Page 1 ... The stochastic approximation version of EM (SAEM) proposed by Delyon et al. in [5] is a powerful alternative to EM when the E-step is untractable.
!" #%$'&() #*,+.-0/ 12 3"4 /52/4 6(&876&
9 :=@?@A B'CDFEHGJILKDNMPGO Q(RSITDNKVUXWYK MRSMDNKMDN\JRHcqI¦H©"cFGi`bKDNCPEH¦cFEHGiK¦H©"K GJIEHGiY RHCY C¦Cô¦H©)K GJILEHGiY YRSMRX^ ßG \JRHC MmDdC§"Zsu¦HIG XRH`>q"cFGHZ¨DNCïDNCÕEHGJITK GqIL¦H©)cFGi`bK£KW\LmMmRSMªYGi\]¦CPEH¦cNWMDF¦CYGJM Gi\]MDF¦CpZ,GJM\S^æDNCGiRSI£RHCYÿC¦C0cNDdCGiRSIb`bD XGiY G Gi\]MK`>¦XYGicNK>\JRHCïRHcNK ¦ß©@G\]¦CKDNYGJIGiYÿRHK DNC)\]¦`>q)cFGJM G6YRSMRª`>¦XYGicNKJ^oghK MDd`bRSMDF¦C ¦Hs!MmG6q)RSILRH`bGJM GJILK'¦HshMmGiK G>`>¦XYGicNK'DNK'RªYD \JWcNM¨\LmRHcdcFGiCHGH^ ²Cq)RSIMDd\JWcNRSIiZXMmGlcNDN§HGicNDNm¦
¦
Y£¦HsMmG¦H©)K GJILEÀRSMDF¦C)K#\JRHCC¦HM¨W)KWRHcNcF«£©@Go`R XDN`D JGiYDNCRb\JcF¦KGiYs¦HIT`^ ¤ mG,G
q@Gi\]MRSMDF¦CX_a`R XDN`D iRSMDF¦C üg 8RHcFH¦HILDFMm)`ZHqI¦Hq@¦K GiY©
«'Gi`>q)K M GJIÝZÕæRHDFITYRHCY>VW©)DNC rZ DNKRl©I¦RHYcF«RSqq)cNDd\JRS©)cFG,RSqqI¦RH\Tmbsu¦HI!MmG#DFM GJILRSMDNEHG¨\]¦`>q)WMRSMDN¦C>¦Hsp`bR XDd`W` cdDF§HGicNDNm¦
¦XYGiK MDd`bRSM GiKJZ WKGJsuWc¨DNCwR EÀRSILDNGJMa«0¦HslDNC)\]¦`>q)cFGJM G]_aYRSMR u¦HIªq)RSIMDNRHcNcN«Õ_r¦H©)KGJIEHGiYX_aYRSMR 6KMRSMDNK MDN\JRHcVqI¦H©)cNGi`bKJ^ ¤ mG K MRHC)YRSILYDNC\]¦`>q)cNGJM G]_aYRSMR KL\LmGi`>Gê\]¦CKDdYGJILKbMm)RSM£MmG ¦H©)K GJILEÀRS©)cNG DNC\]¦`bq)cFGJM GYRSMR IGiKLWcFMKsI¦` q)RSIMDdRHch¦H©)KGJIEÀRSMDN¦C ¦HsV\]¦`>q)cFGJM GYRSMR TZ¥VmGJIG RHC)Y ïRSIGªK ¦`>G §XC¦Ý¥VC YGiC)KDFMa«süWC\]MDN¦CKJ^¨ R XDN`W` cNDF§HGicNDdm¦P¦XYªGiK MDN`RSMDF¦C ¦Hs £\]¦CKLDNK MK'DNC\]¦`>q"WMDNCbMmGESRHcNWG ¦Hs 6MmRSM¨`R XDN`D JGiKMmG¦H©)KGJIEHGiYcNDN§HGicNDNm¦
¦
Y )^ Æg cF¦H RHC)YêMmG£_aK M GJq ¤ mGbg_aK M GJq ¦HsMmGbg*RHcFH¦HILDFMm` \]¦`>q)WM GiK YGJM GJIT`bDNCGiK æRHKæ`bR DN`bD iDNC T^ ¤ mGiCGJM GJIi^ ²C k rZ oWRHCYjl¦CqIL¦Hq¦KG¨RK M ¦X\Lm)RHK MDN\ EHGJILKLDF¦C¦Hs"R VGJ¥#M ¦CX_aVRSq)mK ¦C6RHcFH¦HILDNMm` su¦HIDNC\]¦`>q"cFGJM GYRSMRVGiK MDN`RSMDF¦Cp^ ¤ mGRHcNH¦HILDFMm`2qI¦Hq@¦K GiY ©
« oWRHCY @mPWDNC 8\]¦`©)DNCGiKVRê¬ ¬ôqI¦X\]GiYWIGlRHC)YRbK M ¦X\LmRHKMDN\RSqq)I¦ DN`bRSMDF¦Cs¦HI¨Kq)RSMDNRHc `>¦XYGicNK#GiK MDN`bRSMDF¦CMmGq)RSILRH`>GJM GJILK#¦HsRC¦CcNDNCGiRSI#`D
GiYªG @Gi\]MK'`>¦
YGicf^ Vqq)cdDN\JRSMDF¦Cl¦Hs@UXVg M ¦oMmG,\LmRHCHG]_rq@¦DNCPMK`>¦XYGicÕ¥,RHK(qI¦Hq@¦K GiYDNC ¶ RHC)YM ¦'MmG\]¦CÕEH¦cdWMDF¦C `>¦XYGic,DNC ¶H¶ rZ!©"WMC¦ ILGiKWcFMK¦HsV\]¦CPEHGJIHGiC\]G¦Hs¨MmGRHcFH¦HILDNMm` ¥GJIGDNEHGiCp^ ßGKm¦~¥ MmRSM6MmG \]¦CPEHGJIHGiC\]GILGiKWcFMK¦H©MRHDNCGiY.su¦HIbUVg5RSIGEHGJI« HGiCGJITRHcRHC)Y RSqq"cF«ßM ¦êMmGiK GMa¥¦ßG XRH`>q"cFGiK¦Hs RSqq"cNDN\JRSMDF¦Cp^> ¦CPM Gª¬RSILcF¦DNcNcdWK M ILRSM GMmGbq@GJIsu¦HIL`bRHC\]GiKo¦Hs,MmG>q)I¦Hq@¦K GiYêqI¦X\]GiYWIG6¥¨DNMmêMmGiK G MÒ¥¦`>¦
YGicNKJ^ 4e\W6
c
13
Pk
[2
bmn4ok6X
[K W
a3
9GW]_`
[R'WH4TGH6
j8 h
DJKNFGH6
-
52
N0
c
Y4TGqW6
-
ac
2
l8 h
VJK\6]U 4TKVU >DFGH6Ô¦4TãKH6bþ
ÒPÖ
ÿ=ä
RHKJe Ò
d4 FGH6Má
òd4TGH6ñ
ù Jõ4TGH6fûVä
¤ mGsüWC\]MDF¦CK RHCY RSIGMa¥¨DN\]G\]¦CÕMDNC
W¦WKLcF«£YD GJIGiCPMDNRS©)cNG'¦C ^ ¤ mGosuWC)\]MDF¦C l e ïYG )CGiYRHK [ò
êëì
õ
1/
xÜ
î
ý
]
H 4TGH6Máâ
DNK#\]¦CPMDNCPW¦WKcF«YD @GJIGiCÕMDdRS©)cFGo¦C ^ ./
Ü
Ò Ö
ô © 4E>VJKH6 4TKVU >VFG\6Ô¦4TãKH6
jÜ
ô © 4EÒ Ö 6
tPu
¸ pÂN¿Nº v
!¿ f¹
t |
xwQyxzd{}|~ 5|
t h
áÝfSl¡u¢\H¡¡u¢x!TX#"Ý¡üüS$£ ±HÒNJ"±%Sê¡u¢x&']°'H¡üfSà> (TêS°²±H]°¡r*)³3 "H¡H¡üfSn%+T -V, "1. %/à J 1!0 }lhH21 ¡±J"H¡!]H°3), Su54 ¡u¢Õl ±HÒNJ"±]2" 768b4 ¡u¢Nl¦94h0 ¡u¢N &' ]°' H¡üfSÞ>?S°:) 3¡#;=H< L±ª¡u¢Õ°²HHH¢
S¡,¡u¢x#xT]°]
¤ mGosuWC)\]MDF¦CA@e
YG "CGiYRHK#MmG¦H©)K GJIEHGiYY)RSMRbcF¦HS_acNDF§HGicdDNm¦
¦
Y @ cF¦H cF¦H DNK#\]¦CPMDNCPW¦WKcF«YD @GJIGiCÕMDdRS©)cFGo¦C RHCY ?>%î
HÜ
êëì
Ò
]
f4TGH6Má
¦BD4E>DFGH6PX
./
LM4E>DJKNFGH6Ô¦4TãK\6PX â
¤ mGJIGoG XDdK MK#R>süWC\]MDF¦C be
EDDî
Ò Ö
LM4E>DJKNFGH6Ô¦4TãK\6
Ü
BC
Gå
-
êëì
â
BC LM4E>VJKNFG\6Ô¦4TãKH6ä
6ZKW\LmMmRSMJe
F
°ý
G lÛÞýbJ G
â
Ü
Hd4 F Gå 4 6f6JIKd4 FG\6ä
G°ÛÜgJ
¦HIGJ¦~EHGJIiZMmGlsüWC\]MDF¦C >DNK¨\]¦CÕMDNC
W¦WKLcF«£YD GJIGiCPMDNRS©)cNG'¦C ¨^ Gå
æGJM¨WK#YG "CG
1/
]
ML
R)4TGVU G .6PXâ
N Ò
5ý
cF¦H
9L 6Ô¦4TãKH6ä
LM4E>VJKNFG\6 4TKVU >DFG
²C J\ RHKGiKo¥¨mGJIG6`bR DN`bD iRSMDF¦C ¦Hs O L #DNK'`W\LmßKDd`>q)cFGJI#Mm)RHC Y)DFIGi\]Mo`bR XDd`bD iRSMDF¦C ¦Hs O @ TZDFMbDNK>WK GJsüWcM ¦ RSqq)cN« MmGg RHcFH¦HITDFMm`¥¨mDd\Lmÿ`bR DN`bD JGiK*@ ©
«.DNM GJILRSMDFEHGicF« `bR DN`bD iDNC L T^ ghRH\TmwDFM GJITRSMDF¦C0¦Hsg \JRHCw©GYGi\]¦`>q@¦K GiY0DNCÿMÒ¥¦.K M GJq)KJ^,M£DFM GJITRSMDF¦C Z,MmGg!_aK M GJq \]¦CKLDNK MK>DNC GJESRHcNWRSMDNC T^ ¤ mGiCpZhMmG_aKM GJqw\]¦CKDNKMKbDNC \]¦`>q)WMDdC 6©P« `bR DN`bD iDNC T^ B'KDNC>¦WI¨C¦HMRSMDF¦CKiZMmG P_rMmDFM GJITRSMDF¦C¦HsMmGg RHcFH¦HITDFMm` `bRÝ«©@GG XqIGiKKGiYRHKJe / ¶ P / f 2
13
¦G
µRQ4TGVU G
6
f4TGH6
RQ4TGVU G
13
13
¦G
f4TGH6
6
13
13
k
RQ4TGVU GW6
ïGqW]_`
RQ4TGVU GqW6
Sk
-
RQ4TGVU GW6
X
d4 H4TGW6FGH6
GW-_`
X
4TGqW6PX
4
å 4 \4TGqW6f6ä G
6
4 6
lHGiCGJILRSM GiK>RHC ¤ mG£\]¦CPEHGJIHGiC\]G¦HsMmDdKRHcFH¦HILDNMm` DdKYWG£M ¦ MmGsüRH\]MMm)RSMDNC\]ILGiRHKDNC DNC)\]IGiRHK G¦Hs@ T^ ¤ mDNK\]¦CPEHGJIHGiC\]G mRHK©@GJGiC K MWY)DFGiY ©
« `bRHCP« YD @GJIGiCPMKRHWMm¦HILK üK GJG rZ RQ rZ SUT6K MRÝ«
K¥¨DFMmDNC ¶ RHCY DNKoGiCKLWIGiYpZpsu¦HIlG RH`>q)cFGHZ(WCYGJI ED ¥¨mGiCêMmGbK G
WGiC\]G K ¦`bG\]¦`>q)RH\]M'KW©)K GJM,¦Hs üK GJG T^ ²CMmGlUXVg RHcFH¦HILDNMm`Z
MmG'g!_aK M GJqDNKK q)cNDNMhDNCPM ¦R6KDN`WcNRSMDN¦CK M GJq rUP_aK M GJq hRHC)YRHCªK M ¦X\Lm)RHK MDN\ RSqq)I¦ DN`bRSMDF¦CDNCPM GJHILRSMDF¦CªK M GJqG q)IGi\JDNK G IGiKWcFMK£¦Hs\]¦CPEHGJIHGiC\]GߦHslMm)DNK£RHcNH¦HILDFMm`*¥¨mGJIG ¦H©MRHDNCGiYïDNC r^ [(DNILK MJZ¨DFMªDNK RHKKLW`>GiYôMmRSMMmGßILRHCY¦`4EÀRSILDdRS©)cFGiVK T XW RSIG YG )CGiY ¦CôMmG KRH`>G qI¦H©)RS©)DdcNDFMa«ïK q)RH\]G Y [Z ]\ T^ ßGYGiC¦HM G ^ _^ SUT#MmGoDNC\]IGiRHKLDNClsüRH`bDNcF«6¦Hs _aRHcNHGJ©ILRHGiCGJILRSM GiYª©
«>MmGVITRHCY¦` ESRSILDNRS©)cNGi8K T W P^ ²CRHYY)DFMDF¦CpZX¥GlRHKKW`>GMmRSMJe [¦HIVRHcNc ªDdfC elZ ¶ rhZ gji RHCkY gji W ^ '`badc RHC)Y e H RSILG MDd`>GiKoYD @GJIGiCÕMDdRS©)cFGHZ@¥¨mGJIG %DNK'MmG>DNCPM GJHGJI '`badc @e l KW\LmMmRSM DNKRHC¦Hq@GiCKW©"K GJM¦Hs ^
a3
5GqW]_`¦X
G å 4 qW6
8h
¥GiRS§HGJI'\]¦C)YDFMDF¦C MmRSMVDNKKRSMDNK )GiY¥¨mGiCR RSI§H¦~E\LmRHDNC ¦CPM G]_3¬,RSILcF¦£qI¦X\]GiYWIGDNKW)K GiYDNCªMmGU
_aK M GJq¦Hs!UX'g ^ }G
2
j8 h
VFGW6
¦£
ë
ì
ë
ì
î
î
f
»¼E»
vË=wyx}ÉÍĦÊ
Î ¿PÀ
ÆÈ7Á°Â
Ã%ÉÊ^Ë^ÌHÍoÎ ¿¦Ï
zÍÎ ¿ {  vàÂ{v
[ ¦HIRHCÕ« ZVRHKLKW`>G MmRSMªMmGß\]¦CYDFMDN¦CRHcVY)DNK M ILDF©"WMDF¦C £DNK£MmGßWCD
WG cNDN`bDFMDdC YDdK M ILDF©)WMDF¦C¦HsqIL¦H©)RS©)DNcNDNMa«}| C ^ mGiCMmGVC¦Cb¦H©)KGJIEHGiY£Y)RSMR '\JRHC)C¦HMh©@G¨HGiCGJILRSM GiY G
Û
Ü
4 úeU >DFGH6
+
SKqW
ac
tPu
¸ pÂN¿Nº v
!¿ f¹
xwQyxzd{}|~ 5|
t |
t
WC)YGJI TZ)¥Gl¥¨DdcNcpWK GlMmGlM ILRHCKDNMDF¦Cª§HGJILCGic=| C~ ^ ¤ mGiCpZ)MmG P_rMm DFM GJILRSMDF¦C¦HsMmGlqI¦Hq@¦K GiY RHcFH¦HITDFMm` \JRHC©@GlKW)`b`bRSILD JGiYDdCªMmIGJGlK M GJq)KVRHKsu¦cNcF¦Ý¥VKJe 4 úeU >DFGqW6
Sk
13
,6X H¡üüHeæW)KDNC iZÝHGiCGJILRSM GR,IGiRHcdD iRSMDF¦C hsuI¦`ôMmGM ITRHCKDFMDF¦Coq)I¦H©)RS©)DNcdDFMa«| )¡r "]¢ %áü " TÕ"°²X GiRHCK>MmRSMJZ,DFEHGiC G T
ZMmGITRHCY¦`ESRSILDNRS©)cFGiK
J]ú]ú]úñJGW
°K
T
J]ú]ú]ú^JK W
·£¸H¹º»Sº@¼½(»¾À¿ÁÃÂNÂÁ ¥
RSIGDNCYGJq@GiCYGiCÕMJ^¬,¦Wq)cFGiY¥VDFMmªMmGRHKLKW`>qMDN¦C '`hauc üZ)DFM¨RHcdcF¦Ý¥¨K¨M ¦qIL¦ÝEHGMm)RSM¨MmGKGJILDFGiK g % l\]¦CPEHGJIHGiKMmRHC§XKM ¦MmG'`bRSILMDNCRHc"MmGJ¦HI«H^ ¤ mDdK!qI¦Hq@GJIMÒ«bq)cNRÝ«
KR§HGJ«I¦cFGoDNCMmGVq)I¦P¦Hsp¦Hs MmG>\]¦CPEHGJIHGiC\]Gb¦HsMmGbUXVg RHcFH¦HITDFMm` DNC r^ 3C MmDdK'CGJ¥ EHGJITKDF¦C ¦HshMmG6RHcFH¦HILDNMm`Z@¥G>RHcNcN¦Ý¥ RSI§H¦ÝEXDNRHC YGJq@GiCYGiC\]G©@GJMa¥GJGiC RHC)Y e!¥GKWqq@¦K GoMmRSM ¨DNK,¦H©MRHDNCGiYsI¦` YWGM ¦ RRSI§H¦~E
DdRHCM ILRHC)KDFMDF¦CYGJq@GiCY)DNC6¦C ÃZK ¦bMmRSMV¥Gl¥VDNcNc@CGJGiYK¦`>GM Gi\TmCDN\JRHcæM ¦P¦cNK¨qIGiK GiCPM GiY DNC ¶ q"RH\]MVKW©"K GJJM ¦Hs ^
^V[¦HIRHCP«\]¦`bq)RH\]MKW©)K GJM!¡ô¦Hs ZMmGJIGG XDdK MK!RoIGiRHc\]¦C)K MRHCÕM¢ KW\Tm6MmRSM!su¦HIhRHCP« L DNC ¡ W L KLW §q ¨9© | C -ª | C -ª
^ ¤ mGªM ILRHCKDNMDF¦C.qI¦H©)RS©)¤Dd£.cN¥DF¦ Ma« | C HGiCGJILRSM GiK£RßWCDFsu¦HIL`bcF«êGJIH¦XYDN\ª\TmRHDNC ¥¨mDd\Lm DNCPEÀRSILDdRHCÕM qI¦H©)RS©)DdcNDFMa«£DNKMmGl\]¦CY)DFMDF¦CRHcpYDdK M ILDF©)WMDF¦C Te «¬ C «® C d ¶ G A G Ve | C ¯±° ¬ C ® C ¥¨mGJIG ¯±°0YGiC¦HM GiK¨MmGM ¦HMRHc8EÀRSILDdRSMDF¦CC¦HIL`^ ßGKWqq@¦K GRHcNK¦>MmRSMJe ¬ KWC q ¬ C RHCY ® ôKWC q ® C ¶ Ò Ö
n4TK W6 W
^Ü
-
U
à4TGNJG
4 Jf>N6
4 Jf>N6]U s
dU G
nG
Uüä
4 úeU >VFGH6
ÛÞÒ
_
Û< xJ
8
U
K)Û
kàÛ
U1UúHU1U
U1U
W
4TKNJ]úü6M
4 úeU >VFGH6]U1U
s
W
J
M+
á
þ
'ÿ
á
þ
ä
^ ¤ mGsüWC\]MDF¦C DNK,©@¦WCYGiY¦CA ^ ¨
ô©
ßGRHcNK ¦>¥GiRS§HGiCMmGlRHKLKW`>qMDN¦C +
'`badc
ìÇíNî Z¥GlIGJq"cNRH\]GlDFM©
«ªRHKLKW`>qMDN¦C ë `badc
ìÇí²Eî e ë
'`badc
ìÇí²Eî [¦HI'RHcNcñkªDNCfeZx\WgÛn8 xJ ¶ GO,6u"S° H¡üüHÃ"TS"±Sü¡üüH ¦HIVÄ ]±1 $"LS"±Hu¡üfS0su¦HI£MmG M ILRHC)KDFMDF¦CïqI¦H©)RS©"DNcNDFMÒ«| C üK GJGß\TmRSqM GJI ¶ ¦Hs ¶ T^ ®'MmX_ GJI¥¨DNK GHZ¥GmRÝEHG6M ¦ª\]¦C)KDNYGJI'GiRH\Lmê\JRHK G>DNCY)DFE
DdYWRHcNcF«H^#¬¦CKLDNYGJI¨su¦HIoG XRH`bq)cFGRHCêDNC)YGJq@GiCYGiCPM GJM I¦Hq@¦cNDdK²_ VRHKMDNCKRHcFH¦HILDNMm`eæMmGM ILRHCKDFMDN¦CYGiCKDFMÒ}« C `>GiCPMDF¦CGiYbDNCG
WRSMDF¦C (YG )CGiK RHCDNCYGJqGiC)YGiC\]GoKRH`>q)cFGJIÝe ê
ë
ì
f
Eî
4
:
8 ¨MmGVWCDFsu¦HIL` JG IH¦XYDN\JDFMÒ«DNK!GiCKWIGiY>DNs"MmG¨M ILRHCKDFMDN¦C* C KRSMDNK GiK!MmG#su¦cNcF¦Ý¥VDNCDNCG
WRHcNDFMÒ« üK GJG ¤ mGJ¦HIGi`
^ ¶ DNC ¶ Te f
4
c
8 VFGH6ä
3C \JRHK GiK'¥¨mGJIGlMmG\]¦`>q)RH\]MCGiKKo\]¦CYDFMDF¦C '¸ DdK¨C¦HM'\LmGi\L§HGiY ¦HIoDNKVYD \JWcNMM ¦£\LmGi\§Z@DNMVDNK q¦KLKDF©)cFGM ¦K MRS©)DdcND JGMmGbRHcFH¦HILDFMm)` ©
« W)KDNCMmGb`>GJMm¦XYê¦Hs,Y«
C)RH`bDN\©¦W)CYKVqI¦Hq@¦K GiYê©
« ¬,mGiC i¡ S ,DNC t 8RHCYRHcFILGiRHY«W)K GiYDNCMm)DNK#\]¦CPM G
MV©P«'GicF«H¦C i¡ H DdC reDFs DNK¦WMKDNYG R>DFEHGiC\]¦`bq)RH\]M¨K GJM Æ ¦Hs ¨Z)DNM,DdKIGiDNCDNMDNRHcND JGiYDNCRbK q@Gi\JD "\'\]¦`bq)RH\]MVK GJ7M Æ T ^ ÒM¥,RHKKm¦Ý¥¨CßDNC !Mm)RSMJZ8WCYGJIIGiRHK ¦CRS©)cNG6\]¦C)YDFMDF¦CKiZ8UXVg RX^kKi^bRiEH¦DNYKlM ILRSq)KJZæDr^tGH^FZæ\JRHC ¦CcF«\]¦CÕEHGJILHGM ¦ªRbq)I¦Hq@GJI¨cF¦X\JRHcæ`bR DN`bD JGJIV¦HsMmGcNDN§HGicNDNm¦
¦
Y¦Hs¬,mRSqM GJI ¶ ¦Hs ¶ r^ ¤ mGlHGiCGJILRHc8`b¦
YGic e ë
ë
ë
^î
^î
Yì
ô©
eî
P+
Q
c
ë
c
%î
| C ë 4TK\6| C ë 4TKH6}X | WC ô © 4E>DJKH6 C ô © à X| WC ô © 4E>DJKH6 C ô © WS%` WS%` æ Xjë 4TKH6Më 4TKH6ñ C ô © C ô © æ K ¦¥Gm)RiEHG U | C ë 4TKH6M| C ë 4TKH6]U s U ë 4TKH6Më 4TKH6]UU C ô © C ô © Uüä +ßG6¥¨DNcdc`>¦
YGicDNK\]¦`b`>¦CcN«WKGiYôDNCôK GiDNK`DN\êYGi\]¦CÕEH¦cdWMDF¦CpZsf Y)RSMR0RHCRHcF«XKDNKJZ'¦HI K MRSMDdK MDN\JRHcqMDN¦CKJZæ\]¦C\]GJITCDNCMmGILRHCY¦` KG PWGiC)\]GiK RHC)Y.e á Ê ¶ ³ bDNK£R K G
WGiC\]G ¦HsDNCYGJq@GiCYGiCÕMbRHCYïDNYGiCPMDN\JRHcNcF«ÿYDdK M ILDF©)WM GiY ILRHCY¦`*EÀRSITDNRS©)cFGiKJZ YDdK M ILDF©)WM GiY£RH\J\]¦HILY)DNC6M ¦K ¦`>GlY)DNK M ILDF©"WMDF¦CbsüWC\]MDN¦dC ZRHC)YªMRS§
DNC>MmGiDFIESRHcNWGiKDNCªK ¦`>Gl\]¦`bq)RH\]M ¦Hs >^ áá Ê : ¶ ³ oDdKlRK G
WGiC\]Gb¦HsDNC)YGJq@GiCYGiCPM'K MRHC)YRSILYD JGiY oRHWKKDdRHCßEÀRSITDNRS©)cFGiKJZ ááá Ê RHC)Y Ê RSIGlDNCYGJqGiC)YGiCÕMsu¦HIVRHcNc@q)RHDNILK,¦Hs8MDd`>GlDNCYG XGiK ¶ ³ RHC Y ¶ L ³^ ¤ mDNK>RHKKW)`>qMDF¦C M ¦HHGJMmGJI¥¨DFMm G
WRSMDF¦C r 6K q@Gi\JD GiK>\]¦`>q"cFGJM GicF« MmGcF¦HS_acNDN§HGicNDNm¦
¦
Y.¦Hs'MmG ¦H©)KGJIEHGiY£Y)RSMRKRH`>q"cFGiKJ^q)cNGJM GcF¦HS_acNDF§HGicdDNm¦
¦
YªDNKJZWqM ¦Rb\]¦CK MRHCPMJZ È È ³ cF¦H W ¶ W o " #Oo W cF¦H! cN¦H ! XÚ4
J]ä]ä]äqJ
6
Þ
b2
+
4TK
c
J
s
[Ò
ë
ë
î
6
î
7s
4
J
?
ë
î
c
Þs
Ss
6
c
13
K
-
c
4 H6
}LM4EPJ NFGH6}X
4 6
S4 g
Þ
j
[s
's
s
1
[6 à4 )
Õ
s
O
6
.
7
4 H6
4 H6}XªK
P4 \6ä
_`_
4o¥ 6
Õ
' Gi\]¦CPEH¦cNWMDF¦C£\]¦CKDNKMK!DNC6IGi\]¦~EHGJILDNClMmG#DNCq)WMK G
WGiC\]G$ sIL¦` MmG¦H©)K GJILEÀRSMDF¦C !^®'s"\]¦WILK GHZ YGi\]¦CPEH¦cNWMDN¦C£ILG PWDNIGiKRHCRH\J\JWILRSM GoGiK MDN`bRSMDF¦C¦Hs8MmG'\]¦CPEH¦cNWMDN¦C )cFM GJI$ôRHCY£MmGC¦DNK G'ESRSILDNRHC\]G W ^#UX'g ¥¨DNcNc@©@GlEHGJIL«ªW)K GJsuW)cps¦HIVGiK MDN`bRSMDdCbMmGiK Gq)RSILRH`>GJM GJITKJ^[WIMmGJIT`>¦HIGHZMmG`bRSIDNC)RHcq@GJIL`WMRSMDF¦C ¦Hs ¶ L E6
W
}Ù
¦J ô ©
4EòMWHJ
4 \6f6
k
W J Õ W 6
³ DNK,ITRHCY¦`bcF«\Lm¦KGiCpZ
J \J]ä]ä]äJ Ý
6
öPø
ä
4 6
N0
¶
·£¸H¹º»Sº@¼½(»¾À¿ÁÃÂNÂÁ ¨
DdD s¦HI-, ¶ L ³ÿe ., T^U
GJM ¶ ^Vq)WM G e6
X
J \J]ä]ä]äJ
}rX
Wx4 6
^ 'GiCGJILRSM G Y
Ê
Q©K
@ m:ª ü
7
£RHCYHGiCGJITRSM G
I éX r
j
Õ W
6
4 \6
©
W
X
P4 ú1FfòMW 6T^
¡©K
W
0/ o 1 3 2 4 o o ¶ T^,UXGJM8 DFsÿ ü HR CY9
4
¥
¶W
ÿ7X
su¦HIVRHCP« Ê
XªKqW %`
W
"
4
7
Oþ
@
4 H6
W
o W65 ä
4
¶
6
#¦HMmGJI¥¨DNKGH^
: Wq%`
W'X
ßGV\JRHC6GiRHKDNcF«KLm¦Ý¥0Mm)RSM| C~ DNK(MmG,M ILRHC)KDFMDF¦CqI¦H©"RS©)DNcNDFMÒ«¦Hs"RHC6GJIH¦XYDN\ RSI§H¦ÝE>\TmRHDNCpZ MmRSM,\]¦CPEHGJIHGiKWCDFsu¦HIL`bcN«M ¦MmGV\]¦C)YDFMDF¦CRHc"YDNK M ITDF©)WMDF¦C T^![¦HIGiK MDd`bRSMDNC ( W TZP¥G YG "CGlR>K G
WGiC\]G / W / ñ ,RH\J\]¦HILYDNC>M ¦ f 'e +
4 Wq%`]J]úü6
4 úeU ¦FGqW 6
]
c
4 qW `-J qW
¥
J qW
¥ qW
6
¥
`
Wq%` X X
¤ mGiCpZMmGl`bR DN`bD iRSMDN¦CK M GJq«XDFGicNYK
13
Õ W]_`
X
òMW
4 W 6
?\Wx4
?\Wx4 ô ©
W
X
Wq%` `³6 4 W 6ËÊoqWq%` W 6 ¥ 4 W 6 Wq%` ñ 6¥ä ¥
`ñ?\Wx4
Wq%` ¥ W Wq%` ¥ ñ ¥
W]_`
W
6
4 6
X
qW ¥ W qW ¥ ñ ¥
4EòZJ SJ Õ
4
`³6
%`
&
Ê
4 W 6
W W
¶ ¥ Ê ¥ W Ê ³ ¨IL`bR ¬ ÒG ¥; ?
5
X
j
4Eò[6
4 qW
6
ù
¥
û
W-_` ä
'cNcMmGRHKKW`bqMDF¦CK¦Hs ¤ mGJ¦HIGi` ¶ RSIGKRSMDNK GiY.¥¨mGiCGJEHGJI¼ mRHK>Rê©@¦WCYGiY KWqq@¦HIMJZ!RHCY.MmG UX'g*RHcFH¦HILDNMm` \]¦CÕEHGJILHGiKM ¦R ücN¦
\JRHc '`R XDN`W` ¦HsMmGb¦H©)K GJILEHGiY cNDF§HGicNDdm¦P¦XYp^ ¤ ¦RHKKW)`>G>MmRSM MmG6DNCq"WMEÀRSITDNRS©)cFGi@K ªRSIG©@¦WCYGiYDNKVC¦HM'R£IGiK M ITDN\]MDFEHG6RHKKW`>q)MDF¦Csu¦HIoR£qILRH\]MDd\JRHcæq@¦DNCPM#¦Hs!EXDFGJ¥l^ ²CYGJGiYpZRHCP«C¦Cª©@¦WCYGiYY)DNK M ILDF©"WMDF¦CDdKM ILWC\JRSM GiYDNCªMmGlqITRH\]MDN\]GH^ ßGoWK GiYMmG¨\]¦CPEH¦cNWMDF¦C`>¦XYGicYGiKL\]ILDF©@GiY>DNC r !s¦HIKDN`WcNRSMDNClRHCb¦H©)K GJILEHGiY£K GJITDFGiK ¦HspcFGiCHMm ³ HX^ 3CªMm)DNKG XRH`>q"cFGHZMmGlDNCq"WMKG PWGiC)\]G bRSIGlDNCYGJqGiC)YGiCÕ8M 6 J¡ A CB ILRHCY¦` EÀRSILDdRS©)cFGiK,¦C ¶ ¥¨DFMDm A EB 2
^U
¦MmGK MRSMDdK MDN\ '& ¨DNK W Ûg cF¦H 3g cF¦H ¶ T^ ¤ mG \]¦CPEH¦cNWMDF¦C )cFM GJIDNK ¶ ¨ L L ¨ ¶ T^ ßG'\Lm¦
¦K G W úH DNC>¦HILYGJIhM ¦GiC)KWIG#R6UXDFCRHc M ¦ V¦DNK GILRSMDF¦>G
WRHcpM ¦ ¶ HY 'ZGiK MDd`bRSMDF¦CߦHs A CB ( W T^b ¦CÕM G]_3¬,RSITcF¦©)RHK GiY ¦C ¶ HIGJq)cdDN\JRSMDF¦CK ¥,RHK£W)K GiY0su¦HIGiK MDd`bRSMDNC MmG `>GiRHCïRHCY0MmG K MRHCYRSITY0YGJEXDNRSMDF¦C0¦HsoMÒ¥¦.GiK MDN`bRSM ¦HITKJ^ [DFILK MJZMmG `bR DN`W` cNDF§HGicNDdm¦P¦XYbGiKMDN`bRSM ¦HGI IF H
Z¥¨mDN\Tm£`bR DN`bD JGiKMmGl\]¦`>q)cFGJM GcNDF§HGicdDNm¦
¦
Y ! RHKKLW`bDNC
n4
e6
2
+
X
¡4 6
8 xJ
©@¦HMm RHcN`b¦K MVMmG6KLRH`>GM ITRHCK suGJIMVsüWC\]MDN¦Cp^ ¤ mGq)I¦H©)cFGi` ¦Hsh\]¦CÕEHGJILHGiC\]GbM ¦ªMmGcF¦H©)RHc `bR DN`W`¦HsæMmGcNDN§HGicNDNm¦
¦
Y£DNK©GJ«H¦C)YªMmGK\]¦Hq@G'¦Hs8MmDNKq)RSq@GJI üK GJG ¶H¶ ps¦HI#R6KDd`WcdRSM GiYRHC)CGiRHcNDNC EHGJILKLDF¦C¦Hs(MmDNK#RHcFH¦HITDFMm` T^ C F TS^ ¤ mGILGiKWcFMK'qIGiKGiCÕM GiYßDNC ¤ RS©)cFG ¶ \]¦C IL` MmRSWM IF H£DdKVR`>¦HILGRH\J\JWITRSM GbGiK MDN`bRSM G6¦Hs £Mm)RHE VGJEHGJIMmGicFGiKLKJZX¥Go\JRHCIGi`bRSI§>MmRSMJZX¥¨mGiXC 6DNKC¦HMh¦H©"K GJIEHGiYpZ)UX'g qIL¦ÝEXDNYGiKRH¦
¦
Y£GiK MDN`RSMDF¦C¦Hs ^ Õ
4
Þ4 J ]6PX
NJ
X
Þ
7
H6X
4 x6 4 ]6fè }4 l
]6
%`
Þ4 J ]6 _
4 x6¦X
G
+
6
o
%`
%`
J
ã
13
BD4EPFG\6
G
èx4okQ
4 H6
jxW?X
k
?s
§xW?X
s
Zk
n4
X
X
6
MrgXª¨
à
./
a3
dr5X
ÚX,4 xä
\J³:\ä : h J
-
ä;¨ \J
\ä h
J
ä h ¥xJ xä h ¨J
ä
6 Þ+
7
'4
Q8
¦XYGic8\]¦CKDNYGJILGiYDNC ¶ r^ ßG¦H©)K GJILEHGRIGiRHcæK G
WGiC\]G MmRSMJZ)s¦HI¨RHCP« ¶ , ³Z +
?8 < +
's
c
SnXØ4E>
¶ J
È
gs
s
, s
³ TZ"KW)\Lm 6
H¶ ¶ ¥¨mGJIG ¶ , ³ DNKhRK G PWGiC\]G¨¦Hsp§XC¦ÝÈ ¥VCb¦H©)K È GJILEÀRSMDF¦È CMDN`>GiKRHCY ¶ , ³ DNK!RK G
WGiC\]G ¦HsDNCYGJq@ÈGiCYGiCPM JGJIL¦S_a`>GiRHC oRHW)KKDNRHC ESRSILDNRS©)cFGiK'¥¨DNMm W)CDFM'EÀRSILDdRHC\]GH^ ¤ mÈ GsüWC\]MDF¦C M ¦IGi\]¦~EHGJIDNK q)DNGi\]GJ¥¨DNK Gb\]¦CKMRHCÕMJ^ ¤ mPW)KJZpMmGJIGbG DNK MKRK G
WGiC\]G>¦HsDNCK MRHCPMK ô I oRH`>¦CMmGbK G
WGiC\]G >
S4
J
's
s
b3
6
X
LM4
6^
Õ
J
4
c
4
J
's
O
s
6
c
ïL
-
c
Q4
Jdr
6
c
6
¶
·£¸H¹º»Sº@¼½(»¾À¿ÁÃÂNÂÁ
4
:
¶ J
,
È
's
³ RHCYRbK G
WGiC\]G 6 s
c
OI
4Em
J¦r
¶ ,KW\TmMmRSMJZ)su¦HI¨RHCP« uI ¶ Z su¦HI¨RHcNcô ô 6
LM4 6MX=m
r
%` þ
[s
¶ 4
6
¥¨DNMmªMmG\]¦CPEHGiCÕMDF¦Ckô T X^ ßG DNCÕM IL¦
YW)\]GêRÿcdRSM GiCÕMKG PWGiC)\]GߦHsDNC)YGJq@GiCYGiCPMDNYGiCÕMDN\JRHcdcF«wYDNKM ILDF©)WM GiY GJILC¦WcdcND¨ITRHCY¦` ESRSILDNRS©)cNGiK ¶ , ³ ¶ VMmRSMoMRS§HGiKMmG6EÀRHcdWG ¶ RSMoMmG>\TmRHCHGbDNCKMRHCÕMKRHCYê©@GJMa¥GJGiCêMa¥¦ \TmRHCHGiKle È ¶ DFs8MmGJIGlG DNK MK £KW\TmMmRSM ô ¶ ¦HMmGJI¥VDNK G È È æGJJM ³b©@G#MmG#q)RSITRH`>GJM GJIh¦Hs@MmG GJILC¦WcNcNDXRHCYs¦HIhRHCP[« ¶ , ³ ¶ !DN¼C Y Ý ¶ Z cFGJM ¬ R g ¶ ©@G6MmG>C
W`©@GJIo¦HsKGJ`>GiCÕMK 3 ¬ R ¶ È DNK'MmGbC
W`©@GJI'¦Hs\TmRHCHG]_rq@¦DNCPMK YG "CGiYª©P0« È ^ ¤ mGiÈ CpZ 3³ ³acb ¶ ³ acb ¶ ¬ R #DNK#RHKKLW`>GiY ¬,¦CYDFMDF¦C)RHcNcF«M ¦£MmG\TmRHCHG]_rq@¦DNCPMKVKG PWGiC)\]GHZ"MmGEHGi\]M ¦HI ¶ M ¦b©@G oRHW)KKDNRHCpe è ad b e . ¡ © ³ W 3¡ ¶ ³ gf G
q M ¡ ¬ R^ ¥¨mGJIG³ g ¶ ic hkjQl çè jQl4h DdKMmGlcFGiCHMm¦HsKGJ`>GiCÕM bsu¦HI ¶ ®CMmG¦HMmGJÈ ImRHCYpZ ¥ ¶ È , ³ pDNK8RHKKW`>GiYM ¦'©GR¨K G
WGiC\]G¦Hs)DNC)YGJq@GiCYGiCPM JGJI¦S_a`>GiRHC6RHCY WC)DFM!ESRSILDNRHC\]G oRHWKKDdRHCILRHÈ C)Y¦` ESRSILDNRS©)cNGiKJ^ ¤ mPWKiZÕMmGo\]¦CYDFMDN¦CRHcYDNKM ILDF©)WMDN¦C6¦HsGJM GJILKM d¦ ³ É k
bZ ¡ É RHCY W É ¶ ^ ¤ RS©)cFGlDFEHGiK#MmGGiK MDN`bRSMDN¦Cª¦Hs Û³ 3¡ W T^h ¦CPM G]_3¬,RSILcF¦©)RHK GiYª¦C ¶ H>IGJq"cNDN\JRSMDF¦CK¥,RHK WKGiYsu¦HIVGiK MDd`bRSMDNCbMmG`>GiRHC RHCYMmGK MRHCY)RSILYYGJEXDNRSMDF¦C¦Hs F H
Z"¥¨mDN\Tm`bR DN`bD JGiK¨MmG\]¦`bq)cFGJM G cNDN§HGicNDNm¦
¦
Y ! VRHC Y F TMmRSM`bR DN`bD JGiKVMmG6DNC\]¦`>q"cFGJM GcdDF§HGicNDNm¦
¦XY T^ ßG>\]¦`>q"WM Gi Y FT ¥¨DNMm ¶ HDFM GJILRSMDN¦CK¦Hs!UXVg Z"WKDNC SRHCY 9 Q su¦HI fIï ¶ ^ ¶ su¦HI ¶ ¶ ²CMmDNKq)cNGHZUVg K MDNcNcHq)I¦
Y)W\]GiKæR¨H¦P¦XYGiKMDN`bRSMDF¦C¦Hs ^ 3Cq)RSIMDN\JWcdRSIiZ~MmGC¦DNKGhESRSILDNRHC\]G W DdKoGiK MDN`bRSM GiY ¥¨DFMmßRHcN`b¦K MlMmGKLRH`>GRH\J\JWILRH\]«HZ¥¨mGiCßMmG\TmRHCHG]_rq@¦DNCPMKRSIG§
C¦~¥¨C RHCY ¥¨mGiC MmGJ«RSIGlW)C§
C¦Ý¥¨Cp^
l
d2
©
Wq%`
P4 ú1FfòMWq%`-6
-
-
54
8
+
X
h
}+
X
GSXÚ4 %J PJ Õ
xä
G
S\W
X
2
-
X
Õ
6
G
LM4EPJ NFGH6
X=¨
13
13
9BD4EPFGH6 '+
's
k
9xWYX
s
G 2
Õ
µ adã ý c auãXY[Z µ]\ c c
èx4ok)
6
G
dk
¶
·£¸H¹º»Sº@¼½(»¾À¿ÁÃÂNÂÁ ¥
Ä
Ä
篰¯
&)* ±
®¦#
ßG ILK M,qI¦~EHGR>M Gi\TmCDN\JRHc8cFGi`b`bR¥¨mDd\Lm¥¨DdcNc)©@GlCGi\]GiKLKRSI«ªM ¦bqI¦~EHG®^ ILRHCYDFGJILG,RHC)Y ^P'W ¦Z ì StÕS°Ãu¡u¢ , ]¡r "]¢ .áü ºJ '+"TS)¡rSX°Ã ]"¡Òu ' " ZP'CCp^ 3CKMJ^ ¨GiCITDpQ8¦DdC\JRSI
G O ¶ Q9Q TZp9 Q ÕP^ t VRHCb[)W£¬,mGiCpZ W¦lVD ÕWC oRS¦ZS² J°ü ]# " S"±° & ] ]¡ü '3' #¡u¢ X]u Lf S° S PS°Ãu¡u&¢ , ¡ü°Ã
2 " H¡ L± ¡æ° S"±9 ,¤ 4 S'° 4SP* LSX"%± TZU
M ¦X\LmRHK MDd\Q!I¦X\]GiKKJ^HVqq)cf^ ) ¶ Q TZXC¦^
Z ¶ H ¶ ^ 'DdYDFGJI,¬,¦C\]¦HILYGJM,RHCY®ocNDFEXDFGJI ^ 'WCG HZ à ,6X ¡ ±'# ]± Ë, S"¡ l S°Ã árX "]¢ %]¡ü " TÕ"°²X ^(æRiEXDFGicNcNG£RHCY g#^8æGJ©)RSI©)DNGJIiZo Ã" " H¡üüH >0 ^æRiEXDFGicNcNGRHCYg¨^"¦WcNDNCGiKiZl ¢ S /T S ± /"LSU ÀS¡üüS)ZpU
MRSMDdK MDN\JK#RHCY¬,¦`>q)WMDNC ¶ Q9Q TZ@C¦^ Z"H9 Q H
^ ¶ £'DNRS¦S_a8DÕGiCVRHCYV¦C)RHcNY '^ݨW©)DNCpZÀ ¶ Q9Q TZ@C¦^ ¶ Z ¶ (¶ "¶ ¶ üghCcNDNKm T^ ¶ bU^kQ(^"GJ«XCRHCYl^k!^ ¤ ¥GJGiYDNGHZ S3° )S9 O"]¢ Su Su± ár "J¢ %áü "]¡ &]uÛü¡ 4 üghCcNDdKm T^ ¶ b¬'^ _a[J^ HG W