Minimal Byzantine Storage - UT Computer Science


   


"!#%$'&)(+*',.-/,.0'01!324#"5768,.$:9=?5@!$'AB=DCE-.FG,IH7,J9K24,.LM*N#%!B-:OP#%*'-.,.$ QSR¨š”M› —BœW™b£¤¢8¨M°¨š”M¿©žÃÀ_§”8˜b£©ž/ª"£¯œKÁ ÂK—Y™7—–"˜bB§%£¤Â?”8¨¦œK—Â?§—œW™7—Á”Êâs£¯œG—B¿¯¿¯ªW°‰ÉS”P”8­?—B›£¤œ?”P—œ?œ?Àw¢Mœ?ã?˜b› —ÅK¿¯”ɘb£©™b”M¨§—B˜b£¤—B™b£¯œž¬™bÄK”P¡ ½Û ÀJÏ–"˜b™bW¢M¿ ÉpÄK”8˜b”¦—i¢M¿¯£¯”MœW™¢[—BœKœ?™Â"”8™b”8˜b›£¯œK”pÉpÄK”8œm£©™b¨Sɘb£©™b”M¨¢M›–K¿¯”8™b”ÊWÜ”l¨šÄ?[ÉڙbÄG—B™¡ ½Û À_ÏDÉp£©™bÄmœ?œ%äW¢Mœ?ãK˜b› —BÅK¿¯”lɘb£©™b”M¨ –?˜bY§%£¤Â?”M¨˜b”MÁ K¿¤—B˜+¨š”M› —Bœ%™b£¯¢M¨Ép£©™bÄÖ´ÔPÕ ³¨š”8˜b§Ç”8˜b¨+—BœG™bÄK—B™™bÄ?£¤¨pœ% K›iʼn”8˜Bž:¨š”8˜b§Ç”8˜b¨p£¯¨p›£¯œK£¯› —¿IÊ å

æ"ç¦èGé,.ô0'-.!ô!B$K68#%6@,.="$









  













( ) 3



$

+*





-,

 2

  



/.10

&



%

!

'

54

#"

!

Ü”¢[—¿¯¿
¢Mœ?ãK˜b› —BÅK¿¯”°?Á”Mœ?”8˜b£¯¢







9 /8 $9 3 '8 9 8 9 /8 $3 9 3 '8 9 /8 9

8 $9 8 9

& / 

 )    5 "

 2





+

 #

#



10  



 #





 2

!



#

¡ ½Û À_Ï

½  ?œGœ¨š”8˜b§Ç”@˜l¢8 KœW™

0 2Ô 143 5 ºK¸/6 798I»:,

; 6G¹·Mº >@? 6G¹·M¸M¹6CB%D ? ¹m· ? 7ºB 6G¹·Mº >M? HGÔ21=3 5 ¹ ? DCIKJ.º?¹ , ´ԉÕi³°K˜b”MÁ K¿¤—B˜), 6G¹·M¸M¹6CB%D ? ¹m· ? 7ºB
0'58=%68=GLB="-IH+#?LBLB!H8Hl#DH@ò'ö
 )

 2 

$





 2



" 





4é  7î 

#







$



" 



"



0

#



 2









î7çSé




#"

e

e

e





5 



0

0







0

/ 5 

ZBfbaYVH7!ôÖ#%$K6@,ILH3ñ?ò
ø•*'!D#%ö1=WF"!õ‰! 



0 !

0 

#

5

$

.
   N Q`O N W\UXY j  O2ZMS 

ba a#W\UX[UX[\W [MUXdXUX_ /UTbYW$#2UX[ N %j '&'(*)XOklm[MS,+WMUX[$UX[) . /100,23 (54 )7698 :(*) ^ Y/ZM_ a:ZMe U . /10,02=3 (54$6#b[\[\b~ndXSY/ZMb_ Y %W > ?bYW #2UX[\WGf

h

a SVS

"!;@ G s



CAAC< BEH D (*)F8 : AKACJ3 BED . /'002=3 (5AK4$6 BR< D YZB Y AC(*)IH 8 :(*)FL AKM H O PK([]LN\FM^]_,OQ`$PIaE8b5`dc]e _,fX(*)T_,SU^]^g(_,f VK\7WhB b5)5`5( \i(*_,)TfkSXjm( l < `7b5n,[o,pR\qc][]rCb5\ c_,rTl W )5( (*)8 : (*) . t W\UXY N  ju  &kvCw ACH (*)XOkZMS b)a aWMUX[$UX[MWGf .-h. a SVS

. [MUXdXUX_ /UTbYW$#2UX[ Nyx%z|{ & ACH (*)XORlm[\S+ W\UX[$/UX[) .! < ^ Y/ZM_ ag }} E8 :€">}C? ~ YZ ,Y ) < > ? \=b5`5nb `7\d_,f \7hb5`5b7j . -‚< . Kh. N QF& ZMWMO%:„ƒi… † Ny%N O x WMUXYR Q`ORZMSi> ‡pW\UX[$/UX[\WGf   a SVSˆ

[\UXdXUX_  U`bYW2# UX[ N]‰Šx‹Œ & vCw*(*X) ORlm[\S+ W\UX[$/ UX[) YZYŽ l o,\\7[Q5^ ‘KrKo,`7bdcye _,fXo,fkb‚_,f \7hb5`Fl b5`T\ b `7nZb5`’  !_ l9(*)T“XW BR0”Z2 )5(54 )76Q• (*)•ZMe UXY‚W BE0”Z2 ) (54 )568 : N vCw*(*)XO ; @ _ l|)iL– } ZMe UXY YZY hbm—7_,^y^9cyeZ[]\ib5nb f1c_,f™˜$b5fkc]`7_,fŒ—5bEš } 8 : }X~ ) <  G › 8 :=Z@eUTœT .•a b[žUXW‰ZkZ@_ + UXW\ZMb,+d WR_ YCW BE0,”Z2 )5(54*6 s lmS[kba a J ) Ÿ 0 ‹& lmS[kba a1 ( J¡AC2 L– › &' UXa UgZMU BE3 ) ¢ 2=0 4 J ) Ÿ 0 w ( JAC2 6 lmS[kba a J ) Ÿ 0 &  . .-th. _ l9W BE0,”2 )5(54 J ) Ÿ 0 6Q• (*)TL › Z@eUXY BE3 ) ¢ 2=0 4 J )=Ÿ 0 w7W BE0,”Z2 )5(54 J )=Ÿ 0 6Q• (*)76g8 :W BR0”Z2 )5(54 J ) Ÿ 0 6 .  _ l9(*)TL › ZMe UXY BE3 ) ¢ 2=0 4 )w*(*)768 : N vKw*(*~) O < Y ^Y/ZM_ a£'vd¤$w(*) ¤w ¥¦8 8 ¥§ €U> ? V N]¨ J 8 J L©¥¦ . 8 c]\$BE’K3 n) ¢_,^ 2=p10 b 4 J w*(*) ¤y6k: N vd¤w(*) i¤ OMO Z Y ¡  ­ > ? $ [ « ª , b ª | ¬ « ^ , o o © l R p k f ] c y [ ^ \ b 5 `  n 5 b 5 ` d \  _ , a 7 ` 5 b d b , o X f _ y ¬  .! WMUXYR Ny%x Q z uI®C¯ ‹Œ j  ORZMS™ba aW\UX[$/ UX[\W  . [MUgZM^[\Y N vd¤*w*(*) -¤ O . ;C< °

· ¸º¹5¼»N½¿¾ÁÀ1 



8oD1¼ 3 ¼d±`{Z²`y)|†„:}/Œ uˆ³:Žˆ´dµQ¶rˆVŒ x‰u{ ‡RŠ yg‹‡‰Vˆ~‹Œ:)y‡i’ut,µ@‡i’ygu‚g’#‹Œ˜z4uyPygy|†Vz:u/Œ

4éNêè‰ê•ísê

  2

#

S,.ñ"ò'58! m0'5@!H7!$K68H36@*'!=N&J6@*'58!H@*'="-Iõ ‰ï 3&); LY=?$ ùJüPó]ò'$
È

"

0 

0   0  ' 

+0



0

1Ä dÅÆKÅÇÆ

Ü”Â?”8¨š¢8˜b£¯Å‰”•™bÄK”›˜b”¦Á”Mœ?”8˜7—¿1È% ?˜b ?›










'

¡ ½Û À_Ï–?˜b™bW¢8¿¯¨l£¯œ™bÄK”E®l–?–‰”MœGÂ"£©­
!

!



"

 2







,

 



0

) 





 2

$





%




 2



&

* $,

,

0





#



I GHB3,DFD

øÆ=ö1!Y6@6@!5ò'$


¢

7



H@*'="ò'-IõÞöN!ÖH@!B$K6#%$NõÞþ•#%,/68Hió]=?5 #"/L G$'=Wþ-.!õ‰ñ?ô!B$K68HEó]5@=?ô H@="ô! ?ò!BF?!B$K6@ò
 2



-.!#?Hb6 3 œ 1. h 

 NPN O#  E%$ B3,DFD&  *g ‰"aMh‰R1v\wTw`%R'Z`ba\:9'VvM`WR!pX[rf#"ÃV\:9GX8V[Z;9'`it‰ú•j

VYUWVBRN\_h
>=

3-

¢

2

*

0

. ACBED

CÅÆ !

+

@"



ø•*'!P-.,/F?!B$'!H@H+H7ò'ö68*'!P;¬,IHb68!B$'!58H¦LY=?ôômò'$
0



A

"š$

½ êpì3çPë



$

68*',IHdH@!LY6@,.="$>9¦þ¦!Þ0'58=WF"!Þ-/=Wþ¦!B5öN=?ò'$ 

7  2

#



 2 B & 2





@ACB
NPO > /LOfL,N OQBRGHEI D 
 N  RÝ\:9'VfWh'\:9'VBRN\_Twv8f"\JV/dfÇZ[^WR1v 9GX@`%R1`%hGZ rD`"VXT]\:9úE^ûfWRN\_TIR1V¦aYf%T‰¯h‰X@VYZmfWR%ÖX@V¯Twf#"ÃVv 9'fWRNR1V©Z ¦R1`=¯TIUWVvM`%R "

0





?
B3E GHE BZ  ZBVYR1\"B^ K o

$

@B

gÍrDVYZMZYf ?V

9

\< 9 VZBVBR%%TIR`ba

T.ZS,.$ 

?
B3E GHE B 

"MVÝX@VMf"v 9'V/ "B^ÚX[h‰R
qp`WR'Z[MT ?VYXmf=¯TIUWV X@VMfPn1X8`%\)`vM`:¬hGZMTIR 
ØZBVBX[UÇVBXMZYo3cR9'VBX@VmV8e?T.ZY\lV8eKVMvBh'\wTw`%R'ZaY`WX"X9‰Twv Þ 9 \ ‰9 T.Z¦n1X@`"\J`vM`:•?`VYZR1`%\ ZBf%\_T.Z]aM^ZBfbaYVZBVYrfWR1\wTwvYZYo

"

0

š$‰ó]=?5@ôÖ#"-/-.ð"9N68*',IH5@!#"õ 0'58=%68=GLB="-+H@="ô!B6@,.ô!HPõ‰!LY,Iõ‰!H ="$Ø#FW#%-.ò'!Ö#%óI6@!B5LY=?$ &&'& *
»b ,À /:éH7,/68ò
0

 3  h h œ 1. 

0

¢ ,.$


 


 

   3B3D 

0 !E0'58=WF"!¦-/=Wþ¦!B5ö1="ò'$Nõ'Hó]="5+$'="$‰&šLY=?$#,IHb68!B$'!5E0'58=%68=GLB="-¬#"-.-/=WþEHl68*'! ‰ï 3&š;Ú0'58=%68=GLB="-IH¦6@=ò
 %$





E B3,DFD  0'58=GLB!H8H7,.$'ñ
 t

0



#

  



" 

¢ 0J ( 2=0 *

#

#

 2

 t

t

9 t

 3



#

$



 .

'

%



0

0



,







 h.k = N vK_ l#wZ@(*e) ÷

#





"

*

* %,



*

$

,

$

,

+*

"

,



!

*

,

*

,





&



ï¦!L#%òö1!Yó]="58!õ‰!LB,Iõ‰,.$'ñ3=?$#iFW#%-.ò'!%÷%ø•*'!þ58,/6@!l0'5@="6@=‰LY=?-‰H7ò s!B5MHSó]58="ô $'=uH@òø•*',IHP,IH #%0
$

 2



#

' 2

"

#







& 2 

 2

 2

1  



" 







! )

'





#

 /  $

!





6  E>NPBRGFOQ 3$QOQ O GFE>CBM+$ 
OQ







0 !ÖLY="$NHb685@ò
 2

) / 

h .3

#

 3  h œ' . 

#

þ58,Ã68!H#%58!dH@ò'0'01="5@6@!õÌ#%$Nõ ü,/óiLY=?$ #?õ‰FW#%$K68#"ñ"! =%ó1ô,.$',.ô,/A,.$'ñ¦6@*'!•$Gò'ôöN!5S="ó1H@=%óI6bþ•#%58!l,.ô0'-.!ô!B$K68#%6@,.="$
ŒÃ

2 

#

ºÃ CÃ

#

LB="$ Nñ"ò'5M#W68,/=?$

H@,.AB!Ö="ó^!_#

/ 

Ã

 ‰9S,/68H -.=K#"õ

œ' 3

 2  2



5 5  

à ' ôÖ#%68LM*'!Hu6@*N#W6m="ó  %&

ów#"LY6@=?5=%ó '÷ 

5

h ÷¬CE-/6@*






$

0



"š$ ‰ï23&);p958!#?õ‰!B5MHmôÖ#%,.$K68#%,.$Ø#Ýö'ò#s!B5Ö,.$

1Ä CŌÆKŊÆ



ô!Bô="58ð õ‰ò'58,/$
-



CÅŒÆ "



SèÆë



1

$





!



' 

' 2  2

1Ä CŌÆKŊÆ



$



êé

 





7 & /   

CE-/68*'="ò'ñ?*ö1=%68*Dï¦ðGA#"$K6@,.$'!pów#",.-/ò


  

@B

2





.3

6@*




+



 ! #

"



#

1"

"



R 7ì5Kîbêpç

Ýêpçií

0 !Ö0'58!H@!B$K66bþl=0ô!H8H8#%ñ"! 6@=#%-.-ÆH@!B58F"!58Hi#%$


%



 2

í çiê

"

#

#

#

#

!

¬ë- >ç¦èQ

=

ø•*'!Ö#"ò‰6@*'=?58Hi68*£¤”@˜b¢M”°dÊ l”M£©™b”8˜[°G—œK 3Ê"ܘb£¯ÁÄ%™[ÊS“¦ª"œG—B›£¤¢ ½ ª"¾[—œW™b£¯œK”EÈW KB˜b K› ¨)ª"¨)™b”M›¨MÊSËJœ  ygVˆPu~uXzxo{ ‚†X‡i’u  { ‡\uyP{ „‡ox‰{ „Œ `{//uyXu{ˆ)u*{ *u@Šu{ z„:}/Œ u ‚P‡\u|†‚„{z ”u/‡o— y‚ ° Ç Kœ?”E´"Ê ´W Ê iÊ:®™š™b£©ª%—%°>®3Ê ½ —B˜šÀ ¦[ªW°>—BœGÂ4“PÊ:“•¿¯”M§‰ÊÞ¡"ÄK—B˜b£¯œKÁ֛”M›B˜šª˜bÅ? K¨)™b¿©ª£¯œ4›”M¨š¨b—Á”–K—¨š¨š£¯œKÁd¨)ª?¨)™b”8›¨MÊ wyP{ „‹Œ X…‡i’u  !   "$##‹Œ w|u&%(' °K–G—BÁ”M¨³Y´YÙBäK³MÙW´W°:*³ ))‹E%Ê

ˆ±

F±

©³

ˆ±

ˆ±

Ó%Ê Eʬ®3Ê ½ —B¾M¾M£IÊÚ¡Wª"œK¢7Ä?˜bœ? ?¨ ½ ª"¾[—Bœ%™b£¯œ?”DÈW KB˜b K› ¨)ª?¨)™b”8›¨MÊ4ËJœ yGVˆ)u~uXzxo{ ‚X…‡i’u=‚~x
‡\u~u{‡i’r„ {{w#„‹Œ   ‚~|Š#‚~xow|  {  y)xo{ˆ/x Š2Œ u‚X–z xo‚P‡oy)x\}w#‡\uXzˆ~|pŠCw#‡oxo{ °K–G—BÁ”M¨l´ E )Yä%´ ..%°:³*))DZ%Ê Ù" Ê EÊW®3Ê ½ —¾M¾8£]Ê1®l¢8¢M”M¨š¨¢M¨)™Sž/˜p—B¨)ª?œ?¢@Ä"˜bœ? K¨ ½ ª"¾[—Bœ%™b£¯œ?”¦ÈW KB˜b K› ¨)ª"¨)™b”M›¨MÊ xo‚P‡oyPx\}w#‡\uXz `|ŠCw#‡oxo{  wy){„‹Œ ƒ‹Œ w|u*%   ‚~‚Pwu  °?–G—BÁ”M¨pÙ?³7äWÙ²"° W—Bœ% G—B˜šªD ´ "³Ê EWÊ dÊ«ÄK”¦¿¤—Âm—œG—[§—B£¯¿Ã—BÅK£¯¿¯£©™Jªž ½ ª"¾[—œW™b£¯œK”ÈW ?˜b K› ¨)ª"¨)™b”M›¨MÊ1Ë_œ  ygVˆPu~uXzxo{ ‚#" ‡i’   |Š# ‚Px-w#|  {  yPxo{ ˆ/x ŠCŒ u‚X xo‚P‡oyPx\}w#‡\uXz `|pŠCw#‡oxo{ !   " °K–G—BÁ”M¨l´BÙ )Yä%´ E±W°99ÆH7*
 NPN O `%X3f:‰k¯TIUÇViX@VMf¦n1X8`%\)`vM`:¯ZEhGZMTIR –'4ZBVBX[UÇVBXMZ GaY`WX3f‰'ZBV\]Z `ba4ZBVBX[UÇVBXMZ3fWRKpaY`WXPf:‰
"

0

š$K6@ò',/68,/F?!B-.ð%9Kþ*'!B$
t

œ.



CÃ



+

@B



dÃ

0

+

7*



,

t

œ  .

ø•*'!u-I#"H76l6bþ¦=D-.!BôôÖ#"H¦H@*'=Wþ

" "

6@*N#W6E,.$68*'! LY=?$
















@A B3DFE>DHGHBI J ›E G J ›%i$'! Kò'=?5@ò


õ‰!LY,Iõ‰!H¦=?$#FW#%-.ò'!u#WóI68!B5E58!LB!B,.FG,.$'ñ6@*
Ž!"";"@ "G "s

a SVS,ˆ

M[ UXdXUX_ /UTbYW$#2UX[ N j1&1(*)XORlm[\S+ MW UX[$UX[) . /100,23 (54 )7698 :(*) ^ Y/ZM_ a‹ZMeUF(*)4$6#b[\[\bXn dXS /UX[\W%b ]V^S[\^R+ PS l W\UX[$/UX[\WGf

CAAC< BEH D (*)8 : AKACJ3 BED . /'002=3 (5AC4Q6 BE< D (*)8 : (%L MOQPI8 (*)FSU(VKW B ) ( (*)FSU( <  ACH (*) []\T^«_,`aZb5`dcye _,fX_,^y^_,f'\hb `5\i_,fŒjdl `7b n[o,p \qcy[]rKb \5cQ_,rTl WW\BUXY ) ( (*N ) j8 : u ACH &k(*)vCw ACH (*~) ORZ@S™b)a aWMUX[$ UX[MWGf .=t . h. a SVS,ˆ

. [MUXdXUX_ /UTbYW$#2UX[ Nyxzg{ & ACH (*)XOklm[\S+W\UX[$/UX[) .! < ^ Y/ZM_ a£ } F8?: L }K ~ 8 8 ) I< ?  } YZY _ 5pko,`7p rÁ\ b `7nZb5`5\Te _,nbT\=b5fkc%_,f . -K< . Kh. N QF& ZMWMO%: ƒi… † NyN O x WMUXYR Q`ORZMS™ba aW\UX[$/UX[\W%_ Y W\S+ ULšf   a SVSN

[\UXdXUX_  UTbYW$2# UX[ N]‰Šx‹Œ & vCw(*X) Oklm[\S + W\UX[$/ UX[) YZYŽ lRo,\7\[$7^ ‘‚rKo,`5bdc]e _,fXo,fŒbm_,f'\hb `FlRb5`T\=b5`5nb `$’  !_ l9(*)F“UW BR0”Z2 )5(54 )76Q• (*)•ZMe UXY‚W BE0”Z2 ) (54 )568 : N vCw*(*)XO _ l|)iL– } ZMe UXY YZY hb‚—7_,^y^ŠcyeZ[]\mb5nb f1c%_,f ˜$b f1cy`7_,fŒ—5bEš  ;@ G s ›} 88 ::=}XZ@eJ UF~ œT0 ) < .ta b[žUXW‰J¡ZkACZ@2_ + UXW\› ZMb,+d WR_ YCBEW BE3 0,”Z2 2=)50(54J 6 0 JAC2 lmS[kba a )=Ÿ ‹& lmS)[%ba ak ( L– &1 UXa UgZMU ) ¢ 4 ) Ÿ w ( 6  . t lmS[kba a J )=Ÿ 0 & . -h. _ lŠW BE0”Z2 ) (54 J ) Ÿ 0 6Q• (*)qL › ZMeUXY BE3 )=¢ 2=0 4 J ) Ÿ 0 wW BR0”Z2 )5(54 J ) Ÿ 0 6• (*)56|8 :„W BE0,”2 )5(54 J ) Ÿ 0 6 .  _ l9(*)FL › ZMeUXY BE3 )=¢ 2=0 4 )w7(*)7698 : N vKw*(*X) O < Y ^Y/ZM_ aÇ£'vd¤$w(*) ¤w I‡T8 8 I‡iL XV N]¨ J 8 J L F‡q8 BE3 ) ¢ 2=0­ 4 J w7(*) ¤y6': N vd¤*w*(*) -¤ O\O . Z Y [$ª«b,ªÇ^]oo l©p f1cy[]^|_ 5pko,`7p r¿oI\=b5`5nb `7\d_a,`7b5bio,fX_ ¬]cy\Q’‚n_,^ p1b  .! WMUXYR Nyx Q z uI®C¯ ‹Œ j  ORZMS ba a#W\UX[$/ UX[\W  . [MUgZM^[\Y N vd¤w*(*) -¤ O . ;C< ° 8oD1¼N¼ ™u{CuyG„‹Œ xmVuXzˆ~{Z`² y)|†„:}/Œ u©:³ Žˆ´dµQ(¶ Š yg‹‡‰Vˆ~‹Œ

$>ç5:é  bî Æë





NÀ

ê+ç 

êpçié

\

 4é>O3E>E G J ›%i$'! Kò'=?5@ò






T.Z¯TIUWVBo

0



¢

!LB#"-/3 - ( 68*'! Kò'="58ò'ô =%ópH@!B58F"!B5MHù]$


.

 NPN O   AGF N E>I E>G J   Rc 9'Vmv8`%R !+X[rDf"ÃV*?VBR1VBX@f¯TÃûVDt‰ú¦j4nsX@`%\)`v8`sZBf%\_T.Z‰!¦V[Zf%\)`WrTwvuZBVBrDf%RN\_Twv[Z ¦fÇZMZ[h‰rmTIR DT]\T.Z ¯TIUWVBo

Gò'06@*'!  +-.#"5@ñ?!H76:6@,.ô!H768#"ô0
68=6@*'!35@!#"õ‰!5B÷"ø•*'!E#ÇFW#",/-I#"ö',.-/,/6bði0'5@=?0N!576bðñ"ò
6 :  B3 O >E
2
 B  I2 B
NPO3 L  8   
 N  cR9'VmRs`WRO E>G J   cR9
. ¢ 

 &





$

#



#



ø•*'!u0'58=G=%ó¬ó]=?5-.,/F?!B$'!H@Hl,IH¦,.õ'!B$K6@,ILB#"-16@=6@*