supporting virtuosity and flow in computer music

CHRIS supporting virtuosity and flow NASH in computer music

THIS DISSERTATION IS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY

Computer Laboratory

0122345678 6451365 7 3 67 32154 16 !"#$%%&'(()(*#  +*('"',-'((.%',/01,2-2,3 "-*-4%.*(-,'-&'"''(,.'4,0(,/ 2,3*,-(-4,%%"5,"',-(64(7'2(( 7(4/4"%%1-*4"'(*-'('(6'#  !,7"',/'*('"',-""%("*15((-8, 4.(-'%15(-&.50''(*51'(".',/,"-1 ,'(*(&((,*7%,0",,'(9."%/4"',-#  +*('"',-*,(-,'(64((*:82,* -4%.*-&'"5%("-*/,,'-,'(85.'(64%.*-& "77(-*4(855%,&"7187,',&"78"-**"&"0 #  $%%5"-*-"0("-*(&'((*'"*(0"3.(*- '2,3"('(7,7('1,/'((7(4')(,2-(# ;

;

   34556789  97846 98 69 654874 9

 !"#"$%&'"("&"'%)%*"+,"-",'&"%&('.&")'/,0&"123 "")".)"&")(("%$"'.*"$%%$"!*%$%*))"#("0""+,""%)" &&"%#("%*-*0(&'"+,('")'/,("+)"&-"*'/%0)/0)4 3% ,".'/%)"5#"* /0)6&"/0) "70"%)"1*80%)&'% "+& #"&!""%&"/0)%9,")(&:((!&,".'/%)"*!"%*&"$"%") 0#(&6&")%70",,("*%&"*"$%'.&"'.&!"4;")"&-",')"%'& '%(6.$/"%&"*)'/0(&,(",6)(.('!?49MH9

V8W9>L#,:+%!( 1.O!$(=#+"3V+)!"!(( 17N+#!4*O$"+H=%$*+,":,#M=9+,W'$(!9L#,3#$J( 1/ MHH!"9+rM MHH!"9+rt MHH!"9+r1 MHH!"9+rN MHH!"9+r8 MHH!"9+r; MHH!"9+r

1

I#$4P!#8::!4*(s!:!#!"4! ;%,5+"O=(+41,JH,(+*+," cuvwbfx=!(*+,""$+#!( cuvwbfQ"*!#$4*+,"8)!"*I>H!( cuvwbfy\z{PD@Q@R=BE@F=DA@>DAB>SBD>QCQ@>DAB&!$'!.T8-)!UK

V=A@PDBPW@E=G@D=A+X&%-!"&!))! !#  -% & !!&"())!% 1# $)!",&%%-!!!"-+ YFZ@?@OCGBF=QEABCDEBS@DE@DPA+X'))!"-("$1 !,"!#!!"-$-%,%,)%(1% -,%,%#&,!$1!& !(, !"!,/'!,%"!"!()),$%1# )#"-$!"/#,!#%%%#+ 34[ 3553 \ 8

378   ],,'%"!)&!,$ ""-,(-0

"-)!T8-)!^!'%!-,$%",& !!"-$ ""$)(%!'$!!,"!# !!"-)#"-,#(%&#"-,,&"%-% %,&$ "&'!+X"!",&"!"!#T

12

345367893  78 78 638873  89993 873 7347 98  78878399 9 59878 5736 3456397393 7698 7373477393634536833 8 3788 39836897896955678867987  68 7 6 9 736378 6

366  387363 783936 34536833 93 !"989#37 8 81$$%&  '()*)++ ", 8 71$$-&993.3793 7955673473983936 97 8398736 788 5736/ 8 3  59878  573607839 345368 375 76 3353 737

  93 7  5768 63 /6 34

539  98  63 78876

637 1---76 36  93.336936936

1/3 65368 3 58  6837 3 5868  37 9 28 89 635639373 8 8 7887 8 397 " 5736 %&  9898736 78963 7877 76988 3 6 8736 78" 57363&  9389   98  33   " 57364& 93 993696397 7 6   59 3768 556 397 335

 387 78 93 93 7356*'7'()89':)*+'*+88*7;7'*+6

36 ";?J=482J8:3>

"-C"CB."-.E+.GH.+ +.)"#,.$.BC".E +*FKL$F#$"BC+""#"B.$)+*$

U

U

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

456789   799  95 9 98959

5   99 865 6559

95979 9955!"#"  59$  7%!  &'((()89 99 99 95 56 9 595 65* * 7 896 % ! 99 **969 76 99 *5*9  8 55 9 99+ 9 9955  9 76 75, 9 95  9  9  9 95 9595* 

 659   9 95659 5*  7&9  7 !"#"79*9)%"59999 59$955 79   96 9 6 89 999-6959  559  559986 9 9 69  999 09

5559* 995*95 5795*55.'((/)% .12.34.5 9 * 769769959 5598999599 6.74.8  6965!"#"*5 6599786    59   *5  : 7 9; *99< 5*5*89&99=*6 9'&))98959 5 669 597$9 >;95)% >= *6 91W 9  9  9955X.3Y.5CZ2Y.6 98 97 *5 899959959 K9%?9J" [4\.]54\D3&99=*6 9^@10)9$ 95  9 9 @@ **5 97 9 95 67955 65*5@ 99

995!"#" 6 G% 2E 99  8 9-6959

K958989_9556789  6 9 998   9697 9$ 659 99 95959*5 57 9 75*9795 5* 9 55*58G5*@6 *55'((>)%?5 959* 9 9  7698 G9  99 5*5 955* 76&99T95'%'%1)%

12

345789 4  4  89

!"#$%%&#$%'("#)*+,-. /01234-,-./$%%&#$%'("56.75-84

           395:;?@AB=CDEF 3P5DQR;BSR=:?TSUV=W=X 8

G41H1-1./IJ*45*K-2 4.L4151M/4N1.656.75-84O

Y-L45Z*+570+1.5Z/.L0/K[N-\]JL-5*/65ZM-7 ^_`a.5-1.5114/00-.,ZH.+5Z/.L*/K7-55O

3b5WQc?d=CVUAe=fQSU?dSeUX 8349g5

h-4+/,+-/4/.L,+-/4-5M-74.L4L-.54+H. /.L*/*4NK5*N5i+.K4Z-.12jkl5/57-KO

35mBUdAee=n;oAdB=WAdSAeX 8

pK5*+,-.556L/51_/.Lq_4/K[H1+.LZ 1+01/4L7/4LM/4ZM-7/./1,*15Z1,,5M-K75Z h_H45Z\pJ5Z41K[45M-K75Z5K4M5/.L2.5O

r89st4uX 8u4vw xX 8y

12



+,-./,-0 -0123-040567 

4567891  859 765 9 598 99  6556565689 8 5 79 8  8 89 959  998 5 795  8 98 5 69985 5!7     598   8  59

 89"# 99456789$%598959 8  9 9 587959 !97!98 99 957 569 7 9 5 8122&'()856122*% 85989 99  955 8 89'55 58  9 8:9! 8 9591222';7=#',F 

5 7575 87579:77 8777 8-7 8 =#'P 7Q4)RQS1TT1, UVWXYZ[\[][^_`abcZ[`YadeZY[fY_WYagh8 ,;$"#(!"'?"/!%@'/567 8 O6 765 58 -78i 8574 8-877 7 78 j$'%"/=>#%k/" 8567l   87K  JL6MF,=#'  78  *1Q+O558 -78 7NKPzps -5-rv{78 | - pq6 }}7rs7 8  7~  K5  K877pK88r,877 7 8P 71TT1)77  5872 5872J

12



4566789 9  878 5 8 89  67 7!9 9 "9  #  $98 5% 9 & 5%8 # '& 5  %(  &'%78#%' 8$9 )*78 %( 879 7 %( '"9# %7

%8 %(65 97" %5+ &9 ,-.7/%7"#10012347678

969"78 % 8 8% 87669 #9 %8

5 7 56 878 8% 876 7$%9# $9 57"6 7%87# 8797"65 9 % 7 9% 7'

87 9% (%5 9 %7%9   57"88  7 9%7#879# 6795"7 9% %(65 97"7 %58%#89 7'"9 :59 #9  % 8%"%(87"+ 969 88 7 9%-'& &  9!827#7;D@ (%; I"%'(@EB#("'#%("'('""2 ("2$4=%"2#($$""2  "(   $$2   '%2  $(#%2"A&$ '$$%; E("$,3+5758#19::7; J67*K (""'$ $"(#%$($'( &"$"(8:( #""'( L FG45G47 &$%"M$(% $$$""%" %$5&#&%#'$#($( $#(%$#%("27;N&"'$("& O+7,4  *6+"'((($""2$$ &%## %"$#%(%$#' ""$#'=%"2#'"%%3 %" $$"#  " (%  %#  $("%$(%('2 ''2;P'%:1""($FG4("$ 1 Q553) -RSTT#$$=%%; ?192$4'2#%'$" %$'(#$' $4$$'""3$#

:LP$( U2A''V194WE%$UX'"Y;

12

34567895 94 877

3397 

5 79 7 9

 8 794 59 9 7 38 397 58877895 39 589  78 497 56  7 5 7  7  937 9 5 7 88877895  777   6838698 6 5 797 4 !77 7 857 8  " 9785785 865 #785 86 857 4  # 8 56 5694587  678 66985 7  85  935 " 4 86857 36 94695 8 9 757 8 9586 68878 94 8873679 937 885597895 

$%&'()*+,*-*./012345/6789:950;DE ??@ A887B67C FGH 9"879 F8547 587895I 9"585D2E2J5 95867 659 94576 K(LMN%OPQ 78  5 85 I59 6647895J 8 756 38 5847895 96 4  5 7895I 9 4885

7 #74 694 J 6 7  8 579664 895I87

9" J H99 5 

59 796 85I387  J R'S%TQU 957"87  78  869   85 74 57 I 995   785 859 99  7

6 96 7596 4 5 5 J5594 57 8 I 5J 4

33 67 I

 "7 8 VAJ DEW# 647  8 7"""94 75 7X9Y"86ZF[\\GI] 8 9 98 95^_`a`bcJ

12

                                               



456789 85 99     



 !"#$%&#&%%'$ "'()%&)%* (+!&%"$)$,&%%"&!"'$%(&,+&(.$%+%/- (+#,!(/(0,12341"'-.5!15'0$$( %6#/(&% $% !"//%'0% (+5%&%6#%&%'!% -%0' ' .5!1 #%!+!"//,.5!!(.#($('7"%-(''($"$('5%8 9)%&$%!(5&%(+$%!"#$%&1"'"&05.%'$+(& 5##(&$'0 )&$5($,"'-+/(*(5$/'%-1%'$"/'0$&%%7&("- +$"*", +&(. $%#&'!#/% (+5"7/$,-%0'1" //5$&"$%- "7()%1 (5$/''0"'%++(&$$(.()%7%,('-$%#&(-5!$)$,(+!5&&%'$ (+$*"&%.%$(-1$(*"&- '$%&+"!% $"$5##(&$!&%"$)$,8 :%!$('182#&%%'$"-%+'$('(+;?@ABCD=>>M*+,-./!011234

Y Z 74[\ ]7^_ ^7 `879 ^87  )%%%'%% &$6@(!=>>>3 ijCD,.-EF, FTkljCD,.-EF,

`a 8 ^7 `874 c"A%>>3 $#( @%#)=>>>3 $# 7$%)=>>>!011d3 $# ef$)=>>>3 $#( WA%g"A)=>>>3 $# 96A#)=>X1!=>>h!011h3 $# @()=>>>3 $#(

^7 `87b #"  $ #"A# "#(  $  $ "&"#

7$% )011d3!+$ '#$ $6 "$# $ $ %6 %$6!666f 6 $%$A+$#($%A( $%$&$(#&mijCD,.-EF,%A   $#!"An & % $"#% A "%$$%STGCoJ/JQEC./$'M+#ljCD,.-EF,%A $An$#(!6 $&+  A"%$$%  oET-JDEC./% TJCE./$'4p  6% 6#%$)@#$+!=>hXMWA!0111M*+,-./! 011234qfr6#()=>>h3!&$'6 #!"sAqV$ %$$##(B#%%(!%""An!B "An%$An#"$4p&"%" A+$#(+&$#B$" $$(% "6(#)44@%#!=>>2Mef$!=>>>34 11

3456789 7 456789 7 957 6607 67 675689 9 69

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

4G" #$&2338)##!%%##*7###.$#."%$!."#$"'!"""#5 2( ..!$!#"'$"#%*$""%"#!$$$#$!'$ %$!.##!%%##F

'#'"''$-""!$#*$"#%#$#.$#%*$"$ '$-!.#$#! "$"%.$##"#"%"#M'"#$N$ #".#"$.!$#!#.$H#&0>??2)5

12

3456789 984 7 63  37  459 797 3 5758778 6 4 7 745 9984 58345789539534 58  4 4222 699196937  !95 !9 96 775 !9 439664899475 676"4756 58# $79222%739 6452226991& '())*+,-./0)1+'*.230 94 949  !79 !94 4876 7$ 75 !93 9 79 43966 4+12,-5-,60-.0,710('1+0 3 466 79 737 5 6 7!49$9349753 9 675 18)1+-1.410

99 5  !76 4:93 76 489456

9 ! ;"763!9 1,023?@@A6 9 CDE1')-,10,710-.71+1.,0'*4-2302')14,0*F04+12,-5-,6G0-.H-5-H(230 I.*J31H/1G0-K2/-.2,-*.G0-.')-+2,-*.02.H0-..*52,-*.02+10,710 L2'1'0F*+0'*4-2304+12,-5-,6M0J-,7*(,0-.')-+2,-*.230')2+I'0F+*K0,710 -.H-5-H(23G0'*4-2304+12,-5-,60'-K)36072'0.*0472.410,*0F32+10()0-.0 ,710F-+',0)3241N0O(/K1.,-./02.H0,71.0L1,,1+0(,-3-P-./0-.H-5-H(230 4+12,-5-,60-'0,7('01''1.,-230F*+0247-15-./0'*4-2304+12,-5-,6N0 Q594 !97 6 4$:93 7964;"< 969 3!75 43 9 77 6!48 !9 94 9$9 4R95! 539 !99 645 9=9 79539S;9 7 1,023 ?@@A#334 87575 !9345 9= 4 !76 969 3! !96437  879567456 4 3 77 796 63! 6 673 @9 4  539 58 7 476 745 9 54 9=4 98 75 89 7 T9 6 63! 6 U9 4  539 58U 87 745 969875 93!54473 345 9= 454 9959

 99

75 9693 79 4 5 79V3 7 73  9=93 7454 64 87 93 75 9

3 745 7 ! 84 753RW99 X795966S876366987593 745X?X 58 9  799  7454

3 9 79 483 7

9693 7946437 345 9= 'E P8ER98ECP$'&+#'(!* &+-'!'$!!*&

*!!/==U+$21K1"#(-../0("'(""6')"'(!6 "# *"""'"))#"")'"+"( -..?012*(#""'* +@"'(9:::#7!857676 68 8860557% CD986#$97786 6E F#75!G6?96 8 87866748%H471A$876898$ 7 ?866694684 5$7688$6IJK767796E86!F#75! LMNOPQRSTRUVQRUQWR hijk*8*6(