Prioritised Default Logic as Argumentation with Partial Order Default
Recommend Documents
May 9, 2016 - Dung's argumentation theory [8] has become established as a general framework for ... argumentation semantics is Brewka's prioritised default logic. (PDL) [4]. PDL is ...... 2015-08-30_ASPIC+_fix_revised.pdf, last accessed ...
(Trade costs, Rose 2002; financial crises, Reinhart and Rogoff 2010; lawsuits and sanctions ... partial recovery of thos
2000. 2010 year. Partial Def aults. Across all S&P default : countries default on average on 59% of what is due. ...
Oct 7, 2013 - SDN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SLB. SLE. SLE. SLE. SLV. SYC. TGOTGO. TGO. TGO. TUR. TUR. UKR. URY. URY. URYURY. VEN.
Consistently with the observed market prices, model bond prices with partial information ...... [15] Jarrow, R., and S. Turnbull, 1995, ”Pricing Options on Financial ...
Aug 19, 1995 - We describe an order independent typed default uni cation function, which ... be described using a binary, order independent (i.e., commutative.
In order to find which domains actually lead to results consistent with Reiter concept of ... A variable-free term is a called ground and a closed atomic formula is ...
Dec 16, 2016 - motion and a martingale measure associated with a default jump with ... we present here a rigorous analysis of these BSDEs with default jump.
logic and even if some systems have good performances on certain classes of default ... n this paper, we show that heuristics issued from combinatorial optimization 01% 032 ... we have described a fi rst system GAD e L ( G enetic A lgo 4.
full generalization to arbitrary default theories uses a reduction of default the- ories to prerequisite-free theories. The reduction can be viewed as dual to the.
Abstract. We present a development of the theory of default information structures, combining ideas from domain theory with ideas from non-monotonic logic.
meier,thomas,[email protected]. 3 Faculty of ... size in Bonatti and Olivetti's enhanced calculus for skeptical default reasoning. 1 Introduction.
system. Key words: domain theory, non-monotonic reasoning, default logic, sequent structures, ..... Z. Applying the cut rule we get X;(Y n fbg) ` Z. Now choose a b.
true literals, be defined as the least fixed point of a monotone operator ..... The following table shows the results of applying ?i and ??i to the empty set. In each ...
We provide a description of generalized default logic as a unified formalism for nonmonotonic reasoning. Spe- cial attention will be paid to the role of the ...
Computing Default Logic Extensions: An lementation. A.P. Courtney and N.Y. Foo. G. Antoniou. Basser Department of Computer Science. University of Sydney ...
Department of Mathematics. University of ... We develop an Answer Set Programming formalism based on Default Logic. ... and Remmel 2001), the authors answered this question for. ASP systems ...... N4 = {positionq(vm, m):0 ⤠m ⤠p(n)}.
And that can generate (or cost) your business serious money. Apple's iPhone is the techno-rage these days; and, in the US, iPhone customers must use AT&T.
Jan 27, 2009 - Abstract. We consider a realization of Reiter-style default logic on top of descrip- tion logic knowledge bases (DL-KBs). To this end, we present ...
Mar 5, 1997 - We propose a more liberal, argumentation-theoretic semantics, based upon ... prove either that the accused is guilty or that he is not, the default ...
(1) * ..., welcher Politiker die Minister getroffen haben. ..., which politician (Nom, Sg) the ministers (Nom/Acc, Pl) met have (Pl). (2) * Welcher Politiker, glaubst Du, ...
Key words: anaphora, Default Logic, equality, DOAP. 1 The Search for an Antecedent. Identifying the antecedent of an anaphoric trigger (a pronoun, definite DP, ...
Mar 1, 2014 - and why the famous credit default swaps (CDSs) markets expanded and why ... Keywords: counterparty risk, credit crisis, credit default swap, ...
Prioritised Default Logic as Argumentation with Partial Order Default
Aug 25, 2016 - Anthony P. Young, Sanjay Modgil, Odinaldo Rodrigues ... 3.4.2 The Trivialisation and Rationality Theorems . ... 4.1 The Argument Preference Relation based on Partial Order De- ... ory [3], one example of which is the ASPIC+ framework for ... If f : X → Y is a function and A ⊆ X, f(A) ⊆ Y is the image set of.
arXiv:1609.05224v1 [cs.AI] 25 Aug 2016
Prioritised Default Logic as Argumentation with Partial Order Default Priorities Anthony P. Young, Sanjay Modgil, Odinaldo Rodrigues Department of Informatics, King’s College London, Strand, London, U.K. {peter.young,sanjay.modgil,odinaldo.rodrigues}@kcl.ac.uk
20th September 2016 Abstract We express Brewka’s prioritised default logic (PDL) as argumentation using ASPIC+ . By representing PDL as argumentation and designing an argument preference relation that takes the argument structure into account, we prove that the conclusions of the justified arguments correspond to the PDL extensions. We will first assume that the default priority is total, and then generalise to the case where it is a partial order. This provides a characterisation of non-monotonic inference in PDL as an exchange of argument and counter-argument, providing a basis for distributed non-monotonic reasoning in the form of dialogue.1
1 The results of Section 3 first appeared in the preprint [23] and have been published in the conference proceedings of AAMAS2016 [24]. This paper gives the full proofs of these results.
4 On Lifting the Assumption of a Total Order Default Priority 4.1 The Argument Preference Relation based on Partial Order Default Priorities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.1 A Representation of Rules and their Ordering using Strings 4.1.2 Algorithm and Example Calculation . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.3 Properties of the Generalised SP Order . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.4 The Generalised Argument Preference Relation for
