A RESPONSE TO MASUDUL ALAM CHOUDHURY. Ayman Reda . 101.
REJOINDER. Masudul Alam Choudhury. 111. SYMPOSIUM ON WARREN J.
SAMUELS.
RESEARCH IN THE HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND METHODOLOGY VOLUME 30-A
RESEARCH IN THE HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND METHODOLOGY A RESEARCH ANNUAL EDITED BY
JEFF E. BIDDLE Department of Economics, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA
ROSS B. EMMETT James Madison College, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48825, USA
United Kingdom - North America - Japan India - Malaysia - China
CONTENTS LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS \
,
.
ix •
•
•
EDITORIAL BOARD
xi
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
xiii
OBITUARY: WARREN J. SAMUELS, FOUNDING EDITOR
xv
THE INFLUENCE OF AMERICAN ECONOMISTS ON THE CLAYTON AND FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION ACTS Luca Fiorito
1
THE METHODOLOGY OF ISLAMIC ECONOMIC AND SOCIO-SCIENTIFIC INQUIRY Masudul Alam Choudhury
59
A RESPONSE TO MASUDUL ALAM CHOUDHURY Ayman Reda
.
REJOINDER Masudul Alam Choudhury
101 111
SYMPOSIUM ON WARREN J. SAMUELS SAMUELS ON METHODOLOGICAL PLURALISM IN ECONOMICS John B. Davis
121
vi
CONTENTS
SAMUELS VS. BUCHANAN: GRASPING THE PURPOSE OF THE LAW Daniel W. Bromley
137
REVIEW ESSAYS: RUTHERFORD'S THE INSTITUTIONALISE MOVEMENT IN AMERICAN ECONOMICS, 1918-1947
UNDERSTANDING INSTITUTIONALISM Bradley W. Bateman
A DETAILED AND ACCURATE PICTURE OF AMERICAN INSTITUTIONALISM JeffE. Biddle
153
161
PSYCHOLOGY, SCIENTIFIC CONTROL, CHICAGO, AND THE IMPACT OF EUROPEAN EMIGRES Ross B. Emmett
169
FROM THE PROGRESSIVES TO THE INSTITUTIONALISTS: WHAT THE FIRST WORLD WAR DID AND DID NOT DO TO AMERICAN ECONOMICS Thomas C. Leonard
177
REVIEW ESSAYS
O'BRIEN AND CREED Y'S DARWIN'S CLEVER NEIGHBOR Living on the Edge of Power and Mental Illness Neil T. Skaggs
193
KEPPLER'S ADAM SMITH AND THE ECONOMY OF THE PASSIONS Morality vs. Ethics? Jeffrey T. Young
201
Contents
vii
FARRANT'S HAYEK, MILL, AND THE LIBERAL TRADITION The Slippery Slope of Andrew Farrant Bruce Caldwell
213
FINN'S THE TRUE WEALTH OF NATIONS The Religious Dimension of Human Life and a Reasonable Economic Theory: Relevant Elements in a Fertile Discussion Daniela Parisi
223
SNYDER'S THE PHILOSOPHICAL BREAKFAST CLUB Food for Economists: The Breakfast Club's Recipe for Inductive Economics Michael Perelman
235
HALTEMAN AND NO ELL'S RECKONING WITH MARKETS Repairing the Wall Between Positive and Normative Ross B. Emmett
