established social order of the classroom (and the school). ... As a former high school physics teacher, I found the research on ...... Press, Geelong, Victoria.
!"
" # $ )" " * "% "
$ " " %"& ' ' ( ( ' ( "$ "+ !" " $ ( (
"$ " "& ! "& " "$" " $ ( "& !( + & ( " ( " + + * " ( "% " ( '+ $ && " " " , ( ( "- $ . )("&'" & " " % )" $ ( "$" " $ ( ( "$ / %" %" "* " ( " (+ $ & ( " ( ' " "& !+% )" $ ( ( ( + " "& "% " $ " " & &" " % )" $ " "% " " + $ & " &" " ) + ) "+ " " " ' (+ "" & "" '(+ ( ( " ( + % " ( ' ( "$ $ & ( " ( (" ' " " * " "$ "* + ) ( ( " ( * ) " ( " ) & "" & " ( '" + $ " " " * & ) " ( % ( % + $ 0 '" !" & ' " $ (" " ( " $ !"" !( "& " ( " " " "-%" "& ) . (( ! "(+ '" $ ( ( '" $ !"+ & " (
+( *
123345
12*65* 272,289
"(' * % ( % "* * " ($ * % "& " " " " & " !( " (""%* ! ( % $ "! * ' 10 "% %!"((*
$% " & ( '+* " " +& " ' $ + * 234:* % :5
; + "$ % % " ) ' % %" &"& " "& * % ( (+ "$ * " ""& ." $( " " $ " ( ( (" - ) ) )" " * + ") $ ( " " ") ' +"& * $ ' " ($ " 1 $ " "$" "& 5 %" %" " $ " ( ( % (' ($$ ( +5 ) & " % " ((+ ( "> " "(" ?)"
$ "&
& ) " " $ "$ , ") " "" $ "% )" $ ((+ " ' ( " ' " & " % )" ' %" "% * # ." $ "& !+ " !(" " * % "$" "" % )" ' & "" (
$
"
" +* "
( + " ."
'" ."& !+ "($
"*
"
$$"
" $ &" ( '" * &"$ * &# $ " " $ ' * $$" * & % " "" " " " $ &" + > ( ",( &" * ( " " ' " " " $ (" ' ) " " "& ( "' " "- " ) += %"& ' ' ( " " & !"("$ ' " %"& ' ' ( "$ "" " " = . ' & ) !"("$ * * !"("$ !"( ) " $ " $ " * " " + $( " ( ' " " = " !( "& ( (" * " %" ((+ " $ " $ "- " ((+, & "& ( "$ $ & (&" " ( 1"" " ") !+ ( . & "" * 23:45 " "$" " $ (" ' "% ( '") ' (+
8
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
:
)
"' "& ((+ "* " " " "" $ " + " + &" ' & "+ " "% ((+ )"((,% "% $ ( " " ) (" "& (+ " '(" " $ %"& ' ' ( "$ $ &" % & & " ( (" "
"
& + ("& +C " " (( " $ ' "" ) ' " " 1( ' &"! !(") " " "&5 C " " * " # + $ &" + " & + (" ( (" " &" "-%( $ "( * %" %" " ! $ % ( % + (" + " ( "
+ * $ " %" %" " " $ &+ "% %" $ %"& ' ' ( "$ &"%" & "% )" $ " " + " " %( + "$" " + "" " " ' (" $ " " " = !"("$ &" $ "& ""- " " $ % )" $ ( + "& ) " % $" ( ( " $ " ' "& " " $$ ( (+ $ " " "= ( (" '" " )" " * " " + )" " " & (+ %% " $ " ( ((+ !( & %" %" " $ (" ' "% ( '" ) $ " " & & (" " & & & ( &" " "% " " " $ "" + ) " " ("& !+ & % ' %" %" " " &" "& " ( ( ( ") " ( " (+ "& !+* & * " " " ' " " & &"
;
I
( " $ & . )("&'"
("% " ( '+ " "& ) " " % "> && " " " , ( ( "- $ & " " "$" " $ ( ( "$ ( ! "& ( '"(+ " ( " + $ 0 '" !" ) " (% ( % + ((" '" "$ & " ( " " $ ( "& !# " ) + " % !(" ) ."+ "(" " $ " " + % (+* % &" % )" $ ( " " ( $ ") . $ &" & ' " ( " $ &" "& * $ . ' !(" "% " " + ' " ( (" & % "* & $ &" ' ) " %% % " " ' " " & &" ' = 123865 " + $ ! " $ "" "" " ! " " ( " " $ "( " $ ' $" "& &" " ( & 23:7D "+* 23:85 " " ( "" !"
3
$
&
( ($ "-%(
&" $ " " " ( . )("&'", " + $ " %" " " ( & "% & * & "" " 1 +* "& ) " ( (
" "& " " % (, (+ ( " " 1 (& ' " " $ " " & % ("'"& . )("&'" $ " ) (& " ( ( + ' "& "- ("& " (' " " * & ( "& " ( " " &* ( " * "& "+)" " & "& " " + 1 * 23:95 " & " $ " ( (+ " & ( "& C " " ) (& & ' " )" " " +* " %" ((+ ! ( * " ("& ! ( "& & ("' &" + 1 !" * 238:5 " $ " '( ! ( "A " " $ ! ( "& " ( (+ "&" " ("$$" $ " % A " " !+ %" %" ' " % 1 )" * 23:85 "
5
2E
#
)
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
" % ' )" "
) (( $
=
"
&
($ 1 !"
' " '(+ %"
") . $ * 238:* % FF5
& . )("&'", " "" * " * " ( " ) ' ' ( "( "! $ $ ""$ ) ' "" !" * * &" ( ' ((+, " "& & * " * && "& ) %" " " ( "" "" % + "" " "& ) * * '" " ' "($, ( "$(" " . )("&'"* & ' " ) '! "((" ( + & ( "% !( + 1 +* 23:75
22
"" % + "" "-% " "& $ ) ( " + ( "$ "+ " (+ &" & * " % " " " " "$ " '"& " $% ' * * & $ " !( ' " "& ) " ' (" % ( &" & ' (( ) ("" $" %( * ( & ' " * $ % % * " %" ((+ (& + ( "& & "& !+ " " $ "A " >125"A ( + %% + ' % % " & ( ' ( (" * " & !+ " % )" $ (% % D & 165 ( ) "" $ 1 !("5 ( ((+,$ "& $ (& "* " "% " "& !" " " " " +& + " "
$
" ' "" % + ") . 1 + 5 ' &" !(" & !# " "$(" " ( " ' '" " %" & (* * " ($ $ &" & A +) A " $ &" ( '+* $ +1 +* 23:75
;
& $ " ( $ " "
" " "A " * " "$ "* " ( ( " % % = " ',%" %" " !" ("% " $ ( "($, & ( ' (& ") "! "& " "& " ' ' & " # "% " " (+ $ (+ " * & % ( % +
I
+ & % ' ( %" %" " "$ ) &% % "& ) " " $ ) !(" &" & !" " ) + "$" " $ ( "& % ( !( + #
$
" '
&+ $ %"& ' ' ( " * !+ "($*
( *
'
'$ ,
)(+ " "& %" %" " " " $ " ( ( " $ " * " %" ((+ " !& " & " " $ " ( . )("&'" ! " "* " & " % " $ " " & &" & ( " ( (" '" " " % %' " " + $ (& " %" " + % + " " $ " " "". % ( % + $ ' 1 * 23:4D & " * 23:2D " * 2332D " *23:45 & ' ( % ( % " 1"'* ( * % < * " " * "! ?@ " " !" " '$ ( ? "% (@$ ") .* & !" ) + )" &" & " (+ ' " $ ") . "% & $ " "$(" "& ( ' '" * &,$ "" 1 &" ! "&
"
"&
(+ "( " &"$ ' " $ (" (+ "( " " $ ") . " "% ( &* " " $ " (+ !# " " "" ( " "* . $$ & " * 23:3* % 22:5
1"'* " " +5* " + $ (& " % ( % + $ " " " ' " K " '(" $ (' " %( +"& ) . % %" * $ (( ) ' (" K1 " * 2332* % 2E5 " (* " + $ (& " ' " !"("$ " & $ "& & + !( " $ " 1"'* (% " ' * ('"! "A * " " $ 5 " + + ) " ( "% 1 "* 5* & " () $ % % ( (' " " ( . '* % " "& ") $ " ( " + ( "% $ " " $ " " "& " "$$ + $ += !"("$ " % (" %" $ "& !+ &" =% . )("&'" "$ $ " ' ) " "& &" "( % ' "' " $ ' &" % " " 1$ * ." %= * 23:85* * " !( " " (( %" (+ 1 "5(" "& " ( (" & &"& " & % ("
2F
" $ ((+ %("&
") ("
" "%
(
(" ) "
" %% " (
"- ,! . '" "
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
' (+ & &" ) '1238F5 (("&* +* % " %
' "$$" " " " ' "# ) + -*
" " > &
# ( '"
'$
"
%" %" " $ " % )" ' " " & "' * (" " ( " "& " " $ % $ ! " " " & &" + &"$ (* (+ $ " & ( ( ( "% "&" " &"( " " $ " ( & &" = (" % (" $
(" ' "% ( &" ( & " "%" ( ' " ( " " " " = (" " " %"
& ' ( " * " ( (+ " )"((, " " "& $ & (% ( % + " $ "(& $ "& & "% " ( '+ $ % $" (% "* " %" ((+ " " "& 1 %%("* 2383* 2339D -* 23:9* 233ED - & " * 23:3D * 23:95 " " ((+,' " "& ( * ) " " & 1 "* " " " $ % ", %" $ "& (" ' !# " " 5# $ " " " 1 "* ' (+ % " !"& (" ' " 5* &" ' "& !" %(" " "& (" '
27
"
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
! )
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
24
+= % " ' (' K " % !(" $ %( ( $ (" & & ( '" +K "$ " " !( ' " " ( !( + & ( !( + 1 ." * 233E* % 69E5 " " &* # $+ ' " ( %" " ." "(" ( ' ( " " " "& " ( & "A " " 1 "* "" & # $ " " " 5 " " &* # $+ ' ( %" " ( " &" ( ' (" " " "& ( "& % %(" 1 "* & & $ 5C " " # $ $ ( " & ( " ( * " + $ & (& " &! ' > "" & $ "& + & ) "" " (" & )"($ " $ " " & &" * " ' ") + " ( %" " )" " * &" % " %%" " " +* " " ( " !(" " $ $$ "* ' &"& ( ") " "($,($" &"%" & " !( + $ " " " '" % %("& (" " & ) .$
C
;
I
"" " !(" " % ! "& (+ "$" " $ (" ' "% ( '" 1 (" ') &" & '5 ) " " &"& '" " " & ( " ( (" ' " " ) ((!" # ."& !+% )" $ ( + " " " "" $ " "( " $% ( " " " "% " " + $ (& " & & ( " "& "% " $ " " & &" & ( & " " = $ " %" $ "% " ( ' ( "$ " % )" $ " " + " &" ) ) + / * "+ " " " ' (+ "" & "" '(+ % !(" & + ( " (+ " &* " !( + " &" ( " ( " (+ "+ ' " C ""&"&* " "$ "* "$" " $ "% " ( ' ( "$ " % )" " " " ' '" " &" & "% " " % " " $ " & ' & &" ' $( " " $ "% " " ( ( + ( ( '+
% ' "$" " "' & ( ! "% " ! " !" = & * & " " ( " $ ( " ' !+ " ' " $ "" $& "% " &" ((+* " " $ " " & &" (& !" " "& !+ &" ( ' ((+, " "& & * " * & "& ) " " ( "" " (+* $ "* " "% " " + $ (& " & & ( &" % " ( ( % " " !" " "& !+ " " ,& "& " " % " & & "& " ! " !# " " $ " & " "% & " % % " $ ( ' " ' " '" + $ " " ( %" " & '
28
) & " "
" &" ( $ " & ") " ( ( & ()"($ " $ " &"
"A
" " " !( + $
"
!"' "(("
(*
C " "& " " $ ( '" +* " " ) ((!" " "& ! " (("(" ) " !( ' " ( " " ) $( & " % " " !"&&"& ( A + % ( (+) "& $ " !""-%" " "& A ," % ( ( + $ % !(" ,% ' & % !(" , ( ' ' &"& " ($") (& $ &" " $ " % " ' ' ( * " "$ "* " &" "( % " $ "(+ %" " &" / ( %" %" "* ' ( "A " " " $ " " ' '" &" & $ $& " 1 +( & C (( * 23395 %" & " ) "% " " A + & "-%( ' &" = " ',%" %" " !+ "-%( ' " ($") (& * " %" ((+ " $""( ' * ( " * ' ( & ) (& ") % (" $ "" " " " % "" $ ( * " %" & ' & ) ((* A ( " " "" + + "( % (" & ( " $ %" ((+ ' $ " ',%" %" " " ' "(+ %" " "A " ( &" (" &" "( % " . (( $ ( "($, "$(" ) ) &" ( " " ($") (& $ " "% " " + " !!"& " $ " & & ( '" + (" " (& " " "& ) &" "( % ' $ (" ' 1 . * 23:25 ""( " + ) " " ((+, "& )"! $ ( ' $ " ) ) &" & " " " !"" %" &"& / "- %("* & (' ( &" & ' $ " ( &" "( % " $ , (&" '" " " % &" %% " $ "$(" ' ((+ " % + " ' & (" ' (" " !"" %"& !+ %( % ! " $ ((!( + $ " & " " + $ " ( . )("&'" (& " ( " "& ) " " & &" "' ' ( " " ( (" '" " * + " ( ' ' &" ( ") ) "-% " " " " " && & (. " ) + $ "& ' ) "" " &" " (" " " '" "$(" "& !+ " + (!"("$
/ % " ( ' ( "$ $ " & ( " ( " "$ "* + + ) ( (" ) "- " " & & ( " " !" "-%" "& (&" " ! &" $ " " "% " ( '+ $ " ) ( B + "' A "
2:
* (& '
(( ! " "" &+ $ " " '"* " " ( "& " "- " ) " " =%"& ' ' " " " !"&&"& $ (+ ) ( ( " & ( '" $ " " " % $" ( ) $ "" " " ( (" '" " " !" "" $ " &" !" "% $ * "! < = 123325 &+ $ " % $" (" ( $ &" " " ' &" ( "& $ & & ( " " '" + " $ "% " " ( ( + " ' " &" " " " ' (+ "% !(" "" ( ' $( " " $ " + $ " " " " & & () " "$$" " " &"%" & " "(+ " & & ("$$ $" !+ %" "
( " ( &" & ) " ""& " " ( " $ " $ ' " "& & " " " $ % )" $ " (!+ & . )("&'" "K1% 6665
"* < ' " &" " " " ( + " " %% " * & " "( " " "* " " "$$" * $ +* + ! " " " = ( (" !"&&"& " & ((" " " % !( + $ (( ! ' " ( " &* " " = & & ( "$ "$$ " % ( ( ((" '" " " & (+ &"$(" "& !+ " !( "& & ( &""&* + ) . %% " ( " 'K % ( & " ! % )" * +* "' " & & ( "$$ (" (
"-%" "-%" " "& " " $ " &" ." "% " ( ' ( "$ ( " &" "* " "$ "* " . !(" &"' "" $ $ ""& $ " " " $( " " $ " ( !( + " " ) "( ' # + $ " & + ( " " " " !# " "" ( ' $( " " $ " "& " ( "* (& ' & * %"" * & % " % & " & '" $ %" %" ' " + $ " " " " & & ( & " ' " ( !(" " ( & (" $ "$ , &"& " " " " ( & ( !( " ( " " $ " ( ( %( $ "% " ( ' ( "$ * "" ) " $ " " ) . (( ! "(+ $ " ( " $ " ( "* " + ' ' ( " $ )" " " %"$ " "% " " " $ " ",& " () + $ . ' & ' " ( * " " !" " "(+ %" " $ !"+ & " ( . (("& " * " " ) ((!" " % )" "& " "' " " " ( %" " & " " " !( "& & "% " $ (+ " " ( ! ( " % $" $ " ' ) ! &" ( ( "" " " % (" " "' ' " &= L " $ ( ' & " ( $ ") . ("' " + ! " " $ " & " ( (" $ " " & (" "
23
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
%
"
*
>23:4* = " % % ( $ " ' "% ( % + $ " = * 0 & + 2336* = " $ &" = "% = * & * / (&!" '* & "&&" " 1"& 5* ' 3 / , * ""& ' $ " (C . % "(& "; " + $ " " * F,:* 2332* %% 73,89 & & # "((+* >2377* 1I ( 2* 65* * ") . / 3 # ( "* >23:6* * -$ & ; " + " * ") . . ( "* >23:7* * -$ & ; " + " * ") . " * >238:* = (& " = &" & ' $ " ( !(" = * * 69,64 ' * >2346* 19 & "& 5* "; " + $ ' " * ' +("* C & " * >23:F* = (( ! " "" > " "( % " # & "= *2 165* 289,283 . * > 238E* = /($ & " " & ( '+ $ " $ "" " % ' "= * . & ' "1"& 5* # . * ! &'"; " + " * ") .
62
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
'
66
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
69
""
(" +( ( "+ " "$ ( " " ; " + $ " ( '+ -;23:8* " 4EE2* (
&
"
6F
