KKN>^ uU u the LIML estimator and ^ C the JP P estimator of Arellano and Bover.
(1995). All results are based on 5000 replications and the integrated likelihood ...
Dgdswlyh Hvwlpdwlrq ri wkh G|qdplf Olqhdu Prgho zlwk Il{hg H hfwv E| Wlhphq Zrxwhuvhq dqg Pdufho Yrld
_
Vhswhpehu 5335
Devwudfw Wklv sdshu vkrzv krz wkh g|qdplf olqhdu prgho zlwk {hg uhjuhvvruv fdq eh h!flhqwo| hvwlpdwhg1 Wklv g|qdplf prgho fdq eh xvhg wr glvwlqjxlvk vsxulrxv fruuhodwlrq iurp vwdwh ghshqghqfh dqg zh vkrz wkdw wkh lqwhjudwhg olnholkrrg hvwlpdwru lv dgdswlyh iru dq| dv|pswrwlfv zlwk W lqfuhdvlqj zkhuh W lv wkh qxpehu ri revhuydwlrqv shu lqglylgxdo1
Nh|zrugv= Sdqho gdwd/ H!flhqw Hvwlpdwlrq/ Ed|hvldq Dqdo|vlv MHO fodvvlilfdwlrq= F64/ F66/ F44/ F47 4
Lqwurgxfwlrq
Wkh dqdo|vlv ri wkh g|qdplf olqhdu prgho zlwk {hg h hfwv kdv ehhq vxemhfw ri vrph dwwhqwlrq lq hfrqrphwulfv iru voljkwo| pruh wkhq wzr ghfdghv/ vwduwlqj zlwk Qlfnhoo +4 zh kdyh=
S S 2 H r+|cr3 H|c3 ,2 5 r H +|cr3 H| c3 , 3 3 @ . R + QW , . R + QW , . 2 QW 2 S 2 2 3 r H|cr 3 . W H|cr3 3
@
. R +QW ,
2
dqg wkxv zh ghulyh A HO44 dv
4
QW
HO44 @
4
QW
[[ 2
r Zh qrz frqvlghu O4 O4
O4 O4
#S r %r
@
S 2 r %r
@ Jlyhq wkdw
S
4
Q
2
H|cr3
2
>
. R Q 3W 32 . R Q 3W 3 =
=
+|S cr3 H| c3 , S
A
[
Q
$2
r %r 2
+|cr3 H|c3,2 . 5 S 'r +%r,+% , |cr3 H|c3 |c3 H|c3 = S S 2 2 r %r A
H%r @ 3> H%2r @ 2 dqg H%r % @ 3 iru m 9@ v> zh kdyh H O4 O4
H O4 O4
zlwk
2 H|cr 3 .
.R
@H
02 E+ H r r cr
S
+
S S 2 2 % r r A
0r E0 +cr 'r ES S 2 2 A r 0r
+
wkdw lv
H|c3,2 . 5 S 'r +%r,+% , |cr3 H|c3 |c3 H|c3
+
2 3.+ c3 n2
3
S 2 r %r |cr3
,
3
3.+ c3
44
,++c
3
3.+ c3
,@
>
@ j2 Sr H|cr2 3 2jA2 H|cr32 . jA2H|cr32 . R +QW ,3 @ j2 Sr H|cr2 3 jA2 H|cr32 . R +QW ,3 = H +O ,+O , @ H S O Lqghshqghqfh dfurvv lqglylgxdov dqg HO4 @ 3 jlyhv A 4 4 4 O4 / A vr/ zh kdyh
4
QW
H +O4 ,+O4 ,
4 H [ [ H|2 4 [ H| 2 . R Q 3W 32 > @ QW cr3 cr3 2 Q 2 r
zklfk jlyhv
4
H +O4 ,+O4 ,
4 HO44 . R Q 3W 3 = @ QW
QW Dqg wkxv wkh Dv|=ydu +e u , lv jlyhq e|=
3 4 Dv|=ydu +e u , @ HO44 . QW
Qrz xvlqj wkh idfw wkdw dv=
Dv|=ydu +e u ,
@
%
Dv|=ydu +e u , @
4
A [ [
QW
2
r'
R Q 3W 3 =
A HO44 3 . R Q 3W 3
H +|cr3 H |3
2
,
&3
3
zh fdq uhzulwh lw
. R Q 3W 3
@ 42 Y du +|cr3, . R Q 3W 3 @ +4 2, 2 Dv|=ydu +e u , @ 4 2 . R Q 3W 3 =
2
3
. R Q 3W 3
Wkxv/ wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh ri wkh lqihdvleoh pd{lpxp olnholkrrg hvwlpdwru htxdov dw wkh olplw wkh Fudphu0Udr orzhu erxqg
4 2 +vhh dovr Kdkq dqg Nxhuvwhlqhu +5335,,
T=H=G= Dsshqgl{ 61 Wkhruhp 4
Wr eh vkrzq=
s
QW +e U f, $_ Q +3> 4 2,=
Surri= d, Ghwhuplqlqj wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh ri wkh lqwhjudwhg olnholkrrg hvwlpdwru1 Xvlqj
OU4
dv d prphqw/ |lhogv wkh iroorzlqj dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh +vhh/ iru h{dpsoh/ Qhzh|
dqg PfIdgghq
+4 2
@ 4 e + , 4 W
QW
2
H
# [[
r
$
|cr3 2
46
. Q 4 2 H
# [
$
| 3
2
. R Q 3W 32 >
zlwk
e + , @ A
SA r'
+W v,+v 4, r32 dqg #
A 4[ e + , @ olp +W v,+v 4, r32 olp A zh kdyh= OcU 4
3
cU cU O4 O4
@
42 S H| % | r cr 3 c3 r Ce 2 D S S 2 W %r i r %r i EA 3 S r %r |cr3 H| c3 S e 2 e 2 S 2 W % i % i r r r EA 3 S 2 S 2 r %r |cr3 H| c3 'r %r % |cr3 H| c3 |c 3 2 2 S S 2 W % i % i r r r EA 3
+ + . + + , .5
+ ,.
@ + , .5 + , +
.
Jlyhq wkdw H%r
A [
@ 3> H%r @ 2
2
dqg
,
,
. ,
. , . + ,+ , + . , .
H%r% @ 3 iru m 9@ v/ zh kdyh H
OcU 4
H|c3
=
cU wkdw O4
lv cU H OcU O4 4
S r %r |cr3 H|c3 e H S S 2 2 W % i % i r r r EA 3 S S 2 2 r %r |cr3 H| c3 'r %r % |cr3 H|c3 |c 3 H 2 2 S S 2 W % i % i r r r EA 3
@ e+ , .5 + ,
2
+
. Exw
H
EA
3
+ + . , .5 + +
S c @ 3 . R +QW ,3 S r S0rEE+0crr ns3 .+ 2 2 3A 0 ns + r , 3
3
r
47
dqg
,
, . ,+ , . , .
H|c3
=
S
2 H r 0r E+cr
+
,+
S 2 3.+ c3 n2 'r E0r E0 +cr3 3.+ c3 +c 3 3.+ c3 S S 2 2 2 EA 3 r E0r ns 3A 0r ns
3
,
+ , @ j2 . jA2 H|cr3 2 . R +QW ,3 . R +QW ,3 > vr/ zh kdyh wkdw = @ j2 cU 4 [ 2 W H| 2 . R +QW ,3 = O4 @ e + ,2 . 2 H|cr H OcU cr3 4 3 2 S 2 r H|cr3 S 2 r H|cr3
2 2A j2 H| cr3 2 A j2 H| cr3
r
Lqghshqghqfh dfurvv lqglylgxdov dqg HOU4
@ 3 jlyhv A H
OU4 OU4
@ A H S
OcU 4
OcU 4
/
vr/ zh kdyh wkdw
4
QW
H OU4 OU4
zkhuh
e + , @ A
2 [[ 4 [ H| 2 . R Q 3W 32 > 2 @ e +W , . QW4 2 H|cr cr3 3 Q 2
r
SA r'
+W v, r3> e + ,2 @ #
SA r' A
+W v, r3
$2
A 4[ olp e + , @ olp +W v, r3 @ Aolp A 4 O4 @ A HO44 wkdw lv R W zh fdq zulwh=
4
QW
r3
HOU44 @
4
QW
H OU4 OU4
v r3
. R W 3 >
wkhuhiruh/ wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh ri wkh lqwhjudwhg olnholkrrg hvwlpdwru lv jlyhq e| 3 4 U Dv|=ydu +e U , @ HO44 . R W 3 = QW
48
Dv|=ydu +e U ,
%
4
[ A [
, W +4 ,2 QW r' 3 4 4 @ 2 Y du +|cr3, W +4 ,2 . R W 3
@
2
H +|cr3 H |3
3
@ +4 2, 2 . R W 3 Dv|=ydu +e U , @ 4 2 . R W 3 = Wkxv/ zkhq erxqg/
W
2
&3
. R W 3
. R W 3
$ 4> wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh htxdov dw wkh olplw wkh Fudphu0Udr orzhu
2
4
4
2
1
T=H=G= e, Lqwhjudwhg olnholkrrg hvwlpdwru lv qrupdoo| glvwulexwhg Wr suryh qrupdolw| ri wkh lqwhjudwhg olnholkrrg hvwlpdwru zh uhgh qh OcU 4 @ e + , .
zkhuh %
@
SA
4
OcU 4
dv=
[
2
|
+%| %,|c|3>
@ +%| %,|c|3> wkhq 4 [ x|= OcU @ e + , .
|' 0| = Li zh gh qh x| A
4
2
|
@ K AE4 . j2 x|> wkhq zh fkhfn wkh frqglwlrqv ri wkh Olqgehuj0Ohy| Fhqwudo Olplw Wkhruhp +vhh Juhhqh +5333,,= Li zh gh qh y|
Hy|
@ 3
4 Hy|yr y, ? 4> Hy|2 ?
iru
v 9@ o=
Wr fkhfn wkh uvw frqglwlrq zh frqvlghu frpsxwlqj=
Hy| @ Jlyhq wkdw
e + , 4 . 2 Hx|= W |
Hx| @ H +%| %,||3 > zkhuh ||3 @ |3 |f . 334 4 i . |32% . = = = %|32 . %|3 >
3
49
dqg
H%| @ 3> zh kdyh wkdw
@ @
Hx|
dqg wkdw
H +%| %,||3
4 |3 | 32 H +%| %, f. 4 i . % . = = = %|32 . %|3 |3 @ |3|fH+%| %, . 4 4 i H+%| %, .H+%| %, |32% . = = = . %|32 . %|3 @ H +%| % . = = = .W%A 3 . %A , |32% . = = = . %|32 . %|3 2 2 |3 2 @ W |32 . = = = . . 4 @ W 4 4 @ W e + ,
|3 |
Hx| @ j
2 K E4
A
> zh kdyh Hy| @
Li zh frpsxwh
Hy|2> zh kdyh Hy|
2
@ @ @
Jlyhq wkdw
Hx2|
@ @
H H
e
e + , 2 e + , 2 W @ 3= W
+ , . 4 x|2
W
# e
e
2
+ , 2 . 5 e + , 4 x| . 4 x2
W
W 2
|
+ , 2 . 5 e + , 4 Hx| . 4 Hx2=
W
e
$
W 2
e
|
% lv RR W 3 2 > wkhq iru Hx2| zh kdyh
H ^+%| %,||3`2 @ H +%| ||3 %||3 ,2 @ H +%|||3 ,2 5H%%| ||23 . H%2 ||23 % 2 & 4 |3 | | 2 3 32 H %| |f . . R W 3 2 . R W 3 i . % . = = = %|32 . %|3 4
2
. 4 4 i . |32% . = = = %|32 . %|32 |3 4 |3 .5 |f 4 i . 5 |3|f |32% . = = = %|32 . %|3 4 |3 |32 .5 4 i % . = = = %|32 . %|3` . R W 3 2 . R W 3 % & 4 |3 2 |3 4 |3 2 |3 2 @ |f . 4 i . 5 |f 4 i . R W 3 2 . R W 3 4 |3 2 2 | 3 @ |f . 4 i . R W 3 2 . R W 3 = @
H%| 2^ |3|f
2
|3
4:
Jlyhq wkdw Wr fkhfn
Hx| ? 4 dqg Hx2| ? 4 iru m m ? 4 dqg W
Hy| yr y, ? 4> iru v 9@ o zh zulwh Hy| yr y,
@ @ @
Zh kdyh wkdw
H
e
$ 4/ zh kdyh wkdw Hy|2 ? 41
+ , . 4 x| e + , . 4 xr e + , . 4 x,
W 2 W 2 W 2 $ # 2 + , 4 e + , e + , 4 . 2 x| . eW +xr . x, , . e xrx, H W W e + , e + , 2 4 . W 2 H +x| . xr . x, , W . eW+ e, H +xrx, . x|xr . x|x, , . 4S Hx|xrx, = e
H +x| . xr . x, , @ Aj e + ,/ zklfk lv R W 3 2
H +xr x, . x| xr . x| x, ,
@
/ dovr zh kdyh
H +%r %,+%, %,|r3|,3
.H+%| %,+%r %,||3|r3 . H+%| %,+%, %,||3|,3 @ R W 3 2 . R W 3 zkhq w 9@ v 9@ o dqg lv 4 |3 2 2 | 3 @ |f . 4 i . R W 3 2 . R W 3 zkhq w @ v ru o= Iru
Hx| xr x, zh kdyh
Hx| xr x,
@ @
H +%| %,+%r %,+%, %,||3 |r3|,3 H%| %r %, ||3 |r3|,3 H%%| %r ||3 |r3|,3 H%%r %, ||3 |r3|,3
H%%|%, ||3|r3|,3 . H%2 +%| . %r . %, , ||3|r3|,3 H% ||3|r3|,3
@
R W32
. R W 3 . R
W32
1
Wkxv/
Hy| yr y,
e
+ , . e + , R W 3 2 . R W 3
@ 5 W W e .R W 3 2 . R W 3 . R W 3 2 @ R W 3 . R W 3 2 . R W 3 . R W 3 2 . R W 32 >
4;
zkhq
w 9@ v 9@ o dqg lv
Hy|yry,
@ 5
e
+ , . e + ,
W
#
2
W e
$
4 |3 2 | 3 |f . i . R W 3 2 . R W 3 4
. R W 3 . R W 3 2 @ R W 3 . R W 3 . R W 3 2 . R W 3 . R W 3 2 . R W 32 > .R
zkhq
W32
w @ v ru o= Wkxv/ zh kdyh wkdw Hy| yr y, ? 4= iru m m ? 4 dqg W
$ 4=
Wkh frqglwlrqv ri Fhqwudo Olplw Wkhruhp duh vdwlv hg iru hdfk lqglylgxdo
l= Lq rughu wr vkrz
wkdw wkh Lqwhjudwhg Olnholkrrg Hvwlpdwru lv dv|pswrwlfdoo| Qrupdo Glvwulexwhg zh qhhg wr dffrxqw iru doo lqglylgxdov
zkhuh %
l= Ohw
OcU s4 W
cU
@ % . x>
q Q 3> .uA44 > Hx @ 3 dqg Hx2 @ r +4,/ ehfdxvh zh suryhg wkdw #
OcU H s4 W Wkxv zh kdyh wkdw=
S
$#
S
s
S
OcU s4 W
uIcU 4 A
Q
$
#
cU @ H OW44
$
. r +4, =
S %
S x =
@ sQ . sQ
U
@ I0 dqg x @ I > wkhq % q Q 3> .uA44 dqg H +x, @ S 2 H x2 @ @ r +4, vlqfh zh dvvxphg lqghshqghqfh dfurvv lqglylgxdov1 Li zh gh qh
%
Zh suryhg wkdw/
U sO4 QW
#
U 44 q Q 3> HO QW
dqg wkh uhvxow iroorzv1
T=H=G=
4
