What Diverse Charter Schools Do Differently

What Diverse Charter Schools Do Differently - Education Week

EDUCATION WEEK

TEACHER

DIGITAL DIRECTIONS

MARKET BRIEF

http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2016/06/24/what-diverse-charter-sch...

TOPSCHOOLJOBS

SHOP

ADVERTISE

June 27, 2016 Welcome, Premium Subscriber MY ACCOUNT | LOGOUT

Current Issue

TOPICS

BLOGS REPORTS & DATA

Digital Edition of Education Week

EVENTS

DISCUSSIONS

OPINION MULTIMEDIA/VIDEO

Published Online: June 27, 2016

COMMENTARY

What Diverse Charter Schools Do Differently By Priscilla Wohlstetter, Matthew M. Gonzales, & Amy K. Wang

With the arrival of charter schools in the early 1990s, skeptics predicted they would skim off the best and brightest students from traditional public schools, creating a two-tiered system. As the charter movement spread to include 43 states and the District of Columbia, researchers were surprised to learn that charter schools

Printer-Friendly Email Article Reprints Comments

enrolled students in predominantly urban areas who had not been

Tweet

well served by traditional public schools. That was the good news.

Like

The bad news was that charter schools, like other public schools across the United States, were often isolated by race. In 2007, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1 that school district enrollment plans that relied too heavily on a student’s race were unconstitutional. The ruling and subsequent regulations from the U.S. departments of Education and Justice brought socioeconomic status and parental educational attainment to the forefront of the diversity conversation. A growing number of charter schools and charter networks are now implementing programs to achieve such diversity. While the student population enrolled in

EDUCATION WEEK EVENTS

Administrators’ Data Gaps: A Crisis of Confidence SPONSOR WEBINAR JUNE 28, 2:00 P.M. EASTERN REGISTER NOW. Content Provided by: Education Week Research Center

Using Specialized Lotteries to Increase Diversity in Schools WEBINAR JULY 5, 2:00 P.M. EASTERN REGISTER NOW.

The Maker Movement in K-12 Schools CHAT JULY 7, 2:00 P.M. EASTERN

diverse charters has grown significantly—to

SIGN UP FOR E-MAIL REMINDER.

about 25,000 K-12 students, according to

Sponsored by: DreamBox Learning

one adviser at the National Coalition of

Making Project-Based Learning Work

Diverse Charter Schools—little empirical

WEBINAR JULY 20, 2:00 P.M. EASTERN REGISTER NOW.

research on such schools has been

Sponsored by: littleBits

conducted.

Monitoring and Improving School Climate With Student Surveys

How do charter schools achieve diversity?

WEBINAR JULY 21, 2:00 P.M. EASTERN

How are approaches to teaching and

REGISTER NOW.

learning different in these schools, and with what effects? To answer these questions,

—Getty

MOST POPULAR STORIES

we at Teachers College are conducting a landmark study of 21 charter schools and charter networks that have an explicit commitment to diversity in their schools’ missions. One of our first questions was to consider why these charter schools prioritize diversity. In many cases, the founders hold diversity as a valued good—one that represents a broadly democratic ideal and is worth pursuing on its own merits. As the founder of a charter management organization in Rhode Island told us, “The most powerful thing you can do

Viewed

Emailed

Recommended

Commented

1. The Truth About Teacher Pay (Wal... 2. There's Now a Body of Research on... 3. 10 Lessons Learned From Harry Pot... 4. Three TFA Teachers Resign After Lea... 5. Why Don't Schools Accelerate More...

for kids is to put them in a seat, studying and learning, next to a student from a different background with different life experiences.” We were surprised to learn that white, privileged families were attracted to the progressive education programs of diverse charters, so outreach and recruitment targeted low-income families, including, for example, through Head Start programs.

1 of 4

SPONSORED WHITEPAPERS

• Automated Scoring for ELL Assessment • Technology Implementation and Adoption Strategies for K–12

6/27/2016 4:34 PM



Charter schools design their own education programs, and, yes, they do decide to do things differently from traditional public schools. For one thing, there are high

• Are Students Really Reading in independent reading contexts?

expectations for all students. Most diverse charter schools we studied offer a college-prep

• Using Data to Keep High-Risk Students in the Classroom

curriculum for every student. Some of the charter high schools offer an open-enrollment

• Respond to (Evidence of) Student Learning

honors program, which allows students to opt in; others require all students to take a few

• Going Digital: A Curriculum Management Playbook

designated Advanced Placement classes. We did not find ability tracking in any of our sample elementary, middle, or high schools. Teachers used personalized learning plans, differentiated instruction, and computer-assisted learning

"Are diverse charter schools the wave of the future in public education?"

and assessments. A high school principal in Rhode Island described the benefits of this more personalized approach: “Our teaching strategies allow students to dictate at what pace they learn. If a kid is particularly strong in a class, they

• From Formative Assessment to Informative Assessing in the Math Classroom • Beyond a Single Estimate of Effectiveness • Demystifying the Role of Reading Comprehension in the Common Core • Effective Teaching Strategies for Improving Reading Comprehension in K-3 Students • Identifying skills key to "real world" success • How to start a STEAM program in your school

can move ahead. If a kid needs more time because they struggle with computation or writing, they can continue to work on concepts until they’re mastered.” The diverse charter schools in our sample also differ from some traditional public schools in the disciplinary methods they use. Explained one academic leader in New Orleans: “We take a restorative-justice approach, which is less punitive. We focus more on how the event affects our community and less about the act committed.” Other diverse charters invented their own disciplinary approaches. When one Washington, D.C., high school principal noticed that more girls of color were referred for disciplinary reasons, the school started a gender retreat—an overnight event for female students to hear outside speakers and participate in empowerment activities. After the first year, the girls requested similar programs during the school year, and a monthly event, Girl Code, was birthed. “Now after three years,” the principal told us, “these activities turned on the light bulb in terms of the girls’ behavior. We haven’t suspended anyone this year—down from six last year—and we rarely use detention.”

Kindergarten & Secondary English, Math, Science, P.E. and Business Teachers Teach Away Inc., Dubai, Al Ain, Sharjah, United Arab

What other effects have the founders and leaders of diverse charter school observed? At

Emirates

the elementary and middle school levels, all school leaders noted high levels of parent

Hawaii Department of Education Virtual Career Fair

engagement across all racial and socioeconomic groups. One of the larger CMOs in

Hawaii Department of Education, HI

California and Washington state improved family access by locating schools near publictransportation hubs and providing free metro cards and personalized transportation plans.

Minority Achievement Officer Pinellas County Schools, Largo, FL

Executive Director/Director - 2 openings OSPI, Olympia, WA

Other diverse charters rely on building community within the school. As the director of

Managing Director, Talent and Equity

community development at a New York City charter explained: “Since we are not a

Flamboyan Foundation, DC

neighborhood school, families don’t necessarily see each other once they leave school.”

MORE EDUCATION JOBS >>

POST A JOB >>

This K-8 school created family nights, where families come together for art, music, and sports activities held on campus in the early evenings. Some families volunteer to participate, while others are recruited to balance the groups’ racial and socioeconomic makeup. This school also created play dates for K-3 students, bringing together small groups of kids and their families outside school. For adults, the school sponsors workshops and events, which include cooking classes and book clubs. Such social engineering has proved effective

MORE OPINION

in producing new community relationships. In our surveys of students, the majority across all family income levels agreed that they have a diverse group of friends and that they often hang out with kids from different backgrounds outside school. This finding was confirmed in the parent survey: Parents

Visit Opinion.

reported that their children often socialized at school with students from a range of socioeconomic backgrounds. In closing, our findings suggest that integration at diverse charters is authentic, at least in the 21 schools we studied. But is there evidence of its impact on student achievement?

2 of 4

6/27/2016 4:34 PM



While still preliminary, some upticks have emerged from our data. First, diverse charter schools that have been around longer, especially elementary schools, are among the top performers when compared to traditional public schools in both English/language arts and mathematics. The older CMOs serving high school students earned bragging rights, too: high levels of proficiency in reading and math on state tests and high percentages of graduating seniors accepted into a four-year college or university. One diverse high school ranked in the top 20 percent of all public high schools in its state and third among schools serving students with disabilities. Are diverse charter schools the wave of the future in public education? By definition, schools of choice located in urban neighborhoods have the flexibility to enroll diverse students by drawing from different communities outside attendance areas that have high concentrations of poverty—an option not available to traditional public schools. Until all public schools have this option, the likelihood of achieving socioeconomic integration in urban schools seems very dim indeed. Priscilla Wohlstetter is a distinguished research professor at Teachers College, Columbia University, and co-author of Choices and Challenges: Charter School Performance in Perspective (Harvard Education Press, 2013). Matthew M. Gonzales and Amy K. Wang are graduates of the college’s department of education policy and social analysis. Follow the Education Week Commentary section on Facebook and Twitter. WEB ONLY RELATED STORIES “The Evolution of the 'Chartered School',” June 3, 2016. “Data and the Debate Over Diversity in Charters,” June 3, 2016. RELATED OPINION "Public Education vs. Charter Schools: A Tale of Two Cities," (Teacher in a Strange Land) May 4, 2016. “Resolving the Charter School Debate,” January 27, 2016.

Print

Email

Tweet

Like

You must create a "Display Name" in order to leave a comment. Please visit My Account/Edit My Information, add a display name in the field provided, and update your account.

2 comments

KimGHMI

Sort by:

Score: 0

Report Abuse

10:11 AM on June 27, 2016

Here in Michigan, charters cannot use any enrollment preferences ‐ all charter schools under the general charter school law must admit students from anywhere in the state without preference. The only tool in our toolbox for achieving diversity is the choices we make with regard to marke ng and recrui ng. It would be interes ng to compare the diversity a ainment of charters in states like Michigan, to other states such as California or New York that can priori ze enrollment by socioeconomic status, ZIP codes, or other factors.

Alice Rodeo

Score: 0

Report Abuse

3:50 PM on June 27, 2016

The author never gets to the essen al ques on‐‐namely what

3 of 4

6/27/2016 4:34 PM



does 'diversity" have to do with educa on since there is zero evidence that it helps anyone involved.

Ground Rules for Posting We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement. All comments are public. Back to Top

ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT

CONTACT US

POLICIES

ADVERTISE WITH US

EPE INFO

EDUCATION WEEK PUBLICATIONS

• Register or Subscribe

• Help/FAQ

• User Agreement

• Display Advertising

• About Us

• Education Week

• Online Account

• Customer Service

• Privacy

• Staff

• Teacher

• Print Subscription

• Editor Feedback

• Reprints

• Recruitment Advertising

• Work@EPE

• Digital Directions

• Manage E-Newsletters/ Preferences

• Letters to the Editor

• Mission and History

• Market Brief • TopSchoolJobs

• Group Subscription

© 2016 Editorial Projects in Education 6935 Arlington Road, Bethesda MD 20814 1-800-346-1834 (Main Office) 1-800-445-8250 (Customer Service)

4 of 4

6/27/2016 4:34 PM