Network Games - Cornell Computer Science - Cornell University

Network Games ´ Tardos Eva Department of Computer Science Cornell University Ithaca, NY 14853

eva@cs.cornell.edu

ABSTRACT


 



 !" #! $#%& %'())'

%& %' *,+ - %'(.%'(/(01

2"3

4 #56

 6 %'75"8  9,: 2#%';)%'7.(D7

7E%'F"6

(EG#



 G%'(=(,9 "H  I

J:8($? JK-

(#L %' M %'(N)'

%& %'  ;#(% *,+ A
 

O5E$#) #I%'(E ;  %'(?P6 (@  "H%'(#Q "3

=D %>(($R +   -9- S(,

)')'J$TP,9$#%&UV

(,8 Q  %'A!W1#%' 6

 6; %>7 + - 1##

%'(5 2"X #H Q $%& %>(Y)2)'

%' #%' *,+ - %>(R%>(N(# 

EITZ=J;   %'%'Y(,%'([(?)'

%& #\%'7%' J$O5=)>9, ]%>(?=((Q ,6 D %>7^:_2

TJ@)>9,   L )&` )&9[# %&Q %'a/#%'^ L# =J2(bPEc-; %>7O" + (# %'(_AdB0(#"e

= %'(;i/ ;Q (#)'9[ =

^$#7)'%'(#L E$9,:j$#6($#5([ + P%')'%&9[  ( +

8 YDj  %'%'Y(, j,6   $# #%' 8 %' j$#%'7;

 G)' (Y$=%'(E ;

- A8B( %'!)' I1.2%>)')V +

79="e
 ( Jt  u]%>)'=EAs$#%'%&

%' +ov wxDy %'(,

E$ + J$O #R 

4zY{|~}=€ ‚ƒ6‚ {-}„E…H"e G #1  %'"Y 

-G
g I *,+ %')'%'P#

% + †(Y$R #HP6- # %'=)$# %>(_AdW1#

/Y^P6(F( %>$#; P)'O#



 ^( *,+ - %'(T

%' %'(/"3

‡ #%'R6

 6 %'7^"3 T=(,9ˆ#

P#)' %'(#) + $#%'(#^

 +  %'( v w‰ :SŠE‹ y :X)>$OPY)k(%'(# v Œ :_E: wŽ :_Š:_Š wJy : D  

b 6  J$aJ$[$ %'(_ATW1RP6-
] ˆ%>g #TP6-  ) +  %>(f H%'1-P)'$# %&  #] )&`Y ^%'(, 

-H"j YD Q  %'%'Y(E A8 [

%'(L

%>g"-P%')'%&9^Y1"e, +  J$L(f(01

$# %>( v ‹: wDy ($ˆ

 +  %'( v Ž : wDy A^¡ + (, %&"39%'(fl%'(#9ˆ)>  %'G #.H  9(Y)>5"_##

Ji%>=D %'(=)'

%& :(Y$  =P6-

 6( =#

, T"2`(Y$#%'(#/M
g N *,+ %')'%>P

% + ¢%' ()' + ! g)',J) JD

;XA!Wj(#% *,+ j"3

“  HD

J!"6)&Q 

%& 2YJ7g#)>J9J$f ;9^

)'2%>(f P675$#7)>(, A W1;

5

=(,9=%'6 (,2%>  + 2%'(M(01

2)'%' ] #B(#Q  

(#J:2#

  # UV;" )&`Y (# %' + ;5)' S1)>) + ($# Q - ,E$XAM’ T([i#)':j(# %>$#  I

 +  %'(MP6;1(@(; Q 1

M#

D7E%>$#

.(/ #B0(, 

( v w ‹ y :V g

(; )')&9O(Q  %>$# R =#

, TP,9ˆ2%';h%'(Y$6($#(,(01

[#

D7E%>$#

 P + %')k$‘(Y$ +  O [B0(, 

(JA£’ M=(,99=" + (# %'(#HJ(^P6g7 9 PY$XAnJ17; J:E + ^P$IP6J7%'

H$#, (G K 5Y#6( %'#  %'J)G(E7%&

((,  v w–Dy A/W1

^L"e;¥H9 /#

D7 P6   RP6 + (Y$Z v Š‹ y  J2R TO,E$NP%'

%& 

%>ˆP6 + ($[%' 6  %'P#)>:_2#%>)' v ‹ Œy #

D7E%>$#](O%'#

D7J$/(Y)'9 %'g"e - ¦ J‘  A rE + $9%'(o
g “ *E+ %')>%'P

%kb6JD

? b  + h%')'%'%& )&9  YDg( + )SR9,:6 + ˆ])'  %'(#fJ;O#)k9,; g

J$#%')&9 + V$# =%'R ) +  %'(‘§P6-R

 6(# D¨;:8

JT + h(N *E+ %&Q )'%'P#

% + MAˆ b%')'= 

f

^ ^(%'^6 %& %'7=

 + )& :! 

 %'])' ^-

(7E%>$#(g .%'(M(01

f2 %')')'J

(Q %'(?-  %>L$[(=(E7;

 v ‹ Ž :‹J y A%'P

%k[=-P#)>O$ %'(X:H  ;  Y(o +  Q 2"8(YD + )j)>9L$9(Y%>A1W1#%>.)'J$ + H T  *,+ -Q  %'(b"R

%'O"-P#%>)'%&9,:]($(I #.

JE:#- )&9R"3, +  J$=(=D

! *,+ %')'%'P#

%> v x : ‰ : wwJy : P + T)' [%'() + $#%'(O  T#

P#)':! + oR

 +  %'( v ‹‹ y Ab %'aJD %'(_A’ Gi##)>:

%>=)&Q $ + )_)'

%& 2)>9fT 9=

)'A W1f-T$#7)'6J$m

JO"])'

%& %'M=  9N%'

;(%' 4$# %>(_:6- )&9M$7)'6$M%>(M #5(, iE."G + Q  %'(:X($/- Qª YD

%'(^AB0(/ )' L 2%')')S"e, + g(  #g(;1

=H + M1

 +  %'( v w :Š:X‹JŠE:_‹ xDy :6(Y$f- Q  

%'(]8"3 ! + )& %>- v ‹ w :‹ –Dy :E($R(;1

$# %'( v ‹ ‰ : wDŒy Aˆ«](# )')&9@ 6 E%'(#: #)'T";(%' ˜$ %'(N%'  5$ %'(= %')'H.§;(#%>  

 ,)'¨G + T YD  )'`  +  

H%'(E ;  %'(2%& ^ #%> 2%>)')6

 + )'2%'(fR,E$ *,+ )'%&9? ) +  %'(XAMWX $#%& %'()1;(%' ˜$ %'(["3, +  T(  +  %'(09#68

P)'j($ +  j ,%k),1)&"D

H_ !J +

 "2 ) +  %'( *E+ )'%&9,A=nD 7 J:j"3

˜ #P6D7P

$ 6 Q  6 %'7:81f)' O(# %>$# R =(01

@$# %>(h=" v wJy :  #fP($2%>$ h)>)',JD %'($M( %>$#;  # *,+ - %'(@%&"H ;

%>L %'#)>7

%>(E"H I:8f %>#)' Y(%'( .Y(#%' M: YDH)>)'J22(=%'#

D7$I()&9 %>A 1.‹

A®(# )'7E%';X:#®A#u  + #E: ­ AWS $:6W]A @;i#)' JA v y­ REFERENCES
J Q•] %>=)6
]01

^u] %'(f2%& Mr)&`Y L®(, As

,A Š Ž  /®.”H¯¢rE96 % + ¥(/W1 9L"!”  +  %'(: w ŠA v wJy­ A®(# )'7E%';X:#® A#u  + #E:Y°A±)'%'(EP6

#: ­ AWSD $#: W]A# @i)' J:#($MW]A  + #D $#(XAYs

%'5"!r,P%')'%&9="e


 

^ug %'(f2%' M’Y%& ®)')',J %'(/"!” - A ²( + P)'%' $f=( +  

%'#J: w  Œ A v Š y ®A#®.

 .(Y$´­ ³ AWS $A6’ + )jsD LY(%' A%'( µ_¶G·2¸ w  w A v Œy ®A” a + =Jc:YsSA#±g 9-E:Y(Y$L¹.AYºT» ; E%'(A6rE)&`Y LW_ l ®.)')>, %'(/"e ]r

7; .’Y

AB( µS¼1¶g½ : w–xJ¾Ew‰ E: w  w A v ŽJy °#A  AY”  

JE:6®AYrVArE; + )'a:#(Y$L
A ­ AYrE %' ]¯L A rE)&`Y   +  %'(T%'(O”1Y%& J$M
 

EAYW_#6J .%'( ¿ ‚ š3„;À ‚ š|~}™€- ¶ z#;{ ‚ š|~€ ƒ ™gÁ2;™ ‚ { }„E: w  Œ A v  y ®A” a + =Jc2(Y$M¹A#ºT» ; E%'(AYW1%'E.P6 + (Y$1"e

 

- QªJ  *E+ %')>%'P

%kEAYB0( µj¶!·.¸ : Œ ‹JŠ ¾,Œw : w  w A v xJy5 Aug(##:Y”AYsY$%'%'

%' + ($/rVAr#D"3 EAV•](f # ” )'i%&9^" ­!*,+ %')'%'P#

%>A#B( µS¼1¶g½ w  w A v –Dy
RAug7( + J:
AY«gD

#:  A#±Y(Y$# D J:#ºA#s(Y$%&J: ®5A6rP6

%:($fºRA#ºGa%& (#%AYs

%'5"8(Y

,9,:)>,)'%&9 X:6($LT(# 

= 

7E%'5#

D7E%>$# 2A#²](# + P#)'%> #J$ =( +  

%'#J: w  Œ A v ‰Dy
RAug7( + J:”A#nRAs$#%'%&

%' + :Y®5AYrP6

%_($LºRAºA ºGa%' (%AV¯MD

. *,+ %')'%'P#

% + ¥7%>IR#

%'=)&Q0$ + )&Q~96 )'

%& #MAYB(Mà ¶g½µ w  w A v ‹ y ®A’YP#

%' (,J:®5A#Ä +   : ­ AY¯M(#7:YrVA sY$#%'%&

%> + :($/rVAr#(  JA•](MT
 

f”G

J %'( «gA#B(/Å ¶G·I½ : w ŠEA v ‹‹ y ®A’YP#

%' (,J:Y”As$%>%&

%' + :±IAWS)'1 JAYW1 )'i%&9^" +

g
g M *,+ %')'%'P#

%>AYWj#6J .%'( µj¼1¶g½ : w  Œ A v ‹ wDy °#AY’%'(EP + M:#”AYs$#%'%&

%' + :6r6A6rE(#  JA#r

%'(  #” -."G¯ + )& %>-]W_ (# %>  %'(A6° +

()X" ”  +   .($/rE9- ÆrE%'(.ŠL§ w ‹J¨;:Y#_A w ‹Q Œ ‹A v ‹Š y °#AY’%'(EP + M:#”AYs$#%'%&

%' + :  Ar#%:YrVA rE(#  JA#®¬¹1”H«Q0P J$O¯L;(%' £"3 ]Ä_J1- Q” -   +  %'(#A#B(MÅ ¶!·½ w  w A v ‹ Œy­ AY’#

 %'J$=(XAY«](

%'%&9L($M” (- %>(?” (,

)X%'( rE)&`Y   +  %'(#A²( + P)'%' J$^=( +  ;

%>J: w ŠA v ‹ ŽDy­ AY’#

%'J$=(X:®5A6«

(,H)>$M(Y$/r6 Ar(  JA#ÄXJ

(#%>(# %'(M
 

f” (, iEJZ ­ i#6;

%>(E)  + )& 1"3

 rE%' + )>D %>(A!Ç ‚ À;™ ‚ƒ6ÈRÉ }€ ƒ €ÀR|~}Ê] „ ‚Ë |~€{:6Š Ž Z – DQ‹ w ŠE: w E‹A

v ‹J  y ­ A’#

%'J$#=(_:¯?AYr J:6r6A6rE(#  J:(Y$M¹AYr# JA ­ i#6;

%>(E1(/ÄXJ

(#%>(#T2%& /Ä_%'%& J$^B(#"3

=D %>(_Z
](#Qª(7

(#: ­ i#6;

%>(ED %'(Y)S”1 J$:V(Y$^ # ®]$7(,]"8¹ %>(#^r)'JA6WjI6 .%'(oÇ ‚ À;™ ‚ƒ6È É }€ ƒ €ÀR|~}Ê] „ ‚Ë |~€{A ‹v xJy °#An

 EP6

; J:Y(Y$/r6AYr +

%A#º]%'; 

9fs8

%'](Y$ r#  -. Z (OAY¯MD =D %'"!•]6 D %>(   J

_: 6JD JA ‹ v w y  A#°Y

%j($M°#AW1 %'  %' E)'%'A   +  %'(T($MsS

%'(T%>(M ” 6; %' %'7]B(, 

(;JA#²( + P)'%' $f=( +  

%'#J: w  Œ A v wwJy rVA#±56, (Y$  AY«g

#AY® +  %'(M®.)'

%& #2"3

¯M

 ­G*,+ %')'%'P#

% + MA#WjI6 .%'( µS¼1¶g½ : w  Œ A Šv w y ’ A±)')&9,AY” Y

%'(=($^ D (,

)V"e ])k- %'5 DlA ­8+

6(/W_ (  %'(.(MWj)' + (#%'J %'(#:7) +  – §-‹ ‰‰x ¨2]ŠŠQ0Š x A v wŒy ±IA±(,2(Y$LuRAYrE 

%'(Q0±56D7VA#sS + )>D  %>(/(# ( -])')>, %'(O(L-Jt A#B(M•]6  %'(  J

 s

,J$%>(#.±•]B:# Œ ŠQ Œ– :j‹ ‰‰ EA v wŽJy­ A#± +    + #%>.($/”AYsY$#%'%&

%> + A @

- Q0   *,+ %')'%'P#

%>AB( µS¼¸½µ : Œ  Œ¾Œ ‹Š:‹ ‰‰‰ A v w  y
RA
]%' (M(Y$L®A  ((XA#®)'

%' #%'¯L;(#%>  ug %'(MB( µS¼1¶g½ ‹ ‰‰‰ A v wxJy ”AYsY$%'%'

%' + A®)'

%' #:6«g:(Y$^  B(, 

(#JAB( µS¼1¶g½ : xŒ‰D¾xŽ ŠE: w ‹A v w–D y Ä!AY¡ + %:EÍTA  AEÍ (:#ÍRA6Î6Y(:6r6AYrE(#  JA•](/rE)&`Y   +  %'(#I%'(LB(, 

(# Q0Ä_%'  ­ (E7E%&

((E AB0( µÏ Ç ½H¶ ¿M¿O: w ŠEA v w‰Dy W]A   +  $(_AW1

%>"8(Y

,9L%'2%'(Y$6(Y$(, " #g(;1

 6)'9,A6W_#6J .%'(@ÐE€ÑE{ ƒ6‚ œj€- ½ €ÀzYÑEš0;{ ‚ƒ6È µ …™š0;À µ }|~ ƒ };™ : w  Œ A v Š y W]A   +  $(_AYrE; )>P6;

I ;#J$ + )'%>(#I-  %'A6B0( µS¼1¶]½ :5‹ ŒD¾ ‹‹Š: w ‹A Šv ‹ y W]A   +  $(/($ ­ ³ AYWj $#AYnDdP$f%'. )&`Y 

 +  %'(,Ì@ÐE€ÑE{ ƒ6‚ œj€-gš3„ ¸½ ¿ w  w A v Š wJy rVAYr +

%:”A6W_ _:EÍRA6Î6 + AYr)&`Y LÄ_$M¹1)>(%>(#=($ ®1 %'5” (- %>(ˆ«gAWj6JD .%>( µ Å ¸¸ : w  Œ A Šv Š y ®AºG; A#
g f *,+ %')'%'P#

%>I%'(L6 %& %>7g ,%' %'2%&  #)'%'J %'(2 T"%')>%&09M)',J %'(_: Dl

 +  %>(#I(Y$  +  %'(#AYB(Mà ¶g½µ : w  w A