tions of the theory of learning to the mainstream of mathematics. ..... of language
acquisition mentioned in the introduction is a subject of debate among. 9 ...
% &
! "#$ "#$
! " # #
$% &'''( ) #
! "
*
+ , ) - " . /
" , 0
/ !
1 1 / / !,
) $*234( ! / ) $*252( ) , % $*263( 0 7
% / $*226( / $" ) ) &'''( 8
9 ! # !
) : :
.; 8 8 =
?
@ A* / Æ = / - B C Æ
@
' / 9
7
Æ / / 8 8 8 8 /
@
&
D E
# D E
,
" F $' *( G / @ 8 @
@ *
F 8 H ' * @ * &5 H >
) @ ) @ ) @ 1
= / D7 E = Æ
0 * 7 > $' *( 8
$' *( * @
+
)
*
'
'
= # = / $' *(
7 8 / 4
8
/ ) , ) , 7 8 8
/ 8 B H @
1
7
8
? 8 * ' 0 > 8 ' * 0
H # ) , * Æ Æ D / E >
, 4 3 , * , & / , 4 / =
: / D E D E
F
I D
E D,
=E
F
0
/ /
) + F J 1I
3
0 # / 7 " @ 8 ?
/ @ * 7 - @
@
@
@
@ @
=
>
? B
-
F D E >
7 ? = @ > # 1
? > 8 ? I
@
D /E /
= K
.=
>
@
? = 8
? 8 0 '
@
=
@
@
D/ E / 7 " , * /
@
>
A
) *
> = ) * B ) *
> # ) * >
! "
5
@ @ @
A
A
A
A&
¾
7 @
F , = * @
* @
? >
> @ @ / 'L /
, ) ,
, 3 @ 8 = @ @ '
M
- ,
= , I
? , I $)
*263( #
@
@ '
* )
$
&
* )
'
¾ ) &
- I = & $)
*263( , I FB
) & FBI
* )
&
1 - I
& A
FBI 0
& A 6
& * A * 4
4 3 F @ ' - I
4& FBI , I - I FBI
7 >
@ @ 1
C = )
>
) & / @ ! " ' > '
#
) *
&
¾
1 *
.= @ ' / @ ! A ! @
7
/ 0
# 2
/
=
> 7 - @
G
G
/ =
=
=
) 4 = 0 3 =
-
7
1 @
A
> 8 8 / M
F
0 M 7 = @
*
1
D E
8 / M C 1 B # ? @
*'
1 '
@ ' ,
) *
= ) @ A @ A *
, A
=
" * / G G B = 1 = ? =
, ?
$- *22K( 3* $1 *226( D E D E
=
= C
!
%
% &
*Æ $F
*22&L % / *226( C , ,N
C
# $ % 7 @ 8
7 @ 8 " = 8
@ ' !
F
# @ # #
1
D E # @ # A A # @ "A @
"
#$ %
**
@ * -
@ / *
" = 7 " F / @ " $ $ ' # & ' (%
= 7 % - >
%
=
&
&
%
@ '
F
&
@
& %
% @
' > " ? - " ?
' ( ' ( ( "
7 8 = B
= ? ) 1 = # )
&
@
* * &
F # 1 *
7 "
1 ) @ ' @ =
*&
0 + 0 "
) " & ' > + ,
= ? 8
I
= + ) 8 ) ' ? $0 8
-
= - $#( . - =
7 % - 7 > @ - / //
= 0 * , 0 4 , F
8OF0
- % F F Æ @
( )
)
'
0 K ,
-
? ! / - (
, ! /
* =
7 " - ' > " = $ ' @ @ @ ' ( (
$ " C = =
*4
! " # $ C - - I 0 7 % / $F
*22&L % / *226( 0 4 7 ) ' = ) 0 1 0 / ) = ! '
#
& *
)
'
6
@ @
*
1
B / B = 7 =
7
1 . @ * &
1
$
3 ? @ A &
@
A
&
*3
&
A
1
@ *
A *
&
&
A
@ A
3
¾
1 G G
1
, 7
& & > 8 - @ ' +
#
)
)
. 0
¾
7 0 @ / * 7 1
- ) 4
1
*
3
3 3 @
0
1
*
&
*K
. @ * 0
)
&
)
&
7 * & ¾ 8 / 4 - I D E - .
( 1 - @ *
#
#
1
)
'
8
&-
'
* &
1
@ @
¾
% # & # F P C
P , -
#
#
)
'
* Æ
) & * Æ *5
'2Æ2*
- * Æ A
A ! * Æ A A A & &
¾ 8 & 7 & -
!
#
*
#
'
& *
)
@ @
*5
¾
,N 0 M
,
K
, 0 4 9 ) * Æ Æ =
6 3 A
& *5 A *Æ & /
Æ '
& @
/ Æ - & Æ
*M
' # (
- , 3 F C =
= - 7 " (
$ ( @ " $ * @ "
( 3 3$ #
3
) K
" &
/ $, 0 *22'( = 7 ? * =
@ '
* *
1
3 3
4
3
$ ' $ @ $ F $ @ $
* =
@ . &Æ * &
@ Æ ' -
" *
#
(
+
3 A *
(
"
) ? = ( *
1 7 2 ( & * @ . A * 7 * @ A ( . @ * A * , * * @ @ .
* A A * 2 & * (
" 8 " %
*6
% ( @ % ( ( +
% *
% ( % ( & & & A *
% (
A * ?
( 3 A * ? (
* * ( % ( % ( ¾ 7 8
7 @ 3$ * A* 3$
3
3
$3 ( $3 ( 3 ( 3 ¾ ?
" 4 3 ? * =
@ '
* * 3 A *
!
" ? - > " ? = @ ( - 3 ( 3 & * ( @ $ ? 4 3 ( 3 ( 3 & * ) ¾ # % ' 8
+ 0
) " &
' > + ,
&#
# ' ( & $ )*+ ' + ' + % $ # $ % " (# ),*
-$ ' +
*2
7 (
$ + @ '( G / / / - 0 / $*25M(G 0 8 ) " &
* * 3 ' 4
? / ) @ ) ) @ ' 5 @ & 5 @ " $*225( *'K F 4 D E ) 0 4 + ( $ + @ '( ' #
A* * @
$4
4 7 3 @ $ 3 4 - 3 3 ' 3 '( 3 & * F
' ( $3 @ ' ( 3 2 2
$4
A *
¾ ) 5
* 4
) 5 $" *225( # % ' 8
- > 8 ! / > = -
0 K , 7 (
$
6 " 3 ' $ ' $4"
( 3 3
&'
4" 3 $
= Æ ' ) * Æ =
*5
6 3 A
$4"
* A * A Æ
' > " ' ' 4 4 0
0
1 @ #
$
0 0Q / *226( C $O / *2K2L % / *2K2L 7 9 / !/ *225L 9 &'''( 0 $ *22'(
) * &
@ '
@ '
@ ' ,
8 / K ,N 4 6
@ ' $- *22'L 7 -
*226(
! 1 ' #
!
) * &*
&3
*
,N " * 3 - ,N # % ' 7 "
@ " $ $ '
8 / 2 Æ ' ) * Æ
Æ =
&66 25$ A *
Æ
,N ) K # % ' 8
+ 0
) " &
' > + , 7 (
$ + @ '(
) 5 Æ ' ) * Æ
Æ =
&66 &34$ A *
Æ
K
F 4 3 # % ' 8
> = ! / - > 8 (
$ @ ( Æ ' ) * Æ
=
&3 $4" &66 A *
F 6 " 4" 0 5 &&
Æ
1 " 4 3 = " & D E $ " 4 3 %, =
,N ?
0 4
- *
#
7 ) @
!
!
ºººººººººººººººººººº
ºº ººººº ºº ºººº ººº ººººº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ººº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººº ººººº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ºº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººººº ºº ººº ººººº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ºººº ºº ººººº ºº ºº ººººº º º
0 )
& ) &
# 8
@ ¾
&4
)
*
,-
&3
'
¾
1
3 / =
'
- ,N ? @ 1 ' , ' '2#2* 4# # )
A 3 ¾
- ) M ,N
) # @ * 5 ) M - *
&3
A 2 &*
2 A / @ 2 & A ' = 2
&
¾ ) M 7 0 > = 0 @ @ 0 @ @
0 , #
7 @ 0 0
% .
# % / # /
0
&3
- +
3
0
@ $
A ( 3 $
(
( 7 K ¾ C 0
$
* ) A # 7 @ + - I 8 / 4 0 0 ) # - ,
#
# ' #
A
6
3 3
&
A A # A * A # A A 4
# A # *& A *& A
# * =
7 5 3
& A A ¾ - .
#
2 # A & & & 2 4# & A
'2#2*
'
&
&K
& & & A
@ @ @
& & A @ & & A & A & A & A & & A A & A
=
# C & & 3 # @ # & A 3 ) 4 & ? = ) 4 & & & & 3# 2
# 2 * & @ & & A
$ & - @ # A &# & A & A & A ¾ ) M
7 6 - ) 4 1 ,N 7 K -
@ 7 K
+ , @ 8 = * C F
/ 0 $. / . 9 0 *22M(
&5
7
% / %, % / , / $F
*22&L % / *226(
/
R - , ,N
%, C /
%, $
= 0 / F
!
+
?
@ A = ,
) * A 1
0 /
@
* = " K
9 &M
C ? / / C
9 I ,
0
7 / & @ " ? # @ # # 2 '
;
@
.
* =
> '
'
.
@
;
'
¾
. ;
=
.
@
$
% . $
; .
? > 2 '
. ; ; .
4 K / $0 " F F
" ,
"
'
' @ ' ( (
$ " 1 < 4 & + @
0 * " % ( !
$
'2?2)
' ! %
@
A
"
4K
* $
A 1
@ $ '
& "
$ '
& "
* $
1
4 & + @ ; @ ¾ " 4 / % @ 7 " 3
% @ " @ *
* # & -. &
" 4 8 ! * ) " & ? '2?2) $ ' ( $ + @ '( #
" 4
,
!
4
*
$
1
) ?
A
7 H > + 7 # @ HA ?
> ' #. > + . 4 4 '
& + . 4 & . #. & 4 & . M - + ,
# > F
7 " = @ # ) @ >
(# " $4 "
( + + @ $ ' & A $ ' & A
0
1 3 $
'
&
A
"
*
$4
=
M > @ ?
# 4 1
45
1
# A 1
/ 4 @ 4 4 ? 0 $ *225( ¾ K ? ? ' 2 ? 2 * & 1 2 $0 8 >
@
- /
42
/% /
= , , >
-
- 7 @ - / )
-
- >
%%
8 -/ @ - /
$
-
'
%
%
$
%
=
@
% ,0 - /
-
%
- /
/
- -
- /
- /
0 - -
%
%
%
% - / -
?
0 % - - / - /
" * - I $ **3 $O ? *2MK(
¾
- 8
-
= - $#( . - =
%
$
$
-
-
3'
>
% .
)
? I - ? #
- /
%
/ @
% @
-
$ (
- #
* @ - $#( . - 0 =
¾
! / - - > 8 = > # 0 & , 7 *
*
@ '
+ @ 4 ¾
*
3
F @ ;
;
; ;
!
- >
#
/
(
)
8
#
%
+
- / @
/
"
"
* $F *2M4( @ $' *( % 7 8 3*
*
@
-
%
- / @ / * - @
@ F
-
%
-
@ *
* =
. ¾
- . & = - % ! / - > 8
!
! '
- @ -
-
(
!
U>
%
0
%
- / @
U U/ 3&
>
/
- / -
-
/ /
,0 4 ¾ 1 & - 0 4
U F & 8OF0
/ F
1 # $*2K'( 433 &
"F ! 7 + - = +
@ #- & @ 1 C --
)
'
& @
1
# C - /
7 +
/ = 0
+ F + @ 0 @ 2 = + + / - -- 0 @ - / @ - -- - & + &0 @ & 0 + + 2
@ - - @ -
+ ¾
%
? ! I - U 0
34
! I /
- / @
/ @
U U/
U > 0 - / U U/ @ U U A U/ U/ &U U/ @ - A - / / &- / / - ¾ & , '
*
'
*
8 / 4 7 + @ @ ; ; 0
/ + F
@
&
;
@
&
8
/
@ U U/
+ 4
?
-
@ @ @
!
+
@
+
@
-
/- / @
-
¾
'
@
-
@
¾
+
? - 4 7 * + ) 3
+
@ - - +
+ -- @ '
/ -- @ / @ '
& ¾ 3 F + =
%
%
8 / * + U
F F =
F F = 0 8 @ F
3K
! , * 9 / - / / = ) K
/
8 0 $*246( Æ
8 / = 8 > ' 8
? '
' * ? ' F
*
- /
@
*
8
#
#
8
8
/
@ '
$
> '
8
-
>
-
8
)
¾
( )
2%
- / @
@ 8 A /
- /
# '
, /
- = ) K ? @ / ? @ 8 A ? ¾
/ ,
K @ * @ 8
/ = 8OF0 ! / ! / ,
K
) K # % ' 7 @ 8
@ # @ # # # 1
@
"A "
/ /
& @
B 4
35
@
&
@
F V 4 @ # V # V Æ
#
8 7 M , *3 $- ,/ 0 0 *226(L /
7 @ 8 - > 8 / / " 8 7 U> 8 4 &
B
/ U U/ @
/ 4
@ / @ - /
- = / / . - $( U/ U/ . U/ - $( @ - $(
0 - - ! / 8OF0
- P + @
/ & + - 0 + = + - + @ + % > 8 8 = % @
/ # 0
3M
U = % U @ *% * 4 8 %
/ $33 $0 *223(
8 @
- = +
/ 0
- -
@ - / @
- 0
C - @ - -- =
- - @
-
4 /
4
4 4 4/ @
4 /
-
+ ¾ @ +
7 & @ & 8 & DE
&
F # @ # # 1 D E @ @ * &
7 > 8 8 8 / * A / 8 U @ * 4 U U/ @ -
U > 8 - / *
1 / F
- / @ /
36
% ( - . &
( 3 $ 3 ' ! 3 - > 8 > , 4" " 6 " 4" 6 " 3 ' $ ' #
( )
12'3
,
4"
-
#
$ '
'2?2)
$4" 3
Æ
4"
*
3 !
< ; 4
8 4
Æ ' ; 1Æ
/ /
%
( 3
;
$
4
'
0 & $0
'
( )
,
¾
32
+ .
?
.
@
.
*
-
.
@
.
*--
-
* --
/
/
-
* --
. -
= ,0
¾
7 $ ' - 4 & , @ ) @ * ? @ * & ; @ & * @ * $
$ 5 $
7 > ' . @
>
$ $
$
+ .
- 7 4
& $*
$ . $ & $ $
$ .
0
$ ' 7 & ) @ > @ 46 & ? @ 46 3 Æ @ 6 3 4 @ . " 4 *' 4 @ 8Æ " *' , + "
6 " 0 " 8
I + " , ?
" +
K'
" I 3 , '" 4 " 4
@ '"
' ' '
"
4 4
*
"
= / 4" @ 4 4
( 3 & * 3 $ ¾
'
4
7 - 0 * ,
/ @ 3 =
3
@ A @
= @ ' ? 3 = ) 6 C 3 3 - C 3
,
3
@
'
3
@ A @
4 * , + @ ) @ * @ ; @ 0
@
< ; A @ 8 & > 8 8 B 8 & @ B &
4 8 8 B & @ B &
& 4 3 4
8
8
8 , . @ * @ A 7 @ @ ! + 2%
@
#
.
9
I
7 8
@
?
.= *
& > 8 8 @ *
&
@
9 9
I $-#Q / *225( 0 $. 0 &'''( )
*6 $0 &'''( +
-
! "# $ % & '
()#) # * +$ %, ' - % &' . %'' / ! " "0("0 1
KM
0 # 2
0 ' $* +*' %
' '' ' $% ("" /' ' & ' 0 "( " () * ' *3 45 '$ '' 0 + , * .6 7 ' 2 ! # " *3 45 '$ '' " # $ % * '$ ' % '8 ' *
'* 3$ * , '' 5 %- ()# & & $ " ' ' 5 + +* !3 ' ' -% 7(# & # ( # . ( 6 * '' &) ### 9 :' * 5 * '$' *' ;% ' / #(" &* + $ 2%* # 0 1 2 ') ) & , - 0 ! " 2 3 4 *3 45 '$ '' '" - # - # ###
%, 9 &' % 2 ' -% ("# , & 1 ' ,' 6 * % ' # -55 7("# , ) , # ", ' ." " # ' 15 %3 ' . ." * -" " $ $ ' ' % ' ' &) -6 (70 % / # + % 7 * 5 +$ ';% '' #""" # 66 )(7# # 0 70 ? 3 & @
-7 "(# $ $ 0 " 0 8 * 2 % % # ) 6 %%' ' ** 5%' 5$ 9 9 7 "( # 0 * . ''
K6
# 7 # + A% 6 * %3 ' '
# 7 " *3 45 '$ '' # - * 5' 3
#
: ;5 ("" # ) & 7) * 2 + $ ) * 2 3 ", -6 #)(#"0 = %* > - #0(## 0 ### * 3 *' + %$ . 2 6 6$ C+ D ,% /' = ! * () 6 & 1 ## /'* +* $ - 0 * 2 3 ", #= 9 2%* " 2 * 7) 6 $ 3 ;$ )( ) " ) $ ### " * " *3 45 '$ '' * * 7 + ' * " ) # ### . % * '8 3 - * '$ $ *' * ' ' . # * =
' "(" '' CC * " " * 9%& %'' /' ' ' * # * '' 0 % $ # 4 2 .6 % + 7 , * %, &' '% 5 * ' $ %*3 ' * '
9 7 # 9 % ?C
*2PP " *2PP NNNNNNNNNNNN NNNWNNN *2PP NNNNNNNNNNNN NNNWNNN % * !
K2
*
#
'
$ %*3
" +*
*
* ) # %, " %, * " '* % * ) ' ) ' +* " 3' 5 3 * !3 ' " ! E:' ;%$ 7 * %' $*' )0 $ '' ' # 5 + & )# ' ';% ' ") & # * ' '
'' % 0 % & !3 ' ) '* 3 5 /*3 * ' 0 :' ;%$ % #
* # 2 '
))
#
½
)#
" " Þ " À # ÀÞ )
7
Þ
" À # 0 Þ #
)
#
) " " " 0 " " " D ' :' ;%$ 7 3 ' - 3' 5 E 3$' 5:' ;%$ 7 * - 5 %*3 ) % Þ
5'
*3 ) 5 $ )7 = $ % )
5*
