tual Property Law at the National University of Juridical Sciences (NUJS) in Kolkata, India. .... http://opensource.mit.edu/papers/Thursby.pdf (âPrior to the passage of Bayh-Dole, ...... Indian Council of Medical Research: Fifty-three applications.
! ! "#$%"#&'()*!+,-./0"12!$"!()0(,3! 1"%$!()!$&,)%41,)$,$(")5! ! !
"#$%&$'!($"#))*!$&'!"#+,-./!0,#$1!
! ! ! .2! .&3*+',43.+&!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!567! ..2! 48)$*.&0!!"$3)&3#!3.38)9!4+&3):3,$8.;.&0!3#)!,2"2!($#! "991%='5-&!0%)3)*+!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!BDD! !! G#! >*314%'+)*+!A13)'--6!@&-&M3-48)1*!19!A3.1-'%8.)E!?1-=&%8!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!BDC! !! :#! 0%15-&2'()3!:&9)*)()1*!19!;*(&--&3(4'-!0%1E&%(6!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!2!B7D! !! >#! >M3-48)1*!19!0%)!7D!;K:;"!
567!
.2! .&3*+',43.+&! ! 'M`HPML!H`RTP!PGM!URIIMNUOHWOgHPORJ!RS!HUHKMIOU!NMLMHNUG!GHVM!XWH= _TMK!IHJ]OJK!SRN!HP!WMHLP!HL!WRJ_!HL!PGM!HTPGRNL!GHVM!`MMJ!HNRTJK!OJ!PGOL! YRNWK2!@NRXRJMJPL!RS!URIIMNUOHWOgHPORJ!HN_TM!PGHP^!%&'()*%%)(%+()&,)-./*01+) UHXOPHWOLPOU!YRNWK^!HUHKMIOH!HJK!NMLMHNUG!RT_GP!PR!`M!LT`aMUPMK!PR!IHN]MP! SRNUML2!3GRLM!H_HOJLP!PGM!IRPORJ!KMUNQ!PGM!XNRLPOPTPORJ!RS!YGHP!YHL!RJUM! H!JR`WM!OKMHW2PGHP!OL^!PGM!XTNOPQ!RS!NMLMHNUG!HJK!PGM!XTNLTOP!RS!]JRYWMK_M! SRN!OPL!RYJ!LH]M27! @HNP!RS!PGOL!URJPNRVMNLQ!URJUMNJL!PGM!XHPMJPOJ_!RS!HUHKMIOU!NMLMHNUG^! H!KM`HPM!McHUMN`HPMK!`Q!PGM!(HQG='RWM!$UP!RS!7CAD^!YGOUG!LRT_GP!PR!SHUO= WOPHPM!PGM! XHPMJPOJ_! RS! HUHKMIOU! NMLMHNUG! `Q! OJLPOPTPORJL! NMUMOVOJ_! XT`WOU! STJKL2 5 !#MNM! H_HOJ^! PGMNM! OL! H! LXWOP! VMNKOUP2! EGOWM! 7.&! >31*12)8(! GHOWL! (HQG='RWM!HL!H!XO(3().4)%(5&+%*-&.,)-6*-)!7(8(7+(9/:);+) +%&/() &,-.) &,/>+-7&*%) &77(%(8*,3(?#B!UNOPOUL! XROJP! PR! PGM! KM`OWOPHPOJ_! MSSMUPL! PGHP!(HQG='RWM!GHL!GHK!RJ!PGM!JHPTNM!HJK!KONMUPORJ!RS!TJOVMNLOPQ!NMLMHNUG^! URWWH`RNHPORJ^! HJK! ]JRYWMK_M! LGHNOJ_2 ? !,JSRNPTJHPMWQ^! PGM! MVOKMJUM! OL! OJURJUWTLOVM^! XNMVMJPOJ_! URIIMJPHPRNL! SNRI! UNMKOPOJ_! PGM! HKVHJPH_ML! RN! KOLHKVHJPH_ML!McUWTLOVMWQ!PR!PGM!(HQG='RWM!NM_OIM2! "UGRWHNL! L]MXPOUHW! RS! (HQG='RWM! HN_TM! PGHP! YOPGRTP! (HQG='RWM^! XH= PMJPOJ_!`Q!TJOVMNLOPOML!OJ!PGM!7CADL!HJK!7CCDL!YRTWK!LPOWW!GHVM!_NRYJ!LO_= JOSOUHJPWQ2! %RYMNQ^! &MWLRJ^! "HIXHP^! HJK! ;OM`RJOL! HWLR! URJPMJK! PGHP! PGM! (HQG='RWM! $UP! YHL! RJWQ! RJM! RS! LMVMNHW! SHUPRNL! PGHP! URJPNO`TPMK! PR! PGM! _NRYPG! RS! XHPMJPOJ_! HJK! WOUMJLOJ_! `Q! ,2"2! TJOVMNLOPOML! KTNOJ_! PGM! 7CADL! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 7
!>RN! HJ! RVMNVOMY! RS! PGOL! KM`HPM^! LMM!_MJMNHWWQ! ZHJOUM! &MYLRJ^!7.&! $1%E1%'(&FH)*O&=! I*)''/&69$/'?4)@/1+%')@//4%^!3#)!)4+&+%."3^!3MUGJRWR_Q!iTHNPMNWQ!"MUPORJ^!HP!B!['MU2!75^!5DD5\2! ? !A&&! '$-.'! 42! %+E)*3)*! 3#)! ($36)*+) !TN= PGMNIRNM^! OP! XNRGO`OPMK! HLLO_JIMJPL! TJWMLL! PGM! HLLO_JMM! IHJTSHUPTNML! XNRKTUPL!TLOJ_!PGM!XHPMJP!OJ!PGM!,JOPMK!"PHPML^!H!UWMHN!XNRPMUPORJOLP!IMHL= TNM!IMHJP!PR!SHVRN!WRUHW!OJKTLPNQ275! 3GOL!OL!JRP!PR!LT__MLP!PGHP!PGM!UTNNMJP!(HQG='RWM!LPNTUPTNM!OL!RXPOIHW^! `TP!PGHP!OP!XNRVOKML!H!L]MWMPHW!IRKMW!YGOUG!UHJ!`M!SWMLGMK!RTP!HJK!IRK= OSOMK! `Q! URTJPNOML! HKRXPOJ_! OP! PR! URJLPNTUP! HJ! RXPOIHW! NM_TWHPRNQ! NM_OIM2! 3GOL! OL! XHNPOUTWHNWQ! HPPNHUPOVM! SRN! URTJPNOML^! LTUG! HL! .JKOH^! PGHP! HNM! URJ= !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! F
!A&&!%+E)*!7D!;K:;"! 56B! ! PMIXWHPOJ_! PNHJLXWHJPOJ_! PGM! (HQG='RWM! LPNTUPTNM! `TP! HNM! YRNNOMK! H`RTP! PGM!XRPMJPOHW!JM_HPOVM!MSSMUPL!RS!OJUNMHLMK!XHPMJP!JTI`MNL2! 3GM! .JKOHJ! _RVMNJIMJP! OJPNRKTUMK! PGM! @NRPMUPORJ! HJK! ,POWOLHPORJ! RS! @T`WOU!>TJKMK!.JPMWWMUPTHW!@NRXMNPQ!(OWW^!5DDA!OJ!PGM!*HaQH!"H`GH!OJ!ZHJ= THNQ! 5DDC2! 3GM! (OWW! OL!UTNNMJPWQ! TJKMN_ROJ_! LUNTPOJQ! `Q! H! @HNWOHIMJPHNQ! LPHJKOJ_! URIIOPPMM^7B!HSPMN! YGOUG! OP! YOWW! XHLL! `MSRNM! PGM! PYR! GRTLML! RS! @HNWOHIMJP!SRN!HXXNRVHW27?!"OJUM!PGM!.JKOHJ!(OWW!KNHYL!OJLXONHPORJ!SNRI!PGM! ,JOPMK!"PHPML!(HQG='RWM![('\!$UP^!OP!YOWW!`M!NMSMNNMK!PR!OJ!PGOL!XHXMN!HL! -6()!Q,/&*,)H*06=G.%()H&%%#).7)+&,/(7) -67(*-) .4) +(7&.>+) +*,3-&.,+F) $(3.,/%0?) -6() H&%%1+) XTNVOMY! McPMJKL! `MQRJK! XHPMJPL^! URVMNOJ_! RPGMN! SRNIL! RS! OJPMWWMUPTHW! XNRXMNPQ! LTUG! HL! URXQNO_GP^! XWHJP! VHNOMPOML^! LMIOURJKTUPRN! WHQRTP^! HJK! IRLP! XNR`WMIHPOUHWWQ^! PNHKMIHN]2 7F !3GM! UTNNMJP! .JKOHJ! PNHJLXWHJP! MSSRNP! URTWK!`M!MVMJ!IRNM!SWHYMK!PGHJ!PGM!RNO_OJHW2!.J!SHUP^!PGM!_NHSPOJ_!GHL!`MMJ! LR!`HKWQ!URJUMXPTHWOgMK!HJK!McMUTPMK!PGHP!JRP!RJWQ!OL!OP!WO]MWQ!PR!SHUM!NM= aMUPORJ!`Q!PGM!GRLP!WM_HW!NM_OIM^!`TP!OP!HWLR!IO_GP!MJK!TX!XROLRJOJ_!OP2! 3GTL^!YM!RSSMN!LRIM!URJUNMPM!NMURIIMJKHPORJL!OJ!PGOL!XHXMN!PR!IH]M! PGM!XNRXRLMK!(OWW!IRNM!XHWHPH`WM!PR!PGM!.JKOHJ!HTKOMJUM2!EM!XNRXRLM!NM= _TWHPOJ_!PGM!XHPMJPOJ_!RS!XT`WOUWQ=STJKMK!NMLMHNUG!`Q!OJURNXRNHPOJ_!IRNM! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 7B
!H(3*>+().4)-6()%&M`NTHNQ! A^! 5D7D^! RJM!RS!PGM!HTPGRNL!RS!PGOL!XHXMN!XNMLMJPMK!PR!PGM!HSRNMIMJPORJMK!"PHJKOJ_!4RIIOPPMM!MVOKMJUM!LOIO= WHN! PR! PGM! ]MQ! HN_TIMJPL! OJ! PGOL! XHXMN2! >RWWRYOJ_! PGM! GMHNOJ_^! PGM! "PHJKOJ_! 4RIIOPPMM! HL]MK! PGM! _RVMNJIMJP!PR!NMVOMY!PGM!XNRXRLMK!(OWW^!URJLTWP!YOPG!LPH]MGRWKMNL^!HJK!XNRKTUM!H!VMNLORJ!RS!PGM!(OWW! HKKNMLLOJ_!LPH]MGRWKMN!URJUMNJL2!A&&!42!#2!,JJO]NOLGJHJ^!0'%-)'2&*(!0'*&-!,'*(8!L1+*3! ! @NORN! PR! PGM! ,2"2! (HQG='RWM! $UP^!PGMNM! YHL! URJLOKMNH`WM! TJUMNPHOJPQ! NM_HNKOJ_! YGR! GMWK! XHPMJP! RYJMNLGOX! RS! XT`WOUWQ=STJKMK! OJVMJPORJL9! PGM! OJLPOPTPML! HJK! NMLMHNUGMNL! YGR! UHIM! TX! YOPG! PGM! OJVMJPORJL! RN! PGM! _RV= MNJIMJP! H_MJUOML! PGHP! STJKMK! PGM! OJVMJPOVM! XNRUMLL2! .J! LRIM! UHLML^! PGM! _RVMNJIMJP!HWWRYMK!PGM!OJLPOPTPM!PR!RYJ!PGM!XHPMJPb!OJ!RPGMN!UHLML^!OP!NM= PHOJMK! POPWM! OPLMWS2! "RIM! McXMNPL! `MWOMVM! PGHP! YGMJ! POPWM! VMLPMK! YOPG! PGM! _RVMNJIMJP! H_MJUQ^! PGM! NHPM! RS! URIIMNUOHWOgHPORJ! RS! OJVMJPORJL! YHL! OJ= LO_JOSOUHJP276!3GMNMSRNM^! PGM! (HQG='RWM! $UP! RS! 7CAD! YHL! MJHUPMK! PR! XNR= VOKM!XT`WOUWQ=STJKMK!OJLPOPTPML![@>.L\!YOPG!H!UWMHN!XHPMJP!POPWM2!! 3GMNM! OL! URJLOKMNH`WM! KOLH_NMMIMJP!RJ! YGMPGMN! PGM! ,2"2! _RVMNJIMJP! YHL!HL!TJLTUUMLLSTW!OJ!URIIMNUOHWOgOJ_!XHPMJPL!HL!HNKMJP!(HQG='RWM!LTX= XRNPMNL!UWHOI2!3GMLM!LTXXRNPMNL!HN_TM!PGHP!`MSRNM!(HQG='RWM^!PGM!WOUMJL= !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 7e
!$WPGRT_G!PGOL!XHXMN!7(4(7+)+=(3&4&3*%%0)-.)!=*-(,-+?#)-6()*75>*%) XNRXMNPQ!URVMNMK!`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jTONMK!RTP!RS!LTUG!STJKL!+6*%%)8(+-)&,)-6()+=.,+.7F#5B!3GOL!IMHJL!PGHP! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 7A
!;=#!A&&!'-81!8MPPMN!SNRI!"HI!@OPNRKH^!$KVOLRN!PR!PGM!@NOIM!%OJOLPMN!RS!.JKOH!RJ!@T`WOU!.JSRNIH= PORJ^! .JSNHLPNTUPTNM^! HJK! .JJRVHPORJL^! PR! .JKOHJ! @NOIM! %OJOLPMN! [ZHJ2! 7e^! 5DD6\^! '''/&69$/')7'&$,/'E%'9^!7F!Z2!.&3)882!@*+@2!*3"2! 7C![5D7D\2! 5B !0MJMNHW! >OJHJUOHW! *TWML^! 5DDF^! 57F[B\[7\^! '!7D!;K:;"! 566! ! EGOWM!PGM!XHPMJP!IHQ!`M!PH]MJ!OJ!PGM!JHIM[L\!RS!OJVMJPRN[L\^!PGM! OJLPOPTPORJ!LGHWW!MJLTNM!PGHP!PGM!XHPMJP!OL!HLLO_JMK!PR!OP2!2!2!2!3GM!.J= LPOPTPORJ!LGHWW!PH]M!JMUMLLHNQ!LPMXL!SRN!URIIMNUOHW!McXWROPHPORJ!RS! PGM!XHPMJP!RJ!McUWTLOVMmJRJ=McUWTLOVM!`HLOL!2!2!2!2!dHJKf!NMPHOJ!PGM! `MJMSOPL!HJK!MHNJOJ_L!HNOLOJ_!RTP!RS!PGM!.@*25e! ! .P! `MHNL! JRPOJ_! PGHP! PGM! *TWML! LXMUOSOUHWWQ! LPHPM! PGHP! PGM! LXRJLRNLGOX! STJKL!PGMQ!HTPGRNOgM!LGHWW!JRP!`M!PNMHPMK!HL!H!_NHJP=OJ=HOK2!0OVMJ!PGHP!jTH= WOSOUHPORJ^!OP!OL!JRP!HP!HWW!UWMHN!PGHP!PGM!.JKOHJ!(HQG='RWM!(OWW!OJ!OPL!UTNNMJP! 4.7%/)3.8(7)+>36)+=.,+.7+6&=?)+&,3()&-).,%0)*==%&(+)-.)!57*,-#)+&->H= PORJL2!"MUPORJ!B[7\^!YGOUG!HXXMHNL!PR!`M!PGM!LMUPORJ!PGHP!KMSOJML!PGM!RTPMN! WOIOPL! RS! PGM! (OWW^! LXMUOSOUHWWQ! LPHPML^! !$JQ! NMUOXOMJP! OJPMNMLPMK! PR! PH]M! H! _NHJP!SNRI!PGM!0RVMNJIMJP!SRN!PGM!XTNXRLM!RS!NMLMHNUG!HJK!KMVMWRXIMJP! LGHWW!MJPMN!OJPR!HJ!H_NMMIMJP!YOPG!PGM!0RVMNJIMJP!`MSRNM!NMUMOXP!RS!LTUG! 57*,-F#56! $WPGRT_G!PGM!*TWML!HNM!_TOKMWOJML!HJK!KR!JRP!HXXMHN!PR!GHVM!PGM!SRNUM! RS!WHY^!OP!YRTWK!`M!XNMSMNH`WM!SRN!PGM!XNRXRLMK!(OWW!PR!LXMUOSOUHWWQ!RVMN= NOKM! HJQ! HNMHL! RS! XRPMJPOHW! URJSWOUP! YOPG! PGM! *TWML2! 5A !.J! XHNPOUTWHN^! OP! LGRTWK!LPOXTWHPM!PGHP!STJKL!_OVMJ!PR!HTPRJRIRTL!XT`WOUWQ=STJKMK!OJLPOPTPML! HNM!URVMNMK!TJKMN!PGM!HI`OP!RS!PGM!(OWW^!YGMPGMN!RN!JRP!LTUG!STJKL!jTHWOSQ! HL!_NHJPL2! ! ! ...2!3*$&"@8$&3.&0!($
