Mattress & Reliability - Old Bed Guy

Mattress & Reliability

10/14/16, 11(45 AM

Mattresses Poor

30 of 73 Models Shown

Sort by:

Fair

Good

Very Good

Excellent

Overall score Ratings & Test Results

Firmness rating

Stabilization

Durability

Larger / Taller back sleeper

Average back sleeper

Petite back sleeper

Larger / Taller side sleeper

Brand & Model / Price

Average side sleeper

Overall score

Petite side sleeper

!

Innerspring Overall score

80

Charles P. Rogers Powercore Estate 5000 2 Recommended

Price: $1500.00

6

Add to Compare

Overall score

79

Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Elite Kelburn 1 Recommended

Price: $1350.00

4

Add to Compare

Overall score

79

Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Trust Cushion 1 Best Buy

Price: $1275.00

2

Add to Compare

Overall score

75

Charles P. Rogers St. Regis Pillowtop Best Buy

Price: $1100.00

6

Add to Compare

http://www.consumerreports.org/products/mattress/ratings-overview/

Page 1 of 5

Mattress & Reliability

Overall score

75

10/14/16, 11(45 AM

Sealy Posturepedic Grant Park Cushion Firm Euro Pillow Top

6

Best Buy

Price: $775.00 Add to Compare

Overall score

75

Sealy Posturepedic Posturepedic Plus Deveraux 1 Recommended

Price: $1050.00

5

Add to Compare

Overall score

74

Ethan Allen EA Signature Firm 1 Recommended

Price: $2000.00

7

Add to Compare

Overall score

73

Stearns & Foster Estate Easingwold Luxury Cushion Firm 1 Recommended

3

Price: $1420.00 Add to Compare

Overall score

72

Beautyrest World Class Bridgewater Recommended

Price: $1550.00

6

Add to Compare

Overall score

71

Beautyrest Black Ava Plush Recommended

Price: $2050.00

4

Add to Compare

Overall score

71

Duxiana Dux 515 2 Recommended

Price: $7595.00

3

Add to Compare

Overall score

Sealy Posturepedic Premier Hybrid Copper Cushion Firm 1

http://www.consumerreports.org/products/mattress/ratings-overview/

Page 2 of 5

Mattress & Reliability

70

10/14/16, 11(45 AM

Price: $1275.00

4

Add to Compare

Overall score

70

The Original Mattress Factory Orthopedic Luxury Firm Price: $540.00

4

Add to Compare

Overall score

70

Beautyrest Black Whitten Luxury Firm Pillowtop Price: $2600.00

2

Add to Compare

Overall score

68

Charles P. Rogers Estate Nano 2 Price: $2400.00 5

Add to Compare

Overall score

68

Beautyrest Recharge Shakespeare Collection Luxury Pillowtop Price: $830.00

3

Add to Compare

Overall score

68

Duxiana DUX 101 2 Price: $4800.00 3

Add to Compare

Overall score

67

Beautyrest Black Hybrid Gladney 1 Price: $2750.00 3

Add to Compare

Overall score

Serta iSeries Vantage 1 Price: $1075.00

http://www.consumerreports.org/products/mattress/ratings-overview/

Page 3 of 5

Mattress & Reliability

10/14/16, 11(45 AM

66

4

Add to Compare

Overall score

66

Saatva Luxury Firm Euro Pillowtop Price: $900.00 3

Add to Compare

Overall score

62

Serta iSeries Profiles Prominence Super Pillow Top 1 Price: $2275.00

2

Add to Compare

Overall score

61

Shifman Handmade Original Price: $3500.00 8

Add to Compare

Overall score

61

Beautyrest Recharge Hartfield Price: $750.00 3

Add to Compare

Overall score

61

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elegant Retreat Pillowtop 1 Price: $1000.00

4

Add to Compare

Overall score

59

Beautyrest Black Katarina Lux-Firm Pillowtop Price: $2350.00

2

Add to Compare

Overall score

Serta iComfort Expertise Super Pillowtop 1

http://www.consumerreports.org/products/mattress/ratings-overview/

Page 4 of 5

Mattress & Reliability

58

10/14/16, 11(45 AM

Price: $1775.00

2

Add to Compare

Overall score

53

Serta iSeries Honoree Hybrid 1 Price: $1775.00 2

Add to Compare

Overall score

53

Hotel Collection Vitagenic Cushion Firm HL 2 Price: $2800.00

2

Add to Compare

Overall score

51

Beautyrest Recharge Messala 1 Price: $1465.00 2

Add to Compare

Overall score

50

Serta Perfect Sleeper Eastport Super Pillowtop 1 Price: $880.00

2

Add to Compare 1Includes

a layer of gel-infused foam. a latex-foam layer. 3Made of foam but not memory foam. 4Firm models are memory foam; medium-firm models have latex foam. 5Includes a layer of microcoils inside the foam. 6Certified Organic 2Includes

http://www.consumerreports.org/products/mattress/ratings-overview/

Page 5 of 5