Geno Saccomanno, M.D. New Frontiers in Cytology Award. Evaluation Form.
Evaluator: Poster/Platform Presentation #: Please assess the paper according to
...
Geno Saccomanno, M.D. New Frontiers in Cytology Award Evaluation Form Evaluator:______________________________________________________________ Poster/Platform Presentation #:__________________________________________ Please assess the paper according to the criteria listed below on a scale of 1 – 5 (5 being the best). SCORE PRE-MEETING EVALUATION Contributes to better understanding of cell biology or enhances diagnosis Originality of subject Scientific merit Soundness of content Logic of presentation Soundness of conclusions Significance of conclusions/observations ON-SITE EVALUATION FOR POSTER PRESENTATION Overall visual appeal Quality of illustrations, tables, figures, etc. Did the poster have an introduction, a body Yes (5) and summary/conclusions? No (0) ON-SITE EVALUATION FOR PLATFORM PRESENTATION Clarity of spoken presentation Persuasiveness of verbal presentation Quality of illustrations, tables, figures, etc. Did the paper have an introduction, a body Yes (5) and summary? No (0) Did they read from their paper? Yes (0-4) No (5) Did they run over their time? Yes (0) No (5) Comments:
