"! # " $ % &' ( ) * + ,- + . / ) ( 0 1 2 &' ( ) * + ,3) 4 5 + / ( 01 6 2 + 4879' * * 1 ,:1 4 ; < / ' 4 ' TQ U @ M D"V8@ M W =8B D> U ? X \@ H ] A C>S K B > L @ O DC DA HDE LDE DMF G F ^NH D I H >@ CH A O JD V8A > @P B CA CB BK DQ> L M E DC PDE _ R8D` @ aM LF bNA b"P H Y R8CZ O @ DD Q L A[ PA > CP BA S DB Q cD EJ A D> D H R8H U B@D L G HA P I @S A J> B C K L D S d e f g h k i q j q k z l{ m | n | i } o } n } f xh f j o k q lw m l p f l h o j q k r xh r s o o s s p t v u q r i o r s h p w8v xq y i h r | h w8x y h AB~ CD B JX J @ I"U > > M HM D
"B E P GH G HH B XB BC PX M LC [ PP > B P[ W DG P ABB S8D C PJ D C SH [PB [X A @CDA [ D U @E@ P HD I A B @>C H JLH @D B L X PD> CU H H X B B DY D ?J"A >> C PUU D B> EC M8@ HA U D MPLU @ P? B D D H B A C C B H CD @ D H H> PM BW X @ P D YY H> MD P @ B AJ C B > X B JD P> P D P H @ DU AC >> BB DDP>> H @ D? P BD > U MBB @ IU B@ X M @DH E C >> MB >@ EP D @ BA B @" C B J X DC M > @ A E M W @ S8A@ @ L I A> HU M L > PH B BD A > C HH E BP XX D> H%A DP > C J"P L C J"M > C B M D> PAJ @ E D @ D A"B C H > A D P"? A D @ B L[ D DD E HC > HH B B P X D P B> J"B X D"DH D D H P BE S8S > AX B C CU XU C [ > AM@ >O H C E B P"D PB XB X > DB DB @" [ B DX U DB D EH [B > AM B> CP B PC @ > H M @ A C DB X U J@ J [ > DA D"[ A D PH D B H BM L H P D BB @ A D BP XL DM B P@ Y HD> >A BH C P U J C > D MB X> @H EE A> D H > E M CE H > B I >L M8P D B H P @ M D DE P X D@ IA @ BJX > A BD > M8H B D M?L PP BD P [ P DC @ A HI @ P A J"PD M > H E U > HD B A > U BJ"D > H Y ¡ ¢£¤¥8 ¦ ¢ §&+ ) * A >HB ¿ ¤ ET(U¡ U# 8 ¡ EV ¦ Ä7 ;1 ¨8081+ 48,7 .8, 1 1) 4%4, ; 0 0 ) / ¸1 1 4 5' 4 + ů Ì) ± / ; ¨808+ + / ;+ ; 50 1!1 ; )1 /
Mean clustering success percentage versus number of
Mean clustering success percentage (10 runs)
120 100 80 art3 art5 art6
60 40 20
70 10 0 13 0 16 0 19 0 22 0 25 0 28 0 31 0 34 0 37 0 40 0 43 0 46 0 49 0
40
10
0
8
D > HU M L P B D A C H "P L U U D P P@ O D A b"A L H PI @ AD > U XO > M L D@ I%$
! " #
b b b +
&(' )
HX' P B E + J D > HX' P B E + J"D > HX' P B E + J D > HX' P B E + F @ _a Mb Lb '' bb b ]b ++] a a a_ Xa '' a b < ++ ]a `_ bb '' bb M< < ++ bb LM M\ '' bb bb bb ++ bb L< B C @ 3*H ? W"45> H B P< T c > U X = L L P >J D A B DD B MA"P >S > >H MH 6E M EÊ V8 & c > C @D LB > A SC H ZD SC O D D E A PP C B W%S[ > [8H E%> _ E ] > [ B ] > a B SC @ H%G C RH[ V@ A [ D LP P M >SB C @ > H JP"? @ A IC E U M L D PSB DA C > H P Y \ >V8 H B P S L9"H' C B H< !+ S > [HM C [E 78 Z ] M ] H 9 < W 'b D b A< P + SS [ T[8J < D b A D B C @ H> H E A > [ X[ > A B C B C @ H C H S C H M C 7 ` J D A C U @> HMJE > > B A > U ?X>D Q PS D P C B M X%C J> > A H B CD S U >C > H ME> HB 5P S D C H HB L 45A C H C S :H C J" [ A 6@ O 2C H 3*U M L P B 5D ;A C H C H%/ H L Y H Z"M@ MM @ M c8 W M @ SA =8D > > H L @ P S8> H ^ H D SC U @ L C EB ! S D > A HM > EH E c S[ [8@ H E \ > a M \ > S \ D _ E < P S S [ A C H C P D PA Y c D D E A D M A> > M8S G H _ P Y B C B `%L B DD [@ I B D R8J"D ?U XD AY L @ H =8B X > D? AU @X U D X J D CS U > M A D U @ @ H JH C > B AC @U XH D Q P S W > P H B E"D J¿@ I8 > D H H B B P L S A C H C L P "B D A C H > M @ 6A C (*B X J¿ ? > P D E / ? ('2&;@ A A @ B C545 %#*2:( S [ [ _ ] < _ ] M S a b b a M " b %D2@E M> AE35M @C H ? M D >A; H > G H ET0 D@CE M M P M @E H8@ S? M F'D A S &2 R X DÍ [ C A HÉC H A D D A U @ D H A CM B> C @ SHÉ D P A W M CP H8B DS J D A @ J I¿> H U W> SA [ DM H M Bb D A E O>^ H@ MBD P D UD M >AS J"> [ H [[ E@ H T@ a B _ L XP8CP_ S [ ] [8S MC H LC C \ H X C D B A X > DA U P X B AC UL > U M B UL L A D D P8@ CI HL PP JD A > > M U BU C@ O M C@ B HWC DL P P S C H H&U M L P IB D A P B > ,? C M C B W SJ C H S ! / & K% L % K J2 C', ; 2&M1(* & N "M W H H / > S J" )C U O^ X 2&> W U C5[ @ D2? A P B D D H S BD@ M CA H A @ C B >H 9A S U SaC > b Y bC H%a @ M C H > 95S > &H E"> N8 K8Z>KW >KM SS [ c [ A @ J¿b b L ` P D Ab > U ] U S D P PM M[ \ > B B D A H P _ J ^ 5 @ DE >D DM A U M >L H P BE%D A TC H > X H C E SC HG E I @ D AH J B C > B U C > @ B HC @ P H%U D @ H IB S D a ?%b b L P D AB A > P"UU @ J [ @ P C B C @ HL P C H JL M B C Y ] A @ ? LTP P BB C UO M C L M M P Y BD >A CP H B A @@ >IH > EU U ^D PP">M @ H P S S6 45 > B D @
J", C U > M W% ? S W%O @I >M P Ba > M H L E S [ [ ] M L < b M S8a b b < Z" M C 78S8V8 DL P ? > H E P S ^ 8D W D A S8> H E Ê S D E P SF' !; (* 0> J, ? +"A C E D S Q> P P U2X ! L P D B B I P %S H&M M ] I R# +S2 + 