On the performance of content distribution networks - IBM Research

10 downloads 23 Views 546KB Size Report
On the Performance of Content Distribution Networks. Dakshi Agrawal, James Giles, and Dinesh C. Verma. T. J. Watson Research Center. International ...
     "!$#&%' #)(+*,-#& /.0132 45% 687:91?A@CBD7FE7HGJI-KSGSNP;TIU7MVWX68>SVNY;Z=\[A]^_NYBDLO7 ]K]-ab7:cZ;)deVgfANP;)NP7:BDhi=j[NPV3c)NYB klV3c)NYBDVU7:cZ` >SdeVU7HGnm o;)>pVUNP;Z;qr7HhZ=>SVNP;A[dHBistdCBD7:c)>pdCV ue|+vx7Fw E7TEycZ=UdCqbBDVU>SGSNeGzIfA}>S{C~€NYB5 fAde7MW ƒ:„T…P†M„F‡M„:ˆ-‰8ŠP„Z‹3ŒHD…3ŽˆYŒHU‰5YMŒT†‹ev3„HH‘Mu3’F‚ “e-”•ŽZ–F‹—”™˜FšZ‹ ›+¹ NYœEdCBiW;TžŸz T¡Y¢¤£l¡Y¢'¥§¦©¨ª¢¤«¬¦©­M®:¢¤¦© F¡¯ £&¢J°n F«¬±3²)³-£l«¤´µ F«¬¶R·¡H¸l£ ¿Mº©¦©¸)·D¢¬¦Æ T¡H¨¢¬ «¤£Z¨ª£)«¤ËT£1«¤£Z¨ª T®M«¬¸l£)¨°¦Æ¢¤ÂH¦Æ¡R¢¬ÂM£ ¡H£&¢J°n F«¬±­P»£lëPÎ ¡C·º©»P¨¤¦¼¨l²M½§¨ª£)«—¾£)¨¤¿C T¡H¨¤£ÁÀ1¦©¶£ ¿Mº©¦©¸l¦Ñ¢Ò¨ª¦©ÍF¡H·FºÆ¦©¡MÍCÈnÀ1ÂM£¥§¦ÆÊe£)«¤£)¡T¢¬¦©·¢¤£ZÄÅåP£l«¬ËP¦©¸l£Aè ìDêU·¿H¿M«¤ Y·F¸™Â ¿M«¬ DËP¦©Ä:£Z¨¢¬ÂM£8¡M ¢¬¦Æ T¡Ö ´—¶®MºÆ¢¤¦©¿MºÆ£8¢J»P¿e£)¨  ´§¸lº©·T¨¤¨¤£)¨°¦Ñ¢¬ÂM¦©¡ ?Am w ` fA?5[ ` ¤ ¢ À1ÂM¦¼¨¿H·¿e£l«¿M«¬£)¨¤£l¡Y¢™¨ ·F¡Ã·F¡H·º©»:¨ª¦¼¨  ´—¢¬ÂM£¿C£)«ª´µ T«¤¶R·¡C¸&£8 ´ ¢¤ÂHÂC£·¡x¡M£l ¢J¢¬°zÂM T£l«™«¤¨)±,ÈA°ݗ¦Ñ¢¬ DÂà°n¨¤£l FËT¶£l«Z£²'Ä:¸lº©®M·T£R¨¤¨¤¢¬£) ¨ ¢¤ÍFÂM£l£,¢ª¢¤¦©Ä:¡M£)Í,¸l£l­C¡Y£l¢¤¢ª«™¢¤·£)º©« ¦Æí)¢¬£)«¤ÄÜ£Z·D¡H¢¬·¶ ¢¤®M£)¡Y«¬£¢ ¸& T¡Y¢¤£l¡Y¢ÅÄ:¦¼¨J¢¬«¤¦©­M®:¢¬¦Æ T¡Ç¡M£&¢J°n F«¬±:¨lÈÉÀ1ÂM£x£&Ê3£)¸&¢¤¦©ËF£)¡M£)¨¬¨ ´·  ´¢¤ÂH£ÓÔ¡Y¢¤£l«¬¡M£l¢)²M¦Æ¢—¦©¨—®M¡H¸&º©£)·F«—°ÂM£)¡¨¤®H¸™Â ã  Yå,·¿H¿M«¤ Y·F¸™ÂM£Z¨ ¸& T¡Y¢¤£l¡Y¢Ä:¦¼¨ª¢¤«¬¦Æ­M®M¢¤¦© F¡Ì¡M£&¢J°n F«¬±ÅÄ:£)¿C£)¡HÄM¨ T¡Ì¶·F¡P»+´S·F¸&¢¤ F«™¨)² ¦©¡H¸&º©®HÄ:¦©¡MÍR¢¬ÂM£_¢J»P¿C£_ F´ÂM T¨ª¢¤£ZÄ8·F¿M¿Mº©¦©¸)·D¢¬¦Æ T¡ gý Mþ ; !!.-TC:Bÿ MÿF;ý eYü Yý¬Mþ O2 ý#ÿ "  þ lü  !þ :1þ EF YýV4! Mþ- ÿ FeYü !ªý ¬ÿFü:ý¬1þ 5) i |ˆ]‰3|ˆ r ‰|Šˆ#‹c3Œ ÿ D! %  Dý¬þ ! 0012 Ž  "+#ÿ " 0Ɗ  5Õý L7eÿ 7+ý¬1þ 4Ì ÿ q +Tl% û ,Ðý   &ý¤þ©ÿ Z) Ž þ /, þ 0 02.1ÿ ý  4 0Mµ ü •ý¬þÆÿ ¤ü ‡ $þ lÿ %_5Tü  Dý¤þ©ÿ k.zÿ  þ &ÿ  !&ýÒþ 401!4Yý ý¤þ©ÿ Üÿ -¤ÿFý¤%  !Cÿ 7Åý¤þ  ) > Xý Mþ ;Jý¬ ü %2.8@ÿ A&ÿ 0 ^ªü 4 L + ý 0¤ÿ8 Dý 1þ 7!" 

þ 4lÿYý!Tý=Mþªý¬þÆûHü:ý¤þ©ÿlýzÿ  :0©þ15Tý 012 0ÆÿŠ %;  ¬ÿ 3 012;&ÿ _5F ü  !Z) iZ;s‘m Œ’“|Š€ y 3>  ?& ÿ 5J ý !^&ý nÿ  F.!`=”T•Glÿ (, 5 þ ý¬1þ 4lÿTü: ý \ 3 û 8 ü 7Kû 2 ý ?0©ÿ  - ÿ b&ÿ !&ý¤þ©ÿ &ý¤ ü G  & ý !.¤1þ (_ ý /0Æþ Yý= ?Mÿ- ]25ý¬ÿ KMÿ# ý  ý &ý¤ ü q  &ý k ]"t3û !q0©ÿ ª!ý ) 5ÿT ü G ]"Š2‡0©ÿ b)¢HLI&ÿ ª$þ %!Xý Aµÿ 010©#ÿ þ 5+Tlû ,  ý  •ý¤þ©ÿ z û 2Yý  §(.4!:þ©ü ¨¤¥©©¦rKû 2Yý !§ª. £ `g O! ÿ V4 010T¤¥¦bK  0$  54¤¥«yK û 2Yý  §\_0!!) û %!8ÿT%û ¬!& ý !) £ `g O!1 ÿ a*S`?`?•t 5!TþÆý  !    K "  0 &  ý

   Æ þ ý  G  :  þ 1 F E  

   Yý ?   ¤  ÿ %   ! 

 ª  þ  5  ý¤þ  ) Ž £ f1þ 5T ü  [¥1þ 00Æü J ý  ý !Z(6%!¤þ 4Yý 0  !¤ü 0Ñý Fµÿ Z 1û ¤þ [ "K01lý ?M$þ lý¤ ü  - 7 010F_0) `-! 6%!¤þ 4Yý 4M#ÿ ý  ý µ ÿ  C5Fþ "!P 0Æ$þ  , ý¤þ©ÿ k.  !&"§ a!&'(*) 0~T¨;¦= Y;1,,¢  L9(5(?!67 > Lh,s§ ©|JL"  qªzY+ «K37  %(yG, 99%!&0;= &J ¬ ,;1} 4­J¬ '(GYU GY',9_1J''tGY 9îYèâç,ß9àãàå¢àáç6åìâíâߣãç,ìïçì>â3ðâJà8âã ë ß êñ èçàå^ã ê àâ0ã;ðiò¡àá çâJì8ìç óëçã àãôbÞ:ߣàá âãmî ê ã çéVàá ç ê ïç,ìõ êþVíÿ ç>îYèâJçßàõ$ö ç,ìåìâJíâJߢãç,ìïç,ì ô ç âèè ê í ê âß ê ããë äçtàá ê à ê ãë ììåí ê àç]ßç,çæãVìåë íáèJò àáçnã ê äç_ß9ëä ñ ç,ì~å?ð|ìåë ßæ#õ$àìâJöã_ú`åìàá çnã ê äç_ß#ë ä ñ çì~å?ð ö ê î çYàràì ê ßãäbâ0ãã âåßã ÿ àåyãç,ìïç%àá ç¡îYèâç,ß9à ê ãràá çXåìâíâß ãç,ìïç,ì é ê ßæ ê ããë äç>àá ê à ù ô #âJßîYçàá ç8ìçæ âJìçîYõ àâåßrî ê ß ñ ç2æ&åß ç~âJßbà ånìåë ßæ#õ$àìâJömàâäçãú`åß çìåë ßæ#õ§àìâö àå­âJßâ3àâ ê àçaàá ç£îYåßß çîYàâåß ê ßæKåßç¡ìåë ßæ&õ§àìâöNàåÅã çßæ àáç2ìç ó9ë çã à ê ßæbíç,ààá ç/ìç æ&âJìçîYàâåß ÿ é ç âJèè ê ããë äç~àá ê à /ù ô çbî ê ßXç ê äâß ç>àá çmö ç,ìðiåìä ê ßî,ç>å?ð ê îYåß9àç,ß9à_æ&â0ã;õ àìâ ñ ë&àâåß£ß ç,à åì ñ ò¡îYåäö ê ìâJßíMàáçbìçãö åßãç8àâJäçå?ð ê ãâJß íèJçrãç,ìïçìnãò&ã;àç,ä àå%àá ê àå?ðcàá çMîYåß9àç,ß9àæ&â0ã;àìâ ñ ë&àâJåß ß ç,à åì kô åìàá â0ãmî,åäö ê ìâ0ã åßpé ç âèJèëãçràá ç6ì ê àâå^å?ð àáçrà å¢ìçãöåßãçàâäbç ã ¡ù[÷ *÷ ê ßæ ,ø2ù{÷ ø 5÷ ðiåì àáçhàì ê ßãö ê ìç,ß9àbãë ììåí ê àç ê ìî 78 = 78< 78; : 789 : : ;.:Y Z1:Y [1: Y \4:Y ]6 L"M :Y 6:Y 96: Y Œ Ž‘ ’ “ ”“–•˜—™

ÿ ÿ

: Y9 

 ./ 01/ 21 / 34/ 56/ 6 / 1/ 6/ 6 / "! f ghijk il m ngmjIopq

ã

À

Å « ¬ Ô

ˆ §†

u| u

a 

vxy t uv

 

w

ˆ

£¦ œ¥ ¢£

¤ 

‡ §©

ž ¡

a ƒ

œ ž

a d ^_b ^_` ^_ e a ` ^_ d ^_c ^_b a ^_` a a b.a €1a 1a  ‚4a ƒ6a c6a  d1a e6a `6a  r"s

Ÿ

‡ §« ‡ §Š „…ˆ „…† „… ‹ „… Š „…‰ „…ˆ ‡ „…† ‡ ‡ ˆ.‡§ ¨1‡§ ©1‡ § ª4‡§ «6 š"› ‡§ ‰6‡ § Š1‡§ ‹6‡§ †6‡ §

‡ §†

Å « ¬

À(Ó

º ¡Úš+¤O˜Ãž˜•JšF›Ÿ¥"š+¤O”g•F³2Ÿ³;˜ž±

« ¬ ½ « ¬

ˆ §Š

b x

{~ t} z{

©Z›4žS›Ÿ¥;²›Z¡¨š+˜¡¨šJ´ ¢¹”X•Jš+ž”XœO§¹š+”X›Z¡¡O˜*š ­ ³O§¹š

ÿ

b `

Å « ¬

ç ›4žNš¤O˜uš+žŸ¡£•+–$§2²*˜¡¨š/•J§£ž+ž›Z ¨ƒš+˜Ÿž²¤O”š˜²*š+§Ož˜Z± ­ Z••+§O® ˜iš¤£ƒšvÅG« Æ¿ ÇÈ

ÿ 

b d

ÒËЈÀåâxˍÎÒӆÑ5ËÐZÔJÔ=À(ӌÀjˍÍiâ ã

: Y=

ÿ

Å « ¬ Ô

ª

¾äã

: Y]

ÿ



Å « ¬

« ¬ Ë Ð ½ « ¬

Q

ÿ

 /

« ¬ Ë Ð ½ « ¬

: Y[

O

N OP

”X¡O  ˜*Õ¹³Ož˜••J”X›Z¡£•Œ¥c›4žß1àOá

ß*à

OV

 /

¤O”X–$˜Nš+¤O˜"•J§£ž+ž›Z ¨ƒš+˜”g•v”X¡@š¤O˜ˆ•Ÿ® ˜N²›Z® ®§O¡£”š™

¡£¢O˜žŒš+¤O˜•J˜Z••J§£®u³Oš+”X›Z¡£•± ­

;

TU

 /5 &

#

%$Z•fš¤O˜G²*–X”X˜¡¨š¯ Þ

R

UX NW

 /2

%'(

˜

; Y9

*#, )*

Ö Ù$Ó ±S”¥^š+¤£˜7›Zž”X Z”X¡5•+˜ž©Z˜ž/”X•–X›L²ƒš˜¢5”X¡ÜŸ¡O›Zš+¤O˜ž

; Y=

 /

ËÐÚ¾ÛÓZÙ Ö5²*›4ž+ž˜•+³2›4¡£¢O•š+›5š¤O˜µ•+§Ož+ž›Z ¨ƒš˜7œ;˜”X¡O Ü²*›Z´

–X›L²ƒš˜¢  Z˜š

ÓZÙ ÖO± ­ ×

? @ABCD BE F G@FCIHJK

Òì¨Ô

¬®­÷;õöï°¯ ávɆ–X® ›4•Jš–$”X¡O˜Zž†¢¹˜²ž+˜Z•+˜ˆ”X¡-ß à

Z•

Ë Ð

¢O˜²*ž˜4•J˜•

­

ç ›4ž`š+¤O˜SšžZ¡£•+³£Ÿž˜¡¨šE•J§£ž+ž›Z ¨ƒš+˜SŸž²¤O”$š+˜²1š+§£ž+˜4±*¶OÕ ˜

­

”$–X–†§£•+˜Ã˜*Õ¹³Ož˜••+”$›4¡£•

ÓZÙ ÖO±·Z¡£¢

ˍÎ\¾

Ö Ù‘æ

ˍÍe¾

•+›Ãš+¤2ƒšš¤O˜7³£ž+›¹²*˜•+•+”X¡O -š+”X® ˜F¥c›Zžš+¤£˜

²*–X”X˜¡¨šJ´ •J§£ž+ž›Z ¨ƒš+˜® ˜••+Z Z˜ ˜*ÕO²¤£Z¡O Z˜

­

”$š+¤eÃ²4²¤O˜ ®u”g••/”X•

µ

¹ º»¼½¾ ¼¿ À ÁºÀ½ÂÃÄ

ß àáâãä âå æ çàæãIèéê Û

´ ÒÔ

Ú øú

Ë

ñ

ÎÑ ÇÐ

È ÍÎ Ï È ÉËÌ Ç ÈÉÊ

ô÷ íö

´ ÒÖ

î óô õ î ïñò í îïð

´ Ò·

´ Ò³

±²µ ±²³ ±² ¸ ±² · ±²¶ ±²µ ´ ±²³ ´ ´ µ.´Ò Ó1´Ò Ô1´ Ò Õ4´Ò Ö6´Ò ¶6´ Ò ·1´Ò ¸6´Ò ³6´ Ò Å"Æ



$ )

!( &' !

"$%# !"

×ØÛ ×ØÙ ×Ø Þ ×Ø Ý ×ØÜ ×ØÛ Ú ×ØÙ Ú Ú Û.Úø ù1Úø ú1Ú ø û4Úø ü6 ë"ì Úø Ü6Ú ø Ý1Úø Þ6Úø Ù6Ú ø

      

9

= > ?@AB @C DE>DAGFIHJ

8 XZ Q

TW MV

,2

NU

ST M NO ýþ ýþÿ ý þ  ý þ  ý þ  ý þ  ýþÿ

+, -., /. , 01, 23, 3 , ., 3, ÿ3 , 

8 X\

N

OQRP

, ,ÿ

Ú øÝ

Ú øÙ

,/ '*

Ú øü

8 X;

ÓÕÝ qsr6‰Gor¸wrƒl  lwqGsr±q  lIˆ_À€r6oxƒ”p  x¯lImšq„…ˆyrƒo¿o½˜ow  lIŸGo¤w ˆGm Ž  o m  tvlx  rƒlI“p”  lnˆymÞmpo  £ŒˆGr6ؾœgÊmÁˆ 6‚ or–£¤ˆyr6tŠx’¿qs‡p‡Šnlwq Ž  Il ˆGmbx¯£_l 6‚ rƒoIq  lIŸGon™uqsr6‰GoßqG…ˆy”pm  ˆs‹vtpq  q ŽÜ r±qsmŠxƒ…†lIx6xƒlnˆym qsmbtàxƒ…€qsInor€‡pr6ˆ›wox6xlImp‰  lI…†o­“˜ompo ¼p©ƒ‚ og…ˆ—x  “›™àq w ˆym  om  tvlx  rƒlI“p”  lnˆym¬mŠo  £ŒˆGr6ؘœ Ê  Ó máˆyr6tvor  ˆºr6otv”bw o 6‚ oÚrƒox‡˜ˆGmŠxƒo  ln…†oڈs‹qÛwˆGm  om  tvlx  rƒlI“p”  lnˆym×mpo  £ŒˆGr6ØÕxlI‰Gmpl ¼ wqsm  I™ÛlImÙw ˆy…†‡Šqsr6lIxƒˆGm  ˆ ƒ‚ o.rƒox‡˜ˆGmŠxƒo  lI…†o.ˆs‹ßqxƒlImp‰GIošxorƒŸyor’›l  lx_ox6xƒom  lqs  ˆ ‚ qПyoqsr6‰Go€wrƒl  lwqGßr6q  lIˆ­Àk’¿x…€qsI®xƒ”pr6rƒˆy‰yq  o  ˆ­w Ilnom  r6ˆG”pmŠt ށ rƒlI‡  ln…†oG’bqsmŠtžqsr6‰Go3wqGw ‚ o ް‚ l  r±q  oGœ Ó »kŸyomž‹ˆGr3²G³›´âwqGw ‚ o ŽÜ‚ l  r±q  oG’˜~  x ‚ ˆy”pt{“bonoxƒx ƒ‚ qGm ³pœ¶  ˆ†rƒotv”Šw o1r6oxƒ‡bˆymŠxo  lI…†o3ˆs‹}q†wˆGm  om  tvlx  rƒlI“p”  lnˆym mpo  £¤ˆyrƒØ  ˆ ‚ qsn‹}ˆG‹ ƒ‚ q  ˆs‹ßq†xlImp‰yno.xƒor6ŸGorœ ã•ä®e›åsæ€çbè¥éc^æ^Çåyêpë„ìµêvæ^Çç ÊmáˆGr±tvor  ˆàx  ”Štv™ ƒ‚ o+o ½¾ow  x¬ˆs‹šw r6l  lIwqs1r6q  lIˆŠ’„£Œo qGx6xƒ”p…†o ƒ‚ q  ~dÞÂí³pî¶v’k~}¢ïÂí³Šî ¶p’kqsmŠtº~d ðÂñ¹Gî ³pœóòÚo wqGm ¼ ‘ 6‚ o–ŸqGn”po–ˆs‹¤~}µxƒlImŠw ol  x¥o½˜ow 3‚ qGx3qGnr6oqytv™¬“˜oom ox  qG“pIlIx ‚ ot  ˆÁ“boônlImpoqGr€‹ˆGr¬qÞ£_lItpogr6qGmp‰GogˆG‹3ˆ ƒ‚ or©‡Šq Ž r±qs…†o  orŸÐqGn”ŠoxœÁ¦dlI‰G”Šrƒox¶+qsmŠtºõ+x ‚ ˆ£ 6‚ o{r6q  lIˆôˆs‹•rƒo Ž xƒ‡bˆymŠxo  ln…†oxkz ª qGmŠtz | r6oxƒ‡bow  lIŸGon™yœ Ô ˆ 6‚ r6q  lIˆyxßtvow r6oqGxƒo …†ˆGmpˆ  ˆymplIwqsIn™3qGx ƒ‚ o¤w r6l  lwqs—r±q  lIˆ¥ÀµlnmŠwrƒoqGxƒoxœiöuomŠw o„qs‡ Ž ‡pIlIwq  lnˆymŠx ƒ‚ q š‚ qПGo†qžIqGrƒ‰yowrƒl  lwqGßr6q  lIˆŠ’ 6‚ q  lx’iqsr6‰Go  r±qsmbx…†lxƒxƒlnˆym ŽÜ lI…oÚqsmŠt÷x…€qGn3‡pr6ˆvw ox6xƒlnmp‰ ށ ln…†oÚqsr6oô…†ˆGr6o IlnØyoI™  ˆ×“˜ompo ¼p ‹r6ˆG…øq×wˆGm  om  tvlx  r6ln“p”  lIˆGmÏmpo  £ŒˆGr6ؾœ Ò ‚ oxo ¼ ‰G”Šrƒox1qGIxƒˆ¬x ‚ ˆ£ 6‚ q 3ƒ‚ o‡˜orƒ‹ˆGr6…€qsmŠwoˆG‹Œqžw ˆGm Ž  om  tvlx  r6ln“p”  lIˆGmmpo  £ŒˆGr6Ø1tpˆ—ox}mpˆ  w ‚ qsmЉGo®…–”Šw ‚ ˆymŠw o ƒ‚ o w r6l  lwqs¯r±q  lnˆ†ˆG‹ ƒ‚ ošqs‡p‡pIlwq  lnˆym¬‰yˆ›ox„“˜o™GˆymŠt+¹³pœ

8 X7

46465579 464655

Ú ñ

^]VYb€€ij[«n{ÊÈ[$j^]kg€+he^œ\_|ˆIj0h˜h$j‚[‰Xxj[˜a TŽ[]VYW_Zd0jSa TŽ[œh]fZj

¦OÁ

 C=

Ú Ú

 C @

h]fxY’hKl„TWkZ€wmVSTŽ^˜hQˆIj‚_gj‚¸gh{a []TŽVŲ’Yb[$\TWkZ^KR„ƚǡYW[$defZ\+h$jdÉh$kg[$j^–

 C B

ΊL³Ï/L™J’L™Ð{ÑWL³Ò

 Ú Ú ý  Ú Ú ü Ú û û

ÌÎÍ Ï Ð + Ñ Ò'Ó Ô+Õ'Í Ô Ó ÖØ×Ý Ú Û Ì Í ÏÐ + Î Ñ Ò'Ó Ô+Õ'Í Ô Ó ÖØ×Ü Ý Û Ì Í ÏÐ + Î Ñ Ò'Ó Ô+Õ'Í Ô Ó ÖØ×Ù Ú Û ÿ

Ý Ü þ ý å æè éè êbëÎìîí%ëÎéè ï ç ü

Ó Ä0Ô Ù

ûÚ

 =

B

A

  @ ? " #&% '(% )+*-,/.0*'(% 1 $ >



·MYWVYb\¾—Kjdefg_gTŽ€iTŽW\j^ƒ¢~_Zdb–UÕ¾Ö]×e×ÙØ…ÚbÛÅÜeڒÝxÞ/ׂÝZޅߒàáÉÞÙÖÉà â‚ã¢ä Á

ޑà ڒݮá‚ׂÖÉåà Üe׿Àf™h]h]X¾P&çWç’lFlFl– YW·MYWVYb\‘– d‚TWV»–

=

Ó ËMÔ{脀Yb·ŽjWƒI餖iƒ脀YŽde·IƒxƏ–ƒQR„Yb[$€^]TW_¾ƒx꼖iƒƚYM²™\j^ƒ §

DFE GIHKJMLONQPSRUTWVSXZYW[]\^]TW_`TbacYb[edefg\ih]jd0h]kg[$j^mlF\ih]fonKprqtsgu(v

–iƒxë`YW_gZƒ

ì{–ƒQYb_xwrë`j‚\^]^ƒQë햾ƌjd‚j‚V«ˆxj[ÄîWîŽïg–ðŒÝ¡ñ’Ö]Üeò³à-Þ×eÜ0ޑã¢Ö]×có0ÚbÖ

Yb_xwyn{z|q}sZu v

ߒà ôŒ×0Ö]ׂÝZޑà ñ’Þ×eß±á‚×0ÖÉåà Üe×Éá‚æoõcÍ{RöËb÷³“Wv¢–`fŽh]h]X¾P&çWç’lFlFl–`a YWø³^‚– TW[$³çœ[]a d‚^Éç[]a dËb÷³“M÷x– f™h$V‰€‘–

~_Yb€€gd‚YW^]j^ƒbl„jF_gTbh$j…h]fZYbh†h]fgjcwg\+‡j‚[$j‚_Zd‚jFˆxj‚hlUjj‚_‰h]fZj

Ó ù Ԅè„[eYWw¢j_¾ƒKõœ–iƒ”RU€Yb[$·IƒÆ«–iƒ†Yb_xw|é³fgj‚_Z·Wj‚[ƒ†é–”ÄîWîb÷x–¥ú0ÝZÞ×0ä

hl„TŠYb[edefg\ih]jd0h]kg[$j^‹\^Œ_gjW€\iŽ\iˆg€j\ia†h]fZj‰dYWdefgj‚‘fg\ih‹[eY’h$j\^ŒYŽ^

û Ö]ñ’Þ×eß`üׂÖÉåà Üe×0áµà-Ý}Þ-òZ×yú0ÝZÞ×0ÖÉÝ×0ތðŒÖ$Ü$ò¢à-Þ/×e܂ÞÙã¢Ö]×ý¡ñbÝÿþ…åMׂÖÉä

fg\WfYW^”“WvޕЖ—…fgjcdefgTW\d0j…ˆIjd‚TWVSj^†\VSXxTŽ[˜heYb_™h†lF\+h$f[]jŽYW[$w

åà ×0۔æ

h]TS[$j^]XxTŽ_Z^]jš[eY’h$\iT™^„TW_g€›Š\iaKh$fgjœd‚YŽdefgj0/fg\ih„[eY’h$jm\^F€T’l–

f™h]VS€‘–

ž

—…fgja TW€€T’lF\i_g…\^QYF^]kgVSVYb[$›cTbagd0TŽ_Zd0€kZ^]\iTŽ_Z^¤Yb_xwŒŽkg\w¢j0







ÜeÚ

Ó

h]TSfZYM²ŽjY«€Yb[$Wjd‚[]\ih]\d‚YW€¤[$Ybh]\TS½”ƒZ^]VSYW€i€¾YM²Žj‚[eYbŽj‹[$TWkg_Zw¢

!#"

  )( 3

Z–ƒ

çm[]a dË

 

 

Ë

Ä

Ä

45 87

:=

Ó “ÔZ~_™h]j€i€\ƌǚé–



„Ö$ڒÞڒä

ù – TŽ[]¢ç

”[]TW

WkZ_gj 0–

Ž[$YMl…Yb€‘ƒƏ–ƒ”Yb_xw

Á

¢Ö$ñ’Ýgá ó0ׂÖ

–Uf™h]h]X¾P&çWç’lFlFl– l

– f™h]VS€‘–

Ià Üeñ K۔×âÞÙÖ$ñ’Ýgá‚ñŽÜ0ޑà ڒÝZá0æ

%$ '&

gׂÖÉÞ× ŽÞ

:9

†j‚[$VYgƒÀÆ«–ÀRŒ–

;*

rÚßŽ× +à-Ý û

c_xw¢j‚[FXg[$j‚XIj‚[eY’h$\iTŽ_¾–



müyÖ]× 0ãZ×0áÉÞÙäÖ]Úbã¢ÞÙà-Ý û

6" #"

ÛKò¢à-Þ/×

Zñ Z×0ւæÀf™h˜h]XQP(çŽç

?

Ó ï’Ô



3

†YŽw¢f³›WjŽƒ

DC

x–iƒUÄîWîŽïgƒ

@7 4

Z–ƒÍ{\[]TŽ\ik¾ƒ

$êµT¢w¢j‚€\i_Z»—‹R

Yb_xwy\ih$^cj‚VSXg\[]\d‚YW€¤²MYW€i\wgYbh]\TW_¾ƒ

 49G9 …þ

XgX¾– ù

H+I

BA

–ƒ«—KT’lc^˜€j‚›ŽƒÆ«–iƒSYb_Zw

Åh$fg[]TŽkgWfZXgk¢hP

E(

Á

mkg[]T™^˜jŽƒ

^]\V‰XZ€ijVST¢w¢j‚€

@ 9

„Ö]ÚÜ$×e×eߒà-Ý û áÚ˜óŒð

+F

ü¢ú …ä

ù “’îg–

J"

"

Âc\Wf¥d‚YŽdefgj0/fg\ihU[eY’h]\T‰\^„VSTW[$j‹\VSXxTŽ[˜heYb_™hUa TŽ[…WT³T¢wXxj[˜

Ó î’ÔKé¢YW_Zw¢Xg\Xxj[‹Çcj‚hlUTŽ[]·¢^ƒ³~_Zdb–”ÕKÚÚbÞ ÖÉà-ÝZÞFñWßWñ Iޑà-åM×ÜeÚbÝZÞ×0ÝxÞ

a TW[$VYb_Zd‚j±TWa«h$fgj¼h$[$YW_Z^˜€kZd‚j‚_™h®^˜kg[$[$TWŽYbh]j`Yb[edefg\+h$jd0h]kg[$j

ߒàáÉޑÖÉà â0ã¢Þ‘à ڒÝ

h]fxYb_±h]T¥WT³T¢wrXIj‚[]a TW[$VYb_Zd‚jTbaUh]fgjSh$[$YW_Z^]XZYb[$j‚_™hš^]kg[$[]TW

f™h˜h$X¾P(çŽçMlFlFl–†w¢\W\ih$YW€i\^˜€Yb_xw¤–†_gj0h–

ŽYbh]jmYb[edefg\ih]jd0h]kg[$jW– ¦



ÙÇcT’²– 0–

lFlFl–†\_Žh$j‚€€i\w¢_Z^–Àd0TŽV»–

h][$\XŠh$\iVSjˆIj0hl„j‚j‚_µd‚€i\j‚_™h$^FYW_Zw»^˜kZ[][$TW™Y’h]j^‚–

½`ÃÅÄsg–

š\i€j^ƒ

Ä

>

d‚YŽdefgj0/fg\ih„[eY’h$jW–

¦

Ô

Þ

h][$\Xh]\VSjŒˆIj0hl„j‚j_yd0€\j‚_™h$^„Yb_Zwy^˜kZ[][$TW™Y’h]j^‚ƒŽYb_Zw´Y«€Yb[$Wj

YbXZXg€i\d‚Ybh]\TW_Z^…lF\ih]f»fg\Wfµd‚[]\ih]\d‚YW€¾[$Ybh]\T½À–”‹T’lUj²Wj‚[ƒ³h]fZj



«ÝڒۆÝ





Žæ ’–mõcÍ{R

h]T¢d‚TW€^eç[]a dË

h]fZj®[]j^˜XITW_x^˜j»h$\iVSj®TWaY¼^]\_gW€jr^]j‚[$²Wj‚[ƒ„\+hŠ\^´j^]^]j‚_™h$\YW€

j0‡jd0h]\²Wj_gj^$^À\^”YW€iVSTŽ^˜hÀh$fgjŒ^$YbVSjFa TŽ[UYbXZXg€i\d‚Ybh]\TW_Z^”lF\+h$f



 +* ,-&.&/( 0/1 21   6  

Suggest Documents