Modeling Vehicle-pedestrian Crashes With Excess ...

Download PDF
6 downloads 0 Views 486KB Size Report
Comment
pedestrian crashes on Malaysia federal roads where roadways mostly pass through .... from the MIROS provided by the Royal Malaysia Police database (POL.
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

7--:XL-RXIVREXMSREP'SRKVIWW7YWXEMREFMPMX]SJ6SEH-RJVEWXVYGXYVIW 1SHIPMRKZILMGPITIHIWXVMERGVEWLIW[MXLI\GIWW^IVS EPSRK1EPE]WMEJIHIVEPVSEHW E

%LQEH7LYOVM=ELE]EE 7I]IH1SLEQQEH6I^E+LEHMVME

1ILHM,SWWIMR4SYV .SI[SRS4VEWIXMNS

E

7GLSSPSJ'MZMP)RKMRIIVMRK9RMZIVWMXM7EMRW1EPE]WME2MFSRK8IFEP1EPE]WME

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

©p8LI%YXLSVW4YFPMWLIHF])PWIZMIV0XH 2012 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer-review under responsibility of SIIV2012 Scientific Committee Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. 7IPIGXMSRERHSVTIIVVIZMI[YRHIVVIWTSRWMFMPMX]SJ7--:7GMIRXMJMG'SQQMXXII /I][SVHW :ILMGPITIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWGVEWLTVIHMGXMSRQSHIPWX[STEVXQSHIPWQSHIPWIPIGXMSRGVMXIVME 

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

'SVVIWTSRHMRKEYXLSV8IP )QEMPEHHVIWWLCQILHM$]ELSSGSQ

1877-0428 © 2012 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer-review under responsibility of SIIV2012 Scientific Committee Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2012.09.970

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

1219

JSV  F] VITVIWIRXMRK EFSYX   SJ XSXEP VSEH YWIV JEXEPMXMIW ?A 8S EHHVIWW XLMW TVSFPIQ XLI 1EPE]WMER XVERWTSVXEXMSREKIRGMIWERHVSEHWEJIX]EYXLSVMXMIWLEZIQEHIGSRWMHIVEFPIIJJSVXWXSMQTVSZIXLIWEJIX]SJVSEH RIX[SVOERH QEOIEWEJIV IRZMVSRQIRX JSV VSEH YWIVW*SV I\EQTPI XLIKSZIVRQIRX PEYRGLIH XLI 6SEH7EJIX] 4PER  MR  XS VIHYGI JEXEPMX] VEXIW F] XLI IRH SJ ]IEV  *YVXLIVQSVI XLI KSZIVRQIRX LEW ETTVSZIHERHMQTPIQIRXIHc6SEH7EJIX]4PERd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žHIERH0EVWWSR?A)PZMO?A%WERI\EQTPI+VELEQERH+PEMWXIV ?A I\EQMRIH XLI IJJIGX SJ YVFER WGEPI HIRWMX] ERH PERHYWI QM\ SR XLI SGGYVVIRGI SJ ZILMGPITIHIWXVMER GEWYEPXMIW F] HIZIPSTMRK E WTEXMEP QSHIP EX E HMWEKKVIKEXI PIZIP 8LIMV JMRHMRKW MRHMGEXI XLEX XLI TIHIWXVMER GEWYEPXMIW MW QSVI PMOIP] XS SGGYV MR VIWMHIRXMEP XLER MR IGSRSQMG ^SRIW ERH E UYEHVEXMG VIPEXMSRWLMT MW JSYRH FIX[IIRYVFERHIRWMX]ERHTIHIWXVMERGEWYEPXMIW0IIERH%FHIP%X]?AEREP]^IHZILMGPIgTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWF] YWMRKPSKPMRIEVQSHIPWEXMRXIVWIGXMSRWMR*PSVMHESZIV]IEVWg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gRIMKLFSVLSSH GSQQIVGMEP YWI EVXIVMEP WXVIIXW [MXLSYX TYFPMG XVERWMX IQTPS]QIRX VIWMHIRX TSTYPEXMSR ERH TSTYPEXMSR FIPS[ TSZIVX] PIZIP LEZI E TSWMXMZI GSVVIPEXMSR [LMPI XLI JVEGXMSR SJ TISTPI EKIH  ERH SPHIV EVI RIKEXMZIP] EWWSGMEXIH [MXL TIHIWXVMER GVEWLIW 8SVFMG IX EP ?A HIZIPSTIH E QIXLSHSPSK] JSV MHIRXMJ]MRK XLI IJJIGXW SJ I\MWXMRK VSEH JIEXYVIW ERH TVSTSWIH MQTVSZIQIRXW SR TIHIWXVMERWEJIX]MRYVFERERHWYFYVFEREVXIVMEPW8LIVIWYPXWWLS[IHXLEXHEMP]TIHIWXVMERGVSWWMRKZSPYQIXIRHW XSLEZIWMKRMJMGERXVIPEXMSRWLMTXSTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWEXWMKREPM^IHMRXIVWIGXMSRW-REHHMXMSRXLIKVIEXIVXLIVEXMS SJ QMRSV VSEH XVEJJMG ZSPYQI XS QENSV VSEH XVEJJMG ZSPYQI XLI LMKLIV ZILMGPIgTIHIWXVMER GVEWL JVIUYIRG] [EW SFWIVZIH9OOYWYVMIXEP?AHIZIPSTIHQSHIPWJSVX[SEVIEX]TIPIZIPWREQIHGIRWYWXVEGXPIZIPERH^MTGSHI PIZIPJSVMHIRXMJ]MRK M XLIVIPEXMSRWLMTFIX[IIRPERHYWIERHVSEHHIWMKR[MXLTIHIWXVMERWEJIX]ERH MM XLIIJJIGX SJXLIPIZIPSJWTEXMEPEKKVIKEXMSRSRXLIJVIUYIRG]SJTIHIWXVMEREGGMHIRXWJSV2I[=SVO'MX]SZIVE JMZI]IEV TIVMSH8LIEYXLSVWGSRGPYHIHXLEXXLIGIRWYWXVEGXEREP]WMWTVSZMHIW QSVIMRWMKLXJYPERHFIXXIVVIWYPXWXLERXLI EREP]WMW EX XLI ^MT GSHI PIZIP 8LIMV JMRHMRKW EPWS WLS[ XLEX XVEGXW [MXL LMKLIV TVSTSVXMSR SJ MRHYWXVMEP GSQQIVGMEP ERH STIR PERH YWI LEZI KVIEXIV PMOIPMLSSH JSV GVEWLIW [LMPI XVEGXW [MXL E KVIEXIV TVSTSVXMSR SJ VIWMHIRXMEP PERH YWI LEZI WMKRMJMGERXP] PS[IV PMOIPMLSSH SJ TIHIWXVMER GVEWLIW 8LMW TETIV JSGYWIW SR ZILMGPI TIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWSR1EPE]WMEJIHIVEPVSEHW[LIVIVSEH[E]WQSWXP]TEWWXLVSYKLVYVEPEVIEW[MXLPS[TIHIWXVMER EGXMZMXMIW VIWYPXMRK MR E PEVKI RYQFIV SJ WIGXMSRW [MXL RS TIHIWXVMER GVEWL [LMGL MQTPMIW E QEWW SJ ^IVS GVEWL GSYRXW8LISFNIGXMZISJXLMWTETIVMWX[SJSPH M 8SHIZIPSTERHMRZIWXMKEXIEWIXSJGVEWLTVIHMGXMSRQSHIPWJSV IWXMQEXMRK XLI WEJIX] TSXIRXMEP SJ TIHIWXVMER EGXMZMXMIW SR XLI VSEH PMROW MM  8S I\EQMRI XLI IJJIGXW SJ ZEVMSYW VSEH[E] GLEVEGXIVMWXMGW SR XLI MRGMHIRGI SJ TIHIWXVMER GVEWLIW 8S EGGSQTPMWL XLI SFNIGXMZIW SJ XLMW WXYH] 4SMWWSR2IKEXMZI&MRSQMEP 2& ^IVSMRJPEXIHERH^IVSMRJPEXIHRIKEXMZIFMRSQMEPQSHIPW[IVIHIZIPSTIHERH GSQTEVIHYWMRKHEXEGSPPIGXIHSRGSRWMHIVIHVSEH[E]W

1220

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

 1IXLSHSPSK]  'SYRXQSHIPWJSVTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIW (YIXSXLIVERHSQHMWGVIXIERHTSWMXMZIREXYVISJGVEWLHEXEGSYRXHEXEQSHIPMRKXIGLRMUYIWWYGLEW4SMWWSR ERH RIKEXMZI FMRSQMEP VIKVIWWMSR QSHIPW EVI YWIH MR WYGL GEWIW 8LI 4SMWWSR VIKVIWWMSR QSHIP LEW FIIR XVEHMXMSREPP]GSRWMHIVIH EW XLI WXEVXMRK TSMRXMR QSHIPMRK GVEWLHEXE [MXLXLI EWWYQTXMSRSJ XLI QIER SJ GVEWL GSYRXWFIMRKIUYEPXSMXWZEVMERGI XLEXMWIUYEPHMWTIVWMSR ?A-RXLI4SMWWSRVIKVIWWMSRQSHIPXLITVSFEFMPMX] SJRMTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWSGGYVVMRKEXEKMZIRVSEHWMXIM 4V RM` M GERFIIWXMQEXIHF]XLIIUYEXMSR

 

























 

 

[LIVI M MW XLI I\TIGXIH RYQFIV SJ TIHIWXVMER GVEWLIW EX XLI KMZIR WMXI

MW E ZIGXSV SJ GSZEVMEXIW VSEH

KISQIXVMG IRZMVSRQIRXEP ERH XVEJJMG MRJSVQEXMSR  ERH MW E ZIGXSV SJ IWXMQEFPI VIKVIWWMSR GSIJJMGMIRXW ,S[IZIVMRQYGLSJXLIGVEWLHEXEXLIZEVMERGIMWKVIEXIVXLERXLIQIER[IPPORS[REWSZIVHMWTIVWMSR8LI SZIVHMWTIVWMSRMWEVIWYPXSJI\XVEZEVMEXMSRMRGVEWL QIERWEGVSWWWMXIW [LMGLGERFIGEYWIHF]ZEVMSYW JEGXSVW WYGL EW QSHIP QMWWTIGMJMGEXMSR SQMWWMSR SJ MQTSVXERX GSZEVMEXIW ERH I\GIWW ^IVS GSYRXW -R WYGL E GEWI ETTP]MRK E 4SMWWSR VIKVIWWMSR QSHIP JSV TIHIWXVMER GVEWL HEXE [SYPH VIWYPX MR YRHIVIWXMQEXMSR SJ XLI WXERHEVH IVVSV SJ XLI VIKVIWWMSR TEVEQIXIVW ERH REVVS[IV '-W [LMGL GER PIEH XS E FMEWIH WIPIGXMSR SJ GSZEVMEXIW ?A ,IRGI XS XLMW IRH E KEQQE HMWXVMFYXIH IVVSV XIVQ [EW MRGPYHIH MR XLI 4SMWWSR QSHIP XS WIVZI EW E QM\XYVI 4SMWWSRKEQQESVRIKEXMZIFMRSQMEPQSHIPWYGLXLEX 

















 

[LIVI XLI I\T M  MW KEQQE HMWXVMFYXIH [MXL QIER  ERH ZEVMERGI XLI SZIVHMWTIVWMSR TEVEQIXIV  8LI 2& QSHIP XEOIW XLI YRSFWIVZIH LIXIVSKIRIMX] SJ XLI 4SMWWSR QIER MRXS EGGSYRX F] EPPS[MRK XLI ZEVMERGI XS HMJJIV JVSQXLIQIEREWFIPS[ 











 

-JSZIVHMWTIVWMSR IUYEPWXLIRIKEXMZIFMRSQMEPVIHYGIWXSXLI4SMWWSRQSHIP8LI2&QSHIPEWWYQIWXLEX YRSFWIVZIHLIXIVSKIRIMX]EGVSWWVSEHWIGXMSRWJSPPS[WKEQQEHMWXVMFYXMSR[LMPIGVEWLIW[MXLMRWMXIWEVI4SMWWSR HMWXVMFYXIH8LIQE\MQYQPMOIPMLSSHJYRGXMSRSJXLIFMRSQMEPVIKVIWWMSRQSHIPMWWLS[RF]  





















[LIVI MWMRZIVWIHMWTIVWMSRTEVEQIXIV SJVSEH[E]WIGXMSRW 2! 



MWEZEPYISJKEQQEHMWXVMFYXMSRERH2MWXLIXSXEPRYQFIV

8LI GLSMGI FIX[IIR XLMW RIKEXMZI FMRSQMEP QSHIP ERH XLI 4SMWWSR QSHIP GER PEVKIP] FI HIXIVQMRIH F] XLI WXEXMWXMGEP WMKRMJMGERGI SJ XLI IWXMQEXIH GSIJJMGMIRX  -J MW RSX WMKRMJMGERXP] HMJJIVIRX JVSQ ^IVS XLI RIKEXMZI

1221

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

FMRSQMEPQSHIPWMQTP]VIHYGIWXSE4SMWWSRQSHIP[MXL XLIRIKEXMZIFMRSQMEPQSHIPMWXLIGSVVIGXGLSMGI?A

-J MWWMKRMJMGERXP]HMJJIVIRXJVSQ^IVS

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











 

[LIVI]MWXLIRYQFIVSJTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWJSVWIGXMSRMERH MWXLII\TIGXIHGVEWLJVIUYIRG]MRWIGXMSRMEWE 8LITVSFEFMPMX]SJFIMRKMRXLI^IVSGVEWLWXEXI MWSJXIR JYRGXMSRSJVSEHWIGXMSRGSZEVMEXIW JMXXIHYWMRKPSKMWXMGVIKVIWWMSRQSHIPEWJSPPS[W









[LIVI MWEJYRGXMSRSJWSQII\TPEREXSV]ZEVMEFPIWERH GSIJJMGMIRXW 7MQMPEVXS>-4QSHIPXLITVSFEFMPMX]HIRWMX]JYRGXMSRJSVXLI>-2&KMZIRQIER MWKMZIRF]

 





 

MWXLIIWXMQEFPI ERHHMWTIVWMSRTEVEQIXIV 





 

8LIQE\MQYQPMOIPMLSSHQIXLSHMWYWIHXSIWXMQEXIXLITEVEQIXIVWSJXLI>-QSHIPW-RKIRIVEPWTIEOMRKXLI TVSFEFMPMX]SJSFWIVZMRK^IVSGSYRXWMR>-QSHIPWMWXLIWYQSJXLITVSFEFMPMX]SJSFWIVZMRKERI\GIWW^IVSMRXLI

1222

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

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









































MWXLIWXERHEVHHIZMEXMSRSJ 8LI:YSRKXIWX : JSPPS[WEWXERHEVHRSVQEP [LIVI MWXLIQIERSJ  HMWXVMFYXMSR -J : MW KVIEXIV XLER  XLIR MX JEZors the ZIP/ZINB and V is lower than −1.96 favors tLI 4SMWWSR2&QSHIP-J : MXMRHMGEXIXLEXRIMXLIVQSHIPMWTVIJIVVIHSZIVXLISXLIV -REHHMXMSR[IYWIX[SMRJSVQEXMSRGVMXIVMEQIEWYVIWREQIHXLI%OEMOI %-' ERH&E]IWMER &-' MRJSVQEXMSR GVMXIVMEXSGSQTEVIFSXLRIWXIHERHRSRRIWXIHQSHIPW8LI%-'ERH&-'EVIHIJMRIHEWJSPPS[W 

















 

 















 

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

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

1223

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

8EFPI%WYQQEV]SJWSQITVIHMGXSVZEVMEFPIW

:EVMEFPI

8]TI

(IWGVMTXMSR

8VEJJMGJPS[

'SRXMRYSYW

EZIVEKIHEMP]XVEJJMGMRGPYHMRKEPPQSXSVM^IHJSVQWSJXVEJJMG MIQSXSVG]GPMWXWGEVWFYWXVYGOW 

,IEZ]ZILMGPIJPS[

'SRXMRYSYW

EZIVEKIHEMP]LIEZ]ZILMGPIMRGPYHMRKFYWERHXVYGO

7TIIHPMQMX

'SRXMRYSYW

%GXYEPTSWXIHRYQIVMGEPWTIIHPMQMX VERKMRKJVSQXS 

2SSJPERIW

'SYRX

8SXEPRYQFIVSJPERIWMRXLIHMVIGXMSRSJXVEZIP

7LSYPHIV[MHXL

'SRXMRYSYW

6SEHWLSYPHIV[MHXL VERKMRKJVSQXSQ 

'YVZEXYVI

'SRXMRYSYW

,SVM^SRXEPGYVZEXYVI OQ 

5YEPMXEXMZI

-RHMGEXSVSJZIVXMGEPWPSTIEPSRKVSEHdWPIRKXL JSVJPEXJSVVSPPMRKYRHYPEXMRK 

:IVXMGEPEPMKRQIRX %GGIWWTSMRX 0ERHYWI

'SYRX

2YQFIVSJMRXIVWIGXMSRERHQMRSVEGGIWWTSMRXWTIVOQEPSRKVSEH[E]

5YEPMXEXMZI

0IZIPSJEGXMZMX]EPSRKVSEH[E] JSVRSEGXMZMX]PIZIPJSVPS[EGXMZMX] PIZIP IKWGLSSPJEGXSV] JSVLMKLEGXMZMX]PIZIP IKVIWMHIRXMEPSVGSQQIVGMEP 

 6IWYPXWERH(MWGYWWMSR ;IJMVWXP]HVE[ELMWXSKVEQTPSXJSVXLITIHIWXVMERGVEWLHMWXVMFYXMSREWWLS[RMR*MK8LIJMKYVIWLS[WXLEX XLI RYQFIV SJ ^IVSW MW  ETTVS\MQEXIP]   [LMPI XLIVI EVI  SFWIVZEXMSRW JSV TSWMXMZI GVEWL GSYRXW ETTVS\MQEXIP] -XGSRJMVQWXLITVIWIRGISJI\GIWW^IVSWMRTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIW1SVISZIVXLIVEXMSSJXLI ZEVMERGIXSQIERMWMRHMGEXMRKXLIGVEWLHEXEMWSZIVHMWTIVWIHMQTP]MRKXLI4SMWWSRQSHIPHSIWRdXEHIUYEXIP] JMXXLISZIVHMWTIVWIHGVEWLHEXEXLIRMRXLMWGEWIEPXIVREXMZIQSHIPWWYGLEW2&QSHIPERH>-QSHIPW >-4ERH >-2& GERFIEPXIVREXMZIP]YWIH -RSVHIVXSEWWIWWXLIWSYVGISJSZIVHMWTIVWMSR[IHIZIPSTIHXLVIIQSHIPW2&>-4ERH>-2&%WQIRXMSRIH FIJSVI 2& QSHIP MW E WYTIVMSV QSHIP JSV HIEPMRK [MXL SZIVHMWTIVWMSR HYI XS YRSFWIVZIH LIXIVSKIRIMX] >-4

1224

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

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

*MK,MWXSKVEQSJSFWIVZIHTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWJSVXLIWIGXMSRWHYVMRK

8EFPI  EPWS WLS[W XLI EGXYEP ERH TVIHMGXIH GSYRX GEXIKSVMIW SJ TIHIWXVMER GVEWLIW JSV EPP QSHIPW 8LI GSQTEVMWSRJSVXLI4SMWWSRQSHIPVIZIEPWXLI4SMWWSRQSHIPMWRSXERETTVSTVMEXIQSHIPJSVTVIHMGXMRK GVEWLIW [MXLI\GIWW^IVSGSYRXW3RXLISXLIVLERHJSVXLIVIQEMRMRKQSHIPWXLITVIHMGXIHJVIUYIRGMIWEVIRIEVP]GPSWI XS XLI SFWIVZIH SRIW IWTIGMEPP] JSV XLI >-4 ERH >-2& QSHIPW [LMGL SYXTIVJSVQ XLI 2& QSHIP JSV EPP GSYRX GEXIKSVMIW2I\X [IGSQTEVIEPPHIZIPSTIHQSHIPWYWMRK %-' ERH&-'8LIWIMRJSVQEXMSRFEWIH GVMXIVMEJEZSV XLI>-4QSHIPSZIVEPPSXLIVQSHIPW%WEVIWYPX[IWIPIGXXLI>-4QSHIPEWXLIFIWXEQSRKXLIJSYVQSHIPWERH XEFYPEXIMXWVIWYPXWMR8EFPI6IWYPXWJSVXLI4SMWWSR2&ERH>-2&EVIRSXTVIWIRXIHWMRGIXLI>-4QSHIP[EW JSYRHXSFITVIJIVVIHSZIVXLI4SMWWSR2&ERH>-2&QSHIPW-RXLIGSYRXWXEXIPSKEVMXLQSJ%(8 0R %(8

 PSKEVMXLQSJLIEZ]ZILMGPIXVEJJMG 0R LIEZ]ZILMGPI

WTIIHPMQMXERHPERHYWI[IVIJSYRHXSFIWMKRMJMGERX3YX SJXLIWIZEVMEFPIWe0R %(8 fERHe0ERHYWIfEVITSWMXMZIP]EWWSGMEXIH[MXLTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWEWI\TIGXIH3R XLISXLIVLERHe7TIIHPMQMXfERHe0R LIEZ]ZILMGPI fLEZIERIKEXMZIWMKR 8LIJMRHMRKWWLS[XLEX4'WMRGVIEWIEWXVEJJMGJPS[MRGVIEWIEWI\TIGXIH0SKEVMXLQSJLIEZ]ZILMGPIXVEJJMG LEW E RIKEXMZI MQTEGX SR XLI 4'W MX QIERW XLEX WIGXMSRW [MXL LMKLIV LIEZ] XVEJJMG JPS[ EVI PIWW PMOIP] XS LEZI 4'W3RIVIEWSRJSVXLMWJMRHMRKMWXLEXLIEZ]ZILMGPI[MXLPS[WTIIHPIEHXLIJSPPS[MRKZILMGPIWXSVIHYGIXLIMV WTIIH ERH WYFWIUYIRXP] PIWWIR XLI TVSFEFMPMX] SJ SXLIV ZILMGPIW XS LMX TIHIWXVMERW 8LI VIWYPXW WLS[ XLEX VSEH WIGXMSRW[MXLLMKLIVWTIIHPMQMXWXIRHXSLEZIPS[IVTVSFEFMPMX]SJLEZMRKTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIW-XQIERWXLEXWTIIH PMQMXMWRIKEXMZIP]VIPEXIHXSTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIW8LMWMWI\TIGXIHFIGEYWIXLIVSEHW[MXLLMKLIVWTIIHPMQMXWLEZI WEJIV HIWMKRW ERH IRZMVSRQIRXEP GSRHMXMSRW [LMPI PS[IV WTIIH PMQMXW EVI EWWMKRIH XS XLSWI VSEH WIGXMSRW [MXL YRWEJIHIWMKRSVGSRHMXMSR8LMWVIWYPXMWGSRWMWXIRX[MXLXLITVIZMSYWWXYHMIW?A,S[IZIVLMKLIVEQSYRX SJWTIIHPMQMXWLSYPHRSXFIMRXIVTVIXIHEWEQIEWYVIXSVIHYGI4'W8LIJEGXSVPERHYWILEWETSWMXMZIIJJIGXSR

1225

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

XLI 4'W 6IWMHIRXMEPGSQQIVGMEP EVIEW EW E LMKL PIZIP SJ EGXMZMX] EVI WMKRMJMGERXP] EWWSGMEXIH [MXL 4'W [LMPI EVIEW[MXLPS[IVEGXMZMX]ETTIEVRSXXSFIWMKRMJMGERXP]EWWSGMEXIH[MXLTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIW [MXLTZEPYI %W E VIWYPX PERH YWI GER WIVZIH EW E WYVVSKEXI ZEVMEFPI XS TIHIWXVMER I\TSWYVI [LIVIEW HEXE VIKEVHMRK TIHIWXVMER EGXMZMXMIW[EWRSXEZEMPEFPIMRXLIHEXEWIX-RXLI^IVSWXEXI PSKMWXMGQSHIP XLITVSFEFMPMX]SJEWIGXMSRLEZMRKRS GVEWLMWHITIRHIRXSRSRP]SRIZEVMEFPIREQIP]0R %(8 -RSXLIV[SVHWXLITVSFEFMPMX]SJLEZMRKEXPIEWXSRI GVEWLMRGVIEWIWEWXVEJJMGJPS[MRGVIEWI%EHZERXEKISJ>-4EWEX[SWXEXIQSHIPMWXLEXMXEPPS[WJSVHMJJIVIRXWIXW SJZEVMEFPIWMRFSXLQSHIPWXEXIWXLI^IVSWXEXIERHXLIGSYRXWXEXIERHXLYWJSVHMWXMRKYMWLMRKJEGXSVWEJJIGXMRK XLSWIX[STEVXW

8EFPI8LIEGXYEPERHTVIHMGXIHJVIUYIRGMIWSJTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWF]HIZIPSTIHQSHIPWERHXLIMVKSSHRIWWSJJMXVIWYPXW

'SYRX      4EVEQIXIVW 0SKPMOIPMLSSH TZEPYI %-' &-'

%GXYEP     

4SMWWSR          

2&          

>-4          

>-2&          

2SXI 2& ! RIKEXMZI FMRSQMEP >-4 ! ^IVSMRJPEXIH 4SMWWSR QSHIP >-2& ! ^IVSMRJPEXIH RIKEXMZI FMRSQMEP QSHIP e  TZEPYIf ! GSVVIWTSRHMRKTZEPYIJSV4IEVWSRdWKSSHRIWWSJJMXQIEWYVIERHe TZEPYIf!GSVVIWTSRHMRKTZEPYIJSVHMWTIVWMSRTEVEQIXIVJSVXLI2& ERH>-2&QSHIPW

8EFPI)WXMQEXMSRSJ^IVSMRJPEXIH4SMWWSRVIKVIWWMSRQSHIPSJTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIW

:EVMEFPI 'SYRXWXEXIEW4SMWWSRQSHIP 'SRWXERX 0R %(8  0R ,IEZ]:ILMGPI  7TIIHPMQMX 0ERHYWI2SEGXMZMX] 0S[EGXMZMX] ,MKLEGXMZMX] >IVSWXEXIEWPSKMWXMGQSHIP 'SRWXERX 0R %(8  2YQFIVSJSFWIVZEXMSR 0SKPMOIPMLSSHEXGSRZIVKIRGI :YSRKXIWX >-4ZW4SMWWSR   >-4ZW2&

'SIJJMGMIRX

TZEPYI

    6  

   I   

 

     

1226

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

 'SRGPYWMSR 8LMW TETIV EMQIH XS JSGYW TIHIWXVMER GVEWLIW SR OQ WIGXMSRW SJ 1EPE]WME JIHIVEP VSEHW 8LI WIPIGXIH VSEH[E]WTEWWQSWXP]XLVSYKLVYVEPEVIEWMR[LMGLXLIPIZIPSJTIHIWXVMEREGXMZMXMIWMWZIV]PS[ERHVEVIP]SGGYVW -XMQTPMIWERI\TIGXEXMSRSJGSRWMHIVEFPIRYQFIVSJWIGXMSRW[MXLRSTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWHYVMRKXLIWXYH]TIVMSH *SVQSHIPMRKGSYRXHEXEMRXLITVIWIRGISJI\GIWW^IVSWEWERMQTSVXERXGEYWISJSZIVHMWTIVWMSRWXERHEVHGSYRX QSHIPWPMOI4SMWWSRERH2&QSHIPWEVIJSYRHXSFIQMWWTIGMJMIH%WEREPXIVREXMZI >-4QSHIPGERFIYWIHXS LERHPI SZIVHMWTIVWMSR EVMWMRK SRP] JVSQ I\GIWW ^IVSIW *MVWX [I HIZIPSTIH E 2& QSHIP XS XIWX [LIXLIV XLI HMWTIVWMSR TEVEQIXIV MR XLI GVEWL HEXE MW HYI XS YRSFWIVZIH LIXIVSKIRIMX] SV RSX 8LI VIWYPX WLS[IH XLEX HMWTIVWMSR TEVEQIXIV [EW WXEXMWXMGEPP] VINIGXIH EX  WMKRMJMGERGI PIZIP MQTP]MRK SZIVHMWTIVWMSR MR GVEWL HEXE QE]FIVIWYPXIHJVSQI\GIWW^IVSW8SHSXLMWXLI:YSRKXIWX[EWGSRHYGXIHJSVX[STEMVW4SMWWSRZIVWYW>-4 ERH2&ZIVWYW>-48LIXIWXKEZIEREHZERXEKIXSXLI>-4QSHIP1SVISZIVXLI>-4QSHIP[EWJSYRHXSFIXLI QSWX WYMXEFPI QSHIP WMRGI %-' &-' ZEPYIW [IVI WQEPPIWX MR GSQTEVMWSR XS XLI GSRWMHIVIH QSHIPW 8EFPI   8LMWTETIVEPWSI\EQMRIHJEGXSVWMRJPYIRGMRKSR4'W8LIJEGXSVWXSXEPXVEJJMGZSPYQILIEZ]XVEJJMGJPS[WTIIH PMQMXERHPERHYWIETTIEVXSMRGVIEWITVSFEFMPMX]SJXLIGSYRXTVSGIWW*SVXLIHMGLSXSQSYWTVSGIWWSRP]XVEJJMG JPS[ [EW JSYRH XS FI TSWMXMZIP] EWWSGMEXIH XS XLI TVSFEFMPMX] SJ EX PIEWX SRI 4' 8S GSRGPYHI LMKL EQSYRX SJ ^IVSWMRTIHIWXVMERGVEWLIWWLSYPHRSXFIMKRSVIHJSVVYVEPVSEHWWMRGIXLI]VIWYPXJVSQWMXIW[MXLRSTIHIWXVMER EGXMZMXMIWERHXSLERHPIXLIMWWYIE^IVSMRJPEXIH4SMWWSRQSHIPGERFITVSTSWIH

%GORS[PIHKIQIRXW 8LIEYXLSVW[SYPHPMOIXSXLEROXLI1EPE]WME-RWXMXYXISJ7EJIX]6IWIEVGLERHXLI,MKL[E]4PERRMRK9RMXJSV XLI HEXE YWIH MR XLMW VIWIEVGL 8LMW WXYH] MW E TEVX SJ E VIWIEVGL TVSNIGX WTSRWSVIH F] XLI 9RMZIVWMXM 7EMRW 1EPE]WME8LIEYXLSVWEGORS[PIHKIXLIWYTTSVXERHEWWMWXERGI

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

Mehdi Hossein Pour et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 53 (2012) 1218 – 1227

1227

?A &Vž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