Towards a distributed framework for transportation planning: A food supply chain case study Muhammad Ali Memon, Bernard Archim`ede
To cite this version: Muhammad Ali Memon, Bernard Archim`ede. Towards a distributed framework for transportation planning: A food supply chain case study. IEEE International Conference on Networking, Sensing and Control, Apr 2013, Paris-Evry, France. pp. 603-608.
HAL Id: hal-00932429 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00932429 Submitted on 17 Jan 2014
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ee au d´epˆot et `a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´es ou non, ´emanant des ´etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´es.
Open Archive Toulouse Archive Ouverte (OATAO) OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.
This is an author-deposited version published in: http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/ Eprints ID: 10584
To cite this version:
Memon, Muhammad Ali and Archimede, Bernard Towards a distributed framework for transportation planning: A food supply chain case study. (2013) In: IEEE International Conference on Networking, Sensing and Control , 10 April 2013 - 12 April 2013 (Paris-Evry, France).
Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the repository administrator:
[email protected]
$ !) ) !" #") $ ) ) ! "" ) ) ) ) # %) ) !) "#%) (:/*66*,> 40> (-687> -KEV:QSETZ] N;] ,NUHNUS:] !&( &!,] ] V:KU:]9][:Q:EX] ( ] ],6Q7:S] :9:X] Q6K8:] J6EH] %UD6JJ69HE%:JNK:KET;Q]
"$ $!# %# , , #!!, , %# , !#!, , # !, #' !, #!!, , %# #), , !# %# , # !, #, ( ! , , , !, , # , , !, , #, % , , %!#!, , # ! # # , %, #, ' ,
!, !, , #, & %, , # ! #, , !, , , , # , #, ', % , , !! , # !, !, , # , , !, , # ! # # , ! !, !, #!, #, '#, , ! %#, !, , #, #), , % # , !, ', , ! #% # , ' )!, !, ! , !, , ( ! , , !# , !, #!, #!, ' %!!, #, , , !, , %# , #, #, & #, !%!# #), , #!, #(#, * # , #, , # ! # # , , , % , & , #, , , ), ! + *, !,
)'>
, , , , # ! #, ,
# *, #, , #&, , #!, , !, # , !#, , !# %#, ##% , , , # ! # # , #&#!, , #, ## , %#*, # ! #, ! % !, ), % , !& , !, , # ! #, , , #&, ! #,
$# & ! & !& ! & $ & % "& & & & & &
!]
&*1.+ 31$+*j
,D:] CHN76HE[6TENK] N;] J6QG:TS] 6K9] TD:] S:6Q8D] N;] OQN>T] NO\ ONQTUKETE:S] D6V:] H:9] TN] TD:] Q:HN86TENK] N;] J6KU;68TUQEKC] >QJS] EK] :J:QCEKC] 8NUKTQE:S] ;NQ] >K9EKC] HNW8NST] H67NQ] ;NQ] WNQG] (QN9U8TENK]ES]KNW696YS]9ESTQE7UT:9]NV:Q]S:V:Q6H]J6KU;68TUQEKC] SET:S] TD6T] 6Q:] NA:K] 6T] V:QZ] 9EST6KT] 9ESTQE7UTENK] 8:KT:QS] ,D:] 7USEK:SS] ES] CQNWEKC] 8NKST6KTHY] 6K9] ES] KNT] 6KY] HNKC:Q] HEJET:9] TN] C:NCQ6ODE86H] 7NUK96QE:S] HH] TDES] H:69S] TN] 6K] EK8Q:6S:] EK] TD:] KUJ7:Q] 6K9] ;Q:PU:K8Y] N;] TQ6KSONQT] EK] TD:] WNQH9] 6K9] EK] TD:] 6V:Q6C:] H:KCTD] N;] TQ6V:HEKC] TQEOS] ,Q6KSONQT6TENK] 8NSTS] 6Q:] EK8Q:6SEKC]9U:]TN]TD:]ST:69Y]EK8Q:6S:]EK]NEH]OQE8:S] ,D:S:]8NSTS] D6V:] 7:8NJ:] 6] J6FNQ] 8NK8:R] ;NQ] TD:] EK9USTQE:S] 7:86US:] ET] EK8Q:6S:S] TD:] 8NST] N;] TD:] Q6W] J6T:QE6HS] TD6T] TD:Y] OQN8UQ:] 6S] W:HH] 6S] TD:] 9ESTQE7UTENK]N;] OQN9U8TS]TN] 8NKSUJ:QS] ,D:]EJO68T] N;] TQ6KSONQT6TENK]8NSTS] NK] OQN9U8TS]9NKT]O:QJET]USU6HHY] TDNS:] 8NJO6KE:S] WDE8D] W6KT] TN] Q:68D] ;6Q6W6Y] 8HE:KTS] 6K9] J6K6C:] TD:EQ]NWK]Q:SNUQ8:S]V:DE8H:S] SDEOS] 6EQ8Q6;T] :T8]]]TN]TQ6KSONQT] TD:EQ] CNN9S] ,D:] : 9+/06-,-> -KEV:QSETZ] N;] ,NUHNUS:] !&( &!,] ] V:KU:] 9[:Q:EX] ( ] ],6Q7:S] :9:X] Q6K8:] J6EH] :R6Q9Q8DEJ:9::KET;Q]
ONQT6TENK] ;QNJ] HN69EKC] OQN9U8TS] SEK8:] SUOOHE:QS] W6Q:DNUS:S] TN] TD:] 9ESTQE7UTENK] N;] CNN9S] TN] 8USTNJ:QS] ,D:] EK8Q:6S:] EK] KUJ7:Q] N;] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] NQ9:QS] 9EV:QSETZ] N;] 8HE:KTS] 9U:] TN] 9E;;:Q:KT]GEK9] N;] 7USEK:SS] 68TEVETE:S] 9EST6K8:] ;QNJ] OQN9U8TENK] 8NJO6KE:S] 6K9] 9ESTQE7UTENK] SET:S] TD:] SE[:] N;] TD:] TQ6KSONQT] K:TWNQG] J6G:] ET] :V:K] V:QZ] 8NJOHE86T:9] ;NQ] (# ] TN] J6K6C:] TQ6KSONQT6TENK]OH6KKEKC] ,N] ;UH>HH] 8USTNJ:QS] 9:J6K9S] 6K9] EJOQNV:] TD:] O:Q;NQJ6K8:] N;] SUOOHY] 8D6EKS] ET] JUST] J6K6C:] ETS] NWK] Q:SNUQ8:S] 6K9] N;T:K] 8NHH67NQ6T:] WETD] NTD:Q] 8NJO6KE:S] (# ] 86QQE:QS] 6K9] (# ] ,D:] WNQG] OQ:S:KT:9] EK] TDES] O6O:Q] ;N8US:S] NK] OH6KKEKC] TQ6KSONQT] 68TEVETE:S] 7Y] 6] (#] :KT:QOQES:] EK] 9ESTQE7UT:9] J6KK:Q] Q:SUHTEKC];QNJ]TQ6KSONQT]Q:PU:STS];QNJ]S:V:Q6H] 8USTNJ:QS] ,D:] N7F:8TEV:] ES] TN] :V6HU6T:] TD:] 67EHETZ] N;] TD:] C:K:QE8] JN9:H] N;] OH6KKEKC] + (] +UO:QVESNQ] USTNJ:Q] KVEQNKJ:KT] 6K9] (QN9U8:Q] ;NQ] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OH6KKEKC] OQN8:SS] A:Q] 6] ST6T:] N;] TD:] 6QT] NK] TD:] H6T:ST] Q:S:6Q8D] NK] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OH6KKEKC] W:] 9:S8QE7:] TD:] C:K:QE8] + (] 6K9] ETS] HEJETS] ;NQ] TD:] OH6KKEKC] N;] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] 68TEVETE:S] 0:] OQ:S:KT] D:Q:] TD:] K:W] ,+ (] JN9:H]6K9] EHHUSTQ6T:] ETS] 6OOHE86TENK] WETD] 6] 86S:] STU9Y] EK6HHY] W:] 8NK8HU9:] WETD] TD:] ;UTUQ:] O:QSO:8TEV:S] !!]
/ ( 1 j5+.'0j
+:V:Q6H] 6OOQN68D:S] D6V:] 7::K] OQNONS:9] TN] SNHV:] TQ6KS\ ONQT6TENK] OH6KKEKC] OQN7H:J] IÈ +6U:Q] :T] 6H45] OQNONS:9] 6] 8:KTQ6HE[:9]6OOQN68D]WETD]6]CHN76H]S8D:9UH:Q] WDE8D]S8D:9UH:S] TQ6KSONQT6TENK]OH6KKEKC]68TEVETE:S] ,D:Y]JN9:H]TD:]OQN7H:J]7Y] 6]TUOH:*](] ] ] +]WD:Q:]*]9:KNT:S]TD:]S:T]N;]Q:PUEQ:9] Q:SNUQ8:S] (]TD:]S:T]N;]OQN9U8TS] ¿È TD:]S:T]N;]68TU6H]NQ9:QS]6K9] ] 6K9] +] TD:] S:TS] N;]D6Q9]6K9] SNA] 8NKSTQ6EKTS] Q:SO:8TEV:HY] ,D:Y] US:] 6] QUH:76S:9] 6OOQN68D] 6K9] D:UQESTE8S] TN] OQN9U8:] S:V:Q6H]S8D:9UHEKC]STQ6T:CE:S] ,DES]6OOQN68D]ES]8:KTQ6HE[:9]6K9] ES] HEJET:9] TN] TD:] OH6KKEKC] N;] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] 68TEVETE:S] N;] 6] SEKCH:] :KT:QOQES:] ,N96Y] TD:] :KNQJNUS] SE[:] N;] TD:] TQ6KSONQT] K:TWNQGS] Q:PUEQ:S] TN] Q:6HE[:] TD:] OH6K] WETD] 8NHH67NQ6TENK] N;] J6KY]TQ6KSONQT6TENK]:KT:QOQES:S] ,D:S:]:KT:QOQES:S]JNST]NA:K] WESD] TN] G::O] 8:QT6EK] 8NK>9:KTE6HETZ] N;] TD:EQ] NQC6KE[6TENK] TD:EQ] JN9:HS] TD:EQ] J:TDN9S] 6K9] TD:EQ] 96T6] ,D:] K::9] ;NQ] 8NK>9:KTE6HETZ] HEJETS] TD:] S8NO:] N;] 8:KTQ6HE[:9] 6OOQN68D:S] 6YG6SNCHU] :T] 6H] 4 5] OQNONS:9] 6] JUHTE6C:KT] 6OOQN68D] TN] 699Q:SS] 8NHH67NQ6TEV:] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OQN7H:J] ,DES] 6OOQN68D] ES] 76S:9] NK] 8NNO:Q6TENK] 7:TW::K] TQ6KSONQTNQ9:Q] 6C:KTS] 6K9]
TQU8G]6C:KTS] WDE8D]OQNONS:]CQNUOEKC]JUHTEOH:]NQ9:QS]TNC:TD:Q] EK] 6] V:DE8H:] C:KTS] 8NJJUKE86T:] WETD] :68D] NTD:Q] EK] NQ9:Q] TN] 8DNNS:] TD:] 7:ST] :8NKNJE86H] W6Y] TN] TQ6KSONQT] TD:] NQ9:Q] !K] TDES] 6OOQN68D] TQ6KSONQT] NQ9:Q] 6C:KT] ES] 7NUK9] TN] 688:OT] TD:] OQNONSETENK] ;QNJ] NK:] TQU8G] 6C:KT] WDE8D] OQNVE9:] 6] KNKSTNO] 9:HEV:QZ] ;QNJ] NQECEK] TN] 9:STEK6TENK] NW:V:Q] EK] Q:6HETZ] 8NK\ SE9:QEKC]:KNQJNUS]SE[:]N;]TD:]TQ6KSONQT]K:TWNQG] 6]TQU8G]Q6Q:HY] 6HNK:] TQ6KSONQTS] 6] TQ6KSONQT]NQ9:Q] ] TQ6KSONQT] NQ9:Q] Q:PUEQ:S] JNST] NA:K] S:V:Q6H] TQU8GS] * +OQ:KC:Q] :T] 6H45] OQNONS:9] 6] JUHTE6C:KT] SYST:J] ;NQ] 8NNO\ :Q6TEV:] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OH6KKEKC] ,D:] SYST:J] 9:8NJONS:S] TD:] NV:Q6HH] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OQN7H:J] EKTN] SU7] OQN7H:JS] 6K9] SNHV:] TDNS:] SU7] OQN7H:JS] NK] 6UTNKNJNUS] 76SES] WETD] KT] 8NHNKY] 'OTEJE[6TENK] 6OOQN68D] ,DES] WNQG] K:ETD:Q] :XOH6EKS] SUET67HY] 9:8NJONSETENK]J:TDN9NHNCY]6K9]KNQ]9:8NJONSETENKS]:;;:8T]NK] NV:Q6HH] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OQN7H:J] 99ETENK6HHY] ET] 9N:S] KNT] 8NK\ SE9:Q]OQEV68Y]ESSU:S]7:TW::K]J6KU;68TUQ:QS]6K9]TD:Y]9NKT]T6G:] EKTN] 688NUKT] JUHTEOH:] NQ9:QS] TNC:TD:Q] WDEH:] SD6QEKC] V:DE8H:S] +]3:CNQ9E]6K9]6H]4 5]STU9Y]EKT:CQ6TEKC]TQ6KSONQT6TENK]6K9]OQN\ 9U8TENK]S8D:9UHEKC]7Y]8NKSE9:QEKC]JUHTEOH:]SNUQ8EKC]EK]6]TWN\ ST6C:]SUOOHY]8D6EK]S8D:9UHEKC]OQN7H:J]!K]WDE8D]TD:]>QST]ST6C:] ES] 8NJONS:9] N;] JUHTEOH:] SUOOHE:QS] 9ESTQE7UT:9] NV:Q] V6QENUS] C:NCQ6ODE8][NK:S] !K] TD:] S:8NK9]ST6C:] V:DE8H:S]TQ6KSONQT]FN7S] ;QNJ] SUOOHE:QS] TN] 6] J6KU;68TUQEKC]8NJO6KY] ,DES] TQ6KSONQT6\ TENK] S8D:9UHEKC]ES] 76S:9] NK] C:K:TE8] 6HCNQETDJ] %6KU;68TUQEKC] 8NJO6KY]SOHETS]TD:]NQ9:Q]7:TW::K]JUHTEOH:]SUOOHE:QS]688NQ9EKC] TN] PUNT6] ,D:K] :68D] SUOOHE:Q] TQ6KSONQTS] ETS] PUNT6] N;] Q6W] J6T:QE6H]TN]TD:]SEKCH:]J6KU;68TUQEKC]8NJO6KY] WDE8D]68DE:V:S] 6K] 6SS:J7HEKC] N;] 6HH] TD:] Q:8:EV:9] Q6W] J6T:QE6HS] +UOOHE:QS] HN86T:9]EK]TD:]S6J:]C:NCQ6ODE86H][NK:]8NUH9]TQ6KSONQT]TD:EQ]Q6W] J6T:QE6H] TN] TD:] J6KU;68TUQEKC] 8NJO6KY] 7Y] SD6QEKC] V:DE8H:S] ,DES] 6OOQN68D] ES] 6] 8:KTQ6HE[:9] 6OOQN68D] WDE8D] WEHH] ;68:] TD:] 8NK>9:KTE6HETZ] ESSU:] 99ETENK6HHY] 9U:] TN] 8QETE86H] :8NKNJE8] 8NK9ETENKS] TDES] ES] KNT] 688:OT67H:] TD6T] V:DE8H:S] Q:TUR] :JOTZ] TN] SUOOHE:QS] TD6T] ES] Q:SUHT:9] ;QNJ] TDES] J:TDN9] !K] ;UQTD:Q] STU9E:S] 6] SEJUH6TENK] ;Q6J:WNQG] ES] OQ:S:KT:9] EK45] ;NQ]6SS:SSEKC] TD:] O:Q;NQJ6K8:]N;]8NNO:Q6TEV:]TQ6KSONQT6\ TENK] OH6KKEKC] 6K9] ESNH6T:9] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OH6KKEKC] QNUO6C:] SYST:JS45]6Q:]EKTQN9U8:9]WDE8D]6Q:]9:>K:9]6S]HNCESTE8S]EKT:Q\ NQC6KE[6TENK] SYST:JS] TD6T] EKT:Q8D6KC:] Q:PUEQ:9] EK;NQJ6TENK] 6K9]J6K6C:S]86O68ETZ] 76H6K8:S]7:TW::K]9E;;:Q:KT]EK9:O:K9:KT] TQ6KSONQT:QS] %%:S] :T]6H]45]STU9Y]TD:]EKT:Q68TENK]7:TW::K]EK\ T:HHEC:KT]6C:KT]STQ6T:CE:S];NQ]Q:6HTEJ:]TQ6KSONQT6TENK]OH6KKEKC] ] JUHTE6C:KT]TD:NQ:TE86H]6OOQN68D]NK] 9YK6JE8]TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OH6KKEKC] ES] CEV:K] EK] 45] 26[6K] :T] 6H] 4""5] :X6JEK:S] TD:] :KVEQNKJ:KT6H] EJO68T] N;] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] 6K9] DNW] ET] 86K] 7:] 6HT:Q:9] 7Y] SDNWEKC] 8UQQ:KT] 6K9] Q::KCEK::Q:9] SUOOHY] 8D6EK] TDQNUCD]6] 86S:] STU9Y] !!!] + (]%-#,! &,]%' #] (È
!ESCRHQTHPO^PG^NPDEL^
,D:] + (] JUHTE6C:KT]JN9:H] ECUQ:] ]ES] 7QE:?Y] 6] JN9:H] 9:V:HNO:9] ;NQ] 6HH] TZO:S] N;] OH6KKEKC] 68TEVETE:S4"5] 4 5] WDE8D] EKTQN9U8:S] 6K] EK9EQ:8T] 8NNO:Q6TENK] 7:TW::K] TWN] 8NJJUKETE:S] N;]6C:KTS]8USTNJ:Q]6C:KTS]86HH:9]]6K9]OQN9U8:Q]6C:KTS]86HH:9] (] H:69EKC] TN] 6] DECD] H:V:H] N;] 8NNO:Q6TENK] 68D] 8USTNJ:Q]
)°È
) &; .;
)
) KETENK] :68D] NO:Q6TENK] NKHY] 8NK8:RS] NK:] 8USTNJ:Q] 6C:KT] UT] SNJ:] N7F:8TS] 86K] 7:HNKC] TN] TD:] EKT:QV:KTENK] 9NJ6EKS] N;] S:V:Q6H]OQN9U8:Q]6C:KTS] 7:86US:]JUHTE] J68DEK:S]J6Y] 68DE:V:] TD:] S6J:] 68TEVETZ] ,D:] ONSETENK] ;NQJ6T] N;] N7F:8T] ] ES] 4+] ] &5] WD:Q:] +] ] Q:OQ:S:KTS] 6] 8NKTEKUNUS] T:JONQ6H] EKT:QV6H] 7:TW::K]6] ST6QTEKC]96T:] +] 6K9]6] >K6H]96T:] ] 6K9] &] Q:OQ:S:KTS] TD:] K6J:] N;] Q:SNUQ8:] :X:8UTEKC] N7F:8T] '] 68D] N7F:8T] D6S] ;NUQ] ONSETENKS] WESD:9] ONSETENK] @^ :;;:8TEV:] ONSETENK] (] ONT:KTE6H]ONSETENK]((] 6K9]8NK>QJ:9]ONSETENK](] ,D:] @^ ES]TD:]ONSETENK]Q:PU:ST:9]7Y]TD:]8USTNJ:Q] ,D:] (]Q:SUHTS];QNJ] TD:]S8D:9UHEKC]N;]6HH]TD:]T6SGS]6SSN8E6T:9]WETD]TD:]OQNONSETENKS] 8NHH:8T:9] @NJ] TD:] :KVEQNKJ:KT] ,D:] ((] Q:SUHTS] ;QNJ] TD:] S8D:9UHEKC]N;]NK:]T6SG]6SSN8E6T:9]WETD]6]OQNONSETENK]8NHH:8T:9] ;QNJ] TD:] :KVEQNKJ:KT] ,D:] (] ES] TD:] >K6H] ONSETENK] 6A:Q] 6HH] TD:] S8D:9UHEKC] OQN8:SS] ,D:] SUO:QVESNQ] 6C:KT] OQNVE9:S] BK8TENKS] N;] 8Q:6TEKC] TD:] 6C:KT] SN8E:TZ] C:K:Q6TEKC] TD:] EKSE9:] N7F:8TS] 6K9] EKETE6HE[EKC] TD:]:KVEQNKJ:KT] ,D:K] TD:]SUO:QVESNQ]6C:KT]TQECC:QS]TD:]8Y8H:] N;] 8NNO:Q6TENK]OQN8:SS] 7Y] 68TEV6TEKC] TD:] 8USTNJ:Q] 6C:KTS] 6K9] T:HHEKC]TD:]OQN9U8:Q]6C:KTS]TN]W6ET] ,D:]8USTNJ:Q]6C:KTS]>QSTHY] 6SG] ;NQ] (] 6K9]((] N;]TD:]6SSN8E6T:9]N7F:8TS];QNJ]TD:]:KVEQNK\ J:KT] ,D:] :KVEQNKJ:KT] S:K9S] TD:] Q:SUHTS] 768G] N;] 8NUQS:] TD:] Q:SUHT] ES] KUHH] EK] TD:] >QST] 8Y8H:] ,D:] 8USTNJ:Q] 6C:KTS] S8D:9UH:] TD:]NO:Q6TENKS]WDE8D]D6V:]KNT]7::K]V6HE96T:9]6K9]EK?U:K8:]TD:] 6SSN8E6T:9] N7F:8TS]7Y] 6HT:R6TEV:] wÈ !;] TD:] @^ N;] NK:]N7F:8T] ES] TD:] S6J:] 6S] TD:] (] 6K9]((] 8USTNJ:Q] 6C:KTS] WEHH] J6G:] TD:] 8NK>QJ6TENK] T]H6ST] TD:]8USTNJ:Q]6C:KTS]S:K9](]6K9] @^ N;] TD:]6SSN8E6T:9]N7F:8TS]TN]TD:]:KVEQNKJ:KT] 68D]8USTNJ:Q]6C:KT]
)°È
";1Q "5'Q Q
Q*"2?=)Q Q Q
Q
Q
C"/>Q
^
^
Q
3 -5/;. Q
";1
Q/ ²È
^^
;=68Q Q;KETENK] N;] 6HH] S:PU:KTE6H] 68TEVETE:S] K:8:SS6QZ] 7:TW::K] NQECEK] 6K9] 9:STEK6TENK] ;NQ] :68D] TQ6KSONQT] NQ9:Q] ,DES] S:T] N;] S:PU:KTE6H] 68TEVETE:S] ES] EJONQT6KT];NQ]:68D]8USTNJ:Q]6C:KT];NQ]:V6HU6TEKC]TD:]OQ:9E8T:9] QNUT:] TN] CN] ;QNJ] NQECEK] TN] 9:STEK6TENK] 99ETENK6HHY] V:DE8H:S] Q:PUEQ:] JNST] N;T:K] TD:] CQNUOEKC] N;] JUHTEOH:] NQ9:QS] 688NQ9EKC] TN] TD:EQ] J6XEJUJ] HN69EKC] 86O68ETZ] WDEH:] OQN9U8:Q] 6C:KTS] N;] + (]JN9:H]NKHY]:X:8UT:]NK:]T6SG]6T]6]TEJ:] NQ]TD:S:]Q:6SNKS] TD:] + (] JN9:H] JUST] 7:] :VNHV:9]
^ > = "KET:]86O68ETZ] OH6KKEKC];NQ]6HH] T6SGS] N;] TD:EQ] TQ6KSONQT] NQ9:QS] ,']"] ,
] , ] 6K9] , ] 6S] SDNWK]EK] ECUQ:] ] 6K9]C:K:Q6T:];NQ]TD:J]TD:]WESD:9]ONSETENK] S::] S:8TENK] ] ;NQ] 9:T6EH] A:Q] TD:] WESD:9] ONSETENKS] 6Q:] S:KT] TN] :KVEQNKJ:KT] ,6GEKC] EKTN] 688NUKT] TD:EQ] OU7HESD:9] 76SE8] 68TEVETE:S] :68D] OQN9U8:Q] 6C:KT] O:Q8:EV:S] TD:] 9EKET:]86O68ETZ] OH6KKEKC];NQ]6HH]TD:]O:Q8:EV:9]T6SGS]8NKSE9:QEKC] V:DE8H:S] 86O68ETZ] 6K9] J6XEJUJ] W6ETEKC] TEJ:] 9UQ6TENK] ;NQ] 6] TQ6KSONQT] NQ9:Q] NQ] TDES] >QSTHY] OQN9U8:Q] 6C:KT] SNQTS] TD:] O:Q8:EV:9]T6SGS] 688NQ9EKC]TN]TD:] 8NQQ:SONK9EKC]68TEVETZ] ,6SGS] 6SSN8E6T:9] TN] TD:] S6J:] 68TEVETZ] 6Q:] 6QQ6KC:9] EK] ! '] NQ9:Q] T6GEKC]EKTN] 688NUKT]TD:]6S8:K9EKC]OE8GUO]96T:] +:8NK9HY] OQN\ 9U8:Q]6C:KT]CQNUOS]TD:]9E;;:Q:KT]T6SGS]N;]6K]68TEVETZ] 688NQ9EKC] TN]TD:] J6XEJUJ]W6ETEKC]TEJ:] 9UQ6TENK]6K9]TD:]86O68ETZ] N;]ETS] 6SSN8E6T:9] V:DE8H:] !;] 6SSN8E6T:9] V:DE8H:S] 8UQQ:KT] ST6K9EKC] ONSETENK] ES] 6T] TD:] 7:CEKKEKC]N; TD:]K:XT]68TEVETZ]TD:K]V:DE8H:]:X:8UT:S]TD:]68TEVETZ] ;NQ] TDES] CQNUO] N;] T6SGS] !;] 6SSN8E6T:9] V:DE8H:] ES] KNT] OQ:S:KT] 6T] TD:] K:XT] 68TEVETZ] 7UT] ET] ES] 6T] TD:] 7:CEKKEKC] N;] 6KNTD:Q] Q:TUR] 68TEVETZ] TD:K] OQN9U8:Q]6C:KT] >QST] :X:8UT:S] 9ESOH68:J:KT] ;QNJ] Q:TUR] 68TEVETZ] 6K9] TD:K] C:K:Q6T:S] TD:] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OH6K] ;NQ] TD6T] K:XT] 68TEVETZ] ,6SGS] TD6T] 8NUH9] KNT] 7:8NJ:] O6QT] N;] TD:] CQNUO] EK] >QST] OH68:] 9U:] TN] V:DE8H:S] >KET:] 86O68ETZ] HEJET6TENK] 6Q:]OH6KK:9]H6T:Q]NK]ETS]Q:TUR]TN]TD:]S6J:]68TEVETZ],6SGS]WDE8D] 6Q:] OH6KK:9] H6T:Q] J6Y] 6QQEV:] H6T:] 6T] TD:EQ] 9:HEV:QZ] HN86TENK]
1( j $$$j nc&Ue ^Ycm&mCYUÈZc9 :ceÈ
#j
È
[È
(A^^j V^aQgj
,#j
,
i"È
i"È
5KÈ O"È iXÈ
,
[gÈ
55È
j
Hj
j
#,
[`È
Hj
j
j
;[Qgj
,j
j
Hj
j
Hj
j
j
(A^^j V^aQgj
,j
XÈ
O"È
j
Hj
j
Hj
j
j
;[Qgj
,j
XÈ
iXÈ
j
H j
j
Hj
j
1( j $4j dYqmCUAÈ
gVÈ
a³¬È
%j
%j
j
j
j
j
j
j
g{¨È
¬·¬½È
%j j %j j j j j j %j j j j
1;\>A^b?Ij b?I);\T;U@Aj 1;\>A^b?Ij b?I)VU`;b>;Uj )VU`;b>;U1VbRVb^Aj V\@A;bf ;fj ;fb?Ij b?I);\T;U@Aj V\@A;bf ;fj ;fb?Ij b?I)VU`;b>;Uj )VU`;b>;U1VbRVb^Aj
£È
g
È %I j Ij %I j %I j %Ij I j I j Ij I j I j %I j %Ij
'*+5( ! ) *1j
,D:]Q:S:6Q8D]WNQG]OQ:S:KT:9]EK]TDES]O6O:Q]D6S]7::K]68DE:V:9] EK]TD:];Q6J:WNQG]N;] , +] OQNF:8T] ,D:]6EJ]N;]TDES]OQNF:8T] ES] TN] 9:V:HNO:] T:8DKNHNCE:S] EK] NQ9:Q] TN] OQNJNT:] 8NHH67NQ6TENK] 7:TW::K] TD:] 68TNQS] N;] ;NN9] SUOOHY] 8D6EKS] ,DES] OQNF:8T] ES] BK9:9] 7Y] TD:] UQNO:6K] OQNCQ6J] (', ] WDE8D] ES] 6T] S:QVE8:] N;] TD:] OYQ:K:6K]6Q:6] / . * 0j
'
'
'
^ JG j j
'
'
'
^ ^
!! ' '
' ' ! '
^
^ ^
' ' !# '
' ! '
5J^Ij XV^J`JVUj DV\j ;RRj ^AZbAU`J;Rj `;^P^j VDj 1\;U^XV\`j+\@A\^j
!' '
>QSTHY] WETD]6](6TD] EK9:Q]C:KT]:H67NQ6T:S] WD:K]SNHE8ET:9];NQ] :68D] NQ9:Q] TD:] TQ6V:HEKC] QNUT:S] 7:TW::K] OE8GUO] 6K9] 9:HEV:QZ] HN86TENKS] +:8NK9HY] WETD] 6] QUH:] ;NQ] CQNUOEKC] TQ6KSONQT] NQ9:QS] 6T]OQN9U8:Q]6C:KTS]SE9:] ,D:Q:]6Q:]S:V:Q6H]9EQ:8TENKS];NQ];UTUQ:] Q:S:6Q8D] !KST:69] N;] NK:] (#] JUHTEOH:] (#] :KT:QOQES:S] 86K] 8NHH67NQ6T:] WETD] :68D] NTD:Q] TN] 9:HEV:Q] TD:] NQ9:QS] 6K9] DNW] TD:S:] (# S] WEHH] 8NHH67NQ6T:] WETD] :68D] NTD:Q] K::9S] TN] 7:] EKV:STEC6T:9] 'TD:Q] O6Q6J:T:QS] HEG:] SE[:] TZO:] 6K9] W:ECDT] N;] TD:] OQN9U8TS]D6V:]TN] 7:] 8NKSE9:Q:9]6K9] DNW] JU8D]TD:Y] :KESD:9] W:] 86K] S::] TD:] C6KTT]Q:SUHT]N;]6HH];NUQ],'S]EK] ECUQ:]]8NJOUT:9]7Y] ,+ (] /]
+*(30$+*j * j 313. j 5+.'j
!K] TDES] O6O:Q] W:] 9ES8USS:9] 6] 8NHH67NQ6TEV:] TQ6KSONQT6TENK] OH6KKEKC] OQN7H:J] 6K9] TN] SNHV:] TD6T] OQNONS:9] 6] 9ESTQE7UT:9] JUHTE6C:KT];Q6J:WNQG]86HH:9],+ (]NNO:Q6TENK]7:TW::K] TWN] 8NJJUKETE:S] N;] 6C:KTS] 8USTNJ:Q] 6C:KTS] 6K9] OQN9U8:Q] 6C:KTS] USTNJ:Q]6C:KTS]N;;:Q]TQ6KSONQT]FN7S]TDQNUCD]S:PU:K\ TE6H] 6U8TENKS] 6K9] V:DE8H:] 6C:KTS] 8NJO:T:] WETD] :68D] NTD:Q] TN] S:QV:] TDNS:] FN7S] !K] ,+ (] W:] :XT:K9] + (] JN9:H]
9%:j j \?IJTA@Aj ;U@j 1 j Vb@A\`j.A;?`JcAj ^?IA@bRJUGj b^JUGj ;j TbR`Ji ;GAU`jTV@ARj `IAj^?AXjD\;TAdV\Pj $ $ ) $ 3 ((" + %$*3 % 3 )+! "3 $+ "" $ 3 cVR j jUV j jXX j j 9:j j ;gP;^VGRbj ;U@j tÈ ';XR;UVGRbjj TbR`J;GAU`j ;XX\V;?Ij `Vj RV;@j ?VU^VRJ@;`JVUj JUj `\;U^XV\`;`JVUj -$ *3 $3 $ $ ) $ 3 '/) 3 j 9:j ) j "MNR^T;UUj" j 'VXDA\j- j V\@A^j;U@j ) j RVV^jVRR;>V\;`JcAj `\;U^XV\`;`JVUj XR;UUJUGj JUj ?VTXRAfj ;@;X`JcAj RVGJ^`J?^j ^g^`AT^j j ?VTi XRAfJ`gj ^?JAU?A>;^A@j ;U;Rg^J^j VDj@A?J^JVUT;PJUGj X\V>RAT^jVDjG\VbX;GAj ^g^`AT^j %#(" 03 $ *3 XX j j 9:j È 'VhR;PjÈ \BXb`jtÈ "JR;J\Aj;U@j j 'VbP;Tj)bR`J;GAU`j AUcJ\VUi TAU`j DV\j @gU;TJ?j `\;U^XV\`j XR;UUJUGj ;U@j ^?IA@bRJUGj %#(,++ %$"3 $ 3 3 XX j j j 9:j j );\;^?Vj2IJ\@X;\`gj RVGJ^`J?^j j RJ`A\;`b\Aj \AcJAdj $+ )$+ %$"3 %,)$"3 % 3 )%,+ %$3 %$%# *3 cVR j SjUV j %jXX j j 9:j ) j )A^j) j c;Uj @A\j "AJO@AUj;U@j - j 0?Ibb\j$U`A\;?`JVUj >A`eAAUj JU`ARRJGAU`j ;GAU`j^`\;`AGJA^j DV\j\A;R`JTAj`\;U^XV\`;`JVUj XR;UUJUGj $+)"3 ,)%( $3 %,)$"3 % 3 ( )+ %$*3 * ) 3 XX j j j 9:j È 0;bA\j ;U@j " j XXAR\;`Ij$U`AG\;`JUGj `\;U^XV\`;`JVUj JUj ;j TbR`J^J`Aj ^?IA@bRJUGj AUcJ\VUTAU`j 1*+ #3 $ *3 3 )& $ *3 % 3 + 3 )3 $$,"3 / 3 $+ )$+ %$"3 %$ ) $ 3 XX j XXj j 9:j . j 0X]AUGA]j
