Convergence of a fully discrete finite element method for a degenerate


  
!"# $&%#(')%#*+ ,-.%/,0&%21
345
6 .  #7%#(89: #" !" %?, ,-
3.0,@A%2+(CB+D E!" %F@=ACe\ L;Y RQz:BC&ED FG4=D HJI X SKFG4![LM X D F7ND X 4!LPORQYS4![ ”` UTP*V>WYX YÈuZ6-[B[6@uG\)[W\Y]Y6 Yz5N zaS [ 4 X ;=< 7P>@ c e\ L%^_4 X F7 ` ”` UT Yz5N zCz[ nU{_bz aªVJpWWUiSr^r_TUidr_T€SWUVg€`_”WUŒSkFS`Oe‡z×i5{_`^e^ST|‡p+i5`Oe\ÃW”id`^naNg‚j_VnU|\nªWVC~ Y›h . [7~ˆi\e\VCkŒn/u ].„ Sdn e\VaTU L5VJe z‹|  S5k€e\VaTUVaTa Y f:i5k€/zdY_S`^e7Y z?[}YÈh [ „mÃWj&{$ uS5`^e{($—3” v'3zdN R i5WUjWUj_Vno|\noWUVC~ YÈh . [Y^ i5T&G' u^YOS5`^eÃWqnATVCb5{^k€S5TU€•CVJe LdVCTqno€i5` YÈh .  ƒ [m~ {^noW7z×V no{^r_r_k€VC~ˆVC`‹WUVJez…|!€`_ÃW€S5k2S5`^e z×i5{^`^e_ST|®p+id`^e\”WU€i5`^n €`!idTe\VaT.WiˆzOVS pCk”i‹noVJe!nU|\nªWVC~N&f7n‚€7` R %t SxY…WUj_V: i5k€k€iZ„m”`_b”`^ÃW€S5k¥S`^e!zOid{_`^e_S5TU|3p+id`^e\”WU€i5`^n „m€k€k¥zOVgpCi5`^nUŒe\VCTVae)”`Wj_€n‚rOSr×VCT Y s[N4 Ykgl6u [%>W4 ƒ Ykgl6u [> Ykg[6 Y W[U7vYhgl6u [>Y7 ƒ Yhgi6Uu [:> Yhg[‘6 g o6 Y›t_QN z![ Y s[n4 Yhgi6-j [%>W4 ƒ Ykgl68j [> Yhg[‘6 Y 4[:7vYkgl6-j [C>Y7 ƒ Yhgi6-j [> Yhg[6 Ykgl6-j [No ; UT ] Y›t_N t [ „mj^VCTV ;  T *V> ;  X{YÈEu 68[B[ ׍‚j_Ti5{_bdj_i5{\WmWj_V rOSr×VCTJYO„ V S5e_i5r\WAWj_VnoWS5`^e_S5Te`_i5WSWU€i5` i5T } i5z×i5k€4V LnUr^S5pCVanAS5`^e Wj_VC€T®S5nnUi…pC€SWUVJe `_i5T~3nCNK]_idT`^iWSWU€i5`^S5k pCi5\` L5Va`_€VC`^pCV5YF„ VÝe\TUidr Wj_VÝe\i5~3S€`  Ti5~ Wj_V`_i5T~ S5`^e nUVC~ˆ”w§`_idTU~ nU{_z^np+T€r\WaY\”$Wj_Vge\i5~3S5”`)€nn  ]\VdN bON#`^i5T~ *V> S5`^e)nUVC~ˆ”w§`^i5T~ D ˆD * > D ˆD N&P=V €`‹WUTi\e\{^p+VgS5k€nUi A Y_ [* > 2 o A YS [U* G> Ýi5` ; ?92] O A  H Y_ [* > 2 |oO A  H Y_ [U* > ®i5` ; ?9#6 Y›t_N u [ „mj^VCTV ( * > t ”  &> uS`^ze ( z*V>~3ž’“)”’–—Š/–1’“­Š—™tŽ’Š!, I Ž’“)”›, ¦ JŽ’Š/–³¡¬¤Â‹9–—“­Ž'”:”’–—Š/–1’“t‹ , I 6T, ¦ lw qL 6 J¨

R

S #Y

X 4z![

. ƒ Œ2J4 ƒ 687 ƒ 9 Y›t_QN z![ (Y›t\N¢rt [ .XrY YÈuZ6-[B[6 ‡XKY_ [ [ ]#€TnoWUk€|®€`!Wj_V:WUj_Vai5TVC~6z×VCk€iZ„Y\„Vr_Ti   < 7 ƒ €`{›Y t\N  | z[ Y^S5`^e)Sde_e\€`_bˆ|…”Vak€e_nmWUj^SW B

X
 BC™  < FG4 ƒ X
 B) A &sY8D FG4 ƒ D HJI X F4 ƒ 6‡FZYk < 4 ƒ [-[lB X rYS4 ƒ [ X B „ X [  < 7 ƒ X
 c B X  D F{7 ƒ I A D X 6Z < YS4 ƒ [ X BC™  Yk < 4 ƒ [ X B  YS4 ƒ [ X B „ X 6Z < D F7 ƒ D X BM™  D  < F7 ƒ D X B ^ O Q YS4 ƒ [‘6Z < 4 ƒ ` t > ^ O Q YS4 ƒ I A [6Z < 4 ƒ ` Y›t\N zJt [ I ‚j^Vgp+i5`\LdVWV\ÃWª|3i5UD F }D H  i5T ($ zgS5`^e O # €~r^k”|!WUj^SW z ™  D F  D HJI X F  ‡FZYk <  [U' R D F  D H L’D F  I A D H!S…6 Y§t\N z u S [ ( OR# Q Y  [b <  '— < O # Y  [' OR# Q Y  I A [b <  Y§t\N z u ?z [ f7k€nUi^YOSe_”TVap+WmpaSkŒp+{_kŒSZW”id`)|…€VCkŒe_n WUjOSZW D F  I A D X  < Y  [ X B R Y  [ X B „ X S5 < D F  D X >Y <  RQY  [ X B „ X SbD F  D X  Y›t\N zC\y [ f7r_r_k€|…”`_bˆWj_Vi5r×VCTqSZWi5T  A ™Y\WU9i Y›t_QN z rt [ S`Oe!`_i5WU€`_Ab Y›t_QN z u S^Y ?z [S`O7e Y§t\N zC\y [qY\|…”Vak€e_nm i5T !>#zˆ6qbt 6 -@WUjOSZW z }A‘& t  A FG4 ƒ X
 Be X rY Y_4 ƒ [ X B „ X [  F7 ƒ X
  B ( lF4 ƒ H
 B O YS4 ƒ [b#g  A B  ™  < 4 ƒ X
 B X KY Y_4 ƒ [ X B „ X [  < 7 ƒ X
 B ™  < F4 ƒ X
 t    A c   B X ™  0Yk < 4 ƒ [EF7 ƒ I A X
 B KY Y_4 ƒ [ X B „ X [   < F7 ƒ X
  t 6

 < 4 ƒ

6

X
 B t A

   6

6

6

6

¦

4

8

L

L

¡L

Q

4

L

¡L

L

L

1L

1L

¡L

L L

Q

4

1L

Q

4

M8J8J8

6

6

6

6

6

6

6

t

z

X

=A:6F,6
 B) 

„mj^VCTV G Œnm”`Oe\VCr×VC`^e_VC`‹WAi™S5`^e „ N $ V+W

6

E

6

6



6

6

36

X KY X B „ X [  F X
  6 ¡,

>6

>06

B

6

=A‚& 6 F,6 H B 
 (

< I < =  < <  A – =  4 ƒ YX8 [lB = – = I 4 ƒ I YT8 [ j:o R j I A 86 j 4 ‘ƒ¦  – YX8 86 j [U*V>Y4 ƒ YX8 [6 4 ‘ƒ I  – YX8 68j [U* >W4 ƒ I A YX8 [  j o{Yhj I A 6-j 

4‰ƒ‘ –-YX8 68j U [ *V>

y

6

S

S

t €>#z#6tb6

E

O

Y—, [b#g

€>#z#6 b6M8J8M8J 6 M8J8M8Jn4

G6

Y›t\N zJv [ Y§t\N zx5S [ Y§t\N z5x z?[

Y [mS`Oe ;=< 4 ƒ‘ – B)}Au I 
9O  A  voŽ X YÈZu 6-[}] O d H YS [ zŽ “ Y_ [ [67Y§t\N z!|ZS [  |oŽ X Y›Eu 68[}] d A YS [ [ R
QY_4 ƒ‘ – [ X B „ X S O ; < 7ƒ‘ – Be c F{7 ƒ‘ – F Q ˆg?ˆj> u Y§t\N z!|Z?z [ †‡i5TVCb Y›t_N u u5S^Y ?z [#S5`^e Y§t\N u t5S_Y ?z [Y_S5r_r_k€|‹€`_| b f:Ti5`…„ S5k”k T n€`_%V Md{OSk€ÃWª|!S5`^e)`_iW”`_bˆWj_VgS5nnU{_~ˆVae)TUVab5{_kŒSTÃWª|ˆ|…€VCkŒe_n‚WUj^Vge\VanU”TVae)TVanU{_kÃWJN . ƒ l d H d n$nIsH b 5 7 /&' u E( $m Y›t\N z%[ {Y›t_N t [ „ o{YÈEu 6zWS n{> t 7‚j^VFTUVJno{^kÃW  idk”k€iZ„AnE”~ˆ~ˆVaAe_ €SWUVCk€|t_N < ; = ?> v> t 6 Œo ‡X YS [ 3 4 a\d H a  ; Yo GX   J A „ $Ku d‰ ƒ AY§t\N z%[ Y§t\N¢rt [ E[R$ u 6)Q›6



C6)Q6

@

D G

 

6 Q6

D G



    



D G



D G

6








D G








O

E





Q

D G

6

D G

D G

p6

96

D G

6



6

D G

D G

6

6

6

6

D G

6

D G

Å6

8

E

³6

36

D G

]6

6

6



i6



D G

   




D G

6



D G

36




6

6

6

³6



6

6

6

i6

i6

:6

6

D G

6

6

³6

6

6

6

6

6

6

6



36

6

D G

:6

D G

6



'6

D G

36 6



6  6

D G

36

6

6



6

:6

i6

i6

i6

1*

i*

ńv†+‡H† ]N£Ž’“H¤$½ Ÿ‰” y‹ œtÂJ‰
€J‰
Ž’ŠB•>’Š ’“)‰5Š/£^’“ŸÃ>J’§ ‘yŠ+–1N“~– ¬

»Ž’“)” t¨

Ž’“)”C‹iŠ¡™S‰5¤Â5Š`‰J•

·1¹

º 5‘tŒ¡¼J‰žJŠ¯Š`

¹¯£^MX¬
¨

Ž’“)” ^O

^O

X«

Á

S

Š¡™SŽNŠ Š´

„v† p† 5“»Ž:”:”N–—Š+–1N“²Š`kŠ—™t‰>ŽÂ5‘y•œ)Š+–1N“ST¬ ‰+½i“H–—Š+–1N“ f¨ ’‹ª˜9‰ŽÂ5‘y•C‰Š¡™SŽNŠ Ÿ‹p, €0 ¸O ³– ‰
–—Š¡™S‰J£Ž"žN“ ’‰ œSN§¶¤JÃf’“¢ŽN§”'’•CŽ’–—“²’£ f¨>±)™S‰J“¬
N£Ž’“t¤½ Ÿ‰€” S‹Š—™t‰›5¤Â5Š`‰J•7·1¹ Ž’“¢” ™SŽÂŽk‘y“t– J‘t‰5Š/£^’“ŸÃ>J’§¶‘yŠ/–1’“¬
’£ŽN§—§ ¢¨

|

‹¯Ž’“¢” º ‘tŒ1¼J‰ž
Š

!$V+N W 2J4‚ƒJ6‡7ƒJ9mzOVmS:„VJS‰ nUi5k€{\W”id`i5  YÈh d‚ ƒ4[+Y5„mj_i‹noV‚4V V…ŒnoWUVC`Op+V‚„ Sdn#VanoWSz^k”Œnoj^Vaez‹|‚j_VCidTUVa~Ht\N z5YZ„ V‚„ S5`dW?Wi nUj_iZ„ WUj^SWn254 ƒ 687 ƒ 97SdpWU{OSk€k”|gz×VCk€i5`^bWUi>R Ž.XKY YÈuE68[B[_] ‡XrY_ [ [ SŒXdN#2iWUj^€n&Va`^e YdÃW.nU{ ®p+VJn?WUige\VaTU L5VmS:r_T”idTU\VJnªW”~3SWUVan  idUT 4 ƒ S5`^e|7 ƒ €`®Wj_VŽXrY YÈuE68[B[_] ‡XKY_ [ [.`_i5T~N%s Ž“@YÈZu 6-[}]  Y ;  [ [ 

ƒ

JN§¶‘yŠ+–1N“~Š´·1¹

„v† p† !“)”:‰J£Š¡™S‰"ŽÂ5‘y•œ)Š+–1N“S>X¬ ‰+½i“H–—Š+–1N“ f¨ ‹¥ŽœSŽN–—£CX¬B¬‘y“)ž
Š/–1’“t º ‹i˜–—Š¡™ ~Ž’“)” S‹5‘tŒ1¼J‰€žJŠªŠ` Ž’“¢” – ¬ kJŽNŠ+–³¡½B‰


O

p«

,

’·TŽ º

T,

K

ŽN“¢”

¦

0

–—“¸¾ ’‹ ˜!™S‰J£^‰

0

–—“

€O

O

)¬
N£Ž:¨—‰ŽN–—“ ’Ž’§¶–1”"˜!™S‰J“~Š¡™S‰£^‰
5Š+£5–1žJŠ+–1N“t($’~–³˜9‰ŽMµ'‰J“¢‰”CŠ´N($ f¨

ZY

[

&z

yn !  

 ’Œ …$
¥#

!

  $zJ#

‚{

‘`!WUj_Œn‚noVJpW”id`¥Y…„V:r_TVanUVC`‹W S r_TSdpW€paSkO {_k”k€|®e\ŒnUpCTUVCWUVBP^`_”WUV:VCk€VC~ˆVC`‹W‚~ˆV+WUj^i…e® i5TmSr^r_TUi!V\€~3SZWU€`_bWj_V:TUVab5{_kŒST”•aVae r^TUidz_k”Va~ YÈh .  [YY›t_N y‹S_Y z?[Y\S`Oe3WU.j^V:e\Vab5Va`_VCTqSZWV7r_Ti5z_k€VC~ Y›h . [+Y;Y›t\N y-zJS_Y z?[N?Š.noWS5z_k€€nUj_€`_bnU{_z^nUVM‹{_Va`^p+V:p+i5`\LdVCTb5VC`Op+V i5$Wj_VSr_r_Ti!V\”~3SWU€i5`ˆWUi9YÈN[ YÈh  [Y\„m”WUj&{' u_YJ($’3S`^e „ o{YÈuZ64z4S§Y\S5n z×iWj!Wj_Vnor^SWUŒSkE~ˆVanUj)nU”•aV u®” v>zi5} T YÈ?z [n&$ u3S`^e ( $m!Ã% '&zdY^S5?n ˜¥EY ™ÝS5`^e „ S5k”k WVC`^e„ Wi3•CVaTUiON.‚j_Vg‰dVC|!Vak”Va~ˆVC`‹Wn‚ idTmWUj^Vgp+i5\` LdVCTb5VC`Op+V S5TUV‚WigVanoWS5z_k€€nUj3Se\€np+TV+WVAVC`^VCTb5|gkŒS „KS5`^e3Se\ŒnUpCTUVCWUVA~3KS V…€~ {^~ r_T”`Op+€r_k”V7„mj_€pqj3~ˆ€~ˆ€p‚Wj_VAVa`_VCTb5|k€S #„ Y›t_N dS_Y ?z [ S5`^e)WUj_V~3KS V…€~ {^~ r_T”`^pC”r^k”Vd6Y Y €N [ i5 h/tÝS`Oe rOidk”|…j_VJe\TS5kF”N M> u N ¥VCW 2 9 ×z VÝS=TUVab5{_kŒST ÈS~ˆ”k€| i5*e\€S5~9Y  [S5`^e)˜R• *V> • ~3SKV   ˜ Y$noi)WUjOSZW >    Nt‘` S5e^e\ÃW”id`¥Y¥”W€nSdnUnU{_~ˆVae‡WUj^SW €nS7Y „ VaS5‰‹k€| [7Sdp+{\WVˆr^STUWU”WU€i5`_€`_b?] Wj^SZWŒn7 idTY›S [?z>Ht\Yׁ i5TS`…|r^S5”T:iSde5aoS5pCVC`‹W7WTUŒS`^b5k€VanmWj_V3no{^~/i5.i5r^rOi‹no• ”WUVˆS`_bdk”VJnATVCkŒSZWQLdVgWUi!WUj_V3pCi5~ˆ~ˆi5` nUŒe\Vge\i…Van‚`_i5WAWV V_p+VaVae 0]6Y z [U> u Y…WUj_VgS5`_b5k€VzOVCWª„VaVC`ÝS`…|3ÈSdp+VJn‚i$Wj_VgnS~ˆV:WUV+WTS5j_Vae_TUid`e\i…VJn‚`_iWA4V V\pCVCVJe X N $V+I W . e_VC`_i5WUVAWj_V PO`_ÃWV7Vak”Va~Va`‹W nUr^S5pCVmi$p+id`‹WU€`‹{^i5{^naY5r_€VapCVC„mŒnoV7k”€`_VaS5TF {_`OpWU€i5`OnSdnUnUi\p+ŒSZWUVJeˆ„mÃWj  • ]‹WUj^SW ŒnaY • d A . • *> 5 S ^ ` e . d • * >!. • • o G Y  [_] • D o A 6   o • Q d YS [6 „mj^VCTV A)ŒnWUj_V noVCWˆi5:O k€€`_VaS5T3rOidk”|…`_id~ŒSkŒnˆ€’`  L S5TUŒSz^k”VJnCmN ¥VCW N z×VWUj_V‡nUV+W®i5 YV(  [ i5TAS5k”k |o N&NFfQe\Œnp+TV+WUVnUVC~ˆ”w§€`_`_VaTmr_TUi\e\{OpWAi5` G Y  [ €n Wj_VC`Ýe\4V P^`_Vaez…| Y =A~6 X [ • *V>  • R =AKYhg[ X Yhg[ S1#g b>   =ArYV(  [ X YV(  [‘6 „mj^VCTV  * >Yz#6   [$Ku^N Y u QN z![   ]^i5T:p+i5\` LdVC`_€VC`^pCV5Y_„ Vg„m€k”k#S5nno{^~VWj^SZW r6 †o†O A  Y_ [Yׄmj_VCTV G* > ~ˆKS V2 6k( ˆ9 idTR2 • o1. • * • L" • |o1. d • 9 S5`^e . • * > 2 • o . • * • L# • Œo . d • 9 Y u Nt [ f.

&@$

¹¯£^MX¬
¨

J8J8M8

,

>L

­,

L

¦

¦

~,

"Q

X,

¦

0

tQ

0

¦

²0

¦

¦

g0

-Š¡™S‰J“

} ”~ˆ€k€S5TUk€|KWU#i Y›t\N¢st z![YY7 ƒ L ÝWUj^SW k€”~  – /nU{_d r
R Y/$ ƒ [ X B „ X SqD F,& ƒ D X #g!ˆjU k”€~K – nU{_d r
 • R Y/$ ƒ [ X B „ X SqD F,& ƒ D X #g!ˆj%>
Y_4 ƒX B „ X [‰D F7 ƒ D X #g!#j • • Y u N zJv [ } ”~ˆ€k€S5TUk€|‡Wi Y›t\N¢t u [ Y›t\N¢t5v [Y ”Wg i5k€k€iZ„An: TUid~ Y u QN z u [qY Y u QN za y [qvY Y u QN z rv [:S`^Ue Y u N zJtS^Y z [AWj^SZWi5`=WV V…WUTqS5p+WU€`_bÝS {_ToWj_VCT nU{_z^nUV M‹{_Va`^p+V:Wj^SZW # $ ƒ F,& ƒ L Š 4 ƒ F7 ƒ noWUTi5`_bdk”|3€ ` Ž X YÈEu 68[}]R Ž X Y_ [ S  [‚S5nn ˜l6b™ Š u Y u N zx [ $V+W 3oMŽ X YÈZu 6-[}] G d “ Y  [ [+t N xU &v>Hu^Y „Vˆpqj_i…idnUV >  Ý”8` Y u N yd S [qN xW i5k€k€iZ„AnA Ti5~ Y§t\N x [Y Y u N zrz![q2Y Y u QN z u [qY Y u N zx [qY Y u N z%[+Y Y u N |K[vY Y u N  [S`^U e Y u N¢rv [ u i5T7S5`…| oŽ.rX Y›Eu 68[}]-G/d “ Y  [ [N ‘` i5Tqe\VCT!WUi S5pqj_€4V LdVÝWUj^V pCi5TTUVJnor×i5`Oe\”`^b k”€~ˆÃWÝ€`WUj^V=paS5nU3 V &R$ u_YW A RQz:Be&ED FZYS4‰ƒ:B s[‚D HJI X SKFZY_4‚ƒ:B \[ 5FZR 4‰ƒB tL $ ƒ S5ˆg!#j
T B Y8D F{7:ƒ‘I  – D X 6- • R $ ƒ YS4‰ƒB tL $ ƒ [ S [lB Y ; < $ ƒB)ORQ Y.$ ƒ [LMORI Q Y/$ƒ I [‘6- • R 4‚ƒB SL $ ƒ [ • Q ˆj d O X LM}A R z:Be&ED F $ ƒ D HJI X SKF $ ƒ 1FZR Y 7tL" • [WY_4 ƒ B \[ S1#g!ˆj Y u N z!|r[
xWm idk”k€iZ„An  Ti5~ Y u N  [;Y Y u N zrz![S5`^eS`”\` LdVCTqnoV:”`^V M‹{^Sk€”Wª|3WUj^SW T T A r 7/L# • [WR $ ƒ Y5 • R 4 ƒ B SL $ ƒ [ S X
8 #j G/˜ X I  Y ‰FZY5 • R 4 ƒ B SL $ ƒ [ X
 #j Y u N za  [ d d s/u‡pCSdnoVdY$Wj_V)e_VanU”TVae TVanU{_k”mW Y›t_N y‹S [: idTS5`‹| ozŽrX Y YÈEu 68[B[_] G/d “ Y  [ [N ‚j^Ve\VJno€TVae‡TVanU{_k”W Y§t\N yd S A [A „m”WUPj &'Qu® idTS5`…| ŒoCŽ.X YÈZu 6-[}] O d A  H YS [ Ž:“@A  Y_ [ [/z’£·TŒ º &{$ šŽ’“)” ($’"– ¬|' zŸ¨±)™S‰J“ Š—™t‰
£^‰‰-:–³5Š+$Ž5‘tŒ

‰ 2 $ ƒ 6'& ƒ 9  –‰ ƒ d 5‘tž™Š¡™SŽ’Š ŽÂ!˜l6E™E6 „Š • $ ƒ L Š 4 Š/£^N“fÃ:§¶¤C–—“Ž   YSUT [‘6 $ ƒ & ƒ L Š 417 Š/£^N“fÃ:§¶¤C–—“Ž   YSUT[_]

3 4

u

[Ž’“¢”t A o{RQzˆ6 ]{S/‹l X o R z#6 ]5[J¨ id~ z_€`_€`_b3‚j_VCidTUVa~It\N y^Y_‚j^VCi5TVC~ u N z S5`^e7Y›t\N y‹v [|‹€VCkŒe_n Wj_Vge\VanU€TUVJe!TVanU{_k”WaN






#

n%‚ 

 

Y u N¢tu [

.

˜!™t‰
£€‰2J4#6€0l9"–³ŽC˜9‰ŽMµCJ’§¶‘yŠ/–1’“°Š`¸·1¹ ¹¯£^MX¬
¨

J‘t‰
“)ž‰

n%J#

!

­

‘` Wj_ŒnXP^`^S5knUVap+WU€i5` „ V3r_TUVJnoVa`‹W noVL5 VC– TqSk&`…{_~ˆVaTUŒpCS5kFVWV\r×VCT”~ˆVC`‹Wqng€` Wª„i‡nUr^S5pCV®e\€~Va`^nU”id`^nWUi9bdS{^b5VWUj_V! {_k€k”| e_€np+TV+WVBPO`_ÃWVVCk€VC~ˆVC`‹Wm~ˆV+WUj^i…e¥Y6YÈh• [Y^e\VL5Vak”idrOVJe®€`!Wj_Vr_TV4L…”id{^n‚noVJpW”id`¥N‘`Sde_e\”WU€i5`¥Y\id{_T‚`‹{^~VaTUŒpCS5k TUVJno{^kÃWqn T4V LdVaS5k×nUi5~ˆV:”`‹WUVaTUVJnªW”`^b  VJSZWU{^TUVJnCY_nU{^d‚pq ƒ j)Sdn VWV\€noWUVa`^p+VdY… i5T~3SZWU€i5`)S`^eS`_`^”j_€kŒSZWU€i5`)i#k”€`_Vno€`_bd{_k€S5TU”WU€Van YÈe_V+ Vap+Wn [Y i5FWUj^VŠ.TUŒpq‰\noVa`Ý~i\e\Vak YÈh d [0Y YzdQN zJS_Y ?z [N ‘`=Sk€k$Wj_V`…{_~ˆVaTUŒpCS5k24V V…r×VCT€~Va`‹Wn u^Y }A|> X > c > z5Y?S`^Me O YS4![t>X Y_4JX L z%[oXY?pªN R !t S§N‚j_Ti5{_bdj_i5{\WJY$„ V3{^nUV®S {^`_Á idTU~I€nUidnp+Vak”VJn TU€b5j‹Wow‘S`^b5k€Vae3WTUŒS`^b5{_kŒSZW”id`!i% „m”WUjŒ˜|> t˜S`OeS{_`^Á idTU~6W”~ˆVgnoWUVarz™=N P=V‚nªWqSTUW#„m”WUjS`SdpCSde\VC~ˆŒpFWVanoW#4V V\S5~ˆr_k”VWUi:j_€b5j_k€€b5j‹W$Wj_V‚`‹{^~VaTUŒpCS5k‹e_ ®p+{^kÃW”VJn&ST€nU”`^bm TUid~ WUj_Vme\Vab5Va`_VCTqS5pC| i52Wj_Vr_Ti5z_k€VC~ YÈ%h d![N W 2 ZYkg A 68g X 6-j [6  Yhg A 68g X 6-j [ 9z×Vgpqj_idnUVC`nU{^pqj!Wj^SZW 3 a F4G g $V+/ g×X 4 Yhg A 68g X 6-j [%> y ^ g A YzNL†g A [”g X YzNL†g X [WY z:BMj X [L u z ` 6 7vYhg A 6-g X 68j [%> A Y zBMj X [ Y yONQz![ t nUi5k L5V:Wj_Vr_Ti5z_k€VC~ ; < 4!L 4B@D8F7zD X 4BeORQYS4![> Y6 4 X ; < 73L=e_Q L;Y_4 X F7[:>  € `  T Y yON t [ P=V7TVC~3S5TU‰WUj^SW€`®i5Tqe\VaT&WUiSr_r_T!i V\”~3SWUV‚WUj^VVan zai5u I „X*FSZunW ujz> Su`Oe|Ev u 6Qz z z5zJN&t5‚vj_S5V `^P^7e TqznªWm¢Kv Wªxd„ tdiˆv\N&TUiZf „AnUn ”bdi5`_?Q ]#POpC€b5S5{_`dTWmV VazTUTnUi5j_TmiZ€„ ` & ƒ Y 6-j [‚ŒnAp+k€VaS5TUk€> | L…Œno€z_k€V„mj_VCTV 2‰gŒo W* $ ƒ Yhgi6-j „ [:> bu 9> _N.ŽAiZ„ 4V LdVCTJY…WUj_ŒnmVCTTi5TmŒnAno€b5`^ POpaS`‹WUk€|®TVae\{Op+Vae„mj_Va` Wj_V®TVCbd{_k€S5TU€•aSWU€i5` r^STqS~ˆV+WVCTJY „ Y2Œn€`^p+TVaSdnoVJe WUi‡u zrzdN!‚j_ŒngpCS5` zOV!nUVCVa`= TUid~(WUj^V®zOi5WoWi5~*TiZ„ i5A]2€b5{^TU@V z5Y „mj^VCTV & ƒ Y 6-j [.„m”WUj „ >u Qz zA€nr_k€iWUWUVae!SZ:W j%> z zJt5v_-Y z vS5`^9e z rv xdt5v_N2‚j_V:Sz× u 5| v\Y-z Qz t5vS5`^e9z ¢vKx‹t5vu u-z5N?‚j_”TqeˆTiZ„/* & ƒ Y 6-j [‚SZN W j%>/z Qz t5v_Y z vS5`^e z rv xdtdv„m”WUj „ > u zrzdN T8

T8

'4

'4

'4

T8

t4

S4

z!|

'4

:4

t4

1

1

1

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.8

0.8

0.8

0.7

0.7

0.7

0.6

0.6

0.6

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

0.1

0

0

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0

0.5

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0.5

0

0

0.6

0.8

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1 0.6

0.4

0

0.4

0.2

0.2

0.2 0

0.4

0.8

0.6 0.4

0.2

0.4

0.2

0.3

0.6

0.8 0.4

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.8

1

1 0.6

0.1

−0.5 1 0.8

0.8

0

0.5

−0.5 1

−0.5 1

0

0.2 0

0

0

0 14

13.5

13

12.5

energy

12

11.5

11

10.5

10

9.5

9

0

5

10

15

20 iterations

25

30

35

40

]#€b5{_TVtb* } WS5z_€k””Wª|3i$k€€`_V:e_V+ Vap+WASZW2‰g AN> u ¢v}9=*
ƒ Y 68j [.S5`^e$ ƒ Y 6-j [ SZWUj%> u u5u-z5Y…u u z:S`^e)u uyd^N2‚j_€Tqe®TiZ„/* h u uyOYJ™>u udu z S5`^e „ > u u |\N¥‚j_0V P^TqnªW Wª„ imTiZ„AnOi5_]2€b5{^TUV.t nUj_iZ„9Wj_V.pCi5~ˆr_{\WVaee\€TUVJpWUidT P^Vak€e ƒ Y 6-j [N* >YÈpCidn4Y & ƒ Y 6-j [ [‘6no€`+Y & ƒ Y 6-j [ [ [ S5`^*e $ ƒ Y 6-j [‚SW j%>u udu zdY‹u -u z