and allowing tutors to lead students through a line of reasoning point by point. ... used by our tutor and plan to use them to train our system. In this paper, we ...
! " ! ! # $ % ! & ! '
( $ % & ' & " $ % ! ! ) ' *+ * ! (
! "+ *+
* ! &
( + *+ * ! " ' +$ ! $
! "# $% & ' ( ) * ' +! * * +! ,#, * "-% +! ., /* "0% + ' 1 ! + + * "0$ 2 0.% ( + * * "0-% ( ' /* + ' *+ ' ' * * ' + ' ' 3 ! 45(&6 ' **7 % , -.// /01&0&2&031 ! 4Æ . . 5 6 $ 7/// 5 &8 $ 9%5:7/// " ; ! % % 5
0 * 8 ' * 4 9 + '6 ' . : / ; 4 ' * 6 8 /* ' * +! * ( **
* + + 7 0 ' 8 46 ! * < 46 ! = /*
< 46 ) ! + . * 8 ! * = > 8 ! * * /* # + ( + + + + ! 4?@A@6 B * + ! * C5C5& "0D% & /+! ( E * ' + * ' 4F56 3 0 5 "02% G + /* + ' ( ' ) * * + * ) * ( !* ' ' ' ' ?@A@ ?@A@ '! + +! * ! 5 ** ' + * * ) *
5 & . * *
'! = *
! ** *
* ' *
* 5 & >
/* ! *
! & #
B ** ! * ( * < * * * 4 *
6 4 *
6 ' * ' * ' '!
% * * * 4 * ">%6 ! * ' *
*
*
' ' H * ! "0#% ! ' *
+ ".% 5 '
* ! ' + ! *
5 H * ' +! ' @ * = ' @ ! ) & = * + ' *
+ 5 + "0I% ?! + B ?! * ' /* /* ! ( * + + 9 ' * J * K ' * 4 ' H K * + 6 ( H *
* * 5 + &( 5&
* K 4 = ! *
! 6
( *
* /* 5 * ! * ! + < ! = ! !
+ ! :+ ; B ! ' = * ' ) * ! +
! ( ' "00% *
* *
H @@ /* ! ">% * * 9
/ + < + ' * ' * ! ( * + +! ' *
'!
?@A@ & * * ' * ' (
* ' *+ ' *
*
' *
' B *
! H ) &( 5&! *
+ = ' *
5 & > /* ' *
B * 9 * + * ( 5 &5 "0,% @@ /* ! ">% / ' * * * + ( + ' * * * +! ! **! * ! /* provide parameter select wire
de-energize circuit
remove wire
ordering constraint energize circuit
prevent shock
current must flow to be measured
must measure current in series read-amt-current
connect lead ?x1 polarity is observed & circuit is complete connect lead ?x2 CONNECT THE LEADS set meter to measure DC current
must use DC ammeter and meter must be on
6! ;
H** / H * ' ?@A@ F + F5 / *! * ' * ' + & ( * +! 5
** + < * ' 3 . *
( * /* = 4 .0 .I >,>06 5 .I >,>0 ! + * F .0 *+ 7 ! 4 ' 6 4 * 16 '! = 4 *
6 5 *
+ /* * Simulation Environment
Verbal tutor-student-communication
WORLD
TUTOR SENSING SYSTEM Parser
Simulation Observer
TEXT GENERATION Input/Output
Dialogue context
INTERPRETER Student model
Expectations
Problem solving context Expert + buggy knowledge
Dialog goals DIALOGUE PLANNER Hierarchical Reactive Planner Conversational Game Engine
Problem-Solving Manager (PSM)
Domain Reasoner 1-N
(Agenda) Tutor Teaching strategies
Agent
Curriculum
Domain Knowledge
Plan Recogniser
%
( * +! ** * 3 > ( * +! ( 5& ! "I% L ' 7 0 5' !* * * * * 9 ' * * '! * '! . ( * *+ / /* * 4 * ! *! + 6 > ( * *
# ( * ! ! *
4 ' ) = ' ' + 6 $ 5' * *
- ( *
' / * * 4 ! ' 6 ( *+ 4+!6 * * * Æ ! ( * + < + ' / * ' * ½ * ' *++ * "D% *
?! H /*
+ + * ' L 5 ' ** /* ' ** / H 5 * ! 7 K + * ' '
* ' ' B *
+ *
'! +! ' B ' *
+ 5' * ! ' ( ) ' * 9 ' * * *
) 5
¾ ( *
* ' * ' * * +! 4 * 002 3 #6 ( ' ** / H (@H&(@?M&(@ * ( * + * F *
+ ** ' * ( * * ' 4 6 * ' + * ' N * * +! *+ N ' * +! *
* ( 4 6 (@H&(@?M&(@ 4
6 * ' +! * ' * ½ ¾
! $ %
! ! '
! !$
! "# $"$% %$ ! &
'( ) '( ( *%" " &
) + "# % *, %$ + "# %$ + + + + #
'( + #-" % *,
% *, -" % *, .
! % *, -" !
6 4
4H + 6 3 * ** + ! ** ( / + - / 0 1 2 0 0 + ( 0 ( 0 + 30 1 2 -0
( H *
5N&( F( * *
5N&( F(H @ 4 3 $ * ' "0#%6 ( * * / F5 ( (, 4) 9 6 ( * ' ! *+ 4 0.6 / ( / * /
' ' 3 /* + J H' * ' ) * 5 * ) * ! + ! 4 ! ' 6 ! * ' 4 * 6 ( /* ! * * ' * (0 ( * 4 >6 & ' J * *
** H ' ? '!
( *
@ 5N&( F(. * ¿ ( 5N&( F(H @ * I H' '
( ) 9 < /* 2 46 ' ( @ @ ( *
** ' INSTRUCT-GAME student action(s)
instructions T0
S0
T1
explicit acknowledgment implict acknowledgment
I didn’t understand
acceptance
9.5%%&,>;
*! 2., +! 9 * *! (@HN@O(&(@ * ! * / 4 @0 3 -6 * ' 4 @.6 / H * ' '! / * 4 @0.6 * 5 @NH @N@O( 4 @006 5 @NH @N@O( 4 @0006 ) 4 @00.6 ( + * = 7 N **! H&P * @000 * ( * + ' + ' ( '! * /* ' ' ' * "0>% H
¿
9 !
9.5%%7 $ 9 " ! 9.5%% ! $
' * * ( *+ * ' * ' +! & +! ">% & '
+ + + / & * ' * 3 # ' 3 /* '
+ 4 '( ) + 404 ) + 40404 + + / 4040404 #-" + 4040. + + 40. #-" ) + . '( ( + 30 1 2 -0
> 2 0/ 9
( / H&PH @ @0000 +! = 0,00 ( H&PH @ 5N&( F(H @ / * = ' ' * ( *! 0. /* * @0000 *** ! @000 *** H&PH @ *! ' 0#0- 0D02 @00. @00 @0. @0 *** 7
( @. H&P * ( *+ ) 7 406 * * ' *+ ' + < 4.6 *+ 4' 6 ' < 4>6 *+ 9 * 4 ! 9 ! + 6 ( * *+ *
7 406 4.6 4>6 *
. < ' ' .$ .I
>0 #, * ! + ' . ! +! .. > * *7 46 * '!
* * ' 9 4+6 + * '
F .# 0 * 46 ' > ( + .D>. + ' * 4 * ' = 6 ' + 9 * ' 4 >$ >D6 + * F .D>. + + >. + * N = **! ! * / + * ' +! K
B + * ** < ' 406 + *
= L /+ ** ' * 4.6 * +! ' *
* ( ' H ! "0#% * + + ' *
F *
' ' *
!J *
* ** / H ( * /* /* * 4 .0 .I >,>06 '! .0 5 .I
* *
! + 5 * = ' + * = * = 4 >,>06 + ' * ! ( *
! >. '! ' 5 + ' * ' * '
! + ! 9
' * E ! ! ' * ' ! 9 H
* ' ! Æ /* = *
'! / ' 7 ) 46 46 ) 46 * ( +! ( * ! H *
* ' * ?! *
) + +! / 9 /* + ( !* ' /* + ' * = * < ! * K* = 9 * ! ' !* '
0$ $ 2 ! $ $ % ! " # $% 7@0A717$ 5 0C$ $ ,$ B 2$ B$ > $ %95? > !& $ 9 !& '
(" $)* 73A@/ ; 9 2 0$ $ $ B'$ + , !-
" . $ ! > .2 0@$ 0/$ $ B ! $ , ! # ! ,"
. $ 6 . 03$ 00$ $ B ! $ $ 9 ! /
. (/0 122* 4 7///$
07$ >$ $ , .$ $ 2$ $ ; $ & & $ ! . . ?1DAD77 0D$ 0@$ ,$ ! 2$ ; >$ " ;$ $ && $ 0 D*0+?7@A1C 03$ 01$ 9$ $ > ! $ % &/C@ 59 !& 0$
0D$ 6$ $ ;
! > 07$ 03$ 6$ $ ;
$ ; $ > ! $ 9 %$ 2 6$ ;$ % $ 5
# . 0 $ 5 8 01$ 0$ 5$ ! $ ! " $ % &/C0 59 ! 03$ 0$ $ $ G 2$ 6$ ; $ 8 6$ > $ > ! $ 5! $
H** / H7 H ?@A@
-,%
-,% -,% -,% -,% -,% -,% -,%
40 % ) 5 6 ( ++ 1 1 ( + 0 + ! ( ++ + 6 1 0 * ! ( 1 5 6 ( (
7 ( 0 .0 ( 0 0 ( 0 8 ( / 90 0 :0 "+ 0 8 +6/ ;0 0 0 * ( + + 0 8+6 ( . / ?0 $#5 4@0 + A ! ' ( 0 440 B ' 6 4.0 ( + 490 $#5 4:0 ( 6 4;0 +6 ( 40 + 4?0 * 1 0 .@0 ( 6 1 1 .40 ' ( 1 ..0 + + .90 6 .:0 B ( ++ 6 ' ( ( ++ 6 .;0 ! + %A++ ' ( ( % ! 1 1 ( .0 ! 6
( ! 1 1 ( .?0 B 6 9@0 A ) +6 0 940 C 1 6 ( ! 1 1 9.0 6 ( 1 + + ! 990 ! !+ + + 1 ! +( 1 9:0 $#5 9;0 6 ! +( 15 ( ! ! 90 ( ) ( ! 1 9?0 0 :@0 ( ++ + ( ! 9 ! + 1 !+! !+ ' ( :40 -0 !+ +6 0 :.0
! 1 ! 6 0 D000E
