Portland State University
PDXScholar Community Health Faculty Publications and Presentations
School of Community Health
11-2006
Medical Students’ Assessments of Skill Development in Rural Primary Care Clinics M. L. Hunsaker National Center for Rural Health Professions
M. L. Glasser National Center for Rural Health Professions
K. M. Nielsen National Center for Rural Health Professions
Martin S. Lipsky Portland State University
Let us know how access to this document benefits you. Follow this and additional works at: http://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/commhealth_fac Part of the Medical Education Commons Citation Details Hunsaker, M. L., Glasser, M. L., Neilsen, K. M., & Lipsky, M. S. (2006). Medical students' assessments of skill development in rural primary care clinics. Rural and Remote Health, 6(616).
This Article is brought to you for free and open access. It has been accepted for inclusion in Community Health Faculty Publications and Presentations by an authorized administrator of PDXScholar. For more information, please contact
[email protected].
'
'
)
*
' "
!
""#$
%&
'
""#$
(
! "# &
'
(
+
*
,
'
"'
'
' "
"
'
)) (!
,#
$ !
*
""#
%%
!
-,
* "
)'
' 0
'
'
.
*/ '
" ' '
'
' ( ( 0
'
0
*/
/
'
'
! *
' !
,
' 0
,
' " *
234 6 ' * 3
0
' *
! ' **
'
.
1
5 '
'
* '
' * !
*
!
!
! * *
' " *
! '
! *
* '
/
' '
0
*
'
'
((
" !
7 '
, "
'
,
"'
'
( 0
-
'
'
'
'
' !
'
' * *
8
8 '
'
9
! '
!"
%&&
'
'
'
"
. '
'
(( #
+ 0 *
'
&
# $ (
:
'
' **
* !
9 "
;
/
=
9
/ "
'
!( , ! 9 '
'
*
0
! '
'
! '
'
! '
!
*
"' ' *
'
* '
'0
! 9
' " !
*:
9
*
'
# $@ ! . '
*
9
"
*
!
! ' 9 * B
' *
" 0 ( 0
* '
' * /
! '
' . # $@ A !
,
,
"
( ;
2 DB 5 B
(B4 # $@ '
'
!
'
/
4
. ((
!
'
!
! !
' "
'
"
7
'
*
'
!
! '
' **
!
" "
. " "
**
# $@ A ! ,
# $@
20
0
'
* '"'
' '
9
9
'
#
! '
'
*
'
!!
**
*
'
! 8 ' 0 0
" 0 *
,
*
!
2# $@5 A ! * ' # * '
!
(
'
! *
' $' -
0
'
#
*
'
'
'
((
4
, # = "
!
'
' , ! '
?;
"
"'
!
! 9
' ' 0
.
*
@
''
'
!
' **
"
>
'
'
*
'
*
'"
! '
< *
3< *
=
" 3
' !
!
# $
'
,
'
'
= " *
# $@ !
6
?;
*0
,
" 0 '
-
'
' *
>
' '
!
!
'
'
6 *
C
'
:
2> !
/
' '
! 5
'
' ' " 1 8
*
'
'
9 ' 0
0 **
'
/
0
*
0
,
!
%
'
G ' ! "
6
*
/
!
'
@
*
! '
'
"' '
A
* " ! '
'
'
'
&
' 0
*
* ! '
* ' "
1
0 1
A 1
'
!
!
'
' *
! '
G
'
*
"
# $@ A ! '
*
,
* /
*' " '
/
'
'
! *' '
' ' /
'
* /
.
'5
,
*/
0 '!
/
' 7
!
( 0
' 0 ' '
(33>
"
! '2 **
"
! ' *
'
1
G ' "
' *
,
' "
(( '
*
*' 28 !
' ,
0 '!
(5 !"
%&&
,
:
0
!
*
!
4
H '% ' ? ' % ; ; ' %; ' % 4; 4 % 9 B %' 3 % @ ( % $" % / (( $" % * :! 6 6 2 ( A "' & ' & > !7 ; , ( A # * > # * ' H ? & ; '' 0 4 L/ ' ! B $3 A * ! ( K ! ' " (( $ ( (> A (? , (; -
4
5
( 6 " $ > 3 2 4(5 > 4; 2 445 4> 2( 5 > B 2 B>5 > ? 2 3B5 > ; 2 B?5 > >3 2 335 > ;? 2 BB5 > 3 2 3;5 > ?( 2( (5 > B 2 3?5 > B 2 B?5 > 3( 2 3 5 > ? 2 B5 > >( 2( 5 > >B 2( (5 > ;4 2( 5 > B4 2 445 > 4B 2 4 5 > B 2 4;5 > ?4 2 B;5 > ; 2 3(5 > 2( (5 B 2( 5 B 2( 5 > ( 2 B(5 > ?; 2 3(5 > (? 2 BB5 > 3 2 B45 3 2( 5 > > 2( (5 33 2( (5 B4 2( (5 >( 2 4 5 44 2( 5 > 2( >5 > ; 2( (5 > B 2( 5 B> 2( >5 ( 4> 2( 5 B 2( 5 ; 2 3(5 (3 2( 5 4? 2( (5 ( ; 2( (5 ( ;3 2( (5 ( (? 2( (5 ( (; 2( (5 34 2( (5
56 " $ ? 3 2 ;(5 ? ?; 2 5 > B 2 3(5 ? ;4 2 ;5 ? ? 2 3>5 ? (24 5 ? ? 2 445 ? >B 2 45 ? 2 435 ? ( 2( 5 ? ?( 2 (5 ? >3 2 4 5 ?; 2 5 ? (> 2 ;;5 ? 23 5 ? ( 2 3?5 ? ? 2 B?5 ? ; 2 ;B5 ? ;> 2 ; 5 ? ?4 2 5 ? (> 2 B>5 ? B 2 35 > 4 2( 5 > 4 2( 5 > ?4 2 335 ? 2 45 ? >? 2 35 ? 4 2 B(5 ? (3 2 445 > 43 2 3?5 > 43 2 3 5 > B3 2 335 > 4 2( (5 B 2 445 > 2( 5 ? ; 2( 5 > B> 2( (5 ?; 24 5 > B 2( 5 3 2( >5 > ?> 2( 5 > 23 5 4 2( 5 > ? 2( 5 2( ?5 ;B 2( ;5 ( ? 2( >5 ( ?3 2( ?5 ( > 2( 5
(
'
'
&
4 $
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (( ( ( ( (( ; ( 4 (
!"
%&&
"
# $
1 '
3
+ 23
3 !6 ( : '
> # ' ! ? A ; " C,&A, " %! # ( ( " ! > A ? A ; $ ! 8 4 B / 3 ( 0 (( A . !, ( $9 > ? ; $ 4 0 B ,K& ' 3 A ** " "
(( '
(
(, !
' " ! ' * :A
" !
*' '
"
" !G +A G $'G C,&A,
34
! ' !
* "
0 '! & ' (( ' " 0 '
. '
'
, /
0
/ 0
* # $@ ! 0 *
0 '! &
*' *
'
' 1 '0
, ' "
"
'
6 >
" $ 2 345 3> 2( 5 > ?( 2( (5 > ?? 2( 5 33 2( 5 > ( 2 3B5 ?; 2( >5 > (> 2( (5 > > 2( 5 > (( 2( (5 > B 2( (5 > >? 2( 5 > 2B 5 > ?? 2( (5 > ( 2( (5 > ;; 2( 5 > 2( (5 > ; 2( (5 4? 2( >5 > >( 2( 5 > 3 2 335 > (3 2( 5 > 4B 2( 5 ? 2B 5 > ;3 2 345 > >; 2( 5 > ? 2( 5 > 2( 5 > 3( 2 345 > 43 2( 5 > 2( 5 > 2( 5 > ;( 2( >5 > > 2( >5
! ' ! '
'
*
(
" *'
* *
"
"
4 $
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
G- 8 ! " * G -CA@ G $#@ ! ! * 9G :A : A 1 & G =,: *
'% E8 '
5-
6 " $ ( 3 2( (5 ( >B 2( (5 2( >5 > 2( >5 ( 4? 2( 5 ( 34 2( 5 ( (; 2( 5 (> 2( 5 4 2( 5 2( 5 (( 2( (5 ( 2( (5 > 2 345 ( 2( (5 >3 2( 5 > 2( (5 ?3 2( (5 ;; 2( >5 ( B 2( >5 >3 2( 5 4 2( 5 ( 3; 2( (5 > 2( >5 4 2( 5 ; 2( 5 (? 2( 5 (( 2( 5 >( 2( (5 > (B 2> ;5 ?4 2( 5 4> 2( >5 4B 2( >5 3 2( 5 B 2( 5
'
*
,
5
)* , & ! ! * ! ! , & !
> # * ? =! ( :
@
4
*
*
*' /
! ! *
D
*'
;D
!
'
! !
8 (( '
'"' */ 9
0 0 " !"
%&&
'
'
&
!
# $ 4
! '
' @
'
1
8
E
"
( 5 !
' ,
!
'
" '
, E . . 2
' E
*
@
'
* '
C
*
'
F
2? >35G ' *
"
2
' 50
'
!
'
!
8
'
'
"
' 0
:
!
"'
'
'
'
8
0
' "
!
*
'
' '
! ' '
'
* '
!
' '
2
" ' 0
'
" ?% =,: 2? >>5 2> ; 4 ,0 / ' '
35G *
'
' *
( !
0
'
'
" ' 0 "
"
" '5
/
' ' 0 2 */
0
'
'
'
(B 3
2( ?35G
>; '
0
" '
# 3 24>5G
2? ?>5G
'
' 0
'
2? ; 5G
!
!
!
* 9 2? ;45G
&
! 0
' **
" ! ( 0
* 9 ' ; 2? ;>5G
"
/ !
/ (5 0
2=,: / ? 35G
.
( 5 !
! 2,
'
6 /
' 0
! * ' *
*
!
34
?
'
/
' !
!
!
'
! A
8
* .2
# $ B
1 '
,
4
5
3
6 5
@ " A " = 6 A ' A
' **
'
' *
C -
,
0
* "
0
'
*' * !
'
'
/ '
!
:
*
*/
' ' ! '
D
33
'0
* D
%
'
4>G * D
'
0
* '
'/ 0 '!
'
*' !
'
'
*
* "
' 9
!
(4
'
/ *
9
'
" , '
! '
"' "' ! "' '
!
'
9
*
*
( 0 !
' **
' ' ''
!
* ' ! C
# $@
!
, ' !
*
# $@ A !
0
7 !
' !
' "
'
" *
0
'
!
"
' "
0
! *
'
'
'0
'
: '
H
*
' 0
0
!
' !
"
"
'
B 5 +
6
0 '! , ! 9
*
' "
'
.
' *
!
' "
' **
*/
' " ' *
0 '!
.
'
*' !
'
D
*
'
,
:
!
''
! *
*
! 0 8
'
'
&
# $@
'
!
! # $@
/ '
' "
' 1
' "
*
'
* *
'
=
!
!"
%&&
/
*
''
'
,
0
'
2
; 5
( 0
' **
0 0
' '
0
/
0
@ '
4> 33 B> ;; (> ( (; ( ( >
' '
/
,
>
(B (3
H
! * ' * !
2
4
*
*/
( 0
3
5
*
9
'
(
? ; ? ; ? 3 ? (> ? > 43 B > >( > > ;3
'
*/
! ' '
'
6
> >> >? > 3 >? > ( 3 >( (3 ( 34 > ;
* *
5
' # $
3
9 3
' 0
0
'
' "
'
*
'
.
* .
"
'
0
9
''
! ' *
'
! 0
/ !
" 0
* 9
'
# $@ A !
' "
0
0 :
0
'
' '
' '
9 ' "'
' !
# $@ A !
0 * "
! ,
' "
!
*
'*
9
'
!
'
'
*
! 9
' " **
* '
7
'
' '
'
'
' ,
/
'
/
'
.
1
'
" "
! ! '*
' ** ' "
'
' !
/ !* '
( 0
' ' ,
* '
0 " *
!"
0 '!
*'
'
!
*/
"
* 0 '!
'
'
' * '
'
0 " ' '
'
"
!!
" '
' !
' 7
*'
'
.
'
' !
"
/
'
0
'
0 " '
" ?
"
!
" *'
'
"
*
!
"
*
' "
4
' ' !
/ ''
'
* "
'
! ' ''
0 " "'
((
'
9
*
'
'
0 "'
"
/
C" 0 ! '
'
* ! * '
*/
! !
0 !
'
! !
(?
9
'
1
! 2*
*
'
0
'
! ' ! !"
%&&
'
'
' '
!
, '
'
"
'' "
' ' "
*/
! "
'
9
!
.
5 :
*/
' '
?
*
' 9
*
' !
.
'
/
' "
!! '
* ! * '
0
!
"
*
*
F
!
' >
!! '
"' "
'
: ' !
'
! '
* !
* ' !
*
' "
*
! !
/ "
* 0
!
'
' * '
'
'
(
*
, *
' '
'
*'
*
*/
*
* *
*
! *
0 "
!
9
'
' " !
* !0 '
* '
9
( 0
'
' 7 " ! !
'
* '
' ' * ! ' !
!
!
'
!
*
' ! *
" " !
' $"
'
&
# $ (
-
; + 0
#- A
'
:
' *
'
' 8
( "
0 '
8
' *
!
'
!
*
! ! * ' 1
*
9
'
9 *
1 9
' '
!
"
!
'
#
.
*/
" '
*
'
*
BB/ 3 0 6
@
' II
" '
!
I
'
*
'
'
'
@
-
3 A
:
-
* *
**
' # : !
" 0
"'
' @
!
= "
'
* H
!
I '
%
'
" '
I
G 89 (
H
=
/
'! '
.
A
$
I
#
/
+ )
+ I
((
'
H#
' **
'
)
(G 9= 8
9
*
?4/ ;
'0
'
'
+ )
-@
'
,
" +,
! *
'
;G 8< >> />?
>G ( ((/( ( (
6
+ 9
3/ (;
!
)
@
*
(4/ (
"
9
!
*
>
-
! A
*
*
# * ,$
# $@
" G8
I-
' **
''
*
(
)
A
@
:
!
!
I "
; ? *
'
#
G
"
'
'
(333G > ? ;;/
B
0
6 0 ' -$
)
+ )
1
8H **
4
0 '! ,
!
+ )
! '
"
0 '! '
'
. *
*
"
'
0
'
! '
(33BG 8%
' "
*
" 1
9
' I@ 8
#
*
*
'
'
)
I
-- @ H
'
.
'
@$ , "
' " '*
*
!
(33>G
*
G >
;/>
> / > (> +
> + 0
#
*
' 8
# - 0
' %
"
* =
!
, ' *
'
'
.
!
- #
= I '
@ H
@
?G
(B(/(B
>G = ?B?/?3(
@
$**
* )
9
! (33?G =
H
3(
A
$ *
!
A ' *
9 @
-
'
' ! '
! - !
?G 8 >
'
'
'
&
* '
4/ 3
!"
%&&
0 ,
' ! *
!
! / (?
? +
'
@ "
# $ ((
(; @
$
-
M ! -
!
'
'
! (
! IA %
'
'
(3 C.
"
,H
!
/ "
'
'
%
.
-
A A '
9@
#
# H
$ H
N
/
'
'
+ !' 0
*
,
A ,
!
+
,I
"
( A
I-
' **
#@ C. *
+ ) >> />>4
*
+ '
#
#
#
I O
! '
/
*
-
! '
/44( + 9
$
II #
/
+ )
3/ (; -
.
' ** '
"
O *
0 . * '
C '
(G 88 4
G 89?
I
'
6 *
'
;3?/;3B
(B
#
(333G
A
G
+ )
'
?G
'
)
33/> 4 (4 H
+ !' 0
-A
G % ( B/(4
' #
+
:
"
.
* "
)
'0 G
'
I
" 0 * !
"
'
'
)
* (33(G
*/ 4 /
4 3
!"
%&&
'
'
&
# $ (
