,)-!%3$1(4$)$'&'6!=)!,--&H WLRQYDVFXODUULVNH[HPSOL¿HGE\HVVHQWLDOK\SHUWHQVLRQ $B,/$0@,+$'!0$4&(),1!@0,&)!'#0&)C,4$!,)-!20(1&*$0,+&()! (*!;#&+$!%,++$0!-,%,4$!&)!'2&+$!(*!0$1,+&.$13!'5//$''H *51!/()+0(1!@3!%$-&/,+&()6!!;#&+$!%,++$0!1$'&()'>!,)-!#&22(/,%2,1! YROXPH"'RHVLQFUHDVHGIURQWDODFWLYDWLRQRFFXULQ
0$1,+&()!+(!+#$'$!)$50,1!&)'51+'!,'!+#$!'/,**(1-&)4!%(-$1! SUHGLFWV":HKDYHFROOHFWHGPXOWLSOHPHDVXUHVRI ,4$H0$1,+$-!-$40,-,+&()!()!,!1,04$>!#$,1+#3!1&*$H'2,)! ',%21$!&)/15-&)4!%$,'50$'!(*!,%31(&-!-$2('&+&()>! ;#&+$!%,++$0!#32$0&)+$)'&+&$'>!#&22(/,%2,1!,)-!*0()+,1! .(15%$6!O$!20$'$)+!$.&-$)/$!(5+1&)&)4!+#$!0$1,+&()'#&2! (*!+#$'$!%$,'50$'!+(!*5)/+&(),1!@0,&)!,/+&.&+3!,)-!+(! /(4)&+&()>!,--0$''&)4!;#,+!*,/+(0'!%('+!,**$/+!)$50,1! ,/+&.&+3!,)-!/(4)&+&.$!*5)/+&()6
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lK\]Ym!)$50,1!)(&'$!#32(+#$'&'!,)-!:,1+$'A! lK\Ycm!-$.$1(2%$)+,1!0$'$0.$!/()/$2+!(*!,4&)46! 8(-$1&)4!,4$H0$1,+$-!-$/1&)$!&)!-(2,%&)$!%(-51,+&()! @3!'+(/#,'+&/,113!,++$)5,+&)4!+#$!4,&)!/()+0(1!(*!)$50,1! QHWZRUNVUHVXOWVLQJUHDWHUUDQGRPSURFHVVLQJÀXFWXDH +&()>!'1(;$0!1$,0)&)4!,)-!%(0$!1&%&+$-!21,'+&/&+36!"#$'$! %(-$1H@,'$-!20$-&/+&()'!/,)>!&)!2,0+>!@$!'522(0+$-!@3! 0$/$)+!0$'51+'!'#(;&)4!$**$/+'!(*!-(2,%&)$!0$1$.,)+! JHQHVRQSURFHVVLQJÀXFWXDWLRQOHDUQLQJDQGPHPRU\ 21,'+&/&+36!
5-)2$,)%J9"-DE"#I="@)3" V,/(@'!U$)+$0!()!X&*$1()4!X$,0)&)4> E$50('/&$)/$!,)-!G5%,)!9$0*(0%,)/$>! V,/(@'!R)&.$0'&+3>!:0$%$)>!&$-$:"'*+,#-$.$-/'$&'H+8"5'=87+-#) G0"'M33".-'%3'*0/#$.,+'=.-$:$-/'%&'45,$&'E7&.-$%&$&> "#$!&%2(0+,)/$!(*!2#3'&/,1!,/+&.&+3!*(0!&%20(.$%$)+! ,)-!20$'$0.,+&()!(*!/(4)&+&.$!,@&1&+&$'!&)!(1-!,4$!#,'! 0$2$,+$-13!@$$)!$B,%&)$-6!=+!&'!5)/1$,0>!#(;$.$0>! ZKHWKHUGLIIHUHQWGLPHQVLRQVRI¿WQHVVLHSK\VLFDO DQGPRWRU¿WQHVVDUHGLIIHUHQWLDOO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK /(4)&+&.$!2$0*(0%,)/$!,)-!@0,&)!,/+&.,+&()!2,++$0)'6! S50+#$0%(0$>!'+5-&$'!+#,+!&).$'+&4,+$!+#$!$**$/+'!(*! -&**$0$)+!+32$'!(*!&)+$0.$)+&()'!,)-!1()4$0H+$0%!$**$/+'! ,0$!%&''&)46!:$'&-$'!+#&'>!&+!&'!;$11!C)(;)!+#,+!4$)$+&/! SUHGLVSRVLWLRQVPLJKWLQÀXHQFHFRJQLWLYHSHUIRUPDQFH 2,0+&/51,013!&)!(1-$0!,-51+'6!"#5'>!;$!lKm!,),13I$-!+#$! 0$1,+&()'#&2!@$+;$$)!(1-$0!,-51+'A!%(+(0!,)-!2#3'&/,1! ¿WQHVVDQGWKHLUSHUIRUPDQFHLQFRJQLWLYHIXQFWLRQLQJ lMm!O$!2$0*(0%$-!,!KMH%()+#!&)+$0.$)+&()!'+5-3!+(! &).$'+&4,+$!+#$!$**$/+'!(*!/,0-&(.,'/51,0!,)-!/((0-&),H +&()!+0,&)&)4!l/()+0(1!40(52Z!0$1,B,+&()!,)-!'+0$+/#&)4m! ()!/(4)&+&()!&)!(1-$0!,-51+'6!lLm!O$!,),13I$-!+#$!$**$/+! (*!UJ8"!2(13%(02#&'%!()!+#$!0$1,+&()'#&2!@$+;$$)! ¿WQHVVDQGFRJQLWLRQ5HVXOWVUHYHDOHG WKDWQRW RQO\SK\VLFDO¿WQHVVEXWDOVRPRWRU¿WQHVVVKRZHG ,!'+0()4!,''(/&,+&()!;&+#!/(4)&+&.$!*5)/+&()&)46!S5)/H +&(),1!@0,&)!&%,4&)4!-,+,!0$.$,1$-!+#,+!2#3'&/,1!,)-! PRWRU¿WQHVVZHUHGLIIHUHQWLDOO\UHODWHGWRFRJQLWLYH 20(/$''$'6!lMm!";$1.$!%()+#'!(*!/,0-&(.,'/51,0!(0!/(H (0-&),+&()!+0,&)&)4!&%20(.$-!$B$/5+&.$!*5)/+&()&)4!@5+! ;&+#!-&**$0$)+&,1!$**$/+'!()!'2$$-!,)-!,//50,/36!=)!2,0H ,11$1>!)$50(2#3'&(1(4&/,1!0$'51+'!,1'(!0$.$,1$-!-&**$0$)+! /#,)4$'!l&)/0$,'$'!,)-!0$-5/+&()'m!&)!@0,&)!,/+&.&+3!*(0! @(+#!&)+$0.$)+&()'!&)!*0()+,1>!2,0&$+,1>!,)-!'$)'(0&%(+(0! /(0+&/,1!,0$,'6!F)-!lLm!#&$0,0/#&/,1!0$40$''&()!,),13'$'! UHYHDOHGDSRVLWLYHLQÀXHQFHRIPRWRUDQGSK\VLFDO ¿WQHVVDQGRIWKHLQWHUDFWLRQEHWZHHQPRWRUSK\VLFDO
¿WQHVVDQG&207JHQRW\SHRQH[HFXWLYHIXQFWLRQLQJ "#&'!0$1,+&()'#&2!;,'!2,0+&/51,013!'+0()4!*(0!+#$!.,1_.,1! /,00&$0'6!J50!-,+,!'544$'+!+#,+!@$'&-$'!/,0-&(.,'/51,0! +0,&)&)4!,1'(!(+#$0!+32$'!(*!2#3'&/,1!,/+&.&+3!&%20(.$! /(4)&+&()!(*!(1-$0!,-51+'6!"#$!%$/#,)&'%'>!#(;$.$0>! +#,+!5)-$01&$!+#$!2$0*(0%,)/$!/#,)4$'!'$$%!+(!-&**$0! -$2$)-&)4!()!+#$!&)+$0.$)+&()!,)-!%&4#+!@$!0$1,+$-!+(! 4$)$+&/!2(13%(02#&'%'6
193$)*%G#)3)*6E, XD`E>!7a2,0+$%$)+!-$'!E$50('/&$)/$'!U1&)&?5$'> UGRP>!R)&.$0'&+a!-$!X,5',))$>!X,5',))$> Q;&+I$01,)->!,)-!8,B!91,)/C!=)'+&+5+$!*(0!U(4)&+&.$ E$50('/&$)/$>!X$&2I&4>!!`54$)$>!JD )$.&11$g5(0$4()6$-5 M2;"5$"&-$,+P'K"&"-$.',&8'M;$>"&"-$.'M33".-#'%& B7!$.$)!;&+#&)!,!-(%,&)!(*!20(H FHVVLQJ$WKLUGµSODVWLFLW\SUR¿OH¶LVGHPRQVWUDWHGE\ +#('$!)$50,1!'3'+$%'!+#,+!0$%,&)!/,2,@1$!(*!/#,)4$!@3! $B2$0&$)/$!+#0(54#(5+!1&*$6!!O$!#,.$!,1'(!(@'$0.$-!+#$! +;(!'&-$'!(*!21,'+&/&+3!&)!'$.$0,1!-(%,&)'!(*!20(/$''H LQJ LHV\VWHPVWKDWDUHPRVWPRGL¿DEOH LHGLVSOD\ %(0$!)$50(21,'+&/&+3m!-&'21,3!@(+#!%(0$!$)#,)/$%$)+'! &)!+#$!-$,*!,)-!@1&)-!,)-!40$,+$0!.51)$0,@&1&+3!&)!+#('$! ;&+#!(0!,+!0&'C!*(0!-$.$1(2%$)+,1!-&'(0-$0'6!$.,+'1%&#-5,$&-#'%&'*+,#-$.$-/ 90$),+,1!$B2('50$!+(!-054'!(*!,@5'$!(0!$).&0()%$)+,1! +(B&/,)+'!/,)!20(*(5)-13!,**$/+!)$50(/(4)&+&.$!*5)/+&()6!F! /(%%()!*$,+50$!(*!'5/#!+$0,+(4$)&/!(5+/(%$!,22$,0'!+(! @$!,1+$0$-!@$#,.&(0,1!,)-!)$50,1!21,'+&/&+3!&)!0$'2()'$!+(! 2('+),+,1!$).&0()%$)+,1!'+&%51&!(0!$.$)+'6!"#$!)$50(@$H #,.&(0,1!+$0,+(1(43!(*!S$+,1!F1/(#(1!Q2$/+05%!7&'(0-$0! lSFQ7m!&)!/#&1-0$)>!,-(1$'/$)+'!,)-!3(5)4!,-51+'>! ,)-!+#$!$**$/+'!(*!2$0&),+,1!,1/(#(1!$B2('50$!&)!,)&%,1! %(-$1'>!&115'+0,+$'!+#$!2(+$)+&,1!.,15$!(*!,!%51+&H-&%$)H '&(),1!-$.$1(2%$)+,1!2$0'2$/+&.$!()!21,'+&/&+36!!Q5/#!,! 2$0'2$/+&.$!/,)!,&-!(50!5)-$0'+,)-&)4!(*!+#$!.,0&,@&1&+3! &)!+#$!@$#,.&(0,1!$B20$''&()!(*!SFQ7'>!)$50,1!%$/#,H )&'%'>!,)-!0$'2()'$!+(!$).&0()%$)+H@,'$-!&)+$0.$)H +&()'6!!"#$!1&*$H1()4!/()'$?5$)/$'!(*!&%2,&0$-!)$50(),1! SODVWLFLW\DIWHUSUHQDWDOLQVXOWDUHQRWRIWHQVSHFL¿FDOO\ /()'&-$0$-!&)!,!1&*$H'2,)!-$.$1(2%$)+!/()+$B+>!-$'2&+$! ,!4$)$0,1>!&%21&/&+!,220$/&,+&()!*(0!,)!&)/0$,'$-!0&'C!*(0! +#$!$%$04$)/$!(*!h'$/()-,03!-&',@&1&+&$'i!,'!$B2('$-! /#&1-0$)!40(;6!!90$),+,1!,1/(#(1!$B2('50$!,22$,0'!+(! /()'+0,&)!)$50(@$#,.&(0,1!21,'+&/&+3!,'!$.&-$)/$-!@3!Km! LPSDLUHGOHDUQLQJPHPRU\DQGRWKHUVSHFL¿FFRJQLWLYH *5)/+&()'n!Mm!,1+$0$-!)$50,1!,)-!@$#,.&(0,1!0$'2()'$'! +(!2#,0%,/(1(4&/,1!/#,11$)4$'n!Lm!1&%&+$-!)$50(/#$%&H /,1!,)-_(0!)$50(,),+(%&/,1!21,'+&/&+3n![m!'#&*+'!&)!+&%&)4! ,)-!-$2+#!(*!%,+50,+&(),1!+0,)'&+&()'n!,)-!]m!-&**$0$)+&,1! 0$'2()'$'!+(!$).&0()%$)+,1!$)0&/#%$)+6!!E$.$0+#$1$''>! VXI¿FLHQWQHXURFRJQLWLYHSODVWLFLW\DSSHDUVWRUHPDLQDIWHU
0&'CH1$.$1!20$),+,1!,1/(#(1!$B2('50$!+(!'522(0+!2('&+&.$! 0$'2()'$'!+(!+,04$+$-!+0$,+%$)+'!@3!$B2('$-!,)&%,1'! ,)->!;$!#32(+#$'&I$>!/#&1-0$)!,'!;$116!!F1+$0$-!)$50(@$H #,.&(0,1!21,'+&/&+3!&%21&$'!%30&,-!2(''&@1$!%$/#,)&'%'>! LQFOXGLQJHSLJHQHWLFPRGL¿FDWLRQDQGVXJJHVWVVSHFL¿F ,4$H,220(20&,+$!'+0,+$4&$'!*(0!&)+$0.$)+&()!;&+#!2$(21$!(*! ,11!,4$'!;&+#!SFQ76 L""%B""%+@,*3 8,B!91,)/C!=)'+&+5+$!*(0!G5%,)!7$.$1(2%$)+ ,)-!G5%@(1-+!R)&.$0'&+3>!:$01&)>!!,4$H 0$1,+$-!-$/1&)$!&)!%$%(03!%()&+(0&)4>!&)!&)+$0,/+&()! ZLWKELQGLQJGH¿FLWVFRQWULEXWHWRDJHGLIIHUHQFHVLQ *,1'$!%$%(03!*(0!#&4#13!*,%&1&,0!$.$)+'6!=!;&11!-&'/5''!
WKHH[WHQWWRZKLFKWKHVH¿QGLQJVVXSSRUWWKHWZR /(%2()$)+!*0,%$;(0C>!,)-!20$'$)+!&-$,'!*(0!*5+50$! 0$'$,0/#!+#,+!,&%'!+(!$15/&-,+$!%$/#,)&'%'!(*!1&*$'2,)! -&**$0$)/$'!&)!$2&'(-&/!%$%(036!
G,)*"%5@23)*, 7$2,0+%$)+!(*!E$50(1(43>!O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3 -/#54,)&g2$+6;,3)$6$-5 D%+"'%3'!"5%-%&$&'$&'!/&,;-$.'*+,#-$.$-/) D"+":,&."'-%'G5",-!/#,)4$'!&)!EFF!,0$! '$)'&+&.$!+(!%$+,@(1&/!,)-!*5)/+&(),1!,'2$/+'!(*!)$50,1! DQGJOLDWLVVXHDQGDUHXQOLNHO\WRUHÀHFWFKDQJHVLQPLH /0(.,'/51,+50$6!"0,&)&)4H&)-5/$-!/#,)4$'!&)!EFF!;$0$! ,@'$)+!&)!/,00&$0'!(*!+#$!8$+!'5@'+&+5+&()!&)!+#$!:0,&)H 7$0&.$-!E$50(+0(2#&/!S,/+(0!l:7ESm!4$)$>!;#&/#!&'! C)(;)!+(!0$-5/$!,/+&.&+3H-$2$)-$)+!'$/0$+&()!(*!:7ES6! F%()4!:7ES!P,1!#(%(I34(+$'>!&)/0$,'$'!&)!EFF!;$0$! '+0()413!0$1,+$-!+(!+#$!-$40$$!(*!20,/+&/$H0$1,+$-!&%H 20(.$%$)+!&)!),.&4,+&()!2$0*(0%,)/$>!,)-!)(0%,1&I$-! +(!20$+0,&)&)4!1$.$1'!*(50!%()+#'!,*+$0!+#$!1,'+!+0,&)&)4! '$''&()6!=!/()/15-$!+#,+!/#,)4$'!&)!-$%,)-'!()!'2,+&,1!
),.&4,+&()!/,)!,1+$0!/(0+&/,1!+#&/C)$''>!#&22(/,%2,1!.(1H XPHDQGKLSSRFDPSDO1$$FRQFHQWUDWLRQVFRQ¿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lUm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¿QGLQJIURPWKHVWXG\ZDV +#,+!#&4#$0!U!1$.$1'!;$0$!,''(/&,+$-!;&+#!,)!&)/0$,'$! LQWKHUDWHRIGHFOLQHLQYHUEDOPHPRU\7KLV¿QGLQJZDV UREXVWZLWKUHVSHFWWRFRQWUROOLQJIRUWKHLQÀXHQFHRI SRVVLEOHFRQIRXQGLQJYDULDEOHV7KLVDQGRWKHU¿QGLQJV
*0(%!+#$!'+5-3!;&11!@$!-&'/5''$-!&)!+#$!/()+$B+!(*!,!U!,'! DVLJQL¿FDQWPRGL¿HURIFRJQLWLYHDQGQHXUDOFKDQJHVLQ #5%,)!,4&)46!
49@*%B0%N99$)#$ 7$2,0+%$)+!(*!9'3/#(1(43 O,3)$!Q+,+$!R)&.$0'&+3 k(#)6;((-,0-g;,3)$6$-5 T#$&>'E7&.-$%&,+'6,>&"-$.'D"#%&,&." ($&>',#','4$%!;#&1$!*5)/+&(),1! 8D=!l*8D=m!%,3!20(.&-$!,!;&)-(;!&)+(!$,013!/#,)4$'!&)! @0,&)!*5)/+&()!0$'51+&)4!*0(%!+#$!@&(/#$%&/,1!/,'/,-$!,'H '(/&,+$-!;&+#!F76!",'CH,/+&.,+$-!*8D=!'+5-&$'!#,.$!@$$)! '5//$''*51!&)!20$-&/+&)4!/(4)&+&.$!-$/1&)$!&)!#$,1+#3!(1-$0! ,-51+'!5'&)4!+$'+H0$+$'+!&)+$0.,1'!@$+;$$)!KY!%()+#'!,)-! ¿YH\HDUVI05,DVVHVVLQJUHVWLQJVWDWHFRQQHFWLYLW\ ;#&/#!-($'!)(+!0$13!()!+#$!,@&1&+3!+(!2$0*(0%!,!+,'C>!#,'! 2(+$)+&,1!*(0!0$.$,1&)4!,4$H!,)-!-&'$,'$H0$1,+$-!/#,)4$'! &)!@,'&/!*5)/+&(),1!@0,&)!)$+;(0C'>!'5/#!,'!+#$!h7$*,51+!
8(-$!E$+;(0Ci!l78Em6!78E!-&'052+&()!&'!(*+$)!'$$)!&)! /(4)&+&.$!,4&)4>!,)-!-&'$,'$!'+,+$'>!'5/#!,'!F7!,)-!%&1-! /(4)&+&.$!&%2,&0%$)+!l8U=m6!J50!40(52!0$/$)+13!0$2(0+$-! 0$-5/$-!0$4&(),1!*5)/+&(),1!/())$/+&.&+3!&)!8U=!2,+&$)+'! /(%2,0$-!;&+#!#&4#H0&'C!,)-!/()+0(1!$1-$0'6!!D$-5/$-! 0$'+&)4!'+,+$!#&22(/,%2,1H2('+$0&(0!/&)451,+$!*5)/+&(),1! /())$/+&.&+3!%,3!@$!,''(/&,+$-!;&+#!/(4)&+&.$!-$/1&)$!&)! 8U=>!;#&1$!$1$.,+$-!*5)/+&(),1!/())$/+&.&+3!&)!2$0'()'! DWULVNIRU$'PD\UHÀHFWHDUO\SUHFOLQLFDOFRPSHQVDWRU\ /#,)4$'6!!=)!'5%%,03>!@(+#!'8D=!,)-!*8D=!'#(;!20(%H &'$!*(0!20$/1&)&/,1!20$-&/+&()!(*!F7>!,0$!;&-$13!,.,&1,@1$>! %&)&%,113!&).,'&.$>!,)-!/,)!@$!/('+H$**$/+&.$6!!
5,*$7%B26!F))!F0@(0 /15'+&4g5%&/#6$-5 N0"&'!"&$%5#'U&%I'4"--"5'-0,&'!.$"&-$#-#)' (&8$:$87,+'9$33"5"&."#'$&'6"!2,0+&/&2,)+H/#('$)! '+0,+$4&$'!(*+$)!#,-!,!1,04$0!&%2,/+!()!+0,)'*$0H+,'C! 2$0*(0%,)/$6!!"#&'!;,'!$'2$/&,113!+#$!/,'$!*(0!2,0+&/&H 2,)+'!&)!,!$B2$0&%$)+$0H-$'&4),+$-!/()-&+&()!(0&4&),113! -$'&4)$-!+(!'5220$''!-$$2!20(/$''&)4>!'544$'+&)4! +#,+!+#&'!h0$'&'+,)/$!+0,&)&)4i!%,3!#,.$!#,-!2,0+&/51,013!
EHQH¿FLDOHIIHFWV7KHUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWDOORZLQJROGHU ,-51+'!+(!/#(('$!+#$!20(/$''$'!+#$3!$)4,4$!,+!+0,&)&)4! PD\KHOSLPSURYHWKHWUDQVIHURIWUDLQLQJEHQH¿WVWRRWKHU +,'C'!,)-!+(!$.$03-,3!1&*$6
