6. Social Cohesion Network's definition. â« âSocial cohesion is based on the willingness of individuals to cooperate
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Social Cohesion: Insights from Canadian Research Presentation by M. Sharon Jeannotte at the Conference on Social Cohesion Hong Kong, November 29, 2003 Reference: SRA-827-dck For a PDF copy of this report contact us at:
[email protected] or Fax: (819) 997-6765
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Outline of presentation Debates about definitions of social
cohesion Overview of Canadian research on social cohesion Key findings about social cohesion Public policy implications Possible model for social cohesion 2
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Definitional debates Social cohesion is:
-
often defined as a political, economic or social threat treated both as: • an independent variable • a dependent variable
3
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Jenson’s five dimensions of social cohesion Belonging Inclusion Participation Recognition Legitimacy
Isolation Exclusion Non-involvement Rejection Illegitimacy
4
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Bernard’s formal and substantive dimensions of social cohesion Formal
Substantive
Equality/Inequality
Inclusion/Exclusion
Recognition/Rejection
Belonging/Isolation
Legitimacy/Illegitimacy
Participation/Noninvolvement
5
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Social Cohesion Network’s definition “Social cohesion is based on the
willingness of individuals to cooperate and work together at all levels of society to achieve collective goals.” Focus is on outcomes and behaviours
(dependent variables) No focus on inputs or enabling conditions (independent variables) 6
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Canadian research framework Social Cohesion Research Network
established in 1997 – over 20 departments and agencies are involved Work undertaken to: - develop a conceptual framework - develop indicators - do research under three themes - consult widely on priorities for future research 7
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Faultlines Research addressed three issues:
-
-
intersection of ethnic, gender and agerelated faultlines with economic disadvantage linkages between economic exclusion and political, social and cultural exclusion means of bridging faultlines
8
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Changing axes of community identification Research addressed three issues:
-
-
Citizenship as an element of social cohesion (included national identity, belonging, system of rights and political and civic participation) How values have changed in the 1990s Implications of changing levels of trust (for governments and for citizens) 9
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Implications of changes in social cohesion Research focused on four issues:
-
Economic implications Health and well-being implications Security implications Institutional and governance implications
10
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Key findings on social cohesion
There are faultlines and growing cleavages in Canadian society. These cleavages are contributing to a weakening of the axes of community identification in Canada -- the basis of social cohesion and social citizenship. Consequences of weakened axes of community identification are: poor social and economic outcomes growing political disenchantment 11
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
FIG URE 1- SEG MEN TA TION EV OLUTIO N CA NAD A, 1996-2002 Conform ity and exclusion Nihilists
M aterialists
22% (+15)
13% (+1)
16% (- 3) Outerdirected
Hedo nists
Conservatives Innerdirected
21% (+3)
15% (--)
12% (- 17) E xplorers
Skeptics Individualism and idealism
Source: CROP Inc., “Citizenship, Governance and Social Change”, July 3, 2003
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Public policy implications of social cohesion Research has shown correlations between
social cohesion and: - economic development - population health - well-being of children - security of communities - functioning of institutions - social capital investments 13
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
A systems theory model for social cohesion Social cohesion has multiple independent
and dependent variables linked in a complex system characterized by: - emergent properties (more than the sum of the system parts) - adaptive capabilities (ability to withstand change in the environment) - self-referential and unpredictable outcomes 14
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Figure 2 - How does social cohesion work? Social Social policy policy Economic Economic policy policy
Society Society with with given given propensity propensity to cooperate cooperate
Institutions, Institutions, norms, and norms, and shared shared meanings
meanings
Distribution of income / social benefits
Economic Economic
Education Education
Security Security
Cultural capital Civil Civil society society
Health Health
Community Community wellwellbeing being
Social Capital Social Outcomes Source: Strategic Research and Analysis Directorate, Department of Canadian Heritage
Strategic Research and Analysis
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Dealing with complex social problems Need to recognize that:
-
-
different stakeholders may not agree no definitive statement of problem is possible problem is embedded in a dynamic social context and solutions must be assessed in that context problem-solving is a social process of “learning what works” 16
Strategic Research and Analysis
Is all policy social cohesion policy?
Recherche et analyse stratégiques
Systems model recognizes that social
cohesion results not from the individual components of the system but from: - the interconnections between them - feedback loops between them - the interactions among the parts Good policy is the only lever available to governments to influence social cohesion 17