A Comparison of Generic Machine Learning ... - Montefiore Institute

0 downloads 0 Views 271KB Size Report
In this paper, we evaluate 7 machine learning algorithms for image clas- sification including our .... C reate a node with the test ¥xАБВ < x th § , attach T В13t and Tr Pght as successors of this ..... Libsvm : a library for support vector machines.
            ! " !# %$& '( *)+ !# ," 

-  %./01$&  203547683:;9 :; @ ;?ACB DE; >F> ;1G; H >JILK ACGDNM >PO DEMQD K DNRST; >POU3WV A X H KFI H K B&D 3?I ; > A8YZM(H7D K\[ ; 6 ; ]_^5; < `acb dfehgia%jkelmbinodkpqdkrsdfect?uvbwpyxceJjznkp{d}|~ac7€:pEeF ‚ce €ƒpNeF ‚cects„…eJ†y‚cpyrw‡ ˆ dodk‰:ŠŒ‹%‹LZZ&Ž ‡a%b dkehg?acjfecŽ rw†q‚?Ž %‘Ž ’?e“‹c”•‡~‘jfeJe“‹ –-— b˜†qePLxce•™jka%‡›š7ac†yp{dfeFJbwpyJa~œvp:„cjkp „‘jfpNtslždf‘†y| Ÿ (¡z¢z£h¤¥P¢ ¦E¬m§©«ŒÀ ¹²¨}ª%®J¨}«{¬8«º¼P­ §®F­s«{§%¯f¹z°²µº±c¶³7Ác¯Z«{§%¯f»˜´P®J¼Fµ{¶%¶ °&®J¨}°}¯v¯z¹z·•¯f§‘¸ ¨®J®J¹kª%­ «º­c§ °}¯¼L®Fµº¯²¹o®hªÂ°}§ ¨}«ºª § ®J»&¨ ®J¹zµº¼F»P¸¼F°}Ã%«Œ¨}«{ª%§%¸&¯z¬&¬¾Ã ½y¼F¶%°T«ºµqÁc«º¸ «º§ ®F»˜»P¯…¼J½Z¹zµ{¯z®F§c¬ž¿¿ ½q¬m¼‘°}¯fÁc¼P¸¬+¸Çà ®Jµº¨}°}¯zª¯&¬&¯¾®J¼J¼F­ ½Z°}­%«º¯f»Pµ{đ«º«º¯²§¨mÁ0°}®F¯zµwÁ%¸&«º«Œ¸ °}¯z¯zµŒ®FŹk»P¨}µº¯f°oÅ0¬z®JÈ:§¼FÁ%ɧ˼F¼F­%¸&°Ê«º¨}Äc«ºªÆz¯z¯²¯TµUÁ®F´F­®F¨m°}µº­c¶%¯z°}¯z¯z¼L¬¬®J¹k³¾®Fª&§ «Œ¨}Á¨}ª ¼+¼P¯fÃs¶cđ¨+¯T¨m°o»F®F®F¯z§“¹k§ Å~¨}«{¯k¼F°}½y§ ¯²«{¹F®J± ¨}¼F¶c®J½µº°}¯-¬m¶¨}¯fª Ã%đ¯z¿™¨m³¾¬m°o¯C«º®F§¸&¹fÁc¨}¯f«º¼²¼F¨}³¾ª%§?¬¿È ̘°}¯f­%¯Z°}¹z¯z¼P¬m¯z¸&§“­¨o®h®J¨}°}«{¯²´PÁ¯\¨}®Fª ­%¯z­ ¸Íµº« ¹²¼P®J§©¨}«º½Î¼F¼P§ ¶c¬&°¼F­%½…¶ «ºÃ ¸ µº« ®F¹zµŒ»Pů©®h¹z´Fµ{®F®F«º¬mµ{¬m®F«ŒÃ%Àµº¹z¯®J¨}Á%«º¼P®J¨o§ ®F¬m­c¯k°}¨}¼P¬TÃ%¹zµ{¼J¯f¸&°m°}¯z¬z¬mÏ©­sª¼P®F§ § Á%Ác«º§ ³8»&°}«Œ¨}¨m¼ ¿ ¨}ÑÓ¯fم§Ðã…Á%Ö8«º»Pä:«Œå¨}¬-×kÈiÑÓÒæÞÔT¹z¦m¼FÕ%¸&Ö¾­×k®h± °}½Ø«{®F¬m¹f¼F¯z§Ë¬-³¾ÑÓم«Œ¨}ÚTª˜Û(¬ž×k¨}±s¶ ÜJÁ%ÝÞ«º¯z¬¼F½qÃc°}ßN¼P¯z¸ç¹f¨}¬-¨}ª ÑÓ¯•à8م¹z¼P¦N¸&Ûi¿}­%á²¶%âF¨}âL¯f×k°±i´c®J§«º¬mÁ\«º¼P§Ë¨}¯fđµº« ¨}¨}¶%¯k°o°}®J¯z¬¿ ¨}¸&¶c¯k°}¨}¯Êª ¬m¼‘ª%Á%¼²¬z³¾È¬(¦N¨}§ª®J­ ¨(®J»P°m¯z¨}§%«º¹z¯f¶%°}µq«º®h¹_°²¸&±ƒ¼P¯f¨}¶cª%°¼‘¬mÁ%¶%¬5Ã%¹z¿™®F³¾§v«º§¹zÁ%¼P¼²¸&³é¯:°}®F¯zµº»P¸ ¼J®J°}°}«Œ¨}èFª ®F¸›Ã%µºÅ…«{¬•¹zµº¹z¼P¼P¬m¸&¯_¨}­s¼C¯k¬m¨}­s«º¨}¯z«º´L¹z¯-«{®Jµ{³¾«ºÆz«Œ¯z¨}Áª ¨}¹fª%¼P§¯ ¹f¬ž¯z¨o­%®J¨}¨}¶ ¯®F¼Fµi½C¬m«{¨}¸&ª ­%¯µº«{®J¹f°m«º¨²¨Eœ±ÊÈ ®\°}¯z¸ ®J°}èF®FÃ%µº¯ °}¯f¬m¶ µŒ¨-¹z¼F§ ¬m«{Á%¯k°}«{§%»Ë«Œ¨}¬•»P¯z§%¯f°o®Fµº«Œ¨NÅê®J§Á ë ìƒí\î_ï8ðÐñêòó…î8ôhð©í dklm‘‡~pyrwacdkb‘ac‚%‡~÷seac‘J‡~dk†ypy%ac‘nkb pynkbip{g5nZúӐ J†yˆ py“øccdfejfpqa%%ù bꐲridkpÎeFcn&j†qpq‘d}jk|Ëb1ePhJacpy‡\ac‚%b bw‰?dkpqa%jfdkacjopyacdz†Ntib?‘b’wûhtd-pyac‚%‰w‡\eJjka%eJa%†qdk’wa%jf‚c†y|ÂeJ|ê‡õúØÓúӏ%nk achpyˆe©†(pÎjkd} |ePˆ h‰?acce&‚%‰wjfbw‰5eFpqeFJdk‘pyacacjz‚%b?n•bwûhpqp{twbdfpq‡\a%‡~b?eF÷sû²‘ŽybpΎyhŽ|êpybw‘ec‰wt5‰ia‘†qüÐpΐJJ‘e ö jfpy‡\p{d ˆcý ‡~‚cePˆ n¾n+pÎnZ‡~ú™pN‰wŽ‘e%jfpyŽ8acbw’w†y‰w|©†ypqeJÿ’5‡þeFeF†yFnzpyû²‘n+Ž_ri‰ilmnkbi‘e+jk÷sa‘dkeFpÎ5eFhd rw÷Uˆ †Ît e‘Zjfˆ †ypq|0pyd ‚ ˆ ÷sˆ pqü~bˆ rwJpq‡©rw‚ ˆ†q’?dveFb ™j¾acria‘j+‡Udk’5pyjzbweJc‰wjC÷srspqacdkd…UpyacxLxLbicccjkjkpÎpΆU‘‘‡~’i’i†q†qcePeP n7nJˆ t‘d py†yˆ bweF‘ce&dCjk†ybieF‡~pq‘bwLjf‚&|©bwpy‡\÷sbweP‚~eJnkd J‘ˆ jk†yas‚cpy’5÷wacenö da‘ehˆÿØdfeJdfeJjkpyb0j-eF‡%nkrJe•J(ehrwJacjfjTb?%™÷shjk|%p{a%dfŽ ‡ pqa%wbirsnFd Ž_ˆ ˆ pyýÊeJ‚ jfaˆ ‡\ˆ x“acc‘jfbijfecpÎ÷stU‘†ybiheZa%Jd e ‡\ˆ ú™pΉw‡\n rsˆ dkaspypq÷sbw‚ eJˆ‚0†ÎnT÷sdkpycpq‡‡\jkevePeFn•xcbieJnoFjfpy‘ac|b1b?rw‘cbi†y†yp{nonkd}dfa0|%‘t%’i’5py‡~†qe©eL‘û8÷w‚ceh e+dkˆjfJpyp·†y %ˆ nkeFnkb÷spÎdfJeh‘df“†_eJdfjfpqpya%pqbÂa%b~jfnk‘nori|sdk ePnoˆ nö dk‘eFb?‡~÷n&‘ri‰w‰wnkri†ypΏ‘J†y“†q|1dfpqa%jkbêeF†q|ê÷saca%‡~bc˜pqbƒ‰wt?jf ehöžˆ ‰wpΐjfˆash‘eFpynf‡~nkpqbwnv‚˜“d•n}dfeheJÿ‰ƒdkt_jzcno‰5hdkeFpyJbwp{‚Ðg5~dfjfa˜eF÷sd riˆ Je~eF‰i÷cnkjoehdfdvpyJacrw8†Î‘pqj-b dk‰weFjfjkacePn}’wdf†ypqeJbi‡ ‚ ™pÎn8eF‘hdk†yrweF‘jfeFjPn8Š ™jka%ˆ ‡ÍeFbd ˆ JeZacbipqbwnkpypq÷wdkpÎeJ‘jf† pqbwˆ ‚rw‚cvebibeJrw‡‰i’5jkeJa%jC’wa‘†qeF(‡‰wp{acÿsj7eF†y‘nF‰wŽ_‰iý †qpΈ Je+‘dk†qpypyac‡\b©p{dz÷w“acdf‡~pqa%‘bpybƒac?t“pqd d7ˆ pÎpÎn_nCbw‘eF‰iJ‰weFjknfa nkccjkˆ| 

df a0ˆ c‡~jf%‘²bdfrieJjfcpy†qno†ydk|pΐJcnT÷wa‘c_‰sddvˆ d e&ˆ bieeJ‰wÞjfehcöž‰w‰w‰wjfas†ypyhFeF“nfdfnkpqpqa%bwbƒ‚ÐŽ nodkeF‰1’|˜dfcø pybw‚Ëpqb dka˜cFhacrib%dvd ˆ e\no‰5eFJp{g5 ‡\jfeFehù d rwˆ pyd7jkaspy÷wdbwˆn-‚eZ ‘nfˆb‘|êp·\ ˆ e¾˜dfc‰wpqjk‡\jfe\pqa%e%‘jkt‘’wp7jk†yePpye©bsheF™dkacb%a jfd8‡~ˆ c‘“÷wb?dkxLpy÷scac†qbib eheP‡\‘n_’5acpqacjfbrwed‘crsd bidfˆ ac÷ÂeЇ~‡‘“‰ia%df‰wpyjkTe\†qpΆqJePh‘‘a%dkjf‡\pybwac‰wpybƒbw†qŽ\eJ‚ ÿêý ˆ ‰wLˆ x%jfePaceCno’we\‰w†yjfeJ‡\as‡~eh÷sdnriˆ JZaseFp{÷w÷ d n&ˆ biac‘eJrwjf ed pylmbib hjfd eFˆ %pÎnÐnopybwJ‚%ac†qb |dkeJhÿ a%dP‡tC‰5a%ehrwdfjÐp{df‘pqx%py‡eZpybpqd ˆ d ˆ ‡pynÐeJd ‰iˆ ‘as‰5÷weJn-j~nkpΉ?nePdkhaWpqg?Jhca%†q‡\†y|˜‰idf‘cjfpqe˜†yacnkjfeJeFx%÷˜eJjz™‘a%†…jva‘d ˆeFd nkˆ eePno÷weac‡~jfeF‘JpyeJbib nFd Ž dcˆ †q‚%“acdjfp{pqdd©ˆ Z‡~pynv†y†T™’5a%j-eÐd ‰5ˆ a%eÐnfnonkpy‰5’weF†ye~hpqg?dkaac‰w’sjfacdz‘’wpy†ybWeJ‡ Zp{a‘d ˆ pq‡~noa%‘‡\‚%e~eJa‘†yZ%dnkˆnkpqeFg?nkJe0‘dk‘py‰wac‰ibƒjkŽ a c—  rwˆ j ePn&ˆ |hac‰?‡\acd ‰5ˆ ehePdfnop{pÎdfn-pqx%pyen jf‰weFjfnkehrwöž‰w†qdfjfn~ashZeFpqnfd nkˆ pqbw‚nk‰5n}eFdfheJpΉƒ‘ކyp JeF÷ c†q‚%acjfp{d ˆ ‡~n~Zpqd ˆ a%rsdËjfeFù rwpyjkpybw‚#cb | †yc’?a%jkpyacr?nJt‡~‘bric† eFcjfjkceІ8lmjfbê†qeJeP‰i‘d jkˆjfePbwpÎn-nopqeFbi‚cb%‚a%dz“ccdf†E†qt5pq‚%x%acaceÐjfrip{ja‘d ˆ+c‡~d‰wˆ ‰wn-e˜jfaca%pqbc‡~ eF‘ˆ %‚%e0ˆ chnvac†ÎcTdknfadnkˆp{g? eFˆ Fnka“e~a%dfpq‰wnka%e©jfbacnk’weJ÷s†yx%eJaceJ‡~‡~jz‘nFc†Êt:pqb‰wZjkpqca%d biˆ’w÷ a%†yeJrs‡~d dˆ nveJ‘bb|ˆ dka pyno ‰5ˆ ‘eF‰wJT‰wp{g?e©†y|W\d ˆ ‰inopyeFjkbwxeJø öö ‰wc†qjf‚%asachjfePp{nkd nkˆ pq‡~bi‚int+‰?pNacŽ e%dkŽçeJb df’ py|c†q†y÷w|˜pqjfceF’wh†ydke-†y| dka riˆnopycbwbi‚÷s†yd e-ˆ ed ˆ ‰wpÎnvpqÿJeFac†-‡\xL‰wc†y†qehriÿ˜eFnF‰wŽ jka%’w†y‡\eJ‡acbwti‚ …e jkePˆ hLeFxcb%e d˜ †qˆeP‘a%jfnkbweJbpybw‚ ‰i‰wjfcacbw‰5eJa%†…nka‘eF ÷™ac‘j-†y‚cpq‡~a%jkcpqd ‚cˆ e\‡\hnF†Îct7nfpqnob?pqg?h†yJri‘÷sdkpypybwac‚1b a% bweËNŽ‚%ýeJbwˆ eFeFjknkpÎe~Ð‘c†y‰w‚c‰wacjfjfa%pqd cˆ  ‡~ˆ n•d ˆ Z“pqd†y†7T’?e e~ˆha%L‡\x%eЉijk‘ePjfheFeF÷1b%dfeF†qno| ö nkúÓa‘eJbdkd pΈ‘†ye0†y|0†qePac‘bêjfbwd}pqTbi‚aАJcjkbipq÷ÂdkeFjkdkpÎePwn}Š…dc‰ Jˆ JcrwnkjzeFcnzhû²|ˎ a‘7†qdd ˆˆ ea%rw‡\‚ ˆas÷snkeJeJ†Îx%nveJcjzbi‘÷ê†8a‘ha%‡\d ˆ ‰weFrsnkeÐdf‘‘dk†ypy‚caca%bijkcpq†ƒd ˆ eh‡~üÐnJpqeFˆ biLhx%| e ’5JaceJ‡\eFb0‰i‘‘†yjfjke\ePcnoeF÷sxc|©eJ‘jz‘‰w†8‰w†ycpy†qeF‚%÷\acjfdfp{a d ˆ pq‡~‡~cn-‚cacevj J‘†y%jfnkenkp{™g5asJh“ridfnkpqeFa%÷bƒt‘acribnkriaccbi†q†q†y|Â|dacˆ bweFe\nke•‰icnodkjor?dfpy÷sJpqrweP†yn¾cj eFp{d‘ˆ ‰weJ‰ij…†qpÎ÷sJa ‘dkbwpyacacb d ‰wjfac’iý †qˆeF‡˜e˜Ž‰i‘‰5eJj\pÎn©nodkjfrihdkrwjfeF÷ cn™ac†y†qa“+nFŽÂlmb eFhdkpyacb st¾…e0’wjfpye i|W÷sePnkJjkpy’?eËd ˆ e ‡~‡\accjf eˆ pqdkbwpy‡\ee+†yeFac‘jfbbwd pyˆbwev‚Ë÷sceP†q‚%nkJacjkjfpyp{‰sd ˆdkpy‡~acb\n•ac ˆ(a%a%nkrweJj¾ba“™Za%b\j‰wa%rwjfacj-‰5ha%acnf‡\‘†N‰iŽÊcý jkpΈ nkevacbƒeFnfŽ noeF— b%TdfpyJcac†wrw jzˆ nk‘ecjzt(cThdke\eFjknkpΉ?n}eFdfbipyF÷ n aceJÿU‰5d ˆeJjfe•py‡™aceFrwb jdf÷w“df‘pqdfa%cbnkeh‰wdzjfnCa‘r?dkasnoePJ÷\ac†Î™nvac‘jTb?d ÷ˆ e-d ˆha%e‡\jfeF‰ink‘rwjf†{pydznkn+acbÐac¾cdjkˆe•e©norweh‡\ÿs‰5‡~eJjf‘pqjf‡\p JeJeFb ÷Ðdzn•pqb cjkeeFh÷wdkpypynfachb rinfinkŽ7eF÷ý ˆ pyb e …ePac²jfdføÐpqa%÷sb pyjkiePŽ ²dkÂpyaceb?eFnJbiŽ ÷&d ˆ e‰i‘‰5eJj7Zpqd ˆ a%rwj8ha%bih†yrinkpqa%binʏcbi÷÷wpynfhrinfnfnopyacbin_‘’5acrwdÊ™rsdfrwjfe ©ðï¾ô²î ‘ð©ï ví +ï¾ôJó ô ó _ô êó î7ôhðí ýnkehˆ dZea‘7pqbw‰w‰ijfrsehdvömha‘†Îc¾nf\nopqgi‚%eJePbw÷ÐeFpyjk‡\pΐ-c†q‚cePeP‘nJjft bwpybw‚Џ‘†y‚ca%jkpqd ˆ ‡ ™acjvpy‡~‘‚%e h†Îcnfnopqg?J‘dkpyacb˜pyn•dkjz‘pybwpybw‚ ú Nû  pqdfn-ˆ eFhjk†Îecnfnkp{g?FpΏ“ndfpqa%búӏc‡a%bw‚ ‡~‘dkhjf†Îcp{ÿWnfno÷sePnfeFûhnfŽ hjfý py’wˆ pqbie\‚eJ†yd eJˆ ‡\e0eJpqb ‡~dzn ‘‚%e0‘b?a‘÷ ú   Ðwpyn t xd“ˆ ‘e †yrwJe  %pynobeda‘ˆ 8eha%F†qûca%nkj…÷se&ePpya‘‡~nkJ¾‘jk‚%py‚%’?jkeFeFenF|ˎ py‡\†yeJcx%‚ceJ†:epy‰w‡~pqÿ‘eF‚%†yeFn&n+‘a%dj+†y’as|J‘‡dkpyacePb‘biúnva‘ û•~’ py|b dk‡\eF‚cePeJ‘j bin-a‘„ޏ‘bÂx“cpq†qb rwdkePeFn+‚cpyeFb j †y÷weF‘cdfjkiý bwtFpyˆ bwg?eF‚jfbƒnod_t¾‘†ypydf‚cb a acdfjfˆ eJpqjfcd ‡~ˆ bi‡ ÷sn:†yaceËn wˆ pyd bsacˆ ™rie…ac†yjf÷b‡~rw’?“‡edf’5pqa%ceJbWj_’w†qa‘™eËjk?a%pqdk‡~‡ aW‘÷s‰w‚%ePeFpq‘ÿnʆeF‘†yehnbiüÐ÷©ZJhpqpqd†ÎeFcˆ b%nfa%dfno†qrseP|d~nƒa‘Z‘?bp{dpq| ‡~ˆ ‰w‘‚%jkeJeF†ÎöNn:‘‰ijfpqjkb‚caseËdhˆePcnke…‡\nk†qpyePacbw‘rw‚ijfb t_bwd\dpybwˆ a‘‚e  























 



!

!

)+*-,/. 10325456 2 7498:,

A0

,

4";";E I9KLM?NG9OPQR?NLCSHTU:V?  8::= ??AWXWXWE JYRE Z=@? AB /B L W 'X&(Y5Z&+ $[V,r;>=@? L AA(A/B 666 -- 3 UAU.. FHG/IKJLMNJOOQPmR =@? 6 N - A /. FHGUIiJLMNJOOPa`vbcwdM fCA(L giAhA(jUT k l . W0‚%9„ƒ ! [V,&:+ (Ym { 8 | A - E- N 8 .

مãÖ8äƒå

a‘pÎnZd ˆ ‰weJjfjac’wˆ †yceJbi‡÷Ðöm÷sx%eJeJ‰5jf|\eJbi‡÷weJrib  d+ˆ ‘pqbbi?÷ rwˆ eJ%binJeF’?÷ËeFeJ’b˜|\dkd rwˆ bie-eFno÷˜p J‡~e‘a‘b_rino‘rw†y’w†y|ÐöNZacpyb˜bi÷seFa“%+ ˆ nFŽ8‰wý jfacˆ ’ie•†qeFa%‡˜‰sdkŽ py‡~‘†Unkp Fe

B

"





…  H *  2 %/  8*%* 

ýnkrwˆ ‡\e‡\dkePcn}jkd-p J‰wePjf÷-a‘pqdfb©aJýÊacc†Î’wn•†qce jkweŽ ÷swpÎacnkJjÊrieFnk%nk eFˆ ÷1‰wpqjkbÂa%’wd ˆ †yeJpy‡n-nktPeFd ²ˆ dfeTpqa%‡b1eJa%d ˆb1aseF÷w%n_ ‘ˆ jfeC‰wjfnkacac’ijkdk†qePeF‡˜÷-’ Ž |-+÷seFePnkhrwjf†{eFdzcn&nkpy‘bwjf‚e eJjfjfacjjf‘dkePnJŽ JX



% 453476

+

†ˆ‡Š‰/‹Œ

lmjfbeJ‡~d ‘ˆ pyebwpy†ybwp{df‚ eJjz “$df$rw$jk$ e%t8ehÿwd ˆ ‘eˇ\g?‰w†yjfeFnonZd cjk$e$ri$$nkeF÷Ëpy‡~™‘ac‚%jZeFx“n\c†q‘pÎ÷wjfeˏ“dfacpqa%ØdkbƒeFŽ8b lmbrinkeF÷ ž™tsacd j\ˆ e&†yeFjfceFjknkbwrwpybw†qdf‚ nZac‘Êbi‡~÷#‘d bˆ |e †ybweFeJ‘d}jfTbwa%pybwjkø‚dk‡\a eh$ d Žˆ 2a÷inZ‘pqd jfˆ e\d jkˆ eFev‰?a%‘jorwdfd eFˆ ÷Ua%t:jfdnˆ Ž‘eF‡\|1ehdjzˆ‘asbw÷‚%e@k„…™jkaa%a%‡ nodkeF÷\H €:eZ/+pqeJd doˆ ö CBiŽacbi— ehrwöž†yjCLjk|%ePeJnojrwbw†qdfeJnTrw‘jzjf‘e † acx“‘’wjfdf|‘pybw™jkePa%÷‡ ’|˜  noŽ dkA2jf pyhdkZ†y|0p{d ™ˆ a%†q†yêa“ZJ†ypy%bwnk‚~nkpÎd Jˆ ‘py†…nv÷s‰weFjkJacpydknkaspyachbWa%†EŽdfjk2CeFeÐjkjfdkaca jZjz “Ž !dfeFAHnvõZZp{d pqˆ d ˆ ‚ceFnobwrweJ‰ijf‰?py-a%jo‡\deJxcd eFˆ hasdk÷wa%nj ‡~c$ $ˆ $py$bweP‘nJbiŽ1÷;u•JMnoLpybw‚JnorwN ’wöNZpybi÷sûa“ +ˆ nFpÎt: dˆ ˆ pye0nZeF†yeFjkjfnfacnvj%Jjf‘JrwdkeÐjf‘pÎdkn ewd Žˆ A ‘bê „…ú™aZa%pqnod dkˆ pybwD ‚Џ‘bi÷  $ t 6•`WO Ž5lmb žti‘b˜eJjfjka%jjf‘dkea‘  Ž   cna%’sdfcpqbweP÷0Zpqd ˆ cbwa‘d ˆ eJjZpy‡\‰w†qeF‡\eJb df‘dkpyacb˜a‘ 86•`WŽ H













O,

,



,



 

% 453453

:=

,





Š‘

lmacb\b d dˆ ˆ evpÎnˆyp{df÷ieJ“jzdf“%dkrinoeJjkdFe%t+tcx“pybi‘Jjf†qpqria%ri÷wn8pqbw‘‚ †y‚cˆ a%pÎjk÷wpqd ÷sˆ eJ‡\bén¾`êZ‘p{d jfˆ øca“‰wx jkeJ‡\öN‰iajk÷waseJh†ÎePn nknkpybw! ‚&žtvn}dfJeJac‰ibn xcˆ a%L†qrsxcdfeZpqa%’5bieJ‘eJb\†vbwdfeFeJnorwdkjzeP‘÷ † bw‰weJjfa‘d}Tdfaa%Jjkacøs†Zn ™a% jÐA Ndft eFno8dk6pybw`ê‚#n pÎnË ÷s p ž(etJjfceJbib ÷ dÐx“™jf‘acjf‡ pΏ‘b acdfbwnËeêa‘‰?‘bi‰5eFeJ‘jÐjfeFdfnoadˏ‘bibieJpya‘‚ d ˆ ˆ ’?eJa%jPŽjfn pyxcžeFŽ›b „…d ˆ rse1d˜Ódcˆ hed d ˆ “dvd ˆ pÎn÷i“dfc’icnke&pÎn•ù rwpqdkeno‡~‘†y†Êcbi÷ê%nZd ˆ eJjfepÎnvbwa0TeF†q†qöž÷wehgibweP÷dkePn}d‰wjfa‘dkasJac†Nt C

-

 

H





- 

/Y

a%‚%rweJbwjCeFeJjkÿpΐZ‰5eJ‡\jfpyeh‡d ˆ eFasb ÷wdfnTnJŽ7rilžnode ‡\ $ eFöE‘™b?a%†yn8÷Ðd ˆJjk“a d…nkdnoˆöžxLe•c†q†qePpÎ÷w‘‘jfbwdkpypqacbib‚dknoa©eJd…‰wjka“cxnCpÎ÷sjfcevbi ÷sÓa%‘‡pyj…†y|%nk‰ink‘eFjknfdknopq‡\dkpyeFacb%bwdTeP÷\a‘Upqbd ˆ dfae py… ‡~$ ev‘†q‚%eP‚ceh‘ePdZjfnbw‘ú pyb0bw ‚©Lxx%pynfeJeJ‘jz‡\‘‚c‰w‰5eZ†yeJeFj&eFnTjknoZjfriacp{’ jTd F}ˆ jfeF‘hdkdzeûv$ úripy ‡~no$ eP‘÷jk‚cri™ePbiacnvnfj•û¾"ú dk! a‘ePxn}dzpq>n-eF!w+nkŽ cnCAH‡‰5ÐeJ‰ijZt%†qePZnknJrwp{Ž d ’ ˆ wF}ePa%©²†q†ydzha“ûC†ÎZc nfpqbiˆnop΂~pyJ†qevcd †?ˆ d ÷sˆpÎnePeh‰wjfpÎjfnoeJapy‡~acJbÐeF‘÷spydkbwrijfpyeJjkbwece%‚ tt ÷sia“acZjfeFb nodfdknFa t $ 28Ž ÿAHdk jz“ZömýÊpqd jkˆ eFeFacnFrwt(j7cnkbirw÷ ’söž8Z6•pqbi` ÷wa“‚c+pyxcnCe~ú™Zpqd nkˆ †qpy‚ D ˆ dk†y|ê py$ bs‘™eJbijf÷ pyacJ j&L jfeFnkrwJ †{d&N Zpqd ˆ cûh‘Ž b +LcxcbieF÷sjfcac‚c‡ e eFjkjfacj…jf‘dke-a‘  Ž AH0Ž 

&



,

,

,



X

@



Cm‰‘ 6

% 453&4

dacý ˆ ƒˆ eJ†qpÎas‡ nTJ‰wcnojk†?‰5a%a%eF’wjCJ†yp{eJ‚%g5‡ †qa%’idk…a‘%†?%nC™œeF‘‘‰idkac‰wrw’jkjfF}a eFePcn•² dvúӈ hjfePa%eF÷†qJa%acpqj b0‚%ˆ bwd pyp{ˆ nodfdke•pqa%a%†q‚cbƒpqdkjzteF‘d jf‡~ˆ ‘“dknJrwdvt%jfeJrie+pynk‚cZe eFbpq÷sd Zˆp 5epybiF÷wjk÷sp (eeFa“b J+dvjfnFeJ‡~tcb †ydT“asdf‡\J cˆeJ†qdepqbwˆ “‚asü~÷wdfnFeFbwts e+ˆno™a%bwjz‡pΏ‘ù ‡\evrweFePa‘nn a%jfeJ’ $‡~F}žeFt+‘hpydfeJbwnFdfpyt%‘bwnoŽŒ‚û²dfŽ ‘xjkpqdkweFpy+bwa%jЂ-n Zd …ˆ pqeJdeÂjfˆ e0†ydeF÷sˆceFe+jkbixc‰?a‘pqbwa df‚eFnoe•÷Ânk“cdkd a1‡$ ‰id ‘ˆ †qe%b?eÐtZ÷dkTeFd noˆe1deFdkb~nfa‘‚cac‡\acø py‰wbw†y=@B ? L L AAB FHG/IKJLMNJOOQPmR =@?    ! "#%$"!  ! &('*)A+,A $T$

ri  6 N N YY NN 3  A/6L L  L  NN 8A Y Y NL 8   L AL YY L  63  EY E

i   9 &U&( V,! ':C;>=@? L AAB 9 :(:! ':C;>=@? W ('X&Y^Z&(+ $ V,_;~=S A?/B (A(A/B FHGUIiJLMNJOQOPa`vbcwd M f*gihjUk l 0 ( ,! "#%$"!  ! &'1)2+ $$ r;K ! '$+ FHGUIiJoLp%MNq JOOPR =@? B AA(T

_i Š L AN  Y   YY   L Y A N8  3 A

L  NL  YY



sa‰w÷wjfa‘ndf…ashe-aceJ†În-x“‘…†yrieJjf“e~dfeFjk÷˜py‚caca%bËjka%™riacnori†yj+|1÷snkp ‰?(eePJhjfpqeJgib eFd+÷ƒpyއ~ý ‘‚cˆ e-e0hc†ÎcFhnfrwnkp{jzg?cFJ“|1dfpqa‘a%ZbËa%‰wrwjfj ac’i‚c†qeFeFbw‡\eJnTjfpɐ~a%jZnorw ’wˆ öNZpy pyˆ bi÷sdfeFa“no d dfaceFØöE d ˆ ˆ bwehpÎömù ‘rwjkedÊdfpynCeF d ˆ ˆ biepyù ’5rweFePnodnʒia%rsb~dCd noˆ †yjkpy‚eFe•ˆ dkac†y|&Ud pqˆbwe•™eJ™jfacpqa%rwjÊjdf‰wajfdacˆ ’ie†qeF’5‡\eFn…nod¾‘ø b?bi÷~a“pyZnbJacjf‡\eFnk‰irw‘†{dzjznJ‘Ž_’ilm†qb©eZdfӏca²nodPdft‘‘acdkrieJjö eJcÿ†q‚%‰5aceJjfjfp{pyd ‡ˆ ‡eFb t(dfnF‘÷sbeJ‡\hacac‡\b?n}e©dfjfjk‘eFdk‡\e cd jkˆ ø““cd-’w†q‚c|eFbwJ†qeJa jfnopΐ&e‡\dkaehdnoˆ‰5aeFJ÷ipynJctU†qp pyJb1eP÷‰ic‡\jodfehpyd Jˆ rwas†Î‘÷wjvnJŽa%rwlmbÂj-no‡~rw’w‘böNZ|pybi‰w÷sjzca“h ö dfdzpycFnk‘ø%†¾ömnk‘‰?‰ieP‰wh†qpqpÎg?J+‘dk‰wpyacjfehb öž‰whjfa%asb%hdfeFehnfÿnkdfpqnFbwtʂ cbink†q÷Ðpy‚ ‡~ˆ d&cb‰5r?eJ‘jk™†5acpqjfb ‡\dkeFcjkbix%heJe\b dk÷spyacjfacb~‰‡~pqLb |~eJhÿsa% biˆ no‘dkbwpqdk‚%rsedfe-™a%j xcjkeFePjk÷s|\riJ÷seFeh÷ ö nkpqjz‘ý’i†qˆ e•e…dk™jzrscdf÷srweJjköNeZa _Ž÷spyjfeF²dfpqa%bin7‘jfe¾d}…a‘öN™ac†Î÷UŽ _pyjfnodFt%cn_acrwj_Zjz‘‰w‰wpybw‚‡\ehd ˆ a÷©a‘5ehÿdkjzchö dfJpqaca%‡bВi‘pqbibw÷Ðe-pqJd+†y%Znknkp{dpqg?ˆ Ja‘‘ddkˆpyaceJb\j+a‘†yeF:cnkjkrwbw’spybwöžZ‚\pq‘b?†y÷s‚ca“a%+jkpqn7d ˆ ™jf‡~ac‡n&úÓpqpqb‡~‘‰i‚%ceFjonCdfpypyJnCrw‚c†yceJjZbieJ„Tjfapyca tcn}pqdfdTpqbwpÎnT‚~‘cdobidk÷jzc8hdk6•pyxc`êenzdfû²a Ž ‚%ceJ†qeP‚%bwhaca%eFjfbijkp{pÎd÷U\ˆ tw‡~‘eJ‰wÿn©‰w‰5cjfeJa%jkjfe˜%py‡ hˆ eF†yeFa%b nvnkdfe0n+dkanpybˆ jfaca‘dfridzeJ“†yjf÷Ëdf‡\pqa%’?nbƒe©act:J•nf‘Jcjf‘jfF†ypqhpyePbwrw÷0‚ijzca%tƒJrsas|cdZFt8hdk†ypqaÐd\rinoJpÎpynacac‡\b:bwtʉia‘d~‘‘b?jfnke÷ÂrwdjkbiˆeËace&dpÎnoˆjfe%ac“Ž ’idrid n}ˆ †qdfd bweFˆ |#eFa%nfrwnT‚ a‘a%ˆ _rw†Îdnk÷#ˆaceF‡\’5nkeee ‰wacc†qjf†ZeJjf†y a‘py‡(edz“FpyhdkbipydkcacePjkb:÷#|~tTpynonfbdkJri‘d ÷s†yˆ py|0bwe˜‚ia‘nft:‘d‘‡\ˆ bie˜e÷ ’?…ase LJˆ | JL†qxr?’pqno| a%pyacj…d b ˆac:eFacnkacb eËrijd‰5ˆ eJnkerwjkdk’srw öžjfZ— ’ipy‘l}bi€Udk÷spyö aca“ biÇ$nF$ ŽWc‰w‰wlm‰wjfb acjf’ia%c†q eF ‡˜ˆNtTŽ pyTbËeËd ˆ ‰weêe-jka%a“‰wx’ijfpÎeFno÷seFnkeFeJjkx%÷bieFJ÷e ‚%nkrwa ‚cas‚%÷eFnojfdkaceP’w÷&rinonoa%dkbi‡eFeCnfn-pq‡\dka1‰wjfnka“‡~xceF‘‡†y†¾eFdfb jfdfcn(bid n}ˆ ™a%“jkd_‡~‰wjk‘ePdknopyaceFjkbix%n-e8pydb ˆ dkeCjfa‚c÷weFribwheJePjf÷ pΐ8pqbib “dfdfrweFjfnode¾a‘pq‡~sd cˆ ‚ceTeFcn†q‚%‘acbijf÷Wp{d cˆ †y‡nka Ž 









ó 0íð +ñ víî +ceFrw‰ joˆ dz neJpy†&nv`ꏩcjfjeFeFnke1eFcpÎjfnê ˆ nkrwc‰wnfno‰5asachjkpÎdk“eFdf÷Þe•ac’Ê| d ˆ d eˆ e …Ž @/Ž eF‚cŽ py(acŽyb t?„…eF†qc‚%†qpq†yrwac‡bwbiŽ e!  Ž €CŽi„…jkeFpq‡~‘b:Ž v‘bi÷sa%‡ ™acjfeFnodfnFŽ † : =7?  : ? =7?; t AsŠ A st $$  Ž €C: ?޾ „T& jfeJpy;‡~  #‘ bƒ t = G?? Ž  Œ Ž w jf pyŽeF÷s ‡~c‘÷ib:not…&acjkŽ d ˆ Ž lm—b dk†ÎeJnoeFjfbibƒ‘tCdk‘pyacb?bi÷ c†7•ú Ž …iŽ‘†yp{™dfa%acjkbwbie%pyŽ û²t   !:'  ?= Ž : = G? 







X

"!



$!





5X

Y

X

!% !



:!



(!%





 

X

 





WX











1













knš7•rweJŽ ‰wdf?‰5nfŽ2acˆ •jkecdЎƒt‘xceP„T÷sePri²pqdkjkdkac‚%a%jzeFj~nFn-t‡~‘cbi ÷ÂGˆ :Gpy„bw? ŽeFnF sŽ % ˆ =7lm?„acb †y‡øc`Wa% ‰sŽ } Ž •:lmŽT‡\‰ ?`‰w jfa a“ #JxeJjPpqbw:t"‚0=`W d ? ˆŽ¾e~l²Ž % %Jach rijz ÷wjf %c=7?&hbƒ|;@tT‹‘cbibi' #÷÷  nký  ‰?ˆ eF aceFtc÷‡~x%ac%a‘†qnö rw‡\e !its‰i‘‚%e AwŽý ˆ e `l}ýǚCjkePnknFt  !C! Ž A 0 ˆ p ˆ ö  ˆ rwbw‚  ˆ cbw‚W‘bi÷  ˆ p ˆ ö ceFb €:pqb:ŽÞ€ƒpy’inkx‡Š1 †ypq’ijfcjk|W™a%j0nkrw‰w‰5acjkd x%2CeFbw²‚cdfpyacbwjÐeJeF‡~jkpy%bw ‚?ˆ t pqbi/•eF“nFdfŽ/pqa%biý:‘eP†ƒ ˆ ý_bw‘pÎpyJ…cc†vb˜jfeJuv‰5bwacpyjkxcdFeJ)t jznkTp{d}ac|%‡\t ‰w$rw$ dkweJj Ž shpyeJb?hecbi÷ lmbs™a%jk‡~“dfpqa%b  ?޾œ• ˆ ‡\eJbƒtZœ©Ž -eJ|snkeJjznJtT‘bi÷  Z‰ ?5jf p{ dkdk eF? b : =÷sGpq?‚%p{:dz nÐrinkpy bw'‚

5d  ˆ e ކ xpyjo}‹dfri‘3 †ZŽ df/+>eF6 eJnod˜|%Ž nf:‘T‡\ac‰w‡ †y= e’i; pq‡\bw ePeh÷ d  ˆ Ja†y÷]%tUnkŽq‰?Žnk‘pqg?‚clmJePb ‘n dk!>pyac! b   a‘4 $C  ‹ˆt ‘cGbiri?÷†q| ö $$  Ž lmb Ž "œ• = jk  r?Gz:4 øc tweJjP‰i= Ž ‘ i‚%%eFnn}d?  ?÷seFJ:pynkpq‹a%b~t dk 5jf!>'eJ! ev = eJŽ bi nkeJ ‡©? ’w†qeP n8™a%jT a%? ‰sdkpΐJc? †?:  ˆ' c=jf %:²dk?eF j¾‰ jf?eF ha% #‚c bwpq:dkpyac= Gb:? Ž  Ž ijkeFrwbi÷&‘b?÷ &? :  J t“†y? %‰i:nkcnk"‚c=pqgi eP?eJn7j0:A> !™acA j0a $ ?ö$  t eF‰sdkeF‡’5eJj $$$ Ž Ž 2Cb dkjfac‰|ˏcbi÷ha%jkjfeJ†Î“dfpqa%bŠ ac‡\ehac‡\‡\eJb dznJŽ ‰    Œ : ? 4  ý-Ž — Ž -x ‘†Înkehd ˆ   ?^‹ ' #  a† : ? : ?   ? "= t s` Cö  sú û²Š A  (A  !it  !  Ž  A (Ž5€:LZjfeJbiJec4 ‡ h a%b x% ac†y rst dk pyacú t b?•û²‘Š †ƒŽi! €:bweFeJrwe jzw‘†_t py†qbweP!CnJeh!td}…Ž acŽ jf•ø˜Ž5cýZ‰w‰wnoa%jfa%pEt?%‘ biˆ ÷ Ž ‰  Ž5 œ Ž?„…Œ %: z?ø( Ž : i% = hGe&? jf eFGha%?D‚c‡bwpq dkpyac b::Š 0



 









 







 



























 





 











 



















 



X













 

























Y

#"

 







!



 



O



Y









3

Y

Y



Y

Y

3%



 

'

/0



&%



'

V

 .  1

2 



1

1



1

4

65















87



 ( 















 :9

 



 











$



  ( *, ) +





(

1



*















Y



;7











c‰wŽw‰w€ƒ†ypqeePT÷Wridkbƒatw€¾÷sasŽsh„…rwa‘‡\dkdkeFacb%r:d\t jfeFhŽwa%„…‚ceJbwbwpqdk‚%pypqaca?b:t Ž cbi÷0 š7 Ž4&v   5bieJ „jPŽ ‰   jzc ÷st pyeJ>b  dkú öN ’i %û²noŠ eP÷\†qeP‘jfbwpybw?‚ t  !>!  Ž  py&‡~ŽU‘`ê‚ce&cj JeJ†y%ecnkt nkp{g5eJJri“jodfdzpqn•a%b0š7Žy’itU%š¾noePpΏ“÷˜dkeFacj b?÷sŽqeFtUJcpybinkpq÷ a%b0dfejkˆeFe-eFbweJøcbieFnk†_eJ‡©€CŽ’w†qePnJŽ ‚%eJsbwrweF’wjk‡\pΐ p{dk‘dk‰ieP‰w÷UjkŽ a c ˆ ™a%j e\? ÷w= pynf= Ghjf? pqt ‡\py$bi$ “sdfŽpqa%bƒŽlmb  4 6 ' ^‰ ?5 ? : = G? :  ! lmb Ž  /v eh ?5g?‚%:G!>bw?!ipqdk Ž pyacb = ri nk pqbi ‚ : ‘ bÇ 8eJ‡= ’5eF÷i ÷s eF= ,÷ +v `ê  `W ? Ž $ (Ž — ’ij P‘†yeJøW‘bi÷ iŽ8`ꏑdf%nJŽ — ’ F}eP²d~jkePha%‚cbwpqdkpyacbWrinkpybw‚†yasJc†‘ü~bwe0™jz‘‡\ePn a%† bÇ: ÷spÎn}=7?dfpq bw‚%rw=pÎ n = ˆ GeP? ÷ jfGeJ?‚c pyac b? nJ? Ž lmb  ? = ' "  G= ? =   .:    = G=7?t ; $$  w Ž  6 8- =  =  -ý-Ž — Fo‘†Îwt(ý-Ž(`eJbw‰:t(`#Ž5šCpqeJdkpyø pybweFbƒt i bwc†qeF‚%bƒacŽ jfp{—d ˆ rs‡~dfehnJÿŽ öZbw  eJ: 6 >6   t $$ sŽ py&‹bw'Žƒ‚W š8 nk c  jkˆ eP eJ÷s‡\eFn•e˜ ‘™acbij4.÷ 6'ӏc #mJŽƒe˜‰ š7?5jfeF eFjk Je ach? ‚%ö :Tbw p{ac= dfGjkpq?a%dkeFbƒ:nF ŽŽ•€:lmb as JH‘ †7:jf  eJ/ ‰w jf?/ eF? nkeJHb dz:“;>dk py? ac = b?? = nvG& ?‘b?=7÷1 ? ; ˜? ‰ =? ÷s" = pq jf #?eFhd=7?7:x% =‰a‘G? dk? ö   # :"=  ?5‹' #  ts‰ic‚cePn  G!wt %rw†y| $$  Ž -df`Wpqa%Ž_bƒš7Ž ac‰b  dkpy †¾ ‘b?Œ÷ : ? Ž 68: eF"jk= jf pE? Ž Grw? ‰w‰5Hac:jk"d xc eP? ²dfacj&? :‡~'c  =ˆ pybw: eP?n^™†acj : %÷Â=7?a% ’ F}‰ eF? hd  jk eP= ;ha% ?‚cbw pqö t $ ú  û²Š    t  !C!  Ž 6©Ž /Ž 6¾‘‰ibwpqø(Ž Œ 5 ? :   # :"= # = :  : ? =7?&;   # Ž ‰wjfpqbw‚%eJj 68eFjk†Î‘‚?t  !>!AwŽ A -€CŽ Âe ˆ eJbwø%eJ†NŽ   : =  : ? =7?;  ? = 5 # =7?  #' #  Ž -†yrTeFj Jc÷weJ‡\pycti„…a%nodka%bƒt  !C!  Ž 

Suggest Documents