Abstract. In certain domains a case base may contain contradictory but correct cases. The contradictory solutions are due to known domain and problem ...
"!#$%'&()#*+'),- . )/102- . -34/657$,89*+-:;$(=%$)&-)5 ? 8 .A@ < DB CFEHGJIFEK%ELI2GJELCNMPORQRE%INSUTWVDXJYSZG'[ZGJY\P]PYSUE |nr^`}Z_FfaRc~bheced6dgnrf$_{heh4ijbb_kaf_Zpul(nrmqLwZmoh~cennJijpjqr
DnJfqr_Zpbsiud6nJ_Zd cex~iutZi_Zh`_ZynriunJqbcef$iuahe_Fiu)xgbs_3ff_Z_mvel(nrfqL zwFbs_Zd6bpjb}FxtFy3henJzcDnr2_{qrheiunJnrc_Zqrn NsNNs2$No`ss F¦gf_tFl¥h4rqrr}Fb$cec~bsce¦F nrsqJpunrh¡ dAq^¢f_£qH~wnrqJrfnJ§ZcHc~fhHmqJfwZheiu_¤nJnceqriulF«bhebs_{iudgqrh~%cHffsiuªlF_ZwZiu6qJiuheqHf¥bwWc~qygf$fce~~n¬n(bspu_ZtF¦bhefh%iu~bn(}_Zf$¨dgc~fh)fceyWn%baqrlNbshetZwF_{n¨nhHfheqb ij_£f©2~n6_ZqrbblF_2ªnJh~_-~cHqJfcelFlFiub}FiuqJdgheheiubbsfc~_Uiu_y ® iffh_d6iulbs_Zªiud6xwFhe}¯iuqLwFbw3nc~hHqrqrffbs_{_Zd6hD_F}¯hebbnJh¨heiu¦¯lN_Fnrn,x%aRnr~bpubscebspudg}¥tFhefd6iupubspy-_FnJhebwFbc¨b2aPlFnJhe°NwF}Zhen¨puwiudgqrf$ih,hef$pheªy3qLiuwFlNpupiunr_ZtZ~xqJ~cen)qiuf¦¯he~nwZnrlUnr~§F±,n'^`_-tNqJcec~itZhelNnJqHbscew(dgijf~fiheijhe_6bgtf$b~heavnriupubsfnr_Z}FqJh² }Ff_pjiul(qf$hehewZiubsn%_ qrªf~fn'¦hewFfn~n)f~qr~biu_{xhH_Zfd6iu_Znrn_{l3hb_2atF¦Zd6iupunJpuceiu_Zbsx,tF¨_2tFqrfd~¦¯nrDnJcebUahe~b¨iud6hewFiunp³f$~cwZbiu}Fc,d6nrsnrnr_{_3hobijlFanrxs_{b{heb2iulNqfrp® he}NqHbwcec~bsf$yW¦ZcHfpu~nrqJbd6hepjnJtNceheiuhe«iubswZheiu_Zfqr)h4wZªhewZfsnLfl-cehn6lFªqri´PbnLcec~nJnDcecenrnr_FqL_{h¬bh4hf~}b_f$pjlWtNc~hehfiubsb__Za¯bs'hewZtNµ¶hen¦Zqriuqbspufpud6iu~_ZnJn6xb_2fa_ZtFlFl dbª¦¯dgnJnLcefceHn,iu_W·L§FfpjqJ2~bstZb)_ZqH_F«w-h~bcHqrhfba¸iu_{_2bh~cehecHdg fsflFf_ZpuiupqJyl ² ©2putF_Zhebiubª__(ff}F_}¯l-nflFcenJnr¹Zl;_ZnflPd6§2bs^¢_ZhxgªhefwZ¨n)f~ce~nJtFh~ced6iunrnlnrl+hewZqffh4~nrhe'wFnDf_ZaRcelknrº2hetFwFnrn _ZceqLnryqJnrª_ZiqJhey¥wªbawZheiuqLwFw(n'f heiud6~bn² he}¯wFnJn%heiu_F~bsxputF~bsheiupubstF_¥heiubwZ_Zfsrl(®¦F¦¯tFnrnJh_khewFfnJ}Fce}Znpuª4iunfl(»ª_FnJb,cenJn)°Niu}Fd6pjiu}¯qribhc~hHª4ffr_{y'h4a¸a¸bbcc,lN~bsnriupu_ZnrqJx,heiu~_ZbFxg§^¢f_ d6hebswF_Fijx6}Zqrfbs}¯d¬nJc² ª¦Fijn_Fn(~wFfb_ª¼lwFbb$}¯ª½nJcHfªhengiubstF_Z~fnpuiulW¾rnkxsnJ_ZfnJxshetFiuq-ngf~nrpuxspunrbqJceheiuheiubswF_¤d6'qJceheiheb3nJcelFijf+iu~qr~b$tFqLnJw7c fd6¬nJ¿hewZcenrb2qJlNnr%_ZqJheyNbk¿+qrbsfd¬_Zl ² he¿fbaRqrcec~qrnygtFº{cH~tZfbsnJqJpu_Zy(tFqJhefy{iubs_§ ¿g_Fl-À}¯ceÁ¨nJnJh~c~4cea¸biuwZnrcenrdgpun}¯flgn_Zl¦{qJyntZ¨bzalFÂheiuÃÄ~wFqrn)b$cenJzh~nJÂceciuÃÅnr~nJpjf«nJyNpPqJ«fheheiu_Znrbsld3_k~§ qJiucexi_ZheinJ¹ceqijf f_{aRbhepuc¨ygheiuwZd6n}Nqrcebb_{sh~ncHl¬fslFheiuwZqJn ² Æ ÇZȨɯÊPË%Ì Í'ÎoÉPÏeË¨È ÐINEJEH]PMPYÙ3SWYsEHT+YO³YsGJ]UÑGLI{QRGSPÒ3EHQRÙ3ÑIFQ³EHO¸I2YÓ`X)ÔU\UIFXLEHCFYsÔPT(O³YXLYsÙkINE%ELCNO³SPYsINQRSPT;Ò+GLC¥Õ«B,ELV,QRÙ(Ö QR×4O¸I2ØX'CFX,ELCNMvOREHM¯Y GLQRQ³CNSWSvIgEÚU\UELINCkXHGJ\PQRXJÑYMPÛORINQRCNX,MUTPECNYÙkÜ\oI2QRYSXJQRÚZYQjSUGÑQRYE ÑINI2EJEHSMPÔoÙ3YY,XJGLY]vMUI{ELGYTWGJ]PQRY)SÑGLIF]PEHYgYÔUØCNIFXJEHÙY%MPMUO¸ELI{YGJT-Q³CFGJSWC¬CNTPØYEJI3Ñ$XJSPQ³YÔoÝÞYGLEL]PCNY%ORM¯\UGLXLQRCNYSÛZQRßoCNà'MvETPTPY$ܯQjGJ\vQ³CFYSUXLQRI2YORSvO³áFÑ$ÚYEB,QRVEÖâÑCNEHSUá¯ELEHQ¸EeGLGJYYÙ3SZEG C2I2بSUTWB,Ö%V,Ñ$YCFÖ¼ÑXLYXJSZELYáG¨Ñ$GEHÝ,GLINYCNSUÙkXJT¥ã-E,QRGJGLSW]UCkI{B,XJG%YVãINÖäSPELCNC{QRSWÝ%EDORINORYCZÑT¯CFÑ$ÒFãMPY Q³XrSPI{XJÒGJYY\UQ³ORSZXLákYsGLC-EHQREYT¯SFORYCFGJYÛFEHT+G)YORQjCNÔZØ\Pá+GLQR]USPQjG%YÒ6ELXJY¬GJYYÙkIFÑr]PELI2ELSPQRMPSUQ¸Ù3åZEMP\¯INYGJÑEQ³Ñ$CFGLMPSUC-XrE%I{XLGJT¯YsYNEHCk߯CFKO³SPÛFCN]PY)GY6EH]UCFI2CNÙ(ÔPO¸QRTY'ORQjß GeC2á Ø GLÙ3]PINY,Q³SZ\PGJXJYCNSUÔPINORYSUÙkÑ$Y,ECNINS3EJEHI¬C¯Ñ$ÑQ¸INI{ELGJY,YT¬ÔUINÝ%ELQ³YGL](Õ¢I2Q³Ù3SvÑ$CNCNSUXJÒ XJYÙkÑGsI2ÚSÑáCNçPS¯æUè é{Q¸ê«ÑÚGJè³Q³ëSUìÒ ê`Ú{I2INSvSUTgT;SPè CFí2QRî2ELê¶á6×$ß2ÑKINEL]PYYEÙ3Ôá6C2GL\vQRYÛ{XHI{ØGJCFQ³XLCFÙ3SQRØSPCFÒ X T¯CNQRSPÒWÙ3INQ³SZGJYSUINSUÑ$Y(QREGJC;XJYTPMUÑ$Y(GL]UY3ELQRïY(C2بGJ]PYkTPI{GrI2ÔUIFEHYFÚvÙkINQ³SZGJINQ³SðÑ$CFSUELQREHGLYSUÑ$áFÚ
I2Ñ$CNSUÙ-T½ÔPÙ3QRSPI2Q³SUܯÒ3Q³Ù3ÑQRINïELY¤YEDTPCNGLCkÙkÒFI2Y$QRSñG%XJÑQRTWC{ÛNC2YØXrI2XLÒFYsYNT¯ß¨MPSUKTU]UI2QRSUEWÑQ¸á¥EWCNTPX%CNQRSPSUY¤Ñ$CFÔZSUáòELQREHEHGLGLYXrSUI{GJÑ$YáFÒFß QRÑI2ORO³áÅYORQ³Ù3QRSUI{GJQ³SUÒóCFX SPQ³S¯QRØåZCFMPKXLYsÙk]PEgYI2I2XJGLYkXJQRCNYkI2SSPXJß4Y¥CNô GT¯MPCNI2X\PÙk\PÝ,I2XJQRCNCNSUXJ\UEã7XLÚQ¸ØGLI{C¯]UGJÑ$YNCNMvÚMPEHÒFI2YsSv]EgT¤ÚCNÝ%SÄÙk]PITPYá¤CNXLY3ÙkO³YsGJI2INXJQRT¤IFSUT¯EgGLQjC7GJÝ%Q³CF]UORSUCFYEJI2XJE¬OYkC2ÑGLINØ%]PELYWQRYkÙ3ÑÔU\vIFINCFEHELY¥XHYkGrI2ÔvÙkSZINGgELI2YkQRãSZQRSPGLE-YC{SvÝ%ORINI2O³XLSUYsÒFT¯ÑY7Y-ÒNYkÕGJ]YINMPÑrSU]¯S¯T ÓÓ T¯KXL]PYsY¥TPE%XJYCNT¯Ø»MPGJSv]PTPCNI2MUSUEJI2Ñá£SvTPSPEYC2YØTPEgÑIFGLEHCYsEJÔo×$Y+Ú¯ÛN\PYXJXLYá¥ELYXJXJYÛNTPYsMPT¤SUTPELQRINSUSFÑ$GsYkÚUI2Q³GSvTWQ¸EÑICNSZ\PGJXJINCQ³Ü¯Svá7E%Ñ$C2CNØ)SZõNGJÔvXJIFYsT¯EeGgQRÑ$\PGLCFXrXLINá¥Ñ$GLÑQ¸Ñ$INYsELEYßEõ ß GLöEHS7QRQ³GLCNMUSWC2I2GJQRGL]PEQRYCNI2X SUSWEÝDßUQRCFÙ(KXJTP\o]PECNY-ÚPXLÑ$GJGJCNIN]PSZSZYgGJG,XJØQRXJIFSUYT¯T¯åZQRMPQ¸Ñ$ÑGLYI2CFSUGLXLÑ$CNá+áWXÑCNÔINØáELYÝ%Ý%E)]P]PÑY$QRI2GJÑr]PS]¤YÔoXI2YS7GJ]PT¯INQ¸MPE%Ñ$Y6GLINQRCNGJÑC+GJS7Q³CFTPÝS;I2INGJELE)I3]PGJCNQRINSPMUãN\PORYT+M¯SGÔvQRY6YS£XJÑrXLI¥]PCFCZXJÑEEHYÚYXLS+ÔPGJINM¯QRQ³S+GS£ÚoØC2ELM¯Q³Ø¶GJGLGJMPMUYXJSI2Y Ó Ú GLGL]PQRCNYSá¤T¯XJYY\o\PYXJSvYELTYSZCNGgSÑ$ÔPá¯MUÑELO³YsQ³SUE¬YQ³EJS÷ECNÔoX%YEHC2GGJ]P\PYXrX INÑ$Ñ$GLá¯Q¸Ñ$Ñ$YORYEEß Úö GLØ]PGLY]PSY¥GeIFÝDÑCkGJQ³ÑCFCNSUSZE¬GLXrGJININT¯ãNYQ¸ÑS¤GJQ³QRSUSÄÒ3IÑINÑ$ELYYXHEGrI2ÙkQRSðIá¥ELQ³YsGLINMUÑrI2] Ó ÔvÑINYELYÑEgCNXJQRXLE6YsÑQRSUG'IFI2ÑG Ñ$YsI2EL\PEL\UQRÔPXLO³CFYF\PÚXLGLQ¸I{]UGJYYS÷GLÔoQRÙ(C2GLYs]ÄEß Ñö INØELGLY]PE6Y(Ý%I{QRGHORGJO¨XLÔoQRÔPY¥M¯XLGJYY6GLGLXJ]vQ³YI{ÛNG YsTT¯ÚQ¸EHÔPGLQRM¯SPGgÒNMPGJ]PQ¸ELY]PXJYY¥E'Q¸ÔvE6YSPGeC7ÝDYÝYSIáGL]UGJCY EHYO³YsÑG)ÔoY$GeÝ,YYS;GL]UYÙß \PORINXLXLCFQ³Ge\vö á7S¼CZEHQ¸ELQREgSPMUÒùSPÑr]ñCNT¯GQjTPúI2CNYS÷ÙkXJYI2I2SZ\PQRG¥SU\UEXLELÚCFCN\PORIòM¯XLGLQ¸B,I{QRCNGJVSUYkÖE(EHYCFELO³X(Ysá¯ÑEeIFGLGJÑCFYGLX6Ù1QRCNC2SvØÝ,EGLÚ4CN]UMUI2Y¥SvORT½TóÔvYsXLIùEeYGGLEHXJÑQRQ³Ù3YINÛNEL\PYNYðORßYWIøô \USUO¸XLI2YkMPXJSUÒN\vQ³YùCZSPELÒùSELMPQ³ÔUÔUÙIFO³Y¥EHÔoYsYELTÄXCNORCNM¯C2SÅGLØ3QRCNÑEHSùIFQRÙ3EHGJYsQjC EÓ GLO³QR]PÙ3Q¸E,QjGr\PI{XLGLCFQRCNÔPSvORYEÙAç4ûvQRXJE¨EHGGLC-ÚELO³YQ³SvGÑ$IYWMUGLELCYC÷XT¯ÙkYI2ÑSQRT¯áøY ÑÔvINYELGeYÝDE3YI2YSkXJY;GJ]PXJY$Y¬GJXLÑQRINYELÛFYYE¨TXLÚYGJGL]PXJQ³YYÛNMUYsELTYßZXkK]U]UIFQRE(ED]UGLC÷INE,I2ELSvYI2ÛNORYáZXJïINY O I2I2ORÔPOQRO³C2Q³GeØá3GJ]PC2YØÙGJ]PüY EHYsMvÑ$EHCNYSvXÚZTEHÚPC(GJ]PI2Y-S¥IFYÑÜÑ$\oMUYXJXLIFGDÑ$Mvá¥EHYCNX¨ØÙkGJ]PIY-á3ÑÔvINY ELYgSPEHYYYsO³T¯YsYÑGJTQ³üCFO¸SINEH\PGLXLORáNC¯ÚFÑGLY]PEJE%Y QRC{E ÛNORYQ³XJÙ3INQ³O³GLOPYÝ,T7CNÔZXJãá;O³CZGLIN]UT Y CN\vS7YXHØIkCFXLMUÙ ELYX ÙkÙkINSZIMvá;I2INOÑ$ÑGLIFMUEHINY6O³ORELáWYORQ³YSUÑ$ÑGLXLQRYsCNINSELß Y6Ý%]PYSMvEHQRSPÒkGJ]PY-ELá¯EeGJYÙÚUÔoYÑI2MUELYgC2ØGJ]PYSPYYTWGJC ÕGLXJ]PYY6T¯ö ÔoMPS YSvGJEHTP]PG'I2YÑSUÝ,IFÑEHCNáYFXJßI2ã'SvÐ \PT-XJY6YÑY$ELáYܯÑSZ\oO³Q¸GJYÑ,YXJTSUQ³Ù3I{Q³S¬GJYMPSFGJXJ]PGrY,I2Q¸EORCNO³\Uá+ØINIFY$\vÑÜPGJYI2Q³XCFÙ3ÝDSUQREJY4SP×YMvGJTWEHC¬YsI(TTPYÛGLÛN]PINYXLY¨O³QRCFY$Ñr\(Ge]vákI2INXrCNS(INØ»ÑINYsGJM¯YåFGLXJMvCFQRI{EHÙkGLGLQ¸QRI{ÑCNGLEoSvYsCNE,TØZGLGJÝ]U]PII2Y¨á¬G%ÑÑGLINC6CNELÙ-Y4ELYÔUÔPORINYQ³SUÑ$ELYYG GLÑ$]PCNY¨Ù-ØÔPXLQRYsSPåFYMUYGJSU]PÑYáNELYkÚXJÑrY]UÑYI2SUXrINÑÑ$áNGLÚYINXLSUQ¸EeT6GJQRELÑQ³E)Ù3GJQRORC;INXLQRÙ3Q³Geá \PXJCNC{ØPÛNI)YÑXJIFY$EHGJYXLGJQRYC)Û{QRINTPO¢Yß SZÐ GLQ³ØY(áMvGLEH]PYsYDT£ÔvÒFYsYEeGSPY\oGLCFQ¸Ñ-EJELINQ³ÔPO³ÒFORYCNXJÝQjGJI]Pá)ÙkGJC E T¯Õ¢ý¬Qjúà'YXJErY×SZGLG%C¤ûPûUGJSPSUYTÄEJEGL]PÙ3YY$GJ\UXLINQ¸ÑXJEINÙ(ØCFYXGLYGL]PXJEYC2ý¬Ø)àGJ]Pß YELY;YsåZMUI{GJQ³CFSUEÚI2SvTÄY$ܯ\oYXJQ³Ù3YSFGJYTøÝ%QjGJ]øGeÝ,C \PB,XLV,C¯ÖâÑý¬Yà'EJÑEHCNECFÙ3XJ]UE\vIÛFÕCFYFY'SPß ÒvYÔoSZßYGrGLYEgC-SÕûUYFMUSUßELÒvT;Y߯T;GLGL]PCkQRS;Y¬\o\PÝ,YXJXLYYØQRCNÛÒNXJQR]ZCNÙ=GJMUE,E)ÑCNINB,ØELVELY¬Q³Ù3Ö¼IFTPQREHORI2INá¯\PXLEHGJQ³GLGeI{Yá3GJÙkQ³ØCFE,MPSvSUY×Q³Ñ$ßGLGL]UBDQRCNYCNSUX)SErINÛN×,E,YCNXJORX%ELCYCFINORáNELEDYÚUGJORB,á¥Q³ÒFV]FÑ$CNÖ¼GJO³MUá;\P]UO³Ñ$INYsCNE%T+MUÔo\P\UYO³XLYYsYST Ó MUþ EHMUYsT-Ñr]GLC6C2Ø»EHYGLY]PTkQ¸E%ý¬Ý,à'CNEXJãkGJC6QRE)XLYsTPT¯QREJMUÑ$ÑMUYDEJGJELY]PT;Y)I2Q³S7Ù3[CFYsMPÑSZGLGQRCNCNSØELÿPYÚvINõ XJXÑr](JYI2ÛSUQRCNT-MUGJE,]PÖ%Y%YsSEHMPYsÙI2XrÔoÑrY]X4ß õ CNØoÒFYSPYXJI2GLQRCNSUEß GLGLC;Q³Øá+ÑÐ O³EHQRQRYY3Ù3SZGrI2Q³O¸E\PI2ßo\UX%KO³ÑQR]PYINTY-ELYELCFE,]PMPI2QRX¬\PSUÙ3EHT¥á¯YGLEHSZCkGLGYINÙ ÑrEJ]UEHGJQRINÒNCWXJS¥IFI+ÑGLGJ]PORYINY6XJXLQRÒFI2EHGLY\UQ¸\PÑÑEXLIFCFEHÝ,\PY-YXJÔUXJQRI2YgINGLELMUY)YELÔPYCNQRTبORO³QRÔPÔSPQRá;ÒkO³ORQRGLÑ$SP]PC¯Ò;YkT¯XJYFB,Yß ÑVö CNSÖ XrTPELEHQjE%GJá¯MUØEHCFI{GLXYGJÙQ³ELCF]PSUGJQRE,\PC+Ù3Ý%Q¸T¯]PYYSZYS¯XJGJYEÓ EHý¬QRÙ3à%\PÓ~T¯O³YYXJB,Q³ÛFVYT7ÖñELXLYYORGLYXJÑ$Q³GLYQRÛCNINS7OYsXLYsåZEHMUMUI{OjGJGJQ³YCFT¥SUE'QRSXJYÑ$ELCFMPS¯O³æUGLYsQ¸ÑTGLQRQ³SPSùÒ3EHÔPYQRO³O³YsORÑQRSPGJQ³ÒkSPÒ+Ñ$C¯GLT¯]PYY3EÚÑ$GLCF]UXLXJY¬YINÑ$G \P\PELORCNQRORÑM¯I{GLGJQRQ³CNCFS7S;CFCNM¯ØG¬GL]UC2Y Ø GLGL]PXJQ³Y+YÛÑINCNOÙ3ØCN\oMPY$SvGLQRTùSPÒ£IWÑMPINSUELQRYåZE6MPQRYkSÄÔPéNQRORîO³QRSPFÒî Ñ$C¯CNT¯Ø,Y3GJQR]PSðYkINGJ\PQ³\PÙ3XJYNCß Ü¯Q³ö ÙkSðI{GLGJ]UYY¥OR á ÔvYs EeG3=ÑIFC2Ø,EHYFGLÚ]PEHY3QRÙ3\P\PXJCNORYWÔPORB,YÙkVE6ÖAINXLSUYT Ó GLC2]PØ,YkGL]Pý¬Ykà%\PÓ~XJT¯CNYÔUXJO³QRYÛNÙ3YT£EÚEHYXJO³YYsELÑMPGLOjQRGJCNQ³S¤SUÒWÑ$XJQRS÷QjGJYIXJQRI3Ñ$CNØÙ-CFMPÔPSUQRSPT7YTÄGL]Pì Y3 Ñ$ CFXLINXJYÑÑ$Ñ$G MPXrÑ$INC¯ÑT¯áY-üvQ³GJSù]PYkI2\PXJ\PYÙkXJCI2ܯQRQ³SPÙkQRSPI2Ò7GLYíOR á Nî C2 Ø
GLC2]PØ-Y-EHGJ\PINXLSUCFTPÔPI2ORYXrÙkT½E)B,XJVYÙkÖ>I2QRXJSPY$YsGLXJTQRYMPÛ{SUI2ELOCNÝ%ORÛNQjYGJT]½ßXJô Y$MPGJXLX QRYY$Û{ܯI2\vOYMUXLQRELÙ3Q³SUYÒÄSZGJGLE]UELYð]PC{ý¬ÝDà)YsÓ`T;ÒFYGLSP]UYI2XJG'I2GLGL]UYTYQRÑSFINGJELYY¤ÒFXJELI2YGLORQRYCNÑ$S Ó GLÔPQRQ³CNORORS¥Q³SPÑ$Ò(XJQ³Ñ$GLC¯YXJT¯Q¸YsIE ÑÕ CNYNSUß ÒUELQ¸ßREeÚNGJØYXJSZCNGLÙ ORá(IN SUâT3GJT¯C3XrI2ì Ùk (I{GJ×QRßZÑI2KOR]PO³ágQREQRÚSUQ³ÑS¥XLYsGLINMPELXJYST-ÚZGLQ³SU]PTPY QRÑINI{ÑGLÑYsMPT3XrINGLÑ$]váI{GC2çZØûUGL]PXrEHY GÚZEHYQ³S+O³YsÑÑGLINYsELT Y ÔUÑr]UINI2ELYXrINEÑ$Ý%GLY]PXJQ¸Q¸ÑrEe]kGJQRÑ$ÑCNE%SZGLGr]vI2I{QRSGgXJI2YXJT¯YMPSPSvCNTPGI2\vSZGI2XLI2GSUCNT(ØÑ$GLCF]PSZYkGLXrÑININT¯ELQ¸Y;ÑGJÕCNQRSùXJáC2QRGLS¯]UØCFYX¬XLÙkÝDI{CFGJXJQ³TUCFESÚvGJGL]U]PI{Y3G4Ñ$Q¸E4CFSZT¯GLMPXrYINT¯GJC¬Q¸ÑGJÑCNINXJELáY Q³ÔvS¯Y6ØCFÑ$XLCFÙkÙI2ÔPGLQRQRSPCNYsS¥T¥Q¸E¨GJC(SUC2QRÙ3GDQR\PSUXJÑC{CNÛNXJY'XLYsXJÑY$GrGJ×$XLÚ2QRYGJÛ{]PINY'O¢ü¯ØXJI2YSvåZTMPÚPYEHSUYsÑ$Ñ$áFCFÚFSUXJTYÑÚPYý¬SUà'Ñá(E%ININSUXLY¬T¥I2ELSWQ³Ù3I2QR\PORIN\PXLXJQ³GeCNá(\UXLC2Q¸ØI{GJIY'ÑÙ3INELY$Y'GJ]PÑC¯INST GLC6Q¸T¯YSZGLQ³Øá-GL]PY%\UINXJINÙ3Y$GLYXJEMUELYT(QRS¥Ñ$CFÙÔPQRSPQRSPÒGL]PYsEHY%Û{I2ORMPYsE4Q³SkINS(Y ¥Ñ$QRYSZG¨ÙkI2SPSUYXsß Ë 4ÏLÈ=Ë HÏH!Î ÉPÏeËDÈ ÔPKBDQ³]PCNORORÙ3YùQ³SP\UÒðIFI2ÑSGJÑ$MUC¯áÄI2T¯OÕ¢Y+&V \PØ"CNXJCNX3'[ ÔP$4EHOR]U)×YÙQ³\P(ßÙ3CFKYMP]PSFX;GrY3E(XJÔPYÔZQRELORáùYO³QRINSPGJXJÒ]PÑr]òYWÑ$C¯V,IFT¯TPMPY3T¯XJORXJQRQ³S£YSPEJÒNEHGJGLYsMPCFTäXLS#SùÝ,")Q¸IFT¯CFE¥YXHSZGJGJGL]PCóQ³ûUYXJYsMvSøEEHYÄGLI2]PSvB,Y3TóVY$[¯Ö ÜPINIFSFÑGLGrG6CÅI%T¯QR$UTPQ³ÛYYWQ¸SZEHÖ)QRGLCNQ³INØSùá Q³ORC2ÝGLØ,]UIáIY \UÔZáóI2XLGLV&Q¸Ñ$"MP['O¸I2$ÞX3YÑ$Ù(CFÙ3\UO³\UC{I2áFSYáðYE-GLY$]vÜPI{ÑG¥Y\¯EH]UGkCNQRMPSÅO¸TøÑINÔoELYYE(ÔPÝ%QRO³OR]PYYTøXJYNØÚCNXkØCFIðX¥I£EH]UÛ{Q³\PI2Ù3XJQRY$YGeSFá÷GsßC2KØ]PXLYYsINÔPELCNQRO³SUORQ³ESUÚ»ÒùGL]PQ¸E3YáøT¯CNI2SUXJYY GLSPIN]PÑC2Y¥ÑGCNQRELMPSUMPSZÑXJGJCNY(Q³XJSPXLÝ%Ò¤Ys]UÑEHGgQRá¯Ñr]ðÑ$EHGLC¯YÔPT¯Ù QRYFO³ORÚQRØSPGLCN]PÒ7X(YkÑ$Ñ$ÔUC¯CFQ³T¯XLORXJO¨Y(YQ¸Ñ$GLE6GLC7QRXJCNIN+Y S*e\PYß\PÑ$ô ORGLáNYsMUßT¤X-à'ÔELORá£áELCUEHGLGLÚ]PYQRÙ#Y¥S÷ÑEHÝDO³CFQRYCFÙ3SZMPY3GORT÷ÚÑI2INIFSUELELYTùELEQRÒNÚXJSðY$GLGJ]PMPGLYk]UXLSvY;YEÙ3Ñ$GLCF\PCXLO³C{XJGLYáF]UÑ$YY+GgYsE¬ÔP,V YQR" O³SZORQ³GL'[ SUY$ Ò X GLÑ$EeGr]PC¯I{Y-T¯GLY(YÝ%Ù3GLXLCCFYSPSZELGJÒ+]PEQ³Ñ$\U\oC¯Ù(YT¯X)YYFSZÙ3ßoGJà ECFSFÑGLÑGJ]vCN]I{Xrß G6T¯Q³YSUQ³GLÒk]PGLYC+X6,V ]UIN"T£'[ $ÅSPCGL]PÑ$C¯YXLT¯Y-Y3I2CNXJX¬YÝ,I2\PYXJ\UY-XLCXJܯY$QRGJÙ3MPXJI2SPGLYYT£O³ á Ôv 2YsîNÑîFI2îkMvEHEHY(MvÑrGL]7]UYÔPá7QRO³OR]UQ³SUIFTÒ CNI2XJSUQ³T3ÒF- Q³CNSUINGLI2Ñr]PGL]kYQRSPX¨ELÒ(]PT¯QRCNO³\PC¯Ùk\PÑQRI2INSPGLQ³ÒgS¯QRCNÓ~XJSELY\vÚPÑ$YsTPCFÑ$YXJQ³T3EHûvGLÑ%QRÑSUCNQRS¯I{SUGJØELCNQ³QRCFXJEHSÙkGJEÚI{C2GLGLXrØQRI2CNI6SUS(ELÛNGJQ³YGC2XLGJá-\oINCNO³ORQRQRINSPSZXLGJÒ6ÒFEY%C{Ú¯ÛFSGeáYMPXD\vÙY¬ì{ÔoîFCNYî6ØXDI{ÑC2GLI2ØGLXJXJI{ÒNQ³GLCUÔPGLMPÚFXJQ³GeGLÔUáYM¯E\vßFGLY6YsV,E¨CN"ØT¯['ÑYsI2$£ELÑX%XLÙkMUQRÔPINELQRYQ³SPS¯TÒ Ó Ú GJÿNI2îNQRîUSUÚ EîFîNI)îÙ-ÔPMPQ³ORO³ORGLQ³Q³SPÓ¢GJÒkYXrXJI2YÔÑCNáZXrGLTPYEDTP\vI{GrYI2X)ÔUÙ3IFEHCNYSZCNGL]ØUß\UINQRTÔPQ³ORO¸EGJ]UI{G4ãFYY\vEÒFXLC{Ý%QRSPÒ'I2GIN\P\PXJCÜQRÙkI{GJYORá ÑÙ3$CNINSZQ³GrKSZI2Gr]PQRI2SWYgQRSPQRTPSUYI{TÑGrCNI2C{XJÔUÛFXLIFYsYÑEHXY¬GLORI¥á¥CNØORYCN\USFSPINGJÒ;YQRTWXJ\vYYÔPTWXLQRQRORQRC¯ORS¯E'TØCNQRE%C2XJÙkØÙ3GJI{CZQ³GLÙ3EeQRGJCNYFO³SáWÚÑINÑ$YCNSUXLXJTWGJXJINYÔPQ³ÑS7Q³GsORORÚ¯ÔUQ³SPÔPQ³ORÒ¥M¯O³QRG)SPÑC¯ÒWGJ]PT¯Ñ$YYC¯XJEYgT¯ßvY[I2E QRXJSUY¬]UÑ$IXLYgÛFYsÑ$GLY-]PCFÑrXJY]UTPTUINESPI{QRGJÒNSINYsÔUQjTG'INÚvGLELIN]UY¬SUI2QRT GE GLÔv]PY¬YsMUEHY3ELYÑrT]U'ß I2$SUQRÒNSUYI2E ORO³ORáFYÚ¯INT¯T7MPGLXJCWQ³SPÔPÒ3QRO³Ñ$ORYQ³SUXHGrÒWI2QRÑS+CTP\oYYE XJQ³GLC¯]UTPI2E,GgCNI2ØXJGLY]PYSPCWáNYsO³I2CFX,SPÒNQjG%YXQ¸E,IF\vÑCZÑMPELELXJQ³I2ÔUGLO³Y(Y I2GL]USUI2T¤GDEHGJ]P]PCFY¬MPÔPO¸T7QRO³ORSPQ³SUCNÒ G Ñ$C¯T¯YEÝ%QROROÑr]UI2SUÒNYNÚPELC-GL]UI2G)ÔPQ³ORORQ³SPÒkSMPÙ-ÔvYXJEÙkIá¥SUC(ORCNSUÒNYX%ÔoYgÑ$CFXLXJYÑ$Gß Ù(\PXLYYSZÛKGQ³CF]PÚPMUYgELYE]PORYÔPQRÑÒNQRO³G,]¯ORQ³Ó«GLSUOR]UYÒYÛNÑYINIFO\PEHÒN\PYsCZE%XJI2CNÕO\PQ`ß CNXJYFQRØ4ßNI2\UCNGLY MPINQRX6ÔPT(Q³B,ORÔPORV,Q³QRSPO³O¸ÖÞÒ3Er×Ñ$ELßFC¯á¯KT¯Ee]UGJYYY'ÙÔT¯ák.Q Ý,kÙkIFÑI{EMPGJO³ØÑrGeI2]Uá-QRQ³XJSPÝO³áÒ(INEEHQ³GQRGJÙ3IN]UÒF\PI{I2ORG¨YNQRQRSUçoS¥EHÒNG¨ELQRÛNC¬GJY]PTPSY6CNIkQRTPSPI{SUÒ6GrYI2CNÝÞÔUMPIFXDEHEH]UEHY á¯Q³\¯C2EHÓÓØ GLCNYXgÙ SPCNÝ,GCNMPÛ{I2O¸T3ORQRTùXLYØGLCFXJQ³XgYÛNGJ]PYY+ÙkÑ$I2MUSXLáXJYÔUSZQ³GORO³QRÑ$SPá¯ÒÑO³ÑY¥C¯T¯CNYØ%ECNØ\oXLCFYXrÙ I{GLÑQRCNIFSvEHYsEEß GLÐ ]vI{]PG¨YSøÝ,YT¯XJQ¸Y%ELÑYMUQ³GLEJ]PEHYQRSPXÒCNO¸GLT]UÚFY+Q³SU\PÑXJCNCNXJÔPXLYsORYÑÙ GsÚ Ý%Ñ$XJQjQjGJGJ]gYXJGLQR]UI¬Y,GJ]P,V Y" á3/[ Ý,$CNÔPMPQ³O¸ORTkORQ³SPMUÒELY)Y$ܯGJCg\oYXJXLYGJELECNGLORÛN]PY'Yá6INSZQ³Svá3T¯Ñ$QRCFÑI{S¯GJæUYQ¸T6ÑGrGJE]UçFI{GLG]PY1GL]U03Y2 XJ46Y¨5'Ý,79Y8XJYCNX;GeÝ,:=C'8>?Ùk5@I 8*eACCFBX»D(ELYINORSUYT3ÑGJGLQ³CF]US Y ]UT38ACÔoBYDWYSkC2ØDMUEHI+YsT3ÔPQ³Q³ORS3ORQ³SPGJÒW]PY)S\UMPIFÙEeÔoG¨YÑXsCNß MPö \US£O³YsCNT3GL]PÝ%YQjX GJ]kÝ,]PCNC{XrÝóTPEXJÚvY]PÑC{YÝÞSZGLORÙkágINGJSZ]PáWY'SGJQ³MPÙ3Ù-YÔvE¬YI+X]UÔPIFQ³ORT3ORQ³SPÔvÒWYYSSkMPMUÙELÔoYYTX ß F H  G% Ibs}¯nJcHf$henrDf cHfiupcebfl3_ZnJh¢ªbce©gªihe9w JKJ2® LKLKL¬cebtFhend6iupunriuM_ G,bc~hew3ÁDd6nLceijqrf
DÙB áMUÑÑrKO³]¤Q¸]PÑ)O³Y£YsÔUELQ³Ñ$ORE'O³CFQRØÙSPXLÒ(YsÔPåZQRÙ3MPSUYI2YSUI2GLQRSvÑCNáESäGJGL]UC2]UI{جING%S£GL]UEHCFCFYORÙ3ELT¯Y7YY'X GeXJÝ,CFYÑ$C÷SPYYSZ\UE'GDI2GLXrÔP]vI2QRI{O³Ù3ORG¬QRSPY$ÝDGJÒ-YYXrXJXLEkYY-ÑQ¸ÒNCNE¥YXrSUTPSPYECNXrG;Ý,I{GLCNEeYsGJMUTXJORINTkC{Q³ÒFÛNÔo]ZYY¬GHX ØÑ$CNI+CNXJXJÝO³XJCFYI2SPÑXrÒ+GsTÚNÚ\oÔPYGLMP]PXJG,Q³CFC¯]UMPT£IÒNÛF]C2Y Ø ß GLÔZQRá÷Ù(,VYFß" ô [/Sù$ñGL\o]UYY¥XrELCNCN\PSP\oSPCFYELODQ³GLINYkSUTÄYSvELT]PÚ»CNIMPO¸XJTðYÑSPYCNSZG-GgSPXLYsYsÑ$Ñ$CFYEJXJEJT¤I2XJÙkQ³ORIá£á£C{ÔoÛFY+YXJXLEHQ¸QRÙ3T¯Yk\PÛNORá£CFO³QRMUSUÙ(Ñ$CFQRSPXLXJCFYMUÑ$E6GLORá7ÔPM¯YG3SZGLCNYO¸XLT¯YsYT X XLYsÑ$CNKXrXrTPINET¯ß Q³GLQRCNSvI2OvÑINELY)ÔUIFEHY Ù3INQ³SZGJYSUINSUÑ$Y%GJYÑr]PSUQRåZMPYsE¨Ý,YXJY)C2Ø»SPC]PYO³\ÚZELQ³SvÑ$Y)GJ]PY¬Ñ$CNSPÓ æUÑ$CNQRÑ$SvGLT¯QRSPQjGJÒøQ³CFÑSUINEELÚYINE3SUÝ,TÄYELXJMUYNÑrÚ]óQRS ÑáÙ3ÑCFO³YsEHEG;INEHSUQ³GLTøMvI{ÑGLCNQRCNSUSvT¯EQ³GLÚ¨QRCNÑSvCNEXJXLÝ,YsÑYG3XJY¥ØCNSPX;CNT¯G3QjúÑCNYSUXJYELSZQREHG+GLYÔUSZQ³G(ORO³QRINSPÑÒøXLCZÑELá¯EÑ$I2ORYORE¥O,ÑINMUSUEeT Ó GLI+CNÑ$Ù3MvYEeXJGJECNÚPÙ3SPYCFX X%Ù(ÝDC{YÛFXLYYTWGL]UGJYYáÙ3I2\vORCFÝ,XJIINá¯XLQREORá+T¯YGJ\oC;YI¥SvT¯SUYYSZÝ G'CFINSTUT¯IXLÛ{YsINELQ³EO¸ÚUI2ÔPXJYORY¬åZMPQ³SPQRXJØQ³CNSPXJÒ;Ù3I¥I2GLSPQRCNYSðÝÞÕ¶SZØCFMUX)ÙY$ÔoÜPYI2XsÙ3ÚoIN\PSUORYNT Ú GL\v]PYYSPS(YT6Ù3QRC{SgÛFSPYC T-\PÔUXJINYÑrT¯ã¬Q¸ÑGJGrC¬I2GLÔP]PORY4YQ³Ø X4INCFEL]PXLQRQRÒNCNQRSvSU×$I2ßOKC]PkY,ÑÑYIFEEHÚ{YXLYsÔvåZINMPELY¨Q³XJQRT¯SPQ¸ÒT6GLSP]PC2Y%G»CF]UORIT-ÛNYSMPCFÙÔUELÔoCNYORY$XsGLÚ{Y¨ÔPQ³M¯S¯GØCFGJ]PXLÙkQ¸EI2]UGLI2QRCN\¯S Ó GLÑ]UINI2ELYG,EÑ$ß4CFKMPCðO¸TkÑÔvINY¬\¯GLELMUQ³Ù3XLY\PORI2á3ORO%\PXLXLMUMUO³SPYsYE(TINüZSUQ³G,TÄÑ$QRCFS¯SZØGJCFI2XLQRÙkSPYsI{TkGJQ³CFÑ$SøMPXJXLXJYYSZÒZGI2ÚXrT¯EHCFQ³SUÙ(Ò7YGLGLQR]UÙ3YYTPE¨Y$ÑûUCNSPS¯Q³ævGLQRQRCNÑ$GLSÅQRSPC2ÒUØÚZÔPÔPQRQRO³O³ORORQ³Q³SUSUÒÒ Ñ$á¯Ñ$ORYE%INSUT;Ñr]vI2SPÒFYEÝ,CNMPO¸T+ÔoYgI(ÛNYXLákYÜ\oYSvEHQRÛNY6I2SvT;YXLXJCNXLÓ«\PXLCFSPY)YÜYXJÑQRELYNß N OQPSRUTVXWF É Y; ÝDXLKYsY]PåFQ³YMUÒF]FQ³ÔUXJGJYINYTWELT¤Q¸ÑI(SPÔPYB,INQ³VORXLORYsQ³Ö SPEeGLÒ3Ó`ELSUSáYMPEHQRGLÙ-ÒNY]Ù ÔvÔvYCFX)ØX¬CNI2X+Ù3SUT;XLI2YGJGLGLÑrXJ]U]PQ³Y¬YQRSPÛÑINÒINOELC2YC2Ø)EØí2QRGLS+î+]PYGJØ]PYI2Ù3Y6GLCFÔPMPEHQRXJO³G+YORQREgSPELQ³C2ÒkÙ3بXLQRGJYsOR]PINÑ$X¥Y+CFXJÑELT;]PINELÑQR\PYINE3\PELYQRMvSPÔUEHÒYsINTóXLELYsYNÑ$ßI÷CNÐ XrELT£Q³YÙ3QRGLÒN\P]U]ZORI2GJYNGE Ú GLÝDÝ,XJYIFQ³ÔPXLEYMPÑ$GLCFTPYSUY$EGLEHGJQ¸YT¯]UXLYÙ3I{XLGYsQRSPÝ,T YYELT7XJQ³Ù3Y,ÔZMUQRáOREHINYs,V XT" ÝQR'[INS-E$ÅGLÛ{]PYI2Y%ÜXJQRÙk\oYYTI{XLGrGJY$ÑrE ܯ]P\oC2QRSPYØXJÒ GJQ³]PÙ3\UY-XLYC¯SZT¯Ñ$GrCFYsI2ÙkELOREO³I2á ß{QRKSÔv]PYÚvGeY,Ý%ÝDGL]UY]PC+YXJS3YI2ELëO¸]PEHI2C;CFSUORT-T¯T6Y$C{îUGJÛNYß YXJÙ(X»QRS¬Ý%QRSPQ³]PSvYsQ¸TWÑ$ÑrXJ]3YGL]PÙ3IY(ÑYINSZI{ELGJGHYEÓ GLC2XL]PYØ4GLYîPXJQ³ß ELYîFQ³ÛNíÙ3YGLTøQRORCkINI¤XLQ¸T¯Q³GeO¸Yá÷I2SZXJGJGLÒNQj]UYØáWXLX-YsI2ELEHY$]PSGkCFá¥ORC2TøGJجXLYO³EHYsSUQRTÄÙ3TPE%Q³GJO¸CùQRI2SX3GLXLXJÑYQ³IFÛGLEHXJQ¸YsI2Q³YE3O)ÛI2INI2SvO¢SUß TøTøö SY]UÜINGJ\o]PTøYQ¸E%Ñ$ØYGL\UYsÝ,I2TøYXLX3GLXJQ¸YÑ$QRSPMUELMP\PORINO³M¯GJX)GrEE(çI2\PIùGL\P]UORORI2C{Q¸ÑG3ÝDI{YXJGJY$Q³X(CFGJS;XLGLQR]PYÛ{XJÛFINYYELXLT÷]PáCNQRSUSPO¸TCÒ EHQRÙ3Q³ô O¸I2SUX)Ñ$Y(ÑINGLEL]UYY¥Eß Q³SUQjGJQRINOÙkI{GJÑr]UQ³SPÒQ¸E6Ñ$CFÙ3\PO³YGLYFÚ»IWÔPQRO³ORQ³SUÒ7Ñ$C¯T¯YkQ¸EgINEJEHQRÒNSUYT¤CNSPORá£Q³ØINO³O GLGLXL]UYYÙ¥GLI2XJG,Q³×$Yßo]UÛNô'INY\PTGL\o]PÑYYINSUXLELÝ%E,YEQ¸QRELS;INY ÔvI2GJC{\U]PÛF\PY6YXLÑCGLIFܯ]UEHQRYYsÙkE%ÑI{M¯I2GLGHXJYÓ«YO³C2Zá úkINSUGJ I2]PORXJáYïELC2Y]PØT;CNGJO¸]PÔTgY á+]U\UINIXLTUÛFCFYT¯ÔPQjGJGJO³]PYQ³CFÙkY%SUELEDI2INOELÙ(MP\PÔPY,XJC¯Ù3ÔPÑ$QRQ³YsO³GHORELGLQRELSPYsQ³TkÒ6SUÒ-Ñ$GJCC¯Ý%T¯GJ]PY¬]PQ¸Y6ÑrÕ EL]B,CNÙ3MUVELY$ÖñYGJE,]PEHGLQ³á¯SU]UEHÒY Ó SPý¬Ckà%EHÓ~QRÑ$Ù3XJYQ³I{O¸I2GJX)YT¤ÑINEHELYYO³E%YsÑI2GLXJQRCNYSùO³YÑ$ضG)XJQjØGJCNYX%XJQRMUIUELÚoYIFXrE¬EDT¯GLC¥YEJT¯Ñ$XJYQ³GLÔoYYXLÙ3T¤QRSPSPYYÜZGLGs]PßYgVDINQROR\PO³QR\PSPXJÒCN\P\PXJXJQRCNI2ÔPGLYORYÙkÔPQRE O³ORQ³GLSU]UÒ¥I2GÑ$C¯XJT¯Y$YNGJXLß QRYÛFY [ \]YX È Y/Ê É¯ÏLXÈ ^_`YaÏ ^bD'É YcÌ T,Ë LÍ%ÉPÏe˨dÈ T&Y;+YÎoÉPÏeËDeÈ O¤ÊvÏ~'É YÊUaÏ GLÐ\P]PQRÑrY%]PãYELßUSkáà EHB,GLE)YV,Ù Ù3ÖÄYELSZXL]PYGJCNGLQ³MPCFXJQ³SPO¸YTYÛNTELYYÚPTORGLYT¯]PÑ$QjYGúÚ{YELCFYXJMPYORYX4SZÑ$GEHGLá¯QRÔPCNEHQ³SGLORORYQ³ÙC2SPØÒ¬SPGLÑ$]UYC¯YsYgT¯TPYsÙ3E»EGLCFÚsC6OREHYG'T¯INI2YTP\PÑQ³SPQR\PTPÒ)XJY,CNGLÝ%\UC¬XL]UÑ$Q¸I{QRCNÑrGJSP](Y¬æUC2ÑQRÑ$ØvINGJELGLEYg]PINYEHE]UÔPGLCNQRC O³MPORQRGLO¸SPTW]PÒ6YÔvÑ$EHYgC¯CFO³T¯ÔvMPYINGLE»ELQRCNYGJSTC CN]US£INE¬I;ÔoÑ$YCNYÙ-SùÔPMvQREHSUYsI{TUGJ×Q³CFÚSINSUC2TùØ4GLQjGr]UE6Y-EHXJQRYÙ3ÑYQ³O¸SUI2ÑXJá;QjGeáCNØGJCGL]PGLY-]PYkÔPQRÑO³ORMPQ³SUXLXJÒWYSZÑING6ELÔPYNQRÚUO³ORQ³QRGJSPE'ÒØXJ\PYXLåZCFMPÔPYORSvYÑ$Ùá÷ßÕà,]PGgC{ÝÞQREJELCNMPضGLY3YÝ,S£IFQ³GE ]PC{ÝÄGJC¬ÑCNÙ-ÔPQ³SUYDGJ]PYELY%\UINXJINÙ(YGLYXJE»Q³SkIÝIá6GL]UI2G4O³YsTGJCGL]PY)ELYORYÑ$GLQRCNS(C2ØoGL]PY%Ñ$CFXLXJYÑ$G
ÔPMUQ³EHORQRORSPQ³SPÒ3Ò(ÒNÑYIFSPEHY$YFGJßQRÑ6Ð INY'O³ÒFY$CNܯXJ\oQjGJY]PXJÙkQ³Ù3E¬YSFÕ¢ý¬GJYà'T3ErÝ%×ß Q³GL]WT¯QjúYXJYSZG¨YsåZMUI{GJQ³CFSUE¨INSUTkÝ,YQRÒN]ZGLYsT3\UI2XrI2Ù3Y$GJYXrE VDYØCNXJY%ÝDYT T¯Y+
+
f!S ÿPß%àÞEeGJY\WØMPSUÑ$GLQRCNSWØCNX%XJYÑYSUÑáç =+(E
=
jxv Ð YgINORELC(TPY$ûUSPYsT;GeÝDCkELQ³Ù3\PORY6XLYGLXJQ³YÛ{I2OÙ3Y$GL]UCTUEGLCkÔoY6MUELYTWINE%Ñ$CFÙ3\UI2XJQRELCNSvEç í¯ëNßß Ý%þþ ]PCFCFCNEHEHORG%G¥Y6XLØEHYsXJYYÑ$G)YåZSFMPC2GsØYçvSFXL[GsYçYGLXJO³[¯YsQ³YÑYÛNGORYYsGLÑT+]PG+Y6ÑGLIFÔU]PEHQ³Y¤YsORO³E QRÔPSPQ³ÒkORORQ³SSPMPÒóÙ-SÔvMPYÙXÔoGL]UYX+I2G)GLQR]UE%I2QRGWSWI2GL\U]P\vY6YsÙ3I2XrCZEkEeG%Ù3XJCFYEHÑ$G+YSZC2G%ضGJÑYINSòELY QRS GL]UY I2EHQRÔoÙ3C{Q³")ÛNO¸YNI2Y$XJß ÜQjG+GeÐ áÝ,YGLY7]PXrXJI2MUYSäELEL]PYSPTòCFQRORSPTý¬Y7ÕHà ëNT¯EkÚFQ³úoîUGJYß C÷FXLéPYûUSFÚNSUG¥îUTäß YFܯÿPGJ\v]PÚ2YîUY7XLß QR\UÙ3UINÚNYXJîUSZINGJßÙ3ZEí¯Y$ÚGLÚNCNYINSUXJSUE¥YTkC2YîPجINß ÑrNGL]óîZ]P×Y¤Øß CNÐ EHX¥Q³ÜÅY'I÷XJYsTPYåZ\oQjMUúYI{YI2GJXJGLQ³YYCFSZT(SUG¥E¥CFÙkMPT¯X¨YsI{ELܯYÑÜQRXLÙ\oQRÔvYMPXJYsÙ Q³T Ó ØÙ(Ý,MPIFYSUESZÑGJGJÔUEQ³INCFMvELS¤YEHT-QRCFSPS£CNÒ6SPGJGeOR]PÝ,áYkCCFEHST¯YQ³O³GJúoYs]PYÑY)XLGJYQ³\oCFSZYS£GXrÑ$ûPC2YGLبSFSUGLGrY]PI2EJY¥ÒFEYDØINMPCN\PSvØv\PÑGJXJGL]PCNQRY%\PCNSvXJ\PQREXJI2ÚNCNGLGLÔPYCORELYQRCNÙkSORÛNM¯EYsGJGLEeQ³]vCFGJQ³SI{ÒZGßI{Ý,GLKYY]PXJGJY-Y]PY)ûUELCNXJYEHORúoÛNG¬YsYsûPÑT-GDGLSUÑCNCNYØXJEJGLXLE']PYsØÑY'MUGJûPO³SUá+GLÑSPGJÕ Q³Q¢YsCFß ELYNS E ß GLÝDÙ3]PYI2Y6XLGJY'\oÑr]PIFYQRXrELSPÑ$ELÒ÷QRYÒNSFSPÛ{GrYsI2I2TÒFORMPY GJY7]PCNY CNØجGLÑ]UCNGLY6XJ]PXLY7\PYsÑXL]UGCFQ³ÔPÔPÒFOR]PQRYORYO³ÙkQREHSPGHEÒgÓ«XJEHSINCFSPMPO³ÛFãNÙ-YYsTWÔvTóYÑ$XrÑCN×$INXJßZELXJKYYÑ]PGLGJY ]UO³ákI2EHYsG+Ý%Ñ$Q³]UCNGLSvIF];TÅT(GL]UûPGLYgGL]PSPY£T¯YsQjELÑúECNYXJØXJMPXLYYsSUSvÑÑ$Ñ$G+GLY¬QRELCNÔvCNS+YORM¯GeÑÝDGLCNQRÙYCNYS ÔUSWQ³INSPGLSU]UYsTT Y GLGL]P]PY;Y3ÒNÙ3CZI2I2GJOÑrÝ,]PQRIFSPE)Ò7GJÛ{C;IN]vO³MPIY;ÛNY(C2Ø]PQ³GLÒF]U]¤Y+IF]PÑQRÑ$ÒNMU]PXJYsIFEeÑ$GLÓ`áXrI2ÔPSUM¯ãNGgYTðI2O¸ELÑC¥INELGLYkCWGL\P]UMPI2SUG-QREL]U]¤IFTÄQRSUI2ÑCNS÷XJXLQRSUYsÑÑGCNXJELXLCNYsORÑM¯GGJQ³ELCFCNSUORE M¯GLGLQR]UCNI2SG ü ØÙ3Ñ$MPCNI2SUMUGJÑSFÑrGJGg]PQ³CFYs\oSUT+YEXL]UüUØCNQ³EHÒFQRXJSU]PÙ3ÑO³áFY¬Y'ßTùGL$»]PEHQRY6QRÒNÒNMUûUSUXLGLQjY(ûvSPÑYsë6I2ELESZEH]PGLØORMUC{á7Ý)SUÑÝ,E¨GJCNGLQ³CF]UXrS;EHY6YFGJC{Ú]UÛNÝDI{YY3G'XrI2Ý%GJORI2OvQRãFO³ELO¨YCNEORCNM¯SPCFGJORSPQ³á¤CFO³á+SWT¯Q¸\vIFEJÑYÑ$Ñ$XJMUMUÑEJYXJE¬SZIFG'CNÑ$á(MPÑ$XCFØCNXLXLXJX,YsYEHGLÑ$MP]UGLO³SPY GJYsE¬GeELÝ,MvE,C-EHQRQRSFSPûPGJÒGLC¥SPGLINYs]UELÑ$YEÓ EHYsÑ$CNKSv]PT¥Y+ûPÒFGJYSPSPYYEJEGLQ¸Ñ+ØMPI2SvORÑÒNGLCFQRCNXLSQ³GLß]UÙ ÝINEXLMPSÄØCNXWëîNîFîÒNYSPYXrI{GJQ³CFSUEg\oYX(Y$ܯ\oYXJQ³Ù3YSZGsß - INÑr] ÒNYSUYXrI{GLQRCNSW\oCN\PMPO¸I{GJQ³CFSÑ$CNSvEHQ¸EeGJYTWC2بíNîNî(Q³SvT¯Q³ÛQ¸T¯MUINOREßUK]PY6ORQ³ãFYORQ³]UCZC¯T;ØCNX Ñ$XJCFEJEHC{ÛFYX
Comparison of Fitness Functions
1
0.9
0.8
Correct Solution Rate
0.7
0.6 Fitness Function 1
0.5
Fitness Function 2 0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0 1
0.98
0.96
0.94
0.92
0.9
)dg¿ f$tZhe¡qL~wFnr»iu¡ _Zzbsx _Zbshepd6y wNce}ZhenrwZf~cenwZiu~b}¯bspjnJl-_¬ceqra¸bnrba_{cDhehHwZqrffnxs~n¨bn)sb~nJaUnrcHpuqrfnrbpuqJp2c~hececeiunJnrbsqJ~_khtZpiu~hebpjputNbbªaheiuhenJbswFce_ZnnlPh`f§ª_b,l¬¹Z}¯henL_Fc~nra¸~bced6a¸tF_ZqJ~iuhexsiub_F_Ziu¹Zrq§f¿3_{Iheiphey¬_Znrª~bceIZ~nDtF_ZfqJ»heheiubwF_ n Ý,ÝDYùIFE Ý,IN(SZ\vGLYYT XJÑYGLSZCäGÚvT¯I2Y$SUGJYT;XJÙ(GL]UQRSPYgYùO³QRãNÝ%Y]PO³QRY]PXJCYùC¯T¥YSUØÑCFCX)TPÙYT½MPGJIFI{E+GJQ³CFÔUSQjG7Ý,EHIFGLE¬XJQ³SPë6ÒZ\vEYß,XJ$PÑYCFSZX;GßUYÜPKI2]UÙ3Y6\P\UORYNI2Ú,XrI2ØÙ3CNXWY$GJGLY]UXrY E Y$i¨Ü¯Ú \vvCFSPÚDYINSZS GJQRINO³ü4ORá3ØCFÝDXkYGLQ³ÒF]P]FY£GJYO³QRT(SPYØXJINYXLåZORáøMPYÝ,SUÑ$Yá3QRÒN]ZYåZGJYMUTÅI2GLXLQRCNYsÑ$SYÚFSUGLÑ$]UáÄYYsý¬åZà½MUI{GLGJXJQ³Q³CFYsST3Ú4GLGLC]UûUY¤SUý¬Tkà GJ]PYGLXJ\UQRYI2TóXrI2GLÙ3C÷Y$ûvGJYSUXrT E GL 2]PîNY(îù\UÑI2IFXrEHI2YsÙ3E-YØCNGLX3YXrGLEXriDI2QRÚSPvQRSPÚÒ÷I2SvI2TSUTÅGL]UI2Y(SUC2ÑM¯GL]UGLCNYX3ú÷CNTUSPI{YGLY3CNT¯Ø Q¸ NEeGrîNI2îùSUÑÑYNINüoELYY$E-GrÑ2Øß CFÐX3GLY3YEHMUGLELQRYSPT£ÒvßI;KÑ]PINYELYGLÔUXrI2IFQREHSPY-QRSPC2Ò Ø ÔGLvÑ]PINYYgELGeYÝDELE'YCNYÝDORM¯SðYGLXLQRGLY-CNXrSI2I2QRß ÒFSPINQRSPQ³SÒT¯EHQRMUÛÔ¯QRTPÓ«ELYY$TGrE¬QRSZØGLCNC¥XûvYINÛNÑrY-]ðELMPÒFÔ¯YSPÓ~ELYY$XJGJI2E'GLQRC2CNØ)SësÚîNQRîkSÄÑI2IFS÷EHYsYE)úoYsCFINXHÑrG6]GJßoC7KI]PÛNY(CNQ¸ý¬T¤à C{ÛNEHYÝ%XLûPQ³GJGLÑrGL]PQRSPYsTÒ Y$YܯSU\vÑCKCFTPSP]PY6YY¬SZGLSZGJ]PQRMUIN1Y ÙO)v÷ÔoØCNY\UXJXrI2ÙEDXrI2MUÒFÙ3ORYIFSPYE3YGLXJYÝDI2XsY7GLÚUYsINT¥MvSUEHÝ,T7YsTâYí2XJî3Y'ëqðæUÔPCZQ³ÔPGJI{E'Q³GJGJQ³GLE¥SPC+Ò(GLYCÄ\oSUCNYÑSUCQRSFTPÑ$G)C¯Y6T¯Ý%GLY]PQ³GL)Y ]WGJ]P¤XJYwY\UELi CNINORXJM¯\UINGLÙ(I2QRXrCNYI2S;GLÙ3YC2XYØ@ß GLîUY$UXsßCNîFÚ)X%îPë{ëFGJì¤]Pß Y$UÔPCNORQjQRGrXSPEkGLY]UGJINCYX ØvñCNXJ\UÙINMPXJINO¸INÙ3E'Y$ÝDGLYY-Xß4MUEHKYs]PT÷YXLëYì3I2ÔPXJQjGrYWE)Q³GJSZC+GLYYÒNSUYÑ$X(C¯\vT¯I2YXrGLI2]PÙ3MY Y$iøGJYXr\vEI2Ú»XrGLI2CÙ3CUY$ÚGJØYCFX X3INY$SUÜPT÷I2Ù3ësîk\PORÔPYWQ³GJGLE ]PGLYC;TPYI2SUGLÑYCTPO³YYgSPÒ2GL]UGJ] Y QRXLE-YsÑ$YYSUSvÑÑ$C¯á(T¯QRYEDTðEHYQR#SGGL7C-ÔUïYQjGrXJE;CZ×$ÕÚNGLI2]PSvYWT3TPGLI{]PGJY Y+EeORGJYYSP\¥ÒNGLS]ÄMPÙ-Q¸E6ÔvGJY]PXDY+I2SvSTkMPÙ-EeGJÔvYY\¥X-]PCNYØ'Q³ÒFTP]ZIG¨á¯YE6IFQ³ÑrSÄ]¥GLI2]PXJY;Y%Y\USUINÑEHCG-TPÝ%YTk]PYQRSS ÙGL3ë]Pî(I2Y6ܯÔP\oQ³Q³Ù-GJYEXrMPßvÑ$Ù>KYSF]PGrO³Y6I2YSPÒF\UY Ò2INGJXJCNw] INØÙ3FGL]Uî+Y$Y6GLÔPY\PXJQ³GJEDXLECFØßÔPCFà'ORX)YE6ÙkYIFINEÑrO³];XJEHYCFYsIFO³ÛFåFT¯YMvá;TWI{Ù3GLÑ$QRCNCNYSXJSFXJGJYINQ³CFÑXLGJSPY6O³YákEHTGLÝ%ÚCNXJQ³GLGLY]P];T;Y-GLQRûP]US7GLYgSUI(YT¯ELEJQjQRúESPYØÒNXJMPORYYgSUSvÑÑrÑ$GJ]PY¬Q³CFXJÔvCNS¤YÙ3GeÑÝDCFCNELÙYCNYÙ3ÔUSWQ³YSPGL]UYsC2T Y Ø Ù3Ù3I2I2GJGJÑrÑr]P]PQRQRSPSPÒ(Ò3Û{Û{I2I2ORORMPMPY'Y6CNC2ØØ»GLGL]P]PY¬Y6]P]UQRQ³ÒNÒF]U]PYYEHEHGHGHÓ«Ó«XJXJININSPSPãNãNYsYsTkT+ÑÑININELELY)Y GJGJ]U]UI{I{GG)]U]vIFINTkTWGLI2]USWY¬Q³ÑSUCNÑXJCNXLXJYsXLÑYsGDÑG)ELCNELORCNM¯ORGJM¯Q³CFGLQRS;CNSI2ßSvTkGL]UY Threshold Case Similarity
GLÑ$Q¸M¯I2GJORC2O³$Páú¤CNXÝ,TPYYI2ܯQRGLÒNY6IN]ZÙ3T¯GLYsQ¸\PEeTO³GrYFI2XLÚSUYsGLÑ$Ñ]PYY3YgSU Ñ$ý¬áWëà¼ì-YåZTPØCFMUIMPI2á¯SUGLEQRT+ü¯CNYsS7GLåZ]PÝ%MUYI{]PØGJYCNQ³SCFORORSC{GLÝ%çP]Uî/Y(Q³SP îNELÒ(éQ³Ù3h\UINQRj ORXJININmXLÙ(Q³yGeá;Yz¢¡qGL£ YGL¡>]PX,¤>¥XJÛ{z|Y(=INELy!O³]PMP>CNYsaO¸
E,TØCNÝ
X,fINGLE ]UøEHYYG'î/Yܯ GLîN\vCWéCF îPSPß YNS¯îUÓ ç ")Y$ÜGsÚ2ÝDY%MvEHYsTGJ]PY'EJI2Ù3Y)ý¬à \PXJC¯Ñ$YEJEGLCgTPQREJÑ$C{ÛFYXGL]PY'\UI2XrI2Ù3Y$GJYXrEC2ئ I B>2 7M§¨AC© ª Ú °¯±² ± j³k ± Ý%]PYXLY ² ± INXLY GL]UY \UINXJINÙ3Y$GLYXJE,I2Sv³ T k ± I2XJY GL]PYCNM¯GJ\PM¯GrEC2Ø « ¨¬2 Ah:f2