thesis_I_Rao - University of Twente Research Information

Download PDF
2 downloads 0 Views 2MB Size Report
Comment
Oct 2, 1971 - v. 5.6 Conclusion and Implications for Future Research . ..... with organization of informal firms (Bruton et al, 2012). .... smaller firms were run from inside private homes. ... others in the Gujarat CPD industry, seemed to worD mainly on trust and ..... London and ..... rofile in a particular quadrant, the more is th.
-0%,'8',%2&#3, -0%,'8#"#4'"#,!# $0-+',"',"'+-,"',"31207

) 'G=N 0:H

,85C9C3?==9DD55=5=25BC .KH?=KBK(+HNMA::G KLBMRH?2P>GM>

.KH?=K)NE=>>I)NF:K IKHFHMHK

3GBO>KLBMRH?2P>GM> $EHKB=:'GM>KG:MBHG:E3GBO>KLBMR

.KH?=K(HLO:G&BEE>@>KL;>K@ IKHFHMHK

3GBO>KLBMRH?2P>GM>

.KH?=K *(+ ,B>NP>GANBL

3GBO>KLBMRH?2P>GM>

.KH?=K 2:GR: HG=:KHND

3GBO>KLBMRH?2P>GM>

.KH? =K &%O:G"BLL>E

3GBO>KLBMRH?FLM>K=:F

.KH? =K 1E:P>D+:@:E:

#K:LFNL3GBO>KLBMR

2A> PHKD =>L= BG MABL MA>LBL P:L I>K?HKF>= :M MA> '# '1 @KHNI  $:A:OBHK:E +:G:@>F>GM :G= 1HKLBMR H? 2P>GM>  .- HQ    # #GL=> MA> ,>MA>KE:G=L

.A"MA>LBL 3GBO>KLBMRH?2P>GM> #GL=> MA>,>MA>KE:G=L .KBGM>= :M 'ILD:FI"KNDD>KL 4#GL=> T) 'G=N 0:H #GL=>  EEKB@AMLK>L>KO>=,HI:KMH?MABLIN;EBK>IKH=N= LMHK>=BG:K>MKB>O:ELRLM>FHKMK:GLFBMM>= BG :GR ?HKF HK ;R :GR F>:GL  >E>GI>KFBLLBHGH?MA>:NMAHK

'1 ,      =HB  NKE AMMI=Q=HBHK@

-0%,'8',%2&#3, -0%,'8#"#4'"#,!# $0-+',"',"'+-,"',"31207

"'11#022'-,

MHH;M:BG MA>=>@K>>H?=H3GBO>KLBMRH?2P>GM> HGMA>:NMAHKBMR H?MA>K>IN;EB?>G=>= HG =:R MA> MA H? -K  :M AKL

;R

# !>4E*1? HKGHGMA> G= -K  :M 3=:BINK 'G=B:

2ABL=BLL>KM:MBHGA:L;>>G:IIKHO>=;R FRIKHFHMHK>L

.KH?=K)NE=>>I)NF:K

.KH?=K(HLO:G&BEE>@>KL;>K@

#&'/$%&,+

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

BG=NLMKR ' :ELH MA:GD MA> =BK> 1NK:M  +K ) ) 1A:KF: :G= MA> !A:BKF:G H? %>FL :G= (>P>E>KR #QIHKM .KHFHMBHG !HNGBKNL>?NEBGLB@AML .:KMB:E?BG=BG@LH?MABL K>L>:KK>IK>L>GM>=:ML>O>K:EBGM>KG:MBHG:EK>GL 'MA:GD>:O>KRK>OB>P>K:G=I:KMBMA>BK?>>=;:!KHFIMHG%K>:O>L:G=%# BG+NF;:B:G=BG%NC:K:M MA:MPHKD >QI>KB>G :ELH :==>=MHFRNG=>KLM:G=BG@H?MA>HK@:GBS>=:G=NG HK@:GBS>= ' :=@> LNIIHKM ?KHF MA> 'G=B:G 'GLMBMNM> H? +:G:@>F>GM  AF>=:;:= ''+ BG%NC:K:M  'G=B: ?HK :P:K=BG@F>: .HLM"HEEHPLABI?KHF  ' :ELH MA:GD FR @NB=> .KH?  .) (:BG  "BK>GM 1MN=B>L  +*13  'G=B:  ?HK @NB=:G MAKHN@A FR ?BKLM .A" BG +:G:@>F>GM M>= BG 'A:O>@KHPG=N>MHF>GMHKBG@H?FRM>:KL:G=IKH?>LLHKLBG LG@BG>>KBG@:G= F:G:@>F>GM @>L FRLBGK>@K:MBMN=>MH.KH? %0:@ANK:F .KH?"+.>LMHGC>>:G=.KH?):EI:G:+BLAK: ' :ELH :=@> ?NG=BG@ LNIIHKM ?KHF $EHKB=: 'GM>KG:MBHG:E 3GBO>KLBMR  31 ?KHF   :G=   :G= :EE ?:EIBG@ F> E>:KG MH :K= PHKD :G= I:LL>= MA> M>GQ:F ?HK : .A" ER : L>KB>L H? I>KLHG:E EHO>= ;KHMA>K 2:KNG PAH I:LL>=:P:R BGMA>EBG>H?=NMR =B=G]M:EEHPF>MH MH EBO>BGMA>31 :G='K>MNKG>=MH'G=B: .KH?)NE=>>I)NF:K AHE=BG@ IKH?>LLHKLABI :M$'3:G= :M 3GBO>KLBMR H? 2P>GM> DBG=ER LN@@>LM>= F> MH FHO> MH 2P>GM> .KH? (HL O:G &BEE>@>KL;>K@ ?KHF MA> 3GBO>KLBMR H? 2P>GM> @>G>KHNLER := F> :L :G >QM>KG:E .A":G=H??>K>=:EELNIIHKM 'MBL=N>MH KB@HKHNL@NB=:G:G= LNIIHKM ?KHF FR IKHFHMHK>L :M 2P>GM> MA:M ' A:O> ;>>G :;E> MH PHKD HG :G= M> MABLMA>LBL *:LMER 'MA:GD:EFB@AMR%H=?HKABL;E>LLBG@L LH:L MH ?BG:EER >G=MABLEHG@LMKN@@E> MHP:K=L:GBGM>KG:MBHG:E.A"=>@K>> '>QIK>LLFRA>:KM?>EM@K:MBMNM>MH:EE?KB>G=L :G=?:FBER PAH=?HK:G= BGLIBK>= F>=NKBG@MABLCHNKG>R +RFHMA>K"K1A:BE %NIM:A:L@BO>GLMK>G@MAMHF> +RANL;:G= "K):O>MB*:QFBG:K:R:G:0:H:G= FR LHGL =BMR:  KCNG :G= KR:G A:O> I:MB>GMER LMHH= ;R FR LB=> PBMA MA>BK NG?:BEBG@EHO> >GF>GM:G=LNIIHKM '=>=BMABLMA>LBLMHFRDB=L MH FR ANL;:G=:G= MH FRFHMA>K "K ) 'G=N0:H >F:BEB= B@DEG@F:BED5>DC ' .2$0 ,20-#3"2(-, 

 ,.62=:@9/:1?30'?@/D

 !:?4A,?4:91:=?30'?@/D 

 (30&0>0,=.3$=:-708  

 (30&0>0,=.3#-50.?4A0> 

&0>0,=.3;;=:,.3

 ,D:@? :1?30(30>4> 

' .2$0(2$0 230$$4($5    +3D>?@/D91:=8,7.:9:8D,9/?3091:=8,74=8     .=N9C:H?=,.?    9?=:/@.?4:9    4?0=,?@=0&0A40B 

 &0>0,=.30>429    /(304=8#A0=A40B     /?=,.?  

 (30&0.0>>4:9 

 7:-,7$:>4?4:9492:1?309/4,94,8:9/9/@>?=D  

 :B/:0>?309/4,94,8:9/9/@>?=D#;0=,?0  

 -:@??30:8;,9D 

(30*09@>)94?     A6=9B79    IG=B9GG+C@=7=9G     #9B9F5@!BJ=FCBA9BH 

(30:@9/0=  

!,5:=99:A,?4:9>!470>?:90>  

(3091:=8,7#=2,94E,?4:9'?=@.?@=0  

(30!,9@1,.?@=492$=:.0>>7:B3,=?  

 (30)94  

 (=4A09@>490>>!:/07  



$0:;70!,9,20809?$=,.?4.0>    /F5=B=B; -97FI=HA9BH .5@5FM.HFI7HIF9    #F=9J5B79$5B8@=B;     29@:5F9(95GIF9G    CAAIB=75H=CB492,:9.0;?@,7=,80B:=6     !JC@IH=CBC:*     MB5A=7GC:*  5 .CIF79GC:94:9  =J

:9.7@>4:9 ,9/ 8;74.,?4:9>1:= @?@=0 &0>0,=.3  

' .2$0 +.*(" 2(-,1-%*-! *0(1(1,2$&0 2$312 (, !(*(275(2' 0& ,(8 2(-, *3*230$   ->?=,.?    9?=:/@.?4:9     4?0=,?@=0&0A40B     *F;5B=N5H=CBG5GPI@HIF9GQ   '@>?,49,-474?D:1#=2,94E,?4:9 

 #=2,94E,?4:9,7@7?@=0,9/'@>?,49,-474?D 

 0,/0=>34;#=2,94E,?4:9,7@7?@=0,9/'@>?,49,-474?D 

(=@>?#=2,94E,?4:9,7@7?@=0'@>?,49,-474?D 

 0,/0=>34;,9/(=@>?,>!:/0=,?:=> 

 :9.7@>4:9

 8;74.,?4:9>1:=@?@=0&0>0,=.3,9/$=,.?4.0



' .2$0 $13*21-%0& ,(8 2(-, *3*230 *11$11+$,2 31(,&  ->?=,.? 

  9?=:/@.?4:9    4?0=,?@=0 &0A40B 

 &0>0,=.3!0?3:/    .9@97H=CBC:H423?> 1=:8?30'?@/D:1'>499/4,94,8:9/9/@>?=D#-50.?4A0     (:B,=/>,994?4,7(30:=D:1?3091:=8,74=8#-50.?4A0  

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



2AK>>ANG=K>=R>:KL PABE>L>>FBG@:E:K@>MBF>?K:F> BLGHM:E:K@>=NK:MBHGPA>GK>=BGK>E:MBHG MH:GGM ?BKLM  PHKE= MH ;> ?BG:G= ;R ?K>>ER G>@HMB:;E> LA:K>L 2ABL MRI> H? MK:=> ?HKF>= MA> ;>@BGGBG@L H? MA> FLM>K=:F 1MH HE=>LM LMHQ BG MA> PHKE= 2ABL BG?HKF:MBHG BL >OB=>G= ;R : LA:K> KMB?B PABL ;:IM>F;>K:G=HKB@BG:M>L?KHFMA>FLM>K=:F!BMRKL^5A:MF:D>LMABLG>PER?HNG==HGM LH LI>= =>L =BOB=>G= =BLMKB;NMBHGL NI MH _ AMMIPPPPHKE=LHE=>LMLA:K> ?HKF:EBS>= MH LHF> >QM>GM ;R K>IHKMBG@ K>JNBK>F>GML



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

LI>R MHLNLM:BG :G=IKHOB=>=BK>HK@:GBS:MBHG:E >OHENMBHG=NKBG@BMLEB?> LI:G 1MBGL>:KLMBHG                   'GMA>=B:FHG= 2A> 'G=B:G !." ?BKFL :GGN:EER IKHLL ;BEEBHGL H? =HEE:KL H? NGIHEBLA>= LMHG>L BGMH ;KBEEB:GM = =B:FHG=L 2A>L> =B:FHG=L :K> MK:=>= :LM>KG LM:M> H? 'G=B:  MA> PHKE=]LE:K@>LM=B:FHG=K 2A>=B:FHG==MH;>GM>K>=BGGMP>KI:G= FLM>K=:F ?HK :;HNM ?BO> GMNKB>L  A:L HO>K E:LM MAK>> =>L  LAB?M>= MH %NC:K:M2H=:R >E>O>GHNMH?>O>KRMP>EO>=B:FHG=LL>MBGC>P>EKRPHKE=PB=>:K> =;RMA>L>'1$LBG%NC:K:M%NC:K:M ?BKFL>G@:@>=BGL> NGBML :K> NGK>@BLM>K>= !HEE>ER MA>R >FIEHR FHK> MA:G : FBEEBHG I>HIE> 2H@>MA>K  MA>L> !." NGBML F:D> NI : DGBM G>MPHKD H? =B:FHG= HO>K F:GR H? MA>L> HG> FBEEBHG I>HIE> A:O> FBGBF:E ?HKF:E >=NBMA>K MA>BK HPG>KL GHK F:G:@>KL E>:KG>= ;NLBG>LL F:G:@>F>GM :M ;NLBG>LL L BGM>K>LMBG@I:KMBL :LFRI>KLHG:EBGM>K:O>:E>= MA:M MA>R=H GHML>>FMH ;> BGM>K>LM>= BG LLLHGL -G MA> HMA>K A:G=  :L : K>L>:KK ' P:L BGM>K>LM>=BGDGHPBG@PA:MMA>RDG>P :;HNMLNFIML MH :==K>LL MABL @:I BG DGHPE>=@> ;R NLBG@ MA> MBG@ O:EN>L?K:F>PHKD !4$=>O>EHI>=;R!:F>KHG/NBGG :G=MA>:LLH=  :LL>LLF>GM BGLMKNF>GM = -!' -K@:GBS:MBHG:E !NEMNK> LL>LLF>GM 

'GLMKNF>GM MHNG=>KLM:G=:G=F:IMA>BK5>=BLH? !4$:G=-!'BG !A:IM>K 5>:MM>FIMMH>Q:FBG> MA>H?MA>L>?BKFL :G= :==K>LLMABLBFIHKM:GM@:IBG DGHPE>=@> :;HNM '$L 5> PBEE >QIEHK> MABL ABMA>KMH NG>Q:FBG>= ?HKF H? HK@:GBSBG@ ;RF:IIBG@MA>BGM:G@B;E>:LI>HK@:GBS:MBHG:E H?MA>'$L                 

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

> 1:FIEBG@ ? =FBGBLMK:MBHGH?MA>'GLMKNF>GM @ 0>LNEMLH?MA>LNKO>R +D5@ >171D1 : ":M:G:ERLBL ;">O>EHIBG@:G= .KHIHLBG@:G'GBMB:E2A>HKRH?:G'1$ +D5@ 5F53C1>4!=@C?6D85+DE4I 2ABLBG= LRGMA>LBSBG@K>LNEMLH?MA>:;HO>LM>IL : !HGMKB;NMBHGLH?MA>1MN=RMH 

B 1QM H?!."NGBML '1$L>G@:@>=BG'G=B:G =B:FHG=BG=NLMKR :G=MA:M: ?BKF]L BLBG?EN>G=;RBMLBG=NLMKR 0>RGHE=L   'G K   ' IK>L>GM :G BGBMB:E EBM>K:MNK> K>OB>P ,>QM ' K>IHKM MA> ?BG=BG@LH?>QIEHK:MHKRLMN=RH?MA> 'G=B:G=B:FHG= BG=NLMKR K ?HEEHP>= ;R :  LMN=R H? : LI>L PBMA :G >QM>GLBO> EBM>K:MNK> K>OB>P H? HK@:GBS:MBHG:E PAR NG=>KLM:G=BG@ MA> HK@:GBS:MBHG:E EINL @:BGBGLB@AMLBGMH HK@:GBS:MBHG:E;>A:OBHK:G= MANLBGMA> P:RLH?HK@:GBSBG@H?MA>'1$L 2A>?BKFNG=>KLMN=RBGK P:L ?HNG=>= :MMA>L:F>MBF>:L =B= MA>'G=B:G=B:FHG=BG=NLMKR:G=A:LLNKOBO>= ?HK FHK> MA:G ?HKMR R>:KL  BG  @EH;:E K>LLBHG 2A> >LLBHG H?  BL P>EE DGHPG ?HK A:OBG@ BFI:= LF:EE :G= E:K@> ?BKFL  :EE HO>K MA> PHKE=  BM A:L :ELH L>O>K>ER BFI:= MA> ?BKFL H? MA> 'G=B:G =B:FHG= BG=NLMKR 2A>K>?HK>  BG K   ' IK>L>GM :  HG AHP HK@:GBS:MBHG:E   NL>?NE ?HK LNLM:BG:;BEBMR H? HK@:GBS:MBHGL G >FIBKBLMB@:MBHGH? HK@:GBS:MBHG:EBL=HG>BGK NLBG@-!' -K@:GBS:MBHG:E !NEMNK> :LL>LLF>GM BGLMKNF>GM  PAB=L NL>?NE BGLB@AML HG '1$L !A:IM>KBL: HK@:GBS>= :L ?HEEHPL 81@D5B BL :;HNM MA> BFIHKM:G H? LMN=RBG@ BG?HKF:E ?BKFL '$L  :G= H? MA> 'G=B:G=B:FHG=BG=NLMKR:G=B=>GMB?RBG@K>L>:KL 81@D5B BL:EBM>K:MNK>K>OB>P:;HNM>QBLMBG@EBM>K:MNK>HGMA>BG?HKF:E >L>?BKFL 81@D5B  BL :G HO>KOB>P H? MA> 'G=B:G =B:FHG= BG=NLMKR :G= LI>OHENMBHG  =B??>K>GM LM:D>AHE=>KL  G>MPHKDBG@ :G= MK:GL:IMALMN=RH?:R>:KHE=?BKF >G@:@>=BGQIE:BG AHP HK@:GBS:MBHG:E  MK:GLE:M>L MH HK@:GBS:MBHG:E;>A:OBHK:G=MANL:LL>KML:LMHPARNG=>KLM:G=BG@H?HK@:GBS:MBHG:E H?MA>'1$LA>EILNLBGNG=>KLM:G=BG@'1$L 81@D5B  BL :G :KMB HG LNLM:BG:;BEBMR H? HK@:GBS:MBHGL :G= BL : K2A>B=>:LP>K>:K>LNEMH?A:OBG@H;L>KO>=MA>NGBMNG=>KLMN=RBGK   :G= :G :MM>FIM MH F:D> : MA>HK>MB:=>KLABI:G=MKNLM:LFH=>K:MHKL 81@D5B  BL :G >FIBKBLMB@:MBHG H? HK@:GBS:MBHG:E  H? MA> !." H? MA>  LMN=R BG !A:IM>K  5> NL> MA> -!' -K@:GBS:MBHG:E !NEMNK> LL>LLF>GM 'GLMKNF>GM  MHF>:LNK>MA>L:EB>G H??HNKL B> !E:G  &B>K:KM :G= =AHL> :K MRI>L PBMA K>@:K=L LBQ =BF>GLBHGL H? HK@:GBS:MBHG:E E>:=>KLABI  F:G:@>F>GM H? >FIEHR>>L LMK:M>@BFIA:LBL KB:H?LN 81@D5B BL:LNFF:KRH?AHPP>A:O>F>MMA>H;C>LH?MA>LMN=RPBMAA>EI ?KHF MA> ?BG=BG@L H? MA> :;HO> KL  5> IKHIHL> HNK OB>P H? MA> BG?HKF:E ?BKF?KHFMA> BGLB@AML@:BG>= ?KHFHNKLMN=R'GMA>>G= P> HNMEBG>EBFBM:MBHGLH? MA> LMN=R K:MNK> :G= IK: K>L>:K  BGLMKNF>GML ?HK F>:LNKBG@ HK@:GBS:MBHG:E :G= %KHNG=>= 2A>HKR F>MAH=L L F>GMBHG>= BG !A:IM>K   :MM>GMBHG MHP:K=L K>L>:KKR K>GM !NKK>GMER  L IKHIHL>= : O:KB>MR H? =>?BGBMBHGL MH >QIE:BG MA> BG?HKF:E >K> BL EBMME> K>G :G= GL> =>?BGBMBHGL &HP>O>K  >:L> =>?BGBMBHGL @BO>L NL NL>?NE I>KLI>L HG ;HMA NG=>KLM:G=BG@MA>IA>GHF>GHGH?MA>BG?HKF:E?BKFL :G= MA>@KHPBG@BG?EN>G H?MA>BG?HKF:E>LL 1>:ELPBMAMA>>QBLMBG@EBM>K:MNK>HGBG?HKF:E>LLMA>LBS>H?MA>BG?HKF:E>F>:GBG@ H? BG?HKF:E L>K MBF> 1> F:G:@>F>GM  >LL O:KBHNL I>KLI>LHGMA>F>:GBG@H?MA>BG?HKF:E>K:MNK> HG >= :K>:L MH =BLQBLMBG@ MA>HKB>LH?MA>BG?HKF:EL>LL MA> E>O:G :G= BML LB@GB?BKLM:G=BG@HK@:GBS:MBHGL'MLI>E>O:G H? LMN=RBG@ MA>  H? MA> '$L H? 'G=B:G =B:FHG= BG=NLMKR 1>OB>P H? =B??>K>GM P:RL H? F>:LNKBG@ HK@:GBS:MBHG:E  'G MABL L> :ELH BG =>M:BEL H? LBL P>PBEENL>MA>M>KFL'$L BG?HKF:E?BKFL :G='1$L BG?HKF:EL>K:;ER :L P> LMN=R MA>F BG MA> QM H? MA> BG?HKF:E 'G=B:G =B:FHG= BG=NLMKR '1$L HK '$L K>?>K MH L MA:M :K> >G@:@>= BG E>@BMBF:M> ;NLBG>LL:L;NMF:RGHM?NEER@NE:MHKRH;EB@:MBHGL 

+9J5?6D85!>6?B=1BG?HKF:E>QIHKML '*-  :  2A>   ,11- LNKO>R K>IHKM>= MA:M :IIKHQBF:M>ERH?MA>'G=B:GPHKD?HK FBEEBHGPHKD>KL P:L>FIEHR>= BGMA>NGHK@:GBS>=L>L> GNF;>KL 2A> F>:GBG@ H? MA> BG?HKF:E L>OHEO>= HO>KMBF> 2:;E>:G=2:;E> 

%51>9>7?6D85!>6?B=1?=I 2A>:KMB;R%H=?K>R  HG:@:BG =K:PLMA>:MM>GMBHGH?L LB@GB?B BG?HKF:E >K PHKDL H? :KG:K=   A:O> EHHD>= :M ;HMA MA> =N:EBLMB H? BG?HKF:E >GM:E BGM>K=G>LL :KG>R :G= &:GL>G   :G= &HLF>K 

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

>A=@J>6?E2?56?56C:?(@G6CEJ*65F4E:@? 2?53@@2KGF>GML :G= K>L>:KKL A:O>?BG:EER;>@NGMH:F :LF:GR:FBL>:KKLA:O>=HG>BGMA>I:LM PHNE=;>MHB@GHK>D>R BL:EBLMH?O:KBHNL=>?BGBMBHGLBG=B??>K>GM=BLL:L:MMKB;NM>=MH MA>BG?HKF:E>6?B=1< +53D?B 1EHG@MKB>=MH>QIE:BGMA>>QBLM>G:G=G:MNK>H?MA>BG?HKF:EL> "N:EBLM IIKH: 1MKN@:EBLM 1 ,>H !E:LLBP 

2A> 4E1KGF>GM IKH=NK>L :K> KLHF> :G= >QI>GLBO> 2A> =B??BL BG :MBG@ E>@:E ;NLBG>LL>L E MA>L> K>E:MBO>ER K>LHNK IHHK ?BKFL MH LDBI MA> ?HKF:E E>@:E :LI> IKHLL +:EHG>R    : G>H EB;>K:E >LML MA:M BG?HKF:E >GMK>IK>G>NKL 56=:36C2E6=J :OHB= K>@NE:MBHGL:G=M:Q:MBHG:G=F:R=>:EBG@K>R F:KD>M@HH=LHK>O>GBEE>@:E @HH=L :G= L>KOBL 'G?HKF:E >GMK>IK>G>NKL  MH HI>K:M> BG MA> NG=>K@KHNG=HK;E:@:EER HK>O>GE>>L  :G= HMA>K K:MBG@?HKF:EER



5?3 BG?HKF:E >LIHG=L MH MA> >GM]L =>F:G= ?HK NK;:G L>KOBL :G= LF:EE L F:GN?:L>GM>=BGKLMH :G=LNFF:KBS>=BG!A:IM>K BLMA:MMA>L> ?HNKOB>PL:K> F>GM:KR Z MA>R :K>GHMLN;LMBMNM>L?HK>:K #:L>I>KLI>L =>LL =B??>K>GM:LI>L:F>IA>GHF>GHG '1$L 

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

MK:GLE:M>=-!'BGLMKNF>GM ?HKMA> :LL>LLF>GMH?MA>JN:GMBM:MBO>-K@:GBS:MBHGG:E !NEMNK>IKH?BE>L?HKHNKLMN=R A:O>>LM:;EBLA>=MA>LB@GGB?BBG?HKF:EL>G>>>= MHNG=>KLM:G=AHPMA>R:K>HK@:GBS>>= :G=H?MA>KLM:G=MA>HK@:GBSBG@:LI>FIBKB= F>MAH=L HKR F>MAH=HEH@R 5> = ;HMA JN:EBM:MBO> :G= JN:GMBM:MBO> =:M: ?HK MA> INKIHL> 'G MABL L> ?BKLM CNLMB?R MA> :IIKHIKB:M>G>LL H? JN:EBM:MBO> :G= FBQ>= F>MAH=L K>L>:KQM  P> EH MA> HKB@BGL H? HKR:G=MK:BML=>O>EHIF>GM

 /8IB?E>454,85?BI1C1=5D8?4?