Studies European Journal of Cultural

European Journal of Cultural Studies http://ecs.sagepub.com

Review: Aphra Kerr, The Business and Culture of Digital Games: Gamework/Gameplay. London: Sage, 2006. 177 pp. ISBN 1412900476 (pbk) £21.99; Jon Dovey and Helen W. Kennedy, Game Cultures: Computer Games as New Media. Maidenhead: Open University Press, 2006. 171 pp. ISBN 055521557X (pbk) £19.99 Mark Deuze and Chase Bowen Martin European Journal of Cultural Studies 2008; 11; 197 DOI: 10.1177/1367549408091318 The online version of this article can be found at: http://ecs.sagepub.com

Published by: http://www.sagepublications.com

Additional services and information for European Journal of Cultural Studies can be found at: Email Alerts: http://ecs.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Subscriptions: http://ecs.sagepub.com/subscriptions Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav

Downloaded from http://ecs.sagepub.com at INDIANA UNIV on April 18, 2008 © 2008 SAGE Publications. All rights reserved. Not for commercial use or unauthorized distribution.

DTQNOD@MINTQM@KNE

QDUHDV

#OPYRIGHT¥3!'%0UBLICATIONS ,OS!NGELES ,ONDON .EW$ELHI AND3INGAPORE 6OL n $/) WWWSAGEPUBLICATIONSCOM

2EVIEW !PHRA+ERR 4HE"USINESSAND#ULTUREOF$IGITAL'AMES'AMEWORK'AMEPLAY ,ONDON3AGE PP)3".PBK a *ON$OVEYAND(ELEN7+ENNEDY 'AME#ULTURES#OMPUTER'AMESAS .EW-EDIA-AIDENHEAD/PEN5NIVERSITY0RESS PP)3". 8PBK a 7ITHTHEEXPANSIONINBOOKS JOURNALS ANDCONFERENCESONDIGITALGAMESAND GAMESTUDIESOFLATE TWORELATEDOBSERVATIONSCANBEMADE!LTHOUGHFEW QUESTIONORDOUBTTHETECHNOLOGICAL ECONOMICALANDCULTURALSIGNIFICANCE OFCOMPUTERANDVIDEOGAMES THERESEEMSTOBELITTLERESEARCHARTICULATING SUCHCLAIMSORASSUMPTIONSINANYQUANTITATIVEDETAIL)NDEEDMOST IFNOT ALL OFTHENUMBERSTHATSCHOLARSUSEFORGROUNDINGTHEIRWORKONANDIN GAMESTENDTOBEDERIVEDFROMINDUSTRYANDMARKETRESEARCHSOURCESSUCH ASTHE53BASED%NTERTAINMENT3OFTWARE!SSOCIATION%3! ORTHE.0$ 'ROUPANDTHE5+ BASED%NTERTAINMENTAND,EISURE3OFTWARE0UBLISHERS !SSOCIATION%,30! OR3CREEN$IGEST&ROMSUCHOVERUSEDYETUNDER CHECKEDSOURCESWEDERIVETHEVITALDATAUNDERWRITINGOURASSUMPTIONS ANDEVENOURASSESSMENTSOFTHEROLEGAMESPLAYINSOCIETY !FIRSTCOMMENTREGARDINGTHEWORKOF+ERR ANDOF$OVEYAND+ENNEDY THEREFORE MUSTBETHAT THESE IMPRESSIVE REVIEWS OFTHE KEYISSUESIN UNDERSTANDINGDIGITALGAMESFAILTOMAPTHEFIELD ADEQUATELYORCRIT ICALLY INTERMSOFANINCLUSIVEPERSPECTIVEONITSHISTORYANDCULTURE OR REGARDINGTHEPROBLEMATICNATUREOFASSESSINGTHISHISTORYTHOUGHSOURCES THATREPRESENTVESTEDINTERESTSINTHEREVENUE GENERATINGCAPACITIESOFTHE INDUSTRY!SECONDGENERALOBSERVATIONREGARDINGCONTEMPORARYGAME STUDIESISTHEIRALMOSTCOMPLETEDISREGARDFORTHOSEINVOLVEDINMAKING GAMES4HISISPARTICULARLYPROBLEMATICASDIGITALGAMESAREARGUABLYTHE FIRSTORFOREMOSTMEDIAINWHICHTHECREATIVEROLESOFPRODUCERSANDCON SUMERSOFCONTENTACTIVELYDISSOLVE)NDEED MUCHGAMEWORKISCARRIED OUTBYPROFESSIONALORSEMI PROFESSIONALDEVELOPERS DESIGNERS ARTISTS PROGRAMMERS ANDCODERS/NTHEOTHERHAND ALOTOFGAMEMAKINGIS ACTUALLYDONEBYCONSUMERS USERS ANDGAMERSTHEMSELVESLEVELEDITING CHARACTERCREATION CLANORGUILDFORMATION GAMEMODIFICATION@MODDING ANDEVENORIGINALGAMEPRODUCTIONUSINGFREEORCHEAPSOFTWARESUCHAS QDUHDV Downloaded from http://ecs.sagepub.com at INDIANA UNIV on April 18, 2008 © 2008 SAGE Publications. All rights reserved. Not for commercial use or unauthorized distribution.

D T Q N O D @ M I N T Q M @ K N E B T KS T Q @ K R S T C H D R

-ICROSOFTS8.!'AME3TUDIO%XPRESSALLOWINGPLAYERSTOMAKEGAMES FORTHE8BOXPLATFORM SOFTWAREDEVELOPMENTKITS3$+S DISTRIBUTED BYGAMESTUDIOSSUCHASTHEPOPULAR3OURCE3$+BYDEVELOPER6ALVEBEST KNOWNFORITS(ALF ,IFEGAMESSERIES ORTHE$4ORQUEGAMEENGINEMADE AVAILABLETHROUGHINDEPENDENTGAMEDEVELOPERANDDISTRIBUTOR'ARAGE GAMES!LTHOUGH$OVEYAND+ENNEDYBRIEFLYADDRESSDIGITALGAMESAS BLURRINGTHEBOUNDARIESBETWEENPRODUCINGANDCONSUMINGCONTENTnTHUS FORCINGSCHOLARSTOLETGOOFPARADIGMATICASSUMPTIONSORAPPROACHESTHAT WOULDREIFYSUCHROLESINMEDIASTUDIESnNEITHERTHEIRWORKNOR+ERRS ADEQUATELYDEALSWITHTHISPHENOMENON 4HISISNOTTOSAYTHAT$OVEYAND+ENNEDYSANALYSISOFTHECONSUMER PRODUCTIONCULTUREISNOTRELEVANT ASITISAPPROACHEDFROMAFRESHPER SPECTIVETHATADDRESSESTHEWORKOFGAMEDEVELOPERSANDTHEIRAUDIENCES ONANEQUALFOOTING ANDOPENLYACKNOWLEDGESSOMEOFTHECOMPLICATIONS OFTRYINGTODISTINGUISHBETWEENTHETWO/FPARTICULARSIGNIFICANCEISTHEIR RETELLINGOFTHEOFTENCITEDEXAMPLEOFUSER PRODUCERCO CREATION#OUNTER 3TRIKE AN@AMATEURMODOFTHECOMMERCIALGAME(ALF ,IFE)NSTEADOF FRAMINGTHESTORYOF#OUNTER 3TRIKEASANEXAMPLEOFFANCULTURES $OVEY AND+ENNEDYMAKEUSAWAREOFADISTINCTLEVELOFPROFESSIONALISMEXISTENT WITHINTHEMODCOMMUNITY!MATEURGAMEDEVELOPERSOFTENTENDTOBE STUDENTSINTHEFIELDOFSOFTWAREDEVELOPMENT MODDEVELOPMENTGOES THROUGHSEVERALITERATIONSBEFORE@GOINGGOLD ANDTHEORIGINALDEVELOPERS OF#OUNTER 3TRIKEWEREEVENTUALLYCO OPTEDINTOTHECOMMERCIALFOLDOF (ALF ,IFESORIGINALDEVELOPER 6ALVEPFF 4HISAPPROACHARTICULATES THEDEGREETOWHICHCONSUMERSCANBECONSIDEREDWITHINTHESAMETACTICAL FRAMEASPROFESSIONALPRODUCERSINTHEREALMOFNEWMEDIAWORK7HILE $OVEYAND+ENNEDYSWORKTAKESSTEPSTOWARDSVIEWINGTHISSYSTEMAS SINGLEWHOLE RATHERTHANASSEPARATECLUSTERSOFACTIVITIESANDARRANGE MENTS THEIMPLICATIONSTHEREOFREMAINUNDERUTILIZED "EYONDTHESEOMISSIONS THESEWORKSCANBECONSIDEREDTOBEVALUABLE ADDITIONSTOTHEEMERGINGGAMESTUDIESLITERATURES+ERR AND$OVEYAND +ENNEDY AWARDSIGNIFICANTSPACETOTHEQUESTIONOFWHETHERDIGITALGAMES CANBESEENASTEXTS4HISISANIMPORTANTQUESTION ASGAMESDIFFERFROM MOTIONPICTURESORBOOKSINTHAT ONTHEIROWN THEYDONOTREPRESENT ANYTHING'AMESBECOMETEXTSTHEMOMENTPEOPLESTARTPLAYINGTHEM BUTNOTTEXTSINANYTRADITIONALSENSEnASANYACTOFGAMEPLAYCHANGESTHE TEXTINMOREORLESSFUNDAMENTALWAYS4HISISUNDERSCOREDIN$OVEYAND +ENNEDYSBOOKANDISUSEDTOPOSITIONGAMESASPIVOTALINTHEUNDERSTANDING OFACHANGINGNATUREOFNEWMEDIA%VENTHOUGHTHEFIELDOFGAMESTUDIES ISVERYYOUNG ALREADYTWO@CAMPSAREDEFINEDBYTHESCHOLARSANDSTUDENTS INVOLVEDTHENARRATOLOGISTSTHOSEWHOCOMETOGAMESGENERALLYVIAFILM ANDLITERARYSTUDIES VERSUSTHELUDOLOGISTSTHOSEWHOAREMOREINTERESTED INTHEORIESOFPLAY )NDISCUSSINGTHISSCHISMORTHEALREADYEMERGING DÏTENTEBETWEENTHESECAMPS +ERRPFF AND$OVEYAND+ENNEDY PFF CITEEXACTLYTHESAMEAUTHORS INDICATINGNOTONLYTHEEMERGENT


QDUHDV

NATUREOFTHEFIELD BUTALSO ALREADY ITSQUESTFORPARADIGMATICFORMATION ANDSEDIMENTATION9ETTHESEDISTINCTIONSSEEMSOMEWHATARTIFICIAL POS SIBLYANARTEFACTOFTRYINGTODRAWCOMPARISONSTOMOREESTABLISHED AND FURTHERANALYSED MEDIAFORMS4HISISSOMETHINGHINTEDATINTHECLOSING OF+ERRSCHAPTERINCONSIDERINGGAMESASMEDIATEXTS7HENMORERECENT WORKISCITEDTHATVIEWSGAMESINBOTHTHECONTEXTOFNARRATOLOGYAND LUDOLOGY +ERR CONCLUDESTHAT @ITISCLEAR THATTHEUSERTEXTMEDIUM RELATIONSHIPISINCREASINGLYCOMPLEX.OTONLYDOWEHAVECOMPLEXITY ATTHEPOINTOFRECEPTIONBUTWEALSOHAVEINCREASINGCOMPLEXITYATTHE LEVELOFTHETEXTANDTHEMEDIUMP EXEMPLIFYINGAWILLINGNESS TOFORMTHEDETERMINANTSOFGAMESASTEXTINTOSOMETHINGMOREFLUID THANASINGULARTYPEOFREADING/FTHETWOBOOKS +ERRSEEMSTHEMORE RESPECTFUL OF THOSE ACTUALLY PLAYING GAMES EXTENDING HER DISCUSSION OFDIFFERENTTHEORETICALAPPROACHESTOANANALYSISOFGAMEGENRESAND INCLUDINGTHEPUBLICATIONSNOTONLYOFSCHOLARS BUTALSOGAMEDESIGNERS THEMSELVES )NDEED 4HE"USINESSAND#ULTUREOF$IGITAL'AMESWOULDBETHEPERFECT BOOKFORANINTRODUCTORYOROVERVIEWCOURSEONGAMESTUDIESANDDIGITAL GAMESINGENERAL ASITSAPPROACHISCENTREDONTHEDIGITALGAMESINDUSTRY ASACULTURALINDUSTRY WHICHALLOWS+ERRTOCONSIDERBOTHTHESTRUCTUREAND CULTUREOFGAMESTUDIOS PUBLISHERSANDHARDWAREMANUFACTURERSASWELL ASTHEEMOTIONALANDDEMOGRAPHICMAKEUPOFGAMERSASCO CREATORSOF GAMEWORKANDGAMEPLAY$OVEYAND+ENNEDY ONTHEOTHERHAND FOCUS MOSTOFTHEIRCONSIDERATIONSOFGAMESONTHEGAMESTHEMSELVESANDIN DOINGSOANCHORTHEIRWORKMOSTDELIBERATELYONTHEROLEOFTECHNOLOGYIN PLAYINGANDMAKINGGAMES2IGHTATTHEOUTSETTHEYPOSITIONTHEMSELVES SQUARELYINTHEONGOINGDEBATEONTECHNOLOGYSROLEINMODERNITY PREFACING THEIRENTIREBOOKONTHECONCEPTOFTECHNICITYASANINTERPRETATIONOFTHE INTENSIFYINGINTERACTIONSBETWEENTECHNOLOGYANDEVERYDAYLIFE@4HE SIGNIFICANTASPECTOFTHENEWTERMOFhTECHNICITYvISTOENCAPSULATE INCON CEPTUALTERMS THECONNECTIONSBETWEENANIDENTITYBASEDONCERTAINTYPES OFATTITUDES PRACTICES PREFERENCESANDSOONANDTHEIMPORTANCEOFTECH NOLOGYASACRITICALASPECTOFTHECONSTRUCTIONOFTHATIDENTITYP 4HE PROBLEMISTHATTECHNICITYISNOTA@NEWTERMnITWASINTRODUCEDBY-ARTIN (EIDEGGER;= ANDARGUABLYIN*ACQUES%LLULS;= WORKON@TECHNIQUE)NTHISCONTEXT (EIDEGGERAND%LLULDIDNOTSOMUCH CONSIDERTECHNOLOGYINAMATERIALSENSEnAS$OVEYAND+ENNEDYFOREXAMPLE DO LOCATINGMUCHOFTHEIRINTELLECTUALAMMUNITIONINFASCINATINGYET BEWILDERINGEXCURSIONSINTO$MODELLINGANDPOLYGONSPPn 4HE FRAMEWORKOFTHESCEPTICALPHILOSOPHERSWASMOREAMBITIOUS CONSIDERING TECHNOLOGYONTOLOGICALLYASAWAYOFSEEINGANDBEINGINTHEWORLDDRIVEN BYTHEPOSTULATESOFEFFICIENCYANDCONTROL 4ECHNICITYBECOMESPARTICULARLYPROBLEMATICIN$OVEYAND+ENNEDYS WORKINTHEIRADMITTEDLYBRIEFDISCUSSIONOFTHENATUREANDCULTUREOFGAME


D T Q N O D @ M I N T Q M @ K N E B T KS T Q @ K R S T C H D R

DEVELOPMENT5SINGINTERVIEWSP WITHGAMEDEVELOPERSATONE "RITISHSTUDIOASTHEGROUNDWORKFORTWOCHAPTERSONHOWTHEINDUSTRY WORKS THEAUTHORSFOCUSALMOSTEXCLUSIVELYONTECHNOLOGICALFETISHISM WITHINTHEINDUSTRYANDAMONGGAMEWORKERS4HESUGGESTIONISTHATTHOSE WHOCREATEGAMESUSEANDAREUSEDBYTHECHARACTERISTICSANDEXPECTATIONS OFTECHNOLOGYTOSTRIVEFOREVER MOREREALISTICGAMES CONSIDERING@TECHNOL OGYASADETERMINANTOFPRODUCTIONP !LTHOUGHITISIMPOSSIBLETO ARGUETHATTECHNOLOGYDOESNOTPLAYASIGNIFICANTROLEINGAMEWORK THIS EXCLUSIVEFOCUSONTHEROLEOFHARDWARETHEAFFORDANCESOFNEXTGENERATION CONSOLESOR0#GRAPHICSCARDSANDPROCESSORSPEEDS ANDSOFTWARESUCH ASTHESOURCECODEOFGAMEENGINES SEEMSRATHERSUPERFICIAL&IRST MUCH OFTHEWORKINGAMESTUDIOSISDONEBYPEOPLEWITHOUTUSINGCOMPUTERS ARTISTS3ECOND MOSTCOMPUTERANDVIDEOGAMESAREINFACTNOTREALISTIC ORNATURALISTICATALLnTHESEGMENTOFHIGHLYDETAILEDANDIMMERSIVE$ GAMEWORLDSISINFACTONEOFTHESMALLESTSEGMENTSINTHEINDUSTRY AND GENERALLYREPRESENTSREPETITIVESPORTSLICENSESORBIG BUDGETFIRST PERSON SHOOTERS"YFOCUSINGONTHETECHNICITYOFGAMES THENUANCESOFEQUALLY INFLUENTIALREGIONAL NATIONAL ANDINDIVIDUALORGANIZATIONALSTRUCTURESIS LOST WEIGHTINGGAMESINANOBJECTIVEFOUNDATIONOFINDUSTRY UBIQUITOUS TECHNOLOGICAL STANDARDS AND IGNORING CONTEMPORARY RESEARCH ON THE CULTURALECONOMYOFNEWMEDIAWORK!LTHOUGHVALUABLEASACONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORKTYINGTHEBOOKTOGETHER THEFEWBUTIMPORTANTPUBLICATIONS ONGAMEWORKAVAILABLEATTHETIMETHESEAUTHORSWEREWRITINGTHEIRBOOKS IFANYTHINGSUGGESTAMUCHMOREINEFFICIENT MESSY ANDDYNAMICSYSTEM OFCULTURALPRODUCTION 4HETECHNICITYAPPROACHSEEMSPRIMARILYUSEDTOVALIDATEGAMESTUDIES THUSPOSITIONINGDIGITALGAMESASAREFLECTOROFCONTEMPORARYTECHNO CENTRIC SOCIETY)NDEED THROUGHOUTBOTHPIECESTHERESEEMSTOBEAPERCEIVEDNEED TOLEGITIMIZETHESTUDYOFGAMESTHROUGHBALANCINGTHELEVITYOFPLAY WITHMORE@SERIOUSASPECTSOFTHEMEDIUM+ERRINCLUDESANINTERESTING YETRATHERDISJOINTEDCHAPTERONNON ENTERTAINMENTUSESOFTHEMEDIUM WHILE$OVEYAND+ENNEDYDEPLOYGAMESTUDIESTOVALIDATETHELARGERIM PLICATIONSOFHAVINGATECHNICALIDENTITY INCLUDINGACHAPTERONGAMESAS ACYBORGMEDIUM"OTHSELECTIONSSEEMTOIMPLYTHATSTUDYINGGAMESAS ENTERTAINMENTISSIMPLYNOTGOODENOUGHnALTHOUGHEACHBOOKISDIRECTLY STRUCTUREDTODOSO)TCOULDBEARGUEDTHATTHECONTEXTOFDIVERSIONISIN FACTFUNDAMENTALTOTHENATUREOFGAMES$OVEYAND+ENNEDYSCHOICE TOSTRUCTURETHEIRCONCEPTUALIZATIONOFGAMESWITHINALARGERFRAMEWORK OFTECHNO CULTURALCHANGENEGLECTSTHEFRIVOLITYOFHUMANITYASSOCIATED WITHPLAYINGAMES ASWELLTHESOCIALITYTHATPEOPLEEXPERIENCETHROUGH ONLINEANDOTHERWISECOOPERATIVEGAMEPLAY /VERALL BOTHBOOKSCANBEUSEDINTANDEMFORADVANCEDUNDERGRADUATE COURSESONDIGITALGAMES THEGAMEINDUSTRYANDGAMESTUDIES"EYOND THESIGNALLEDSHORTCOMINGS THEBOOKSAREWRITTENINANACCESSIBLESTYLE ANDTAKETHEIROBJECTOFSTUDYVERYSERIOUSLYINDEED7ORKBY!PHRA+ERR


QDUHDV

ESPECIALLYCANBECONSIDEREDAFRIENDLY INCLUSIVEANDINTERDISCIPLINARY APPROACHTODIGITALGAMES WHEREASTHEINSPIRINGWORKOF$OVEYAND +ENNEDYISMOREDIRECTLYAFFILIATEDWITHCULTURALSTUDIES/NAFINALAND PERHAPSTRIVIALNOTEWITHALLTHEATTENTIONTHECONTEMPORARYCULTURAL ECONOMYINGENERAL ANDINTHISCASEGAMESCHOLARSINPARTICULAR PAYTO DESIGNANDINTERFACEOREVENAESTHETICS WHYDOACADEMICPUBLISHERSCREATE SUCHINTENSELYUGLYBOOKS 2EFERENCES

%LLUL *;= ,ATECHNIQUE,ENJEUDUSIÒCLE0ARIS%CONOMICA (EIDEGGER -;= @4HE!GEOFTHE7ORLD0ICTURE IN4HE1UESTION #ONCERNING4ECHNOLOGYAND/THER%SSAYSTRANS7,OVITT PPn .EW9ORK(ARPER2OW

-ARK$EUZEAND#HASE"OWEN-ARTIN )NDIANA5NIVERSITY 53!
