ugc@thebbc

1 downloads 141 Views 9MB Size Report
Sep 16, 2008 - one of a steadily growing network of blogs which allow members of the public to post .... pausing to cons
! !

"##$

! .7)U5*4NN)! ! ! !

! ! V/%4$05#/%&/7!&50!&1W#)5!.W+/! )+/5$&N.5+$02!/+/R)+/5$&N.5+$0!#/%!66"! C4:0!

P$!",#&$4!Q#$%,4!#/%!P$!=/%$4:!Q&,,

!!"#$%&'()*#$+%*,(%-I!J&K!L+:4,,!#/%!M+N&/!L#11#/! .(-(+%)/#0(+12!O$+'400+$!-.05&/!J4:&02!P$!8#$&/!Q#*,R -+$74/04/2!P$!S#11T!6+T)4!#/%!P$!L+:#$%!6#$$4,,!

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`WW+$5./&5&40EO#740E8/+:,4%749\)*#/74O$+7$#114Z#0W\!

! !

!

",#&$4!Q#$%,4!

! !

!

=/%T!Q&,, !

!!

!

J&K!L+:4,,!

!

!

! ! ! ! ! !

!

! ! ! ! ! "+/54/50! ! ! 9\4).5&>4!(.11#$T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!@! ! &)42!66"!P4>+/2!! 66"!Q#,402!66"!(*4''&4,%!#/%!66"!J44%0Z! !! S*4!%#5#!W$+>&%40!#!)+1W$4*4/0&>4!W&)5.$4!+'!5*4!:#T! eV]"^!&0!.04%!:&5*&/!5*4!66"2!*+:!eV]"^!&0!W4$)4&>4%!NT! [+.$/#,&050!#/%!04/&+$!1#/#74$02!+'!5*4!1+5&>#5&+/0!+'! )+/5$&N.5+$02!5*4!%&0&/)4/5&>40!'+$!5*+04!:*+!%+/^5! )+/5$&N.542!#/%!5*4!#55&5.%40!+'!5*4!74/4$#,!#.%&4/)4!5+! 5*4!&/)$4#04%!.04!+'!V]"!&/!/4:0!:&5*&/!5*4! +$7#/&0#5&+/Z!! ! S*4!W$+[4)5!:#0!)+R'./%4%!NT!5*4!=$50!#/%!L.1#/&5&40! M404#$)*!"+./)&,!#/%!5*4!66"2!#0!W#$5!+'!#!8/+:,4%74! 9\)*#/74!O$+7$#114Z!S*4!$404#$)*!05#$54%!+/!@!=.7.05! GAAf!#/%!:#0!)+1W,454%!+/!B@05!-.,T!GAAHZ!S*4! $404#$)*!54#1!:#0!,4%!NT!P$!",#&$4!Q#$%,4!#/%!5*4! M404#$)*!=00+)6!:#0!P$!=/%$4:!Q&,, Z!S*4!54#1! #,0+!)+1W$&04%!P$!L+:#$%!6#$$4,,2!P$!S#11T!6+T)42! O$+'400+$!-.05&/!J4:&02!#/%!P$!8#$&/!Q#*,R-+$74/04/Z! S*4$4!:4$4!5*$44!#%R*+)!M404#$)*!=00&05#/50I!Q&,,! S#T,+$!#/%!`%T!"+/05#/5&/+.!#/%!J&4K4,!J+/7N+#/Z! !

*)

9\4).5&>4!(.11#$T! ! S*&0!$4W+$5!&0!5*4!).,1&/#5&+/!+'!@G!1+/5*0!+'! )+,,#N+$#5&>4!$404#$)*!N45:44/!#!54#1!+'!"#$%&''! V/&>4$0&5T!$404#$)*4$0!#/%!5*4!66"Z!!4!$404#$)*!5+!N4!)+1W,454%!+/!5*4! 0.N[4)5!+'!V04$!]4/4$#54%!"+/54/5!cV]"d!&/!/4:0Z!! ! S*&0!7$+./%N$4#Y&/7!W$+[4)5!&/>+,>4%!D!%&''4$4/5! 145*+%+,+7&40I!! ! !

! /4:0$++1!+N04$>#5&+/0!&/!F!%&''4$4/5! /4:0$++10!#)$+00!5*4!66"! ! ! @@a!&/54$>&4:0!:&5*!66"![+.$/#,&050! #/%!@A!&/54$>&4:0!:&5*!04/&+$! 1#/#74$0!#/%!66"!4\4).5&>40! ! ! #/!#/#,T0&0!+'!@Aa!*+.$0!+'!/4:0! +.5W.5!'$+1!@B!/#5&+/#,!#/%!$47&+/#,! S;!#/%!$#%&+!W$+7$#1140!c#/%!5*4&$! #00+)6%!:4N0&540d! ! ! #!/#5&+/#,,T!$4W$404/5#5&>4!3`M4T!+'!Fbb!W4+W,4! ! ! #/!+/,&/4!0.$>4T!+'!DFa!66"! )+/5$&N.5+$0! ! ! @G!'+).0!7$+.W0!:&5*!@AA!W4+W,4Z!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

+)

!"#$%&'((#)

!

# # # # 3,*%&45)*6&,# ! 34%&#!+$7#/&0#5&+/02!0+!5*4!)+/>4/5&+/#,!05+$T!7+402! *#>4!/+5!'#)&,&5#54%!#!5:+R:#T!)+/>4$0#5&+/!N45:44/! /4:0!W$+%.)4$0!#/%!#.%&4/)40Z!3+$4!$4)4/5,T!&5!*#0! N4)+14!)+11+/W,#)4!5+!W+&/5!+.5!5*#5!/4:! 54)*/+,+7&40!4/#N,&/7!1+$4!)+,,#N+$#5&>4!'+$10!+'! [+.$/#,&01!*#>4!'+$)4%!.0!5+!$4)+/0&%4$!5*4!5$#%&5&+/#,! 1+%4,!+'!1#00!)+11./&)#5&+/Z!S*&0!e)&5&K4/^!+$! e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dZ! ! =!0.05#&/4%!&/54$405!&/!#.%&4/)4!W#$5&)&W#5&+/!&/!5*4! W$+%.)5&+/!+'!/4:0!#5!5*4!66"!*#0!N44/!1+$4!$4)4/52! #/%!*#0!N44/!%$&>4/!'+$:#$%!NT!#!/.1N4$!+'!*&7*R W$+'&,4!/4:0!4>4/50Z!S*4!C4:!g+$Y!54$$+$!#55#)Y0!&/! (4W541N4$!GAA@!:4$4!),4#$,T!#!>4$T!&1W+$5#/5!:#Y4R.W! )#,,!5+!14%&#!+$7#/&0#5&+/0!#N+.5!5*4!W+54/5&#,!+'!5*4! 74/4$#,!W.N,&)!5+!0.WW,T!#.%&+>&0.#,!#/%!4T4:&5/400! #))+./50Z!S*4T!:4$4!#,0+!&1W+$5#/5!&/!#,4$5&/7! [+.$/#,&050!5+!5*4!W+:4$!+'!#,54$/#5&>4!14%&#!'+$10!,&Y4! N,+70!#/%!N.,,45&/!N+#$%0!&/!0.WW,T&/7!%&''4$4/5!0+.$)40! +'!/4:0!+/!N&7!4>4/50!,&Y4!5*&0!GZ!6.5!FE@@!:#0!/+5!#! *.74!eV]"^!4>4/5!'+$!5*4!66"!0W4)&'&)#,,TZ!?+$!4\#1W,42! +/,T!5:+!4T4:&5/400!4R1#&,0!04/5!&/!NT!5*4!W.N,&)!5+!5*4! 66"!'$+1!C4:!g+$Y!74/4$#54%!,&>4!&/54$>&4:0!+/!5*4! /4:0!cQ#,5+/!GAAfdBZ!=!5.$/&/7!W+&/5!#5!5*4!66"!)#14! :&5*!5*4!=0&#/!50./#1&!&/!P4)41N4$!GAAb2!#/%!5*4! J+/%+/!6+1N&/70!&/!-.,T!GAAaZ!S*404!4>4/50!$4#,,T!1#$Y! 5*4!N47&//&/7!+'!#!W4$&+%!%.$&/7!:*&)*!)&5&K4/!+$!.04$! 74/4$#54%!)+/54/52!&/!5*4!:+$%0!+'!(5.#$5!=,,4/!e:4/5! 1#&/05$4#1X!#5!5*4!66"!c044!'++5/+54!GdZ!?+$!4\#1W,42! M&)*#$%!(#1N$++Y!5*4!P&$4)5+$!+'!5*4!66"^0!],+N#,! C4:0!%&>&0&+/2!*#0!05#54%!5*#5!&5!:#0!#/!41#&,!#N+.5!5*4! N+1N&/70!04/5!&/!NT!#!>&4:4$!:*&)*!'&$05!)*#,,4/74%!5*4! &/&5&#,!+''&)&#,!$4W+$50Z!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! %

!S*4!Q*4$4!4!0&540!*#>4!N44/!$4R5&5,4%!66"!J+)#,!#/%!:&,,! N4!$4'4$$4%!5+!#0!0.)*!5*$+.7*+.5!5*&0!$4W+$5Z! "!=,,4/2!(5.#$5!cGAAfd!eS*4!".,5.$#,!O+,&5&)0!+'!"&5&K4/! -+.$/#,&01^2!"#$%&''!V/&>4$0&5T!"$&5&)#,! S*4+$T!(41&/#$2!Gb5*!`)5+N4$Z! B !Q#,5+/2!"*$&0!cGAAfd!eL#>4!S*4T!]+5!C4:0!?+$!V0h^2!66"! "+,,474!+'!-+.$/#,&01!V]"!5$#&/&/7!0400&+/2!66"!Q#,402!@@5*! P4)41N4$!

!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 5*#5!5*4!%&05.$N#/)40!*#%!N44/!)#.04%!NT!#!W+:4$! 0.$74!+/!5*4!5.N4Z!! ! Q&5*&/!0&\!*+.$0!:4!$4)4&>4%!1+$4!5*#/!@2AAA! #1#54.$!W*+5+7$#W*02!GA!W&4)40!+'!#1#54.$! >&%4+2!b2AAA!54\5!1400#7402!#/%!GA2AAA!41#&,0Z! O4+W,4!:4$4!W#$5&)&W#5&/7!&/!+.$!)+>4$#74!&/!#! :#T!:4!*#%!/4>4$!044/!N4'+$4Z!6T!5*4!/4\5!%#T! +.$!1#&/!S;!/4:0)#05!N47#/!:&5*!#!W#)Y#74! 4%&54%!4/5&$4,T!'$+1!>&%4+!04/5!&/!NT!>&4:4$0Z@@!! ! !4/5!*#0!*#WW4/4%!&5X0!&/)$4%&N,4Z!g+.!)+.,%/X5!745! #!)#14$#!)$4:!5*4$4Z!#,&%!#/%!4$T! &1W+$5#/5^Z!64'+$4!fEf!66"!C4:0!&/54$#)5&>4!&/!J+/%+/! 7+5!#$+./%!BAA!4R1#&,0!+/!#/!#>4$#74!%#TZ!S*&0!*#0!/+:! $&04/!5+!#$+./%!@G2AAA2!:&5*!0W&Y40!#$+./%!)4$5#&/! W+W.,#$!05+$&40Z!S*4!66"!$4)4&>4%!Ga2AAA!4R1#&,0![.05!+/! 5*4!(.%#/!54%%T!N4#$!05+$T!&/!P4)41N4$!GAAfZ!?$+1!#! >4$T!,+:!N#04!#$+./%!B!T4#$0!#7+2!5*4T!/+:!745!#$+./%! @AAA!05&,,0!#/%!>&%4+!),&W0!04/5!&/!+/!#!_.&45!:44Y2!#/%! %.$&/7!5*4!',++%0!&/!-./4!GAAD!5*4T!$4)4&>4%!#$+./%! fAAA!W*+5+0!#/%!>&%4+0!&/!'&>4!%#T0Z!S*404!#$4![.05! #WW$+\&1#54!'&7.$40!'+$!5*4!&/'+$1#5&+/!#/%!$#:!! 1#54$&#,!',+:&/7!&/5+!5*4!66"^0!7$+:&/7!V04$!]4/4$#54%! "+/54/5!L.N2!#/%!%+!/+5!)+./5!5*4!>+,.14!+'!)+/54/5! 04/5!%&$4)5,T!5+!&/%&>&%.#,!W$+7$#11402!+$!5+!5*4!1#/T! ,+)#,!#/%!$47&+/#,!/4:0$++10!#)$+00!5*4!V82!:*&)*!)#/! N4!)+/0&%4$#N,42!40W4)&#,,T!%.$&/7!N&7!eV]"!05+$&40^Z! ! ?#)4%!:&5*!5*&0!,4>4,!+'!#.%&4/)4!W#$5&)&W#5&+/!&/!5*4! )+>4$#74!+'!0.)*!/4:0!05+$&40!&5!&0!/+!0.$W$&04!5*#5!5*4! 66"!*#0!0&/)4!%4)&%4%!5+!4/5*.0&)#,,T!41N$#)4!! eV]"^!&/!#!/.1N4$!+'!:#T0Z!=1+/705!+5*4$!5*&/70I!&5!*#0! &/>4054%!*4#>&,T!&/!&50!eV]"!*.N^!c5*4!%4W#$514/5!! $40W+/0&N,4!'+$!5*4!',#70*&W!L#>4!g+.$!(#T!:4N0&54d! :*&)*!+/,T!41W,+T4%!#!*#/%'.,!+'!W4+W,4!&/!GAAa!N.5!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! @@

!(#1N$++Y2!M&)*#$%!cGAAad!e"&5&K4/!-+.$/#,&01!#/%!5*4!66"^2! C&41#/!M4W+$502!aF!cbdI!@BR@DZ!

! ! ! ! !"#$%&'((#) ! ! ! ! ! *#0!0&/)4!7$+:/!5+!GFj!&5!*#0!W$+1+54%!#!/45:+$Y!+'! N,+70!$4,#5&/7!5+!/4:0!#/%!).$$4/5!#''#&$0!W$+7$#11&/7!! ! 5+!4\54/%!5*4!)+/>4$0#5&+/!+''!#&$2!#/%!&/!0+14!)#040! c0.)*!#0!5*4!C4:0/&7*5!#/%!O3!N,+70d!5+!1#Y4!5*4! 4%&5+$&#,!W$+)400!&504,'!1+$4!)+,,#N+$#5&>4!#/%! 5$#/0W#$4/5j!#/%!&5!*#0!)+/)4/5$#54%!+/!5$#&/&/72! W.55&/7!#!eV]"^R$4,#54%!)+.$04!)#,,4%!eL#>4!S*4T!]+5! C4:0!'+$!V0^!#5!5*4!*4#$5!+'!5*4!/4:!66"!"+,,474!+'! -+.$/#,&01Z! ! ='54$!5*&0!*4#%T!5&14!+'!eV]"^R$4,#54%!4\W#/0&+/!5*4! 66"!*#0!/+:!4/54$4%!#!W4$&+%!+'!$4',4)5&+/2!#/%!&0! W#.0&/7!5+!)+/0&%4$!5*4!N405!:#T0!'+$:#$%Z!=5!#!5&14! :*4/!1#/T!V8!14%&#!+$7#/&0#5&+/0!#$4!05&,,!$.0*&/7!5+! 41N$#)4!+/,&/4!W#$5&)&W#5&+/!&/!5*4!'+$1!+'!%&0).00&+/! #/%!)+114/50!*+054%!+/!5*4&$!:4N0&5402!04/&+$!66"! 4%&5+$0!#$4!N47&//&/7!5+!_.405&+/!*+:!5*4!"+$W+$#5&+/! 0*+.,%!N4!*+05&/7!5*404!)+/>4$0#5&+/0I! ! O454$! ",&'5+/! cL4#%! +'! 9%&5+$&#,! P4>4,+W14/5! '+$! 3.,5&14%&#dI!`>4$!5&142!:4!1#T!:#/5!5+!%4>+54! ,400!5&14!5+!4/)+.$#7&/7!*4#54%!%4N#54!:*&)*!&0! [.05! *+5! #&$! #/%! #)5.#,,T! /+5! #! *.74! #1+./5! +'! >#,.4! #/%! #)5.#,,T! '+).0&/7! 1+$4! +/! 5*4! $4#,! #%%4%!>#,.4!&/0&7*5!&/!V04$!]4/4$#54%!"+/54/5Z! ! O454$!M&WW+/!c9%&5+$2!M#%&+!b^0!O32!&O32!Q+$,%!#5! `/42! #/%! 6$+#%)#05&/7! L+.04dI! &0&+/!+'!*&7*!_.#,&5T!/4:0!)+/54/5Z!(+14! 0.77405!5*#5!5*4!4''+$5!%4>+54%!5+!1#&/5#&/&/7!5*4! )+/>4$0#5&+/!N45:44/!5*4!/4:0!+$7#/&0#5&+/!#/%!&50! #.%&4/)4!:+.,%!N4!N4554$!0W4/5!4/)+.$#7&/7!5*+04!:*+! *#>4!:&5/4004%!#!/4:0!4>4/52!+$!:*+!*#>4!0+14! 4\W4$&4/)4!+$!4\W4$5!Y/+:,4%74!+'!&52!5+!)+/5#)5!5*4! 66"Z!! ! (.)*!#!1+>4!:+.,%!N4!#WW,#.%4%!NT!1#/T![+.$/#,&050! :&5*&/!5*4!66"2!#0!:4,,!#0!NT!)4$5#&/!04)5&+/0!+'!5*4! 66"^0!#.%&4/)4Z!S*4!.04!+'!4T4:&5/400!#.%&4/)4! )+/54/52!#/%!&/'+$14%!+W&/&+/!'$+1!#1#54.$02!&0!:&%4,T! #WW$4)6%!#1+/705!66"![+.$/#,&050!#/%!#.%&4/)4! 141N4$0!#,&Y4!c:&5*!0+14!&1W+$5#/5!$&%4$0!#/%! )#>4#502!+'!)+.$04dZ!L+:4>4$2!1#/T!N4,&4>4!1.)*!+'!5*4! #.%&4/)4!+W&/&+/!#N+.5!5*4!/4:0!5*#5!7450!W.N,&0*4%2! :*#5!:4!)#,,!=.%&4/)4!"+114/52!&0!+'54/!%+1&/#54%!NT! 5*4!./&/'+$14%!#/%!5*+04!:*+!*+,%!4\5$414!c#/%! 0+145&140!%&05#054'.,d!>&4:02!#/%!5*4$4'+$4!41W*#0&0! 0*+.,%!N4!W,#)4%!+/!+5*4$!5TW40!+'!=.%&4/)4!3#54$&#,Z! ! S*4$4!&0!/+!0&1W,4!#/0:4$2!*+:4>4$Z!3#/T!0.WW+$54$0! +'!5*4!66"^0!L#>4!g+.$!(#T!'+$.12!'+$!4\#1W,42!0.77405! 5*#5!&'!&5!:4$4!/+5!'+$!5*404!&1W+$5#/5!0W#)40!'+$!%4N#54! 1#/T!/4:0!05+$&40!#/%!5*4!)#04!05.%&40!#/%!4T4:&5/400! #))+./50!:*&)*!#))+1W#/&4%!5*41!:+.,%!/4>4$!*#>4! N44/!'+./%Z!-+.$/#,&050!#5!5*4!eV]"^!*.N!0W4/%!1.)*!+'! 5*4&$!5&14!5$#:,&/7!5*$+.7*!)+114/50!#/%!W$4R 1+%4$#5&/7!%4N#5402!#/%!&'!5*4T!%&%/^5!%+!5*&0!1#/T! >#,.#N,4!/.77450!+'!.04'.,!&/'+$1#5&+/!1&7*5!0,&W! 5*$+.7*!5*4!/452!/4>4$!5+!N4!%&0)+>4$4%!#/%! &/>405&7#54%!'.$5*4$!NT!66"!/4:0![+.$/#,&050Z! ! (+14!N4,&4>4!eV]"^!&0!/+5*&/7!/4:2!+5*4$0!N4,&4>4!5*4! 54)*/+,+7&)#,!%4>4,+W14/502!&'!)+$$4)5,T!5#WW4%2!! W$+>&%4!$4#,!+WW+$5./&5&40!'+$!$4R)+//4)5&/7!:&5*!5*4! #.%&4/)4!'+$!/4:0!#/%!).$$4/5!#''#&$0Z!Q*#54>4$!5*4!! +W&/&+/2!5*&0!$404#$)*!%41+/05$#54%!5*#5!4>4$T+/4!*#%! #/!+W&/&+/!#N+.5!V04$!]4/4$#54%!"+/54/5!#5!5*4!66"2!! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :*45*4$!&5!:#0!#!04/&+$!4\4).5&>42!/4:,T!_.#,&'&4%! [+.$/#,&05!+$!#!,&)4/)4!'44!W#T4$Z! ! =0!(54>4!L4$$1#//!c66"!Q4N0&54!4%&5+$d!#$7.4%2! ! &+.0,T! *#>4!5+! )+/5&/.4!5+! 4/7#74! :&5*!kV]"lZ!4$T!&1W+$5#/5!#$4#Z!Q4! )#//+5! &7/+$4! &5Z! &)4! +$7#/&0#5&+/2! *#>4! 5+! N4! 4>4/! N4554$! #5! &5! 5*#/! +5*4$:&04Z!+&)40! #/%! +W&/&+/0! #/%! W+&/50! +'! >&4:Z! 4,+W! $4#,,T! 0+W*&05&)#54%2!01#$52!4/7#7&/7!:#T0!+'!)+/5&/.&/7! 5+! %+! &5Z! 6.5! &5^0! 7+&/7! 5+! N4! +/4! +'! 5*4! N&7! )*#,,4/740! :4! '#)4Z! &%4!&/0&7*50!N+5*!&/5+!5*4! :#T0!&/!:*&)*!eV]"^!&0!N4&/7!.04%!#5!5*4!66"!#0!:4,,!#0! 5*4!>&4:0!+'!5*4!#.%&4/)40!cN+5*!5*+04!:*+!)+/5$&N.54! #/%!5*+04!:*+!%+!/+5dZ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! !

345*+%+,+7T!

! ! ! ! !"#$%&'((#) ! ! ! ! ! #55&5.%40!#N+.5!eV]"^!:&5*&/!%&''4$4/5!/4:0$++102!5+! '&/%!+.5!#N+.5!4\#1W,40!+'!7++%!W$#)5&)42!#/%!5+!,4#$/! #N+.5!+N05#),40!#/%!)*#,,4/740!'#)4%!NT![+.$/#,&050! .0&/7!#/%!0*#$&/7!eV]"^Z!S*404!&/54$>&4:4%!5+5#,,4%!@@a! %.$&/7!5*4!Bf!%#T0!+'!+N04$>#5&+/0Z! !

.)

"+/54/5!=/#,T0&0!

"+/54/5!=/#,T0&0!&0!#!145*+%+,+7T!:*&)*!)#W5.$40!,#$74! #1+./50!+'!14%&#!+.5W.5!#0!#!:#T!5+!7#.74!./%4$,T&/7!! W#554$/0Z!3.5.#,,T!4\),.0&>4!)#547+$&40!#$4!.04%!5+! e)+%4^!%&''4$4/5!#0W4)50!+'!5*4!14%&#!+.5W.52!&/!5*&0! )#04!! ! 5*4!/.1N4$!+'!$4_.4050!'+$!eV]"^! ! 5*4!5TW40!+'!$4_.4050! C4:0$++1!+N04$>#5&+/0!! ! 5*4!5TW40!+'!eV]"^!$4_.4054%! ! ! 5*4!,4/75*!+'!5&14!+'!4#)*!$4_.405!0,+5! =!54#1!+'!a!$404#$)*4$0!0W4/5!#!5+5#,!+'!Bf!%#T0!&/!F! ! 5*4!/.1N4$!+'!04714/50!&/!:*&)*!eV]"^!:#0! /4:0$++10Z!S*+04!Bf!%#T0!N$4#Y!%+:/!#0!'+,,+:0Z! .04%! ! ! 5*4!/.1N4$!+'!&/%&>&%.#,!)+/5$&N.5&+/0! M9]&)4I!C4:0*+.$!m!Q+$,%! ! D!+^!),+)Y!C4:0!c66"!@d! L#>4#g+.$!(#T!c@!%#Td! ! @A!+^),+)Y!C4:0!c66"!@d! ! ! C4:0N4#5!cM#%&+!@d! S*4!$404#$)*4$0!:4$4!'+,,+:&/7!W#$5&)&W#/5!+N04$>#5&+/! ! -4$41T!;&/4!cM#%&+!Gd! 54)*/&_.402!#5541W5&/7!5+!N4!#0!./+N5$.0&>4!#0!W+00&N,4! ! S+%#T!cM#%&+!bd! &/!+$%4$!5+!+N04$>4!#/%!)#W5.$4!5*4!:#T0!&/!:*&)*! ! O3!cM#%&+!bd! eV]"^!&0!N4&/7!.04%!NT![+.$/#,&0502!:&5*+.5!*#>&/7!5+!$4,T! ! 6$4#Y'#05!cM#%&+!a!J&>4d!! 0+,4,T!+/!#0Y&/7![+.$/#,&050!5+!4\W,#&/!4>4$T%#T!#)5&+/0! ! P$&>4!cM#%&+!a!J&>4d! c1#/T!+'!:*&)*!#$4!0+!/#5.$#,&04%!&5!&0!&1W+00&N,4!5+! ! Q4,0*!6$4#Y'#05!*#,'!*+.$,T!).5#:#T0!'$+1!66"! )+/0)&+.0,T!)+/0&%4$!#,,!5*4!5*+.7*50!#/%!#)5&+/0! 6$4#Y'#05!c66"!Q#,40d! &/>+,>4%dZ!P.$&/7!5*4!5&14!&/!5*4!/4:0$++102!5*4! ! Q#,40!S+%#T!c66"!Q#,40d! $404#$)*4$0!./%4$5++Y!#!/.1N4$!+'!041&R05$.)5.$4%! ! ]++%!3+$/&/7!Q#,40!c66"!M#%&+!Q#,40d! &/54$>&4:0!:&5*![+.$/#,&050!#/%!4%&5+$0!&/!+$%4$!5+!7#.74!! ! ]++%!9>4/&/7!Q#,40!c66"!M#%&+!Q#,40d! ! ! !

! S*&0!W$+[4)5!)+/0&054%!+'!a!%&''4$4/5!145*+%+,+7&40I! C4:0$++1!`N04$>#5&+/0j!"+/54/5!=/#,T0&0j!3`M4Tj!`/,&/4!(.$>4T!+'!66"!)+/5$&N.5+$0j!#/%!?+).0! ]$+.W07## !

!

!

/)

!

!"#$%&'((#)

! =7#&/2!5+!1#Y4!5*4!0#1W,&/7!1#/#74#N,42!:4!)*+04!+/4! :44Y!&/!?4N$.#$T!c3+/%#T!@@R?$&%#T!@a!GAAHdZ@G!=,,! 1#54$&#,!:#0!$4)+$%4%!#/%!5*4!%#5#!:#0!#/#,T04%!#5!#! ,#54$!%#54!NT!#!M404#$)*!=00&05#/5Z@B!&,T!+/!W#$5&).,#$!/4:0!05+$&40!cW#$5&).,#$,T!! N$4#Y&/7!/4:0d2!:4!%40&7/4%!#!Gb!*+.$!0#1W,4!+'!/4:0! +>4$!#!@D!%#T!W4$&+%2!$4)+$%&/7!@Za!*+.$0!+'! W$+7$#11&/7!4#)*!%#TZ!(+!+/!P#T!@!cG@05!-#/.#$T!GAAHd! 5*4!W4$&+%!N45:44/!1&%/&7*5!#/%!@ZBA#1!:#0! $4)+$%4%Z!`/!P#T!G!cGG/%!-#/.#$T!GAAHd!5*4!W4$&+%!+'! 5&14!@ZBA#1RB#1!:#0!$4)+$%4%Z!Q44Y4/%0!:4$4!/+5! &/),.%4%!&/!5*4!0#1W,4!c(44!'++5/+54!a!'+$!4\W,#/#5&+/dZ! ! S*4!:4N0&540!'+$!4#)*!+'!5*404!W$+7$#11402!#0!:4,,!#0! 5*4!L#>4!g+.$!(#T!'+$.1!:4$4!#,0+!#/#,T04%!.0&/7!#! _.#,&5#5&>4!54)*/&_.4!c#0!_.#/5&5#5&>4!54)*/&_.40!:+.,%! /+5!*#>4!T&4,%4%!W#$5&).,#$,T!&/54$405&/7!%#5#dZ!=!'.,,! %40)$&W5&+/!+'!5*4!:4N0&540!#/%!5*4!%&''4$4/5!:#T0!5*4T! .04!V]"!&0!%45#&,4%!&/!5*4!#WW4/%&\Z# # 4T!%40&7/4%!NT!5*4! "#$%&''!$404#$)*!54#1!N45:44/!GF5*!C+>41N4$!i!f5*! P4)41N4$!GAAfZ!! Fbb!#%.,50!+>4$!@D!:4$4!&/54$>&4:4%Z!S*4!%#5#!:#0! :4&7*54%!5+!5*4!Y/+:/!6$&5&0*!W+W.,#5&+/!W$+'&,42!:&5*! @Hb!0#1W,4!W+&/50!#)$+00!6$&5#&/Z!S*4!&/54$>&4:0!:4$4! )+/%.)54%!.0&/7!"+1W.54$!=00&054%!O4$0+/#,! &4:&/7!&/!$40W+/%4/50^!*+140!.0&/7!5*4!4!N44/!&/54$405&/72! #))400!5+!$4)+$%&/7!4_.&W14/5!:#0!/+5!W+00&N,4!#5!5*4! :44Y4/%0Z!(&1&,#$,T!@@!*+.$0!+'!W+54/5&#,!N$+#%)#05!1#54$&#,! %&%!/+5!$4)+$%!0.))400'.,,T!0+!)+.,%!/+5!N4!&/),.%4%!&/!5*4! 0#1W,4Z! @B !64)#.04!#,,!)+%&/7!$4,#54%!5+!5*4!eW$404/)4E#N04/)4^!+'! V]"!&/54$R)+%4$!$4,&#N&,&5T!:#0!/+5!/4)400#$TZ!

! ! ! 3`M4T0!0.''4$!'$+1!5*4!&00.4!+'! 04,'R04,4)5&+/!5*4!W+00&N,4!%&0#%>#/5#740!+'!.0&/7!#/! +/,&/4!0.$>4T!:4$4!+.5:4&7*4%!NT!5*4!#))400!&5! W$+>&%4%!5+!5*+04!:*+!%+!)+/5$&N.54!1#54$&#,!5+!5*4! 66"!c#!*#$%!7$+.W!5+!$4#)*!NT!#/T!+5*4$!14#/0Zd!! ! 4TZ! S*4!0.$>4T!:#0!,&/Y4%!5+!'$+1!5*4!66"!:4N0&542!#/%!#0! W#$5!+'!#/!#.5+1#5&)!$4W,T!+/!5*4!T+.$W&)0UNN)Z)+Z.Y! 41#&,!#%%$400!'+$!#,1+05!B!1+/5*0!c@05!3#$)*!./5&,!GA5*! 3#T!GAAHdZ!S*4$4!:#0!#!W$+1+5&+/#,!N+\!+/!5*4! NN)Z)+Z.YE4/7,#/%!:4N0&542!#/%!+/!#!04,4)5&+/!+'!66"! J+)#,!*+14W#740!#)$+00!9/7,#/%2!#0!:4,,!#0!5*4! *+14W#74!+'!5*4!66"!4$#,,!N$4#Y%+:/!&0!#0!'+,,+:0I! ! ! ! 8)&*9+,4#3-9+,4#!9&::6,:#;