Selforganisation-Countereconomic-Strategies

0240_057_self_org.indd 2-3

25/09/06 17:40:16

3ELF /RGANISATIONô #OUNTER %CONOMICô3TRATEGIES 4HISôBOOKôISôPUBLISHEDôBY 3TERNBERGô0RESSô 0RODUCEDôBYô .)&#! ô.ORDICô)NSTITUTEôFORô#ONTEMPORARYô!RTô )NôCOLLABORATIONôWITH 4HEô!CADEMYôOFô&INEô!RTS ô(ELSINKI 4HEô6ANô!BBEMUSEUM ô%INDHOVEN -ONTANA ô$ENMARK %DITORSô7ILLô"RADLEY ô-IKAô(ANNULA ô#RISTINAô2ICUPERO ô3UPERlEX %DITORIALô#O ORDINATORô3YLVESTERô2OEPSTORFFô #OPYô%DITINGô#HRISTYô,ANGE $ESIGNô2ASMUSô+OCH !SSISTANTSô4HOMASô&REDERIKSEN ô!LEXANDERô(³GGSTR¢M 4YPEFACEô!KZIDENZ 'ROTESKô"1ô 0RINTINGôANDôBINDINGô#ENTERTRYKô!3 ô$ENMARK )3".ô ô 3TERNBERGô0RESS #AROLINEô3CHNEIDER ô"ROADWAYô ô.EWô9ORKô.9ô ,INIENSTRAEô ô$ ô"ERLIN WWWSTERNBERG PRESSCOM .)&#!ôPUBLICATIONôô 5NLESSôOTHERWISEôSTATED ôTHEôMATERIALôCONTAINEDôIN THISôBOOKôISôMADEôAVAILABLEôUNDERôTHEô#REATIVEô#OMMONS !TTRIBUTION}.ON #OMMERCIAL}3HARE!LIKEô,ICENCEô

)NTRODUCTION

4HISôBOOKôISôABOUTôTHEôMANYôAPPROACHESôTOôTHEôCREATION ôDIS SEMINATIONôANDôMAINTENANCEôOFôALTERNATIVE ô@BOTTOM UPôMODELSô FORôSOCIALôORôECONOMICôORGANISATION ôANDôTHEôPRACTICALôANDôTHEO RETICALôIMPLICATIONS ôCONSEQUENCESôANDôPOSSIBILITIESôOFôTHESEô SELF ORGANISEDôSTRUCTURESô 4HEôTERMôSELF ORGANISATIONôISôBORROWEDôFROMôSYSTEMSôTHEORYô ANDôTHEôNATURALôSCIENCES ôWHEREôITôDESCRIBESôSYSTEMSôWHOSEô INTERNALôORGANISATIONôTENDSôTOôINCREASEôINôCOMPLEXITYôWITHOUTô BEINGôGUIDEDôBYôANôOUTSIDEôSOURCEô)NôRECENTôYEARSôITôHASôBEENô USEDôINôRELATIONôTOôCERTAINôKINDSôOFôSOCIALôGROUPSôORôNETWORKSô INôTHISôCONTEXT ôTHEôTERMôDOESôNOTôHAVEôAôSTRICTôDEkNITION ôBUTô BROADLYôSPEAKINGôITôREFERSôTOôGROUPSôTHATôAREôINDEPENDENTô OFôINSTITUTIONALôORôCORPORATEôSTRUCTURES ôAREôNON HIERARCHICAL ô OPENôANDôOPERATEôPARTICIPATORYôDECISION MAKINGôPROCESSESô 4HEôCOUNTER ECONOMICôSTRATEGIESôDISCUSSEDôHEREôAREôRADICALô ALTERNATIVESôTOôCLASSICALôCAPITALISTôECONOMICôORGANISATIONôTHATô EXPLOIT ôORôHAVEôBEENôPRODUCEDôBY ôTHEôEXISTINGôGLOBALôECO NOMICôSYSTEM

WWWCREATIVECOMMONSORGLICENSESBY NC SA

7RITERSôFROMôDIFFERENTôkELDSôHAVEôBEENôINVITEDôTOôINVESTIGATEô THESEôTHEMESôWITHôREFERENCEôTOôPARTICULARôSITUATIONSô4HEôESSAYSô THEYôHAVEôCONTRIBUTEDôDISCUSSôAôWIDEôCROSS SECTIONôOFôACTIVITY ô FROMôNEWôAPPROACHESôTOôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôANDôIMPACTôOFôTHEô FREEOPENôSOURCEôSOFTWAREôMOVEMENTôTOôPOLITICALôACTIVISMôANDô THEôDEôFACTOôSELF ORGANISATIONôEMBODIEDôINôINFORMALôARCHITECTUREô ANDôTHEôSO CALLEDôBLACKôECONOMYô4HEYôREPRESENTôDIVERSE ôANDô SOMETIMESôCONlICTING ôVIEWPOINTSôANDôINTERPRETATIONS

3ELF ORGANISATIONôCOUNTERôECONOMICôSTRATEGIES



25/09/06 17:40:17

3ELF ORGANISATION#OUNTER ECONOMICôSTRATEGIESôISôNOTôAôCOM PREHENSIVEôOVERVIEWôORôANôATTEMPTôTOôUNIFYôTHESEôDIVERSEôIN TERPRETATIONSô)TôISôINTENDEDôASôAôTOOLBOXôOFôIDEAS ôSITUATIONSô ANDôAPPROACHES ôINCLUDINGôBOTHôTHEORETICALôRElECTIONSôANDô CASE STUDIESô)NôTHISôSPIRIT ôWEôHAVEôALSOôCOLLECTEDôMANYôSHORT ô PRACTICALôEXAMPLESôOFôSELF ORGANISEDôGROUPSôORôSTRATEGIESôTHEô THEMATICôINDEXôISôINTENDEDôTOôASSISTôTHEôREADERôINôUSINGôTHEô BOOKôFROMôTHEôPOINTôOFôVIEWôOFôTHEIRôOWNôAREAôOFôINTEREST 4HISôBOOKôHASôBEENôPRODUCEDôASôAôRESULTôOFô3UPERlEXSôRESI DENCYôINôTHEô!MAZONôREGIONôOFô"RAZIL ôORGANISEDôBYô#RISTINAô 2ICUPEROôFORô.)&#!ô7EôWOULDôLIKEôTOôTHANKôALLôOFôTHEôWRITERSô ANDôCONTRIBUTORS ôANDôTOôEXPRESSôOURôGRATITUDEôTOô2ASMUSô+OCH ô 3YLVESTERô2OEPSTORFF ô#HRISTYô,ANGEôANDô#AROLINEô3CHNEIDERôFORô HELPINGôTOôTURNôTHEôCONCEPTôOFôTHISôBOOKôINTOôPHYSICALôREALITYô 7EôWOULDôALSOôLIKEôTOôACKNOWLEDGEôTHEôSUPPORTôOFô.)&#!ôTHEô !CADEMYôOFô&INEô!RTS ô(ELSINKIôANDôTHEô6ANô!BBEMUSEUM ô %INDHOVENôANDô-ONTANA ô$ENMARK 3UPERlEX #RISTINAô2ICUPERO -IKAô(ANNULA 7ILLô"RADLEY



)NDEXING

!CTIVISMô !ESTHETICS !GRICULTURE !LBANIA !RCHITECTURE !RT !RTSôFUNDING !UTONOMY "ALKANS "ARRIOS "RANDING "RAZIL #APITALISM #ENSORSHIP #ITIES #IVILô3OCIETY #OMMUNITY #OMPETITION #ONlICT #OOPERATIVE #OPYING #OPYING #OPYRIGHT #ORPORATIONS #OUNTER ECONOMICS #REATIVEô#OMMONS #RIME #ULTURE $EMOCRACY )NDEXING

25/09/06 17:40:17

$EMONSTRATIONS $ENMARK $ISSEMINATIONôPUBLICITY ôINFORMATION ô02 $OCUMENTARY %CONOMICS %DUCATION %MPIRE %MPOWERMENT %NVIRONMENT %THICS %XPERIMENTSRISKS &AIRôUSE &ARMERS &INANCE &REE &REE/PENô3OURCE 'ATEDô#OMMUNITIES 'LOBALIZATION 'OVERNMENT3TATE 'UARAN¶ )DEOLOGY )NDEPENDENT )NFORMAL )NTERNET777 ,ABOUR ,AW ,IBERAL ,OCAL -AkA -ARGINALISATION -ARKETFREEôMARKET -ARX

-EDIA -EXICO -IGRATION -ODELSEXAMPLES -OVEMENTS -34 ,ANDLESSôWORKERSôMOVEMENT -USEUMS .ATIONS .ATURALôRESOURCES .EO ,IBERAL .ETWORK /RGANISATIONALôMETHODS /WNERSHIP 0ARADOX 0ARALLELôECONOMIES 0ARODY 0ARTICIPANT 0IRACY 0OLICE 0OLITICALôPARTIES 0OVERTY 0OWER 0RODUCTS 0ROkTNOT FOR PROkT 0ROPERTY 0ROTEST 0UBLIC 0UBLICô$OMAIN 2EPRESENTATION 2ESISTANCE 2IGHTS

)NDEXING

)NDEXING


25/09/06 17:40:18

2URAL 3ELF ORGANISATION 3HARING 3ODA 3TARô4REK 3TRATEGIES 3USTAINABILITY 4ACTICS 4OOLS 5NIONS 53! 7AGESMINIMUMôWAGE

)NDEXING

0240_057_self_org.indd 10-11

4%0)4/ôAôBARRIOôOFôARTISANSôINôLIGHTôOFôGLOBALôPIRACY

25/09/06 17:40:18

4%0)4/ AôBARRIOô OFôARTISANSô INôLIGHTôOFô GLOBALôPIRACY !LFONSOô(ERN¶NDEZ 4RANSLATEDôBYô(UGOô(OPPING


0240_057_self_org.indd 12-13


25/09/06 17:40:18

4HEôGLOBALIZEDôMARKETôHASôGENERATEDô RADICALôINEQUALITY ôANDôTHEôLONGSTANDINGô CRISISôINôTHEôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôWEALTHôANDôINô EMPLOYMENTôOPPORTUNITIESôHASôCREATEDô NEWôTYPESôOFôCRIMEôWHOSEôMODALITIESô AREôNOWôBEINGôINTERPRETEDôTHROUGHôWHATô MIGHTôBEôTERMEDôAôREALISTICô#RIMINOLOGY )TôISôGENERALLYôACKNOWLEDGEDôTHATôCRIMEôHASôFOURôBASICôPILLARSô ô THEôSTATEôANDôITSôAGENCIESôINôTHEôPENALôSYSTEMô

WHICHôHAVEôDONEôAWAYôWITHôTRADEôAPPRENTICESHIPSôINôFAVORôOFô PROMOTINGôAô&ORDISTôASSEMBLY LINEôMODELôOFôPRODUCTION 7ITHôTHEôLIQUIDATIONôOFôTHEôWELFAREôSTATEôTHEôEFFECTSôOFôECONOMICô INEQUALITYôHAVEôINCREASED ôANDôTHEôCUMULATIVEôCRISISôHASôLEDôTOô ANôINCREASEôINôCRIMEô)TôISôAôWELL KNOWNôFACTôTHATôINôEVERYôBAR RIOôFORBIDDENôACTIVITIESôAREôTOLERATED ôEVENôCOMMON ôANDôTHATô ILLEGALITYôHASôAôLEVELôOFôCOMMUNITYôACCEPTANCEô4HEôGOVERNMENTô HASôNOTôMETôTHEôNEEDSôOFôFAMILIESôORôTHEôCOMMUNITYôANDôSOôTHEYô HAVEôIMPLEMENTED ôATôSTREETôLEVEL ôAôNEWôSOCIALôFABRICôWITHôAô RANGEôOFôALTERNATIVESôFORôSELF EMPLOYMENTôANDôURBANôSURVIVAL

ô THOSEôWHOôCOMMITôCRIMESô ô THEôVICTIMSô ô THEôCOMMUNITYôANDôSOCIETYô

4HESEôMAKEôUPôANôOVERALLôSTRUCTUREôTHROUGHôWHICHôWEôCATCHô GLIMPSESôOFôTHEôHIDDENôLEVELSôOFôDELINQUENCYôANDôGANGSTERISMô 0ASTôDEkNITIONSôOFôFEDERALôCRIME ôANDôSIMILARôPROVISIONSôINôCOM MONôLAW ôAREôNOWôBEINGôREPLACEDôBYôLEGISLATIONôWHOSEôALLEGEDô PURPOSEôISôTOôCONTROLôgDELINQUENCYuô4HEôSTATEôSPENDSôITSôTIMEô DEkNINGôANDôCATEGORIZINGôNEWôFORBIDDENôBEHAVIORSôANDôILLEGALô ACTS ôANDôTHISôNEWôLEGISLATIONôISôPRIMARILYôUSEDôTOôFRIGHTENôTHEô SOCIALôGROUPSôATôWHICHôITôISôTARGETED

4HEôINTENSIkCATIONôOFôPRIVATEôFORMSôOFôECONOMICôSOVEREIGNTYô ANDôLABORôAUTONOMYôRANKLESôAôBOURGEOISIEôTHATôWASôITSELFôCRE ATEDôBYôVIOLENCE ôSINCEôTHEôPROCESSôOFôgPRIMITIVEôACCUMULATIONô OFôCAPITALuôCAMEôFROMôCRIMINALôEXPROPRIATIONSômôAôgCAPITALISTô GANGSTERISMuôTHATôAMASSEDôWEALTHôBYôMEANSôOFôTHEFT ôFRAUDôANDô PLUNDERô4HEôMAkAôORôTHEôLOCALôBANDITRYôCANôBEôSEENôASôSUB STITUTESôFORôTHEô3TATE ôPRESERVINGôTHEôORGANIZATIONôANDôCONTROLô OFôCRIMEô%VENôTHOUGHôEACHôLOCALôMAkAôHASôREVIVEDôAôCERTAINô BACKWARDôAPPROACHôTOôCONTROLLINGôITSôTERRITORY ôWHENôTHEôPROC ESSôOFôPOLICEôMODERNIZATIONôISôWORNôOUTôORôCORRUPTEDôTHEôMAkAô SERVESôTOôREVEALôTHISôNEUTRALIZATIONôOFôPOLICEôACTIVITY ôANDôWITHô ITôTHEôLACKôOFôINSTITUTIONALôPROTECTIONôFORôTHOSEôWHOôMAKEôUPôITSô gCLIENTELEuô

!ôNEWôPOLICEôMODELôISôBEINGôSTRUCTUREDôALONGôTHEôLINESôOFôAô MILITARYôORôCOUNTER INSURGENCYôOPERATION ôWEAVINGôAôkNEôNETôTHATô ONLYôCATCHESôSMALLôkSHô3TATEôPOLICYôFANTASIZESôABOUTôAôgSECUREô -EXICOuôWITHOUTôTRYINGôTOôSOLVEôSTRUCTURALôPROBLEMS ôANDôPRE TENDSôTOôCOMBATôPOVERTYôBYôINCRIMINATINGôANDôPERSECUTINGôTHEô POORô!TôTHEôSAMEôTIME ôLOCALôARTISANSôANDôFAMILYôWORKSHOPSô HAVEôCOMEôUNDERôATTACKôFROMôTHEôSTATEôANDôITSôINSTITUTIONS ô

)NôOURôSOCIETY ôTHEôNEWôPOORôUNDERSTANDôTHATôCAPITALôISôCOOR DINATEDôGLOBALLYôANDôTHATôUNEMPLOYMENTôISôFRAGMENTEDôLABOR ô WHILEôTHEôCRISISôHASôLEDôTOôTHEôCOLLAPSEôOFôTRADITIONALôTRADESô)Nô THISôSITUATION ôTHOSEôINôSEARCHôOFôNEWôSTRATEGIESôFORôCONTROLLINGô CRIMEôHAVEôTURNEDôTOôBUREAUCRATICôSOLUTIONSô4HEôPREOCCUPATIONô ISôNOôLONGERôWITHôTHEôSOCIALôPROkLEôOFôINDIVIDUALSôBUTôRATHERôTHEô



0240_057_self_org.indd 14-15

25/09/06 17:40:18

4HEô"LACKôSPOTô3NEAKER $ESCRIPTION %THICALôCONSUMERISMôMAKESôAôBIDôFORôHIPNESSô!DBUSTERSôSTARTôADVERTISING 4EXT 4HEô"LACKSPOTô!NTICORPORATIONôANDôTHEô"LACKSPOTô3HOESôVENTUREôAREôPROJECTSôOFô!D BUSTERSô-EDIAô&OUNDATIONô ô

/URôMISSIONôISôTOôESTABLISHôAôWORLDWIDEôCONSUMERôCOOPERATIVEôANDôTOôREASSERTô

CONSUMERôSOVEREIGNTYôOVERôCAPITALISMô7EôHOPEôTHISôBLACKSPOTôSNEAKERôVENTUREôISôTHEô BEGINNINGôOFôAôNEWôERAôINôETHICAL ôWORKER FRIENDLY ôENVIRONMENTALLYôFRIENDLYôPRODUCTIONô INôTHEôSHOEôINDUSTRY 4HEô3HOESôômôô4HEôCLASSICô"LACKSPOTô3NEAKERôANDôVô4HEô5NSWOOSHERôAREôBOTHôDE SIGNEDôBYô*OHNô&LUEVOG ôKNOWNôFORôHISôCUTTINGôEDGEôINNOVATIVENESSôANDôlAIRô4HEôSHOESô COMPLYôWITHôVEGANôSTANDARDS ôANDôAREôBEINGôMONITOREDôBYô2OBINô7EBBôOFô6EGETARIANô 3HOESôINôTHEô5+ô2OBINôISôANôINDUSTRYôLEADERôDEDICATEDôTOôTHEôPRODUCTIONôOFôETHICALô FOOTWEARô"LACKSPOTSôAREôSOLDôONLYôINôINDEPENDENTLYôOWNEDôRETAILôSTORESôWORLDWIDE ô

7EREôUSINGôôORGANICôHEMP ôWHICHôISôPROCESSEDôWITHôNATURALôMETHODSôSUCHô

ASôWATERôRETTING ôELIMINATINGôTHEôNEEDôTOôUSEôCHEMICALSô4HEô"LACKSPOTô3NEAKERôHASô AôRUBBERôSOLEôANDôAôTOEôCAPôTHATôISôôBIODEGRADABLE ôWHEREASô4HEô5NSWOOSHERô HASôAôSOLEôMADEôFROMôRECOVEREDôCARôTIRESô 4HEô0ROkTSôômôô9ES ô"LACKSPOTô3HOESôISôAôFOR PROkTôVENTUREôôWEôWOULDNTôHAVEôITôANYô OTHERôWAYô6IEWôTHEôCOSTôBREAKDOWNôFORôVô4HEô5NSWOOSHER ô0ROkTSôLETôUSôDOô WHATôTHEôSHOEôHASôALWAYSôPROMISEDô&ORôROUNDôONE ôWELLôLAUNCHôOURô46ôCAMPAIGN ô ANDôIFôANYôNETWORKôREFUSESôTOôSELLôUSôAIRTIME ôWELLôHAULôTHEMôINTOôCOURTô4HEN ôIFôTHISô RECYCLED TIRE ôORGANIC HEMPô5NSWOOSHERôREALLYôTAKESôOFFôASôAôNEWôKINDôOFôCOOLôINô THEôSNEAKERôINDUSTRY ôWELLôUSEôEVERYôPENNYôOFôPROkTôONôKICK ASSôSOCIALôCAMPAIGNSô ANDôANTI CORPORATEôMARKETINGô4HEôBESTôPARTôISôTHATôITLLôBEôUPôTOôTHEôSHAREHOLD ERSôOFô4HEô"LACKSPOTô!NTICORPORATIONôTOôBRAINSTORMôANDôDECIDEôONôHOWôWEôDOôITôô $OôWEôGOôAFTERô-C$ONALDSôWITHôSPOTSôONôTHEô&OODô.ETWORKô 3OURCEôô WWWADBUSTERSORGMETASCORPOBLACKSPOTSHOESINFOPHP &ORôMOREôINFORMATIONô !DBUSTERS ôTHEôMEDIAFOUNDATIONôv7EôAREôAôGLOBALôNETWORKôOFôARTISTS ôACTIVISTS ôWRITERS ô PRANKSTERS ôSTUDENTS ôEDUCATORSôANDôENTREPRENEURSôWHOôWANTôTOôADVANCEôTHEôNEWô SOCIALôACTIVISTôMOVEMENTôOFôTHEôINFORMATIONôAGEô/URôAIMôISôTOôTOPPLEôEXISTINGôPOWERô STRUCTURESôANDôFORGEôAôMAJORôSHIFTôINôTHEôWAYôWEôWILLôLIVEôINôTHEôSTôCENTURYh WWWADBUSTERSORG WWWADBUSTERSORGMETASCORPOBLACKSPOTSHOES

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñI>@HñPMLQñ0KB>HBO

0240_057_self_org.indd 16-17

25/09/06 17:40:20

!RTISTô0ENSIONô4RUST $ESCRIPTION !Nô)NVESTMENTô0ROGRAMô$ESIGNEDô3PECIkCALLYôFORô!RTISTS 4EXT !04,ONDON !RTISTô0ENSIONô4RUSTôISôAôHYBRIDôCURATORIALôANDôkNANCIALôORGANISATIONôTHATôMAKESôITô POSSIBLEôFORôARTISTSôTOôSAVEôTHEIRôARTôWORKSôDURINGôTHEôFORMATIVEôYEARSôOFôTHEIRôCAREERô 4HISôENABLESôARTISTSôTOôBENEkTôDIRECTLYôFROMôTHEôEVENTUALôSALEôOFôTHEIRôWORKS ôANDôTHEô WORKSôOFôTHEIRôPEERS ôATôANôAPPRECIATEDôVALUEô ô

/VERôTIMEôTHEôWORKSôWILLôFORMôAôWORLD CLASSôCOLLECTION ôWITHôEACHôARTISTôREPRESENTEDô

INôDEPTHô0ARTICIPATINGôARTISTSôWILLôINVESTôINôTHEMSELVESôBYôADDINGôONEôORôTWOôARTôWORKSô PERôYEARôTOôTHEôCOLLECTION ôUNTILôTHEYôHAVEôSAVEDôôWORKSôOVERôAôPERIODôOFôôYEARSô ô

!TôANôAPPROPRIATEôTIMEôINôTHEôFUTURE ôTHESEôWORKSôWILLôBEôRETURNEDôTOôTHEôMARKETô!Tô

THISôPOINTôTHEôWORKSôAPPRECIATEDôSECONDARY MARKETôVALUEôWILLôBEôREALISEDôôOFôTHEô NETôPROCEEDSôFROMôTHEôSALEôWILLôBEôDEPOSITEDôDIRECTLYôINTOôTHEôSAVINGSôACCOUNTôOFôTHEô INDIVIDUALôARTISTôWHOSEôWORKôHASôBEENôSOLDô!NOTHERô ôLESSôSOMEô!04ôOPERATINGô COSTS ôWILLôBEôSHAREDôEQUALLYôBETWEENôALLôOFôTHEôARTISTSôINôTHEôTRUSTô4HEôREMAININGô ôWILLôBEôRETAINEDôBYô!04ôASôAôFEEôFORôTHEôLONG TERMôMANAGEMENTôOFôTHEôENTIREô PROCESSô ô

!04ôISôANôINNOVATIVEôINITIATIVEôCONCEIVEDôANDôDEVELOPEDôBYô-UTUAL !RT ô)NC ôAôkNAN

CIALôSERVICESôCOMPANYôFORMEDôWITHôSPECIALISEDôEXPERTISEôDIRECTEDôTOWARDSôMEETINGô THEôUNIQUEôANDôUNMETôNEEDSôOFôTHEôARTôWORLD 3OURCE WWWARTISTPENSIONTRUSTORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWARTISTPENSIONTRUSTORG *UNEôôTHEREôAREô!04SôINô"ANGKOK ô"ERLIN ô"EIJING ô)STANBUL ô,ONDON ô,OSô!NGELES ô -EXICOô#ITY ô-UMBAI ô.EWô9ORK ô3AOô0AULO

%XAMPLESôôYôôOQFPQñ-BKPFLKñ1ORPQ

0240_057_self_org.indd 18-19

25/09/06 17:40:21

CHARACTERISTICSôOFôLARGERôPOPULATIONS ôANDôTHEôOBJECTIVEôOFôECO NOMICôPOLICYôISôNOTôTOôCHANGEôTHOSEôCHARACTERISTICSôTOOôMUCHô BUTôTOôNEUTRALIZEôTHEIRôDISTURBINGôEFFECTôONôTHEôRESTôOFôSOCIETYô 4HISôSITUATIONôLEADSôTOôANôATTEMPTôTOôCONTROLôTHEôINFORMALôECON OMYôANDôCRIMEôTHATôCOMBINESôLOGICôWITHôTHEôPRACTICEôOFôLEGALô COSTôACCOUNTINGôBYôINSURANCEôCOMPANIESô4HISôASSUMESôTHEô REDUCTIONôOFôRISKôWITHôMERCANTILEôEFkCIENCYôTHEôMARKETôBEGINSô TOôSUBSTITUTEôITSELFôFORôTHEôPOLITICALôPROCESS ôWHILEôPRIVATEôINSUR ANCEôCOMPANIESôBEGINôTOôPROGRESSIVELYôTAKEôOVERôTHEô3TATE ô ADMINISTERINGôCOSTôBENEkTSôTOôTHOSEôWHOôINSUREôTHEIRôGOODSô ANDôWELLBEINGô ô 7EôAREôFACINGôAôSTAGEôOFôCAPITALISMôINôAôPHASEôOFôDESTRUCTIVEô REPRODUCTIONôOFôEVERYTHINGôTHATôSTANDSôINôITSôWAY ôINôWHICHôTHEô FREEôMARKETôSOCIETYôUNFETTEREDôCAPITALISM ôNOWôREPRESENTSôTHEô PURSUITôOFôPRIVATEôGAINôTHATôERODESôANDôSUBORDINATESôTHEôPOPU LARôECONOMYô4HISôPHASEôHASôLEDôTHEô-EXICANô3TATEôTOôARMôANDô STANDARDIZEôTHEôPOLICEôINôANôATTEMPTôTOôRESTRAINôTHATôWHICHôITô CANNOTôCONTROLôASôAôGOVERNMENTô 4HISôECONOMICôMODELôGENERATESôAôLEVELôOFôDISPARITYôTHATôENDAN GERSôTHEôCOMMUNITYSôQUALITYôOFôLIFEôANDôSPAWNSôCRIMINALITYô)Tô FOMENTSôFEAR ôMAKINGôPEOPLEôFEELôTHATôDELINQUENCYôANDôILLEGAL ITYôAREôEVERYWHERE ôANDôCREATESôANôUNCERTAINTYôTHATôSHATTERSô CITIZENSôTRUSTôINôONEôANOTHER )FôAôNATIONSôDEVELOPMENTôISôMEASUREDôBYôITSô'.0ôGROSSôNA TIONALôPRODUCT ôTHENôTODAYôTHEô'#0ôGROSSôCRIMINALôPRODUCT ô MEASURESôCRIMINALôDEVELOPMENT ôASôITôHASôPERMEATEDôALLôLEVELSô OFôPOLITICSôANDôOFôTHEôECONOMYôMOREôANDôMOREôTHEREôISôEVI DENCEôTHATôAôGOVERNMENTôDOESôNOTôALWAYSôHAVEôPOWERôORôTHEô


0240_057_self_org.indd 20-21

ABILITYôTOôRULEô4ODAYôONEôNEGOTIATESôWITHôTHEôMARKETôANDôNOTô WITHôTHEô3TATE ô #ONSEQUENTLY ôTHEôGROWTHôOFôANYôBUSINESS ôLEGALôORôOTHERWISE ô ISôCONDITIONEDôBYôTHEôNEWôCULTUREôOFôMASSIVEôCONSUMERISM ô OVERWHELMINGLYôBASEDôONôPROkTSôATôANYôPRICE ôWHEREôgIMPATIENTô CAPITALISMuôHASôGENERATEDôECONOMICôCRIMEôTHATôHASôFORôSOMEô TIMEôDISPLACEDôMERCHANDISEôINôCERTAINôPREVIOUSLYôUNSUSPECTEDô COMMERCIALôNICHES ô 4HEôNEWôMARKETôSOCIETYôISôSOôINTERTWINEDôWITHôBOTHôLEGITIMATEô ANDôCRIMINALôINTERESTSôTHATôYOUôCANôNOôLONGERôTELLôWHICHôISô WHICH ôALTHOUGHôWHATôISôMOSTôEVIDENTôISôTHEôGEOPOLITICSôOFôTHEô CRIMINALôMARKETô 4HEôPEOPLEôOFô4EPITOôUNDERSTANDôTHATôWEôHAVEôBEENôBRANDEDô WITHôTHISôCRIMINALôSTIGMA ôANDôINôORDERôTOôOVERCOMEôIT ôWEôAREô FREEINGôOURSELVESôOFôIT ôTHROUGHôOURôOWNôSKILLEDôARTISANSHIPôANDô COMMERCIALôBARRIOôCHARISMA 4HEô3TATEôISôSEEINGôCONTROLôOFôITSôOWNôTERRITORYôSLIPôAWAY ôWHICHô LEADSôTOôAôRENEWALôOFôDELINQUENTôPOWERôAMONGôTHEôGROUPSôTHATô SUBSTITUTEôFORôTHEô3TATEômôGROUPSôTHATôAREôTAKINGôOVERôCONTROLô WHEREôTHEô3TATEôHASôBEENôFORCEDôOUT ôORôWHEREôITôHASôLEFTôVA CANTôAREASôTHATôITôNOôLONGERôCONSIDERSôCRUCIALôFORôTHEôPRIMARYôAC CUMULATIONôOFôCAPITALô4HEôUPSHOTôOFôTHISôISôTHATôTHEôBREAKDOWNô INôTHEôCONTROLôOFôCRIMEôGOESôBEYONDôTHEôPROBLEMSôOFôTHEôVICTIMô ANDôTHEôCOMMUNITY ôSINCEôTHEôABILITYôOFôTHEôMODERNôGLOBALôPI RATESôTOôPUNISHôDOESôNOTôSEEMôTOôHAVEôANYôLIMITSôORôBORDERS #HILANGOS ôORôTHEôPEOPLEôOFô-EXICOô#ITY ôHAVEôBEENôFRIGHTENEDô BYôTHEôSMOKESCREENôOFôWHATôISôHAPPENINGôINô4EPITO ôBUTôDONTô


25/09/06 17:40:21

REALIZEôTHATô-EXICOôTODAYôISôTHEô4EPITOôOFôTHEôWORLDô-EXICOôISô IMMERSEDôINôTHEôGLOBALôBARBARISMôOFôSAVAGEôCAPITALISM ôASôITô ISôOVERWHELMEDôBYôCHINADERAS ôANDôDRUGôDEALINGô4HEôNEWô GEOPOLITICSôHAVEôLEGALIZEDôSMUGGLING ôMODERNIZEDôPIRACY ôANDô CHEAPENEDôDRUGôADDICTION ôWHICHôISôWHYôNEIGHBORHOODôBAN DITRYôISôBARELYôAôNICHEôFORôANARCHYôINôCOMPARISONôWITHôTHEôSANC TUARYôOFôIMPUNITYôENJOYEDôBYôCARTELSôANDôTRANSNATIONALôMAkASô 0REVIOUSLY ôRURALôBANDITSôANDôURBANôGANGSTERSôFOUGHTôAGAINSTô THEôLOCALôCHIEFôORôLANDOWNERô4HEYôHADôNOôIDEOLOGYôOFôPOWERô ANDôTHEYôDIDôNOTôASPIREôTOôUSEôONEô4ODAY ôHOWEVER ôMODERNô CRIMEôISôAôPUNITIVEôINVOLUTIONôTHATôSEEKSôTOôWIELDôPOWER ôINCITINGô BARBARISMôANDôTERRORISMô4HEREôISôAôRESURGENCEôOFôAôMODERNô REPRESSIVEôSTATEôTHATôPROTECTSôONLYôTHEôGLOBALôMOBILITYôOFôCAPITAL ô ANDôCOVERSôUPôTHEôGEOPOLITICSôOFôCRIMINALôMARKETSôTHATôCONTINUEô TOôIMPOVERISHôCOUNTRIESôANDôTRIGGERôMIGRATIONômôFROMôTHEôCOUN TRYSIDEôTOôTHEôCITYôANDôFROMôONEôCOUNTRYôTOôANOTHER !NYôSIMILARITYôBETWEENôLOCALôSUFFERINGôANDôWHATôWEôAREôEXPERI ENCINGôATôAôNATIONALôLEVELôISôPRESENTEDôASôPUREôCOINCIDENCE ôASô THEôMEDIAôREINFORCESôTHEôBLACKôLEGENDôOFô4EPITOô#ONSEQUENTLY ô WEôFEELôTHEôNEEDôTOôREVEALôWHYôWEôREBELôAGAINSTôTHOSEôWHOôATô ALLôCOSTôWANTôTOôMAKEôOFôOURôBARRIOôBRAVOôAôSOCIAL ECONOMICô LABORATORYôOFôDELINQUENCYôANDôDRUGôDEALINGô ô *USTôASôNATIONALôSOVEREIGNTYôISôDISAPPEARING ôTHEôMODERNôRE PRESSIVEôSTATEôGERRYMANDERSôBOTHôTHEôEXISTINGôDISTRICTSôANDôTHEô VIRTUALôUBIQUITYôOFô4EPITO ôALTERINGôTHEôECONOMICôEQUILIBRIUMôFROMô WITHINôASôWELLôASôFROMôWITHOUTô

ANDôTHEôSUBSISTENCEôECONOMIESôTHATôSURROUNDôIT ôWITHOUTôEVERô AFFECTINGôTHEôBLACKôMARKETôPROkTABILITYôTHATôISôkNANCIALLYôADMIN ISTEREDôBYôWHITE COLLARôEXECUTIVESô )NôTHISôPITCHEDôBATTLEôAGAINSTôTHEôBARRIOôBRAVO ôMANYôOFôOURô YOUTHôHAVEôBEENôCORRUPTED ôOTHERSôHAVEôLOSTôTHEIRôLIVES ôANDô MANYôMOREôHAVEôBECOMEôPRISONôFODDERô.EVERTHELESS ô4EPITOô LIVES ôRISKINGôEVERYTHING ôKNOWINGôTHATôFORôAôBASTARDôYOUôNEEDô AôBASTARDôANDôAôHALFô%VENôTHEôBLACKôSHEEPôISôAôMEMBERôOFôTHEô FAMILYôANDôCHARISMAôWILLôPUTôANôENDôTOôTHEôSTIGMA Úô#%4%0)3ô WWWBARRIODETEPITOCOMMX

4RANSLATORSôNOTEô#HINADERASôISôTHEôNOMENCLATUREôASSIGNEDôTOôIMPORTEDôGOODSôFROMô#HINA ôUSUALLYô THOSEôTHATôAREôKNOCK OFFSôORôREPLICASôOFôOTHERôBRANDEDôCOMMODITIESô)TSôAôCLOSEôVARIATIONôOFôCHINOISERIEô WHICHôWASôEMPLOYEDôINôTHEôTHôANDôTHôCENTURYô!NGLOôSPEAKINGôWORLDôTOôALLôkNEôGOODSôCOMINGôFROMô #HINAôIEôPORCELAINôANDôSILKôANDORôITSôINlUENCEôUPONôDOMESTICôPRODUCTIONôOFôGOODSô"UTôMOREôLIKELY ô #HINADERASôCOMESôFROMôDIRECTôWORDôPLAYôWITHôTHEôWORDô#HINGADERASô#HINGAôTHEô-EXICANô3PANISHôSLANGô TERMôFORôFUCK ôTOôFUCKôORôFUCKINGôANDôCOMPOUNDEDôWITHôDERAS ôROUGHLYôMEANINGôTHINGS ôTHUSô@FUCKINGô THINGS ôANDôADDINGô#HINAôINTOôTHEôWORDôPLAYôCOMESôOFFôASô@FUCKINGô#HINESEôTHINGS

)TôISôHARDôTOôBELIEVEôTHATôPIRACYôIMPOVERISHESôCOMMERCEô0IRACYô CREATESôCONTROLLEDôkNANCIALôSPACESôFORôTHOSEôWHOôMAKEôTHEIRô LIVING ôBYôMILKINGôTHEôCONlICTôBETWEENôFORMALôANDôINFORMALôTRADEô


0240_057_self_org.indd 22-23


25/09/06 17:40:21

4HEôRECOVEREDôFACTORYôMOVEMENTôô INô!RGENTINA $ESCRIPTION 7ORKERSôSELF MANAGEMENT 4EXT )NôTHEôWAKEôOFôTHEôôECONOMICôCRISIS ôABOUTôTWOôHUNDREDô!RGENTINEôCOMPANIESô WEREôgRECOVEREDuôBYôTHEIRôWORKERSôANDôTURNEDôINTOôCOOPERATIVESô4HEôPROLIFERATIONôOFô THESEôgRECOVERIESuôHASôLEDôTOôTHEôFORMATIONôOFôAôRECOVEREDôFACTORYôMOVEMENT ôWHICHô HASôTIESôTOôAôDIVERSEôPOLITICALôNETWORKôINCLUDINGô0ERONISTSôONôTHEôLEFTôANDôRIGHT ôANAR CHISTSôANDôCOMMUNISTSô;=ô ô

!SôOFô ôABOUTô ô!RGENTINEôWORKERSôRUNôRECOVEREDôFACTORIESô

3OURCEô WWWENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI2ECOVERED?FACTORY "RUKMANôômô)TSôWORKERSôHAVEôOCCUPIEDôTHISôTEXTILEôFACTORYôINôTHEôCAPITALôCITYôSINCEô $ECEMBERô ôô3INCEô*ANUARYôôTHISôYEAR ôTHEYôHAVEôPUTôITôINTOôOPERATIONô9URI ô SHOPôSTEWARDô@4HEôIMPORTANCEôOFôTHISôMEETINGôISôTOôGIVEôAôSTEPôTOWARDSôTHEôUNITYô OFôOCCUPIEDôFACTORIES ôWORKERSôSTRUGGLES ôPOPULARôASSEMBLIES ôSTUDENTS ôPICKETSô 5NEMPLOYMENTôISôTHEôHOTTESTôTOPICôWEôAREôTHEôMOSTôAFFECTED :ANONôômôôWORKERSôADMINISTERôANDôRUNôTHISôCERAMICSôFACTORY ôINôTHEôPROVINCEôOFô .EUQU¯Nô4HEôFACTORYôHASôBEENôOCCUPIEDôSINCEô/CTOBERô ôôANDôHASôBEENôOP ERATINGôSINCEô&EBRUARYôô)TôISôAôSYMBOLôOFôTHEôSTRUGGLEôFORôSTATE PROPERTYôUNDERô WORKERSôCONTROLô2AULô'ODOY ô'ENERALô3ECRETARYôOFôTHEô5NIONôOFô#ERAMICSô7ORKERSôOFô .EUQU¯Nô3/%#. ô@ôFACTORIESôSHUTôDOWNôINôTHEôLASTôMONTHS ôTHEREôAREôôTHATôINô ONEôWAYôORôANOTHERôWORKERSôHAVEôTRIEDôTOôSAVEô4HISôISôTHEôkRSTôSTEPôTHEôSELF DEFENCEô 7EôHAVEôANôINTERESTINGôDEBATEôOVERôWHETHERôTOôFORMôCOOPERATIVES ôORôTOôkGHTôFORô STATE PROPERTYôUNDERôWORKERSôCONTROLô"UTôTHEREôISôONEôTHINGôWEôAREôCERTAINôOF ôTHATô WEôWILLôGETôNOWHEREôWITHOUTôSTRUGGLEôEITHERôWEôkGHTôORôNOTHINGôWILLôHAPPEN7ITHô ôOFôTHEôPOPULATIONôBELOWôTHEôPOVERTYôLINE ôIFôWEôDONTôCHANGEôTHEôMOSTôPROFOUNDô PROBLEMS ôIFôWEôDONTôGETôTOGETHERôINôAôCOMMONôSTRUGGLE ôNOôMATTERôWHATôFACTORYôWEô HAVEôWORKING ôWEôAREôGOINGôTOôLOSEôITôALL *UNINô#LINICôômô4HEôCLINICôISôINôTHEôCITYôOFô#ORDOBA ôTHEREôAREôôWORKERSô)TôHASôBEENô OCCUPIEDôSINCEô-AYôôANDôOFFERINGôHEALTH CAREôSERVICESôTOôTHEôCOMMUNITYôSINCEô *UNEôô 2IOô4URBIOôômôôMINERSôWORKôINôTHEô2IOô4URBIOôMINEôINô3ANTAô#RUZô-ENDEZ ôLEADERô OFô!4% 2IOô4URBIOô@7EôWENTôANDôTOOKôOVERôTHEô#HAMBERôOFô2EPRESENTATIVESôOFô3ANTAô #RUZôTOôDEMANDôTHATôGOVERNMENTôTAKEôOVERôTHEôCOMPANYôTODAYôWEôAREôGOINGôFORô

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñOB@LSBOBAñC>@QLOVñJLSBJBKQñFKñODBKQFK>

0240_057_self_org.indd 24-25

25/09/06 17:40:22

THEôLASTôSTEP ôTHATôISôWORKERSôCONTROL ôTHEôGENERALôCONTROLôOFôTHEôWHOLEôCOMPANY ôOFô

SITUATIONôANDôTHATôHAVEôBEENôRECOVEREDôBYôWORKERSôWEôWANTôTOôBRINGôAôPROPOSALôTHEô

THEôWHOLEôADMINISTRATIONô7EôDOôNOTôWANTôANYôMOREôWORKERSôOUTôINôTHEôSTREETô4ODAYô

UNITYôOFôALLôTHEôESTABLISHMENTSôWHOôAREôkGHTINGôTODAYôANDôTHATôAREôNOTôHEREôYETô)FôWEô

WEôCONTINUEôkGHTINGôFORôOURôJOBS

AREôCAPABLEôOFôUNIFYINGôWITHôALLôTHEôRESTôWHOôAREôkGHTINGôWEôCANôPROMOTEôAôPROJECTôTOô LEGITIMATEôTHOSEôCOOPERATIVESôSOôTHATôTHEYôCANôSTARTôWORKINGôTHATôISôAôSTEPôTOWARDSô

%Lô!GUANTEôômô4HISôCOOPERATIVEôISôINôNORTHERNô"UENOSô!IRESô4HEôFACTORYôHASôBEENô

WORKERSôCONTROL

OCCUPIEDôSINCEô!PRILôô@7EôADVISEôTHEôBROTHERSôWHOôFORMôCOOPERATIVESôTOôCONTINUEô kGHTINGôANDôTOôNEVERôISOLATEôFROMôOTHERôSTRUGGLESô4HISôISôOURôDESIREôANDôTHEôMAN

$ELô6ALLEôômô4HISôISôAôCERAMICSôFACTORYôWITHôôWORKERSô4HEYôHAVEôPUTôUPôANôIMPORTANTô

DATEôTHATô)ôBRINGôFROMôTHEôGRASSROOTSôASSEMBLYôWEôCARRIEDôOUTôINôOURôFACTORYôTOôCALLô

STRUGGLE ôOVERôôMONTHS ôWITHôROADôBLOCKSôANDôPROTESTS ôUNTILôTHEYôDEFEATEDôTHEôSACK

FORôUNITYô7EôDONTôWANTôTOôBEôUNDERESTIMATED ôWEôAREôHEREôBECAUSEôTHISôMEETINGôISô

INGSô4HEYôAREôPARTôOFôTHEô5NIONôOFô#ERAMICSô7ORKERSôOFô.EUQU¯Nô

REALLYôCALLEDôBYôTHEôWORKERS 3OURCE 4IGREô3UPERMARKETôômô&ORôôMONTHS ôWORKERSôHAVEôOCCUPIEDôTHISôSUPERMARKETôINô

%XTRACTSôFROMôAôREPORTôOFôAôMEETINGôOFôFACTORIESôUNDERôWORKERSôADMINISTRATION ô"UENOSô

2OSARIOô4HEôOWNERSôTOOKôOFFôWITHôôMILLIONôDOLLARSôLEAVINGôôFAMILIESôOUTôONôTHEô

!IRES ô3EPTEMBERôTH ô ô'UILLOô0ISTONESI ôPUBLISHEDôINô,Aô6ERDADô/BRERAô

STREETô@7EôWANTôTOôTELLôTHEôBOSSôWITHôGREATôPRIDEôTHATôAFTERôHAVINGôWALKEDôALLôAROUNDô 2OSARIOôBLOCKINGôROADSôTOôKEEPôUPôOURôSTRUGGLE ôYESTERDAYô3EPTEMBERôôATôAM ôTHEô

&ORôMOREôINFORMATION

BROTHERSôFROMô4IGREôBEGANôWORKINGô

WWWFASINPATCOMAR

ô

WWWOBREROSDEZANONORG

&ROMôTHEôPOWERSôTHATôBE ôTHEôONLYôHELPôWEôGOTôWASôkVEôBROTHERSôARRESTEDôANDôô

EVICTIONôTHREATSô4HISôISôWHY ôWITHôTHEôEVICTIONôHANGINGôOVERôOURôHEADS ôWEôDECIDEDôTOô

WWWTHETAKEORG

LOOKôFORôSOLIDARITYôATô4IGREôTHEREôISôAô#OORDINATORôOFôNEIGHBORHOODôASSEMBLIESô!LLô THEôSOCIALôMOVEMENTSôINVOLVEDôINôTHEôSTRUGGLE ôTHEôSTUDENTS ôTHEôWORKERSôWHOôSUFFERô

)MAGEôSOURCE

UNDERôTREACHEROUSôBUREAUCRACIESôTHATôDONTôLETôTHEMôORGANIZEôINôTHEIRôUNION ôTHEYôAREô

)NDYMEDIAô!RGENTINA

PARTICIPATINGôATô4IGREô!LLôTHATôWEôAREôLEARNINGôWILLôLETôUSôMOVEôAHEAD #UYOô'LASSWAREôômô,OCATEDôINôTHEôCITYôOFô2OSARIO ôTHEôGLASSWAREôFACTORYôHADôMOREô THANôôWORKERSô)Nô&EBRUARYô ôTHEôCOMPANYôWENTôBANKRUPTô&ROMô3EPTEMBERô ôMOREôTHANôôWORKERSôINSTALLEDôAôCAMPôATôTHEôGATES ôDEMANDINGôTHEôIMMEDIATEô REOPENINGôOFôTHEôPLANTô ô

@7EôAREôOUTSIDEôTHEôPLANT ôWEôHAVEôNOTôOCCUPIEDôITôYET ôBECAUSEôTHEôCONlICTôWASô

AôYEARôAGO ôTHEôGLASSôINDUSTRYôUNIONôHAVEôABANDONEDôUSôJUSTôLIKEôALLôTHEôRESTô4HEô BROTHERSôWEREôSCATTEREDôANDôWITHôTHEôPASSINGôOFôTIMEôTHEôCAMPôBEGANôTOôBRINGôTHEô BROTHERSôBACKô4HEREôAREôMANYôALTERNATIVESô4HEôTHINGôISôWEôMUSTôDEBATEôTHEôBESTôOUT COMEô0ERSONALLYô)ôTHINKôTHATôTHEôBESTôISôWORKERSôCONTROL ôBUTôTHEREôAREôBROTHERSôWHOô MAYôNOTôSEEôTHIS ôTHENôTHEôKEYôISôTOôDEBATEôANDôTOôkGHTôALLôTOGETHER ôASôWORKERS #(),!6%24ôômô4HISôPRINTINGôPLANTôHASôBEENôOCCUPIEDôFORôTHEôPASTôôMONTHSôINôTHEô CAPITALôCITYô4HEôSOLIDARITYôOFôASSEMBLIES ôOFôSOCIALôORGANIZATIONSôANDôLEFTISTôPOLITICALô PARTIESôSTOPPEDôTHEôEVICTIONôATTEMPTôCARRIEDôOUTôLASTô-AYô &RICADERôômô/Nô-AYô ôôFORMERôEMPLOYEESôOCCUPIEDôTHEôREFRIGERATINGôPLANTôOFôTHEô SURROUNDINGSôOFô'ENERALô2OCA ô2IOô.EGROô4HEôSTRUGGLEôFORôTHEôRE OPENINGôOFôTHEô PLANTôCONTINUESô &LEXICOOPôômô@)ôCOMEôFROMô#ORDOBAôREPRESENTINGôFOURôCOMPANIESôTHATôAREôINôTHEôSAMEô


0240_057_self_org.indd 26-27


25/09/06 17:40:23

4HEô2IGHTô TOô-ARYô3UEô !NUPAMô#HANDERôANDô-ADHAVIô3UNDERô

ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 28-29

4HEô2IGHTôTOô-ARYô3UE

25/09/06 17:40:23

@'EE ôGOLLY ôGOSH ô GLORIOSKY ôTHOUGHTô -ARYô3UEôASôSHEôSTEPPEDô ONôTHEôBRIDGEôOFôTHEô%NTER PRISEô @(EREô)ôAM ôTHEôYOUNG ESTôLIEUTENANTôINôTHEôlEETô môONLYôkFTEENôANDôAôHALFô YEARSôOLDô #APTAINô+IRKôCAMEôUPôô TOôHERô@/H ô,IEUTENANT ôô )ôLOVEôYOUôMADLYô7ILLôYOUô COMEôTOôBEDôWITHôMEô @#APTAINô)ôAMôNOTô THATôKINDôOFôGIRLô

@9OUREôRIGHT ôANDô )ôRESPECTôYOUôFORôITô(ERE ô TAKEôOVERôTHEô SHIPôFORôAôMINUTEô WHILEô)ôGOôGETô SOMEôCOFFEEôFORôUSô -Rô3POCKôCAMEô ONTOôTHEôBRIDGEô @7HATôAREôYOUôDOINGôINôTHEô COMMANDôSEAT ô,IEUTEN ANTô @4HEô#APTAINôTOLDôMEôTOô @&LAWLESSLYôLOGICALô )ôADMIREôYOURôMINDô mô0AULAô3MITH ô!ô4REKKIESô4ALEô ;I=ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 30-31


25/09/06 17:40:24

'OINGôWHEREôONLYôMENôHADôGONEôBEFORE ô,IEUTENANTô-ARYô3UEô TOOKôTHEôHELMôOFôTHEô3TARSHIPô%NTERPRISE ôPERFORMINGôTOôAC CLAIMôANDôEARNINGôTHEô6ULCANô/RDERôOFô'ALLANTRYô4HISôWAS ôOFô COURSE ôFANTASY ôBUTôDOUBLYôSOô"Yô ôNOôWOMANôHADôCOM MANDEDôTHEô%NTERPRISESôBRIDGE ôACCORDINGôTOôTHEôOFkCIALô3TARô 4REKôFANTASYô)NDEED ôITôWOULDôBEôôBEFOREô#APTAINô2ACHELô 'ARRETTôWOULDôBEôSEEN ôBRIElY ôINôCHARGEôOFôTHEô%NTERPRISEôINôAô LATERô3TARô4REKôSERIESô

7EôDISSENTôFROMôTHISôVIEWô)NôTHISôESSAY ôWEôREHABILITATEô-ARYô 3UEôASôAôkGUREôOFôSUBALTERNôCRITIQUEôAND ôINDEED ôEMPOWER MENTô!SôEXEMPLIkEDôBYô,IEUTENANTô-ARYô3UE ôSHEôSERVESôTOô CONTESTôPOPULARôMEDIAôSTEREOTYPESôOFôCERTAINôGROUPSôSUCHôASô WOMEN ôGAYS ôANDôRACIALôMINORITIESô7HEREôTHEôPOPULARôMEDIAô MIGHTôSHOWôSUCHôGROUPSôASôLACKINGôAGENCYôORôEXHIBITINGôOTHERô NEGATIVEôCHARACTERISTICS ô-ARYô3UESôAREôPOWERFUL ôBRAVE ôBEAU TIFULôANDôINTREPIDô

4REKKIEô0AULAô3MITH ôHOWEVER ôWASôIMPATIENTô3OôSHEôINSERTEDô THEôYOUNGô,IEUTENANTô-ARYô3UEôINTOôTHEô3TARô4REKôUNIVERSE ôNOTô ASôCOMMUNICATIONSôOFkCER ôNURSE ôTHEôVOICEôOFôTHEôONBOARDôCOM PUTER ôORôPASSINGô+IRKôLOVE INTEREST ôBUTôASôCOMMANDERô)NôSOô DOING ô3MITHôBEGANôTHEôMODERNôINCARNATIONôOFôANôOLDôPHENOM ENONômôRETELLINGôAôCANONICALôSTORYôTOôBETTERôREPRESENTôONESELFô

4HEôPHENOMENONôOFôREWRITINGôTHEôSTORYôTOôREVALUEôYOURôPLACEôINô ITôISôNOTôSIMPLYôANôEXERCISEôINôNARCISSISMô0OPULARôSTEREOTYPESô HAVEôSUBTLEôYETôIMPORTANTôCONSEQUENCESôFORôOURôSOCIAL ôPOLITICALô ANDôECONOMICôRELATIONSô"EFOREôTHEô7ORLDô7IDEô7EB ô-ARYô 3UEôAUTHORSôMIGHTôHAVEôSTASHEDôWHATôTHEYôPENNEDôINôAôDRAWER ô DISTRIBUTEDôPHOTOCOPIES ;VI=ôOR ôATôMOST ôPUBLISHEDôTHEIRôWORKôINô ANôUNDERGROUNDôMAGAZINEô4HEôEMERGENCEôOFôTHEô7ORLDô7IDEô 7EBôOFFERSôWRITERSôAôRELATIVELYôINEXPENSIVEôANDôSIMPLEôMASSô DISTRIBUTIONôVEHICLEô0OSTINGôAôSTORYôTOôAôFANôkCTIONôWEBSITEôISô LITERALLYôFREE ôATôLEASTôFORôTHOSEôWITHôACCESSôTOôTHEô)NTERNETô

4HEôNAMEôOFôHERôCHARACTERôHASôCOMEôTOôSTANDôFORôALLôSUCHôCHAR ACTERSôINôTHEôUNIVERSEôOFôFANôkCTION;II=ô&ANôkCTIONôSPANSôALLôGENRESô INôPOPULARôCULTURE ôFROMôANIMEôTOôLITERATUREô)NôEVERYôWORKôOFôFANô LITERATURE ôTHEREôISôAô-ARYô3UEô@3HEôFENCESôWITHô-ETHOSôANDô $UNCANô-AC,EODôSHEôSAVESôTHEô%NTERPRISE ôTHEô6OYAGER ôORô THEôFABRICôOFôTIMEôANDôSPACEôSHEôkGHTSôWITHô*IMô%LLISONôINôDE FENSEôOFô#ASCADEôSHEôBATTLESôEVILôINô3UNNYDALEôALONGSIDEô"UFFYô 3OMMERS;III=ô!CCORDINGôTOô7IKIPEDIA ôAô@-ARYô3UEôISô@AôkCTIONALô CHARACTERôWHOôISôANôIDEALIZEDôSTAND INôFORôTHEôAUTHOR ôORôFORôAô STORYôWITHôSUCHôAôCHARACTER;IV=ô!ôHIGHLYôPOPULARôCONTEMPORARYô VARIANTôISôTHEô@3UEIkCATIONôOFô(ERMIONEô'RANGERôINô(ARRYô0OTTERô FANôkCTION ôRECASTINGôTHEôSIDEKICKôASôLEADERôORôkNDINGôHERôAôNEWô ROMANCE ôESPECIALLYôINô(ARRY ô$RACOô-ALFOYôORô'INNYô7EASLEYô

9ETôTHEôLAWôMAYôTREATô-ARYô3UESôASôILLEGALôARTô!UTHORSôOFô-ARYô 3UESôMAYôFACEôCOPYRIGHT ôTRADEMARKôORôPUBLICITYôRIGHTSôCLAIMSô BROUGHTôBYôTHEôOFkCIALôOWNERSôOFôTHEôPOPULARôWORKô)NôTHISôES SAY ôWEôARGUEôTHATôSUCHôAUTHORSôSHOULDôNOTôREADILYô@CEASEôANDô DESIST ôASôDEMANDEDôBYôTHEôOFkCIALôOWNERSô7HILEôNOôCOURTô HASôYETôSQUARELYôADDRESSEDôTHEôQUESTION ôWEôSUGGESTôTHATô-ARYô 3UESôMAYôWELLôBEôLEGALôUNDERôEXISTINGôLAWôINôCERTAINôCIRCUM STANCESô7EôALSOôSUGGESTôTHATôCOURTSôCLARIFYôTHEôBOUNDARIESôOFô PERMISSIBLEô-ARYô3UESôINôORDERôTOôAVOIDôTHEôCHILLINGôEFFECTôOFô LEGALôTHREATSôTOôSUCHôSPEECHô

7IKIPEDIAôOBSERVESôTHATô@-ARYô3UEôISôAôPEJORATIVEôEXPRESSIONô SUCHôFANôkCTIONôISôTYPICALLYôDERIDEDôINôFANDOMôASôNARCISSISTIC;V=ô

/URôESSAYôPROCEEDSôINôTWOôPARTSô0ARTô)ôEXPLORESôTHEôCULTURALô



0240_057_self_org.indd 32-33

25/09/06 17:40:24

4HEô"AREFOOTô#OLLEGE $ESCRIPTION %DUCATIONôMEETSôSELF SUFkCIENCYôINôRURALô2AJASTHAN 4EXT 0ROMOTINGô3ELF 3UFkCIENCYôINô2URALô)NDIA 4HEô"AREFOOTô#OLLEGEôISôAôSELF SUSTAINABLEôEDUCATIONALôSETTLEMENTôSPREADôOVERô ô SQUAREôFEETôABOUTô ôSQUAREôMETERS ôINôAôRURALôAREAôNEARô4ILONIA ô2AJASTHAN ô)NDIAô 4HEôCOLLEGEôISôENTIRELYôSOLAR ELECTRIkEDôANDôROOFSôOFôITSôBUILDINGSôAREôDESIGNEDôTOôCOL LECTôRAINWATERôTHUS ôTHEôSETTLEMENTôISôALMOSTôCOMPLETELYôSELF SUFkCIENTô4HEôPRINCIPLEô OFôSELF SUFkCIENCYôISôSUPPORTEDôBYôTHEôCOMBINATIONôOFôLOCALôKNOWLEDGEôANDôADVANCEDô TECHNOLOGYôINôAôREGIONôTHATôHASôEXPERIENCEDôANôUNRELIABLEôSUPPLYôOFôPOWERôANDôWATERô 4HEôREGIONôHASôALSOôGONEôTHROUGHôLARGE SCALEôMIGRATIONôFROMôRURALôTOôURBANôAREASô4HEô "AREFOOTô#OLLEGEôWASôFOUNDEDôINôôWITHôTHEôCONVICTIONôTHATôSOLUTIONSôTOôRURALôPROB LEMSôLIEôWITHINôTHEôRURALôPOPULATIONô4HROUGHôITSôCOMMITMENTôTOôEDUCATION ôTHEô#OLLEGEô ENCOURAGESôINDIVIDUALôEMPOWERMENTô4HEô#OLLEGEôSHARESôITSôEXPERIENCEôOFôDEVELOP INGôSELF RELIANCEôTHROUGHôTHEôMANAGEMENTôOFôNATURALôRESOURCESôWITHôNEIGHBORINGôRURALô COMMUNITIESôASôWELLôASôWITHôOTHERôCOMMUNITIESôACROSSôTHEô)NDIANôSUBCONTINENTô4HEô #OLLEGEôALSOôWORKSôINTERNATIONALLYôWITHôCOMMUNITIESôINô!FGHANISTAN ô%THIOPIA ô3IERRAô ,EONE ô+ENYA ô3ENEGAL ôANDôELSEWHEREô)TSôMEMBERSôPROMOTEôPRACTICALôKNOWLEDGEô ANDôSKILLSôRATHERôTHANôACADEMICôDEGREESôTHEôEMPHASISôHEREôISôONôgLEARNINGôBYôDOINGuô 4HEô#OLLEGEôVIEWSôITSELFôASôANôEFFECTIVEôALTERNATIVEôTOôINSTRUCTIONALôMODELSôBASEDôONô ACADEMICALLYôTRAINEDôARCHITECTS ôDOCTORSôANDôEDUCATORSô4HEôENTIREô#OLLEGEôSETTLEMENTô WASôBUILTôBYôTHEôNON ACADEMICALLYôTRAINEDô"AREFOOTô!RCHITECTS ô

ô

3OURCE WWWBAREFOOTCOLLEGEORGôANDô-ARJETICAô0OTRC &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWBAREFOOTCOLLEGEORG

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ>OBCLLQñ LIIBDB

0240_057_self_org.indd 34-35

25/09/06 17:40:25

BACKGROUNDôAGAINSTôWHICHô-ARYô3UESôAREôDRAWNô!SôWEôSHOW ô -ARYô3UESôCHALLENGEôAôPATRIARCHAL ôHOMOPHOBICôANDôRACIALLYô STEREOTYPEDôCULTURALôLANDSCAPEô4HEYôCONFRONTôTHEôTRADITIONALô PRODUCTIONôOFôKNOWLEDGEôBYôREWORKINGôTHEôCANONôTOôVALORISEô WOMENôANDôMARGINALISEDôCOMMUNITIESô-ARYô3UESôOFFERôFUNDA MENTALôEPISTEMOLOGICALôINTERVENTIONSôINôTHEôREIGNINGôDISCOURSEô 0ARTô))ôEXAMINESôTHEôLEGALôFRAMEWORKôGOVERNINGôTHEôMAKINGôOFô -ARYô3UES ôFOCUSINGôONôTHEôLAWôPREVAILINGôINôTHEô5NITEDô3TATESô 7EôREVIEWôCOPYRIGHTôCLAIMSôTHATôMAYôIMPERILô-ARYô3UESô4HEô SKEPTICôWILLôASKô7HYôNOTôWRITEôYOURôOWNôORIGINALôSTORYôRATHERô THANôINSERTINGôYOURSELFôINTOôAôSTORYôWRITTENôBYôSOMEONEôELSEô 7EôRESPONDôTOôTHISôCRITIQUEôHEREô ô

)ô-ARRY ô3UEô ô )Nô ôWHENô3TARô4REKôDEBUTEDôONôTELEVISION ôITôWASôGROUND BREAKINGô)TSôCREATOR ô'ENEô2ODDENBERRY ô@ENVISAGEDôAôMULTI RACIALôANDôMIXED GENDERôCREW ôBASEDôONôHISôASSUMPTIONôTHATôRA CIALôPREJUDICEôANDôSEXISMôWOULDôNOTôEXISTôINôTHEôRDôCENTURY;VII=ô ,IEUTENANTô5HURAôWASôTHEôkRSTô!FRICAN !MERICANôWOMANôTOôBEô FEATUREDôINôAôMAJORôTELEVISIONôSERIES;VIII=ô/FkCERô3ULUôOFFEREDôAô RAREô!SIAN !MERICANôFACEôOUTSIDEôAôMARTIALôARTSôMILIEUô

7OMEN ôGAYSôANDôRACIALôMINORITIESôHAVEôMADEôMAJORôSTRIDESô OVERôFOURôDECADESôOFôTELEVISIONô3TARô4REK ôTOO ôEVOLVEDô)Nô ôANô!FRICAN !MERICANôWOULDôCOMMANDôTHEôSPACEôSTATIONô INôTHEô3TARô4REKôSERIESô$EEPô3PACEô.INEô!ND ôINô ôMOREô THANôTWOôDECADESôAFTERô,IEUTENANTô-ARYô3UE ô#APTAINô+ATHRYNô *ANEWAYôTOOKôCOMMANDôOFôTHEôSTARSHIPô6OYAGERôINôTHEôSERIESô OFôTHEôSAMEôNAMEô 9ET ôWHILEôWEôMAYôHAVEôCOMEôAôLONGôWAY ôTHEREôISôSTILLôAôLONGô WAYôTOôGOô4AKEô!MERICANôTELEVISIONômôFORôTHOSEôOFôUSôINôTHEô 53! ôAôPRINCIPALôSOURCEôOFôINFORMATIONôABOUTôOURôWORLDô!ôRE CENTôREPORTôBYô#HILDRENô.OWôSHOWSôTHATôMALEôCHARACTERSôRE MAINôDOMINANT ôCONSISTENTLYôOUTNUMBERINGôFEMALEôCHARACTERSô BYôNEARLYôTWOôTOôONEôSINCEô;X=ô0RIMEôTIMEôTELEVISIONôPOR TRAYSô@AôWORLDôINôWHICHôWOMENôAREôSIGNIkCANTLYôYOUNGERôTHANô THEIRôMALEôCOUNTERPARTSôANDôWHEREôOLDERôWOMENôAREôHARDôTOô kND;XI=ô0ERHAPSôESPECIALLYôTELLINGôISôTHEôOCCUPATIONALôDIFFERENTIA TIONôOFôMENôANDôWOMENô@-ALEôCHARACTERSôOUTNUMBEREDôFEMALEô CHARACTERSôASôATTORNEYSôôWEREôMALE ôEXECUTIVES#%/Sô ôPHYSICIANSô ôLAWôENFORCEMENTôOFkCERSô ô PARAMEDICSFIREFIGHTERSô ôELECTEDAPPOINTEDôOFFICIALSô ôANDôCRIMINALSô ;XII=ô

"UTôDESPITEôITSôASPIRATIONS ôEQUALITYôWASôNOTôYETôTRULYôCOMPLETEô INô&EDERATIONôSPACEô5HURA ôOFôCOURSE ôWASôRELEGATEDôTOôSERVINGô ASôTHEôCOMMUNICATIONSôOFkCERô7OMENôPLAYEDôSECONDARYôROLES ô OFTENôSERVINGôASôEPISODE LONGôLOVEôINTERESTSôFORôTHEôWHITEôMALEô MEMBERSôOFôTHEôCREWô5HURAôHERSELFôBROKEôGROUNDôAGAINôWHENô SHEôPARTICIPATEDôINôNETWORKôTELEVISIONSôLIKELYôkRSTôINTERRACIALôKISSô môWITHô#APTAINô+IRK ôOFôCOURSE;IX=ô3AMEôSEXôROMANTICôRELATION SHIPSôAPPARENTLYôDIDôNOTôSURVIVEôINTOôOURôFUTUREô

4HEôRACIALôDIVIDEôONôPRIMEôTIMEôTELEVISIONôREMAINSôALARMING ô ASôTHEô#HILDRENô.OWôSURVEYôSHOWSô7HILEôôPERCENTôOFô !MERICANôYOUTHôAGEDôôANDôUNDERôAREôCHILDRENôOFôCOLOR ;XIII=ô NEARLYôTHREE QUARTERSôOFôALLôPRIMEôTIMEôCHARACTERSôDURINGôTHEô môTELEVISIONôSEASONôWEREôWHITEô4HEôRACIALôDIVERSITYô THATôDOESôEXISTôCANôBEôFOUNDôMOSTLYôDURINGôTHEôTENôOCLOCKô HOUR ôWHENô!MERICANôCHILDRENôAREôLEASTôLIKELYôTOôBEôWATCHINGô @4HEôEIGHTôOCLOCKôHOURôREMAINEDôTHEôLEASTôRACIALLYôDIVERSEôHOURô INôPRIMEôTIMEôWITHôONEôINôkVEôSHOWSô ôFEATURINGôMIXEDô



0240_057_self_org.indd 36-37

25/09/06 17:40:25

OPENING CREDITSôCASTS;XIV=ô,ATINOôCHARACTERSôAREôOFTENôCASTôINô @LOW STATUSôOCCUPATIONS;XV=ô%VENôWHENôTHEYôWEREôREPRESENTED ô !SIAN !MERICANôCHARACTERSô@WEREôFARôLESSôLIKELYôTHANôCHARACTERSô FROMôOTHERôRACIALôGROUPSôTOôAPPEARôINôPRIMARYôROLES;XVI=ô!NôEARLIERô STUDYôBYô#HILDRENô.OWôCONCLUDEDôTHATôAôYOUTHôWATCHINGôPRIMEô TIMEôTELEVISIONôWOULDôMOSTôLIKELYôSEEôAô@WORLDôOVERWHELMINGLYô POPULATEDôBYôABLE BODIED ôSINGLE ôHETEROSEXUAL ôWHITE ôMALEô ADULTSôUNDERô;XVII=ô7HENôMINORITYôGROUPSôAREôDEPICTEDôINôTHEô MEDIA ôTHEYôAREôGENERALLYôSTEREOTYPED ôWITHô!SIANôWOMEN ôFORô EXAMPLE ôCASTôASô@#HINAôDOLLSôORô@DRAGONôLADIESôANDô!SIANôMENô DENIEDôANYôPOSITIVEôSEXUALITY;XVIII=ô,ATINOSôAREôCOMMONLYôDEPICTEDô ASô@CRIMINALS ôBUFFOONS ô,ATINôLOVERS ôORôLAWôENFORCERS;XIX=ô /THERôPOPULARôMEDIAôSHOWôSIMILARôDISPARITIESô(OLLYWOODôSTUDIOSô ANDôOTHERô!MERICANôMEDIAôMULTINATIONALSôHAVEôGLOBALISEDô!MERI CANôTELEVISIONôSHOWS ôANDôTHEôkCTIONALôWORLDSôENVISIONEDôTHEREINô NOWôCHARMôTHEôREALôWORLDSôYOUTHô(OLLYWOODSôGLOBALôCULTURALô HEGEMONYôTRANSLATESô(OLLYWOODSôPREJUDICESôTOôTHEôWORLDô 0SYCHOLOGICALôANDôSOCIOLOGICALôRESEARCHôREVEALSôTHATôMEDIAô REPRESENTATIONSôHAVEôECONOMICôCONSEQUENCESô2ACIALôANDô GENDERôSTEREOTYPESôDEPICTEDôINôPOPULARôMEDIAôIMPACTôCHIL DRENSôPERCEPTIONSôOFôCAREERôPATHSô#HILDRENô@ASôYOUNGôASôkVEô YEARSôOFôAGEôLEARNôTOôGENDERôSTEREOTYPEôOCCUPATIONSôBASEDôONô THEôGENDERôOFôAôTELEVISIONôROLEôMODEL;XXI=ô 7HILEôTHEôACTRESSôWHOôPLAYEDô,IEUTENANTô5HURUôINô3TARô4REK ô .ICHELLEô.ICHOLS ôWOULDôLATERôHELPôRECRUITôFEMALEôANDô!FRICAN !MERICANôASTRONAUTS ;XXVI=ôTHEôRESULTSôOFôONEôPARTICULARôSTUDYôAREô ESPECIALLYôINFORMATIVEô2ESEARCHERô2EBECCAô"IGLERôANDôHERô COLLEAGUESôINVENTEDôNEW ôkCTIONALôOCCUPATIONSôANDôPRESENTEDô VARIOUSôCOMBINATIONSôOFôWHITEôANDôBLACKôPERSONSôINôTHOSEô


0240_057_self_org.indd 38-39

ô CCUPATIONSôTOôCHILDRENô0OORERô!FRICAN !MERICANôCHILDRENô O WEREôLESSôLIKELYôTOôASPIREôTOôJOBSôTHATôHADôBEENôDEPICTEDôWITHô WHITEôWORKERSôEXCLUSIVELY;XXII=ô"IGLERSôRESEARCHôPOINTSôOUTôTHEô POTENTIALôFORôAôVICIOUSôCYCLEô !FRICANô!MERICANôCHILDREN ôESPECIALLYôTHOSEôFROMôDISADVANTAGEDô BACKGROUNDS ôMAYôPREFERENTIALLYôSEEKôOUTôLOW STATUSôJOBSôINô WHICHôMINORITIESôAREôWELLôREPRESENTEDôANDôTHEREBYôENSUREôTHATô SUCHôJOBSôREMAINôOVERPOPULATEDôBYôMINORITIES ôTHUSôPERPETUAT INGôTHEôSKEWEDôMODELSôFORôNEWôGENERATIONSôOFôPOORô!FRICANô !MERICANôCHILDREN;XXIII= %VENôLIMITINGôONESELFôTOôMAGAZINESôWRITTENôSPECIkCALLYôFORôGIRLSôISô NOôGUARANTEEôOFôANôEMPOWERINGôEXPERIENCEô2EVIEWINGô3EVEN TEENôMAGAZINE ôSOCIOLOGISTô+ELLEYô-ASSONIôOBSERVESôTHATô@MENô DOMINATEôITSôPAGES ôASôBOTHôSUBJECTSôANDôJOBôHOLDERS;XXIV=ô4HISô MAYôNOTôBEôSURPRISINGôASôSUCHôMAGAZINESôAREô@THEôPRODUCTSôOFô COMPANIESôOFTENôOWNEDôANDôCONTROLLEDôBYôELITEôMENô!SôFORô WORK ô-ASSONIôCONCLUDESô@)NôTHEôOCCUPATIONALôWORLDôOFô3EVEN TEEN ô0RINCEô#HARMINGôSTILLôEXISTSôASôTHEôULTIMATEôGOAL;XXV=ô 4HEôIMPLICITôINSTRUCTIONôINôTHESEôPAGESô@-ARRY ô3UEô )TôISôNOTôONLYôWHATôISôDEPICTEDôTHATôISôIMPORTANTô)TôISôALSOôWHATô ISôOMITTEDô-AGAZINESôFORôTEENAGEôGIRLS ôACCORDINGôTOô-ASSONI ô @OVERTLYôSUGGEST ôTHROUGHôCONTENTôANDôPICTURES ôHOWôWOMENô SHOULDôLOOK ôDRESS ôANDôACTôTHEYôMOREôSUBTLYôSUGGEST ôTHROUGHô EXCLUSIONôOFôPICTURESôANDôCONTENT ôWHATôWOMENôSHOULDôNOTôDO ô BE ôORôTHINK;XXVII=ô ,IEUTENANTô-ARYô3UEôANDôTHOSEô-ARYô3UESôTHATôHAVEôFOLLOWEDô INôHERôWAKEôAPPEARôAGAINSTôTHISôBACKDROPô4HEôFACTôTHATô-ARYô


25/09/06 17:40:26

4HEô#ATHERINEô&ERGUSONô!CADEMY $ESCRIPTION &ARMINGôINô$OWNTOWNô$ETROIT 4EXT 4HEô#ATHERINEô&ERGUSONô!CADEMYôISôAôSECONDARYôSCHOOLôFORôGIRLSôTHATôSERVESôTEENAGEô MOTHERSôANDôMOTHERS TO BEô)TôISôLOCATEDôINôAôDERELICTôNEIGHBORHOODôINôDOWNTOWNô $ETROIT ô-ICHIGANô4HEôSCHOOLôSEESôEDUCATIONôASôTHEôkRSTôSTEPôTOWARDôINDIVIDUALôEM POWERMENTô)TSôSCIENCEôPROGRAMôREVOLVESôAROUNDôAôFULLYôFUNCTIONINGôON SITEôURBANô FARMôLOCATEDôBEHINDôTHEôSCHOOLô"YôTAKINGôCAREôOFôTHEôFARMôANIMALSôSUCHôASôSHEEP ô GOATS ôANDôHORSES ôRAISINGôFRUITôTREES ôANDôCULTIVATINGôkELDS ôTHEôSTUDENTSôLEARNôHOWô TOôLIVEôINôHARMONYôWITHôTHEôLANDôINôAôPARTôOFôTHEôCITYôTHATôBECAMEôANôURBANôVOIDôAFTERô THEôCOLLAPSEôOFôTHEôLOCALôCAR MANUFACTURINGôECONOMYô4HEô#&!ôSETSôANôEXAMPLEôTOô OTHERSôINôANôAREAôWHEREôTHEôONCE DENSELY BUILTôCITYôCENTERôHASôUNDERGONEôEXTENSIVEô DEMOLITIONô4ODAY ôDOWNTOWNô$ETROITôISôAôMIXôOFôABANDONEDôBUILDINGS ôEMPTYôLOTS ôANDô STILL OCCUPIEDôSTRUGGLINGôBUILDINGSôINôWHICHôMUCHôOFôTHEôINFRASTRUCTURE ôSUCHôASôPUBLICô TRANSPORTATION ôISôUNRELIABLEô7HEREôTHEREôWEREôONCEôLIVELYôURBANôNEIGHBORHOODS ô EMPTYôLOTSôAREôTODAYôBECOMINGôkELDSô)NDEED ôSATELLITEôPICTURESôSHOWô$ETROITSôINNERô CITYôTOôBEôGREENô5RBANôFARMS ôSUCHôASôTHEôONEôDEVELOPEDôBYôTHEô#&! ôAREôEXAMPLESô OFôBOTTOM UPôINITIATIVESôôAôSTRATEGYôFORôSURVIVALôINôRESPONSEôTOôMISMANAGEDôMU NICIPALôGOVERNMENT ô

$ETROITôPRESENTSôAôCASEôSTUDYôFORôTHEôSHRINKINGôCITY ôINôWHICHôAôMAJORôECONOMYôHASô

COLLAPSEDôANDôRESIDENTSôMOVEDôELSEWHEREô)TôALSOôEXEMPLIkESôBOTHôTHEôSHIFTINGôCITYô ANDôTHEôSEGREGATEDôCITY ôINôWHICHôAôONCE VIBRANTôURBANôCENTERôISôNOWôAôRURALôDISTRICTô ANDôTHEôURBANôPOPULATIONôHASôMIGRATEDôTOôTHEôSUBURBSô"YôFARôTHEôGREATERôPARTôOFô THISôMIGRATIONôHASôBEENôWHITE ôLEAVINGôTHEôCITYôCENTERôTOôTHEôPOORERôSEGMENTSôOFôTHEô !FRICAN !MERICANôPOPULATIONô4HEô#&!ôOFFERSôITSôNEIGHBORSôAôROBUSTôEXAMPLEôOFôSELF EMPOWERMENTô4HEôSCHOOLôSHOWSôTHATôHUMANITY ôNOTôECONOMICS ôISôTHEôPROPERôGOALô FORôAôTHRIVINGôCOMMUNITY 3OURCEô -ARJETICAô0OTRC &ORôMOREôINFORMATION #!4(%2).%ô&%2'53/.ô!#!$%-9ô ô3ELDENô3TREET ô$ETROIT ô-)ô ô ô;PHONE= ô;FAX=

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ >QEBOFKBñ#BODRPLKñ@>ABJV

0240_057_self_org.indd 40-41

25/09/06 17:40:27

3UESôAREôMARKEDôBYôRELENTLESSLYôSUPERLATIVEôQUALITIESôBECOMESô MOREôUNDERSTANDABLEôAGAINSTôAôPOPULARôCULTUREôTHATôMARGINAL ISESôCERTAINôGROUPSô&LATTERINGôSELF INSERTIONôBECOMESôAôPARTIALô ANTIDOTEôTOôAôMEDIAôTHATôNEGLECTôORôMARGINALISEô3ELF EMPOWER MENTôREQUIRESôTHATôONEôRECOGNISESôONESôOWNôPOTENTIAL ôEVENô IFôOTHERSôDOôNOTô/VERLOOKEDôFORôTHEôPRINCIPALôROLEôINôTHEôOFkCIALô CANON ô-ARYô3UEôISôNOôPASSIVEôPERIPHERALôCHARACTERô@3HEôDOES ô NOTôJUSTôSIMPLYôEXISTSô3HEôSLAYS ôSHEôRUNSôAôSTARSHIP ôSHEôTYPES ô SHEôWIELDSôAôSWORD;XXVIII=ô2EWRITINGôPOPULARôCULTUREôISôAôSTEPô TOWARDSôBREAKINGôTHEôCYCLICALôREPRODUCTIONôOFôDOMINANCEô

LASTôPAIRINGôISôESPECIALLYôSATISFYINGôFORôSOMEô@!SôTHEô0OTTERôSERIESô ôBRILLIANTôBOOKWORM ô(ERMIONEôISôAôROLEôMODELôFORôSMARTôGIRLSôANDô BOYS ôWHOôkNDôTHEMSELVESôOVERSHADOWEDôBYôTHEIRôlASHIERôPEERSô 4HERESôAôCERTAINôAPPEALôTOôTHINKINGôTHATôAôYOUNGôACADEMICôCOULDô COUPLEôWITHôTHEôHEROôOFôTHEôWIZARDINGôWORLDôw;XXIX=ô ô

ôô(ARRYô0OTTERôINô+OLKATA

ô

@(ARRYôGETSôONTOôHISô.IMBUSôôBROOMôANDôZOOMSôACROSSôTOô#AL CUTTAôATôTHEôINVITATIONôOFôYOUNGôBOYôCALLEDô*UNTO ôREADSôTHEôTEXTôOFôANô )NDIANôTALE ô(ARRYô0OTTERô+OLKATAYEômô(ARRYô0OTTERôINô+OLKATA;XXX=ô7RITTENô INô"ENGALI ôTHEôBOOKôBRINGSô(ARRYô0OTTERôTOô+OLKATAôWHEREôHEô@MEETSô

4AKEôTHREEôEXAMPLES

FAMOUSôkCTIONALôCHARACTERSôFROMô"ENGALIôLITERATURE;XXXI=ô5TTAMô'HOSH ô THEôAUTHOR ôDESCRIBESôTHEôSTORYôASôAô@POORôMANSô0OTTER ôCOSTINGôJUSTô

ô

ôô+IRK3POCK

ôRUPEESômôLESSôTHANôONEô53ôDOLLARô4HISôISôYETôANOTHERôVARIANTôOFô

ô

%VENôTHOUGHô3TARô4REKôENVISIONEDôAôPURPORTEDLYôEGALITARIANôFUTURE ô

THEô-ARYô3UEô)TôINTRODUCESôAôYOUNGô)NDIANôBOYôINTOôTHEô(ARRYô0OTTERô

THEôREALITYôITôPOSITEDôWASôFARôFROMôIDEALô*USTôASô0AULAô3MITHôINTRO

LEGENDôANDôALSOôAôNEWôENVIRONMENTômô+OLKATAômôRATHERôTHANô(ARRYSô

DUCEDô,IEUTENANTô-ARYô3UEôTOôMAKEôUPôFORôTHEôABSENCEôOFôFEMALEô

FAMILIARô%NGLANDô"YôSITUATINGô(ARRYôINô+OLKATA ôITôMAKESôITôEASIERôTOô

LEADERS ôEARLYôFANôkCTIONôWRITERSôOFTENôIMAGINEDôSAME SEXôROMANTICô

IMAGINEôTHEôLOCALôSTREETôCORNERôASôAôPLACEôOFôMAGICô

RELATIONSHIPSôAMONGôTHEôSHIPSôCREWô2EFERENCEDôOFTENôASô@+3ôFORô @+IRK3POCK ôSUCHôSAME SEXôPAIRINGSôINôFANôkCTIONôCAMEôTOôBEôKNOWNô ASô@SLASHô3LASHôTHUSôFUNCTIONSôASôAôKINDôOFô-ARYô3UE ôRElECTINGôAô DESIREôTOôINTRODUCEôHOMOSEXUALITYôWHEREôITôISôOMITTEDô ô

ôô4HEô!DVENTURESôOFô(ERMIONEô'RANGER

ô

3OMEô(ARRYô0OTTERôFANôkCTIONôGIVESôCENTERôSTAGEôTOô(ERMIONEô'RANGERô 'IVENôTHATô(ERMIONEôALREADYôISôDEPICTEDôWITHôEXTRAORDINARY ôPOSITIVEô CHARACTERISTICS ôITôMAYôHAVEôSEEMEDôUNNECESSARYôTOôREWRITEôHERôSTORYô

3OMEôMAYôSEEôINô(ARRYô0OTTERô+OLKATAYEôTHEôFURTHERôINSINUATIONô OFôAôFOREIGNôCHARACTERôINTOôTHEôIMAGINATIONôOFô"ENGALIôYOUTH ôBUTô THISôOVERLOOKSôTHEôPOWERôOFôPOPULARôMEDIA ôWHICHôMAKESôSUCHô FOREIGNôCHARACTERSôDIFkCULTôTOôAVOIDôEVENôFORôTHEôMIDDLEôCLASSô +OLKATAôYOUTHôLIKELYôTOôBUYôTHEôBOOK;XXXII=

))ô3UINGô-ARYô

"UTôTHEôSTORIESôOFFERôTWOôTWISTSôONôTHEôOFkCIALôTALEô&IRST ôTHEYôPLACEô (ERMIONEôATôTHEôCENTERôOFôTHEôACTIONô)TôBECOMESôHERôSTORY ôNOTôSOME ONEôELSESôSTORYôINôWHICHôSHEôPLAYSôAôPARTô3ECOND ôTHEôSTORIESôOFTENô REPLACEô2ONô7EASLEYôASôHERôROMANTICôPARTNERôWITHô'INNYô7EASLEY ô $RACOô-ALFOYôORôESPECIALLYô(ARRYô0OTTERô!SôONEôCRITICôPOINTSôOUT ôTHEô


0240_057_self_org.indd 42-43

0OTTERôINô+OLKATAôWASôQUICKLYôPULLEDô#OPYRIGHTôLAWYERSôISSUEDô AôCEASEôANDôDESISTôLETTERôTOôTHEô)NDIANôPUBLISHER ôWHOôQUICKLYô COMPLIEDô*+ô2OWLING ôHOWEVER ôHASôGENERALLYôTOLERATEDôLITER ALLYôHUNDREDSôOFôTHOUSANDSôOFôOTHERôFANôkCTIONôSTORIESôLARGELYô


25/09/06 17:40:27

NON COMMERCIALôANDôWEB ôRATHERôTHANôPRINT BASED ôBASEDôONô HERôCHARACTERS ôINCLUDINGôSTORIESôTHATôFOCUSôONô(ERMIONEô4HEô OWNERSôOFôTHEô3TARô4REKôFRANCHISEôCONTEMPLATEDôLEGALôACTIONô AGAINSTô3TARô4REKôSLASH ôBUTôDEMURREDôBECAUSEôOFôSTRATEGICô CONSIDERATIONS;XXXIII=ô 7HATôAREôTHEôRESPECTIVEôLEGALôRIGHTSôOFôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERôOFô THEôOFkCIALôWORKôANDôTHEôAUTHORôOFôTHEô-ARYô3UEô)FôANYôOFôTHESEô CASESôHADôGONEôTOôCOURT ôWHOôWOULDôHAVEôWONô 5NITEDô3TATESôLAWôPERMITSôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERôTOôCLAIMôNOTô ONLYôHISôORôHERôOWNôSTORIES ôBUTôALSOôTHEôCHARACTERSôINôTHOSEô STORIES;XXXIV=ô4HUS ôAôFANôkCTIONôWRITERôCANôPENôSTORIESôEMPLOYINGô SUCHôCHARACTERSôONLYôIFô ôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERôEXPLICITLYôPER MITSôSUCHôFANôkCTIONô ôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERôCHOOSESôNOTôTOô PURSUEôLEGALôACTIONôAGAINSTôTHEôFANôkCTIONôWRITERôORô ôTHEôFANô kCTIONôCONSTITUTESôFAIRôUSEôOFôTHEôCOPYRIGHTEDôWORKô 4HISôTHIRDôAVENUEôALLOWSôFANôkCTIONôWRITERSôTHEôFREEDOMôTOôCREATEô USINGôEXISTINGôCREATIVEôWORLDSôWITHOUTôNEEDINGôTHEôPERMISSIONô môEITHERôEXPLICITôORôTACITômôOFôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERô)FôAôUSEôISô JUDGEDô@FAIR ôTHENôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERôCANNOTôBARôITô7HETHERô AôUSEôISôFAIRôDEPENDSôONôAôNUMBERôOFôFACTORS ôINCLUDINGôTHEô PURPOSEôOFôTHEôWORKôINCLUDINGôWHETHERôTHEôUSEôISôCOMMERCIALô ORôNOT FOR PROkT ôANDôWHETHERôTHEôUSEôINJURESôTHEôCOPYRIGHTô OWNERSôMARKETôFORôHISôORôHERôWORKô7HETHERôAôUSEôISôFAIRôORôNOTô ISôLEFTôTOôTHEôJUDGMENTôOFôAôCOURT ôINTERPRETINGôAôPROVISIONôINôTHEô COPYRIGHTôSTATUTE ôASôWELLôASôAôLONGôCASEôHISTORYô 4HEôLEADINGôCASEôDEkNINGôTHEôCONTOURSôOFôFAIRôUSEôCONCERNSôAô RAPôGROUPSôREWORKINGôOFôANôEARLIERôSONG ô@/H ô0RETTYô7OMANô )Nô#AMPBELLôVô!CUFF 2OSEô-USIC ô)NC ôTHEôOWNERôOFô2OYô


0240_057_self_org.indd 44-45

ô RBISONSôSONGôSUEDôTHEôRAPôGROUPôô,IVEô#REWôFORôCOPYRIGHTô / INFRINGEMENTôFORôTHEIRôSONGô@0RETTYô7OMAN;XXXV=ô4HEô3UPREMEô #OURTôREVERSEDôTHEôTRIALôCOURTSôGRANTôOFôSUMMARYôJUDGMENTô INôFAVOURôOFôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNER ôHOLDINGôTHATôô,IVEô#REWSô PARODYôOFôTHEôORIGINALôMIGHTôCONSTITUTEôFAIRôUSEô%VENôTHEôCOM MERCIALôNATUREôOFôô,IVEô#REWSôWORKôDIDôNOTôDEFEATôTHEôGROUPSô CLAIMôTOôMAKINGôAôFAIRôUSEô *USTICEô3OUTER ôWRITINGôFORôTHEô#OURT ôCHARACTERISEDôô,IVEô #REWSôVERSIONôASôAôPARODYôOFôTHEôORIGINALô ;7=EôTHINKôITôFAIRôTOôSAYôTHATôô,IVEô#REWSôSONGôREASONABLYô COULDôBEôPERCEIVEDôASôCOMMENTINGôONôTHEôORIGINALôORôCRITICIZ INGôIT ôTOôSOMEôDEGREEôô,IVEô#REWôJUXTAPOSESôTHEôROMANTICô MUSINGSôOFôAôMANôWHOSEôFANTASYôCOMESôTRUE ôWITHôDEGRADINGô TAUNTS ôAôBAWDYôDEMANDôFORôSEX ôANDôAôSIGHôOFôRELIEFôFROMôPATER NALôRESPONSIBILITYô4HEôLATERôWORDSôCANôBEôTAKENôASôAôCOMMENTô ONôTHEôNAIVET¯ôOFôTHEôORIGINALôOFôANôEARLIERôDAY ôASôAôREJECTIONô OFôITSôSENTIMENTôTHATôIGNORESôTHEôUGLINESSôOFôSTREETôLIFEôANDôTHEô DEBASEMENTôTHATôITôSIGNIkES;XXXVI= 4HEô#OURTôOBSERVEDôTHATôPARODIESôTRANSFORMôTHEôORIGINAL ôPRO VIDINGô@SOCIALôBENEkT ôBYôSHEDDINGôLIGHTôONôANôEARLIERôWORK ôAND ô INôTHEôPROCESS ôCREATINGôAôNEWôONE;XXXVII=ô 3IMILARLY ô-ARYô3UESôCOMMENTôONôORôCRITICISEôTHEôORIGINAL ô WHILEôATôTHEôSAMEôTIMEôCREATINGôSOMETHINGôNEWô4HEYôHIGHLIGHTô THEôABSENCEôINôTHEôORIGINALôOFôSOCIETYSôMARGINALôVOICES ôTHEô ôSTEREOTYPEDôACTIONSôORôINACTIONSôOFôCERTAINôCHARACTERSôANDôTHEô ORTHODOXYôOFôSOCIALôRELATIONSHIPSôINôTHEôORIGINALô)NôBLUNTôFASH ION ô,IEUTENANTô-ARYô3UEôBEAMEDôONôBOARD ôkNALLYôBRINGINGôAô LEADINGôWOMANôCHARACTERôTOôTHEôBRIDGEôANDôREFUSINGô#APTAINô +IRKSôSEXUALôADVANCESô 4HEô2IGHTôTOô-ARYô3UE

25/09/06 17:40:28

4AKEôTHEôCASEôOFô!LICEô2ANDALLSôREWORKINGôOFô-ARGARETô-ITCH ELLSôLITERARYôCLASSICô'ONEô7ITHôTHEô7INDô'747 ôTOôCRITIQUEô THATôNOVELSôDEPICTIONôOFôSLAVERYôANDôRACEôINôTHEô#IVILô7AR ERAô 2ANDALLSôNOVEL ô4HEô7INDô$ONEô'ONEô47$' ôTELLSô-ITCHELLSô TALEôFROMôTHEôPERSPECTIVEôOFôAôBLACKôSLAVEôWOMAN ô#YNARA ôONô THEô/(ARAôPLANTATIONô4HEôTWOôNOVELSôDEPICTIONSôOFôRACEôANDô SEXôRELATIONSôDIFFERôSHARPLY ôASôCHARACTERISEDôBYô*USTICEô3OUTERô )NôTHEôWORLDôOFô'747 ôTHEôWHITEôCHARACTERSôCOMPRISEôAôNOBLEô ARISTOCRACYôWHOSEôIDYLLICôEXISTENCEôISôUPSETôONLYôBYôTHEôINTRU SIONôOFô9ANKEEôSOLDIERS ôAND ôEVENTUALLY ôBYôTHEôLIBERATIONôOFôTHEô BLACKôSLAVESôwô-ITCHELLôDESCRIBESôHOWôBOTHôBLACKSôANDôWHITESô WEREôPURPORTEDLYôBETTERôOFFôINôTHEôDAYSôOFôSLAVERYô@4HEôMOREô )ôSEEôOFôEMANCIPATIONôTHEôMOREôCRIMINALô)ôTHINKôITôISô)TSôJUSTô RUINEDôTHEôDARKIES uôSAYSô3CARLETTô/(ARAwô&REEôBLACKSôAREô DESCRIBEDôASôgCREATURESôOFôSMALLôINTELLIGENCEôô;L=IKEôMONKEYSô ORôSMALLôCHILDRENôTURNEDôLOOSEôAMONGôTREASUREDôOBJECTSôWHOSEô VALUEôISôBEYONDôTHEIRôCOMPREHENSION ôTHEYôRANôWILDômôEITHERô FROMôPERVERSEôPLEASUREôINôDESTRUCTIONôORôSIMPLYôBECAUSEôOFô THEIRôIGNORANCEô )TôISôCLEARôWITHINôTHEôkRSTôkFTYôPAGESôOFô#YNARASôkCTIONALôDI ARYôTHATô2ANDALLSôWORKôlIPSô'747SôTRADITIONALôRACEôROLES ô PORTRAYSôPOWERFULôWHITESôASôSTUPIDôORôFECKLESS ôANDôGENERALLYô SETSôOUTôTOôDEMYSTIFYô'747ôANDôSTRIPôTHEôROMANTICISMôFROMô -ITCHELLSôSPECIkCôACCOUNTôOFôTHISôPERIODôOFôOURôHISTORYôw

4HEôCOPYRIGHTôHOLDERSôOFôTHEôORIGINALôWORKôSUEDô2ANDALLSôPUB LISHERô"UTôTHEô#IRCUITô#OURTôREFUSEDôTOôENJOINô2ANDALLSôBOOK ô HOLDINGôTHATôITôWASôAôPARODYôOFôTHEôORIGINALôLIKELYôTOôCONSTITUTEô FAIRôUSEô 4HEô3UEIkCATIONôOFôTHEô!FRICAN !MERICANSôINôTHEôSTORYôISôUN MISTAKABLEô!SôTHEô#IRCUITô#OURTôNOTED ô@)Nô47$' ôNEARLYôEVERYô BLACKôCHARACTERôISôGIVENôSOMEôREDEEMINGôQUALITYômôWHETHERô DEPTH ôWIT ôCUNNING ôBEAUTY ôSTRENGTH ôORôCOURAGEômôTHATôTHEIRô '747ôANALOGUESôLACKED;XXXIX=ô 7HILEôPARODIESôMAYôOFTENôCONSTITUTEôFAIRôUSE ôSATIRESôGENER ALLYôDOôNOTô3ATIRESôEMPLOYôTHEôORIGINALôWORKô@ASôAôVEHICLEôFORô COMMENTINGôONôSOMEôINDIVIDUALôORôINSTITUTIONôANDôONôTHEôWORKô ITSELF;XL=ô!SôTHEô3UPREMEô#OURTôEXPLAINEDôINôTHEôô,IVEô#REWô CASEô@0ARODYôNEEDSôTOôMIMICôANôORIGINALôTOôMAKEôITSôPOINT ô ANDôSOôHASôSOMEôCLAIMôTOôUSEôTHEôCREATIONôOFôITSôVICTIMSôORô COLLECTIVEôVICTIMS ôIMAGINATION ôWHEREASôSATIREôCANôSTANDôONô ITSôOWNôTWOôFEETôANDôSOôREQUIRESôJUSTIkCATIONôFORôTHEôVERYôACTô OFôBORROWING;XLI=ô %VENôWHILEô-ARYô3UESôMAYôHAVEôSTRONGôFOOTINGôTOôCLAIMôFAIRô USEôINôLAW ôTHEYôCANôBEôCRITICISEDôONôOTHERôGROUNDSô&IRST ôWHYô RELYôUPONôTHEôCANONôRATHERôTHANôSIMPLYôWRITEôYOURôOWNôSTORYô FROMôWHOLEôCLOTHô3ECOND ôWHYôNOTôREQUIREôTHATôTHEô-ARYô3UEô BEôLICENSEDôFROMôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERô7EôRESPONDôTOôBOTHô CRITIQUESôHEREô

wô)Nô'747 ô3CARLETTô/(ARAôOFTENôEXPRESSESôDISGUSTôWITHô ANDôCONDESCENSIONôTOWARDSôBLACKSôINô47$' ô/THER ô3CAR LETTSôCOUNTERPART ôISôHERSELFôOFôMIXEDôDESCENTô)Nô'747 ô!SH LEYô7ILKESôISôTHEôINITIALôOBJECTôOFô3CARLETTSôAFFECTIONôINô47$' ô HEôISôHOMOSEXUALôw;XXXVIII=


0240_057_self_org.indd 46-47


25/09/06 17:40:28

4HEôCOCONUTô2EVOLUTION $ESCRIPTION !ôDOCUMENTARYôOFôAôNATIVEôPEOPLESôREMARKABLEôVICTORYôOVERô7ESTERNô#OLONIALôPOWERô !ô0ACIkCôISLANDôROSEôUPôINôARMSôAGAINSTôGIANTôMININGôCORPORATIONô2IOô4INTOô:INCô24: ô môANDôWONôDESPITEôAôMILITARYôOCCUPATIONôANDôBLOCKADE 4EXT 7HENô2IOô4INTOô:INCô24: ôDECIDEDôTOôSTEPôUPôPRODUCTIONôATôTHEô0ANGUNAô-INEôONô THEô0ACIkCô)SLANDôOFô"OUGAINVILLE ôTHEYôGOTôMOREôTHANôTHEYôBARGAINEDôFORô4HEôISLANDSô PEOPLEôWEREôFEDôUPôWITHôBEINGôUSEDôASôPAWNSôBYôTHEôWESTô24:ôREFUSEDôTOôCOMPEN SATEôTHEM ôSOôTHEôPEOPLEôDECIDEDôITôWASôTIMEôTOôPUTôANôENDôTOôOUTSIDEôINTERFERENCEôINô THEôISLANDSôAFFAIRSô4OôDOôTHISôTHEYôFORCIBLYôCLOSEDôDOWNôTHEôMINEô ô

4HEô0APUAô.EWô'UINEAô!RMYô0.'$& ôWEREôMOBILISEDôINôANôATTEMPTôTOôPUTôDOWNô

THEôREBELLIONô4HEôNEWLYôFORMEDô"OUGAINVILLEô2EVOLUTIONARYô!RMYô"2! ôBEGANôTHEô kGHTôWITHôBOWSôôARROWS ôANDôSTICKSôôSTONESô!GAINSTôAôHEAVILYôARMEDôADVERSARYô THEYôSTILLôMANAGEDôTOôRETAINôCONTROLôOFôMOSTôOFôTHEIRôISLANDô2EALISINGôTHEYôWEREôBEATENô ONôTHEôGROUND ôTHEô0.'$&ôIMPOSEDôAôGUNBOATôBLOCKADEôAROUNDô"OUGAINVILLE ôINôANô ATTEMPTôTOôSTRANGLEôTHEô"2!ôINTOôSUBMISSIONô"UTôTHEôBLOCKADEôSEEMEDôTOôHAVEôLITTLEô ORôNOôEFFECTô ô

7ITHôNOôSHIPMENTSôGETTINGôINôORôOUTôOFôTHEôISLAND ôHOWôDIDôNEWôELECTRICITYôNETWORKSô

SPRINGôUPôINô"2!ôHELDôTERRITORYô(OWôWEREô"2!ôTROOPSôABLEôTOôDRIVEôAROUNDôTHEôISLANDô WITHOUTôANYôSOURCEôOFôPETROLôORôDIESELô ô

7HATôWASôHAPPENINGôWITHINôTHEôBLOCKADEôWASôANôENVIRONMENTALôANDôSPIRITUALôREVO

LUTIONô4HEôRUINSôOFôTHEôOLDô0ANGUNAôMINEôWHEREôBEINGôRECYCLEDôTOôSUPPLYôTHEôRAWô MATERIALSôFORôTHEôWORLDSôkRSTôECO REVOLUTIONô 3OURCEô WWWCULTURESHOPORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION $IRECTEDô$OMô2OTHEROE ô0RODUCEDôBYô-IKEô#HAIMBERLAIN ô3OUNDôBYô#ARLOSô3OTO $URATIONôôMIN ô9EARô WWWECO ACTIONORG

0240_057_self_org.indd 48-49

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ@L@LKRQñ/BSLIRQFLK

25/09/06 17:40:29

#RITIQUEôô 7HYô.OTô7RITEô9OURô/WNô %NTIRELYô/RIGINALô3TORYô )Nô#AMPBELLôVô!CUFF 2OSE ôTHEô3UPREMEô#OURTôINDICATEDôITSô DISTASTEôFORôSOMEONEôWHOôBORROWSôSOMEONEôELSESôCOPYRIGHT EDôWORKôMERELYô@TOôAVOIDôTHEôDRUDGERYôINôWORKINGôUPôSOMETHINGô FRESH;XLII=ô)NDEED ôASôTHEôSKEPTICôMIGHTôASKô7HYôNOTôSIMPLYôWRITEô YOURôOWNôWORLDô)NôAôLETTERôTOôHERôFANS ôTHISôISôPRECISELYôTHEô ADVICEôOFôTHEôWRITERô!NNEô2ICEô )ôDOôNOTôALLOWôFANôkCTIONô4HEôCHARACTERSôAREôCOPYRIGHTEDô)Tô UPSETSôMEôTERRIBLYôTOôEVENôTHINKôABOUTôFANôkCTIONôWITHôMYôCHAR ACTERSô)ôADVISEôMYôREADERSôTOôWRITEôYOURôOWNôORIGINALôSTORIESô WITHôYOURôOWNôCHARACTERS;XLIII=ô "OTHôTHEôPREFERENCEôFORôPARODYôOVERôSATIREôANDôTHEôPENCHANTô FORôENTIRELYôORIGINALôSTORIESôTURNôONôTHEôUNDERLYINGôLEGALôNOTIONôOFô SUBSTITUTABILITYô4HEôCRITICALôLEGALôINQUIRYôISô)SôTHEREôAôVIABLEôSUB STITUTEôFORôTHEôCOPYRIGHTEDôWORKô#ANôTHEôLATERôWRITERôLICENSEô AôCOPYRIGHTEDôWORK ôEMPLOYôAôPUBLICôDOMAINôWORK ôORôINVENTô AôWHOLLYôORIGINALôWORKôASôANôALTERNATIVEôVEHICLEôFORôEXPRESSINGô HISôORôHERôCRITIQUEô0AULô'OLDSTEINôEXPRESSESôHISôCONkDENCEô THAT ôFORôSATIREôATôLEAST ôSUCHôALTERNATIVESôWILLôBEôREADILYôAVAIL ABLEô@4HEREôWILLôRARELYôBEôAôSHORTAGEôOFôWORKS ôINCLUDINGôPUBLICô DOMAINôWORKS ôTHATôWITHôSOMEôINGENUITYôCANôBEôMADEôTOôSERVEô ASôEQUALLYôEFFECTIVEôVEHICLESôFORôTHEôINTENDEDôSATIRE;XLIV=ô

IôNVENTIVENESSôORôBRILLIANCEôMIGHTôHAVEôCONTRIBUTEDôTOôITSôCURRENTô CULTURALôSTATUS ôITôISôTHEôVERYôPOPULARITYôOFôTHEôCANONôWORKôTHATôISô THEôFOCUSôOFôTHEô-ARYô3UEô/FôCOURSE ôBYôPIGGYBACKINGôONôTHEô CANONôWORK ôTHEô-ARYô3UEôCANNOTôGUARANTEEôITSELFôAôSHAREôINô THEôORIGINALSôPOPULARITYô2ATHER ôFORôTHEôAUTHORôANDôAôPARTICULARô SETôOFôREADERS ôTHEô-ARYô3UEôHELPSôRE IMAGINEôTHEôWORLDôBYô REWORKINGôTHEôELEMENTSôOFôPOPULARôCULTUREô 4HEREôARE ôOFôCOURSE ôBRILLIANT ôENTIRELYôORIGINALôTEXTSôTHATôRElECTô ANôEGALITARIANôWORLDVIEWô9ET ôFORôWHATEVERôREASON ôSUCHôTEXTSô HAVEôNOTôYETôATTAINEDôTHEôPOPULARôCULTURALôSTATUSôOFôAôSMALLôSETô OFôICONICôWORKSô0OPULARITYôMIGHTôARISEôTHROUGHôAôGRASSROOTS ô WORD OF MOUTHôGROUNDSWELL ôBUTôITôISôMOREôOFTENôCAREFULLYôCUL TIVATEDôBYôMEDIAôCORPORATIONSô3UCHôANôEFFORTôREQUIRESôAôLARGEô CAPITALôINVESTMENT ôANôINVESTMENTôOUTôOFôREACHôOFôMANYôMARGIN ALISEDôCOMMUNITIESô%VENôWHENôPOPULARôALTERNATIVESôEMERGE ô THEYôCANôOFTENôBEôCO OPTEDôBYôTHEôDOMINANTôPLAYERSô4AKEôTHEô ALTERNATIVEôTEENAGEôGIRLôMAGAZINEô3ASSY ôWHICHôWASôPURCHASEDô BYô4EENôMAGAZINE ô@WHICHôkRSTôINTEGRATEDôITôASôAôCOLUMNôANDô LATERôPHASEDôITôOUTôCOMPLETELY;XLV=ô4EENôITSELFôWASôLATERôACQUIREDô ANDôINTEGRATEDôINTOô3EVENTEENôMAGAZINE;XLVI=ô

#RITIQUEôô 7HYô.OTô,ICENSEôTHEô&ANô&ICTION

"UTôFORô-ARYô3UEôkCTION ôTHEREôAREôNOôSUBSTITUTESô)TôISôNOTôTHEô ABSENCEôOFôCREATIVEôGENIUSôONôTHEôPARTôOFôTHEôLATERôAUTHORôTHATô REQUIRESôTHEôUTILISATIONôOFôTHEôEARLIERôWORKô4HEôEARLIERôCANONô WORKôHASôUNIQUEôCULTURALôPOWERô7HILEôTHEôCANONôWORKSô

#OPYRIGHTôLAWôASSUMESôTHATôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERSôWILLôBEôRELUC TANTôTOôLICENSEôCRITICISMôOFôTHEIRôWORKô4HEô3UPREMEô#OURTôSOô STATEDôINô#AMPBELLôVô!CUFF 2OSE ôBOLSTERINGôTHEôPOINTôWITHô LITERARYôSUPPORTô@9ETôTHEôUNLIKELIHOODôTHATôCREATORSôOFôIMAGI NATIVEôWORKSôWILLôLICENSEôCRITICALôREVIEWSôORôLAMPOONSôOFôTHEIRô OWNôPRODUCTIONSôREMOVESôSUCHôUSESôFROMôTHEôVERYôNOTIONôOFô



0240_057_self_org.indd 50-51

25/09/06 17:40:30

AôPOTENTIALôLICENSINGôMARKETôg0EOPLEôASKôwôFORôCRITICISM ôBUTô THEYôONLYôWANTôPRAISEuô3ô-AUGHAM ô/Fô(UMANô"ONDAGE ;XLVII=ô 4HEô#OURTôACCORDINGLYôCONCLUDEDôTHAT ôIFôTHEREôISôNOôDERIVATIVEô MARKETôFORôCRITICISM ôCRITICISMôOFôTHEôORIGINALôWORKôCANNOTôINTER FEREôWITHôTHEôPOTENTIALôMARKETôFORôTHEôCOPYRIGHTEDôWORKô4HISô SUPPORTSôTHEôCONCLUSIONôTHATôCRITIQUEôOFôTHEôWORKôITSELFôWILLôLIKELYô CONSTITUTEôFAIRôUSEô

&IGUREôô 3PIDER -ANô)NDIAôBYô*EEVANô*ô+ANG

ô ô

"UTôSOMEôMIGHTôARGUEôTHATôTHISôISôTOOôPESSIMISTICô)FôTHERESôAô MARKETôFORôAôWORK ôTHENôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôOWNERôSHOULDôSEEKôTOô MAXIMISEôHISôORôHERôPROkTôBYôEXPLOITINGôITômôEVENôIFôITôMEANSô TOLERATINGôCRITICISMô!NôALTERNATIVEôVIEWôISôTHATôRATHERôTHANôCALL INGôFORôFAIRôUSEôFORôCRITICISM ôANYôRELUCTANCEôTOôLICENSEôCRITICISMô SHOULDôSIMPLYôIMPLYôAôCOMPULSORYôLICENSE ôREQUIRINGôAôROYALTYô PAYMENTôINôLIEUôOFôAôROYALTY FREEôUSE ô"RUCEô+ELLERôANDô2E BECCAô4USHNETôPOINTôOUTôTHATô$#ô#OMICS ôTHEôOWNERôOFô"AT MAN ô3UPERMAN ôANDôOTHERôSUPERHEROES ôHASôLICENSEDôSTORIESô INôWHICHôTHEôHEROESôTURNôVILLAINOUS;XLVIII=ô 4WOôRECENTôMOVESôBYôCORPORATEô!MERICAôSUGGESTôTHATô@/FkCIALô -ARYô3UESôAREôNOTôENTIRELYôUNLIKELYô-ARVELô%NTERPRISES ô)NCô LICENSEDôANô)NDIANôVERSIONôOFô3PIDER -AN ôWITHôTHEôSUPER HEROôDONNINGôAôTRADITIONALô)NDIANôLOINCLOTHôANDôSPARRINGôWITHô THEô'REENô'OBLINôRECASTôASôAôRAKSHASA ôAôDEMONôFROMô(INDUô ôCOSMOLOGYôSEEôkGUREô ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 52-53


25/09/06 17:40:30

!SôTHEô)NDIANôPUBLISHERôANNOUNCESô 3PIDER -ANô)NDIAôINTERWEAVESôTHEôLOCALôCUSTOMS ôCULTUREôANDô MYSTERYôOFôMODERNô)NDIA ôWITHôANôEYEôTOôMAKINGô3PIDER -ANSô MYTHOLOGYôMOREôRELEVANTôTOôTHISôPARTICULARôAUDIENCEô2EADERSô OFôTHISôSERIESôWILLôNOTôSEEôTHEôFAMILIARô0ETERô0ARKERôOFô1UEENSô UNDERôTHEôCLASSICô3PIDER -ANôMASK ôBUTôRATHERôAôNEWôHEROômôAô YOUNG ô)NDIANôBOYôNAMEDô0AVITRô0RABHAKARô!Sô3PIDER -AN ô 0AVITRôLEAPSôAROUNDôRICKSHAWSôANDôSCOOTERSôINô)NDIANôSTREETS ô WHILEôSWINGINGôFROMôMONUMENTSôSUCHôASôTHEô'ATEWAYôOFô)NDIAô ANDôTHEô4AJô-AHAL;XLIX= .EARôTHEôENDôOFô ô$ISNEYôANNOUNCEDôTHATôITôWOULDôREVISEô ITSôMOSTôLUCRATIVEôSTORY ô7INNIEôTHEô0OOH ôBYôREPLACINGô#HRIS TOPHERô2OBINôWITHôAô@RED HAIREDôSIX YEAR OLDôTOMBOYôGIRL;L=ô4HEô REACTIONôTOô$ISNEYSôANNOUNCEMENTôWASôMIXEDô.ICHOLASô4UCK ER ôAUTHORôOFô4HEô2OUGHô'UIDEôTOô#HILDRENSô"OOKS ô@THOUGHTô THEôNEWôCHARACTERôAôHUGEôERRORô(EôCONTINUED ô@4HEYREôBUILTô AROUNDôAôBOYôWHOôARRIVESôANDôPUTSôTHINGSôRIGHT ôLIKEôLITTLEôBOYSô DO;LI=ô9ETôANOTHERôSCHOLARôOFôCHILDRENSôLITERATUREôDOUBTSôWHETHERô THEôABSENCEôOFôFEMALEôCHARACTERSôINô7INNIEôTHEô0OOHôHASôAô DELETERIOUSôEFFECTô+ATHLEENô(ORNING ôWHOôTRAINSôCHILDRENSôBOOKô LIBRARIANSôATôTHEô5NIVERSITYôOFô7ISCONSINô-ADISON ôREPORTSôTHAT ô @GROWINGôUP ô)ôHADôNOôPROBLEMôRELATINGôTOô#HRISTOPHERô2OBINô (EôALMOSTôHADôAôNON SPECIkCôGENDER;LII=ô

THREEôREASONSô&IRST ô$ISNEYSôMOVEôCOMESôAFTERôALMOSTôô YEARSôOFôTHEôMALE DOMINATEDô(UNDREDô!CREô7OODô3PIDER -ANSôNEWôETHNICITYôCOMESôAFTERôMOREôTHANôôYEARSôOFôAôWHITE ONLYôSUPERHEROô)TôSEEMSôUNREASONABLEôTOôEXPECTôTHEôWORLDSô WOMENôANDôMINORITIESôTOôWAITôPATIENTLYôFORôEACHôSUCHôMOVEô 3ECOND ôTHEôOFkCIALô-ARYô3UEôMAYôSTILLôLEAVEôMUCHôTOôBEôDE SIREDôINôTHEôCHARACTERISATIONôOFôTHEôNEWLYôREPRESENTEDôGROUPô 4HIRD ôEVENôWHEREôITôEXPANDSôTHEôREPRESENTATION ôITôSTILLôLEAVESô LARGEôOMISSIONSôWEôHAZARDôTOôPREDICTôTHATôTHEôNEWôTOMBOYô GIRLôWILLôBEôWHITEô&INALLY ôTHEôCORPORATEôMASTERSôOFôPOPULARô CHARACTERSôAREôUNLIKELYôTOôLICENSEôTHEôMOSTôDISFAVOUREDôUSESô &ORôEXAMPLE ôWHILEô$#ô#OMICSôPRODUCEDôANôALTERNATIVEôSTRIPô FEATURINGôANôEVILô"ATMAN ôITôISSUEDôAôCEASEôANDôDESISTôLETTERôTOô ANôARTISTôDEPICTINGô"ATMANôANDô2OBINôASôLOVERSôSOMETIMESô EXPLICITLY ôSEEôkGUREô ;LIII=ô!NôEVILô"ATMAN ôITôSEEMS ôISôMOREô PALATABLEôTHANôAôGAYôONEô ô

$OôTHESEôTWOôMAJORôMOVESômôINVOLVINGôWHATôAREôLIKELYôTOôBEô THEôSINGLEôMOSTôPOPULARôSUPERHEROôINôTHEôWORLDôANDôTHEôSINGLEô MOSTôPOPULARôCHILDRENSôCARTOONôCHARACTERômôSUGGESTôTHATôUN DERGROUNDôVERSIONSôOFôPOPULARôCULTUREôAREôUNNECESSARYô 4HEôPOSSIBILITYôOFôANôOFkCIALô-ARYô3UEôISôINADEQUATEôFORôATôLEASTôô


0240_057_self_org.indd 54-55


25/09/06 17:40:30

&IGUREôô "ATMANôANDô2OBINôBYô-ARKô#HAMBERLAIN

ô ô

)NôOURôOWNôHOUSEHOLD ôWEôHAVEôBEENôUNWILLINGôTOôWAITô!ôPOP SICLEôSTICKôANDôGLUEôHELPôUSôRECREATEôTHEôPOPULARôIMAGESôWITHô WHICHôOURôDAUGHTERôGROWSôUPô #OMPAREôTHEôFOLLOWINGôTWOôkGURESô ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 56-57


25/09/06 17:40:31

&IGUREôô 4HEô!DVENTURESôOFô#HRISTOPHERô2OBINôBYô%RNESTô(ô3HEPARD

ô ô

&IGUREôô 4HEô!DVENTURESôOFô!NOUSHKAô#HANDERôBYô%RNESTô(ô3HEPARD ôASôMODIkEDôBYô!NUPAMô#HANDER

ô ô ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 58-59


25/09/06 17:40:31

)))ô#ONCLUSION

&//4./4%3 ;I=ôô

2EWORKINGôTHEôPROPRIETARYôICONSôOFôOURôAGEôOFFERSôONEôCOUNTER ECONOMICôSTRATEGYô-EDIAôSTEREOTYPESôPLAYôANôIMPORTANTôROLEôINô EDUCATINGôPEOPLEôABOUTôTHEôCAPACITIESôOFôOTHERSô-OREôSINISTERô YET ôTHEYôPLAYôANôIMPORTANTôROLEôINôEDUCATINGôUSôABOUTôOURôOWNô CAPACITIESô'IVENôAôPOPULARôMEDIAôTHATôMARGINALISESôVARIOUSô SEGMENTSôOFôSOCIETY ôTHEôACTôOFôREWORKINGôPOPULARôSTORIESôTOô ASSERTôONESôOWNôVALUEôISôEMPOWERINGô4HATôACTôOPENSôTHEô PATHôTOôNEWôLIVELIHOODSôANDôROLESô3ELF INSERTIONôTHUSôCHANGESô POPULARôMEANINGSôANDôREDISTRIBUTESôPROkTSô4HEôACTôOFôCOPYINGô CANôBEôSIMULTANEOUSLYôHOMAGEôANDôSUBVERSIONô 4HISôPAPERôDRAWSôUPONôAôLONGERôWORKôINôTHEô#ALIFORNIAô,AWô2EVIEW


0240_057_self_org.indd 60-61

0AULAô3MITH ô!ô4REKKIESô4ALEô ôREPRINTEDôINô#AMILLEô"ACONô3MITH ô%NTERPRISINGôô 7OMENô4ELEVISIONô&ANDOMôANDôTHEô#REATIONôOFô0OPULARô-YTHô5NIVERSITYôOFô0ENNSYLVANIAô 0RESSô ôô ;II=ôô &ANôkCTIONôISô@kCTIONôWRITTENôBYôPEOPLEôWHOôENJOYôAôkLM ôNOVEL ôTELEVISIONôSHOWôORôOTHERô MEDIAôWORK ôUSINGôTHEôCHARACTERSôANDôSITUATIONSôDEVELOPEDôINôITôANDôDEVELOPINGôNEWô PLOTSôINôWHICHôTOôUSEôTHESEôCHARACTERSô7IKIPEDIA ô&ANô&ICTION ôHTTPENWIKIPEDIA ORGWIKI&AN?kCTIONôLASTôVISITEDôô$ECEMBERô ô ;III=ôô 0ATô0lIEGER ô4OOô'OODôTOôBEô4RUEôô9EARSôOFô-ARYô3UE ôHTTPWWWMERRYCOZORGPA PERS-!2935%(4-ôDATEDô ôLASTôVISITEDôô$ECEMBERô ô ;IV=ôô 7IKIPEDIA ô-ARYô3UE ôATôHTTPENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI-ARY?3UE?FANkCTIONôVISITEDôONôô $ECEMBERô ô ;V=ôô )BIDô ;VI=ôô 3EEô"ACON 3MITH ôSUPRAôNOTEôô ;VII=ôô 7IKIPEDIA ô3TARô4REKô4HEô/RIGINALô3ERIES ôHTTPENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI3TAR?4REK?4HE? /RIGINAL?3ERIESôLASTôVISITEDôô$ECEMBER ô ô ;VIII=ô 7IKIPEDIA ô.ICHELLEô.ICHOLS ôHTTPENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI.ICHELLE?.ICHOLSôLASTôVISITEDôô $ECEMBERô ô ;IX=ôô ""# ô,Tô5HURA ôHTTPWWWBBCCOUKCULTSTORIGINALUHURASHTMLôTHEôKISSô@ESSENTIALLYô TAKESôPLACEôOFF SCREEN ôBECAUSEôOFôTHEôNETWORKSôCONCERNSôABOUTôUPSETTINGôVIEWERSôINôTHEô SOUTHERNôSTATES ôLASTôVISITEDôô$ECEMBERô ô ;X=ôô #HILDRENô.OW ô&ALLô#OLORSô0RIMEô4IMEô$IVERSITYô2EPORTôm ô#HILDRENô.OWô ô ôAVAILABLEôATôHTTPPUBLICATIONSCHILDRENNOWORGPUBLICATIONSMEDIAFALLCOLORS? CFMô ;XI=ôô )BID ôô ;XII=ôô )BID ôô ;XIII=ô )BID ôô ;XIV=ô )BID ôô ;XV=ô )BID ôô ;XVI=ô )BID ôô4HEô#HILDRENô.OWôREPORTôDOESôNOTôBREAKôDOWNôROLESôACCORDINGôTOôTHEôINTERSECTIONô OFôRACEôANDôGENDERô ;XVII=ô #HILDRENô.OW ô&ALLô#OLORSô0RIMEô4IMEô$IVERSITYô2EPORT ômô#HILDRENô.OWô ôô ;XVIII=ô 3EEô!ô-EMOôFROMô-!.!!ôTOô(OLLYWOODô!SIANô3TEREOTYPESô-EDIAô!CTIONô.ETWORKôFORô !SIAN !MERICANS ôAVAILABLEôATôHTTPWWWMANAAORGARTICLESSTEREOHTMLôLASTôVISITEDô ô$ECEMBERô ô3EEôALSOô$AVIDô,ô%NG ô2ACIALô#ASTRATIONô-ANAGINGô-ASCULINITYôINô !SIANô!MERICAô ômôDESCRIBINGôTHEôFEMINISATIONôOFôTHEô!SIAN !MERICANôMALEô INôTHEô53ôCULTURALôIMAGINATION ô'INAô-ARCHETTI ô2OMANCEôANDôTHEô@9ELLOWô0ERIL ô ôô NOTINGôTHATô!SIANôMENôAREôDEPICTEDôASôEITHERô@RAPISTSôORôASEXUALôEUNUCHôkGURES ôWHILEô !SIANôFEMALESôAREôDEPICTEDôASô@SEXUALLYôAVAILABLEôTOôTHEôWHITEôHERO ô$ARRELLô(AMAMOTO ô -ONITOREDô0ERILô ômôDISCUSSINGôHOWôRACISTôIMAGESôHAVEôBEENôIMPOSEDôUPONô !SIAN !MERICANSôONôTELEVISION ô0ETERô+WAN ô)NVENTION ô)NVERSIONôANDô)NTERVENTIONô4HEô /RIENTALô7OMANôINô-ô"UTTERlY ô4HEô7ORLDôOFô3UZIEô7ONG ôANDô4HEô!DVENTURESôOFô0RISCILLA ô 1UEENôOFôTHEô$ESERT ôô!SIANô,AWô*OURNALô ôô ;XIX=ôô $ANAô%ô-ASTROôô"RADLEYô3ô'REENBERG ô4HEô0ORTRAYALôOFô2ACIALô-INORITIESôONô0RIMEô4IMEô 4ELEVISION ô*OURNALôOFô"ROADCASTINGôô%LECTRONICô-EDIA ô&ALLô ômô ;XX=ôô .ON WHITESôAREôSPECIkCALLYôIDENTIkEDôBYôRACE ôWHILEôWHITENESSôISôASSUMEDôFORôALLôOTHERSô +EITHô7OODS ô(ARRYô0OTTERô!NDô4HEô)MBALANCEôOFô2ACE ô0OYNTER/NLINE ôô*ULYô ô HTTPWWWPOYNTERORGCOLUMNASPIDAIDôVISITEDôô$ECEMBERô ô ;XXI=ôô -ARKô7ATSONôô-ARYô-C-AHON ô#HILDRENSôCAREERôDEVELOPMENTô!ôRESEARCHôREVIEWôFROMô AôLEARNINGôPERSPECTIVE ô*OURNALôOFô6OCATIONALô"EHAVIOURôô ô ôôCITINGô3ô,ô /"RYANTôô#ô2ô#ORDER "OLZ ô4HEôEFFECTSôOFôTELEVISIONôONôCHILDRENSôSTEREOTYPINGôOFôWOM ENSôWORKôROLES ô*OURNALôOFô6OCATIONALô"EHAVIOURô ô ôô ;XXII=ôô 2EBECCAô3ô"IGLERôETôAL ô2ACEôANDôTHEô7ORKFORCEô/CCUPATIONALô3TATUS ô!SPIRATIONS ôANDô 3TEREOTYPINGô!MONGô!FRICANô!MERICANô#HILDREN ô$EVELOPMENTALô0SYCHOLOGYôô ô ôô)NTERESTINGLY ôRICHERô!FRICAN !MERICANôCHILDRENôWEREôMOREôLIKELYôTOôASPIREôTOôJOBSô THATôTHEYôSAWôPERFORMEDôSOLELYôBYôWHITESôORôBYôBOTHôWHITESôANDôBLACKSôTHANôBYôBLACKSô EXCLUSIVELYô ;XXIII=ôô )BIDô ;XXIV=ôô +ELLEYô-ASSONI ô-ODELINGô7ORKô/CCUPATIONALô-ESSAGESôINô3EVENTEENô-AGAZINE ô'ENDERô ANDô3OCIETYô ô ô ômô ;XXV=ôô )BID ôô ;XXVI=ôô HTTPENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI.ICHELLE?.ICHOLSôLASTôVISITEDôô$ECEMBERô ô ;XXVII=ôô )BID ôôEMPHASISôADDED ô


25/09/06 17:40:31

;XXVIII=ô

HTTPWWWMERRYCOZORGPAPERS-!2935%(4-ôLASTôVISITEDôô$ECEMBERô ôEM PHASISôINôORIGINAL ô .EVAô#HONIN ô@)FôYOUREôANôOBSESSEDô(ARRYô0OTTERôFAN ô6OLDEMORTôISNTôTHEôPROBLEMô)TSô (ERMIONEôVERSUSô'INNY ô3ANô&RANCISCOô#HRONICLE ôô!UGUSTôô ;XXX=ô @0OTTERôTRANSLATIONSôWITHDRAWN ô-AYô ô ôHTTPWWWNEWSCOM.EWS%NTERTAIN MENT!BROAD ? HTMLôLASTôVISITEDôô$ECEMBERô ô ;XXXI=ôô -ANJIRAô-AJUMDAR ô7HENô(ARRYô-ETô+ALIô4HEôNEWSôREPORTSôDOôNOTôTELLôUSôWHETHERôTHEô kCTIONALôCHARACTERSôFROMô"ENGALIôLITERATUREôAREôNOWôCLEARLYôOUTôOFôCOPYRIGHTô ;XXXII=ôô !NUPAMô#HANDER ô7HOSEô2EPUBLIC ôô5NIVERSITYôOFô#HICAGOô,AWô2EVIEWô ôô ;XXXIII=ô !CCORDINGôTOôANôENTRYôINô7IKIPEDIAôATôTHEôENDôOFô ô@UPLOADINGôFANkCTIONSôBASEDôONô WORKSôBYôTHEôFOLLOWINGôAUTHORSôISôFORBIDDENôONô&AN&ICTION.ETô0ô.ô%LROD ô2AYMONDô &EIST ô4ERRYô'OODKIND ô,AURELLô+ô(AMILTON ô2OBINô(OBB ô$ENNISô,ô-C+IERNAN ô2OBINô -C+INLEY ô)RENEô2ADFORD ô!NNEô2ICE ôANDô.ORAô2OBERTS*$ô2OBBô0ERHAPSôTHEôPROPRIETORô OFô&AN&ICTION.ETôHASôPREVIOUSLYôRECEIVEDôCEASEôANDôDESISTôLETTERSôFROMôTHESEôAUTHORSô REPRESENTATIVESôORôHASôOTHERWISEôLEARNEDôTHATôTHESEôAUTHORSôDOôNOTôTOLERATEôFANôkCTIONô 7IKIPEDIA ô&AN&ICTIONNET ôHTTPENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI&ANkCTION.ETôLASTôVISITEDô$ECô ô ô ;XXXIV=ô %VENôTHEôSETTINGômôTHEôWORLDôCREATEDôBYôAôWRITERôDEVOIDôOFôITSôSPECIkCôCHARACTERSômôWILLô LIKELYôBEôSUBJECTôTOôCOPYRIGHTô0UPILINGô(OGWARTSôWITHôNEWLYôINVENTEDôCHARACTERSôISôNOTô ENOUGHôTOôESCAPEô2OWLINGSôCOPYRIGHTôCLAIMô ;XXXV=ô #AMPBELLôVô!CUFF 2OSEô-USIC ô)NC ôô53ô ôô ;XXXVI=ô )BID ôô ;XXXVII=ô )BID ôô ;XXXVIII=ô 3UN4RUSTô"ANKôVô(OUGHTONô-IFlINô#O ôô&DôôTHô#IRô ô ;XXXIX=ô )BIDô ;XL=ôô 0AULô'OLDSTEIN ô@'OLDSTEINôONô#OPYRIGHTôeB ôRDôED ô!SPENô0UBLISHERSô ô ;XLI=ôô #AMPBELL ôô53 ô ô ;XLII=ôô )BID ôô ;XLIII=ô HTTPWWWANNERICECOMFA?WRITING?ARCHIVEHTMôEMPHASISôADDED ô ;XLIV=ô 'OLDSTEIN ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôeB ô ;XLV=ô -ASSONI ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôô ;XLVI=ô )BIDô ;XLVII=ô #AMPBELL ôô53 ôô ;XLVIII=ô "RUCEô0ô+ELLERôô2EBECCAô4USHNET ô@%VENô-OREô0ARODICô4HANôTHEô2EALô4HINGô0ARODYô ,AWSUITSô2EVISITED ô4RADEMARKô2EPORTERô3EPTEMBERm/CTOBERô ô ôô ;XLIX=ô HTTPWWWGOTHAMCOMICSCOMSPIDERMAN?INDIAôLASTôVISITEDôô*ANUARYô ô ;L=ôô ""#ô.EWS ô@.EW LOOKô0OOHôgHASôGIRLôFRIENDu ôô$ECEMBERô ôHTTPNEWSBBCCOUK HIENTERTAINMENTSTMô ;LI=ô 7ILLô0AVIA ô@-Y ô#HRISTOPHERô2OBIN ôYOUVEôCHANGED ô4HEô4IMESô,ONDON ôô$ECEMBERô ôô ;LII=ô -ARCOô2ôDELLAô#AVA ô@$ISNEYôLETSôGIRLôINTOô7INNIESôWORLD ô53!ô4ODAY ôô$ECEMBERô ô $ô ;LIII=ô @g'AYô"ATMANuô!RTISTô'ETSôg#EASEôô$ESIST uô!RTNETCOMôô!UGUSTô ôATôHTTPWWW ARTNETCOMMAGAZINEUSNEWSARTNETNEWSARTNETNEWS ASPôLASTôVISITEDôô*ANU ARYô ô ;LIV=ô 3UPERlEX ô4OOLSô ôô ;XXIX=ôô


0240_057_self_org.indd 62-63


25/09/06 17:40:32

4HEôPOLITICALô ACTIONôOFôô THEô,AND LESSô7ORKERSô -OVEMENTôô INô"RAZIL "RUNOô+ONDERô#OMPARATO


0240_057_self_org.indd 64-65

4HEôPOLITICALôACTIONôOFôTHEô,ANDLESSô7ORKERSô-OVEMENTôINô"RAZIL

25/09/06 17:40:32

)NôAôCOUNTRYôOFôCONTINENTALôSIZEôSUCHôASô"RAZIL ôWHEREôMOSTôOFô THEôPOLITICALôPARTIESôAREôWEAKôANDôREGIONALôINôSCOPE ôONEôCANNOTô OVERLOOKôTHEôSIGNIkCANTôROLEôPLAYEDôBYôOTHERôPOLITICALôACTORSô 4HISôISôPARTICULARLYôTRUEôWHENôTHEYôMAKEôTHEIRôPRESENCEôFELTôATô THEôNATIONALôSCALE ôASôISôTHEôCASEôWITHôTHEô,ANDLESSô7ORKERSô -OVEMENTômôINô0ORTUGUESE ô@-OVIMENTOôDOSô4RABALHADORESô 3EMô4ERRAôORô-34ô3PECIALôATTENTIONôISôDUEôTOôGROUPSôTHATô REPRESENTôANôAUTHENTICôNOVELTYôINôTHEôNATIONALôPOLITICALôSCENEô ANDôTHATôHAVEôACHIEVEDôkRSTôCLASSôPOLITICALôSTATUS ôEVENôIFôNONEô OFôTHEIRôACTIONSôORôORGANISATIONALôCHARACTERISTICSôISôORIGINALôPERô SEô4HEô-34ôRECOMBINESôANDôREARTICULATESôKNOWNôTACTICSôANDô ELEMENTSôINôNEWôWAYSôANDôSHOWSôAôREMARKABLEôPOLITICALôABILITYô INôBUILDINGôALLIANCESôWITHôVARIOUSôINlUENTIALôSEGMENTSôOFôCIVILô SOCIETYô7EôAREôDEALINGôHEREôWITHôAôNEWôFORMôOFôSHAPINGôANDô STRENGTHENINGôSOCIALôCLAIMS ôOR ôPERHAPS ôWITHôAôNEWôFORMôOFô ORGANISINGôPOLITICALôACTIONô/VERôTHEôLASTôDECADE ôTHEô-34ôHASô CONQUEREDôANôIMPORTANTôPOLITICALôSPACEôINôTHEô"RAZILIANôPUBLICô SCENEô)TôHASôDONEôSOôBYôCONTRADICTINGôAôSUPPOSEDôTRADITIONô OFôPASSIVITYôANDôANOMIEôALLEGEDLYôCHARACTERISTICôOFôCOMMONô PEOPLEôINô"RAZIL ôANDôHASôSUCCEEDEDôINôORGANISINGôITSELFôONô AôVERYôLARGEôSCALE ôGATHERINGôPOLITICALôINlUENCEôANDôGROWINGô INCREASINGLYôCAPABLEôOFôCHALLENGINGôTHEôSTATUSôQUO 4HEô-34ôORIGINATEDôFROMôTHEôCONVERGENCEôANDôMERGERôOFôSEV ERALôPOPULARôMOVEMENTSôCENTREDôONôLANDôSTRUGGLES ôORGANISEDô AROUNDôLANDôOCCUPATIONSôINôTHEôSOUTHERNôANDôSOUTHWESTERNô STATESôOFô2IOô'RANDEôDOô3UL ô3ANTAô#ATARINA ô0ARAN¶ ô3Óô0AULOô ANDô-ATOô'ROSSOôDOô3ULôDURINGôTHEôkRSTôHALFôOFôTHEôSô"RAZILô WASôTHENôGOINGôTHROUGHôAôGRADUALôDEMOCRATISATIONôPROCESSôASô THEôMILITARYôREGIMEôESTABLISHEDôBYôTHEôôCOUPôWASôDRAWINGô TOôAôCLOSEô4HEôCOMBINATIONôOFôHIGHLYôCONCENTRATEDôLANDôOWNER SHIPôANDôTHEôRAPIDôMODERNISATIONôOFôCAPITAL INTENSIVEôAGRICULTUREô

LEDôTOôRURALôUNEMPLOYMENT ôTHEôEXPULSIONôOFôTHEôPOORôFROMôTHEô LARGEôESTATESôANDôAôMASSIVEôRURALôEXODUSôTOôTHEô@FAVELASôANDô SHANTY TOWNSôONôTHEôPERIPHERYôOFôMID SIZEDôORôLARGEôCITIESô4HISô TENDENCYôCOINCIDEDôWITHôTHEôBREAKDOWNôOFôGOVERNMENT SPON SOREDôLANDôSETTLEMENTôPOLICIESôINôTHEô!MAZONôAREAôDURINGôTHEô MILITARYôREGIMEô)TôWASôAGAINSTôTHISôBACKGROUNDôOFôCRISESôANDô VIOLENTôLANDôCONlICTSôTHATôSEVERALôDIFFERENTôMOVEMENTSôBEGANôTOô ORGANISEôRESISTANCEôANDôTHEôSTRUGGLEôFORôPEASANTSôRIGHTSô ô 4HEô-OVIMENTOôDOSô4RABALHADORESô3EMô4ERRAôWASôTHEô DIRECTôRESULTôOFôTHOSEôEXPERIENCESôWHICH ôATôAôCERTAINôPOINT ô CONVERGEDôTOôLAUNCHôTHEô%NCRUZILHADAô.ATALINOôENCAMPMENTô INô2ONDAô!LTA ôINôTHEôSOUTHERNMOSTôSTATEôOFô2IOô'RANDEôDOô3UL ô BIRTHPLACEôOFôTHEô-OVEMENTô/FkCIALLY ôITôWASôFOUNDEDôINô#AS CAVELôINôTHEôSTATEôOFô0ARAN¶ ôINô ôDURINGôTHEôSTô.ATIONALô -EETINGôOFôTHEô,ANDLESSô2URALô7ORKERSô-OVEMENT ôWHICHôWASô ATTENDEDôBYôôREPRESENTATIVESôFROMôôSTATESô ô 4HEôSTATESôOFô2IOô'RANDEôDOô3ULôANDô0ARAN¶ôPIONEEREDôTHEô INTRODUCTIONôOFôMODERNôTECHNOLOGYôANDôCAPITAL INTENSIVEôFARMINGô METHODS ôMAINLYôFORôTHEôPRODUCTIONôOFôSOYAôANDôSOYAôDERIVATIVESô FORôEXPORTô!TôTHEôSAMEôTIME ôMINIFUNDIAômôTHEôSUBDIVISIONôOFôLANDô UNTILôINDIVIDUALôPLOTSôAREôTOOôSMALLôTOôBEôVIABLE ôOFTENôDIVIDEDô BETWEENôSONSôASôTHEYôAREôHANDEDôONôTOôTHEôNEXTôGENERATIONômôISô WIDESPREADôINôTRADITIONALôAREASôTHATôHAVEôBEENôSETTLEDôBYô)TALIAN ô 'ERMANôANDô0OLISHôIMMIGRANTSôAMONGôOTHERS ôANDôHASôBEENôTHEô MAJORôCAUSEôOFôEMIGRATIONôTOôNEIGHBOURINGô0ARAGUAYôANDô2ON DONIAôANDô-ATOô'ROSSOôINôTHEô!MAZONôSINCEôTHEôSô4HUS ô ALTHOUGHôVIOLENTôCONlICTôOVERôLANDôPREVAILSôALONGôTHEôSHIFTINGô AGRICULTURALôFRONTIERôATôTHEôPERIPHERYôOFôTHEô!MAZONIANôRAINFOR EST ôTHEôPOLITICALôORGANISATIONôOFôTHEôLAND STRUGGLEôMOVEMENTôISô MOSTLYôAôPHENOMENONôTHATôWASôNURTUREDôALONGSIDEôMODERNôAG RICULTURE ôANDôDEVELOPEDôINôAREASôOFôSTRONGô%UROPEANôIMMIGRANTô INlUENCE



0240_057_self_org.indd 66-67

25/09/06 17:40:32

4WOôDECADESôAFTERôITSôLAUNCHôINô ôTHEô-34ôISôPRESENTôINôô OFôTHEôô"RAZILIANôSTATESôANDôISôCAPABLEôOFôORGANISINGôDEMON STRATIONSôINôMOREôTHANôôSTATEôCAPITALSôSIMULTANEOUSLYô"YôTHEô LATESTôEVALUATION ôITôENGAGESôMOREôTHANôôMILLIONôPEOPLE ôORô ALMOSTôôOFôTHEôPOPULATIONôOFô"RAZILô!BOUTô ôFAMILIESô HAVEôBEENôSETTLEDôONôTHEIRôOWNôLAND ôANDôANOTHERô ôLIVEô INôENCAMPMENTSôWAITINGôFORô'OVERNMENTôACTION 4HEô-34ôHASôBECOMEôIMPORTANTôFORôTHEôECONOMICôLIFEôOFôTHEô LOCALITIESôWHEREôITôISôPRESENTô4HEô-OVEMENTôHASôCREATEDôABOUTô ôASSOCIATIONSôINôTHEôkELDSôOFôPRODUCTION ôCOMMERCIALISATIONô ANDôSERVICESôô!GRICULTURALôANDô#ATTLE RAISINGô#OOPERATIVESô #0! ôWHICHôINVOLVEô ôFAMILIESôô3ERVICEô#OOPERATIVES ô WITHô ôDIRECTôPARTNERSôTWOô2EGIONALô#OMMERCIALIZATIONô #OOPERATIVESôANDôTHREEô#REDITô#OOPERATIVES ôWITHôAôTOTALôOFô ôMEMBERSô!DDITIONALLY ôôSMALLôANDôMEDIUM SIZEDôCO OPERATIVESôPROCESSôFRUIT ôVEGETABLES ôDAIRYôPRODUCTS ôGRAINS ô COFFEE ôMEATôANDôSWEETSô!LLôTHESEô-34ôECONOMICôENTERPRISESô GENERATEôEMPLOYMENT ôSALARYôANDôPROkTSôTHATôINDIRECTLYôBENEkTô ABOUTôôSMALLôTOWNS

FEDERALôGOVERNMENTô"ECAUSEôOFôTHESEôIMPRESSIVEôRESULTS ôTHEô -OVEMENTôRECEIVEDôTWOôRECOGNITIONôAWARDSôFROMô5.%3#/ô !SôSTATEDôBYô*OÓô0EDROô3T¯DILE ôONEôOFôTHEô-OVEMENTSôLEAD ERS ôTHEô-34SôAIMôISôTOôSTRUGGLEôAGAINSTôTHREEôBARRIERSôTHEô PHYSICALôFENCESômôTHEôBARBED WIREôFENCESôTHATôENCLOSEôLARGEô ESTATESôANDôBLOCKôANYôACCESSôTOôLANDôTHEôBARRIERôOFôLACKôOFô CAPITAL ôTHATôIS ôMONEYôTOôkNANCEôAGRICULTURE ôTHEôPOSSIBILITYô OFôPURCHASINGôTRACTORSôANDôAGRICULTURALôEQUIPMENTôINôGENERALô AND ôkNALLY ôTHEôBARRIERôOFôIGNORANCE ôMEANINGôBOTHôTHEôLACKô OFôMODERNôAGRICULTURALôTECHNOLOGYôANDôOFôKNOWLEDGEôOFôONESô RIGHTSôANDôTHEôCAPACITYôTOôDEFENDôTHEM

!NOTHERôONEôOFôTHEô-34SôGREATôACHIEVEMENTSôISôEDUCATIONô !PPROXIMATELYô ôCHILDRENôATTENDôCLASSESôFROMôTHEôSTô TOôTHEôTHôGRADESôINôTHEô ôPUBLICôELEMENTARYôSCHOOLSôINôTHEô -OVEMENTSôSETTLEMENTS ôANDôTHEô-34ôEMPLOYSô ôTEACHERSô WHOôHAVEôCREATEDôAôSPECIkCôKINDôOFôPEDAGOGYôFORôITSôSCHOOLSô 4HEô%SCOLAô.ACIONALô&LORESTANô&ERNANDES ôAôGRADUATIONôSCHOOLô INôAGRONOMYôCREATEDôANDôMANAGEDôBYôTHEô-OVEMENT ôWASôIN AUGURATEDôNEARô3Óô0AULOôINô*ANUARYôô7ITHôTHEôHELPôANDô COLLABORATIONôOFôSEVERALôUNIVERSITIES ôTHEô-34ôHASôVIRTUALLYôELIMI NATEDôILLITERACYôAMONGôTEENAGERSôANDôADULTSôINôTHEôSETTLEMENTS ô WITHôMUCHôBETTERôRATESôTHANôTHEôSIMILARôLITERACYôPROGRAMSôOFôTHEô

/FôCOURSE ôTHEô-34ôWASôNOTôTHEôkRSTôLAND STRUGGLEôMOVEMENTô INô"RAZILIANôHISTORY ôWHICHôHASôSEENôMANYôOTHERôEPISODESôOFô PEASANTôREVOLTô!LLôTHEôPREVIOUSôMOVEMENTS ôHOWEVER ôREMAINEDô CIRCUMSCRIBEDôTOôTHEôREGIONSôWHEREôTHEYôkRSTôEMERGEDô4HEô 0EASANTô,EAGUESôACTIONô,IGASô#AMPONESAS ôINô0ORTUGUESE ôINô THEôS ôFORôINSTANCE ôWASôCONCENTRATEDôINôTHEôSTATEôOFô0ER NAMBUCOôANDôITSôVICINITYô4HEôSAMEôHAPPENEDôWITHôTHEôHISTORICô "ACKLANDôREBELLIONôOFô#ANUDOS ôATôTHEôENDôOFôTHEôNINETEENTHô CENTURY ôANDôWITHôTHEôSO CALLEDô7ARôOFôTHEô#ONTESTADO ôATôTHEô BEGINNINGôOFôTHEôTWENTIETHôCENTURY ôWHICHôWEREôRESTRICTEDôTOô .ORTHEASTERNô"AHIAôANDô7ESTERNô3ANTAô#ATARINAôRESPECTIVE LYô)NôADDITION ôBOTHôINô#ANUDOSôANDôINôTHEô#ONTESTADO ôTHEô REBELSôWEREôANIMATEDôBYôMESSIANICôANDôMYSTICôINSPIRATIONS ô ANDôASPIREDôTOôRETURNôTOôAôMYTHICôPASTôRATHERôTHANôTOôTRANSFORMô THEôCONDITIONSôOFôTHEôPRESENTô!NOTHERôIMPORTANTôDISTINCTIONô BETWEENôTHEô-34ôANDôALLôTHEôPREVIOUSôLAND STRUGGLEôMOVE MENTSôISôTHATôITôIDENTIkESôTHEôFEDERALôGOVERNMENT ôANDôNOTôTHEô GREATôLANDOWNERS ôASôITSôPRINCIPALôTARGETô4HEô-OVEMENTSôLEAD ERSôKNOWôINDEEDôTHATôONLYôTHEôGOVERNMENTôHASôTHEôMEANSôTOô



0240_057_self_org.indd 68-69

25/09/06 17:40:32

#OPYSHOP $ESCRIPTION g)&ô6!,5% ô4(%.ô#/09u 4EXT #/093(/0ôISôAôPLACEôWHEREôYOUôCANôPHOTOCOPYôEVERYTHINGôFROMôTEXTôTOôIMAGESôô ô7 EôUSEôTHISôNAMEôFORôAôSHOPôANDôINFORMATIONôFORUMôWHICHôWILLôINVESTIGATEôTHEô ôPHENOMENONôOFôCOPYINGô)Nô#/093(/0ôYOUôWILLôkNDôPRODUCTSôTHATôCHALLENGEôIN TELLECTUALôPROPERTYô4HEYôCANôBEôMODIkEDôORIGINALS ôIMPROVEDôCOPIES ôPOLITICALôANTI BRANDSômôORôAô350%2#/09ôASôTHEôNEWôORIGINALô#/093(/0ôWILLôDISCUSSôTHEôCONTROLô OFôVALUEôINôTHEôSAMEôPLACEôWHEREôITôISôPRODUCEDôANDôDISTRIBUTEDôTHEôMARKETô!SôANô ACTIVEôPLAYERôTHEôFUNCTIONôOFô#/093(/0ôWILLôBEôASôANôORDINARYôSHOPô&URTHERMORE ô #/093(/0ôWILLôFUNCTIONôASôAôGATHERINGôPOINTôANDôNETWORKôFORôAôDIVERSEôGROUPôWHOô SHAREôAôCRITICALôVIEWôONôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTY môô @)NTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôISôTHEôOILôOFôTHEôSTôCENTURYômô-ARKô'ETTY ô!MERICANô ô

BUSINESSMANôANDôGRANDSONôOFôTHEôOILôTYCOONô*ô0AULô'ETTY

môô @4HEREôHASôNEVERôBEENôAôTIMEôINôHISTORYôWHENôMOREôOFôOURôgCULTUREuôWASôASôgOWNEDuôô ô

ASôITôISôNOWô!NDôYETôTHEREôHASôNEVERôBEENôAôTIMEôWHENôTHEôCONCENTRATIONôOFô

ô

POWERôTOôCONTROLôTHEôUSESôOFôCULTUREôHASôBEENôASôUNQUESTIONINGLYôACCEPTEDôASôITôô

ô

ISôNOWô ô,AWRENCEô,ESSIG ôLAWYERôANDôWRITER

)NTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôINôTHEôFORMôOFôCOPYRIGHT ôLICENCESôANDôPATENTSôHASôANôINCREASINGô IMPORTANCEôINôSOCIETYômôITôAFFECTSôWHATôWEôSAY ôWHEREôWEôSAYôIT ôANDôTOôWHOMôWEôSAYô ITô4HEôCONTROLôOFôRIGHTSôTOôIDEASôMAINTAINSôTHEôSTATUSôQUOôWITHINôTHEôCURRENTôECONOMICô ORDERô4HEôLASTôôTOôôYEARSôHASôSEENôANôEXPONENTIALôRISEôINôTHEôRANGEôANDôSCOPEô OFôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTY ôDUEôTOôTHEôECONOMICSôOFôGLOBALISATIONôANDôTOôTHEôSPREADôOFô INFORMATIONôTECHNOLOGYô4HEôFUNDAMENTALôLEGALôCONCEPTôISôASôFOLLOWSô@IFôVALUEôTHENô RIGHT ôOR ôTOôPUTôITôANOTHERôWAY ô@WHEREôTHEREôISôECONOMICôVALUEôTHEREôISôINTELLECTUALô PROPERTYô(OWEVER ôMANYôSUCCESSFULôALTERNATIVESôTOôTHESEôDOMINANTôIDEASôHAVEôBEENô PROPOSED ôANDôHAVEôLEDôTOôEFFECTIVEôSTRATEGIESôTHATôSUBVERTôORôBYPASSôEXISTINGôLAWSôANDô CONVENTIONSômôTHEô&REE/PENô3OURCEô3OFTWAREôMOVEMENTôANDôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôTHEô ,INUXôOPERATINGôSYSTEM ôFORôEXAMPLE ôORôTHEôSTATE SANCTIONEDôINFRINGEMENTôOFôINTELLECTUALô PROPERTYôINô"RAZILôTHATôHASôENABLEDôTHEôPRODUCTIONôOFôAFFORDABLEôDRUGSôFORôTHEôTREATMENTô OFô()6ô7EôWANTôTOôCONFRONTôTHISôDEVELOPMENTôANDôPRODUCE ôPROMOTEôANDôSELLôPRODUCTSô THATôCHALLENGEôTHEôCONCEPTô@)FôVALUEôTHENôRIGHTô 3OURCEô WWWCOPY SHOPORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION #/093(/0ôISôINITIATEDôBYô3UPERlEXôANDô#OPENHAGENô"RAINS

0240_057_self_org.indd 70-71

%XAMPLESôôYôô LMVPELM

25/09/06 17:40:34

ô ROMOTEôLANDôREFORM ôTOôCREATEôSETTLEMENTS ôANDôTOôPROVIDEô P LOANSôTOôSMALLôFARMERSôONôVIABLEôTERMSô"ESIDES ôTHEô-34ôDOESô NOTôNEEDôTHEôMEDIATIONôOFô#ONGRESSIONALôREPRESENTATIVESôINô ORDERôTOôMAKEôTHEIRôCLAIMSôKNOWNôTOôTHEô0RESIDENTôOFôTHEô2E PUBLICôANDôTHEôOTHERôCOMPONENTSôOFôTHEô%XECUTIVEô"RANCH ôASô ITSôMILITANTSôHAVEôFREQUENTLYôBEENôRECEIVEDôBYôTHEô0RESIDENTôANDô BYô&EDERALô-INISTERSô 4HEô-34SôORGANISATIONALôSTRUCTUREôISôkRSTôCHARACTERISEDôBYôAô STRONGôSENSEôOFôHIERARCHYôANDôDISCIPLINEô)NôTHEôENCAMPMENTS ô MARRIEDôCOUPLESôAREôSEPARATEDôFROMôSINGLEôPEOPLEôTHEôLATTERô AREôDIVIDEDôACCORDINGôTOôGENDERô4HEôSINGLESôHAVEôTHEIRôOWNô KITCHENôANDôAREôCLOSELYôMONITOREDô'UNSôANDôSPIRITSôAREôPROHIB ITEDô#RITICSôSAYôTHESEôRULESôEXPOSEôTHEôCONSERVATIVEôBIASôOFôTHEô MOVEMENT ôPROVINGôTHATôITôISôAGAINSTôMODERNITYô4HEIRôLEADERS ô HOWEVER ôSIMPLYôEXPLAINôTHATôTHEYôAREôCONFRONTINGôSTRICTLYôDISCI PLINEDôORGANISATIONSôSUCHôASôTHEô!RMYôANDôTHEô-ILITARYô0OLICE ô SOôTHEYôMUSTôBEôDISCIPLINEDôTOOô3ECONDLY ôTHEô-34ôHASôLEARNEDô FROMôTHEôEXPERIENCESôOFôTHEôPREVIOUSôLAND STRUGGLEôMOVEMENTSô POWERôISôDIVIDEDôBETWEENôôNATIONALôLEADERSôANDôPHYSICALôIN STALLATIONSôAREôDISPERSEDôTHROUGHOUTôVARIOUSôLOCALITIESô"ESIDESô POWERôDECENTRALISATION ôTHOSEôLEADERSôMOSTôOFTENôTARGETEDôAREô PERIODICALLYôREPLACEDôINôORDERôTOôAVOIDôTHEIRôELIMINATIONôTHROUGHô ARRESTôOR ôINôTHEôMOSTôEXTREMEôCASES ôASSASSINATIONô4HIRDLY ôTHEREô ISôAôPEDAGOGICôPROCESSôOFôEDUCATIONôANDôIDEOLOGICALôFORMATION ô ALONGôWITHôTHEôINCORPORATIONôOFôNEWôMILITANTSôTHROUGHôCOLLECTIVEô WORKôANDôTHEôCREATIONôOFôFAMILYôENCAMPMENTS

THEYôCEASEôTOôBEôEXCLUDEDôANDôBECOMEôAôCOMMUNITYôOFôINDI VIDUALSôNEWLYôINCLUDEDôINôSOCIETYô4HISôISôWHYôTHEôMILITANTSôAREô ABLEôTOôESTABLISHôAôDIALOGUEôWITHôTHEôGOVERNMENT ôORôTOôMAKEô THEIRôIDEASôPUBLICôINôSPITEôOFôTHEôFREQUENTôCRITICISMôORôOPENôHOS TILITYôFROMôAôCONSIDERABLEôPARTôOFôTHEôMEDIAô/NCEôTHEYôJOIN ôTHEô -34ôMILITANTSôACQUIREôAôNEWôFAMILY ôAôJOBôANDôAôCAUSEôTOôkGHTô FORôINôOTHERôWORDS ôTHEYôkNDôAôNEWôMEANINGôFORôTHEIRôLIVESô)Nô THEôWORDSôOFô-ARLENE ôAôMILITANTôFROMôTHEôSTATEôOFô-ATOô'ROSSOô @4HEô-34ôISôAôVERYôGOODôEXPERIENCEô%VERYTHINGô)ôKNOWôABOUTô TODAYSô"RAZILIANôREALITYô)ôLEARNEDôATôTHEôMOVEMENTô)ôOWEôEVE RYTHINGô)ôKNOWôTOôITô)ôWILLôNEVERôFORGETôITô7ATCHINGôTHEôFAMILIESô THATôWEREôINôNEED ôTHATôWEREôSTARVINGôINôTHEôCITIES ôUNEMPLOYEDô RURALôWORKERSôwôWHOôAREôNOWôLIVINGôASô)ôAM ôITôISôAôGREATôDREAMô COMEôTRUEô7EôLIVEôINôCOMMUNITYôWEôHAVEôEDUCATIONôFORôTHEô KIDS ôWEôHAVEôHEALTHô(EALTHôISôTHEôMOSTôIMPORTANTôTHINGôwô )TôISôIMPLICITôINôTHISôTESTIMONYôTHATôWHATôMATTERSôFORôTHEô-34Sô MEMBERSôISôNOTôJUSTôTHEôMATERIALôCONDITIONSôNECESSARYôFORôSUR VIVALô2ATHER ôTHEô-34SôGREATESTôACHIEVEMENTôISôITSôCAPACITYô TOôOFFERôPEOPLEôTHEôMINIMALôCONDITIONSôTOôIMPROVEôTHEIRôOWNô LIVES ôTOôGIVEôTHEMôAôNEWôSENSEôOFôPERSONALôDIGNITY ôTOôENABLEô THEMôTOôCONDUCTôTHEIRôOWNôSTRUGGLEôFORôIMPROVEMENTô&ROMôTHISô PERSPECTIVE ôSOCIALôMOVEMENTSôSUCHôASôTHEô-34ôPLAYôAôROLEôINô POLITICALôLIFEôTHATôISôVERYôSIMILARôTOôTHATôOFôTHEôWELFAREôSTATEô

!DVERSARIESôOFôTHEô-34ôCOMMONLYôMAKEôTHEôMISTAKEôOFôBELIEV INGôTHATôTHEôMOVEMENTôISôHISTORICALLYôRETROGRESSIVEôANDôTHATôITSô MEMBERSôFORMôAôGROUPôOFôPEOPLEôEXCLUDEDôFROMôMODERNô"RAZIL IANôSOCIETYô4HEôTRUTHôIS ôONCEôRURALôWORKERSôJOINôTHEôMOVEMENT ô

4HEô-34SôSUCCESSôINôSETTINGôFORTHôITSôIDEASôANDôPOSITIONSôISô TOôAôLARGEôEXTENTôDUEôTOôITSôCONSIDERABLEôPOLITICALôFORCEô/NEô CANôEVALUATEôTHISôCAPACITYôTOôINlUENCEôPOLITICALôEVENTSôBYôANô INDIRECTôMETHODôOBSERVINGô-34SôPRESENCEôINôTHEôDAILYôCOVER AGEôOFôNATIONALôPOLITICALôDEVELOPMENTSôBYôTHEô"RAZILIANôPRESSô )NôAôPREVIOUSôSTUDY ôWEôCOUNTEDôTHEôNUMBERôOFôTIMESôTHEô -OVEMENTôWASôCITEDôINôEDITORIALSôINôTHEôFOURôPRINCIPALô"RAZILIANô NEWSPAPERSô&OLHAôDEô30AULO ô/ô%STADOôDEô30AULO ô*ORNALô



0240_057_self_org.indd 72-73

25/09/06 17:40:34

DOô"RASIL ô/ô'LOBO ô4HEôRESULTSôINDICATEôTHEôSTATUSôTHATôTHEô -34ôATTAINEDôINôTHEô"RAZILIANôPOLITICALôSCENEôOVERôTHEôSECONDô HALFôOFôTHEôSô4HEô-34ôISôNOT ôOFôCOURSE ôTHEôONLYôLANDLESSô WORKERSôMOVEMENTôINô"RAZILôMANYôSIMILARôMOVEMENTSôAREôAC TIVE ôSEVERALôOFôTHEMôINSPIREDôBYôTHEô-34ô!ôSTUDYôBYô"ERNARDOô -AN±ANOô&ERNANDESôHASôSHOWNôTHATôTHEô-34ôWASôDIRECTLYôRE SPONSIBLEôFORôONLYôONE THIRDôOFôLANDôOCCUPATIONSôINô"RAZILôFROMô ôTOô ôANDôREPRESENTSôAPPROXIMATELYôTWO THIRDSôOFô THEôENCAMPEDôFAMILIESôRECORDEDôUPôTOôô4HEôOTHERôLAND STRUGGLEôMOVEMENTS ôTHEN ôDISPUTEôTHEôSAMEôPOLITICALôSPACEô ASôTHEô-34ô!ôDAY TO DAYôEXAMINATIONôOFôPOLITICALôNEWSôCOVER AGEôREVEALS ôHOWEVER ôTHATôTHEô-34ôREMAINSôUNDOUBTEDLYôTHEô PRINCIPALôACTORôINôALLôMATTERSôRELATEDôTOôAGRARIANôREFORMôANDôTHEô MAINôSOURCEôOFôORGANISEDôPRESSUREôUPONôTHEôGOVERNMENTô4HEô -34ôISôALSOôTHEôONLYôLANDLESSôWORKERSôMOVEMENTôTOôHAVEôBEENô ACCORDEDôEDITORIALSôINôALLôFOURôOFôTHEôNEWSPAPERSôMENTIONEDô ABOVEô!ôCOMPARISONôWITHôTHEôLARGESTôFEDERATIONôOFôWORKERSô UNIONSô#ENTRALô5NICAôDOSô4RABALHADORESôORô#54 ôWHICHôHASô BEENôCONSIDERED ôSINCEôITSôCREATION ôAôSORTôOFôTRADE UNIONôARMô OFôTHEô7ORKERSô0ARTYô04 ôANDôANôIMPORTANTôCRITICôANDôADVER SARYôOFôSEVERALô&EDERALô!DMINISTRATIONSôBEFOREôTHEô04ôCAMEô TOôPOWER ôSHOWSôTHATôTHEô-34SôMEDIAôPRESENCEôISôCLEARLYôONô THEôRISEô)Nô ôFORôINSTANCE ôTHEô-34ôINSPIREDôôEDITORIALS ô VERSUSôôFORôTHEô#54ô4HREEôYEARSôLATER ôINô ôTHEô-34ô GARNEREDôôEDITORIALS ôWHILEôTHEô#54ôHADôBEENôREDUCEDôTOô ô)Nô ôTHEô-34ôWASôTHEôSUBJECTôOFôôEDITORIALS ôANDôTHEô #54ôONLYôô4HESEôNUMBERSôSHOWôTHATôINôTHEôPERIODôBETWEENô ôANDô ôTHEô-34ôWASôMENTIONEDôATôLEASTôONCEôAôWEEKô INôONEôOFôTHEôFOURôLARGESTôNEWSPAPERSôEDITORIALSôINô"RAZIL

)Nô ô&ERNANDOô(ENRIQUEô#ARDOSOôBECAMEô0RESIDENTôANDô SEEMEDôDETERMINEDôTOôDILUTEôANDôWEAKENôTHEôMOVEMENTôTHROUGHôô AôMASSIVEôSETTLEMENTôEFFORTô5NTILôTHATôPERIOD ôLANDôSETTLEMENTSô FORôAGRARIANôREFORMôPURPOSESôHADôAVERAGEDôAROUNDô ô FAMILIESôPERôYEARô4HEô#ARDOSOô!DMINISTRATIONSôADVISORSôES TIMATEDôTHATôTHEYôCOULDôSETTLEôAPPROXIMATELYô ôFAMILIESô OVERôTHEôFOURôYEARSôOFô#ARDOSOSôkRSTôTERMô4HEYôkGUREDôOUTô THATôIFôTHISôPLANôCOULDôBEôREALISED ôTHEôAGRARIANôQUESTIONôWOULDô NOôLONGERôCONSTITUTEôAôMAJORôGOVERNMENTALôPROBLEMô4HEYôRECK ONED ôINôEFFECT ôTHATôSUCHôAôMASSIVEôSETTLEMENTôPOLICYôWOULDô CONSIDERABLYôERODEôTHEôLANDLESSôWORKERSôMOVEMENTSôPOTENTIALô TOôATTRACTôNEWôADHERENTSôANDôTHATôONCEôMOSTôOFôTHEôDEMANDSô FORôAGRARIANôREFORMôHADôBEENôMET ôTHEôSUBJECTôWOULDôLOSEôMUCHô OFôITSôAPPEALôANDôLEGITIMACYôINôTHEôEYESôOFôTHEôPUBLICô4HEôPRO POSEDôGOALSôHAVEôBEENôATTAINED ôANDô ôFAMILIESôWEREô SETTLEDôDURINGôTHEôkRSTô#ARDOSOô!DMINISTRATIONôm ô ACCORDINGôTOôOFkCIALôkGURESô7HATôTHEôOFkCIALôPLANNERSôHADôNOTô FORESEEN ôHOWEVER ôWASôTHATôTHEô-34ôINCREASEDôINôSTRENGTHôANDô VISIBILITYôINô"RAZILIANôSOCIETYôOVERôTHISôVERYôSAMEôPERIOD

)NôORDERôTOôUNDERSTANDôTHESEôNUMBERS ôWEôMUSTôRECAPITULATEô SOMEôKEYôEVENTSôRELATEDôTOôTHEô-34ôANDôTHEôCOUNTRYSôPOLITICSô

/Nôô!PRILô ôNINETEENôMILITANTSôFROMôTHEô-34ôWEREôSHOTô ANDôKILLEDôBYôTHEôMILITARYôPOLICEôOFôTHEôNORTHERNôSTATEôOFô0AR¶ô WHILEôDEMONSTRATINGôONôAôROADôATô%LDORADOôDOSô#ARAJ¶S ôINôTHATô STATEô4HEôINCIDENTôWASôTELEVISEDôANDôRE TRANSMITTEDôWORLDWIDEô 4HEôMOVEMENTôGAINEDôIMMEDIATEôPUBLICITY ôPROMPTINGôTHEôGOV ERNMENTôTOôMONITORôITSôACTIONSôWITHôENHANCEDôATTENTIONô)NôSPITEô OFôTHISôPRECEDENT ôJUSTôONEôYEARôLATERôTHEôGOVERNMENTôDIDôNOTô SERIOUSLYôCONSIDERôTHEôPOSSIBILITYôTHATôAôMARCHôTOô"RAS«LIAôORGAN ISEDôBYô-34ôLEADERSôBETWEENô&EBRUARYôANDô!PRILôôWOULDô HAVEôMUCHôIMPACTô4HREEôCOLUMNSôOFôLANDLESSôWORKERSôMETôINô "RAS«LIAôAFTERôTHEôTWO MONTHôMARCHô4HEôAIMôOFôTHEôINITIATIVEô WASôTOôPRESSUREôTHEôGOVERNMENTôTOôRECEIVEô-34ôLEADERSôANDô



0240_057_self_org.indd 74-75

25/09/06 17:40:34

#OUNTER STRIKEô3ELF ORGANISE $ESCRIPTION 4HEô#OUNTER STRIKEôPROJECTôISôANôARCHIVEôOFôkLMSôTHATôDOCUMENTôORôkCTIONALISEôSELF OR GANISEDôCOMMUNITIES ôALONGôWITHôAôFREE ôPUBLICôPRESENTATIONôOFôTHEôONLINEôMULTIPLAYERô VIDEOGAMEô#OUNTER STRIKE 4EXT 4HEôGAMEô#OUNTER STRIKEôBEGANôLIFEôASôAôMODôFORôTHEôCOMMERCIALôRELEASEô(ALF ,IFEô CREATEDôBYôANôINFORMALôGROUPôOFôHACKERSôANDôGAMERSôFORôTHEIRôOWNôENTERTAINMENTôANDô INITIALLYôDISTRIBUTEDôFORôFREEô#OUNTER STRIKEôISôANôONLINE ôMULTIPLAYER ôTEAMôGAMEômôINô ITSôCOMMERCIALLYôRELEASEDôFORM ôONEôOFôTHEôMOSTôPOPULAR ôWITHôUPôTOô ôGAMESô TAKINGôPLACEôATôANYôONEôTIMEô ôTHATôYOUôCANTôPLAYôALONEô0LAYERSôFORMôNEWôTEAMSôFROMô GAMEôTOôGAME ôOFTENôPLAYINGôALONGSIDEôCOMPLETEôSTRANGERSôTHATôTHEYôWILLôNEVERôMEET ô BUTôWITHôWHOMôTHEYôMUSTôCOOPERATEôIFôTHEYôAREôTOôSUCCEEDô#OUNTER STRIKEôALSOôPLAYSô OUT ôINôLIMITEDôFORM ôAôSCENARIOôWITHôAôCERTAINôCONTEMPORARYôRESONANCE ôAôCONlICTô BETWEENô@TERRORISTSôANDô@COUNTER TERRORISTSô ô

4HEôkLMSôRANGEôFROMô%ISENSTEINSôCLASSICô@3TRIKE ôAôkCTIONALISEDôACCOUNTôOFôTHEô

FAILEDô"OLSHEVIKôREVOLUTIONôOFô ôTHROUGHôDOCUMENTARIESôSUCHôASô@#HRISTIANIA ôYOUô HAVEôMYôHEART ôTHATôPRESENTSôTHEôHIPPY ANARCHISTôENCLAVEôOFô#HRISTIANIAôINô#OPEN HAGENôASôAôFUNCTIONING ôALTERNATIVEôSOCIALôMODEL ôANDô@4HEô#OCONUTô2EVOLUTIONôTHATô DOCUMENTSôANôUPRISINGôONôTHEô0ACIkCôISLANDôOFô"OUGAINVILLE ôAôREBELLIONôATôAôMINEô OWNEDôBYô2IOô4INTOô:INCôTHATôTURNEDôINTOôANôARMEDôSTRUGGLEôBETWEENôTHEôNEWLYôFORMEDô "OUGAINVILLEô2EVOLUTIONARYô!RMY ôANDôTHEôSTATEôFORCESôOFô0APUAô.EWô'UINEAô4HEô kLMSôPRESENTôAôRANGEôOFôSCENARIOS ôFROMôTHEôOPTIMISTICôTOôTHEôDISASTROUS ôTHATôSHOWô SELF ORGANISATIONôASôSIMPLYôAôMETHODô ôAôNECESSARYôRESPONSE ôAôCALCULATEDôSTRATEGYô ORôTHEôACCIDENTALôOUTCOMEôOFôAôSITUATION 3OURCEô 7ILLô"RADLEY &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWSUPERlEXNETTEXTARTICLESCOUNTERSTRIKESHTML 4HEôPROJECTôWASôPRESENTEDôATôTHEôFOLLOWINGôVENUES môô 3UPERlEXôTOOLSôôCOUNTER STRIKE ô2OOSEUMôMALM¢ ô3WEDEN ô môô #OUNTER STRIKEô3ELF ORGANISE ô-USEUMôOFô#ONTEMPORARYô!RTô+IASMA ô(ELSINKI ô &INLAND ô môô 3OCIALôPUDDING ô2IRKRITô4IRVANIJAôô3UPERlEX ô'&:+ ô,EIPZIG ô'ERMANY ô môô !RCADIA ô'OVETTô ô"REWSTERô!RTô'ALLERY ô.EWô:EALAND ô

0240_057_self_org.indd 76-77

%XAMPLESôôYôô LRKQBO PQOFHB ñ0BIC LOD>KFPB

25/09/06 17:40:35

4HEô$IGGERS $ESCRIPTION 2ADICALôGUERILLAôSTREETôTHEATERôGROUPôWHOôREALIZEDôTHEIRôVISIONôOFôAô&REEôCOMMUNITYô INôSIXTIESô3ANô&RANCISCO 4EXT 4HEô0OST #OMPETITIVE ô#OMPARATIVEô'AMEôOFôAô&REEô#ITYômô/URôSTATEôOFôAWARENESSô DEMANDSôTHATôWEôUPLIFTôOURôEFFORTSôFROMôCOMPETITIVEôGAMEôPLAYINGôINôTHEôUNDERGROUNDô TOôTHEôCOMPARATIVEôROLESôOFôFREEôFAMILIESôINôFREEôCITIES ô

7EôMUSTôPOOLôOURôRESOURCESôANDôINTERACTôOURôENERGIESôTOôPROVIDEôTHEôFREEDOMôFORô

OURôINDIVIDUALôACTIVITIES ô

)NôEACHôCITYôOFôTHEôWORLDôTHEREôISôAôLOOSEôCOMPETITIVEôUNDERGROUNDôCOMPOSEDô

OFôGROUPSôWHOSEôAIMSôOVERLAP ôCONlICT ôANDôGENERALLYôENERVATEôTHEôDESIREDôGOALôOFô AUTONOMYô"YôNOWôWEôALLôHAVEôGUNS ôKNOWôHOWôTOôUSEôTHEM ôKNOWôOURôENEMY ôANDô AREôREADYôTOôDEFENDô7EôKNOWôTHATôWEôAINTôGONNAôTAKEôNOôMOREôSHITô3OôITSôABOUTô TIMEôWEôCARRIEDôOURSELVESôAôLITTLEôHEAVIERôANDôGOTôDOWNôTOôTHEôBUSINESSôOFôCREATINGô FREEôCITIESôWITHINôTHEôURBANôENVIRONMENTSôOFôTHEôWESTERNôWORLD ô

&REEô#ITIESôAREôCOMPOSEDôOFô&REEô&AMILIESôEG ôINô3ANô&RANCISCOô$IGGERS ô"LACKô

0ANTHERS ô0ROVOS ô-ISSIONô2EBELSôANDôVARIOUSôREVOLUTIONISTôGANGSôANDôCOMMUNES ô WHOôESTABLISHôANDôMAINTAINôSERVICESôTHATôPROVIDEôAôBASEôOFôFREEDOMôFORôAUTONOMOUSô GROUPSôTOôCARRYôOUTôTHEIRôPROGRAMSôWITHOUTôHAVINGôTOôHASSLEôFORôFOOD ôPRINTINGôFACILI TIES ôTRANSPORTATION ôMECHANICS ôMONEY ôHOUSING ôWORKINGôSPACE ôCLOTHES ôMA ôCHINERY ô TRUCKS ôETC ô

!TôTHISôPOINTôINôOURôREVOLUTIONôITôISôDEMANDEDôTHATôTHEôFAMILIES ôCOMMUNES ôBLACKô

ORGANIZATIONSôANDôGANGSôOFôEVERYôCITYôINô!MERICAôCOORDINATEôANDôDEVELOPô&REEô#ITIESô WHEREôEVERYTHINGôTHATôISôNECESSARYôCANôBEôOBTAINEDôFORôFREEôBYôTHOSEôINVOLVEDôINôTHEô VARIOUSôACTIVITIESôOFôTHEôINDIVIDUALôCLANSô%VERYôBROTHERôANDôSISTERôSHOULDôHAVEôWHATô THEYôNEEDôTOôDOôWHATEVERôNEEDSôTOôBEôDONEô &REEô#ITYômô!NôOUTLINEôAôBEGINNINGô%ACHôSERVICEôSHOULDôBEôPERFORMEDôBYôAôTIGHTô GANGôOFôBROTHERSôANDôSISTERSôWHOSEôCOMMITMENTôSHOULDôENABLEôTHEMôTOôHANDLEôANô OVERLOADôOFôWORKôWITHôABILITYôANDôENTHUSIASMô@4RIPSTERSôSOONôGETôBORED ôHOPEFULLYô BEFOREôTHEYôCAUSEôANôECONOMICôSTRAIN ô

&REEô#ITYô3WITCHBOARD)NFORMATIONô#ENTERôSHOULDôCOORDINATEôALLôSERVICES ôACTIVITIES ô

ANDôAIDôANDôDIRECTôASSISTANCEôWHEREôITôISôMOSTôNEEDEDô!LSOôPROVIDEôAôREFERENCEôPOINTô FORôLEGALôAID ôHOUSING ôMACHINERY ôETCôACTôASôAôMAILINGôADDRESSôFORôDISLOCATEDôGROUPSô ORôINDIVIDUALSôANDôGUIDEôRANDOMôENERGIESôWHEREôTHEYôAREôMOSTôNEEDEDô4HEôWORKô LOADôUSUALLYôPREVENTSôORôSHOULDôPREVENTôTHEôHANDLINGôOFôMESSAGESôFROMôPARENTSôTOô THEIRôRUNAWAYôCHILDRENôTHATôSHOULDôBEôLEFTôUPôTOôTHEôCHURCHESôOFôTHEôCOMMUNITY &REEô&OODô3TORAGEôANDô$ISTRIBUTIONô#ENTERômô3HOULDôHITôEVERYôAVAILABLEôSOURCEôOFô FREEôFOODPRODUCEôMARKETS ôFARMERSôMARKETS ôMEAT PACKINGôPLANTS ôFARMS ôDAIRIES ô

0240_057_self_org.indd 78-79

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ!FDDBOP

25/09/06 17:40:36

SHEEPôANDôCATTLEôRANCHES ôAGRICULTURALôCOLLEGES ôANDôGIANTôINSTITUTIONSôFORôTHEôUNEATENô

&REEô#ITYô3TORESôANDô7ORKSHOPSômô.OTHINGôINôTHESEôSTORESôSHOULDôBEôTHROWAWAYô

VATSôOFôFOOD ANDôkLLôUPôTHEIRôTRUCKSôWITHôTHEôSURPLUSôBYôBEGGING ôBORROWING ôSTEALING ô

ITEMSôSPACEôSHOULDôBEôAVAILABLEôFORôCHICKSôTOôSEWôDRESSES ôMAKEôPANTSôTOôORDER ô

FORMINGôLIAISONSôANDôCOMMUNICATIONSôWITHôDELIVERYôDRIVERSôFORôTHEôLEFTOVERSôFROMôTHEIRô

RECUTôGARMENTSôTOôkT ôETCô4HEôMANAGEMENTôSHOULDôALLôBEôLIFE ACTORSôCAPABLEôOFôTURNINGô

ROUTESôôôôBESTôMETHODôISôTOôWORKôINôTWOôSHIFTSôMORNINGôGROUPôPICKSôUPôTHEôFOODSTUFFSô

BULLSHITTERSôINTOôMUDô)MPORTANTôTHATôTHESEôPLACESôAREôkRSTôCLASSôENVIRONMENTSôWITHô

ANDôTHEôAFTERNOONôSHIFTôDELIVERSôITôTOôTHEôLISTôOFô&REEô&AMILIESôANDôTHEôPOORôPEOPLESôOFô

NOôTRACEôOFôSALVATIONôARMYSTôVINNIEôDEôPAULôCHARITYôROTô%VERYTHINGôGROOVYô%VERYTHINGô

THEôGHETTOSô%VERYDAYô(ARDôWORK

WITHôSTYLEôMUSTôBEôkRSTôCLASSô)TSôALLôFREEôBECAUSEôITSôYOURSô

ô

4HISôGANGôSHOULDôHELPôPEOPLEôPOOLôTHEIRôWELFAREôFOODôSTAMPSôANDôGETôTHEIRôOLDô

LADIESôORôAôGROUPôTOôOPENôAôFREEôRESTAURANTôFORôPEOPLEôONôTHEôMOVEôANDôTHOSEôWHOôLIVEô

&REEô-EDICALô4HINGômô3HOULDôBEôESTABLISHEDôINôALLôPOVERTYôAREASôANDôRUNôBYôPRIVATEô

ONôTHEôSTREETSô'IANTôSCORESôSHOULDôBEôSTOREDôINôAôGARAGE TYPEôWAREHOUSEôEQUIPPEDô

PHYSICIANSôANDôFREEôFROMôANYôBUREAUCRATICôSUPPORTô4HEô&REEô#ITYô"ANKôSHOULDôTRYôTOô

WITHôFREEZERSôANDôITSôWHEREABOUTSôKNOWNôONLYôTOôTHEô&REEô&OODô'ANGô4HISôGROUPô

COVERôTHEôEXPENSES ôANDôPHARMACEUTICALôHOUSESôSHOULDôBEôHITôFORôMEDICALôSUPPLIES ô

SHOULDôALSOôSETôUPôANDôPROVIDEôHELPôFORôCANNING ôPRESERVING ôBREADôBAKING ôANDôFEASTSô

ETCô)MPORTANTôTHATôTHEôDOCTORSôAREôBROTHERSôANDôDOôNOTôASKôTOôBEôSALARIEDôORôAREôNOTô

ANDôANYTHINGôANDôEVERYTHINGôELSEôTHATôHASôTOôDOôWITHôFOOD

OUTôTOôMAKEôCAREERSôFORôTHEMSELVESôWITNESSô$Rô$AVIDô3MITHôOFôTHEô(IPPIEô&REEô#LINICô INô3ANô&RANCISCOôWHOôISôFARôFROMôAôBROTHERôVERYôFAR

&REEô#ITYô'ARAGEôANDô-ECHANICSômô4OôREPAIRôANDôMAINTAINôALLôVEHICLESôUSEDôINôTHEô VARIOUSôSERVICESô4HEôRESPONSIBILITYôFORôTHEôNECESSARYôTOOLSôANDôPARTSôNEEDEDôINôTHEIRô

&REEô#ITYô(OSPITALômô3HOULDôBEôAôHOUSEôCONVERTEDôINTOôBEDôSPACEôANDôPREFERABLYôWITHô

WORKôISôENTIRELYôTHEIRSôANDôUSUALLYôAVAILABLEôBYôMAINTAININGôFRIENDLYôRELATIONSôWITHô

AôGARDENôANDôUSEDôFORôCONVALESCENCEôANDôPEOPLEôWHOSEôMINDSôHAVEôBEENôBLOWNôORô

JUNKYARDS ôGIANTôAUTOMOTIVEôSCHOOLS ôANDôGENERALLYôSCROUNGINGôAROUNDôTHOSEôAREASô

WHOôHAVEôJUSTôBEENôRELEASEDôFROMôAôSTATEôINSTITUTIONôANDôWHOôNEEDôTHEôCOMFORTôANDô

WHEREôAUTOôEQUIPMENTôISôEASILYôOBTAINEDô4HEôGARAGEôSHOULDôBEôLARGEôENOUGHôANDô

SOLACEôOFôTHEIRôPEOPLEôRATHERôTHANôTHEôCOLDôALIENATEDôWALLSôOFôANôURBANôINSTITUTION

FREEôOFôTRIPSTERSôWHOôONLYôCREATEôMOREôWORKôFORôTHEôEARNESTôMECHANICS &REEô#ITYô%NVIRONMENTALôANDô$ESIGNô'ANGômô'ANGSôOFôARTISTSôFROMôUNIVERSITIESôANDôARTô &REEô#ITYô"ANKôANDô4REASURYômô4HISôGROUPôSHOULDôBEôRESPONSIBLEôFORôRAISINGôMONEY ô

INSTITUTESôSHOULDôBEôTURNEDôONôANDôHELPEDôINôATTACKINGôTHEôDANKôSQUALORôOFôTHEôSLUMSô

MAKINGôFREEôMONEY ôPAYINGôRENTS ôFORôGASOLINE ôANDôANYôOTHERôNECESSARYôEXPENSESôOFô

ANDôMOSTôOFôTHEô&REEô#ITYô&AMILYôDWELLINGSôPAINTôLANDSCAPESôONôTHEôSIDESôOFôTENE

THEô&REEô#ITYô&AMILIESô4HEYôSHOULDôALSOôORGANIZEôANDôCREATEôSMALLôRACKETSôCOOKIEô

MENTSôkBERGLASSôSTAIRWELLSôMAKEôCRAZYô4IGHTôGROUPSôOFôGOODôPAINTERS ôSCULPTORS ô

SALES ôETC ôFORôTHEôPOORôKIDSôOFôTHEôGHETTOESôANDôAIDôINôTHEôREPAIRôANDôMAINTENANCEô

DESIGNERSôWHOôCOMFORTABLYôCONSTRUCTôENVIRONMENTSôFORôTHEôCOMMUNITYô-ATERIALSôANDô

OFôTHEôMACHINERYôREQUIREDôINôTHEôPERFORMANCEôOFôTHEôVARIOUSôSERVICES

EQUIPMENTôCANôBEôHUSTLEDôFROMôUNIVERSITYôPROJECTSôANDôMANUFACTURERS ôETC

&REEô#ITYô,EGALô!SSISTANCEômô(IGH STYLE ôHARD NOSED ôTOP CLASSôLAWYERSôWHOôAREôWILLINGô

&REEô#ITYô3CHOOLSômô3CHOOLSôDESIGNEDôANDôRUNôBYôDIFFERENTôGROUPSôACCORDINGôTOôTHEô

TOôDEFENDôTHEôRIGHTSôOFôTHEô&REEô#ITYôANDôITSôSERVICESôNOôHONKY ôLIBERAL ôBLEEDING

CONSCIOUSNESSôOFôTHEIRô&REEô&AMILIESôEG ô"LACKô-ANSô&REEô3CHOOL ô!NARCHISTSô

HEART ôGUILT RIDDENôADVOCATESôOFôJUSTICE ôBUTôkRST CLASSôCASE WINNERSôTURNôONôTHEôBESTô

#REATIVEô!RTSô3CHOOL ôETC ô4HEôSCHOOLSôSHOULDôUTILIZEôTHEôSPACEôLIBERATEDôFORôTHEMô

LAWYERSôWHOôCANôSETôUPôAIRTIGHTôRECEIVERSHIPôFORôFREEôMONEYôANDôPROPERTY ôANDôBEATô

BYôTHEô&REEô#ITYô3PACEô'ANG

DOWNôTHEôPOLICEôHARASSMENTôANDôBRUTALITYôOFôYOURôAREAS &REEô#ITYô.EWSôANDô#OMMUNICATIONô#OMPANYômô0ROVIDERSôOFôAôDAILYôNEWSPAPER ô &REEô#ITYô(OUSINGôANDô7ORKô3PACEômô2ENTôORôWORKôDEALSôWITHôTHEôURBANôGOVTôTOôTAKEô

MONTHLYôMAGAZINE ôFREEô'ESTETNERôANDôPRINTINGôOFôNOTICESôFORôOTHERôGROUPSôANDôANYô

OVERôSPACESôTHATôHAVEôBEENôABANDONEDôFORôUSEôASôCARPENTRYôSHOPS ôGARAGES ôTHEATERS ô

SPECIALôBULLETINSôANDôPROPAGANDAôFORôTHEôVARIOUSôFAMILIESôOFôTHEô&REEô#ITYô4HEôMA

ETC ôRENTôWHOLEôHOUSES ôBUTôDONTôLETôTHEMôTURNôINTOôCRASHôPADSô3ETôUPôHOTELSôFORôNEWô

CHINERYôSHOULDôBEôKEPTôINôTOPôCONDITIONôANDôSUPPLIEDôBYôANYôOFôTHEôVARIOUSôSERVICESô

ARRIVALSôORôTRANSIENTSôBYôWORKINGôOUTôDEALSôWITHôSMALLôHOTELôOWNERSôFORôFREEôROOMSôINô

0APERôCANôBEôSCAVENGEDôATôLARGEôMILLSôANDôCUTôDOWNôTOôPROPERôWORKINGôSIZE

EXCHANGEôFORôLIGHTôHOUSEWORK ôPORTERôDUTIES ôETCô"IGôWAREHOUSESôCANôBEôWORKEDôONô BYôENVIRONMENTALôARTISTSôANDôTURNEDôINTOôGIANTôFREEôDANCE kESTA FEASTôPALACES

&REEô#ITYô%VENTSô&ESTIVALô0LANNINGô#OMMITTEESômô5SUALLYôINVOLVESôSEVERALô&AMILIESô

ô

!ôSTRONGôTRIOôOFôSERIOUSôBUSINESS ORIENTEDôCATSôSHOULDôDEVELOPôTHISôLIBERATIONô

INTERACTINGôTOôSPONSORôTOURSôFORôTHEôKIDSôô"ALLS ô(APPENINGS ô4HEATRE ô$ANCE ôANDô

OFôSPACEôWITHINôTHEôCITIESôANDôBEôABLEôTOôWORKôWITHôTHEôLAWYERSôTOôMAKEôDEALSôANDô

SPONTANEOUSôEXPERIMENTSôINôJOYôô0ARKô%VENTSôUSUALLYôAREôBESTôSETôUPôBYôHIRINGô

OUTMANEUVERôURBANôBUEAUCRACIESôANDôSLUMôLANDLORDSôONEôOFôTHEôMAINôTARGETSôFORô

Aô FOOTôlATBEDôTRUCKôFORôTHEôROCKôBANDôTOôUSEôASôAôSTAGEôANDôTOôTRANSPORTôTHEIRô

SPACEôAREôTHEôCHURCHESôWHIOôAREôTHEôHOLDERSôOFôMOSTôREALôESTATEôANDôTHEYôSHOULDôBEô

EQUIPMENTôPEOPLEôSHOULDôBEôADVISEDôBYôLEAlETSôTOôBRINGôFOODôTOôEXCHANGEôWITHôTHEIRô

APPROACHEDôWITHôAôNO BULLSHITôHARDôLINE

NEIGHBORSôBANNERS ôPROPS ôBALLOONS ôKITESôETC ôSHOULDôBEôHANDLEDôBYôAôCOMMITTEEôô


0240_057_self_org.indd 80-81


25/09/06 17:40:37

ANôELECTRICIANôSHOULDôBEôAROUNDôTOôRUNôTHEôGENERATORôANDôMAKEôSUREôTHATôTHEô0!ôSYS TEMSôWORKôHARDôWORKôMADEôEASYôBYôGIVINGôRESPONSIBLEôPEOPLEôTHEôTOUGHôJOBS #OOPERATIVEô&ARMSôANDô#AMPSITESômô4HEôFARMSôSHOULDôBEôRUNôBYôEXPERIENCEDôHANDSô ANDôTHEô&REEô,ANDôSET ôTLEDôONôBYôCOTTAGEôINDUSTRIALôPEOPLEôWHOôWILLôSENDôTHEIRôWARESô INTOôTHEô&REEô#ITYô4HEôFARMSôMUSTôPRODUCEôVITALôFOODôFORôTHEôFAMILIESôSOMEôFREEô LANDôTHATôISôNOôGOODôFORôFARMINGôSHOULDôBEôUSEDôASôCAMPSITESôANDORôCABINôAREASôFORô CITIZENSôWHOôAREôINôNEEDôOFôCOUNTRYôLEISURE ôASôWELLôASôKIDSôWHOôCOULDôUSEôAôSUMMERô INôTHEôWOODS 3CAVENGERô#ORPSôANDô4RANSPORTô'ANGômô)SôRESPONSIBLEôFORôGARBAGEôCOLLECTIONôANDôTHEô PICKINGôUPôANDôDELIVERYôOFôITEMSôTOôTHEôVARIOUSôSERVICES ôASôWELLôASôLIBERATINGôANYTHINGô THEYôTHINKôUSEFULôFORôONEôPROJECTôORôANOTHERô4HEYôAREôTOôBEôRESPONSIBLEôFORôTHEôTRUCKô lEETôANDôESPECIALLYôAWAREôOFôTHEôECONOMICôSTRAINôIFôTRUCKSôAREôMISUSEDôBYôTRIPSTERS &REEô#ITYô4INKERSôANDô'UNSMITHS ô%TCômô7ILLôREPAIRôANDôKEEPôTHINGSôGOINGôINôTHEô HOUSESôEXPERIENCEDôREPAIRMENôOFôALLôSORTS ôELECTRICIANS ôANDôCARPENTERSô4HEYôSHOULDô MAINTAINôAôWAREHOUSEôORôWORKINGôSPACEôFORôTHEIRôOUTkT &REEô#ITYô2ADIO ô46ôANDô#OMPUTERô3TATIONSômô$EMANDô&REEôTIMEôONôRADIOôANDô46ôSTA TIONSôDEMANDôAô&REEô#ITYôFREQUENCYôTOôSETôUPôYOURôOWNôSTATIONSôRENTôCOMPUTERSôTOô CALLôTHEôPUNCHESôFORôTHEôREVOLUTIONôORôUSEôTHEMôINôANYôCONSTRUCTIVEôWAYôPOSSIBLE 3OURCEô 4HEô$IGGERô0APERS ô3ANô&RANCISCOô &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWDIGGERSORG


0240_057_self_org.indd 82-83

TOôREOPENôTALKSôTHATôHADôBEENôINTERRUPTEDôAFTERôTHEô%LDORADOô DOSô#ARAJ¶SôMASSACREô4HEôRESULTôWASôAôRESOUNDINGôSUCCESSô ONôTHEIRôARRIVALôINô"RAS«LIA ôREPRESENTATIVESôOFôTHEôDEMONSTRATORSô WEREôRECEIVEDôBYôTHEô0RESIDENTôOFôTHEô2EPUBLICôANDôALSOôMETô THEô0RESIDENTSôOFôTHEô.ATIONALô#ONGRESSôANDôOFôTHEô3UPREMEô #OURTôOFô*USTICEôTHATôIS ôALLôTHEôMOSTôIMPORTANTôAUTHORITIESôOFô THEô%XECUTIVE ô,EGISLATIVEôANDô*UDICIALôBRANCHESô 4HEô-34ôHASôBEENôSUCCESSFULôSOôFARôINôGAININGôPUBLICôSYM PATHYôTHANKSôTOôTHEôSTRICTôORGANISATIONôANDôGOODôDISCIPLINEôOFô ITSôDEMONSTRATIONSô4HEôMAJORITYôOFôTHEô"RAZILIANôPOPULATIONô LIVES ôINôFACT ôINôURBANôAREASô ôAGAINSTôONLYôABOUTôô INôRURALôLOCALITIESô(ENCE ôTHEôSTRUGGLEôFORôAGRARIANôREFORMôHASô TOôBEôFOUGHTôANDôWONôINôTHEôCITIES ôCLOSEôTOôTHEôMAJORITYôOFô PUBLICôOPINIONô4HISôEXPLAINSôWHYôTHEô-OVEMENTôATTACHESôSOô MUCHôIMPORTANCEôTOôLAUNCHINGôDEMONSTRATIONSôANDôMEETINGSô SIMULTANEOUSLYôINôASôMANYôSTATEôCAPITALSôASôPOSSIBLEô!LLôTHEô -34SôINITIATIVESômôMARCHES ôLANDôOCCUPATIONS ôENCAMPMENTSô môALWAYSôHAVEôTHEôNATUREôOFôMASSôDEMONSTRATIONSôBECAUSEôTHEô -OVEMENTSôLEADERSôKNOWôTHATôTHISôISôTHEôBESTôWAYôTOôPREVENTô THEIRôVIOLENTôREPRESSIONô ô )NôSPITEôOFôTHEôSYSTEMATICôNEGATIVEôPRESENTATIONôOFôTHEô-34ô BYôMOSTôOFôTHEôMEDIA ôITôGENERALLYôMANAGESôTOôOBTAINôSIGNIk CANTôLEVELSôOFôREACTIONôTOôITSôSTATEMENTSôORôACTIONSôANDôTOôREACHô LARGEôSECTORSôOFôPUBLICôOPINIONô4HEô-OVEMENTSôLEADERSôHAVEô AôKEENôSENSEôOFôOPPORTUNITYôANDôKNOWôVERYôWELLôWHATôKINDôOFô ACTIVITIESôWILLôCATCHôTHEôMEDIASôATTENTIONô&ORôINSTANCE ôINôORDERô TOôENSUREôADEQUATEôVISIBILITYôINôTHEôMEDIA ôLANDôOCCUPATIONSô AREôPREFERENTIALLYôLOCATEDôNEARôROADSôANDôHIGHWAYSôFORôEASYô ACCESSô)NôTHEôSAMEôSPIRIT ôTHEôCHOICEôOFôGOVERNMENTôSEATS ôBU REAUSôOFôOFkCIALôAGENCIESôORôBANKôOFkCESôFORôTHEôORGANISATIONô OFôTEMPORARYôENCAMPMENTSôGUARANTEESôTHATôSUCHôPROTESTôACTSôô


25/09/06 17:40:38

WILLôCERTAINLYôAPPEARôPROMINENTLYôINôTELEVISIONôNEWSôANDôINôTHEôô NEWSPAPERSô/CCUPATIONSôOFôGOVERNMENTôBUILDINGSôORôDEM ONSTRATIONSôINôFRONTôOFôTHEôRURALôPROPERTYôOFôFORMERô0RESIDENTô ô#ARDOSOSôFAMILYôWEREôSUCCESSFULôEXAMPLESôOFôTHEô-34SôWELL KNOWNôTALENTôFORôEXPLOITINGôTHEôMEDIASôHUNGERôFORôSPECTACULARô NEWS $EMONSTRATIONSôANDôURBANôOCCUPATIONSôAREôREALISEDôINôSTRATEGI CALLYôCHOSENôPLACESôSOôASôTOôGAINôTHEôHIGHESTôPOSSIBLEôVISIBILITYô WITHOUTôDISTURBINGôTHEôDAILYôROUTINEôOFôTHEôCITYôORôITSôINHABITANTSô &ROMôTHEôPOINTôOFôVIEWôOFôTHEô-OVEMENTSôLEADERS ôTHEôGOALôISô TOôMAKEôTHEôPOPULATIONôAWAREôOFôTHEôKEYôQUESTIONSôRELATEDôTOô AGRARIANôREFORM ôRATHERôTHANôTOôCAUSEôANNOYANCEôANDôTROUBLEô)Nô EFFECT ôMILITANTSôONLYôRARELYôBLOCKôANôAVENUEôORôPREVENTôGOVERN MENTôEMPLOYEESôFROMôENTERINGôTHEIRôWORKPLACESô !SôAôSTRATEGYôTOôWINôTHEôSYMPATHYôOFôTHEôURBANôPOPULATIONôANDô TOôSHOWôSOLIDARITYôAMONGôWORKERS ôTHEô-34ôALSOôSUPPORTSô TYPICALôURBANôSTRUGGLESôSUCHôASôDEMONSTRATIONSôFORôINCREASINGô MINIMUMôWAGES ôDEMONSTRATIONSôBYôTEACHERSôORôPUBLICôHEALTHô EMPLOYEESôFORôBETTERôWORKINGôCONDITIONS ôUNIONôSTRIKESôANDô EVENôPOLICEôOFkCERSôPROTESTSôFORôBETTERôSALARIESô-34ôLEAD ERSôPUBLICôSTATEMENTSôINôSUPPORTôOFôURBANôPOPULARôMOVEMENTSô AREôSOMETIMESôINTERPRETEDôBYôTHEôPRESSôASôEVIDENCEôTHATôTHEô -OVEMENTôISôNOTôSINCERELYôINTERESTEDôINôAGRARIANôREFORM ôBUTô ACTSôMAINLYôINôAôREVOLUTIONARYôSENSEô

ôMARCHôTOô"RAS«LIAôTHEôMOVEMENTSôPOPULARITYôREACHEDôITSô PEAK ôWITHôPUBLICôSUPPORTôREACHINGôô 7HATôPARTICULARLYôWORRIESôTHEô"RAZILIANôGOVERNMENTôISôTHEôDIF kCULTYôOFôNEUTRALISINGôTHEôABILITYôOFôTHEô-34ôTOôREMAINôVISIBLEôINô THEôMEDIAô)NôEFFECT ôTHEô-OVEMENTôWOULDôHAVEôNEVERôBECOMEô SUCHôAôFORMIDABLEôOPPONENTôIFôITôHADôADOPTEDôTHEôINSTITUTION ALISEDôFORMôOFôPOLITICALôOPPOSITIONôFAVOUREDôBYôTHEôESTABLISHEDô UNIONSô4HEôUNIONôORGANISATIONôISôNOTôANôATTRACTIVEôALTERNATIVEô TOôTHEô-OVEMENTô&ARôFROMôTHEô-34ôIMITATINGôTHEôUNIONS ôITôISô THEôLATTERôTHATôHAVEôBEGUNôTOôREPLICATEôTHEôSTRATEGIESôADOPTEDô BYôTHEô-34ô!NOTHERôALTERNATIVEôWOULDôBEôTHEôPARLIAMENTARYô PATH ôCONVERTINGôTHEôORGANISATIONôINTOôAôPOLITICALôPARTYô3OMEô ANALYSTSôINDEEDôARGUEôTHATôTHISôISôTHEôLIKELYôFUTUREôDEVELOPMENTô OFôTHEô-OVEMENTô ô !SôNOTEDôABOVE ôANôINCONTROVERTIBLEôPROOFôOFôTHEôPOLITICALô FORCEôOFôTHEôLANDLESSôWORKERSôMOVEMENTôISôTHATôITôDOESôNOTô NEED ôORôDOESôNOTôWANT ôTOôRESORTôTOôTHEôMEDIATIONôOFô#ONGRESSô TOôPRESENTôITSôCLAIMSôTOôTHEô%XECUTIVEôBRANCHô

0UBLICôOPINIONôPOLLSôTAKENôOVERôRECENTôYEARSôSHOWôTHATôTHEô MAJORITYôOFôTHEô"RAZILIANôPOPULATIONôSUPPORTSôTHEô-34ôANDôITSô GOALSô4HEôSUPPORTôFORôAGRARIANôREFORMôVARIESôBETWEENôôANDô ôWHILEôAPPROXIMATELYôTWO THIRDSôOFôTHEôPOPULATIONôCONSID ERSôTHEô-34ôAôLEGITIMATEôMOVEMENTô/VERôTHEôPERIODôOFôTHEô

!MONGôTHEôôMEMBERSôOFôTHEô"RAZILIANô(OUSEôOFô2EPRESENT ATIVES ôNOôMOREôTHANôTENôOPENLYôDEFENDôTHEô-34SôINTERESTSô)Nô CONTRAST ôNEARLYôONE THIRDôOFô2EPRESENTATIVESôAREôCOMMITTEDôTOô THEôDEFENCEôOFôLANDOWNERSôINTERESTS ôOFTENôBEINGôBIGôLANDOWN ERSôTHEMSELVESô/NôAôRECENTôOCCASION ôLANDOWNERSôGAVEôANô ADDITIONALôPROOFôOFôTHEIRôOVERWHELMINGôINlUENCEôINô#ONGRESSô BYôAPPROVINGôANôEXTREMELYôBIASEDôREPORTôOFôTHEô#ONGRESSIONALô )NQUIRYô#OMMITTEEôONô,ANDô)SSUESô#0-) ô4HISôCOMMITTEEôHADô BEENôCREATEDôINôôWITHôTHEôAIMôOFôCARRYINGôOUTôAôBROADô EVALUATIONôANDôANôIMPARTIALôDIAGNOSISôOFôTHEô"RAZILIANôAGRARIANô STRUCTUREôANDôREFORMôPROCESS ôASôWELLôASôOFôTHEôCAMPAIGNSôCON DUCTEDôBOTHôBYôTHEôWORKERSôANDôTHEôLANDOWNERSôMOVEMENTSô



0240_057_self_org.indd 84-85

25/09/06 17:40:38

!LTHOUGHôITSôMANDATEôWASôTOôIDENTIFYôTHEôPATHôTOôAôREASONABLEô SOLUTIONôTOôLANDôPROBLEMS ôTHEôMAJORITYôOFô#OMMITTEEôMEMBERSô PREFERREDôTOôCOMEôDOWNôSQUARELYôONôTHEôSIDEôOFôCRIMINALISINGô LANDLESSôWORKERSôMOVEMENTS ôPARTICULARLYôTHEô-34 ôINSTEADôOFô PROPOSINGôEFFECTIVEôSOLUTIONSôTOôTHISôLONG LASTINGôSTALEMATEô !FTERôTWOôYEARSôOFôRESEARCH ôFACT kNDINGôVISITSôTOôNINEôDIFFER ENTôSTATES ôôINTERVIEWS ôTHEôINSPECTIONôOFô ôPAGESôOFô DOCUMENTS ôANDôTHEôANALYSISôOFôDOZENSôOFôAGREEMENTSôENTEREDô INTOôBYôTHEô&EDERALô'OVERNMENTôWITHôBOTHôWORKERSôANDôLAND OWNERSôBODIES ôTHEôREPORTôRELEASEDôINôôCONCLUDEDôWITHô THEôOVERLYôSIMPLISTICôANDôUNILATERALôINTERPRETATIONôTHATô"RAZILIANô AGRARIANôPROBLEMSôWEREôPRIMARILYôRELATEDôTOôTHEôWAYôFEDERALô RESOURCESôHADôBEENôDISTRIBUTEDôTOôENTITIESôCONNECTEDôWITHô LANDLESSôWORKERSô ô 4HEôAPPROVEDôREPORTôISôCOMPLETELYôSILENTôASôFARôASôVIOLENCEô INôRURALôAREASôISôCONCERNED ôANDôIGNORESôTHEôHIGHôNUMBERôOFô RURALôWORKERSôASSASSINATIONSôANDôTHEôILLEGALôAPPROPRIATIONôOFô PUBLICôLANDSôBYôGREEDYôLANDOWNERSô)TôMAKESôNOôMENTIONôWHAT SOEVERôOFôFORCEDôORôENSLAVEDôLABORôORôOFôTHEôARMEDôMILITIASô FORMEDôBYôSOMEôBIGôLANDOWNERSô4HEôTEXTôISôSOôBLATANTLYôRE ACTIONARYôASôTOôRECOMMENDôTHEôAPPROVALôOFôAôLAWôTHATôWOULDô BRANDôLANDôOCCUPATIONSôASôHEINOUSôCRIMESôANDôTHEôACTIONSôOFô THOSEôWHOôCARRYôOUTôOCCUPATIONSôASôTERRORISTôACTSô ô 1UESTIONEDôABOUTôTHEôUNBALANCEDôREPRESENTATIONôOFô AGRARIANôINTERESTSôINô#ONGRESS ôTHEô-34ôLEADER ô*OÓô0EDROô 3T¯DILE ôANSWEREDôTHATôTHEôLOCUSôOFôTHEôSTRUGGLEôFORôAGRARIANô REFORMôHADôMOVEDôFROMô#ONGRESSôTOôOTHERôSECTORSôOFôSO CIETYô#ONGRESSôWASôTHEôTHEATREôOFôTHEôMOVEMENTSôSTRUG GLEôDURINGôTHEôPERIODôWHENôTHEôNEWôCONSTITUTIONôWASôINôTHEô PROCESSôOFôBEINGôDISCUSSEDôANDôDRAFTED ôINôôANDôô 4HISôISôCERTAINLYôTRUE ôBUTôONEôCOULDôADDôTHAT ôAFTERôTHATôVERYô

ô ARTICULARôHISTORICôMOMENTôMARKEDôBYôDEMOCRATISATIONôAFTERô P ôUNINTERRUPTEDôYEARSôOFôMILITARYôRULE ôTHEôCONSERVATIVEôANDô FAR RIGHTôFORCESôWEREôBETTERôABLEôTOôRE GROUPôANDôRE ASSERTô THEIRôTRADITIONALôPOWERôINôALMOSTôALLôSECTORSôOFô"RAZILIANôSOCI ETYô3INCEôTHEN ôTHEREôHASôBEENôAôPERCEPTIBLEôREACTIONôAGAINSTô WHATôTHOSEôFORCESôPERCEIVEôASôTHEô@EXCESSESôOFôTHEôSO CALLEDô #ITIZENô#ONSTITUTION ôINôTERMSôNOTôONLYôOFôAGRARIANôREFORMôBUTô INôRELATIONôTOôSOCIALôRIGHTSôINôGENERALô!CCORDINGôTOô3T¯DILE ô 0ARLIAMENTôISôNOôMOREôTHANôTHEôMIRRORôOFôSOCIETYSôCURRENTô CORRELATIONôOFôFORCES ôWHICHôIMPLICITLYôADMITSôTHATôTHEôAGRARIANô REFORMôMOVEMENTSôHAVEôLOSTôPOWERôSINCEôTHEô#ONSTITUTIONô WASôDRAFTEDô4HISôCORRELATIONôWILLôONLYôCHANGEôIFôANDôWHENô PEOPLEôAREôABLEôTOôORGANISEôTHEMSELVESôINôORDERôTOôkGHTôFORô THEIRôRIGHTSô@0ARLIAMENTARYôWORKôISôNECESSARY ôHEôADDS ô@BUTô THEôFUNDAMENTALôASPECTôISôTHEôORGANISATIONôOFôTHEôMASSESô!LLô THEôPROFOUNDôCHANGESôINôMANKINDSôHISTORYôWEREôDUEôTOôMASSô MOBILISATIONôOFôORGANISEDôPEOPLEô ô !NôIMPORTANTôALLYôOFôTHEôLANDLESSôWORKERSôCAUSEôISôTHEô"RA ZILIANô#ATHOLICô#HURCH ôESPECIALLYôTHEô,ANDô0ASTORALô#OMMIS SIONô#04 ôWHOSEôHELPôHASôBEENôOFôGREATôUSEôBECAUSEôOFôITSô ALL PERVASIVEôPRESENCEôEVENôINôTHEôMOSTôREMOTEôPARTSôOFô"RAZIL ô NEARôTHEôFRONTIERôAREASôWHEREôTHEôMAJORITYôOFôLANDôCONlICTSôOC CURô)TôENJOYS ôTHUS ôAôGOODôPOSITIONôFROMôWHICHôTOôACCURATELYô RECORDôTHEôMURDERSôOFôRURALôWORKERSôANDôTOôDENOUNCEôTHEôMUR DERSôPUBLICLYô)TSôLOGISTICALôSUPPORTôHASôALSOôBEENôIMPORTANT ôASô DURINGôTHEôMARCHôTOô"RAS«LIA ôWHENôTHEô#ATHOLICô#HURCHôALLOWEDô MARCHERSôTOôSTAYôOVERNIGHTôINôCHURCHESôANDôPAROCHIALôHOUSESô ALLôALONGôTHEôROUTEôANDôHELPEDôTOôFEEDôANDôASSISTôTHEMô!NOTHERô SIGNIkCANTôTYPEôOFôMATERIALôSUPPORTôGIVENôBYôTHEô#HURCHôISôTHEô kNANCIALôAIDôOBTAINEDôTHANKSôTOôDONATIONSôFROMôINTERNATIONALô #HRISTIANôORGANIZATIONSôSUCHôASô-ISEREOR ô"ILANCE ô)CCO ô(EKSô ANDô#HRISTIANô!IDô!CCORDINGôTOôSOMEôESTIMATES ôAPPROXIMATELYô



0240_057_self_org.indd 86-87

25/09/06 17:40:38

&REE#ULTUREORG $ESCRIPTION !NôINTERNATIONALôSTUDENTôMOVEMENTôFORôFREEôCULTURE 4EXT &REEô#ULTUREô-ANIFESTO 4HEôMISSIONôOFôTHEô&REEô#ULTUREôMOVEMENTôISôTOôBUILDôAôBOTTOM UP ôPARTICIPATORYô STRUCTUREôTOôSOCIETYôANDôCULTURE ôRATHERôTHANôAôTOP DOWN ôCLOSED ôPROPRIETARYôSTRUC TUREô4HROUGHôTHEôDEMOCRATIZINGôPOWERôOFôDIGITALôTECHNOLOGYôANDôTHEô)NTERNET ôWEô CANôPLACEôTHEôTOOLSôOFôCREATIONôANDôDISTRIBUTION ôCOMMUNICATIONôANDôCOLLABORATION ô TEACHINGôANDôLEARNINGôINTOôTHEôHANDSôOFôTHEôCOMMONôPERSONômôANDôWITHôAôTRULYôACTIVE ô CONNECTED ôINFORMEDôCITIZENRY ôINJUSTICEôANDôOPPRESSIONôWILLôSLOWLYôBUTôSURELYôVANISHô FROMôTHEôEARTH ô 7EôBELIEVEôTHATôCULTUREôSHOULDôBEôAôTWO WAYôAFFAIR ôABOUTôPARTICIPATION ôNOTôMERELYô CONSUMPTIONô7EôWILLôNOTôBEôCONTENTôTOôSITôPASSIVELYôATôTHEôENDôOFôAôONE WAYôMEDIAô TUBEô7ITHôTHEô)NTERNETôANDôOTHERôADVANCES ôTHEôTECHNOLOGYôEXISTSôFORôAôNEWôPARADIGMô OFôCREATION ôONEôWHEREôANYONEôCANôBEôANôARTIST ôANDôANYONEôCANôSUCCEED ôBASEDôNOTô ONôTHEIRôINDUSTRYôCONNECTIONS ôBUTôONôTHEIRôMERIT 7EôREFUSEôTOôACCEPTôAôFUTUREôOFôDIGITALôFEUDALISMôWHEREôWEôDOôNOTôACTUALLYôOWNôTHEô PRODUCTSôWEôBUY ôBUTôWEôAREôMERELYôGRANTEDôLIMITEDôUSESôOFôTHEMôASôLONGôASôWEô PAYôTHEôRENTô7EôMUSTôHALTôANDôREVERSEôTHEôRECENTôRADICALôEXPANSIONôOFôINTELLECTUALô PROPERTYôRIGHTS ôWHICHôTHREATENôTOôREACHôTHEôPOINTôWHEREôTHEYôTRUMPôANYôANDôALLôOTHERô RIGHTSôOFôTHEôINDIVIDUALôANDôSOCIETY 4HEôFREEDOMôTOôBUILDôUPONôTHEôPASTôISôNECESSARYôFORôCREATIVITYôANDôINNOVATIONôTOôTHRIVEô 7EôWILLôUSEôANDôPROMOTEôOURôCULTURALôHERITAGEôINôTHEôPUBLICôDOMAINô7EôWILLôMAKE ô SHARE ôADAPT ôANDôPROMOTEôOPENôCONTENTô7EôWILLôLISTENôTOôFREEôMUSIC ôLOOKôATôFREEô ART ôWATCHôFREEôkLM ôANDôREADôFREEôBOOKSô!LLôTHEôWHILE ôWEôWILLôCONTRIBUTE ôDISCUSS ô ANNOTATE ôCRITIQUE ôIMPROVE ôIMPROVISE ôREMIX ôMUTATE ôANDôADDôYETôMOREôINGREDIENTSô INTOôTHEôFREEôCULTUREôSOUP 7EôWILLôHELPôEVERYONEôUNDERSTANDôTHEôVALUEôOFôOURôCULTURALôWEALTH ôPROMOTINGôFREEô SOFTWAREôANDôTHEôOPEN SOURCEôMODELô7EôWILLôRESISTôREPRESSIVEôLEGISLATIONôWHICHô THREATENSôOURôCIVILôLIBERTIESôANDôSTIlESôINNOVATIONô7EôWILLôOPPOSEôHARDWARE LEVELô MONITORINGôDEVICESôTHATôWILLôPREVENTôUSERSôFROMôHAVINGôCONTROLôOFôTHEIRôOWNôMACHINESô ANDôTHEIRôOWNôDATA 7EôWONTôALLOWôTHEôCONTENTôINDUSTRYôTOôCLINGôTOôOBSOLETEôMODESôOFôDISTRIBUTIONôTHROUGHô BADôLEGISLATIONô7EôWILLôBEôACTIVEôPARTICIPANTSôINôAôFREEôCULTUREôOFôCONNECTIVITYôANDô

0240_057_self_org.indd 88-89

%XAMPLESôôYôô#OBB RIQROBLOD

25/09/06 17:40:39

PRODUCTION ôMADEôPOSSIBLEôASôITôNEVERôWASôBEFOREôBYôTHEô)NTERNETôANDôDIGITALôTECH NOLOGY ôANDôWEôWILLôkGHTôTOôPREVENTôTHISôNEWôPOTENTIALôFROMôBEINGôLOCKEDôDOWNôBYô CORPORATEôANDôLEGISLATIVEôCONTROLô)FôWEôALLOWôTHEôBOTTOM UP ôPARTICIPATORYôSTRUCTUREô OFôTHEô)NTERNETôTOôBEôTWISTEDôINTOôAôGLORIkEDôCABLEô46ôSERVICEômôIFôWEôALLOWôTHEôES TABLISHEDôPARADIGMôOFôCREATIONôANDôDISTRIBUTIONôTOôREASSERTôITSELFômôTHENôTHEôWINDOWô OFôOPPORTUNITYôOPENEDôBYôTHEô)NTERNETôWILLôHAVEôBEENôCLOSED ôANDôWEôWILLôHAVEôLOSTô SOMETHINGôBEAUTIFUL ôREVOLUTIONARY ôANDôIRRETRIEVABLE 4HEôFUTUREôISôINôOURôHANDSôWEôMUSTôBUILDôAôTECHNOLOGICALôANDôCULTURALôMOVEMENTôTOô DEFENDôTHEôDIGITALôCOMMONS &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWFREECULTUREORGMANIFESTOPHP WWWFREECULTUREORG 4HEôMOVEMENTôISôINSPIREDôBYôTHEôBOOKô&REEô#ULTUREôBYô,AWRENCEô,ESSIG WWWFREE CULTURECC

ôOFôTHEô-34SôRESOURCESôCOMEôFROMôTHISôINTERNATIONALôSOLI DARITYôNETWORKô ô 4HEôPOLITICALôIMPORTANCEôOFôTHEô#HURCHSôSUPPORTôTOôTHEôLANDô REFORMôCAUSEôLEDôTHEô#ARDOSOôGOVERNMENTôTOôCONDUCTôAôSYS TEMATICôCAMPAIGNôINôTHEô6ATICANôTOôDEFENDôTHEôGOVERNMENTSô ACTIONSô4HEô,ANDô2EFORMô-INISTERôUNDERTOOKôkVEôVISITSôTOôTHEô 6ATICANôTOôTHATôENDô 4HEREôIS ôINôCONSERVATIVEôCIRCLES ôAôWIDESPREADôFEARôTHATôTHEô -34ôMAYôBECOMEôAôGRAVEôTHREATôTOô"RAZILIANôDEMOCRACYô4HOSEô WHOôAREôHOSTILEôTOôTHEôMOVEMENTôARGUEôTHATôTHEô-34SôASPIRA TIONSôANDôGOALSôMAYôBEôLEGITIMATE ôBUTôTHEôMETHODSôITôUSESôTOô ADVANCEôITSôCAUSEômôOCCUPATIONSôOFôLANDôORôPUBLICôBUILDINGSô môAREôQUESTIONABLEôBECAUSEôTHEYôCLEARLYôVIOLATEôTHEôLAWô )TôISôNECESSARYôTOôEXPLAINôHEREôTHEôCRUCIALôDIFFERENCEôBETWEENô THEôTERMSô@INVASIONôANDô@OCCUPATIONô4HEôTERMô@INVASIONôBE LONGSôTOôTHEôMILITARYôVOCABULARY ôANDôPRESUMESôANôINTENTION ô ONôTHEôINVADERSôPART ôTOôSETTLEôDOWNôONôTHEôLANDôANDôTOôRESISTô ANYôATTEMPTôBYôOWNERSôORôAUTHORITIESôTOôRETAKEôTHEôCONQUEREDô POSITIONô4HEôTERMô@OCCUPATIONôSUGGESTS ôINSTEAD ôAôTEMPORARYô ACTIONôTOôPREPAREôFORôANôEVENTUALôANDôDEkNITIVEôSETTLEMENTô)Tô ISôNOTôUNINTENTIONALLYôTHATôTHOSEôWHOôDISAPPROVEôOFôTHEô-34Sô ACTIONSôREFERôTOôTHEMôASô@INVASIONSôWHEREASôTHEô-OVEMENTSô MILITANTSôCONSIDERôTHEMôMERELYô@OCCUPATIONSô &ROMôTHEô-OVEMENTSôPOINTôOFôVIEW ôWHENôITôOCCUPIESôAôPUBLICô BUILDINGôORôSOMEôOTHERôSTRATEGICôPLACE ôITôDOESôSOôINôORDERôTOô DRAWôSOCIETYSôATTENTIONôTOôTHEôVIOLATIONôOFôAGREEMENTSôENTEREDô INTOôORôPROMISESôMADEôBYôTHEôGOVERNMENT ôFORôINSTANCE ôFUNDSô FORôSETTLEMENTSôPROMISEDôBYôTHEô!DMINISTRATIONôBUTôNOTôRELEASEDô BYôTHEô-INISTRYôOFô&INANCEô

%XAMPLESôôYôô#OBB RIQROBLOD

0240_057_self_org.indd 90-91


25/09/06 17:40:40

4HEôLOGICôTHATôGUIDESôTHEô-34SôACTIONSôISôTOôDRAWôPUBLICôATTEN TIONôTOôTHEôSITUATIONôOFôEXTREMEôPOVERTYôTHATôAFFECTSôTHEôLANDLESSô WORKERSôANDôTOôCONTRASTôITôWITHôTHEôINADEQUATEôORôINEFkCIENTôEX PLOITATIONôOFôGREATôEXPANSESôOFôLANDô7HENEVERôTHEôMOVEMENTô MAKESôANôENCAMPMENTôONôAôPARTICULARôPROPERTY ôTHEôOBJECTIVEôISô TOôDENOUNCEôTHEôLACKôOFôADEQUATEôEXPLOITATIONôOFôTHATôLAND ôORôTOô POINTôTOôIRREGULARITIESôTHATôCANôBEôRELATEDôTOôUNPAIDôTAXES ôVIOLA TIONSôOFôENVIRONMENTALôLAWSôETC ôINôSUCHôAôWAYôTHATôITôPLACESôTHEô LANDOWNERôINôDEBTôTOôTHEôFEDERALôGOVERNMENTô)NôOTHERôWORDS ô WHATôTHEôMOVEMENTSôMILITANTSôWANTôFROMôTHEôGOVERNMENTôISô DUEôRESPECTôTOôTHEô@SOCIALôFUNCTIONôOFôTHEôLAND ôASôDEkNEDôINô THEô"RAZILIANô#ONSTITUTIONô/NôTHESEôGROUNDS ôTHEôMOVEMENTSô LEADERSôCANôSAYôTHATôTHEôOCCUPATIONSôAREôNECESSARY ôBECAUSEô THEYôPROVEôTHATôTHEôLAWôISôONôTHEIRôSIDEô7HENôTHEYôAREôSUM MONEDôBYôTHEô*UDICIARYSôREPRESENTATIVESôTOôENDôTHEIRôOCCUPA TIONS ôTHEYôDOôNOTôRESISTô%VENôIFôTHEYôWANTEDôTO ôTHEYôWOULDô HAVEôNOôMEANSôTOôRESIST ôASôTHEYôDOôNOTôCARRYôGUNS ôINôCONTRASTô TOôTHEô-ILITARYô0OLICEôANDôTHEô!RMY ôWHOôAREôUSUALLYôCALLEDôTOô GUARANTEEôIMPLEMENTATIONôOFôJUDICIALôORDERSô )TôISôNOôEXAGGERATIONôTOôSTATEôTHATôTHEô-34ôREPRESENTSôANôENOR MOUSôADVANCEôINôTERMSôOFôITSôMETHODSôFORôRAISINGôTHEôLEVELôOFô SOCIETYSôPOLITICALôCONSCIENCEô7HENôAôGROUPôOFôLANDLESSôWORK ERSôPRESSURESôTHEôGOVERNMENTôTOôSETTLEôTHEôWORKERSôONôLANDô APPROPRIATEôFORôAGRARIANôREFORMôANDôTOôRELEASEôFUNDSôFORôTHEô SETTLEMENT ôTHEYôAREôNOTôASKINGôFORôAôFAVOUR ôBUTôCLAIMINGôAô #ONSTITUTIONALôRIGHTô)TôISôNOTôAôMINORôRIGHT ôBUTôTHEôFUNDAMENTALô RIGHTôTOôWORK ôASôSTATEDôINôTHEôTHô)NTERNATIONALô#OVENANTôONô %CONOMICôANDô3OCIALô2IGHTS ôAPPROVEDôBYôTHEô5NITEDô.ATIONSô INôôANDôDULYôRATIkEDôBYô"RAZILô4HISôISôTHEôROOTôOFôTHEôRADI CALôFORMôASSUMEDôBYôTHEô-34SôCLAIMSô)NôEFFECT ôITôISôPERFECTLYô POSSIBLEôTOôNEGOTIATEôAôSALARYôRISEôORôBETTERôWORKINGôCONDITIONSô


0240_057_self_org.indd 92-93

INôAôSPIRITôOFôCOMPROMISEôANDôTRANSACTION ôBUTôNOBODYôSHOULDô BEôASKEDôTOôRENOUNCEôAôFUNDAMENTALôRIGHTô)NSTEADôOFôREPRE SENTINGôAôPOTENTIALôRISKôTOô"RAZILIANôDEMOCRACY ôASôSOMEôANA LYSTSôSAY ôTHEô-34ôISôAôVALUABLEôFACTORôTOWARDSôSTRENGTHENINGô DEMOCRATICôLIFEôSINCEôITôUNDERSCORESôTHEôCENTRALôNEEDôTOôRESPECTô ANDôACTIVELYôDEFENDôFUNDAMENTALôRIGHTSô4HUS ôFORMERô0RESIDENTô &ERNANDOô(ENRIQUEô#ARDOSOôWASôRIGHTôWHENôHEôEMPHASISED ô INôAôSPEECHôONôTHEôOCCASIONôOFôTHEôSANCTIONINGôOFôTHEôLAWôTHATô CREATEDôTHEôPUBLICôLANDôREGISTRYôSYSTEM ôONôô!UGUSTô ô @THEôGREATôCOOPERATIONôPROVIDEDôBYôTHEô-34ôFORôTHEôCHANGEôOFô "RAZILIANôSOCIETY ôEVENôWHENôSOMETIMESôITôHASôGONEôTOOôFARô )Nô*ANUARYô ô,U«Sô)N¶CIOô@,ULAôDAô3ILVAôBECAMEô0RESIDENTô "EINGôAôLONGTIMEôFRIENDôOFôTHEô-34 ôMANYôHOPEDôTHATôLANDô REFORMôWOULDôTAKEôAôDECISIVEôSTEPôAHEADôUNDERôHISô!DMINIS TRATIONô.EVERTHELESS ôHEôARGUEDôTHATôTHEôPREVAILINGôECONOMICô CONDITIONSôDIDôNOTôALLOWôTHEôNEWô!DMINISTRATIONôTOôFULkLLôALLô THEôLANDLESSôWORKERSôDEMANDSô4HEôNUMBERôOFôCOMPLETEDôSET TLEMENTSôHASôEVENôBEENôFRUSTRATING ôINôCOMPARISONôWITHôTHEô PREVIOUSô!DMINISTRATIONô,ULASô!DMINISTRATIONôHASôCHOSENôTOô PRIVILEGEôTHEôPROVISIONôOFôkNANCIALôCREDITSôANDôTHEôQUALITYôOFôSET TLEMENTSôINSTEADôOFôOPENINGôNEWôSETTLEMENTSôINôFRONTIERôAREASô WHEREôMATERIALôCONDITIONSôAREôANôOBSTACLEôTOôSUCCESSô )NôCONCLUSION ôTHEô-34ôDOESôNOTôOCCUPYôONLYôLANDôANDôPUBLICô BUILDINGS ôBUTôALSOôOCCUPIESôMINISTERIALôMEETINGS ôPRESIDENTIALô SPEECHES ôINTELLIGENCEôSERVICESôREPORTS ôNEWSPAPERôEDITORIALS ô NEWSôHEADLINES ô#ONGRESSIONALôDEBATES ôPUBLICôOPINIONôPOLLSô ANDôOFkCIALôCONVERSATIONSôBETWEENô"RAZILSô0RESIDENTôANDôTHEô 0OPEô4HEô-34SôAIMôISôNOTôCONkNEDôTOôTHEôIMPLEMENTATIONô OFôAGRARIANôREFORM ôBUTôCOVERSôTHEôDISCUSSIONôOFôPUBLICôPOLI CIESôRELATEDôINôSOMEôWAYôTOôAGRARIANôQUESTIONS ôEXPRESSING ô


25/09/06 17:40:40

&//4./4%3

FORôINSTANCE ôTHEôMOVEMENTSôOPINIONôINôRELATIONôTOôTHEôUSEôOFô GENETICALLYôMODIkEDôSEEDS ôCHEMICALôFARMINGôANDôOTHERôMATTERSô THATôAFFECTôSMALL SCALEôAGRICULTUREô

ôô ô ô ô ô ô

3TEDILE ô*ô0ôANDô"ô-ô&ERNANDES ô"RAVAô'ENTEômô!ôTRAJET¥RIAôDOô-34ôEôAôLUTAôPELAôTERRAôNOô "RASILô3Óô0AULOô&UNDA±Óô0ERSEUô!BRAMO ôô 3ANTOSô!ô0 ô3ô,ô3ô2IBIEROôANDô*ô#ô3ô"ô-EIHY ô6OZESôDAô-ARCHAôPELAô4ERRAô 3Óô0AULOô,OYOLA ôô #OMPARATO ô"ô+ ô,!CTIONô0OLITIQUEôDESô3ANS 4ERREôAUô"R¯SILô0ARISô,(ARMATTAN ôô &ERNANDES ô"ô- ô!ô&ORMA±ÓôDOô-34ôNOô"RASILô0ETR¥POLISô6OZES ôô #OMPARATO ô"ô+ ô,!CTIONô0OLITIQUEôDESô3ANS 4ERREôAUô"R¯SILô0ARISô,(ARMATTAN ôô

!GRARIANôREFORMôCANNOTôBEôSEPARATEDôFROMôOTHERôRELEVANTôISSUESô INôTERMSôOFôTHEôVALUESôTHATôOUGHTôTOôORIENTôSOCIETYSôCHOICESô FORôTHEôBENEkTôOFôHEIGHTENEDôWELFAREôFORôTHEôMAJORITYôOFôTHEô POPULATION ôANDôFORôAôMOREôBALANCEDôANDôFAIRôPOLITICAL ôECO NOMICôANDôSOCIALôORGANISATIONôOFôTHEôCOUNTRYô)TôREQUIRES ôASô ANô-34ôMILITANTôSTATED ôAôFUNDAMENTALôREVOLUTION ôAôREVOLUTIONô THATôTAKESôPLACEôINSIDEôOURôOWNôMINDSô)NôTHISôSENSE ôWHATôTHEô -34ôBASICALLYôDOESôISôPROVIDEôTHEôPOOR ôTHEôWEAK ôTHEôVULNER ABLE ôTHEôLANDLESS ôTHEôHOMELESS ôTHOSEôWHOôLACKôEVERYTHINGôBUTô THEIRôHUMANôPOTENTIAL ôWITHôAôPOWERFULôINSTRUMENTôTOôOVERCOMEô DIFkCULTIESôTHROUGHôSELF ORGANISATIONô)TSôULTIMATEôGOALôISôADMIT TEDLYôTOôINlUENCEôTHEôRESHAPINGôOFôECONOMICôANDôSOCIALôLIFEô ACCORDINGôTOôTHEôHIGHESTôHUMANôPRIORITYômôTHEôEMPOWERMENTô OFôCOMMONôPEOPLEôSOôTHATôTHEYôBECOMEôCAPABLEôOFôIMPROVINGô ANDôENRICHINGôTHEIRôLIVESô


0240_057_self_org.indd 94-95


25/09/06 17:40:41

'9"/ $ESCRIPTIONô 'ETô9OURô"OOTLEGô/N ôANôINTERNETôMESSAGEôBOARDôFORô$JSôANDôMUSICIANSôWHOôCREATEô @BOOTLEGSôORô@MASH UPSômôNEWôMUSICôCREATEDôBYôMIXINGôEXISITINGôCOMMERCIALôTRACKSô TOGETHERô'9"/ôHASôMOVEDôANDôCHANGEDôSEVERALôTIMESôUNDERôTHEôTHREATôOFôLEGALôAC TIONô4HEôCURRENTôVERSIONôISôATôWWWGYBO VCOUK 4EXT 4OPICô,EGALITYôOFô-ASH UPS DJSXXXXô3UNô*UNô ôôôPMô mô (IôALL ôNEEDôSOMEôHELPô)MôVERYôCONFUSEDôWITHôTHEôWHOLEôgLEGALITYuôOFôMASHUPSô )ôUSEDôTOôENJOYôCREATINGôTHEMôô)ôHAVEôMADEôMANYôOVERôTHEôPASTôFEWôYEARSôBUTô SINCEôPUTTINGôTHEMôONôMYôWEBSITEô)ôRECIEVEDôANôEMAILôFROMôTHEô"0)ô"RITISHô0HONO GRAPHICô)NDUSTRY ôORDERINGôMEôTOôREMOVEôTHEMôFROMôMYôWEBSITEôôSTOPôDISTRIBUTINGô MYôMASHESôôEVENôôSECONDôSAMPLESôOFôTHEMôWHICHôAREôOFôAôPOORôQUALITYôLIKEô KBSô mô -OREôTOôTHEôPOINTô)ôAMôDISAPPOINTEDôINôTHEôRULESôôREGSôô)ôWONDEREDôIFôTHEREôISô ANYôWAYôAROUNDôTHISôSTICKYôSITUATIONôô -IXXXXXXXXô3UNô*UNô ôôôPM mô )FôTHEôAUDIOôISôPROTECTEDôBYôCOPYRIGHT ôANDôYOUôDONTôHAVEôTHEôPERMISSIONôTOôUSEô IT ôYOUREôBREAKINGôTHEôLAWô3IMPLEôASôTHAT (EAXXXXXXXô3UNô*UNô ôôôPM mô 4HEREôISôNOôLEGALôPRECEDENTôTHATôDIFFERENTIATESôBOOTLEGSôFROMôANYôOTHERôCOPYRIGHTô INFRINGEMENTôSOôNO ôITSôENTIRELYôILLEGALômôENDôOFôWHETHERôTHEYôTURNôAôBLINDôEYE ô HOWEVER ôISôANOTHERôMATTERôENTIRELYôYOUVEôNOTôBEENôSOôLUCKYôIôSUGGESTôCLOSINGô DOWNôFORôAôFEWôMONTHS ôANDôCOMINGôBACKôQUIETLYôWITHôONLYôTWOôORôTHREEôSONGSô HOSTEDôATôANYôONEôTIME DJSXXXXô3UNô*UNô ôôôPM mô (EYôHO ô)ôGUESSôTHATSôTHEôENDôOFôTHATôTHENô,/, -IXXXXXXXXô3UNô*UNô ôôôPM mô )Tô MAYô BEô ILLEGAL ô BUTô SOô WASô $*ô $ANGERô -OUSESô 4HEô 'REYô !LBUMôô ô

!NDôLOOKôWHATôHAPPENEDôTOôHIM

-ARXXXXXXXô3UNô*UNô ôôôPM mô 7HATôIFôYOUôJUSTôRENAMEôTHEôMP ôWITHôAôNON EXISTINGôEXTENSIONôô4HEôkLEôITSELFô WILLôTHENôBEôUNREADABLEôFORôANYôMEDIAPLAYERô4HENôTHEôUSEôOFôCOPYRIGHTEDôMATERIALô CANNOTôBEôPROVENôONôTHEôkLEôYOUôDISTRIBUTE !BEXXXXXXXô3UNô*UNô ôôôPM

0240_057_self_org.indd 96-97

%XAMPLESôôYôô$6,

25/09/06 17:40:42

mô $ONTôHOSTôTHEôSTUFFôONôYOURôWEBSITE ôORôGETôAôWEBHOSTôTHATôDOESNTôCARE ôTHENô

mô $AFXXXXXXXôWROTEô!TôLEASTôINôTHEô53 ôTHEô2)!!ôHASôPASSEDôLAWSôTHATôSPECIkCALLYô

IGNOREôTHEô"0)

OUTLAWôgILLEGITIMATEuôMUSICôFROMôBEINGôAIREDôACROSSôINô)NTERNETôRADIOôWAVESô mô 4HEô2)!!ôCANTôPASSôLAWSô4HEYREôAôGROUPôOFôRECORDôLABELS ôNOTôTHEôGOVERNMENT

DJ?XXXXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôAM

ôô

mô /NEôOFôTHEôPROBLEMSôISôBYôHAVINGôAôgCOUKuôSITEô9OUôCOULDôTRYôHOSTINGôYOURôkLESô

DJSXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôPM

ONô-ULTIPLYôORô-USICBUILDER ôORôIFôYOUREôNOTôKEENôONôGIVINGôUPôTHEôCOUKôDOMAIN ô

mô #HEERSôEVERYONE ô)ôAMôINTERESTEDôONôHEARINGôALLôYOURôVIEWSôôOPINIONSô)ôREALLYôDONTô

YOUôCANôDOôSOMETHINGôSIMILARôTOôWHATô'9"/ôHASôDONEôANDôJUSTôHAVEôLINKSôTOôTHEô

WANTôTOôGIVEôUPôJUSTôYETôBUTô)ôDONTôREALLYôFEELôLIKEô)ôHAVEôAôCHOICEôANYMOREô)ôDONTô

SONGSôWHICHôAREôHOSTEDôELSEWHERE

QUITEôUNDERSTANDôHOWôOTHERSôGETôAWAYôWITHôIT ô)ôMEANôEITHERô)VEôBEENôSTITCHEDôUPô ORô)MôJUSTôEXTREMELYôUNLUCKYôô

3OCXXXXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôPM

mô )ôDOôHAVEôLOADSôOFôGREATôIDEASôFORôNEWôMASHESôBUTô)MôNOWôAFFRAIDôTOôMAKEôONE ô)ô

mô .OPEô#EASEôô$ESISTôMEANSôITSôAôg./uôGOô

MEANôIVEôBEENôWARNEDôNOWôôDONTôREALLYôFANCYôPUSHINGôMYôLUCKô4OôTHOSEôOFôYOUô WHOôSUGGESTEDôHOSTINGôMYôkLESôELSEWHEREôSURELYôIFôMYôNAMEôISôONôITô)ôAMôSTILLô

$AFXXXXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôPM

LIKELYôTOôGETôINTOôTROUBLEôASôTHEYôWILLôKNOWô)ôAMôTHEôONEôWHOôSTARTEDôSHARINGôITôINô

mô *USTôTOôBEôANNOYINGô-AKINGôAôMASHUPôISôNOTôILLEGALô&ORôEXAMPLE ôIFôYOUôOWNôTWOô #$S ôRIPôTWOôSONGS ôANDôMASHôTHEMôTOGETHERômôTHATSôNOTôILLEGALô,ISTENINGôTOôTHEô

THEôkRSTôPLACEô mô !LLô)ôWANTôTOôDOôISôEXPRESSôMYôFEELINGôôSHAREôMYôPASSIONôFORôMUSICôBYôCREATINGô

MASHUPôYOUôMADEôFORôYOURSELFôISôNOTôILLEGALô

DIFFERENTôRYTHYMSôôVIBESô3URELYôTHATSôNOTôTOOôMUCHôTOôASKôFORôIFôALLô)ôAMôGAININGô OUTôOFôITôISôRECOGNITIONô

mô (OWEVERômô$ISTRIBUTINGôITôISôILLEGALô#$S ô-0S ôETC ôWHENôDONEôINôAôMETHODôTHATôISô COMMERCIALôIEôSELLINGôAô#$ôORôkLE ôORôCANôBEôDISTRIBUTEDôINôMASSôNUMBERSôSUCHô

mô 4HANKSôFORôALLôTHEôSUPPORTôPEEPSôô

ASôANôMP ôDOWNLOAD ô)NôTHEORY ôMAKINGôAôTAPEôFORôYOURôPALôANDôLETTINGôTHEMôLISTENô

ôôô

TOôITôISNTôEXACTLYôILLEGAL ôBUTôISôQUESTIONABLEô.APSTERôYEôOLDENôDAYS ôTRIEDôTOôARGUEô

-AGXXXXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôPM

THISôLOOPHOLEôINôTHEôCOPYRIGHTDUPLICATIONôISSUEôTOôJUSTIFYôITôBACKôINôTHEôDAYô

mô $*ô3PARK ôIFôTHERESôONEôTHINGôUôMUSTôLEARNôTOôDOôIFôYURôGONNAôMAKEôMASHESôIS

mô 0LAYINGôITôONô)NTERNETôRADIOôISôILLEGALô!TôLEASTôINôTHEô53 ôTHEô2)!!ôHASôPASSEDôLAWSô

34)#+ô)4ô4/ô4(%ô-!.

THATôSPECIkCALLYôOUTLAWôgILLEGITIMATEuôMUSICôFROMôBEINGôAIREDôACROSSôINô)NTERNETô RADIOôWAVESô4HEôLAWôWASNTôINTENDEDôTOôBLOCKôHOMEôREMIXESôANDôMASHUPS ôBUTô

0ILXXXXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôPM

BYôTHEôLETTERôOFôTHEôLAWôHASôDONEôSOô%VENôIFôYOUREôPLAYINGôYOURôOWNôMASHUPô

mô )FôYOUôWANTôTOôKEEPôYOURôDOMAINôNAMEômôIôSEEôYOUôGOTôAôGOODôONE ôDONTôHOSTô

mô 4HEREôAREôSOMEôARGUMENTSôINôgFAIRôUSEuôSUCHôASôPROTEST ôPARODYôANDôFREEDOMôOFô

ANYTHINGôONôIT SETôUPôAôDIVERTôTOôANOTHERôHOST ôWHICHôHASôYOURôTUNESôONôIT ôTHENôYOUô

EXPRESSIONô&ORôEXAMPLE ôIFôYOUôMASHUPô'REENô$AYôTOôPROTESTôTHEIRôMUSICôFORôPOLITI

CANôPISSôTHEMôOFFôGETôCLOSEDôDOWNôETCôTOôYOURôHEARTSôCONTENTô/URSôISNTôWORKINGô

CALôPURPOSES ôCHANCESôAREô7ARNERôWOULDNTôGIVEôYOUôTHEôRIGHTSôTOôUSEôTHEIRôMUSICô

ATôTHEôMOôCOSôWEôFORGOTôTOôPAYôTHEMôIEôWWWDOT0ILXXXXXXXôDOTôTVôBUTôTHEôTUNESô

TOôDOôTHEôPROTESTô3O ôTHEREôISôSOMEôROOMôFORôALLOWINGôAôPROTESTôWITHOUTôPERMIT

AREôONôWWWDOTSCOTTCAIROôDOTôCOôDOTôUK0ILXXXXXXX

TINGôCOPYRIGHTôHOLDERSôTOôBLOCKôYOURôFREEDOMôOFôEXPRESSIONô(OWEVER ôJUSTIFYINGô AôREALISTICALLYôANDôLEGALLYôVALIDôPROTESTôAGAINSTô'REENô$AYôWHILEôMASHINGôUPôTHEIRô

TBCXXXXXXXô4UEô*UNô ôôôAM

MUSICôISôSOMEWHATôUNREALISTICô

mô ALSOôHOSTôYOURôDOMAINôATôAôSEPARATEôDOMAINôHOSTôNOTôYOURô)30ôORôWEBHOSTô-IGHTô COSTôAôLITTLEôBITôMOREôBUTôYOUôUSUALLYôHAVEôTOôPAYôTHEôHOSTINGôFEESôANYWAYôSOô

2OBXXXXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôPM

MAKESôLITTLEôODDS ôORôCOULDôSAVEôMONEY ôBUTôITSôANOTHERôTARGETôTOôHITôANDôMOREô

mô $AFXXXXXXXôWROTEô-AKINGôAôMASHUPôISôNOTôILLEGALô&ORôEXAMPLE ôIFôYOUôOWNôTWOô

LIKELYôTHATôYOURôDOMAINôWONTôGOôWITHôYOURôHOSTôIFôTHEYôPULLôTHEôPLUGDUNNOôIFôTHEô

#$S ôRIPôTWOôSONGS ôANDôMASHôTHEMôTOGETHERômôTHATSôNOTôILLEGALô,ISTENINGôTOôTHEô MASHUPôYOUôMADEôFORôYOURSELFôISôNOTôILLEGAL

HOSTôCANôCONkSCATEôTHEôDOMAINôBUTôTHEYôDEkNITELYôCANTôIFôITSôANOTHERôCOMPANYô mô 0ARANOIDô-Eô9EPô"UTô)ôHAVEôBEENô#$DôINôTHEôPAST

mô 4OTALLYôWRONGô%VENôJUSTôRIPPINGôTHEôTRACKSôTOôSTARTôWITHôISôILLEGALô2ENDERINGôCON SOLIDATING ôEXPORTING ôORôWHATEVERôYOURôSOFTWAREôCALLSôIT ôYOURôMASHUPôISôILLEGALô

#ORXXXXXXXô4UEô*UNô ôôôPMô

7HEREVERôYOUôMAKEôAôCOPYôOFôSOMETHINGôTHATôISôCOPYRIGHTED ôITSôILLEGALômôNOTWITH

mô ,OOKôONôTHEôBRIGHTôSIDE ôATôLEASTôYOUôGOTôAô2%!,ô#$ ôANDôNOTôAôFAKEôONE

STANDINGôTHEôUSUALôEXCEPTIONSôFORôCRITICISM ôPARODYô53ôONLY ôETCô mô 5NLESSôCOPYRIGHTôLAWôINôTHEô53ôISôVERYôMUCHôMOREôDIFFERENTôTOôCOPYRIGHTôLAWôINôTHEô 5+ôTHATô)DôPREVIOUSLYôUNDERSTOODô


0240_057_self_org.indd 98-99

(EAXXXXXXXô4UEô*UNô ôôôPM mô !ôCOUPLEôOFôREASONSôWHYôYOUôMAYôHAVEôBEENôPICKEDôONôONEôOFôYOURôTRACKSôMADEô


25/09/06 17:40:42

ITôgBIGuôONôTHEôNETôSEARCHôTOôSEEôIFôYOUVEôBEENôMASSIVELYôBLOGGEDôOVERôAôPARTICULARô

KINXXXXXXXô7EDô*UNô ôôôPM

TRACKôHAVEôAôLOOKôATôTHEôAMOUNTôOFôHITSBANDWIDTHôUSEDôLATELYômôHASôTHEREôBEENô

mô 7HATEVERôHAPPENEDôTOôGOODôOLDôFASHIONEDôREBELLIOUSNESS

AôSURGEô/RôYOUôTYPEDôOUTôANDôLISTEDôEVERYôCOMPONENTôTRACKôANDôARTISTôINôYOURô MASHESôINôWHICHôCASE ôTHEYôDONTôNEEDôTOôDOôANYôRESEARCHôORôHARDôWORK ôTHEYôCANô

,ANXXXXXXXô-ONô*UNô ôôôAM

JUSTôCPôYOURôTRACKôINFORMATIONôINTOôAô#$ôANDôkREôITôOFFôEASYôPICKINGS ôINNIT

mô 4ALKINGôABOUTôgLEGALITYuôINôTHEôCONTEXTôOFôTHEôMUSICôINDUSTRYôISôLIKEôTALKINGôABOUTô gNUTRITIONuôINôTHEôCONTEXTôOFôAôCAKEôSHOP

DJSXXXXô4UEô*UNô ôôôPM mô 3OUNDSôLIKEôYOUôGUYSôDEFOôKNOWôYOURôSTUFFô4OôTHOSEôOFôYOUôWHOôSUGGESTEDôUSINGô ANOTHERôHOSTô)ôWOULDNTôMINDôDOINGôTHAT ô)MôJUSTôWORRIEDôTHEYôCOULDôPROSECUTEôMEô

&ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWGYBO VCOUK

ORôLOCKôMEôUPôLOLô mô )ôMEANôTOôBEôHONESTô)ôLIKEôMYôDOMAINôNAMEôBUTôATôTHEôENDôOFôTHEôDAYô)MôNOTôOVERLYô FUSSEDôIFôTHEYôTOOKôTHATôAWAYôFROMôMEô7HATôISôTHEôWORSTôTHEô"0)ôCOULDôDOô&ORô THOSEôOFôYOUôWHOôAREôINTERESTEDôINôMYôPREVIOUSôWORKôTHESEôINCLUDEô ô

!4&#ô6Sô!LICEô$EEJAYômô"ETTERô"ADô(ABITô

ô

"LUô#ANTRELLôô3EANô0AULô6Sô-ARYô*ô"LIGEômô"REATHEô!FFAIRô

ô

!RETHAô&RANKLINôVSô-ICHAELô'RAYômô$EEPERô7EEKENDô,OVEô

ô

+ELISô6Sô##ô-USICô&ACTORYômô%VERYBODYô$ANCEô4Oô-ILKSHAKEô

ô

3CISSORô3CISTERSôVSô,IPPSô)NCômô&UNKY'ORGEOUSô

ô

ô&INGERSô6Sô0AULô*OHNSONômô'ETô$OWNô/Nô-Yô3HORTô$ICKô

ô

"ASEMENTô*AXXôVSô3HAKEDOWNômô'OSHô.IGHTô

ô

'WENô3TEFANIôVSô3ILICONEô3OULômô(OLLAô2IGHTô"ACKô'IRLô

ô

-ADONNAô6Sô$ANNIIô-INOGUEômô)ô7ANNAô2AYô/Fô,IGHTô

ô

$ESTINYSô#HILDô6Sô3HAPESHIFTERSômô,OLASô"UGô!ô"OOô

ô

-ARIAHô#AREYôVSô2OBINô3ômô,OVEô,IKEô4HATô

ô

%MINEMô6Sô3TARDUSTômô-USICô3OUNDSô"ETTERô7ITHOUTô-Eô

ô

'WENô3TEFANIôVSôô5NLIMITEDômô.Oô7AITINGô,IMITô

ô

"EYONCEôVSô!MERIEômô/NEô#RAZYô4HINGôô

ô

$ANNIIô-INOGUEôVSô'INAô'ômô/OHô!HHô4HISô)SôITô

ô

%MINEMô6Sô$ARUDEômô3HADYô3ANDSTORMô

ô

"RITNEYô3PEARSô6Sô%URYTHMICSômô3LAVEô$REAMSô

ô

/NEPHATDEEVAô6Sô3TONEBRIDGEômô4AKEô/NEPHATDEEVAô!WAYô

ô

"RANDYôô-ONICAô6Sô!ALIYAHômô4HEô"OYô)Sô-INEô!GAINô

ô

-ADONNAôVSô!4"ômô4ILô-USICô#OMESô

ô

$ESTINYSô#HILDô6Sô+ELISômô4RICKô7OMANô

MRXXXXXXXô7EDô*UNô ôôôPM mô DJSPARKôWROTEô ô

ô&INGERSô6Sô0AULô*OHNSONômô'ETô$OWNô/Nô-Yô3HORTô$ICKô

ô

-ARIAHô#AREYôVSô2OBINô3ômô,OVEô,IKEô4HATô

ô

%MINEMô6Sô3TARDUSTômô-USICô3OUNDSô"ETTERô7ITHOUTô-Eô

ô

'WENô3TEFANIôVSôô5NLIMITEDômô.Oô7AITINGô,IMITô

ô

$ MN ô)ôLOVEôTHESE ôESPECIALLYôg,OVEôLIKEôTHATuôKEEPSôMEôGOINGôALLôNIGHTôô


0240_057_self_org.indd 100-101


25/09/06 17:40:43

4HEôô ARCHITECTUREô OFôINNOVATION "Yô,AWRENCEô,ESSIG


0240_057_self_org.indd 102-103

4HEôARCHITECTUREôOFôINNOVATION

25/09/06 17:40:43

%VERYôSOCIETYôHASôRESOURCESô THATôAREôFREEôANDôRESOURCESô THATôAREôCONTROLLEDô!ôFREEô RESOURCEôISôONEôTHATôANYONEô EQUALLYôCANôTAKEôAôCONTROL LEDôRESOURCEôONEôCANôTAKEô ONLYôWITHôTHEôPERMISSIONôOFô SOMEONEôELSEô%-#ôISôAô FREEôRESOURCEô9OUôCANôTAKEô ITôANDôUSEôITôWITHOUTôTHEô PERMISSIONôOFôTHEô%INSTEINô ESTATEôô-ERCERô3TREET ô 0RINCETON ôISôAôCONTROLLEDô ôRESOURCEô4OôSLEEPôATôô -ERCERô3TREETôREQUIRESôTHEô PERMISSIONôOFôTHEô)NSTITUTEô FORô!DVANCEDô3TUDY


0240_057_self_org.indd 104-105

!ôTIMEôISôMARKEDôNOTôSOôMUCHôBYôTHEôIDEASôTHATôAREôARGUEDô ABOUT ôBUTôBYôTHEôIDEASôTHATôAREôTAKENôFORôGRANTEDô4HEôCHARAC TERôOFôANôERAôHANGSôONôWHATôONEôNEEDôNOTôQUESTIONôTHEôPOWERô INôAôPARTICULARôMOMENTôRUNSôWITHôTHEôNOTIONSôTHATôONLYôTHEôCRAZYô WOULDôDRAWôINTOôDOUBT 3OMETIMESôTHATôISôJUSTôkNEô)MôHAPPYôTHEôQUESTIONôOFôINFAN TICIDEôISôOFFôTHEôTABLEôHOWôEXTRAORDINARILYôTEDIOUSôITôWOULDôBEô IFôWEôREGULARLYôHADôTOôDEBATEôWHETHERôWEôWANTEDôTOôBEôAôDE MOCRACYô)NôTHEôLANGUAGEôOFôCOMPUTERôPROGRAMMING ôITôISôAô GREATôANDôVALUABLEôTHINGôTHATôCERTAINôIDEALSôGETôCOMPILEDôINTOô SOCIALôLIFEô)TôISôANôADVANTAGEôTHATôEVERYTHINGôNEEDôNOTôATôEVERYô MOMENTôBEôINTERPRETED "UTôSOMETIMESôAôSOCIETYôGETSôSTUCKôBECAUSEôOFôANôIDEAôITôCANTô QUITEôQUESTION ôORôDISLODGEô3OMETIMESôTHEôIDEAôgSTICKSuôTHEô SOCIETYô!NDôWHENôTHATôHAPPENS ôTHEôHARDESTôPARTôOFôPOLITICALô ACTIONômôTHEôHARDESTôPARTôOFôCHANGINGôANôASPECTôOFôSOCIETYômôISô TOôGETôPEOPLEôTOôSEEôHOWôTHISôTAKEN FOR GRANTEDôIDEAôMIGHTôBEô WRONGô4OôGETôPEOPLEôTOôBELIEVEôTHATôTHEREôMIGHTôBEôSOMETHINGô CONTESTABLEôABOUTôWHATôSEEMEDôUNQUESTIONABLE ôORôEVENôTOôGETô THEMôTOôSEEôTHATôTHEôSTORYôISôMOREôCOMPLEXôTHANôTHEYôBELIEVED !NDôSOôITôISôWITHôUS 7EôLIVEôINôANôERAôWHENôTHEôIDEAôOFôPROPERTYôISôJUSTôSUCHôAô THOUGHT ôORôBETTER ôJUSTôSUCHôAôNON THOUGHTôWHENôTHEôIMPOR TANCEôANDôVALUEôOFôPROPERTYôISôTAKENôFORôGRANTEDôWHENôITôISô IMPOSSIBLE ôORôATôLEASTôFORôUS ôVERYôHARD ôTOôGETôANYONEôTOôEN TERTAINôAôVIEWôWHEREôPROPERTYôISôNOTôCENTRALôWHENôTOôQUESTIONô THEôUNIVERSALITYôANDôINEVITABILITYôOFôCOMPLETEôPROPERTIZATIONôISôTOô MARKôYOURSELFôASôANôOUTSIDERô!SôANôALIEN


25/09/06 17:40:44

)ôDONTôMEANôTHEôDEBATEôABOUTôCOMMODIkCATIONôCRYSTALLIZEDôBYô FEMINISM ôORôAôDEBATEôABOUTôWHETHERôWEôCONCEIVEôOFôSOCIALô RELATIONSôASôAôKINDôOFôPROPERTYôRIGHTô4HATôISôAôFUNDAMENTALLYô CONTESTEDôDISCOURSE ôRICHôWITHôPOSSIBILITYôANDôPROFOUNDLYôIM PORTANT

STATEôLEADSôUSôTOôIGNOREôANôISSUEôTHATôCOMESôBEFOREô.OTôTHEô QUESTIONôOFôWHICHôSYSTEMôOFôCONTROLôISôBESTôFORôANYôGIVENô RESOURCE ôBUTôINSTEADôTHEôQUESTIONômôSHOULDôAôRESOURCEôBEô SUBJECTôTOôCONTROLôATôALLô.OTôTHEôMARKETôVERSUSôTHEôSTATE ôBUTô CONTROLLEDôVERSUSôFREE

)ôMEANôSOMETHINGôMUCHôMOREôMUNDANEôANDôSIMPLEô)ôMEANô THEôQUESTIONôOFôPROPERTYôINôRESOURCESô/R ôMOREôPRECISELY ôTHEô QUESTIONôOFôWHETHERôRESOURCESôSHOULDôBEôCONTROLLEDômôORôHOWô THEYôSHOULDôBEôCONTROLLED

)FôCOMMUNISMôVERSUSôCAPITALISMôWASôTHEôSTRUGGLEôOFôTHEôTWEN TIETHôCENTURY ôTHENôCONTROLôVERSUSôFREEDOMôWILLôBEôTHEôDEBATEô OFôTHEôTWENTY kRSTôCENTURYô)FôOURôQUESTIONôTHENôWASôHOWôBESTô TOôCONTROL ôOURôQUESTIONôNOWôWILLôBECOMEôWHETHERôTOôCONTROLô 7HATôWOULDôAôFREEôRESOURCEôGIVEôUSôTHATôCONTROLLEDôRESOURCESô DOôNOTô7HATôISôTHEôVALUEôINôAVOIDINGôSYSTEMSôOFôCONTROL

&ORôABOUTôTHISôQUESTION ôTHEREôISôAPPARENTLYôNOôDEBATEô!Sô 9ALEô5NIVERSITYô0ROFESSORô#AROLô2OSEôPUTSôIT ôWEôLIVEôINôAôTIMEô WHENôTHEôVIEWôISôTHATôgTHEôWHOLEôWORLDôISôBESTôMANAGEDôWHENô DIVIDEDôAMONGôPRIVATEôOWNERSuô4HEôMOSTôCREATIVEôMINDSôINô PUBLICôPOLICYôTURNôTHEIRôATTENTIONôTOôHOWôBESTôTOôDIVIDEôRE SOURCESôUPô4HEôASSUMPTIONôISôTHATôWELL DIVIDEDôRESOURCESô WILLôALWAYSôWORKôBEST 7EôHAVEôTHISôVIEWômôTHISôTAKEN FOR GRANTED ôBACKGROUNDôVIEWô môBECAUSEôFORôTHEôLASTôHUNDREDôYEARS ôWEVEôDEBATEDôAôRELATEDô QUESTION ôANDôTHATôDEBATEôHASôCOMEôTOôANôENDô&ORôTHEôLASTô HUNDREDôYEARS ôTHEôQUESTIONôEXCITINGôPOLITICALôPHILOSOPHYôHASô BEENôWHICHôSYSTEMôOFôCONTROLôWORKSôBESTô3HOULDôRESOURCESôBEô CONTROLLEDôBYôTHEôSTATE ôORôCONTROLLEDôBYôTHEôMARKETô!NDôTHISô QUESTION ôWEôALLôRIGHTLYôBELIEVE ôHASôBEENôANSWEREDô)NôALLôBUTôAô FEWôCASES ôFORôAôWIDEôRANGEôOFôREASONS ôWEôKNOWôTHISôTHATôTHEô MARKETôISôAôBETTERôTOOLôFORôCONTROLLINGôRESOURCESôTHANôTHEôSTATEô 4HATôBETWEENôTHEôTWO ôTHEREôISôNOôREALôDEBATE

.OW ôTHISôISôAôHARDôQUESTIONôTOôASKôATô$UKEô)TSôACTUALLYôAôHARDô QUESTIONôTOôASKôANYWHERE ôASôITôUSUALLYôELICITSôAôSHEEPLIKEôSTAREô AMONGôMOSTôINôTHEôAUDIENCEô"UTôITôISôPARTICULARLYôHARDôTOôASKô HEREôBECAUSEôHEREôITSôBEENôASKED ôANDôANSWERED ôMANYôTIMESô BEFORE 4HEôCONTROLLEDôVERSUSôFREEôDEBATEôGETSôREBORNôWITHINôLAWôINôANô ESSAYôABOUTôTHEôPUBLICôDOMAIN ôPENNEDôBYô0ROFESSORô$AVIDô ,ANGEô4HEôPARADOXôBETWEENôTHEôCONTROLLEDôANDôTHEôFREEôISô CRYSTALLIZEDôINôTHEôkRSTôGREATôBOOKôOFôTHEôINFORMATIONôERA ôBYô ONEôWHOôHASôROMANTICALLYôDENIEDôTHEôROMANCEôINôAUTHORSHIP ô 0ROFESSORô*AMESô"OYLEô!NDôTHEôSTRUGGLEôTOôPRESERVEôINTER NATIONALLYôTHEôSPACEôOFôTHEôFREEôINôTHEôCOREôOFôSCIENCEôANDôTHEô PERIPHERYôHASôATôITSôCENTERôTHEôENERGYôOFô0ROFESSORô*EROMEô 2EICHMAN

"UTôTHISôCONkDENCEôOBSCURESôAôDISTINCTôANDôMOREôBASICôQUES TIONô4HISôCERTAINTYôABOUTôTHEôSUPERIORITYôOFôTHEôMARKETôTOôTHEô

!NDôSOôHEREôISôTHEôREALôSTRUGGLEôOFôONEôINVITEDôTOô$UKEôTOôSPEAKô OFôTHINGSôLEARNEDôFROMô$UKEô4HEôEXERCISEôQUICKLYôFEELSôLESSô LIKEôAôLECTURE ôANDôMOREôLIKEôANôEXAMô!TôEACHôMOMENTô)ôFEELô



0240_057_self_org.indd 106-107

25/09/06 17:40:44

&2%%ô"%%2 $ESCRIPTION &REEôASôINôSPEECH ôNOTôFREEôASôINôBEER 4EXT &2%%ô"%%2ôISôBASEDôONôCLASSICôBREWINGôTRADITIONS ôBUTôWITHôADDEDô'UARAN¶ôFORôAô NATURALôENERGYôBOOSTô4HEôRECIPEôANDôBRANDINGôELEMENTSôOFô&2%%ô"%%2ôAREôPUBLISHEDô UNDERôAô#REATIVEô#OMMONSô!TTRIBUTION 3HARE!LIKEô ôLICENSE ôWHICHôMEANSôTHATô ANYONEôCANôUSEôTHEôRECIPEôTOôBREWôTHEIRôOWNô&2%%ô"%%2ôORôCREATEôAôDERIVATIVEôOFô THEôRECIPEô!NYONEôISôFREEôTOôEARNôMONEYôFROMô&2%%ô"%%2 ôBUTôTHEYôMUSTôPUBLISHôTHEô RECIPEôUNDERôTHEôSAMEôLICENSEôANDôCREDITôOURôWORKô!LLôDESIGNôANDôBRANDINGôELEMENTSô AREôALSOôAVAILABLEôTOôANYONEôWHOôWISHESôTOôUSEôTHEM ôANDôCANôBEôMODIkEDôTOôSUIT ô PROVIDEDôCHANGESôAREôPUBLISHEDôUNDERôTHEôSAMEôLICENSEô!TTRIBUTION 3HAREô!LIKE ô

&2%%ô"%%2ôISôBASEDôONô6ORESôLôVô4HEôLATESTôVERSION ô&2%%ô"%%2ôV ôISô

ôCURRENTLYôBEINGôPRODUCEDôINô$ENMARKôINôCOLLABORATIONôWITHô3KANDSô"REWERY 3OURCEô WWWFREEBEERORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWCREATIVECOMMONSORG WWWBRYGGERIET SKANDSDK

%XAMPLESôôYôô#/""ñ""/

0240_057_self_org.indd 108-109

25/09/06 17:40:45

MYSELFôPULLEDôTOôLOOKôUPôFORôCORRECTIONôORôSCORINGô)ôSITôSPINNINGô ATôMYôDESKôWONDERINGôWHETHERôTHEREôISôANYTHINGôNEWôTOôSAYôTOô AôSCHOOLôTHATôREMINDSôUSôABOUTôHOWôMUCHôOFôTHEôOLDôTHEREôISô INôEVERYTHINGôNEWô!NDôTHEN ôFORôAôMOMENT ô)MôRELIEVEDôBYôTHEô THOUGHTôTHATôIFô)ôSAYôNOTHINGôNEW ôTHENôYOUôALLôWILLôFEELôATôLEASTô VINDICATEDôINôYOURôVIEWôOFôHOWôLITTLEôNEWôTHEREôISôINôTHEôWORKôOFô ANYôAUTHOR ôORôATôLEASTôTHISôAUTHOR "UTôHERESôTHEôWAYô)ôWANTôTOôTAKEôYOURôARGUMENTS ôANDôSAYô SOMETHINGôNEWô0UTôMOSTôABSTRACTLY ô)ôWANTôTOôTRANSLATEôYOURôAR GUMENTSôINTOôSPACEôTOôPLACEôTHEMôWITHINôANôARCHITECTUREô!NDô THENôTOôDEMONSTRATEôTHEôPOINTSôYOUVEôALREADYôMADEôTHROUGHô THEôMACHINESôWEVEôCOMEôTOôKNOWô4HROUGHôTHEôMACHINESôTHATô HAVEôDEkNEDôTHEôPOTENTIALôFORôAôKINDôOFôFREEDOMôTHATôWE ôASôAô CULTURE ôHAVEôNOTôKNOWNôFORôAôVERYôLONGôTIME

#OMMUNICATIONôSYSTEMS

.OW ôEACHôOFôTHESEôLAYERSôINôPRINCIPLEôCOULDôBEôCONTROLLEDô ORôFREEô4HEYôWOULDôBEôFREEôIFôTHEYôWEREôORGANIZEDôINôAôCOM MONSômôORGANIZEDôSOôTHATôANYONEôCOULDôGETôACCESSôORôEQUALô TERMS ôWHETHERôTHEYôHADôTOôPAYôAôkXEDôANDôNEUTRALôCHARGE ô ORôNOTô4HEYôWOULDôBEôCONTROLLEDôIFôTHEYôWEREôTHEôPROPERTYôOFô SOMEONEôELSEômôSOMEONEôWHOôHADôAôRIGHTôTOôEXCLUDE ôORôTOô DECIDEôWHETHERôTOôGRANTôACCESSôBASEDôUPONôHISôORôHERôOWNô SUBJECTIVEôREASONS $EPENDINGôONôWHETHERôTHESEôLAYERSôAREôFREE ôORôAREôCONTROLLED ô THEôCOMMUNICATIONSôSYSTEMôTHATôGETSôBUILTôDIFFERS

#ONSIDERôFOURôPOSSIBILITIESôASôWEôVARYôWHETHERôEACHôOFôTHESEô LAYERSôISôOWNEDôORôFREE ô ô

3PEAKERSô#ORNER /RATORSôANDôLOONSôGATHERôEVERYô3UNDAYôINô(YDEô0ARKSô3PEAKERSô#OR NERôTOôRAGEôABOUTôSOMETHINGôORôNOTHINGôATôALLô)TôHASôBECOMEôAô,ONDONô

0ROFESSORô9OCHAIô"ENKLERôOFô.EWô9ORKô5NIVERSITYô3CHOOLôOFô,AWô ISôAôTHEORISTôOFôFREEôCOMMUNICATIONôWHOôSAYSôTOôTHINKôABOUTôAô SYSTEMôOFôCOMMUNICATIONôDIVIDEDôAMONGôTHREEôLAYERSô4HESEô LAYERSôINTERCONNECTôEACHôDEPENDSôUPONôTHEôOTHERôANYôCOM MUNICATIONôDEPENDSôUPONôALLôTHREE

TRADITIONô)TôISôAôCOMMUNICATIONôSYSTEMôORGANIZEDôINôAôSPECIkCôWAYô 4HEôPHYSICALôLAYERôOFôTHISôCOMMUNICATIONôSYSTEMôTHEôPARK ôISôAôCOM MONSôTHEôLOGICALôLAYERôTHEôLANGUAGEôUSED ôISôALSOôAôCOMMONSô!NDô THEôCONTENTôLAYERôWHATôTHESEôNUTSôSAY ôISôTHEIRôOWNôCREATIONô)TôTOOôISô UNOWNEDô!LLôTHREEôLAYERSôINôTHISôCONTEXTôAREôFREEôNOôONEôCANôEXERCISEô CONTROLôOVERôTHEôKINDSôOFôCOMMUNICATIONSôTHATôMIGHTôHAPPENôHERE

!TôTHEôBOTTOMôOFôTHESEôTHREE ôTHEREôISôTHEôPHYSICALôLAYERômôTHEô WIRESôTHATôCONNECTôTHEôPHONESôORôTHEôCOMPUTERSôTHEôCABLEô ACROSSôWHICHôTELEVISIONôMIGHTôBEôBROADCASTôABOVEôTHAT ôTHEô LOGICALôLAYERômôTHEôSYSTEMôTHATôCONTROLSôWHOôGETSôACCESSôTOô WHAT ôORôWHATôGETSôTOôRUNôWHEREôANDôABOVEôTHAT ôTHEôCONTENTô LAYERômôTHEôSTUFFôTHATôGETSôSAIDôORôWRITTENôWITHINôANYôGIVENôSYS TEMôOFôCOMMUNICATION


0240_057_self_org.indd 110-111

ô

-ADISONô3QUAREô'ARDEN

ô

.EWô9ORKô#ITYSôARENA ô-ADISONô3QUAREô'ARDEN ôISôANOTHERôPLACEô WHEREôPEOPLEôGIVEôSPEECHESô"UTô-ADISONô3QUAREô'ARDENôISôOWNEDô /NLYôTHOSEôWHOôPAYôGETôTOôUSEôTHEôAUDITORIUMôANDôTHEô'ARDENôISôNOTô OBLIGATEDôTOôTAKEôALLôCOMERSô4HEôPHYSICALôLAYERôISôTHEREFOREôCONTROLLEDô "UTôLIKEô3PEAKERSô#ORNER ôBOTHôTHEôLOGICALôLAYERôOFôTHEôLANGUAGEôANDô


25/09/06 17:40:45

THEôCONTENTôTHATôGETSôUTTEREDôISôNOTôCONTROLLEDôINôTHEôCONTEXTôOFôTHEô 'ARDENô4HEYôTOOôREMAINôFREE ô

4HEô4ELEPHONEô3YSTEM

ô

"EFOREôTHEôBREAKUP ôTHEôTELEPHONEôSYSTEMôINôTHEô5NITEDô3TATESôWASô AôSINGLE UNITARYôSYSTEMô4HEôPHYSICALôINFRASTRUCTUREôOFôTHISôSYSTEMô WASôOWNEDôBYô!44ôSOôTOOôWASôTHEôLOGICALôINFRASTRUCTURE ôWHICHôDE

ZEROôCOST ôBUT ôIFôTHEREôISôAôCOST ôITôISôAôNEUTRALLYôIMPOSEDôORô EQUALLYôIMPOSEDôCOST .EWô9ORKSô#ENTRALô0ARKôISôAôCOMMONSôANôEXTRAORDINARYôRE SOURCEôOFôPEACEFULNESSôINôTHEôCENTERôOFôAôCITYôTHATôISôANYTHINGô BUTôANôESCAPEôANDôREFUGEôTHATôANYONEôCANôTAKEôANDôUSEôWITH OUTôTHEôPERMISSIONôOFôANYONEôELSE

TERMINEDôHOWôANDôTOôWHOMôYOUôCOULDôCONNECTô"UTôWHATôYOUôSAIDôONô ANô!44ôPHONEôWITHINôLIMITSôATôLEAST ôWASôFREEô4HEôCONTENTôOFôTHEô TELEPHONEôCONVERSATIONSôWASôNOTôCONTROLLED ôEVENôIFôTHEôPHYSICALôANDô LOGICALôLAYERôUNDERNEATHôWERE ô

#ABLEô46

ô

&INALLY ôTHINKôOFôCABLEô46ô(EREôTHEôPHYSICALôLAYERôISôOWNEDôINôTHEôFORMô OFôTHEôWIRESôTHATôRUNôTHEôCONTENTôINTOôYOURôHOUSEô4HEôLOGICALôLAYERôISô OWNEDômôONLYôTHEôCABLEôCOMPANIESôGETôTOôDECIDEôWHATôRUNSôINTOôYOURô HOUSEô!NDôTHEôCONTENTôLAYERôISôOWNEDômôTHEôSHOWSôTHATôGETôBROADCASTô

4HEôPUBLICôSTREETSôAREôAôCOMMONSôONôNOôONESôSCHEDULEôBUTô YOURôOWN ôYOUôENTERôTHEôPUBLICôSTREETS ôANDôGOôINôANYôDIREC TIONôYOUôWISHô9OUôCANôTURNôOFFôOFô"ROADWAYôONTOô&IFTY SECONDô 3TREETôATôANYôTIME ôWITHOUTôAôCERTIkCATEôORôAUTHORIZATIONôFROMô THEôGOVERNMENT &ERMATSô,ASTô4HEOREMôISôAôCOMMONSôAôCHALLENGEôTHATôANYONEô COULDôPICKôUPôANDôCOMPLETE ôASô!NDREWô7ILES ôAFTERôAôLIFETIMEô OFôSTRUGGLE ôDID

AREôCOPYRIGHTEDôSHOWSô!LLôTHREEôLAYERSôAREôWITHINôTHEôCONTROLôOFôTHEô CABLEô46ôCOMPANYôNOôCOMMUNICATIONSôLAYER ôINô0ROFESSORô"ENKLERSô SENSE ôREMAINSôFREE

4HISôTHENôISôTHEôRANGEô!ôCOMMUNICATIONSôSYSTEM ôANDôHENCE ô AôSYSTEMôFORôINNOVATION ôCOULDôBEôANYôOFôTHEôFOUR ôOR ôOFôCOURSE ô MOREôTHANôTHESEôFOURô"UTôTHESEôFOURôSETôTHEôRANGEôTHATôWILLôBESTô HELPôUSôUNDERSTANDôAôVERYôSPECIkCôEXAMPLEô4HEô)NTERNET

/PENôSOURCE ôORôFREEôSOFTWARE ôISôAôCOMMONSôTHEôSOURCEôCODEô OFô,INUX ôFORôEXAMPLE ôLIESôAVAILABLEôFORôANYONEôTOôTAKE ôTOôUSE ôTOô IMPROVE ôTOôADVANCEô.OôPERMISSIONôISôNECESSARYôNOôAUTHORIZA TIONôMAYôBEôREQUIRED

"YôAôCOMMONSô)ôMEANôAôRESOURCEôTHATôISôFREEô.OTôNECESSARILYô

4HESEôAREôCOMMONSôBECAUSEôTHEYôAREôWITHINôTHEôREACHôOFô MEMBERSôOFôTHEôRELEVANTôCOMMUNITYôWITHOUTôTHEôPERMISSIONô OFôANYONEôELSEô4HEYôAREôRESOURCESôTHATôAREôPROTECTEDôBYôAôLI ABILITYôRULEôRATHERôTHANôAôPROPERTYôRULEô0ROFESSORô2EICHMAN ôFORô EXAMPLE ôHASôSUGGESTEDôTHATôSOMEôINNOVATIONôBEôPROTECTEDô BYôAôLIABILITYôRULEôRATHERôTHANôAôPROPERTYôRULEô4HEôPOINTôISôNOTô THATôNOôCONTROLôISôPRESENT ôBUTôRATHERôTHATôTHEôKINDôOFôCONTROLôISô DIFFERENTôFROMôTHEôCONTROLôWEôGRANTôTOôPROPERTY 4HEô)NTERNETôISôAôCOMMUNICATIONôSYSTEMô)TôTOOôHASôTHESEôTHREEô


)TôISôCOMMONPLACEôTOôTHINKôABOUTôTHEô)NTERNETôASôAôKINDôOFôCOM MONSô)TôISôLESSôCOMMONPLACEôTOôACTUALLYôHAVEôANôIDEAôWHATôAô COMMONSôIS


0240_057_self_org.indd 112-113

25/09/06 17:40:45

&REEô3HOP $ESCRIPTION 'OODSôINôANôEXISTINGôSHOPôAREôFREEôTOôTAKEômôATôUNANNOUNCEDôTIMES 4EXT !NYôMERCHANDISEôTHEôCUSTOMERôPURCHASESôISôFREEô &REEôSHOPôTAKESôPLACEôOCCASIONALLY &ORôMOREôINFORMATION -OREôINFOôWWWSUPERlEXNETPROJECTSFREESHOP 4HEôPROJECTôWASôPRESENTEDôATôTHEôFOLLOWINGôVENUES mô .OBODYôISôANôISLAND ô'!+ ô"REMEN ô'ERMANY môô (APPINESS ô-ORIô!RTô-USEUM ô4OKYO ô*APAN môô 4HEôPARALLELôACTION ôPUBLICôPROJECTôINô#IESZYN ô0OLANDôANDô#ZECHô2EPUBLIC

0240_057_self_org.indd 114-115

%XAMPLESôôYôô#OBBñ0ELM

25/09/06 17:40:47

LAYERSô!TôTHEôBOTTOM ôTHEôPHYSICALôLAYER ôAREôWIRESôANDôCOMPUT ERS ôANDôWIRESôLINKINGôCOMPUTERSô4HESEôRESOURCESôAREôOWNEDô 4HEôOWNERSôHAVEôCOMPLETEôCONTROLôOVERôWHATôTHEYôDOôWITHôTHEIRô WIRESôORôCOMPUTERS ôORôWIRESôLINKINGôCOMPUTERSô0ROPERTYôGOV ERNSôTHISôLAYER /NôTOPôOFôTHEôPHYSICALôLAYERôISôAôLOGICALôLAYERômôTHEôPROTOCOLSô THATôMAKEôTHEô.ETôRUNô4HESEôPROTOCOLSôAREôMANY ôALLôCHUCKEDô INTOôAôSINGLEôBOXôCALLEDô4#0)0ô4HEIRôESSENCEôISôAôSYSTEMôFORô EXCHANGINGôDATAGRAMS ôBUTôWEôMISSôSOMETHINGôIMPORTANTôABOUTô THEôSYSTEMôIFôWEôFOCUSôEXCLUSIVELYôONôTHEôESSENCE &ORôATôTHEôCOREôOFôTHISôLOGICALôLAYERôISôAôPRINCIPLEôOFôNETWORKôDE SIGNô!TôTHEôCOREôOFôTHEô)NTERNETSôDESIGNôISôANôIDEALôCALLEDôgEND TO ENDuôEE ô&IRSTôARTICULATEDôBYôNETWORKôARCHITECTSô*EROMEô 3ALTZER ô$AVIDô2EED ôANDô$AVIDô#LARK ôEEôSAYSôTOôBUILDôTHEô NETWORKôSOôTHATôINTELLIGENCEôRESTSôINôTHEôENDS ôANDôTHEôNETWORKô ITSELFôREMAINSôSIMPLEô3IMPLEôNETWORKS ôSMARTôAPPLICATIONS

4HISôMEANSôTHATôTHISôLAYERôOFôTHISôNETWORKômôTHISôFEATUREôOFô THEôNETWORKôTHATôDISTINGUISHEDôITôFROMôALLôTHATôHADôBEENôBUILTô BEFOREômôBUILTôTHISôNETWORKôINTOôAôCOMMONSô/NEôWASôFREEô TOôGETôACCESSôTOôTHISôNETWORKôANDôSHAREôITSôRESOURCESô4HEô PROTOCOLSôWEREôDESIGNEDôFORôSHARING ôNOTôEXCLUSIVEôUSEô$IS CRIMINATION ôWHICHôLIESôATôTHEôHEARTôOFôAôPROPERTYôSYSTEM ôWASô NOTôPOSSIBLEôINôEEô4HISôSYSTEMôWASôCODEDôTOôBEôFREEô4HATô WASôITSôNATURE 4HUS ôONôTOPôOFôAôPHYSICALôLAYERôTHATôISôCONTROLLEDôRESTSôAôLOGICALô LAYERôTHATôISôFREEô!NDôTHEN ôONôTOPôOFôTHISôFREEôLAYERôISôAôCONTENTô LAYERôTHATôISôBOTHôFREEôANDôCONTROLLED 4HEôFREEôPARTôISôALLôOFôTHEôCONTENTôTHATôEFFECTIVELYôRESTSôINôTHEô PUBLICôDOMAINô4HEôFACTS ôDATA ôABANDONEDôPROPERTY ôUNDISCOV EREDôTHEFTômôTHISôISôTHEôCONTENTôTHATôISôOPENôFORôTHEôTAKINGôANDô THATôISôTAKENôOPENLYô"UTôITôALSOôINCLUDESôAôPARTôDEDICATEDôTOôBEô OPENôOPENôSOURCEôORôFREEôSOFTWARE ôDEDICATEDôTOôBEôFREE

4HEôREASONôFORôTHISôDESIGNôWASôSIMPLEô7ITHôEE ôINNOVA TIONôONôTHEô)NTERNETôDIDNTôDEPENDôUPONôTHEôNETWORKô.EWô CONTENTôORôNEWôAPPLICATIONSôCOULDôRUNôREGARDLESSôOFôWHETHERô THEôNETWORKôKNEWôABOUTôTHEMô.EWôCONTENTôORôNEWôAPPLICA TIONSôWOULDôRUNôBECAUSEôTHEôNETWORKôSIMPLYôTOOKôPACKETSôOFô DATAôANDôMOVEDôTHEMôALONGô4HEôFUNDAMENTALôFEATUREôOFôTHISô NETWORKôDESIGNôWASôNEUTRALITYôAMONGôPACKETSô4HEôNETWORKô WASôSIMPLE ôORôgSTUPID uôINô$AVIDô)SENBERGSôSENSE ôANDôTHEô CONSEQUENCEôOFôSTUPIDITY ôATôLEASTôAMONGôCOMPUTERS ôISôTHEô INABILITYôTOôDISCRIMINATEô)NNOVATORSôTHUSôKNEWôTHAT ôIFôTHEIRô IDEASôWEREôWANTED ôTHEôNETWORKôWOULDôRUNôTHEMôTHATôTHISô NETWORKôWASôARCHITECTEDôNEVERôTOôALLOWôANYONEôTOôDECIDEô WHATôWOULDôBEôALLOWED

4HISôFREEôRESOURCEôDOESôMOREôTHANôENTERTAIN ôORôBUILDôCULTUREô THISôFREEôRESOURCEôTEACHESôTHEôWORLDôABOUTôHOWôTHEô.ETôFUNC TIONS ôORôISôFREEô&ORôEXAMPLE ôEVERYôWEBôPAGEôBOTHôDISPLAYSô ANDôCARRIESôITSôSOURCE ôSOôTHATôITSôSOURCEôCANôBEôCOPIEDôANDô MODIkEDôFORôDIFFERENTôDISPLAYS



0240_057_self_org.indd 116-117

4HISôFREEôCONTENTôCOEXISTSôWITHôCONTENTôTHATôISôCONTROLLEDô3OFT WAREôTHATôISôSOLDôDIGITALôCONTENTômôMUSIC ôMOVIES ôGREETINGô CARDSômôTHATôISôCONTROLLEDô9OUôCANôLINKôTOôMPCOMôANDôLISTENô TOôMUSICôTHATôISôFREEôYOUôCANôLINKôTOôAMAZONCOMôANDôREADôAô BOOKôTHATôISôCONTROLLEDô4HEôNETWORKôDOESNTôCAREôMUCHôABOUTô WHATôLINKINGôOCCURSô)TSôNEUTRALôAMONGôTHEôLINKING ôANDôTHEôRE SULTôOFôTHISôNEUTRALITYôISôAôMIX

25/09/06 17:40:47

'RAMEENô"ANK $ESCRIPTION -ICROkNANCEôINITIATIVEôINô"ANGLADESH ôFOUNDEDôINô ôANDôALMOSTôWHOLLYôOWNEDô BYôITSôBORROWERS 4EXT 'RAMEENô"ANKô'" ôHASôREVERSEDôCONVENTIONALôBANKINGôPRACTICEôBYôREMOVINGôTHEô NEEDôFORôCOLLATERALôANDôCREATEDôAôBANKINGôSYSTEMôBASEDôONôMUTUALôTRUST ôACCOUNT ABILITY ôPARTICIPATIONôANDôCREATIVITYô'"ôPROVIDESôCREDITôTOôTHEôPOORESTôOFôTHEôPOORôINô RURALô"ANGLADESH ôWITHOUTôANYôCOLLATERALô!Tô'" ôCREDITôISôAôCOSTôEFFECTIVEôWEAPONôTOô kGHTôPOVERTYôANDôITôSERVESôASôAôCATALYSTôINôTHEôOVERôALLôDEVELOPMENTôOFôSOCIO ECONOMICô CONDITIONSôOFôTHEôPOORôWHOôHAVEôBEENôKEPTôOUTSIDEôTHEôBANKINGôORBITôONôTHEôGROUNDô THATôTHEYôAREôPOORôANDôHENCEôNOTôBANKABLEô0ROFESSORô-UHAMMADô9UNUS ôTHEôFOUNDERô OFôg'RAMEENô"ANKuôANDôITSô-ANAGINGô$IRECTOR ôREASONEDôTHATôIFôkNANCIALôRESOURCESôCANô BEôMADEôAVAILABLEôTOôTHEôPOORôPEOPLEôONôTERMSôANDôCONDITIONSôTHATôAREôAPPROPRIATEô ANDôREASONABLE ôgTHESEôMILLIONSôOFôSMALLôPEOPLEôWITHôTHEIRôMILLIONSôOFôSMALLôPURSUITSô CANôADDôUPôTOôCREATEôTHEôBIGGESTôDEVELOPMENTôWONDERu "REAKINGôTHEôVICIOUSôCYCLEôOFôPOVERTYôTHROUGHôMICROCREDIT 4HEô'RAMEENô"ANKôISôBASEDôONôTHEôVOLUNTARYôFORMATIONôOFôSMALLôGROUPSôOFôkVEôPEOPLEô TOôPROVIDEôMUTUAL ôMORALLYôBINDINGôGROUPôGUARANTEESôINôLIEUôOFôTHEôCOLLATERALôREQUIREDô BYôCONVENTIONALôBANKSô!TôkRSTôONLYôTWOôMEMBERSôOFôAôGROUPôAREôALLOWEDôTOôAPPLYôFORô AôLOANô$EPENDINGôONôTHEIRôPERFORMANCEôINôREPAYMENTôTHEôNEXTôTWOôBORROWERSôCANô THENôAPPLYôAND ôSUBSEQUENTLY ôTHEôkFTHôMEMBERôASôWELL ô

4HEôASSUMPTIONôISôTHATôIFôINDIVIDUALôBORROWERSôAREôGIVENôACCESSôTOôCREDIT ôTHEYô

WILLôBEôABLEôTOôIDENTIFYôANDôENGAGEôINôVIABLEôINCOME GENERATINGôACTIVITIESômôSIMPLEô PROCESSINGôSUCHôASôPADDYôHUSKING ôLIME MAKING ôMANUFACTURINGôSUCHôASôPOTTERY ô WEAVING ôANDôGARMENTôSEWING ôSTORAGEôANDôMARKETINGôANDôTRANSPORTôSERVICESô7OMENô WEREôINITIALLYôGIVENôEQUALôACCESSôTOôTHEôSCHEMES ôANDôPROVEDôNOTôONLYôRELIABLEôBOR ROWERSôBUTôASTUTEôENTERPRENEURSô!SôAôRESULT ôTHEYôHAVEôRAISEDôTHEIRôSTATUS ôLESSENEDô THEIRôDEPENDENCYôONôTHEIRôHUSBANDSôANDôIMPROVEDôTHEIRôHOMESôANDôTHEôNUTRITIONALô STANDARDSôOFôTHEIRôCHILDRENô4ODAYôOVERôôPERCENTôOFôBORROWERSôAREôWOMEN ô

)NTENSIVEôDISCIPLINE ôSUPERVISION ôANDôSERVICINGôCHARACTERIZEôTHEôOPERATIONSôOFôTHEô

'RAMEENô"ANK ôWHICHôAREôCARRIEDôOUTôBYôg"ICYCLEôBANKERSuôINôBRANCHôUNITSôWITHôCON SIDERABLEôDELEGATEDôAUTHORITYô4HEôRIGOROUSôSELECTIONôOFôBORROWERSôANDôTHEIRôPROJECTSô BYôTHESEôBANKôWORKERS ôTHEôPOWERFULôPEERôPRESSUREôEXERTEDôONôTHESEôINDIVIDUALSôBYô THEôGROUPS ôANDôTHEôREPAYMENTôSCHEMEôBASEDôONôôWEEKLYôINSTALLMENTS ôCONTRIBUTEô TOôOPERATIONALôVIABILITYôTOôTHEôRURALôBANKINGôSYSTEMôDESIGNEDôFORôTHEôPOORô3AVINGSô HAVEôALSOôBEENôENCOURAGEDô5NDERôTHEôSCHEME ôTHEREôISôPROVISIONôFORôôPERCENTôOFô LOANSôTOôBEôCREDITEDôTOôAôGROUPôkNDôANDô4KôôISôCREDITEDôEVERYôWEEKôTOôTHEôFUND ô

4HEôSUCCESSôOFôTHISôAPPROACHôSHOWSôTHATôAôNUMBERôOFôOBJECTIONSôTOôLENDINGôTOô

THEôPOORôCANôBEôOVERCOMEôIFôCAREFULôSUPERVISIONôANDôMANAGEMENTôAREôPROVIDEDô&ORô

%XAMPLESôôYôô$O>JBBKñ>KH

0240_057_self_org.indd 118-119

25/09/06 17:40:49

EXAMPLE ôITôHADôEARLIERôBEENôTHOUGHTôTHATôTHEôPOORôWOULDôNOTôBEôABLEôTOôkNDôRENU MERATIVEôOCCUPATIONSô)NôFACT ô'RAMEENôBORROWERSôHAVEôSUCCESSFULLYôDONEôSOô)TôWASô THOUGHTôTHATôTHEôPOORôWOULDôNOTôBEôABLEôTOôREPAYôINôFACT ôREPAYMENTôRATESôREACHEDô ôPERCENTô)TôWASôTHOUGHTôTHATôPOORôRURALôWOMENôINôPARTICULARôWEREôNOTôBANKABLEôINô FACT ôTHEYôACCOUNTEDôFORôôPERCENTôOFôBORROWERSôINôEARLYôô)TôWASôALSOôTHOUGHTô THATôTHEôPOORôCANNOTôSAVEôINôFACT ôGROUPôSAVINGSôHAVEôPROVENôASôSUCCESSFULôASôGROUPô LENDINGô)TôWASôTHOUGHTôTHATôRURALôPOWERôSTRUCTURESôWOULDôMAKEôSUREôTHATôSUCHôAôBANKô FAILEDôBUTôTHEô'RAMEENô"ANKôHASôBEENôABLEôTOôEXPANDôRAPIDLYô)NDEED ôFROMôFEWERôTHANô ôBORROWERSôINô ôTHEôMEMBERSHIPôHADôGROWNôTOôNEARLYô ôBYôMID ô "YôTHEôENDôOFô ôTHEôNUMBERôOFôBRANCHESôINôOPERATIONôWASô ôWITHôôMILLIONô MEMBERSôôMILLIONôOFôTHEMôWOMEN ôINô ôVILLAGESô4HEREôAREô ôCENTRESôOFô GROUPS ôOFôWHICHô ôAREôWOMENô'ROUPôSAVINGSôHAVEôREACHEDô ôMILLIONôTAKAô APPROXIMATELYô53$ôôMILLION ôOUTôOFôWHICHôôMILLIONôTAKAôAPPROXIMATELYô53$ô ôMILLION ôAREôSAVEDôBYôWOMEN ô

)TôISôESTIMATEDôTHATôTHEôAVERAGEôHOUSEHOLDôINCOMEôOFô'RAMEENô"ANKôMEMBERSôISô

ABOUTôôPERCENTôHIGHERôTHANôTHEôTARGETôGROUPôINôTHEôCONTROLôVILLAGE ôANDôôPERCENTô HIGHERôTHANôTHEôTARGETôGROUPôNON MEMBERSôINô'RAMEENô"ANKôVILLAGESô4HEôLANDLESSô HAVEôBENEkTEDôMOST ôFOLLOWEDôBYôMARGINALôLANDOWNERSô4HISôHASôRESULTEDôINôAôSHARPô REDUCTIONôINôTHEôNUMBERôOFô'RAMEENô"ANKôMEMBERSôLIVINGôBELOWôTHEôPOVERTYôLINE ô ôPERCENTôCOMPAREDôTOôôPERCENTôFORôCOMPARABLEôNON 'RAMEENô"ANKôMEMBERSô 4HEREôHASôALSOôBEENôAôSHIFTôFROMôAGRICULTURALôWAGEôLABOURôCONSIDEREDôTOôBEôSOCIALLYô INFERIOR ôTOôSELF EMPLOYMENTôINôPETTYôTRADINGô3UCHôAôSHIFTôINôOCCUPATIONALôPATTERNSôHASô

4HIS ôTHEN ôISôAôPICTUREôOFôTHEôCOMPLEXITYôWEôCALLôTHEô)NTERNETôô !TôTHEôBOTTOMôISôAôPHYSICALôLAYERôTHATôISôCONTROLLEDôONôTOPôOFô ITôISôAôLOGICALôLAYERôTHATôISôFREEôANDôONôTOPôOFôBOTHôISôAôCONTENTô LAYERôTHATôMIXESôFREEôANDôCONTROLLED 4HISôCOMPLEXITYôBUILDSôAôCOMMONSô!NDôTHISôCOMMONSôHASô BEENôTHEôLOCATIONôOFôSOMEôOFôTHEôMOSTôEXTRAORDINARYôINNOVATIONô THATôWEôHAVEôSEENô.OTôINNOVATIONôINôJUSTôTHEôDOTCOMôSENSE ô BUTôINNOVATIONôINôTHEôWAYSôHUMANSôINTERACT ôINNOVATIONôINôTHEô WAYSôTHATôCULTUREôISôSPREAD ôANDôMOSTôIMPORTANTLY ôINNOVATIONô INôTHEôWAYSôINôWHICHôCULTUREôGETSôBUILTô4HEôINNOVATIONôOFôTHEô )NTERNETômôBUILTôINTOôITSôARCHITECTUREômôISôANôINNOVATIONôINôTHEô WAYSôINôWHICHôCULTUREôGETSôMADEô,ETôTHEôDOTCOMôERAôlAMEôOUTô )TôWONTôMATTERôTOôTHISôINNOVATIONôONEôBITô4HEôCRUCIALôFEATUREôOFô THISôNEWôSPACEôISôTHEôLOWôCOSTôOFôDIGITALôCREATION ôANDôTHEôLOWô COSTSôOFôDELIVERINGôWHATôGETSôCREATED

ANôINDIRECTôPOSITIVEôEFFECTôONôTHEôEMPLOYMENTôANDôWAGESôOFôOTHERôAGRICULTURALôWAGEDô LABOURERSô7HATôSTARTEDôASôANôINNOVATIVEôLOCALôINITIATIVE ôgAôSMALLôBUBBLEôOFôHOPEu ôHASô THUSôGROWNôTOôTHEôPOINTôWHEREôITôHASôMADEôANôIMPACTôONôPOVERTYôALLEVIATIONôATôTHEô NATIONALôLEVEL 3OURCE WWWGRAMEEN INFOORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWGRAMEEN INFOORGBANK'"'LANCEHTM

#LOSINGôCOMMUNICATIONôSYSTEMS .OWô)ôHAVEôDISSECTEDôTHISôCOMMONSôINTOôTHESEôLAYERSôTOôHELPô USôSEEôMOREôPRECISELYôJUSTôHOWôITôWILLôBEôENCLOSEDô3OôFARôMYô MESSAGEôHASôBEENôFAIRLYôBRIGHTôBUTôMYôBRANDôISôPESSIMISM ôANDô SOôWEôNEEDôAôGOODôDOLLOPôOFôDARKNESS !NDôTHEôFACTôIS ôDARKNESSôHEREôISôNOTôHARDôTOôkNDô&ORôTHOUGHô WEôHAVEôJUSTôBEGUNôTOôSEEôHOWôTHISôFREEDOMôFUNCTIONS ôWEôAREô QUICKLYôCOMINGôTOôSEEôHOWôTHISôFREEDOMôWILLôBEôREMOVEDô4HESEô LAYERSôMIXINGôTHEôFREEôANDôTHEôCONTROLLEDôAREôQUICKLYôBECOMINGô LAYERSôTHATôSIMPLYôMIXôDIFFERENTôKINDSôOFôCONTROL 7EôAREôINôTHEôMIDSTôOFôAôPROCESSôBYôWHICH ôTHROUGHôLAWôANDô

%XAMPLESôôYôô$O>JBBKñ>KH

0240_057_self_org.indd 120-121


25/09/06 17:40:49

THROUGHôTECHNOLOGY ôTHESEôFEATURESôOFôTHISôINITIALôARCHITECTUREôAREô CHANGINGô"ECAUSEôWEôBELIEVEôgTHEôWHOLEôWORLDôISôBESTôMAN AGEDôWHENôDIVIDEDôAMONGôPRIVATEôOWNERS uôWEôAREôCHANGINGô THEôARCHITECTUREôOFôTHEô.ETôTOôENABLEôITôTOôBEôDIVIDEDôANDôCON TROLLEDôBECAUSEôWEôBELIEVEôgTHEôWHOLEôWORLDôISôBESTôMANAGEDô WHENôDIVIDEDôAMONGôPRIVATEôOWNERS uôWEôAREôEXPANDINGôANDô REINFORCINGôCONTROLôOVERôCONTENTôTHROUGHô)0ôLAWôBECAUSEôWEô BELIEVE ôASôOURôIDEOLOGYôSAYS ôWEôAREôREMAKINGôTHEô)NTERNETôTOô kTôTHISôIDEOLOGYô7ITHOUTôEVENôPAUSINGôTOôUNDERSTANDôITôWITH OUTôTAKINGôAôMOMENTôTOôSEEôHOWôITôMIGHTôACTUALLYôWORKôWEôAREô MAPMAKERSôWHO ôUPONôkNDINGôTHATôTHEôCITYôDOESNTôQUITEôkTô OURôMAPômôANôEXTRAôBUILDINGôHERE ôANDôRIVERôWEôDIDNTôEXPECTô THEREômôPROCEEDôTOôREMAKEôTHEôCITYôTOôMAKEôSUREôITôkTSôTHEôMAP #ONSIDERôTHESEôREMAKINGS )ôSAIDôTHATôTHEôCOMMONSôTHATôFUELSôINNOVATIONôISôTHEôCOMMONSô THATôEXISTSôATôTHEôLOGICALôLAYERôOFôTHEô.ETô4HISôISôTHEôCOMMONSô CONSTITUTEDôBYôTHEôPRINCIPLEôOFôEND TO ENDôITôISôTHEôCOMMONSô THATôGETSôBUILTôBYôAôSETôOFôPROTOCOLSôTHATôDONTôDISCRIMINATEô)TôISô THEôNEUTRALôPLATFORMôUPONôWHICHôINNOVATIONôHAPPENSô!NDôTHISô NEUTRALITYôISôNEUTRALITYôBUILTôINTOôTHEôCODE "UTôTHISôCODEôISôNOTôGIVENô4HEôCODEôGOVERNINGôAôNETWORKôISô NOTôkXEDô4HEôCODEôTHATôGOVERNSôATôONEôTIMEôCOULDôBEôREPLACEDô BYôAôDIFFERENTôCODEôLATERôONô!NDôMOREôIMPORTANTLY ôTHEREôISô NOTHINGôTHATôFORCESôPEOPLEôWHOôCONNECTôTOôTHEô.ETôTOôOBEYô THEôNEUTRALITYôOFôTHEôNETô4HEREôISôNOôBRANDôCALLEDôgTHEô)NTERNETuô THATôCARRIESôWITHôITôAôSETôOFôASSUMPTIONSôABOUTôOPENNESSôANDô BALANCEôTHEREôISôINSTEADôAôBASICôSETôOFôPROTOCOLSôTHATôANYONEô ISôFREEôTOôSUPPLEMENTôWITHôPROTOCOLSôADDEDôONôTOP

CHANGINGôITô/NEôSUCHôEXAMPLEôISôTHEôPROVIDERSôOFôBROADBANDô SERVICES !SôTHEô)NTERNETôMOVESôFROMôTHEôTELEPHONESôFROMôMODEMSôANDô ôORôKôCONNECTIONS ôTOôBROADBAND ôTOôFAST ôALWAYS ONô CONNECTIONS ôTHEôPHYSICALôLAYERôACROSSôWHICHôTHEô)NTERNETôTRAV ELSôISôDIFFERENTô4HEôDOMINANTôTECHNOLOGYôTODAYôFORôSERVINGôTHISô BROADBANDôCONTENTôISôCABLE .OW ôASôCABLEôCONVERTSôTOôMAKEôITSELFôOPENôTOôTHEô)NTERNET ôITô ISôMODIFYINGôTHEôARCHITECTUREôOFôTHEô)NTERNETôINôANôIMPORTANTô WAYô7HILEôTHEôESSENCEôOFôTHEôCOMMONSôOFôTHEô)NTERNETôWASô NEUTRALITYôANDôSIMPLICITY ôTHEôESSENCEôOFôWHATôTHEôBROADBANDô CABLEô)NTERNETôWILLôBEôISôTHEôPOWERôTOôDISCRIMINATEôINôCONTENTô ANDôSERVICESô4HEôAIMôOFôTHISôFORMôOFô)NTERNETôACCESSôWILLôNOTôBEô OPENNESSôANDôNEUTRALôPLATFORMSôTHEôAIMôOFôTHISôFORMôOFô)NTERNETô ACCESSôWILLôBEôCONTROLôOVERôTHEôCONTENTôTHATôGETSôPLAYED &ORôEXAMPLEô#ABLEôCOMPANIESôMAKEôAôGREATôDEALôOFôMONEYô STREAMINGôVIDEOôTOôTELEVISIONôSETSô4HATôISôTHEôCOREôOFôTHEIRôLEG ACYôMONOPOLYôPOWERô3OMEôTHINKôITôWOULDôBEôUSEFULôTOôSTREAMô VIDEOôTOôCOMPUTERSô#ABLEôCOMPANIESôWEREôNOTôEAGERôTOôSEEô THISôFORMôOFôCOMPETITIONô3OôTHEYôIMPOSEDôRULESôONôBROADBANDô USERSômôNOôMOREôTHANôTENôMINUTESôOFôSTREAMINGôVIDEOôCOULDôBEô CONTRACTEDôFORôATôANYôTIMEô7HENôTHEYôWEREôSMART ôTHEYôSAIDô THEYôWEREôWORRIEDôABOUTôCONGESTIONô"UTôWHENôTHEYôWEREôHON ESTôTHEYôSAIDôSOMETHINGôDIFFERENTô$ANIELô3OMERS ôOFô!44 ôSAIDô THATôTHEôCOMPANYôDIDNTôSPENDôkFTY SIXôBILLIONôDOLLARSôONôAôCABLEô NETWORKôgTOôHAVEôTHEôBLOODôSUCKEDôOUTôOFôOURôVEIN;S=u

!NYONEôISôFREEôTOôCHANGEôIT ôANDôSOMEôIMPORTANTôPEOPLEôAREô

"ROADBANDôPROVIDERSôWILLôINSISTôTHATôTHISôCONTROLôISôTHEIRôRIGHTô môTHATôNOTHINGôSHOULDôINTERFEREôWITHôTHEIRôRIGHTôTOôLAYERôONTOôTHEô



0240_057_self_org.indd 122-123

25/09/06 17:40:50

FREEôLOGICALôLAYERôAôSYSTEMôOFôCONTROLô!NDôAôBUDDINGôLINEôOFô&IRSTô !MENDMENTôDOCTRINEôEMBRACEDôANDôPUSHEDôBYôJUDGESôINôTHEô 5NITEDô3TATESô#OURTôOFô!PPEALSôFORôTHEô$ISTRICTôOFô#OLUMBIAô #IRCUIT ôSTRONGLYôSUPPORTSôTHISôCLAIM

4HEôCONTENTô)ôWANTôTOôFOCUSôONôHEREôISôCONTROLLEDôBYôCOPYRIGHTô LAWô)DEAS ôOR ôMOREôPROPERLY ôINVENTIONS ôGETôCONTROLLEDôBYô PATENTôLAWôCONTEXT ôORôTHEôEXPRESSIONôOFôIDEAS ôISôREGULATEDô BYôCOPYRIGHT

4HESEôCASESôAREô"LADE 2UNNER ESQUEô2EMEMBERôTHATôONEô OFôTHEôMILLIONôAMAZINGôPUZZLESôINôTHATôEXTRAORDINARYôkLMôISôTHEô SLOWôRECOGNITIONôTHATôTHESEôMACHINESôAREôHUMANô7ELLôHEREô TOO ôWITHôTHEôCABLEôSYSTEM ôITôISôTHEôINCREASINGôRECOGNITIONôTHATô THESEôSYSTEMSôTOôDELIVERôELECTRICITYôAREôINôFACTô&IRSTô!MENDMENTô SPEAKERSô7IRESôPLUSôAôCERTAINôLOGICôPRODUCEôgTHEôPRESSuôANDô THENôINTOôTHEôMIXôCOMESôTHEô$ISTRICTôOFô#OLUMBIAô#IRCUITôEA GERôTOôBESTOWôONôTHISôPRESSôLONGôSTANDINGô&IRSTô!MENDMENTô POWER

#OPYRIGHTôLAWôHASôCHANGEDô#HANGEDô)NôTHEôSENSEôTHATôBE COMINGôANôOAKôTREEôISôAôCHANGEôOFôTHEôACORN ôMODERNôCOPYRIGHTô LAWôISôAôCHANGEôOVERôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôLAWôTHATôWAS

!NDôHENCEôWEôSHOULDôEXPECT ôASôTHEô)NTERNETôMOVESôTOôTHISô BROADBAND ôTHATôTHEôRULESôGOVERNINGôTHEôPROVIDERSôWILLôBEôDIF FERENTô5NLIKEôTHEôTELEPHONEôCOMPANY ôTHESEôPROVIDERSôWILLôBEô ALLOWEDôTOôDISCRIMINATEôANDôDISCRIMINATE ôTHEYôWILLôAND ôWHENô THEYôDO ôTHISôOPENôFEATUREôOFôTHEô)NTERNETôCOMMONSôWILLôBEô REMOVEDô%NCLOSEDô#HOPPEDôUPôANDôSOLDôOFFô7ITHôTHEôCON SEQUENCEôTHATôINNOVATIONôHEREôWILLôBEôDIFFERENT ô

7HENôTHEô5NITEDô3TATESôWASôFORMED ôTHEô#ONSTITUTIONôGAVEô #ONGRESSôTHEôPOWERôTOôGRANTôgAUTHORSuôEXCLUSIVEôRIGHTSôFORôTHEIRô gWRITINGSuôFORôAôgLIMITEDôTIMEuôTOômôASôTHEô#ONSTITUTIONôEXPRESSLYô STATESômôgPROMOTEôPROGRESSuô4HEô0ROMOTEô0ROGRESSô#LAUSEô ISôUNIQUEôINôTHEô#ONSTITUTIONSôENUMERATIONôOFôPOWERSômôEVERYô OTHERôCLAUSEôLEAVESôTHEôPURPOSEôUNSPECIkEDôONLYôTHISôCLAUSEô SPECIkESôFORôWHATôTHEôPOWERôMAYôBEôUSED

4HATSôAôCHANGEôATôTHEôLOGICALôLAYERômôORôMOREôPRECISELY ôAôSETô OFôCONTROLSôTHATôGETSôLAYEREDôONôATôTHEôLOGICALôLAYERô"UTôTHEô CHANGESôAREôNOTôJUSTôHEREô-OREôDRAMATIC ôLESSôJUSTIkED ôBUTô MOREôLIKELYôAREôCHANGESôATôTHEôCONTENTôLAYERô4HESEôAREôTHEô CHANGESôMOSTôREMARKEDôUPONôHEREô!NDôHENCEôTHESEôWILLôBEôAô BITôEASIERôTOôDESCRIBE

4HEôkRSTôFEDERALôCOPYRIGHTôSTATUTEôWASôENACTEDôINôô4HATô !CTôREGULATEDôTHEôgPRINTINGuôANDôgVENDINGuôOFôgMAP;S= ôCHART;S=ô ANDôôôôBOOK;S=uôFORôANôINITIALôTERMôOFôFOURTEENôYEARSô7HILEô INôPRINCIPLEôANYONEôCOULDôVIOLATEôTHEôEXCLUSIVEôRIGHTôTOôVEND ô INô ôTHEREôWEREôONLYôôPRINTINGôESTABLISHMENTSôINôTHEô 5NITEDô3TATESô#OPYRIGHTôWASôNOTôAUTOMATICôREGISTRATIONôWASô REQUIREDôMOSTôOFôTHEôEARLYôREGISTRATIONSôWEREôFORôSCIENTIkCôORôIN STRUCTIONALôTEXTSô"ETWEENôôANDô ô ôTITLESôWEREô PUBLISHEDôINô!MERICA ôBUTôONLYôôCOPYRIGHTôREGISTRATIONSôWEREô kLEDô-OREôTHANôôOFôPUBLISHEDôWORKôTHEREFOREôFELLôIMME DIATELYôINTOôTHEôPUBLICôDOMAINômôINCLUDING ôOFôCOURSE ôôOFô FOREIGNôWORKô/URôOUTRAGEôATô#HINESEôPIRACYôNOTWITHSTANDING ô WEôSHOULDôNOTôFORGETôTHATôUNTILô ôFOREIGNôCOPYRIGHTSôWEREô NOTôPROTECTEDôINô!MERICAô7EôWEREôBORN ôINôOTHERôWORDS ôAô PIRATEôNATION


#ONTROLLINGôCOMMUNICATIONôSYSTEMS


0240_057_self_org.indd 124-125

25/09/06 17:40:50

)THACAô(OURS $ESCRIPTION !ôLOCALôCURRENCYôINô)THACA ô.EWô9ORK 4EXT g)Nô)THACAô7Eô4RUSTu )THACAô(OURSôISôAôLOCALôCURRENCYôSYSTEMôTHATôPROMOTESôLOCALôECONOMICôSTRENGTHôANDô COMMUNITYôSELF RELIANCEôINôWAYSôWHICHôWILLôSUPPORTôECONOMICôANDôSOCIALôJUSTICE ô ECOLOGY ôCOMMUNITYôPARTICIPATIONôANDôHUMANôASPIRATIONSôINôANDôAROUNDô)THACA ô.EWô 9ORKô)THACAô(OURSôHELPôTOôKEEPôMONEYôLOCAL ôBUILDINGôTHEô)THACAôECONOMYô)TôALSOô BUILDSôCOMMUNITYôPRIDEôANDôCONNECTIONSô/VERôôPARTICIPANTSôPUBLICLYôACCEPTô)THACAô (/523ôFORôGOODSôANDôSERVICESô!DDITIONALLYôSOMEôLOCALôEMPLOYERSôANDôEMPLOYEESô HAVEôAGREEDôTOôPAYôORôRECEIVEôPARTIALôWAGESôINô)THACAô(OURS ôFURTHERôCONTINUINGôOURô GOALôOFôKEEPINGôMONEYôLOCAL 7HYô3HOULDô)ô*OINô )FôYOUôHAVEôAôBUSINESSôORôPROVIDEôAôSERVICEôTHEREôAREôTHREEôMAINôREASONSôTOôJOINôTHEô(/523ô NETWORK )TSôGOODôFORôYOURôBUSINESSômôBEINGôLISTEDôINôTHEôPRINTôVERSIONôOFôTHEô(/523ô$IRECTORYô ANDôONôTHEô(/523ôWEBSITEôPROVIDESôADDITIONALôCUSTOMERSôWHOôHAVEô(/523ôTOôSPENDô ANDôAREôLOOKINGôFORôBUSINESSESôTHATôTAKEôTHEMô)TôSUPPORTSôTHEôLOCALôECONOMYômôUNLIKEô DOLLARSô(/523ôKEEPSôMONEYôINôTHEôCOMMUNITYôTOôBUILDôOURôLOCALôECONOMY ô

)TôPAYSôFORôITSELFôIMMEDIATELYômôYOUôPAYôôFORôAôSINGLEôLISTINGôINôTHEô$IRECTORYôANDô

WEôIMMEDIATELYôGIVEôYOUôô(/523 ôWORTHôôô(/523ôIFôYOUôJOINôORôRENEWôATôOURô !NNUALô-EETING ô4HEôMAINôCONCERNôAôBUSINESSôOFTENôHASôWHENôCONSIDERINGôACCEPTINGô (/523ôISôWHATôWILLô)ôDOôWITHôTHEô(/523ô)ôGETôFROMôCUSTOMERSôORôCLIENTSô4HEôkRSTô THINGôTOôNOTEôISôTHATôYOUôDECIDEôWHATôRATEôOFô(/523ôYOUôWILLôACCEPTôFORôPURCHASESôORô SERVICESô3OMEôMEMBERôBUSINESSESôACCEPTôô(/523ôBUTôMANYôLIMITôTHEô(/523ô THEYôWILLôACCEPTô ô

9OUôSHOULDôCALCULATEôAôRATEôOFô(/523ôTHATôISôPROPORTIONALôTOôYOURôABILITYôTOôPUTôTHEMô

BACKôINTOôTHEôLOCALôECONOMYô)NôTHINKINGôABOUTôTHISôYOUôMAYôBEôSURPRISEDôTOôLEARNôTHATô INôFACTôTHEREôAREôMANYôOUTLETSôFORôTHEôUSEôOFô(/523ô)FôYOUôLOOKôINôTHEô$IRECTORYôYOUô WILLôkNDôMANYôOTHERôPLACESôYOUôCANôEASILYôSPENDô(/523ô/RôWRITEôUSôFORôHELPôMAILTO INFO ITHACAHOURSORGô ô

)FôYOUôDONTôSELLôANYôGOODSôORôSERVICESôTHEREôAREôSTILLôGOODôREASONSôTOôJOINô)THACAô

(/523ô)THACAô(/523ôISôOURôLOCALôCURRENCYô)TôKEEPSôMONEYôLOCAL ôBUILDINGôOURôLOCALô ECONOMYô)TôBUILDSôCOMMUNITYôPRIDEôANDôCONNECTIONSô!NDôYOUôWILLôBEôPARTICIPATINGôINô THEôOLDESTôANDôLARGESTôLOCALôCURRENCYôSYSTEMôINôTHEô53ô )TSôALSOôFUNôTOôGETôANDôUSEôSOMETHINGôOTHERôTHANôDOLLARSôREMEMBERôHOWôMUCHôYOUô ENJOYEDôORôSTILLôENJOYôUSINGôMONOPOLYôMONEY ôANDôUNLIKEôMONOPOLYôMONEYô)THACAô (/523ôREALLYôAREôACCEPTEDôJUSTôTHEôSAMEôASô53ôDOLLARSôATôHUNDREDSôOFô)THACA

0240_057_self_org.indd 126-127

%XAMPLESôôYôô&QE>@>ñ%LROP

25/09/06 17:40:51

AREAôMERCHANTSôANDôSERVICEôPROVIDERSô"UTôUNLIKEô53ôDOLLARSôWHENôYOUôSPENDôANô (/52ôYOUôKNOWôITôISôGOINGôTOôSTAYôINôOURôCOMMUNITY ôKEEPôCIRCULATING ôSUPPORTINGôOURô ECONOMYôANDôMAYBEôEVENôENDôUPôRIGHTôBACKôINôYOURôPOCKETô!NDôALSOôUNLIKEôDOLLARSô THISôISôYOURôSYSTEMô9OUôCANôGETôTOôKNOWôTHEôPEOPLEôWHOôRUNôTHEôSYSTEMô(/523ô "OARDôOFô$IRECTORS ôASôWELLôASôTHOSEôBUSINESSôPEOPLEôTHATôACCEPTô(/523 ôANDôYOUô CANôEVENôHELPôMAKEôTHEôDECISIONSôWHICHôMAKEôTHEôSYSTEMôRUNôBYôATTENDINGôTHEô!N NUALô-EETING ôELECTINGôANDôTALKINGôWITHôMEMBERSôOFôTHEô"OARD ôORôEVENôRUNNINGôFORôAô SEATôONôTHEô"OARDôYOURSELF (OWôCANô)ôPARTICIPATE )THACAô(/523ô/FFERSô"USINESSô,OANSôATô.Oô)NTERESTô)NDIVIDUALSôORôBUSINESSESôWHOô AREôMEMBERSôOFô)THACAô(/523ôAREôELIGIBLEôTOôAPPLYôFORôBUSINESSôLOANSô4HESEôLOANSô AREôMADEôINô(/523ôWITHôANôAMAZINGôRATEôOFôôINTERESTô !PPLICANTSôFORôLOANSôMUSTôSUBMITôAôLETTERôOUTLININGôTHEôFOLLOWING ôô4HEôSIZEôOFôTHEôBUSINESSôLOANôYOUôAREôREQUESTING ôô4HEôWAYôTHEô(/523ôWILLôBEôSPENTôLOANSôSHOULDôBEôSPENTôWITHINô ô

SIXôMONTHSôOFôRECEIPT

ôô(OWôTHEôAPPLICANTôEXPECTSôTOôBEôABLEôTOôREPAYôTHEôLOAN ôô!ôPROPOSEDôLOANôREPAYMENTôSCHEDULE ôATôôINTEREST ôWITHô ô

REPAYMENTôWITHINôONEôYEAR

ôô4HEôNAMEôOFôTHEôINDIVIDUALôPERSONALLYôRESPONSIBLEôFORôREPAYINGô ô

THEôLOAN

4HUSôTHEôLAWôWASôSLIGHT ôASôWASôTHEôACTUALôSCOPEôOFôPROTECTIONô #OPYRIGHTôDIDôNOTôPROTECTôDERIVATIVEôWORKSôYOUôCOULDôTRANSLATEô ORôADAPTôORôABRIDGEôORôSETôTOôSONGôCOPYRIGHTEDôWORKS ôWITH OUTôTHEôPERMISSIONôOFôTHEôAUTHORô4HEôMONOPOLYôRIGHTSôTHATôTHEô ôSTATUTEôGRANTEDôWEREôESSENTIALLYôPROTECTIONSôAGAINSTôPIRATEô PRESSESô4HEôTARGETôOFôTHEôREGULATIONôWASôTHEôPRESSôTHATôWOULDô TAKEôANô!MERICANôAUTHORSôBOOKôANDôSIMPLYôREPRODUCEôITôWITHOUTô COMPENSATIONôTOôTHEôORIGINALôAUTHORô4HESEôPIRATEôPRESSESôWEREô TOôFOCUSôTHEIRôENERGYôONôSTEALINGôFROMôTHEô"RITISHôANDô&RENCHô !MERICANSôWEREôTOôBEôEXEMPTEDôFROMôTHEôPIRATEôTRADE #OPYRIGHTôHASôCHANGEDô)TôNOôLONGERôISôLIMITEDôTOôMAPS ôCHARTSô ANDôBOOKSô)TôNOWôTOUCHESôPRACTICALLYôANYôCREATIVEôWORKôRE DUCEDôTOôAôTANGIBLEôFORMô)TôPROTECTSôMUSIC ôANDôPERFORMANCES ô ANDôARCHITECTURE ôANDôCERTAINôDESIGNô)TôPROTECTSôMACHINESôWRIT TENôINôWORDSômôWEôCALLôTHATôSOFTWAREômôANDôWORDSôWRITTENôONô MACHINESômôWEôCALLôTHATôTHEô)NTERNET

ôô2EFERENCES ,OANôAPPLICATIONSôWILLôBEôEVALUATEDôONôTHEôCOMPLETENESSôOFôTHEôAPPLICATIONôABILITYô TOôREPAYôTHEôLOANôABILITYôTOôSPENDôTHEô(/523ôINôDIVERSEôWAYSôWITHINôTHEôCOMMUNITYô ANDôTHEôEXTENTôTOôWHICHôTHEôPROPOSEDôACTIVITYôWILLôSUPPORTôORôSTIMULATEôENTREPRENEUR SHIPôANDôOPPORTUNITYôWITHINôTHEôCOMMUNITY ôCONSISTENTôWITHôTHEôMISSIONôOFô)THACAô (/523ô ô

)FôYOUôHAVEôAôBUSINESSôSTART UPôORôEXPANSIONôIDEAôPLEASEôCONSIDERôANô)THACAô

(/523ôLOANô9OULLôBEôHELPINGôYOURSELF ôANDôBYôPUTTINGôMOREô(/523ôINTOôCIRCULATIONô ALSOôTHEôCOMMUNITYô ô

9OUôCANôSENDôYOURôLOANôAPPLICATIONôTOôMAILTOINFO ITHACAHOURSORGôORôMAILôITôTOô

)THACAô(/523 ô0/ô"OXô ô)THACAô.9ô 3OURCEô WWWITHACAHOURSORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWITHACAHOURSCOM WWWITHACAHOURSCOMHOURFAMILYHTML WWWITHACAHEALTHORG

%XAMPLESôôYôô&QE>@>ñ%LROP

0240_057_self_org.indd 128-129

!NDôITôNOôLONGERôPROTECTSôTHESEôCREATIVEôACTSôFORôANôINITIALôTERMôOFô FOURTEENôYEARSô)TôPROTECTSôTHESEôCREATIVEôWORKSôFORôTHEôLIFEôOFôTHEô AUTHORôPLUSôSEVENTYôYEARSômôWHICHôMEANS ôFORôEXAMPLE ôINôTHEô CASEôOFô)RVINGô"ERLIN ôAôTERMôTHATôEXCEEDSôôYEARSô)TôPROTECTSô THISôWORKôNOTôCONTINGENTLYôNOT ôTHATôIS ôUPONôREGISTRATIONô)TôPRO TECTSôIT ôANDôALLôCREATIVEôWORK ôAUTOMATICALLYômôFORôAôTERMôTHATôDOESô NOTôHAVEôTOôBEôRENEWED ôFORôAôLIFEôTHATôEXCEEDSôTHEôAUTHORS !NDôITôPROTECTSôNOTôJUSTôAGAINSTôPIRATEôPUBLISHERSô4HEôSCOPEôOFô COPYRIGHTôNOWôPROTECTSôANôEXTRAORDINARILYôBROADôDERIVATIVEôRIGHTô 4HEôRIGHTôTOôTRANSLATE ôWITHôSOMEôWORKS ôTHEôRIGHTôTOôPERFORM ôTHEô RIGHTôTOôADAPTôTOôAôPLAY ôORôMAKEôAôMOVIEômôALLôTHESEôAREôRIGHTSô THATôAREôNOWôINCLUDEDôWITHINôTHEôORIGINALLYôSPARSEôgEXCLUSIVEô RIGHTuôTHATôTHEôORIGINALôCOPYRIGHTôACTôGRANTED


25/09/06 17:40:52

!NDôkNALLY ôBECAUSEôITôDOESNTôPROTECTôONLYôAGAINSTôPIRATEôPUB LISHERS ôBECAUSEôINôôTHEôSTATUTEôSHIFTEDôITSôTERMS ôTOôSPEAKô OFôgCOPIESuôANDôNOTôPRINTING ôANDôBECAUSEôTHEôTECHNOLOGYô OFôCOPYINGôHASôNOWôEXPLODEDôTOôCOVERôJUSTôABOUTôANYTHINGô ANYONEôDOESôWITHôAôCOMPUTER ôTHEôREACHôOFôTHISôREGULATIONôISô NOôLONGERôTHEôôPUBLISHERSôTHATôEXISTEDôINôô4HEôREACHô OFôTHISôREGULATIONôONôTHEôRIGHTôTOôSPEAKôEXTENDSôTOôTHEôô MILLIONô!MERICANSôWHOôTODAYôUSEôCOMPUTERSô4HISôTINYôREGULA TIONôOFôAôTINYôPROPORTIONôOFôTHEôEXTRAORDINARYôRANGEôOFôCREATIVEô WORKôINôôHASôMORPHEDôINTOôTHISôMASSIVEôREGULATIONôOFô EVERYONEôWHOôHASôANYôCONNECTIONôTOôTHEôMOSTôTRIVIALôOFôCREA TIVEôAUTHORSHIP .OôDOUBT ôANDô)ôCERTAINLYôBELIEVE ôMUCHôOFôTHEôEXPANSEôINôCOPY RIGHTôOVERôTHEôPASTôTWOôHUNDREDôYEARSôWASôCOMPLETELYôJUSTIkEDô UNDERôAôPROPERôREADINGôOFôTHEôBALANCEôTHEôFRAMERSôMEANTôTOô STRIKEô4HOUGHôTHEYôDIDNTôPROTECTôMUSIC ôITôWOULDôBEôWRONGôFORô USôNOTôTOôPROTECTôMUSICô)ôREALIZEôTHEREôAREôTHOSEôONôTHEôOTHERô SIDEômôTHOSEôWHOôNOTEôTHATôWHILEôOURôSYSTEMôOFôPROTECTIONôHASô PRODUCEDô"RITNEYô3PEARSôANDô-ADONNA ôTHEôFRAMERSôSYSTEMô OFôNONPROTECTIONôPRODUCEDô"EETHOVEN ôANDôMAYBEôTHATôMEANSô THEôFRAMERSôWEREôONôTOôSOMETHINGômôBUTô)MôNOTôONôTHEôSIDEô OFôFREEôMUSICôIFôFREEôMUSICôMEANSôARTISTSôDONTôGETôPAIDô)NôMYô VIEW ôTHEôISSUEôISôNOTôWHETHERôARTISTSôGETôPAIDôTHEôISSUEôISô HOWô#ONGRESSôHASôBEENôCORRECTôINôITSôEFFORTSôTOôEXTENDôRIGHTSô TOôASSUREôARTISTSôGETôPAID ôSOôASôTOôASSUREôAôSUFkCIENTôINCENTIVEô TOôPRODUCEôART

MUSTôBLOCKôITôIFôTHEôINEVITABLEôITôPROMISESômôTHEôINEVITABLEôOFô PERFECTôCONTROLômôISôTOôBEôAVOIDED )NSTEAD ôSOMETHINGôBIGôHASôHAPPENEDôTHATôHASôACCELERATEDôTHEô PUSHôTOôPERFECTôCONTROLô!NDôPARADOXICALLY ôTHATôSOMETHINGôBIGô THATôWILLôPUSHôCOPYRIGHTôTOôPERFECTôCONTROLôISôTHISôARCHITECTUREô OFôFREEDOMôWEôCALLôTHEô)NTERNET &ORôBEFOREôTHEô)NTERNET ôINôMYôHUMBLEôVIEW ôTHEREôWASôLITTLEô REASONôTOôWORRYôABOUTôTHEôEMERGENCEôOFôCONTROLô)ôREALIZEôTHISô ISôAôCONTROVERSIALôVIEWôHEREô0ROFESSORô,ANGEôWASôLAMENTINGô THEôCOMMONSôLONGôBEFOREôANYôOFôUSôHADôLINKEDôWITHôHTML ô ,ONGôBEFOREôTHEôNAMEô(ILARYô2OSENôBECAMEôAôCHATROOMôSLUR ô 0ROFESSORô,ANGEôWASôBUILDINGôOUTRAGEôATôTHEôTENDENCYôOFô)0ô LAWYERSôTOôOVERREACHô)NDEED ôINôAôPASSAGEôFROMôHISô2ECLAIM INGôTHEô0UBLICô$OMAIN ô0ROFESSORô,ANGEôCAPTURESôTHEôESSENCEô OFôWHEREôWEôAREôNOW ôWITHôAôSTYLEôANDôAUTHORITYôTHATôREMINDSô ONEôOFô#HARLESô"LACKSôACCOUNTôOFô"ROWNôVô"OARDôOFô%DUCA TIONô0ROFESSORô,ANGEôTELLSôUSôWHATôWEôALLôKNOW ôBUTôREMINDSô USôHOWôTHEôLEGALôSYSTEMôMAKESôITôIMPOSSIBLEôTOôSAYôWHATôWEô KNOW

4HUSôWEôSHOULDôNOTICEôTHISôEXPANSIONôNOTôSOôMUCHôTOôOPPOSEô IT ôBUTôTOôRECOGNIZEôITSôINERTIAô#ONTROLôISôOURôDIRECTION ôANDôOURô VELOCITYôHASôBEENôSETô3OMETHINGôBIGôWILLôHAVEôTOôHAPPENôIFôTHISô INERTIAôISôTOôBEôCHECKEDô3OMETHINGôSIGNIkCANTôINôTHEôCULTUREô

4HEôDEFENDANTS ôOFôCOURSE ôWEREôOBLIGEDôTOôTAKEôEACHôOFôTHESEô CLAIMSôSERIOUSLYôANDôTOôRESPONDôTOôTHEMôWITHôEARNESTôDENIALSô ROOTEDôkRMLYôINôLAWô"UTô)ôAMôFREEôTOôRECOGNIZEôTHEMôFORôTHEô UTTERôNONSENSEôTHEYôAREô,EGITIMATEôWORKSôDESERVEôPROTECTIONô FROMôREALôTHREATSô"UTôCLAIMSôOFôTHISôKINDôAREôSOôEXTRAVAGANTôINô RELATIONôTOôTHEôREALITYôFROMôWHICHôINôTHEORYôTHEYôOUGHTôTOôSPRINGô THATôONEôISôTEMPTEDôNOTôMERELYôTOôDISMISSôTHEMôASôNONSENSE ô BUTôTOôSUGGESTôINôADDITIONôTHATôONEôDAYôONEôOFôTHEMôOUGHTôTOô BEôMADEôTHEôSUBJECTôOFôAôSERIOUSôCOUNTERCLAIMôFORôPUNITIVEô DAMAGESôROOTEDôINôSOMEôSORTôOFôTORTôDESIGNEDôEXPRESSLYôFORô



0240_057_self_org.indd 130-131

25/09/06 17:40:52

THEôPURPOSE ôPERHAPSôTOôBEôTERMEDôgUNCONSCIONABLEôOVER REACHINGu 4HUSôTHEôPRACTICEôWEôCANTôESCAPEôSEEINGôTODAYôIS ôOFôCOURSE ô AôPRACTICEôTHATôOTHERSôHAVEôNOTICEDôFROMôTIMEôIMMEMORIALô4HEô EXTREMESôOFôTHEô2ECORDINGô)NDUSTRYô!SSOCIATIONôOFô!MERICAô 2)!! ôWEREôNOTôINVENTEDôBYôTHEô2)!!ô0ROFESSORô,ANGEôRETELLSô INôTHEôSAMEôARTICLEôTHEôEXTRAORDINARYôSTORYôOFô7ARNERô"ROTHERSô THREATENINGôTHEô-ARXô"ROTHERSôWHENô'ROUCHOôWASôCONSIDERINGôAô PRODUCTIONôTOôBEôTITLEDôg!ô.IGHTôINô#ASABLANCAuô&OR ôOFôCOURSE ô 7ARNERô"ROTHERSôBELIEVEDôITôOWNEDôTHEôNAMEôg#ASABLANCA uô WHICHôINSPIREDô'ROUCHOôTOôRESPONDôTHATôHEôBELIEVED ôSINCEôTHEô -ARXô"ROTHERSôPREDATEDô7ARNERô"ROTHERS ôTHATôHEôOWNEDôTHEô WORDôg"ROTHERSuôANDôTHATô7ARNERôHADôBETTERôBACKôOFF

4HISôLAYERôOFôCONTROLôISôNEWôINôTHEôGAMEôTHISôLAYERôISôEXPLODINGô ANDôTHEôLAWôISôEXPANDINGôTOôBACKôITôUPô!NDôHENCEôNOW ôJUSTô ATôTHEôMOMENTôTHATôTECHNOLOGYôCOULDôENABLEôAôBILLIONôLIFELIKEô INNOVATIONS ôAôBILLIONôI-ACSôCRAFTINGôMOVIESôBYôREMIXINGôCULTUREô FROMôTHEôPAST ôJUSTôATôTHEôMOMENTôWHENôTHEôTECHNOLOGYôCOULDô MAKEôREALôTHEôIDEAôCAPTUREDôINôANô!PPLEôCOMMERCIALômôRIP ôMIX ô ANDôBURN ôAFTERôALL ôASôTHEôCOMMERCIALôENDS ôITôISôYOURôMUSICô môTHEôTECHNOLOGYôISôTAKINGôTHATôFREEDOMôAWAYô4HEôVERYôSAMEô I-ACôWHICHô!PPLEôTRIESôTOôSELLôWITHôTHISôPICTUREôOFôFREEDOMômôRIPô MIXôANDôBURNômôISôENCODEDôWITHôSOFTWAREôTOôHANDLEô$6$SôTHATô DOESôNOTôENABLEôTHEôRIPPING ôMIXING ôORôBURNINGôOFô(OLLYWOODSô MOVIESô4RYôTOôRIP ôMIX ôANDôBURNôTHATôSTUFFôANDôTHEôSYSTEMôWILLô QUICKLYôCRASHô#ONTROLôOFôTHATôCONTENTôHASôBEENôENCODEDôANDô THISôSYSTEMôOFôgFREEDOMuôHASôBEENôENCODEDôTOôRESPECTôTHATô CONTROL

9ETôTHEREôISôAôDIFFERENCEôINôTHESEôBLUSTERINGSôOFôLAWYERSôTODAY ô ANDôTHEôDIFFERENCEôISôINôTHEôCODEô.OTôINôTHEôCODEôARCHITECTEDô BYô%ASTô#OASTôCODERSômôLEGISLATORSôINô7ASHINGTONômôBUTôINôTHEô CODEôARCHITECTEDôBYô7ESTô#OASTôCODERSômôTHEôCODEôOFôSOFT WAREôANDôTHEôCONTROLôBUILTôINTOôITô4HEôDIFFERENCEôISôTHATôNOW ô THESEôSYSTEMSôOFôCONTROLôCANôBEôBUILTôINTOôANôARCHITECTUREôTHATô MUSTôRECOGNIZEôTHEMôTHEôENCODINGSôANDôCONTROL ôASô0ROFESSORô "OYLEôPUTSôIT ôFOLLOWINGô-ICHAELô&OUCAULT ôGETôINSCRIBEDôINTOôTHEô WIRESô!ND ôWHENôTHISôDISCIPLINEôGETSôENCODEDôINTOôTHEôWIRES ô THENôTHISôDISCIPLINEôISôBIZARRELYôMOREôIMPORTANTôTHANôWHENôITôISô SIMPLYôTHEôOVERREACHINGôOFôLAWYERSô.OWôTHEôOVER REACHINGôOFô ANôE BOOKôTHATôSAYS ôg9OUôCANôREADôTHISôONôAô7INDOWSôMA CHINE ôBUTôNOTôONôAô-ACINTOSH uôISôSOMETHINGôMOREôTHANôBLUSTERô )TôISôAôSETôOFôCONTROLSôWITHôTHEôPOWERôOFôMATHEMATICSôBEHINDôITô môWEôCALLôTHATôENCRYPTIONômôANDôNOWôTHESEôCONTROLSôHAVEôTHEô POWERôOFôLAWôTOôDEFENDôTHEMômôWEôCALLôTHATôTHEô$IGITALô-ILLEN NIUMô#OPYRIGHTô!CT

4HISôISôTHEôCONlICTôBETWEENôTWOôPICTURESôOFôTHEôFUTUREô/NE ô THEôFUTUREôOFôIMPERFECTôCONTROLôATôTHEôCONTENTôLAYERômôMUSICô THATôGETSôRIPPED ôMIXED ôANDôBURNEDôTHEôOTHER ôTHEôFUTUREôOFô PERFECTôCONTROLômôOFô$6$SôTHATôGETôRIPPED ôMIXED ôANDôBURNEDô ONLYôASô*ACKô6ALENTI ô0RESIDENTôANDô#%/ôOFôTHEô-OTIONô0ICTUREô !SSOCIATIONôOFô!MERICA ôALLOWSô!NDôMYôBETôISôWITHôTHEôFUTUREô OFôPERFECTôCONTROLô&ORôASôWELLôASôANôINFRASTRUCTUREôTHATôCANôHAVEô CONTROLôLAYEREDôONTOôITômôTHEô)NTERNETômôANDôASôWELLôASôCODEô THATôCANôBUILDôCONTROLôINTOôCONTENTômôCOPYRIGHTôMANAGEMENTô REGIMESômôANDôASôWELLôASôLAWôTHATôWILLôBACKôUPôTHEôCONTROLôTHATô GETSôBUILTôINTOôCONTENTôTHATôGETSôSERVEDôACROSSôTHISôINFRASTRUC TUREômôTHEô$-#!ômôTHEôMOREôIMPORTANTôREASONôTOôBETôONôAô FUTUREôOFôCONTROLôISôCULTUREô)TôISNTôTHEô7ESTô#OASTôCODEôTHATô WILLôMATTERôMOSTôITôISNTôTHEô%ASTô#OASTôCODEôTHATôWILLôMAKEôTHEô DIFFERENCEôTHEôREALôISSUEôISôTHEôCULTURE ôANDôITSôCODEôTHEôREALô POWERôISôINôAôSETôOFôIDEASôTHATôISôSTILLôTAKENôFORôGRANTED



0240_057_self_org.indd 132-133

25/09/06 17:40:53

'UARAN¶ô0OWER $ESCRIPTION &ORôENERGYôANDôEMPOWERMENT 4EXT '5!2!.Óô0/7%2ôISôANôENERGYôSOFTDRINKôPRODUCEDôBYôAôGUARAN¶ôFARMERSôCOOPERATIVEô FROMô-AU¯SôINôTHEô"RAZILIANô!MAZON ôINôCOLLABORATIONôWITHô4HEô0OWERô&OUNDATIONô4HEô FARMERSôHAVEôORGANISEDôTHEMSELVESôINôRESPONSEôTOôTHEôACTIVITIESôOFôTHEôMULTINATIONALô CORPORATIONSôôôôôôôôôôôôôôôANDôôôôôôôôôôôôôô ôAôCARTELôWHOSEôMONOPOLYôONôTHEôPURCHASEôOFôTHEô RAWôMATERIALôHASôDRIVENôTHEôPRICEôOFôGUARAN¶ôBERRIESôDOWNô ôWHILEôTHEôCOSTôOFôTHEIRô PRODUCTSôTOôTHEôCONSUMERôHASôRISEN '5!2!.Óô0/7%2ôEMPLOYSôGLOBALôBRANDSôANDôTHEIRôSTRATEGIESôASôRAWôMATERIALôFORôAô COUNTER ECONOMICôPOSITIONôWHILEôRECLAIMINGôTHEôORIGINALôUSEôOFôTHEô-AU¯SôGUARAN¶ô PLANTôASôAôPOWERFULôNATURALôTONIC ôNOTôJUSTôAôSYMBOL '5!2!.Óô0/7%2ôCONTAINSôORIGINALô-AU¯SôGUARAN¶ôFORôENERGYôANDôEMPOWERMENT &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWGUARANAPOWERORG

0240_057_self_org.indd 134-135

%XAMPLESôôYôô$R>O>K³ñ-LTBO

25/09/06 17:40:54

#ONCLUSIONS &ORôTHISôISôWHATô)ôSPOKEôOFôATôTHEôSTART ôANDôITôISôTHISôTHATôWILLô DEkNEôTHEôENDô)DEASôTHATôAREôTAKENôFORôGRANTEDôTHATôAREôUN QUESTIONEDôINôTHISôCULTUREôTHATôTOôQUESTION ôWOULDôRENDERôYOUô ANôALIENôTHESEôIDEASôAREôTHEôIDEASôTHATôWILLôMAKEôCONTROLôTHEô FUTURE &ORôTHESEôIDEASôTAKEôFORôGRANTEDôTHEôPROPERTYôINôINTELLECTUALô PROPERTYô4HESEôIDEASôHAVEôLOSTôTHEôDISTINCTIONôTHATôOURôFRAM ERSôMADEôCLEARômôBYôSPEAKINGôASôTHEYôDID ôNOTôOFôINTELLECTUALô PROPERTY ôBUTôOFôMONOPOLIESôANDôEXCLUSIVEôRIGHTSô4HATSôWHATô AôCOPYRIGHTôORôPATENTôISômôAôGOVERNMENTôBACKEDôMONOPOLY ôNOTô OVERôAôRIVALROUSôORôSCARCEôRESOURCEôLIKEôLANDôORôAPPLESôORôHEATEDô HOMES ôBUTôOVERôAôNONRIVALROUSôRESOURCEôTHATôTHEô%NLIGHTENMENTô TAUGHTôUSôSHOULDôBEôSHAREDôAMONGôMOREôTHANôTHEô#HURCHô)0ô ISôNOTô0 ôBUTôTHISôTRUTHôISôLOSTôONôUS !NDôSOôDEEPLYôISôITôLOSTôTHATôWEôDONTôEVENôNOTICEôTHEôIRONYôITô PRODUCESô7EôSPEAKôOFôAôCOMMONSôASôIFôITôISôONLYôAôTRAGEDYôWEô RECALLôTHEôPUBLICôDOMAINôASôIFôITôWEREôSIMPLYôANôECHOôFROMôSOMEô ROMANTICôPASTôWEôEMBRACE ôASô0ROFESSORô2OSEôSAYS ôTHEôIDEAô THATôTHEôWHOLEôWORLDôISôBESTôMANAGEDôWHENôDIVIDEDôAMONGô PRIVATEôOWNERS ôANDôWEôPROCEEDôTOôDIVIDEôTHEôWORLDôAMONGô PRIVATEôOWNERSô-OSTô!MERICANSôAGREEôWITHôTHEô7ALTô$ISNEYô #ORPORATIONôTHATô-ICKEYô-OUSEôISô$ISNEYSôNOWôANDôFOREVERô THEYôDONTôEVENôNOTICEôTHEôIRONYôTHENôWHENô$ISNEYôCANôMAKEô MILLIONSôOFFôOFô6ICTORô(UGOSôCREATION ôTHEô(UNCHô"ACKôOFô.OTREô $AME ôORô3ERGEIô0ROKOkEVôORô0OCAHONTASô3OôINVISIBLEôISôPUBLICô DOMAINôTHATôWEôDONTôEVENôSEEôITôWHENôITôISôEVERYWHEREôAROUNDô SOôINVISIBLEôISôTHEôIDEAôTHATôTHEôFREEôMIGHTôMATTERôTOôCREATIVITY ô THATôWHENôITôISôENCLOSED ôWEôAREôCONVINCEDôTHISôISôPROGRESS


0240_057_self_org.indd 136-137

/URôFUTUREôISôTHISôTHEô&REEô3PEECHô#LAUSEôOFôTHEô&IRSTô!MEND MENTôWILLôBEôREADôTOôENTITLEôTHOSEôWHOôOWNôTHEôWIRESôTOôCHANGEô THEôLOGICALôLAYERôANDôMAKEôITôOWNEDôASôWELLôTHEôFREEôCOMPETI TIONôPRINCIPLEôOFôTHEô3HERMANô!CTôWILLôBEôREADôBYôTHEôSAMEô #IRCUITô#OURTôOFô!PPEALS ôWEôMIGHTôNOTICE ôTOôENTITLEôTHEôOWNERô OFôTHEôPLATFORMôTHATôMOSTôAFFECTSôTHISôLOGICALôLAYERôTHATôONEô COMPANYôWHOSEôNAMEô)ôHAVEôNOTôUTTERED ôTOôCODEôTHATôPLAT FORMôTOôDISCRIMINATEôASôITôWANTSôANDôTHEôFREEôCULTUREôTHATôWEô HAVEôSEENôlOURISHôINôTHISôCOMMONSôBUILTôBYôTHEô)NTERNETôWILLô BEôCAPTUREDôANDôCONTROLLEDôAGAINôBYôTHOSEôWHOôCONTROLôMOSTô OFôTHEôCONTENT ôANDôBYôTHOSEôWHOôSUCCEEDôINô#ONGRESSôINô EXPANDINGôTHEIRôCONTROLôFROMôTHEôIMPERFECTôTOôTHEôPERFECTô!NDô THISôFUTUREôOFôCONTROLôWILLôGETôBUILTôBYôANôIDEAôTHATôPROPERTYôISô GOOD ôSOôMOREôPROPERTYôISôBETTERô)TôWILLôGETôSANCTIONEDôBYôAô CULTUREôTHATôHASôFORGOTTENôDISTINCTION ôANDôTHATôISôSOôBLINDEDô BYôWHATôITôHASôFORGOTTENôTHATôITôDOESôNOTôEVENôNOTICEôWHENô THEôMOSTôEXTRAORDINARYôINNOVATIONôTHATôOURôCULTUREôHASôSEENô ISôBUILTôNOTôONôANôARCHITECTUREôOFôPERFECTôFREEDOMôNOTôINôAô WORLDôWHEREôEVERYôLAYERôISôINôTHEôCOMMONS ôBUTôALSOôNOTôONô ANôARCHITECTUREôWHEREôCONTROLôISôTHEôRULEô.OT ôINôOTHERôWORDS ô ONôANôARCHITECTUREôWHEREôEVERYôLAYERôISôOWNEDôBUTôINSTEAD ô ONôANôARCHITECTUREôTHATôMIXESôFREEDOMôANDôCONTROL ôTHATôBUILTô PROPERTYôWITHINôAôCOMMONS ôANDôTHATôGOTôITSôLIFEôFROMôTHISôMIXô OFôPROPERTYôANDôTHEôCOMMONS !TôEVERYôLAYER ôWEôAREôDISPLACINGôTHEôFREEôWITHôCONTROL ôANDô THEôREASONSôFORôTHISôDISPLACINGôAREôNOTôHARDôTOôSEEô4HISôAR CHITECTUREôOFôINNOVATIONôTHATôWEôCALLôTHEô)NTERNETôTHREATENSôTHEô SYSTEMSôOFôCONTROLôTHATôTHRIVEDôBEFOREôTHEREôWASôSUCHôAôTHINGô ASôTHEô)NTERNETô!NDôTHOSEôWHOSEôINTERESTSôAREôMOSTôTHREATENEDô BYôTHISôINNOVATIONôHAVEôRALLIEDôTOôUNDERMINEôWHATôISôSPECIALô ABOUTôIT


25/09/06 17:40:55

4HISôISôNOTHINGôNEWôWITHôTHEô)NTERNETô)NôHISôEXTRAORDINARYôWORK ô 4HEô0RINCE ô.ICCOLOô-ACHIAVELLIôHADôTHISôTOôSAYôABOUTôINNO VATION 3UCHôANôINNOVATORôHASôASôENEMIESôALLôTHEôPEOPLEôWHOôWEREô DOINGôWELLôUNDERôTHEôOLDôORDER ôANDôONLYôHALFHEARTEDôDEFENDERSô INôTHOSEôWHOôHOPEôTOôPROkTôFROMôTHEôNEWô4HISôHALFHEARTEDNESSô DERIVESôPARTLYôFROMôFEARôOFôOPPONENTSôWHOôHAVEôTHEôLAWôONôTHEIRô SIDE ôANDôPARTLYôFROMôHUMANôSKEPTICISM ôSINCEôMENôDONTôREALLYô BELIEVEôINôANYTHINGôNEWôTILLôTHEYôHAVEôSOLIDôEXPERIENCEôOFôIT 7EôALLOWôTHESEôCHANGESôTHEYôDONTôJUSTôHAPPENô7EôSTANDô BACKôASôTHEYôOCCURôTHEYôDONTôHAPPENôINôTHEôNIGHTô7EôLETôTHEMô OCCURôBECAUSEôMOSTôOFôUSôBELIEVEôTHEYôSHOULDôTHATôCONTROLôISô GOOD ôBETTERôCONTROLôISôBETTER ôANDôTHATôTHESEôSYSTEMSôOFôCONTROLô AREôWAYSôTOôMAKEôSUREôTHEôBETTERôCOMESôFROMôTHEôGOOD )TôISôANôATTITUDEôANDôBLINDNESSôANDôAôPATHETICôRESIGNATIONôTHATô PERMITSôTHISôCHANGEô3OôENAMOREDôWEôAREôWITHôTHEôINVISIBLEô HAND ôSOôCONVINCEDôWEôAREôOFôTHEôGENIUSôOFôPROPERTY ôSOôBLINDô WEôAREôTOôWHATôMAKESôINNOVATIONôPOSSIBLE ôTHATôWEôALLOWôTHEô UNDOINGôOFôTHEôMOSTôSIGNIkCANTôCHANCEôFORôSOMETHINGôDIFFERENTô THANôWEôHAVEôEVERôSEEN 7HENô)ôTALKôABOUTôTHISôLOSSôINôOTHERôPLACES ôMOSTôDONTôREALLYô GETôITô4HEYôCLAPôPOLITELY ôANDôTHENôTHEYôASK ô7HATôISôINNOVA TIONô9OUôHAVENTôDEkNEDôTHEôGOODôINôINNOVATIONô7HATôDOôWEô LOSEôWHENôCONTROLôISôTHEôNORMô7HATôREALLYôISôTOôBEôGAINEDô FROMôFREEDOM

WHOMôTHEôIDEAôOFôCULTURALôPRODUCTIONôISôONLYôEVERôASSOCIATEDô WITHôTHEôSTATEôASôINô#HINA ôORôTHEôCORPORATIONôASôINôAôPRODUC TIONôDEPARTMENT ô4HESEôAREôPEOPLEôWHOôCANTôIMAGINEôCULTUREô BEINGôREPRODUCEDôANDôRECREATEDôBYôINDIVIDUALS ôORôBYôSMALLô GROUPSôWORKINGôTOGETHER ôWITHôAôTECHNOLOGYôTHATôENABLESôAôRE MAKINGôOFôCULTURE 4HESEôAREôPEOPLEôWHOôHAVEôNOTôSEENôTHEôkLMSôOFô0ROFESSORô ,ANGESôSTUDENTSôWHOôHAVEôNOTôREADôTHEôPOLITICSôINô0ROFESSORô "OYLESôWRITINGSôWHOôHAVEôNOTôBEGUNôTOôUNDERSTANDôTHEôLESSONô OFôTHEôHARMôTOôSCIENCEôTAUGHTôBYô0ROFESSORô2EICHMAN 4HESEôAREôPEOPLEôWHOôHAVEôNOTôBEENôTOô$UKEô!NDôSOô)ôCOMEô TOô$UKEôTOôDOôLITTLEôMOREôTHANôREPORTôONôAôWARôWEôAREôLOSINGô /FôAôCULTUREôTHATôCANTôSEEôTHEôPOTENTIALôTHATôTHISôARCHITECTUREô PRESENTSô/FôAôPOLITICSôTHATôSCORNSôANYONEôWHOôQUESTIONSôTHATô BERVISIONôOFôPERFECTôCONTROL 4HEôIRONYôASTOUNDSô7EôWINôTHEôCOLDôWARôAGAINSTôSTATEôCONTROLô SOôASôTOôREENTRENCHôTHISôSYSTEMôOFôCONTROLôINôTHEôNAMEôOFôTHEô MARKETô7EôkGHTôBATTLESôINôTHEôNAMEôOFôFREEôSPEECH ôONLYôTOô HAVEôTHOSEôTOOLSôTURNEDôOVERôTOôTHEôARSENALôOFôTHOSEôWHOôWOULDô CONTROLôSPEECHô7EôDEFENDôTHEôIDEALôOFôPROPERTY ôANDôTHENô CONFUSEôITSôLIMITS ôANDôEXTENDôITSôREACHôTOôAôSPACEôNONEôOFôOURô FOUNDERSôWOULDôEVERôHAVEôIMAGINED 7EôMOVEôTHROUGHôTHISôMOMENTôOFôANôARCHITECTUREôOFôINNOVA TION ôTOôONCEôAGAINôANôARCHITECTUREôOFôCONTROLô7ITHOUTôNOTICEô WITHOUTôRESISTANCEôWITHOUTôAôQUESTION

4HESEôAREôPEOPLEôWHOôCANTôIMAGINEôAôWORLDôWHEREôCULTUREô ISôANYTHINGôELSEôBUTôSERVEDôONôAôPLATTERô4HESEôAREôPEOPLEôFORô

4HIS ôYOUôMAYôNOTICE ôISôAôCONTRADICTIONôINôOURôTRADITIONô9OUô MIGHTôBEôTEMPTEDôTOôTHENôREPEATôMYôFAVORITEôLINEôFROMô0ROFESSORô



0240_057_self_org.indd 138-139

25/09/06 17:40:55

"OYLESôBOOKôg)ôHAVEôNOTHINGôAGAINSTôCONTRADICTIONS ôSOMEôOFô MYôBESTôFRIENDSôAREôCONTRADICTIONSôôôôu 4HISôISôAôCONTRADICTIONôWEôSHOULDôBEôAGAINSTô9ET ôWE ô!MERI CANS ôAREôNOT

&//4./4%3 #OPYRIGHTôÚôôBYô,AWRENCEô,ESSIG 0ROFESSORôOFô,AW ô3TANFORDô,AWô3CHOOLô 4HISôLECTUREôWASôDELIVEREDôASôTHEôINAUGURALô-EREDITHôANDô+IPô&REYô,ECTUREôINô)NTELLECTUALô0ROPERTYô ATô$UKEô5NIVERSITYô3CHOOLôOFô,AWôONô-ARCHô ô

ô ô ô ô

ô ô ô ô

ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 140-141

#AROLô2OSE ô4HEô#OMEDYôOFôTHEô#OMMONSô#USTOM ô#OMMERCE ôANDô)NHERENTLYô0UBLICô 0ROPERTY ôô5ô#()ô,ô2%6ô ôô $AVIDô,ANGE ô2ECOGNIZINGôTHEô0UBLICô$OMAIN ôô,!7ôô#/.4%-0ô02/"3ôô!UTUMNô *!-%3ô"/9,% ô3(!-!.3 ô3/&47!2% ô!.$ô30,%%.3ô,!7ô!.$ô4(%ô#/.3425#4)/.ô /&ô4(%ô).&/2-!4)/.ô3/#)%49ô *(ô2EICHMAN ô/Fô'REENô4ULIPSôANDô,EGALô+UDZUô2EPACKAGINGô2IGHTSôINô3UBPATENTABLEô )NNOVATIONS ôô6!.$ô,ô2%6ôô ô;HEREINAFTERô2EICHMAN ô/Fô'REENô4ULIPS=ô*(ô 2EICHMANôô0AULô&ô5HLIR ô$ATABASEô0ROTECTIONôATôAô#ROSSROADSô2ECENTô$EVELOPMENTôANDô 4HEIRô)MPACTôONô3CIENCEôANDô4ECHNOLOGY ôô"%2+%,%9ô4%#(ô,*ôô ô0AMELAô 3AMUELSON ô2ANDALLô$AVIS ô-ITCHELLô$ô+APORôô*(ô2EICHMAN ô!ô-ANIFESTOô#ONCERNINGô THEô,EGALô0ROTECTIONôOFô#OMPUTERô0ROGRAMS ôô#/,5-ô,ô2%6ôô 9OCHAIô"ENKLER ô&ROMô#ONSUMERôTOô5SERSô3HIFTINGôTHEô$EEPERô3TRUCTURESôOFô2EGULATIONô 4OWARDô3USTAINABLEô#OMMONSôANDô5SERô!CCESS ôô&%$ô#/--ô,*ô ô ô 3EEô,!72%.#%ô,%33)' ô4(%ô&5452%ô/&ô)$%!3ô4(%ô&!4%ô/&ô4(%ô#/--/.3ô).ô!ô #/..%#4%$ô7/2,$ô ô ôEXPLAININGôTHEôAPPLICATIONôOFôTHEôLAYERSôAPPROACHôTOô THEô)NTERNET 3EEôGENERALLYôIDôDISCUSSINGôTHEôIDEAôOFôTHEôCOMMONSôINôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôTHEORY )ôUSEDô#ENTRALô0ARK ô&ERMATSô,ASTô4HEOREM ôANDôOPENôSOURCEôASôEXAMPLESôOFôCOMMONSô INôANô!DDRESSô"EFOREôTHEô&IRSTô!MENDMENTôANDôTHEô-EDIAô3YMPOSIUMôATôTHEô&ORDHAMô 5NIVERSITYô3CHOOLôOFô,AWôONô&EBRUARYô ôô&ORôTHEôFULLôTEXTôOFôTHISôLECTURE ôSEEô,AW RENCEô,ESSIG ô#OMMONSôANDô#ODE ôô&/2$(!-ô).4%,,ô02/0ô-%$)!ôô%.4ô,*ôô 3EEôGENERALLYô2EICHMAN ô/Fô'REENô4ULIPS ôSUPRAôNOTEôôARGUINGôTHATôPROTECTINGôSMALL ô SUBPATENTABLEôINNOVATIONSôWITHôAôLIABILITYôRULEôRATHERôTHANôAôPROPERTYôRULEôWOULDôYIELDôAô NETôBENEkTôTOôSOCIETY ,%33)' ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATô )DôATôô$AVIDô)SENBERGôWASôANôENGINEERôATô"ELLô,ABSô(EôADVOCATEDôgSTUPIDuôTELEPHONEô NETWORKS ôEARNINGôHIMôGREATôSUPPORTôONôTHEôWEB ôBUTôNOTôFROMôHISôEMPLOYERSô)D 2OSE ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATô ,%33)' ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATô $AVIDô,IEBERMAN ô-EDIAô'IANTSô.ETô#HANGEô-AJORô#OMPANIESô%STABLISHô3TRONGô&OOTHOLDô /NLINE ô53!ô4/$!9 ô$ECô ô ôATô" 3EEô&OXô4ELEVISIONô3TATIONS ô)NC ôVô&EDERALô#OMMUNICATIONSô#OMMISSIONôANDô5NITEDô 3TATES ôô&Dô ô ô$#ô#IRô ôACCEPTINGôTHEôARGUMENTôTHATôCABLEôSTA TIONSôAREôSPEAKERS 53ô#/.34ôARTô) ôeô !CTôOFô-AYô ô ôCHô ôô3TATôôREPEALEDô )Dôeô ôô3TATôATô ,%33)' ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATô )D !CTôOFô-ARô ô ôCHô ôeô ôô3TATô ô )ôDISCUSSEDôTHEôHISTORYôOFôCOPYRIGHTôLAWôINôTHEô-ELVILLEô6ô.IMMERô-EMORIALô,ECTUREôATô 5#,!ôONô-ARCHô ôô&ORôTHEôFULLôTEXTôOFôTHISôLECTURE ôSEEô,AWRENCEô,ESSIG ô#OPYRIGHTSô &IRSTô!MENDMENT ôô5#,!ô,ô2%6ôô ô53#ôeôô !CTôOFô-ARô ô ô0UBô,ô.Oô ôeô ôô3TATô ôôCODIkEDôASôAMENDEDôATô ô53#ôeôô ,ANGE ôSUPRAôNOTEô ,%33)' ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATôô!SôPRESIDENTôOFô2)!! ô(ILARYô2OSENôDECLAREDôTHATôTHEôINDUS TRYSôOBJECTIVEôWASôTOôLIMITôVENTUREôCAPITALôSUCHôTHATôCONTENTôAVAILABLEôONôTHEô)NTERNETôHADô BEENôAPPROVEDôBYôTHEôINDUSTRYô)D !PPELLANTSô2EPLYô"RIEF ô"ROWNôVô"DôOFô%DUC ôô53ôô


25/09/06 17:40:55

ô ô ô ô

ô ô ô ô

,ANGE ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATô )DôATô )DôATô 3EEô*AMESô$ô"OYLE ô&OUCAULTôINô#YBERSPACEô3URVEILLANCE ô3OVEREIGNTY ôANDô(ARDWIREô #ENSORS ôô5ô#).ô,ô2%6ô ô ô ôDESCRIBINGôHOWôTECHNOLOGICALôCONTROLSô EMBEDDEDôINôINFORMATIONôCOULDôDICTATEôINFORMATIONôlOWôONôTHEô)NTERNET ôSEEôALSOô!LBERTô +OVACS ô.OTE ô1UIETINGôTHEô6IRTUALô0RISONô2IOTô7HYôTHEô)NTERNETSô3PIRITôOFôg3HARINGuô-USTô "Eô"ROKEN ôô$5+%ô,*ô ô ô ôAPPLYINGô&OUCAULTSôANALYSISôTOôMUSICôSHAR INGôONôTHEô)NTERNET 0UBô,ô.Oô ôô3TATôô ôCODIkEDôATôô53#ôeeô ô ô 2OSE ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATô .)##/,Ãô-!#()!6%,,) ô4(%ô02).#%ôô2OBERTô-ô!DAMSôTRANS ô77ô.ORTONôô#O ô)NCô ED ô ô "/9,% ôSUPRAôNOTEô ôATô


0240_057_self_org.indd 142-143


25/09/06 17:40:55

3TRATEGIESô OFô4RANSITIONô 0ARALLELISMô ANDô&RAGMEN TATIONôINô THEô7ESTERNô "ALKANSôô ANDôTHEô ô%UROPEANô 5NIONô -ARJETICAô0OTRC


0240_057_self_org.indd 144-145

3TRATEGIESôOFô4RANSITION

25/09/06 17:40:56

,ETôMEôBEGINôBYôQUOTINGôANôARTICLEô)ôREADôRECENTLYôINô 4HEô%CONOMIST

3OMALIAôDOESôNOTôSPRINGôTOôMINDôASôAô GOODôPLACEôTOôDOôBUSINESS ôBUTôINôTELE COMSôATôLEASTôITôHASôSOMETHINGôTOôTEACHô THEôWORLDô!ôCALLôFROMôAô3OMALIôMOBILEô PHONEôISôGENERALLYôCHEAPERôANDôCLEARERô THANôAôCALLôFROMôANYWHEREôELSEôINô!FRICAô 4HEôTRICKôISôTHEôLACKôOFôREGULATIONô3OMA LIAôHASôHADôNOôGOVERNMENTôSINCEôôô )TôWASôCUTôOFFôFORôAôWHILE ôBUTôTHENôPRIVATEô MOBILEôCOMPANIESôMOVEDôINôANDôFOUNDô THATôTHEôCOLLAPSEDôSTATEôPROVIDEDôAô ôCURIOUSôCOMPETITIVEôADVANTAGEô .OôGOVERNMENTôMEANSôNOôSTATEôTELECOMSô COMPANYôTOôWORRYôABOUT ôNOôCORRUPTô ôMINISTRYôOFkCIALSôTOôPAYôOFFôTHEREôISôNOô MINISTRY ôANDôTHEôFREEDOMôTOôCHOOSEôTHEô BEST VALUEôEQUIPMENTô4AXES ôPAYABLEô TOôAôTENTATIVEôLOCALôAUTHORITYôORôSTRONG MAN ôAREôSELDOMôMOREôTHANô ôSECURITYô ISôANOTHERôôMOREôINô-OGADISHU ôANDô CUSTOMSôDUTIESôAREôNEXTôTOôNOTHINGôôôô

3OMALIAôMAY ôTOôBEôSURE ôREPRESENTôAôWORST CASEôSCENARIOô môTHEôTRULYôUNREGULATEDôSOCIETYômôBUTôEVENôTHEôHIGHLYôREGU LATEDôSTATESôOFôTHEô%UROPEANô5NIONôAREôTOôAôCERTAINôDEGREEô IRREGULARô3OCIETIES ôAFTERôALL ôMUSTôCONSTANTLYôBALANCEôTHEô FORMALôWITHôTHEôINFORMALô7HENôAôSOCIETYôUNDERGOESôECO NOMICôANDôPOLITICALôCHANGE ôINFORMALôSTRUCTURESôCOMEôTOô THEôFOREFRONTôANDôNEGOTIATIONSôBETWEENôTHEôFORMALôANDôTHEô INFORMALôINTENSIFYô)TôWAS ôINDEED ôTHEôINFORMALôECONOMYôTHATô HELPEDôREBUILDô!LBANIANôSOCIETYôAFTERôTHEôECONOMICôANDô POLITICALôCOLLAPSEôOFôTHEôSô7HILEôTHEôINFORMALôMAYôBEô ILLUSTRATEDôBYôREFERENCEôTOôSUCHôCONCRETEôPHENOMENAôASôTHEô INFORMALôCITY ôHEREô)ôWOULDôLIKEôTOôDRAWôATTENTIONôTOô@INFORMALô STRATEGIESôANDôTOOLSôOFôOPERATIONô)NôTHEôCITIESôOFôTHEô7EST ERNô"ALKANS ôWHEREô)ôHAVEôRECENTLYôSPENTôQUITEôAôBITôOFôTIME ô THEôMOSTôSTRIKINGôSTRATEGIESô)ôHAVEôOBSERVEDôAREôPARALLELISMô ANDôFRAGMENTATION

&ROMôAôDISTANCEôITôLOOKSôLIKEôAôFREE ôMARKETôNIRVANAôAFTERô4HEô%CONOMISTSô HEARTôBUTôCLOSERôUPôITôBETTERôRESEMBLESô ANôARMEDôOLIGARCHY ôCAPABLEôOFôTAKINGô ANYTHINGôITôWANTSôATôTHEôPOINTôOFôAôGUNô môEVENôAô.OKIAôHANDSET

0ARALLELôCITIES ôPARALLELôECONOMIESôANDôPARALLELôGOVERNANCEôAREô THRIVINGôINôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSô4ODAY ôPARALLELôSYSTEMSôAREô kRMLYôESTABLISHEDôHEREôANDôGENERALLYôWORKôWELLôSIDEôBYôSIDEô 3INCEôTHEôPOLITICALôCHANGESôOFôTHEôS ôTHEôTERRITORYôOFôTHEô 7ESTERNô"ALKANSôHASôRESTRUCTUREDôITSELFôASôAôCONGLOMERATIONô OFôDISTINCTôANDôHIGHLYôINVENTIVEôSOCIETIESôTHATôDOôNOTôCOMPETEô WITHôEACHôOTHERôBUTôRATHERôEXISTôINôPARALLELô.OTôONLYôHAVEôCITIESô DOUBLEDôINôSIZEôBYôEXPANDINGôINTOôTHEôSUBURBSôINôINFORMALôSET TLEMENTS ôBUTôALSOôNEWôCITIESôHAVEôBEENôLAIDôONôTOPôOFôEXISTINGô ONESô4HESEôAREôPARALLELôCITIES ôWHICHôSUPPLEMENTôWHATôWASô ALREADYôTHEREô4HEYôDOôNOTôOPPOSEôTHEôPAST ôBUTôkNDôNEWôWAYSô OFôUSINGôITô7ITHINôCITIES ôSELF SEGREGATIONôHASôBECOMEôAôMODEô OFôCOEXISTENCEôINô0RISHTINA ôFOREIGNERSôFENCEôTHEMSELVESôOFFô INôSEPARATEôRESIDENTIALôENCLAVES ôWHILEôTHEôLARGE SCALEôAPART MENT BLOCKôNEIGHBORHOODSôTHATôWEREôONCEôAôSHOWCASEôFORôTHEô



0240_057_self_org.indd 146-147

25/09/06 17:40:56

'UERRILLAô'IRLS $ESCRIPTION 2EINVENTINGôTHEôgFuôWORDôFEMINISM 4EXT 7EREôAôBUNCHôOFôANONYMOUSôFEMALESôWHOôTAKEôTHEôNAMESôOFôDEADôWOMENôARTISTSôASô PSEUDONYMSôANDôAPPEARôINôPUBLICôWEARINGôGORILLAôMASKSô ô

7EôHAVEôPRODUCEDôPOSTERS ôSTICKERS ôBOOKS ôPRINTEDôPROJECTS ôANDôACTIONSôTHATô

EXPOSEôSEXISMôANDôRACISMôINôPOLITICS ôTHEôARTôWORLD ôkLMôANDôTHEôCULTUREôATôLARGEô ô

7EôUSEôHUMORôTOôCONVEYôINFORMATION ôPROVOKEôDISCUSSION ôANDôSHOWôTHATôFEMI

NISTSôCANôBEôFUNNYô7EôWEARôGORILLAôMASKSôTOôFOCUSôONôTHEôISSUESôRATHERôTHANôOURô PERSONALITIESô$UBBINGôOURSELVESôTHEôCONSCIENCEôOFôCULTURE ôWEôDECLAREôOURSELVESô FEMINISTôCOUNTERPARTSôTOôTHEôMOSTLYôMALEôTRADITIONôOFôANONYMOUSôDO GOODERSôLIKEô 2OBINô(OOD ô"ATMAN ôANDôTHEô,ONEô2ANGERô/URôWORKôHASôBEENôPASSEDôAROUNDôTHEô WORLDôBYôKINDREDôSPIRITSôWHOôWEôAREôPROUDôTOôHAVEôASôSUPPORTERSô)TôHASôALSOôAPPEAREDô INô4HEô.EWô9ORKô4IMES ô4HEô.ATION ô"ITCHôANDô"USTôONô46ôANDôRADIO ôINCLUDINGô.02 ô THEô""#ôANDô#"#ôANDôINôCOUNTLESSôARTôANDôFEMINISTôTEXTSô4HEôMYSTERYôSURROUNDINGô OURôIDENTITIESôHASôATTRACTEDôATTENTIONô7EôCOULDôBEôANYONEôWEôAREôEVERYWHERE ô

"ECAUSEôOFôOURôANONYMITY ôWEôNEVERôSAYôEXACTLYôHOWôMANYôWEôAREô-ANYôWOMENô

HAVEôCOMEôINôANDôOUTôOFôTHEôGROUPôOVERôTHEôYEARS ôBUTôWEVEôALWAYSôBEENôFAIRLYôSMALLô ATôANYôONEôTIMEô4WOôOFôUS ô+ATHEô+OLLWITZôANDô&RIDAô+AHLO ôHAVEôBEENôINôTHEôGROUPô SINCEôTHEôBEGINNINGôAND ôWITHôOTHERôTERRIkCôMEMBERS ôHAVEôWORKEDôONôALMOSTôEVERYô POSTER ôBOOKôANDôPROJECTôTHATôHASôCOMEôOUTôUNDERôTHEô''ôNAME 3OURCEô WWWGUERRILLAGIRLSCOM &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWGUERRILLAGIRLSCOM

0240_057_self_org.indd 148-149

%XAMPLESôôYôô$RBOOFII>ñ$FOIP

25/09/06 17:40:57

SOCIALISTôSTATEôHAVEôBECOMEôGHETTOS ôHOUSINGôPEOPLEôWITHôLOWô INCOMESô.'/SôOPERATEôPARALLELôTOôGOVERNMENTôINSTITUTIONSô 4HEôOFkCIALôCURRENCYôOFô+OSOVOôISôTHEôEUROô4ODAY ô0RISHTINAôISô RULEDôBYôTHREEôPARALLELôADMINISTRATIONSô+OSOVAR ô3ERBIANôANDô THATôOFôTHEô5NITEDô.ATIONSô0EOPLEôSAYôTHATôNOôONEôREALLYôGOV ERNSôHERE ôSOôINDIVIDUALSôHAVEôBECOMEôTHEôSMALLESTôSTATEô"UTô AREôTHEYôCITIZENSô!REôTHEYôAôSOCIETYô#ANôWEôLEARNôANYTHINGô FROMôTHEôCITIZENSôOFô0RISHTINA $URINGôTHEôS ôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSôUNDERWENTôAôRAPIDô COLLAPSEô!TôTHEôTIME ôTHEôREGIONôWASôEXTENSIVELYôANALYSEDô ANDôDISCUSSEDô,ATER ôHOWEVER ôINTERESTôDIEDôDOWN ôASôIFôTHEô REGIONôWASôJUSTôSTANDINGôSTILL ôBUTôTHISôISôHARDLYôTHEôCASEô)N DEED ôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSôHAVEôBEENôONôFAST FORWARDô/NEô MIGHTôSAY ôFORôEXAMPLE ôTHATô4IRANAôISôAôFASTôCITYôWHILEôTHEôCITIESô OFôTHEô%UROPEANô5NIONôAREôSLOWô0ERHAPS ôTHEN ôWEôCANôSEEô THEô%5SôFUTUREôBEINGôPLAYEDôOUTôINôTHEôCITIESôOFôTHEô7ESTERNô "ALKANSô(ASôTHEôREGIONôDETERIORATEDôINTOôLAWLESSôSTATESôANDô OLIGARCHIES ôORôDOôWEôSEEôHEREôAôNEWôKINDôOFôDEMOCRACYôINô THEôMAKING ôONEôDIFFERENTôFROMôTHATôWHICHôWASôPRACTISEDôINô THEôMODERNISTôSTATEô)NôTHEôPREVIOUSôCENTURY ôBOTHô7ESTERNô ANDô%ASTERNô%UROPEôEMBRACEDôTHEôSOCIALôSTATEôWITHôITSôSLO GAN ô@%QUALITYôANDôJUSTICEôFORôALLômôANôIDEALôWELLôVISUALIZEDôINô MODERNISTôFUNCTIONALôARCHITECTUREô7HILEôMODERNISMôOPERATESô INôAôTOP DOWNôWAYôANDôTHINKSôONôTHEôLARGEôSCALE ôTHEôCITIESô ANDôREGIONSôOFôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSôTODAYôCELEBRATE ôANDôAREô THEôPRODUCTôOF ôBOTTOM UPôINITIATIVESô)NFORMALITYôREIGNSôHERE ô ASôDOôFRAGMENTATION ôADAPTABILITY ôANDôANôEMPHASISôONôTHEôLO CALô4HEôSTATEôOFôCONSTANTôTRANSITIONôISôACCEPTEDôASôAôWORKINGô MODELôANDôAôCOREôGAINô)ôWOULDôPOINTôOUT ôTOO ôTHATôTHEôINFOR MALôCONSOLIDATIONôOFôPROkTSôTOOKôOFF ôONCEôTHEôFORMALôREGULA TIONSôBECAMEôOUTMODEDôANDôNOôLONGERôRElECTEDôTHEôREALITYô


0240_057_self_org.indd 150-151

4ODAY ôINFORMALITYôISôITSELFôTRANSITIONALô7HATôISôNOWôINFORMALôISô BECOMINGôRESTRUCTUREDôANDôINTEGRATEDôINôTHEôSOCIETYô)NôTHISô RESPECT ôTHEôINFORMALôSTRUCTURESôSHOWôHOWôMUCHôTHEôCITIZENSô OFôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSôHAVEôCONTRIBUTEDôTOôCOMPLEXôDYNAMICô SYSTEMSôSUCHôASôGOVERNMENTôINôBUILDINGôAôNEWôSOCIETYô4ODAY ô INFORMALITY ôTOôSOMEôDEGREEôATôLEAST ôFORETELLSôTHEôVALUESôANDô ORGANISATIONALôPRINCIPLESôOFôTHEôSOCIETYôOFôTOMORROWômôONEôTHATô ISôCURRENTLYôSTILLôINôTHEôMAKINGôBUTôMAYôEVENTUALLYôBECOMEôAô MAINSTREAMôPHENOMENON /NôAôVERYôBASICôLEVEL ôTHEôRESTRUCTURINGôOFôMODERNISMôISôSOME THINGô%5ôCITIESôSHAREôWITHôTHEIRô7ESTERNô"ALKANôCOUNTERPARTSô #ITIESôLIKEô"ELGRADE ô0RISHTINAôANDô4IRANAôILLUSTRATEôNOTôONLYôTHEô DISSOLUTIONôOFôTHEôSOCIALôSTATEôANDôTHEôFAILUREôOFôMODERNISTôAR CHITECTUREôANDôITSôNOW DEGRADEDôUTOPIANôPUBLICôSPACES ôBUTô THEYôALSO ôINôTHEôMOSTôBLATANTôWAYS ôSHOWCASEôSTRATEGIESôTHATô %5ôCITIESôAPPROACHôONLYôTIMIDLYômôSTRATEGIESôTHATôINCLUDEôAôNEWô EMPHASISôONôPRIVACY ôSECURITYôANDôLOCALLYôBASEDôSOLUTIONS ôASô WELLôASôAôPREFERENCEôFORôSMALL SCALEôGROWTHô)NôALLôCITIES ôONEôOFô THEôGAINSôOFôECONOMICôANDôPOLITICALôRESTRUCTURINGôHASôBEENôTHEô lOURISHINGôOFôSMALL SCALEôORGANISATIONS 7HILEôNOôONEôINôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSôISôLOOKINGôBACKôATôMOD ERNISM ôTHEô%5ôISôONLYôNOWôDIGESTINGôTHEôDECLINEôOFôMODERN ISMôANDôTHEôMODERNISTôSOCIALôSTATEô#ONSIDER ôFORôEXAMPLE ôTHEô REJECTIONôLASTôYEARôOFôTHEô%5ô#ONSTITUTIONôBYô&RENCHôANDô$UTCHô VOTERSôTHISôSIGNALEDôAôVERYôCLEARôDESIREôTOôLIVEôINôAôMOREôLO CALISEDô%5ô)NôFACT ôTHEô%5ôDOESôOPERATEôALONGôAôPARADIGMôINô WHICHôTHEôREGIONôSERVESôTOôCOUNTERBALANCEôTHEôNATION STATEô,O CALôEMPHASISôMEANSôTHATôMOREôDECISIONSôAREôTAKENôATôTHEôLOCALô LEVEL ôBOTTOM UPôINITIATIVESôINCREASE ôANDôSTATEôANDôLOCALôINSTITU TIONSôBECOMEôMOREôADAPTABLEô&RAGMENTATIONôANDôPARALLELISMô


25/09/06 17:40:57

môWHATô)ôCALLô@INFORMALôSTRATEGIESômôARE ôINDEED ôNOTôONLYôkRMLYô @"ALKANôTHEYôAREôALSOôALREADYôWELL ESTABLISHEDô%5ôSTRATEGIESô )NôCONTRASTôTOôTHEô5NITEDô3TATES ôWHICHôISôTODAYôAôMOREôORôLESSô WELL INTEGRATEDôTERRITORYôWITHôAôSTRONGôCENTRALISEDôGOVERNMENT ô %UROPEôISôDYNAMIC ôCONSISTINGôOFôAôNUMBERôOFôPARALLELôGOVERNINGô BODIES ôEACHôOFôWHICHôDEkNESôAôDIFFERENTôOVERLAPPINGôTERRITORYô 4HEREôISôAô3CHENGENô%UROPE ôAôTAXô%UROPE ôANô%5 MEMBERSHIPô %UROPE ôAô.!4/ô%UROPE ôETCô!SôAôGEOPOLITICALôENTITY ô%UROPEôISô CONSTANTLYôEXPANDING ôADDINGôNEWôSTATESôTOôTHEô%5ôANDôCREAT INGôEXPECTATIONSôINôOTHERôPROSPECTIVEôNEWôMEMBERSô)NSIDEôITSô BOUNDARIES ôTHEôCONSEQUENCESôOFôTHEôSLOWôDISSOLUTIONôOFôTHEô SOCIALôSTATEôANDôTHEôIDEOLOGYôOFôMULTICULTURALISMôCANôBEôSEENô INôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôSMALLERôTERRITORIESôCONSOLIDATEDôAROUNDô ETHNICôORôOTHERôKINDSôOFôCOMMUNITIESô@4RANSITIONôISôACCEPTEDô ASôAôWORKINGôMODEL ôWITHôTHEôRESULTôTHATôAôCIVILôSOCIETYôQUITEô DIFFERENTôFROMôTHEôONEôENVISIONEDôBYôMODERNISMôISôNOWôEMERG INGô4HEôCOUNTRYô)ôLIVEôIN ô3LOVENIA ôISôNOWôPARTôOFôTHEô%5 ôBUTôITô SEEMSôCLEARôTHATôITôWILLôNEVERôHAVEôTHEôSAMEôRIGHTSôANDôOBLIGA TIONSôASôTHEô%5SôFOUNDINGôSTATESô3LOVENESôMAYôBEôEQUAL ôBUTô INôAôDIFFERENTôWAY !NôINTERESTINGôPARALLELôTOôTHEôCURRENTôSITUATIONôCANôBEôSEENôINô THEô.ETHERLANDS ôWHEREôTHEôSOCIALôSTATEôISôINôSLOWôBUTôSTEADYô DECLINEô7HATôWASôONCEô@MULTICULTURALô(OLLANDôISôNOWôMOVINGô AWAYôFROMôMULTICULTURALISMôTOWARDôAôSOCIETYôWITHôETHNICALLYôANDô ECONOMICALLYôDEkNEDôCONSOLIDATEDôTERRITORIESô#URRENTôTRENDSô INCLUDEôTHEôMIGRATIONôOFôTHEôETHNICô$UTCHôFROMôURBANôTOôRURALô AREASô#ITIES ôNOWôLABELEDôDANGEROUS ôAREôBECOMINGôNEGOTIATEDô TERRITORIESôBETWEENôTHEôREMAININGôNATIVEôANDôIMMIGRANTôPOPULA TIONSô"Yô ôTHEôETHNICô$UTCHôAREôEXPECTEDôTOôBEôAôMINORITYô WITHINôTHEôPRESENTôBORDERSôOFôTHEô.ETHERLANDSô4HEôCONCERNSô OFôTHEôLARGERôSOCIETYôAREôMIRROREDôONôTHEôPERSONALôLEVELôBYôMID


0240_057_self_org.indd 152-153

DLE CLASSôRESIDENTSôWHO ôINôPURSUITôOFôTHEIRôOWNôCONSOLIDATEDô TERRITORIES ôMOVEôFROMôCITIESôINTOôGATEDôCOMMUNITIESôWITHôCLEARLYô DEkNEDôBOUNDARIESô(AVERLEIJ ôAôRECENTô6INEXôDEVELOPMENTôINô AôRURALôAREAôôKILOMETERSôFROMô2OTTERDAM ôPRESENTSôAôGOODô EXAMPLEô/NôAPPROXIMATELYôôHECTARESôOFôMOSTLYôUNTOUCHEDô COUNTRYSIDE ôAôNUMBERôOFôSEPARATEôGATEDôCOMMUNITIESôHAVEô BEENôBUILTô4HESEôCOMMUNITIESôAPPROPRIATEôTHEôAESTHETICôOFôAô MEDIEVALôFORTRESSôTOWN ôCOMPLETEôWITHôMOATSômôWHICHôSHOWS ô INDEED ôTHATôIFôTHEôIDEOLOGYôOFôMODERNISMôINôARCHITECTUREôISôTODAYô ONôTHEôWAYôOUT ôTHEôAESTHETICSôOFôARCHETYPALôARCHITECTUREôISôVERYô MUCHôINô&IFTYôHECTARESôOFôGREENôLANDSCAPEôHAVEôBEENôSETôASIDEô FORôGOLFôCOURSES ôONEôOFôTHEôMEASURESôTAKENôTOôPRESERVEôTHEôIDYL LICôGREENôLANDSCAPEô4HEôWINNINGôFORMULAôHEREôISôAôHIGH TECHô COMMUNICATIONSôINFRASTRUCTUREôCOMBINEDôWITHôHUMAN SCALEôSUR ROUNDINGS ôPRIVACY ôSAFETYôANDôTHEôCONTROLôOFôNATURALôRESOURCES /VERôTHEôPASTôYEAR ôWHILEôWORKINGôONôTHEôPROJECTô%UROPEô,OSTô ANDô&OUND ôMYôCO CURATOR ô+YONGô0ARK ôANDô)ôHAVEôTRAVELLEDôSEV ERALôTIMESôTOôTHEôCITIESôOFôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSô-OSTôIMPRESSIVEô INôALLôTHEôCITIESôWEôVISITEDôWASôTHEôBOOMINGôCONSTRUCTIONôINDUS TRYô4AKEô4IRANA ôFORôEXAMPLEôITSôSKYLINEôISôTHATôOFôANôEXTREMELYô VIBRANTôCITYô.UMEROUSôADDITIONSômôMANYôAREôSMALL ôBUTôSOMEô AREôBIGGERôEVENôTHANôTHEôORIGINALôSTRUCTURESôTHEYôAREôBUILTôONô môCOMPETEôWITHôHIGH RISES ôINDIVIDUALôHOUSES ôGATEDôCOMMUNI TIES ôANDôSMALL ôBIGôANDôBIGGERôBUSINESSESô!LLôTHESEôPHENOMENAô CO EXISTôWITHôOLDôSOCIALISTôHOUSING ôWHICHôHASôBEENôRESTRUCTUREDô ANDôREPAINTED ôSOôITSôNEWôFACEôkTSôINôWITHôAôCONkDENT ôFORWARD LOOKINGôSOCIETYôkRMLYôGROUNDEDôINôTHEôHEREôANDôNOWô !ôCITYôREADSôLIKEôANôOPENôBOOKô!RCHITECTURE ôAFTERôALL ôISôTHEô MOSTôIMMEDIATE ôMOSTôEXPRESSIVE ôANDôMOSTôENDURINGôRECORDôOFô THEôHUMANôCONDITIONô)ôBELIEVEôTHATô4IRANA ô0RISHTINA ô"ELGRADEô


25/09/06 17:40:58

+ARLSKRONA $ESCRIPTION 4HEôINTERNETôASôAôLOCALôNETWORKôSELF ORGANISINGôAôMODELôOFôAôREALôCITY 4EXT 4HEôPROJECTôWASôTOôCREATEôAôDIGITALôCOPYôOFôTHEôCITYôOFô+ARLSKRONAôINô3WEDEN ôCALLEDô +ARLSKRONA ôANDôWASôACTIVEôFORôTHREEôYEARSô4HISôCOPYôWASôACCESSIBLEôTOôTHEôCITIZENSô OFôTHEôCITYôVIAôTHEôINTERNET ôWHEREôTHEIRôAVATARSôCOULDôINTERACTôWITHôANDôAMONGôTHEô STREETSôANDôBUILDINGSôOFôTHEôCITYôCENTREôTOôCREATEôAôVIRTUALôVERSIONôOFôTHEôSTRUCTUREôANDô PERSONALôRELATIONSHIPSôINô+ARLSKRONAôTHEôREALôCITY ô ô

4HEôPROJECTôWASôINTENDEDôASôANôEXPERIMENTôINôUSINGôTHEôINTERNETôASôAôLOCALôNET

WORKôRATHERôTHANôAôGLOBALôCOMMUNICATIONôTOOLô4OôWHATôEXTENTôWILLôBEôAôFULkLMENTô OFôINDIVIDUALôORôCOLLECTIVEôFANTASIESô4OôWHATôEXTENTôWILLôITôCONFORMôTOôTHEôPATTERNôOFô +ARLSKRONAô7HATôNEWôPOSSIBILITIESôDOESôTHEôINTERNETSôgFREEôSPACEuôOFFERôTOôANôEXIST INGôCOMMUNITYô+ARLSKRONAôWASôAô@FREEôSPACE ôINôTHEôSENSEôOFôNOTôHAVINGôTOôOBEYô THEôLEGAL ôECONOMICôORôSOCIALôRULESôOFô+ARLSKRONAô!TôTHEôSAMEôTIME ôITôWASôINHABITEDô BYôATôLEASTôPARTôOFôTHEôSAMEôCOMMUNITYôOFôINDIVIDUALSôASôTHEôREALôCITY ôBRINGINGôTHEô CHALLENGEôOFôVIRTUALôREALITYôINTOôTHEôLIVESôOFôNEIGHBOURSôANDôFRIENDSô ô

+ARLSKRONAôWASôINITIALLYôAôREPLICAôOFôTHEôREALôWORLDôCITYôBUTôASôTHEôVIRTUALôCITIZENSô

METôANDôINTERACTEDôTHINGSôCHANGED ôBUILDINGSôREDEkNEDôTHEIRôFUNCTION ôSOCIALôHIERAR CHIESôALTERED ôLAWSôWEREôRECONSTITUTEDôANDôRENEWEDô)TôWASôINTENDEDôTHATôTHEôVIRTUALô +ARLSKRONAôBEôVISIBLEôTOôTHEôREALôCITYôTHROUGHôAôLARGE SCALEôVIDEOôPROJECTIONôINôTHEô MAINôSQUARE ôWHEREôCITIZENSôWOULDôGATHERôINôREALôSPACEôTOôFOLLOWôTHEôACTIVITIESôOFôTHEIRô AVATARSôANDôCONSIDERôTHEôDIVERGENCESôBETWEENô+ARLSKRONAôANDô+ARLSKRONAôTHOUGHô THISôPARTôOFôTHEôPROJECTôWASôNEVERôREALISED ô+ARLSKRONAôISôSTILLôPERHAPSôAôMODELôTHATô COULDôBEôAPPLIEDôINôOTHERôPLACESôANDôOTHERôSITUATIONS SOURCEô 7ILLô"RADLEYô &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWSUPERlEXNETTEXTARTICLESKARLSKRONASHTML WWWSTAFFHUMKUDKTROELSDYKHTM +ARLSKRONAôWASôDEVELOPEDôINôCOLLABORATIONôBETWEENô3UPERlEXôANDô2UNEô.IELSENô

0240_057_self_org.indd 154-155

%XAMPLESôôYôô(>OIPHOLK>

25/09/06 17:41:00

+0&+ôANDô0ACIkCAô2ADIO $ESCRIPTION )NDEPENDENTôRADIOô3TATION 4EXT -ISSIONô3TATEMENTô +0&+ôANDô0ACIkCAôAREôFOUNDEDôUPONôAô-ISSIONô3TATEMENTôWHICHôTOôTHISôDAYôREMAINSô UNIQUEôINôRADIOôBROADCASTINGô 4(%ô0!#)&)#!ô2!$)/ô&/5.$!4)/.ô-)33)/.ô34!4%-%.4 ô 4OôESTABLISHôAô&OUNDATIONôORGANIZEDôANDôOPERATEDôEXCLUSIVELYôFORôEDUCATIONALô PURPOSESôNOôPARTôOFôTHEôNETôEARNINGSôOFôWHICHôINURESôTOôTHEôBENEkTôOFôANYôMEMBERô OFôTHEô&OUNDATIONô ôô 4OôESTABLISHôANDôOPERATEôFORôEDUCATIONALôPURPOSES ôINôSUCHôMANNERôTHATôTHEôFA CILITIESôINVOLVEDôSHALLôBEôASôNEARLYôSELF SUSTAININGôASôPOSSIBLE ôONEôORôMOREôRADIOô BROADCASTINGôSTATIONSôLICENSEDôBYôTHEô&EDERALô#OMMUNICATIONSô#OMMISSIONôANDô SUBJECTôINôTHEIRôOPERATIONôTOôTHEôREGULATORYôACTIONSôOFôTHEô#OMMISSIONôUNDERôTHEô #OMMUNICATIONSô!CTôOFô ô!Sô!MENDED ôô )NôRADIOôBROADCASTINGôOPERATIONSôTOôENCOURAGEôANDôPROVIDEôOUTLETSôFORôTHEôCREATIVEô SKILLSôANDôENERGIESôOFôTHEôCOMMUNITYôTOôCONDUCTôCLASSESôANDôWORKSHOPSôINôTHEô WRITINGôANDôPRODUCINGôOFôDRAMAôTOôESTABLISHôAWARDSôANDôSCHOLARSHIPSôFORôCREATIVEô WRITINGôTOôOFFERôPERFORMANCEôFACILITIESôTOôAMATEURôINSTRUMENTALISTS ôCHORALôGROUPS ô ORCHESTRALôGROUPSôANDôMUSICôSTUDENTSôANDôTOôPROMOTEôANDôAIDôOTHERôCREATIVEô ACTIVITIESôWHICHôWILLôSERVEôTHEôCULTURALôWELFAREôOFôTHEôCOMMUNITY ô )NôRADIOôBROADCASTINGôOPERATIONSôTOôENGAGEôINôANYôACTIVITYôTHATôSHALLôCONTRIBUTEôTOôAô LASTINGôUNDERSTANDINGôBETWEENôNATIONSôANDôBETWEENôTHEôINDIVIDUALSôOFôALLôNATIONS ô RACES ôCREEDSôANDôCOLORSôTOôGATHERôANDôDISSEMINATEôINFORMATIONôONôTHEôCAUSESô OFôCONlICTôBETWEENôANYôANDôALLôOFôSUCHôGROUPSôANDôTHROUGHôANYôANDôALLôMEANSô COMPATIBLEôWITHôTHEôPURPOSESôOFôTHISôCORPORATIONôTOôPROMOTEôTHEôSTUDYôOFôPOLITICALô ANDôECONOMICôPROBLEMSôANDôOFôTHEôCAUSESôOFôRELIGIOUS ôPHILOSOPHICALôANDôRACIALô ANTAGONISMS ô )NôRADIOôBROADCASTINGôOPERATIONSôTOôPROMOTEôTHEôFULLôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôPUBLICôINFORMA TIONôTOôOBTAINôACCESSôTOôSOURCESôOFôNEWSôNOTôCOMMONLYôBROUGHTôTOGETHERôINôTHEô SAMEôMEDIUMôANDôTOôEMPLOYôSUCHôVARIEDôSOURCESôINôTHEôPUBLICôPRESENTATIONôOFô ACCURATE ôOBJECTIVE ôCOMPREHENSIVEôNEWSôONôALLôMATTERSôVITALLYôAFFECTINGôTHEôCOM MUNITY 3OURCE WWWKPFKORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION ô&-ô,OSô!NGELESôô\ôôô&-ô3ANTAô"ARBARA

0240_057_self_org.indd 156-157

%XAMPLESôôYôô(-#(ñ>KAñ->@Fh@>ñ/>AFL

25/09/06 17:41:01

ANDô3ARAJEVO ôOFTENôREFERREDôTOôASô@CITIESôINôCRISIS ôAREôINôFACTô JUSTôCHANGINGôFASTERôTHANôTHEôCITIESôOFôTHEô%5ô!LWAYSôMOREô FRAGMENTEDôTHANô%5ôCITIES ôTHEIRôFACESôTODAYôASSERTôFRAGMEN TATIONôONôAôGRANDôSCALEô!SôARCHITECTô3RDJANô*OVANOVICô{ô7EISSô OBSERVES ôWHEREASôINôTHEô%5ô@FRAGMENTATIONôISôAôSOURCEôOFôFEARô ANDôINSTABILITY ôINôTHEô"ALKANSô@FRAGMENTATIONôISôNORMALô /NEôEXAMPLEôOFôFRAGMENTATIONôISôTHEôSTRIKINGôREDUCTIONôINôTHEô NUMBERôOFôUNITSôCONSIDEREDôIDEALôFORôAôRESIDENTIALôBUILDINGô4HEô SOCIALISTôMODELôOFôTHEôAPARTMENTôBLOCKôCOMPLEXôHOUSINGôUPôTOô ôRESIDENTSôISôBEINGôREPLACEDôBYôTHEôURBANôVILLA ôWHICHô HOUSESôAPPROXIMATELYôôFAMILIESô5RBANôVILLASôAREôHOMEôTOô SMALLôCOMMUNITIESôWITHôSIMILARôCULTURALôVALUESôANDôSTANDARDSôOFô LIVINGô.OTôUNLIKEôTHEôURBANôVILLAGESôOFô(AVERLEIJ ôTHEôEMPHASISô ISôPLACEDôONôPERSONALôVALUESôANDôCONCERNS ôSUCHôASôPRIVACYô ANDôSECURITYô!ôSECONDôEXAMPLEôISôTHEôEXTREMEôPERSONALISATIONô OFôARCHITECTURALôSTYLESô5RBANôVILLASôDISPLAYôEXTREMELYôORNATE ô RICHLYôDIVERSEôANDôHIGHLYôACCENTUATEDôFA±ADESô4HEREôISôNOôSIN GLEôDOMINANTôSTYLE ôBUTôRATHERôAôMULTIPLICITYôTHATôEXPRESSESôTHEô INDIVIDUALôOWNERSôPERSONALôTASTES ôWHETHERôTHISôISôORIENTALISM ô MODERNISMôORôHISTORICISMô3TYLEôHEREôISôEMPHASISEDôTOôSUCHôAô DEGREEôTHATôITôTURNSôINTOôKITSCHôINôTHEôPROCESS ôAUTHENTICITYôMAYô BEôLOSTôBUTôHYBRIDITYôISôGAINEDô!ôHIGHLYôPERSONALISEDôSTYLEôONô AôBUILDINGSôFA±ADEôDISPLAYSôTHEôSELF ASSERTIONôOFôTHEôINDIVIDUALô INôAôSOCIETYôTHATôHASôEXPERIENCEDôTHEôDISSOLUTIONôOFôTHEôSOCIALô STATEô(ERE ôAESTHETICSôHAVEôBECOMEôAôBATTLEkELDô@7HATôISô BEAUTIFULôISôWHATô)ôPERSONALLYôCONSIDERôTOôBEôGOOD

"ALKANISATIONôUSEDôTOôBEôCONSIDEREDôAôNEGATIVE ôAôBYWORDôFORô THEôBREAKUPôOFôUNITYôANDôTHEôUNDERMININGôOFôTHEôSTATEô"UTôTHEô TERMôHASôUNDERGONEôSOMEôRETHINKINGôOFôLATEô4ODAY ôBALKANISA TIONôCANôBEôSEENôASôAôCOUNTERACTIONôTOôGLOBALISATIONô"YôGIVINGô POWERôTOôPARTICLESôANDôGROUPôIDENTITIES ôBYôASSERTINGôBOTTOM UPôINITIATIVESôANDôSELF RULE ôBALKANSZATIONôBECOMESôAôPOTENTIALô FORCEôFORôDEMOCRACYô-OREôTHANôANYTHING ôBALKANISATIONôISôAô SOURCEôOFôDIFFERENCEô&RAGMENTARYôANDôDECENTRALISINGôTENDEN CIESôLEADôTOôTHEôPIXELISATIONôOFôSOCIETY ôGREATERôLOCALôADAPTABILITY ô ANDôPARALLELôSTATESôOFôEXISTENCE

4HEôDRAMATICôREDUCTIONôINôTHEôNUMBERôOFôUNITSôINôAôRESIDENTIALô BUILDINGôANDôTHEôEXTREMEôPERSONALIZATIONôOFôARCHITECTURALôSTYLESô TESTIFYôTOôTHEô@CENTRIFUGALôFORCESôOFôFRAGMENTATIONô4HESE ôINô SHORT ôILLUSTRATEôTHEôVERYôMEANINGôOFôTHEôTERMô@BALKANISATIONô

)FôTHEôFA±ADESôOFôURBANôVILLASôCELEBRATEôINDIVIDUALôEXISTENCE ô THEYôALSOôREASSERTôCONkDENCEôINôAôSOCIETYôINôTHEôMAKING ôIE ôINô TRANSITIONô/VERôTHEôLASTôôYEARS ôMOREôTHANôHALFôTHEôCITIESôINô THEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSôHAVEôBEENôSELF BUILTô)Nô0RISHTINAôANDôINô 4IRANA ôTHEôINFORMALôECONOMYômôOFôWHICHôTHEôGREATESTôCONTRIBU TIONôCOMESôFROMôTHEôCONSTRUCTIONôINDUSTRYômôISôLARGERôTHANôTHEô FORMALôECONOMYô7HEREASôCITYôAUTHORITIESôTURNEDôAôBLINDôEYEô TOôSELF INITIATEDôCONSTRUCTIONôDURINGôTHEôLARGE SCALEôMIGRATIONSô TOôCITIESôINôTHEôS ôTODAYôTHEôPOLICYôISôTOôACCEPTôTHEôFACTSô ONôTHEôGROUNDôANDôINTEGRATEôINFORMALôCONSTRUCTIONSôTOôMAKEô THEôCITYôANDôTHEôECONOMYôSUSTAINABLEô4WOôEXAMPLESôCOMEô TOôMINDô4HEôTOPôlOORSôOFôSOMEôOFôMOSTôPROMINENTôHIGH RISESô INôTHEô4IRANAôCITYôCENTER ôWHICHôWEREôADDEDôWITHOUTôANYôLEGALô PERMITS ôAREôINôTHEôPROCESSôOFôBEINGôLEGALISEDôTHEôCONSTRUC TIONôCANôREMAIN ôPROVIDEDôTHATôTHEôOWNERSôPAYôFORôITôAFTERôTHEô FACT ô4HEôMUNICIPALITYôISôNEGOTIATINGôNOTôONLYôWITHôDEVELOPERS ô BUTôALSOôWITHôINDIVIDUALSôWHOSEôHOUSESôMAKEôUPôTHEôINFORMALô CITYôONôTHEôOUTSKIRTSôOFô4IRANAô4HEôMAYORôWENTôONôPUBLICôTELEVI SIONôWITHôREPRESENTATIVESôOFôTHESEôSETTLEMENTSôTOôDISCUSSôTHEô INFRASTRUCTURALôPROBLEMSôTHEYôFACED ôSUCHôASôDIFkCULTIESôWITHôTHEô WATERôANDôPOWERôSUPPLYôANDôTHEôSEWAGEôSYSTEMô



0240_057_self_org.indd 158-159

25/09/06 17:41:01

.EGOTIATIONSôBETWEENôFORMALôANDôINFORMALôSTRUCTURESôWORKô WELLôINô4IRANAô)TôAPPEARSôTHATôINFORMALôSTRUCTURESôAREôBEINGô ACCEPTEDôASôEQUALôPARTNERSôWITHôTHEôFORMALôCITYô!FTERôALL ôTHEô INFORMALôECONOMYôWASôAôKEYôFACTORôINôREBUILDINGôAôFUNCTIONALô SOCIETYôAFTERôTHEôFORMALôECONOMYôANDôPOLITICALôSTRUCTURESôCOL LAPSEDôINôTHEôSô4IRANASôEXAMPLE ôHOWEVER ôISôHARDLYôUNI VERSALô)NôTHEôVASTôMAJORITYôOFôCASES ôTHEôSHEERôMASSôOFôINFORMALô STRUCTURESôDOESôNOTôGUARANTEEôANYôCHANGEôINôATTITUDEôONôTHEô PARTôOFôTHEôFORMALôSYSTEM ôWHICHôCONTINUESôTOôHOLDôTHEôREINSô OFôPOWERôINôITSôOWNôHANDS ôKEEPINGôTHEôINFORMALôSTRUCTURESô ONôTHEôMARGINSôWHILEôTHOSEôWHOôTAKEôPARTôINôSUCHôSTRUCTURESô REMAINôSECOND CLASSôCITIZENSô4OôCHANGEôPOLICIESôVIS · VISôTHEô INFORMALôMEANSôTOôACKNOWLEDGEôSOCIALôCHANGEô&ORôMANYôPEO PLE ôINFORMALITYôREMAINSôAôSCARYôWORDô4HOUGHôEVERYôECONOMYô INCLUDESôAôCERTAINôPERCENTAGEôOFôINFORMALôSTRUCTURES ôTHEôUSUALô FEARôISôTHATôIFôTHESEôSTRUCTURESôWEREôTOôGROWôOUTôOFôPROPORTION ô THEYôCOULDôPOTENTIALLYôOVERWHELMôTHEô@REGULATEDôSOCIETYôANDô BRINGôABOUTôITSôDOWNFALL 7EôTENDôTOôFORGETôTHATôREGULATIONôISôITSELFôAôNATURALôPROCESSô 4AKEôLANDôLAWS ôFORôEXAMPLEô/NEôOFôTHEôPRINCIPALôOBJECTIVESô BEHINDôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôLANDôLAWSôISôTHEôEQUITABLEôDISTRIBU TIONôOFôLANDô)Nô3OUTHô!MERICA ôWHEREôTHEôLEGACYôOFôCOLONIALô HISTORYôCREATESôRESISTANCEôTOôCHANGE ôINFORMALôSETTLEMENTSôMAYô BEôUNDERSTOODôASôNATURALôPROCESSESôINôTHEôREDISTRIBUTIONôOFô LANDôOWNERSHIPô)TôISôTELLINGôTHATôONEôOFôTHEôkRSTôPOLICIESôOFôTHEô CURRENTô@LEFTISTô#HAVISTAôGOVERNMENTôINô6ENEZUELAôWASôTOôSTARTô LEGALIZINGôTHEôINFORMALôCITYôINô#ARACASô)Nô4IRANA ôWHEREôINFORMALô CONSTRUCTIONSôCLAIMôPUBLICôLANDôTHATôHADôBEENôNATIONALIZEDôDUR INGôTHEôSOCIALISTôPERIOD ôTHEôSTRATEGYôOFôAFTER THE FACTôLEGALIZINGô OFôTHEôILLEGALôCITYôHAPPENEDô@NATURALLY


0240_057_self_org.indd 160-161

-OSTôPEOPLEôINô+OSOVOôWORKôOUTSIDEôTHEôFORMALôECONOMY ôINô CASUALôORôUNREGISTEREDôEMPLOYMENTô4HEôCONSTRUCTIONôINDUSTRYô ACCOUNTSôFORôAôLARGEôPARTôOFôTHEôINFORMALôECONOMYô4HEô5.ô ADMINISTRATIONôANDôLOCALôPOLITICALôINSTITUTIONSôFACEôTHEôGROW INGôDISENCHANTMENTôOFôTHEôCITIZENS ôWHOôSEEôTHEôGOVERNINGô BODIESôASôUNRESPONSIVEôTOôTHEIRôCONCERNSô4HEREôISôAôLACKôOFô CLEARôPERSPECTIVEôONôRESOLVINGô+OSOVOSôSTATUSôANDôNOôCLEARô POLICYôONôDOMESTICôISSUESô4HEôECONOMYôISôNOWôTRYINGôTOôADAPTô TOôAôFUTUREôWITHOUTôRECONSTRUCTIONôASSISTANCEô%5ôINSTITUTIONSô HAVEôBEENôANDôCONTINUEôTOôBEôTHEôLARGESTôDONORS ôTHOUGHôTHEô AMOUNTôOFôAIDôHASôRECENTLYôDECREASEDô4HEôPOSTWARôBOOMôINô +OSOVOôHASôGRADUALLYôTURNEDôINTOôAôPOSTWARôCRISISô4HEôMASSIVEô INTERNATIONALôSUPPORTôCOMINGôTOôTHEôREGIONôAFTERôTHEôWARôHADô ANôEFFECTôTHATôWASôNOTôUNLIKEôTHEôSTRIKINGôOFôOILô"UTôTHEôINITIALô ECONOMICôBOOMôDIDôNOTôGENERATEôAôSUSTAINABLEôECONOMYôINô 0RISHTINAômôWHICHôWASôSOMETHINGôTHATô4IRANAôMANAGEDôTOôDOô THROUGHôTHEôHELPôOFôTHEôINFORMALôECONOMYôANDôWITHOUTôTHEô LARGEôAMOUNTôOFôFOREIGNôAIDôTHATô0RISHTINAôRECEIVEDô/THERôVITALô TOPICSôINô+OSOVOôAREôSECURITYôANDôTHEôPUSHôFORôDECENTRALISA TIONô4HEôDESIREôTOôINCREASEôTHEôNUMBERôOFôMUNICIPALITIESôONô THEôSAMEôAMOUNTôOFôTERRITORYôPRESENTSôMOREôANXIETIESô7ILLô +OSOVOôBECOMEôAôSEGREGATEDôSOCIETYô#ANôAôFOCUSôONôTHEô LOCALôBEôHARMFULô )NôTHEôCASEôOFô+OSOVO ôTHEôMAINôPROBLEMôISôTHEôLACKôOFôINTERNA TIONALLYôRECOGNISEDôSOVEREIGNTYô4HISôMAKESôITôIMPOSSIBLEôFORô LOCALôGOVERNMENTôTOôTACKLEôSUCHôFUNDAMENTALôCHALLENGESôASô PRIVATISATIONôANDôPROPERTYôLAWSô)TôALSOôMAKESôITôIMPOSSIBLEôFORô +OSOVOôTOôBEôAôPARTNERôONôEQUALôFOOTINGôWITHôTHEôINTERNATIONALô COMMUNITYô#ANôWEôSAYôTHATô+OSOVOôISôBEINGôTREATEDôASôANô @INFORMALôNATIONôINôTHEôCOMMUNITYôOFô%UROPEANôNATIONSô


25/09/06 17:41:02

4ODAY ô+OSOVOSôPOPULATIONôISôTHEôYOUNGESTôINô%UROPE ôWHILEô THATôOFôTHEô%5ôISôSHRINKINGô4HESEôTWOôFACTSôALONEôCREATEôAô CRISISôMENTALITYô)SôITôPOSSIBLEôTOôSWITCHôFROMôAôCRISISôMENTALITYô TOôTHINKINGôINôTERMSôOFôAôSTATEôOFôCONSTANTôTRANSITIONô7ITHOUTô AôDOUBT ôINôTHISôREGARDôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSôAREôWAYôAHEADô OFôTHEô%5ô4HEôREGIONôHASôNOTôEXPERIENCEDôTRUEôPOLITICALôANDô ECONOMICôSTABILITYôSINCEôTHEôDECLINEôANDôCOLLAPSEôOFôTHEô/TTO MANôANDô(ABSBURGôEMPIRESôTHEôCITIESôOFôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSô HAVEôBEENôINôCONTINUOUSôTRANSITIONôSINCEôTHEôLATEôTHôCENTURYô 4HEYôHAVEôADAPTEDôTOôTHEôSTRATEGIESôOFôPARALLELISMôANDôFRAG MENTATIONô)NDEED ôTHESEôSTRATEGIESôHAVEôCREATEDôTHEôDYNAMICô TERRITORYôWEôIDENTIFYôASôTHEô7ESTERNô"ALKANSô#ANôTHEôCITIESô INô%5ôMEMBERôSTATES ôASôWELLôASôINôTHOSEôCOUNTRIESôCURRENTLYô PLANNINGôTOôJOINôTHEô%5 ôLEARNôFROMôSUCHô@"ALKANôSTRATEGIESô #ANôSUCHôINFORMALôSTRATEGIESôLEADôTOôAôCIVILôSOCIETYôDIFFERENTô FROMôTHEôONEôENVISIONEDôBYôTHEôMODERNISTôSOCIETIESôOFôTHEôTHô CENTURYô)ôBELIEVEôTHEYôCANô7EôEMBRACEôANDôEXPLOREôTHEôSTATEô OFôTRANSITIONôBECAUSEôWEôAREôCURIOUSôABOUTôWHATôITôLOOKSôLIKEô ANDôHOWôITôWORKSô"UTôATôHEART ôTHEôSTATEôOFôTRANSITIONôFASCINATESô USôBECAUSEôWEôLIVEôIT


0240_057_self_org.indd 162-163


25/09/06 17:41:02

)NDEPENDENTô MEDIAôAND SELF ORGANISED CULTUREôINô THEô53ô 3ITUATIONSô ANDô STRATEGIES #OMPILEDôANDôEDITEDôBYô -ARTHAô7ALLNERôANDô7ILLô"RADLEY


0240_057_self_org.indd 164-165

)NDEPENDENTôMEDIAôANDôSELF ORGANISEDôCULTUREôINôTHEô53ô3ITUATIONSôANDôSTRATEGIES

25/09/06 17:41:02

)NDYMEDIAômô3ASHAô#ONSTANZA #HOCK

)NDYMEDIA

&REEô3PEECHô2ADIOô.EWSômô!DRIENNEô,AUBY

3ASHAô#ONSTANZA #HOCK

%LECTRONICô)NTIFADAômô.IGELô0ARRY /THERô#INEMAôANDô!4!ô'ALLERY ômô#RAIGô"ALDWIN 4EMPORARYô3ERVICESômô"RETTô"LOOM

4OôCOMPILEôTHISôSECTIONôOFôTHEôBOOK ôWEô INVITEDôAôNUMBERôOFôINDEPENDENTôORôCOM MUNITY BASEDôMEDIAôANDôCULTURALôORGANI SATIONSôBASEDôINôTHEô53ôTOôRESPONDôTOôAô SHORTôQUESTIONNAIREôABOUTôTHEIRôACTIVITIESô 7EôWEREôINTERESTEDôBOTHôINôTHEôDAY TO DAYôPRACTICALITIESôOFôCREATINGôANDôMAIN TAININGôTHISôKINDôOFôSELF ORGANISEDôPRAC TICEôANDôINôTHEôUNDERLYINGôMOTIVATIONSô ANDôINSPIRATIONSô4HEôSIXôQUESTIONSôWEô ASKEDôWERE ô7HATôAREôTHEôAIMSôOFôTHEôPROJECTôYOUôAREôINVOLVEDôIN ô(OWôISôTHEôPROJECTôORGANISED ô(OWôDOôYOUôSUPPORTôTHEôWORKôkNANCIALLYôANDôWHATôIMPACTô DOESôTHISôHAVEôONôYOURôPROJECT ô7HATôDOôYOUôFEELôYOUôHAVEôACHIEVED ôANDôWHATôAREôTHEôPROB LEMSôYOUôFACE ô!REôTHEREôANYôPASTôPROJECTSMODELSôWHICHôHAVEôINSPIREDô YOU ô7HATôAREôYOURôHOPESôFORôTHEôFUTURE 7EREôGRATEFULôTOôALLôTHEôCONTRIBUTORSôFORôPROVIDINGôAôWEALTHôOFô INFORMATION ôINSIGHTôANDôINSPIRATIONô4HEIRôRESPONSESôAREôPRE SENTEDôHEREôWITHôMINIMALôEDITINGô

ô7HATôAREôTHEôAIMSôOFôTHEôPROJECTôYOUôAREôINVOLVEDôIN )LLôRESPONDôTOôTHESEôBASEDôONôMYôINVOLVEMENTôWITHôTHEô)NDY MEDIAôNETWORKô/VERôTHEôPASTôFEWôYEARSô)VEôWORKEDôTOôHELPôOR GANIZEDôTEMPORARYô)-#SôTOôCOVERôMASSôMOBILIZATIONSô#ANCUN ô -IAMIô&4!! ôONôCOLLABORATIVEôDOCUMENTARYôPROJECTSôINCLUDINGô THEô-IAMIô-ODELôFTAAIMCORGMIAMIMODEL ôANDôONôVARIOUSôOTH ERôAUTONOMISTôMEDIAôGATHERINGSôANDôPROJECTSô)ôALSOôWORKôWITHô VIDEOINDYMEDIAORGôANDôOCCASIONALLYôONôFEATURESôFORôGLOBALô )-#ôWWWINDYMEDIAORG ôASôWELLôASôPUBLISHôTOôLOCALô)-#Sô CURRENTLYô)ôkNDôMYSELFôLIVINGôINô,! ôSOôTOô,!ô)NDYMEDIA @)NDYMEDIAôISôAôCOLLECTIVEôOFôINDEPENDENTôMEDIAôORGANIZATIONSô ANDôHUNDREDSôOFôJOURNALISTSôOFFERINGôGRASSROOTS ôNON CORPORATEô COVERAGEô)NDYMEDIAôISôAôDEMOCRATICôMEDIAôOUTLETôFORôTHEôCREA TIONôOFôRADICAL ôACCURATE ôANDôPASSIONATEôTELLINGSôOFôTRUTH 4HEô)NDYMEDIAôVIDEOôDISTRIBUTIONôNETWORKôVIDEOINDYMEDIA ORG ôISôANôATTEMPTôTOôBETTERôCOORDINATEôSHARINGôOFôVIDEOôMATE RIALôTHROUGHOUTôTHEô)NDYMEDIAôNETWORKôANDôBEYONDô3EEôTHEô NEXTôQUESTION ô(OWôISôTHEôPROJECTôORGANISED 4HEô)NDYMEDIAôNETWORKôISôORGANIZEDôINôAôKINDôOFôGLOBALLYôFEDER ATEDôNETWORKôOFôLOCALôCOLLECTIVESô%ACHôLOCALôCOLLECTIVEôHASôAô GREATôDEALôOFôAUTONOMYôFROMôTHEôNETWORK ôALTHOUGHôALLôHAVEôTOô ADHEREôTOôTHEôBASICô0OINTSôOFô5NITY $ECISION MAKINGôATôBOTHôLOCALôANDôINTERNATIONALôLEVELSôHAPPENSô


0240_057_self_org.indd 166-167


25/09/06 17:41:02

,ADYFEST $ESCRIPTION ,ADYFESTôISôFORôEVERYONE 4EXT 7HATôISô,ADYFEST ,ADYFESTSôAREôNON PROkTôEVENTSôORGANISEDôMAINLYôBYôWOMENôTHEYôAIMôTOôSHOWCASEô THEôTALENTSôOFôFEMALEôARTISTSôANDôPERFORMERSô4HEôEVENTSôAREôFOCUSEDôMAINLYôONôEN COURAGINGôTHEôTALENTôOFôWOMENôANDôGIRLS ôBUTôAREôOPENôTOôEVERYONEô)TSôROOTSôAREôINô THEôUNDERGROUNDôSCENE ô

4HEôkRSTôEVERô,ADYFESTôTOOKôPLACEôINô/LYMPIA ô7ASHINGTONôINôô4HEôFOLLOWINGô

YEARôSIMILARôEVENTSôTOOKôPLACEôACROSSôTHEô53ô,ADYFESTô-IDWESTôINô#HICAGOôANDô ,ADYFESTô%ASTôINô.EWô9ORK ôANDôALSOôINô'LASGOW ô3COTLANDô,ADYFESTô3COTLAND ô

&ORôTHEôFOLLOWINGôTHREEôYEARS ôGRRLSôFROMôTHEô53ôANDô%UROPEANôCOUNTRIESôALSOô

ORGANIZEDôTHEIRôOWN ôANDôITôLOOKSôLIKEôTHEôTRENDôISôNOTôOVERôYETô ô

,ADYFESTôISôALSOôMEANTôTOôBEôAôPLACEôWHEREôVISITORSôCANôDISCUSSôANDôTAKEôACTIONô

ONôTHEIRôVIEWSôONôTOPICSôSUCHôASôMYSOGINISMôINôTHEôARTSôANDôBEAUTYôSTANDARDSôANDô OTHERS ôATTENDôSHOWSôBYôFEMALEôPERFORMERS ôANDôCANôJUSTôHAVEôAôGOODôTIMEôINôAôSPACEô WHEREôTHEYôFEELôCOMFORTABLEôTOôBEôTHEMSELVES 3OURCE WWWLADYFESTEUROPEORGOLDGENERALINFOHTML &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWLADYFESTEUROPEORG WWWLADYFESTORG

0240_057_self_org.indd 168-169

%XAMPLESôôYôô)>AVCBPQ

25/09/06 17:41:03

THROUGHôCONSENSUSô4HEôCONSENSUSôPROCESSôISôDIFFERENTôINôDIF FERENTôPARTSôOFôTHEôWORLDôANDôSOMETIMESôISôMOREôFORMAL ôSOME TIMESôLOOSER ôOCCASIONALLYôLEADSôTOôSPLITSôANDôCONlICTS ôBUTôFORô THEôMOSTôPARTôFUNCTIONSôWELLôANDôISôAôPARTôOFôTHEô)NDYMEDIAô MODELôANDôOFôPREkGURATIVEôPOLITICSôINôGENERALôBUILDôTHEôNEWô WORLDôWEôWANTôWITHINôTHEôROTTINGôSHELLôOFôTHEôOLDôw 7HENôDECISIONSôHAVEôTOôHAPPENôTHATôAFFECTôTHEôWHOLEôNETWORK ô THEYôHAPPENôVIAôDELEGATESôFROMôALLôTHEôLOCALSô4HISôISôINCREDIBLYô COMPLICATEDôBYôLANGUAGEôSINCEôEVERYTHINGôHASôTOôBEôTRANSLATEDô INTOôASôMANYôOFôTHEôNETWORKSôWORKINGôLANGUAGESôASôPOSSIBLE ô WHICHôISôAôLARGEôNUMBERôTHATôKEEPSôGROWINGôEVERYôFEWôMONTHSô w 4HEREôISôAôVALID ôCRITIQUEôOFô)-#ôPROCESSôTHATôISôALSOôAôCRITIQUEô OFôTHEôNETWORKôINôGENERAL ôWHICHôISôTHATôITSôINTERNET CENTRICôANDô THEREFOREôTHOSEôWITHôTHEôMOSTô)NTERNETôACCESSôPERSONALôCOMPUT ERS ôBROADBANDôCONNECTIONS ôETC ôHAVEôTHEôMOSTôSAYô)ôWOULDôSAYô THATôTHEôTRUTHôOFôTHEôCRITIQUEôFORôLOCALô)-#SôVARIESôWILDLYôACROSSô THEôNETWORKôNODESômôSOMEôUSEôTHEôNETôMOSTLYôASôAôRESOURCEô ANDôKINDôOFôLIKEôAôNEWSôWIREôTOôPULLôCONTENTôDOWNôFORôLOCALôDISTROô VIAôPAPERS ôRADIOôSTATIONS ôLEAlET ôWHATEVERôWORKSô/THERSôHAVEô REVERSEôPRIORITIESôANDôALMOSTôDOôEVERYTHINGôONôTHEôWEBSITE ôONLYô OCCASIONALLYôDOINGôOFlINEôPROJECTSô)TôDEPENDSôONôTHEô)-# ô(OWôDOôYOUôSUPPORTôTHEôWORKôkNANCIALLYôANDôWHATôIMPACTô DOESôTHISôHAVEôONôYOURôPROJECT 4HISôISôAôHUGEôQUESTIONôô!GAIN ôLOCALô)-#SôHAVEôAUTONOMYô OVERôkNANCESô)NôPRACTICE ôNONEôOFôTHEô)-#ôWEBSITESôRUNSôADSô NONEôOFôTHEôRADIOôSTATIONSôLINKEDôTOô)NDYMEDIAôRUNôADSôTHATô)ô KNOWôOF ôMANYôOFôTHEôPRINTôPROJECTSôDOôCHOOSEôTOôRUNôADSôFROMô RADICALôORôPROGRESSIVEôBUSINESSESôWORKER OWNEDôCOOPSôFORô


0240_057_self_org.indd 170-171

EXAMPLE ôINôORDERôTOôCOVERôPRINTôCOSTSô/NE TIMEôMOBILIZATIONô COSTSôSETTINGôUPôAôTEMPORARYô)-# ôTRANSPORTATIONôANDôEQUIP MENTSôCOSTS ôAREôSOMETIMESôFUNDEDôBYôFUNNELINGôMONEYôFROMô FOUNDATIONSôORô.'/SôTHROUGHô)-# CONNECTEDôINDIVIDUALSôORô SPIN OFFôRADICALôMEDIAôPROJECTS ôBUTôALMOSTôNEVERôTHROUGHô@)N DYMEDIAô5RBANAô#HAMPAIGNô)-#ôHASôC ô;TAX EXEMPTô CHARITABLE=ôSTATUSôANDôHASôSERVEDôASôkSCALôSPONSORôFORôMANYô PROJECTS ôBUTôTHATôSTATUSôITSELFôHASôGENERATEDôINTENSEôHEATEDô DEBATEôWITHINôTHEôNETWORKôBASEDôONôSOMEôLOCALSôBELIEFôTHATôNOô )-#ôSHOULDôBEôAôLEGALôENTITYôWITHôRECOGNITIONôFROMôANYô3TATE ô LETôALONEôTHEô53ô'OVERNMENTô,OCALLY ô5#)-#ôHASôBEENôVERYô SUCCESSFULôATôRAISINGôMONEY ôANDôLASTôYEARôTHEYôRAISEDôENOUGHô TOôPURCHASEôTHEô53ô0OSTô/FkCEôBUILDINGô 4HEREôISôAôLONG RUNNINGôDEBATEôINô)-#ôOVERôgVALIDuôSOURCESôOFô FUNDINGô3OMEôTHINKôEVERYTHINGôMUSTôBEôVOLUNTARYôORôIN KINDô CONTRIBUTIONS ôOTHERSôPOINTôOUTôTHATôTHISôPRIVILEGESôTHOSEôWITHô ACCESSôTOôOTHERôINCOMEô6ERYôFEWôPEOPLEôHAVEôEVERôRECEIVEDô WAGESôFORô)NDYMEDIAôWORK ôBUTôITôHASôHAPPENEDôONôOCCASIONô WITHINôPARTICULARôLOCALôCONTEXTS 4HEREôWASôAôHUGEôDEBATEôAôCOUPLEôYEARSôAGOôWHENôTHEô&ORDô &OUNDATIONôOFFEREDôAôLARGEôGRANTôTOô)NDYMEDIA ôBUTô,ATINô!MERI CANô)-#SôINSISTEDôTHEôMONEYôBEôREJECTEDôBOTHôONôGROUNDSôOFô PRINCIPLEDôINDEPENDENCEôFROMôPRIVATEôFOUNDATIONS ôANDôSPE CIkCALLYôBECAUSEôOFôTHEôHISTORYôOFôTHEô&ORDôCOMPANYôINô,ATINô !MERICANôPOLITICS ô7HATôDOôYOUôFEELôYOUôHAVEôACHIEVED ôANDôWHATôAREôTHEôPROB LEMSôYOUôFACE ,ETôMEôJUSTôSAYôTHATôTHEREôAREôLOTSôOFôIMPORTANTôCRITIQUESôOFô ô)NDYMEDIAô7HITEôMALE ôTECH CENTRICITY ôQUESTIONSôOFôACCESS ô


25/09/06 17:41:03

THEôTYRANNYôOFôSTRUCTURELESSNESS ôETCô(OWEVER ôATôTHEôSAMEô TIMEô) ôLIKEôMANY ôCONTINUEôTOôPARTICIPATEôINôTHEôNETWORKôBECAUSEô ATôITSôBESTôMOMENTSôITôBECOMESôAôPOWERFULôEXAMPLEôOFôgACTU ALLYôEXISTINGuôRADICALLY DECENTRALIZED ôAUTONOMOUSôFROMôSTATEô ANDôMARKET ôDEEPLYôGLOBALLYôINTERCONNECTED ôBOTTOM UPôCOM MUNICATIONôNETWORKôTHATôWALKSôTHEôWALKôANDôPRODUCESôINTENSE ô VIBRANT ôPASSIONATEôTELLINGSôOFôTRUTHôANDôCIRCULATIONôOFôSTRUGGLESô THROUGHOUTôTHEôWORLD -OREôINFORMATIONô WWWINDYMEDIAORG

&REEô3PEECHô2ADIOô.EWS !DRIENNEô,AUBY

ô7HATôAREôTHEôAIMSôOFôTHEôPROJECTôYOUôAREôINVOLVEDôIN &REEô3PEECHô2ADIOô.EWSô&32. ôHASôASôITSôPRIMARYôGOALôTOô PRODUCEôAô MINUTEô-ONDAYm&RIDAYôINDEPENDENTôRADIOôNEWS CASTô7ITHôAôNETWORKôOFôOVERôôFREELANCEôREPORTERSôAROUNDô THEôWORLD ô&32.ôSERVESôOVERôôRADIOôSTATIONSôANDôAôGROWINGô CADREôOFô)NTERNETôOUTLETSô&32.ôAIMSôTOôBRINGôTHEôWORLDôTOôTHEô 53ôINôkRST HANDôREPORTAGEôOFôEVERYôCONTINENTôBYôINDEPEND ENTôREPORTERSôCOVERAGEôTHATô#..ôCANôONLYôDREAMôOFô7ITHôAô DIVERSITYôOFôVOICES ôINôETHNICITY ôAGEôANDôCLASS ôWHICHôOUTSTRIPSô EVERYôOTHERôNEWSôORGANIZATIONô&32.ôAIMSôTOôBEôTHEôVANGUARDô 53ôNEWSôSOURCEôFORôTHEôMAJORITYômôTHOSEôQUESTIONINGôWARSôONô INNOCENTôPEOPLEôATôHOMEôANDôABROADô/URôOVERôONEôMILLIONôLIS TENERSôINCLUDEôMANYôWITHOUTô)NTERNETôACCESSôANDôWEôAREôPROUDô TOôJOINô.ATIONALô.ATIVEô.EWSôASôTHEôONLYôPROGRESSIVEôDAILYôNEWSô OUTLETSôFORôTHOSEôFORGOTTENôBYôHIGH TECHôHYPE ô(OWôISôTHEôPROJECTôORGANISED &32.ôISôAôMULTI GENERATIONAL ôMULTI CLASS ôMULTI RACEôORGANIZA TIONôWITHôMANYôSTRONGôWOMENôOFôCOLORôINôLEADERSHIPô2EPORT ERSôWHOôACHIEVEôAôMINIMUMôLEVELôOFôPRODUCEDôSTORIESôANDôALLô STAFFôAUTOMATICALLYôBECOMEôVOTINGôMEMBERSôOFô&32.ô$AILYô NEWSCASTôDECISIONSôAREôMADEôBYôEDITORIALôANDôPRODUCTIONôSTAFFô TEAMôMEMBERSôWHOôWORKôINôCONSTANTôCOMMUNICATIONôTHROUGH OUTôTHEôDAYô/RGANIZATIONALôDECISIONSôANDôPRIORITIES ôINCLUDINGô PERSONNEL ôkNANCEôANDôHIRINGôCOMMITTEEôWORK ôAREôSETôBYôAô MEMBER ELECTEDô3TEERINGô#OMMITTEEô&INALôRESPONSIBILITYôANDô GOVERNANCEôPOWERôRESTSôWITHôTHEôELECTEDôBOARDôOFôDIRECTORSôASô MANDATEDôBYôOURôBY LAWSôANDô#ALIFORNIAôNON PROkTôLAW


0240_057_self_org.indd 172-173


25/09/06 17:41:04

/URôINTERNALôSTRUCTUREôISôlEXIBLE ôPOROUSôANDôPEER DRIVENô7Eô ATTEMPTôTHEôlUIDITYôANDôINCLUSIVENESSôOFôVOLUNTEER STAFFEDôNON PROkTS ôUTILIZEôTHEôTOOLSôOFôCORPORATEôEXECUTIVESôANDôDEMON STRATEôTHEôCOHESIONôOFôAôWINNINGôBASKETBALLôTEAMô/URôGOALôISô ANôONGOINGôDEMONSTRATIONôTHATôINDIVIDUALSôWHOôWORKôFORôAôMOREô EQUITABLEôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôWEALTHôANDôPOWERôDOôNOTôHAVEôTOôMAKEô EACHôOTHERôMISERABLEôALONGôTHEôWAY ô(OWôDOôYOUôSUPPORTôTHEôWORKôkNANCIALLYôANDôWHATôIMPACTô DOESôTHISôHAVEôONôYOURôPROJECT /URôWORKôISôSUPPORTEDôBYôOURôAFkLIATEôSTATIONSôTHOSEôWHOôAIRô OURôBROADCAST ôOCCASIONALôGRANTSôANDôBYôLISTENERSôWHOôMAKEô REGULARôDONATIONSô)NDIVIDUALôSTATIONSôNOTôONLYôINCLUDEôUSôINôTHEIRô BUDGETSôBUTôALSOôSHAREôWORKINGôSPACEôANDôOTHERôORGANIZATIONALô RESOURCESô4HISôISôPARTICULARLYôTRUEôOFôTHEô0ACIkCAô&OUNDATION ô WHICHôSHARESôOURôHISTORYôANDôWHOSEôkVEôSTATIONSôAREôAMONGô OURôLARGESTôAFkLIATES 4HEREôAREôMANYôADVANTAGESôINôWORKINGôSOôCLOSELYôWITHôAFkLIATEô STATIONS ôINCLUDINGôTHEôABILITYôTOôSHAREôREPORTERSôANDôLOCALôUN DERSTANDINGôOFôIMPORTANTôSTORIESô7ITHOUTôTHEM ôESPECIALLYôTHEô 0ACIkCAô&OUNDATION ôWEôCOULDôNOTôMAINTAINôTHEôBASICôQUALITYô ANDôCREDIBILITYôOFôTHEôNEWSCAST /URôSTAFFôMEMBERSôCURRENTLYôWORKôWITHOUTôHEALTHôANDôOTHERô BENEkTS ôANDôTHEôFEEôWEôOFFERôREPORTERSôISôNOTôCONSISTENTôWITHôAô LIVINGôWAGEô7EôASKôFORôDIFkCULT ôNUANCEDôWORKôFROMôOURôREPORT ERSôANDôOFFERôTHEMôPEANUTSôINôEXCHANGEô"ECAUSEôOURôkNANCESô SEVERELYôLIMITôOURôWORK ôWEôHAVEôOCCASIONALLYôSPENTôTOOôMUCHô TIMEôCHASINGôLARGEôAMOUNTSôOFôMONEYô,ATELY ôWEôHAVEôPURSUEDô BULKôMAILôANDôOTHERôMETHODSôTOôDIVERSIFYôANDôDEEPENôOURôBASEô OFôSUPPORT


0240_057_self_org.indd 174-175

ô7HATôDOôYOUôFEELôYOUôHAVEôACHIEVED ôANDôWHATôAREôTHEôPROB LEMSôYOUôFACE 4HEô&32.ô.EWCASTôHASôRAISEDôTHEôBARôFORôRADIOôNEWSôINôTHEô 53ôINôREPORTINGôFROMôTHEôNEWSôSITEôANDôINôTHEôNUMBERôOFôIN TERVIEWEESôQUOTEDô/THER ôMOREôCOMMERCIAL ôNEWSôPROGRAMSô HAVEôCLOSEDôINTERNATIONALôBUREAUSôANDôLAIDôOFFôFOREIGNôREPORT ERSô7EôHAVEôEXPANDEDôANDôSOUGHTôSTORIESôAROUNDôTHEôWORLDô FROMôPEOPLEôWHOôHADôkRSTôHANDôKNOWLEDGEôANDôEXPERIENCEô 7EôAREôONEôOFôTHEôFEWôRADIOôOUTLETSôTOôOFFERôTRAININGôANDôAC CEPTôREPORTSôFROMôINDIVIDUALSôWHOôAREôNEWôTOôREPORTINGô!SôAô PAIDôOUTLETôFORôREPORTERSôINôOURôAFkLIATEôSTATIONôNEWSôDEPART MENTS ôWEVEôPLAYEDôAôPARTôINôKEEPINGôLOCALôNEWSôALIVEôINôCOM MUNITYôRADIO 0RIMARILY ôWEôHAVEôBROUGHTôNEWSôTHATôISôCENSOREDôANDôIGNOREDô INôTHEô53ôMAINSTREAMôMEDIAôTOôOURôLISTENERSô7EVEôCOVEREDô MOVEMENTSôSUCHôASôTHEôANTI DEATHôPENALTY ôREPARATIONS ôLESBIANô RIGHTS ôPRISONôACTIVISM ô.ATIVEô!MERICANôSOVEREIGNTYôANDôENVI RONMENTALôMOVEMENTSô7EVEôCOVEREDôISSUESôLIKEôVOTERôRIGHTS ô ANTI STERILIZATION ôIMMIGRATION ôATTACKSôONôTHEô!MERICANSôWITHô $ISABILITIESô!CT ôDAYôLABORERS ôSWEATSHOPSôANDôUNIONôBUILD ING ô:APATISTAôDEMANDSôFORôINDIGENOUSôRIGHTS ô#ONGRESS ôTHEô 3UPREMEô#OURT ô"USHôô#O ôPROSTITUTEôRIGHTS ôFORESTôACTIVISTS ô ELECTIONôREFORM ôREPRESSIONôOFô-IDDLE %ASTôIMMIGRANTôCOMMUNI TIES ô(AITI ôHOMELESSôPEOPLE ô',"4)ôCONCERNS ôHIGHôSTAKESôTEST INGôINôSCHOOLS ôCIVILôRIGHTS ôTORTUREôANDôPRIVACYôENCROACHMENT ô LABORôREFORMôANDôMUCH ôMUCHôMOREô%ACHôDAY ôASôWEôBENDôOURô HANDSôANDôHEARTSôTOôGATHERINGôANDôPRODUCINGôTHISôNEWS ôWEô MAKEôTHEôACTIVISTSôMOREôVISIBLE ôSETôALTERNATIVEôFRAMEôSTORIESô ANDôGIVEôOURôLISTENERSôHARDôINFORMATIONôTHEYôNEEDôTOôMAKEôDAILYô DEMOCRATICôDECISIONS


25/09/06 17:41:04

)TSôAôBIGôCHALLENGEôTOôOPERATEôAôDAILYôNEWSCASTômôWHEREôMANYô DECISIONSôMUSTôBEôMADEôQUICKLYômôASôAôCOLLECTIVE ôWHICHôTRADI TIONALLYôTAKESôMOREôTIMEôTOôDISCUSSôISSUESôANDôBRINGôEVERYONEô INTOôDECISION MAKINGô&INDINGôSUFkCIENTôFUNDINGôISôALWAYSôAô PROBLEM ôSINCEôWEôSERVEôAôWORLDWIDEôCOMMUNITYôTHATôDOESôNOTô HAVEôDEEPôPOCKETSômôORôSOMETIMESôANYôPOCKETSô/URôDESIREôTOô COVERôEVENTSôAROUNDôTHEôWORLDôTOOôOFTENôSHORTôCIRCUITSôONôOURô ABILITYôTOôREACHôOUTôTOôMOREôNEWôREPORTERS ôOFFERôMOREôTRAININGô ANDôHELPôWITHôTHEôNECESSARYôEQUIPMENT

TOôADDôPRODUCTIONôOFôAôLIVEôBROADCAST ôANôEARLYôMORNINGôAUDIOô NEWSôPACKAGE ôANDôNEWSôHEADLINESôTHROUGHOUTôTHEôDAYô)NôTHEô SHORTôTERMôWEôHOPEôTOôEXPANDôOURôCOVERAGEôINTOôNEWôAREAS ô INCLUDINGôOURôCURRENTôPRIORITIESôINô!SIA ô!FRICAôANDôTHEô53 -OREôINFORMATIONô WWWFSRNORG

ô!REôTHEREôANYôPASTôPROJECTSMODELSôWHICHôHAVEôINSPIREDô YOU 7EôDRAWôONôôYEARSôOFôLISTENER SPONSOREDôRADIO ôASôEXEMPLI kEDôBYôTHEô53ôCOMMUNITYôRADIOôNETWORKôANDôTHEô0ACIkCAô.ET WORKô7EôHAVEôOFTENôBEENôINSPIREDôATôTHEôANNUALô'RASSROOTSô 2ADIOô#ONFERENCESôBYôTHOSEôWHOôOPERATEôCOMMUNITYôRADIOô STATIONSôWITHôEVENôFEWERôRESOURCESôTHANôOURôOWNôANDôWHOSEô PARTICIPANTSôAREôCOMMITTEDôTOôAôHEALTHYôCOLLECTIVEôPROCESSô )NDIVIDUALSôAMONGôUSôAREôINSPIREDôBYôMANYôCURRENTôANDôPASTô MOVEMENTS ôINCLUDINGôWORKERôCOLLECTIVES ôUTOPIANôPROJECTS ôIN DIGENOUSôCOMMUNITIESôANDôPERSONALôCONTACTôWITHôANYONEôWHOô EVERôTRANSLATEDôAôDREAMôOFôAôBETTERôWORLDôINTOôCONCRETEôANDô USEFULôACTIVITIES ô7HATôAREôYOURôHOPESôFORôTHEôFUTURE 7EôHOPEôFORôLONG TERMôkNANCIALôVIABILITYôSOôWEôCANôPAYôAôLIVINGô WAGEôANDôBENEkTSôTOôSTAFF ôANDôOFFERôCOMPETITIVEôCOMPENSA TIONôTOôREPORTERSô7EôHOPEôTOôCONTINUEôANDôEVENôINCREASEôOURô kGHTINGôROLEôTOôTAKEôBACKôMEDIAôINôTHEô53ôFROMôCORPORATEô SPONSORSôANDôJOURNALISTSôWHOôBECOMEôCOZYôWITHôTHEIRôPOWER FULôSOURCESô7EôHOPEôFORôAôCONSISTENTLYôOUTSTANDINGôNEWSCASTô INôTERMSôOFôCONTENT ôTECHNICALôQUALITYôANDôTIMELINESSô7EDôLIKEô


0240_057_self_org.indd 176-177


25/09/06 17:41:04

,%43YSTEMS $ESCRIPTION !LTERNATIVEôCURRENCIESôANDôTRADINGôNETWORKS 4EXT 7HATôISôAô,%43YSTEM !ô,%43YSTEMôISôAôTRADINGôNETWORKôSUPPORTEDôBYôITSôOWNôINTERNALôCURRENCYô)TôISôSELF REGULATINGôANDôALLOWSôITSôUSERSôTOôMANAGEôANDôISSUEôTHEIRôOWNô@MONEYôSUPPLYôWITHINô THEôBOUNDARIESôOFôTHEôNETWORK 4HEôKEYôPOINTSôINCLUDE môCO OPERATIONôNO ONEôOWNSôTHEôNETWORK môSELF REGULATIONôTHEôNETWORKôISôCONTROLLEDôBYôITSôUSERS môEMPOWERMENTôALLôNETWORKôUSERSôMAYô@ISSUEôTHEô@INTERNALôCURRENCY môMONEYôMONEY ôASôAôMEANSôOFôEXCHANGE ôISôANôINTEGRALôFEATURE ,%43YSTEMôRECORDINGôSERVICESôKEEPôTRACKôOFôTRANSACTIONSôANDôISSUEôSTATEMENTSôOFô ,%43YSTEMôTRADING )SôAô,%43YSTEMôAôTYPEôOFôBARTERôSYSTEM ,%43YSTEMSôUSEôTHEIRôOWNôTYPEôOFô@MONEYômôTHEYôAREôMONEYôSYSTEMS "ARTERôISôAôTYPEôOFôEXCHANGEôWHEREôWEôSWAPôGOODSôANDôSERVICESôWITHOUTôUSINGôMONEYô mô)ôGIVEôYOUôAôLOAFôOFôBREADôANDôYOUôGIVEôMEôTWOôCABBAGESô9OUôkXôMYôCARôANDô)LLô COOKôYOUôDINNERô"UTôYOUôMAYôNOTôLIKEôMYôCOOKING ô

-ONEYôOVERCOMESôTHEôLIMITATIONSôOFôBARTERô)ôGIVEôYOUôMONEYôFORôYOURôGOODSôANDô

SERVICESôANDôYOUôCANôSPENDôITôELSEWHEREô)NôAô,%43YSTEMôYOUôCANôUSEôYOURôACCOUNTô TOôBUYôWHATôYOUôWANTôFROMôONEôPERSONôANDôTHENôSELLôWHATôYOUôCANôTOôANOTHER 7HATôDOESô,%43ôSTANDôFOR 4HEôWORDôg,%43uôWASôCHOSENôTOôHIGHLIGHTôANôINVITATIONôLETS ôANDôAôCULTUREôOFôCONSENTô ,%43ôEMBODIESôTHEô@,AWôOFô4WOô&EETômôg)FôYOUôLIKEôIT ôYOUôWALKôINô)FôYOUôDONT ôTHENô YOUôWALKôAWAYu ô

%RICô&RANKô2USSELL ôTHEôSTORYôWRITER ôEXPRESSEDôTHISôASôg&REEDOMô)ôWILL ô&REEDOMô)ô

WONTuômôEVERYBODYôHASôCHOICESô ô

,%43ôSUPPORTSôTRADINGôWHICHôRESULTSôINôWIN WINôOUTCOMESô4HISôISôTOôBEôCONTRASTEDô

TOôTHEôMOREôCOERCIVEôTYPESôOFôBEHAVIOURôOFTENôSEENôINôCOMMUNITIESôWHICHôAREôSHORTô OFôMONEYômôg)VEôGOTôTHEôMONEY ôSOôYOUôHAVEôTOôWORKôFORôMEuô)Nô,%43 ôTHEREôISôNEVERô ANYôOBLIGATIONôTOôTRADE ô

4HEôUSEôOFô,%43ôASôANôACRONYMôWASôANôAFTERTHOUGHTô4HEôMOSTôCOMMONôRENDERINGô

ISô@,OCALô%XCHANGEô4RADINGô3YSTEMô(OWEVER ôWEôPREFERôTOôAVOIDôTHEôUSEôOFôTHEôWORDô @LOCAL ôASôITôSUGGESTSôAôGEOGRAPHICALôEMPHASIS ôWHICHôCANôBEôMISLEADING

0240_057_self_org.indd 178-179

%XAMPLESôôYôô)"10VPQBJP

25/09/06 17:41:06

7HATôISôTHEôBASISôOFô,%43 ,%43ôISôBASEDôONôTHEôVALUEôOFôTHEôINDIVIDUALôWITHINôTHEôCOMMUNITYô4HISôINVOLVESôBOTHô FREEDOMSôANDôRESPONSIBILITIESô7EôCANôOUTLINEôTHEôMAINôCRITERIA

%LECTRONICô)NTIFADA .IGELô0ARRY

mô CONSENT ôNOTHINGôHAPPENSôWITHOUTôIT mô NOôINTERESTôTOôBEôCHARGEDôONôACCOUNTôBALANCES mô COMMONôOWNERSHIP ôRESULTINGôINôCOST OF SERVICEôPROVISIONôOFôSUPPORTôSERVICES mô DISCLOSUREôOFôINFORMATIONômôTOôENSUREôTHEôINFORMEDôACTIONôOFôUSER 3OURCEô WWWGMLETSU NETCOM #OPYRIGHTôHELDôBYô2OBERTô3OUTARô,TDôôONôBEHALFôOFôTHEô,%43YSTEMôCOMMON WEALTH &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWGMLETSU NETCOM )MAGEôSOURCEô WWWLETSWINNIPEGCOMHQCFM

ô7HATôAREôTHEôAIMSôOFôTHEôPROJECTôYOUôAREôINVOLVEDôIN 4HEô%LECTRONICô)NTIFADAô%) ôISôAôNOT FOR PROkT ôINDEPENDENTôON LINEôPUBLICATIONôCOMMITTEDôTOôCOMPREHENSIVEôPUBLICôEDUCATIONô ONôTHEôQUESTIONôOFô0ALESTINE ôTHEô)SRAELI 0ALESTINIANôCONlICT ô ANDôTHEôECONOMIC ôPOLITICAL ôLEGAL ôANDôHUMANôDIMENSIONSôOFô )SRAELSô YEARôOCCUPATIONôOFô0ALESTINIANôTERRITORIESô%)ôISôNOTô ALTERNATIVEôMEDIAôRATHER ô%)ôISôSUPPLEMENTARYôMEDIAô7HILEô gALTERNATIVEôNEWSuôWEBSITESôHAVEôBECOMEôINCREASINGLYôPOPU LARôSINCEôTHEôMID S ôTHEôFACTôISôTHATôTOôBEôTRUEôALTERNATIVEô MEDIA ôONESôCONTENTôBYôDEkNITIONôNEEDSôTOôMAKEôOTHERôMEDIAô REDUNDANTô#LEARLY ôORGANISATIONSôSUCHôASô%) ôWITHôLIMITEDôRE SOURCESôANDôAôSMALL ôPRIMARILYôVOLUNTEERôTEAMôOFôWRITERSôANDô RESEARCHERS ôAREôNOTôINôTHEôPOSITIONôTOôREPLACEôORôACTôASôSUB STITUTESôFORôLARGEôMEDIAôORGANISATIONSôSUCHôASôTHEô""#ôORôTHEô .EWô9ORKô4IMESô7EôARE ôHOWEVER ôINôAôPOSITIONôTOôSUPPLEMENTô EXISTINGôMEDIAôBYôOFFERINGôDIFFERINGôANALYSESôANDôBYôHIGHLIGHT INGôKEYôSOURCESôOFôINFORMATIONôFROMôONôTHEôGROUNDôTHATôDOô NOTôUSUALLYôGETôFULLôREPRINTSôINôTHEôCOMMERCIALôMEDIAô4HEôTIMEô ANDôRESOURCESôWEôDOôHAVEôAREôNOTôTHEREFOREôBESTôEMPLOYEDô INôREPORTINGôONôEVENTSôTHATôAREôALREADYôWIDELYôCOVEREDôINôTHEô COMMERCIALôMEDIAô ,AUNCHEDôONôô&EBRUARYôôATôELECTRONIC)NTIFADANETôASôAô PIONEERINGôONLINEôRESOURCEôFORôMEDIAôANALYSIS ôCRITICISM ôANDô ACTIVISM ô%)ôHASôPROGRESSIVELYôEXPANDEDôITSôSCOPEôINTOôNEWôARE NASôREFERENCEôMATERIALS ôLIVEôREPORTING ôEDITORIALS ôARTSôCOVERAGE ô ANDôSATIRE ôWITHôTHEôAIMôOFôPRESENTINGôANôACCESSIBLE ôCREDIBLE ô ANDôRESPONSIBLEô0ALESTINIANôNARRATIVEôOFôDEVELOPMENTSôONôTHEô

%XAMPLESôôYôô)"10VPQBJP

0240_057_self_org.indd 180-181


25/09/06 17:41:07

GROUNDôTOôTHEô!MERICANôPUBLICôANDôINTERNATIONALôCOMMUNITY !LTHOUGHô%)ôADDRESSESôTHEôPREVAILINGôPRO )SRAELIôSLANTôINô53ô MEDIAôCOVERAGEôBYôOFFERINGôINFORMATIONôFROMôAô0ALESTINIANôPER SPECTIVE ôOURôVIEWSôONôTHEôCONlICTôAREôBASEDôkRMLYôONôUNIVERSALô PRINCIPLESôOFôINTERNATIONALôLAWôANDôHUMANôRIGHTSôCONVENTIONS ô ANDôOURôREPORTINGôISôBUILTôONôAôSOLIDôFOUNDATIONôOFôDOCUMENTEDô EVIDENCEôANDôCAREFULôFACT CHECKINGô ô(OWôISôTHEôPROJECTôORGANISED &OURôACTIVISTS ô3COTSMANô.IGELô0ARRY ô$IASPORAô0ALESTINIANSô !LIô!BUNIMAHôANDô!RJANô%Lô&ASSEDôANDô!MERICANô,AURIEô+INGô ôCOLLABORATEDôOVERôTHEô)NTERNETôONôTHEô%LECTRONICô)NTIFADASôDE VELOPMENTôFORôkVEôMONTHSôBEFOREôINTRODUCINGôTHEôSITEô /NôANYôDAY ôMOSTôOFôTHEôEDITING ôILLUSTRATING ôPUBLISHING ôANDô PROMOTIONALôBURDENôISôCARRIEDôBYômôPEOPLEôONôAôLARGELYôVOL UNTARYôBASISô%)ôUNDERTAKESôRESEARCH ôANDôCOMPILESôANDôPUB LISHESôREFERENCEôMATERIAL ôCOMMENTARYôANDôANALYSIS ôPERSONALô JOURNALSôFROMôTHEôFRONTLINESôOFôTHEôCONlICT ôMEDIAôNEWSôANDô ANALYSISô%)ôAIMSôASPECTSôOFôITSôINFORMATIONôSERVICEôATôJOURNALISTSô ANDôEDITORS ôACTIVISTSômôOCCASIONALLYôENCOURAGINGôLETTERSôOFôCON CERNômôATôSTUDENTSôOFôTHEôMEDIA ôANDôRESEARCHERSôLOOKINGôFORô REFERENCEôMATERIAL ôANDôOFFERSôAUTOMATICALLYôUPDATINGôSTREAMINGô CONTENTôVIAôOURôgWIREôSERVICEôFORôWEBSITESu ô%)ô7IREô 4HEô%LECTRONICô)NTIFADAôALSOôWELCOMESôUNSOLICITEDôTEXTôANDô VISUALôCONTRIBUTIONSôFROMôWRITERS ôPHOTOGRAPHERS ôMULTIMEDIAô CONTENTôCREATORS ôANDôkLMMAKERSôTOôANYôOFôITSôCONTENTôFEEDSô%)ô PUTSôAôHIGHôPRIORITYôONôWELL WRITTENôORIGINALôANALYSISôANDôREPORT AGE ôCONTRIBUTIONSôFROMôPEOPLEôONôTHEôGROUNDôINô0ALESTINEô

DOESôTHISôHAVEôONôYOURôPROJECT %)ôISôPOWEREDôPRIMARILYôBYôVOLUNTARYôWORKôFROMôITSôFOURôFOUND ERSôANDôAôLOOSEôNETWORKôOFôCORRESPONDENTS ôTECHNICALôPEOPLE ô ANDôPHOTOGRAPHERSôAROUNDôTHEôWORLD ôINCLUDINGôINô0ALESTINE ô THEô53 ô#ANADA ôANDô%UROPEô)NôADDITION ô%)ôISôFUNDEDôBYôINDI VIDUALôDONORS ôMOSTLYôINôTHEô5NITEDô3TATES ôôOFôWHOMôAREô GIVINGôSMALLôAMOUNTSôOFô ôTOôKEEPôOURôPROJECTôGOING ô WITHôAôSMALLôSCATTERINGôOFôOCCASIONALôLARGERôDONORSô/URôANNUALô BUDGETôINôôWASôJUSTô53ô ô)NôBOTHôôANDô ô WEôSPENTô ô 7HILEôOURôNEEDSôCONTINUEôTOôGROW ôOURôENTIREôBUDGETôCOULDôNOTô PAYôTHEôSALARYôOFôAôSINGLEôFOREIGNôCORRESPONDENTôFROMôAôMAJORô NEWSôORGANISATIONô7EôAREôABLEôTOôFUNCTIONôONôSUCHôAôSMALLô BUDGETôBECAUSEôSOôMUCHôOFôTHEôLABOURôTHATôGOESôINôTOô%)ôISô DONATEDô7EVEôMADEôDOôATôDIFFERENTôTIMESôWITHôTHEôRESOURCESô WEôHAVE ôBEGINNINGôFROMôAôBALANCEôOFôZEROôINô&EBRUARYôô 3INCEôTHENôWEVEôEXPANDEDôASôVOLUNTARYôHELPôANDôRESOURCESô HAVEôALLOWED ôBUTôINôTRUTH ôWEôCOULDôOBVIOUSLYôBEôDOINGôMUCHô MORE ôWITHôAôHIGHERôQUALITY ôMOREôCONSISTENTLY ôIFôWEôHADôACCESSô TOôGREATERôRESOURCES ôWHICHôHASôPERIODICALLYôBECOMEôFRUSTRAT INGô.ONEôOFô%)SôFOUNDERSôORôWRITERSôISôABLEôTOôWORKôFULLôTIMEô ONô%)ôASôTHEYôHAVEôOTHERôJOBS ôANDôASôTHEôPROJECTôHASôGROWN ô THEREôISôANôINCREASEDôWORKLOADô

ô(OWôDOôYOUôSUPPORTôTHEôWORKôkNANCIALLYôANDôWHATôIMPACTô

ô7HATôDOôYOUôFEELôYOUôHAVEôACHIEVED ôANDôWHATôAREôTHEôPROB LEMSôYOUôFACE %)ôISôRECOGNISEDôASôAôMAJORôWEBôRESOURCEôONô0ALESTINE ôANDô HASôBEENôABLEôTOôMAKEôSOMEôCONTRIBUTIONôTOôTHEôDEBATEô7Eô RECOGNISEôTHEôGROWINGôPOWERôOFôAôGLOBALôDEMOCRATICôSOCIETYô OFôINFORMED ôCONCERNED ôANDôACTIVISTôINDIVIDUALSôANDôGROUPSô!Sô THEô.EWô9ORKô4IMESôNOTEDôINôAôô&EBRUARYôôEDITORIALôTHEô



0240_057_self_org.indd 182-183

25/09/06 17:41:07

DAYôAFTERôTHEôLARGESTôGLOBALôANTI WARôDEMONSTRATIONSôINôHUMANô HISTORYôg4HEREôAREôTWOôSUPERPOWERSôINôTHEôWORLDôAGAINôTHEô53ô ANDôGLOBALôPUBLICôOPINIONu )TôISô%)SôAIMômôANDôDUTYômôTOôBEôPARTôOFôTHISôEMERGINGôDEMO CRATICôSUPERPOWERôBYôDISSEMINATINGôINFORMATIONôBLOCKEDôORô IGNOREDôBYôTHEôMAINSTREAMôMEDIA ôBYôANALYSINGôDIMENSIONSô ANDôCORNERSôOFôPOLICYôTHATôMAINSTREAMôMEDIAôAREôHESITANTôTOô TOUCHô%)ôWILLôCONTINUEôTOôINFORMôPEOPLEôABOUTôTHEôSITUATIONô ONôTHEôGROUNDôSOôTHATôTHEYôHAVEôACCESSôTOôUNDERSTANDINGôTHEô ACTUALôCOSTôOFôTHEôCONlICTôFORôNORMALôPEOPLE ôANDôHAVEôTHEôTOOLSô TOôGETôPASTôTHEôDEMONISATIONôTHATôFORMSôMUCHôOFôTHEôMEDIASô 0ALESTINIANôREPERTOIREô 7EôHAVEôTOôMAKEôITôAôMAINSTREAMôCONCERNôANDôTHEôONLYôWAYô WEôCANôDOôTHATôISôBYôEFFECTIVELYôCOMMUNICATINGôTHEôREALITIESô ATôGROUNDôZEROôFORô*OEôANDô*ANEô0ALESTINIANôTOôTHEô!MERICANô PUBLICô.OBODYôWOULDôSIGNôOFFôONôTHEô)SRAELI 0ALESTINIANôCONlICTô IFôTHEYôKNEWôWHATôHAPPENEDôATôGROUNDôZERO ôNOBODYô/NLYôTHEô MOSTôARDENTôANDôENTRENCHEDôSUPPORTERSôOFô)SRAEL

ô7HATôAREôYOURôHOPESôFORôTHEôFUTURE )NôRELATIONôTOôTHEôSITE ô%)ôWOULDôLIKEôTOôEXPANDôTHEôSCOPEôOFôOURô COVERAGEôOFôON THE GROUNDôEVENTSôTOôAôFARôGREATERôDEGREE ôDE VELOPINGôDEEPERôLINKSôWITHôORGANISATIONSôANDôSKILLEDôINDIVIDUALSô ONôTHEôGROUNDô7EôWOULDôALSOôLIKEôTOôOFFERôWIDERôCOVERAGEôOFô THEô0ALESTINIANôCOMMUNITYôOUTSIDEôTHEôCOUNTRYôANDôOURôRELATION SHIPôWITHôRELATEDôORGANISATIONS ôASôWELLôASôINCREASINGôTHEôPROkLEô OFôTHEôPROJECTô/URôHOPEôISôTHATôFUTUREôFUNDERSôANDôCONTRIBUTORSô WILLôENABLEôUSôTOôMEETôTHESEôGOALSô3PECIkCôGOALSôINCLUDEôANô INCREASEôOFôPHOTOGRAPHIC ôVIDEOôANDôOTHERôMULTIMEDIAôONôTHEô SITE ôANDôMOREôREGULARôANDôIN DEPTHôADDITIONSôTOôALLôOFôTHEôCON TENTôSECTIONSôONôOURôSITEô )NôTHEôWIDERôSENSE ôTHEREôAREôTHINGSôTHATôAREôBAND AIDSôTHATô COVERôTHEôBLEEDINGôBUTôWHATôWEôALSOôREALLYôNEEDôTOôDOôISôSTOPô THEôCONlICTôSOôTHEREôISôNOôBLEEDING ôANDôTHEôWAYôTOôDOôTHATôISô WEôNEEDôTOôINFORMôPEOPLEôWHATôISôHAPPENINGô4OTALô)NFORMATIONô !WARENESSôISôSOMETHINGôTHATô%)ômô%LECTRONICô)NTIFADAôANDôITSô NEWERôSISTERôSITEô%LECTRONICô)RAQômôISôVERYôINôFAVOURôOFô -OREôINFORMATIONô

)FôWEôCOULDôTAKEôPEOPLEôTHROUGHôTHEô3TARô4REKôTRANSPORTERôTOô 2AFAHôDURINGôg/PERATIONô2AINBOWuôANDôGIVEôTHEMôkVEôMINUTESô TOôEXPERIENCEôWHATôTHATôWASôLIKEôTHEYôWOULDôNOTôSIGNôONôTOôTHEô )SRAELI 0ALESTINIANôCONlICTô

ELECTRONICINTIFADANET

3OôEVERYTHINGôISôAôCHALLENGEôOFôkNDINGôNEWôWAYSôTOôEXPLOREô THATô-ANYôOFôTHEôPROJECTSôTHATô%)ôWANTSôTOôWORKôONômôWEôJUSTô CANTôDOôITô7EREôJUGGLINGôTOOôMANYôPLATESôATôTHEôMOMENTôANDô THEôONLYôWAYôWEôWILLôEVERôBREAKôTHROUGHôTHATôBARRIERôISôWITHôMOREô MONEYô4HATSôWHATôITôBOILSôDOWNôTO


0240_057_self_org.indd 184-185


25/09/06 17:41:07

4HEô,ANDô

ô

ô

ô

ô

$ESCRIPTION )NITIATEDôINô ôTHEôLANDôMOREôDIRECTôTRANSLATIONôFROMô4HAIôTOô%NGLISHôWOULDôBE ôTHEô RICEôkELD ôWASôTHEôMERGINGôOFôIDEASôBYôDIFFERENTôARTISTSôTOôCULTIVATEôAôPLACEôOFôANDôFORô SOCIALôENGAGEMENT 4EXT 4HEôLANDôISôLOCATEDôINôPROXIMITYôTOôTHEôVILLAGEôOFô3ANPATONG ôAôTWENTYôMINUTESôDRIVEô FROMôTHEôCENTERôOFôTHEôPROVINCIALôCAPITALô#HIANGô-AIô!SôSOMEôRICEôFARMERSôAREôHAV INGôDIFkCULTôTIMESôINôTHEôAREA ôDUEôTOôTHEôLEVELSôOFôlOODSôANDôHIGHôWATERôLEVEL ôRICEô FARMINGôHASôNOTôBEENôVERYôPRODUCTIVEô"ECAUSEôOFôTHIS ôSOMEôRICEôkELDSôINôTHEôAREAô HAVEôBEENôOFFEREDôFORôDEVELOPMENT ôASôTHEôRICEôFARMERSôAREôLOOKINGôTOôkNDôBETTERô AREASôFORôTHEôkELDS ô

4HOUGHôINITIALLYôTHEôACTIONôTOôAQUIREôTHEôRICEôkELDSôWEREôINITIATEDôBYôTWOôARTISTSôFROMô

4HAILAND ôTHEôLANDôWASôINITIATEDôWITHôANONYMITYôANDôWITHôOUTôTHEôCONCEPTôOFôOWNER SHIPô4HEôLANDôWASôTOôBEôCULTIVATEDôASôANôOPENôSPACE ôTHOUGHôWITHôCERTAINôINTENTIONSô TOWARDSôCOMMUNITY ôTOWARDSôDISCUSSIONSôANDôTOWARDSôEXPERIMENTATIONôINôOTHERôkELDSô OFôTHOUGHTS ô

4HEôLANDôANDôITSôTOPOGRAPHICALôENVIRONMENTôLANDSCAPE ôASôITôNOWôSTANDS ôWASô

CULTIVATEDôTHROUGHôTHEôPHILOSOPHYôANDôARGICULTURALôTECHNIQUEôOFôAô4HAIôFARMERôBYôTHEô NAMEôOFô#HALOUIô+AEWKONGô4HEôIDEASôAROUNDôTHEôCULTIVATIONôOFôTHEôTOPOGRAPHYôWHICHô ISôôEARTHôMASS ôANDôôWATERôLIQUID ôISôBASEDôONôTHEôCOMPOSITIONôOFôTHEôHUMANô BODYô!SôTHEREôISôWATERôAROUND ôANôARGICULTUREôIRRIGATIONôSTREAMôONôTHEôONEôSIDEôANDô AôNATURALôSTREAMôONôTHEôOTHER ôAôSERIESôOFôPONDSôANDôPOOLSôWEREôLAYEDôOUTôINôRELATIONô TOôTHEôUSAGEôOFôWATER ô

)NôTHEôMIDDLEôOFôTHEôLANDôLIESôTWOôWORKINGôRICEôkELDS ôWHICHôISôANôONôGOINGôREALTION

SHIPôTOôTHEôINITIALôRICEôkELDôITSELFôANDôAôLOSEôGROUPôOFôSTUDENTSôFROMôTHEô5NIVERSITYôOFô #HIANGô-AIôANDôTHEôLOCALôVILLAGEô2ICEôHASôBEENôGROWNôANDôHARVESTEDôYEARLY ôTHOUGHô INITIATEDôASôANôEXPERIMENTALôPROJECTôTOôGROWôANDôHARVESTôRICEôYEARôROUNDôRATHERôTHANô SEASONALY ôANDôTHEôHARVESTôWHICHôYIELDSôINôAPPROXIMATIONôôTOôôKILOGRAMSôAREô SHAREDôBYôALLôPARTICIPANTSôINVOLVEDôANDôTOôSOMEôFAMILIESôINôTHEôLOCALôVILLAGEôTHATôHASô FALLENôILLôFROMôTHEô!)$3ôEPIDEMICô0RESENTLYôTHESEôTWOôkELDSôHAVEôBEENôTHEôMOSTôAC TIVEôPARTôOFôTHEôUSAGEôOFôTHEôLANDô!SôWELL ôFRUITSôTREESôANDôEDIBLEôPLANTSôAREôDISPERSEDô INôTOôTHEôLANDSCAPE ôTHOUGHôAWAITING ôTHEôFRUITSôTOôBEôBAREDô6EGETABLESôANDôDIFFRENTô ASSORTMENTSôOFôSALADSôANDôHERBSôWILLôBEôPLANTEDôASôWELLô ô

4HEREôISôNOôELECTRICTYôORôWATER ôASôITôWOULDôBEôPROBLEMATIC ôINôTERMSôOFôLANDôDEVEL

OPMENTôINôTHEôAREAô!SôITôISôNOTôTHEôINTENTIONôTOôDEVELOPôTHEôLANDôFORôANYôVALUEôINTRENSICô TOôLANDôDEVELOPMENT ôTHEôLACKôOFôSUCHôAMMENITIES ôWASôAôSIMPLEôSOLUTIONôFROMôSUCHô DEVELOPMENTô4HEREôWILLôBEôDEVELOPMENTôANDôEXPERIMENTATIONSôTOôUSEôNATURALôRENEW ABLEôRESOURCESôASôSOURCESôFORôELECTRICôANDôGASô4HEôARTISôGROUPô3UPERlEXôFROMô#OPEN HAGENôHAVEôBEENôDEVELOPINGôTHEIRôIDEAôOFôTHEô3UPERGASôôAôSYSTEMôUTITISINGôBIOMASS ô SUCHôASôSHIT ôTOôPRODUCEôGAS ôANDôTHEYôHAVEôBEENôENGAGINGôINôUSINGôTHEôLANDôASôAôLABô

0240_057_self_org.indd 186-187

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ)>KA

25/09/06 17:41:09

FORôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôTHEIRôBIOGASôSYSTEMô4HEôGASôPRODUCEDôWILLôINITIALLYôBEôUSEDô

BEINGôTHEôCOMMUNALôSPACEôWITHôAôkREôPLACEôMADEôWITHôTHEôIDEAôOFôACCOMODATINGôAô

FORôTHEôSTOVESôINôTHEôKITCHEN ôASôWELLôASôLAMPSôFORôLIGHTô!RTHURô-EYERôANôAMERICANô

GATHERINGôANDôEXCHANGES ôTHEôSECONDôlOORôFORôREADINGôANDôMEDITATIONôANDôRElECTIONô

ARTISTôFROMô#HICAGO ôHASôALSOôBEENôINTERESTEDôTOôDEVELOPôAôSYSTEMôFORôUTILISINGôSOLARô

OFôEXCHANGE ôANDôTHEôTOPôlOORôFORôSLEEPô3TRUCTURESôINôPROCESSôAREôAôSTRUCTUREôBYô

POWER ôASôANOTHERôSOURCEôOFôENERGYôTOôBEôSTOREDôANDôUSEô4HESEôPROJECTSôWILLôASôWELLô

!LICIAô&ARMIS ôTHEô"ILLBOARDôHOUSE ôANDôAôYOUNGô4HAIôARTISTô!NGKRITô!LLôSTRUCTURESôAREô

ENGAGEôINTERESTEDôPARTICIPATIONôOFôTHEôLOCALôVILLAGEôASôWELLôASôSTUDENTSôFROMôTHEôLOCALô

OPENôTOôBEôUSED

SCHOOLSôANDô5NIVERSITIESô7ATERôISôNOTôAôPROBLEM ôHOWEVER ôCHEMICALôPESTICIDESôANDô

ô

OTHERôSUCHôPRODUCTSôHAVEôBEENôINTORDUCEDôINTOôTHEôRICEôkELDS ôWHICHôINôTURNôFEEDSô

ANDôCANôBEôUSED

4HEREôISôNOTôAôTIMEôLIMITATIONôTOôTHEôCULTIVATIONôOFôTHEôLAND ôITôISôTHEREôTOôBEôUSEDô

INTOôTHEôWATERôSTREAMSôANDôSYSTEMô)NôTHEôCENTERôOFôTHEôLANDôISôANôISOLATEDôPOOLôOFô GROUNDôWATER ôMADEôFROMôNATURALôkLTERINGôOFôTHEôGROUNDôCONTENT ôHOWEVER ôTESTSôWILLô

3OURCE

HAVEôTOôBEôMADEôTHROUGHôOUTôTHEôYEARôFORôANYôCONTAMINATIONSô!SôWELLôVARIOUSôPOOLSô

WWWTHELANDFOUNDATIONORG!BOUT?THE?LAND

ANDôPONDSôWILLôBEôUSEDôFORôTHEôFARMINGôOFôkSHES ôAôPROJECTôTOôBEôINITIATEDôBYôAôYOUNGô 4HAIôARTISTô0RACHYAô0HINTONGô


ô

WWWTHELANDFOUNDATIONORG

0ARALLELôTOôTHEôLANDôASôLABôFORôSELFôSUSTAINABLEôENVIRONMENT ôARCHITECTURALôIDEASôFORô

LIVINGôWILLôBEôCARRIEDôOUTôALONGôSIDEôTHEôDULTIVATIONôOFôTHEôLANDô!ôGARDENERSôHOUSEô WASôBUILDôBYôTHEô4HAIôARTISTô+AMINô,ERDCHAIPRASERT ôTHOUGHTôBUILTôOUTôOFôPRACTICAL ITY ôITôWOULLDôBEôCONSIDEREDôASôHISôCONTRIBUTIONôTOôTHEôIDEAô4HEôGARDENERSôHOUSESô HOUSES ôTHEôGARDENERôANDôHISôWIFE ôASôTHEYôTENDôTOôTHEôLANDôANDôMANAGEDôTHEôDAILYô NECESSASITIESô4HEôKITCHEN ôDEVELOPEDôFROMôAôCOLLABORATIVEôDISCUSSIONSôBETWEENôTHEô ARTISTSô+AMINô,ERDCHAPRASERT ô3UPERlEX ô4OBIASô2EHBERGERôANDô2IRKRITô4IRAVENIJAô4HEô KITCHENôWASôDEVELOPEDôINôTWOôPARTSô0ARTôONEôWASôTHEôINVITATIONôOFôTHEôARTISTSô3UPER lEX ô2EHBERGERôANDô4IRAVANIJAôTOôPARTICIPATEôINôANôEXHIBITONôINô,ISBONôUNDERôTHEôTITLE ô -OREôWORKSôABOUTôBUILDINGSôANDôFOOD ôCURATEDôBYô0EDROô,APAS4HEôARTISTSôDECIDEDô THATôTHEYôWOULDôINITIATEôAôPROJECTôWHICHôCOULDôINTERGRADEôANDôLINKôTHEIRôINTERESTSôINôTHEô IDEASôAROUNDôTHEôEXHIBITIONô3UPERlEXôDEVELOPEDôTHEôSYSTEMôFORôPRODUCTIONôOFôBIOGASô ANDôTHEôSTORAGEôOFôBIOGAS ôWHEREô2EHBERGERôDESIGNEDôTHEôPLATFORMôWHICHôACTIVATESô THEôBIOGASôWHICHôISôCONNECTEDôTOôAôGASôLAMP ôDESIGNEDôASôWELLôBYô2EHBURGER ôANDôTHEô KITCHENôDESIGNEDôANDôTOôBEôUSEDôBYô4IRAVANIJAô&OLLOWINGôTHEôEXHIBITONôINô,ISBON ôTHEô SYSTEMôDEVELOPEDôFORôTHEôEXHIBIITONôISôTHENôTRANSFEREDôTOôTHEôLANDôANDôTOôBEôINSTALLEDô INôAôSTRUCTUREôDESIGNEDôANDôBUILTôBYô+AMINô,ERDCHAIPRASERTô!TILIERô6ANô,EISHOUPôHASô ALSOôBEENôENGAGEDôINôTOôTHEôIDEAôOFôDEVELOPINGôTHEôTOILETôSYSTEM ôWHICHôWOULDôBEô LNKEDôTOôTHEôPRODUCTIONôOFôBIOGASô4HEôARTISTô0HILIPPEô0ERRENOôANDôARCHITECTô&RANCIOSô 2OCH ôAREôPRESENTLYôDEVELOPINGôANôIDEAôFORôWHICHôWOULDôBEôDEVELOPEDôINôTOôTHEôCENTRALô ACTIVITYôHALL ôAôCENTRALôLOCATIONôTOôBEôUSEDôASôAôWORKSHOPôFORôVARIOUSôACTIVITIESô ô

3URROUNDINGôTHEôGENERALôSPACESôOFôTHEôRICEôkELDS ôKITCHEN ôTOILETS ôBATHROOMSôANDô

CENTRALôHALL ôWILLôBEôDIFFRENTôSTRUCTURESôFORôLIVINGô"ASEDôONôTHEôCOMMONLYôFOUNDôMEDI TATIONôHUTSôINôBUDDISTôMONASTARIES ôTHESEôSTRUCTURESôFORôLIVINGôWOULDôBEôACCOMODA TIONSôFORôMEDITATIONô)NITIATEDôNOTôPURELYôASôSTRUCTURESôTOôBEôDESIGNEDôANDôMADEôBYô ARTISTS ôMOSTôOFôTHEôPROJECTSôTOôDATEôAREôBEINGôDEVELOPEDôBYôARTISTSô3TARTINGôWITHôTHEô 4HAIôARTISTô-ITô*AIô)N ôPLANTINGôAôCIRCLEôOFôNURSERYôTEAKôPLANTS ôINôTIMEô*AIô)N ôINTENDSôTOô WEAVEôTOGEATHERôTHEôPLANTôASôITôGROWSôINôTOôAôBASKETôWHICHôWOULDôBEôTHEôPLATFORMôFORô WHICHôHEôWOULDôLIVEôINô4OBIASô2EHBERGER ôHASôDESIGNôANDôBUILDôALMOSTôTOôCOMPLETION ô AôSTRUCTUREôINSPIREDôBYôAôPLATEôOFôFOODôFROMôHISôNATIVEô3CHWABIAô4IRAVANIJAôALSOôALMOSTô COMPLETEôSTRUCTUREôISôBASEDôONôTHREEôSPHEARôOFôNEEDSôTHEôLOWERôlOORôORôBASEôlOORô


0240_057_self_org.indd 188-189


25/09/06 17:41:10

/THERô#INEMAô ANDô!4!ô'ALLERY ô3ANô&RANCISCO #RAIGô"ALDWIN

ô7HATôAREôTHEôAIMSôOFôTHEôPROJECTôYOUôAREôINVOLVEDôIN )NôTHEôCASEôOFô/THERô#INEMA ôOURôAIMSôAREôTOôPRESERVEôANDô ARCHIVEô@ORPHANôkLMSôEXCEPTôINôTHEôCASEôWHEREôWEôPROVIDEô FOOTAGEôFROMôTHOSEôkLMSôFORôRE USEôINôCONTEMPORARYôMEDIAôART WORKS ôTOôMAKEôOURôOWNôSERIESôOFô@EXPERIMENTALCOLLAGE ESSAYô DOCUMENTARIESôTOôPRODUCEôSCREENINGSôONôAôWEEKLYôBASISôOFô MOSTLYôEXPERIMENTALPERSONALôNON kCTION ôBUTôALSOôAGITATIONALô ANDôJOURNALISTICôDOCUMENTARIES ôANDôEXPERIMENTALôANDôUNDER GROUNDôANDôOCCASIONALLYôANIMATIONôANDôNARRATIVE ôkLMS ôVIDEOS ô ANDôDIGITALôWORKS ôOFTENôINôCONJUNCTIONôWITHôINSTALLATIONSôANDô PERFORMANCESôAND ôkNALLY ôTOôCURATEôANDôDISTRIBUTEôONô$6$ô GENERALLYôCOMPILATIONSôOF ôPERSONALEXPERIMENTALôDOCUMENTA RIESESSAYS ôANDôkNE ARTôANDôMEDIA ARCHAEOLOGICALôPIECESôTOô ANôINTERNATIONALôAUDIENCE )NôTHEôCASEôOFô!RTISTSô4ELEVISIONô!CCESSô'ALLERY ôOURôAIMSôAREô TOôENCOURAGE ôEDUCATE ôANDôENABLEôTHEôPRODUCTIONôANDôEXHIBI TIONôOFôLOCALôANDôREGIONALôMEDIAôARTWORK ôANDôSERVEôASôANôART RESOURCEôFORôMANYôANDôVARIOUSôCOMMUNITYôPROJECTSô@!4!ôHAVEô ALSOôPRODUCEDôANDôCABLECASTôAôWEEKLYô#ABLEô!CCESSôTELEVISIONô PROGRAMôFORôOVERôôYEARS ôCONTINUOUSLY

OURôWEEKLYôSCREENINGSô"EINGôSOôSMALL ôITôISôMOREôBENEVOLENTô DESPOTISMôTHANôCONSENSUS ôBUTôEVERYONEôWORKSôASôAôVOLUNTEERô OUTôOFôPERSONALôENGAGEMENTôWITHôTHEôPROJECTôNOôSALARIES ôANDô ANYONEôCANôDROPôOUTôFORôLONGôORôSHORTôPERIODSôOFôTIME ôIFôTHEô PROJECTôGOESôINôAôDIRECTIONôTHATôCEASESôTOôBEôINTERESTINGô4HEô DISTRIBUTIONôARMôOFô/#ômôWHICHôISôCALLEDô/THERô#INEMAô$IGITALô môISôACTUALLYôAôFOR PROkTôCORPORATION ôTHOUGHôITôISôTHREEôYEARSô OLDôANDôHASôNEVERôTURNEDôAôPROkTô4HEREôISôONEôPAIDôEMPLOYEE ô ANDôDECISIONSôAREôMADEôTHROUGHôAôLOTôOFôARGUMENTômô)ôGUESSô ONEôCOULDôCALLôITôCONSENSUSômôANDôSOMETIMESôACTUALôCOMMIT TEEôVOTING !4!ôOPERATESôBYôCONSENSUS ôTHOUGHôFROMôTIMEôTOôTIMEôTHEYô HAVEôPROBABLYôVOTEDô4HEREôISôAôBOARD ôBUTôITôISôTHEôSTAFFôTHATô RUNSôTHEôDAY TO DAYôBUSINESSôONôAôVOLUNTEERôBASIS ôANDôTHEREô AREôCERTAINôTASKSôFORôCERTAINôSTAFFôMEMBERSôANDôTHESEôTASKSôRO TATE ô4HEôSTAFFôHASôALWAYSôBEENôAôPRETTYôLOOSEôGROUPômôSOME WHEREôBETWEENôôANDôômôANDôMEETINGSôAREôHELDôEVERYôMONTH ô THOUGHôTHEREôISôAôLOTôOFôINTERNALôDECISION MAKINGôGOINGôONôASô PARTôOFôTHEôDAYôTOôDAYôACTIVITY ôANDôALSOôTHOUGHôANôEMAILôSYSTEMô ACCESSIBLEôVIAôWEBSITE

ô(OWôISôTHEôPROJECTôORGANISED 4HEREôAREôDIFFERENTôLEVELSô/THERô#INEMAôISôAôSMALLôGROUPôOFô ôINDIVIDUALS ôWITHôMEôASôTHEôDEôFACTOôCENTRALôORGANIZER ôWHOô MEETôAôFEWôTIMESôAôWEEKôTOôDOôkLMôRESEARCHô7EôMEETôWITHô THEôSCHOOLSôANDôPRESENTôEDUCATIONALôINITIATIVES ôANDôPRODUCEô

ô(OWôDOôYOUôSUPPORTôTHEôWORKôkNANCIALLYôANDôWHATôIMPACTô DOESôTHISôHAVEôONôYOURôPROJECT )NôTHEôCASEôOFô/THERô#INEMA ôITôISôWHATôISôCALLEDôINôTHEô53ô gEARNEDôREVENUESu ôTHATôIS ôMONEYôTENDEREDôATôTHEôDOORôFORô EVENTSôORôTHEôBAR ôORôgFOUND FOOTAGEuôSALES ô)TôISôMORE OR LESSôAô@BREAK EVENôAFFAIRôNOôONEôREALLYôDOESôITôFORôTHEôMONEY ô BUTôRATHERôFORôAôLOVEôOFôTHEôARTôANDôPOLITICSôOFôCINEMAô!SôTOô THEôkNANCIALôIMPACTSôwôWELL ôONEôMIGHTôTHINKôTHATôTHATôKINDôOFô kNANCINGôMODELôWOULDôDRIVEôOURôPROJECTSôTOWARDSôTHEôMARKETô PLACE ôBUTôTHATôHASNTôREALLYôHAPPENEDô)TôISôAôSMALLôSTOREFRONTô



0240_057_self_org.indd 190-191

25/09/06 17:41:10

ANDôSOôONLYôSOôMANYô ôPEOPLEôCANôkTôINôHEREôANYWAY ôSOôWEô CANôgAFFORDuôTOôCONTINUEôWITHôAôgNICHEuôAESTHETICô3OôTHEôBUDGETô ISôNECESSARILYôLIMITEDômôTHATSôWHYôITôISôCALLEDôAôMICROCINEMAô ANDôWHYôWE ôINôTERMSôOFôPROGRAMMING ôCONCENTRATEôONôSHORTERô WORKS ôONôSMALLERôgFORMATSuô%4,S ôPUBLICITY ôANDôPRODUCTIONô COSTSôAREôCOVEREDôBYôMEANSôOFôTHEôMONIESôFROMôTHEôPAYINGô CUSTOMERSômôôAôHEAD !4! ôONôTHEôOTHERôHAND ôHASôRECEIVEDôGRANTSôINôITSôôYEARS ô HOWôMANYô)ôCOULDNTôSAYôEXACTLY ôBUTô)ôWOULDôGUESSôAROUNDô mô4HEYôALSOôCOLLECTôATôTHEôDOORôFROMôTHEIRôOCCASIONAL EVENTô PATRONS ôAND ôMOREôTHANôANYôOTHERôINCOMEôSTREAM ôACTUALLYô RENTôTHEôGALLERYôOUTôTOôOTHERôEVENT PRODUCERSôINôTHEôREGIONô 4HEôPROGRAMMINGôANDôHARDWAREôHAVEôSTAYEDôLARGELYôTHEôSAMEô OVERôTWOôDECADES ôTHOUGHôTHEREôHASôBEENôAôGENERALôSHIFTôTO WARDSôTHEôgMAINSTREAMuôBECAUSEôTHEôOUTSIDEôPRODUCERSôHAVEô GAINEDôSUCHôAôPRESENCEô!NDôNEVERôENOUGHôOFôAôGRANTôTOôBUILD ô SAY ôAôNEWôTHEATER ôBUTôALWAYSôENOUGHôTOôSTAYôTHEôCOURSEô!4!ô ORIGINALLYôHADôPUBLICôFUNDINGôFORôTHEôSO CALLEDôVISUALôARTS ôBUTô WHENôTHATôDRIEDôUPôTHEYôMADEôUPôTHEôLOSTôINCOMEôBYôMOVINGôTOô TIME BASEDôMEDIA ARTôSCREENINGSôWHEREôPEOPLEôPAYôFORôSEATS ô THOUGHôTHEôlATôVISUALôARTôDISPLAYôANDôINSTALLATIONSôHAVEôREMAINEDô ATôTHEôMARGINSôOFô!4!SôOFFERINGS

lOOR ôANDôNOôONEômôTHEREôAREôGENERALLYô ôPEOPLEôLIVINGôINôTHISô LARGERôgLIVE WORKuôSPACEômôHASôBEENôABLEôTOôSHOWERôINôTHREEô DAYSô4HISôISôVERYôTYPICAL ô/URô$3,ôLINEôWENTôDOWNôYESTERDAY ô ANDôTHEôMMôANDô3UPERôPROJECTORSôHAVEôBEENôBROKENôFORô MONTHSô"ECAUSEôOURôRENTALôSTATUSôISôgCOMMERCIALu ôTHEôLANDLORDô ISôNOTôRESPONSIBLEôFORôkXINGôMOSTôOFôTHESEôPROBLEMSô"UTôTHEô GOODôTHINGôIS ôTHEôLANDLORDôLETSôUSôDOôWHATôWEôWANTôWITHôTHEô BUILDING ôLIKEôBUILDINGôWALLSôANDôLOFTSôANDôHAVINGôLOTSôOFôPEOPLEô INôTHEôSPACEôFOURôDAYSôAôWEEKô /FôCOURSE ôBEYONDôALLôTHATôTHEREôAREôALWAYSôPSYCHOLOGICALôPROB LEMSôTHATôWEôSUFFERôASôAôGROUPômôITôCANôBEôVERYôCLAUSTROPHOBIC ô ANDôTHEREôAREôAôLOTôOFôCONTENDINGôIDEASômôTHEREôISôAôVERYôDIVERSEô MIXôOFôPEOPLEôINVOLVED ôWITHôPEOPLEôFROMôALLôOVERôTHEôWORLDô)Tô ISôALSOôTRUEôTHOUGHôMANYôWOULDôNOTôBRINGôITôUP ôTHATôWHENôYOUô OPENôYOURôDOORSôTOôVOLUNTEERS ôSOMETIMESôPEOPLEôGETôINVOLVEDô WHOôAREôNOTôSOôSKILLED ôORôPSYCHOLOGICALLYôSTABLEôFORôTHATôMATTERô 7HENôEVERYONEôISôJUSTôWORKINGôONôAôVOLUNTEERôBASISôANDôPER SONALôCONlICTSôARISEôTHEREôCANôBEôPERSONNELôSHIFTS ôWHICHôCANô ENDANGERôCONTINUITYô&INALLYôTHEREôISôTHEôgPROBLEMuôOFôCOMPETI TIONôOUTSIDEôTHEôVENUEômôTHEREôAREôMAYBEôAôDOZENôOTHERôOUTkTSô OFFERINGôCOMPETINGôPROGRAMMINGôANDôSOôITôISôOFTENôANôEFFORTô TOôDRAWôAôSUFkCIENTôAUDIENCEôTOôMAKEôTHEôTROUBLEôWORTHWHILE ô ESPECIALLYôWITHôNOôADVERTISINGôBUDGETô

ô7HATôDOôYOUôFEELôYOUôHAVEôACHIEVED ôANDôWHATôAREôTHEôPROB LEMSôYOUôFACE 7ELL ôITôWOULDôHAVEôTOôBEôAôMIRACLEôFORôEITHERôORGANIZATIONôTOô HAVEôSURVIVEDôINôAôVERYôCOMPETITIVEôAREA ôINôONEôOFôTHEôMOSTô EXPENSIVEôCITIESôINôTHEôWORLDô4HEôPROBLEMSôAREôCERTAINLYôECO NOMIC ôTHATôISôWITHôRENTôANDôBILLS ôBUTôALSOôTHATôTHEôPHYSICALôPLANTô ISôSERIOUSLYôDETERIORATEDôFORôEXAMPLE ôRIGHTôTHISôVERYôMOMENT ô !PRILô ô ôOURôWATERôHEATERôISôLEAKINGôALLôOVERôOURôKITCHENô

!SôTOôWHATôWEôHAVEôACHIEVED ôWELLôITôWONTôBEôCOUNTEDôINô AWARDS ôTHOUGHôWEôHAVEôWONôMAYBEôkVE ôORôGRANTSôORôMONEYô )TôSOUNDSôLIKEôAôCLICH¯ ôBUTôITôHAPPENSôTOôBEôTRUEôTHEôMARKôOFô OURôSUCCESSôISôOURôCONTINUALôANDôONGOINGôOUTREACHôANDôEN GAGEMENT ôTOôWHATôHASôBEENôALLôINôALLôAôVERYôLARGEôAUDIENCEô INDEED ôARGUABLYôINôTHEôTOPôTENôINôTHEôWESTERNô53ôFORôTHEôTYPEô OFôPROGRAMMINGôPROVIDEDô!NDôFORôWHATôITôISôWORTH ôBOTHô/THERô



0240_057_self_org.indd 192-193

25/09/06 17:41:10

-ECCAô#OLA $ESCRIPTION #OLAôWARSôFORôTHEôSTôCENTURY 4EXT 4HEôSPIRITôWHICHôGOVERNEDôTHEôCREATIONôOFô-ECCA #OLAôWASôTOôCREATEôAôPROkT MAKINGô BUSINESSôWHICHôWOULDôHELPôTOôRELIEVEôHUMANôSUFFERINGôWHEREôACTIONôISôSTILLôPOSSIBLEô4HEô MOSTôINTOLERABLEôANDôTHEôMOSTôIMMEDIATEôSUFFERINGôISôTHATôOFôTHEô0ALESTINIANôPEOPLE ô

4HEô0ALESTINIANôPEOPLEôAREôEXPERIENCINGôINDIFFERENCEôANDôGENERALôCOMPLICITY ôTHESEô

BEINGôTHEôMOSTôWRETCHEDôANDôTHEôMOSTôCONTEMPTIBLEôACTSôOFôAPARTHEIDôANDô:IONISTôFAS CISMô"UT ôASôWEôAREôPROFOUNDLYô-OSLEMôINôSPIRITôANDôINôTRAINING ôWEôCANôONLYôADHEREôTOô OURôPRECEPTS ôNAMELY ôGIVEôBACKôTHEôGOODôTHATôWEôHAVEôRECEIVEDôINôGREATERôMEASURE ô BUTôALSOôSPREADôGOODôAROUNDôONESELFô)TôISôFORôTHISôREASONôTHATôWEôHAVEôOPTEDôFORô THEôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôAôSHAREôOFôTHEôDIVIDENDSôINôCOUNTRIESôWHICHôHAVEôSOôGENEROUSLYô WELCOMEDôUS ôANDôINôTHEôPOPULATIONSôAMONGSTôWHOMôWEôLIVE ô

-ILITANTôPEOPLEôWHOôAREôEXPERIENCINGôkNANCIALôDIFkCULTIESôOFTENôHAVEôNOôOTHERô

ALTERNATIVEôTHANôTOôCREATEôPROkT MAKINGôACTIVITIESôTOôENABLEôTHEMôTOôACHIEVEôTHEIRô OBJECTIVES ôEVENôTHOUGHôTHEYôDIDôNOTôSTARTôOUTôASôEITHERôTRADERSôORôCAPITALISTSô/NEôOFô THEôPERVERSIONSôOFôCAPITALISMôLIESôINôTHEôGENERATIONôWITHINôONESELFôOFôTHEôMOSTôBRUTALô ANDôTHEôMOSTôINHUMANEôPARTôOFôONESELF môôOFôNETôPROkTSôGOôTOô0ALESTINIANôCHILDRENSôCHARITIES môôTOôLOCALôCHARITYômô.'/ 3LOGANô PASôBUVEZôSTUPIDE ôBUVEZôENGAG¯ôNOôMOREôDRINKINGôSTUPID ôDRINKôWITHôCOMMITMENT 3OURCEô WWWMECCA COLACOM &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWMECCA COLACOM

0240_057_self_org.indd 194-195

%XAMPLESôôYôô*B@@>ñ LI>

25/09/06 17:41:12

#INEMAôANDô!4!ôAREôWELLôLOVED ôANDôTHOSEôKINDSôOFôCOMMUNI TARIANôFEELINGSôCOULDôREALLYôBEôCONSIDEREDôANôACHIEVEMENTô7Eô HAVEôTRAINEDôMANY ôMANYôPEOPLEô7EôHAVEôCERTAINLYôSERVEDôASô AôCATALYSTôFORôLOCALôPOLITICALôDETERMINATIONS

4EMPORARYô3ERVICESô ANDô-ESSô(ALL ô#HICAGO

ô!REôTHEREôANYôPASTôPROJECTSMODELSôWHICHôHAVEôINSPIREDô YOU 7ELL ôTHEREôAREôMANYôTHEôTHINGSôOURôSISTERôGALLERIESôANDôALTERNA TIVEôSPACESôANDôYOUTHôCULTURALôCENTERSôWEREôDOINGôCONSTITUTEDôAô NATURALôGROUNDôFORôOURôOWNôOPERATIONSô3OMEôOFôTHOSEôOLDERôONESô HAVEôDIEDôOFF ôBUTôTHEREôAREôSOMEôNEWERômôNOTôASôMANYôHAVEô STARTEDôUP ôMAYBEôBECAUSEôITôISôJUSTôTOOôPROHIBITIVELYôEXPENSIVEô HEREô)NTERSECTIONôFORôTHEô!RTS ô0ROJECTô/NE ô0ROJECTô4WO ô0ROJECTô !RTAUD ôCELL3PACE ôTHEô,UGGAGEô3TORE ô28ôGALLERY ôTHEô,AB ôô ,ANGTON ô.EWô,ANGTONô!RTS ô#AMERAWORK ô#APPô3Tô0ROJECT ô 0EOPLESô#ULTURALô#ENTER ô,Aô0ENA ô%PICENTER ô+LUBô+OMMO TION ôTHEô/FFENSIVE ô#LUBô'ENERIC ô3&ô#ENTERôFORôTHEô"OOK ô#LUBô &OOT ô!2% ô*ETô7AVE ô6ALENCIAô4OOLôANDô$IEôANDôTHEREôAREô DOZENSôMOREô0LEASEôUNDERSTANDôTHATôITôWASôNOTôAôPARTICULARô gORGANIZATIONALôMODELuôTHATôSERVEDôASôAôTEMPLATE ôITôWASôJUSTô MOREôTHEôPRESENCEôANDôENERGYôANDôSTRENGTHôOFôALLôTHOSEôKINDREDô GROUPS ôCULTIVATINGôCRITICALôMEDIAôAUDIENCESôTHATôWEôOURSELVESô WEREôALLôAôPARTôOF ôANDôTHENôTHEôOPPORTUNITYôAROSEôFORôUSôTOôGETô ANôAUTONOMOUSôSITE

ô7HATôAREôTHEôAIMSôOFôTHEôPROJECTôYOUôAREôINVOLVEDôIN )ôAMôINVOLVEDôINôSEVERALôINITIATIVESômô4EMPORARYô3ERVICES ô-ESSô (ALL ô)NôTHEô&IELD ô,EARNINGô'ROUP ô4HEô,IBRARYôOFô2ADIANTô/PTI MISMôFORô,ETSsô7E -AKEôTHEô7ORLD ôANDô4HEô*OURNALôFORô.ORTH EASTô)SSUESô(AMBURG ômôBUTôWILLôONLYôFOCUSôONôTWOôINôORDERô TOôKEEPôTHEôREPLIESôASôBRIEFôASô)ôCANô%ACHôHASôITSôOWNôSETôOFô CONCERNS ôSOMEôOFôWHICHôOVERLAPô

ô7HATôAREôYOURôHOPESôFORôTHEôFUTURE )TSôHARDôTOôANSWERôTHATôQUESTIONôWITHôAôSTRAIGHTôFACEôEVERYBODYô HEREôKNOWSôTHATôTHEREôISôNOôFUTUREôw -OREôINFORMATIONô /4(%2ô#).%-! ô6ALENCIAô3TREET ô3ANô&RANCISCO ô#!ô

"RETTô"LOOM

4EMPORARYô3ERVICESôOFFERSôARTôANDôOURôACTIVITIESôASôAôSERVICEô TOôOTHERSô4HISôMEANSôTHATôWEôARENTôFOCUSEDôONôTHEôPRODUC TIONôOFôOBJECTSôORôTRADITIONALôFORMSôOFôARTôEXPRESSION ôBUTôRATHERô THATôWEôAREôMOREôCONCERNEDôWITHôTHEôSOCIALôCONTEXTSôWITHINô WHICHôARTôISôANDôCANôBEôEMBEDDED ôANDôADDITIONALLYôHOWôARTô CANôBEôUSEDôTOôOPENôUPôALLôKINDSôOFôSITUATIONSôTOôNEWôTHINKINGô ANDôPOSSIBILITIESô7EôAREôALSOôINTERESTEDôINôCOMPELLINGôHUMANô CREATIVITYôWHEREVERôWEôkNDôITô -ESSô(ALLôISôANôEXPERIMENTALôCULTURALôCENTERô.INEôOFôUSôESTAB LISHEDôITôINôORDERôTOôHAVEôAôPLACEôWHEREôARTôANDôVISUALôCULTUREô COULDôBEôPUTôINTOôAôBROADERôDIALOGôWITHôOTHERôPRACTICESôTHATô BOTHôINFORMEDôOURôWORK ôBUTôALSOôREPRESENTEDôOTHERôCOMMU NITIESôTHATôWEôAREôACTIVEôINô-ESSô(ALLôSEEKSôTOôFOSTERôDIALOGô AMONGôGROUPSôOFôTHINKERS ôMAKERS ôDOERSôTHATôRARELYôINTERSECTô WITHôTHEôHOPEôTHATôMOREôINTERESTINGôPRACTICES ôIDEASôANDôFORMô OFôRESISTANCEôTOôTHEôDOMINANTôCULTURE ôCANôEMERGEô7EôSEEKôTOô ESTABLISHôALTERNATEôFORMSôOFôEXCHANGEôANDôAREôACTIVELYôBUILDINGô AôCULTUREôORôGENEROSITYô

WWWOTHERCINEMACOM


0240_057_self_org.indd 196-197


25/09/06 17:41:12

ô(OWôISôTHEôPROJECTôORGANISED 4EMPORARYô3ERVICESôISôAôGROUPôOFôTHREEôPERSONSô7EôWORKôINô SEVERALôDIFFERENTôWAYSôSIMULTANEOUSLYôASôARTISTS ôPRODUCERS ô ORGANIZERS ôCURATORS ôACTIVISTS ôDESIGNERSôANDôSOôONô7EôALWAYSô DEVELOPôCONSENSUSôFORôTHEôTHINGSôWEôCHOOSEôTOôWORKôONô)FôWEô DONTôREACHôCONSENSUS ôTHENôSOMETHINGôISNTôDONEôUNDERôTHEô NAMEôOFô4EMPORARYô3ERVICES

AREôALSOôTHEôCONTACTôPERSONSôFORôTHOSEôOUTSIDEôTHEôGROUPôWHOô WANTôTOôUSEô-(ôASôAôRESOURCEô7EôCALLô-(ôANôEXPERIMENTALô CULTURALôCENTERô)TôISôAôPLACEôINFORMEDôBYôVISUALôCULTURE ôBUTôISô NOTôAôGALLERYô7EôHAVEôMULTIPLEôCONSTITUENCIESôINTERESTEDôINô AôWIDEôRANGEôOFôTOPICSôANDôISSUESôFROMôFOODôDEMOCRACYôANDô EXPERIMENTALôURBANôPLANNING ôTOôRADICALôCARTOGRAPHYôANDôSUS TAINABLEôDESIGNôANDôECOLOGY

-ESSô(ALLô-( ôISôINôPARTôANôEXTENSIONôOFô4EMPORARYô3ERV ICES ôBUTôISôALSOôAôLOTôMOREôINôTHATôITôINVOLVESôFOURôOTHERôACTIVEô MEMBERS ôANDôTWOôAT LARGEôMEMBERSô7EôCALLôOURSELVESôgKEY HOLDERSuô4HISôSTARTEDôASôAôJOKE ôBUTôQUICKLYôTOOKôONôAôLOTôOFô MEANINGôVIS · VISôHOWô-(ôISôORGANIZEDô7EôAREôALLôINVOLVEDôINô MANYôTHINGSôANDôTHEôLASTôTHINGôWEôWANTEDôWASôANOTHERôGROUPô WITHôANOTHERôGROUPôPROCESSô7EôWANTEDôTOôSTREAMLINEô-(Sô FUNCTIONSôANDôMAKEôITôASôEASYôASôPOSSIBLEôFORôUSôTOôCOORDINATEô 4OôTHISôEND ôWEôSETôUPôSOMEôBASICôRULESôTHATôBOTHôENCOURAGEDô GROUPôCOHESION ôBUTôALSOôPROVIDEDôFORôINDIVIDUALôEXPRESSIONô ANDôDISSENTô4HEôRULESôWEREô ô)FôYOUôHAVEôAôKEYôAREôAôKEY HOLDER ôTHENôTHEôULTIMATEôRESPONSIBILITYôFORôTHINGSôTOôHAPPENô ATô-(ôFELLôUPONôYOUô)FôNOôONEôWANTEDôTOôORGANIZEôANYTHING ô THENôNOTHINGôWOULDôHAPPENô4HEREôWOULDôBEôNOôGROUPôPRES SUREôEXERTEDôONôINDIVIDUALSôTOôPERFORMôSOMEôPRODUCTIVEôROLEô ô%VERYTHINGôATô-(ôISôFREEô.OôONEôSHOULDôBEôASKEDôTOôPAYô ORôMAKEôAôDONATIONôFORôANYTHINGôTHATôHAPPENSôATô-(ô-(ôISô TOôBEôAôPLACEôASôFREEôASôPOSSIBLEôFROMôMARKET BASEDôFORMSô OFôEXCHANGEôANDôTHINKINGômôAôSAFEôPLACEôFORôOTHERôWAYSôOFô BEINGôANDôDOINGô ô&ORMALôANDôINFORMALôRULESôCANôBEôBROKENô BYôANôINDIVIDUALôIFôTHEYôAREôINôTHEôWAYôOFôTHATôINDIVIDUALôHAVINGô COMPLETEôFREEDOMôTOôEXPLOREôHISHERôIDEASô4HEôKEYHOLDERSôAREô THEôCOREôGROUPôANDôORGANIZEôMOSTôOFôTHEôEVENTS ôEXHIBITIONS ô SCREENINGS ôTALKS ôANDôOTHERôTHINGSôTHATôHAPPENôATô-(ô4HEYô

ô(OWôDOôYOUôSUPPORTôTHEôWORKôkNANCIALLYôANDôWHATôIMPACTô DOESôTHISôHAVEôONôYOURôPROJECT 4EMPORARYô3ERVICESôGETSôSMALLôAMOUNTSôOFôFUNDINGôANDôCOM MISSIONSôTOôPRODUCEôOURôWORK ôBUTôWEôCANTôLIVEôOFFôOFôTHISôMON EYô%ACHôOFôUSôHASôTOôHAVEôINCOMEôFROMôOTHERôSOURCESôUSUALLYôINô THEôFORMôOFôPARTôORôFULLôTIMEôJOBSô7EôREFUSEôTOôTAKEôPARTôINôTHEô COMMERCIALôARTôMARKETôASôITôISôANATHEMAôTOôOURôCONCERNSôANDô HOWôWEôWANTôOURôWORKôTOôFUNCTIONôINôTHEôWORLDô



0240_057_self_org.indd 198-199

-ESSô(ALLô4HEôSPACEô-(ôINHABITSôWASôGIVENôTOôUSôFORôFREEô7Eô PROVIDEôEVERYTHINGôATô-(ôFORôFREEô7EôTAPôINTOôTHEôSURPLUSESô EVERYONEôHASôWHETHERôTHATôISôTIME ôMONEY ôRESOURCES ôSKILLSô ANDôSOôONô7HENôPEOPLEôSTARTôSHARINGôTHESEôTHINGSôONôAôLARGERô SCALE ôMONEYôISôNEEDEDôLESSôANDôLESSô7EôDOôPAYôFORôTHEôBASICô OPERATIONôOFô-(ôOUTôOFôOURôOWNôPOCKETSômôANDôSOMETIMESô FROMôMONEYôTHATôCOMESôINôTHEôFORMôOFôDONATIONS ôPAYMENTSô FORôLECTURES ôSMALLôGRANTSôANDôSOôONô4HEREôISôSUCHôAôLOW LEVELô ECONOMYôTHATôITôISôEXTREMELYôEASYôFORôUSôTOôMAINTAINôTHEôPLACEô ANDôITSôCOMMUNITY ô7HATôDOôYOUôFEELôYOUôHAVEôACHIEVED ôANDôWHATôAREôTHEôPROB LEMSôYOUôFACE 4EMPORARYô3ERVICESôHASôBEENôABLEôTOôDOôSOôMUCHôMOREôWORKô THANôWEôEVERôTHOUGHTôWEôWOULDôANDôTOôINSERTôAôVOICEôOFôDISSENTô

25/09/06 17:41:12

ANDôCOMPLICATIONôINTOôTHEôDISCOURSEôAROUNDôCONTEMPORARYôARTô PRACTICEôINôTHEô53ôANDôELSEWHEREô7EôWANTôTOôCONTINUEôTOô BUILDôUPôOURôPRACTICEôANDôITSôIMPACTôONôOTHERSôANDôOURôOWNô LIVESô)TôISôHARDôTOôMAINTAINôTHISôKINDôOFôNON COMMERCIAL ôANTI AUTHORITARIANôPRACTICEôINôTHEô5NITEDô3TATESô9OUôGETôWORNôOUTô EASILYôDOINGôITô(AVINGôTHEôSTRENGTHôTOôCONTINUEôISôOFTENôTHEô MOSTôIMPORTANTôTHINGô -ESSô(ALLôHASôBUILTôUPôAôUNIQUE ôSUPPORTIVEôCULTUREôANDôISôAô MODELôFORôOTHERSôONôHOWôTOôDOôTHEôSAMEôTHINGô4HINGSôAREô GOINGôWELLôNOW ôBUTôWHATôWEôHAVEôBUILTôISôSOôFRAILô7EôHAVEô MADEôNOôPLANSôFORô-(ôTOôCONTINUEôSHOULDôOURôFREEôRENTôSITUATIONô CEASEô)ôAMôNOTôSUREôTHATô-(ôSHOULDôCONTINUEôBEYONDôITSôLIFEôINô ITSôCURRENTôLOCALEô4HEôLARGERôCHALLENGEôISôTOôENSUREôSPACEôFORô PLACESôLIKEô-(ô4HISôISôAôMUCHôBIGGERôTASKôANDô)ôDONTôKNOWôIFô THEôCURRENTô-(ôCREWôWILLôADDRESSôIT

WAYôTOôSUSTAINôOURôWORKôECONOMICALLY ôBUTôWHILEôMAINTAININGôOURô PRINCIPLESôANDôTHEôBASICôCONCERNSôTHATôINFORMôOURôWORK -ESSô(ALLôWASôSTARTEDôASôAôSHORT TERMôEXPERIMENTô.ONEôOFôUSô EXPECTEDôITôTOôLASTôORôDEVELOPôINôTHEôWAYSôITôHASô)TôHASôCOM PLETELYôSURPASSEDôOURôEXPECTATIONSôANDôWEôHOPEôITôCONTINUESô TOôDEVELOPôANDôLASTôFORôASôLONGôASôITôNEEDSôTOô)TôHASôALREADYô ENCOURAGEDôMANYôOTHERSôTOôBUILDôTHEIRôOWNôPLACESôLIKEô-(ô 7EôWOULDôLOVEôTOôSEEôAôPLACEôLIKEô-(ôINôEVERYôNEIGHBORHOODô OFô#HICAGOô -OREôINFORMATIONô WWWTEMPORARYSERVICESORG WWWMESSHALLORG WWWINTHEkELDINFO WWWGROUPSANDSPACESNET WWWLEARNINGSITEINFO

ô!REôTHEREôANYôPASTôPROJECTSôWHICHôHAVEôINSPIREDôYOU 4HEô%X ô(A(A ô'ROUPô-ATERIAL ô'ENERALô)DEA ô4HEô7EATHERMEN ô -/6% ô4HEô%XPERIMENTALô3TATION ô. ô7(7 ô7OCHENKLAUSUR ô 4HEô*ANEô.ETWORK ô!XEô3TREETô!RENA ô0!$$ ô5PôAGAINSTôTHEô WALLôMOTHERFUCKER ô3OLVOGNEN ô4HEô3ITUATIONISTS ô#ANô-ASDEU ô 4HEô3TEELYARD ô&ORTô4HUNDER ô3ONICô9OUTH ô&UNKADELIC0ARLIA MENT ô4HEô$IGGERS ô4HEô2ESOURCEô#ENTERô#HICAGO ô4HEô-ADô (OUSERS ô4HEô,ANDLESSô-OVEMENTôOFô"RAZILô-34 ô&REEô2ADIOô "ERKELEY ô4HEô%MPTYô6ESSELô0ROJECT ô7OMENôONô7AVES ô4HEô &ARM ô4HEô7HOLEô%ARTHô#ATALOG ô:APATISTAS ô"OINGô"OING ôANDô MANYôMOREô)ôAMôNOTôREMEMBERINGôATôTHEôMOMENT ô7HATôAREôYOURôHOPESôFORôTHEôFUTURE )ôHOPEôTHATô4EMPORARYô3ERVICESôWILLôCONTINUEôTOôWORKôTOGETHERô UNTILôWEôAREôALLôINôOURôSô)ôALSOôHOPEôTHATôWEôkNDôAôBETTERô


0240_057_self_org.indd 200-201


25/09/06 17:41:12

4HEôNOôBORDERôNETWORK $ESCRIPTION 4HEô.OBORDERôNETWORKôNOôLONGERôEXISTSômôANDôISôMOREôACTIVEôTHANôEVERô @.O ONEôISôILLEGAL 4EXT 4HEôNOôBORDERôNETWORKôISôAôTOOLôFORôALLôGROUPSôANDôGRASSROOTSôORGANIZATIONSôWHOôWORKô ONôTHEôQUESTIONSôOFôMIGRANTSôANDôASYLUMôSEEKERSôINôORDERôTOôSTRUGGLEôALONGSIDEôWITHô THEMôFORôFREEDOMôOFôMOVEMENT ôFORôTHEôFREEDOMôFORôALLôTOôSTAYôINôTHEôPLACEôWHICHôTHEYô HAVEôCHOSEN ôAGAINSTôREPRESSIONôANDôANDôTHEôMANYôCONTROLSôWHICHôMULTIPLYôTHEôBOR DERSôEVERYWHEREôINôALLôCOUNTRIESô4HISôNETWORKôISôDIFFERENTôFROMôLOBBYINGôGROUPSôANDô .'/SôBECAUSEôITôISôBASEDôONôGROUPSôOFôGRASSROOTSôACTIVISTSôANDôINTENDSôTOôSTAYôSO 4HEôCOORDINATIONôBETWEENôTHEôGROUPSôISôDONEôTHROUGHôTWOôMEETINGSôEVERYôYEARôANDô AôWORKINGôLISTôONôE MAIL ô

4HEôNOôBORDERôNETWORKôISôBORNôOFôTHEôCONVERGENCEôOFôCAMPAIGNSôINôVARIOUSô%U

ROPEANôCOUNTRIESôATôTHEôMOMENTôWHENôUNDOCUMENTEDôFOREIGNERSôHADôSTARTEDôTOôGETô SELFôORGANIZEDôTOôGETôTOGETHERôANDôBECOMEôVISIBLEôTOôALLôOCCUPATIONS ôESPECIALLYôOFô CHURCHES ôACTIONS ôDEMONSTRATIONS ôTOôTAKEôTHEIRôSTRUGGLEôINôTHEIRôOWNôHANDS ôINôSHORTô TOôBEôAUTONOMOUSô&REEDOMôOFôMOVEMENT ôDOCUMENTSôFORôALL ôABOLISHôRACISTôLAWS ôNOô DEPORTATIONSôWEREôTHEôMAINôSLOGANSôOFôTHESEôSANS PAPIERS ô

4HEôNOôBORDERôNETWORKôWASôCREATEDôINôô4HEô%UROPEANôSUMMITôOFô4AMPEREô

INô/CTOBERôôWASôONEôMOREôSTEPôTOWARDôTHEôCONSTITUTIONôOFôgCORPORATIONô%UROPEuô WITHôITSôLEVELôOFôCONTROLôADAPTEDôTOôTHEôLEVELôOFôEXPLOITATIONô6ARIOUSô%UROPEANôGROUPSô CALLEDôFORôDEMONSTRATIONSôAGAINSTôTHISôSUMMIT ôUNDERôTHEôMOTTOôgTHISôACTUALLYôMEANSô MOREôCONTROLS ôMOREôARRESTS ôMOREôDEPORTATIONSuô!CTIONSôANDôDEMONSTRATIONSôTOOKô PLACEôINôEIGHTôCOUNTRIES ô

4HEôkRSTôNOôBORDERôMEETINGôTOOKôPLACEôINô!MSTERDAMôINô$ECEMBERôô)TSôTHEREô

THATôAôMAILINGôLISTôWASôESTABLISHEDô)TôENABLESôMANYôGRASSôROOTôGROUPS ôINCLUDINGôOUTôOFô %UROPE ôTOôCOORDINATEôACTIONS ôTOôEXCHANGEôINFORMATIONôANDôTOôDISCUSSôABOUTôMIGRA TIONSôANDôBORDERSô7ITHINôTHEôNOBORDERôNETWORK ôWEôAIMôTOôWORKôAGAINSTôALLôFORMSôOFô EXPLOITATIONôANDôDIVISION ôBYôWORKINGôTOGETHERôTOôCREATEôNEWôFORMSôOFôCOLLABORATIONô ANDôRESISTANCEô7EôAIMôTOôCREATEôAôPLATFORMôFORôEXCHANGEôOFôINFORMATIONôANDôEXPE RIENCEôAMONGôGROUPSôANDôINDIVIDUALSôINVOLVEDôINôDIFFERENTôPOLITICALôSTRUGGLESôWITHô ANôEMANCIPATORYôANTI CAPITALISTôPERSPECTIVEô7EôALSOôAIMôTOôWORKôTOGETHERôWITHôSELFô ORGANIZEDôGROUPSôOFôMIGRANTSô7EôAIMôTOôINTERCONNECTôPEOPLEôWORKINGôFROMôDIFFERENTô POLITICALôPRACTICESôANDôCOMINGôWITHôDIFFERENTôREGIONALôEXPERIENCES 3OURCE WWWNOBORDERORGABOUTPHP &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWNOBORDERORGLINKSPHPôômôôWWWILLEGALTMAHOSTORG

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñKLñ?LOABOñKBQTLOH

0240_057_self_org.indd 202-203

25/09/06 17:41:14

3ELF ORGANISATIONô !ôSHORTô STORYôOFô AôFAMILYôTREE -IKAô(ANNULAô


0240_057_self_org.indd 204-205

3ELF ORGANISATIONô!ôSHORTôSTORYôOFôAôFAMILYôTREE

25/09/06 17:41:14

1UITEôAôLONGôWHILEôAGOôAôMANôCALLEDô!RISTOTLEôCLAIMEDôTHATô ôHUMANôBEINGSôAREôSOCIALôANIMALSô"ASICALLY ôWHATôHEôMEANTô WASôTHATôOURôIDENTITIESôANDôREALITIESôAREôSHAPEDôANDôFORMEDô WITHINôAôSOCIETY ôINôTRANSACTIONSôWITHôOTHERôPEOPLEôANDôSTRUC TURESôINôTHEôPARTICULARôCONTEXTômôTHATôIS ôWHEREôYOUôHAPPENô TOôBEôRIGHTôHEREôRIGHTôNOW ôWHEREôYOUôAREôFROMôANDôHOWôYOUô RELATEôTOôYOURôBACKGROUNDô)TôISôANôONGOINGôPROCESSôTHATôULTI MATELYôTAKESôPLACEôSIMULTANEOUSLYôINôCONNECTIONôWITHôTHEôPAST ô PRESENTôANDôFUTUREô

7HATôKINDôOFôAôDEALôAREôWEôTALKINGôABOUTôBETWEENôINDIVIDUALSô ANDôAôSOCIETYô)NôORDERôTOôMAKEôTHEôMOSTôEFFECTIVEôPOINTôPOS SIBLE ô)ôWILLôPRESENTôEACHôSIDEôINôITSôEXTREMEôVERSIONô+EEPINGô THISôDELIBERATEôEXAGGERATIONôINôMIND ôWEôCONFRONTôAôVERSIONôOFô INDIVIDUALISMôWHEREôTHEREôISôNOôCOMMONôGROUNDôAMONGôANYôOFô THEôPERSONSôINVOLVEDô4HEREôISôNOôSOCIETY ôTHEREôAREôNOôRULES ô THEREôISôNOôSOLIDARITYôWHATSOEVERô!LLôTHATôISôLEFTôISôAôPOTENTIALô NON STOPôWARôOFôALLôAGAINSTôALLô

1UITEôSOMEôTIMEôLATERôAôMANôCALLEDô!LASDAIRô-AC)NTYREôCHOSEô TOôINTERPRETô!RISTOTLESôIDEAôINôAôBRANDôNEWôWAYô)Nô ôINô HISôBOOK ô!FTERô6IRTUEô!ô3TUDYôINô-ORALô4HEORY ô-AC)NTYREôEX TENDEDôTHEôORIGINALôIDEAôWITHôAôREMARKABLEôINVENTION ôBYôSTATINGô THATôWEôHUMANSôAREôSTORY TELLINGôANIMALSôWHOôWEôARE ôHOWôWEô ARE ôWHEREôWEôHAPPENôTOôBE ôANDôWHOMôWEôAREôWITHôDEPENDô ONôWHATôKINDôOFôCOHERENTôNARRATIVEôOFôOURôSEARCHôFORôAôGOODôLIFEô WEôSEEKôTOôTELLôANDôMAINTAINô

&OLLOWINGôTHISôPATHôILLUMINATEDôINôSTARKôLIGHTôANDôDRAMATICôSHAD OW ôWEôGETôAôSECONDôVERSIONôOFôAôSOCIETYôASôAôTOTALITYô4HISô VERSIONôISôALLôABOUTôCENTRALLYôDEkNEDôANDôIMPLEMENTEDôVIEWSô ANDôVISIONSôINôWHICHôAôSINGLEôINDIVIDUALôHASôAôMINORôANDôDIMIN ISHINGôROLEôTOôPLAYô)TôISôAôVISIONôOFôAôSOCIETYôTHATôHASôACHIEVEDô TOTALôCONTROLôOFôITSôPARTSôANDôPEOPLESô)TôISôTHOROUGHLYôPLANNED ô EXECUTINGôAôPURELYôRATIONALôAGENDAôINôAôDYNAMICôANDôTECHNO LOGICALLYôADVANCEDôFASHIONô)TôHASôBECOMEôONE ôANDôATôTHEôSAMEô TIME ôMUCHôMOREôTHANôJUSTôTHEôSUMôOFôITSôPARTSô

)FôWEôAREôABLEôTOôACCEPTôTHEôPRESUPPOSITIONSôOUTLINEDôABOVE ô WHATôKINDôOFôSTORYôISôTHEREôTOôTELLôABOUTôTHEôCONCEPTôOFôSELF OR GANISATIONô7ITHOUTôDOUBT ôITôISôAôCOMPLEXôCASEôWITHôNUMEROUSô PLOTSôANDôSUB PLOTS ôBUTôITSôBASICôSTRUCTUREôISôRATHERôCLEARô)TôISôAô NARRATIVEôTHATôINCLUDESôANDôSTRONGLYôENTWINESôTWOôEVIDENTôANDô VALIDôOPPOSINGôSIDESôANDôPROTAGONISTSô)NôSHORT ôITôISôAôSTORYô ABOUTôWHATôHAPPENSôINôAôPARTICULARôPLACEôAMONGôTHEôPEOPLEô INHABITINGôIT ôANDôHOWôTHESEôPEOPLEôHAVEôDECIDEDôTOôORGAN ISEôANDôSTRUCTUREôTHEIRôSOCIETYô4HEôPROTAGONISTSôAREôTHEREFOREô BOTHôTHEôINDIVIDUALSôANDôTHEôSOCIETYôASôANôENTITYôOFôACTIVITIESô 2EMEMBERôTHATôBOTHôSIDESôAREôCHARACTERISTICALLYôPLURALISTICôINô THEIRôCONTENT ôANDôTHEYôDEkNEôTHEMSELVESôINôINTERACTIONôANDô SOMETIMESôINôJUXTAPOSITIONôWITHôTHEIRôCOUNTERPARTSô

!NYTHINGôWEôCANôSAYôABOUTôSELF ORGANISATIONôTAKESôPLACEôBE TWEENôTHESEôTWOôEXTREMESô3ELF ORGANISATIONôASôANôABSTRACTô PHENOMENONôISôAôMEETINGôOFôDIFFERENT ôOFTENôCOLLABORATIVEô FORCES ôBUTôALSOôCONlICTINGôDESIRES ôWISHESôANDôFEARSô)TôISôAô TRANSACTION ôAôKINDôOFôPLATFORM ôORôANôINTERSECTIONôOFôlOWSôOFô INFORMATION ôCAPITAL ôATTITUDES ôAMUSEMENTS ôANDôYES ôNOTôTOô FORGETôAMAZEMENTSô4HEôDIRECTIONSôOFôTHESEôlOWSôDEPENDôONô WHETHERôTHEYôSTEMôFROMôANôINDIVIDUALISTôBACKGROUNDôFROMôTHEô SINGULARôTOWARDSôTHEôGENERAL ôORôFROMôTHEôEVERYDAYôGRASSROOTSô LEVELôTOôTHEôLEVELôOFôSOCIALôSTRUCTURES ôORôFROMôTHEôSOCIETYôSIDEô TOP TO DOWNôMODELôOFôINTERACTIONôANDôINlUENCE ô)NôWHATôFOL LOWS ô)ôWILLôMAINLYôFOCUSôONôTHEôINDIVIDUALISTôASPECTSôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONô



0240_057_self_org.indd 206-207

25/09/06 17:41:14

/PENô3OURCEô)CEô#REAM $ESCRIPTION )TSôICEôCREAMô!NDôITSôOPENôSOURCE 4EXT )CEôCREAMôFORô%VERYONE )%ôAREôMAKINGôTHEIRôICEôCREAMôCODEôAVAILABLEôFORôYOUôTOôUSEô 9OULLôNOTICEôTHATôWEôGIVEôYOUôQUANTITIESôOFôINGREDIENTSôASôVARIABLESô4HISôISôTOôEN COURAGEôDIVERSITYôINôICEôCREAMôWEôHOPEôTHATôYOUôUSEôTHEôCODEôTOôMAKEôYOURôOWNô ICEôCREAMôRATHERôTHANôJUSTôTRYôTOôREPRODUCEôOURSôEXACTLYô/NCEôYOUVEôHITôONôAôGOODô VERSION ôWEDôAPPRECIATEôITôIFôYOUDôMAILôUSôYOURôNEWôRECIPEômôMAYBEôJUSTôCHANGEôTHEô VARIABLESôINTOôCONSTANTS (ERESôWHATôWEôSAIDôINôô g4HEYôSAIDôITôCOULDNTôBEôDONE ôBUTôWEVEôREVIVEDôTHEôLOSTôRECIPEôOFô7AKEkELDSôRIGHT FULôICEôCREAMôGENERALES ôTHEôg'RECOô"ROTHERSuô4HROUGHôCAREFULôSTUDYôANDôMONTHSôOFô REVERSE ENGINEERING ôWEVEôMANAGEDôTOôPIECEôTOGETHERôAôTASTEôFROMôTHEôRECENTôPASTô FROMôPOPULARôMEMORY ôTHEôPEOPLESôICEôCREAMôFROMôBEFOREôTHEôDAYSôOFôDAIRY GLUTôANDô SELF ABSORBED ôLUXURYôFROZENôFONDANTôTHEôMEETINGôOFô)TALIANôANDô"RITISHôPOPULAR CUL TURESô,OCALLYôMADEôWITHôWHOLEôINGREDIENTSôANDôNOôPRESERVATIVESôORôSTABILIZERS ôTHISô ICEôCREAMôDEkESôTHEôRESTRICTIVEôPRACTICESôOFôCORPORATEôFOODôEMPIRES ôRELEASINGôICEô CREAMSôPOTENTIALôTOôSPEAKôFROMôMANYôANDôVARIEDôCULTURALôCONTEXTSô3OôFAR ôITSôBEENô MADEôONLYôINôSMALLôBATCHESôAôSECRETôLETôSLIP ôSPOONFULôBYôSPOONFUL ôTOôEAGERôFRIENDSô ANDôFAMILYô"UTôNOWôITSôTIMEôTOôGOôPUBLICuô mô -ARKô'RECOôô3IMONô0OPEô/CTOBERô ô

)%ô/PENô3OURCEô)CEôCREAMôWWWBAKSPCORGICEOPEN?SOURCEHTML

%XCERPTSôFROMôINTERVIEWôWITHô-ARKô'RECOôANDô3IMONô0OPE 7HATôWEôGOTôUPôTOôWASôMOREô@CRACKôTHANôREVERSEôENGINEERINGô7EôWANTEDôTOôEXPLOITôAô FEWôlAWSôINôMANUFACTUREDôICEôCREAMômôTHATôITôCONTAINSôSUPERlUOUSôSHITôANDôISôPROPRIE TORYômôBUTôWEôALSOôWANTEDôTOôRECOVERôAôLOSTôANDôINACCESSIBLE ôRECIPEôORô@SOURCEôCODEô 7HYôDOESôANYONEôCRACKôTHIRD PARTYôSOFTWAREô0ROBABLYôBECAUSEôTHERESôSOMETHINGôINô THEREôTHATSôANNOYINGô)NSULTINGôEVENôLIKEôSERIALôNUMBERSôORôPASSWORDSô7EôLIKEôTHEô

IDEA ôOFôWHATôCOMMERCIALôICEôCREAMôISômôCHEAP ôPOPULAR ôSOCIALôFOODômôBUTôCANTôSTANDô WHATôITô ACTUALLY ôISô7HYôISôGUARôGUMôINôTHEREô7HYôTHEôHELLôAREôlAVOURôENHANCERSôINô THEREô7EôHAVEôTHEôSKILLSôTOôCRACKôTHIRD PARTYôICEôCREAMô ôBUTôNOTôTOôRE ASSEMBLEôITô7Eô CANTôMODIFYôITôINôITSôNATIVEôLANGUAGEôORôATôTHEôSCALEôONôWHICHôITôISôMANUFACTURED ôSOô WEôAIMôTOôABSTRACTôTHEôCODEôSOôASôTOôWORKôWITHôITôATôAôDOMESTICôSCALEô7EôGENERATEDô DIAGRAMSôTOôHELPôUSôUNDERSTANDôTHEôRELATIONSHIPSôBETWEENôCOMPONENTS ôLIKEôSOMEô OFôTHEôMOREôARCANEôOBJECTôORIENTEDôREVERSEôENGINEERINGôMETHODOLOGIESô7EôIDENTI kEDôCLASSESôANDôTHEôRELATIONSHIPSôBETWEENôOBJECTSôORôINGREDIENTSô7EôGENERALISEDô LABELLEDôINGREDIENTSôINTOôCLASSESôACCORDINGôTOôACCEPTEDôFORMULATIONSôFORôCOMMERCIALô

%XAMPLESôôYôô,MBKñ0LRO@Bñ&@Bñ OB>J

0240_057_self_org.indd 208-209

25/09/06 17:41:16

ICEôCREAMSôMILKFAT ôMILKôSOLIDS NOT FAT ôSUGAR ôSTABILIZERS ôEMULSIkERSôANDôlAVOURSô THENôLOOKEDôATôTHEôOBJECTSôINôEACHôCLASSôANDôTHEIRôPROPERTIESô7EôFOUNDôTHATôSOMEô CLASSESôWEREôUSEFULôONLYôINôMASS PRODUCEDôICESôTHERESôAôSURPRISEô3INCEôWEREô MAKINGôSMALLôBATCHESôOFôTHEôSTUFF ôWEôkGUREDôONôCUTTINGôTHEMôOUTô7EREôLEFTôWITHô INGREDIENTSôTHATôCANôBEôCOMBINEDôINôDIFFERENTôWAYSô4HEôMOREôSUGAR ôTHEôMOREô@BITEô FORôEXAMPLEô#HANGEôTHEôPROPERTYôOFôTHEôMILKôBYôHEATINGôITôFORôLONGERôANDôYOUôGETôAô THICKER ôSWEETERôICEôCREAMô7HATôWEVEôGOTôISôAôGENERATIVEôMACHINEôWEôCANôMAKEô INkNITEôRECOMBINATIONSôOFôAôFEWôKEYôINGREDIENTSô)TôPROVESôTHATôTHERESôNOôNATURAL ôIDEALô STATEôFORôICEôCREAMô.OôORIGINALôTOôCOPYô7EôCANôMAKEôITôANYôWAYôWEôCHOOSE ôANDôSOô CANôYOU ô"UTôITôJUSTôSOôHAPPENSôTHEôONEôWEVEôCHOSENôMAKEôATôTHEôMOMENTôISô6%29ô CLOSEôTOô-ARKSôLOSTôFAMILYôRECIPEôô ô

)TôWASôWASô2ICHARDô3TALLMANôWHOôSUGGESTEDôWEôCALLôITô@FREEô4HISôWASôAFTERôOURôkRSTô

GIGôATôTHEô&OUNDRYôINô/LDô3TREET ô,ONDON ôWHEREô@FREEôSPEECHôWASôDEkNITELYôINlUENCEDô BYôTHEô@FREEôBEERô7EôMENTIONEDôTHATôWEREôGOINGôTOôINVITEôPEOPLEôTOôEXTENDôTHEôCODEô BASEôOFôTHEôICEôCREAMôINôWHATEVERôWAYôTHEYôSEEôkTômôSOôTHATôITôBECAMEô@/PENô3OURCEô INôSOMEôWAYômôBUTôWEôBOWEDôTOô3TALLMAN ôFORôOBVIOUSôREASONS ôWHENôHEôSUGGESTEDô g.OTô@OPENôSOURCEôICEôCREAMôCALLôITôFREEuô4OôPARAPHRASEôTHEô&3& ôg&REEô)CEôCREAMuôISô AôMATTERôOFôLIBERTY ôNOTôPRICEu ô

"EFOREôTRYINGôTOôANALYSEôWHATôSELF ORGANISATIONôIS ôMIGHTôBE ô ANDôEVENôOUGHTôTOôBE ô)ôNEEDôTOôCLARIFYôTHEôPOSSIBLEôMOTIVA TIONSôBEHINDôITô!SôINôANYôACTIONôTHATôTRIESôTOôACHIEVEôSOME THINGôDIFFERENTôTHANôWHATôCAMEôBEFOREôIT ôORôDIFFERENTôTOôTHEô CURRENTôSITUATION ôITôISôBASEDôONôAôNEEDôTOôCHANGEôSOMETHINGô môWHATEVERôTHATôSOMETHINGôISô7HATôWEôHAVEôISôAôNEEDôTOô PARTICIPATE ôTOôARTICULATEôAôNEWôVERSIONôOFôTHATôVERYôSAMEô SOMETHINGô

)TSôNOTôTHATôYOUôDONTôHAVEôTOôPAYôFORôIT ôBECAUSEôWEô$/ôACCEPTôDONATIONS ôBUTôTHISô

TYPEôOFôICEôCREAMôISô9/523ô4HISôISô)CEô#REAMôFORô%VERYONEô!ôSOCIALôFOOD ôRATHERô THANôAôINSULAR ôEXPENSIVEôSELF INDULGENCEô3TOPôWATCHINGô!LLYô-C"EALô'ETôOUTôTHEREô ANDôMAKEôICEôCREAM 3OURCEô WWWBAKSPCORGICENETTIME?INTERVIEWHTML &ORôMOREôINFORMATION 4HEôPROJECTôRANôFROMôôUNTILôGOINGôINTOôHIBERNATIONôINôôITôCOULD

)ôHAVEôREFERREDôTOô@SOMETHINGôSOôOFTENôBECAUSEôWEôHAVEôTOô PAYôCLOSEôATTENTIONôTOôTHISôSOMETHINGôWHICHôISôNOTôYETôTHEREô OR ôINôFACT ôITôISôTHEREôBUTôJUSTôASôAôPROMISE ôAôPOTENTIALôSITEô ORôSITUATIONô)NôOTHERôWORDS ôTHATôSOMETHINGôISôTHEôCONTENTôOFô SELF ORGANISATIONô(OWEVER ôTHATôSOMETHINGôISôNOTôNEUTRAL ôITôISô NOTôNATURAL ôITôISôNOTôGIVENôANDôITôISôNOTôABSOLUTEô)TôISôALWAYSô ANDôCONSTANTLYôCONTESTED ôCONSTRUCTEDôANDôQUESTIONEDô)TôISôAô SELF CORRECTINGôANDôSELF RElECTIVEôPROCESSôDURINGôWHICHôEACHô PARTICIPANTôANDôTHEôWHOLEôINôITSôHETEROGENEOUSôSELFôAREôSHAPEDô INôANôONGOINGôINTERACTION ôANôUNCEASINGôGIVEôANDôTAKE ôPUSHô ANDôPULLô

RETURNôATôANYôMOMENT WWWBAKSPCORGICENETTIME?INTERVIEWHTML

ô)%ôHOMEPAGEôANDôLINKSôATôWWWBAKSPCORGICE

ôAôREVIEWôBYô*AMIEô+INGôATôWWWBAKSPCORGICENINFOHTML

ôORIGINALô@MISSIONôSTATEMENTôWWWBAKSPCORGICEINTRODUCTIONHTML

ôRICHARDôSTALLMANôQUOTEôATôWWWBAKSPCORGICEFOUNDRYHTML

ôICEôCREAMôRECIPEôASôCODEôWWWBAKSPCORGICEOPEN?SOURCEHTML

%XAMPLESôôYôô,MBKñ0LRO@Bñ&@Bñ OB>J

0240_057_self_org.indd 210-211

!SôANôABSTRACTôPHENOMENON ôSELF ORGANISATIONôISôAôSO CALLEDô THIRDôSPACEô6AD¯Nôô(ANNULA ô)TôISôAôPECULIARôCONCENTRATIONô OFôTIMEôANDôENERGYôINôAôPARTICULARôPLACEôWHEREôTHEôINTERESTSô OFôTHEôPARTICIPANTSôINôTHATôCONTEXTôAREôDEBATED ôCONSTITUTED ô DEkNED ôCLARIkEDôANDôDEFENDEDô)TôDOESôNOTôBELONGôTOôEITHERô!ô ORô" ôBUTôISôCONSTRUCTEDôSPONTANEOUSLYôTHROUGHôTHEôINTERACTIONô BETWEENô!ôANDô"ô)TôISôAôMEETINGôPOINTôATôWHICHôBOTHôSIDESô HAVEôFOUNDôTHEôCAPACITYôTOôLISTENôTOôEACHôOTHERôONôTHEôOTHERSô TERMSô)TôISôBASEDôONôACKNOWLEDGINGôINTERACTIONôTHATôSEEKSô TOôNEGOTIATEôAôSUSTAINABLEôCOMPROMISEôFORôEXISTINGôALONGSIDEô ONEôANOTHER ôNOTôASôAôUNITY ôBUTôINôAôPLURALITYô)TôISôANôATTITUDEô


25/09/06 17:41:16

THATôPHILOSOPHERSôDESCRIBEôASôANôANTI ESSENTIALISTôSENTIMENTô WITHôTHEôUNDERSTANDINGôOFôCO EXISTENCEôOFôPLURALôWORLDSô4HEREô CANNOTôBEôFULLôTRANSLATIONôBETWEENôPLURALôWORLDSô4HEREôISôCER TAINLYôAôWEAKôINCOMMENSURABILITYôBETWEENôDIFFERENTôVERSIONS ô BUT ôATôTHEôSAMEôTIME ôTHESEôVERSIONSôSHAREôSIMILARôENOUGHô PERCEPTIONSô4HEYôSHAREôENOUGHôTOôBEôCOMPREHENSIBLEôANDô RECOGNIZABLE ôALLOWINGôANDôEVENôCHERISHINGôCROSS DWELLINGô BETWEENôVARIOUSôWORLDSôANDôPOSITIONSô3PINOSAôô$REYFUS ô 7HENôTHESEôDIFFERENTôWORLDSôMANAGEôTOôCO EXISTôTHEYôFORMô ANôUNSTABLEôBUTôSIGNIkCANTôSITEôCALLEDôTHEôTHIRDôSPACEô)TôISôAô TRANSITORYôANDôALWAYSôEVOLVINGôPLACEôTHATôPRESUPPOSESôSOME THINGôTHATôISôNOTôALWAYSôEASYôTOôFULkLLôORôSUSTAINôAôPRINCIPLEôOFô NON VIOLENCEô)TôALSOôREQUIRESôANôATTITUDEôTHATôMIGHTôBEôEVENô HARDERôTOôFULkLLôMUTUALôRESPECTôANDôRECOGNITIONôOFôEACHôOTHERSô CREDIBLEôVIEWSôANDôPOSITIONSô

POLICE ôPARLIAMENT ôTHEôTWOôMAINôQUESTIONSôTOôASKôREGARDINGô CIVILôSOCIETYôAREô ô (OWôDOôWEôACTIVATEôANDôEMPOWERôINDIVIDUALSôANDôCOLLECTIVESô ô )NôOURôPOST INDUSTRIALô7ESTERNôDEMOCRACIES ôWHYôISôTHEôDOMAINôOFôCIVILô SOCIETYôSOôPASSIVEôAND ôINôTHEôEND ôSOôINCREDIBLYôUNDER USEDô

7EôCANôOBVIOUSLYôDEBATEôWHETHERôTHESEôTWOôQUESTIONS ôINôFACT ô AREôTHEôMOSTôIMPORTANTôONESôORôNOT ôBUTôLETôUSôCONTINUEôWITHô THEMôFORôTHEôSAKEôOFôARGUMENTô)ôWILLôkRSTôTACKLEôTHEôLATTERôONEô ANDôTHENôRETURNôLATERôONôTOôTHEôQUESTIONôOFôACTIVATINGôPOTENTIALô PARTICIPANTSôINôAôCIVILôSOCIETYô

)NôTERMSôOFô7ESTERNôDEMOCRACIESôBASEDôONôFREEôANDôFAIRôVOTING ô THEôSTRUCTURALôPRINCIPLESôOFôCHECKSôANDôBALANCES ôANDôRIGHTSô ANDôGUARANTEESôBETWEENôDIFFERENTôPARTSôOFôGOVERNMENTôLAW ô

7HYôISôCIVILôSOCIETYôSOôUNDER USEDô7HYôSOôGRAYôANDôSADô 7HYôSOôUTTERLYôPHLEGMATICô4HEôANSWERôHASôTWOôSIDES ôWHICHô NOTôSOôSURPRISINGLYôAREôTIGHTLYôINTERWOVENô/NEôCLEARôREASONôISô AôGENERALôPASSIVITYôANDôAPATHYôOFôTHEôPUBLICôTHATôCOMPRISESô THEôPOSSIBLEôPARTICIPANTSôINôTHEôCIVILôSOCIETYô)TôISôVERYôDIFkCULTô TOôOBSERVEôAôGREATôDEALôOFôACTIVITYôORôPERCOLATINGôPRESSUREô TOôkNDôAôVEHICLEôBYôWHICHôTOôBREAKôINTOôTHEôPUBLICôDOMAINô 'RANTED ôTHEREôISôINCREASINGôACTIVITYôWITHINôTHEôLARGEôSCALEô OFôPUBLICôMEDIA ôBUTôITôISôPREDOMINANTLYôFOCUSSEDôONôVARI OUSôKINDSôOFôENTERTAINMENT ôNOTôCRITICALôPERSPECTIVESôANDôAR TICULATIONôOFôALTERNATIVESô4HENôAGAIN ôWEôCANôQUITEôCORRECTLYô WONDERôABOUTôTHEôREASONôBEHINDôTHISôOVERWHELMINGôPASSIVITYô 4HEôCLASSICôCLAIMôISôTHATôPEOPLEôHAVEôBECOMEôALIENATEDô4HATô MIGHTôBEôSO ôBUTôITôCERTAINLYôBEGSôTHEôQUESTIONôALIENATEDô FROMôWHATô /NEôWAYôTOôANSWERôTHISôISôTOôPOINTôTOôTHEôSECONDôPARTôOFôTHEô MAINôFRAMINGôQUESTIONô#IVILôSOCIETYSôPUBLICôSPHEREôISôSOô ôUNDER USEDôPRIMARILYôBECAUSEôOFôTHEôDECREASINGôPOSSIBILITIESô


4HEREôISôANOTHERôWORDôWEôCANôUSEôTHATôMOSTôOFôUSôHAVEôLEARNEDô TOôRECOGNISEôWHENôDISCUSSINGôTHEôRELATIONSôBETWEENôINDIVIDUALSô ANDôAôSOCIETYô@#IVILôSOCIETYôISôWHATôWEôLABELôSELF ORGANISA TIONôASôAôSUMôOFôMANYôSELF ORGANISINGôACTIVITIESôWITHINôAôLARGERô FRAMEôOFôAôSOCIETYôANDôITSôHISTORIESô)NôAôCIVILôSOCIETY ôWEôHAVEô PLAYERSôANDôPARTICIPANTSôTHATôHAVEôALREADYôSELF ORGANISEDôINTOô MOREôORôLESSôSTABLEôSTRUCTURESô4HEREôAREôORGANISATIONSôSUCHô ASô!MNESTYô)NTERNATIONAL ôVARIOUSôKINDSôOFôLABOURôUNIONSôANDô .'/S ôORôMANYôTYPESôOFôSPECIkCôINTERESTôCOLLECTIVESôFORôISSUESô LIKEôFAITH ôSEXUALITYôORôOUTDOORôACTIVITIES ôWHICHôMATERIALISEôINô WILDLYôDIFFERENTôFORMS ôFROMôSPORTôCLUBSôVIAô'AYô0RIDEôPARADESô TOô2ECLAIMôTHEô3TREETSôPROTESTSô


0240_057_self_org.indd 212-213

25/09/06 17:41:17

ANDôOPENINGSôITôSEEMSôTOôOFFERô4HEôCURRENTôSITUATIONôINôMOSTô OFô7ESTERNôPUBLICLY ôANDôPRIVATELY OWNEDôMEDIAôISôNOTôAôVERYô ENCOURAGINGôORôPRETTYôSIGHTô)NSTEADôOFôLIVELYôANDôCHALLENGINGô PUBLICôDISCOURSE ôWEôHAVEôAôLITANYôOFôCOMPLAINTSôTHATôUNFORTU NATELYôAREôMOREôOFTENôTRUEôTHANôNOTô7EôFACEôAôMEDIAôREALITYô THATôA ôINSTRUMENTALISESôISSUESôFORôITSôOWNôENDS ôB ôINTENTIONALLYô lATTENSôTHEôTHEMESôITôCOVERS ôC ôTENDSôTOôPRESENTôTHEMESôTHATô CANôBEôDEALTôWITHôEASEôANDôSPEED ôD ôLOOKSôFORôSCANDALS ôE ô DENIESôROOMôFORôCONTENTôANDôPRODUCESôPRE LOCKEDôUPôVIEWS ô ANDôF ôLACKSôTHEôWILLôANDôABILITYôFORôCONSTRUCTIVEôCRITICISMô4HEô OVERALLôRESULTôISôAôPUBLICôSPHEREôTHATôISôNOôLONGERôAôPLACEôFORô DEBATE ôBUTôAôHUGEôSPACEôFORôCONSUMPTIONô 4HUS ôTHEôALIENATIONôISôNOTôFROMôANYôKINDôOFôAôTRUEôSELF ôAôTRUEô SETôOFôREALôVALUES ôORôTHEô@TRUTHFULôPAST ôBUTôITôISôCONNECTEDôTOô THEôHORIZONôOFôOPENôANDôPOTENTIALôCHANCESôTOôAFFECTôYOURôDAILYô LIFEôANDôTHEôDEGREEôANDôRELEVANCEôWITHôWHICHôYOUôAREôABLEôTOô PARTICIPATEôINôDISCUSSIONSôWITHINôTHEôPUBLICôSPHEREô4HEôDIMIN ISHINGôCHANCESôAREôDUEôMAINLYôTOôTHEôONE SIDEDNESSôOFôMASSô MEDIAôOUTPUTôAND ôSELF EVIDENTLY ôINPUTô4HEôWELL KNOWNôDRIVINGô FORCESôAREôHIGHERôPROkTSôANDôHIGHERôLEVELSôOFôVIEWERS ôWHICHô SUPPORTôTHEôCONSEQUENCEôOFôMOREôOFôTHEôSAMEôKINDôOFôMAIN STREAMôPRODUCTIONô4HEôSTRANGEômôAND ôINôTHEôENDômôPERVERSEô PARTôOFôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôRELATESôTOôHOWôANDôWHYôPUBLICôBROAD CASTINGôCOMPANIESôHAVEôCHOSENôTOôFOLLOWôTHEôEXAMPLESôANDô AIMSôOFôTHEôPRIVATEôSECTORô

HENDEDôPUBLICôSPHEREôTHEôACKNOWLEDGEDôFRAGMENTATIONôOFôCON TEMPORARYôSOCIETIESôANDôPUBLICSôINTOôSPECIkCôSEGMENTSô4HISôINô ITSELFôDOESôNOTôDENYôTHEôPOSSIBILITYôOFôAôCOMMONôDENOMINATOR ô BUTôITôMAKESôITôMUCHôHARDERôTOôACHIEVEôANDôCONCEPTUALISEôITô 3OôFAR ôSOôGOOD ô)ôGUESSômôRELATIVELYôSPEAKINGô7EôHAVEôAô SOMEWHATôPLAUSIBLEôTHOUGHôOBVIOUSLYôABSTRACTôIDEAôOFôCIVILô SOCIETYôTHATôAIMSôHIGHô)TôSTRIVESôFORôAôDEMOCRATICôEGALITARIANô SOCIETYôTHATôSEARCHESôFORôADEQUATEôFORMSôOFôSELF EMPOWERMENTô ANDôSELF MANAGEMENT ôINTER PUBLICôCOORDINATIONôOFôAIMSôANDô VALUES ôANDôOPENôANDôTRANSPARENTôPOLITICALôACCOUNTABILITYô7Eô HAVEôALSOôARRIVEDôATôAôDEkNITIONôOFôAôPUBLICôSPHEREôTHATôSTANDSô FORôAôNETWORKôOFôCOMMUNICATIONôTHATôCREATESôAôPARTICULARôSOCIALô SPACEô)TôISôAôSPACEôINôTHEôWIDESTôSENSEôOFôTHEôWORDô)TôCREATESô AôSPACE ôASôINôAôDISCOURSE ôTHATôHASôBOTHôSPATIALôANDôMENTALô ASPECTSô#IVILôSOCIETYôISôSHAPEDôINôTHESEôINTERACTIONSôWITHINôTHEô PUBLICôSPHEREô!NDôYES ôSELF ORGANISATIONôISôONEôOFôTHEôMEANSô TOôACTIVATEôTHESEôPROCESSESô %XAMPLESôOFôMEANINGFULôANDôCONSTRUCTIVEôSELF ORGANISATIONôAREô READILYôAVAILABLEô$ELIBERATELYôPICKINGôUPôEXAMPLESôFROMôDIFFER ENTôkELDS ôWEôCANôBRIElYôFOCUSôONôTHREEô ôô )SRAELIôPILOTSôREFUSINGôTOôBOMBô0ALESTINEôVERSUSô)SRAELIôSOLDIERSôREFUS INGôTOôPARTICIPATEôINôTHEôWITHDRAWALôFROMôTHEô'AZAô3TRIPô

(OWEVER ôITôWOULDôBEôCHILDISHôTOôBLAMEôMARKETôFORCESôFORôTHEô SADôSOUNDôOFôONGOINGôBOOGIEôWITHINôTHEôPUBLICôSPHEREô7HILEô WITNESSINGôTHEôACCELERATINGôCONGLOMERATIONôOFôMEDIAôPRODUC TION ôDISTRIBUTIONôANDôOWNERSHIP ôWEôHAVEôANOTHERôPHENOMENONô THATôUNDERMINESôTHEôPROSPECTSôOFôAôLARGER ôCOMMONLYôCOMPRE

4HISôISôAôHIGHLYôCONTROVERSIALôANDôPOLITICISEDôMATTERôTHATôDE SERVESôCAREFULôATTENTIONô7EôHAVEôAôSITUATIONôWITHINôTHEô)SRAELIô MILITARYôSTRUCTURE ôWHICHôINôITSELFôISôFARôFROMôTRANSPARENTôANDô CLEAR ôREGARDINGôOFkCERSôWITHôRESERVISTôSTATUSôWHOôREFUSEôTOô TAKEôPARTôINôCAMPAIGNSôDIRECTEDôATôPREVENTIVEôSTRIKESôAIMEDôATô MILITANTSôINô0ALESTINIANôAREASôANDôCAMPSô3DDEUTSCHEô:EITUNGô



0240_057_self_org.indd 214-215

25/09/06 17:41:17

/PEN3TREET-AP $ESCRIPTION /PEN3TREET-APôISôORôISôALMOST ôAôFREEôEDITABLEôMAPôOFôTHEôWHOLEôWORLDô)TôISôSTILLô BEINGôCREATEDô 4EXT 4HEôPROJECTôWASôSTARTEDôBECAUSEôMOSTôMAPSôYOUôTHINKôOFôASôFREEôACTUALLYôHAVEôLEGALô ORôTECHNICALôRESTRICTIONSôONôTHEIRôUSE ôHOLDINGôBACKôPEOPLEôFROMôUSINGôTHEMôINôCREATIVE ô PRODUCTIVEôORôUNEXPECTEDôWAYSô ô

/PEN3TREET-APôHASôCREATEDôANôONLINEôEDITINGôINTERFACEôTOôALLOWôANYONEôTOôCONTRIB

UTEôTOôTHEôMAPô4HEôEDITORôALLOWSôYOUôTOôUPLOAD ôSHAREôANDôTRACEôYOURô'03ôTRACKSôONô TOPôOFôFREEôAERIALôANDôSATELLITEôIMAGERYô4HEôDATAôCREATEDôCANôTHENôBEôUSEDôFORôFREEôINô LOTSôOFôDIFFERENTôWAYSôTHATôOFTENôARENTôPOSSIBLEôWITHôCOMMERCIALôMAPPINGô 7HYôMAKEô/PEN3TREET-APôômôô'EOGRAPHICALôDATAôGEODATA ôISôNOTôFREEôINôMANYô PARTSôOFôTHEôWORLD ôINCLUDINGôTHEô5NITEDô+INGDOMôANDôMUCHôOFô%UROPEô'ENERALLYô THESEôPLACESôHAVEôGIVENôTHEôTASKôOFôMAPPINGôTOôVARIOUSôGOVERNMENTôAGENCIESôWHOô INôRETURNôGETôTOôMAKEôMONEYôBYôSELLINGôTHEôDATAôBACKôTOôYOUôANDôMEô4HEô53!ôISôTHEô ONLYôMAJORôCOUNTER EXAMPLEôWHEREôDUEôTOôCOPYRIGHTôRESTRICTIONSôONôTHEôGOVERNMENT ô THEYôHAVEôTOôGIVEôITôAWAYôFREEô ô

)FôYOUôLIVEôINôONEôOFôTHESEôCOUNTRIES ôTHENôYOURôTAXESôPAYôFORôTHEôMAPPINGôANDôTHENô

YOUôHAVEôTOôPAYôAGAINôTOôGETôAôCOPYôOFôITô 4HEôDATAôYOUôGETôDOESNTôCHANGEôMUCHôOVERôTIME ôINôGENERALô2OADSôDONTôTENDôTOôGETô BOREDôANDôMOVEôAROUNDô9OUôCANôUSUALLYôNAVIGATEôINôMANYôAREASôWITHôANYôPOST WARô ORôMOREôRECENTôMAPSô ô

4HEôDATAôYOUôGETôCONTAINSôLIES ôORôEASTERôEGGS ôTOôCATCHôOUTôANYONEôCOPYINGôITô

4HESEô%ASTERôEGGSôTAKEôTHEôFORMôOFôFAKEôORôMISSINGôSTREETS ôORôFEATURESôLIKEôCHURCHESô ANDôSCHOOLSôTHATôDONTôINôFACTôEXISTô)FôYOUôMAKEôAôMAPôUSINGôTHEIRôDATA ôTHEYôCANôSAYô gAH HAô'OTCHAuôFROMôLOOKINGôIFôYOUôALSOôCOPIEDôTHESEôFAKEôPIECESôOFôMAPô4HEôMAPô MAYôALSOôJUSTôBEôINCORRECTôBECAUSEôFORôEXAMPLEôYOUôBOUGHTôITôAôYEARôAGOôANDôAôPATHô HASôBEENôDUGôUPôINôYOURôLOCALôPARKôSINCE ôORôSOMEONEôJUSTôMADEôAôMISTAKEô ô

)FôYOUôACCEPTôALLôOFôTHISôTHENôYOUôSTILLôCANTôDOôANYTHINGôWITHôTHEôDATAôBUTôPHOTOCOPYô

ITô)NôLOTSôOFôPLACESôTHATSôILLEGALôTOOôIFôYOUôGOôBEYONDôYOURôFAIRôUSEôORôFAIRôDEALING ô RIGHTSô9OUôCANTôCORRECTôAôSTREETôNAME ôORôADDôTHEôPUBBARôOVERôTHEôROAD ôORôUSEôTHEô DATAôINôAôCOMPUTERôPROGRAMôWITHOUTôPAYINGôAôLOTôOFôMONEYô-OREôMONEYôTHANôYOUô PROBABLYôHAVEô7HATôABOUTôSENDINGôITôTOôAôFRIEND ôENCLOSINGôITôINôANôINVITATIONôORôPOSTINGô ITôONôAôNOTICEôBOARDô!ôLOTôOFôTHESEôAREôLESSôLEGALôTHANôYOUôMIGHTôTHINKô ô

!DVANCESôINôTECHNOLOGYôLIKEôCHEAPô'03ôUNITSôMEANôYOUôCANôNOWôCREATEôYOURôOWNô

MAPS ôINôCOLLABORATIONôWITHôOTHERSôANDôHAVEôNONEôOFôTHEôRESTRICTIONSôOUTLINEDôABOVEô 4HEôABILITYôTOôDOôSOôALLOWSôYOUôTOôREGAINôAôLITTLEôBITôOFôTHEôCOMMUNITYôYOUôLIVEôINômôIFô YOUôCANTôMAPôITôYOUôCANTôDESCRIBEôITô

0240_057_self_org.indd 216-217

%XAMPLESôôYôô,MBK0QOBBQ*>M

25/09/06 17:41:18

7HYôDONTôYOUôJUSTôUSEô'OOGLEô-APSWHOEVERôFORôYOURôDATAôômôô3HORTôANSWERô "ECAUSEôTHATôDATAôISôCOPYRIGHTEDôANDôOWNEDôBYôPEOPLEôLIKEôTHEô/RDNANCEô3URVEYô 'OOGLEWHOEVERôJUSTôLICENSEôITô)FôWEôUSEDôIT ôWEDôHAVEôTOôPAYôFORôITô mô,ONGôANSWERô-OSTôHACKERSôAROUNDôTHEôWORLDôAREôFAMILIARôWITHôTHEôDIFFERENCEôBE TWEENôgFREEôASôINôBEERuôANDôgFREEôASôINôSPEECHuô'OOGLEô-APSôAREôFREEôASôINôBEER ô NOTôASôINôSPEECHô ô

)FôYOURôPROJECTSôMAPPINGôNEEDSôCANôBEôSERVEDôSIMPLYôBYôUSINGôTHEô'OOGLEô-APSô

ô3EPTEMBERô ô4HENôAGAIN ôWEôWITNESSôALMOSTôTHEôOP POSITEôWISHôWITHINôTHEôSAMEôFRAMEWORKôREGARDINGôRESERVISTôSOL DIERS ôOFTENôINlUENCEDôBYôANô/RTHODOXôREADINGôOFô*UDAISM ôWHOô REFUSEôTOôTAKEôPARTôINôTHEôPLANNEDôWITHDRAWALôFROMôTHEôOCCUPIEDô AREASôOFô'AZAô3DDEUTSCHEô:EITUNGô ô*ANUARYô ô

!0) ôALLôTOôTHEôGOODô"UTôTHATSôNOTôTRUEôOFôEVERYôPROJECTô7EôNEEDôAôFREEôDATASETôWHICHô WILLôENABLEôPROGRAMMERS ôSOCIALôACTIVISTS ôCARTOGRAPHERSôANDôTHEôLIKEôTOôFULkLôTHEIRô PLANSôWITHOUTôBEINGôLIMITEDôEITHERôBYô'OOGLESô!0)ôORôBYôTHEIRô4ERMSôOFô3ERVICE (OWôCANô)ôGETôINVOLVEDôômôô4HEREôAREôLOTSôOFôWAYSôTOôCONTRIBUTEôTOôTHEô/PENSTREETMAPô PROJECTô)FôYOUôHAVEôAô'03ôUNITôYOUôCANôUSEôITôTOôCOLLECTôDATAôANDôUSEôOURôONLINEôTOOLSô TOôADDôTHEôDATAôTOôOURôCOLLECTIONô)FôYOUôDONTôHAVEôAô'03ôUNITôYOUôCANôSTILLôHELP 3OURCEô WWWOPENSTREETMAPORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWOPENSTREETMAPORG

ô #AR FREEô(ELSINKIô!CTIONô$AYô3PRINGôô

4HISôISôAôRATHERôCOMMONôEXAMPLEôTHATôBEARSôAôRESEMBLANCEôTOô MANYôOTHERôSIMILARôACTIVITIESôINôMANYôOTHERôPLACESô)TôISôANôACTIONô MOTIVATEDôBYôANôEVIDENTLYôCREDIBLEôNEEDôTOôLOWERôTHEôNUMBERô OFôPRIVATEôCARSôGOINGôINôANDôOUTôOFôTHEôCITYôCENTREô4HEôREASONSô AREôNOTôONLYôOFôANôAESTHETICôNATURE ôBUTôBASEDôONôAIRôQUALITYô ANDôTHEôLEVELôOFôHARMFULôPARTICLESôINôTHEôAIRô4HUS ôWEôHAVEôAô PROBLEM ôANDôAôSTRONGôMOTIVATIONôANDôVASTôSYMPATHYôFORôTHEô EVENTô(OWEVER ôTHEôRESULTôWASôAôFUNNYôMIXôOFôSUAVEôIGNORANCEô ANDôIMPOTENTôPROTESTô#ARSôWENTôINôANDôOUTôWITHOUTôEVENôNO TICINGôTHEôSPECIALôTHEMEôOFôTHEôDAYô)NôOTHERôWORDS ôITôDIDôNOTô MATERIALISEôATôALLô)TôWASôAôONE OFFôEVENTôTHATôWASôNOTôVERYôWELLô PLANNEDôORôCOMMUNICATEDôTOôALLôPOTENTIALôPARTICIPANTSô3EENô FROMôANOTHERôANGLE ôTHEREôWASôNOTôENOUGHôCREDIBLEôMOTIVATIONô môEITHERôOUTôOFôGOODWILLôORôINôRESPONSEôTOôTHEôTHREATô ô )DEOLOGICALôTENDENCIESôINôTHEô#ATHOLICô#HURCHô

(EREôWEôkNDôMANYôCASESôTHATôEXEMPLIFYôHOWôANôEXTREMELYôINlU ENTIALôANDôIMPORTANTôPARTôOFôTHEôCIVILôSOCIETYômôRELIGIONôORôRELIGIOUSô AUTHORITYômôISôSTRONGLYôSHAPINGôTHEôPUBLICôSPHEREô)TôISôANôEXTREMEô CASEôAGAIN ôBUTôDEkNITELYôWORTHôNOTINGô7EôHAVEôPREACHINGôBYôAô KNOWNôCONSERVATIVEô#ARDINALôFROMô#OLOGNE ô*OACHIMô-EISNER ô ATôTHEôFEASTôOFô%PIPHANYôINô ôINôWHICHôHEôFOCUSSESôONôTHEô THEMEôOFôMASSôKILLINGSô(EôMAKESôAôCONSIDERABLYôLONGôARCHôOFô

%XAMPLESôôYôô,MBK0QOBBQ*>M

0240_057_self_org.indd 218-219


25/09/06 17:41:18

COMPARISONôSTARTINGôFROMôTHEôACTôOFô(ERODôMURDERINGôTHEôCHIL DRENôOFô"ETHLEHEM ôCONTINUINGôTOôTHEôEXECUTIONôOFôMILLIONSôOFô PEOPLEôBYôTHEôMACHINERYôOFôBOTHô3TALINôANDô(ITLER ôANDôENDINGô UPôWITHôTHEôCONTEMPORARYôCASEôOFôTHEôDAILYôMURDERSôOFôMILLIONSô OFôUNBORNôABORTEDôBABIESô3EE ô3DDEUTSCHEô:EITUNGô ô*ANU ARYô ô.EEDLESSôTOôSAY ôOURôDEARô#ARDINALSôVIEWSôAREôVERYô PROVOCATIVE ôBUTôATôTHEôSAMEôTIME ôVERYôPOWERFULô(EôSHAPESô ANôAGENDAôBYôAPPEALINGôFORôACTION ôANDôYES ôSELF ORGANISATIONô môAGAINSTôSOMETHINGôANDôFORôSOMETHINGôELSEô

ô ô ô 4HESEôEXAMPLESôHIGHLIGHTôTHEôOPEN ENDEDôOUTCOMEôOFôPARTICI PATIONôWITHINôAôPUBLICôSPHEREôTHATôCREATESôTHEôSTATEôANDôSITU ATIONôOFôAôCIVILôSOCIETYô)TôHASôTOôBEôACKNOWLEDGEDôTHATôWHILEô THEôOPENôSITEôOFôCIVILôSOCIETYôCANôINDEEDôFUNCTIONôASôAôPLACEô FORôEMPOWERMENTôANDôENLIGHTENMENT ôITôCANôJUSTôASôWELLôBEô AôFRAMEWORKôFORôAUTHORITATIVEôOPINIONSôANDôESPECIALLYôFORôTHEô PRODUCTIONôOFôTHEôPROCESSESôOFôNORMALISATIONô 4HEôSERIOUSôPOINTôISôTHATôTHEôPUBLICôSPHEREôOUGHTôTOôBEôSEENôASô OPEN ôEASILYôUSABLEôANDôASôADAPTABLEôASôPOSSIBLEô4HISôOPEN NESSôDELIBERATELYôANDôNECESSARILYôRESULTSôINôTHEôLACKôOFôANôAô PRIORIôGUARANTEEôOFôTHEôQUALITYôOFôDISCOURSEôORôTHEôVALUESôOFôTHEô PARTICIPATINGôVOICESô/PENôSOCIETYôIS ôANDôHASôTOôBE ôINôITSELFô AôTYPICALôMYTHôLIKEô0ANDORASô"OXômôITôMUSTôBEôOPENED ôBUTôITSô POSSIBLEôSHORT COMINGSôMUSTôALSOôBEôRECOGNISEDô "UTôHOLDôON ôWHATôAREôTHESEôDANGERSô)NôONEôSENSE ôITôISôAôSO CALLEDôPSEUDO PROBLEMôTHATôONLYôTURNSôINTOôANôACTUALôONEôIFôANDô WHENôTHEREôISôAôLACKôOFôOPENôANDôTRANSPARENTôPOSITIONINGôANDô SITUATEDôOPINIONSôANDôKNOWLEDGEômôWHICHôUNFORTUNATELYôCANô OFTENôBEôTHEôCASEô)ôAMôREFERRINGôTOôLAZYôANDôCYNICALôRELATIVISMô


0240_057_self_org.indd 220-221

ORôEVENôMOREôCYNICALôIMPOTENCEôRESULTINGôFROMôTHEôINABILITYôTOô STATEôYOURôVIEWSôANDôMAKEôCLEARôWHATôYOUôSUPPORTôANDôSTANDô FOR ôWHATôYOUôOPPOSEôANDôWHYô7EôNEEDôARGUMENTS ôANDôREC OGNITIONôOFôOURôRESPONSIBILITYôFORôTHEôINPUTôOFôALTERNATIVEôCONTENTô TOôkLLôCONCEPTSôOFôSUCHôCENTRALôMATTERSôASôLOVE ôHATE ôGARDENINGô ANDôMARRIAGEôCOUNSELINGô 4HATôSAID ôLETôUSôGETôBACKôONôTHEôMAINôTRACKôANDôRETURNôTOôTHEô QUESTIONôOFôHOWôTOôACTIVATEôANDôEMPOWERôINDIVIDUALSôANDôCOL LECTIVESô/NCEôAGAIN ôWEôAREôTALKINGôABOUTôHOWôTOôPARTICIPATEô INôTHEôENDLESSLYôSPINNINGôCAROUSELôONôWHICHôTHEôCONTENTôOFô CONCEPTSôANDôACTSôAREôSHAPED ôMAINTAINEDôANDôRENEWEDô !NOTHERôWORDôFORôTHEôCAROUSELôISôAôDISCOURSEômôANôENTITYôTHATô FUNCTIONSôLIKEôANôUMBRELLAôUNDERôWHICHôWEôCANôANDôHAVEôTOôPAYô ATTENTIONôTOôRULES ôHABITS ôINTERPRETATIONS ôVALUES ôAIMS ôWISHES ô ANDôFEARSôRELATINGôTOôAôGIVENôSITEôANDôSITUATIONô!NDôWHENôWEô PAYôATTENTIONôTOôTHESEôINTER LINKEDôASPECTSôOFôTHEôDISCOURSE ôWEô AREôCONTINUOUSLYôSHAPINGôANôAGENDAôWITHINôTHATôGIVENôDISCOURSEô môANôAGENDAôABOUTôTHEôINHERENTôPRIORITIESôOFôTHEôSET UP ôANDô THUS ôABOUTôTHEôPOWERôTOôDEkNE ôWHICHôAGAINôCANNOTôANDôSHOULDô NOTôEVERôBEôDENIEDô0RIORITIESôAREôREQUIRED ôBUTôTHEYôCANNOTôBEô SOLIDôORôFULLYôSETTLED ôBUTôCONSTANTLYôDEBATEDôANDôREARRANGEDô 4HUS ôAôCIVILôSOCIETYôDEPENDSôONôTHEôDISCOURSEôTHATôEMERGESô ANDôGOESôONôWITHINôITSôFRAMEô)TôISôAôVERSIONôOFôCIVILôSOCIETYô THATôHASôTWOôCOREôCRITERIAôQUALITYôOFôDISCOURSEôANDôQUANTITYôOFô PARTICIPATIONôINôTHEôDISCOURSESô(ABERMAS ô4HESEôDISCOURSESô SETôUPôAôPLATFORM ôAôKINDôOFôNETWORKôOFôWIDELYôVARYINGôVOICESô ANDôCOMMUNITIESôWHICHôEACHôINôTHEIRôOWNôWAYôGETôTOGETHERô TOôDEBATEôANDôDEkNEôTHEôWAYSôINôWHICHôTHINGSôAREôORGANISEDô ANDôACHIEVEDô


25/09/06 17:41:19

.OWô)ôTHINKôWEôHAVEôREACHEDôAôPOINTôWHEREôWEôCANôCLAIMôTOô AGREEôUPONôTHEôDEkNITIONôOFôCIVILôSOCIETYôDESCRIBEDôABOVE ôANDô WEôCANôALSOôAGREEôTHATôITôISôANôENTITYôANDôAôPROCESSôCURRENTLYô VERYôMUCHôBOTHôMISSINGôANDôNEEDEDôINôOURôDAILYôREALITYô7HATô ISôLEFTôISôTOôWONDERôHOWôTOôACHIEVEôANDôCONSTRUCTôITô

#LASSICALôVERSIONôOFôCIVILôSOCIETYô 4HISôIDEAôISôBASEDôONôTHEôFOLLOWINGôAIMSô ô )TôISôACCESSIBLEôENOUGHôTOôALLôWHOôWANTôTOôPARTICIPATEôINôITô ô )TôISôCONDUCTEDôINôAôNON VIOLENTôANDôRATIONALôMANNERô

7HATôFOLLOWSôISôAôSTRATEGICôDISTINCTIONôBETWEENôTWOôPOSSIBLEô ROADSôTHATôCANôBEôFOLLOWEDôWHENôTRYINGôTOôARTICULATEôAôVERSIONôOFô HOWô)TôMUSTôBEôSTRESSEDôTHATôHEREôTHISôHOWôISôNOTôUNDERSTOODô INôTHEôSENSEôOFôURGINGôYOUôTOôDOôTHISôORôTHATôANDôNOTôTOôDOôTHISô ANDôTHAT ôBUTôASôAôHOWôOFôWHATôEXACTLYôAREôTHEôDRIVINGôFORCES ô MOTIVATIONS ôWORLDôVIEWSôANDôATTITUDESôBEHINDôANDôWITHINôYOURô ACTIVEôPARTICIPATIONô)NôOTHERôWORDS ôWHATô)ôAMôDESCRIBINGôHEREô ISôTHEôEXTENTôTOôWHICHôALLôOFôOURôPRESUPPOSITIONSôCOLORôANDôAFFECTô THEôOUTCOMEôOFôOURôACTSô 4HEôkRSTôMODELôISôTHEôCLASSICALôVERSIONôOFôAôLIBERALôCIVILôSOCIETY ô ANDôTHEôSECONDôMODELôCANôBEôSEENôASôAôCRITICALôDEVELOPMENTô OFôITô4HISôMEANSôTHATôBOTHôVERSIONSôSTILLôDEkNITELYôREQUIREôEACHô OTHERSôHELPô4HEYôAREôINôTHEôSAMEôGAME ôANDôEVENôIFôTHEYôAREô NOTôCOHERENTLYôPLAYINGôTOGETHER ôTHEYôAREôATôLEASTôUSUALLYôPLAY INGôTOWARDSôTHEôSAMEôGOALô"OTHôSTRATEGIESôANDôSETSôOFôATTI TUDESôAREôLOOKINGôFORôTHEôMEANSôTOôMOVEôAWAYôFROMôTHEôCULTUREô OFôCONSUMPTIONôTHATôISôCURRENTLYôTHEôDOMINANTôELEMENTôINôTHEô PUBLICôSPHERE ôTOWARDSôANôINTELLIGENT ôCONTENT DRIVENôSELF CRITI CAL ôTOLERANTôANDôWARMLYôIRONICôVERSIONôOFôAôTRULYôDISCURSIVEôANDô PLURALISTICôPUBLICôSPHEREô


0240_057_self_org.indd 222-223

ô )TôISôBASEDôONôPEER TO PEERôDIALOGUEô ô )TôISôBASEDôONôTHEôSUSPENSIONôOFôSTATUSôDURINGôTHEôARGUMENTô

7HATôTHISôALLôADDSôUPôTOôISôAôVERSIONôOFôCIVILôSOCIETYôTHATôISô STRONGLYôSHAPEDôTHROUGHôTHEôWISHôTOôACHIEVE ôATôTHEôENDôOFôTHEô PROCESS ôAôCONSENSUSôTHATôSERVESôASôTHEôLEGITIMATEô@TRUTHôOFôTHATô GIVENôDISCOURSEô4HISôSCHEMEôPRESUPPOSESôTHEôDESIRE ôWILLING NESSôANDôABILITYôOFôTHEôPARTICIPANTSôTOôTAKEôPARTôINôEQUALôENOUGHô WAYSôINôTHEôPROCESSESôOFôINTERSUBJECTIVEôARGUMENTATIONô)TôREFERSô TOôTHEôFAMOUSôIDEALôSPEECHôSITUATIONôCONSTRUCTEDôBYô*RGENô (ABERMASôINôHISô0HILOSOPHICALô$ISCOURSEôOFô-ODERNITY ôINôWHICHô RATIONALITYôMEANSôTHATôTHEôBESTôARGUMENTôWINSôONôTHEôMERITSôOFô ITSôARGUMENTATIVEôPOWERS ôANDôTHATôTHEôARGUMENTôCANNOTôBEô BASEDôONôPOSITION ôBACKGROUND ôRELIGION ôMONEY ôPOWERôETCô 4OôMAKEôTHEôPOINTôCLEAR ôTHISôSTANCEôISôVERYôCLOSEôTOôTHEôVAL UESôOFôTHEô%NLIGHTENMENTôTRUTH ôPROGRESS ôUNIVERSALôJUSTICE ô ôPERPETUALôPEACE ôSHAREDôHUMANôINTERESTSôANDôMUTUALôUNDER STANDINGômôAIMSôTHATôHARDLYôANYONEôCANôBEôAGAINSTôASôABSTRACTô NOTIONS ôBUTôAIMSôTHATôMATERIALISEDôTHROUGHôHISTORYôINôBRUTALô WAYSôTHATôHAVEôSERIOUSLYôTAINTEDômôSMELLINGôOFôREALPOLITIK ôBLOODô ANDôMONEYômôTHEIRôCREDIBILITYô


25/09/06 17:41:19

0IRATGRUPPENORG $ESCRIPTION g3HARINGôISô#ARINGu

ô 4EXT 0IRATGRUPPENôWASôFOUNDEDôINô3EPTEMBERôôINôSUPPORTôOFôTHOSEôWHOôCONTINUEôTOô FREELYôCOPYôANDôDISTRIBUTEôCULTUREôINôTHEôFACEôOFôTHEôPREVAILINGôCOPYRIGHTôLEGISLATIONô 4HEôPURPOSEôOFô0IRATGRUPPENôASôAôGROUPôISôTHEREFOREôNOTôTOôPROVIDEôORôENGAGEôINôTHEô FREEôSHARINGôOFôCULTURE ôASôTHEREôALREADYôEXISTSôAôMASS MOVEMENTôOFôMILLIONSôOFôPEOPLEô WHOôAREôACTIVELYôDOINGôTHISô/URôPURPOSEôISôTOôREPRESENTôTHEôVIEWôANDôINTERESTSôOFô kLE SHARERSôINôTHEôPUBLICôDEBATE ôDOMINATEDôBYôTHEôINTERESTSôOFôTHEôCULTURALôINDUSTRY ô ANDôWHEREôWEôAREôOFTENôPORTRAYEDôASôPARASITESôANDôCRIMINALôPIRATESô ô

&ORôAôLONGôTIMEôTHEô!NTIô0IRACYô'ROUP ôWHOôCONSISTôOF ôANDôREPRESENTôTHEôINTERESTSô

OFôTHEôINDUSTRY ôWEREôTHEôONLYôONESôHEARDôINôTHEôPUBLICôDEBATEô'UARDINGôTHEIRôPROkTô INTERESTS ôTHEYôAREôATTEMPTINGôTOôCRIMINALIZEôSHARING ôANDôPROHIBITôTHEôNEWôPOSSIBILI TIESôOFôDISTRIBUTINGôCULTUREôANDôKNOWLEDGEôTHATôTHEôDIGITALôREVOLUTIONôHASôGIVENôRISEô TOô4HEREôISôAôCONlICTôOVERôTHEôOWNERSHIPôANDôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôCULTUREôANDôKNOWLEDGEô ANDôWEôWANTôTOôMAKEôTHISôCONlICTôVISIBLE ô

(OWEVER ôOURôCONTRIBUTIONôTOôTHEôkLE SHARINGôMOVEMENTôISôNOTôJUSTôINôTHEôPOLITICALô

DEBATEô/NEôOFôOURôAIMSôISôTOôCONTINUOUSLYôDEVELOPôANDôSPREADôTHEôPRACTICEôOFôkLE SHARINGôTHROUGHôTECHNICALôSUPPORTôFORUMSôONôOURôWEBSITEôANDôBYôMAKINGôUSER GUIDESô TOôkLE SHARINGôPROGRAMSô!SôOURôMAINôAMBITIONôISôAôDEMOCRATIZATIONôOFôACCESSôTOô CULTUREôANDôKNOWLEDGE ôTECHNICALôSUPPORTôISôIMPORTANTôTOôENSUREôTHATôEVERYONEôCANô ACCESS ôANDôKEEPôUPôWITHôTHEôTECHNOLOGICALôDEVELOPMENT ô

4HEôCURRENTô#OPYRIGHTôLEGISLATIONôISôTHEôGREATESTôTHREATôTOôkLE SHARING ôASôTHEô!NTIô

0IRATEô'ROUPôHASôSENTôOUTôHUNDREDSôOFôLEGALôCLAIMSôTOôkLESHARERS ô4HEô$IGITALô,EGALô !IDôWASôFOUNDEDôINôORDERôTOôHELPôTHOSEôWHOôAREôSTUCKôINôTHEôLEGALôGREY ZONESôOFôTHEô INTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôSYSTEM$ENMARKôISôONEôOFôTHEôCOUNTRIESôTHATôHASôBEENôHITôTHEô HARDESTôBYôTHEôLEGALôCRUSADEôOFôTHEôCULTURALôINDUSTRY ôWITHôLEGALôCLAIMSôRUNNINGôUPôTOô ôEUROô3OôFARôTHEô$IGITALô,EGALô!IDô&OUNDATIONôHASôPAIDô ôEUROôTOôHELPô kLE SHARERSôWITHôCOURTôCASES ô

6IDENSDELINGNUô+NOWLEDGESHARINGôNOW ôISôANOTHERôPROJECTôTHATôWEôHAVEôINITIATEDô

INôWHICHôSTUDENTSôAREôENCOURAGEDôTOôDIGITIZEôANDôSHAREôTHEôEXPENSIVEôBOOKSôONôTHEIRô READINGôLISTSô)NôTHISôWAYôkLE SHARINGôBECOMESôAôWAYôFORôSTUDENTSôTOôCREATEôAôDIGITALô LIBRARYôRESOURCE ôCIRCUMVENTINGôTHEôCOSTSôANDôCONTROLôOFôLARGEôPUBLISHERSô3OôFAR ôTHEô CAMPAIGNôHASôRESULTEDôINôBOOKSôBEINGôSHAREDôONô4HEô0IRATEô"AYô4HEôPUBLISHINGô COMPANIESôHAVEôRESPONDEDôBYôJOININGôTHEôENTERTAINMENTôINDUSTRYôINôTHEIRôDESPERATEô HUNTôDOWNôOFôkLE SHARERS &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWPIRATGRUPPENORGôômôôWWWPIRATBYRANORGôômôôWWWBITTORRENTORG WWWVIDENSDELINGNUôômôôWWWPIRATPARTIETSETHE?PIRATE?PARTY

%XAMPLESôôYôô-FO>QDORMMBKLOD

0240_057_self_org.indd 224-225

25/09/06 17:41:20

!LTERNATIVEôVERSIONôBASEDôONô PLURALISTICôREALITIESô 4HISôISôBASEDôONôTHEôFOLLOWINGôAIMSô

(EREôTHEôCHARACTERISTICôVALUESôAREôCLOSEôTOôAôPARTICULARôCRITI CALôHERMENEUTICôVERSIONôOFôPOSTMODERNISMôINCOMMENSURABLEô LANGUAGEôGAMES ôNARRATIVEôDIFFERENDS ôCONlICTINGôIDEOLOGIES ô RIVALôCONCEPTSôOFôTRUTH ôJUSTICEôANDôPROGRESS ôALTERITY ôOTHERNESSô ANDôHETEROGENEITYô

ô +NOWLEDGEôISôPOWER ôANDôNOôKINDôOFôPOWERôISôNEUTRALô ôô !LLôKNOWLEDGEôISôPRODUCEDôANDôCONSTRUCTEDô ô !LLôKNOWLEDGEôISôMEANINGFULôONLYôASôSITUATEDôKNOWLEDGEôTHOUGHôô THEôTRANSPARENTôARTICULATIONôOFôITSôBACKGROUND ôHISTORY ôHIDDENôAGENDAô ANDôPOSSIBLEôUNWANTEDôCONSEQUENCESô ôô #IVILôSOCIETYôAIMSôINôNON VIOLENTôWAYSôTOôSHAPEôAôCOMMONôGROUNDôFORô ANôETHICALLYôSOUNDôANDôRESPECTFULôENCOUNTERô4HISôENCOUNTERôISôBASEDô ONôTOLERANCE ôCOMPASSION ôMUTUALôRESPECT ôRECIPROCALôRECOGNITION ôANDô SYMPATHETICôINSIGHTô

(OWEVER ôITôISôVERYôIMPORTANTôTOôDRAWôAôLINEôBETWEENôAôCYNICALô POSTMODERNISMôTHATôFALLSôDOWNôTHEôSTAIRSôOFôSELF NEGATINGôRELA TIVISMôANDôAôKINDôOFôPOSTMODERNISMôTHATôISôBASEDôONôPLURALITYô ANDôTOLERANCE ôTHATôISôONLYôPOSSIBLEôANDôACCOUNTABLEôIFôANDô WHENôITôISôTRANSPARENTLYôGROUNDEDôTOôAôPOSITIONômôTHEôNECESSITYô OFôTHEôSITUATEDôSELFô4HUS ôTHEôCHOICEôOFôTHISôWRITERôISôTHEôPLURAL ISTICôVERSION ôBUTôONLYôIFôANDôWHENôITôISôCONTEXTUALLYôGROUNDEDô 6AD¯Nôô(ANNULA ô

ôô /NEôPRESUPPOSITIONôFORôALLôKINDSôOFôENCOUNTERSôHASôTOôBEôAôPLURALITYôOFô VIEWSôANDôVALUESôTHATôLEADSôBYôNECESSITYôTOôCERTAINôMISUNDERSTANDINGSô THATôNEEDôTOôBEôNEGOTIATEDô ôô 4HEôAIMôISô./4ôANôOVER ARCHINGôCONSENSUS ôBUTôAôNEGOTIATEDôANDô AGREEDôCOMPROMISEôTHATôCANôBEôCHARACTERIZEDôASôREASONABLEôDISA GREEMENTô*OHNô2AWLS ôANDORôASôAôLOVINGôCONlICTô+ARLô*ASPERS ô ôô 0LURALISMôANDôACCEPTANCEôOFôINHERENTôMISUNDERSTANDINGôDOESôNOTô LEADôTOôAôPOLITICSôOFôANTAGONISM ôBUTôTOWARDSôTHEôPOLITICSôOFôAGONISMô #HANTALô-OUFFE ô ô )NSTEADôOFôAVOIDINGôTHEôUSEôOFôDIFkCULTôANDôCOMPLEXôSYMBOLS ôCONCEPTSô ANDôLOGOS ôWEôNEEDôTOôSTEALôTHEMôBACKôANDôPROVIDEôALTERNATIVEôDEkNI TIONSôOFôWORDSôSUCHôASôDEMOCRACY ôSELF ORGANISATION ôFUNôANDôFAILUREô 4HUS ôITôISôNOTôABOUTôTHEôACTôOFôGETTINGôRIDôOFôTHEôLOGO ôBUTôABOUTôTHEô ATTITUDEôOFôMAKINGôANDôSHAPINGôTHOSEôSYMBOLSôSOôTHEYôAREôBASEDôONô

4OôSUMôUPôTHISôPRELIMINARYôANDôUNFORTUNATELYôBRIEFôDESCRIPTIONôOFô THEôSHORTôSTORYôOFôTHEôFAMILYôTREEôOFôAôCONCEPTôOFôSELF ORGANISA TION ôITôHASôTOôBEôUNDERLINEDôTHATôTHEôCHOICEôPRESENTEDôABOVEô ISôNOTôBETWEENôLEFTôWINGôORôRIGHTôWINGôPOSITIONSôANDôPOLICIES ôITô ISôNOTôABOUTôANôEITHER ORôSCHEME ôBUTôABOUTôNUANCES ôSCALESô ANDôINTERPRETATIONSô)TôISôABOUTôSELF RElEXIVITYômôTHEôABILITYôTOô CONSTANTLYôQUESTIONôTHEôLITANYôOFôWHAT ôWHO ôWHYôETC ôWHILEô PARTICIPATINGôINôSHAPINGôTHEôCONTENTôOFôTHEôDISCOURSESôWITHINôAô CIVILôSOCIETYô4HISôIMPLIESôANôATTITUDEôTHATôALLOWSôTHEôBENEkTôOFô THEôDOUBTôWITHOUTôSUCCUMBINGôTOôITSôPRESSUREô7HATôWEôNEEDô ISôTHEôWILLINGNESSôANDôABILITYôTOôACCEPTôAôREASONABLEôLEVELôOFô UNCERTAINTYôINôTHEôPROCESSôINôORDERôTOôKEEPôTHEôSTORYôALIVEôANDô KICKINGô

YOURôVIEWS ôWANTSôANDôVALUESô4HUS ôINSTEADôOFôNOôLOGO ôWEôNEEDôMOREô PARTICULARôANDôWELLôARTICULATEDôLOGOSô


0240_057_self_org.indd 226-227

(OWEVER ôATôTHEôENDôOFôTHEôDAY ôTHINGSôAREôNOTôLOOKINGôTHATô GLOOMYô7EôTENDôTOôFORGETôTHATôWEôALREADYôDOôHAVEôSOME THINGôSPECIkCôTHATôHELPSôUSôALONGôTHEôROADô7EôHAVE ôINDEED ôô


25/09/06 17:41:20

AôDIRECTIONôFORôTHEôSTORYô7EôWANTôTOôSHAPEôAôCRITICAL ôACTIVEôANDô PLURALISTôVERSIONôOFôAôCIVILôSOCIETY ôAôSITEôANDôSITUATIONôOFôLOVINGô CONlICTôWHEREôWEôCANôFEELôFORôANDôFEELôWITHô7EôKNOWôWHATôWEô WANT ôBUTôWEôAREôNOTôSOôSUREôHOWôTOôGETôTHEREô7EôAREôUNCERTAINô THATôWHATôWEôTHINKôINôTHEORYôWOULDôINôFACTôFUNCTIONôINôPRACTICEô 7EôCANNOTôKNOWôFORôSUREôBEFOREôWEôTRYôITô)TôISôAôNEVER ENDINGô PROCESSôOFôSMALL ôTENTATIVEôANDôWOBBLINGôSTEPS ôAôSTORYôOFôTRIALSô ANDôERRORSôDURINGôWHICHôWEôJUSTôHAVEôTOôkNDômôFOLLOWINGôTHEôLATEô SOULôSINGERô#URTISô-AYkELD ôWHOôDEkNITELYôKNEWôWHATôHEôWASô TALKINGôABOUTômôENOUGHôHOPEôANDôCOURAGEôTOôKEEPôONôKEEPINGô ONô!NDôTOôDOôSOôDAYôIN ôDAYôOUTô #LOSINGôIN ôANDôRETURNINGôTOô!RISTOTLE ôITôISôAôPROCESSôDURINGô WHICHôWEôTRYôTOôAIMôATôAôMOVINGôTARGETôCALLEDôTHEôCONCEPTôOFôAô GOODôLIFEômôAôGOODôLIFEôTHATôISôSPENTôLOOKINGôFORôTHEôGOODôLIFEô!ô LIFEôASôAôSTORYôANDôAôJOURNEYôTHATôHASôTOôGETôITSôKICKSôANDôPLEAS URES ôITSôDESIRESôANDôDELUSIONS ôNOTôVIAôARRIVINGôSOMEWHERE ô BUTôWHILEôENJOYINGôTHEôLONGôANDôHARDôRIDEôTOWARDSôSOMETHINGô SOMEWHEREôOUTôTHEREô


0240_057_self_org.indd 228-229

!ôBRIEFôAFTERWORD 4HISôESSAYôDRAWSôONôANDôCOMMENTSôONôAôWIDEôRANGEôOFôSOURC ESôANDôAREASôOFôKNOWLEDGEôPRODUCTIONô-YôMAINôINlUENCES ôFORô GOODôORôWORSE ôHAVEôBEENôWRITERSôSUCHôASô!LASDAIRô-AC)NTYRE ô -ICHELô&OUCAULT ô*RGENô(ABERMASôANDô-ICHAELô(ARDTô4HISôTEXTô DEALSôWITHôAôHUGEôTHEMEôANDôAôDEBATEôTHATôHASôBOTHôAMAZINGLYô DEEPôROOTSôANDôLONGôCORRIDORSôFULLôOFôBOOKSôWRITTENôABOUTôITô -YôAIMôWASôNOTôTOôSAYôSOMETHINGôSIGNIkCANTLYôNEWô)NSTEAD ô THISôESSAYôSERVESôASôAôFOCUSSEDôANDôDELIBERATELYôCONDENSEDô ARTICULATIONôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôASôANôINVITATIONôTOôTHINKôWITHô )TôIS ôIFôANYTHING ôAôBEGINNINGôOFôAôBEGINNINGô.OTHINGôMORE ô NOTHINGôLESSô


25/09/06 17:41:21

,ITERATUREô *RGENô(ABERMAS ô3TRUKTURWANDELôDERô¿FFENTLICHKEIT ô3AMMLUNGô,UCHTERHANDôô *RGENô(ABERMAS ô4HEô0HILOSOPHICALô$ISCOURSEôOFô-ODERNITY ô4HEô-)4ô0RESSôô 4EREô6AD¯Nôô-IKAô(ANNULA ô2OCKôTHEô"OAT ô,OCALIZEDô%THICS ôTHEô3ITUATEDô3ELF ôANDô0ARTICULARISMô INô#ONTEMPORARYô!RT ô3ALONô6ERLAGôô !LASDAIRô-AC)NTYRE ô!FTERô6IRTUE ôAôSTUDYôINôMORALôTHEORY ô$UCKWORTHôô #HANTALô-OUFFE ô4HEô$EMOCRATICô0ARADOX ô6ERSOôô #HARLESô3PINOSAôô(UBERTô,ô$REYFUS ô4WOô+INDSôOFô!NTIESSENTIALISMôANDô4HEIRô#ONSEQUENCES ô #RITICALô)NQUIRYô ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 230-231


25/09/06 17:41:21

#OMMUNITIESô OFôTHEô 1UESTIONô ORô7HOô7ANTSô TOô+NOW ô

3USANô+ELLY

ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 232-233

*OHNô-OWITT ô*ULYôTH ô ôô4HISôWASôONEôOFôTHEôkNALôQUESTIONSôPOSEDôASôPARTôOFô 4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôOFôTHEô#ITYôOFô,EEDSwôANDô,UNCHôCONDUCTEDôBYô*ANNAô'RAHAMôANDô 3USANô+ELLYôINôCONJUNCTIONôWITHôTHEô5NIVERSITYôOFô,EEDSôWARPWOOFôCONFERENCEôONôAURALITYô ANDôTHEôVOICE

#OMMUNITIESôOFôTHEô1UESTIONôORô7HOô7ANTSôTOô+NOW

25/09/06 17:41:21

!ôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEô ôQUESTION ôOFôINITIATIVE ôô OFôABSOLUTEôINITIALITY ô BUTôALSOôAôTHREATENEDô ôCOMMUNITY ôINôWHICHô THEôDECISIONôHASôNOTôYETô FOUNDôTHEôLANGUAGEôITô HASôDECIDEDôTOôSPEAK ôISô NOTôYETôSUREôOFôITSôOWNô ôPOSSIBILITYôWITHINôTHEô ôCOMMUNITYô!ôCOMMUNITYô OFôTHEôQUESTIONôABOUTôô THEôPOSSIBILITYôOFôTHEô QUESTION $ERRIDAô


0240_057_self_org.indd 234-235

4HEôCONCEPTôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôSETSôINTOôMOTIONôSEVERALôCRUCIALô ANDôINSEPARABLEôQUESTIONSô7HATôISôTHEô@SELFôTHATôCONSTITUTESô ANDôSEEMINGLYôGENERATESôSELF ORGANISATIONô7HATôISôTHEôNATUREô OFôTHEôCOLLECTIVEôORôCOMMUNITYôPRODUCEDôINôTHISôWAYôANDôHOWô MIGHTôAôMODEôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôENCOUNTERôOTHERôFORMSôOFôOR GANISATIONô$OESôITôTAKEôANYôSPECIkCôFORMô4HISôESSAYôWILLôNEC ESSARILYôPROCEEDôFROMôTHEôLEVELôOFôTHEôMICROôBYôWORKINGôTHROUGHô TWOôRECENTôANDôONGOINGôPROJECTSôTHATô)ôHAVEôBEENôINVOLVEDôWITHô 7HATôISôTOôBEô$ONEô4HEô,ENINô-USEUM ô4AMPEREô&INLANDô 4HEô+RASNOYARSKô-USEUMô#ENTREôANDôOTHERôVENUES ôm ô ANDô4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWô4ORONTO ô.EWô9ORK ô$UBROVNIK ôANDô ,EEDS ô ô"OTHôPROJECTSôUSEDôSPECIkCôTOOLSôTOôGATHER ôAS SEMBLEôANDôCIRCULATEôQUESTIONSôANDôQUESTIONERS ôRESPONSESô ANDôRESPONDENTSô/RGANISINGôTHISôESSAYôAROUNDôTHESEôPROJECTSô WILLôSETôUPôAôFRAMEWORKôOFôCONCRETEôPRACTICESôTHROUGHôWHICHôTOô TRACEôWHATô)ôBELIEVEôAREôTHEôCENTRALôISSUESôATôSTAKEôINôTHEôCON CEPTôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONômôTHATôIS ôTHEôQUESTIONôOFôCOMMUNITYô ANDôPOTENTIALôFORMSôOFôPOLITICALôORGANISATION 4HEôRESPONSESôTOô7HATôISôTOôBEô$ONEôOSTENSIBLYôWORKôONôAô MACRO LEVEL ôSPEAKINGôTOôANDôQUESTIONINGôTHEôCURRENTôGLOBALô POLITICALôSITUATIONô-ANYôOFôTHEôRESPONSESôGRAPPLEôWITHôHOWôONEô MIGHTôGOôABOUTôEVENôADDRESSINGôTHEôQUESTION ôWHEREôONEôMIGHTô BEGINôTOôRESISTôANDôASKôHOWôUSEFULôCURRENTôORGANISATIONALôFORMSô ANDôPOLITICALôSTRUCTURESôAREôANYMOREô!LTHOUGHôTHESEôAREôLARGEô ANDôGRANDôQUESTIONS ôTHEôACTUALôPROCESSôOFôTHINKINGôABOUTôWHATô ISôTOôBEôDONEôANDôCONSTRUCTINGôAôRESPONSEôTOôAôPARTICULARôANDô SITUATEDôCALL ôUNDOESôAôCERTAINôDISTINCTIONôBETWEENôTHINKINGôANDô DOINGôOFTENôASCRIBEDôTOôTHEôVERYôQUESTIONô@WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEô 4RACINGôTHEôPROCESSESôOFôRESPONDINGôINôTHISôPROJECT ôINôPARALLELô WITHôTHEôRESPONSESôTHEMSELVES ôPOINTSôTOôTHEôNECESSITYôOFôAD DRESSINGôTHEôQUESTIONôOFôPOLITICALôORGANISATIONôNOTôONLYôTHROUGHô


25/09/06 17:41:21

2AGINGô'RANNIESô $ESCRIPTION 'RANNIESôSAYô7!4#(ô53ô2!'% 4EXT ,ETôUSôBEôCLEARôABOUTôTHEô'RANNIESô7EôAREôTOTALLYôNON VIOLENT ôBELIEVEôINôONLYôPEACEFULô PROTESTôWITHôLOTSôOFôLAUGHTER ôWORKôFORôTHEô@MANYôNOTôTHEôFEWôMOTTOôOFôTHEôOLDô-E CHANICSô)NSTITUTE ôANDôSEEôOURôWORKôASôTHEôSPREADINGôGREENôBRANCHESôOFôAôGREATôTREE ô RISINGôUPôTOôPROVIDEôSHELTERôANDôNOURISHMENTôFORôTHOSEôWHOôWILLôCOMEôAFTERôUS ô

'RANNIESôAREôBESTôEQUIPPEDôTOôMAKEôPUBLIC ôCORRUPTôTHINGSôTHATôHAVEôBEENôHID

DENôOFTENôFORôPROkT ô,OCALôTOXICôWASTEôSITESôTHATôNO ONEôSEEMSôPREPAREDôTOôTACKLE ô ASBESTOSôSITESôEMPLOYINGôYOUNGôPEOPLEôDESPERATEôFORôWORK ôNUCLEARôWASTEôPRODUCTSô BEINGôDUMPEDôOUTSIDEôANôUNINFORMEDôSMALLôTOWN ôLAWSôTHATôAFFECTôANôENTIREôCOM MUNITY ôPASSEDôQUICKLYôWITHôNOôOPPORTUNITYôFORôSTUDYô4HEôLISTôGOESôON ô

4HEôPITFALLSôINôGRANNYINGôCANôINCLUDEôACTINGôONôUNVERIkEDôINFORMATION ôCREDITINGô

RUMOURSôASôFACT ôIMPATIENCEôINôPUTTINGôFORWARDôANôAGENDA ôGETTINGôCAUGHTôUPôINôAô MOVEMENTôWITHOUTôUNDERSTANDINGôTHEôWHOLEôPICTURE ôBELIEVINGôCONSPIRACYôTHEORIESôô ô

4HEôDELIGHTSôOFôGRANNYINGôINCLUDEôô$RESSINGôLIKEôINNOCENTôLITTLEôOLDôLADIESôSOôWEô

CANôGETôCLOSEôTOôOURô@TARGET ôWRITINGôSONGSôFROMôOLDôFAVOURITESôTHATôSKEWERôMODERNô WRONGS ôSATIRIZINGôEVIL DOINGôINôPUBLICôANDôGETTINGôEVERYONEôSINGINGôABOUTôIT ôWATCHINGô AôWRONGôBACKôDOWNôANDôôTURNôTAILôANDôRUN ôSHARINGôAôHISTORYôWITHôOTHERôWOMENôWHOô KNOWôWHOôTHEYôAREôANDôWHATôTHEYREôABOUTô'RANNYINGôISôTHEôLEASTôUNDERSTOODôYETô MOSTôPOWERFULôWEAPONôWEôHAVEô3OMETIMES ôLOOKINGôBACK ôWEôCANôSEEôGRANNYINGô WASôTHEôONLYôTHINGôTHATôCOULDôHAVEôMETôTHEôNEED ô

&ROMôTHEôMOSTôANCIENTôTIMES ôTHEôSTRONG ôWISE ôOLDERôWOMENôWEREôTHEôONESôWHOô

ADVISED ôMEDIATEDôANDôFOUGHTôFORôWHATôWASôRIGHTô"ELIEFôINôTHEô$ISIRôORô$IVINEô'RAND MOTHERS ôTHEô-OTHERSôOFô4IME ôISôANCIENTôANDôRUNSôTHROUGHôALLôSOCIETIESôô ô

7HATôANôINHERITANCEô!NDôWHATôAôHISTORYôOFôTROUBLE RAISINGôWHENôNOTôLISTENEDôTOô%VENô

INôOURôTIMES ôWEôGRANNIESôHAVEôRAISEDôAôFEWôMOUNTAINS ôCAUSEDôAôFEWôlOODS ô

7HATôDOôYOUôNEEDôTOôBEôAôGRANNYô!ôSENSEôOFôHUMOURôANDôANôABILITYôBOTHôTHEôBEô

OBJECTIVEôANDôTOôCOMPROMISEôWHENôWORKINGôWITHôOTHERSôô7ILLINGNESSôTOôMAKEôNOISEô !NôOPENôHEARTôTOôLEARNôSOMETHINGôNEWô.OôSINGINGôABILITYô0ASSIONô*OYô$ELIGHTô.Oô COLOURôSENSE ôOBVIOUSLYô!ôFRIENDLYôDISPOSITIONô+INDNESSô3CIENTIkCôCURIOSITYôCANTô HURTô-AYBEôAôSENSEôOFôHISTORYôANDôOURôPLACEôINôITô4HEREôISôSOôMUCHôMOREôTOôBEôWRIT TENôONôBEINGôAGRANNYôBYôTHOSEôYETôTOôCOME 2OSEô$E3HAW ô+INGSTONô2AGINGô'RANNIES 3OURCEôô WWWGEOCITIESCOMRAGINGGRANNIESôôWWWRAGINGGRANNIESCOM &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWGEOCITIESCOMRAGINGGRANNIESôôWWWRAGINGGRANNIESCOM

0240_057_self_org.indd 236-237

%XAMPLESôôYôô/>DFKDñ$O>KKFBP

25/09/06 17:41:23

THEô@CONTENTôOFôTHEôRESPONSES ôBUTôALSOôTHROUGHôANôEXAMINATIONô OFôTHEôACTIVITYôBROUGHTôABOUTôBYôTHEôSTRUCTUREôOFôTHEôPROJECTô ITSELFô3TRUCTURESôOFôQUESTIONINGôANDôRESPONDINGôANDôHOWôTHEYô MIGHTôDE STABILISE ôOPENôOUTôANDôRE ORGANISEôSUBJECTIVITYôITSELFô ISôEXPLOREDôINôMUCHôMOREôDETAILôTHROUGHôTHEôRELAYôOFô4HEô/PENô )NTERVIEWô4HROUGHôAôCONVERSATIONôBETWEENôTHESEôTWOôPROJECTS ô THISôESSAYôCONTENDSôTHATôLARGERôQUESTIONSôOFôPOLITICALôORGANISA TIONôANDôCONCEPTSôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôCANNOTôBEôADDRESSEDô WITHOUTôANôEXAMINATIONôOFôTHEôNOTIONôOFôSUBJECTIVITYôATôWORKôINô COLLECTIVITYô4HISôESSAYôENDEAVOURSôTOôREWINDôTHEôDISCRETEôANDô DECISIVEôSUBJECTôWHOôMIGHTôKNOWôWHATôISôTOôBEôDONEôALONE ôINô ORDERôTOôDISASSEMBLEôANDôPOTENTIALLYôRE ORGANISEô@AôCOMMUNITYô OFôTHEôQUESTIONô

7HATôISôTOôBEô$ONEô 1UESTIONSôFORôTHEôSTô#ENTURY 7HATôISôTOôBEôDONEôISôTHEôQUESTIONôTHATôISôNOTôBEINGôASKEDôTODAYô7EôRE MEMBERô,ENINôBECAUSEôHISôREVOLUTIONôSUCCEEDEDô(OWôMANYôFAILEDô4HEô POTENTIALôCOSTôOFôNOTôASKINGô@WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEôISôAôPERIODôOFôBLOODYôANDô INEFFECTIVEôREBELLIONS ôSOMEôOFôTHEMôDEEPLYôREACTIONARYô.EITHERôISôINVOKINGô 3EATTLEôMUCHôHELPô4HEôPROTESTSôAGAINSTôOURôCURRENTôMODEôOFôGLOBALIZATIONô AREôAôSIGNôANDôAôSLOGAN ôBUTôNOTôANôORGANIZINGôPRINCIPLEô!NDôWAITINGôFORôAô -ESSIAHôWILLôONLYôWASTEôTIMEô7HATôWEôFACEôINSTEADôISôTHEôHARDôWORK ôTHEô COLLECTIVEôWORKôOFôTHEORIZINGôPOSSIBILITIESôTHATôAREôINHERENTôINôOURôCURRENTô CONJUNCTUREôANDôPOSSIBLEôWAYSôTOôPROCEEDô4HEôONLYôTHINGôWORSEôTHANô PICKINGôTHEôWRONGôMOMENTôWOULDôBEôMISSINGôTHEôRIGHTôONE ôANDôITôMAYô

0ROCEEDINGôFROMôAôNOTIONôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôDEMANDSôAôCER TAINôSHIFTôINôLOGICô)NôORDERôTOôMAINTAINôTHEôQUESTIONôTHROUGHOUTô THISôENQUIRYôITôISôkRSTôNECESSARYôTOôlIPôTHEô@QUESTIONôOFôCOM MUNITYôTOôAôMOREôIMMANENTôTRACINGôOFô@THEôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEô QUESTIONô&ORôIFôTHEôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEôQUESTIONôISôPREDICATEDô ONôUNSETTLINGôTHEôSUBJECTôANDôRECONkGURINGôTHEô@) YOU WEôOFô THEôINTERVIEW ôISôITôPOSSIBLEôTOôSEPARATEôAôSITUATIONôINôWHICHô THEôQUESTIONôISôNOTôALWAYSôALREADYôANSWEREDôFROMôTHEôMODEô ANDôSTRUCTURESôTHROUGHôWHICHôTHEôQUESTIONôISôMAINTAINEDô)Nô OTHERôWORDS ôBYôPROPOSINGôAôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEôQUESTION ôTHEô MAINTENANCEôOFôTHEôPOTENTIALITYôINHERENTôINôTHEôQUESTIONôCANNOTô BEôSEPARATEDôFROMôAôRE THINKINGôOFôORGANISATIONALôMODESôANDô STRUCTURESôTHROUGHôWHICHôTHEôQUESTIONôISôSUPPORTEDô$RAWINGô ONôTHEôWORKôOFô*EAN ,UCô.ANCY ôTHEôFOLLOWINGôPAGESôWILLôSTRUC TURALLYôANDôTHEORETICALLYôDOCUMENTôANDôTRACEôTHEôCOMMUNITYôOFô THEôQUESTIONôANDôRELATEDôISSUESôOFôTHOUGHT ôACTION ôORGANISATIONô ANDôPOTENTIALITYô

COMEôSOONERôTHANôWEôTHINKô .ICHOLASô"ROWNôANDô)MREô3ZEMAN 53!ôANDô#ANADA ô/CTOBERôTH ô 6OTEôALWAYSôTHEôCOALITION ô3WEDISHôNATIONALôPARTYôORôATôLEASTôTHEô'REENô 0ARTYô$OôNOTôLETô*³³TTEENM³KIôBEôTHEôPRIMEôMINISTERô !NôUNKNOWNôGREATNESS 4AMPERE ô&INLAND ô-ARCHô )ôMUSTôSAYôTHATôTHEôQUESTIONôHASôMEôTOTALLYôlUMMOXEDô)ôMEAN ôWHATô)3ô TOôBEôDONEô7HOôKNOWSô)ôSUREôDONT ôANDô)ôHAVEôENOUGHôLIFEôEXPERIENCEô TOôNOTôBEôSOôPRESUMPTUOUSôASôTOôTHINKôTHATô)ôDOô2EALLY ô)ôFEELôCOMPLETELYô HUMBLEDô)ôCANTôTHINKôOFôANôANSWERôTHATôDOESNTôSOUNDôREDUCTIONIST ôAR ROGANT ôINEPT ôGLIB ôSELF RIGHTEOUSôORôOTHERWISEôGROSSLYôINADEQUATE 0ATô-ANISCALCO .EWô9ORK ô4UE ô$ECEMBERôRD ô ôPM 4HEôANTI IMPERIALISTôPEOPLESôFRONTôMUSTôBEôACTIVATEDô!SôANôORGANIZATIONôITô


0240_057_self_org.indd 238-239


25/09/06 17:41:23

ALREADYôEXISTSôINô&INLANDôUNDERôTHEôTITLEô@-UUTOSVOIMATô3UOMIôRPô&ORCESôFORô #HANGEôINô&INLAND ô4HEô#OMMUNISTSôPARTICIPATEôINôTHISôORGANIZATIONô"YôALLô FORCESôWEôMUSTôSTRIVEôFORôUNITINGôTHEôCOMMUNISTôMOVEMENTôOFô&INLANDô (EIKKIô3IPIL³ (ELSINKI ôô&EBô 4OôME ô,ENINôHASôALWAYSôBEENôTHEôEXAMPLEôFORôMAKINGôREVOLUTION ôVAST ô CATACLYSMICôCHANGEôTHROUGHôFORCEôRATHERôTHANôBYôINCREMENTALôLEGALôRE FORMSô(ISôVIEWSôWILLôALWAYSôECHOôINôTHEôYOUNG ôTHEôDESPERATEôANDôINôTHEô MOSTôDEPRIVEDôPEOPLESôBECAUSEôTHEYôHAVEôTHEôLEASTôTOôLOSEôANDôTHEôMOSTô TOôGAINô)ôTHINKôMOREôPEOPLEôAREôWILLINGôTOôCHOOSEôVIOLENTôREVOLUTIONôTHESEô DAYSôBECAUSEôEVENTSôOFôTHEôLASTôFEWôDECADESôHAVEôPROVENôTHEôRICHôAREô GETTINGôRICHERôWITHOUTôANYôEFFECTIVEôRESTRAINTôONôTHEIRôACCUMULATIONô4HEô COLLAPSEôOFô%NRONôANDô7ORLD#OMôINôTHEô5NITEDô3TATES ôESPECIALLYôAFTERô THEYôRAPEDôTHEôPEOPLEôOFô#ALIFORNIAôANDô)NDIAôWITHôONE SIDEDôCONTRACTS ô PURCHASEDôWITHôPOLITICALôBRIBES ôSHOWSôMOREôCLEARLYôTHANôEVER ô#APITALISMô ISô/RGANIZEDô#RIMEô,ENINôANDô-ARXISTSôAREôBEINGôVINDICATEDôASôCORRECT ô DESPITEôTHEôANTI DEMOCRATICôTOôSAYôTHEôLEAST ôPRACTICESôOFô3TALINô0ERSON ALLY ô)ôAMôAôFANôOFôTHEôNON VIOLENT ôDEMOCRATICôREVOLUTIONôTHATôBROUGHTô ABOUTôAôNON RACIALôREPUBLICôINô3OUTHô!FRICAô !NNô3CHNEIDERô3AT 3EPTEMBERôTH ô ôPM ô"ROOKLYN ô.EWô9ORK ô53! 4HEôLOWESTôLIMITôOFôTAXABLEôINCOMEôISôTOôBEôLIFTEDôTOôôEUROSôPERôMONTHô !ôMINIMUMôWAGEôLAWôWOULDôGUARANTEEôATôLEASTôôEUROSôPERôMONTHô

7HATôKINDôOFôQUESTIONôISô@WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEô3OôOFTENôITôISô SEENôTOôMARKôTHEôMOMENTôWHENôTHOUGHTôISôOVERôANDôACTIONôMUSTô PROCEEDômôAôQUESTIONôTHATôPUNCTUATESôANDôkRMLYôSEPARATESôTHEô REALMôOFôTHOUGHTôFROMôTHEôREALMôOFôACTIONô)TôISôAôQUESTIONôTHATôISô SOôHUGE ôSOôIMPOSSIBLEôTOôEVENôCONTEMPLATEô)TôISôAôQUESTIONôONô EVERYONESôLIPS ôAôQUESTIONôPOSEDôTOôPHILOSOPHERSôANDôTHEORISTSô WHOôSEEMINGLYô@THINKôTOOôMUCHôANDôDOôLITTLEô4HISôQUESTIONôBE COMESôONEôTHATôEMBODIESôSOôMANYôOFôTHESEôKNOTSôOFôTHEORYôANDô PRACTICE ôOFôTHOUGHTôANDôACTIONôANDôTHEôWAYôTOôORGANISEôTHEIRôRE LATIONSHIPô4HEORIESôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôANDôSINGULARITY ôHOWEVER ô MAINTAINôAôDIFFERENTôLOGICôOFôTHOUGHT ACTIONô4HISôLOGICôDEEMSô INSEPARABLEôTHEôREASONSôWHYôONEôMIGHTôORGANISEôTHOUGHT ôANDô HOWôONEôMIGHTôGOôABOUTôORGANISINGôACTION ô%MBEDDEDôINôMANYô NOTIONSôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôISôAôCRITIQUEôOFôTHEôIDEAôTHATôTHEôWAYô ONEôKNOWSôWHATôITôISôRIGHTôTOôTHINKôANDôTHEREFOREôDO ôISôSEPARATEô FROMôTHEôSTRUCTURESôTHATôPRODUCEôQUESTIONSôANDô@KNOWINGôSUB JECTSô#ONSEQUENTLY ôAôNOTIONôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôPUSHESôAGAINSTô RATIONALôPOLITICALôPROGRAMMESôTHATôSEPARATEôPOLITICALôGOALSôANDô ISSUESôFROMôTHEôMOREôIMMANENTôPRACTICESôOFôCOMMUNITIESô4HISô ARCHIVEôOFôRESPONSESôTOôTHEôGRANDôQUESTIONôOFôWHATôISôTOôBEô DONE ôTHEN ôBECOMESôANôUNLIKELYôLOCUSôFORôAôSOMETIMESôIMPLICITô DISCUSSIONôOFôTHEôSUBJECTôANDôCOMMUNITY ôHOWôSUCHôSUBJECTSô WOULDôEVENôBEôABLEôTOôASKôTHEôQUESTIONô@WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEô INôAôMEANINGFULôWAY ôANDôWHEREôINôTHEIRôLIVESôSUCHôTHOUGHTSôANDô ACTIONSôCOULDôBEôARTICULATED

-OVEôTOôAôWORKINGôDAYôOFôôHOURSôWITHOUTôLOWERINGôTHEôINCOMEôLEVELô%VE RYBODYôMUSTôHAVEôTHEôRIGHTôTOôPROPERôANDôFAIRLYôPRICEDôLIVINGô3PECULATIONô

&IRSTôTHEôQUESTIONôSHOULDôMOVEôFROMôTHEôPASSIVEôTOôTHEôPOSITIVEô ôTOô@7HATô

ISôTOôBEôPREVENTEDôBYôRETURNINGôTOôRATIONINGôRENTSôANDôTHEôARAVA SYSTEMô

DOôWEôDOôEVENôTOô@7HATôAREôWEôDOINGô,ENINôCOULDôUSEôTHEôPASSIVEôFORM ô

4HESEôAREôSOMEôQUICKôTHOUGHTSôONôAô4HURSDAYôAFTERNOON ô&EBRUARYô ô

HEôCOULDôASSUMEôANôARMYôOFôFOLLOWERSôMOVINGôALONGôTHEôREASONABLYôWELLô

ôAôDEFENDERôOFôTHEôSMALLôMAN ô(ERKKUô(ERMESNIEMIôFORMô.OKIAôANDô

MAPPED OUTôROADôOFôSOCIALISMôô(AVINGôNEITHERôARMIESôNORôROADôNOWADAYS ô

AôTHOUGHTôINôHISôHEADô

THEôPASSIVEôQUESTIONôINDICATESôNOTHINGôMOREôTHANôARMCHAIRôTHEORISINGô

(ERKKUô(ERMESNIEMI

&ROMô7HEREô)ô3TANDô)ôSTANDôINôAôKITCHENôINôAôôMETREôRANGEôTHERESôATô

TH

-ARCHô ô.OKIA ô&INLAND


0240_057_self_org.indd 240-241


25/09/06 17:41:24

LEASTôAôHUNDREDôPEOPLEô ôINôTHEIRôKITCHENS ôSAUNAS ôLIVINGôROOMSô)ôKNOWô

#ONSTRUCTôALLIANCES ôNETWORKSôBETWEENôDIFFERENTôINDIVIDUALSôANDôGROUPSô

NEXT TO NONEôOFôTHEM ôTHEYôHARDLYôKNOWôEACHôOTHERô&ROMôWHEREô)ôSTANDôINô

WHO ôWHICHôAREôINTERESTEDôINôACTUALIZINGôOTHERôMODESôOFôLIFEôOUTSIDEôCAPI

&INLANDôMYôRELATIONSHIPôTOôTHEôGLOBALôSOUTHôISôNEXT TO NONEXISTENTô4HERESô

TALISTôNORMSô!TôTHEôSAMEôTIMEôENCOURAGEôDISSENT ôREFUSALôWHENôTHISôISô

NEXT TO NOôSOLIDARITY ôCOMMUNITY ôEVENôCOMMONôINTERESTô2EALLYôTHEôMAINô

STRATEGICALLYôAPPROPRIATEô4HIRDLY ôLOOKôCLOSELYôATôYOURôOWNôSUBJECTIVITYô

CONNECTIONô)ôHAVEôWITHôTHEôRESTôOFôTHEôWORLDôISôMEDIATEDôFROMôABOVE ôANDô

môHOWôISôITôBEINGôPRODUCEDô(OWôMIGHTôYOUôCREATIVELYôREMAKEôITô7HATô

ISôBASEDôONôTHEIRôEXPLOITATIONô.O ONESôEXPECTINGôOURô@LEADERSôTOôCHANGEô

CONSTITUTESôAôREVOLUTIONARYôSUBJECTô

THISô ôOURôELITESôTHATôPROkTôFROMôTHEôDIVISIONSôANDôEXPLOITATIONSôWEôHAVEô

3IMONô/3ULLIVAN

!NYôPOSITIVEôCHANGEôWILLôHAVEôTOôCOMEôFROMôBELOW ôFROMôUSô7EôHAVEô

ô.OVEMBERô ô ô,ONDON

TROUBLEôEVENôTOôANSWERôTHEôQUESTIONô ô7HOôAREô@7Eô!TôTHEôMOST ôWEREô ONLYôCAPABLEôOFôREACTINGôTOôTHEôCHANGESôIMPOSEDôFROMôOUTSIDE ôABOVEô ANDôRARELYôEVENôTHATô3OôWEôCANTôANSWERôTHEôQUESTIONô ô@WHATôDOôWEôDOô

ôCANTôEVENôDEALôWITHôITôINôANYôMEANINGFULôWAYôUNTILôWEôBUILDôTHESEôAXISô OFôCOMMUNITYôANDôOFôSOLIDARITYôFROMôOURSELVES ôTHROUGHôOURôLIVES ôCON COMITANTôWITHôOURôWORKô!ôLOTôOFôFOLKSôUNDERSTANDôTHIS ôITSôTHEôMOTIVATIONô BEHINDôAôLOTôOFôTHISôOTHERWISEôANNOYINGôPOLITICALôLIFESTYLISMô ôTHEôNEEDôWEô HAVEôTOôBUILDôAôCOMMUNITYô4HEôREASONôFORôTHEôMASSôINTERNATIONALôPROTESTSô ANDô)NDYMEDIASôANDôFAIRôTRADEôMOVEMENTSô ôCONNECTING ôOUTSIDEôTHEôELITESô "UILDINGôSTRUCTURESôINôWHICHôWEôCANôCOMMUNICATEôANDôASKôTHESEôQUES TIONSô ôNOTôJUSTôOFôMYSELFôORôYOURSELF ôBUTôTOôAôSOCIETYôOFôOTHERSô&ORôTHEô MOMENT ôWHATôWEôDOôISôTOôBUILDôTHESEôSTRUCTURESôANDôSTRUCTUREôOURSELVESô WITHINôTHEMôô"UILDôTHESEôRELATIONSHIPSôWITHINôOURôLIVESôSOôTHATôWELLôBEôABLEô TOôASKôTHISôQUESTIONôINôAôMEANINGFULôWAYô ô7HATSôTOôBEôDONEô $AVIDô,ANDY 4AMPERE ô&INLAND ôô-AYô wô"UTôBEFOREôWEôCANôRECONSIDERô/52ôDREAMS ôSHOULDNTô7%ôALSOôRECON SIDERôgWEuôANDôgUNIVERSALITYuôSOôTHATôTHEREôISôROOMôFORôOTHERôDREAMS ôOTHERô VISIONSô#ANôTHEREôBEôgWEuôWITHOUTôEXCLUSIONô)FôINôFACTôTHEREôISôAô,EFTôLEFT ô THEREôHASôTOôBEôDEBATEôABOUTôTHEôSHAREDôGROUNDS ôTHEôGROUNDSôFORôALLI ANCESôANDôDIFFERENCESô7HATôCANôANôALLIANCEôBEôORôLOOKôLIKEôTODAYô7HATô ISôTHEôPLACEôOFôALLIANCEôWITHINôAôPOLITICALôPLATFORM ôWHICHôINVITESôDIFFERENCEô ANDôDIVERSITYô(OWôCANôITôBEôMANAGED ôORCHESTRATED ôORôREALIZEDô

)Nô-AYô ôONEôHUNDREDôYEARSôAFTERôTHEôPUBLICATIONôOFôTHEô ORIGINALôBOOK ô3TEPHENô-ORTONôANDô)ôDISPATCHEDô,ENINSôQUES TION ô@7HATôISôTOôBEôDONEôFROMô4AMPERE ô&INLANDô4HEôQUESTIONô WASôFRAMEDôTHROUGHôAôSERIESôOFôSHORTôSTATEMENTSôTHATôREFERREDô TOôTHEôCURRENTôSTATEôOFôGLOBALôPOLITICS ôTHEôPOSSIBLEôRELEVANCEô OFô,ENINSôTHOUGHTôTOôQUESTIONSôOFôANTI IMPERIALISMôANDôORGANI SATIONALôSTRATEGIESôTODAYôANDôTOôTHEôSITEôOFôTHEô,ENINô-USEUMô ANDô,ENINSôHISTORYôINô&INLANDô4HROUGHôEMAILS ôLETTERS ôCONVER SATIONSôANDôMEETINGSôWEôGATHEREDôOVERôAôHUNDREDôRESPONSESô TOôTHEôQUESTION ôWHICHôWEREôTRANSFERREDôTOôYELLOWôTIMEôCARDSô ANDôDISPLAYEDôINôOLDôFACTORYôTIME CARDôHOLDERSôATôTHEô,ENINô -USEUMôINô4AMPEREô4HEôEXHIBITIONôLASTEDôTHREEôMONTHSôANDô DURINGôTHISôTIMEôANôAREAôWASôSETôUPôWHEREôMOREôRESPONSESô COULDôBEôWRITTENôANDôADDEDôTOôTHEôARCHIVEô)NôADDITION ôAôSERIESô OFôFOURôDOCUMENTARIESôPUTôTOGETHERôBYô&LORIANô3CHNEIDERôINô ôANDôCOLLECTIVELYôENTITLEDô7HATôISôTOôBEô$ONEô!ô7ORLDôTOô )NVENT WASôPLAYEDôCONTINUOUSLYô!NôEVENINGôSCREENINGôOFô/LIVERô 2ESSLERSô$ISOBEDIENTTIô ôWASôALSOôHELDôASôTHEôBASISôFORô AôWORKSHOPôANDôDISCUSSIONôOFôTHEôRESPONSESôANDôTHEôISSUESô ADDRESSEDôWITHINôBOTHôVIDEOSô!TôTHEôENDôOFôTHEôEXHIBITIONôINô 4AMPEREôTHEREôWEREôOVERôTWOôHUNDREDôRESPONSES ôMAINLYôFROMô %UROPE ô2USSIAôANDôTHEô!MERICAS ôINCLUDINGôMUSEUMôVISITORS ô ARTISTS ôACTIVISTS ôPOLITICIANS ôUNIONôREPRESENTATIVES ôPOLITICALô

2ENEô'ABRI .EWô9ORK ô*ANUARYô


0240_057_self_org.indd 242-243


25/09/06 17:41:24

Sô CIENTISTS ôPHILOSOPHERS ôFRIENDSôANDôALLôKINDSôOFôPEOPLEôUN KNOWNôTOôUSôWHOôOFTENôUSEDôTHEôEXHIBITIONôASôAôFORUMôTOôAR TICULATEôTHEIRôCONCERNSôABOUTôTHEôCURRENTô@WARôONôTERROR ôTHEô WARôINô)RAQôANDôWHATôMIGHTôBEôDONEôTOôINTERVENEô!TôTHEôTIMEôOFô WRITINGôTHISôPIECE ôTHEôARCHIVEôISôALREADYôTHREEôTIMESôTHEôSIZEôITô WASôATôTHEô,ENINô-USEUM ôASôITôCONTINUESôINôPUBLICôINSTITUTIONSô INô'ERMANY ô,ITHUANIAôANDô+RASNOYARSK ô3IBERIAô4HEôRESPONSESô HAVEôALSOôBEENôTHEôSUBJECTôOFôAôRECENTô@)NTERNATIONALô,UNCH4IMEô 3UMMITôORGANISEDôBYô"EAVERô'ROUPôINôTWENTY FOURôCITIESô AROUNDôTHEôWORLDô )NôWHATôISôTOôBEôDONE ô,ENINôPUTSôFORWARDôAôDEkNITION ôAôNEWôCONCEPTôOFô POLITICSô(EôWANTSôASôAôPOINTôOFôDEPARTUREôNOTôTHEô3TATEôOFô0OWER ôBUTôAô REVOLUTIONARYôCONSCIOUSNESSô4HEôPARTYôHASôTOôBEôTHEôRESULTôOFôTHEôOR

'ILLESô$ELEUZEôREMINDSôUSôTHATôRATHERôTHANôkRSTôCRITICISEôAôCON CEPTôWEôMUSTôLOOKôATôTHEôQUESTIONôFORôWHICHôITôMIGHTôBEôTRYINGô TOôPROVIDEôANôANSWERôORôAôUSEô!SôAôPROJECTôCONCERNEDôWITHô QUESTIONSôANDôANSWERS ôQUESTIONINGôANDôMAINTAININGôTHEôQUES TION ôWEôMUSTôTHENôASKôTOôWHATôQUESTIONôORôkELDôOFôQUESTIONSô MIGHTôTHEôCONCEPTôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôBEôTHEôANSWERô'IVENô THATôMANYôRESPONSESôINôTHEôARCHIVEôDEALTôWITHôFORMSôOFôPOLITICALô ORGANISATION ôONEôCOULDôEASILYôCONCLUDEôTHATôTHEôCONCEPTôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôMIGHTôINDEEDôBEôONEôOFôTHEôANSWERSôTOôTHEôQUESTIONô @WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEôBUTôTHISôTOOôMIGHTôSHORT CIRCUITôTHEôENQUIRYô 7HILEôKEEPINGôINôMINDôTHESEôLARGEôQUESTIONSôOFôFORMSôOFôPOLITICALô ORGANISATION ô)ôPROPOSEôTOôLINGERôONôTHEôQUESTIONôOFô@WHATôAREôWEô DOINGôAôLITTLEôLONGER ôRETAINôAôkDELITYôTOôTHEôEXCHANGESôGATHEREDô ANDôCONTINUEôTOôTRACEôTHISôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEôQUESTIONô

GANISATIONôOFôTHATôCONSCIOUSNESSô7EôHAVEôTOôLOOKôATô,ENINSôPATHô4HEô PARTYôFORMôISôNOWôIMPRACTICABLEô"UTôTHEôNECESSITYôOFôORGANISINGôAôPOLITICALô

)TôISôUSELESSôANDôCOUNTERPRODUCTIVEôTODAY ôINôMYôVIEW ôTOôFORCEôPOLITICALô

SUBJECTIVITYôOUTSIDEôANYôSUBMISSIONôTOôTHEôRULESôOFôTHEôSTATEôREMAINSô7Eô

STRUGGLESôINTOôTHEôTRADITIONALôTWOôPARTôCONCEPTUALôFRAMEWORK ôASôEITHERô

ESPECIALLYôMUSTôCOMPLETELYôCRITICISEôELECTORALôDEMOCRACYô7EôNEEDôTOôIN

DISTRIBUTEDôANDôSPONTANEOUS ôONôTHEôONEôHAND ôORôCENTRALIZEDôANDôORGAN

VENTôAôPOLITICSôWITHOUTôPARTIES ôWHICHôWOULDôBEôSUBMISSIVEôTOôTHEôDISCIPLINEô

IZED ôONôTHEôOTHERô4HISôVIEWôASSUMESôTHATôTHEôONLYôWAYôTOôORGANIZEôPOLITI

OFôCONCRETEôPOLITICALôPROCESSESô

CALôSTRUGGLESôISôUNDERôHIERARCHICALôLEADERSHIPô/NôTHEôCONTRARY ôTHEôMOSTô

!LAINô"ADIOU

INTERESTINGôPOLITICALôSTRUGGLESôEMERGINGôTODAY ôFROMôTHEô:APATISTASôTOôTHEô

0ARIS ô-ARCHô

MOVEMENTSôOFô3EATTLEôANDô'ENOVA ôAREôORGANIZEDôINôNEWôWAYS ôWAYSôTHATô CONSTANTLYôREFUSEôHIERARCHYôANDôLEADERSHIPô4HEôNETWORKôFORMôISôOFTENô

3O ôTHEôSTôCENTURYô,EFTôNEEDôHAVEôNOôIDENTITY ôNOôHEADôOFkCE ôLEADERSHIP ô

USEDôTOôTRYôTOôNAMEôTHISôNEWôORGANIZATIONALôSTRUCTUREôASôISôTHEôSLOGANôTHEô

ORôkXEDôTERRITORYô0ARTICIPANTSôNEEDôAGREEôONLYôONôAôMANNERôOFôCOLLEC

MOVEMENTôOFôMOVEMENTSô)NôORDERôTOôFOLLOWô,ENIN ôWEôMUSTôTHENôMOVEô

TIVEôDECISION MAKING ôWHICHôVALUESôBREADTHôOFôPARTICIPATIONôANDôISôBIASEDô

BEYONDô,ENINôANDôAPPLYôHISôORGANIZATIONALôGENIUSôTOôOURôOWNôREALITYô7Eô

TOWARDôOPERATINGôBYôCONSENT ôMINIMISINGôCOERCIONô3UCHôAôMODEôOFôCOL

MUSTôSPECIkCALLYôREALIZEôTHEôPOWERFULôFORMSôOFôPOLITICALôORGANIZATIONôTHATô

LECTIVEôDECISION MAKINGôENCOURAGESôSELF DEFENCE ôANDôTENDSôTOôBLOCKôTHEô

AREôEMERGINGôTODAYôANDôWORKôTOôFURTHERôTHEIRôSTRUGGLESô

FORMATIONôOFôCONVENTIONALôARMIESôANDôPOLICINGô)TôDISABUSESôTHEôGROUPôOFô

-ICHAELô(ARDT

ANYôASPIRATIONôTOôEXERCISEôPOWER ôWHETHERôOVERôAôTERRITORY ôAôPEOPLE ôORôANô

53! ô&EBRUARYôTH ô

EPOCHô:ONESôOFôTHISôKINDôAREôAôWAYôFORWARDô

ô

+ATHYô+ANG

/NEôSHOULDôHAVEôPATIENCEôTOôREADôMOREô,ENINôANDôTRYôTOôUNDERSTANDôHOWô

3YDNEY ô7ED ôô.OVô


0240_057_self_org.indd 244-245


25/09/06 17:41:24

HEôCANôBEôADAPTEDôTOôTHEôSITUATIONôTODAYô7HENôGLOBALôCAPITALISMôIMPE

INABILITYôTOôADDRESSôTHISôISSUEô4HEôFACTôISôTHATô3EATTLEôANDô'ENOAôDIDô

RIALISMôHASôMONOPOLIZEDôTHEôSITUATIONôTODAY ôOPPONENTSôSHOULDôkNDôNEWô

NOTôDEMONSTRATEôTHATôCAPITALISMôCANôBEôRESISTED ôONLYôTHATôITôCANôBEôPRO

FORMSôFORôCO OPERATION

TESTEDô2ESISTINGôCAPITALSôGLOBALôDRIVEôTOôSUBJECTôALLôSOCIALôRELATIONSôTOô

!IMOô-INKINNEN

THEôLOGICôOFôTHEôMARKET ôREQUIRESôTHATôWEôNEVERôLOOSEôSIGHTôOFôTHISôCENTRALô

4AMPERE ô&INLAND ôST ô

OFô,ENINSôOBSERVATIONSôWITHOUTôATTENTIONôTOôTHEôQUESTIONôOFôSTRATEGY ôNOô POLITICALôPROJECTôCANôSUCCEEDô7ITHOUTôANôUNDERSTANDINGôOFôTHEôNEEDôTOô

0ROCLAMATIONSôFROMôABOVEôWILLôPROVIDEôNOôANSWERSô2EVOLUTIONARIESôWORK

BUILDôPOPULARôCOALITIONSôWHICHôWILLôCHALLENGEôANDôMODIFYôTHEôIDENTITIESôOFô

INGôINSIDEôTHEôNEWôMOVEMENTôALONGSIDEôTHOUSANDSôOFôOTHERôACTIVISTS ôHOW

ALLôTHEIRôPARTICIPANTS ôRADICALISMôCANôONLYôBE ôINô,ENINSôFAMOUSôPHRASE ô

EVERôCANôPLAYôAôKEYôROLEô4HEôEFFECTIVEôORGANISATIONôOFôTHEôREVOLUTIONARYô

@ANôINFANTILEôDISORDERô

MINORITYôINSIDEôANDôAMONGôTHEôMOVEMENTôOFôTHEôMAJORITYôISôTHEôVERYôES

*EREMYô'ILBERT

SENCEôOFô,ENINISMô4HISôISôWHYô,ENINôINSISTEDôONôAôCLANDESTINEôPROFES

,ONDON ô&EBRUARYô

SIONALôORGANISATIONôINôôANDôONôTHEôOPENINGôUPôOFôTHEô"OLSHEVIKôPARTYô

4HEôGREATôWEAKNESSôOFôCONTEMPORARYôANTI CAPITALISMôISôITSôCONSTITUTIVEô

@0ERHAPS ôTHOUGH ôWEôKNOWôONEôTHINGôATôLEASTôg7HATôISôTOôBEô DONEuôMEANSôFORôUSôHOWôTOôMAKEôAôWORLDôFORôWHICHôALLôISôNOTô ALREADYôDONEôPLAYEDôOUT ôkNISHED ôENSHRINEDôINôAôDESTINY ôNORô STILLôENTIRELYôTOôDOôINôTHEôFUTUREôFORôALWAYSôFUTUREôTOMORROW ô .ANCYô ô&ORô.ANCY ôWHATôISôIMPORTANTôABOUTôASKINGô@WHATô ISôTOôBEôDONEôISôTHISôSENSEôOFôTHEôNOW ôTHEôSENSEôINôWHICHôTHEô SUBJECTSôPRESENT TENSEôANDôCONTINUOUSôINVENTIONôOFôAôWORLDôISô PRECISELYôNOTôAô@MEASURINGôOUTôOFôEQUALôAMOUNTSôOFôSUBMISSIONô ANDôREVOLTô.ANCYô ô)NVENTIONSôNEVERôHAVEôPRIORôMODELSôANDô SOôTHEIRôHORIZONSôCANôNEVERôBEôCONTAINEDôWITHINôWHATôALREADYô EXISTSô!NôINHERENTôSENSEôOFôPOTENTIALITYôISôTHEREFOREôCONTAINEDô WITHINôTHEôQUESTION ôANDôTHEôEXPERIENCEôOFôTRYINGôTOôANSWERôTHATô QUESTIONôFORôMANYôBECOMESôAôSOMETIMESôFRUSTRATINGôANDôANXI ETY MAKINGôWRESTLINGôMATCHôWITHôTHATôVERYôHORIZONô#OVERINGôTHEô WALLSôOFôTHEô,ENINô-USEUMôANDôTHEôTEMPORARYôSTUDYôWITHINôTHEô +RASNOYARSKô-USEUMôISôEVIDENCEôOFôTHOSEôWRESTLINGôMATCHES ô MUSINGSôANDôINSCRIPTIONSôOFôAôPARTICULARôPOTENTIALITYô(EREôISôAô PARTIALôARCHIVEôOFôFUTURITY ôOFôTHOUGHTôABOUTôAôFUTUREôINôWHICHô THEôQUESTIONôISôNOTôALWAYSôALREADYôANSWEREDô)F ôASô!GAMBENô SAYS ôTHEôPOTENTIALôCHARACTERôOFôTHOUGHTôRENDERSôITSôEXPERIENCEô


ONLYôôYEARSôLATERô4HEôREVOLUTIONôOFôôCHANGEDôTHEôCONDITIONSôRADI CALLYôANDôSOCIALISTôORGANISATIONôHADôTOôCHANGEôACCORDINGLYô/NLYôTHROUGHô THEôCONSCIOUSôORGANISATIONôOFôREVOLUTIONARIES ôAGITATINGôANDôARGUINGôANDô kGHTINGôWITHINôTHEôCLASSôANDôTHEôWIDERôSOCIALôMOVEMENTSôCANôWEôHOPEôTOô AVOIDôFURTHERôDEFEATôANDôREALISEôWHATô-ARXôHIMSELFôTERMED ôTHEôBEGINNINGô OFôREALôHUMANôHISTORY 4IMô2OBINSON /SLO ôô&EBRUARYô 2EMEMBERôTHATô,ENINôSAIDô!UTHORITYôPOISONSôEVERYBODY ôWHOôTAKESôAU THORITYôONôHIMSELFô$EMOCRACYôISôBUTôONEôFORMôOFôSTATE ôANDôWEô-ARXISTSô AREôOPPOSEDôTOôALLôANDôEVERYôKINDôOFôSTATEô3OôLONGôASôTHEôSTATEôEXISTSô THEREôISôNOôFREEDOMô7HENôTHEREôISôFREEDOM ôTHEREôWILLôBEôNOôSTATEô 2ICHARDô'ô"UNKER ô*R 53!ô7ED ô/CTôRD ô ôPM 4HEôRIGHTôWAYôTOôINTERPRETôTHISôQUESTIONôOFô,ENINôISôTOôSEEôITôASôPOSINGô THEôQUESTIONôWHICHôISôINôFACTôTHEôCONSTITUTIVEôQUESTIONôOFôPOLITICSôITSELFô THEôQUESTIONôOFôSTRATEGYô(OWôDOôWEôGOôABOUTôGETTINGôWHATôWEôWANTô


0240_057_self_org.indd 246-247

25/09/06 17:41:24

ALWAYSôANôEXPERIENCEôOFôAôCOMMONôPOWER ôTHENôWHATôMIGHTôTHEô NATUREôOFôTHATôCOMMONALITYôBEô!GAMBENô ô"OTHô"ROWNôANDô 3ZEMAN ôANDô.ANCYôWARNôOFôTHEôFUTILITYôOFôALWAYSôREFERRINGôTOô AôTOMORROWôORôOFôONLYôWAITINGôFORôAô-ESSIAHô4HEôSENSEôOFôPO TENTIALITYôCANNOTôTHEN ôBEôSOLELYôTEMPORAL ôBUTôMUSTôALSOôBEôANô IMMANENTôINSCRIPTIONôOFôANôOPENôANDôUNkNISHEDôCOMMUNITYô

ITôHASôCREATEDô)NFALLIBLEô4HEREFOREôWEôMUSTôCREATEôTHEôBASISôFORôAôNEWô WORLDôORDERô-OSTôOFôALLôWEôMUSTôBREAKôTHEôWESTERNôWAYôOFôTHINKINGô@)ô HAVEôRIGHTSô %LINAô+ESKITALO /ULU ô&INLAND ô4UESDAY ôô&EBRUARYô ô 4HEREôISôNOôINEVITABILITYôASôLONGôASôTHEREôISôAôWILLINGNESSôTOôCONTEMPLATEô

'LOBALôCAPITALISMôISôMADEôPOSSIBLEôBYôUNION BUSTERSôOFôMANYôSTRIPESô/URô

WHATôISôHAPPENINGô

LABORôUNIONSôAREôBUSTED ôCERTAINLY ôBUTôSOôAREôOURôCIVICôUNIONS ôOURôSOCIALô

$ONô-C'REGOR

UNIONS ôEVENôOURôFAMILIALôUNIONSôAREôBURSTôASUNDER ôERODEDôBYôTHEôCOLD ô

-ONTREALô#ANADA ô*ANUARYôST ô

RUSHINGôCURRENTSôOFôCAPITALô7EôAREôNOTôWORKERS ôMEMBERSôOFôCOMMUNITIES ô

REALITIESôOFôCAPITALISMô#APITALISMôISôINôTHEôPOSITIONôOFô'ODôINôTHEôWORLDô

)F ôASôSPECULATEDôEARLIER ôNOTIONSôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôIMPLYôTHATô HOWôONEôMIGHTôKNOWôWHATôITôISôRIGHTôTOôTHINK ôCANNOTôBEôSEPA RATEDôFROMôTHEôSTRUCTURESôFROMôWHICHôTHEôQUESTIONS ôISSUESôANDô ACTIONSôEMANATE ôAôSINGULARôUNkNISHEDôNOTIONôOFôTHEôSUBJECTô EMERGESôINôPLACEôOFôTHEôFULLYôPRE CONSTITUTEDôINDIVIDUALô3INGU LARITYôINôTHISôSENSEôREFERSôTOôAôCONCEPTôOFôBEINGôTHATôISôALWAYSô MANY ôYETôINCOMPLETEôANDôCANôCOMMUNICATE ôSHARE ôLINKôTOGETH ERôANDôORGANISEôTHROUGHôAôDIFFERENTôSETôOFôCONSTELLATIONSô4HINK INGôABOUTô@WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEôORôUNDERSTANDINGôTHEôWORLDôISô THEREFOREôNOTôAôRATIONALISED ôSEPARATEôACTIVITYôCARRIEDôOUTôBYô AôDISCRETEôINDIVIDUAL ôBUTôMOREôOFôANôEMBEDDEDôPROCESSôOFô THOUGHTôANDôCOMMUNICATIONô)NôLINEôWITHôTHEôSHIFTôFROMôTHINKINGô @WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEôTOôAôTRACINGôOFô@WHATôDOôWEôDOô.ANCYô CONSIDERSôHOWôWEôMIGHTô@ACTôINôSUCHôAôWAYôTHATôTHISôWORLDôISô AôWORLDôABLEôTOôOPENôITSELFôUPôTOôITSôOWNôUNCERTAINTYôASôSUCHô .ANCYô ô4HEô@SELFôTHATôACTS ôTHATôGENERATESôSELF ORGANISA TIONôANDôISôITSELFôORGANISED ôMUSTôBEôAôSINGULARôSUBJECTômôONEô CAPABLEôOFôMAINTAININGôAôQUESTIONôWITHOUTôHORIZON ôCAPABLEôOFô COMMUNICATION ôOFôCOMMUNITYôALONGôDIFFERENTôLINESôOFôBOTHôFRAC TUREôANDôALLIANCEô)SôTHISôANôOPENINGôINTOô"ADIOUôORô/3ULLIVANSô POLITICAL ôSUBJECTIVITYô


FRIENDSôORôFAMILY WEôAREôBUTôSOôMANYôVENTUREôCAPITALISTSôDEPRIVEDôOFôFUNDSô )TôISôIMPOSSIBLEôTOôBUILDôUNITYôWITHôTHEôTOOLSôOFôCAPITALô)TôISôIMPOSSIBLEôTOô BUILDôAôCOMMUNITY ôAôFRIENDSHIP ôAôFAMILYôWITHINôITSôCONkNESô)TôISôIMPOS SIBLEôTOôSEEôWORKôEXCEPTôINôTERMSôOFôPROkTô9ETôTHISôISôPRECISELYôWHATôISôTOô BEôDONEô/URôCOMMUNITYôHASôBEENôTAKENôFROMôUSôBECAUSEôITôISôOURôMOSTô DANGEROUSôWEAPONô4HEôOVERWHELMINGôBEAUTYôOFô3EATTLEôORô'ENOAôISôTHEô RECOGNITIONôOFôTHEôSTRENGTHôOFôTHESEôBONDS ôEVENôAFTERôSOôMANYôYEARSôOFô ASSAULTô7HENô,ENINôASKED ô@7HATôISôTOôBEôDONE ôHISôANSWERôWASôPREDICT ABLEô@EVERYTHINGô.OWôWEôMUSTôASK ô@WHEREôDOôCOMMUNITIESôFORMô4HEô ANSWERôISô@EVERYWHEREô#APITALISMôHASôGIVENôUSôTHEôTOOLSôTOôFORMôMOREô INTIMATEôANDôACTIVEôCOMMUNITIES ôBUTôWEôMUSTôTAKEôUPôTHOSEôTOOLS ôANDô USEôTHEMôASôWEAPONSô%ACHôONEôOFôUSôMUSTôHOLDôONôTOôHERôNEIGHBORôWITHô ONEôHANDôANDôCAPITALSôTHROATôWITHôTHEôOTHERô@.OTôINôMYôTOWNôWILLôBECOMEô @NOTôINôMYôREGION ô@NOTôINôMYôCOUNTRY ô@NOTôINôMYôWORLDô)TôISôIMPOSSIBLE ô YES BUTôONLYôWHENôWEôUSEôCAPITALISMSôDEkNITIONôOFô@POSSIBLE 3AMUELô"UTLER .ORTHAMPTON ô-ASSACHUSETTS ô53!ô!GEô ô g7HITEô!MERICANôINTELLECTUALôWITHôAGRARIANôROOTSu #APITALISMôISôHOLYôTOôTHEôCAPITALISTSôSOôITôCANNOTôBEôDISMISSEDôBYôTHEô


0240_057_self_org.indd 248-249

25/09/06 17:41:25

2ECLAIMôTHEô3TREETS $ESCRIPTION $IRECTôACTIONôINôPUBLICôSPACE 4EXT 2ECLAIMôTHEô3TREETSô243 ôISôAôGROUPôOFôPEOPLEôWITHôAôCOLLECTIVEôIDEALôOFôCOMMUNITYô OWNERSHIPôOFôPUBLICôSPACESô)TôHASôBEENôCHARACTERISEDôASôAôRESISTANCEôMOVEMENTôTOô THEôCORPORATEôFORCESôOFôGLOBALISATION ôAND ôMOREôSIGNIkCANTLY ôASôAôFORMôOFôOPPOSITIONô TOôTHEôCARôASôTHEôDOMINANTôMODEôOFôTRANSPORT ô

2ECLAIMôTHEô3TREETSôOFTENôSTAGEôNON VIOLENTôDIRECTôACTIONôSTREETôRECLAIMINGôEVENTSô

SUCHôASôTHEô@INVASIONôOFôAôMAJORôROAD ôHIGHWAYôORôFREEWAYôTOôSTAGEôAôPARTYô7HILEôTHISô MAYôOBSTRUCTôTHEôREGULARôUSERSôOFôTHESEôSPACESôSUCHôASôCARôDRIVERSôANDôPUBLICôBUSô RIDERS ôTHEôPHILOSOPHYôOFô2ECLAIMôTHEô3TREETSôISôTHATôITôISôVEHICLEôTRAFkC ôNOTôPEDES TRIANSôWHOôAREôCAUSINGôTHEôOBSTRUCTION ôANDôTHATôBYôOCCUPYINGôTHEôROADôTHEYôAREôINô FACTôOPENINGôUPôPUBLICôSPACEô243ôEVENTSôAREôUSUALLYôSPECTACULARôANDôCOLOURFUL ôWITHô DANCING ôSANDôPITSôFORôKIDSôTOôPLAYôIN ôFREEôFOODôANDôMUSICô!LLôTHESEôALLOWôAô4EMPORARYô !UTONOMOUSô:ONEô4HEôSTYLEôOFôTHEôPARTIESôINôMANYôPLACESôHASôBEENôINlUENCEDôBYô THEôRAVEôSCENEôINôTHEô5+ ô

2ECLAIMôTHEô3TREETSôEVENTSôHAVEôALSOôBEENôKNOWNôTOôBEôFOLLOWEDôBYôTHEôSUBSE

QUENTôARRIVALôANDôCONFUSIONôOFôPOLICEôOFkCERSôANDôDRIVERSô3OMETIMESôTHEôPARTIESô PRODUCEôENOUGHôNOISEôTOôDROWNôOUTôTHEôSOUNDôOFôTHEôJACKHAMMERSôWHICHôHAVEôBEENô USEDôTOôDIGôUPôSECTIONSôOFôROADS ôANDôPLANTôOVERôTHEMôWITHôSOD ô

2ECLAIMôTHEô3TREETSôISôALSOôUSEDôTOôDENOTEôSUCHôTYPESôOFôPOLITICALôACTION ôREGARD

LESSôOFôTHEIRôACTUALôRELATIONôTOôTHEô243ôMOVEMENT 3OURCEô WWWENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI2ECLAIM?THE?STREETS &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWCRITICAL MASSORG WWWAFRIBIKEORG )MAGEôSOURCEô WWWRTSGNAPCORG

%XAMPLESôôYôô/B@I>FJñQEBñ0QOBBQP

0240_057_self_org.indd 250-251

25/09/06 17:41:27

2ESISTôANDôNEVERôSUBMITô+EEPôFAITHôANDôARGUEôFORôTHEôSUPERIORôMORALITYô

/NôAôGLOBALôLEVELôITSôHARDôTOôIMAGINEôCHANGINGôTHINGS ôONôAôLOCALôLEVELô

ANDôHUMANITYôOFôCOMMUNISMô)TôISôNOTôTHEôENDôOFôHISTORYô-Rô&UKUYAMAô

ITSôHARDôTOôCHANGEôTHINGS ôWHATôCANôBEôDONEôISôBASEDôONôWHATôCANô)ôDOô

4IOCFAIDHô¶Rô,¶ô

7HATôCANôWEôDOô%XPOSEôHYPOCRACY ôQUESTIONôMORALôINADEQUACIES ôALLOWô

$¶ITHIô-

TRUTHôTOôBEôVISIBLEô+EEPôYOURôOWNôCOUNCIL ôBUILDôASôBESTôASôYOUôCAN ôKEEPô

)RELAND ôô&EBRUARYô ô

FEMINISTôANDôECOLOGICAL ôTECHNOLOGICAL ôDEVELOPED ôALIVEôANDôPROGRESSIVEô )TôLIESôINôTHEôDETAILSôOFôOURôEXPRESSIONSôANDôLOVEôFORôOURSELVESôINôRELATIONô

(OWôDOôWEôRESISTôTHEôPOSSIBILITYôTHATôGROUPSôNOTôCENTRALôTOôGLOBALôANDôNA

TOôTHEôWORLDô

TIONALôPOWERôWILLôBEôIGNOREDôUNLESSôTHEYôBECOMEôTHEôSAMEô4HESEôPEOPLEô

3ALLYô#HAPMAN

MAYôNOTôBEôHEARDôATôALL ôORôTHEYôMAYôONLYôBEôHEARDôIFôTHEYôSPEAKôINôAôWAYô

'LASGOW ô-ON ôô$ECô ô

THEôPOWERFULôSPEAKôANDôLOSEôTHEIRôSITUATEDNESS ôLOSEôWHATôTHEYôWANTôTOô SAYôEMBEDDEDôINôHOWôTHEYôSPEAKô(OWôDOôWEôRECOGNISEôTHATôDIFFERENCEô ISôSOMETHINGôWEôMAKEôNOTôSOMETHINGôTHATôEXISTSôIMMUTABLYôWITHOUTôOURô PRESENCEôANDôACTIVITYô7HATôISôTOôBEôDONEô(OWôCANôWEôDEVELOPôDIFFER ENTôPUBLICôSPACESôWHEREôPEOPLEôFROMôORôINôDIVERSEôGROUPSôCANôSPEAKôANDô BEôHEARDôBYôTHEMSELVESôANDôBYôOTHERSô&INDINGôOUTôQUESTIONSôISôPARTôOFô THEôANSWER ôSO môGOôHAVEôAôCUPôOFôTEAôWITHôAôFRIEND môGOôHAVEôAôCUPôOFôTEAôWITHôSOMEONEôYOUôDONTôUNDERSTAND môGOôHAVEôAôCUPôOFôTEAôWITHôANôENEMY

(UNTERôANDô,ANDYôSPEAKôOFôBUILDINGôPUBLICôSPACESôANDôSTRUC TURESôINôWHICHôTOôSTRUCTUREôONESELFôANDôWITHINôWHICHôDIFFER ENTôKINDSôOFôSUBJECTIVITIESôANDôCOMMUNITIESôCANôBEôDEVELOPEDô THROUGHôLISTENINGôANDôCOMMUNICATIONô(ERE ô)ôWILLôCONTINUEôTOô CALLôTHISôAôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEôQUESTION ôAôSPACINGôOFôSINGULARI TIESôTHATôMAINTAINôTHEôPOSSIBILITYôOFôASKINGôNOTôONLYôTHEôQUESTIONô @WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEôBUTôOFôMAINTAININGôTHEôIMMANENTôPOTENTI ALITYôOFôTHEôQUESTIONôITSELFô

,YNETTEô(UNTER ,EEDS ô5+ ô $ESTROYôTHEôSILENCEô"EôREADYôTOôSTANDôUPôFORôYOURSELFôANDôOTHERôPEO PLEôDESPITEôTHEôOVERWHELMINGôRESISTANCEôYOUôWILLôFACEô!LLOWôYOURSELFôTOô CHANGEô4RYô .INNIô3ANDELIUS 4AMPERE ô&INLAND ôô-ARCHô ô 4RULYôITôSEEMSôTHATôTHEREôISôONLYôONEôTHING ôNOôMATTERôHOWôTHOROUGHLYô #HRISTIANôTHISôSOUNDSô0EOPLEôSHOULDôBECOMEôLESSôSELkSH !NNINA 4AMPERE ô&INLAND ôô!PRIL ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 252-253


25/09/06 17:41:27

4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWwôANDô,UNCH 1UESTIONôFROMô3USANô 1UESTIONôTOô,AURA ô 7HYôDOôYOUôTHINKôYOUôTALKôTOOôMUCH ôWHYôISôTHATôAôBADôTHING !NSWERôFROMô,AURA ô "ECAUSE ô)ôTHINKôYOUôCANôLEARNôMOREôFROMôLISTENINGô-OSTô TIMESô)ôTHINKôMYôSTORYôISôMOREôINTERESTINGôTHANôTHEIRSôANDô)ô CANTôWAITôFORôTHEMôTOôSHUTôUPô)TSôAôBADôTHING ô)MôTRYINGôTOô GETôAWAYôFROMôITô)MôLIVINGôWITHôTHISôGUYôCALLEDô0AULôWHOSô QUITEôPHILOSOPHICALô(ESôDOINGôAô-ASTERSôINô,ANDSCAPEô!R CHITECTUREôANDôBEENôTOôALLôTHESEôSELF DEVELOPMENTôGROUPSô !NDôHESôLEARNEDôSOôMUCHô(EôSITSôANDôLISTENSôCONTENTLYô ANDôHESôSUCHôAôPROBLEMôSOLVER ôHELLôSITôANDôLISTENôTOôYOURô PROBLEMôANDôHELLôHAVEôANôANSWERôFORôITô(ELLôLOOKôATôITôFROMô AôDIFFERENTôPERSPECTIVE ôSOô)ôWANTôTOôGETôBETTERôATôLISTENING ô DEkNITELYô 1UESTIONôFROMô3USANô 1UESTIONôTOô,AURA ô "UTôDOôYOUôTHINKôSOMETIMESôTHATôMAYBEôYOUôJUSTôHAVEôAôLOTô TOôSAY !NSWERôFROMô,AURA ô 9EAH ô)ôDO ôYEAHô"UTôISôITôRELEVANTô)ôMEANôYOUVEôGOTôTOôSI PHONôOUTôTHEôGOODôSHITôFROMôTHEôBADôSHITô)TSôSELF DISCIPLINEô )ôHAVEôAôLOTôOFôSELF DISCIPLINEôINôSOMEôAREASôOFôMYôLIFE ôBUTôINô OTHERSô)MôABSOLUTELYôSHITô,IKEôREALLY ôREALLYôCRAPô,IKEô)ôHAVEô TOôLEARNôTOôHOLDôBACKô.O ôYOUôDONTôHAVEôTOôGIVEôôTOô PEOPLEôWHENôYOUôkRSTôMEETôTHEMôANDôLETôTHEMôGETôTOôKNOWô YOUôINSTEADôOFôGOING ôTHISôISôME ôTHISôISôME ô)ôWANTôYOUôTOô LIKEôME ôLOVEôME ôLOVEôMEô-OSTôPEOPLEôWANTôPEOPLEôTOôLIKEô THEMôANDôTHEYREôFRIGHTENEDôTOôDOôCERTAINôTHINGSôBECAUSEô

THEYôWANTôPEOPLEôTOôLIKEôTHEM ôANDô)VEôGOTôTOôGETôPASTôTHATô /NCEôYOUôGETôPASTôTHATôYOUREôINôAôDIFFERENTôLEAGUEô 1UESTIONôFROMô3USANô 1UESTIONôTOô,AURA "UTôWHATSôRELEVANT !NSWERôFROMô,AURA ô 7ELL ôITôDEPENDSôONôTHEôSITUATIONôANDôWHOôYOUREôTALKINGôTOô )ôSOMETIMESôKNOWôTHATô)VEôJUSTôGOTôTOôSHUTôTHEôFUCKôUPô)Mô DOINGôSOCIOLOGYôATôUNIVERSITYôSOô)MôQUITEôDEEPôLIKEôTHATô 1UESTIONôFROMô3USANô 1UESTIONôTOô,AURA 7HATôAREôYOUôINTERESTEDôINôDOINGôWITHôTHEôDEGREE !NSWERôFROMô,AURA ô 7ELLô)ôKNOWô)ôJUSTôCANTôSITôINôANôOFkCEô)VEôJUSTôDONEôSOMEô OFkCEôWORKôATô,EEDSô5NIVERSITY ôHELPINGôWITHôTHEôSTUDENTô RECRUITMENTôWHENôOPENôDAYôWASôON ôANDôALTHOUGHôITôWASô ALRIGHT ô)ôJUSTôCANTôDOôTHATôANDô)ôJUSTôDONTôKNOWôWHATô)MôGO INGôTOôDOôWITHôMYôLIFEô)MôQUITEôSPORTY ô)ôDOôBOBSLEIGHô)ôJUSTô HAVEôNOôIDEAô)ôHAVENTôHADôAôJOBôTHISôYEAR ôBEENôBUMMINGô AROUNDô5NIô)VEôJUSTôLOSTôMYôDRIVEôFROMôWHATô)ôHADôTWOôYEARSô AGOô)ôFEELôAôBITôLETHARGICôINôGENERALôINôLIFEôANDô)VEôJUSTôGOTôTOô GETôMYSELFôKICKEDôUPôTHEôARSEôANDô)ôHAVEôNOôIDEAôWHATô)Mô GOINGôTOôDOôAFTERôMYôDEGREEô 1UESTIONôFROMô,AURA 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô !NDôSO ôTHATSôMYôQUESTIONô7HATôAMô)ôGOINGôTOôDOôWITHôMYô LIFEô)MôDOINGôAôSOCIOLOGYôDEGREE ô)ôTALKôAôLOTôANDôFAST ô)Mô PRETTYôCLEVERôIFôYOUôASKôMEôANDô)MôSPORTYô!NDô)ôDONTôWANTô ANôOFkCEôJOB ôBUTôHAVEôYOUôSEENô4HEô3ILENCEôOFôTHEô,AMBSô (AVEôYOUôSEENô#LARICEô3TARLINGô)ôWANTôTOôBEôSOMETHINGôLIKEô THAT ôMANô$OôSOMEôKINDôOFôCRIMINOLOGYôSTUFF ô)ôDONTôKNOW ô BUTô)VEôBEENôSOôLAZYô)VEôJUSTôGONEôOUTôANDôGOTôPISSEDôANDô



0240_057_self_org.indd 254-255

25/09/06 17:41:28

)VEôGOTôTOôSTOPôDOINGôTHAT ôITSôDOINGôMYôHEADôINô4HERESô SOôMUCHôMOREô)ôWANTôTOôBEôMOREôCULTURALôASôWELLô.OWôDOô )ôPISSôOFF !NSWERôFROMô-Rô+ô"ENJAMIN ô 7ELLô,AURA ôWHATô)ôTHINKôYOUôSHOULDôDO ôYOUôSHOULDôDOô SOMETHINGôINVOLVINGôSPORTS ôPREFERABLYôWITHôTHEôHANDI CAPPEDôPEOPLEôCOSôSHEDôGETôMOREôBENEkTôOUTôOFôTHATôANDô SOMETHINGôWITHôSPORTSôCOSôSHEôSAYSôSHEôLIKESôSPORTSôANDô THENôSHEôCOULDôTALKôTOôTHEM ôIFôTHEYVEôGOTôANYôPROBLEMSôINô THEIRôLIVES ôCOSôSHEôTALKSôAôLOT ôSOôSHEôCOULDôBEôAôCOUNSELLOR ô TOôADVISEôPEOPLEôONôWHATôTOôDOôWITHôTHEIRôLIVESô3HEôMIGHTô BEôABLEôTOôSORTôTHEMôOUTôCOSôSHEôTHINKSôSHESôQUITEôBRAINYô 3HEôSAYSôSHESôLETHARGIC ôSOôSHEôSHOULDôDOôSPORTSôANDôBEô AROUNDôPEOPLEôWHOôAREôDOINGôLOTSôOFôSPORTSôACTIVITIESô4HATô WILLôHELPôHERôTOôGETôMOREôENTHUSIASTICôTOôDOôOTHERôTHINGSô "ASICALLYôTHATSôABOUTôITôREALLY 1UESTIONôFROMô-Rô+ô"ENJAMIN 1UESTIONôTOô0EOPLEôOFô,EEDS ô )ôWOULDôLIKEôTOôKNOWôIFôANYONEôWOULDôGIVEôMEôAôJOBô)MôAôHARDô WORKER ôENTHUSIASTIC ôRELIABLE ô)DôLIKEôAôJOBôWHATSôINTERESTINGô .OTôJUSTôSTUCKôINôANôOFkCEôORôSTUCKôINôAôRUT ôSOMETHINGôTHATô GETSôYOUôROUNDôANDôABOUTôMEETINGôDIFFERENTôPEOPLEô)ôLIKEô MEETINGôPEOPLEô!NDô)DôJUSTôLIKEôTOôKNOWôIFôYOUôCOULDôGIVEô USôAôJOBôORôHELPôMEôTOôkNDôAôJOB ôAôGOODôJOBô4HATSôIT !NSWERôFROMô.ICKôINôRESPONSEôTOô,AURA ô )ôTHINKôTHATôSHEôSHOULDôJOINôTHEôCIRCUSô4HERESôPLENTYôTOôDO ô SHEôWONTôGETôBOREDô3HEôWONTôGETôAôCHANCEôTOôGOôOUTô DRINKINGôANDô)ôTHINKôITôWOULDôBRINGôHERôMUCHôHAPPINESS

ANDôELSEWHERE ô4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôISôANôEXPERIMENTôWITHô THEôINTERVIEWôANDôTHEôSTRUCTURESôITôEMPLOYSôCALLôANDôRESPONSE ô QUESTIONôANDôANSWER ôSPEAKERôANDôLISTENERô)NITIATEDôORIGINALLYô VIAôAôTHREE DAYôE MAIL ôANDôEVENTUALLYôMANIFESTINGôITSELFôASôAô SETôOFôCARDSôPUBLISHEDôWITHôTHEô@$EMOCRACIESôISSUEôOFô&USEô MAGAZINE ôAôSIMPLEôGAMEôSTRUCTUREôREPLACEDôTHEôCONVENTIONALô @) 9OU INTERVIEWER INTERVIEWEEôRELATIONSHIPô4HEôRULESôSTATE mô mô mô mô

3OMEONEôASKSôAôQUESTION 3OMEONEôANSWERS ôANDôASKSôANOTHERôQUESTION 1UESTIONSôANDô!NSWERSôCIRCULATE 7EôHAVEôLUNCH

)Nô&EBRUARYô ô0ETERô,ASCHôANDô*ANNAô'RAHAMôLAUNCHEDô THEôFIRSTô4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôwôANDô,UNCHôBETWEENô&USEô MAGAZINEôINô4ORONTOôANDôTHEô"EAVERô#OLLECTIVEôINô.EWô9ORKô

4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôCONTINUEDôFORôTHREEôDAYSôINôAUDIOôFORMATô OUTSIDEôTHEô4OWNô(ALLôINô,EEDS ô5+ôINô*ULYôô4HISôTIMEô ANôINTERVIEWôBOOTHôWASôSETôUPôBETWEENôAôCONFERENCEôTAKINGô PLACEôINôTHEô4OWNô(ALLôWARPWOOFôONôAURALITY ôTEXTUALITYôANDôTHEô VOICE ôANDôTHEôSTREETôANDôSQUAREôOUTSIDEô*ANNAô'RAHAMôANDô)ô OPENEDôTHEôINTERVIEWôBYôRECORDINGôANDôkLINGôQUESTIONSôDIRECTEDô SOMETIMESôTOôPEOPLEôWEôKNEWôATôTHEôCONFERENCE ôPEOPLEôWHOô WORKEDôINôTHEô4OWNô(ALLôTHATôMIGHTôPASSôBY ôORôOPENôQUES TIONSôDIRECTEDôTOôANYONEôWHOôCAREDôTOôANSWERô1UESTIONSôWEREô PICKEDôUPôINTERMITTENTLYôBYôPASSERS BYôANDôCONFERENCEôDEL EGATESôANDôANSWERSôWEREôRECORDEDôBACKôONTOôTHEôSAMEôTAPESô &URTHERôQUESTIONSôWEREôGENERATEDôBYôTHEôANSWERERSô4HROUGHô ANSWERINGôTHEôQUESTIONôANDôPOSINGôANOTHERôONE ôQUESTIONSôANDô ANSWERSôCIRCULATEDôAMONGôPASSERS BYôANDôCONFERENCEôPARTICI PANTSôANDôAôTAPEDôAUDIOôARCHIVEôBEGANôTOôAMASSô)MPROVISEDô CATEGORIESôWEREôESTABLISHEDô(OTô!IR ô7HATôISôTOôBEô$ONE ô 6OICE !CCENT /PERAô/Nô,OVINGô"ARBARAô%NGH ô.Oô&URTHERô 1UESTIONS ô1UESTIONSôTOôTHEô$EADôETC ôANDôARCHIVEDôONôTHEô METALôRACKSô4HEôBOOTHôBECAMEôAôSPACEôOFôRELAYôWHEREôTHEô



0240_057_self_org.indd 256-257

25/09/06 17:41:28

ROLESôOFôTHEôINTERVIEWERôANDôINTERVIEWEEôWEREôPASSEDôAROUNDô THEôCONFERENCEôANDôTHEôSTREETôOVERôTHREEôDAYS 1UESTIONôFROMô.ICK 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô 7ILLô)ôkNDôHAPPINESSôASôAôTRAVELLINGôMARKETINGôMAN !NSWERôFROMô,EEô#ROSBY ô -YôANSWERôWOULDôBEô.OôTOôTHATô7HYô7ELL ôHAPPINESSô ISôNOTôTOôBEôFOUND ôNOTôTOôBEôCOMEôUPONôREALLYô4OôASKôISô NOTôTOôHAVEô3OôTOôMEôTHEôGUYôISôTRAPPEDôBYôHISôOWNôLIFEô ANDôHISôRESPONSIBILITYôANDôTHATSôWHATSôKEEPINGôHIMôBUSYô)ô DONTôKNOWôWHATôELSEôTOôSAYô9OUôCANTôACQUIREôHAPPINESSô ITSôSPONTANEOUSô4HROUGHôMYôEYES ôWHATô)VEôSEENôOFôTHEô WORLD ôSOMEONEôWHOôHASôGOTôTHISôTHATôTHEôOTHER ôITôLOOKSôLIKEô THEYôAREôDOINGôWELLôINôLIFE ôBUTôWELLôINôWHATô4HATSôWHATô)Dô LIKEôTOôASKô4HEYôCANôRUNôAôLIFE ôHAVEôAôHOMEôANDôAôSHELTER ô BUTôTHATôAINTôLIFEô)NôMYôEYES ôCOMMUNICATIONôWITHôPEOPLE ô EVENôINôSALESôINôANYTHING ôISôAôKINDôOFôMANIPULATIONôINôORDERô TOôSELLôTHINGSôTOôPEOPLE ôBECAUSEôTHEYôNEEDôTOôEARNôAôLIVINGô 0EOPLEôAREôSOôCOLDô9OUôCANôSITôONôAôBUSôANDôEVERYBODYSô OFFôINôTHEIRôOWNôLITTLEôWORLD ôTHERESôNOTôMUCHôCOMPASSIONô FORôPEOPLEômôITSôNOTôABOUTôJOININGôTHISôRELIGIONôORôTHAT ôCOSô ITSôCREATINGôWARSô"EINGôABLEôTOôSITôDOWNôWITHôPEOPLE ôGETô ONôAôLEVELô)ôBELIEVEôWEREôALLôINTELLIGENTôINDIVIDUALôPEOPLEôANDô HAVEôALLôGOTôGIFTSô!NDôTOôME ôFEARSôBEENôAôBIGôELEMENTôINô MYôLIFE ô)VEôACTEDôONôTHATô&EARôTOôMEôIS ôISôLIKEôSAY ôAôSNAKEô ISôGOINGôTOôCOMEôANDôPOUNDôONôME ô)ôACTôINSTANTLY ôSOôTHATSô AôNATURALôIMPULSEôANDô)ôACTô"UTôFEARSô)ôMEANôLIKE ôOH ô)ôMUSTô GETôAôJOB ô)MôTOLDôTOôGETôAôJOB ôIFô)ôDONTôTHENô)VEôGOTôNOô MONEY ô)VEôGOTôNOôROOFôOVERôMYôHEADô)VEôGOTôTOôHAVEôTHISô THATôTHEôOTHER ôANDôTHATôALLôBREEDSôFEARSô/H ô)ôMUSTôBEôSUC CESSFULôATôTHIS ô)ôMUSTôBEôSUCCESSFULôATôTHATô!NDôTOôMEôITSô


0240_057_self_org.indd 258-259

THEôWRONGôEDUCATION ôWEVEôNOTôSATôDOWNôANDôDISCUSSEDô ITô%VERYONESôTOOôBUSYô4HROUGHôEDUCATIONôTHEYôTRYôTOôSAYô READôAôBOOKôANDôCONCENTRATEôONôONEôTHINGô4OôMEôTHATSôJUSTô ANOTHERôFORMôOFôANôESCAPEô!TôTHEôENDôOFôTHEôDAYô)MôLOOKINGô FORôWHEREô)MôNOTôGOVERNEDôBYôANYTHINGô#OSôEVENôTHOUGHô )MôHEREô)MôGOVERNEDôBYôSOMETHINGômôMYôCONDITIONING ôHOWô SOCIETYôISô&ROMôTHEôAGEôOFô ôYOUôGETôAôNATIONALôINSURANCEô NUMBERôTHROUGHôYOURôDOORôANDôYOUôHAVEôTOôPAYôTAXESô/URô CONDITIONINGômôITSôLIKEôDESIREôISôAôBIGôONEô,IFEôISôABOUTô PLEASUREôANDôPAIN ôBUTôTHESEôLITTLEôDESIRESô,IKEô)ôMIGHTôGOô OFFôANDôSEEôTHATôCARôOVERôTHEREôANDôTHINK ôOH ô)ôWANTôTHATô !NDôMYôLITTLEôDESIREôGOESôANDôMYôDESIREôSAYS ôYEAH ôLETSô HAVEôTHATôCAR ôHOWôCANô)ôGETôTHATôCARô)ôWANTôTOôSITôINôITôANDô RIDEôITôCOSô)VEôGOTôAôFEELINGôTHEREô)ôBELIEVEôTHATôTHEôBRAIN ô YOUVEôGOTôAôNATURALôENERGYôTHATSôINôTHERE ôANDôYOUVEôGOTô ALLôTHOSEôCONDITIONSôTHATôBREAKôTHATôENERGYôDOWNôSOôTHATôYOUô DONTôWALKôINôTHISôWORLDôWITHôNOôTHOUGHTSôATôALLô4HEYREôSTILLô MINE ôTHATSôWHATôTHEôKEYôOFôLIFEôIS 1UESTIONôFROMô,EE 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô 4HEôQUESTIONô)DôLIKEôTOôASKô7HATôISôLOVEô7HATôISôLOVEô 5NDEVOUREDôLOVE ôASôINôLOVE ôNOTôTHISôDOMINATIONôANDôPOS SESSION ôBUTôWHATôISôLOVE 4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôBOOTHôINô,EEDSôSTARTEDôOFFôINôAôTHREE METREô SQUAREôOFôWOOD EFFECTôTABLESôCOVEREDôBYôAôWHITEôGARDENôGA ZEBOô4HEôGAZEBOôTWISTEDôANDôBLEWôAWAYôUPô#ALVERLEYô3TREETô BYôDAYôTWOô)NSIDEôTHEô4OWNô(ALLôAôCONFERENCEôCALLEDôWARP WOOFôPROCEEDEDôTOôINVESTIGATEôSOUND ôTHEôVOICEôANDôTEXTUALITYô !TôTHEôTABLESô4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWô"OOTH ôTHEREôWEREôCOM INGSôANDôGOINGS ôLOTSôOFôWINDôANDôANôALMOSTôCONSTANTôSOUNDôOFô SIRENSôFROMôTHEôNEARBYôHOSPITALô,ININGôTHEôTABLESôWEREôOLDôlATô


25/09/06 17:41:28

3EASTEAD $ESCRIPTION 4HEô3EASTEADINGô0ROJECTôAIMSôTOôBUILDôSOVEREIGN ôSELF SUFkCIENTôlOATINGôPLATFORMS ô THUSôCREATINGôNEWôTERRITORYôONôTHEôOCEANS 4EXT g3EASTEADINGuôMEANSôTOôCREATEôPERMANENTôDWELLINGSôONôTHEôOCEANômôHOMESTEADINGô THEôHIGHôSEASô,IKEôTHEôPIONEERSôOFôOLD ôSEASTEADERSôWILLôBEôDRIVENôTOWARDSôTHEôNEXTô FRONTIERôBYôTHEIRôADVENTUROUSôSPIRITSôANDôDESIREôFORôFREEDOMô"UILDINGôSOVEREIGNôREALô ESTATEôWILLôLETôTHEMôEXPERIMENTôWITHôAôVARIETYôOFôDIFFERENTôSOCIAL ôPOLITICAL ôLEGAL ôANDô ECONOMICôSYSTEMS ôWHICHôISôCURRENTLYôVERYôDIFkCULTô4HISôRESEARCHôINTOôTHEôBASICôELE MENTSôOFôHOWôSOCIETIESôCANôBEôORGANIZEDôWILLôINCREASEôOURôCOLLECTIVEôWISDOMôANDô BENEkTôEVERYONEô ô

3TARTINGôYOURôOWNôCOUNTRYôONôTHEôOCEANôMAYôSOUNDôLIKEôAôSTRANGEôIDEA ôBUTôTHEREô

HAVEôBEENôHUNDREDSôOFôNATION FOUNDINGôGROUPSôANDôVENTURESôOVERôTHEôPASTôHALF CEN TURY ôMANYôOFôWHICHôWEREôMARINE BASEDô5NFORTUNATELY ôTHEôPEOPLEôINVOLVEDôTENDôTOôBEô ATôBESTôIDEALISTIC ôANDôATôWORSTôCRANKSôANDôSCAMôARTISTSô&EWôOFôTHESEôVENTURESôEVENô GOTôOFFôTHEôGROUNDô/FôTHOSEôTHATôDID ôALMOSTôALLôWEREôIMPRACTICALôANDôFAILEDôDISMALLYô WITHôAôTINYôNUMBERôOFôNOTABLEôEXCEPTIONS ô ô

)NôCONTRAST ôOURôPHILOSOPHYôISôTOôBEôPRAGMATIC ôFOCUSINGôONôREALISTICôMETHODSôIN

STEADôOFôVISIONSôTHATôAREôINSPIRINGôBUTôIMPOSSIBLEô7EôCOMBINEôPROVENôTECHNOLOGIESô RATHERôTHANôTRYINGôTOôINVENTôNEWôONESô7EDôRATHERôSTARTôWITHôSOMETHINGôSMALLôANDôREALô THANôGRANDôANDôIMAGINARYô7EôEXPECTôMOSTôRESIDENTSôTOôBEôPART TIMEôATôTHEôBEGINNING ô RATHERôTHANôDROPPINGôTHEIRôENTIREôLIFEôTOôJUMPôONBOARDôSUCHôAôSPECULATIVEôVENTUREô 7HILEôTHISôCOMMON SENSEôAPPROACHôMAYôSEEMôPRETTYôOBVIOUS ôITôISôUNFORTUNATELYô QUITEôRARE ôWHICHôISôWHYôWEôTHINKôTHATôOURôPROJECTôHASôAôDECENTôCHANCEôOFôSUCCEEDINGô WHEREôSOôMANYôOTHERSôHAVEôFAILEDô ô

3ETTLINGôTHISôNEWôFRONTIERôREQUIRESôSTRUCTURESôDESIGNEDôSPECIkCALLYôFORôTHEôMARINEô

ENVIRONMENTô7EôTHINKôTHEôBESTôDESIGNôISôTHEôgBIRDSôANDôkSHuôAPPROACHô.OTHINGôLIVESô ONôTHEôSURFACEôOFôTHEôWATERôBECAUSEôITSôTOOôUNSTABLEô3EAôCREATURESôEITHERôLIVEôBELOWô THEôWAVESôkSH ôORôlYôABOVEôTHEMôBIRDS ô/URôSEASTEADôDESIGNôISôBASEDôONôTHESEôTWOô SAFEôAREASô7ELLôBELOWôTHEôWATERSôSURFACEôISôAôlOTATIONôHULL ôCONTAININGôAIRôTOôMAKEô THEôSTRUCTUREôlOATôANDôBALLASTôTOôKEEPôITôSTABLEô7ELLôABOVEôTHEôCRESTSôOFôTHEôLARGESTô ANTICIPATEDôWAVESôISôAôMULTI LEVELôPLATFORMôWHEREôTHEôRESIDENTSôLIVEô)TSôLOWESTôDECKôISô AôSAFETYôHULLôWHICHôCANôSUPPORTôTHEôENTIREôSTRUCTUREôINôANôEMERGENCY ôORôDURINGôCERTAINô MANEUVERS ô#ONNECTINGôTHEôTWOôISôAôHOLLOWôVERTICALôTUBE ôCALLEDôAôSPARô5NLIKEôAôBOAT ô THISôSTRUCTUREôISôMASSIVEôANDôHASôLITTLEôCONNECTIONôTOôTHEôWAVES ôSOôITôWONTôBOBôORô SWAY ôEVENôINôMAJORôSTORMSô ô

%LECTRICITYôCOMESôFROMôAôCOMBINATIONôOFôSOLAR ôWIND ôWAVE ôANDôDIESELôGENERATORSô

7ATERôISôPROVIDEDôBYôCAPTUREDôRAINWATER ôSOLARôDISTILLATION ôANDôREVERSEôOSMOSISô&OODô CONSISTSôOFôHYDROPONICALLYôGROWNôFRUITSôANDôVEGETABLES ôAQUAPONICôkSHôANDôALGAE ôANDô HIGHôDENSITYôGARDENSô3ELF SUFkCIENCYôWILLôBEôCLOSELYôRELATEDôTOôHOWôFARôTHEôSEASTEADô

0240_057_self_org.indd 260-261

%XAMPLESôôYôô0B>PQB>A

25/09/06 17:41:30

EXPECTSôTOôBEôFROMôLAND ôPROGRESSINGôFROMôINITIALô"AYSTEADSôANDô#OASTSTEADSôTOô EVENTUALô$EEPSEASTEADSô ô

#URRENTLY ôWEôAREôCOMPLETINGôOURôBASICôBACKGROUNDôRESEARCHô4HENôWEôWILLôkNISHô

DESIGNINGôTHEôkRSTôHABITABLEôVERSION ôCALLEDô"AYSTEAD ôWITHôABOUTôTENôTHOUSANDôSQUAREô FEETôOFôAREAôPRELIMINARYôWORKôHASôBEENôDONE ô5SINGôTHISôDESIGN ôWELLôBUILDôAôTUB SIZEDôMODEL ôTHENôAôPOOL SIZEDôMODEL ôANDôkNALLYôTHEôFULL SIZEDôSTRUCTURE ôWHICHôWEô PLANôTOôLOCATEôINôTHEôSHELTEREDôWATERSôOFôTHEô3ANô&RANCISCOô"AYô4HISôWILLôLETôUSôTESTô THEôTECHNOLOGYôANDôBECOMEôFAMILIARôWITHôIT ôASôWELLôASôSERVINGôASôAôDEMONSTRATIONô ANDôPUBLICITYôPIECEô)NTERESTEDôPEOPLEôCANôTAKEôTOURSôTOôLEARNôMOREôABOUTôOURôPROJECTô ANDôTECHNOLOGIESô ô

/NCEô"AYSTEADôISôBUILTôANDôOCCUPIED ôWELLôBEGINôPLANNINGôANDôDESIGNINGôTHEôkRSTô

SOVEREIGNôSEASTEADô)TLLôBEôBIGôENOUGHôFORôAROUNDôAôHUNDREDôRESIDENTSô7HILEôAôFEWô ENTHUSIASTSôWILLôSIGNôUPôTOôLIVEôTHEREôFULLôTIME ôWEôEXPECTôMOSTôPARTICIPANTSôTOôBUYô TIMESHARESôENABLINGôTHEMôTOôSPENDôAôFEWôWEEKSôAôYEARôONôBOARDô4HISôWILLôGIVEôUSôAô MUCHôBROADERôBASEôOFôPEOPLEôTOôDRAWôFROMô ô

7HENôENOUGHôDEPOSITSôHAVEôBEENôMADEôANDôCONTRACTSôSIGNEDôWITHôRESIDENTS ô

CONSTRUCTIONôONô3EASTEADô)ôWILLôBEGINô/NCEôTHEôkRSTôSOVEREIGNôSEASTEADôHASôBEENô BUILT ôTHEôHARDESTôPARTôOFôTHEôWORKôHASôBEENôDONE ôANDôTHEôMOVEMENTôCANôTAKEôOFFô ONôITSôOWNôSTEAMô7ITHôANôOPERATINGô3EASTEADôDEMONSTRATINGôTHATôSEASTEADINGôISô TECHNOLOGICALLY ôkNANCIALLY ôANDôPOLITICALLYôFEASIBLE ôINTERESTôWILLôCONTINUEôTOôGROWô-OREô PLATFORMSôWILLôBEôBUILTôANDôCONNECTEDôINTOôLARGERôGROUPSô ô

!SôSEACITIESôDEVELOP ôTHEôSEACONOMYôWILLôGROW ôANDôSEASTEADINGôCANôBECOMEôAô

FULL TIMEôWAYôOFôLIFEôFORôANôINCREASINGôNUMBERôOFôPEOPLEô4HEYLLôEXPERIMENTôWITHôAô VARIETYôOFôGOVERNINGôSYSTEMS ôANDôTHEôMOSTôSUCCESSFULôWILLôBEôEMULATEDô7EôDONTô EXPECTôTOôCREATEôTHEôPERFECTôSOCIETY ôBUTôWEôDOôTHINKôWEôCANôACHIEVEôAôSIGNIkCANTô IMPROVEMENT ôAôFREERôANDôMOREôADAPTABLEôFORMôOFôLIFE 3OURCE WWWSEASTEADORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION g"UYôLANDômôTHEYREôNOTôMAKINGôITôANYôMOREuôATTRIBUTEDôTOô-ARKô4WAIN WWWSEASTEADORG WWWSEALANDGOVCOM WWWHAVENCOCOM WWWENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKIMICRONATIONS

TAPEôRECORDERSôTHATôCOULDôPLAYôANDôRECORD ôANDôlATôMETALôRACKSô TOôSTACKôTAPESôINô,ISTSôOFô@QUESTIONôFROMôQUESTIONôTOôANSWERô FROMôWEREôMADEôONôTHEôTAPEôCOVERSô4HEôTAPESôWEREôARCHIVEDô ONôTHEôRACKSôANDôPULLEDôOUTôAGAINôWHENôPASSERS BYôWANTEDôTOô LISTEN ôANSWERôANDôASKôANOTHERôQUESTION ôORôPEOPLEôWHOôHADô QUESTIONSôDIRECTEDôSPECIkCALLYôTOWARDSôTHEMôWANTEDôTOôCON TINUEôAôTHREADô)NôTHISôPROCESSôORCHESTRATEDôBYô*ANNAô'RAHAMô ANDô) ôTAPESôOCCASIONALLYôTOOKôTHEIRôOWNôDIRECTIONôFORôAôWHILE ô WHILEôWEôCAMEôUPôWITHôIMPROVISED ôTEMPORARYôARCHIVALôCAT EGORIESô0EOPLEôCAMEôTOôRECORDôANSWERSôANDôQUESTIONSôINôTWOô WAYSô#URIOSITYôBROUGHTôMANYôPEOPLEôBY ôSEEKINGôEXPLANATIONSô FORôWHATôWASôGOINGôONôANDôOFTENôLISTENINGôTOôTHEôTAPESôTHATôHADô BEENôRECORDEDôSOôFARô4HEYôWOULDôTHENôSOMETIMESôADDôTHEIRô OWNôANSWERSôANDôAôFURTHERôQUESTIONô4HEREôWEREôALSOôSMALLô CARDSôTHEôSIZEôOFôBUSINESSôCARDSôTHATôSAIDô$EARô????? ô4HEREôISô AôQUESTIONôWAITINGôFORôYOUôATôTHEô/PENô)NTERVIEWô"OOTH ôWHICHô COULDôBEôSURREPTITIOUSLYôORôOTHERWISEôHANDEDôTOôSOMEONEôYOUô HADôLEFTôAôDIRECTôQUESTIONôFORô5PONôDIRECTôINTERPELLATION ôTHEô ADDRESSEEôCOULDôRARELYôRESISTôCOMINGôTOôkNDôOUTôWHATôHADôBEENô ASKEDôANDôWHOôHADôASKEDôITô4HEôRULEôSTATEDôTHATôUPONôANSWER ING ôANOTHERôQUESTIONôMUSTôBEôGENERATED ôANDôSOôTHEôTAPESô WENTôONô4HEôBOOTHôBECAMEôAôSPACEôOFôRELAY ôAôPLACEôTOôCOMEô ANDôPICKôUPôANDôDROPôOFF ôORôAôSPACEôTOôHANGôAROUNDôCHAT TINGôANDôLISTENINGôWITHôHEADPHONESô4HEREôWEREôALWAYSôSEVERALô QUESTIONSôLEFTôHANGINGôONôDIFFERENTôTAPES ôANDôSOôASôWELLôASô BEINGôSPECTATORSôOFôSORTSôLISTENINGôTOôWHATôOTHERôPEOPLEôSAID ô LISTENERSôALWAYSôHADôANôENTRYôPOINTôWHEREôTHEYôCOULDôANSWERô ORôSTARTôAôNEWôTHREADôWITHôAôNEWôQUESTION !NSWERôFROMô,AURAô INôRESPONSEôTOôHERôRESPONSESôANDôTOôTHEôQUESTIONô@WHATôISôLOVE

ô

%XAMPLESôôYôô0B>PQB>A

0240_057_self_org.indd 262-263

)ôMUSTôSAYô)ôFOUNDôYOURôANSWERôREALLYôINTERESTINGô7EôAREôALLô


25/09/06 17:41:30

TRAPPEDôINôOURôOWNôFEARSôANDôATôTHEôMINUTEô)MôJOBLESSôANDô HAVEôHARDLYôANYôMONEYô)MôTRAPPEDôINôTHEôFEARôTHATôNOTHINGô WILLôKICKôOFFôFORôMEô!NOTHERôYEARôATô5NI ô)ôSTILLôHAVENTôGOTô ANYôMONEYôANDô)MôTRYINGôTOôGETôAWAYôFORôTHEôSUMMERôANDô)ô FEELôTHATô)ôWONTôBEôABLEôTOôGETôAWAYw ô 7HATôISôLOVEô7ELL ôITSôNEVERôHAVINGôTOôSAYôYOUREôSORRY ôCOSô YOUôLOVEôANDôACCEPTôTHEôOTHERôPERSONôSOôMUCHôTHATôYOUôJUSTô ACCEPTôTHEM ôTHATSôWHATô)ôBELIEVEô!NYWAY ôTHANKôYOU !NSWERôFROMô3TEPH ô 9OUôKNOWôHOWôPEOPLEôFORGET ôLIKEôINôRELATIONSHIPS ôPEOPLEôACTô ASôTWOôCONSUMERSôINôAôUNITô!ôLOTôOFôPEOPLEôPICKôAôPARTNERô AôBITôLIKEôAôCOMPLEMENTôTOôTHEMSELVES ôLIKEôAôCO CONSUMERô 4HEYôARENTôWILLINGôTOôRELATEôTOôEACHôOTHER ôTHEYôSTANDôASôANô ENHANCEDôCONSUMERôUNITôANDôTHEôLOVEôTHATSôDIRECTEDôISôNOTô OUTWARDS ôITSôSELF LOVE ôITSôREALLYôNOTôVERYôEFFECTIVEô,OVEô COMESôFROMôTHEôRELATIONôWITHôANOTHER ôOFôDIFFERENCEô)TôWASô 3CHLEGELôWHOôSAIDôTHAT ôWHENôYOUôLOVEôSOMEONEôYOUôSTOPô WANTINGôTOôKNOWôTHEM ôITSôTHEôQUALITYôOFôMISUNDERSTANDINGô ISôWHATôBEINGôINôLOVEôIS ôWHATôSUSTAINSôIT ôTHEôACCEPTANCEô OFôAôMISUNDERSTANDINGô3O ôTHATSôWHATôWEREôAIMINGôFOR ô NOTôAôPOLITICSôOFôEFkCIENCY ôAôTOGETHERNESSôAMONGôPEOPLEô WHOôDONTôQUITEôkTôTOGETHERô)ôTHINKôAôLOTôOFôMULTICULTURALISMô ISôBASEDôONôTHEôFACTôTHATôWEôMIGHTôMELTôTOGETHER ôFORMôAô ONE ôAôMOREôPERFECTôUNIONô5NIONôISNTôABOUTôTHEôPERFECTIONô OFôUNION ôBUTôABOUTôDIFFERENTôVALUEôOFôPERFECTIONô!BOUTôTHEô AFFECTIONôEXPRESSEDôTOWARDSôIMPERFECTIONôPERHAPSô4HOSEô QUESTIONSôABOUTôTHEôPOLITICS ôTHATôISNTôABOUTôAôSOLUTION ôBUTô ABOUTôANôACCOMMODATION ôTOWARDSôTRADITIONSôTHATôEXISTôNOWô 4HEôPROCESSôBECOMESôTHEôOBJECTôNOTôTHEôSOLUTIONw 1UESTIONôFROMô3TEPH 1UESTIONôTOô*ANNA ô $OôYOUôTHINKôOFôYOURSELFôASôAôCONDUIT ôLIKEôAôPUBLICôSWITCH

BOARDôFORôPEOPLEôINôAôSENSE !NSWERôFROMô*ANNA ô )TSôSOMETHINGô)VEôBEENôTHINKINGôABOUTôTODAYôAôLOT ôCOSô)ô DONTôNECESSARILYôSEEôMYôVOICEôASôAôSWITCHBOARD ôBUTô)ôASKEDô 3USANôTODAY ô@WHATôISôTHEôAGENTôOFôCONTINGENCYô)FôALLôAGENTSô AREôCONTINGENTôWHATôAREôTHEôAGENTSôOFôTHOSEôCONTINGENCIESô 4HATSôWHEREô)ôCAREôABOUTôSITUATINGôMYSELFôWHEREôTHEôBONDSô INôRELATIONSHIPSôAREôVERYôDIFkCULT ôTHEYôAREôNOTôEASYôBONDSô ,IKEôWHENôYOUôTRYôANDôBRINGôANôACADEMICôCOMMUNITYôINTOôAô COMMUNITYôOFôPEOPLEôWHOôAREôWALKINGôTHEôSTREETSôFORôWHAT EVERôREASON ôGOINGôTOôWORK ôUNEMPLOYED ôHOMELESSôWHAT EVERô4HOSEôAREôVERYôDISSONANTôVOICES ôTHEYôDONTôMEETôEACHô OTHERôONôANYôKINDôOFôCOMMONôGROUND ô)ôMEANôTHEYôMIGHTôBUTô THEYôDONT ôINôTHEôCONTEXTôOFôTHISôKINDôOFôCONFERENCEô"UTôWHATô AREôYOUôWHENôYOUREôTHATôAGENT ôAôTRANSMITTERôORôWHATEVER ô ANDôWHATôISôITôTOôFEELôTHEôTENSIONôOFôTHATôDISSONANCE ôHOWô DOôYOUôARTICULATEôIT ôTALKôABOUTôIT ôWHATôISôITôTOôBEôTHATô4HATSô SOMETHINGô)MôVERYôINTERESTEDôINô)ôWOULDNTôBEôSOôBOLDôASôTOô SAY ôOHôWEREôTHEôTRANSMITTERS ôWEôTRANSMITôONEôKNOWLEDGEô TOôANOTHER ôBECAUSEô)ôDONTôTHINKôTHEYôAREôSEPARATE ôBUTôTHEYô AREôARTICULATEDôwô;TAPEôRUNSôOUT=



0240_057_self_org.indd 264-265

!NôEXCHANGEôOFôSORTSôTAKESôPLACEôANDôTHEôQUESTIONSôMOVEô AROUNDô3OMETHINGôGETSôPASSEDôAROUNDôANDôRELAYED ôBUTôITô ISôMESSYôANDôUNSYSTEMATIC ôWITHôPLENTYôOFôBREAKSôANDôDEAD ENDSô3OMETIMESôTHEôANSWERERSôSTRUGGLEôORôCANNOTôASKôANOTHERô QUESTION ôTHEYôMUSTôBEôPERSUADED ôCAJOLEDôANDôCHARMEDôOURô VOICESôCREEPôINôAGAINô9ETôGENERATINGôANOTHERôQUESTIONôISôKEYô 8ôHEARSôTHATôSOMEONEôHASôLEFTôHIMôAôQUESTIONô(EôFEELSôlAT TERED ôADDRESSED ôLIKEôMAYBEôSOMEONEôACTUALLYôLISTENEDôTOôHISô PAPERôIFôHEôISôAôCONFERENCEôSPEAKER ôORôATôLEASTôASôIFôSOMEONEô CARESô4HISôMAKESôHIMôTHINKôCAREFULLYôABOUTôTHEôANSWER ôTOôTRYô

25/09/06 17:41:31

ANDôANSWERôITôINôTHEôSPIRITôOFôGENUINEôINTERESTôWITHôWHICHôTHEô QUESTIONôHASôBEENôASKEDô(EôRElECTSôCAREFULLYôONôTHEôQUES TIONôANDôCOMESôUPôWITHôANôANSWERô(AVINGôBEENôADDRESSEDôSOô DIRECTLYôANDôSPENTôSOMEôCONCENTRATEDôTIMEôWITHôAôMICROPHONEô RElECTINGôONôHISôOWNôPERSONALôANDôPARTICULARôTAKEôONôTHEôISSUEô ATôHAND ôHEôMUSTôSUDDENLYôOPENôITôOUTôAGAINô4HISôOBLIGATIONô TOôGENERATEôANOTHERôQUESTIONô8ôSAIDôHEôWOULDôPLAY ômôINôTHEô SPIRITôOFôGENUINEôINTEREST ôWONDERINGôTOôWHOM ôIFôANYONE ôABOUTô WHAT ôIFôANYTHINGômôOFTENôIMMEDIATELYôOPENSôOUTôANDôSOMETIMESô DE CENTRESôTHATôRElECTIVEôVOICEô(EôQUESTIONER ôASKEDôMEôAD DRESSEE ôAôQUESTIONôANDôNOWô)ôQUESTIONER ôMUSTôASKôSOMEONE ô ANYONEôNEWôADDRESSEE ôAôQUESTION ôWHOôMAYôPOTENTIALLYôASKô MEôPOTENTIALôADDRESSEEôXô ôAôQUESTIONôAGAINôWHICHôWOULDôBEô NICE ôORôATôLEASTôHAVEôTOôGENERATEôAôRELATEDôQUESTIONô)ôWONDERô WHATôTHATôWOULDôBE ôWHATôQUESTIONôMYôADDRESSEEôWOULDôASKô 4HISôISôOFTENôTHEôPROCESS ôWITHINôTHEôSTRUCTUREôOFôTHEôBOOTHôANDô THEôMANYôLISTENINGôANDôRECORDINGôDEVICES ôTHROUGHôWHICHôTHEô QUESTIONôISôCARRIEDôONô4HISôSTRUCTURINGôOFôRELATIONSôISôIMPORTANTô BECAUSE ôASô$ERRIDAôSTATES ôQUESTIONINGôITSELFôDOESNTôMAKEô FORôANôETHICSôOFôTHOUGHTô.ANCYôADDSôTHATô@THEôOBLIGATIONôISô MOREôSIMPLY ôMOREôMODESTLY ôONEôOFôMAINTAININGô;GARDER=ôTHEô QUESTION ôASôAôQUESTIONô.ANCYô ô)FôTHEôSTRUCTUREôSETôUPôBYô 4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôLAYSôSOMEôKINDôOFôPRELIMINARYôGROUNDôORô MECHANISMôFORôEXCHANGEôANDôCONNECTION ôHOWôIMPORTANTôISôTHISô SHIFTINGôOFôTHEô@) YOU WEôTOôMAINTAININGôTHEôQUESTIONô 1UESTIONôFROMô0ATRICIA 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô !NôOPENôQUESTION ôBECAUSEô)ôHAVENTôHEARDôANYBODYôSPEAKô YETôANDôSOô)ôDONTôKNOWôWHOôTOôDIRECTôITôTOôwôBUTôUMô4Oô PEOPLEôDELIVERINGôPAPERSôHERE ôORôMAYBEôTOôTHEôPEOPLEôINô ,EEDSô)ôGUESSôTHEôQUESTIONôISôwôEMô/NEôQUESTIONô)ôHADôISô

wôWHEREôINôYOURôBODYôDOôYOUôFEELôYOURôVOICEô!NDôANOTHERô WAY ôDOôYOUôRECOGNIZEôwô)VEôMETôPEOPLEôWHOôHAVEôMADEô ANôEFFORTôNOTôTOôSOUNDôLIKEôTHEYREôFROMô"ROOKLYNô!NDô)ôEVENô NOTICEôNOWôTHATô)MôGETTINGôOLDERôTHATô)MôSOUNDINGôMOREô "ROOKLYN ôBECAUSEô)MôNOTôCONTROLLINGôITôASôMUCHôANYMORE ô )ôKNOWôPEOPLEôWHOôHAVEôCHOSENôAôDIFFERENTôVOICE ôAôMOREô CONTROLLEDôVOICEôwôSOô)ôHAVEôTHISôUNFORMULATEDôQUESTIONô THATôwôEMôwôTHEôIDEAôTHAT ôISôTHEREôAôVOICEôTHATôYOUôKNOWô ISôYOURôREALôVOICE ôANDôAôVOICEôTHATôYOUôKNOWôISôYOURôSORTôOF ô EMôwôCONTROLLEDôVOICE ôANDôWHENôDIDôYOUôSTARTôTOôCREATEôAô CONTROLLEDôVOICE !NSWERôFROMô#HERIE ô %Môwô-YôNAMEôISô#HERIEôANDô)ôHAVEôNOôIDEAôWHEREôMYô VOICEôCOMESôFROMô)ôDONTôKNOWôABOUTôTHATôQUESTIONô#ANTô ANSWERôTHATôONEô4HEôOTHERôONEôISôwôWHEREôVOICEôCOMESô FROMôORôSOMETHINGô)NôTERMSôOFôACCENTSôwôHMMôwô)ôDONTô KNOWôWHATôTOôSAY ô)ôGUESSô)ôWOULDNTôHAVEôTHOUGHTôTHATôMYô ACCENTôWOULDôCHANGEôATôALL ôBUTô)ôHAVEôNOTICEDôTHATôEVERYô TIMEô)ôSAYô@#ANADAôITôSOUNDSôSTRANGEôTOôME ôANDô)ôDONTô KNOWôTHATôIFôITSôCOSô)MôNOTôUSEDôTOôSAYINGô)MôFROMô#ANADA ô BECAUSEô)ôHAVENTôTRAVELLEDôVERYôMUCH ôORôBECAUSEô)MôSAY INGô@#ANADAôDIFFERENTLYô)ôDONTôKNOWô)ôDONTôKNOWôIFôTHATô ANSWERSôTHATôQUESTION ôBUTôITSôONEôTHINGô)VEôBEENôAWAREôOFô ACCENTS ôANYWAYôwôANDôALSO ôITSôINTERESTINGôTHATôYOUôSHOULDô MENTIONô.EWô9ORK ôCOSôTHEREôWASôAôGUYôONôTHEôPLATFORMôATô 4HORNTONô(EATHôWHOôGAVEôMEôDIRECTIONS ôHEôWORKSôFORôTHEô TRANSITôCOMMISSIONôHERE ôANDô)ôHADôAôWHOLEôCONVERSATIONô WITHôHIM ôANDô)ôDIDNTôEVENôNOTICEôTHATôHISôACCENTôWASôNOTô %NGLISHôANDô)ôTHINKôTHATSôBECAUSEôAô.ORTHô!MERICANôACCENTô SOUNDSôNATURALôTOôME ôANDôEVENôTHOUGHô)MôINô%NGLAND ô)ô DIDNTôEVENôQUESTIONôTHEôFACTôTHATôHISôACCENTôWASôNOTô%NG LISHôANDôWHENô)ôkNALLY ô)ôWASôGETTINGôONôTHEôTRAINôHEôASKED ô



0240_057_self_org.indd 266-267

25/09/06 17:41:31

3EEDYô3UNDAY $ESCRIPTION 3OCIABLEôAGRICULTURE 4EXT !NôUNTOLDôNUMBERôOFôCROPôVARIETIESôHAVEôBECOMEôEXTINCTôSINCEôTHEôONSETôOFôINDUSTRIALô AGRICULTUREôINôTHEôLASTôôORôSOôYEARSôANDôTHEôONLYôWAYôTOôREVERSEôTHISôTRENDôISôFORôTHEô EXISTINGôHERITAGEôVARIETIESôTOôBEôSPREADôANDôGROWNôASôWIDELYôASôPOSSIBLEô!SôWELLôASô BEINGôIMPORTANTôINôORDERôTOôPRESERVEôTHEôDIVERSITYôOFôNATURE ôSWAPPINGôSEEDSôALSOô PLAYSôAôCRUCIALôROLEôINôRECLAIMINGôCONTROLôOVERôTHEôFOODôCHAINôFROMôLARGEôSEEDôCOM PANIESô0ROkTôINôTHEôSEEDôBUSINESSôRELIESôONôCUSTOMERSôCOMINGôBACKôYEARôAFTERôYEAR ô WHICHôHASôLEDôTOôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôVARIOUSôHYBRIDôSEEDSôSPECIkCALLYôDESIGNEDôTOôBE COMEôSTERILEôAFTERôONEôSEASONôTOôSERVEôTHEôBUSINESSôINTERESTSôOFôSEEDôCOMPANIESô ô

4HISôCOMMERCIALôATTITUDEôTOWARDSôSEEDôHASôSHOWNôITSELFôTOôBEôFUNDAMENTALLYôUN

SUSTAINABLEôANDôISôTOTALLYôCONTRADICTORYôTOôTHEôSPIRITôOFôSEED SWAPPINGôWHICHôREGARDSô THEôCYCLEôOFôLIFEôFROMôSEEDôTOôPLANTôTOôSEEDôASôAôPRECIOUSôGIFTôOFôNATURE ôTOôBEôSHAREDô WITHôEVERYONEô3EEDYô3UNDAYôALSOôHOPESôTOôPROMOTEôSOCIALôDIVERSITYôSOôTHATôPEOPLEô OFôALLôAGESôANDôBACKGROUNDSôCANôCOMEôTOGETHERôTOôDISCUSSôTHEIRôCROPSôANDôMUCHô MORE ôEN ABLINGôCONNECTIONSôTOôBEôMADEôBETWEENôGROWERSôINôTHEôLOCALôCOMMUNITYô SOôTHATôPEOPLEôCANôWORKôTOGETHERôONôENSURINGôTHEIRôOWNôFOODôSECURITY /RGANISEôYOURôOWNôSEEDYôSUNDAY 9OUôPROBABLYôALREADYôSWAPôSEEDSôWITHôYOURôNEIGHBOUR ôBUTôHOWôABOUTôSWAPPINGôWITHô YOURôWHOLEôCOMMUNITYô3EEDôSWAPPINGôCONNECTSôANDôSUSTAINSôTHEôLOCALôGARDENINGô NETWORKô)TôOFFERSôGARDENERSôOLDôANDôNEWôAôCHANCEôTOôGROWôTHEIRôOWNôFOODôANDôTOôTRYô DIFFERENTôVARIETIESôTHUSôKEEPINGôOUTôHERITAGEôVEGETABLESôFROMôEXTINCTIONô)TôGIVESôGAR DENERSôAôCHANCEôTOôSHAREôKNOWLEDGEôANDôSEEDôTHATôHASôADAPTEDôTOôLOCALôCONDTIONSô ô

)TSôNOTôTHATôDIFkCULTôTOôORGANISEôYOURôOWNôSEEDôSWAPô

ô

7HENôISôUPôTOôYOUô7EôHAVEôGONEôFORô&EBRUARYôBECAUSEôTHATôISôWHENôAôLOTôOFôPEOPLEô

AREôTHINKINGôABOUTôWHATôTHEYôAREôGOINGôTOôGROWôTHISôSEASONô)TôCOULDôEASILYôTAKEôPLACEô INôTHEô!UTUMNôORôLATERôINôTHEô3PRING ô

3EEDSôCANôCOMEôFROMôALLôSORTSôOFôSOURCESô4ALKôTOôYOURôLOCALôCOUNCILSôPARKSôANDô

GARDENSôDEPARTMENT ôSTORES ôGARDENôORôALLOTMENTôSOCIETIESôORôCLUBSôANDôJUSTôASKô)Fô YOUôDONTôASKôYOUôDONTôGETô7EôWROTEôTOôLOCALôANDôNOTôSOôLOCALôSEEDôCOMPANIESô!SKô USôASôWELLôASôWEôMAYôHAVEôSPAREôSEEDôTOôSENDôYOU 3OURCEôô WWWSEEDYSUNDAYORG &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWSEEDYSUNDAYORGôôôôWWWVSHIVANET WWWENWIKIPEDIAORGWIKI"IOPIRACY

%XAMPLESôôYôô0BBAVñ0RKA>V

0240_057_self_org.indd 268-269

25/09/06 17:41:33

@7HEREôAREôYOUôFROMôANDôHEôSAIDôHEôWASôFROMô.EWô9ORKô môANDô)ôTHOUGHTôHEôWASôASKINGôMEôIFô)ôWASôFROMô.EWô9ORK ô ANDô)ôSAID ô@)MôFROMô#ANADAôANDôHEôWASôACTUALLYôTELLINGôMEô HEôWASôFROMô.EWô9ORKôANDô)ôHADNTôEVENôNOTICEDôTHATôHISô ACCENTôSOUNDEDôSTRANGEô)TôDIDNTôSOUNDôSTRANGEôTOôME ôANô %NGLISHôACCENTôSOUNDSôSTRANGEôTOôMEô;3IRENS= 1UESTIONôFROMô#HERIE 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô $OôYOUôTHINKôABOUTôTHEôSOUNDôOFôYOURôOWNôVOICE !NSWERôFROMô*OHNNY ô *OHNNYô-AGUIREô)ôWASôJUSTôASKINGôHERôIFôSHEôWASô&RENCHô wôCOSôTHERESôAôLOTôOFô&RENCHôINô#ANADAôwôANôAWFULôLOTôOFô &RENCHôTHEREôwôLIKEôINô.EWô/RLEANSôwôTHATSôWHEREôTHEô #AJUNSôCOMEôFROM ôYOUôKNOWôWHATô)ôMEANô-YôMOTHERôANDô FATHERôwô)ôWASôBORNôINô+ENTôINôTHEôSOUTHôOFô%NGLANDô"E CAUSEô)MôAôTRAVELLINGôMANôwôWEôTRAVELLEDôAROUNDô%NGLAND ô 3COTLAND ô7ALES ôNOTô)RELAND ôBECAUSEôMYôWIFEôwô)VEôBEENô TOô)RELAND ôYEAH ôBUTôWHATô)MôTRYINGôTOôSAYôISôwôMYôWIFESô %NGLISH ôMYôCHILDRENôAREô%NGLISHôSOôTHATSôWHYô)MôHEREôw ô )ôCLASSôMYSELFôASôANô)RISHôTRAVELLINGôMANôwôBECAUSEôTHATSô WHATô)ôAMôwôALLôBELONGINGôTOôMEôWASôTHAT ôEVENôMYôCHIL DREN ôYOUôASKôTHEMôWHATôTHEYôARE ôTHEYLLôSAYôTHEôSAME ô COSôTHEYôSPEAKôTHEôSAMEôASôMEô3EEôNOWôMYôLANGUAGEôISô DIFFERENTôINô)RISH ôITSôWHATôYOUôCALLô@CANTô9OUREôAôCOUNTRYô PERSONô)FôYOUREôNOTôAôTRAVELLERôYOUREôCLASSEDôASôAôCOUNTRYô PERSONô%VENôTHOUGHôYOUôCOULDôBEôRAISEDôINôTHEôCITYôTHATSô WHATôYOUDôBEô)ôSPEAKôMOSTLYô%NGLISH ôEVENôOVERôHEREôWEô SPEAKôMOSTLYô%NGLISH ôWEôONLYôSPEAKôOURôLANGUAGEôAMONGô OURSELVES ôIFôWEôDONTôWANTôSOMEONEôTOôKNOWôWHATôWEREô TALKINGôABOUTô"UTôMOSTLYôAMONGôOURSELVESôWEôSPEAKô%NG LISH ôTHEô1UEENSô%NGLISHôASôTHEYôCALLôIT ôLIKEôINô)RELAND ôMOSTô OFôTHEôLANGUAGEôISô%NGLISH ôISNTôITô5NLESSôTHEYôCOMEôFROMô

AôSMALLôCOMMUNITY ôLIKEôTHEôLITTLEô!RANô)SLANDSô)ôNEVERôWANTô MYôCHILDRENôTOôLOSEôMYôLANGUAGE !NSWERôFROMô,YNNô4URNER ô -YôNAMEôISô,YNNô4URNERôANDô)ôAMôNOTô!USTRALIANô,ETôMEôSTAYô THATôONEôMOREôTIMEô)ôAMôNOTô!USTRALIAN ôCALLERSô%VERôSINCEô )ôMOVEDôTOôTHEô3OUTH ôHOMEôOFôMANYôMOREôHOMEôCOUNTIESô ACCENTS ôSOôMANYôPEOPLE ôESPECIALLYôEMPLOYERS ôACADEM ICS ô)ôTHINKôITSôAôCODE ôSOMETHINGôTHATSôNOTôMODULATINGôAô HOMEôCOUNTIESôACCENTôPERFECTLY ôTHERESôSOMEôKINDôOFôCHINK ô SOMEôKINDôOFôOTHERôRHYTHMô)ôTHINKô)ôONCEôCALLEDôITôAôPEASANTô TWANGô3OôTHEôCODEôIS ôINSTEADôOFôWHEREôDOôYOUôCOMEôFROMô wôITSô@!REôYOUô!USTRALIANô3OôSOON ô)ôWILLôMAKEôITôUPôANDô SAY ô@YESô)ôAM ôANDôGIVEôMYSELFôAôWHOLEôOTHERôLIFE ôkCTIONALô HISTORYô-YôPARENTSôHAVEôFAIRLYôCOUNTRYô3USSEXôACCENTSô 4YPICALôOFôPEOPLEôOFôWHOôHAVEôlATTENEDôOUT ôINTOôAôMOREô QUOTE UNQUOTEô@WELL SPOKENôACCENT ôISôWHENôTHEYôSPEAKô ONôTHEôPHONEôTOôTHEIRôPARENTS ôYOUôSTARTôSPEAKINGôDIFFERENTLYô ANDôYOUREôTHEôOTHERôPERSONôINôTHEôROOMô-YôFRIENDô#HERYL ô HERôVOICEôISôQUITEôPOSH ôBUTôONôTHEôPHONEôSHEôWENTôINTOôTHEô VERY ôVERYôROUNDEDô7ELSHôwôANDôYOUôCOULDôHAVEôCONVERSA TIONSôWITHôHERôWHILEôSHEôWASôONôTHEôPHONEôANDôSHEôWOULDô SWITCHôBETWEENôTHEôTWOôWITHOUTôHELPINGôIT 1UESTIONôFROMô,YNNô4URNER 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô 7HENôYOUôLOSEôYOURôACCENT ôWHEREôDOESôITôGO !NSWERôFROMô0AULô"OWMAN ô 2IGHT ôANôACCENTôISôAôTRACEôWITHOUTôAôPRESENCE 1UESTIONôFROMô0AULô"OWMAN 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô %M ôHOWôCANô)ôGETôRIDôOFôMYôHANGOVERô/+ôwô !NSWERôFROMô*ANNAô'RAHAM ô )ôHAVEôSOMEô!DVIL



0240_057_self_org.indd 270-271

25/09/06 17:41:33

1UESTIONôFROMô*ANNAô'RAHAM 1UESTIONôTOô0AULô"OWMAN ô 7OULDôYOUôLIKEôSOME !NSWERôFROMô0AULô"OWMAN ô )MôGOINGôTOôSTICKôWITHôCOFFEEôANDôTUNAôSANDWICHESôFORôTHEô TIMEôBEING

1UESTIONôFROMô*ANNA 1UESTIONôTOô0AULô"OWMAN ô 3OôINTERVIEWINGôISôAôWAYôOFôMAPPINGôTHATôOUT ôBUTôALSOôBRING INGôTHEMôINTOôCONVERSATIONôWITHôEACHôOTHER ô 7HATSôYOURôINVESTMENTôINôYOURôINTERVIEWEESôANDôWHATSô THEIRôINVESTMENTôINôYOUôANDôTHEIRôOWNôPRACTICES !NSWERôFROMô0AUL ô )ôTHINKôPEOPLEôLIKEôTOôTALKôABOUTôTHEMSELVESôYOURSELFôINCLUDEDô mô*ANNA ô.O ôYEAHôwôWELLôINôAôWAYôYOUREôALWAYSôTALKINGô

ABOUTôYOURSELFôIFô$ERRIDASôRIGHT ôINôAôSENSEôALLôYOUôCANôDO ô EVENôIFôYOURôTALKINGôABOUTôWHATEVER ôYOUREôALWAYSôTALKINGô ABOUTôYOURSELFô"UTôWHATô)VEôALWAYSôWANTEDôTOôDOôISôGETôANô ESSAYôORôAôSTATEMENTôORôAôPROPOSITION ôNOôMATTERôHOWôSHIT ô ACTUALLYôTHEôSHITTERôTHEôBETTERô4HENôSENDôTHATôSTATEMENTôTOô SOMEONEôELSEôTOôGETôTHEMôTOôWRITEôANôESSAYôONôITôANDôTHENô SENDôITôTOôSOMEONEôELSEô/RôDOôANôINTERVIEWôANDôTHENôPLAYôITô TOôSOMEONEôELSEôANDôGETôITôGOINGôTHATôWAYô"UTô)ôDONTôTHINKô PEOPLEôLIKEôTOôBEôPUTôUNDERôTHATôKINDôOFôPRESSUREô3AYôRIGHT ô HEREôISôAôDISCRETEôINTERVIEW ôNOTôABOUTôYOUôBUTôABOUTôTHATô THINGôTHATôYOU ôINSTEADôOFôRIGHTô8 ô9ôSAIDôTHISô9OUVEôGOTôALLô SORTSôOFôDIFFERENTôFRIENDSHIPSôANDôLOYALTIESôwô4RICKY ô ;!3)$%ôE MAILôWHILSTôWRITINGôTHISôESSAY= 1UESTIONôFROMô3USAN 1UESTIONôTOô*ANNAô'RAHAMôANDô0ETERô,ASCH ô (OWôTHEôHELLôSHOULDô)ôGOôABOUTôCITINGôAUTHORSôINôTHISôPIECE !NSWERôFROMô*ANNA ô 4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôISôPARTICULARLYôPERPLEXINGôONôTHEôQUES TIONôOFôAUTHORS ôGIVENôTHEôNUMBERôOFôAUTHORSôTHATôWEREô INVOLVEDôINôBOTHôITERATIONSôOFôTHEôPROJECTôwôANYONEôWHOô ASKED ôANSWERED ôANDôPOSSIBLYôEVENôTHOSEôWHOôWEREôASKEDô ANDôDIDNTôANSWERôWEREôAUTHORSôINôSOMEôWAYô4HISôKINDôOFô AUTHORSHIPôISôGENERATIVEôANDôGENEROUS ôITôkNDSôITSôROOTSôINô BOTHôFRIENDSHIPôANDôTHEôKINDôOFôHANDINGôOVERôOFôONESôAIR TIMEôTOôANOTHER ôANDôEGOôANôINTERESTôINôPUTTINGôONESôVOICEô ORôTHOUGHTôTOôRECORD ô)ôWONDERôIFôTHEREôWOULDôBEôAôWAYô OFôREPLICATINGôTHISôINôTHEôDIAGRAMômôAôWAYôOFôKEEPINGôTHEô INTERVIEWôMOVING ôTOôACKNOWLEDGEôTHOSEôWHOôHAVEôBEENô INVOLVEDôANDôBEôHOSPITABLEôTOôNEWôAUTHORS !NSWERôFROMô0ETER ô !GREEôMOSTLYôWITHô*ANNAôANDôCOULDNTôPHRASEôITôBETTERô!Sô USUAL ô)ôLIKEôTOôTHINKôOFôWHATôWEREôDOINGôINôTERMSôOFôGAMESô


ô"EAVERôCOLLECTIVEôWASôINVITEDôTOôSOMEHOWôREPRESENTôWHATô @WETHEYôDOôINôANôEXHIBITIONôINô7EIMAR ô'ERMANYôENTITLEDô@'ETô 2IDôOFô9OURSELFô4HEôEXHIBITIONôWASôALLôABOUTôCOLLECTIVEôANDôCOL LABORATIVEôPRACTICESôANDôCONTAINEDôFEWôPROPERôNAMESôOTHERôTHANô THOSEôOFôTHEô@COLLECTIVESôINVOLVEDô@'ETTINGôRIDôOFôYOURSELFôFORô THEôSAKEôOFôAôCOLLECTIVEôISNTôPERHAPSôASôSTRAIGHTFORWARDôASôTHEô SACRIkCIALôSYNTAXôWOULDôMAKEôITôAPPEARô,ANDYSôPROPOSITIONôINô HISôRESPONSEôTOô@WHATôISôTOôBEôDONEôOFô@CREATINGôSTRUCTURESôANDô STRUCTURINGôYOURSELFôWITHINôTHEMôREMAINSôAôCENTRALôCONCERNôFORô ANYôPROJECTôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONô'ETTINGôRIDôOFôYOURSELFôINô4HEô /PENô)NTERVIEWôISôANôAGREEMENTôTOôTAKEôUPôTEMPORARYôPOSITIONS ô TOôOPENôOUTôTHEôQUESTIONôTHROUGHôDE CENTRINGôTHEôANSWER ôAôTAK INGôAPARTôANDôCONSTANTôRE CONkGURATION ôGUIDEDôBYôTHEôQUESTIONô 4HEôVOICEôORGANISES ôISôORGANISED ôISôPASSEDôAROUND ôANDôLIKEô THEôACCENT ôSOMETIMESôGETSôDE CENTREDôANDôDISLOCATED


0240_057_self_org.indd 272-273

25/09/06 17:41:33

4HEREôISôAôTRICKYôBALANCEôWHENôYOUôASKôSOMEONEôIFôTHEYô WANTôTOôPLAYô4OOôMUCHôRESPECTôFORôAUTHORIALôORIGINSôCANô RUINôANYôKINDôOFôGAMEô!SôCONCERNSôME ôYOUôCANôCITEôMEô ORôNOTôCITEôME ô)MôkNEôWITHôBOTHô7HENô)ôWORKôCOLLABORA TIVELY ô)ôSTARTôWITHôTHEôASSUMPTIONôTHATôTHEôGESTUREôCOMESô WITHôAôCERTAINôWILLINGNESSôTOôGIVEôUPôCONTROLôANDôTHISôISôTHEô STRENGTHôOFôITô(OWEVER ôWEôALLôKNOWôTHATôARTôISôBASICALLYôAô BIGôVANITYôTOURNAMENT ôSOô)ôWOULDôASSUMEôTHEôSAFESTôTHINGôISô TOôLETôTHEôLISTôGROWô4OôME ôTHEôGROWINGôLISTôOFôAUTHORSôISôAES THETICALLYôPLEASING ôPOLITICALLYôRELEVANT ôSOCIALLYôWELCOMING ô ANDôITôALSOôHASôTHEôADDEDôADVANTAGEôOFôSCARINGôAWAYôTHEô RIDICULUMôVITAEôFOLKôWHOôAREôSOMEWHATôDISAPPOINTEDôBYôNOTô kNDINGôTHEIRôBIGôBOLDôNAMEôONôTHEôPUBLICATIONSôHEADINGô!ô PHRASEô)ôkNDôAPPEALINGôANDôNOTôTOOôRESTRICTIVEôISôTHEôIDEAôOFô ANôINDIVIDUALôORôAôGROUPô@INITIATINGôSOMETHINGô@#ONCEIVED ô INVENTED ôDESIGNED ôRUNSôTHEôDANGERôOFôCLOSINGôTHINGSôOFFô ANDôADDINGôTHEôLANGUAGEôOFôBABY MAKINGôANDôCAPITALISMô TOôAôPROCESSôWHICHôONLYôWORKSôIFôITSôSOCIALô(AVEôYOUôREADô ,EVINASô@0ROPERô.AMES

1UESTIONôFROMô8 1UESTIONôTOô/PENôô!DRIANô2IFKIN ô (OWôLONGôCANôYOUôHOLDôYOURôBREATH

!NSWERôFROMô3USAN ô,YNN ô*ANNAôANDô*EN ô /+ ôTHISôISô3USAN ô,YNN ô*ANNAôANDô*EN ôHOLDINGôORôBREATHSô w ôwôOHôCRAP ôSTARTôOVER ô /+ ôTHISôISôTAKEôTWOôONôHOLDINGôOURôBREATHô3USAN ô*EN ô ,YNN ô*ANNAôwô ôwô,AUGHS ô 7HATSôTHATôSOUNDô,AUGHS ô4HERESôAôLOTôOFôHOTôAIRôONôTHISô HOTôAIRôTAPEô7EREôGOINGôTOôTRYôONEôMOREôTIMEô(AVEôYOUô GOTôTHEôSTOPWATCHô3USANô/+ôwô !NSWERôFROMô!DRIANô2IFKIN ô !NSWERôTOôYOURôQUESTIONôISôNOTôLONGô!ôGENERICôANSWERôTOôAô GENERICôQUESTION ôABOUTôSOMETHINGôTHATôWHICHôINôFACTôCAN NOTôBEôMEASURED ôABOUTôSOMETHINGôTHATôHASôNOôSPECIkCô LENGTH ôALTHOUGHôHASôRELATIVEôLENGTH ôALTHOUGHôSOMEôPEOPLEô CANôDOôITôFORôLONGERôTHANôOTHERSô4HERESôAôPIECEôTHATô#OR NELIUSô#ARDORYôWROTEôFORô*OHNô4ILBURYôCALLEDô@6OLO3OLO ôINô WHICHôTHEôINSTRUCTIONôISôTOôPLAYôITôASôFASTôASôPOSSIBLEôANDôOFô COURSEôASôFASTôASôPOSSIBLEôHASôNOôLENGTHôATôALLô3OôTHESEôAREô RELATEDôPROBLEMS 1UESTIONôFROMô!DRIANô2IFKIN 1UESTIONôTOô*ULIANô(AMMOND ô (OWôMUCHôDOôYOUôLOVEô%LVISô4HISôINôAôSENSEôISôVENGEANCEô FORôTHEôQUESTIONSôJUSTôASKEDôTOôMEômôHOWôLONGôCANôYOUôHOLDô YOURôBREATHô3OôHOWôMUCHôDOôYOUôLOVEô%LVIS !NSWERôFROMô*ULIAN ô 4HISôISô*ULIANôANSWERINGô!DRIANSôQUESTIONô(OWôMUCHôDOô)ô LOVEô%LVISô)ôTHINKôTHATô)ôLOVEô%LVISôMOREôTHANôITôWOULDôTAKEôFORô MEôTOôCONTAINôTHEôBREATHôTOôSAYôHOWôMUCHô)ôLOVEô%LVISôANDô THATô)ôALSOôLOVEôHIMôMOREôTHANôTHEREôAREôNOTôENOUGHôWORDSôTOô EXPRESSô7HATôORôHOWôMYôLOVEôISôOFô%LVISô)TSôNOTôASôSIMPLEôASô SAYING ô@THEREôAREôNOTôWORDSôENOUGHô)TôISôTHATôALLôTHEôWORDSô PUTôTOGETHERôWOULDôNOTôFULLYôCIRCUMSCRIBEôHOWô)ôLOVEô%LVIS ô HOWôMUCHô)ôLOVEô%LVISô3O ôTHEôSHORTôANSWERôISôAôLOT


!SôWITHôTHEôINVITATIONôTOô"EAVERôTOôREPLICATEô@WHATôWEôDO ô THEôPROCESSôOFôWRITINGôABOUTô4HEô/PENô)NTERVIEWôCANôNEVERôBEô ANYTHINGôMOREôTHANôAôSTAGING ôAôTRACING ôPERHAPSôAôRE CONkGU RATIONôOFôSOMEôOFôTHEôVOICES ôRE ENACTEDôWITHôAôCERTAINôkDELITYô TOôTHEôPROCESSôITSELFô4HEô@MATERIAL ôTHEôVOICES ôQUESTIONSôANDô RESPONSESôAREôORGANISEDôPARTLYôACCORDINGôTOôTHEôLOGICôOFôWHATô ISôSAIDôANDôPARTLYôINôACCORDANCEôWITHôTHEôSTRUCTURESôANDôDE VICESôTHROUGHôWHICHôTHEYôSPEAKô


0240_057_self_org.indd 274-275

25/09/06 17:41:34

1UESTIONôFROMô*ULIANô(AMMOND 1UESTIONôTOô*OHNô-OWITT ô /NCEôMUSICôGETSôINSIDEôTHEôHEAD ôHAVINGôGONEôUNDERNEATHô THEôSKINôORôINSIDEôTHEôEAR ôWHEREôDOESôITôTRAVELôTOôANDôDOESô ITôEVERôENDôUPôANYWHERE !NSWERôFROMô*OHNô-OWITT ô 5Môwô)ôMEANôTHEôISSUEôOFôTHEôDESTINATIONôOFôAôPIECEôOFô MUSICôOFôAôPIECEôOFôSOUNDôISôASôCOMPLICATEDôASôTHEôTHEMEô OFôDESTINATIONôINôRELATIONôTOôTHEôPROBLEMôOFôTHEôLETTER ôOFôTHEô SIGNIkER ôOFôTHEôCHAINôOFôSIGNIkCATIONô7HETHERôUNDERSTOODô LINGUISTICALLYôORôNOT ôASôYOUôKNOW ôPARTôOFôTHEôMEDIUMôOFô COMMUNICATIONô#ANô) ôANDôITôSEEMSôTOôMEôMANYôINTERESTINGô THINGS ôTHISôNEUROBIOLOGICALôWORKôBEINGôDONEôOFôCOGNITIONô ANDôSOUNDôRETENTIONôANDôWHATNOT ôTHATôITôHASôDEVELOPEDô AôKINDôOFôMODELôFORôTHINKINGôABOUTôDESTINATIONôTHATôPLACESô ATôITSôVERYôCENTREôAôLACK ôANôABSENCE ôAôHOLE ôTHATôPOROUSô kGUREôWEôHAVEôDISCUSSEDôTHEôOTHERôDAYô)NôANYôCASEô)ôTHINKô THATôWHATôTHATôBELIESôISôAôSENSEôINôWHICHôTHEôPRECISIONôOFô LOCATION ôOFôTHEôWHEREôSOUNDôGOESôTHATôEVENôINôTHEôMOSTô PRECISEôDESCRIPTIONôOFôTHEôORGANôOFôRECEPTIONôHASôTOôINCLUDEô THEREôAôCERTAINôKINDôOFôACKNOWLEDGEMENTôTHATôANYôPOSSIBILITYô OFôCONSTRUALôOFôTHEôLOCATIONôOFôTHEôDESTINATIONôISôlAWED ôISô LIMITEDôINôAôDECISIVEôWAYô.OWôTHEôISSUEôISôREALLYôTHATôTHEô EFFECTôOFôTHEôMODELLINGôOFôHOWôTOôEXPLAINôTHISôOR ôAREôWEô REALLYôTRYINGôTOôSAYôTHATôSOUNDôTRAVELSôTOWARDSôWHATô&REUDô CALLEDôTHEôNAVELôOFôTHEôDREAMômôTHEôPOINTôATôWHICHôTHEôBODYô ANDôTHEôMINDôAREôSOôKNOTTEDôTHATôYOUôCANTôkGUREôOUTôWHATô DESTINATIONôEVENôMEANS ôATôTHATôPOINTô 1UESTIONôFROMô*OHNô-OWITT 1UESTIONôTOô/PEN ô 4HISôISôONEôFORôEVERYONEô)ôPROMISEDô)ôWOULDôASKôIT ôSOô)ô SHOULDôANDôITôISô7HOôWANTSôTOô+NOW

&ORô.ANCY ôCOMMUNITYôISôAôSPACEôOFôSINGULARITIESôANDô)SôWHOô AREôALWAYSôOTHERSô)Nô7ALTERô"ENJAMINSôESSAYô@4HEô3TORYTELLER ô THEôCONCERNôFORôCOMMUNICATIONôANDôFORôCOMMUNICABILITYôITSELFô ISôARTICULATEDôTHROUGHôTHEôSCENEôOFôSTORYTELLING ôAôPARTICULARô SITUATIONôINôWHICHôKNOWLEDGEôISôPASSEDôONôINôAôCOMPLEXôANDô EMBEDDEDôRELAYôACROSSôTIMEôANDôSPACEô4AKINGô*OHANNô(EBELSô STORIESôASôANôEXAMPLE ô"ENJAMINôTRACESôTHEôROLEôOFô@THEôRIGHT EOUSôMANôASôITôOCCURSôINôVARIOUSôSTORIESô)NôEACHôCASE ôNOôONEô ISôUPôTOôTHISôROLE ôANDôSOôITôGETSôPASSEDôAROUNDô4HISôPASSINGô AROUNDôOFôTHEôROLEôOPENSôAôSPACEôTHATôIMPLICATESôTHEôLISTENER ô ASôTHEôRIGHTEOUSôMANôPOTENTIALLYôENCOUNTERSôHIMSELFôASôSOMEONEô ELSEô&ORô"ENJAMIN ôASôFORô.ANCY ôTHEREôWOULDôSEEMôTOôBEôANô ETHICSôASSOCIATEDôWITHôTHEôSHIFTINGôPRONOUN ôWHEREôCOMMUNI CATION ôCOMMUNICABILITYôANDôULTIMATELYôCOMMUNITYôCANôONLYôBEô PREDICATEDôONôTHISôPARTICULARôSHIFTINGôSUBJECT IN RELATIONô4HEô@)ô WHOôISôALWAYSôANOTHERôANDôTHEôPROCESSôOFôBUMPINGôINTOôYOURSELFô ASôSOMEONEôELSEôORôINDEED ôMEETINGôYOURSELFôCOMINGôBACK ôISô AôDE CENTRING ôPERHAPSôEVENôAôSINGULARISINGôPROCESS ôTHATôCANô ONLYôHAPPENôWHENôTHEREôISôAôDIFFERENTôNOTIONôOFôTHEôSELFôATôWORKô môANDôWHENôTHEREôISôMOREôTHANôONEô"ENJAMINSôkGUREôOFôTHEô STORYTELLERôBECOMESôAôMODEôTHROUGHôWHICHôHEôCANôADDRESSô WHATôHEôCONSIDERSôTOôBEôCRUCIALôISSUESôOFôTHEôCOMMUNICABILITYô OFôEXPERIENCEôANDôTHEôPASSINGôONôOFôHISTORYôITSELFô)NôTHEôSCENEô OFôSTORYTELLING ôAôFORMôOFôKNOWLEDGEôISôEMBEDDEDôTHROUGHôAô SENSEôOFôDUTY ôkDELITYôANDôULTIMATELY ôETHICSô



0240_057_self_org.indd 276-277

*OHNô-OWITTSôQUESTIONôINôTHEôTITLEôOFôTHISôESSAY ô@7HOôWANTSôTOô KNOWôECHOESô'AYATRIô3PIVAKSôASSERTIONôTHATôPOLITICSôISôNEVERô AôQUESTIONôOFôWHOôWILLôSPEAK ôBUTôOFôWHOôWILLôLISTENô4HEôLIMITA TIONSôOFôTHISôVOLUNTARYôRELATIONôBETWEENôLISTENERôANDôSPEAKERôAREô CLEARôINô@4HEô3TORYTELLERôANDôINô-OWITTSôOWNôPAPERôDELIVEREDôATô THEôWARPWOOFôCONFERENCEô-OWITTôREFERSôTOô"ENJAMINSôESSAYô

25/09/06 17:41:34

ONô-ARCELô0ROUST ôWHEREôTHEô@WOOFôOFôFORGETTINGôANDôTHEô@WARPô OFôREMEMBERINGôAREôRELATEDôTOôTHEôWORKôOFôINVOLUNTARYôMEMORYô -OWITTôCONTENDSôTHATôWHENôCONSIDERINGôTHEôSOCIALôPRODUCTIONô OFôCRITICALôCONSCIOUSNESS ôEXPERIENCESôTHATôMAYôBEôPOLITICIS ABLE ôAREôONLYôSOôTHROUGHôTHEIRôSTRUCTURALôCHARACTER ôNOTôTHROUGHô VOLUNTARYôDECISIONSôTOôMAKEôTHEMôSOô@%XPERIENCEôBECOMESô POLITICISABLEô;w=ôNOTôASôAôRESULTôOFôAôDECISIONôTOôBRINGôITôABOUTô -OWITT ô ô&ORô0ROUSTôANDô-OWITT ôTHEREôISôAôCOLLECTIVEô LATENTôINôALLôENDURINGôEXPERIENCESô%NDURINGôEXPERIENCESôLEAVEô TRACESôINôTHEôPRESENTôINôTHEôFORMôOFôINVOLUNTARYôMEMORIESô3O ô RATHERôTHANôTHEôDECISIVEôPRODUCTIONôOFôAôCONSCIOUSNESSôTHATô CANôBEôPOLITICALLYôDEPLOYED ôFORô"ENJAMIN ôTHISôMEMORYôISôTHEô LOCUSôOFôWHATôISôPOLITICISABLEô4HESEôOBSERVATIONSôMAYôTHENô SPEAKôTOôAôNOTIONôOFôCOLLECTIVITY ôWHEREôAôSHAREDôSTRUCTUREôOFô THOUGHTôANDôKNOWINGôISôEMBEDDEDôINôRELATIONSôNOTôBETWEENô DISCRETEôINDIVIDUALS ôBUTôBETWEENôTHEôSINGULARITIESôANDô)SôWHOô AREôALWAYSôOTHERSô 4HEôANSWERôTOôTHEôQUESTION ô@7HOôWANTSôTOôKNOWôTHEN ôCOULDô NEVERôBEôAôSIMPLEôLISTôOFô@CONCERNEDôLISTENERSôORôAôDELINEATIONô OFôWHYôITôWOULDôBEôRIGHTôANDôPROPERôFORôCERTAINôPEOPLEôTOôKNOWô ORôBEôTOLDôCERTAINôTHINGSô4HEôANSWERôWOULDôHAVEôTOôPRACTISEô AôRESPONSEôONôTHEôLEVELôOFôTHEôSTRUCTURAL ôWHEREôTHEôRELATION SHIPôBETWEENôSPEAKERSôANDôLISTENERSôISôRE ORGANISEDôANDôWHEREô ANôALTEREDôCONCEPTôOFôKNOWLEDGEôISôINôOPERATIONôTOôAôDEGREEô WHEREô-OWITTSôQUESTIONôWOULDôNOôLONGERôMAKEôSENSEô4HEô /PENô)NTERVIEWôPLAYSôINôAôMODESTôWAYôWITHôTHESEôSTRUCTURESô OFôKNOWLEDGE ôDESIREôANDôTHEôROLESôANDôSUBJECTIVITIESôOFôTHEô @WHOôTHATôADDRESSESôANDôISôADDRESSEDô4HEôCONCRETEôPROCESSô OFôGENERATINGôANOTHERôQUESTIONôFROMôANôANSWERôPRODUCESôOPENô STRUCTURESôOFôPOTENTIALôCOMMUNITYôWHEREôTHEôRESPONSEôOFôTHEô RESPONDENTôISôINEXTRICABLYôLINKEDôTOôAôBROADERôRESPONSIBILITYôANDô


0240_057_self_org.indd 278-279

kDELITYôTOôAôCOMMUNITYôOFôLISTENERSôANDôSPEAKERSôINTERESTEDôINô MAINTAININGôTHEôQUESTIONô!LTERINGôTHEôSITUATIONSôANDôSTRUCTURESô WITHINôWHICHôCOMMUNICATIONôCANôTAKEôPLACE ôASôWELLôASôWORKINGô WITHôANôALTEREDôNOTIONôOFôTHEô@SELFôMUSTôBEôCENTRALôTOôANôETHICSô OFôCOMMUNITYôINôWHICHôTHEôQUESTIONôCANôBEôMAINTAINED ôORôATô LEAST ôISôNOTôALWAYSôALREADYôANSWEREDô4HISôISôWHATôISôTENTATIVELYô PROPOSEDôASôAôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEôQUESTION )NôAôCRITIQUEôOFô%MPIRE ô/LIVERô-ARCHARTSôESSAYô@4HEô#ROSSEDô 0LACEôOFôTHEô0OLITICALô0ARTYôSTATESôTHATôTHEORIESôOFôSELF ORGANI SATIONôANDôTRANSVERSALITYôINôNOôWAYôADDRESSôTHEôCENTRALôQUES TIONôOFôCONTEMPORARYôPOLITICALôMOVEMENTSôTHEôPROBLEMôOFôTHEô FORMôOFôORGANISATIONô4HEôGRAMMARôOFô-ARCHARTSôARGUMENT ô @THEôCOLLECTIVEôMUSTôBEôORGANISEDôWORKSôTOôBOLSTERôHISôCONTEN TIONôTHATôTHEôMULTITUDEôCANNOTôSPONTANEOUSLYôBECOMEôPOLITI CALLYôORGANISEDô-ARCHARTôARGUESôTHATôWHATôISôTOôBEôDONE ôISôTOô @SEARCHôFORôNEWôORGANISATIONAL ôFORMSôOFôPROGRESSIVEôDE INDI VIDUALISATIONô4HEôCOMMUNITYôOFôTHEôQUESTIONôWOULDôRARELYôUSEô SUCHôGRAMMARôORôPLACEôSUCHôQUESTIONSôOFôORGANISATIONôONôTHEô OUTSIDEô(OWEVER ôITôWOULDôALSOôBEôWARYôOFôOVERLYôORGANICISEDô MODELSôOFôORGANISATIONôTHATôELIDEôTHEôPRODUCTIONôOFôSTRUCTURESô ANDôAGENTSôOFôCONTINGENCYô9ETô-ARCHARTSôLARGERôPOINTôABOUTô THEôPOLITICALôRELEVANCEôANDôEFkCACYôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôASôAô FORMôOFôCONTEMPORARYôPOLITICALôORGANISATIONôISôCRUCIALô)TôISôCLEARô ISôTHATôUNLESSôFORMSôOFôPOLITICALôORGANISATIONôTAKEôONôBOARDôAô GRAMMARôOFôORGANISATONôTHATôDOESNTôRELYôONôAôKINDôOFôVOLUNTAR ISM ôANDôDOESNTôSEPARATEôGRANDERôPOLITICALôQUESTIONSôFROMôTHEô MICROPOLITICSôOFôCOLLECTIVEôSELVES ôTHEYôAREôLIKELYôTOôREMAINôWEAKô ALTERNATIVESôANDôWEAKôOPPONENTSôOFôDOMINANTôPOLITICALôFORMS


25/09/06 17:41:34

3UPERCHANNELô4ENANTSPIN $ESCRIPTION g)-ô./ô0!8-!.ô/2ô+),2/9 ô"54ô)-ô$/).'ô)4u 3TEVEô4HOMAS ô#HILDWALL ô4ENANTSô0RESENTERô 4EXT 4ENANTSPINôISôAôWEBCASTôCHANNELôWITHôLIVEôCHAT ROOMôFACILITYôTHATôENABLESôEXCLUDEDô CITIZENSôTOôPARTAKEôINôDEMOCRATICôANDôCULTURALôPROCESSESô)TôWASôDEVELOPEDôANDôPRO DUCEDôBYôTHEôTENANTSôINô,IVERPOOLSôOLDESTôTOWERôBLOCK ô#ORONATIONô#OURTômôAôHIGH RISEô SOCIALôHOUSINGôPROJECTôWHOSEôRESIDENTS ôMOSTLYôOVERôôYEARSôOLDôWEREôTRAINEDôINô STUDIOôMANAGEMENTôANDôTHEôTECHNICALôASPECTSôOFôPRODUCTION ô

3TARTEDôASôAôSIX MONTHôPROJECTôINôôITôISôSTILLôRUNNINGôANDôHASôBUILTôUPôANôONLINEô

ARCHIVEôOFôUNMEDIATEDôONE HOURôCULTURALôANDôPOLITICALôDISCUSSIONSôTHATôCHALLENGEôANDô CONFRONTôQUESTIONSôOFôSOCIALôEXCLUSION ôE DEMOCRACY ôTOP DOWNôCULTUREôANDôCROSS GENERATIONALôDEBATEô4ENANTSPINôWEBCASTSôHOURômôLONGôSHOWSôONCEôAôWEEK ôLOOKINGô ATôISSUESôSUCHôASôRENTôINCREASES ôRESIDENTPARTICIPATIONôANDôTECHNOLOGY ôLANDLORDS ô DEMOLITION ôTHEôBUILTôENVIRONMENT ôHIGHôRISEôLIVING ôREGENERATIONôANDôBEANSôONôTOASTô 3OURCEô WWWTENANTSPINORGABOUTABOUT?TENANTSPINHTM &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWSUPERCHANNELORG(OME0ROkLE#HANNELS30). WWWTENANTSPINORG 4ENANTSPINôISôCO MANAGEDôBYô&!#4ô&OUNDATIONôFORô!RTôô#REATIVEô4ECHNOLOGY ô ô,IVERPOOLô(OUSINGô!CTIONô4RUSTôANDô!RENAô(OUSINGô!SSOCIATION ôANDôWASôCREATEDô INôCONJUNCTIONôWITHôTHEô$ANISHôARTISTSôGROUPô3UPERlEXôWWWSUPERlEXNET ô3EANô 4READWAYôANDôTHEô3UPERCHANNELôCOMMUNITYôWWWSUPERCHANNELORG

0240_057_self_org.indd 280-281

%XAMPLESôôYôô0RMBO@E>KKBI ñ1BK>KQPMFK

25/09/06 17:41:36

$IGITALô PROMISESô 4HEôFUTUREôOFô INFORMATIONô SOCIETIESôANDô TWOôTYPESô OFôSOCIALô ORGANISATIONô 4EREô6AD¯N


0240_057_self_org.indd 282-283

4HEôFUTUREôOFôINFORMATIONôSOCIETIESôANDôTWOôTYPESôOFôSOCIALôORGANISATION

25/09/06 17:41:36

!BSTRACTô$IFFERENTôTYPESôOFôVOLUNTEERôORGANISATIONSôWORKINGô INôANDôTHROUGHôTHEô)NTERNETôHAVEôBEENôSEENôASôNEWôFORMSôOFô SOCIALôSELF ORGANISATIONôANDôSELF MANAGEMENTôTHATôRESULTôINô NEWôPOLITICALôPOSSIBILITIESôANDôAGENDASô,IKEWISE ôTHEôNATUREô OFôDIGITALôINFORMATIONôASôAôNON SCARCEôRESOURCEôHASôLENTôIN FORMATIONôSOCIETIESôAôRADICALLYôDIFFERENTôNATUREôFROMôPREVIOUSô SOCIALôFORMATIONSô(OWEVER ôGIVENôTHEôCURRENTôFORMSôOFôECO NOMICôPRODUCTIONôANDôCORPORATEôMARKETS ôTHEôLIBERATINGôANDô DEMOCRATICôPOTENTIALôOFôDIGITALôINFORMATIONôISôCOUNTERACTEDôBYô THEôCONCENTRATIONôOFôMEDIAôOWNERSHIP ôASôWELLôASôBYôPOLICY ô LEGISLATION ôANDôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôPROPRIETARYôFORMSôOFôTECH NOLOGYô4HEôNOTIONôOFôgINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYuôPRODUCESôARTIkCIALô SCARCITYôWHEREôDIGITALôTECHNOLOGYôCOULDôREMOVEôITô4HISôTENSIONô BETWEENôTHEôPROPRIETARYôANDôNON PROPRIETARYôASPECTSôOFôTHEô INFORMATIONôSOCIETYôCANôBEôANALYSEDôBYôLOOKINGôATôTWOôTYPESô OFôKNOWLEDGEôCREATIONSôORGANISATIONALôANDôDISORGNISATIONALô 7HILEôORGANISATIONALôKNOWLEDGEôWORKôCANôBENEkTôFROMôAôNOTIONô OFôgINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYu ôDISORGANISATIONALôKNOWLEDGEôWORKôISô DISRUPTEDôIFôNOTôDESTROYEDôBYôPROPRIETARYôBARRIERSôONôINFORMA TIONô4HISôISôUNFORTUNATEôIFôANDôWHENôTHEôCRUCIALôINNOVATIONSôANDô ETHICALôPOTENTIALôOFôTHEôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYôAREôCONNECTEDôTOô DISORGANISATIONALôCOMMUNITIES ôEVENôTHOUGHôTHEôORGANISATIONALô TYPEôISôMOREôVISIBLEôANDôBETTERôREPRESENTEDôINôTHEôTRADITIONALô STRUCTURESôOFôSOCIETYô +EYWORDSôDISORGANISATIONS ôFREEôSOFTWARE ôINFORMATIONôSOCIETY ô INTELLECTUALôPROPERTY ôKNOWLEDGEôCREATION ôUTOPIAô ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 284-285

4HEôDIGITALôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYô ANDôPOSTMODERNôPHILOSOPHYô 4HEôCONCEPTôOFôTHEôDIGITALôCONTAINSôAôPLETHORAôOFôHOPESôANDô FEARSô!ôNEWôWAYôOFôgDIGITALôBEINGuôISôTHOUGHTôTOôPROMPTôTHEô NEEDôFORôNEWôDIGITALôONTOLOGIESôANDôEPISTEMOLOGIES ôWHILEôRE SULTINGôINôNOVELôETHICALôDILEMMASô#ORRESPONDINGLY ôONôTHEôLEVELô OFôSOCIALôORGANISATION ôTHEôDIGITALôISôSEENôASôAôTORCHBEARERôOFô NEWôFORMSôOFôORGANISATIONôTHATôHAVEôRADICALôPOLITICALôIMPLICA TIONSô6OLUNTEERôHACKERôORGANISATIONS ôFREEôANDôOPENôSOURCEô SOFTWAREôCOMMUNITIES ôVARYINGôAPPLICATIONSôOFôTHEôOPENôSOURCEô MODELôINôOTHERôAREASô7IKIPEDIA ôOPENôSOURCEôDEMOCRACY ôOPENô SOURCEôCURRICULA ôETC ôANDôTHEôORGANISATIONôOFôVARIOUSôCIVILôAC TIVITIESôTHROUGHôTHEô)NTERNETôHAVEôBEENôSEEN ôONôONEôHAND ôTOô PROVIDEôNEWôBLOODôFORôTHEô(ABERMASIANôIDEALôOFôDEMOCRATICô COMMUNICATIONô/NôTHEôOTHERôHAND ôTHEYôAREôALSOôSEENôASôCOM PLETELYôNEWôFORMSôOFôCIVICôSELF ORGANISATIONôANDôSELF MANAGE MENTôFORôHACKERôCOMMUNITIESôANDôTHEORIESôOFôTHEM ôSEEô#AS TELLSô ô(IMANENô ô$I"ONAôETôALô ô7HILEôLOOKINGô FORôEXAMPLESôOFôTHEôNEWôMULTITUDESôTHATôTHEYôADVOCATEôASôTHEô BASICôSELF ORGANISINGôMODELSôOFôFUTUREôPOLITICS ô-ICHAELô(ARDTô ANDô!NTONIOô.EGRIô ôPôFF ôTURNôTOôFREEôANDôOPENôSOURCEô COMMUNITIESôANDôRELATEDôACTIVITIESô7HENôTHEôSELF ORGANISATIONALô NATUREôOFôHACKERôCOMMUNITIESôISôCOMBINEDôWITHôTHEôOBSERVATIONô THATôDIGITALôCODEôISôNOTôINHERENTLYôAôSCARCEôRESOURCEôBUTôCANôBEô READILYôCOPIEDôANDôDISTRIBUTEDôWITHôCLOSEôTOôZEROôCOST ôWEôGETô AôCYBERCOMMUNISTôUTOPIA ôINôWHICHôVOLUNTEERôORGANISATIONSôAREô ABLEôTOôMANAGEôTHEMSELVESôINôAôPOST SCARCITYôECONOMYôSEE ôFORô INSTANCE ôTHEôDISCUSSIONSôINô:IZEKô ô ô ô 4HEôSO CALLEDôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYôNECESSITATESôAôRESTRUC TURINGôOFôMODESôOFôPRODUCTION ôINCLUDINGôTHEôSETôOFôBELIEFSôTHATô


25/09/06 17:41:36

Aô CCOMPANYôORôSUSTAINôTHEôNECESSARYôSOCIALôANDôECONOMICô STRUCTURESô/NEôOFôTHEôCORNERSTONESôOFôTHISôSETôOFôBELIEFSôISôTHEô gCYBERNETICuôIDEA ôWHICHôCLAIMSôTHATôSOMEôKINDôOFôINFORMATIONô ORôCODEôISôTHEôBASICôONTOLOGICALôLEVELôTHATôGUARANTEESôBOTHô THEôEXPLANATIONôANDôCONTROLôOFôALLôPHENOMENAô4HISôCYBERNETICô IDEALôINCLUDES ôAMONGôOTHERS ôTHEôBELIEFSôTHATôTHEôFUNCTIONSôOFôAô COMPUTERôAREôBASEDôONôCODE ôTHATôHUMANôTHINKINGôISôBASICALLYô SOMEôSORTôOFôINFORMATIONôPROCESSINGômôMAYBEôOFôAôSELF ORGAN IZINGôKINDômôANDôTHATôTHEôSTRUCTUREôOFôBIOLOGICALôORGANISMSôIS ôINô THEôLASTôINSTANCE ôBASEDôONôCODE ôORô$.!ô!SPECTSôOFôHUMANô LIFEôAREôUNDERSTOODôANDôOPERATIONALISEDôASôIFôTHEYôWEREôULTI MATELYôINFORMATIONôPROCESSINGôACCORDINGôTOôAôCODIkEDôSYSTEMô OFôREPRESENTATIONSô4HUS ôTHINKINGôISôSEENôASôTHEôPROCESSINGôOFô REPRESENTATIONSôACCORDINGôTOôTHEôABSTRACTEDôFORMôOFôTHEôREPRE SENTATIONSô4HEôFORMôANDôFUNCTIONôOFôAôBIOLOGICALôORGANISMôSUP POSEDLYôRESIDEôINôTHEô$.!ôCODEôANDôTHEôWAYSôITôISôgREADuô%VENô SOCIALôSKILLSôANDôCOPINGôINôTHEôWORLDôAREôTHOUGHTôTOôBEôINCLUDEDô INôPRACTISESôANDôAGREEMENTSôTHATôCANôBEôFORMALLYôREPRESENTEDô g#YBERNETICSuôINôTHISôSENSEôISôNOTôONLYôAôSCIENTIkCôWAYôOFôLOOK INGôATôTHEôWORLDôANDôEXPLAININGôPHENOMENAôASôIFôTHEYôWEREô BASICALLYôALGORITHMIC ôITôISôALSOôANôECONOMICôANDôSOCIALôPRINCIPLEô OFôORGANISATIONô )F ôANDôAS ôINFORMATIONôANDôKNOWLEDGEôAREôQUICKLYôGAININGôIMPOR TANCEôASôTHEôMEANSôANDôENDSôOFôPRODUCTIONôINôTHEôINFORMATIONô SOCIETY ôITôISôBECOMINGôCLEARôTHATôTHEôCYBERNETICôIDEALôISôCLOSELYô COUPLEDôWITHôTHEôOWNERSHIPôOFôINFORMATIONôANDôCONCEPTSôSUCHô ASôgINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYuô4HESEôIDEASôAREôPERTINENTôINôAôWORLDô INôWHICHôECONOMICôPRODUCTIONôISôDEPENDENTôONôINTANGIBLESô 4HEôCONCEPTôOFôgINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYuôHASôBEENôEMPLOYEDôASôAô WAYôOFôCONTROLLINGôANDôCOLONISINGôTHEôNEWôPRODUCTIONôITôISôES SENTIALLYôUSEDôTOôWIDENôDIGITALôDIVIDESô4WOôTHINGSôAREôNEEDEDô


0240_057_self_org.indd 286-287

TOôSUSTAINôTHISôPROCESSôkRST ôAôBELIEFôINôTHEôEXISTENCEôOFôCODEô môAôBELIEFôTHATôgCODEuôISôTHEôRIGHTôDESCRIPTIONôOFôTHEôFUNCTIONSô OFôBIOLOGICAL ôTECHNOLOGICAL ôSOCIALôORôPSYCHOLOGICALôSYSTEMSô 3ECOND ôAôBELIEFôTHATôTHEôCODEôCANôANDôSHOULDôBEôOWNEDômôTHATô ITôSHOULDôBEôTREATEDôASôPROPERTYô4HISôDOUBLE BINDôCREATESôANô INCREASINGLYôCOMMODIkEDôSOCIETYô )TôISôESSENTIALôTOôNOTEôTHATôTHESEôPROCESSESôANDôTHEôCONCEPTSô BEHINDôTHEMômôgCODEu ôgDIGITALu ôgPROPERTYuômôAREôHISTORICALLYôANDô SOCIALLYôCONTINGENTô4HEôKINDôOFôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYôTHATôISôTOô COMEôDEPENDSôINôPARTôONôHOWôTHESEôCONCEPTSôAREôUNDERSTOODô ANDôEMPLOYEDô/NEôOFôTHEôMOSTôPROMINENTôTHEMESôINôTHôCEN TURYôPHILOSOPHYôVIEWEDôTECHNOLOGYôNOTôASôAôNEUTRALôTOOLôBUTôASô INHERENTLYôINTEREST LADENô4HEôINTERESTINGôQUESTIONSôABOUTôTECH NOLOGY ôINCLUDINGôINFORMATIONôTECHNOLOGY ôCANôONLYôBEôFORMEDô WHENôTHEôSTRUCTURESôOFôPOWERôAREôANALYSED ôINôCOMBINATIONô WITHôTHEôINSIGHTôTHATôTECHNOLOGYôISôNOTôONEôTHINGôITôISôNOTôONEô IDENTIkABLEôWHOLEôWITHôAôLASTINGôESSENCEôORôDRIVEôLEADINGôTOô PARTICULARôFORMATIONSôOFôSOCIETYôg4HEôSAMEuôKINDôOFôTECHNOLOGYô WITHôITSôFORMSôANDôUSESôMAYôBENEkTôTHISôGROUPôOFôPEOPLEôTODAY ô ANDôANOTHERôGROUPôOFôPEOPLEôORôgFORMôOFôLIFEuôTOMORROWô3OôTHEô QUESTIONSôBECOMEôMOREôCONCRETEôWHATôFORMATIONSôOFôPOWER ô COMMUNITY ôSUBJECTIVITY ôETCôDOôPARTICULARôUSESôOFôTECHNOLOGYô SUPPORT ôNEED ôPRESUPPOSEôORôUNDERMINEô


25/09/06 17:41:36

4HEô3IXTHô3ECTION $ESCRIPTIONô !ôDOCUMENTARYôABOUTô-EXICANôIMMIGRANTSôORGANIZINGôACROSSôBORDERS 4EXT -EXICANôIMMIGRANTSô/RGANIZINGô!CROSSô"ORDERS !LEXô2IVERASô4HEô3IXTHô3ECTIONôTELLSôAôCONTEMPORARYôSTORYôTHATôREVEALSôAôNEWôPERSPEC TIVEôONô-EXICANôMIGRANTôLABORôLIFEô2IVERAôANDôCO PRODUCERô"ERNARDOô2UIZôFOLLOWEDô*OS¯ô 'ARCIA ôAôYOUNGôMANôFROMôTHEôSMALLô-EXICANôTOWNôOFô"OQUERONô'ARCIAôDECIDEDôTOôLEAVEô TOôSUPPORTôHISôWIFEôANDôFAMILY ôCOMINGôTOôTHEô53ôHIDDENôINôTHEôTRUNKôOFôAôCARô/NCEô HERE ôHEôMOVEDôTOô.EWBURGH ô.EWô9ORK ôANDôFOUNDôMUCHôMOREôTHANôAôJOBômôHEôSAWôTHATô HEôCOULDôUSEôHISôOWNôLABORôINô!MERICAôTOôRELIEVEôTHEôSTARKôPOVERTYôOFôHISôHOMETOWN ô

)Nô.EWBURGH ô'ARCIAôBEGANôSPEAKINGôTOôOTHERSôABOUTôANôIDEAômôEVENTUALLYôOVERô

ôPEOPLEôFROMô"OQUERONôSETTLEDôTHEREômôANDôSOONôTHEYôFORMEDô'RUPOô5NI¥N ôAô gHOMETOWNôASSOCIATION uôDEDICATEDôTOôRAISINGôDOLLARSôINô!MERICAôANDôUSINGôTHEôMONEYô TOôREVITALIZEôTHEIRôHOMETOWNôINô-EXICOô7ITHôSOôMANYôPEOPLEôFROMô"OQUERONôNOWô TRANSPLANTEDôTOô.EWBURGH ôTHEYôREFERôTOôTHEMSELVESôASôTHEôgSIXTHôSECTIONuôBECAUSEô "OQUERONôITSELFôISôDIVIDEDôINTOôkVEôSECTIONS ôORôNEIGHBORHOODSô)Nô.EWBURGH ôTHESEô MENôWORKôLONG ôHARDôHOURSôINôCONSTRUCTION ôATôRESTAURANTS ôDRIVINGôTAXISôANDôOTHERô PRIMARILYôLOW PAYINGôJOBSô9ETôTHEYôMEETôONCEôAôWEEKôANDôCAREFULLYôCOUNTôOUTôTHEô ô ôORôôEACHôHANDSôOVERôTOô*OS¯ô'ARCIA ôTHEô'RUPOô5NI¥NôTREASURERô)TôUSUALLYôADDSô UPôTOôABOUTôôORôôEACHôWEEKô ô

7HATôMAYôBEôMOSTôSURPRISINGôFORô.ORTHô!MERICANSôISôJUSTôHOWôMUCHô"OQUERONSô

gSIXTHôSECTIONuôHASôMANAGEDôTOôACCOMPLISHô4HEYôBROUGHTôELECTRICITYôTOôTHEôTOWNôINô TIMEôFORôTHEôSTôCENTURYômôSOMETHINGôNEITHERôTHEô-EXICANôGOVERNMENTôNORôINTERNA TIONALôAIDôPROGRAMSôACCOMPLISHEDô4HEYôBUILTôAôCAFETERIAôFORôTHEôKINDERGARTENôANDô BOUGHTôANôAMBULANCEôFORôTHEôTOWN ôDRIVINGôITô ôMILESôTOô"OQUERONô!NDôINôANô ASTOUNDINGôBOOSTôFORôTHEôTOWNSôMORALE ôTHEôMENôINô.EWBURGHôFUNDEDôTHEôBUILDINGô OFôAô SEATôBASEBALLôSTADIUMôINô"OQUERONô ô

"OQUERONSô'RUPOô5NI¥NôISôNOTôANôISOLATEDôINSTANCEô)TôISôONEôOFôATôLEASTôAôTHOUSANDô

gHOMETOWNôASSOCIATIONSuôINVOLVINGôNOTôONLYô-EXICANS ôBUTôWORKERSôFROMôTHEô0HILIP PINES ô#HINA ô)TALY ôANDôFROMôALLôOVERôTHEôWORLDô4HEôSELF DIRECTEDôSOCIALôACTIONôOFôTHESEô GROUPSôISôONEôOFôGLOBALIZATIONSôUNANTICIPATEDôEFFECTSô 3OURCE WWWSIXTHSECTIONCOM &ORôMOREôINFORMATION $IRECTORôôPRODUCERô!LEXô2IVERAôô#O PRODUCERô"ERNARDOô2UIZôô$URATION ôôMIN 0HOTOôCREDIT 2ODOLFOô6ALTIERRAôô!LEXô2IVERA

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ0FUQEñ0B@QFLK

0240_057_self_org.indd 288-289

25/09/06 17:41:38

4HEô4OPFREEô%QUALô2IGHTSô!SSOCIATION $ESCRIPTION 4HEô4OPFREEô%QUALô2IGHTSô!SSOCIATIONô4%2! ôHELPSôWOMENôWHOôENCOUNTERôDIFkCULTYô GOINGôWITHOUTôTOPSôINôPUBLICôPLACESôINô#ANADAôANDôTHEô53! ôANDôINFORMSôTHEôPUBLICô ONôTHISôISSUE 4EXT 4HISôWEBSITEôISôINTENDEDôASôANôINFORMATIONôRESOURCEô)TôSHOULDôINTERESTôWOMENôANDô MEN ôWHOôUNDERSTANDômôORôWANTôTOôUNDERSTANDômôTHATôWOMENSôBREASTSôAREôJUSTôkNE ô ANDôINôNOôWAYôINDECENT ôOBSCENE ôDANGEROUS ôORôSOMEôOTHERôVERSIONôOFôBAD ôANYô MOREôTHANôMENSôARE ô

)NôMOSTôJURISDICTIONSôINô.ORTHô!MERICA ôEXPLICITôSEXUALôACTIVITYôINôPUBLICôVIEWôISôIL

LEGALô4HATôISôNOTôINVOLVEDôHEREô)FôMENôMAYôDECIDEôTOôHAVEôEXPOSEDôBREASTSôWITHOUTô IT ôSOôMAYôWOMEN ô

)FôWOMENôACTôONôTHISôUNDERSTANDINGôBYôINNOCUOUSLYôHAVINGôUNCOVEREDôBREASTSôINô

PUBLIC ôTHEYôAREôUSUALLYôCRITICIZED ôRIDICULED ôANDôHASSLED ôANDôMAYôBEôkNEDôORôJAILEDô 4HEIRôEXPERIENCESôTELLôQUITEôTHEôSTORY ôWHICHôISôGRADUALLYôUNFOLDINGôONôTHISôSITEôANDô SIMILARôONES ô

/URôBASICôCLAIMôISôTHATôWOMENôDESERVEôEQUALôRIGHTSô7EôDOôNOTôSUGGESTôTHATô

WOMENôORôMENôSHOULDôGOôABOUTôWITHôBAREôBREASTSô4HATôISôEVERYôINDIVIDUALSôDECISIONô 7EôDOôBELIEVEôTHATôSINCEôMENôMAYôCHOOSEôTOôDOôSOôINôMANYôSITUATIONS ôWOMENôMUSTô ALSOôBEôABLEôTOôATôLEASTôINôTHEôSAMEôSITUATIONSô7ITHOUTôPENALTYôOFôANYôKIND ô

7OMENôPAYôSEVERELYôFORô.ORTHô!MERICASôLEERINGôPUNISHMENTôOFôTHEIRôBREASTSô-ANYô

kNDôTHEMSELVESôTHEôOBJECTôOFôUNWANTEDôANDôUNWARRANTEDôATTENTIONôFROMôMENôINôPOSI TIONSôOFôPOWERôOVERôTHEMô-ANYôHAVEôDEBILITATINGôBODYôIMAGEôPROBLEMS ôHATINGôTHEô BREASTSôONôTHEIRôOWN ôUNIQUEôBODIESô-ANYôUNDERGOôHAZARDOUSôCOSMETICôSURGERYôTOô CONFORMôTOôSOMEôNON EXISTENTôSTANDARDô4OôPLEASEôOTHERS ôMANYôWEARôBRASôTHATôCONkNEô ANDôHURTôANDôMAYôBEôHARMFULô-ANYôAREôAFRAIDôTOôBREASTFEED ôESPECIALLYôWITHôOTHERSô PRESENT ô

7HYôDOôMANYôWOMENôWANTôTOôLETôTHEIRôBREASTSôOUTôOFôTHEôPRISONôOURôSOCIETYôHASô

PUTôTHEMôINô4HEYôWANTôTOôBEôCOMFORTABLEô4HEYôWANTôTHEôCONVENIENCEô4HEYôWANTôTOô FURTHERôTHEIRôWELL BEINGô4HEYôWANTôOWNERSHIPôANDôCONTROLôOFôTHEIRôOWNôBREASTS ô

4HEYôDESERVEôEQUALôTREATMENTôUNDERôTHEôLAW

)FôYOUôTHINKôTHATôTHEôISSUEôOFôEXPOSEDôBREASTSôISôTRIVIAL ôORôYOUôDISAGREEôWITHôTHEôABOVE ô HAVEôAôLOOKôAROUNDôTHISôSITEô9OUôMAYôCHANGEôYOURôMIND 3OURCE WWWTERACA0URPOSE &ORôMOREôINFORMATIONô WWWTERACA

0240_057_self_org.indd 290-291

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ1LMCOBBñ"NR>Iñ/FDEQPñPPL@F>QFLK

25/09/06 17:41:39

$IGITALôINFORMATIONôASôAôRESOURCEô

ôô 0HILOSOPHICAL ôIDEOLOGICALô mô CYBERNETICSô mô THEôONTOLOGICALôORôEPISTEMOLOGICALôCODIkCATIONôOFôTHEORIESôABOUTô

!SôAôPROPERTYôOFôINFORMATIONôPROCESSING ôDIGITALITYôISôCREATEDô BYôDIFFERENTôTECHNOLOGICALôMEANSôELECTRICAL ôOPTICAL ôMAGNETIC ô ETC ôBUTôCANôFACILITATEôTHEôALMOST ôPERFECTôCOPYINGôANDôAL MOST ôUNLIMITEDôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôTHEôINFORMATIONôCONTENTô4HEô REPRODUCTION ôCOPYINGôANDôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôDIGITALôINFORMATION ô ORôgCODEu ôAREôSUBSTANTIALLYôDIFFERENTôFROMôTHEôREPRODUCTION ô COPYINGôANDôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôANALOGUEôINFORMATION ôSUCHôASôTHEô PRINTEDôPAGEôORôAôSPEECHô4HEôCRUCIALôPOINTôISôNOTôONLYôTHATô COPYINGôANDôREDISTRIBUTIONôOFôDIGITALôINFORMATIONôISôMUCHôMOREô PRECISE ôITôISôALSOôMUCHôLESSôEXPENSIVEôCOMPAREDôTOôANALOGUEô INFORMATIONô4HEôQUICKôDEVELOPMENTôANDôDISTRIBUTIONôOFôDIGITALô TECHNOLOGYôPROMISESôTOôDELIVERôDIGITALôINFORMATIONôTOôANYôPLACEô ATôANYôTIMEô4HISôISôATôTHEôROOTôOFôTHEôGREATôDEMOCRATICôPOTENTIALô OFôDIGITALôTECHNOLOGYôANDôTHEôKEYôTOôCYBERCOMMUNISTôUTOPIAô (OWEVER ôTHEôEXISTINGôSTRUCTURESôOFôPRODUCTIONôANDôCORPORATEô LOGICôAREôBASEDôONôAôMARKETôINôWHICHôDIGITALôCONTENTôISôAôSCARCEô COMMODITYôWHOSEôDISTRIBUTIONôCANôBEôCONTROLLEDôTOôGUARANTEEô AôCONTINUOUSôREVENUEôSTREAMô

ô

PROPERTIESôOFôNATUREôINFORMATION ôGENETICôCODE ôTHINKING ôETC ô

ô 3OCIAL ôCULTURALô môô THEôNOTIONôOFôPROPERTYô môô PRACTICESôOFôgINTELLECTUALuôPROPERTYô mô FORMSôOFôDISTRIBUTIONô ô %CONOMICô môô CONCENTRATIONôOFôMEDIAôOWNERSHIPô mô INTERNATIONALôTRADEôAGREEMENTSô7)0/ ô74/ ôETC ô ô ,EGALô môô gINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYuôLAW ôCOPYRIGHTS ôTRADEMARKS ô ô

PATENTSô$-#! ô%5#$ ô

mô LAWSôCONTROLLINGôINFORMATIONôSECURITYô ô 4ECHNOLOGICALô mô COPY PROTECTIONôANDôOTHERôgDIGITALôRIGHTSôMANAGEMENTuôSCHEMESô mô PREFERREDôCONTENTô

#ONSEQUENTLY ôMANYôPROPERTIESôOFôNEWôTECHNOLOGYôTHATôAREôMAR KETEDôASôIMPROVEMENTS ôARE ôINôEFFECT ôDIMINISHINGôTHEôINHERENTô POTENTIALSôOFôDIGITALôTECHNOLOGYô$IGITALôINFORMATIONôISôOFTENôNOTô TREATEDôASôANôABUNDANT ôUNLIMITEDôRESOURCE ôBUTôASôAôPRODUCTô ORôLIMITEDôASSETô!SôDIGITALôTECHNOLOGYôITSELFôDOESôNOTôPRODUCEô THEôNECESSARYôSCARCITY ôITôHASôTOôBEôMAINTAINEDôTHROUGHôOTHERô MEANSô!TTEMPTSôTOôLIMITôTHEôPOTENTIALôOFôDIGITALôTECHNOLOGYôANDô DIMINISHINGôDIGITALôRESOURCESôFALLôUNDERôTHEôFOLLOWINGôGROUPSô

mô NON STANDARDôARCHITECTURES ôINTERFACES ôANDôFORMATSô



0240_057_self_org.indd 292-293

mô gTRUSTEDôCOMPUTINGuô

25/09/06 17:41:39

!RGUMENTSôFORôTHEôDEGRADATIONôOFôTECHNOLOGYôAREôOFTENôBASEDô ONôTHEôNATUREôOFôPROkT CREATIONôMECHANISMSôINôAôMARKETôECON OMYô2ECENTLY ôHOWEVER ôARGUMENTSôBASEDôONôINFORMATIONôSE CURITYôHAVEôGAINEDôMOREôPROMINENCEô)NCREASINGLY ôCYBERCRIMEô ANDôTHEôTHREATôOFôTERRORISMôAREôUSEDôASôGROUNDSôFORôTHEôARTIkCIALô SCARCITYôOFôDIGITALôRESOURCESôANDôLESSôEFFECTIVEôTECHNOLOGYô0O LITICALôARGUMENTSôFORôSCARCITYôHAVEôALSOôBEENôFOUNDô4HEôUN LIMITED ôSCARCITY REMOVINGôPOTENTIALôOFôDIGITALôTECHNOLOGYôWASô HAILEDôBYô2ONALDô2EAGANôINôHISôSPEECHôATô,ONDONSô'UILDHALLô *UNEô ô ôg4ECHNOLOGYôWILLôMAKEôITôINCREASINGLYôDIFkCULTô FORôTHEôSTATEôTOôCONTROLôTHEôINFORMATIONôITSôPEOPLEôRECEIVEôô4HEô 'OLIATHôOFôTOTALITARIANISMôWILLôBEôBROUGHTôDOWNôBYôTHEô$AVIDôOFô THEôMICROCHIPuôCITEDôINô+ALATHILôô"OASô ô(OWEVER ôSUCHô OPTIMISMôHASôBEENôNOTABLYôCOOLEDôBYôRECENTôDEVELOPMENTSô &ORôINSTANCE ôAUTHORITARIANôREGIMESôHAVEôFOUNDôINNOVATIVEôANDô EFFECTIVEôTECHNOLOGICALôANDôSOCIALôWAYSôOFôLIMITINGôDIGITALôRE SOURCESô+ALATHILôô"OASô ô (ERE ôASôELSEWHERE ôTHEôVERYôSTRUCTUREôOFôTECHNOLOGYômôITSôARCHI TECTUREômôISôPOLITICALLYôRELEVANTô!CCORDINGôTOôANôOLDôANECDOTEô RECOUNTEDôBYô,ESSIGô ôTHEREôWASôAôHIDDENôPLANôINôTHEô .APOLEONICôRECONSTRUCTIONôOFô0ARISô7HILEôTHEôOFkCIALôARGUMENTô INôFAVOURôOFôWIDEôBOULEVARDSôWASôPRESENTEDôINôTERMSôOFôHEALTH ô PUBLICôSAFETYôANDôAESTHETICS ôTHEôBOULEVARDSôALSOôALLOWEDôFORô THEôTOPôMILITARYôTECHNOLOGYôOFôTHEôTIMEômôCANNONôkREômôTOôEF FECTIVELYôCLEARôANYôROADBLOCKSôERECTEDôBYôREVOLUTIONARYôCROWDSô môTHEôPROMINENTôSTREET kGHTINGôTECHNOLOGYôOFôTHEôTIMEô7HILEô WEôAREôCURRENTLYôLIVINGôTHROUGHôTHEôGESTATIONôPERIODôOFôDIGITALô BOULEVARDS ôWEôSHOULDôBEôVERYôCAREFULôINôTHINKINGôABOUTôTHEô POLITICALôANDôSOCIALôCONSEQUENCESôPRESENTEDôBYôDIFFERENTôAR CHITECTURAL TECHNOLOGICALôMODELSô


0240_057_self_org.indd 294-295

!LONGôWITHôTHEôONTOLOGICALôANDôEPISTEMOLOGICALôQUESTIONS ôDIG ITALôINFORMATIONôPROCESSINGôRAISESôETHICALôQUESTIONSôONôAôGLOBALô SCALE ôNOTôLEASTôBECAUSEôOFôTHEôCOMMODIkCATIONôOFôCODEôINTEL LECTUALôPROPERTYôRIGHTS ôINFORMATIONôPATENTS ôPATENTSôONô$.! ô COPYRIGHTSôONôIMMATERIALôASSETSôETC ô&ORôAôREVIEWôOFôCURRENTô LEGALôANDôSOCIALôDEVELOPMENTS ôSEEô$RAHOSôô"RAITHWAITEô ô4HEôCOMMODIkCATIONôOFôCODEôAND ôCONSEQUENTLY ôOFô KNOWLEDGE ôNEEDSôTWOôPRECONDITIONSôAôSUSTAINEDôBELIEFôINô THEôEXISTENCEôOFôgCODEu ôINôWHICHôINFORMATIONôCONTENTôCANôBEô EXPRESSED ôTRANSFERREDôANDôIDENTIkED ôANDôAôSYSTEMôOFôOWNER SHIPôFORôTHISôCODEô)NôTHISôSENSE ôTHEôkRSTôCONDITIONôISôNOTôONLYô COMPRISEDôOFôAôSCIENTIkCôVIEWôOFôTHEôWORLDôANDôEXPLANATIONSôOFô PHENOMENAôASôIFôTHEYôWEREôINôTHEôLASTôINSTANCEôALGORITHMICôITôISô ALSOôANôECONOMICôANDôSOCIALôPRINCIPLEôOFôORGANISATIONôg#ODEuô ISôAôSCIENTIkCôENTITYôAôTHEORETICALôTERM ôIFôYOUôWISH ôWITHôANô EPISTEMOLOGYôANDôONTOLOGYôOFôITSôOWN ôBUTôALSOôAôGOVERNMEN TALôANDôJURIDICALôCONCEPTôINVESTEDôWITHôECONOMICôANDôPOLITICALô INTERESTSô)TôISôBECOMINGôCLEARôTHATôTHEôkRSTôCONDITIONôISôCLOSELYô COUPLEDôTOôTHEôSECONDôCONDITIONôOFôSOCIAL LEGALôSETTINGSôFORôTHEô OWNERSHIPôOFôCODEôg)NTELLECTUALôPROPERTYuôASôAôCONCEPTôISôAôWAYô OFôCONTROLLINGôANDôORGANISINGômôINôTHEô4AYLORISTôSENSEômôTHEôNEWô TYPEôOFôPRODUCTIONô#OPYRIGHTôLEGISLATIONôANDôLAWSôCONCERN INGôOTHERôSO CALLEDôIMMATERIALôRIGHTSôAREôBEINGôCHANGEDôATôAô RAPIDôPACEô4HISôTRENDôISôMOSTôMARKEDôINôTHEô53 ôBUTôTHEô%5ô ISôFOLLOWINGôCLOSEôBEHINDô!CCORDINGôTOô,ESSIG ôg.EVERôBEFOREô HAVEôSOôFEWôOWNEDôSOôMUCHôAôPARTôOFôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYuô ,ESSIGô ôSEEôALSOô,ESSIGô ô4HESEôWORDS ôINTENTION ALLYôORôNOT ôHAVEôAôFAMILIARôRINGô 4HEôHYPOTHESISôIS ôTHEN ôTHATôWHATôWASôCALLEDôgCOMMODIkCATIONô OFôCODEuôABOVEôISôAôCOMBINATIONôOFôTWOôINFORMATIONôTECHNOLOGI CALôINTERESTSô ôTHEôBELIEFôINôAôFUNCTIONINGôLAYERôOFôCODEôTOôBEô


25/09/06 17:41:40

5"5.45 $ESCRIPTION 5BUNTUôISôAôCOMPLETEô,INUX BASEDôOPERATINGôSYSTEM ôFREELYôAVAILABLEôWITHôBOTHô ôCOMMUNITYôANDôPROFESSIONALôSUPPORTô 4EXT 4HEô5BUNTUôCOMMUNITYôISôBUILTôONôTHEôIDEASôENSHRINEDôINôTHEô5BUNTUô0HILOSOPHYô THATôSOFTWAREôSHOULDôBEôAVAILABLEôFREEôOFôCHARGE ôTHATôSOFTWAREôTOOLSôSHOULDôBEôUS ABLEôBYôPEOPLEôINôTHEIRôLOCALôLANGUAGEôANDôDESPITEôANYôDISABILITIES ôANDôTHATôPEOPLEô SHOULDôHAVEôTHEôFREEDOMôTOôCUSTOMISEôANDôALTERôTHEIRôSOFTWAREôINôWHATEVERôWAYô THEYôSEEôkTô ô

4HESEôFREEDOMSôMAKEô5BUNTUôFUNDAMENTALLYôDIFFERENTôFROMôTRADITIONALôPROPRIETARYô

SOFTWAREôNOTôONLYôAREôTHEôTOOLSôYOUôNEEDôAVAILABLEôFREEôOFôCHARGE ôYOUôHAVEôTHEôRIGHTô TOôMODIFYôYOURôSOFTWAREôUNTILôITôWORKSôTHEôWAYôYOUôWANTôITôTOô ô

5BUNTUôISôSUITABLEôFORôBOTHôDESKTOPôANDôSERVERôUSEô4HEôCURRENTô5BUNTUôRELEASEô

SUPPORTSô0#ô)NTELôX ô BITô0#ô!-$ ôANDô0OWER0#ô!PPLEôI"OOKôANDô0OWER BOOK ô'ôANDô' ôARCHITECTURESô ô

5BUNTUôINCLUDESôMOREôTHANô ôPIECESôOFôSOFTWARE ôBUTôTHEôCOREôDESKTOPôINSTAL

LATIONôkTSôONôAôSINGLEô#$ô5BUNTUôCOVERSôEVERYôSTANDARDôDESKTOPôAPPLICATIONôFROMô WORDôPROCESSINGôANDôSPREADSHEETôAPPLICATIONSôTOôWEBôSERVERôSOFTWAREôANDôPROGRAM MINGôTOOLSô 3OURCE WWWUBUNTUCOM &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWUBUNTUCOM WWWEDUBUNTUORG g5BUNTUuôISôANôANCIENTô!FRICANôWORD ôMEANINGôgHUMANITYôTOôOTHERSu

0240_057_self_org.indd 296-297

%XAMPLESôôYôô22+12

25/09/06 17:41:41

SEPARATEDôFROMôTHEôPHYSICALôSETTING ôANDô ôTHEôSET UPôOFôAô SYSTEMôOFôOWNERSHIPôFORôTHEôCODEô)FôTHISôISôTHEôCASE ôTWOôWAYSô OFôCOUNTERACTINGôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôANôINCREASINGLYôASYMMETRI CALôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYôPRESENTôTHEMSELVESô4HEôSTRAIGHTFORWARDô STANCEôISôTOôACCEPTôTHEôEXISTENCEôOFôCODEômôTOôBELIEVEôINôIT ô ANDôACTôACCORDINGLY ôTOôDEFENDôITôASôAôWAYôOFôUNDERSTANDINGô THEôWORLDômôBUTôATôTHEôSAMEôTIMEôTOôINSISTôTHATôTHEôOWNERSHIPô OFôCODEôLEADSôTOôBLATANTôCONTRADICTIONS ôNOTôTOôSPEAKôOFôSOCIALô INJUSTICEôANDôECONOMICôIMBALANCEô/NEôOFôTHEôENSUINGôCONTRA DICTIONSôISôPERHAPSôMOSTôEVIDENTôINôTHEôCASEôOFôSCIENTIkCôKNOWL EDGE ôWHICHôRECEIVESôITSôSPECIALôSTATUSôANDôCREDIBILITYôFROMôTHEô VERYôFACTôTHATôITôISôNOTôOWNEDôKNOWLEDGEôBECOMESôSCIENTIkCô ONLYôTHROUGHôTHEôOPENôANDôFREEôCRITIQUEôOFôTHEôSCIENTIkCôCOM MUNITYô4OôQUOTEô*ACQUESô$ERRIDAôg;w=ôINôAôSCIENTIkCôTEXTô;w=ô THEôVALUEôOFôTHEôUTTERANCEôISôSEPARATED ôORôCUTSôITSELFôOFF ôFROMô THEôNAMEôOFôTHEôAUTHORôWITHOUTôESSENTIALôRISK ôAND ôINDEED ôMUSTô BEôABLEôTOôDOôSOôINôORDERôTOôLAYôCLAIMôTOôOBJECTIVITYuô ôPô ô!SôAôSPEECHôACT ôAôSCIENTIkCôTEXTôHASôTOôBEôDISTINGUISHEDô FROMôTHEôPERSONôORôPERSONSôWHOôgSIGNuôIT ôOTHERWISEôWEôAREôNOTô DEALINGôWITHôAôTEXTôTHATôCANôASSUMEôTHEôSPECIALôCHARACTERISTICS ô AUTHORITYôANDôALLOWANCESôACCEDEDôTOôAôSCIENTIkCôTEXTô4HISôHASô BEENôANDôSTILLôISôLARGELYôTHEôWAYôINôWHICHôSCIENTIkCôINFORMATIONô ANDôKNOWLEDGEôAREôSEVEREDôFROMôAôCONCEPTôOFôPRIVATEôPROPERTYô THATôISôDEPENDENTôONôTHEôLINKôBETWEENôAôPERSONôANDôANôENTITYô 4HEôAUTHORômôTHEôONEôWHOôgSIGNSuôSCIENCEômôISôTHEôSCIENTIkCô COMMUNITYô!ôPARTICULARôWAYôOFôSPEAKINGôORôAôPARTICULARôTYPEô OFôSPEECHôACTômôTHATôOFôSCIENTIkCôTEXTSômôCREATESôAôCOMMUNITYô ANDôAôWAYôOFôAPPROPRIATINGôKNOWLEDGEôTHATôISôDIFFERENTôFROMôTHEô CASEôOFôPRIVATEôPROPERTYô

4HEôSO CALLEDôFREEôSOFTWAREôISôBUILTôBYôAôCOMMUNITYôOFôSHARE AND SHAREôALIKEôTHEôGOALôISôTOôDEVELOPôSOFTWAREôTHATôTHEôUSERô ISôFREEôTOôUSE ôMODIFYôANDôREDISTRIBUTEôPROVIDEDôTHATôTHEôSAMEô FREEDOMSôAREôTRANSFERREDô)NôTHISôSENSEôTHEôIDEALôISôCLOSEôTOô THEôIDEALôOFôSCIENCEô&ORôTHISôPURPOSEôTHEôMOVEMENTôNEEDSôAô LEGALôANDôSOCIALôTOOL ôONEôTHATôUSESôTHEôCOPYRIGHTôCLAIMôSETôONô AôPIECEôOFôSOFTWAREôFORôCOMMUNITYôBUILDINGôRATHERôTHANôPRIVATEô PROPERTYôBUILDINGô4HISôTOOL ôDEVELOPEDôBYô2ICHARDô-ô3TALL MANôANDôHISôCO WORKERS ôISôOFTENôCOLLOQUIALLYôCALLEDôgCOPYLEFTuô 4HEôCOPYRIGHTôSTATEMENTôINôQUESTIONôGIVESôTHEôUSERôTHEôRIGHTôTOô MODIFYôANDôREDISTRIBUTEôTHEôMODIkEDôVERSIONôOF ôTHEôSOFTWAREô PROVIDEDôTHATôTHEôRIGHTôISôALSOôTRANSFERREDô3TALLMANô ô4HISô VIRALôNATUREôOFôTHEôgCOPYLEFTuôCOPYRIGHTôPROTECTSôTHEôINFORMATIONô ANDôKNOWLEDGEôAMASSEDôINôTHEôSOFTWAREôFROMôBECOMINGôCLOSEDô BYôOWNERSHIPô4HEôKNOWLEDGEôISôAPPROPRIATEDôTOôTHEôCOMMONô CONTROLôOFôTHEôCOMMUNITYô )NôTHEôCASESôOFôBOTHôSCIENCEôANDôFREEôSOFTWARE ôTHEôGOALôANDô THEôPREREQUISITEôISôAôCOMMUNITYôOFôSHARINGôBASEDôONôAôCOMMONô SETôOFôVALUESôANDôPRACTICESô"OTHôCANôBEôSEENôASôWAYSôOFôACT ING ôORôPOWER STRUCTURES ôWHICHôAREôINSTRUMENTALôINôCREATINGôANô INFORMATIONôSOCIETYôTHATôCONTRADICTSôTHEôTRENDSôOFôSEEINGôEVERY THINGôASôCODEôANDôSETTINGôUPôAôSYSTEMôOFôOWNERSHIPôFORôCODEô !SôSUCH ôTHEôPRACTICESôOFôTHESEôCOMMUNITIESôALSOôDEMONSTRATEô THATôDIGITALôINFORMATIONôPROCESSING ôORôANYôOTHERôTECHNOLOGY ô DOESôNOTôFORCEôUSôTOôACCEPTôTHEôCOMMODIkCATIONôOFôCODEô

!ôSIMILARôDEVICEôFORôCO OPERATINGôWITHOUTôTHEôINTRUSIONôOFôPRIVATEô PROPERTYôHASôBEENôDEVELOPEDôINôTHEôCASEôOFôCOMPUTERôSOFTWAREô

4HEôSECONDôWAYôTOôRESISTôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôANôINCREASINGLYô ASYMMETRICôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYôISôTOôDIRECTôOURôATTENTIONôTOôTHEô kRSTôCONDITIONômôTHEôPROCESSôOFôSEEINGôTHEôMOSTôSALIENTôFEATURESô OFôTHEôWORLDôASôCODEôAND ôESPECIALLY ôTOôTHEôPECULIARôKINDôOFô EXISTENCEôOFôCODEôSEEô6AD¯Nô ô7ITHôAôCERTAINôRHETORICALô



0240_057_self_org.indd 298-299

25/09/06 17:41:41

TURN ôITôCOULDôBEôCLAIMEDôTHATôgTHEôDIGITALuômôTHEôBELIEFôINôTHEô EXISTENCEôOFôSOMETHINGôPERFECTLYôREPEATABLEôANDôMEDIA INDE PENDENTôTHATôCANôBEôOWNEDôANDôOPERATIONALISEDômôTAKESôPARTô INôPRODUCINGôTHEôTRUTHôOFôTHEôEXISTENCEôOFôAôDISEMBODIEDôANDô SELF IDENTICALôSELFôMAKINGôTHINGSôLIKEô!) ôTRANSHUMANISMôANDô GENETICôPERFECTIBILITYôFACTSôOFôTHEôPRESENTôORôTHEôFUTURE ô!TôTHEô SAMEôTIME ôTHISôSETôOFôBELIEFS ôTHISô&OUCAULTIANôEPISTEME ôSHOWSô ITSôOWNôLIMITSô5NIQUEôPROCESSESômôTHOSEôCONNECTEDôTOôPARTICU LARôCAUSALôCHAINSôSUCHôASôHUMANôPHYSICALôINTERACTIONS ôFEELINGSô ORôTREESômôCANNOTôEVENôBEôDIGITALISEDôINôPRINCIPLEô4HEYôAREôNOTô gCODEu ôATôLEASTôNOTôSELF INCLUSIVE ôFORMALISABLEôANDôCALCULABLEô CODEô/NEôHASôTOôASKôATôLEASTôTHEôFOLLOWINGôQUESTIONSôWHATôIFô THEôNON DIGITALISABLEôPROCESSESôINCLUDEôPROCESSESôOFôKNOWL EDGEôTHATôAREôVITALôTOôTHEôINFORMATIONôSOCIETIESô7HATôIFôTHEô APPROPRIATIONôOFôTHEôDIGITALôINTOôTHEôSCHEMEôOFôPRIVATEôPROPERTYô REQUIRESôSOCIALôFORMATIONSôTHATôAREôREPRESSIVEô

4WOôTYPESôOFôORGANISATIONôINô THEôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYô /NEôOFôTHEôMOSTôINTERESTINGôDEBATESôAROUNDôTHEôOWNERSHIPô OFôINFORMATIONôHASôBEENôCENTREDôONôCOMPUTERôSOFTWARE ôNOTô LEASTôBECAUSEôSOFTWAREôPROVIDESôEXTREMEôEXAMPLESôOFôBOTHôTHEô PROPRIETARYôANDôNON PROPRIETARYôFORMSôOFôRELATINGôTOôCODEô/Nô ONEôHAND ôWEôHAVEôTHEôIDEASôANDôCORRESPONDINGôPRACTICESôAC CORDINGôTOôWHICHôPIECESôOFôCOMPUTERôSOFTWAREôAREôIDENTIkABLEô WORKSôTHATôAREôOWNEDôBYôTHEIRôAUTHORSô4HROUGHôTHIS ôWEôGETôTHEô PROPRIETARYôSYSTEMôINôWHICHôTHEôOWNERSôOFôSOFTWARE ôTYPICALLYô SOFTWAREôCOMPANIES ôGIVEôTHEôUSERôTHEôRIGHTôTOôUSEôTHEôSOFT WAREôUNDERôCERTAINôCONDITIONSôSPECIkEDôINôTHEôENDôUSERôLICENSEô AGREEMENTSô/NôTHEôOTHERôHANDôAREôTHEôIDEASôANDôPRACTICESô ACCORDINGôTOôWHICHôCOMPUTERôSOFTWAREôISôALGORITHMICôINôTHEô SENSEôTHATôITôCANNOTôBEôOWNEDômôITôISôCREATEDôINôTHEôINTERACTIONô OFôAôBODYôOFôINDIVIDUALSôANDôORGANISATIONSôANDôSIGNEDôINôTHEô SENSEôOFôgTHEôAUTHORôWHOôDISCOVEREDôSOMETHINGuôRATHERôTHANô gTHEôAUTHORôWHOôOWNSôSOMETHINGuô4HESEôEXTREMESôAREôEXEM PLIkEDôONôTHEôLEVELôOFôCOMPUTERôOPERATINGôSYSTEMS ôINôWHICHôTHEô DOMINANTô-ICROSOFTô7INDOWSôSYSTEMôISôTHEôPURESTôEXAMPLEôOFô AôPROPRIETARYôSYSTEM ôWHILEôTHEô'.5,INUXôSYSTEMôMAYôBEôTHEô MOSTôWELLôKNOWNôEXAMPLEôOFôAôNON PROPRIETARYôSYSTEMô 4HEôMAINôECONOMIC CUM SOCIALôARGUMENTôFORôTHEôOWNERSHIPôOFô SOFTWAREôORôCODEôIS ôOFôCOURSE ôTHATôONLYôTHEôECONOMICôINCENTIVEô OFôPROPERTYôANDôWEALTHôCANôGUARANTEEôTHEôPROSPERITYôOFôAôSOCI ETYô!RGUMENTSôFORôTHEôFREEDOMôOFôSOFTWAREôAREôSIMILARôTOôARGU MENTSôFORôTHEôFREEDOMôOFôSCIENCEôTHEôSPEEDôOFôDEVELOPMENT ô THEôTRUSTWORTHINESSôOFôTHEôSOFTWAREôANDôTHEôAVAILABILITYôOFôCODEô AREôALLôIMPROVEDôBYôTHEôNON PROPRIETARYôNATUREôOFôSOFTWARE ôAND ô


0240_057_self_org.indd 300-301


25/09/06 17:41:41

ATôTHEôSAMEôTIME ôTHEôVALUESôOFôCO OPERATIONôANDôSHARINGôAREô ENCOURAGEDô 4HEôQUESTIONôCANôBEôINVESTIGATEDôFROMôTHEôPOINTôOFôVIEWôOFô KNOWLEDGEôWORKôANDôPRODUCTIONô"OTHôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFô PROPRIETARYôSOFTWAREôINôSOFTWAREôCOMPANIESôANDôTHEôDEVELOP MENTôOFôFREEôSOFTWAREôINôVOLUNTEERôHACKERôORGANISATIONSôAREô CERTAINLYôINSTANCESôOFôKNOWLEDGE INTENSIVEôWORK ôRESULTINGôINô GOODSôTHATôAREôDIGITALôINFORMATIONô"UTôTHEôCONTEXTS ôINCLUDINGô THEôUNDERLYINGôETHICAL ôSOCIALôANDôPOLITICALôIDEAS ôAREôDIVERGENTô 4HESEôSETSôOFôBELIEFSôAREôNOTôUNIFORM ôTOôBEôSURE ôBUTôTHEYôDOô RESULTôINôDIFFERENTôVIEWSôOFôTHEôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYô 3OFTWAREôDEVELOPMENTôINôAôBIGôSOFTWAREôCOMPANYôISôORGANISEDô ANDôINSTITUTIONALISED ôMOREôORôLESSôLIKEôAô4AYLORISTôENTERPRISEô 4HEôKNOWLEDGEôPRODUCTIONôHAPPENSôINôANôORGANISATIONôWITHôITSô STRUCTURE ôAIMSôANDôFUNCTIONSô3UCHôKNOWLEDGEôPRODUCTIONôHASô BEENôSTUDIEDôEXTENSIVELY ôEGôINôVIEWôOFôTHEôTYPESôOFôIMPLICITôANDô EXPLICITôKNOWLEDGEôCIRCULATINGôINôTHEôORGANISATIONôSEEô.ONAKAô ô4AKEUCHIô ô4OôUSEôAôDEkNITIONôBYôTHEôSOCIOLOGISTô3COTTô ,ASHô ôTHEôFUNCTIONSôOFôANôORGANISATIONôAREôSTRUCTUREDô THROUGHôNORMSôANDôTHEôPOWERôLEGITIMISEDôBYôTHOSEôNORMSô!Nô ORGANISATIONôLIKEôTHISôISôHIERARCHICAL ôWITHôTHEôENSUINGôCHANNELSô OFôCOMMANDôANDôDIVISIONôOFôLABOURô )NôCONTRAST ôTHEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôFREEôSOFTWAREôOFôTHEô'.5 ,INUXôTYPEôHAPPENSôINôAôWIDELYôDISTRIBUTEDôANDôNON INSTITU TIONALôMANNERôINôAôGLOBALôVOLUNTEERôCOMMUNITYôCO OPERATINGô MAINLYôTHROUGHôTHEô)NTERNETô4HISôKINDôOFôKNOWLEDGEôCREATIONô ISôNOTôLIKEôTHATôOFôTHEôORGANISATIONALôTYPEô2ATHER ôUSINGô,ASHSô TERMINOLOGY ôTHEôFREEOPENôSOURCEôSOFTWAREôCOMMUNITYôISôAô DISORGANISATIONôBASEDôNOTôONôNORMSôANDôRULESôBUTôONôSHAREDô


0240_057_self_org.indd 302-303

VALUESô,ASHôILLUSTRATESôTHEôDIFFERENCEôBETWEENôANôORGANISATIONô ANDôAôDISORGANISATIONôINôRELATIONôTOôTHEôDIFFERENCEôBETWEENôAô CHURCHôANDôAôSECTô4HEôFUNCTIONôOFôAôCHURCHôISôTYPICALLYôBASEDô ONôAôCERTAINôHIERARCHYômôAôSETôOFôNORMSôANDôLEGITIMISEDôUSESôOFô POWERômôWHEREASôAôSECTôISôFORMEDôAROUNDôAôSETôOFôSHAREDôBE LIEFS ôCONVICTIONSôORôVISIONS ôOFTENôEXEMPLIkEDôBYôAôCHARISMATICô LEADERô4HEôDIFFERENCEôISôCRYSTALLISEDôINôTHEôOPERATIVEôFORCEôINô ANôORGANISATION ôPEOPLEôAREôCONTROLLEDôANDôCOMMANDEDôBYôTHEô USEôOFôLEGITIMATEôPOWER ôWHEREASôINôAôDISORGANISATIONôPEO PLEôCANôONLYôBEôCONTROLLEDôANDôPERSUADEDôTHROUGHôTHEôUSEôOFô PHYSICALôORôNON PHYSICALôVIOLENCEô!ôDISORGANISATIONôISôFORMEDô AROUNDôAôSETôOFôSHAREDôVALUES ôTHEREFOREôTHEôLEADERôTHEôGURU ôINô THEôCASEôOFô,INUX ô,INUSô4ORVALDS ôCANôCONTROLôITôBYôSAYINGôWHATô ISôRIGHTôANDôWHATôISôWRONG ôWHATôWORKSôANDôWHATôDOESNT ôEVENô THOUGHôHEôDOESôNOTôHAVEôANYôLEGALôNORMATIVEôPOWERô%VENôIFô AôDISORGANISATIONôISôNON INSTITUTIONALôANDôINFORMAL ôITôISôNOTôBYô ANYôMEANSôCHAOTICô)TôCANôBEôMUCHôMOREôTIGHTLYôCONTROLLEDôANDô gORGANISEDuôTHANôANôORGANISATION ôBECAUSEôTHEôAPPROPRIATIONô OFôRESOURCESôDOESôNOTôOBEYôTHEôNORMATIVISEDôCOMPARTMENTSô OFôANôORGANISATIONô!ôSECT ôAôMOVEMENTôORôAôTRIBEôCANôFUNCTIONô INôAôVERYôCONTROLLED ôEFFECTIVEôANDôRATIONALôMANNERô4HISôISôONEô OFôTHEôELEMENTSôOFôFREEôANDôOPENôSOURCEôSOFTWAREôDEVELOP MENTôTHATôHASôSURPRISEDôANDôCONTINUESôTOôSURPRISEôECONOMICô THEORYôACCORDINGôTOôRECEIVEDôECONOMICôWISDOMôTHEREôISôNOô REALôINCENTIVEôFORôTHEôVOLUNTEERSôTOôCONTRIBUTEôTOôFREEôSOFTWAREô DEVELOPMENTô !GAINSTôTHISôBACKGROUNDôTHEôQUESTIONôOFôOWNERSHIPôOFôINTELLEC TUALôPROPERTYôINôTHISôCASEôSOFTWARE ôCANôBEôSEENôINôDETAILô3OFT WAREôDEVELOPMENTôINôAôCOMPANYôORôORGANISATIONôCANôBENEkTô FROMôTHEôFACTôTHATôPIECESôOFôINFORMATION ôKNOWLEDGEôANDôCODEô AREôSEENôASôPROPERTYô4HEôOWNERSHIPôOFôCODEôNOTôONLYôCREATESô


25/09/06 17:41:41

ANôECONOMICôMOTIVATION ôITôPROVIDESôAôTOOLôFORôTHEôSTREAMLINING ô RATIONALISINGôANDôECONOMISINGôOFôTHEôORGANISATIONALôSTRUCTURE ô ANDôMEASURESôFORôEFFECTIVENESSôANDôINFORMATIONôlOWS ôETCô4HEô PROPRIETARISATIONôANDôCOMMODIkCATIONôOFôINTANGIBLE ôABSTRACTô CODEôISôTHEREFOREôAôREALôASSETôTOôORGANISATIONALôKNOWLEDGEôCRE ATIONô4HISôALSOôCREATESôANôONTOLOGICALôPULLôITôISôGOODôTOôBELIEVEô INôTHEôINDEPENDENTôEXISTENCEôOFôCODEô+NOWLEDGEôCREATIONôINô ORGANISATIONSôGAINSôWHENôCODEôISôAPPROPRIATEDôALONGôTHEôLINESô OFôPRIVATEôPROPERTYômôWHENôITôISôCOMMODIkEDôANDôCONTROLLEDô THROUGHôDIGITALôRIGHTSôMANAGEMENTô )NôCONTRAST ôKNOWLEDGEôCREATIONôINôAôDISORGANISATIONôISôATôTHEô VERYôLEASTôDISTURBEDôANDôATôWORSTôDESTROYEDôIFôCODEôISôTHEôPROP ERTYôOFôOWNERSô)NôTHEô'.5,INUXôCOMMUNITY ôTHEôDEVELOPERSô TAKEôPARTôOUTôOFôTHEIRôOWNôWILLômôTHEYôgSCRATCHôTHEIRôOWNôITCHuô môANDôTHEôSYSTEMATISEDôANDôSELF MANAGEDôSHARINGôOFôINFORMA TIONôGUARANTEESôTHATôTHEIRôWORKôCONTRIBUTESôTOôAôGROWING ôCOM MONôBODYôOFôKNOWLEDGEô4HEôPARTICIPANTSôCANôCONTRIBUTEôONLYô INôSOôFARôASôTHEôlOWôOFôINFORMATIONôISôNOTôCONTROLLEDôBYôOWNER SHIPô4HEôUNDERLYINGôVALUESôFORMINGôTHEôCOMMUNITYôINCLUDEôAô BELIEFôINôTHEôFREEDOMôOFôINFORMATIONôANDôAôPASSIONôFORôIMPROVEDô INFORMATIONôTECHNOLOGYô!ôDISORGANISATIONôISôTYPICALLYôSELF OR GANISINGôTHEôFUNCTIONSôOFôTHEôDISORGANISATIONôAREôBASEDôONô INFORMALôANDôNON INSTITUTIONALôCO OPERATIONôANDôSHARING ôWHICHô CANNOTôBEôCOMPARTMENTALISEDôBYôDECREEôORôRATIONALISEDôBYôUSEô OFôPOWERô4HEôSHAREDôVALUESôAREôEMBEDDEDôINôTHEôFUNCTIONSôOFô THEôDISORGANISATION ôANDôTHOSEôFUNCTIONSôAREôATôTHEôSAMEôTIMEô THEôGOALôOFôTHEôDISORGANISATIONô$ISORGANISATIONS ôLIKEôSELF OR GANISEDôWHOLESôINôGENERAL ôWORKôASôkNALITIESôTHEREFOREôTHEYô DOôNOT ôINôGENERAL ôBENEkTôFROMôTHEôINTRODUCTIONôOFôEXTERNALô GOALSô4HEôPROPRIETARISATIONôOFôINFORMATIONôANDôKNOWLEDGEôISô HARMFULôTOôKNOWLEDGEôCREATIONôINôDISORGANISATIONSô4HEôHARMô


0240_057_self_org.indd 304-305

TOôKNOWLEDGEôCREATIONôISôDONEôIFôWEôBELIEVEôINôTHEôEXISTENCEôOFô CODEôANDôASSIGNôAôPROPRIETARYôSYSTEMôOFôOWNERSHIPôTOôCODEô &ROMôTHEôPOINTôOFôVIEWôOFôTHEôINFORMATIONôSOCIETY ôITôISôCRUCIALô TOôRECOGNISEôTHEôEXISTENCEôOFôTHESEôTWOôTYPESôOFôKNOWLEDGEô WORKôANDôTHEIRôDIFFERENTôPRECONDITIONSô!ôBIASôISôPRODUCEDôBYô THEôFACTôTHATôTHEôVISIBILITYôOFôTHESEôTWOôPROCESSESôISôDIFFERENTô /RGANISATIONALôKNOWLEDGEôCREATIONôISôORGANISEDôINôTHEôSENSEôOFô ITSôOWNôEFFECTIVEôLOBBYôANDôREPRESENTATIVEôSYSTEM ôWHILEôDISOR GANISATIONALôKNOWLEDGEôCREATIONôRELIESôONôMOREôUNDERHANDEDô METHODSôOFôSOCIALôANDôPOLITICALôINlUENCEô4HISôBIASôISôALLôTHEô MOREôUNFORTUNATEôIFôTHEREôISôREASONôTOôBELIEVEôTHATôINFORMA TIONôSOCIETIESôAREôINCREASINGLYôDEPENDENTôONôDISORGANISATIONSô 4HISôISôTHEôECONOMIC POLITICALôSIDEôOFôTHEôISSUE ôHOWEVER ôWHICHô CANNOTôBEôSEPARATEDôFROMôTHEôETHICALôONEô!ôSOCIETYôINôWHICHô KNOWLEDGEôISôASYMMETRICALLYôDIVIDEDôANDôFRAGMENTEDôISôLESSô EFFECTIVE ôLESSôINNOVATIVEôANDôLESSôEQUALôANDôDEMOCRATICôTHANô ONEôINôWHICHôKNOWLEDGEôISôCONSIDEREDôNON PROPRIETARYô 4HEôFACTôREMAINSôTHATôEVENôHACKERSôHAVEôTOôEATôSOMETHINGôNON DIGITALôAND ôCONSEQUENTLY ôTHEôUTOPIAôOFôPOST SCARCITYôSOCIETIESô ISôUNATTAINABLEô7HILEôDISORGANISATIONALôSELF ORGANISATIONôASô SUCHôMIGHTôNOTôBEôNEW ôTHEôRESURRECTIONôOFôCOLLECTIVEôKNOWL EDGEôCREATIONôANDôEFFECTIVEôSELF MANAGEMENTôEXEMPLIkEDôBYô THEôHACKERôCOMMUNITIESôPROVIDEôCONCRETEôEXAMPLESôOFôUTOPIA IN ACTIONô4HEYôALSOôPOINTôOUTôTHATôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYôALWAYSô NEEDSôTOôBEôVIEWEDôINôTHEôPLURAL ôASôINFORMATIONôSOCIETIESôTHATô OVERLAPôANDôEXISTôINôTHEôBANALôEVERYDAYôACTSôTHATôNEGOTIATEôTHEô TENSIONSôBETWEENôCONlICTINGôPOLITICALôAGENDASô ô


25/09/06 17:41:42

2EFERENCESô -ô#ASTELLSô4HEô2ISEôOFôTHEô.ETWORKô3OCIETYô"LACKWELL ô,ONDONôô *ô$ERRIDAô.EGOTIATIONSô)NTERVENTIONSôANDô)NTERVIEWSô%DITED ôTRANSLATEDôANDôWITHôANôINTRODUCTIONô BYô%LIZABETHô2OTTENBERGô3TANFORDô5NIVERSITYô0RESS ô3TANFORDôô #ô$I"ONA ô3ô/CKMAN ôANDô-ô3TONEôEDS ô/PENô3OURCESô6OICESôFROMôTHEô/PENô3OURCEô2EVOLU TIONô/2EILLY ô3EBASTOPOLôô 0ô$RAHOSôANDô*ô"RAITHWAITEô)NFORMATIONô&EUDALISMô7HOô/WNSôTHEô+NOWLEDGEô%CONOMYô%ARTH SCAN ô,ONDONôô -ô(ARDTôANDô!ô.EGRIô-ULTITUDEô7ARôANDô$EMOCRACYôINôTHEô!GEôOFô%MPIREô4HEô0ENGUINô0RESSô .EWô9ORKôô 0ô(IMANENô4HEô(ACKERô%THIC ô2ANDOMô(OUSE ô.EWô9ORKôô ô3ô+ALATHIL ô3HANTHIôANDô4ô"OASôg4HEô)NTERNETôANDô3TATEô#ONTROLôINô!UTHORITARIANô2EGIMESô#HINA ô #UBA ôANDôTHEô#OUNTERREVOLUTIONuô&IRSTô-ONDAY ôVOLUMEô ôNUMBERô ôô 3ô,ASHô#RITIQUEôOFô)NFORMATIONô3!'% ô,ONDONôô ,ô,ESSIGô4HEô&UTUREôOFô)DEASô4HEô&ATEôOFôTHEô#OMMONSôINôAô#ONNECTEDô7ORLDô2ANDOMô(OUSE ô .EWô9ORKôô ,ô,ESSIGôg&REEôCULTUREuôPRESENTATIONôATôTHEô/3#/.ôôCONFERENCEôHTTPRANDOMFOONETOS CONLESSIGô ,ô,ESSIGô&REEô#ULTUREô0ENGUIN ô,ONDONôô )ô.ONAKA ô)KUJIROôANDô(ô4AKEUCHIô4HEô+NOWLEDGEô#REATINGô#OMPANYô/XFORDô5NIVERSITYô0RESS ô /XFORDôô 2ô3TALLMANô&REEô3OFTWARE ô&REEô3OCIETYô3ELECTEDô%SSAYSôOFô2ICHARDô-ô3TALLMANô%DITEDôBYô *OSHUAô'AY ô4HEô'.5ô0RESS ô"OSTONôô 4ô6AD¯Nôg$IGITALô.OMINALISMô.OTESôONôTHEôETHICSôOFôINFORMATIONôSOCIETYôINôVIEWôOFôTHEôONTOLOGYôOFô THEôDIGITALuô%THICSôANDô)NFORMATIONô4ECHNOLOGYôVOLô ôNOô ôô 3ô:IZEKô/Nô"ELIEFô2OUTLEDGE ô,ONDONôô 3ô:IZEKô/RGANSôWITHOUTô"ODIESô/Nô$ELEUZEôANDô#ONSEQUENCESô2OUTLEDGE ô,ONDONô


0240_057_self_org.indd 306-307


25/09/06 17:41:43

5++ômô9OUNGôARTôWORKERS ô$ENMARK

mô 4HEôESTABLISHMENTôOFôANô)NSTITUTEôFORô#ONTEMPORARYô!RTôINô$ENMARK ôWITHôEQUALô

$ESCRIPTION

mô 4HEôESTABLISHMENTôOFôkXEDôRATESôANDôMINIMUMôWAGESôFORôARTISTSôEXHIBITINGôATôINSTITU

FOCUSôONôANDôFUNDINGôFORôRESEARCH ôPRODUCTIONôANDôEXHIBITION 5++ ô9OUNGô!RTô7ORKERS ôISôANôORGANIZATIONôFORôYOUNGERôARTISTSôANDôARTôWORKERSôINô $ENMARK

TIONSôANDôFORôFREELANCEôCURATORSôWORKINGôFORôINSTITUTIONS mô !ôLARGERôANDôFAIRERôREPRESENTATIONôOFôCONTEMPORARYôARTôINôMASSôMEDIA mô 4HEôESTABLISHMENTôOFôANôUNEMPLOYMENTôFUNDôANDôRATEôFORôARTISTS

4EXT 4HEôORGANIZATIONôWASôFORMEDôINôTHEôSUMMERôOFô ôASôANôOUTCOMEôOFôTHEôPROTESTSô

3OURCE

AGAINSTôTHEôNEWLYôELECTEDôULTRAôRIGHTôWINGôGOVERNMENTôANDôITSôPOLICIESô3INCEôGAIN

WWWUKKDK

INGôPOWERôINôTHEô.OVEMBERôôELECTIONS ôTHEôRIGHTôWINGôGOVERNMENTôHASôTARGETEDô CONTEMPORARYôARTôAMONGôOTHERôAREASôINôTHEô$ANISHôSOCIETYôSUCHôASôENVIRONMENTALô


PROTECTION ôEDUCATION ôIMMIGRATIONôANDôHUMANôRIGHTSôWITHôECONOMICôCUTôBACKSôANDô

WWWUKKDK

POLITICALôRESTRICTIONSô4HEôCUTôBACKSôDIRECTEDôATôTHEôARTSôSECTORôPARTICULARLYôHITôYOUNGô ANDôEXPERIMENTALôART ôASôWELLôASôINTERNATIONALôEXCHANGESôANDôEFFORTSô/NEôOFôTHEô REASONSôTHISôWASôPOSSIBLE ôEVENôRELATIVELYôEASY ôWASôDUEôTOôTHEôFACTôTHATôNOôOTHERô ORGANIZATIONSôSPOKEôONôTHEôBEHALFôOFôTHOSEôWORKINGôINôTHISôkELDô!SôSUCH ô5++ôWASô ALSOôFORMEDôINôOPPOSITIONôTOôTHEôEXISTINGôARTISTSôASSOCIATIONSôANDôTHEôROYALôARTISTSô GUILDôANDôTHEIRôCONSERVATIVE ôELITISTôPOLICIESôANDôAGENDAS ô

5++ôTHUSôHAVEôAôDUALôAIMôATôONCEôDIRECTEDôOUTWARDôTOWARDSôTHEôPOLITICALôkELDô

ANDôTHEôMEDIA ôANDôINWARDSôTOWARDSôTHEôORGANIZATIONôANDôSTRUCTUREôOFôTHEôARTôWORLDô ANDôITSôINSTITUTIONSô5++ôAIMSôFORôAôMOREôDYNAMICôANDôOPENôkELDôFORôCONTEMPORARYô ART ôANDôISôTHEôONLYôORGANIZATIONôTOôINCLUDEôTWOôGROUPSôOFôARTôWORKERS ôARTISTSôASôWELLô ASôCRITICSCURATORSôINôANôEFFORTôTOôBRIDGEôTHEôTRADITIONALôGAPôBETWEENôPRACTICEôANDô THEORY ôBETWEENôPRODUCTIONôANDôMEDIATIONô4HEôORGANIZATIONôFOCUSESôONôTHEôRIGHTSô ANDôWORKINGôCONDITIONSôOFôCONTEMPORARY ôYOUNGERôARTôWORKERS ôWITHôAôDELIMITATIONôOFô ôYEARSôOFôPROFESSIONALôLIFEô!SôOPPOSEDôTOôOTHERôORGANIZATIONS ôMEMBERSHIPôINô5++ô SHALLôBEôGAINEDôTHROUGHôPURELYôNOMINALôRATHERôTHANôAESTHETICôGROUNDSôANYONEôWORK INGôPROFESSIONALLYôWITHINôCONTEMPORARYôARTôSHALLôBEôACCEPTEDôINôORDERôTOôREPRESENTô THEôkELDôINôITSôBROADEST ôRATHERôTHANôNARROWEST ôELITISTôSENSEô5++ôALSOôREPRESENTSô STUDENTSôATôACADEMIESôANDôUNIVERSITIES 4HEôORGANIZATIONôWILLôWORKôTOWARDSôTHEôFOLLOWINGôGOALS mô !ôMOREôOPENôANDôTRANSPARENTôSTRUCTUREôINôTHEô$ANISHôARTôSYSTEM mô 4HEôDEVELOPMENTôOFôANôARTôSYSTEMôTHATôINCLUDEôEXPERIMENTALôART ôNEWôMEDIAôANDô INTERNATIONALôEXCHANGE mô !ôBROADERôANDôMOREôENHANCEDôDEBATEôONôCONTEMPORARYôARTôANDôITSôPLACEMENT ô BOTHôONôTHEôARTôSCENEôANDôINôTHEôGENERALôPUBLICôSPHERE mô -OREôEXHIBITIONSôOFôCONTEMPORARYôANDôEXPERIMENTALôARTôINôMUSEUMSôANDôPUBLICô INSTITUTIONS mô %QUALITYôBETWEENôMENôANDôWOMENôINôPOSITIONSôATôINSTITUTIONS ôASôWELLôASôINôCOLLEC TIONSôANDôEXHIBITIONSôINôTHEôINSTITUTIONS mô 2EPRESENTATIONôOFô5++ôINôPUBLICôANDôMINISTERIALôCOMMITTEESôANDôCOUNCILSôTHATô PERTAINSôTOôCONTEMPORARYôART

%XAMPLESôôYôô2((ñjñ6LRKDñ>OQñTLOHBOP ñ!BKJ>OH

0240_057_self_org.indd 308-309

%XAMPLESôôYôô2((ñjñ6LRKDñ>OQñTLOHBOP ñ!BKJ>OH

25/09/06 17:41:44

'UARAN¶ô 0OWER 7ILLô"RADLEY


0240_057_self_org.indd 310-311

'UARANAô0OWER

25/09/06 17:41:44

'UARAN¶ô0OWERôISôAôCOMMERCIALLYôMANU FACTUREDôANDôMARKETEDôSOFTôDRINKôPRO DUCEDôBYôANôORGANISATIONôCALLINGôITSELFô THEô0OWERô&OUNDATION ôBUTôTHEô'UARAN¶ô 0OWERôPROJECTôASôAôWHOLEôISôTHEôRESULTôOFô AôSPECIkCôCOMBINATIONôOFôGROUPS ôIDEAS ô STRATEGIESôANDôECONOMICôANDôLEGALôCONDI TIONS ôANDôITSôPOTENTIALôIMPLICATIONSôAREô FARôWIDERôANDôMOREôCOMPLEXôTHANôTHEô SIMPLEôCREATIONôOFôYETôANOTHERôBRANDôOFô SODAôMIGHTôSUGGEST !TôTHEôCENTREôOFôTHEôPROJECTôISôANôALLIANCEô BETWEENôTHEô#/!)-!ôCOOPERATIVE ôAôSELF ORGANISEDôGROUPôOFô!MAZONIANôFARMERSô LOOKINGôFORôAôWAYôTOôSECUREôTHEIRôLIVELI HOODôINôTHEôFACEôOFôCORPORATEôMANIPU LATIONôOFôTHEôMARKETôFORôTHEIRôPRODUCE ô ANDô3UPERlEX ôAôGROUPôOFô$ANISHôARTISTSô ôINTERESTEDôINôBOTHôTHEôCREATIONôOFôCON CEPTUALôANDôPRACTICALôTOOLSôFORôCOMMUNITYô EMPOWERMENT ôANDôPRACTICALôSTRATEGIESô FORôNON EXPLOITATIVEôEXCHANGEôINôTHEô ôCURRENTôGLOBALôECONOMYô

'UARANAô0OWER

0240_057_self_org.indd 312-313

"ACKGROUND 'UARAN¶ôISôAôVINEômôTECHNICALLYôAôWOODYôLIANAômôTHATôCANôBEôPER SUADEDôTOôGROWôASôAôBUSHôONôOPENôLANDô4HEôPLANTôISôORIGINALLYô NATIVEôTOôTHEô-AU¯SôREGIONôOFô"RAZIL ôANDôTHEôFRUIT ôAôREDôBERRY ô HASôLONGôBEENôHARVESTEDôBYôTHEôLOCALôINDIGENOUSôPEOPLE ôTHEô -AU¯ 3ATAR¯ ôFORôITSôMEDICINALôANDôENERGY GIVINGôPROPERTIESô 4HEôWORDôGUARAN¶ôITSELFôCOMESôFROMôTHEôLOCALôLANGUAGEôANDô MEANSô@LIKEôEYES ôBECAUSEôTHEôCLUSTERSôOFôRIPEôFRUITôSPLITôOPENô ONôTHEôVINEôTOôREVEALôDARKôBROWNôSTONESôSURROUNDEDôBYôWHITEô PITHô4HEôCAFFEINE PACKEDôBERRIESôFORMôTHEôBASISôOFô"RAZILSô MOSTôPOPULARôSOFTôDRINKSômô"RAZILôISôONEôOFôTHEôFEWôCOUNTRIESô ONôTHEôPLANETôWHEREô#OCA #OLAôISôNOTôTHEôMARKETôLEADERômôANDô GUARAN¶ôISôFARMEDôCOMMERCIALLYôBYôSMALLôPRODUCERSôWHOôSELLô TOôTHEôBIGôSODAôMANUFACTURERSô2ECENTLY ôHOWEVER ôTHEôMULTINA TIONALôCORPORATIONSôTHATôBUYôMOSTôOFôTHEôGUARAN¶ôHAVE ôTHROUGHô MERGERSôANDôMUTUALôAGREEMENTS ôEFFECTIVELYôFORMEDôAôCARTELôANDô NOôLONGERôCOMPETEôFORôTHEôCROPô#ONSEQUENTLY ôACCORDINGôTOô THEôLOCALôFARMERS ôTHEôPRICEôPAIDôTOôTHEôPRODUCERSôHASôDROPPEDô FROMôKILOôTOôKILOôINôONLYôFOURôYEARS ôWRECKINGôTHEôLOCALô ECONOMYôANDôTHEôLIVELIHOODSôOFôTHEôFARMERS ôWHILEôTHEôPRICEôOFô THEôPRODUCTSôTHEôCORPORATIONSôSELLôHASôREMAINEDôTHEôSAMEôORô RISENô4HEôCORPORATIONSômô!M"EV ôANôAFkLIATEôOFô$UTCHôFOODô GIANTô7ESSANENôFORMEDôOUTôOFôTHEôMERGERôOFô"RAZILIANôDRINKSô MANUFACTURERSô!NTARCTICAôANDô"RAHMA ôANDô0EPSI#O ôWHOôHAVEô SIGNEDôAôMUTUALôDISTRIBUTIONôDEALôWITHô!M"EVômôHAVEôALSOôES TABLISHEDôAôSMALLôPLANTATIONôOFôTHEIRôOWN ôWHICHôFUNCTIONSôASôAô VEILEDôTHREATôTOôTHEôLOCALôPRODUCERSôACCEPTôTHEôSITUATION ôORôWEô WILLôEXPANDôANDôPUTôYOUôOUTôOFôBUSINESSôCOMPLETELYô

'UARANAô0OWER

25/09/06 17:41:44

4HEô7EATHERô5NDERGROUND $ESCRIPTION g(ELLO ô)MôGOINGôTOôREADôAôDECLARATIONôOFôAôSTATEôOFôWARWITHINôTHEôNEXTôôDAYSôWEô WILLôATTACKôAôSYMBOLôORôINSTITUTIONôOFô!MERICANôINJUSTICEuô mô"ERNARDINEô$OHRN 4EXT )Nô/CTOBERôôHUNDREDSôOFôYOUNGôPEOPLE ôCLADôINôFOOTBALLôHELMETSôANDôWIELDINGôLEADô PIPES ôMARCHEDôTHROUGHôANôUPSCALEô#HICAGOôSHOPPINGôDISTRICT ôPUMMELINGôPARKEDô CARSôANDôSMASHINGôSHOPôWINDOWSôINôTHEIRôPATH ô

4HISôWASôTHEôkRSTôDEMONSTRATIONôOFôTHEô7EATHERô5NDERGROUNDSôg$AYSôOFô2AGEuô

/UTRAGEDôBYôTHEô6IETNAMô7ARôANDôRACISMôINô!MERICA ôTHEôORGANIZATIONôWAGEDôAôLOW LEVELôWARôAGAINSTôTHEô53ôGOVERNMENTôTHROUGHôMUCHôOFôTHEôS ôBOMBINGôTHEô #APITOLôBUILDING ôBREAKINGô4IMOTHYô,EARYôOUTôOFôPRISON ôANDôEVADINGôONEôOFôTHEôLARGESTô &")ôMANHUNTSôINôHISTORY ô

4HEô7EATHERô5NDERGROUNDôISôAôFEATURE LENGTHôDOCUMENTARYôTHATôEXPLORESôTHEôRISEô

ANDôFALLôOFôTHISôRADICALôMOVEMENT ôASôFORMERôMEMBERSôSPEAKôCANDIDLYôABOUTôTHEôIDE ALISTICôPASSIONôTHATôDROVEôTHEMôTOôgBRINGôTHEôWARôHOMEuôANDôTHEôTRAJECTORYôTHATôPLACEDô THEMôONôTHEô&")SôMOSTôWANTEDôLIST 3OURCEô WWWUPSTATEkLMSORGWEATHERMAINHTML &ORôMOREôINFORMATION $IRECTED ô3AMô'REEN ôCO DIRECTORôôPRODUCERô"ILLô3IEGEL ôPRODUCERô#ARRIEô,OZANOô $URATIONôôMIN ô9EARô 0HOTOôCREDITô$AVIDô&ENTON

0240_057_self_org.indd 314-315

%XAMPLESôôYôô1EBñ4B>QEBOñ2KABODOLRKA

25/09/06 17:41:46

#/!)-! ô3UPERlEX ôANDô'UARAN¶ô0OWER 3UPERFLEXôWEREôINVITEDôBYô.)&#!ôTHEô.ORDICô)NSTITUTEôFORô ô#ONTEMPORARYô!RT ôTHEô3Óô0AULO BASEDôFOUNDATIONô%XTRAô !RTE ôANDôTHEô!MAZONIANôGOVERNMENTôTOôTRAVELôTOô"RAZILôANDô EXPLOREôTHEôPOSSIBILITYôOFôPRODUCINGôSOMEôKINDôOFôCONTEMPORARYô ARTôPROJECTôINôTHEô!MAZONôREGIONô4HISôOPEN ENDEDôINVITATIONô EVOLVEDôAFTERôMUCHôINVESTIGATIONôANDôDISCUSSIONôWITHôVARIOUSô ORGANISATIONSôINôTHEôREGION ôPARTICULARLYôTHEô)NSTITUTEôFORôTHEô 0ROTECTIONôOFôTHEô!MAZONô%NVIRONMENTô)NSTITUTOôDEô0ROTE±Óô !MBIENTALôDOô!MAZONASôORô)0!!- ôINTOôTHEôINTENTIONôTOôTRAVELô TOô-AU¯SôWHEREôTHEôMAYOR ô3IDNEYô,EITE ôHADôAôREPUTATIONôASô ANôEDUCATIONALISTôANDôAôPRO ACTIVEôREFORMERô/VERôTHEôCOURSEô OFôTHEIRôkRSTôTHREEôWEEKSôINô-AU¯S ô3UPERlEXôWEREôINTRODUCEDô TOôTHEôSITUATIONôFACINGôTHEôLOCALôFARMERS ôANDôTOôTHEô#/!)-!ô COOPERATIVE ôNEWLYôFORMEDôINôRESPONSEôTOôTHEôACTIONSôOFôTHEô MULTINATIONALSô4HEIRôINITIALôCONVERSATIONSôLEDôTOôTHEôORGANISATIONô OFôAôTWO DAYôWORKSHOPôTOôEXPLOREôPOSSIBLEôSTRATEGIESôFORôTHEô COOPERATIVESôFUTURE

&ROMôTHEôPOINTôOFôVIEWôOFôTHEô7ESTERNôARTISTS ôAôDIFFERENTôDI LEMMAôALSOôPRESENTSôITSELFô7HATôAREôOURôRESPONSIBILITIESôINôTHISô SITUATIONô!REôWEôHEREôTOôPRODUCEôAôPROJECTôTHATôWILLôHAVEôSOMEô METAPHORICALôRESONANCEôINôTHEô%UROPEANôARTôWORLDô!REôWEô HEREôTOôADVANCEôANôIDEOLOGICALôACTIVISTôAGENDA ôORôASôSOMEô KINDôOFôINTERNATIONALôSOCIALôWORKERSô/FôCOURSE ôITSôNOTôPOSSI BLEôFORôAôSMALLôCOOPERATIVE ôWITHôFEWôRESOURCESôANDôNOôCAPITAL ô TOôCOMPETEôDIRECTLYôWITHôAôMULTINATIONALôCORPORATION ôANDôONEô ANSWERôTOôSOMEôOFôTHEôQUESTIONSôRAISEDôBYôTHISôSITUATIONôISô THATôEFFECTIVEôCOMPETITIONôINôTHEôGLOBALôMARKETPLACEôISôNOT ôORô SHOULDôNOTôBE ôTHEôAIMômôETHICALôCONSUMERISMôISôAôCONTRADIC TIONôINôTERMS ôANDôEFFORTSôTOWARDSôREALôCHANGEôSHOULDôBEôAIMEDô ATôCREATINGôSITUATIONSôOFôCONlICTôINôWHICHôTHEôPOSSIBILITYôOFôAô NEW ôHUMANEôSOCIALôANDôPOLITICALôORDERôISôCLEARLYôOPPOSEDôTOô THEôPREVAILINGôSYSTEMô4HESEôCONSIDERATIONSôAREôREAL ôANDôVITAL ô BUTôINôTHEôCONTEXTôOFôAôDEBATEôAMONGSTôAôGROUPôOFô!MAZONIANô FARMERSôPRIMARILYôCONCERNEDôWITHôBASICôECONOMICôSURVIVAL ôTHEYô WEREôALSOôQUICKLYôREEVALUATEDôONôPRAGMATICôTERMS

#/!)-!ôANDôTHEôCORPORATIONSôSHAREôAôMUTUALôANTAGONISM ô ANDôTHEôWORKSHOPôPARTICIPANTSôRAISEDôTWOôCONTRADICTORYôPOINTSô &IRST ôINôORDERôTOôESCAPEôFROMôTHEôCORPORATEôMONOPOLYôONôTHEô RAWôMATERIALôTHEYôWEREôGROWING ôITôWASôNECESSARYôTOôkNDôAôWAYô TOôPRODUCEôAôSECONDARYôPRODUCTôTHATôCOULDôBEôSOLDôINôAôDIFFER ENTôMARKET ôPERHAPSôEVENôCOMPETINGôDIRECTLYôWITHôTHEôCORPORATEô BRANDSô3ECOND ôTHEôCOMMUNITYôHASôNOôCAPITALôANDôNOôACCESSô TOôMANUFACTURINGôEQUIPMENTôORôDISTRIBUTIONôMECHANISMSôTOô MAKEôTHISôPOSSIBLEômôASôONEôOFôTHEôPARTICIPANTSôPOINTEDôOUT ô @ALLôWEôHAVEôISôGUARAN¶ô3OôTHEôWORKSHOPôBEGANôTOôFOCUSôONô WAYSôOFôRESOLVINGôTHISôCONTRADICTION

3UPERlEXôPRESENTEDôTHEMSELVESôASôSIMPLYôONEôVOICEôAMONGSTô MANYôAND ôONCEôITôWASôESTABLISHEDôTHATôTHEYôCOULDôNOTôOFFERô ANYôINSTANTôkNANCIALôSALVATION ôTHISôWASôJUSTôWHATôTHEYôWEREô (OWEVER ôTHEIRôPRESENCEôUNDOUBTEDLYôFUNCTIONEDôASôAôCATALYSTô FORôTHEôDISCUSSIONSôTHATôTOOKôPLACEô!TôTHEôWORKSHOP ôMEMBERSô OFôTHEôCOOPERATIVEôPRESENTEDôAôVARIETYôOFôLOCALôPRODUCTSôFORôDIS CUSSION ôFROMôCHOCOLATESôANDôSOFTôDRINKSôTOôSCULPTURESôOFôGUAR AN¶ôFRUITôMADEôOUTôOFôPOWDEREDôGUARAN¶ ôENERGY HITôPOTIONSô FORôLONG DISTANCEôTRUCKERSôANDôGUARAN¶ôICE CREAMô3UPERlEXô OFFERED ôASôAôPOTENTIALôMODEL ôTHEôPHENOMENONôOFô@-ECCAô#OLAô môAôBRANDôOFôCOLAôCREATEDôBYôAô&RENCHôCOMPANYôTHATôDONATESô AôPERCENTAGEôOFôPROkTSôTOô0ALESTINIANôCHARITIESôWITHôTHEôSLOGANô @0ASôBUVEZôSTUPIDE ôBUVEZôENGAG¯ô@$ONTôDRINKôSTUPID ôDRINKô

'UARANAô0OWER

'UARANAô0OWER

0240_057_self_org.indd 316-317

25/09/06 17:41:46

WITHôCOMMITMENT ô4HEôASSEMBLEDôPARTICIPANTSôSELECTEDôCER TAINôPROPOSALSôFORôDEVELOPMENT ôANDôDECIDEDôTOôRECONVENEôLATERô INôTHEôWEEKôONCEôTHESEôHADôBEENôWORKEDôONôFURTHER 4HEôSECONDôWORKSHOPôSESSIONôINVOLVEDôTHEôPRESENTATIONôOFô SEVERALôPROTOTYPEôPRODUCTS ôALONGôWITHôIDEASôFORôHOWôTHEYô MIGHTôBEôMARKETEDô4HEôRECIPESôRANGEDôFROMôGUARAN¶ôANDôGIN GERôSWEETSôTOôALLôKINDSôOFôENERGY GIVINGôSOFTôDRINKS ôBUTôTHEô EXAMPLEôOFô-ECCAô#OLAôALSOôPROVEDôTOôBEôAôPOWERFULôINSPIRA TIONô#HOCOLATEôBARSôWEREôBRANDEDô@-AU¯Sô"ARSôASôOPPOSEDô TOô@-ARSô"ARS ôANDôlAVOUREDôWITHôCUPUASSU ôANô!MAZONIANôFRUITô WHOSEôINTENSE ôINDESCRIBABLEôlAVOURôISôLITTLE KNOWNôELSEWHEREô VARIOUSôDRINKSôWEREôPROPOSEDôINCLUDINGô@!MAZONIAôASôANôAD APTATIONôOFô@!NTARCTICA ô!M"EVSôMAINôGUARAN¶ôDRINKôPRODUCTô SUGGESTEDôBYô0AOLOô,EVI ôONEôOFôTHEôCOOPERATIVESôMAINôORGAN ISERS ô@-AU¯SCAF¯ôAGAINSTô@.ESCAF¯ôASôAôBREAKFASTôWAKE UP ô ANDô@0EP3IMô@%NERGY9ESôINô0ORTUGESE ôAô3UPERlEXôPROPOSAL ô AGAINSTô0EPSIôCOLAô4HESEôLASTôTHREEôWEREôALLôTHEôMOREôINTEREST INGôBECAUSEôTHEYôWEREôPURELYô@CONCEPTUALôMARKETINGôSUGGES TIONS ôWITHôNOôEXISTINGôLOCALôPRODUCTôBEHINDôTHEM ôYETôTHEYôWEREô AMONGôTHEôMOSTôPOPULARôPROPOSALS &URTHERôRESEARCHôLEDôTOôTHEôCONCLUSIONôTHATôSOFT DRINKôMANU FACTURINGôWASôTHEôEASIESTôWAYôFORôTHEôCOOPERATIVEôTOôTRANSLATEô THEIRôRAWôMATERIALôINTOôAôSALEABLEôPRODUCTôWITHOUTôHAVINGôTOô BUILDôAôFACTORYôOFôTHEIRôOWNô)TôWASôALSOôQUICKLYôREALISEDôTHATô 0AOLOô,EVISôSUGGESTIONôOFôAôSUBVERSIONôOFôTHEô!NTARCTICAôBRANDô OFFERED ôINôADDITION ôANôEFFECTIVEôWAYôTOôPUBLICISEô#/!)-!Sô SITUATIONôINôRELATIONôTOô!M"EV ôANDôAFTERôSOMEôFURTHERôORGANI SATIONALôEFFORTôONôTHEôPARTôOFô3UPERlEX ôTHEôkNALôPRODUCTôWASô DEVELOPEDôINôCOLLABORATIONôWITHôTHEôSMALLô$ANISHôMANUFACTURERô 3OEBOGAARD

'UARANAô0OWER

0240_057_self_org.indd 318-319

4HEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôLABELôUSESôTHEôSAMEôRED ôGREENôANDôBLACKô COLOURôSCHEMEôANDôSHAPESôASôTHEô!NTARCTICAôLABEL ôBUTôWITHô AôHEAVYôBLACKôBARôOVERôTHEôSPACEôWHEREôTHEôCORPORATEôLOGOô WOULDôNORMALLYôBEô4HEôLABELôMAKESôITôCLEARôTHATôTHATôPROD UCTôISôNOTôFROMô!M"EVôBUTôISô@REALô-AU¯SôGUARAN¶ôFORôENERGYô ANDôEMPOWERMENTô4HEôWHOLEôISôSUPERIMPOSEDôONôAôPHOTOôOFô MEMBERSôOFôTHEô#/)!-!ôCOOPERATIVE ôANDôAôSHORTôTEXTôONôTHEô BACKôOFôTHEôBOTTLEôREADS ôWITHôTHEôNAMESôOFôTHEôCORPORATIONSô ALSOôBLACKEDôOUT '5!2!.Óô0/7%2ôISôANôENERGYôSOFTDRINKôPRODUCEDôBYôAô GUARAN¶ôFARMERSôCOOPERATIVEôFROMô-AU¯SôINôTHEô"RAZILIANô!MA ZON ôINôCOLLABORATIONôWITHô4HEô0OWERô&OUNDATIONô4HEôFARMERSô HAVEôORGANISEDôTHEMSELVESôINôRESPONSEôTOôTHEôACTIVITIESôOFôTHEô MULTINATIONALôCORPORATIONSô!MBEVôANDô0EPSICO ôAôCARTELôWHOSEô MONOPOLY LIKEôPOSITIONôONôTHEôPURCHASEôOFôTHEôRAWôMATERIALô HASôDRIVENôTHEôPRICEôOFôGUARAN¶ôBERRIESôDOWNô ôWHILEôTHEô COSTôOFôTHEIRôPRODUCTSôTOôTHEôCONSUMERôHASôRISENô'5!2!.Óô 0/7%2ôEMPLOYSôGLOBALôBRANDSôANDôTHEIRôSTRATEGIESôASôRAWô MATERIALôFORôAôCOUNTER ECONOMICôPOSITIONôWHILEôRECLAIMINGôTHEô ORIGINALôUSEôOFôTHEô-AU¯SôGUARAN¶ôPLANTôASôAôPOWERFULôNATURALô TONIC ôNOTôJUSTôAôSYMBOLô'5!2!.Óô0/7%2ôCONTAINSôORIGINALô -AU¯SôGUARAN¶ôFORôENERGYôANDôEMPOWERMENT

'UARAN¶ô0OWERôASôART 3UPERlEXôHAVEôPRESENTEDôDOCUMENTATIONôOFôTHEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERô PROJECT ôANDôTHEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôDRINK ôATôARTôINSTITUTIONSôANDô INTERNATIONALôBIENNIALS ôANDôTHEôPROJECTôHASôBEENôDISCUSSEDôANDô CRITIQUEDôINôTERMSôOFôTHEôRECENTLY FORMEDôBUTôOFTENôRETROSPEC TIVELY APPLIEDôCATEGORYôOFô@SOCIALôPRACTICEô(OWôISôITôPOSSIBLEô

'UARANAô0OWER

25/09/06 17:41:47

7IKIPEDIA Wikipedia:Text of the GNU Free Documentation License - Wikipedia, the free encyc...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Text_of_the_GNU_Free_Documentation_Li... Wikipedia:Text of the GNU Free Documentation License - Wikipedia, the free encyc...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Text_of_the_GNU_Free_Documentation_Li...

$ESCRIPTION

text near the most prominent appearance of the work's title, preceding the beginning of the body of the text.

Wikipedia:Text of the GNU Free Documentation License

A section "Entitled XYZ" means a named subunit of the Document whose title either is precisely XYZ or contains XYZ in parentheses following text that translates XYZ in another language. (Here XYZ stands for a specific section name mentioned below, such as "Acknowledgements", "Dedications", "Endorsements", or "History".) To "Preserve the Title" of such a section when you modify the Document means that it remains a section "Entitled XYZ" according to this definition.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Version 1.2, November 2002

The Document may include Warranty Disclaimers next to the notice which states that this License applies to the Document. These Warranty Disclaimers are considered to be included by reference in this License, but only as regards disclaiming warranties: any other implication that these Warranty Disclaimers may have is void and has no effect on the meaning of this License.

Copyright (C) 2000,2001,2002 Free Software Foundation, Inc. 51 Franklin St, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA 02110-1301 USA Everyone is permitted to copy and distribute verbatim copies of this license document, but changing it is not allowed.

2. VERBATIM COPYING

0. PREAMBLE The purpose of this License is to make a manual, textbook, or other functional and useful document "free" in the sense of freedom: to assure everyone the effective freedom to copy and redistribute it, with or without modifying it, either commercially or noncommercially. Secondarily, this License preserves for the author and publisher a way to get credit for their work, while not being considered responsible for modifications made by others.

You may copy and distribute the Document in any medium, either commercially or noncommercially, provided that this License, the copyright notices, and the license notice saying this License applies to the Document are reproduced in all copies, and that you add no other conditions whatsoever to those of this License. You may not use technical measures to obstruct or control the reading or further copying of the copies you make or distribute. However, you may accept compensation in exchange for copies. If you distribute a large enough number of copies you must also follow the conditions in section 3. You may also lend copies, under the same conditions stated above, and you may publicly display copies.

This License is a kind of "copyleft", which means that derivative works of the document must themselves be free in the same sense. It complements the GNU General Public License, which is a copyleft license designed for free software.

3. COPYING IN QUANTITY

We have designed this License in order to use it for manuals for free software, because free software needs free documentation: a free program should come with manuals providing the same freedoms that the software does. But this License is not limited to software manuals; it can be used for any textual work, regardless of subject matter or whether it is published as a printed book. We recommend this License principally for works whose purpose is instruction or reference.

If you publish printed copies (or copies in media that commonly have printed covers) of the Document, numbering more than 100, and the Document's license notice requires Cover Texts, you must enclose the copies in covers that carry, clearly and legibly, all these Cover Texts: Front-Cover Texts on the front cover, and Back-Cover Texts on the back cover. Both covers must also clearly and legibly identify you as the publisher of these copies. The front cover must present the full title with all words of the title equally prominent and visible. You may add other material on the covers in addition. Copying with changes limited to the covers, as long as they preserve the title of the Document and satisfy these conditions, can be treated as verbatim copying in other respects.

1. APPLICABILITY AND DEFINITIONS This License applies to any manual or other work, in any medium, that contains a notice placed by the copyright holder saying it can be distributed under the terms of this License. Such a notice grants a world-wide, royalty-free license, unlimited in duration, to use that work under the conditions stated herein. The "Document", below, refers to any such manual or work. Any member of the public is a licensee, and is addressed as "you". You accept the license if you copy, modify or distribute the work in a way requiring permission under copyright law. A "Modified Version" of the Document means any work containing the Document or a portion of it, either copied verbatim, or with modifications and/or translated into another language. A "Secondary Section" is a named appendix or a front-matter section of the Document that deals exclusively with the relationship of the publishers or authors of the Document to the Document's overall subject (or to related matters) and contains nothing that could fall directly within that overall subject. (Thus, if the Document is in part a textbook of mathematics, a Secondary Section may not explain any mathematics.) The relationship could be a matter of historical connection with the subject or with related matters, or of legal, commercial, philosophical, ethical or political position regarding them. The "Invariant Sections" are certain Secondary Sections whose titles are designated, as being those of Invariant Sections, in the notice that says that the Document is released under this License. If a section does not fit the above definition of Secondary then it is not allowed to be designated as Invariant. The Document may contain zero Invariant Sections. If the Document does not identify any Invariant Sections then there are none. The "Cover Texts" are certain short passages of text that are listed, as Front-Cover Texts or Back-Cover Texts, in the notice that says that the Document is released under this License. A Front-Cover Text may be at most 5 words, and a Back-Cover Text may be at most 25 words. A "Transparent" copy of the Document means a machine-readable copy, represented in a format whose specification is available to the general public, that is suitable for revising the document straightforwardly with generic text editors or (for images composed of pixels) generic paint programs or (for drawings) some widely available drawing editor, and that is suitable for input to text formatters or for automatic translation to a variety of formats suitable for input to text formatters. A copy made in an otherwise Transparent file format whose markup, or absence of markup, has been arranged to thwart or discourage subsequent modification by readers is not Transparent. An image format is not Transparent if used for any substantial amount of text. A copy that is not "Transparent" is called "Opaque". Examples of suitable formats for Transparent copies include plain ASCII without markup, Texinfo input format, LaTeX input format, SGML or XML using a publicly available DTD, and standard-conforming simple HTML, PostScript or PDF designed for human modification. Examples of transparent image formats include PNG, XCF and JPG. Opaque formats include proprietary formats that can be read and edited only by proprietary word processors, SGML or XML for which the DTD and/or processing tools are not generally available, and the machine-generated HTML, PostScript or PDF produced by some word processors for output purposes only. The "Title Page" means, for a printed book, the title page itself, plus such following pages as are needed to hold, legibly, the material this License requires to appear in the title page. For works in formats which do not have any title page as such, "Title Page" means the

1 of 4

If the required texts for either cover are too voluminous to fit legibly, you should put the first ones listed (as many as fit reasonably) on the actual cover, and continue the rest onto adjacent pages. If you publish or distribute Opaque copies of the Document numbering more than 100, you must either include a machine-readable Transparent copy along with each Opaque copy, or state in or with each Opaque copy a computer-network location from which the general network-using public has access to download using public-standard network protocols a complete Transparent copy of the Document, free of added material. If you use the latter option, you must take reasonably prudent steps, when you begin distribution of Opaque copies in quantity, to ensure that this Transparent copy will remain thus accessible at the stated location until at least one year after the last time you distribute an Opaque copy (directly or through your agents or retailers) of that edition to the public. It is requested, but not required, that you contact the authors of the Document well before redistributing any large number of copies, to give them a chance to provide you with an updated version of the Document.

4. MODIFICATIONS You may copy and distribute a Modified Version of the Document under the conditions of sections 2 and 3 above, provided that you release the Modified Version under precisely this License, with the Modified Version filling the role of the Document, thus licensing distribution and modification of the Modified Version to whoever possesses a copy of it. In addition, you must do these things in the Modified Version: A. Use in the Title Page (and on the covers, if any) a title distinct from that of the Document, and from those of previous versions (which should, if there were any, be listed in the History section of the Document). You may use the same title as a previous version if the original publisher of that version gives permission. B. List on the Title Page, as authors, one or more persons or entities responsible for authorship of the modifications in the Modified Version, together with at least five of the principal authors of the Document (all of its principal authors, if it has fewer than five), unless they release you from this requirement. C. State on the Title page the name of the publisher of the Modified Version, as the publisher. D. Preserve all the copyright notices of the Document. E. Add an appropriate copyright notice for your modifications adjacent to the other copyright notices. F. Include, immediately after the copyright notices, a license notice giving the public permission to use the Modified Version under the terms of this License, in the form shown in the Addendum below. G. Preserve in that license notice the full lists of Invariant Sections and required Cover Texts given in the Document's license notice. H. Include an unaltered copy of this License. I. Preserve the section Entitled "History", Preserve its Title, and add to it an item stating at least the title, year, new authors, and publisher of the Modified Version as given on the Title Page. If there is no section Entitled "History" in the Document, create one stating the title, year, authors, and publisher of the Document as given on its Title Page, then add an item describing the Modified Version as stated in the previous sentence. J. Preserve the network location, if any, given in the Document for public access to a Transparent copy of the Document, and likewise the network locations given in the Document for previous versions it was based on. These may be placed in the "History" section. You may omit a network location for a work that was published at least four years before the Document itself, or if the original publisher of the version it refers to gives permission. K. For any section Entitled "Acknowledgements" or "Dedications", Preserve the Title of the section, and preserve in the section all the substance and tone of each of the contributor acknowledgements and/or dedications given therein.

18/09/06 17:05 2 of 4

Wikipedia:Text of the GNU Free Documentation License - Wikipedia, the free encyc...

18/09/06 17:05

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Text_of_the_GNU_Free_Documentation_Li... Wikipedia:Text of the GNU Free Documentation License - Wikipedia, the free encyc...

L. Preserve all the Invariant Sections of the Document, unaltered in their text and in their titles. Section numbers or the equivalent are not considered part of the section titles. M. Delete any section Entitled "Endorsements". Such a section may not be included in the Modified Version. N. Do not retitle any existing section to be Entitled "Endorsements" or to conflict in title with any Invariant Section. O. Preserve any Warranty Disclaimers.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Text_of_the_GNU_Free_Documentation_Li...

9. TERMINATION You may not copy, modify, sublicense, or distribute the Document except as expressly provided for under this License. Any other attempt to copy, modify, sublicense or distribute the Document is void, and will automatically terminate your rights under this License. However, parties who have received copies, or rights, from you under this License will not have their licenses terminated so long as such parties remain in full compliance.

You may add a section Entitled "Endorsements", provided it contains nothing but endorsements of your Modified Version by various parties--for example, statements of peer review or that the text has been approved by an organization as the authoritative definition of a standard.

10. FUTURE REVISIONS OF THIS LICENSE

The author(s) and publisher(s) of the Document do not by this License give permission to use their names for publicity for or to assert or imply endorsement of any Modified Version.

The Free Software Foundation may publish new, revised versions of the GNU Free Documentation License from time to time. Such new versions will be similar in spirit to the present version, but may differ in detail to address new problems or concerns. See http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/. Each version of the License is given a distinguishing version number. If the Document specifies that a particular numbered version of this License "or any later version" applies to it, you have the option of following the terms and conditions either of that specified version or of any later version that has been published (not as a draft) by the Free Software Foundation. If the Document does not specify a version number of this License, you may choose any version ever published (not as a draft) by the Free Software Foundation.

How to use this License for your documents

5. COMBINING DOCUMENTS You may combine the Document with other documents released under this License, under the terms defined in section 4 above for modified versions, provided that you include in the combination all of the Invariant Sections of all of the original documents, unmodified, and list them all as Invariant Sections of your combined work in its license notice, and that you preserve all their Warranty Disclaimers. The combined work need only contain one copy of this License, and multiple identical Invariant Sections may be replaced with a single copy. If there are multiple Invariant Sections with the same name but different contents, make the title of each such section unique by adding at the end of it, in parentheses, the name of the original author or publisher of that section if known, or else a unique number. Make the same adjustment to the section titles in the list of Invariant Sections in the license notice of the combined work.

4EXT 7IKIPEDIAôPRONOUNCEDô?WIKEE?PI?DI?ôORô?W?KA?P?DI?ôORô?W?KI ôISôAôMULTILIN GUALô7EB BASEDôFREE CONTENTôENCYCLOPEDIAôWIKIôCLUSTERô7IKIPEDIAôISôWRITTENôCOLLABO RATIVELYôBYôVOLUNTEERS ôALLOWINGôMOSTôARTICLESôTOôBEôCHANGEDôBYôANYONEôWITHôACCESSô TOôAôWEBôBROWSERô4HEôPROJECTôBEGANôONô*ANUARYô ôôASôAôCOMPLEMENTôTOôTHEô EXPERT WRITTENô.UPEDIAôANDôISôNOWôOPERATEDôBYôTHEôNON PROkTô7IKIMEDIAô&OUNDA TIONô7IKIPEDIAôHASôMOREôTHANô ôARTICLES ôINCLUDINGôMOREôTHANô ôINôTHEô %NGLISH LANGUAGEôVERSION ôANDôASôOFô*ANUARYôôITôHASôMOREôTHANô ôREGISTEREDô USERSô3INCEôITSôINCEPTION ô7IKIPEDIAôHASôSTEADILYôRISENôINôPOPULARITY ôANDôITSôSUCCESSô HASôSPAWNEDôSEVERALôSISTERôPROJECTSô4HEREôHAS ôHOWEVER ôBEENôCONTROVERSYôOVERôITSô RELIABILITY ô

7IKIPEDIAôISôREGULARLYôCITEDôINôTHEôMASSôMEDIAôANDôACADEMIA ôSOMETIMESôCRITICALLY ô

ANDôSOMETIMESôTOôPRAISEôITôFORôITSôFREEôDISTRIBUTION ôCONSTANTôEDITING ôANDôDIVERSEôCOV ERAGE ôNOTôTOôMENTIONôITSôMULTILINGUALôDIMENSIONSô)TôISôOFTENôCITEDôNOTôASôAôSUBJECTôBUTô ASôSOURCEôONôOTHERôSUBJECTSô%DITORSôAREôENCOURAGEDôTOôUPHOLDôAôPOLICYôOFôgNEUTRALô POINTôOFôVIEWuôUNDERôWHICHôNOTABLEôPERSPECTIVESôAREôSUMMARIZEDôWITHOUTôANôATTEMPTô TOôDETERMINEôANôOBJECTIVEôTRUTHô7IKIPEDIASôSTATUSôASôAôREFERENCEôWORKôHASôBEENôCON TROVERSIALôSINCEôITSôOPENôNATUREôALLOWSôVANDALISM ôINACCURACY ôINCONSISTENCY ôUNEVENô QUALITY ôANDôUNSUBSTANTIATEDôOPINIONSô)TôHASôALSOôBEENôCRITICISEDôFORôSYSTEMICôBIAS ô PREFERENCEôOFôCONSENSUSôTOôCREDENTIALS ôANDôAôPERCEIVEDôLACKôOFôACCOUNTABILITYôANDô

Title (section 1) will typically require changing the actual title.

If the Modified Version includes new front-matter sections or appendices that qualify as Secondary Sections and contain no material copied from the Document, you may at your option designate some or all of these sections as invariant. To do this, add their titles to the list of Invariant Sections in the Modified Version's license notice. These titles must be distinct from any other section titles.

You may add a passage of up to five words as a Front-Cover Text, and a passage of up to 25 words as a Back-Cover Text, to the end of the list of Cover Texts in the Modified Version. Only one passage of Front-Cover Text and one of Back-Cover Text may be added by (or through arrangements made by) any one entity. If the Document already includes a cover text for the same cover, previously added by you or by arrangement made by the same entity you are acting on behalf of, you may not add another; but you may replace the old one, on explicit permission from the previous publisher that added the old one.

g4HEô&REEô%NCYCLOPEDIAôTHATôANYONEôCANôEDITu

To use this License in a document you have written, include a copy of the License in the document and put the following copyright and license notices just after the title page: Copyright (c) YEAR YOUR NAME. Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation; with no Invariant Sections, no Front-Cover Texts, and no Back-Cover Texts. A copy of the license is included in the section entitled "GNU Free Documentation License".

AUTHORITYôWHENôCOMPAREDôWITHôTRADITIONALôENCYCLOPEDIASô"UTôTHEôSCOPEôANDôDETAILôOFô ITSôARTICLES ôASôWELLôASôITSôCONSTANTôUPDATES ôHAVEôMADEôITôAôUSEFULôREFERENCEôSOURCEô FORôMILLIONS ô

4HEREôAREôOVERôôLANGUAGEôEDITIONSôOFô7IKIPEDIA ôAROUNDôôOFôWHICHôAREôAC

TIVEô4WELVEôEDITIONSôHAVEôMOREôTHANô ôARTICLESôEACHô%NGLISH ô'ERMAN ô&RENCH ô *APANESE ô0OLISH ô)TALIAN ô3WEDISH ô$UTCH ô0ORTUGUESE ô3PANISH ô#HINESEôANDô2USSIANô )TSô'ERMAN LANGUAGEôEDITIONôHASôBEENôDISTRIBUTEDôONô$6$ 2/- ôANDôMANYôOFôITSôOTHERô EDITIONSôAREôMIRROREDôORôHAVEôBEENôFORKEDôBYôWEBSITES

If you have Invariant Sections, Front-Cover Texts and Back-Cover Texts, replace the "with...Texts." line with this: In the combination, you must combine any sections Entitled "History" in the various original documents, forming one section Entitled "History"; likewise combine any sections Entitled "Acknowledgements", and any sections Entitled "Dedications". You must delete all sections Entitled "Endorsements."

6. COLLECTIONS OF DOCUMENTS

with the Invariant Sections being LIST THEIR TITLES, with the Front-Cover Texts being LIST, and with the Back-Cover Texts being LIST.

If you have Invariant Sections without Cover Texts, or some other combination of the three, merge those two alternatives to suit the situation.

You may make a collection consisting of the Document and other documents released under this License, and replace the individual copies of this License in the various documents with a single copy that is included in the collection, provided that you follow the rules of this License for verbatim copying of each of the documents in all other respects. You may extract a single document from such a collection, and distribute it individually under this License, provided you insert a copy of this License into the extracted document, and follow this License in all other respects regarding verbatim copying of that document.

If your document contains nontrivial examples of program code, we recommend releasing these examples in parallel under your choice of free software license, such as the GNU General Public License, to permit their use in free software.

WWWWIKIPEDIAORG

Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Text_of_the_GNU_Free_Documentation_License" Categories: Spoken articles | Permanently protected | Wikipedia copyright | Wikipedia official policy

7. AGGREGATION WITH INDEPENDENT WORKS A compilation of the Document or its derivatives with other separate and independent documents or works, in or on a volume of a storage or distribution medium, is called an "aggregate" if the copyright resulting from the compilation is not used to limit the legal rights of the compilation's users beyond what the individual works permit. When the Document is included in an aggregate, this License does not apply to the other works in the aggregate which are not themselves derivative works of the Document.

3OURCEô


This page was last modified 02:54, 9 September 2006. All text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License. (See Copyrights for details.) WikipediaJ is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.

WWWWIKIPEDIAORG

If the Cover Text requirement of section 3 is applicable to these copies of the Document, then if the Document is less than one half of the entire aggregate, the Document's Cover Texts may be placed on covers that bracket the Document within the aggregate, or the electronic equivalent of covers if the Document is in electronic form. Otherwise they must appear on printed covers that bracket the whole aggregate.

8. TRANSLATION Translation is considered a kind of modification, so you may distribute translations of the Document under the terms of section 4. Replacing Invariant Sections with translations requires special permission from their copyright holders, but you may include translations of some or all Invariant Sections in addition to the original versions of these Invariant Sections. You may include a translation of this License, and all the license notices in the Document, and any Warranty Disclaimers, provided that you also include the original English version of this License and the original versions of those notices and disclaimers. In case of a disagreement between the translation and the original version of this License or a notice or disclaimer, the original version will prevail. If a section in the Document is Entitled "Acknowledgements", "Dedications", or "History", the requirement (section 4) to Preserve its

3 of 4

18/09/06 17:05 4 of 4

18/09/06 17:05

%XAMPLESôôYôô4FHFMBAF>

0240_057_self_org.indd 320-321

25/09/06 17:42:19

TOôDESCRIBEôSUCHôAôCOMPLEXôSETôOFôSOCIALôANDôECONOMICôRELA TIONSHIPSôASôARTô!ND ôPERHAPSôMOREôIMPORTANTLY ôWHYôPRESENTô ITôTHISôWAYôATôALL 3INCEôTHEôEARLYôSôITôHASôBEENôIMPOSSIBLEôTOôDESCRIBEôTHEô CATEGORYôOFôARTôINôFORMALôTERMSô/NCEôTHEô2EADYMADE ôCONCEP TUALôART ôINSTRUCTIONôWORKS ôWORKSôTHATôNEEDôNOTôBEôMADE ôARTISTSô PERSONALôACTIONSôORôSOCIALôINTERACTIONSôETC ôHADôBECOMEôPARTô OFôTHEôMAINSTREAMôDISCOURSEôOFôART ôTHEREôWASôNOôWAYôBACKô .UMEROUSôEFFORTSôHAVEôBEENôMADEôINôTHEôINTERVENINGôYEARSô TOôPRESERVEôAôQUALITATIVEôDISTINCTIONôBETWEENôARTôANDôNON ART ô FROMôATTEMPTSôTOôCREATEôTHEORIESôOFôAESTHETICSôTHATôINCORPORATEô EVERYDAYôSOCIALôINTERACTIONôTOôSIMPLEôCATEGORICALôASSERTIONSôOFô THEôROLEôOFôTHEôARTIST ôBUTôALLôHAVEôSOôFARôBEENôDEFEATEDôBYôTHEô RANGEôANDôCOMPLEXITYôOFôTHEôACTIVITIESôTHATôCONTINUEôTOôBEôSUC CESSFULLYôCLAIMEDôBYôARTISTSôASôTHEIRôPRACTICEô7HATôREMAINSôISô NOTôAôDEkNITION ôBUTôAôCONTEXTômôROUGHLYôSPEAKING ôIFôITSôMADEô BYôPEOPLEôCLAIMINGôTOôBEôARTISTS ôANDôEVENôMOREôSOôIFôITôCANôBEô DISCUSSEDôINôTERMSôOFôTHEôHISTORYôOFôART ôANDôISôSPONSOREDôBYôANô ARTôINSTITUTION ôTHENôWEôMUSTôATôLEASTôCONSIDERôTHEôPOSSIBILITYôTHATô ITSôARTô(ISTORICALLY ôEXTERNALôSOCIALôCONDITIONSôHAVEôDETERMINEDô THEôFORMôOFôARTôPRACTICEôASôMUCHôASôHAVEôTHEôINNOVATIONSôOFô ARTISTSôTHEMSELVESô.OWôTHEôDEBATEôOVERôTHEôNATUREôOFôARTôHAS ô TOôAôLARGEôEXTENT ôBEENôREPLACEDôBYôAôMARKETPLACEôINôWHICHôALLô FORMSôORôDEkNITIONSôOFôARTôAREôEQUALLYôAVAILABLE ôANDôTHEôBUYERSô môWHETHERôTHEYôAREôPUBLICôORôPRIVATEôGALLERIES ôCORPORATEôCOL LECTORSôORôSTATEôCOMMISSIONERSômôAREôFREEôTOôSELECTôTHOSEôTHATô BESTôSERVEôTHEIRôINTERESTS

FUNDINGô/RôRATHER ôTHEôIDEOLOGYôISôCHANGING ôFROMôAôSOCIAL DEMOCRATICôVISIONôOFôAô@HEALTHYôSOCIETYôNURTUREDôONôACCESSIBLEô STATE SUPPORTEDôCULTUREôkLLEDôWITHôNUTRITIOUSôVALUES ôTOôNEO LIB ERALôMODELSôINôWHICHôALLôAVAILABLEôMECHANISMSôOFôSOCIALôCONTROL ô INCLUDINGôCULTURE ôAREôWAITINGôTOôBEôMOBILISEDôASôINCREASINGô INEQUALITYôGIVESôRISEôTOôINCREASINGôDISORDER ôANDôTOôSO CALLEDô THIRDôWAYôIDEOLOGIES ôUNDERôWHICHôTHEô@CULTUREôINDUSTRIESôAREô SETôTHEôIMPOSSIBLEôTHREEFOLDôTASKôOFôDRIVINGôECONOMICôGROWTH ô PRESENTINGôAôCHICôINTERNATIONALô02ôIMAGEôANDôCOMBATINGôWHATô ISôEUPHEMISTICALLYôKNOWNôASô@SOCIALôEXCLUSIONô)NôTHISôTRANSITIONALô PHASEôARTSôFUNDINGôINôMANYô%UROPEANôSTATESôREPRESENTSôAôGENU INEôLOOPHOLE ôAôREALôTHROWBACKôTOôSOCIALôDEMOCRATICôTHINKINGô!LLô THEôSIGNSôAREôTHATôTHISôPERIODôISôDRAWINGôRAPIDLYôTOôAôCLOSEômôFORô ONEôRELEVANTôEXAMPLE ô.)&#! ôWHICHôFUNDEDôBOTHôTHISôPUBLICA TIONôANDôTHEôINITIALôPHASEôOFôWHATôBECAMEô'UARAN¶ô0OWER ôISô CURRENTLYôBEINGôWOUNDôUPômôBUTôFORôAôBRIEFôTIMEôITôHASôREMAINEDô POSSIBLEôFORôARTISTSôINôCERTAINô%UROPEANôCOUNTRIESôTOôUSEôSTATEô MONEYôTOôPURSUEôPROJECTSôTHATôEXAMINEôORôACTIVELYôCRITIQUEôTHEô PARTICULARôPOLITICALôANDôECONOMICôDIRECTIONôTHEôSTATEôITSELFôISô TAKINGô!TôTHEôSAMEôTIME ôTHEôEMPHASISôONôUSINGôCULTURALôFUND INGôTOôDIRECTLYôADDRESSôWIDERôSOCIALôPROBLEMSômôRATHERôTHANôASô AôSOURCEôOFôASPIRATIONALôVALUESômôISôTOOôRECENTôTOôHAVEôCREATEDô THEôCULTUREôITôISôULTIMATELYôDESIGNEDôTOôSUPPORTôAND ôALONGSIDEô THEôCOOPTIONôOFôARTISTSôTOôVALIDATEôPROPERTYôDEVELOPMENTôANDôINô LIEUôOFôSOCIALôSERVICES ôISôGIVINGôSPACEôTOôMOREôRADICALôIDEAS

2ELATIVELYôSTRONGôSTATEôSUPPORTôFORôTHEôARTSôISôAôFEATUREôOFôMANYô %UROPEANôECONOMIES ôBUTôTHEREôISôCURRENTLYôAôGENERALôMOVEô TOWARDSôINCREASINGôIDEOLOGICALôINSTRUMENTALISATIONôOFôSTATEô

4HEôRECENTôEMERGENCEôOFô@SOCIALôPRACTICEôASôAôRELATIVELYôWELL DEkNEDôARTISTICôCATEGORYôISôDUE ôINôPARTôATôLEAST ôTOôTHISôTRANSI TIONALôSITUATION ôWHICHôISôITSELFôAôPRODUCTôOFôEXTERNALôCHANGESô)Nô THEôARTôWORLD ôTHEôRADICALôEXPERIMENTSôOFôEARLIERôDECADESôHAVEô BECOMEôFORMALISEDôANDôFOUNDôINSTITUTIONALôACCEPTANCEôPERHAPSô JUSTôINôTIMEôFORôARTISTSôTOôUSEôTHISôACCEPTANCEôTOôCONTRIBUTEôTOôAô

'UARANAô0OWER

'UARANAô0OWER

0240_057_self_org.indd 322-323

25/09/06 17:42:21

WIDERôREINVENTIONôOFôACTIVISTôSTRATEGIESôFORôSOCIALôCHANGEô7HILEô THEôARTôMARKETôIS ôATôLEASTôINôkNANCIALôTERMS ôSTRONGERôTHANôEVER ô ANDôSTATEôATTEMPTSôTOôINSTRUMENTALISEôCULTUREôBECOMEôMOREô SOPHISTICATED ôITôISôSTILLôPOSSIBLEôTOôTURNôTHEôSITUATIONôAROUNDô ANDôUSEôTHEôARTôWORLDôITSELFôASôAôTOOLômôAôSOURCEôOFôFUNDING ôOFô PUBLICITY ôOFôCRITICALôREACTION ôOFôPOLITICALôACCESS ôANDôOFôDEFENCEô FORôRADICALôIDEASôINôTHEôTERMSôOFôTHEôLIBERALôPHILOSOPHYôTHATôJUSTI kESô-ODERNô7ESTERNôCULTUREô

)TôISôALSOôCLEARôTHATôGLOBALISATIONômôNOTôOFôTRADE ôWHICHôISôNOTô SUBSTANTIALLYôMOREôGLOBALôINôNATUREôTHANôITôWASôAôHUNDREDôYEARSô AGOômôBUTôOFôINDUSTRIALôCAPITALISTôRATHERôTHANôOLDERôIMPERIALISTô FORMSôOFôEXPLOITATION ôANDôOFôTHEôTRANSMISSIONôOFôINFORMATIONô ANDôOFôFORMSôOFôORGANISATION ôHASôGIVENôUNPRECEDENTEDôCOM MONôCAUSEôTOôINTERNATIONALôLABOURôSTRUGGLESôWHILEôALSOôCREATINGô AôNEEDôTOôUNDERSTANDôTHEôSPECIkCôORôLOCALôNATUREôOFôPARTICULARô CONDITIONSôANDôISSUESô

"OTHôTHEôRESEARCHôPHASEôANDôTHEôkRSTôPRODUCTIONôRUNôOFô'UAR AN¶ô0OWERôWEREôFUNDEDôBYôSTATE RUNôARTôINSTITUTIONSôINITIALôPUB LICITYôFORôTHEôPROJECTôASôARTôGENERATEDôMAINSTREAMôCOVERAGEôINô THEô$ANISHôMEDIAôAôPLANNEDôFUTUREôLAUNCHôINô"RAZILôWILLôBEô FACILITATEDôBYôARTSôORGANISATIONSôTHEREôBUTôHASôALREADYôATTRACTEDô INTERESTôFROMôAôVARIETYôOFôOTHERôGROUPS ôANDôAôCERTAINôAMOUNTô OFôMAINSTREAMôPOLITICALôSUPPORTô!ND ôALTHOUGHôITôMAYôORôMAYô NOTôBECOMEôANôISSUEôINôTHEôCASEôOFô'UARAN¶ô0OWER ô3UPERlEXô AREôINôTHEôPROCESSôOFôkGHTINGôANôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôCASEôRE LATINGôTOôANOTHERôPROJECTôONôTHEôGROUNDSôOFôFAIRôUSEôFORôARTISTICô EXPRESSION

4HEôTRADEôUNIONôMOVEMENTôHASôITSôROOTSôINôBOTHôRADICAL ôIN TERNATIONALISTôPOLITICALôORGANISATIONôINôTHEôNINETEENTHôCENTURYô ANDôINôOLDERôPROTECTIONISTôGUILDSôTHATôSERVEDôONLYôTHEIRôMEM BERSôINTERESTSôMODERNôTRADEôUNIONISMôISôAôHYBRIDôOFôTHESEô TWOôSTRANDSô)NôCONTEMPORARYô7ESTERNôPRACTICEôTHISôCANôBEô SEENôINôTHEôWAYôTHAT ôTHOUGHôNATIONALôLABOURôUNIONSôCOLLECTIVELYô RESISTôANYôATTEMPTôTOôDISMANTLEôCERTAINôHARD WONôCONCESSIONSô ONôBASICôRIGHTSôANDôCONDITIONS ôTHEYôTENDôNOTôTOôOPPOSEôAôNEO LIBERALôCONSENSUSôTHATôSIDELINESôPROSPECTSôFORôPOLITICALôORôSOCIALô CHANGEôINôTHEôFACEôOFôTHEôPERCEIVEDôTHREATôOFôCHEAPôLABOURôINô LOWôWAGE ôLOWôRIGHTSôECONOMIESôELSEWHEREô,EAVINGôASIDEôTHEô SPECTACULARôDOUBLETHINKôREQUIREDôTOôCONSTITUTEôTHEôTHREATôASô COMINGôFROMô@CHEAPôLABOURôRATHERôTHANôFROMôVAST ôSTRUCTURALô IMBALANCESôINôGLOBALôPOWERôANDôTHEôEXPLOITATIONôTHISôENABLES ô THEôPREVALENCEôOFôTHISôAPPARENTLYôPRAGMATICôPROTECTIONISMôISôAô REALôCONSEQUENCEôOF ôPARADOXICALLY ôBOTHôTHEôWEAKENEDôPOSI TIONôOFô7ESTERNôLABOURôMOVEMENTSôINôTHEôCONTEMPORARYôGLOBALô ECONOMYôANDôTHEIRôHISTORICALôSUCCESSôATôCLAIMINGôAôSHAREôOFôTHEô WEALTHôGENERATEDôBYô7ESTERNôPOWER

'UARAN¶ô0OWERôANDôSELF ORGANISATION 3OCIALôSELF ORGANISATIONôOFôTHEôKINDôTHATôISôTHEôSUBJECTôOFôTHISô BOOKôISôFARôFROMôAôNEWôPHENOMENONôTHEôRESURGENCEôOFôCRITICALô INTERESTôINôNON HIERARCHICALôORôGENUINELYôPARTICIPATORYôFORMSôOFô môPARTICULARLYôPOLITICALôORôLABOURômôORGANISATIONôCANôBEôSEENôASô AôRESPONSEôTOôTHEôWAYôTHATôTHEôINSTITUTIONALISATIONôOFôTHEôRESIST ANCEôTOôCAPITALISMôINôHIERARCHICALôMASSôMOVEMENTSôOVERôTHEô TWENTIETHôCENTURYôHASôCULMINATEDôINôAôPOLITICALôACCOMMODA TIONôTHATôCONTINUALLYôSEEKSôTOôRESTOREôANôIMAGINARYôSTATUSôQUOô

'UARANAô0OWER

0240_057_self_org.indd 324-325

)TôISôAGAINSTôTHISôBACKGROUNDôTHATôTHEôALTERNATIVEôOFô@SELF OR GANISATIONôISôOFTENôDISCUSSEDô)NôSITUATIONSôOFôCONlICTôTOOôSPE CIkC ôTOOôlUID ôTOOôISOLATEDôORôTOOôVOLATILEôFORôTRADITIONALôUNIONô

'UARANAô0OWER

25/09/06 17:42:21

IôNVOLVEMENTômôALLIANCESôOFô@ILLEGALôWORKERS ôMOMENTSôOFôSOLIDAR ITYôAMONGSTôFREELANCEôSPECIALISTS ôMOVEMENTSôTHATôARISEôWHEREô WORKERSôORGANISATIONôISôLEGALLYôPROHIBITEDômôSELF ORGANISATIONôISô OFTENôTHEôONLYôVIABLEôMODEôOFôRESISTANCE ôAôLASTôRESORTôOFôTHOSEô WITHôLITTLEôLEFTôTOôLOSEô)NôOTHERôSITUATIONSômôSUCHôASôTHEôVIGOROUSô COOPERATIVEôMOVEMENTôINô"RAZIL ôFORôEXAMPLEômôTHEôOPPOSITEô TENSIONSôCANôSOMETIMESôARISE ôWITHôCOOPERATIVESôACCUSEDôOFô PROTECTIONISMôANDôEXCLUSIONISMôBYôUNIONISEDôWORKERSôINôSIMILAR ô NON COOPERATIVELYôRUNôENTERPRISES 4HEôPARADOXôISôTHATôTHEôSPECIkC ôLOCALôNATUREôOFôMOSTôOFôTHESEô INSTANCESôOFôWORKERSôSELF ORGANISATIONôMEANSôTHATôTHEYôAREô FOCUSEDôONôSPECIkC ôLOCALôBATTLESômôOFTENôFORôTHEôSAMEôBASICô RIGHTSôTHATôTHEôTRADITIONALôUNIONSôSTILLôTOôSOMEôEXTENTôDEFENDô môANDôCONSEQUENTLYôTHEIRôRADICALISMôISôULTIMATELYôISOLATEDôANDô CONTAINED ôLEAVINGôTHEM ôPRAGMATICALLY ôINôTHEôSAMEôSITUATIONôASô THEôTRADITIONALôLABOURôMOVEMENTôASôAôWHOLE

INôONEôLARGEôROOMôWITHôALLôMEMBERSôINVOLVEDôANDôFREEôTOôSPEAK ô QUESTION ôINTERJECT ôORôPRESENTôTHEIRôOWNôPROPOSALS /FôCOURSE ôTHEREôISôANôOBVIOUSôTENSIONôWITHINôANYôORGANISA TIONôTHATôASPIRESôTOôREPRESENTôITSôMEMBERSôORôTHEIRôINTERESTS ô BETWEENôTHEôINTERESTSôORôDESIRESôOFôINDIVIDUALôMEMBERSôANDô THEôABILITYôOFôTHEôORGANISATIONôTOôFUNCTION ôTOôDEkNEôITSELFôORôTOô MAKEôANDôACTôUPONôCOLLECTIVEôDECISIONSô%VENôWITHINôTHEôSMALLô ORGANISATIONôOFô#/!)-!ôTHEREôHAVEôBEENôDISSENTINGôVOICES ô INDIVIDUALSôWHOôAREôUNHAPPYôWITHôTHEôCONSENSUSôTOôTHEôEXTENTô OFôDECIDINGôTOôWITHDRAWôTHEIRôPARTICIPATION ôANDôITôISôATôTHISôPOINTô THATôITôBECOMESôCLEARôTHATôTHEôIDEALôOFôSELF ORGANISATIONôCANNOTô BEôANôENDôINôITSELFô

)NTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôANDôTHEôECONOMICSô OFô'UARAN¶ô0OWER

/NEôTHINGôTHATôMAKESôTHEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôPROJECTôINTERESTING ô FROMôTHEôPOINTôOFôVIEWôOFôTHISôDISCUSSIONôOFôSELF ORGANISATION ôISô THATôTHEôSTRUCTUREôOFô#/!)-!ômôAôLOCAL ôSMALL SCALEôCOOPERA TIVE ôWITHôSHAREDôAIMSôANDôAôNON HIERARCHICALôDECISION MAKINGô PROCESSômôHASôMADEôPOSSIBLEôAôCOURSEôOFôACTIONôTHATôCOULDôNOTô HAVEôBEENôIMAGINEDôEITHERôUNDERôTHEôAUSPICESôOFôAôTRADITIONALô UNION ôOR ôCONVERSELY ôWITHOUTôSOMEôFORMôOFôCOLLECTIVEôORGANISA TIONô4HOUGHôITôWOULDôBEôOVERLYôROMANTICôTOôSEEôTHEôPROJECTôASô PRESENTINGôAôREALôCHALLENGEôTOôTHEôCORPORATIONSôWHOSEôACTIVI TIESôLEDôTOôITSôCONCEPTION ôTHEôDIRECTNESSôOFôTHEôSTRATEGYôEM PLOYEDôREQUIRESôAôCOMMITMENTôANDôCARRIESôAôRISKôTHATôCOULDô NOTôOTHERWISEôHAVEôBEENôCONTEMPLATEDô4HEôSMALLôSCALEôANDô NON BUREAUCRATICôSTRUCTUREôOFô#/!)-!ôALSOôFACILITATEDôTHEôDE VELOPMENTôOFôTHEôSTRATEGYôITSELFô$ISCUSSIONSôCOULDôTAKEôPLACEô

7HATôMAKESôTHEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôPROJECTôPARTICULARLYôINTERESTINGô ISôITSôPOTENTIALôTOôGENERATEôCONlICT ôTOôIDENTIFYôANDôCONTESTôAôSITEô INôTHEôCAPITALISTôECONOMICôSYSTEMôINôWHICHôCORPORATEôPOWERô ANDôTHEôINTERNATIONALôLEGALôSYSTEMôTHATôSUPPORTSôITôGOESôLARGELYô UNQUESTIONEDô&ORôTHISôREASON ôTHEôECONOMICôCOUNTER STRATEGYô UNDERLYINGôTHEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôPROJECTôCARRIESôAôVERYôREALôELE MENTôOFôRISKôFORôALLôTHOSEôINVOLVEDô

'UARANAô0OWER

'UARANAô0OWER

0240_057_self_org.indd 326-327

4HEôTHREATôOFôCONVENTIONALôFAIRôTRADEôTOôCORPORATEôECONOMICSô REMAINSôMARGINALômôFAIR TRADEôGOODSôACCOUNTôFORôONLYôAROUNDô ôOFôWORLDôTRADEômôANDôTHEôECONOMICôMODELôISôPREDICATEDô ONôTHEôPREMIUMôPRICESôPAIDôBYôCONCERNEDôBUTôAFlUENTôCONSUM ERSô4HEôSUBSIDISEDôSUBVERSIONôOFôAôBRANDôIDENTITYôTOôPUBLICISEôAô PARTICULARôCASEôOFôEXPLOITATIONôISôANôALTOGETHERôDIFFERENTôMATTER

25/09/06 17:42:21

9OMANGO $ESCRIPTION 9OUôWANTôITô9OUôGOTôIT 4EXT ô3TYLEôTIPSôFORôAôMOREô9/-!.'/ôLIFEBECAUSEôYOUôCANTôBUYôHAPPINESS ô 9/-!.'/ô;-ANGOôISôAôPOPULARô3PANISHôCLOTHINGôCHAIN9/-!.'/ ôINô3PANISHô SLANGôMEANSô@)ôSTEALô@MANGAôISô3PANISHôFORôSLEEVE ôHENCEô@MANGAR ôTOôSLEEVE ôTOô STEAL=ôISôAôBRANDôNAMEôWHOSEôPRINCIPALôOBJECTIVE ôASôISôTHEôCASEôWITHôALLôIMPORTANTô BRANDS ôISôNOTôTHEôSELLINGôOFôTHINGS ôBUTôTHEôMASSôPROMOTIONôOFôAôLIFESTYLEô3PECIk CALLY ôTHEôPROMOTIONôOFôSHOPLIFTINGôASôAôFORMôOFôDISOBEDIENCEôANDôDIRECTôACTIONô AGAINSTôMULTINATIONALôCOORPORATIONS ôô$AREôTOôDESIREô9/-!.'/ôISôYOURôSTYLEôRISKY ôINNOVATIVEô)TôISôTHEôARTICULATEôPROLIF ERATIONôOFôCREATIVEôGESTURESô9/-!.'/ôISôNOTôABOUTôTHEFT ôITSôABOUTôMAGIC ôABOUTô THEôLIBERATIONôOFôDESIREôANDôINTELIGENCEôCRYSTALLIZEDôINôTHEô@THINGSôOFFEREDôFORôSALEô )Fô9/-!.'/ôHASôAôPOLITICS ôITôISôTHEôPOLITICSôOFôHAPPINESS ôOFôPUTTINGôTHEôBODYôkRSTô "EôHAPPY ôINSULTINGLYôHAPPYô9/-!.'/ôFEELôPRETTY ôô"ECAUSEôYOUôCANTô"59ôHAPPINESSô#APITALISMôCURRENTLYôWORKSôTHROUGHôTHEôEXPLOI TATIONôOFôCOLLECTIVEôINTELLIGENCEôANDôCREATIVITYô4HEôMARKETôNOURISHESôITSELFôONôTHEô IDEAS ôTHEôLIFEôFORMSôANDôTHEôMULTIPLEôWAYSôINôWHICHôPEOPLEôEXPRESSôTHEMSELVESô THROUGHôWORDS ôCLOTHES ôGESTURES ôSEXUALITYô#OMMERCEôAPPROPRIATESôYOURôDESIRES ô YOURôEXPECTATIONS ôYOURôEXPERIENCESôANDôGIVESôTHEMôBACKôTOôYOU ôALIENATED ôDISTANT ô CONVERTEDôINTOô@THINGSôFORôYOUôTOôBUYô"UYôYOURôOWNôHAPPINESS ôFROMôCONCENTRATESô 4HEô9/-!.'/ôSTYLEôPROPOSESôREAPPROPRIATING ôLEGITIMIZINGôANDôEXTENDINGôTHEô @EXPROPRIATIONôOFôWHATôIS ôINôEFFECT ôPREVIOUSLYôTOôITSôCONVERSIONôINTOô@THINGS ôWASô PARTôOFôTHEôCOMMONSô9/-!.'/ ôITSôVERYôMUCHôINSIDEôOFôYOU ôô)NVENTINGôNEWôGESTURESôTHAT ôONCEôREPEATED ôOPENôNEWôWORLDSôFORôUSôTOôINHABITô @"UYINGôISôANôEXCERCISEôINôPASSIVITYô"ORINGôANDôALIENATING ôITôISôAôSOCIALLYôPREDETER MINEDôACTô9/-!.'/ôISôAôCREATIVEôANDôEXCITINGôPRACTICEô@3TEALINGôISôUNDERSTOODô TOôBEôAôCRIME ôBUTô9/-!.'/ôDOESôNOTôACKNOWLEDGEôLEGALITIESôORôILLEGALITIESô-ORE ô ITôSPEAKSôOFôAôKINDôOFôLEGITIMACYôWHICHôCOMESôFROMôBELOW ôTHEôLEGITIMACYôOFôDAILYô LIFE ôOFôWANTINGôTOôLIVEôFREELY ô#REATIVELYô"UYINGôISôANôACTIONôBASEDôONôOBEDIENCEô 9/-!.'/ôISôAôDISOBEDIENTôSTYLEô9/-!.'/ôISôTHEôHAND ôWHICHôINôANôIRREDUCIBLEô INSUBORDINATEôDANCE ôDRAWSôANôUNMEDIATEDôARCHôOFôDESIREôFROMôTHEôSTANDôTOôYOURô POCKET ôWITHOUTôMONEYôORôCREDITôCARDS ôô9/-!.'/ôISôNOTôTHEôPROPAGATIONôOFôPRIVATEôPROPERTYôTHROUGHôOTHERôMEANSô)TôDOESô NOTôPROPOSEôACCUMULATIONô)TôCONSISTSôINôTAKINGôTOôTHEôEXTREMEôTHEôFREEôCIRCULA

0240_057_self_org.indd 328-329

%XAMPLESôôYôô6LJ>KDL

25/09/06 17:42:23

TIONôOFôGOODSô0OTLATCHôREAPROPRIATEôANDôMAKEôCIRCULATE ôSATISFYôTHEôDESIRESôANDô NECESSITIESôOFôYOURôLOVEDôONESô(AVEôPEOPLEôOVERôFORô9/-!.'/ôDINNERSô3TEALô THISôBOOK ôô4HEôMARKETôOFFERSôUSôAôFALSEôALTERNATIVE ôAôFALSEôLIBERTYôTOôCHOOSEôBETWEENôONEôWAYô TOôSPENDôOURôMONEYôORôANOTHERô9OURôHOPESôANDôDREAMS ôBEôTHEMôOFôONEôBRANDôORô ANOTHER ôALMOSTôALWAYSôBENEkTôTHEôSAMEôGUYô9/-!.'/ôAFkRMSôTHEôREALôALTERNA TIVEô)TSôEITHERô-/.%9ôORô9/-!.'/ ôô9/-!.'/ôTURNSôTHEôMALLôINTOôAôPLAYGROUNDô4HESEôSUPPOSEDôPUBLICôSPACES ôWHEREô THEôMARKETôCOMMERCIALIZES ôREGULATESôANDôCONTROLSôOURôBASICôWISHôTOôLIVEôSHAREDô EXPERIENCES ôTHESEôHUMANôANTFARMSôTHATôCROSSôLEISUREôANDôCULTUREô9/-!.'/ô BREAKSôOUTôOFôTHEôAISLESôANDôDEkESôDREARYôROUTINES ôô9/-!.'/ôISôWITHôYOUôINôEVERYôDAILYôGESTUREôYOUôMAKEô)TSôWITHôYOUôDURINGôYOURô BESTôMOMENTSô4HOSEôTHATôDONTôCOSTôMONEYô9/-!.'/ôSYSTEMATIZESôDAILYôACTSô )Nô"ARCELONA ôTHEô9/-!.'/ôFRANCHISEôHELDôCIVILôDISOBEDIENCEôWORKSHOPSôADAPTEDô TOôTHEô9/-!.'/ôLIFESTYLE ôASôWELLôASôWORKSHOPSôWHEREôIMAGINATIVEôANDôUSEFULLô TOOLSôWEREôPRODUCEDô!LSO ôENCOUNTERS ôDISCUSSIONS ôDINNERS ôPARTIES ôALLôFORôTHEô PUBLICôTOôENJOY ôô9/-!.'/ôISôAôFRANCHISEôYOUôCANôFORMôWHEREVERôYOUôWANTô4HEô9/-!.'/ôSTYLEô ISôANôOPENôENDEDôPROCESS ôGENERATINGôTOOLS ôPROTOTYPESôANDôDYNAMICSôWHICHôlOWô ANDôPROLIFERATE ôWAITINGôTOôBEôREAPROPRIATEDôANDôTOôCIRCULATEô!ôBRANDôNAMEôTHATSô EVERYONESô4HATôISôBORNôFROMôANDôFORôTHEôCOMMONSô2EMEMBERô9/-!.'/ ôONLYô INôYOURôCLOSESTôMULTINATIONAL

4HEôORTHODOXôVIEWôISôTHATôSTRONG ôIDENTIFIABLEôBRANDSôAREôAô CORPORATIONSôGREATESTôANDôMOSTôDURABLEôASSETô)NôFACT ôBRANDô VALUESômôTHEôPREMIUMôCOMPANIESôCANôCHARGEôCUSTOMERSôFORô AôRECOGNISEDôPRODUCTômôANDôBRANDôLOYALTYôAREôFALLINGôAWAYôINô ALMOSTôEVERYôMARKETôFORôEXAMPLE ôkVEôYEARSôAGOô3ONYôCOULDô CHARGEôANôAVERAGEôôMOREôTHANôTHEIRôCOMPETITORSôNOWôTHEIRô EDGEôISôDOWNôTOô ôAND ôINôPRACTICE ôBRANDôINFRINGEMENTô CASESômôASôDISTINCTôFROMôSTRAIGHTôUPôBRANDôPIRACYômôAREôCOSTLYô ANDôDIFkCULTôTOôWINô#OCA #OLAôSETTLEDôOUTôOFôCOURTôWITHô5+ô SUPERMARKETô3AINSBURYSôINôTHEôNINETIESôWHENôTHEôSUPERMAR KETôPRODUCEDôITSôOWNô@#LASSICô#OLAôINôAôREDôCANôWITHôWHITEô SCRIPTôLETTERING ôANDôTHEôONLYôCONCESSIONôACTUALLYôMADEôWASôAô CHANGEôINôTHEôTYPEFACEô)TôTOOKô-C$ONALDSôFOURTEENôYEARSôTOô WINôAôCASEôAGAINSTôTHEô"IGô-AKôBURGERôCOMPANYôINôTHEô0HILIP PINES ôANDôINôFACTô"IGô-AKôSUCCESSFULLYôAPPEALEDôAGAINSTôTHEô INITIALôDECISIONô%VENôONCEôTHEôCASEôWASôkNALLYôDECIDEDôINôTHEIRô FAVOUR ô-C$ONALDSôRECEIVEDôAôSETTLEMENTôOFôLESSôTHANôô .ONEôOFôTHISôHASôDISCOURAGEDôCORPORATIONSôFROMôFREELYôUSINGô THEôTHREATôOFôLEGALôACTION ôANDôWITHôITôTHEôASTRONOMICALôCOSTôOFô LEGALôDEFENCE ôTOôDEFENDôTHEIRôTRADEMARKôTERRITORY

ô9/-!.'/ ô

9OUôWANTôITô9OUôGOTôITô

3OURCE WWWYOMANGONET &ORôMOREôINFORMATION WWWYOMANGONET )MAGEôSOURCEô WWWYOMANGONET

%XAMPLESôôYôô6LJ>KDL

0240_057_self_org.indd 330-331

!ROUNDô ôBOTTLESôOFô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôSODAôHAVEôBEENô PRODUCEDôTOôDATEômôITôHASôBECOMEôAôCULTôDRINKôINô$ENMARK ôGEN ERATEDôNATIONALôPUBLICITYôANDôISôNOWôEVENôDISTRIBUTEDôTOôCONVEN IENCEôSTORESôWHEREôITôSITSôALONGSIDEôTHEôCORPORATEôBRANDSômôBUTô !M"EVSôANNUALôSALESôTOTALôAROUNDô ôTIMESôTHISôAMOUNTô !M"EVSôLAWYERSôHAVEôNONETHELESSôBEGUNôTOôDEMANDôCHANGESô TOôTHEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôLABELôANDôPUBLICITYôMATERIALô!NUPAMô #HANDER ô0ROFESSORôOFô,AWôATô5NIVERSITYôOFô#ALIFORNIAô$AVIS ô BELIEVESôTHATôTHEREôISôAôSTRONGôCASE ôUNDERôEXISTINGôINTERNATIONALô LAWôANDôPRECEDENT ôFORôBELIEVINGôTHATôAôLEGALôCHALLENGEôFROMô THEôMULTINATIONALôWOULDôFAILô(ISôARGUMENTôISôTHATôTHEôLABELSôAREô

'UARANAô0OWER

25/09/06 17:42:23

DISTINCTôENOUGHôTHATôPURCHASERSôCOULDôNOTôCONFUSEô'UARAN¶ô 0OWERôWITHô!M"EVSô!NARCTICAôSODA ôANDôTHATôTHEôCLEARôAS SERTIONSôOFôTHEôDIFFERENCESôBETWEENô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôANDô!NT ARCTICAôPRINTEDôONôTHEôLABELôMEANôTHATô!NTARCTICASôIDENTITYôISô NOTô@DILUTEDômôCONFUSIONôANDôDILUTIONôOFôTRADEMARKSôBEINGôTHEô TWOôMAINôINFRINGEMENTSôPROTECTEDôBYôINTERNATIONALôTREATIESô)Nô ADDITION ôHEôPUTSôFORWARDôTHEôDEFENSEôOFô@FAIRôUSE ôAôCAVEATô OFôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTYôLAWôTHATôALLOWSôTHEôUSEôOFôCOPYRIGHTô MATERIALôFORôTHEôPURPOSESôOFôCRITICISM ôPARODY ôCOMMENT ôNEWSô REPORTING ôTEACHING ôSCHOLARSHIPôORôRESEARCH

&OUNDATIONôISôAôNON PROkTôORGANISATIONôANDôTHATô#/!)-!ôISô AôCOOPERATIVE ôTHEô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôPRODUCTôMUSTôREACHôAôFARô LARGERôMARKETô#OINCIDENTALLY ôTHEô"RAZILIANôSOFTôDRINKSôMARKETô ISôONEôOFôTHEôBIGGESTôONôTHEôPLANET

5NFORTUNATELY ôTHEôRESOURCESôTOôkGHTôTHISôPARTICULARôLEGALôBAT TLEôAREôPROBABLYôOUTôOFôREACHôOFôTHEô0OWERô&OUNDATION ôWHICHô PLANSôTOôLAUNCHô'UARAN¶ô0OWERôINô"RAZILôINôTHEôNOT TOO DISTANTô FUTUREô(OWEVER ôTHEôSTRATEGYôEMPLOYEDôSOôFARôOFôBLACKING OUTô THEôLEGALLYôPROBLEMATICôPARTSôOFôTHEôDESIGNôANDôTHEôASSOCIATEDô TEXTôSEEMSôTOôOFFERôAôWAYôTOôMAINTAINôTECHNICALôCOMPLIANCEôWITHô THEôLAWYERSôDEMANDSôWHILEôKEEPINGôTHEôASSOCIATEDôCONlICTô INôPUBLICôVIEWôANDô#/!)-!ôOUTôOFôTHEôkRINGôLINEô(OWôFARôTHISô GAMEôCANôBEôPLAYEDôOUTôOFôCOURT ôANDôWITHOUTôRISKôTOôTHEôCO OPERATIVE ôREMAINSôTOôBEôSEEN ôBUTôSUCCESSôREMAINSôAôREALôPOS SIBILITYô#ERTAINLYôFEW ôIFôANY ôSIMILARôPROJECTSôHAVEôCONTEMPLATEDô SUCHôDIRECTôENGAGEMENTôONôAôCOMPARABLEôSCALE /NEôkNALôCONSIDERATIONôISôTHATôTHEôCURRENTôLEVELôOFô'UARAN¶ô 0OWERôPRODUCTION ôORôRATHERôTHEôREVENUEôTHATôTHISôPRODUCTIONô GENERATES ôISôNOTôYETôSUFFICIENTôTOôSUPPORTôTHEôMEMBERSôOFô #/!)-! ôWHOôMUSTôSTILLôSELLôTOôTHEôCORPORATIONSôANDôREMAINô INôAôDIFkCULTôSITUATIONô)FôTHISôAIMômôTHEôORIGINALôANDôPRIMARYôAIMô OFôTHEôENTERPRISE ôTOôGENERATEôAôLIVINGôFORôTHEôFARMERSôTHATôISôATô LEASTôEQUIVALENTôTOôTHATôWHICHôTHEYôHADôJUSTôAôFEWôYEARSôAGOô môISôTOôBEôREALISED ôNOTWITHSTANDINGôTHEôFACTôTHATôTHEô0OWERô

'UARANAô0OWER

0240_057_self_org.indd 332-333

'UARANAô0OWER

25/09/06 17:42:24

#ONTRIBUTORS

!LFONSOô(ERNANDEZôISôTHEôDIRECTORôOFôTHEô#ENTROôDEô%STUDIOSô4EPITE§OSô#ENTREôFORô4EPITOô3TUDIES ô INô-EXICOô#ITYô !NUPAMô#HANDERôISôAôPROFESSORôOFôLAWôATôTHEô5NIVERSITYôOFô#ALIFORNIA ô$AVISô(EôTEACHESôANDôWRITESô ONôINTERNATIONALôLAWôANDôCYBERLAWô(ISôRECENTôPUBLICATIONSôINCLUDEô'LOBALIZATIONôANDô$ISTRUSTô9ALEô ,AWô*OURNALô ôANDô4HEô2OMANCEôOFôTHEô0UBLICô$OMAINôWITHô-ADHAVIô3UNDER ô#ALIFORNIAô,AWô 2EVIEWô "RUNOô+ONDERô#OMPARATOôISôAô0ROFESSORôINôTHEô$EPARTMENTôOFô0OLITICSôATôTHEô5NIVERSITYôOFô3Óô 0AULO ANDôTHEôAUTHORôOFôTHEôBOOKôg,!CTIONô0OLITIQUEôDESô3ANS 4ERREôAUô"R¯SILuô,(ARMATTAN ô0ARISô ,AWRENCEô,ESSIGôISôAôPROFESSORôOFôLAWôATô3TANFORDô,AWô3CHOOLôANDôFOUNDERôOFôTHEôSCHOOLSô#ENTERô FORô)NTERNETôANDô3OCIETYô(EôISôTHEôAUTHORôOFô&REEô#ULTUREô ô4HEô&UTUREôOFô)DEASô ôANDô #ODEôANDô/THERô,AWSôOFô#YBERSPACEô ô(EôCHAIRSôTHEô#REATIVEô#OMMONSôPROJECT ôANDôSERVESô ONôTHEôBOARDôOFôTHEô&REEô3OFTWAREô&OUNDATION ôTHEô%LECTRONICô&RONTIERô&OUNDATION ôTHEô0UBLICô ,IBRARYôOFô3CIENCE ôANDô0UBLICô+NOWLEDGEô -ADHAVIô3UNDERôISôAôPROFESSORôOFôLAWôATôTHEô5NIVERSITYôOFô#ALIFORNIA ô$AVIS ôWHEREôSHEôSPECIALIZESô INôINTELLECTUALôPROPERTY ôINTERNATIONALôLAW ôANDôCULTURALôSTUDIESô(ERôWORKôHASôAPPEAREDôINôTHEô9ALEô ,AWô*OURNAL ô3TANFORDô,AWô2EVIEW ôANDô#ALIFORNIAô,AWô2EVIEW -ARJETICAô0OTRCôISôAô,JUBLJANA BASEDôARTISTôANDôARCHITECTô(ERôWORKôHASôBEENôFEATUREDôINôEXHIBI TIONSôTHROUGHOUTô%UROPEôANDôTHEô!MERICAS ôINCLUDINGô3KULPTURô0ROJEKTEôINô-UENSTER ô'ERMANYô ôANDô4HEô3TRUCTUREôOFô3URVIVALôATôTHEô6ENICEô"IENNIALô ôASôWELLôASôINôSOLOôSHOWSôATô THEô'UGGENHEIMô-USEUMôINô.EWô9ORKô ôANDôTHEô-)4ô,ISTô6ISUALô!RTSô#ENTERôINô#AMBRIDGE ô -ASSACHUSETTSô -ARTHAô7ALLNERôISôTHEô.ATIONALô'RASSROOTSô#OORDINATORôFORôTHEô53 BASEDô-EDIAôô$EMOCRACYô #OALITIONô3HEôLIVESôINô"ERKELEY ô#ALIFORNIA -IKAô(ANNULAôISô0ROFESSORôFORô!RTôINô0UBLICô3PACEôATôTHEô!CADEMYôOFô&INEô!RTS ô(ELSINKIô(ISôRECENTô PUBLICATIONSôINCLUDEô%VERYTHINGôORô.OTHINGÕ#RITICALô4HEORY ô#ONTEMPORARYô!RTôANDô6ISUALô#ULTUREô !CADEMYôOFô&INEô!RTSô ô7ITHô"RANISLAVô$IMITRIJEVICôHEôRECENTLYôCURATEDôTHEôEXHIBITIONô3ITU ATEDô3ELFô ô#ONFUSED ô#OMPASSIONATEôANDô#ONlICTUAL ôATôTHEô#ONTEMPORARYô!RTô-USEUM ô"ELGRADE ô ANDôTHEô#ITYô!RTô-USEUM ô(ELSINKI ô 4EREô6AD¯NôISôCURRENTLYôDIRECTINGôTHEô/PENô3OURCEô2ESEARCHô'ROUPôATôTHEô(YPERMEDIAô,ABORATORYô OFôTHEô5NIVERSITYôOFô4AMPERE ôWHEREôHEôISôAôPROFESSORô7ITHô-IKAô(ANNULA ôHEôISôTHEôAUTHORôOFô2OCKô 4HEô"OATô,OCALIZEDô%THICS ôTHEô3ITUATEDô3ELF ôANDô0ARTICULARISMôINô#ONTEMPORARYô!RTô3ALONô6ERLAG ô 3USANô+ELLYôISôANôARTISTôANDôWRITER ôBORNôINô)RELANDôINô(ERôPRACTICEôEXPERIMENTSôWITHôFORMSô OFôRHETORIC ôCOMMUNICATION ôMOVEMENTôANDôINTERVENTIONôINôTHEôCONTEXTôOFôARTISTICôANDôPOLITICALô PRACTICEô2ECENTôPROJECTSôHAVEôBEENôSHOWNôATôTHEô,ENINô-USEUM ô4AMPERE ô&INLAND ô0ROJECTô !RTSô#ENTREô$UBLIN ôTHEô0RAGUEô"IENNIAL ô.ATIONALô#ENTREôFORô#ONTEMPORARYô!RT ô3Tô0ETERSBURG ô !MORPHô&ESTIVALôOFô0ERFORMANCEô!RT ô(ELSINKI ô-ERCERô5NION ô4ORONTO ôPMô'ALLERY ô:AGREBôANDô!RTô INô'ENERAL ô.EWô9ORKô3HEôHASôPUBLISHEDôARTICLESôINô0UBLICô#ULTURE ô4HEô*OURNALôOFô6ISUALô#ULTURESô ANDô3OCIALôANDô#ULTURALô'EOGRAPHYô+ELLYôISôCURRENTLYôAôLECTURERôINô&INEô!RTôANDô0H$ôCANDIDATEôATô 'OLDSMITHSô#OLLEGE ô,ONDON 7ILLô"RADLEYôWRITESôABOUTôCONTEMPORARYôARTôFORôVARIOUSôPUBLICATIONSôINCLUDINGô&RIEZEôANDô!FTERALLô (EôISôCURRENTLYô6ISITINGô#URATORôATôTHEô#ALIFORNIAô#OLLEGEôOFô!RTSôINô3ANô&RANCISCO

0240_057_self_org.indd 334-335


25/09/06 17:42:24